Psychologist Julian Jaynes came up with a stunning hypothesis in 1976, that human consciousness only developed in the last 3000 years. And he seemed to have proof in ancient texts. Scholars have been picking it apart ever since and today we join the club.
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
No summary for this episode yet.
This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human. And now, Superhuman Shack. I keep telling them not to say that. I'm no superhuman. Believe it or not, I struggle with moderate obstructive sleep apnea, or OSA. In adults with obesity, moderate to severe OSA is a condition where breathing is interrupted during sleep, with loud snoring, choking, gasping for air, and even daytime fatigue. Let's just say it can sound a lot like this. Sound familiar? Learn more at dontsleeponosa.com. This information is provided by Lilly, a medicine company. It's time for Cyber Monday, Dell Technologies' biggest sale of the year.
Enjoy the lowest prices of the year on select PCs like the Dell 16 Plus featuring Intel Core Ultra processors. And with built-in advanced features, it's the PC that helps you do more faster. Plus, earn Dell rewards and enjoy many other benefits like free shipping, price match guarantee, and expert support. They also have huge deals on accessories that pair perfectly with your Dell PC and make perfect gifts for everyone on your list. Shop now at Dell.com slash deals. Welcome to Stuff You Should Know, a production of iHeartRadio. Hey, and welcome to the podcast. I'm Josh, and there's Chuck, and Jerry's here too.
and this is Stuff You Should Know, the ongoing, amazing, mind-blowing edition. You've been into this stuff lately. What's going on with you? I don't know. I don't know, man. But yes, I'm definitely into it lately. It's weird. Approaching 50? Existential crisis? I don't know about crisis. Maybe more like pondering, existential pondering. I don't think it's a crisis yet. I've still got five years till 50, so give me time. Are you 45? I thought you were like 47. I'm 45 and eight ninths. Yeah, you got time. Yeah, great. Thank you for that. But no, there's no like one thing that's making me say like, hey, when did humans become conscious?
Or when did humans become intelligent? Or what do we do if aliens come down? Like for some reason, it's just maybe a little more appealing to me than it has been in the past lately. I don't know. But yes, I'm definitely into this kind of thing right now. And this stuff, what we're going to talk about today, it's based on a How Stuff Works article that Robert Lamb wrote. And I'm not at all surprised that Robert Lamb is into this. But I just want to note that I've heard about this years and years and years ago and have been meaning to do an article or an episode on it. So I don't want you to think this is something you just stumbled across.
This is actually the fruition of years of planning and hope and dreams coming to pass in maybe the best episode we'll ever make. And, of course, Robert and not Robert Lamb, the lead singer of the band Chicago. Just to make it clear. There's another Robert Lamb and he was in Chicago? Still is in Chicago. Is that Peter Cetera's stage name? No. Satera was the bass player and part lead singer, along with Robert Lamb, who played keyboards and also sang lead on some. And before Terry Kath died, he played guitar and also sang. So they had three singers in the early days of Chicago. That's just confusing.
But none of them are our colleague, Robert Lamb, who along with our colleague Joe have been doing stuff to blow your mind for many, many years. Another great show. Yeah, and I didn't check, but I would place a substantial amount of money on the idea that they have their own episode on this, Julie and Jane's Bicameral Mind. I bet they have. And we should also shout out Philosophy for Life, Psychology Today, and Frontiers in Psychology. And I'm going to make one up, Psychology Fu Young. Okay. I've got two more that aren't made up. A slate star codex and a poster named Hazard on the site Less Wrong.
That sounds like a great source. It is. Hazard knows what he's talking about. Oh, and one more. I'm sorry. A guy named Joff Ward or Jeff Ward. But, you know, when they spell it like Joff on Medium. So all of those combined with Robert Lamb's article that coalesce into, again, probably the greatest episode we'll ever do. Yeah. And I sort of get some of this. I think you're going to help me out some because I do have some questions that I'll just throw out here and there because at times I found myself reading this stuff and going, yeah, but isn't that just blank? Okay, great. I'll do my best to answer.
And you're probably right when you're thinking that. The answer is probably like yes. All right. Well, I mean, I guess we should say then that the whole hypothesis that we're going to be kind of breaking down today is controversial and it's not provable necessarily scientifically speaking. So it's sort of one of those. I mean, I think it goes beyond thought experiment for sure. Definitely. Into true hypothesis land, but it was proposed by a psychologist here in the United States named Julian Jaynes in the mid-1970s, of course. Yeah, the year I was born. Yeah, 76, baby. So what he proposed was an answer to a longstanding question, and that was, when did humans become conscious?
Like, when did consciousness emerge? Is it something that came along like in the earliest archaic humans? Is it something that came along much later than that? And how could we ever possibly answer that? Like what relics have been left in history, in prehistory, that would say like, hey, this is evidence of consciousness? And Julian Jaynes took that up and he did it as an outsider, which was a huge strike against him. Because automatically, legitimate scientists are like, well, I can't build upon this theory, possibly. This man is actually in my field of consciousness studies. But the thing is, is this hypothesis is so well-liked.
It's just roundly liked. People just like it. It's just such an interesting hypothesis that it just won't go away. It hasn't gone away. And in fact, there's like a Julian Jaynes Institute. There's like groups that have sprung up based on this hypothesis. And what he says in a very small nutshell is that sometime about 1,000, 2,000 years ago, humans became conscious in the way that we understand consciousness today. They developed the ability to think about thinking. They developed the ability to think about that other people are thinking. They developed basically what's called subjective introspection.
And then as a result of that, they almost automatically gained free will and volition. So what he's saying is that if we went back in time in the Wayback Machine, Chuck, and we met somebody who lived 3,000 years ago, 4,000 years ago, they would not be a conscious human in the way that we understand conscious humans. That's right. And he thinks that it was a learned thing. and the idea that he throws down is that our our mind our brain is or was rather uh very important was because it no longer is uh bicameral uh which means split into two parts and we'll get to some actual science about the hemispheres of the brain later on but in this case he means split into two parts where you have a part that makes decisions and a part that follows and that neither one of them were conscious.
And here's where I get a little tripped up, right out of the gate. Sure. Is basically he says that instead of an internal dialogue, which we all have and which indicates a consciousness, like us talking to ourselves, us saying things like everything from like, you know, hey, get up and go do this, to just internally thinking about things like humans do, that instead of that, we were sort of like human zombies in that we were creatures of habit. We had routines and behaviors that we followed to a T. And whenever something disrupted that behavior, which is when like a conscious mind, you would think would speak up, that instead of that, an external agent, in this case, they thought they were gods, would enter their brain and create an auditory hallucination.
Yeah, and that they unquestioningly obeyed that auditory hallucination, and that's what helped them get through novel situations that they didn't have like a, basically a prescribed script for, you know, a mindless automatic thing, something new came along that got in their way, this god would speak to them and say, go around that rock. It wasn't there yesterday. Don't worry about it. Just go around it. And it could be one of their gods. It could be an ancestor guiding them. I think the Sumerians maybe made reference to angels walking beside them. Or, and this is really important later on. It's a big part of Jane's hypothesis.
It could be your local ruler, the divine king who's in charge of you and everybody else that you know and love and have ever lived among. It could be that person guiding you in your life too. And the idea is these people heard this in the same way, like you said, that we hear our own internal dialogue, but they never chalked it up to themselves. It was always coming from the outside. All right. Here's, I guess, where I had my first issue kind of grasping this, is there were no gods speaking to them and guiding them. This was just their internal dialogue. They just didn't know it. Yes. Yes. Yes.
There was no gods. But to them, and this is a really important point, to them, it definitely was a god talking to them or an ancestor talking to them. And in the same way that if an actual god got into your brain and like was speaking to you and you responded to it, if you could have looked at their brains lighting up, presumably in like a wonder machine, it would respond the same way. So it was entirely real to them. And the same way that a placebo effect has real effects on your body, this would have been the same thing. And then in addition to that, it was culturally supported. Everyone that they knew believed the same thing, that the gods were talking to them.
And so like that just lent support to this idea so that no one questioned it. It was just, that's the way it was. Well, so this, I guess, brings me to, let me macro this out a little bit in my own dumb brain. And it may just be 21st century person thinking that I'm engaging in. But if the idea is that before this, there was no consciousness, but what we're really saying is there actually was consciousness. They just didn't recognize it as such. is that the whole point was that if you do not recognize it as consciousness, therefore you are not conscious. Yes, because you're not experiencing consciousness in any way that we would recognize as you being conscious.
You're just kind of, Julian Jaynes referred to it. I see what this guy's doing now. Okay, but the thing is there's a lot of scholarly discussion on like, okay, what did Jaynes mean exactly? How literal was he? Because he used words like automaton. He never called them zombies. Other people called them like zombies. Yeah, no one talked about zombies back then. No, that's true. But, well, Evil Dead had, or not Evil Dead, Living Dead. No, Living Dead had come out by then. Yeah, but it wasn't like today. Okay. You know what I'm saying? No, no, I know. They're definitely overdone today. Automatons.
So he called them automatons, and it's essentially the same thing, that they just behaved automatically. They didn't stop and think about how they felt. And this is really important too, Chuck. of course they still had feelings. They had feelings about the people that were in their kin group. They had feelings about their local ruler. They had feelings about, you know, stubbing their toe. It's not like they just had no inner life whatsoever. It's that they weren't, they didn't reflect on their inner life. They didn't think about thinking. They didn't have what we would recognize as consciousness.
And in the terms that Jane's is describing consciousness, which is a really narrow definition of consciousness. And then on top of that, he also goes to great lengths to say, hey, I understand that you're going to get all up in a tizzy, that I'm saying that these people weren't conscious. I'm not talking about consciousness in general. And I think that you overestimate just how much consciousness makes up our lives. Okay. How about we take a break? Okay. I'm going to go rip a bong. Kidding. We'll take a break. We'll come back and we'll talk about what lots of other stuff right after this. Support for the show comes from Public, the investing platform for those who take it seriously.
On Public, you can build a multi-asset portfolio of stocks, bonds, options, crypto, and now generated assets, which allow you to turn any idea into an investable index with AI. It all starts with your prompt. From renewable energy companies with high free cash flow to semiconductor suppliers growing revenue over 20% year over year, you can literally type any prompt and put the AI to work. It screens thousands of stocks, builds a one-of-a-kind index, and lets you backtest it against the S&P 500. Then, you can invest in a few clicks. Generated assets are like EFTs with infinite possibilities. completely customizable and based on your thesis, not someone else's.
Go to public.com slash podcast and earn an uncapped 1% bonus when you transfer your portfolio. That's public.com slash podcast. Paid for by Public Investing. Brokerage services by Open to the Public Investing, Inc. Member FINRA, SIPC. Advisory services by Public Advisors, LLC. SEC registered advisor. Generated assets is an interactive analysis tool. Output is for informational purposes only and is not investment recommendation or advice. Complete disclosures available at public.com slash disclosures. Everybody knows Shaq, but off camera, he's just a regular guy. People never believe me when I say I'm just like them.
I take out the trash, do dishes, and I struggle with moderate obstructive sleep apnea or OSA. And a lot of adults with obesity also struggle with moderate to severe OSA. You know those scary breathing interruptions during sleep? The loud snoring, choking, and daytime fatigue? I knew I had to talk to my doctor. Don't sleep on the symptoms. Learn more at dontsleeponosa.com. This information is provided by Lilly, a medicine company. That's right. And you can get your content discovered fast with integrated SEO tools. Every Squarespace website is optimized to be indexed with meta descriptions and auto-generated sitemap and more.
So you show up more often to more people in global search engine results. Just go to squarespace.com slash stuff and you can get a free trial. And when you're ready to launch, use our offer code stuff, S-T-U-F-F, to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or a domain. Stay cozy, stay home, and save big online during Lowe's December deal drops. Because honestly, why go anywhere when the deals come to you? Check this out. Lowe's is going to give you two free select tools from DeWalt, Craftsman, or Cobalt when you buy a select battery or combo kit. Yeah, two tools. Free. It's basically a holiday miracle.
Plus, rewards members get free standard shipping all month long. Yet another reason not to leave your couch. So kick back, click around, and let the savings roll in. Shop new December deal drops on Lowe's.com every week this month. Fresh deals, cozy vibes, zero effort. All right, so I've kind of wrapped my head around what this guy's saying now. I will admit it's a little navel-gazy for me when it comes to certain types of philosophy and hypotheses. I get a little bit like, what's the word? Maybe I can be a little too concrete, or as the French might say, concrete and literal in my thinking, because it's not Friday night in college, like two in the morning kind of discussion.
Right. So I think that's where I am now. But I do think it's very interesting in that he, I mean, I think a lot of this is very interesting, but I think it's interesting that he thought around the first or second millennium BC is when things to him changed and a consciousness began to emerge because of, well, eventually language, but specifically metaphor, which is to say that all of a sudden we could make analogies in our brain. We could link things together. We saw ourselves as almost as if they were characters. Ourselves were characters that had like choices that they could make as characters.
Yeah. And as these things like connected in the brain, then it created just an effect like a domino effect basically. Yeah. Where all of a sudden we could work out our own solutions or we knew we were capable of working out our own solutions. And then it wasn't God saying walk around the rock. They realized it was ourselves making the decision to walk around the rock. Yes. But in part of that, that also required them to be able to reflect on the idea, like you said, that they were able to now make their own decisions, right? And you said something earlier where you're like, you know, you're talking about your own internal dialogue.
where you think, hey, I should get up and go outside for a second. Like, that's different, right? You're thinking about you, yourself, and you realize that you are thinking about yourself. That's modern consciousness. What somebody who was a bicameral person during this time would have thought is get up and go outside, and they would stand up and go outside without questioning because God had just instructed them to do that. So it must be important. And they didn't think about where it came from. They definitely didn't think it was from themselves. And they didn't reflect on it. They just obeyed it.
That's Jane's position. And that if you compare those two things, you're talking about two totally different forms of mental life. And it's so different, he said, that this is – that what we understand is consciousness just wasn't around until a couple thousand years ago. Okay. I can buy that. I like it as a hypothesis. I can swim in this pool. Okay, good, good. For the next 30 minutes. Here's the thing. It's really important to realize, like, you said something that you're a literalist, right? That's actually really appropriate to approach this. Because Julian Jaynes, one of the very radical things that he did was he took the ancients literally.
Because when he started looking around, and we'll talk more about this later, but he was looking for those artifacts that would prove his hypothesis or lend support to it at least. And he was an expert in ancient languages, right? So he was – it was really appropriate. He could actually read Sumerian and Mesopotamian. And he took what they were saying when they said things like, you know, the gods told us to do this, that they thought that the gods told them to do this, not that they were using metaphors. So he took them literally on their word, and that is a real departure from anybody else who's ever examined the ancients of what they were saying.
Yeah, and I think it's also something we should point out now, even though it comes up later in our research, is that when you think of an, I guess, an automatic society or a society of automatons, that's not to say that they weren't successful. He's describing some of the most successful, you know, ancient civilizations that existed. But I think his contention is that it was a hive mind all working together as automatons that allowed this stuff to get accomplished and not the conscious mind. Right. And he didn't, I don't think he ever used it as like, I don't think he ever explicitly said that it was an emergent property of a hive mind.
But that's kind of what he was describing, kind of like if you take one stone cutter and one stone mason and three stone carriers and multiply that unit by 500 and give it a year, you have a ziggurat built. That's just all those people knew what to do. They knew their position and their place and they just did it. And so, yeah, you could totally do that with people who are thinking in this way and weren't conscious. You could probably actually get it done more easily than you could with people who stopped and thought, I'm above this. This work is not suited for me. I should be doing something else.
Or why is the foreman being so mean to me today? Like they didn't think like that under Jane's hypothesis. So they would probably get the work done more efficiently, at least more quietly, I would guess. Oh, I mean, consciousness proposed or brought along a whole host of problems. It's true. I imagine. If you're the ruling class, I think one thing that's interesting is that you mentioned about what, is it Jane's? Not Jines, Jane's? Yeah. Jane's thought about, I love Robert Lamb's Jane's a Dixon joke in here, by the way. That was mine. Oh, that was yours? Mm-hmm. Oh, well, way to go. Thanks. You said Jane's says, and then in parentheses you put, ha.
It's a very good joke. But what Jane said was that, and it's something you mentioned earlier, was that consciousness, I think we think consciousness plays too big of a role in what is actually a life that can largely be still automatic on a lot of levels. Yeah. And this is from the actual book in 1976. And it's a little mind-blowy. I kind of like it. Consciousness is a much smaller part of our mental life than we're conscious of. Mm-hmm. Because we cannot be conscious of what we are not conscious of. It's like asking a flat, and this is where it kind of comes home to me. It's like asking a flashlight in a dark room to search around for something that does not have any light shining upon it.
So that's where it comes home to me is when you, and hey, it's metaphor, so how about that? He lays down a metaphor that makes me understand it a little bit more. Yeah, because, you know, wherever the flashlight looks, there's light. And his point is, is wherever your conscious mind looks, there's consciousness. But that doesn't mean that there's consciousness all over the place. And yeah, Robert Lamb uses a really good example of unloading a dishwasher, right? Like when you're unloading the dishwasher, especially if you're one of those people who put like all of your knives in one place, all of your forks in one part of the basket, all of your spoons and so on, right?
A maniac, in other words. Sensible human. If you do it like that, you can just be on autopilot because you've done it so many times. But when you do something like drop a fork, that's out of the norm. That's a novel thing that doesn't happen every time. And so in the bicameral mind, God would have said, I command thee to pick up thine fork, butterfingers. And you would lean over and pick up the fork, and that was that. Instead, you might not even think about picking up the fork. You might do that automatically. But it's still out of the norm. It's still different. And you have to kind of think about it a little more than just unloading the dishwasher.
Now, if you take that dishwasher metaphor, Chuck, and you realize that 3,000, 5,000, 9,000 years ago, there were no dishwashers. There was no ice cream scoop. There was no cookie scoop. There was no avocado splitter. There was nothing like that. Wait, what's that? Is that a thing now? Yeah, you don't have one of those? No. Oh, I'll send you one. You're missing out. It's a multi-tool for cutting avocados, getting the pit out, and then slicing them as you scoop them out. They're essential, as a matter of fact. All right. I do pretty well with my knife, but I would love to see one of these. Okay.
I'm going to get you one for Christmas. All right. Okay. So, the point is that, like, there wasn't a big variety of stuff. So, there wasn't that many novel situations. Like we encounter novel situations like almost constantly. That's just modern life. And that's the basis of James' hypothesis that the reason that consciousness evolves is because we started to get faced with more and more novel situations on a much more frequent basis. So maybe it became inefficient for God to be talking to us every 30 seconds. Or maybe we just got better at thinking for ourselves and consciousness kind of evolved out of that.
But the point is life was much less complex back then, so you could have something like a bicameral mind. You could have somebody who consciousness hadn't evolved in yet because they hadn't been introduced to enough experience in life. And with that experience came the fork falling on the floor, in other words? Yeah, or, you know, there's a lot more dishes to put away and much more different dishes to put away rather than just forks, you know? Okay, sure. You know what I'm saying? Yeah. Or you have one fork and you just carry it with you everywhere, you know? Like you don't have to think about that.
There was just less stuff to think about is what I'm saying. Well, now you're speaking my language because if I had it my way, every member of my family would have one fork, one spoon, one knife, one bowl, one cup, one plate. Yeah. And they were all responsible for keeping them clean and put away. Man, every time I hear one cup, I'm like, there's a joke in there somewhere. But even if I could come up with it, I wouldn't be able to say it. Oh, yeah, that's true. All right, so now we're at the point where we can talk a little bit more about this idea of metaphor and language sort of bringing about this change.
And so what Janes was throwing down in 1976, besides apparently a bunch of roach clips, was the emergence of agricultural societies kind of changing everything. And that all of a sudden, we are not living in groups of, you know, 10 or 12 people that are hunting and gathering where even if there was sort of a leader within that group, it was very easy to disseminate information and follow that leader. once we started settling down, planting and growing things, engaging in trade with other peoples that did a lot of things that complicated every process. And it meant that societies were much, much larger and that rulers couldn't necessarily speak directly to people anymore.
Yeah. So another part of- Not to specific people, like they could lay down an edict and that would get disseminated, in other words. Right. So like I've read before back when I was an anthropology student that hunter gatherer bands usually numbered no more than 30 people. Like that was the absolute mass. And once you reach that, you'd split off into two different bands. So yeah, like the person in charge was like part of your moment to moment life. And if you're, if you have, if you're suddenly in a civilization and you're building a ziggurat for somebody, he's probably not deigning to talk to you.
And part of Jane's hypothesis is that this bicameralism emerged from, you know, all those new novel situations like learning to plant crops, learning to domesticate cows, learning to engage in trade and talk to other people that we started to like need direction from the gods more and more. And it started to kind of get faster and faster. But in the meantime, it was a form of social control because one of the people you could think was talking to you was that local ruler who you were building the ziggurat for. So that would be a way to keep an increasingly large population in check. Right. And as they got bigger and bigger and they started, you know, trading with people, like we were saying, that, you know, that was sort of the beginning of the end for his, not his bicameral mine, but the bicameral mine.
And one of the biggest problems with all of that was when we started writing stuff down. Because all of a sudden, these auditory hallucinations that he felt like everyone was having to instruct them on what to do, there was now stuff down on paper that you could read and you could refer to and go back to and pass around and post on tablets at the walls of the city or whatever. And that was, all of a sudden, you weren't waiting around for a God to tell you what to do. You could just go read that tablet. Yeah, so the power that we gave to the God's commands were kind of transferred to the written word.
And yeah, that seems to have been like the death knell for the bicameral mind, right? And there's something really interesting that's worth pointing out. James apparently didn't have any hypothesis on what came before the bicameral mind. because he said it started as a result of the increasing organization that agriculture brought along and that there wasn't bicameral minds before then. But he doesn't say what was before then. And people even asked him, like, okay, what about, you know, hunter-gatherer societies that are still around today? You know, where would they have gotten consciousness?
And he never really answered that. But it's definitely worth pointing out that that's an open question. But he basically says bicameralism or the bicameral mind, I should say. Bicameralism is the Senate in the House. But the bicameral mind lasted from the advent of agriculture about 11,000 years ago till about 2,000-ish, maybe 1,500 or no, 3,000-ish years ago. So it was about a 7,000-year span of bicameral mind. And then as life got more and more sophisticated, we started thinking for ourselves. And what he says is that language, and in particular the written word, but also language got more and more sophisticated.
And as it got more sophisticated, there was more of a potential for us to start thinking in metaphors. And metaphors, as you said, is the basis of consciousness and the way we think in Julian Jane's mind. And there's actually a lot of support for that, Charles. May I? Oh, please. So that post by Hazard on Less Wrong. Oh, yeah. Let's see what Hazard has to say. It's called Consciousness as Metaphor, What Janes Has to Offer. And what Hazard says is that, like, Hazard just puts out, like, a paragraph from, like, an economic report. And it's about recessions in Europe. And it talks about Germany plunging into a recession or the UK falling deeper into a recession or France emerging from a recession.
And what Hazard points out is that all of these descriptors imagine a recession as a three-dimensional physical thing that we can – entire nations can move into and out of. That's not true. Recessions aren't three-dimensional. They aren't physical things. You can't emerge from them. You can't fall into them. But we just think about it like that. And that's metaphor. So we think in metaphors so frequently, we don't even recognize it anymore. And that was Jane's point, that when we gain the ability to think in metaphors, we became conscious. We started thinking for ourselves. We became capable of introspection.
And it was the evolution of language that led us to that point. Like basically, we just hit a threshold where suddenly language is sophisticated enough that it could unlock new thoughts in our brains and in turn unlock consciousness. I mean, that makes sense because, you know, a metaphor is literally not literal. And if that was not a thing yet, then it chives with the whole notion that everything they were doing was very literal up until that point. Yes. And that would have been a pretty seismic shift. if you can compare like with like, you know, all of a sudden. Yeah, and you even see this in like movies that are trying to emphasize how backwards or back in time, you know, some group is.
And they emphasize it by having that group take everything literally, usually to comic effect. Like in Kingpin when Randy Quaid was an Amish person, right? Yeah, yeah, yeah. He took everything literally and it was hilarious. Hilarity ensued. But it was also to demonstrate how just simple and behind he was. He couldn't engage in metaphors. He didn't think like that. That's actually based on, I don't know whether on purpose or not, but that's based on Julian Jayne's hypothesis. Yeah, and you know what? That's a nice segue to children because when you have a human child, it's very funny to see how literal they are for those first years.
Yeah. And that they don't understand metaphor. They don't understand, certainly don't understand things like sarcasm. And you have to change the way you talk to little kids because they do take everything so literally and think so literally. And children are referenced with Jane's, the idea that I think what age, like kids up until the age of five, basically, don't really have much of a human consciousness. And it's, you know, the idea that children are just little narcissists walking around is a fun joke. But it's true because they don't know that other people think differently than they think up until about the age of five.
They don't realize there are other lines of thought and ways of thinking and ways of feeling about things that other people have. Exactly. That's what's called theory of mind, right? And on Slate Star Codex, Scott Alexander went to great lengths to basically say that Julian Jaynes using the term consciousness just really muddied the waters unnecessarily. And if he had just used theory of mind, it would have made a lot more sense. And Scott Alexander, I think I said Anderson, Scott Alexander makes a really good case for it. And that's kind of what he's pointing out is, you know, like it's possible that because you learn, you're not born with it.
You learn it through experience. It just kind of evolves in you as you grow as a person and experience more and more novel stuff and interact with people more. Almost like a microcosm of what happened in civilization a few thousand years ago. You gain theory of mind. So the fact that you can learn and that you do learn something that integral to consciousness really supports the idea that maybe consciousness as we understand it was learned. It did evolve. It was an emergent property of an increasingly sophisticated language. it's a fascinating thing to see happen in a child's life to see these little light bulbs come on seemingly out of nowhere but you realize it is very much a learned thing very fascinating alright I say we take a break and we'll talk a little bit about just some other fascinating stuff when we get back right after this Stop, you should know.
over year, you can literally type any prompt and put the AI to work. It screens thousands of stocks, builds a one-of-a-kind index, and lets you backtest it against the S&P 500. Then you can invest in a few clicks. Generated assets are like EFTs with infinite possibilities, completely customizable and based on your thesis, not someone else's. Go to public.com slash podcast and earn an uncapped 1% bonus when you transfer your portfolio. That's public.com slash podcast. Paid for by Public Investing. Brokerage services by Open to the Public Investing Inc. Member FINRA SIPC. Advisory services by Public Advisors LLC.
SEC Registered Advisor. Generated assets is an interactive analysis tool. Output is for informational purposes only and is not investment recommendation or advice. Complete disclosures available at public.com slash disclosures. And now, Superhuman Shack. I keep telling them not to say that. I'm no superhuman. Believe it or not, I struggle with moderate obstructive sleep apnea, or OSA. In adults with obesity, moderate to severe OSA is a condition where breathing is interrupted during sleep, with loud snoring, choking, gasping for air, and even daytime fatigue. Let's just say it can sound a lot like this.
Sound familiar? Learn more at DontSleepOnOSA.com. This information is provided by Lilly, a medicine company. Stay cozy, stay home, and save big online during Lowe's December deal drops. Because honestly, why go anywhere when the deals come to you? Check this out. Lowe's is going to give you two free select tools from DeWalt, Craftsman, or Cobalt when you buy a select battery or combo kit. Yeah, two tools. Free. It's basically a holiday miracle. Plus, rewards members get free standard shipping all month long. Yet another reason not to leave your couch. So kick back, click around, and let the savings roll in.
Shop new December deal drops on Lowe's.com every week this month. Fresh deals. Cozy vibes. Zero effort. Running a business is hard enough, so why make it harder with a dozen different apps that don't talk to each other? One for sales, another for inventory, a separate one for accounting. Before you know it, you are drowning in software instead of growing your business. And this is where Odoo comes in. Odoo is the only business software you'll ever need. It's an all-in-one, fully integrated platform that handles everything. CRM, accounting, inventory, e-commerce, HR, and more. No more app overload.
No more juggling logins. just one seamless system that makes work easier. And the best part, Odoo replaces multiple expensive platforms for a fraction of the cost. It's built to grow with your business, whether you're just starting out or already scaling up. Plus, it's easy to use, customizable, and designed to streamline every process. So you can focus on what really matters, which is running your business. Thousands of businesses have made the switch. So why not you? Try Odoo for free at odoo.com. That's O-D-O-O dot com. I was going to summarize what we were going to talk about, but I didn't feel like it all of a sudden before the break.
I think it's nice. It's loosey-goosey. I think that's the way it should be. Can I talk about one of my favorite parts of this hypothesis? Definitely. is we were kind of jumping around now, but jumping back to where we talked about writing things down all of a sudden. It was around here in human history that there was a collapse of societies in the Mediterranean around the Middle East. It was called the Late Bronze Age Collapse. And it didn't take that long. And it meant like these very advanced sort of societies in a matter of decades. a number of them, a lot of their culture was lost. It was, it sort of, they called it, in fact, the Greek Dark Ages, and it lasted for hundreds of years.
And jiving with this was when humans started to lose, and it kind of all makes sense that they were losing, with the written word, with metaphor and language coming along, they were losing this voice as a god. They felt like they were losing their gods because all of a sudden, the gods were silent to them. They weren't speaking to them in their mind because they were gaining consciousness. And here's where it gets super interesting. Jane's has a hypothesis that says it's about here where the organized religions that we know today were born out of a kind of nostalgia, basically, for these gods that left them.
Right. Yeah. I think that idea is really interesting. It is. And I mean, the timetable really jibes. And it is really interesting that that late Bronze Age collapse happened when it did. But the idea is not just nostalgia, but also desperation. Yeah. Because these people had guidance. They didn't have to think. And this poor set of generations over a few hundred years are maybe some of the most pitiful humans that ever lived. Yeah. Because they went from just knowing what to do because the gods told them what to do to having no idea what to do because their gods had abandoned them. And as a result of that, they started forming religions.
They started, you know, beseeching the gods to give them a sign. This is when oracles started to become a thing. Prophets started to become a thing. Superstitions, like omens grew. Like there was a Sumerian omen. And if a horse comes into your house and bites you, you will soon die and your family will soon be scattered. Stuff like that, right? So this didn't exist before because the gods were in charge of everything. Now they were suddenly gone. And I just think it must have been really pitiful and dark to live through that time. Yeah. I mean, they were lost, I guess, as a people. Yeah. And that was figuratively they were lost, but literally too, because that late Bronze Age collapse, they think was brought on at least in part by climate change and probably invasion.
There's this mysterious group called the Sea Peoples that seem to have overrun different cultures. And so like culture after culture would fall. Those people would become refugees, descend upon another culture, end up pushing that to the breaking point. That culture would fall. It was just like a domino effect of collapsing cultures all at once. So they really felt like the gods had abandoned them, like they'd angered them or something like that. They were genuinely lost. So what Janes did to help support his hypothesis, which makes sense, was to go back and look at literature of the time and see if it sort of supported this.
I know one of the things he wrote a lot about in his book in 1976 was Homer's Iliad because he's kind of like, here's proof right here. I mean, if you look at the Iliad, they were basically automatons. They just listened to the gods and did what the gods said, and they substituted, like the words that we would use to substitute in for the Iliad to indicate consciousness just weren't there. Right. So, they were more like physical descriptors, like my belly was quivering or my heart was fluttering or something like that. I think the example that's used is fear-filled Agamemnon's mind. Well, there wasn't a mind.
So, they would describe fear in other physical terms, right? Like a stomachache. Yeah. And that it wasn't until later on when new translations were coming along that people who were now conscious turned the stuff into metaphor. And James is saying they didn't mean it as metaphor before. They meant it as literally and they didn't have descriptors for minds. And when they say the gods were guiding them along, they meant it literally. And he was saying that the Iliad in particular started to be written about 1100 BCE and then around 700 BCE it was like in its form that we see it today. But along the way it was kind of added to and it was written during the transition from bicameral mind to modern consciousness.
So he sees it as basically a document that traces that transition. Yeah, very interesting. There was some other stuff too, right, literature-wise? Yeah, so that wasn't the only one. He also found in some of the religious texts, like evidence that people felt like God had abandoned them. There's something, a Mesopotamian poem called the Ludlul Bel-Nemeke. And it says, my God has forsaken me and disappeared. My goddess has failed me and keeps at a distance. The good angel who walked beside me has departed. And again, most other scholars would say there's something happened. This guy was blue. He was in a funk.
Who knows? But it's all metaphorical. And James is saying, no, this guy had God talking to him. Now he doesn't anymore. So should we talk a little bit about actual science here with the brain? Yeah, I think so. Because this is something we've covered before in the past when we talked about alien hand syndrome. Oh, is that where it came up? From a gazillion years ago. So there was evidence that when the – there were certain epilepsy patients where it was so severe that they would sever the corpus callosum, undergo a corpus callostomy. And the corpus callosum is basically the thing that makes the two hemispheres of the brain communicate with one another.
And with alien hand syndrome, I think they found that it could be brought on by this surgery where all of a sudden the left arm was doing something and without being told to do it by the right brain. And they have – Janes, I think, or people since Janes – was it Janes or was it just people trying to sort of prove his theory? I think that people saw these experiments as support for Janes' theory. Okay, so they looked at these surgeries, these corpus colostomies, and they're called split brain patients, basically, where they, you know, after the surgery, it's not like they felt all out of whack.
They felt like a regular, you know, whole human being. But they learned that there were these little things that would pop up where a hemisphere would take an action based on this information that it didn't have access to. And the example they gave was if they instructed the right hemisphere to just walk to the kitchen, and they would get up and walk to the kitchen, but they would say, hey, why did you get up and walk to the kitchen? The language, the left hemisphere, the language-dominant hemisphere is the only part that can respond to that. But the left hemisphere doesn't know why it got up.
And the really fascinating part is that they wouldn't say, well, I don't know. I'm not sure why I just did that. I just did it. They would make something up on the spot and say, you know, I felt like getting up and going to make a bowl of cereal. Right. And it's almost like we had this natural instinct to BS somebody when faced with a question that we can't answer about why we did something. Yeah, because the left hemisphere wants to explain things. It wants to tell the story using metaphors usually. And this became the left brain interpreter theory. and it kind of supports Jane's idea that the consciousness is a flashlight looking for a dark spot in a room and it just can't find it.
And the idea is that the left hemisphere creates the explanation, the stories for our behavior, even if it doesn't know why we did something, but that's just what it does. And there's a saying in consciousness research among people who subscribe of the left brain interpreter theory is that consciousness isn't in the oval office like it thinks it is. It's more in the press office. Like it's the one that's public facing and explaining what you're doing, but it might not have all the information. So sometimes it's just BSing. That's very interesting stuff. Yeah. And sort of tying in with the kid thing, who is this, how do you pronounce the name of that one researcher?
Kuchin? Ashton Kuchar? K-U-I-J-S-T-E-N. Oh, yeah. I'm just going to say Kustin. I think that's pretty dead on. That's the person who runs the Julian Jaynes Society. Today, because Jaynes died in 1997. I don't think we ever pointed that out. Yeah. But this person basically says, hey, if you look at people who hear voices, and that's not necessarily to say someone that has schizophrenia because that is 1% of the population. Apparently as high as 10% of the population can, you know, does hear things basically. So these, it's the idea of the command voice basically is to do something. And if you're hearing a voice that says, you know, move to the window and look out on the street, that's one thing.
If you hear a voice that says, take the knife from the drawer and put it in someone's head, then that's another thing altogether. And we were talking about kids earlier. The idea of the imaginary friend kind of jives with this lack of consciousness. 65% of kids have imaginary friends. I had imaginary friends. My daughter had for years what she called her ghost friends, which is a lot creepier way to put it. But I think that's all just sort of to say that like that 9% of people who are hearing voices who are not suffering from schizophrenia is that's proof of that initial bicameral mind at work, right?
Yeah, and I mean, Julian Jaynes believed that children go from a bicameral state to a conscious state as evidenced by that development of theory of mind or as evidenced by imaginary friends. and that they're kind of recreating what society or the human species went through thousands of years ago as they age and develop. Very interesting. So you might be out there, especially if you're a concretist like Chuck, thinking like you might be rocking in your seat right now, face flushed, about to faint out of rage. Oh, wait, is my camera on? because like this is by definition unscientific. It's not provable in the form that Jane's put it forth.
It's more of a concept, an idea. And apparently he was well aware of that. He didn't tout it as anything more than that. But Kustin, the director of the Julian Jane Society, likes to point out that he was basically laying the groundwork for an entirely new way of looking at things so that other people could come along and, you know, take it up and figure out how he was wrong, how he was right, what needed fleshing out, what made sense in that form. And people have been doing that. Again, this is like a crackpot theory that has never gone away because the more people pay attention to it and the more we start to understand about the brain, the more sense it kind of makes.
and it seems to be gaining traction rather than losing it over the like 50 years that it's been around. I think it's interesting. I don't hate this stuff. I'm not rocking in my chair. David Bowie loved it. He said that the origin of consciousness is the breakdown of bicameral mind. I think that was it. The book. Is that a song? No. He said it was one of the top 100 books to read. Oh, all right. I believe that. Totally. It's a very Bowie thing. For sure. And other people, too. And then one other thing, another way to put all this, to kind of sum it up, that I saw it put, is that we developed at some point back in history a left brain bias.
That's it. You know? Which kind of ties into your original view of the whole thing, which was, you know, they weren't conscious that they were conscious. Right. I like that. You got anything else? I might. but I might just not be aware of it. Man. As I said, this is the best episode we've ever done. Since Chuck giggled, which everybody loves, I think then it's time for Listener Mail. This is about the Freedom of the Press episode. And this was a Josh request. Hey, guys. How Freedom of the Press works struck a particular chord with me. I used to work as a science teacher, but was finding more and more students were being duped by pseudoscience on the internet and weren't being provided the tools to recognize this.
So I did a master's in library and information science and now a school librarian on a mission to vanquish disinformation. Awesome. While I've included the topic of journalism in terms of approaching news critically, as with any online source of information, your recent podcast on how freedom of the press works really inspired me to put forward more information and content about media freedoms and the risks for journalists. Here in Sweden, it's very easy to take freedom of the press for granted. Last year, in sympathy with my American colleagues, I put up a display of banned books tracked by the ALA, and each book had a tag listing the years and ranking a book was challenged, and I encouraged the students to guess what for.
It led to a lot of really good—I love this experiment with students— led to a lot of really good discussions. Many students hadn't realized the scale of how many books had been banned or challenged, were horrified to see their own favorite books on display, and were also shocked by the justification, as are we always. Now that COVID restrictions are being lifted, I'm very much looking forward to taking students to the world's first library of censored books, the Dawit Isaac Library in the Malmur Archives. That's an umlaut. Yeah. So that students can see the extent of limitations on the press and media freedoms around the world.
Thanks again for the fascinating show and all-around amazing series. Kind regards. Med vengliga helsningar. That must just be a salutation in Swedish. That comes from Ms. Alice Antonsen. She, her, hers. Thank you, Alice. That is amazing. I'm so glad we got to that listener mail because I've been proud of that person for a very long time, ever since that email came in. Totally. How about Sweden, huh? Keeping the American dream alive. I love it. And Chuck, also, before we sign off, there's something I've been meaning to address that you said earlier. You said you have a dumb brain. No, you don't.
Did I say that? Yeah, you did. Okay. So if you want to get in touch with us like Alice did and show the world what a hero you are, we would love to hear that kind of thing. You can email us to stuffpodcasts at iheartradio.com. Stuff You Should Know is a production of iHeart Radio. For more podcasts from iHeart Radio, visit the iHeart Radio app. Apple Podcasts are wherever you listen to your favorite shows. Living with an autoimmune condition isn't easy, and every journey is different. That's why Season 5 of Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition from Ruby Studio and Argenics, shares powerful firsthand stories from people with conditions like MG and CIDP.
Hosted by Martine Hackett, these conversations dive into what resilience really looks like through setbacks, breakthroughs, and finding strength in community. Listen on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Toyotathon is on! So stop by your local Toyota dealer for incredible year-end deals on the cars, trucks, and SUVs known for their legendary reliability. Like the stylish and efficient Camry, the ready-for-anything RAV4, or check out a rough-and-rugged Tacoma or Tundra. All with great financing and lease options available to qualified customers. Visit buyatoyota.
com to find out more. Toyota, let's go places. Support for the show comes from Public, the investing platform for those who take it seriously. On Public, you can build a multi-asset portfolio of stocks, bonds, options, crypto, and now generated assets, which allow you to turn any idea into an investable index with AI. It all starts with your prompt. From renewable energy companies with high free cash flow to semiconductor suppliers growing revenue over 20% year over year, you can literally type any prompt and put the AI to work. It screens thousands of stocks, builds a one-of-a-kind index, and let you backtest it against the S&P 500.
Then you can invest in a few clicks. Generated assets are like EFTs with infinite possibilities, completely customizable and based on your thesis, not someone else's. Go to public.com slash podcast and earn an uncapped 1% bonus when you transfer your portfolio. That's public.com slash podcast. Paid for by Public Investing. Brokerage services by Open to the Public Investing, Inc. Member FINRA SIPC. Advisory services by Public Advisors, LLC. SEC registered advisor. Generated assets is an interactive analysis tool. Output is for informational purposes only and is not investment recommendation or advice.
Complete disclosures available at public.com slash disclosures. And now, Superhuman Shack. I keep telling them not to say that. I'm no superhuman. Believe it or not, I struggle with moderate obstructive sleep apnea or OSA. In adults with obesity, moderate to severe OSA is a condition where breathing is interrupted during sleep with loud snoring, choking, gasping for air, and even daytime fatigue. Let's just say it can sound a lot like this. Sound familiar? Learn more at dontsleeponosa.com. This information is provided by Lilly, a medicine company. This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human.