Economists love their data because somewhere in the numbers lies the answer to the ills of the country. They also love to frame data in a way people can relate to. Such is the case with the famous "misery index."
Learn more about your ad-choices at https://www.iheartpodcastnetwork.com
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
No summary for this episode yet.
This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed Human. Banking with Capital One helps you keep more money in your wallet with no fees or minimums on checking accounts and no overdraft fees. Just ask the Capital One Bank Guy. It's pretty much all he talks about, in a good way. He'd also tell you that this podcast is his favorite podcast, too. Thanks, Capital One Bank Guy. What's in your wallet? Terms apply. See CapitalOne.com slash bank. Capital One N-A, member FDIC. 250 years ago, a promise was made to connect family and friends near and far. And during the holidays, that promise is more important than ever.
That's why USPS is building a better network to meet your needs. With timely deliveries, easy and affordable ways to ship, and everything you need to make your season full of holiday cheer. Their purpose is delivering your peace of mind, knowing your love will arrive, bringing joy to all. The United States Postal Service. Learn more at USPS.com slash holidays. Welcome to Stuff You Should Know from HowStuffWorks.com. Hey and welcome to the podcast. I'm Josh Clark and there's Charles W. Chuck Bryant. The W stands for Wayne. Dwayne Coyne. That gets you every time. I know. It's funny to be 45 years old and named after Wayne Coyne.
He's like 48, right? No, he's in his 50s. 50s too. But it would be weird. I would have been named after a very kindergarten age Wayne Coyne. Right. Maybe your parents were friends with his parents and they really thought a lot about him. Boy, he's a real achiever. Right. Get Wayne Coyne going places. Okay. That was a weird sidetrack. It was already out of the gate, man. How are you feeling? I'm good. Got a lot on your plate? Got a lot going on? Meh. Oh, you know what today is? What? Dude, today is the day that I leave this office and I go to a shop in Inman Park and pick up four brand new Last Chance Garage hats.
Oh, wow. It's a big day. Very big day. Big day. So I have a couple of people I'd like to thank. It's a bigger deal than it should be for a grown man in a hat, but we all understand. First of all, Katie, my custom patch maker, this is really where it all came together. If the patch isn't right, the hat's not right. Right. Katie killed it. It looks identical. And you can find her work at tulipcake.com. Nice. T-U-L-I-P, cake. And I said, you know, people might ask you to make them last chance garage patches. Did you ever destroy the mold? And I said, you know, it's on you. It's up to you legally.
I'm just saying you might get requests. You should have been like Ivan the Terrible who blinded his architects after they built his palace. No, I don't care. People, I'd love to see these things around. And Lamoud Big Hats, L-A-M-O-O-D, for big heads. Because part of the problem was finding. A big and tall hat? Yeah, man. Like the problem I have with hats these days, I don't look like I have a huge head. No. They just fit so snugly and they don't go far down enough on my head. So I finally looked up oversized hats and found Lammut hats. And, dude, they're exactly like the old hat. Nice. Except it doesn't stink.
Oh, yeah. These are great. I got four brand new ones. That's an improvement for sure. So are you going to put one in like the seed vault in Norway? Probably one there. There will be one in the nuclear suitcase. And I'll wear the other two. at the same time. At the same time. Front and back like Sherlock Holmes. That's right. Anyway, I'm super excited. That's pretty cool. Thank you to Katie and Lamoud Hats for allowing me to spend too much money getting four hats remade. And speaking of, while we're thanking people, we owe a long overdue thank you to a guy who made us a really cool sign. Oh, you mean the sign this guy made for us like seven years ago?
Yeah. His name's Matt Street. He's at fatbison.com. I mean, he made a really cool wood carved sign. Yeah, it was in our TV show. It was. Like the production company got clearance rights for it and all this stuff. And we love the sign. But we just forgot to ever thank Matt. So, Matt, thank you so much for the sign. We love it. We have it hanging here in the studio. It is a work of art. And we appreciate it. And we're sorry for the oversight. Yeah. Okay. Is that all the thank yous? I think so. Let's talk about the misery index, huh? Yeah. What a great transition. Had you heard of it before you came across this article?
Yeah. I didn't know a lot about it, though. Apparently, it's gone a little bit out of fashion lately, from what I understand. Yeah, I think so. Because, well, let's get into it. Okay. It turns out economics as a whole is in danger of going out of fashion. Oh, yeah? I read this really interesting article on Aeon, which is maybe the greatest website on the planet. Aeon. It might be .co, because I think it's British. You say that about a lot of websites. I think I say it about Aeon a lot. Okay. And it just seems like I'm talking about different ones. But there's this article by Alan J. Levinowitz, and it's called The New Astrology.
And he basically makes a parallel between economics and economists and economic theory when you take economics and try to apply it to future forecasting. Right. And the BCE Chinese astrologers that basically directed the way that the economy or the government was going to move based on the movements of the stars. So what are they saying? You might as well just do that? He draws some pretty interesting parallels between the two. That economics in and of itself is not necessarily flawed, but when it's used to forecast the future, then it becomes inherently flawed. Yeah. This article really kind of – Submits that.
Yeah, a little bit. Yeah, to an extent. I mean, the misery index is a legitimate economic tool, and it's hit or miss in a lot of ways. Yeah, I think one thing that hit home to me with researching this is it just seems impossible to say that there's one correct way of doing things. Right. That is absolute. And you're like, you know, if you do things this way, then there will be nothing but growth in jobs and the GDP. Sure. And GNP. And it just doesn't seem to work that way. Right. I think the problem is, is that if you listen to economists, they like to act like they do have a handle on that kind of thing.
But if you really look into economics, it's very politicized. There's liberal economics and there's conservative economics. And the fact that each one's saying it's right kind of makes you think that maybe no one is. But the misery index actually is it started out from a guy who was pretty good at walking the line between conservative and liberal economics. A guy, what was his name? Okun. Yeah, Arthur Okun. Right. And he worked on Kennedy's staff, his Council of Economic Advisors, John F. Kennedy, that is. And he was, I get the feeling, one of the main influences in talking Kennedy, who initially did not necessarily agree, but talking Kennedy into kind of trying to enact both conservative and liberal economic policies simultaneously.
Right. The U.S. was in a recession when Kennedy took office in 1961. And they talked him into not only increasing government spending like welfare programs, they raised the minimum wage and some other stuff like that. But they also cut taxes, which you do one or the other. You cut taxes and hope everything goes for the best because businesses will start investing in spending. Or you start investing in welfare programs to help your ailing lower and middle classes, right? You don't do both. Yeah. And Kennedy did both, and it was successful. Yeah. Well, at first he said, I don't know about this.
I don't know about this, Arthur. Mike Kennedy sounds like a robot. Mine kind of did too, actually. Yours is fine. But Arthur, Mr. Okun. Okun? Okun. I think Okun. Okun. It's a weird name. O-K-U-N. He talked him into it and said, trust me. And things worked out in that case. Yeah, well, and a lot of guys, including Okun's names, were made by this advice that panned out. Like the U.S. entered a boom. Yeah. And Okun ended up as being the head of the Council of Economic Advisors for Kennedy's successor, Lyndon Johnson, right? Yeah. And one thing that economists love to do is, I mean, they love to forecast and all that stuff, but it's all about data.
Sure. And, man, they love to pour over data. Yeah. Like stuff that makes the average person, their mind bleed from boredom. They just find it fascinating. That's what they do on Friday nights. Friday nights. They pour over data, historical data, trying to find – it's like the big puzzle, and they're all trying to solve it. Right. So they pour over this data, Okun did, and he said, you know what? I noticed something here. Between 1948, when we started recording some decent unemployment rates. Right. Which I didn't know. I didn't know we started that in 1948. Yeah, it seems like it would have gone back before then.
But between 1948 and 1960, he said, you know what? I've noticed that the gross national product rises 3% for every percentage point that unemployment falls with the caveat that unemployment has to be between 3% and 7.5%. Right. Which is a pretty bold statement to say I've noticed this is a definite trend. It is. And it came to be called Okun's Law because it was verified. Other people poured over the data in and were like, this guy's right. Man, he just keeps coming up with hits, doesn't he? That's right. And the reason you would want to know some arcane piece of data like that is that if you know that that's the case, then you can say, well, if we attack unemployment and can get it down a couple of points, we can raise GDP or GMP by 3% every time we drop it.
So when we need to bulk GMP up, we just attack unemployment, right? Right. Easy peasy. Yeah. And everyone said, thank you, Art. Yeah, things worked out pretty well for a while, but then the 1970s came along. And we're going to talk a little bit about stagflation now, but if you haven't heard it, we have a pretty good episode. Was it good? I think so. Okay. It's called What is Stagflation from February 24, 2011. Yeah, I think as far as our economics episodes, it was not bad. Okay. I went back and listened to a lot of it. Oh, okay, good. Before I got bored. So it checks out? Yeah, the first three minutes were great.
But yeah, go back and listen to that. But like he said, he served as chairman of the CEA for Johnson. And then in 1973, a very unfortunate thing happened that kind of ended up rocking the world and the United States in particular with our economy. So we're going to take a break and we're going to talk when we get back about the Middle East. The universe is full of mysteries. Black holes, quantum physics, galaxies. On TikTok, millions of people are learning more about the universe around them every day. Scientists break down complex theories, demonstrate experiments, and connect dots between the cosmos and our daily lives.
One scroll might reveal the concepts on the fabric of space-time, the next an optical illusion. It's discovery on a massive scale, where millions learn something new every day. You know, everyone living with a rare autoimmune condition has their own story to tell. And that's why in Season 5 of Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition, a Ruby Studio production, in partnership with Argenix, you'll hear powerful, real-life perspectives. That's right. This podcast explores stories of what life is really like with MG or CIDP. Host Martine Hackett sits down with people who faced it all, the early signs and symptoms, the search for answers, and the strength it takes to keep moving forward.
Yeah, and this season, the stories go even deeper, showing us what resilience truly looks like through setbacks, breakthroughs, and the communities that make all the difference. So listen to Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition, on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Alright, what happened in 1973? I'm two years old. I am negative three. the Arab oil embargo happened, right? That's right. So at the time, until very recently, the U.S. was super dependent on foreign oil. Yeah. Like other countries we wouldn't even sit down at the table with, we were getting oil from, right?
Yeah, we're doing better now. Yeah. With our dependency, but back then, very bad. Very. And it was a source of anxiety for a lot of people, and that anxiety actually panned out. So in 1973, Egypt and Syria and a few other Arab nations invaded the Golan Heights and the Sinai Peninsula to attempt to take back land from the state of Israel. That's right. The U.S. was found to be supplying arms to Israel. So as far as the Arab states were concerned, the U.S. had cast its lot on Israel's side. Yeah. And they were fairly peeved about that. So they literally shut off the tap of oil flowing to the United States and to other countries that were found considered to be on the side of Israel in this war.
Huge deal. It was an enormous deal. This foreign dependency and the precarious situation that it placed the United States in came to pass. And the price of oil rose 37%. The long lines at the gas station were never seen before or since, even after the financial crisis of 2008. Yeah. It was just insane. There was gas rationing in the United States in 1973 because of the oil embargo. And after a while, the tariffs were turned back on. But that shock to the system screwed the economy up for a decade. Yeah. Inflation went out of control. and another unfortunate thing happened. Along the same timeline, unemployment started to creep up.
And these two things happening at the same time is devastating. Yeah, and up to this point, so first of all, the U.S. had never had a shock to the system like that. That was one thing. Yeah, it wasn't a gradual thing. No, it was abrupt. Yeah. But the other thing is when you have something that has never happened before, you can look at it and say, wow, what happened? And new things that have never happened before come out of that. And one of the things was inflation and unemployment going up. Because up to this point, economists just assumed that the two were mutually exclusive. If inflation was up, prices were high, that meant that companies could go out and hire more people.
Yeah. So unemployment, of course, would be low. Yeah, it kind of made sense. Well, not after the oil embargo. The shock to the system led to, like you said, high unemployment rates and high inflation. And it was a miserable time. Yeah. And that was called stagflation. It also led to skateboarding, as we all know. Oh, yeah, because of the pools, right? Yeah. Well, actually, that was the drought. But I think the drought was also tied into the economics. Sure. But they couldn't fill up swimming pools, so they started skating in swimming pools. Well, yeah, if you have a drought, then you lose your crops.
And if you lose your crops, you lose money, a significant sector of money. Exactly. So good news. We have half pipes now. And quarter pipes. And Powell Peralta. And Powell and Peralta. They're still around, right? I think so, yeah. Of course. Bad news is, like you said, it had a devastating effect for many, many years on the United States. Right. So Okun starts to look around. He said, you know what? Things are pretty bad here. One might even say miserable. I haven't gotten any acclaim for a while. Yeah. Nothing's been named after me in a while. All right. So let me create this new method for looking at the economy.
And it turns out to not be like a look over a period of time or anything, but just sort of like a Polaroid of that day. And not just that day for like the country as a whole or for the Fed or anything like that. But what he did that was different was he looked into what it was like that day or that year for the average American in their daily life. Right. And he called it the misery index. Yeah. And it was very rudimentary at the time. It was just a simple calculation of the yearly rate of inflation plus the unemployment rate. Yeah. So if you have like 5% inflation and 2% unemployment, you have a 7% misery index.
It's as simple as that. I don't know why it got so much, you know, why it was hailed as a big deal. Because I think Okun had a knack for noticing things that seemed obvious in retrospect. Right. But at the time, no one had ever noticed before. Okay. I'll buy it. Thank you. Why not? All right. So now he has this index. And not only can he look at a snapshot of that day, he can go back because he was a data wonk. Sure. And he could look at data throughout history. Well, at least in 1948. Yeah. Which is when we started recording unemployment, like we said. Which must have been frustrating for him because our inflation rates data goes back to 1914.
But that's only part of the equation. So he must have been like, oh, man. Sure. And to be able to look at the Great Depression, you could have learned a lot. Sure. So he went and he looked back and he says, here is what we've noticed. And this is so obvious to me that presidents and political parties are brought in and out of office largely depending on how the economy is doing. Yeah. But they kind of proved it. But not even just how the economy is doing. He was saying the misery index, you can use it to predict whether the presidency is going to change hands politically. Yeah. So 1956, misery index is 6.
53, which is great. That's during Ike. Yeah, very low. Mr. Eisenhower, President Eisenhower. And he got reelected because things were pretty good. Right. As far as the misery index goes. Yeah. Yeah. Everybody was pretty happy. Even though they didn't really know what the misery index was because it wasn't invented yet. Right. They just had a general sense. Well, yeah. They didn't call it that at the time. No. They were just like, seems fine to me. You miserable? We like Ike. No, I'm not miserable. Are you? So in 1968, Johnson came to the end of his term and the misery index was up to 8.13. And then he had his democratic successor, Hubert Humphrey, in line.
and because the thing had crept up, people a little more miserable, and they said, no, get out of here. I want Mr. Nixon in office. Right, and I guess I'm not sure about this, so I don't understand why Johnson was replaced by Humphrey by the Democrats. And this article seems to be because of this misery index that it would have predicted that. But he was the incumbent president in his own party. Oh, is he only a one-termer? so let's see so he was he would have i should know this no he yeah he was a one-termer technically one in a third or one in a quarter because he took over after kennedy's assassination but if his term was up in 68 then he would have won the 64 election so he technically i think would have been able to have been president again i'm not sure we could have found this out too sure but i'll bet there's somebody out there who can explain it to us and so email us will you At any rate, Nixon gets elected, and the misery index shot up to 11.
67 during the first term, but then started to decline enough that he did get reelected. But then, in 1974 with Watergate, the misery index leapt all the way up to 17.01. That's not good. No. That was the all-time high at the time, from what I understand. I think so. And that happened around 1974, which meant that when Watergate broke, some people who really subscribe to the misery index say Watergate might not have been quite as big a deal if the misery index had been low at the time. Right. He might have been able to squeak by without resigning or being forced out of office. I think everyone has more leeway if things are great.
Sure. But his currency had been spent. Man, I watched All the President's Men a few weeks ago again. Yeah. You ever seen that? No. Great, great movie. Yeah. I've always meant to. Really, really good. And just sort of like, they don't make a lot of movies like that anymore. Spotlight reminded me of All the President's Men. Sure. I haven't seen that one yet either. It's good. It's just, I call it movies for adults. You know, there's no chase scenes or anything remarkable. It's just good, dramatic movie making. Yeah. Good stuff. Anyway. Wait, what's wrong with chase scenes? Huh? What's wrong with chase scenes?
No, there's nothing inherently wrong with the chase scene. I know what you mean. Just for the sake of a chase scene, which we see a lot of these days. You know what I mean? Like Mark Ruffalo's chasing a priest in a car in the spotlight. Yeah. Where were we? Okay, we were with Nixon. Well, not with Nixon. You know what I mean. Ford comes in office for a short time. And he actually managed to get the misery index down. Well, I think just the fact that Nixon was out, I think that probably helped. and inspire consumer confidence and the like. So it crept back down to 12.66, but not enough to keep the Democrats and Jimmy Carter from coming into office.
And Carter actually cited the misery index. It was relatively new at the time. Yeah, he talked too much about it. But it was a gee whiz thing that you could really just point to, like this plus this, this is the misery index. Can you hear me? Yeah. That's my quote. That was his famous quote. Can you hear me? It came back to haunt him, though, to say the least, because he talked a lot about the misery index. And then in his term, the it reached an all time high of twenty one point nine eight. Yeah. Which, man, I really think that shock to the system under the oil embargo and plenty of other stuff.
This stuff gets laid at Carter's feet, I think, unfairly in a lot of respects. Well, I mean, I would love for someone to really that really knows their stuff to explain to me exactly how much a president's influence has on the economy and how long it takes for that to bear fruit. Yeah, I would love to know that, too. I think, though, the guy who came after Carter, Reagan, is a pretty sterling, unassailable example of an impact a president can have on the economy. Whether you agree with his politics or his economic policies or not, he most decidedly had an effect on the economy. Yeah, I just remember hearing one time, I need to look this up, but somebody told me once that the economic impact of a presidential four-year term is felt the most like eight years later or something.
Yeah, that makes sense to me. Economies don't move on a dime. Yeah, I just don't know if that's correct. They're big, hulking, lumbering things that aren't fully understood by anybody. Yeah, it's interesting to me now more than ever before, though, because remember, economics used to just bore me to tears. I know. I was really, really surprised when you suggested this one. It's slightly more interesting to me now. What changed? Oh, just wondering things like that during an election season. Yeah. Like, are the decisions we make now going to affect us in one year, two years, eight years? Mm-hmm.
Yeah. Well, if there's any economists who are still listening after that initial remark about the new astrology, we'd love to get a primer on how long it takes for a president to impact an economy, if they do at all. And I'm sure it's a range, you know. Sure. It's not like starting at eight years. And really, honestly, was Carter that bad or was he a victim of cross stars? Yeah. I mean, you can make a case where a lot of bills of presidencies not being directly at their feet. Well, you remember that Simpsons where they unveiled a statue of Jimmy Carter in Springfield and on the pedestal it says malaise forever.
And somebody goes, Jimmy Carter, he's history's greatest monster. Poor Carter. So, like we said, it came back to haunt Carter because he talked a lot about the index. It rose a lot. Then Reagan came in and was like, well, let's talk about that misery index that you like to talk about so much. Right. That's at an all-time high. Reagan got in there, knocked it down to 9.55 by the end of his term, enough to get Bush Sr. in. It inched up some. Then Clinton was able to – it didn't go up that much, though. And I read an interesting article today on whether or not Ross Perot really got Clinton elected because that's sort of the popular thought.
He was a spoiler? Yeah. I could see that. He was definitely more in line with Bush senior's policies than Clinton's at the time. Yeah, you would think. But I read I read one article that said that it was kind of a myth that basically that Clinton won by six million votes and it would have taken 75 percent of Perot supporters to have been aligned with with Bush. And supposedly exit polls showed it more like 38 to 40 percent. And so they're saying it's sort of a myth that Perot swung the election to Clinton. I see. But, I mean, that was one person's opinion, so who knows? You know, I've been reading a lot about – you know that suspicion you can't quite kick that there's really no difference between Republicans and Democrats these days, that they're really just kind of all in the same little club?
I think people feel that way sometimes. I've been reading a lot about that, and apparently it's all based on neoliberalism. That's like the key. Oh, yeah. And there's a lot of – if you look into neoliberalism and the policies of neoliberalism, you realize we're like living in the thick of it. But no one – everyone's kind of blind to the idea that it's just a single thing that basically everybody in power subscribes to. Right. And that it has a trickle-down effect of screwing over everybody below the top. Yeah. But just the name itself seems totally fine, you know, but it's interesting. Yeah, I researched that a little bit lately, too.
Yeah. There's been some good articles. We totally should. Yeah. Let's do it, Chuck. Agreed. Man, we're going to get some emails for that one from billionaires. Yeah. So let's just finish out this quick little recap. Clinton brought it down to 7.35. Things were great. Bush Jr. gets elected, despite the fact that Clinton had a low index. Well, it depends on how you look at the 2000 election. We should do one on that one, too. But that's considered one of those rare instances where the misery index didn't indicate where it was going to go. But you could also say it might have had things gone slightly differently in the Supreme Court.
George W. Bush, the index rose from 7.35 to 11.4. And then Obama came in and it went down to 7.87. But another weird flaw in the system is exposed there because despite the fact that the misery index was lower, things were not good. The stock market had crashed. Unemployment was rising at a rapid rate. And they said, you know, this it basically was another example of like, look, this misery index isn't all it's cracked up to be. Right. So let's work on it. Yeah. I think a lot of people said this is too simplistic. You can't rely on this. But we'll talk about some of the additional factors that people have worked into the misery index after this.
Our listeners love puzzles, paradoxes and hidden patterns almost as much as we do. On TikTok, those fascinations come to life. People are breaking down physics, exploring geology and explaining why the world works the way it does. You'll see impressive experiments, explanations that finally make sense, and connections you didn't expect. It's like having a lab, a lecture hall, and science museum in your pocket. TikTok is where wonder is shared, where curiosity turns into discovery, and where millions learn something new every day. You know, everyone living with a rare autoimmune condition has their own story to tell.
And that's why in Season 5 of Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition, a Ruby Studio production, in partnership with Argenix, you'll hear powerful, real-life perspectives. That's right. This podcast explores stories of what life is really like with MG or CIDP. Host Martine Hackett sits down with people who faced it all, the early signs and symptoms, the search for answers, and the strength it takes to keep moving forward. Yeah, and this season, the stories go even deeper, showing us what resilience truly looks like through setbacks, breakthroughs, and the communities that make all the difference.
So listen to Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition, on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. All right, Chuck. So the misery index, Oaken, everybody's happy with him. Yeah. They're like, this is just too simple, especially in what's called the post-stagflation era after the oil embargo. Yeah. And so some people have said, okay, you can, there's certainly, there's other things you can add in to give a genuine, true snapshot of what the conditions are like on the ground, as it were. Right? Well, yeah, not only what the conditions are, but whether or not performance over a period of time is getting better or getting worse.
Yes. And rather than say, oh, under this president, the misery index was this, and it gives you a pretty good idea. Yeah. This one guy named Robert Barrow, he wrote a 1996 book called Getting It Right, Markets and Choices in a Free Society. And in it, he takes the misery index, Okun's misery index, and he says, we can add some stuff to this to make it an even clearer picture, not just of the conditions underground, but you can take it and apply it genuinely to a president's entire term to see just how good their economic policies were or weren't for the health of the economy. And he added some other stuff.
Yeah, he added four main new measurements. took the inflation rate during the last year of the president's term compared it to the average inflation rate over the entire course of the subsequent president's term. Which is based on what you were saying, that like a four-year term, the effects are felt like years down the road. Sure. So I think that's what he was doing there, right? Yeah, it makes sense. He did the same thing with the rate of unemployment. That was number two. He added in changes for the 30-year government bond yield over presidency. And then finally, he said, I need to look at the difference between the long-term GDP growth and the real rate of growth.
Right. Compare all these things along with the original this plus this equals this. Right. And with the real growth rate, that's where you take the actual change, either the shrinking or the growth of the economy, the GDP, year over year. Right. And he took that for year after year over the course of a presidency and averaged it out, I guess. That's right. Yeah, and he came up with what's called the Barrow Misery Index. And a lot of people think that that's where the Misery Index started when, in fact, it was Oaken who came up with it about 20 years before Barrow took it up and improved it. Yeah.
So under Barrow's Misery Index, Clinton and Reagan, that's Bill Clinton, of course, came out on top. And then a guy named Steve Henke about 10 years later. This was originally in 1996, and then Hankey came along in 2006 and said, you know what? We need to add even more things. And this all just makes sense. You need to, if you want a more detailed picture, then add more detail to the data going in, you know? Right. So he said, we need more detail. Why don't we do this? Let's measure inflation and unemployment like we're doing, and then let's now add interest rates and subtract annual percentages from the GDP to get a more accurate picture.
Right. And he said, you can use this anywhere. You can use it all over the world. Well, that's what he did, and that's kind of what made his version of it pretty famous. He figured out how to apply it to other countries, even countries that used price controls to keep inflation in check, which means inflation is held back artificially. So Hanke looked into other things like the exchange rate in the black market in a given country, that kind of thing. And he figured out real inflation rates. And he applied it around the world to find out what country is the most miserable and what country is the least miserable.
And what he found in 2014 was that the most miserable country in the world was Venezuela, which had a hanky misery index of 79.4. It's pretty high. Very high. And then Japan had the lowest misery at 5.41. Yeah, the U.S. came in at about 19, correct? I think 11. Oh, 11th? Yeah. No, no, no. 11 was our... Oh, I'm sorry. 19th. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, ranked 19th with an 11 rating. I didn't hear the... Yeah, because my tooth is still gone. You'd think it'd be more pronounced. The THs. If it were 19th, I would have heard it clear as a bell. August. Can't get here soon enough. So there are critics of this one, too, though.
There's critics of all these indexes. Yeah, a lot of them say, nope, still too elementary. Yeah. Some people say this is all just tripe. Like you can't use this stuff to make any real predictions. You could use it to look back at the past, but to use it for the future, probably not. But some people do believe in the idea that if you have enough data and the right kind of data, you can get a clearer picture of misery. And again, that's what we're after here. The whole point of the misery index is to figure out how unhappy and just low the average person in a country is feeling at that moment. Yeah.
Right? So HuffPo actually came up with a pretty good one. HuffPo. Boo! Yay! In 2009, HuffPo came up with what they called the real misery index, right? And so a lot of people cite the use of what's called U3 unemployment statistics. Which when you hear unemployment numbers in the news, that's what you're hearing. That's what the Bureau of Labor Statistics issues as the official unemployment numbers, right? Yeah, and that's the very first thing that people will say if they want to poo-poo the unemployment numbers. That these are just false numbers. Yeah, if someone says, hey, man, look how great X president is doing.
Look at the unemployment rate. They say, man, they're just using the U3. They need to use the U6. Wake up, pal. Open your eyes. Which, you know, is valid. Well, yeah. So the BLS has six measurements of unemployment, U1 through U6. And U6 is the broadest. Yeah. It includes people who are so discouraged with the state of the job market that they've given up looking for work and are just like have given themselves over entirely to Judge Alex. Sure. Right. And then it also includes people who are working part-time but wish they could work full-time, but there's no full-time work available. Yeah, like I'm a graphic designer, but I work at Starbucks.
So that's the U6 measurement, and that's considered the broadest snapshot of unemployment, the real vision of unemployment. Yeah, like you said, mostly they use U3, I guess because it's in the middle. I mean, U1, they would never use. U2. everybody used to like but not anymore I still like U2 yeah you know not like I used to I'm not poo pooing anything but I did see that concert they did on HBO and I have to hand it to them my big problem with U2 for years was that they just got so out of control with those live shows like these giant spider spaceships and things and I was always of the belief that, man, you need to go back to basics and just get up on stage and play again.
Yeah. And that's what they did with this new tour. I mean, there was a cool visual element, but the stage setup and the way they did it was very much back to basics. Oh, that's cool. I think they really connected with fans again. Yeah, that's got to help. Yeah. Because when the interactions between you and the fans rather than the fans and giant spiders. Yeah, you can only go so far in that direction. I think they realize that. Sure. Anyway. Way to go, you two. I'll defend those guys. Even though I know everyone in the world generally wants to punch Bono in the face. I know. I'm not one of them.
It's got to feel weird. I like him. Yeah, I'm on record. Sure. Bono, if you're listening. Well, if your Jared indicator is any predictor, Bono's going to come out to be canonized one day. If what? Oh, yeah, yeah. You're like, there's something about Jared. I don't like him. And, you know, we found out about Jared. Right. And then now you're saying, I like Bono's. Good guy. Something's going to, like, they're going to find a cure for cancer in his saliva or something. You never know. So did we even mention what the HuffPo, what kind of outrageous numbers they came up with? No, we didn't mention everything they used.
We were talking about the U6 measurement. HuffPo used that measurement. The most extreme one. Of unemployment numbers. They also used other things like the inflation rate of food and drink and fuel and health care because the misery index just uses the consumer price index, which is inflation as a whole. HuffPo used the inflation of some really essential things that people can't do without and where you're going to immediately feel the pinch when prices go up with those key factors. Right. They also included the rate of credit card delinquency, the cost of housing, how many people are using food stamps.
Yeah. That seems like a smart move. Totally. Home equity loan deficiencies. I guess people who are late on their payments. And they took the average of those seven numbers and added it to the U6 unemployment numbers, which here you can step back and say, wait a minute. How would you how are you adding this together? How does this make any sense? You can't just keep adding things. Right. And really, you can take that all the way back to the initial misery index. Like, what? You're just adding unemployment percentage and inflation, and all of a sudden you have a magic number? That doesn't make any sense.
This HuffPo metric really points out the inherent flaw in it, I think. Yeah, because in 2008, the Okun misery index was 8.1, but HuffPo's real misery index, a.k.a. you think things are bad, here's how bad they really are index, was 29.9 compared to the 8.1. Right. And some people are like, oh, well, that just shows how off the Oaken misery index is. Yeah. Who knows? I know they quit doing the real misery index at HuffPo like five years ago. I think it was a, am I going to call it a stunt? It was a bit of a stunt. Maybe. But I'm sure really what happened was the writer who was contributing it for free.
Sure. Like left for a paying job. That's probably what happened to the HuffPo real misery index. Yeah, you're probably right. I was reading this guy, Tim McMahon. He has a site, or he writes for a site. I'm not sure if it's his or not, called InflationData.com. Jim McMahon? Tim McMahon, his brother. Gotcha. Not the Super Bowl shuffle. No, his brother. Okay. So he mentioned this 2001 paper that concluded that unemployment causes 1.7 times more misery than inflation. And so if you're doing any kind of misery index that uses those two, you need to first multiply the unemployment number by 1.7 before adding it to the inflation number to properly weight it.
I'm like, how did they come up with that? So I looked at the paper and it was actually pretty clever. There's like 23 years of this survey of life satisfaction and happiness that these researchers looked at back in 2001. And they found that… Economically based or just like how happy are you? No, here's the thing. It was how happy are you? It was like a single question. Like, would you say, based on how you're feeling right now, that you are fairly satisfied, unsatisfied, very satisfied with your life right now, right? And then they took that measurement for that country as a whole. And you can do this for any country that participated in the survey.
And then they looked at inflation. And then they looked at unemployment for those years. And they could figure out the variation between or the interplay between unemployment and inflation and satisfaction. And they found that unemployment was 1.7 times more miserable than inflation in regards to life satisfaction, as that survey goes. Pretty clever. Yeah. It's a lot of hocus pocus, but I thought it was pretty clever how they did it. That makes sense to me because to be without work, like if you have a job and things, inflation is happening, you still have your job. Sure. And you're like, man, this sucks to pay this much more, but you can still conceivably pay for it.
Yeah. I'll cut back here or there. Right. If you're unemployed, then there's not a lot of hope. Right. Yeah. That number might be conservative. Yeah. Yeah. I agree with you. Very interesting stuff, sir. So that's it, man. That's the misery index. Mm-hmm. You got anything else? No, but I'm looking forward to hearing from economists that – Me too. Like in an unbiased way, try to explain things. Me too. If you send just these crazy political emails, they're going to fall in deaf ears because everyone yells at each other that they're right. I just want to hear some real numbers. Yeah. Do it, Chuck.
If you want to know more about the Misery Index, you can type those words in the search bar at HowStuffWorks.com. And since I said search bar, just plain old search bar, it's time for listener mail. I'm going to call this a follow-up on Vocal Fry once again. Oh, yeah. Regarding Vocal Fry, guys, you guys were offended because someone said Vocal Fry was repulsive. But there is another side to this, dudes. I suffer from a neurological disorder known as misophonia, which we totally should do a show on this. I agree. It's a condition where a person has extreme emotional response to commonly occurring sounds.
And I remember hearing a lot of times just like people chewing noises or gum or whatever. He said, in my case, my trigger noise is the high-pitched S sound when some people speak. It feels like my brain is cringing as if an allergic reaction is taking place. Cannot stress enough, this is not a mere annoyance. It's a legitimate mental disorder that can vary greatly in severity. I don't visibly freak out when I hear my trigger noise, but it really kills me inside. It gives me an instant headache, which is why I will get away from the noise if at all possible. I believe in avoiding complaining in life and playing the victim, but this disorder really has made my life like a subtle hell.
It's been especially toxic to my family relationships and my ability to learn in school. I felt compelled to email you guys because you definitely appreciate interesting medical conditions. I think would be a great topic for a show someday. There's a documentary about it called Quiet, Please. If you watch the trailer, you might be inspired to watch it to learn what the condition is. Oh, yeah. Huge thanks to everyone at Stuff You Should Know. You make mundane parts of my life interesting and educational. I'm going to anonymize this from Texas because I didn't hear back from them. From Tex. Yeah, Tex.
P.S. I was in disbelief when Chuck said he had not seen Billy Madison or Happy Gilmore. That's a good PS. Believe it. It's a good postscript. And post-PPS, right? Not PSS. I think it's post-postscript. Yeah, but people often put PSS. It doesn't mean anything. Do you think Stuff You Should Know could ever become a television show? No. Well, Tex. Never. We actually did that. We found out the hard way that it came. Yeah, we did a TV show on the Science Channel. And it ran for one full season that played out over the course of several days. Which we'll always have, Chuck. We'll always have that season of television we did once.
It lasted nine or ten days. Yeah. Let's just show them all at once. Yeah. Out of order. But you never know. We might get another shot at stardom. But we're not looking to it. No. I like it in this room where no one's looking at us. Yeah. Jerry doesn't even look at us. No. She's just there looking away. In disgust. That's right. Good idea about the misophonia. I think we mentioned that before. I really liked that vocal fry episode. And that was the one thing that I wish we would have mentioned. Because it's a legitimate thing. It does affect some people. But yeah, look for a misophonia episode at some point in the future.
Text. If you want to get in touch with us, we're all over social media. We're on Twitter and Instagram at SYSK Podcast. We're on Facebook.com slash Stuff You Should Know. You can send us an email to stuffpodcast at howstuffworks.com. And you can join us at our very own home on the web, StuffYouShouldKnow.com. For more on this and thousands of other topics, visit HowStuffWorks.com. Living with an autoimmune condition isn't easy, and every journey is different. That's why Season 5 of Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition from Ruby Studio and Argenix, shares powerful firsthand stories from people with conditions like MG and CIDP.
Hosted by Martine Hackett, these conversations dive into what resilience really looks like through setbacks, breakthroughs, and finding strength in community. Listen on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Attention parents and grandparents. If you're looking for a gift that's more than just a toy, give them something that inspires confidence and adventure all year long. Give them a Guardian bike, the easiest, safest, and number one kid's bike on the market. Yeah, with USA-made kid's specific frames and patented safety technology, kids are learning to ride in just one day with no training wheels needed.
It's why Guardian is America's favorite kid's bike and the New York Times and Wirecutter's top pick three years in a row. That's right. My daughter has a Guardian bike and she loves it. And that thing was really easy to put together. And get this, this holiday season, Guardian is offering their biggest deal of the year, over 40% in savings on all bikes, plus $100 in free accessories. Guardian bikes have become one of the most sought-after gifts of the season, and inventory is going fast, so don't wait. Join over a half a million families who've discovered the magic of Guardian. Visit guardianbikes.
com to shop now. This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human.