Main Topic: The effectiveness of tariffs in protecting American manufacturing, specifically in the case of Milton Magnus III, CEO of M&B Hangers, who waged a 20-year trade war to protect his family's business from Chinese imports.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Ryan Knutson
Welcome to The Journal. I'm Ryan Knutson.
Jessica Mendoza
And I'm Jessica Mendoza.
Ryan Knutson
Today, we're talking about tariffs and trade. And we have a very special guest, Milton Magnus III, the CEO of M&B Hangers, one of the last makers of wire hangers in the U.S.
Jessica Mendoza
That's right. Milton has waged a decades-long tariff battle against Chinese manufacturers to try to stay afloat. Welcome to the show, Milton.
Milton Magnus III
Thanks for having me on the show.
Ryan Knutson
So, Milton, how long did it take you to get the hang of your industry?
Milton Magnus III
Well, it's taken me 50 years to get the hang of my industry, but it's a good industry.
Jessica Mendoza
That's impressive. So, Milton's business is making wire hangers. It's called M&B Hangers. And when you're not working, where do you hang out?
Milton Magnus III
I hang out in Birmingham, Alabama, at the lake.
Ryan Knutson
And are there times when you feel like it's better to just hang back?
Milton Magnus III
I've had those times, for sure.
Jessica Mendoza
Do you have a favorite hanger joke?
Milton Magnus III
People ask me how I'm doing, I tell them I'm hanging in there.
Ryan Knutson
[laughs] So that's about it. That's it?
Milton Magnus III
[laughs] Yeah, that's about it.
Jessica Mendoza
As you can tell, Milton is mostly humoring us. Because he takes wire hangers pretty seriously. So seriously, he's waged a more than 20-year trade war to protect his American-made hangers from less expensive Chinese imports.
Ryan Knutson
It just kind of made me sad to think that we were going to push all that to China and do away with what my family has grown.
Milton Magnus III
That's what motivated me to start fighting.
Jessica Mendoza
And I felt honored that my father let me come into business with him. And I was honored that my grandfather started the business and I wasn't going to let my business die on my watch.
Ryan Knutson
Welcome to The Journal, our show about money, business and power. I'm Ryan Knutson.
Jessica Mendoza
And I'm Jessica Mendoza. It's Thursday, September 26th.
Ryan Knutson
Coming up on the show, what one person's trade war against China reveals about the effectiveness of tariffs.
Jessica Mendoza
Milton Magnus III is 72. He has wispy silver hair, and he's the type of guy who always has a tie on, even when he's on the factory floor.
Ryan Knutson
Milton started working at his family's hangar plant during the summers when he was a teenager.
Milton Magnus III
Probably sweeping the floor and then loading trucks.
Ryan Knutson
At the time, we loaded trucks one box at a time instead of on pallets, and it was a summertime in Alabama. It's hot and humid.
Milton Magnus III
In 1974, Milton started full-time at the factory, where he still works today.
Ryan Knutson
Can you describe for us the process of how wire hangers are made?
Milton Magnus III
Sure. We buy a wire rod, and then we stretch it and compress it to the diameter we need to make the hangers.
Jessica Mendoza
We have arbors that spin at about 5,000 rotations per minute.
Milton Magnus III
And what that does, it bends the wire back and forth to where it straightens it, and then a knife cuts it.
Ryan Knutson
Then, a machine forms what's called the body of the hanger, the main lower part.
Milton Magnus III
They run on cams and sprockets, and they'll click, click, click, making hangers.
Jessica Mendoza
And the twist is pretty solid, and so is the hook.
Ryan Knutson
Milton became president of the family company in the early 1990s.
Milton Magnus III
It wasn't long before his business took a turn.
Ryan Knutson
When did your business first start struggling?
Milton Magnus III
In the late 90s, early 2000s, with the introduction of Chinese hangers into the market, it happened pretty quickly, too.
Jessica Mendoza
Their prices were so much less expensive than ours, and there wasn't anything we could do about it.
Ryan Knutson
At that time the world was opening up and lots of goods started pouring into the U.S. manufactured in other countries especially China.
Jessica Mendoza
It is clear that the world was opening up and lots of goods started pouring into the U.S. manufactured in other countries especially China.
Ryan Knutson
It is clearly a step in the right direction and it is clearly in the short- and long-term best economic interests of the American working people.
Jessica Mendoza
President Bill Clinton was pushing to normalize trade relations with China, paving the way for China to join the World Trade Organization in 2001.
Ryan Knutson
It was the era of globalization, the unleashing of the free market.
Milton Magnus III
And Milton can see a direct line between the U.S. opening up to China and his company's decline.
Ryan Knutson
Do you remember a moment when it really sunk in?
Milton Magnus III
I guess it was at a conference, talking to other people that make hangers, too.
Jessica Mendoza
And it was, my gosh, what are we going to do?
Milton Magnus III
I mean, it's the surge of hangers coming in from China, and we can't compete.
Ryan Knutson
So it was that, and then slowly watching my competitors close plants and go out of business.
Jessica Mendoza
By 2006, the competition had gotten so intense that Milton had to shut down one of his factories.
Milton Magnus III
We closed a plant in Virginia.
Ryan Knutson
Had no option but to do that, to stop the bleeding.
Milton Magnus III
It was a very hard decision.
Jessica Mendoza
I went to our Virginia plant and had a meeting with all the employees to let them know what was happening.
Milton Magnus III
And it was 85 people or so that we had to tell that they no longer had a job with us.
Ryan Knutson
It was very difficult.
Jessica Mendoza
Business was tough.
Milton Magnus III
And Milton even considered moving his production to China and closing his last U.S. factory, the one in Alabama.
Ryan Knutson
But then he went to a meeting for the wire industry, where he rubs shoulders with people who make other wired-based products like springs, clips, and nails.
Milton Magnus III
I talked to a man in the nail business that was facing the same struggles we were facing.
Jessica Mendoza
I asked him if he was going to move to China, and he said, no, I'm going to file an anti-dumping case.
Milton Magnus III
And that started me thinking.
Ryan Knutson
And I talked to our trade attorneys, and I said, what do you think?
Milton Magnus III
And he basically said we're a poster child for a dumping case.
Jessica Mendoza
Dumping is when an overseas company sells products in the U.S. at prices that are below market in their home country.
Ryan Knutson
This can violate international trade law.
Milton Magnus III
So Milton sued.
Jessica Mendoza
When we went in to file the case, I didn't know how in the world we were going to be able to pay for it because it is a lot of money to pay for an anti-dumping case.
Milton Magnus III
An anti-dumping case is a seven-figure number, so it's pushing a million dollars to do that.
Ryan Knutson
In the final hearing for Milton's case, the Chinese manufacturers didn't appear.
Jessica Mendoza
The U.S. importers of Chinese hangars argued that American producers weren't competitive.
Milton Magnus III
Nevertheless, Milton won.
Ryan Knutson
And the Commerce Department announced steep tariffs, specifically against Chinese wire hangers.
Milton Magnus III
The tariffs went as high as 187 percent.
Jessica Mendoza
What did it feel like at that moment?
Milton Magnus III
Oh, it was wonderful.
Ryan Knutson
I took my wife out to dinner. We celebrated.
Milton Magnus III
It was besides my marriage day and the birth of our three children.
Jessica Mendoza
That had to go right up there with the top of them.
Ryan Knutson
Did you have steak and wine?
Milton Magnus III
Went to a nice restaurant and had steak, and one of our steel suppliers actually called the restaurant and ordered us a bottle of wine.
Jessica Mendoza
It was very nice.
Ryan Knutson
He was happy we did it too.
Milton Magnus III
So he was happy we survived also.
Jessica Mendoza
Okay, so you win this battle. You win this case.
Milton Magnus III
How did these new tariffs impact your business?
Ryan Knutson
We started regaining the business we had lost.
Milton Magnus III
And at that time, we put on shifts to run 24 hours a day, seven days a week.
Jessica Mendoza
And it was a very exciting time for us because we were building our business back and growing it further than it had ever been.
Ryan Knutson
And it was an exciting time for all our employees and it was just a great time.
Jessica Mendoza
Those good times didn't last long.
Milton Magnus III
We won a battle. We thought we won the war, but we won a battle.
Jessica Mendoza
We started seeing hangers coming in from different countries, Vietnam, Taiwan, several others.
Milton Magnus III
And we got feedback from a lot of our customers that these are really Chinese hangars.
Ryan Knutson
So we actually hired an investigator to go to Taiwan and Vietnam.
Milton Magnus III
Like a private investigator?
Ryan Knutson
Yes.
Milton Magnus III
Go undercover, act as a purchaser of wire hangars.
Jessica Mendoza
And he went to Taiwan and couldn't find any of the factories that were so-called making the hangars.
Milton Magnus III
And in Vietnam, Milton's investigator found that factories were receiving pre-made wire hangers from China, adding paper covers or paper tubes, and then marking them as made in Vietnam.
Ryan Knutson
To Milton, this showed that Chinese manufacturers were trying to avoid U.S. tariffs.
Jessica Mendoza
So we gathered that information, and our attorneys and myself went to Washington and met with Customs and Border Protection, showed them our evidence, and they said thank you.
Milton Magnus III
I thought everything was going to be wonderful after that, but nothing happened.
Ryan Knutson
So we had to file another two dumping cases, one against Taiwan, even though we didn't find any hangers coming from Taiwan, and Vietnam.
Jessica Mendoza
Milton's efforts paid off. He won again.
Ryan Knutson
But again, it was only temporary.
Milton Magnus III
But then we had Thailand come in, and Laos come in, Malaysia come in.
Jessica Mendoza
We were meeting with other wire-producing companies that were seeing the same thing that we were producing.
Milton Magnus III
People that produce nails, interspring wire for mattresses, PC strand for construction, and things like that.
Ryan Knutson
They were all seeing the exact same thing we were seeing.
Jessica Mendoza
So we had a coalition to try to get customs in Congress to pass legislation to enforce the dumping orders we had in place.
Milton Magnus III
Milton was fighting and winning each individual battle.
Ryan Knutson
But it became a game of whack-a-mole.
Jessica Mendoza
He'd stop the flow of Chinese-made hangars moving through one country just to see them pop up somewhere else.
Ryan Knutson
Which raises the question, do tariffs even work?
Jessica Mendoza
That's next.
Ryan Knutson
At the beginning, Milton was fighting a bit of a lonely journey, pushing for tariffs in the era of free trade.
Jessica Mendoza
These days, he's got more people on his side because low-cost Chinese goods of all kinds have poured into the U.S., undercutting American manufacturing and leading to the loss of an estimated 2 million jobs.
Ryan Knutson
The U.S. has been talking to China about its unfair trade practices for a long time, and nothing's changed.
Jessica Mendoza
That's our colleague Chow Deng, who covers the economy.
Ryan Knutson
And so therefore, there's this realization by both Democrats and Republicans that they need to take a different tack towards China.
Jessica Mendoza
And that has included tariffs.
Ryan Knutson
A big advocate for tariffs has been Donald Trump.
Jessica Mendoza
While president, he slapped tariffs on a wide range of Chinese goods.
Ryan Knutson
Everything from clothing and toys to laptops and smartphones.
Jessica Mendoza
We've taxed China on $300 billion worth of goods and products being sold into our country.
Ryan Knutson
And President Joe Biden not only continued most of those tariffs, he added more.
Jessica Mendoza
We're also implementing a 25 percent tariff on electric vehicle batteries from China and 25 percent tariff on critical minerals that make those batteries.
Ryan Knutson
But tariffs are still controversial.
Jessica Mendoza
On the campaign trail Trump is calling for broader and higher tariffs while Vice President Kamala Harris is arguing for a more measured approach.
Ryan Knutson
Part of it is you don't just throw around the idea of just tariffs across the board.
Jessica Mendoza
And that part of the problem with Donald Trump.
Ryan Knutson
Frankly, I think if you talk to most economists, they will still argue that tariffs are more trouble than they're worth.
Jessica Mendoza
But politically, both Democrats and Republicans have come around to the idea that something needs to be done and that tariffs are a worthy trade tool.
Ryan Knutson
Do tariffs work? No.
Jessica Mendoza
Economists will argue that they increase input costs for American businesses, which end up passing along those costs to consumers.
Ryan Knutson
And studies have certainly shown that tariffs have increased costs for middle-class American families.
Jessica Mendoza
So what do these economists say should be done?
Ryan Knutson
They'll argue, look, the U.S. really doesn't need to be making products like these, which they would argue are low-end and commoditized, and that the U.S. should be making more advanced products like chips and solar panels and electric vehicle batteries.
Jessica Mendoza
But what does that mean for the Miltons of the world?
Ryan Knutson
I think Milton represents a chorus of American industry saying, you know, we want to be doing what we have been doing without interference from China.
Jessica Mendoza
And his story and the fact that he's been able to survive kind of shows that lobbying efforts are strong, that trade cases make a difference.
Ryan Knutson
I took this argument to Milton.
Milton Magnus III
What do you say to economists who say, you know, tariffs protect uneconomical businesses?
Ryan Knutson
They're economists, they're not business people.
Milton Magnus III
I think the United States is made up of millions of small businesses like ours or medium-sized businesses like ours that without some type of protection would be out of business.
Jessica Mendoza
And uh, you know, although we you know you think we'd love to just be a high-tech industry and high-tech businesses there are people that need our business people that work in our business people that like to do what they do.
Milton Magnus III
And if there were just high-tech jobs around, they might not be available for them or qualified for them.
Ryan Knutson
Milton does see the benefit of manufacturing outside the U.S.
Jessica Mendoza
He has a plant in Mexico.
Milton Magnus III
It makes about half his total output and helps keep his Alabama factory going.
Ryan Knutson
And Milton admits that while tariffs have helped his business, they're not a panacea.
Jessica Mendoza
So the tariffs are easily evaded.
Milton Magnus III
They're very easily evaded, yes.
Ryan Knutson
Why haven't you given up on tariffs?
Milton Magnus III
I'm very stubborn and committed to my business and my industry.
Jessica Mendoza
And we have one competitor today that used to produce in the United States and now imports everything from Asia.
Ryan Knutson
And I'm sure they do very well, but that's not in my DNA.
Milton Magnus III
I like to be a manufacturer. I don't want to be just a distributor.
Jessica Mendoza
Milton says he now spends 30% of his time fighting off lower-priced Chinese imports.
Ryan Knutson
But he says that time is what's kept him in business.
Jessica Mendoza
I'm sort of proud that we're still here, and we've fought a good fight, and we're continuing to fight.
Milton Magnus III
We don't give up. We're going to hang in as long as we can, and we think that we've got a good team working for us in the factory and on our legal team.
Ryan Knutson
And we plan on using all tools in our arsenal to stay around.
Theme music starts playing
That's all for today, Thursday, September 26th.
Jessica Mendoza
The Journal is a co-production of Spotify and The Wall Street Journal.
Ryan Knutson
If you like the show, follow us on Spotify or wherever you get your podcasts.
Jessica Mendoza
We're out every weekday afternoon.
Ryan Knutson
Thanks for listening. See you tomorrow.