Part 2 of 2... Ed Cooke is a dear friend and a Grandmaster of Memory. In 2010, he was interviewed by a journalist named Joshua Foer. Under Ed's Yoda-like training, Joshua became the very next American Memory Champion in 2011. It took less than a year for Ed to transform a novice from unknown to world-class. But how?!? Aha... This interview explores Ed Cooke's brilliant techniques (many of which I use), strategies, and practical philosophies. To boot, he's also a wicked funny bastard! If you enjoyed the epic interviews with Kevin Kelly, Josh Waitzkin, or Maria Popova, you'll love Ed. He's one of a kind.
***
If you enjoy the podcast, would you please consider leaving a short review on Apple Podcasts/iTunes? It takes less than 60 seconds, and it really makes a difference in helping to convince hard-to-get guests. I also love reading the reviews!
For show notes and past guests, please visit tim.blog/podcast.
Sign up for Tim’s email newsletter (“5-Bullet Friday”) at tim.blog/friday.
For transcripts of episodes, go to tim.blog/transcripts.
Interested in sponsoring the podcast? Visit tim.blog/sponsor and fill out the form.
Discover Tim’s books: tim.blog/books.
Follow Tim:
Twitter: twitter.com/tferriss
Instagram: instagram.com/timferriss
Facebook: facebook.com/timferriss
YouTube: youtube.com/timferriss
Past guests on The Tim Ferriss Show include Jerry Seinfeld, Hugh Jackman, Dr. Jane Goodall, LeBron James, Kevin Hart, Doris Kearns Goodwin, Jamie Foxx, Matthew McConaughey, Esther Perel, Elizabeth Gilbert, Terry Crews, Sia, Yuval Noah Harari, Malcolm Gladwell, Madeleine Albright, Cheryl Strayed, Jim Collins, Mary Karr, Maria Popova, Sam Harris, Michael Phelps, Bob Iger, Edward Norton, Arnold Schwarzenegger, Neil Strauss, Ken Burns, Maria Sharapova, Marc Andreessen, Neil Gaiman, Neil de Grasse Tyson, Jocko Willink, Daniel Ek, Kelly Slater, Dr. Peter Attia, Seth Godin, Howard Marks, Dr. Brené Brown, Eric Schmidt, Michael Lewis, Joe Gebbia, Michael Pollan, Dr. Jordan Peterson, Vince Vaughn, Brian Koppelman, Ramit Sethi, Dax Shepard, Tony Robbins, Jim Dethmer, Dan Harris, Ray Dalio, Naval Ravikant, Vitalik Buterin, Elizabeth Lesser, Amanda Palmer, Katie Haun, Sir Richard Branson, Chuck Palahniuk, Arianna Huffington, Reid Hoffman, Bill Burr, Whitney Cummings, Rick Rubin, Dr. Vivek Murthy, Darren Aronofsky, and many more.
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
No summary for this episode yet.
Hey folks, Tim here. My best-selling card game, Coyote, which I made with the amazing team at Exploding Kittens, just won the Pop Insider Best Geeky Game of 2025 and also Best Stocking Filler in the Made for Mums Toy Awards 2025. It is on sale everywhere. It's cheap. It's fast to learn. It has 4.8 stars out of 5. People are loving it. CoyoteGame.com will take you to all the retailers, but you can find it everywhere. It is a game of thinking fast and laughing faster. Thinks charades meets hot potato meets a bunch of brain fun. It's good for your head. It's perfect for families with kids age 10 plus or adults who are kids at heart or don't take themselves too seriously.
A lot of adults love this game. And as I said, it's available everywhere. Amazon, Walmart, Target, 8,000 plus retail locations, you name it. So please check it out. I loved making it. People are really enjoying it. It has 300 or 400 million plus social views of gameplay online. And try it, enjoy it this holiday season. Check it out, coyotegame.com. One more time, that's coyotegame.com or anywhere you buy your games. Now, back to the episode. What you're about to hear is part two of a two-part conversation with Ed Cook, Grandmaster of Memory, and much more than that. He is a hilarious dude. You will love him.
If you didn't catch the first part, however, you might want to do that before venturing in. But this is really a conversation that jumps around and we answer a lot of different questions and different topics. So if you don't mind, your stories is more of a jigsaw puzzle, then by all means, keep on listening. So without further ado, please enjoy part two of the Tim Ferriss Show with Ed Cook. At this altitude, I can run flat out for a half mile before my hands start shaking. Can I ask you a personal question? Now would have seen the perfect time. What if I did the opposite? I'm a cybernetic organism living tissue over a metal endoskeleton.
The Tim Ferriss Show. That was an example of where intuition was thwarted by a kind of banal kind of self-recriminating rationality resulting in, I'm almost certain, like a less interesting product and less fun. Now, you bring up a really interesting set of questions. And this is something that at times I do better with, at times I do more poorly with. But I've tried to, at various points in my life, increase the speed with which I make decisions. So if a decision is reversible and non-fatal, then I find my life is generally much better when I just do exactly what you mentioned, which is like left, right, who gives a fuck?
I'm going right. It'll be fine. And if it's not, I'll figure it out later. And making these types of reversible decisions as quickly as possible so that you don't have a lot of cognitive burden and you're not sort of stuck up your own ass all the time. but in the case of the bus and the business let's just say or how do you balance the intuition which at times can be an irrational exuberance with the sort of prefrontal cortex calculation that is the question and it's not a question I have an answer to but I assume it's something to do God damn it, Ed. Why did I do this interview? I'm just kidding.
Yeah, it's pathetic, isn't it? By the way, I suppose we're quite far into this interview. There are two things, by the way, we must come back to. One of which is how you think about merit. How you think about merit. And the other one of which is Burning Man, because I went to that this year. And it is the most perfect example of any institution I've ever seen. And it's also a sublime exemplar of memory techniques put into the outside world. So anyway, so those are two little sort of thoughts which we must come back to. But where were we? We were, yeah, so I've got no idea about the intuition thing.
But I think, and I'm basically learning from my girlfriend who is a more spiritual, connected, intuitive person than I am by kind of disposition and native structure, so to speak, who can come to a discussion. discussion, you know, and this might get back to our kind of point about relationships, fundamentally with like calm, like with where normally your mind is like, oh, that's normally your mind. That's actually the best description of my mind I've ever heard right there. Yeah. And it's kind of rubbish, isn't it? Because you kind of, you know, like one wants to be kind of like a didgeridoo, like but but you know unfortunately you're just oh fuck oh maybe i'm a loser oh no i should really like you know um but by the way uh so so one thing i quite enjoy about our friendship tim is that um that you're quite good at like coming up to rational conclusions and implementing them and i'm not so early this week i was like jesus christ i smoke the whole time i drink lots of wine I should sort my act out.
I'm going to start doing yoga. And yoga is even something which I find fascinating and interesting, you know, rich. I think it's like a fundamentally profound system of thought which, you know, connects autonomous rhythms with the body's capacity of movement and the mind. You know, I don't have enough good things to say about yoga, but I never fucking do it. And so I was like, okay, Jesus. I was like, Jesus, I'm going to go do some yoga. You know, I need to be healthy. I said, I'm going to go do some yoga. and so I went down to the yoga thing and then I played they had this big great deal 25 pounds for 10 days of consecutive sessions and I was like genius this time I'm going to do 10 days consecutive sessions then went to the first one because I was there and um and did it and it was great and you know felt fantastic super pepped up and the rest of it and that was that was five days ago I mean I just I'm just inept I I don't know what what kind of consistency of perspective is required to actually implement uh worthy plans like that and actually that's why i um why i i quite enjoy chatting and just generally brainstorming with you because you seem to have a capacity to sort of come up to a conclusion like that it's oh yeah yoga really good i should do some more yoga and then actually do it a capacity which i find mysterious and suspicious well you know it all comes down to black magic uh you have to get a dead cat preferably black swing it counterclockwise over your head before the next.
Honestly, I find it endlessly amusing how, particularly in some media pieces, I'm played up to be this stalwart of self-discipline and systems thinking. And I function like Bishop from Aliens. I just have this incredible ability to execute, execute, execute. And at the end of the day, I'm just good at setting up incentives for myself that punish me and flog me if I don't do things. So the way that I would conquer the yoga has nothing to do with convincing yourself or rationalizing. I would take extremely unflattering photos of yourself in tighty whities front and center, give those to a friend who can keep an agreement, but who will also show no mercy and just say, if I don't, if I don't prove to you as my judge that I've gone to yoga for 10 days straight, like these are going to go, on the homepage as a pop-up or something like that or on Facebook.
You know what this connects with? This is a bit like Goethe and his friends in the room. It's like externalizing beyond yourself the sources of the things you need for yourself. Yeah. A bit. I think self-discipline is so overrated. If you break it down, self-discipline is actually, it's kind of a poor label. It's poorly defined, at least. It's overused to the extent that it's really lost any type of clarity in its meaning. So for me, self-discipline, it's like, no, we're like rats in the lab. Put us in a Skinner box, which is life, and we respond to inputs that are punishment and reward, and we adjust our behavior accordingly.
So it's like, all right, great. Well, make that external. You're not going to punish or reward yourself, typically. It's usually not enough and it's, it's too easily reneged. Uh, so you can, you can externalize it. Uh, it also puts some money on the line. That's also very useful for people, but, um, but how the hell did we get this far? So the, the, the, uh, we're going to talk about burning man. We're going to come back to your discussion with your girlfriend, which we left long ago, but we'll come back to that. The, the, then merit. So merit is merit. I'm still struggling with this and I'm a bit of a semantic pain in the ass is merit close to the the in your mind sort of the Roman uh arete like this virtue or is it just uh is can it be boiled down to sort of deservedly winning is that uh is that what so yes so I think virtue um of which I have none but virtue is is like i think is the correct is how we should think about merit so um you know in some sense in some sense like um the humanities in better commas have had this nailed for like 2 000 years what like the fundamental tendencies of a good human being are you know empathy um temperance generosity kind of non-egotism we sort of know what good human beings are and we have done for thousands of years but that's not what we celebrate or immediately associate with merit so we tend to associate merit with tangible outcomes in life path which might include getting a Harvard law degree or being Bill Gates or whatever And so the concept of improving oneself is obviously an excellent concept, regardless of how socially you perceive human action and existence.
Because to improve yourself is to improve the world, it's to improve your interactions with others. It's not a kind of lonely activity. but at the same time you know if you look at like you know Silicon Valley startups which are in some sense the great drivers of human culture at the moment besides like ISIS and whatever but like anyway but you know the natural tendency in that way of thinking is to become personally more efficient so it's to like store files more effectively get things done better be quicker, optimize oneself and this is a kind of merit thing in its way but it's quite a selfish one and goodness knows for lots of subtle reasons we're all selfish but you can imagine an alternative culture of creativity and power of the kind that Tilica Valley has, which would all be focused on making communities better and institutions better and hacking not oneself, but the situations which comprise the world.
And, you know, I'll give you my kind of go-to example about this. If you go to San Francisco, unbelievable town, full of just the most magical people, so like intellectually vibrant and open and fun and awesome and beautiful um but and so rich and there's fucking like homeless people everywhere and you're like seriously guys that's twitter hq there it's a 15 billion dollar company or whatever everyone inside is being paid more than 100 000 a year and this happens on their doorstep do they have no like conception No, no, like, basic grasp over what, like, happy existence is. Because your existence will be happier if you didn't have to, at a purely selfish level, walk past all these people who were clearly in a state of distress and maybe hassling you and whatever.
And anyway, so I think that's, like, that's one of the most interesting things about San Francisco. And it's kind of, to me, emblematic of a tendency of thought which looks to optimize the individual over the situations qua your like external stuff influencing the self rather than the self into itself rather than external situations which are the things which actually make us happy like the ability to play chess on the street and you know giving people things and whatever other yeah no I agree I think that just to take us down too much of a political rat hole but I think that the part of what makes San Francisco very fascinating in the Bay Area in general is there are many divergent opinions on many different subjects.
And some people think Bitcoin is a fraud. Other people think it's the future. And there's everything in between for every conceivable subject. Some people believe in long-term monogamous relationships, and then you have the whole polyamorous community, and there's everything in between. And simultaneously, for instance, I think that San Francisco could learn a lot as it relates to homeless people and other aspects of rejuvenating a city from New York City. I think Giuliani and Bloomberg have done just a phenomenal job with converting Manhattan into a pleasant place to walk. And that was not, it wasn't in the distant past that it was terrifying to walk in areas that are now very popular.
The challenge, I think, is that in San Francisco, among many, there are many reasons for this, but one of the challenges is, I'm sure you, or maybe you've heard the expression a liberal is someone who doesn't know to take his own side in a fight, that in San Francisco there's such a divergence of opinions, no one can agree on fucking anything. And that makes it very challenging to deal with systemic issues that involve a lot of people. But, yeah, I agree with you. I wonder if that's really right, Tim, because there was lots of consensus in San Francisco in certain regions of life, right? So, you know, the whole kind of entrepreneurial ecosystem is so fluid and dynamic because everyone agrees how it should work.
You know, you've got the venture capitalists, the entrepreneurs, the talented young guys, the angel investors, and there's like a very kind of clear shared set of concepts about, and also a lot of generosity and consensus. Everyone's always helping everyone. You know, there's no overt selfishness at all, really. You know, it's like that's what I describe as like almost a perfect harmonious community where people are like doing amazing things, trying as hard as they can. But, you know, for instance, like Memrise, one of the rival sites to Memrise in some sense is this site called Quizlet. and I'm incredibly good mates with the CEO of Chris and this guy called Andrew Sutherland who's a terrific character and it's so striking on meeting him.
You know, we see each other, we have a wonderful time together and we brainstorm together and he helps me wherever he can and there's a kind of a sense of shared journey which defies any notion of normal competition. and that's the kind of thing which is going on in the entrepreneurial community and yet there are these quite radical divisions between that and you know for instance I don't understand the history of the homeless people but it is striking that there are you know so many of them and that these two worlds coexist spatially but have zero social or emotional or conceptual connection in a way No, I agree.
I think that it's very easy to succumb to the belief that SF is tech or that the Bay Area is tech when in fact that perception is because of the prominence in the media and otherwise of outliers. and that the sort of sexiness and romance of building multi-billion dollar companies in short periods of time has created a misperception, I think, of how much of the population benefits from being employed at tech companies. But I think it brings up kind of an interesting question. Maybe we won't get into it right now. I want to talk about Burning Man a bit, But that there are a lot of people in Silicon Valley and in New York City and all over the world who struggle with the question of should I give back now?
Should I try to create positive karma in the world and benefit others now? Or should I be completely selfish now so that I can be completely selfless later? So for instance, there are people I know, and this is going to sound crazy, who say, who would argue that Mother Teresa is a media hound and she should not be looked at as a saint and that it would be better to look at someone like Bill Gates who is not exactly the nicest kid on the block when it came to competition and ruthless capitalism for a long period of time. but who now with the stroke of a pen can wipe out ostensibly, you know, wipe out malaria or polio.
And that we're, we're, we live in a culture where the former has been romanticized because it's easier. Yeah. Perhaps it's comes back to like general mental functioning. It's easier to, for us to take this archetypal image of a saint in our mind as opposed to the more complex narrative of somebody who, like a Jobs, for instance, who's kind of a son of a bitch, if we really look at it objectively, who's now being deified. And how do you... Yeah, it's tricky, isn't it? I mean, sorry to interrupt your question, but I think Gates is a really... If that was a question, that was the longest question of all time.
I think it was just a rant. So go ahead. You know, I assume since it's probably past 3pm in San Francisco that you've moved on of the gin and tonics. And that's the, but I think Gates is a good example because the, because Gates is deified, you know, is considered a heroic figure because of this sort of this generosity after the fact of wealth accumulation. And it, I had quite big arguments with close friends about this because there's one perspective which says a Gates through personal merit accrued $60 billion. and so deserves to be able to spend it. And B, he's this hyper-competent character who's much better than some inept, internally strife-ridden charitable institution who aren't going to get anything done.
This guy's got the competence and the rest of it to go and solve the world's problems unilaterally and he'll get it done really efficiently. And I can kind of see the merit in that type of perspective. But here's another perspective, which would be, So Gates exploited probably pretty illegally monopolistic practices to accrue from the population of the world immense undeserved wealth at the expense of their computing experience. And now as a unilateral actor, he now has the opportunity to spend this on whatever he feels is right, where in fact, it shouldn't be Bill Gates' decision what humanity's wealth gets spent on to sort out problems.
that should be a democratic process. You know, Gates, you know, that old phrase, power corrupts absolutely, I think is kind of fundamentally psychologically real. That's actually kind of an aside. But, you know, I would like to see, as an alternative history of 1980 to 2010, I'd have liked to have seen Gates become very rich in the course of the 80s and spend 50 million dollars on its local community and a thousand people around the world or everyone around the world have a much better computing experience and a thousand or a million people around the world have the opportunity to divide divert their fraction of the great sum he has at his disposal to the situations in their local communities or in the broader world which they judge to be meritorious to merit this sort of spending and the extreme way of saying that is like Gates is basically the last person on earth you want spending this kind of resources because he is I think he's quite a likable character but because nobody should be spending 60 billion dollars there should be like 60 million people spending a thousand dollars and there's something fundamentally wrong with our institutional structure and you know until the objection that it's just not as efficient as when you've got like a big head honcho just like calling the shots that's probably true but efficiency on both sides of the of the equation either charitable side and the wealth accumulation side seems to be a very ambiguous good right well being more efficient yeah you know i i uh i don't want to beat the dead horse too too long but i one of the one of the the ways my thinking has flipped in the last few years is related to judging, prioritizing intentions or outcomes.
So what I mean by that is as relevant to this conversation is, you know, would you rather have someone who in their heart of hearts is pure, I was going to say as pure as gold, but that's not really, it doesn't make much sense. But you get the idea, someone who is truly altruistic, who has the greater good in mind with a million dollars or someone who is, uh, at their core, uh, Scrooge, but who out of guilt to absolve themselves of guilt is going to behave as if they are altruistic with a hundred million dollars, which would you, which would you prefer if they're of equal intellectual capacity, right?
So their ability to problem solve is equal. And now I think I would probably opt if I'm just focused on outcomes, fixing aspects of the educational system, fixing healthcare, whatever, global literacy, whatever it might be, I'm happy to take the extrinsically motivated rich guy as opposed to the intrinsically motivated less rich guy. You know what I mean? If I'm just looking for outcomes because I used to, and that doesn't mean don't give back. I think there are many arguments that could be made and I wrote a blog post for people interested called the karmic capitalist about my thinking on this but the let me ask you a just to sort of take us in a related but slightly different direction because I'm probably more I'm not a Randian by the way exactly this is the moment to bring in Burning Man by the way okay bring it in bring it in yeah can I ask you Can I ask you one other question?
And if it's going to be a long answer, we can come back to it. But I want to know what is financial security to you? And where does money fit into your life? Well, I think it's very difficult to starve in Northern Europe. Meaning it's unpleasant when you starve or it's difficult to end up starving? it's just like by 2014 people were of the opinion that starving in New York was actually quite unpleasant in 2007 starving was great fun I meant that I suppose that we are blessed a bit with with what the low bar is in terms of life outcomes. You know, starving doesn't really happen in Western countries, although of course there's lots of tricky kind of situations which get close to that.
But it's funny actually, because I'm not sure if I have a totally kind of honest internal perspective on this tip because part of me is like you know part of me is like um you know to be honest i i'd be perfectly happy just schlepping around europe chatting to people uh you know uh having the odd espresso and just generally experiencing the world but that what i actually care about is um conscious experience and understanding and you know But at the same time, you know, I do enjoy a good party and, you know, a nice home and so on. And I also quite enjoy like sitting, you know, one of my dreams, it's funny, dreams, you have dreams all the time in your life.
And, you know, when I was five, I wanted to be a carpenter. When I was six, I wanted to be Beethoven, whatever. Some of them stick with you. And one of the ones that just stuck with me is a mixture of exactly this blend between like, I don't give a crap about money. And I basically want to live in the kind of utopian situation, which can only be sustained by enormous private wealth. And this dream is that I, I, and I've had it since age 15, and it won't go away, which is that my, my idea for what I really want to do in my life is to have a philosophical academy in, in Greece. and basically what I'm seeing is like Mediterranean sunshine, beautiful people in white robes, you know, people playing guitar on the beach, a kind of network of pavilions.
You'd sit in one for a while just contemplating the meaning of the color green for like six weeks and then you kind of wander up the, you know, the arcade of columns by the swimming pool with all the beautiful people and have scintillating intellectual conversation and you'd somehow be apart from the world of ambition and trying to sustain progress. And you'd be sitting back and contemplating the concepts which normally drive our intentions. And you'd just basically be having a good old think about what the meaning of it all is. But also you'd be surrounded by beautiful people in great luxury and sunshine.
So it's like right here is like a conflict. And so certainly, like, I hold in contempt the idea of counting score in life through wealth. And there's fairly small evidence to me. In fact, I just go with the accepted evidence that up to a certain point, it's great to have some resources because it allows a certain level of relaxation, comfort and kind of sustainable existence in the world. But beyond that, it's kind of vanity and stupidity to pursue worldly resources. But, you know, funny enough, random thing. Aristotle is really funny as a moral philosopher. And one of the reasons he's funny is that he doesn't really believe you can be happy if you're not beautiful.
Which is kind of probably true, but, like, you know, we don't dwell on it. and uh anyway he's also not a popular advertising campaign yeah exactly he's also got like a virtue which is only available to the rich um and his virtue system is kind of um is about polls like for every virtue there's an extreme exaggeration of that virtue which becomes a kind of a sin or a vice and there's uh there's a thing in the opposite direction so not enough and so uh one of his virtues only available to rich people is magnificence. And so he thinks that the correct use of the energy that is wealth is to be magnificent, which is to say to throw amazing festivals and build awesome buildings, add foster great artists and do this kind of thing.
And then that can go in its extreme form to ostentation and sort of vanity, you know, sort of like the kinds of characters I think who are, you know, who occur wherever there's extreme wealth, you know, Russian oligarchs being the classic contemporary example, or towards miserliness where you have all this wealth and you're not organizing any parties. What the fuck? You know, and I think that's probably like, you know, it's probably orthogonal, but it's probably a quite good way of thinking about wealth, which is that there is a responsibility to create joy. And there is a responsibility to, and there's nothing inherently sinful about being wealthy or whatever.
But anyway, going back to this academy, to which, by the way, Tim, you're going to be hugely welcome. I hope you're going to hang out there very often. You know, I think it's going to be really cool. We're just going to sort of just hang about and chat about stuff. Yeah. Green is also my favorite color, so I have a lot to ponder there. Okay. Very good, yeah. Interrogate yourself about that. You know, a favor. I think the use of riches is an interesting segue to Burning Man because there's a lot of discussion about this, of course. But tell me your impression of Burning Man. I'll leave it wide open since you brought it up.
Yeah, I did bring it up. So, I mean, I love parties, and so I wanted to go to Burning Man for a while. My best friend Al is often at Burning Man. Eventually, we got it together. We went to Burning Man. Burning Man is an absolute ordeal to get to, especially if you're coming from the UK. So you've got to get to San Francisco. Then there's all this, like, you've got to purchase lots of objects and water and snacks and costumes and all this stuff. And then you've got to do an eight-hour road trip. About four hours on the road trip, you're like, wow, this is getting pretty much into the middle of nowhere.
and then you keep on schlepping on and then you spend four hours in a queue in a dust storm or whatever. Get to the gate and then some annoyingly enlightened looking character says welcome home. And you're like, fuck off mate. I live in Hackney. I can't hear a music festival. Anyway, in between that and leaving Burning Man, something happens where as you're leaving you're like, well he was right. This was my home. and so what's happened in between and so and what's interesting is that i was not indoctrinated into the quite sophisticated kind of moral conceptual framework around burning man all their principles and so on um i was just sort of going along for a good party but um but here's like my kind of quick fire theory about why burning man is the most brilliant institution I've encountered and is the first evidence I've seen that, oh, not the first, whatever, whatever, but is a compelling case for why Silicon Valley is actually a culturally important place on a par with, say, the Renaissance in Florence or something, where, like, if you look at the buildings in Silicon Valley, you're like, Jesus, these guys may build good software companies, but they sure don't know how to live.
you know just like it's like it's like the car park you're like here you know anyway so why is burning man so good so there's no money which cuts out one fundamental aspect of your social relationship to the world there's basically no time because no one's got um a watch on them and no one would care if they did although there is time but it's a different quality of time it's basically the rhythm of sun and night. And then there's no mobile phone. So no one is basically able to connect with their normal, unbelievably banal set of preoccupations. And as a result, people are kind of stripped down.
So you've got no money, no ambition, no obsession with what you're supposed to be doing. And there's basically no agenda whatsoever as regards what happens. And it's long enough for about a week that like, unlike a kind of UK festival of which there are many great ones, including things like the secret garden party, the secret garden party on the Saturday, you're like aware that on Sunday you're going to have to pack up and go home. But a burning man, the temporal horizon is just long enough that basically it might as well be infinite. You're just like, I am here. So that's the first thing is like, you're stripped away of a lot of the kind of tendencies of interaction, which normally kind of make you basically a fucking boring person.
And then the second thing is that it's, that it, you kind of bounce around Burning Man and it operates, as far as I can tell, at four scales, which interweave in this kind of fractal way. So you've got like camps. So you've been in Wild West camp and you're there in Wild West. And at one point I found myself playing a piano naked in a Wild West bar surrounded by Frenchmen singing the French national anthem. you know it's sort of basically a quite undistinguish way to be spending 20 minutes of your life but anyway so you're in the wild west and you're feeling kind of like you're in the wild west and then you know an art car go past you wonder how you get on the art car and the art car buzzes you off so the art car is kind of the second order of bankers you're in the wild west feels like the wild west you're kind of open because you're not thinking about money or time or what you're supposed to be doing or your career or like how you really want to achieve this by next year but unfortunately this is getting all that's cleared out and so um so you get on the art car art car one order of magnitude scale-wise down and the outcome might be like a fish or a boat or whatever get on the boat and then you're living on a boat you know and the whole vibe is boatish so you've entered a different world and then you talk to a person on the boat sort of third scale of spatial organization down and the person is not does not have an agenda because they have basically completely forgotten about all the things which preoccupy them normally and so you get further in about five minutes of conversation than you do with a flatmate in about a year because you know just say how are you feeling it's like oh not so good because of the sort of thing which no one would ever tell you normally and then you know where are you from and then because you're really open because you're not thinking about your money or your time or your the things you have to do you're like oh well actually the fact that you're from wisconsin and a little farm is kind of interesting in a way which it wouldn't be according to my normal filters and of course this is none of this is rational.
It's just a kind of intuitive flow. But so you have very rich. And so people are their own worlds, which you dive into. So we've had the camp where you're like in a world and then you've got the art car, which is basically like kind of floating nightclubs. But anyway, you've got an art car and that's kind of a world and then a person is the world. And then it's got this gift economy where the gifts are themselves their own world. So sometimes it's like, you know, a little object which expresses some profound story about this person's life or about the world or anything else um one person and i should add uh since we're on record that i didn't indulge was like this my friend is uh one of only 10 dmt inhalers in the entire world so that would have been a world to dive into as a gift anyway so um and because of the lack of temporal horizon you kind of bounce between these spatial levels you're in a camp You're talking to a person.
You're like on an art car. And you cease to kind of track how they relate to each other. So the whole thing has the character of an external hallucination where one fascinating piece of the world will pop up and dissolve into the next fascinating bit of the world. And there's no attachment and there's no nothing kind of thing. You're just bouncing around this extraordinary experience. And as a result of that, quite fundamental concepts change. You know, your relationship to the distinction between a nightclub and a piece of art dissolves. Your concept of what a friend is and what someone you don't know is blurs, because everyone's kind of a friend.
And you're, um, and of course, like this all sounds quite pompous, but, but you're also having a terribly good time. So, um, anyway, so like this kind of, this is really striking because I was not indoctrinated before going there. Right. And within two days I was living in this kind of magical invented thing where what was so striking was that it was all based on giving and generosity and openness. and transient creativity. And the structure of the party, if that's what Burning Man is, is just an unbelievable genius. I mean, I was staggered. I love parties. I studied it. I once tried to write a book about house parties, actually.
It wasn't very good, and I never completed it. But I love parties, and I'd never imagined a party could be like a dance in the brain of a philosopher or something like that. And it's really like, it's a way of like, it's a party which kind of gives you insights into totally different ways of relating to yourself and the world. And I love the fact that it's transient because A, it means that only through the proactive participation of the people who are involved will it ever exist. but b it um it means that the meaning has to go outside into the world in a way so you know you don't go to any man and they you have your like isolated kingdom like my philosophical academy in greece for instance where you're kind of denying the world and then living your own private dream in a kind of onanistic kind of nonsense it's actually just like an opportunity to reconceive stuff and then go back to the world and then like think oh fuck well just like burning man the world is a consequence of the actions of everybody who's in it just like burning man any form of relationship is possible you know whatever and so it's fundamentally a mind expanding thing and although i have no knowledge of this whatsoever it seems to me to be intuitively very plausible that um that um the kind of genius of silicon valley The fact that it's creating experiences and possibilities of life which genuinely touch upon the transformation of humanity in subtle ways at the moment and bit by bit and iterative, of course.
I can only assume they are somehow connected. I have a challenge for you. Well, the first is a recommendation. I think you'd really enjoy a book called Spectacle by David Rockwell and Bruce Mao, M-A-U. It's basically a visual compilation, essays and photographs that look at the phenomenon and history of massive public performances or events around the world, which is really just a phenomenal tome. The challenge is, and this is something I've thought about, because I get, I wouldn't say agoraphobic, but because I'm intrinsically quite introverted, I've been to Burning Man twice, I enjoyed it, but I end up spending a lot of time in my own camp, partially just to recharge.
if you were tasked with creating as much of the benefits that you derive from Burning Man with a group of 20 people on your own, so you're creating your own experience to provide many of the benefits of Burning Man for 20 people, what would you do? How would you do that? That's a super question. Okay, so of course in some sense I'm just going to make up whatever I want to say. And no budgetary constraints. But let's just sort of do it with my little theory there about why Bernie Man is a co-host. Let's just apply that to 20 people. So a massive hero narrative road trip to get wherever you're going.
So you're spatially and experientially separated from your boring life. um no phones no money no motivation to talk about um your intentions in the world but more just sort of thing um a shared creative project where you um somehow like spontaneously democratically come up with a cool way of making everyone else happy you know perhaps collaboratively in in this other space and then enough time to be to not be worried that it's going to end tomorrow um and so just like riffing on this just like thinking of it you know what we should do is um you know what we might do is collect the crew some i think with 20 people to be good if they're like someone known to each other but it was kind of a mixture of groups of friends or whatever um agree on like some round of distant point okay we're going to go to the hebridean island for a week i'll see you there on the 3rd of january next year whatever it's miles away what have you and then um and then um yeah then just go there minus mobile phone blah blah blah and just rejoice i guess in the fact that like people are so cool which is kind of thing which are oddly rather forgotten before very much just like oh people are so annoying they're always like in the queue in front of me while waiting for the bus and like you know etc um but like you know of course this blends quite easily into sort of cults right right which is why why having a a participatory non um um yeah non sort of not driven by concepts experience is quite important i mean i suppose one of the paradoxes about it is driven by concepts in a sense like there's this concept of radical self-sufficiency and generosity and so on.
But, um, but you know, I've got a party in mind. I mean, I think that, um, the, I mean, you can hardly fail to have a good experience if you're with 20, like generous, open people with loads of time away from your life. Um, and you're feeling great about yourself because you're in the middle of a hero narrative because you actually successfully got there. And, um, and this could probably be done with two people as well. I feel like, I feel like, um, So I've thought about this. I've thought about doing it in a wilderness setting, primarily in my own head, sort of recreating the elements of… Your head's a lot of wilderness, Tim.
Yeah, of Burning Man. There's a project you might find interesting or people listening might find interesting called Station to Station. And there's a guy named Doug Aitken, A-I-T-K-E-N. And he basically packed this. I think it's 11 cars. I'm making up the numbers a bit. but 11 cars of a train full of musicians and artists and all sorts of craziness. I mean, think about it as sort of Burning Man on a train and went from city to city doing these massive pop-up performances where they would take these abandoned buildings or old train stations and turn them into concerts for one night and then pack up and move on their way, which were called nomadic happenings.
Pretty cool stuff. But how do you take the experience of Burning Man and create more of those peak experiences, if you want to call them that? What are other ways of pulling your head out of the mundane bullshit and doldrums that constitute the vast majority of most people's waking existences? I mean, great question. And not one I've really successfully answered for myself, but I'm more than happy to advise about it. Yeah, I mean, I think it is a fundamental question. And I think that many of the kind of inherited cultural tendencies are like this a bit. You know, like one of the best parties I ever went to was like a moon celebration.
and it was kind of, it was on a cliff and the sea was like formidable and raging beneath. And it was all night and it was a full moon and the tide over the course of the night came up and there were kind of crazy ritual dances to celebrate them. It was pretty eccentric. But I'll tell you what I came out of that with was I kind of was like, oh, fuck. the moon and the tide are connected and of course like i'd learned that as a five-year-old school boy and not understood it in the interesting way the interesting way to understand it is to perceive the moon and perceive its pull on the sea in real time to actually like feel in your bones the connection between these two things um and anyway so that was a kind of a really cool thing and i guess it kind of gets back to like uh commonality i guess commonality between people which is that being yourself is quite a fun thing um but it's not quite as nice as noticing that you are like an instance of humanity um and that um everyone else is kind of basically the same and actually so are the animals and in fact it's all matter and whatever and you know it's a paradoxical thing that when you perceive in your bones your own insignificance you feel better yeah you know that's a really good way that's an astute way to put it that's very true when you when you're yes when you're less concerned with all the just the minutiae and bullshit in your life that is really at the end of the day very trivial in the span of of history and the scale the scale of the world you feel a lot better about it uh it's really interesting isn't it but like i actually i had this when i was at school like occasionally i would like i don't know i would lose a debating competition or like discover that i was a loser in a more general sense and um i had like a what you might kind of call in a way like a a mind hack which you know i'd be sitting on the loo or something and i just think about like oh everything feels terrible and awful and it's all it's all gone to shit sort of thing and then i'd be like but if you think about it the stars really far away and then you kind of try to imagine the world from the stars and then you sort of zoom in and you'd be like oh this is tiny little character there for a fragment of time worrying about it's just like just take a chill pill it's all you know um but you know like it's it's you know to your question how to put that into your life i don't really know it's really tricky but I guess another thing is to try and draw this back is to segment a little bit, you know, to make sure there's one day a week where your mobile phone's off and to make sure that, you know, with your best friends, you find a time, whatever, once every three months to update them on just how stupid reality is and to share that.
And, you know, if you're in a relationship where, like, you kind of, you know, the struggle of, like, existence is kind of occluding the parallel magic of what could be happening there, you at least occasionally find the time to do that, you know, whatever. And, of course, I suppose the more fundamental suggestion would be to, like, stop trying so much. Right, right. Which, you know, I mean, like, tricky. Because one's got such an interesting project. I got this wonderful friend called Paul, who's one of the most intelligent people I've ever met. And very, he, he lives. So when I was talking to him about the academy, the Greek idea of my kind of imaginary possible future existence, he was like, well, you know, why does it need to be in one place?
And I was like, oh, it's true. It could just be, you know, in the world. And then he was like, why does it need to be with the same group of people? And I was like, oh, that's true. You know, like updating the people is quite good fun. And then he was like, and, you know, why does it have to be in sunshine? Why can't it be in a mixture of things? And I was like, it's true. Like, I quite like rainstorms and, you know, Nordic climates and so on. And, you know, and then, you know, kind of almost went further. Just like, you know, why does it even need to be outside of your life at all? And he lives a life which is very humble in a way, but quite profound in another where, you know, he travels, he works an absolutely minimal amount.
He's so clever that he can sort of do like five hours of translation a week and survive, you know, like whatever. And, you know, he learns languages and he falls in love with people. Um, and he, uh, watches amazing music and he has the most incredible network of friends. I mean, I feel he's one of my best friends and he probably feels I'm one of about a hundred because he spends 10 hours a day on friendship. you know and uh you know we're in the middle of that conversation i was like ah jesus christ i'm just like you know i'm just guilty of um of um grandiose fantasy where it's uh you know the life i'm desiring through these um these concepts whatever is actually just it's right there it's something which I could be living if I would only see sort of working 12 hours a day in a startup.
Yeah, it's very hard, that balance. And I even hesitate to use the word balance. But there is a, it's challenging to balance the appreciation of the present moment with the drive to build things because the people who tend to spend, uh, and this, I mean, quite apart from that, we could debate the value of building different things, but the people who build the most very often have the least present state appreciation and the people who have are entirely in the present moment don't build very much. Uh, so you, you could, you could argue, um, you could argue very strongly for both, uh, ends of the spectrum, but trying to borrow the best practices from both is, is challenging.
And maybe the, and maybe the answer is that you, that you, that you oscillate between the two. I don't know, but, um, yeah, it's interesting. I mean, yeah, I mean, I think that's the kind of, um, and I think the, the, the question you alluded to is, is a very interesting one, which is like, is it, cause in some sense, both you and I, um, are enthusiasts for building. So, you know, I've, you know, I've devoted the last five years of my life obsessively to memorize. And, you know, you've produced a wonderful, like, collection of books and amusing and rich perspectives which you've shared with other people.
And, you know, you've enriched a lot of people's lives, no doubt. And, you know, that seems inherently meritorious. Right. It seems like that's got to be like a good thing to be doing, to be trying to do something. Right. But on the other hand, like, you know, if nobody was trying to do things, what would that be so bad? or if everyone tried to do quarter as much. I mean, there's a great book by Bertrand Russell called In Praise of Idleness. Oh, it's a great essay, yeah. And he's got this great quote in there, which is like, workers of two kinds, moving objects at or near the Earth's surface or telling other people to do so.
The first is ill-paid and unpleasant. The second is great fun and rather well remunerated. And anyway, that kind of concept of moving objects at or near the Earth's surface, you'd have to update to the present day to like moving information at or near the Earth's surface. Anyway, in that essay, he's like, well, you know, a kind of classic economic insight, I guess, which is that, you know, we can make stuff twice as efficient and work half as much, or we can make stuff twice as efficient and work the same amount. And it's not clear to me that making stuff twice as efficient and then working the same amount is the correct response.
Agreed. Agreed. Well, Ed, I'd love to ask you a couple of bite-sized questions. I know that it's, I want to let you get to your proper Friday evening since I've kind of got you under lock and key here in the office. I'd like to unleash you upon the world, but I'd love to ask you a couple of fast questions. And you can feel free to elaborate, but I'll try to, I'd love to sort of hit you with a couple of these before we come to a close. The first is one I don't usually ask, but I have to ask because you've used the words press up, which is push up for you, Yanks listening, and other things. For instance, what is the one stereotypically British thing that Americans should really appreciate or might get enjoyment of?
That's a good question. I think... I love the ka-ching. Was that a toaster? that's a new subscription Tim oh nice alright congratulations thanks yeah but yeah the it was kind of comedy in the office but I think the I've lived a bunch in Boston when I did textiles there and I've seen it in America and the thing which always kind of really impresses and amazes me about Americans and which by contrast is different in the British people is that British people are like fundamentally embarrassed about the expression of intention that it's almost like there's something like fundamentally vulgar in human in British life I suppose human life British life it's like the American calling baseball the world series But anyway, there's something fundamentally embarrassing about stating intentions.
And what's so liberating about Cali to America is that that embarrassment doesn't exist. But at the same time, going back to Britain, it's this terribly beautiful thing. And I think it's kind of connected a lot to British humor, which is this basic kind of consciousness of the absurdity of trying combined with actually still trying. What is a good gateway drug for British comedy for people who are for real dyed in the wool Americans who perhaps I've because I've I've seen some British humor. I have a lot of trouble with. I just can't quite figure it out. And then there's other British humor or British-ish humor, like Shaun of the Dead, which I find completely hilarious.
So what is a good gateway drug if you had to pick one entry point? Gateway? Why are you asking me about gateway? Can't you just ask me what I think is pure genius? Sure. Okay. All right. All right. All right. I'll let you upgrade my question. What is pure genius? I just don't want it to be pearls before swine. I want to educate, and I'm throwing myself in that same group. Right, you know, I mean, I think, does the thick of it exist in America? It's a kind of American version of it. Well, my favorite comedian is a guy called Armando Yannucci. So Armando, and then Yannucci is I-A-N-N-U-C-C-E-I.
and he had this show called the Amanda Unichi Show which I think was a failure even on British TV so this man will be brilliant for a Gary Dogue and I think part of the reason for that is that he's personally he's actually not a terribly charismatic performer he's just an absolutely brilliant writer and conceiver of comedy but the Amanda Unichi Show was this brief had a brief appearance on British TV and somehow captured both like a wicked love of life and an absolute horror at everything which is going on through a kind of completely incoherent, the absurdist humor. So for instance, I don't think of a good example, but for instance, there was one sketch which involves a guy driving his car really fast where at a very, very specific miles per hour, about 157 miles an hour, he enters into a flawless state of perfect meditative perfection where he doesn't have to make any decisions.
He just avoids all pedestrians and just disappears, but then has to get back down to zero miles an hour without killing people. Another one begins with a cityscape where you see all the lights coming on in the morning, and with each light you hear the audio of the person screaming about the futility of their existence as the narrator says this man designs bacon packaging for a living this person is in charge of bedford's water supply oh god this is the manager of bewitched bastards i hate it Sorry, I'm... It's very, like, Kierkegaard. Yeah, that's such a poor advertisement for a genius comic.
Yeah, yeah, no, no. It's always a bit tricky. But, you know, I would recommend, I'd recommend to your original question, what's a good gateway? I think Monty Python's a great gateway still, because you can't help but be delighted by their kind of cheeky enthusiasm, even as you're just tuning in to the humor. And then in contemporary things, there's a thing called Alan Partridge, which is sort of written by Armando Iannucci as well, which is the story of a radio DJ from Norfolk who is actually, has shadows of like David Brent from The Office but in a kind of rich and more amusing fashion and it is sort of trials and tribulations so Alan Potridge would be my gateway drug perfect you were really looking for a one line answer there no no I love it you have one of the most colorful vocabularies and cadences of anyone I know So I love your emails.
I was going to actually read the sequence of emails that you had recently where you introduced me to one of your friends, now a mutual friend. It's just where most people are like, Joe me, John, John me, Joe, take it from here. You create these wonderfully. I'm not going to say they're not antiquated. That's not the word that I'm looking for, but they're very they read like a Civil War love letter or something. They're so eloquent and I'm like, god damn, like this guy I wonder if the amount of effort you expend on that is the amount of effort that I would have to expend to create such a thing because you're very prosaic and very entertaining in that way is, is what did your parents do?
If you don't mind me asking professionally. Uh, uh, so my dad, um, was a coder. Um, actually, uh, he refused to teach me to code by the way, because he thought I should play in the garden, which I still vaguely resent, but I did it. I did enjoy playing the garden. And my mom was a sort of teacher. I guess I did. I did have an interesting education because I was in, um, we lived near Oxford and I ended up going to a school which had lots of Oxford academics children in it. And I was part of a class, you know, maybe I was quite good at my subjects. I was part of a class where the other people in this class were just sort of this amazingly colourful bunch of precociously intellectual characters.
And so I guess I did have a bit of that. I still kind of laugh about the kind of situation that represented. But it was in many respects quite unhealthy. Why was that unhealthy? Well, I don't think it's good to peak intellectually at the age of 13. And I think that... Do you think a lot of them did or do you think that it was... Well, I think that it was actually quite a magical time. And I think that it's quite rare in life to be surrounded by people who challenge you and who like you. Yeah, for sure. And so it's quite a great experience. It's a wonderful experience to have. But I think a lot of the people who are in that situation in the school then went off to other schools, a variety of other schools, where that didn't exist.
And so they ended up being quite, all of us ended up in some sense being quite nostalgic at the age of 14. So just to give you an example, our favorite film as a group in our teenagers was With Nail and I. I don't know if you've seen With Nail and I. Have you seen the film With Nail and I? No. With Nail? Oh, my goodness. With Nail. N-A-I-L? No, it's actually, it's all one word, with Nail. So it's the name of a character in this film. So this is your gateway drug to British humour. All right, all right. What's with Nail like? So it's basically a film about some washed up actors, but full of passion, struggling their way on a kind of comedy road trip in their late 20s.
I feel like every Netflix description of British comedy just makes me want to slip my wrists before I even get started. Oh, my God. But yes, With Nell and I. Oh, yeah. Please watch With Nell and I because it's basically a film made out of fragments of insanely quotable bits and bobs. and it's and it's I mean it's intensely funny incredibly romantic and kind of like a profound narrative I guess about what it's like to have high hopes for life and then discover that it's not quite as easy as you think it's so charming and you know it's about friendship It's a really wonderful film. Anyway, but it's also very nostalgic.
It's not a healthy age of 14. It's like, oh, gosh, I remember when I was 13. Everything was so good. We used to use words like portentous, but now I just say spoon. Aside from it sounds like you had an intellectually stimulating schooling experience at that point, Can you think of a specific defining moment of your childhood? Is there anything that stands out in terms of forming you into the person you are today? I think I can't think of something which I could honestly report as like a causal factor. But I do have a couple of favorite childhood memories. One of which was, which I think is like, it's like, this is like, This memory is something which I would, if I was held hostage and someone was about to delete this memory, I would pay, if I had them, hundreds of thousands of dollars to not delete.
Because it was a moment in my childhood, maybe I was five, in the garden, looking out at some trees in the distance. And for whatever reason with my dad, I was discussing basically visual perception, but seeing. and he was saying we must have been i must have been commenting on i don't know how it began but he was saying oh the light bounces off the trees and goes into your eyes and i found this incredibly confusing and i was like no no but my eyes go out and touch the trees that my my vision goes out and touches the trees and he was like no no no the the your eye the the photons bounce at the tree or from the sun and they enter your eye and that's how you come up with the picture and i was like and i remember just intensely the weirdness of the confusion i remember getting to a point where i was happy to accept that my vision reached out to the halfway point to meet the light in between me and the trees and uh but i just couldn't even conceive of how perception could be passive um and anyway I bumped into this thing years later when studying psychology, where a lecturer mentioned the theory of an Arabic psychologist and philosopher called, oh my goodness, I'm not sure if I can remember his name, but Al-Hazan, I think his name is.
And Al-Hazan was a guy who in the 12th century or something disproved the theory of exteroception, which apparently was really popular until like the year 1200 the theory that your eye went out and met the world rather than your eye just sits there passively and receives information and then the second thing which amplified this memory you know beyond the family connection and and just the preciousness of the virgin perspective on the world was that when i got intensely into the philosophy of perception as an undergraduate um i got into this guy called morris merlot ponty who's a kind of poetic super cool cigarette smoking french philosopher who writes beautiful prose and he um he has this theory of perception where where the activity is given back to perception not because vision goes out spatially but because perception is this active probing question asking activity involving like a profound resonance between you and the world which is so far away from neuroscience as it's normally thought of where it's all like input processing representation experience this was um this really much more beautiful and and um and i'll come back to this in a second but much more true to experience theory of perception which is that we're in this kind of dialogue or resonance with the world where our brains and the world um kind of devoted resonance which means that our brain changes and then the meaning of the stuff in the world is altered and it's a bit like dancing with somebody you know there's input there's output but it's the the pattern between you which makes the most sense in the end which is what's actually happening and so to wheel that back um the the core memory is incredible because it describes a naivety of perception which you can never get back you can never perceive the world with such a stupid idea of how perception works but at the same time you can never actually experience perception devoid of the concepts we have for what's happening to it um and the second thing is is that it's true that's what it feels like to perceive and we we suppose that so that's my favorite it actually only became significant later on, but I love it.
Let me touch on some of the aspects of perception that you brought up. I think you and I, and if you're not comfortable talking about this, let me know, but I believe you and I were chatting when we had some wine many moons ago in San Francisco about effectively augmented synesthesia. So using hardware, if I'm mixing people up, let me know, but using hardware to see smells or have this type of commingling of the senses and perception. Can you talk about that for a second? I don't know where that went or where it was, but if you could explain what you were doing, I think people would find it very interesting.
well yeah so um so after um i'll give a bit of biography i'll be as quick as possible here but i went to study under a guy called um kevin o'regan in paris and kevin o'regan i'd encountered when i was right up to my final exams at university i you know i was in this intense period of study partly because i've been drunk most of the rest of the time and so i had to really ram it in and so all these kind of ideas were new in my mind they're fusing together And I discovered this paper by this guy, Kevin O'Regan, which was in behavioral and brain sciences and was called A Sensory Motor Theory of Visual Perception.
and in it he quoted a series of the most wonderful obscure experiments from psychology which um one of which was this tactile visual substitution device created by a guy called paul barky rita bark like the composer why like and in spanish rita like lovely rita paul barky rita and he was building devices for the blind to see through touch. So the tactile visual stimulation system, TVSS, basically would take a camera on your glasses and would transform that visual input into basically a highly pixelated sort of 100 by 100 array of vibrating pins that hold against your back or your thigh or your leg or wherever.
There was a nice surface on your body to touch. And the fascinating thing about this device is if someone else is holding the camera and you have this, it just feels like random, totally patternless scratching. And when you are wearing the glasses and you first touch it to your skin, it also feels like that. But when you move around, you begin to track the correspondences between movement and sensation. And to cut a long story short, eventually you end up short-circuiting all the noise and you actually perceive through touch a visual-like experience of space before you. So you feel looming objects.
You see things going past the side. You feel things approaching as you go to them. And you have a feeling of space. And the feeling of space is based not on input, which is now like a totally different form of input, but on the patterns and connections between your movement and the sensations which arise. And so this is like an incredibly profound thing about the nature of consciousness, which is roughly speaking Kevin's theory, which I basically roughly believe is that the quality of experience is like the pattern of movements you're able to make and the expected consequences of those movements.
And so his metaphor was if you're holding a bottle of wine in your hand, as I am now, by the way, and I've nearly finished it, but you're holding a bottle of wine, you're only touching, you have your eyes closed. You're only touching part of the bottle of wine, but you kind of feel the rest of it even though you're not feeling it you know that if you move your hand upwards it's not like it couldn't be a tube or just like a little blocky sphere or something even though the touch will be the same your your perceptual experience extends beyond the current input and it's based in expectation okay so that's the preamble and as a result of that i ended up doing a phd trying to do a phd in philosophy of perception where the output that year was to consider what the difference between color and smell is.
And to do that, I kind of did what that tactile visual substitution system, in a way describes the difference between touch and vision, because it says touch feels totally different. But actually, if touch is given the same sensory motor patterns as vision, it begins to feel like vision. So you can experience vision through touch by the patterns of interaction and so i tried to come up with a theory of how color and smell feel like they do and my god they feel mysterious you know you smell cinnamon how what connection does that have with reality you see any color and particularly a beautiful rich color you know the azio blue of a morning sky or or green or whatever of a kind of rainforest canopy and it feels like inherently weird like what is the connection between your experience this rich uh intangible emotion in a way and reality it's very easy with vision because you're like oh the glass looks round it is round you know it's a very kind of military connection but with color you're like wow that orange i'm just looking at a kind of blinking light of an orange computer here and actually you tune into the orange it's like what the hell fucking relationship does that have to atoms bumping around space it seems like a totally different kind of quality so anyway i couldn't tell this i think that any longer sorry tim sorry listeners but if anyone's still here about seven hours but anyway so um um the if anyone is still listening i'm just gonna interrupt this is something that kevin rose buddy might pull by me if anyone is still listening to this podcast please let us know what you think shoot me or ed a note on twitter and put hashtag ed ed good good um this is an inside joke from a long time ago to let us know but ed please continue yeah at ted cook on twitter by the way yeah anyway so um so you know and so the thought experiment i came up with was like let's let's imagine you you see in black and white so your basic vision is black and white and then when you look at what is in fact in reality a green object you experience a particular smell say the smell of whatever leaves and then you look at what is a blue object and you experience whatever the smell of a fresh sea wind or something like that so arbitrary connections between the things But the first question was, like, could you experience those as qualities of the object?
And the answer I came up with was basically, well, of course you would, because, you know, when I currently look at an orange object, I'm just especially looking at it. And then I'm having the experience of orange and I look away and I cease having the experience of orange. And I look back and I have the experience of orange. And so if that orange was being kind of put into my head by an evil goblin who just gave me the orange feeling every time I looked at the, in fact, orange hammer, which I see in black and white. But then I would experience that color as being, which the color is in fact a smell or a sound, it could be, on the object.
So the connection between movement, I address with my perceptual organs. I look at the hammock and suddenly it's going, jing, jing, jing, jing, jing, jing, jing, jing, jing, jing, jing. Look away, it's easy to do that. I look back at it, jing, jing, jing, jing, jing, jing. I look away, it's easy to do that. after like doing that a million times you wouldn't think that the sound was coming from any other place than the surface of the object right and i i'm still of the kind of somewhat smug completely incoherent opinion that this is actually quite a fundamental insight into um into into like the mystery of sensations which is that we attribute to the cause of the sensation everything which comes with it emotionally and and we kind of project those project is actually a poreware but it's an easy one to relate to we kind of project those onto the surface of the object when in some sense they come from us it's just that when we look at the object they're there um and you know in a way this kind of goes back to the chats we were having earlier about um about our relationships with other people and even situations and aspects of ourselves which is that when we think about a particular thing if all the things that evokes in us are only evoked by that thing we think that is a characteristic of the thing not of our interaction with a thing or a person.
No, I love this. I want to ask you, have you experimented with removing different types of sensory input, going a period of time without sight, going a period of time without hearing, anything like that? I have occasionally done, yeah, little games like that. Not to the heroic extent of a mathematician called Seymour Papet, who trained himself to look through mirrors so the world was up, down, reversed for like months at a time so that it kind of righted itself. But anyway, I have had an experience with friends where you walk around town blindfolded, led by another person. And that is so cool.
So you just get a good friend, somebody you trust, and say, I'm going to be blindfolded, or you're going to be blindfolded, and I'm just going to lead you around town. And that's magic because you can have the experience of perceiving the world, not visually, but just through sound. And, you know, it's fun in the obvious sense, but it's also like, oh, wow. Like I actually can perceive the world through sound. And what's more, I perceive it in a different, but in many ways, richer fashion. since by the way since occasionally you're citing some cool books there's a book called Touching the Rock by Touching the Rock I'm not sure if I remember the guy's name by John something or other Holt perhaps but Touching the Rock, Google it and it's the story of a guy who goes blind very very gradually for 20 years and then finally becomes completely blind.
And many interesting things about it. One of which is that he says that the difference between having a tiny crack of indeterminate light and nothing was as big as the difference between indeterminate light and full vision because suddenly he was just in the abyss. Right. And there was just no visual connection. But the second thing is kind of like that he has, he's a kind of theologian. But he has this wonderful reflections on how he came to enjoy the world being blind. And one go-to example is that rain is the best thing for blind people because you can hear the world in three dimensions. Because the pattering of the raindrops on the roofs and the pavement, the lampposts and the buildings gives you, because of the echo, because of the particulate, It gives you a sense of 3D space where most of the time your 3D space only goes like a couple of yards in front of you.
And otherwise, it's just the void. Stuff like that, which kind of cool way games for just enjoying your senses generally. So fascinating. I'm sorry, go ahead. I was just thinking that for anyone who's endured this long, that would be a kind of valuable recommendation. recommendation it's like you know we're drawing a few things together you know next time there's due to be a rainstorm rather than thinking like oh no i'm not going to be able to go to santa cruz and sun myself or something think like get one of your best friends go out in the rain blindfold them and allow them to perceive through the magic of hearing the world in all its mysterious or awesomeness via audition.
Oh, it's a brilliant suggestion. I also wonder, you know, at what point will we see, and it could be done a couple of different ways technologically, but people using, let's just say blind people, using something like an Oculus Rift, or it wouldn't necessarily be an Oculus Rift, could just be some type of device that's attached where you can upload very accurate, you know, to the centimeter, uh, mapping 3d mapping of the world around them. Let's just say in a 10 mile radius. Uh, or there could be some device for sensing all of this that provides them with auditory feedback or other types of feedback that tells them exactly where they are.
And what this makes me think of, there's a, one of my, one of my favorite articles I've read in the last 10 years is an article in, uh, in men's journal. I just looked it up. People can Google the blind man who taught himself to see. And it's about Daniel Kish, K-I-S-H. And he's been sightless since he was a year old. He can mountain bike. He can navigate the wilderness alone. He can recognize a building as far away as a thousand feet. I'm just kind of reading the subtitle here, but he does it through echolocation, the same way that bats find their way around. He has the ability to click in a very, very methodical, uh, precise way to determine exactly where things are and where he is.
And, uh, I'll just give people a teaser with the first paragraph because this, this entire piece blew my mind. And the first paragraph is the first thing, this is the, the author speaking, Michael Finkel. The first thing Daniel Kish does when I pull up to his tidy gray bungalow in Long Beach, California is make fun of my driving. You're going to leave it that far from the curb. He asks, He's standing on his stoop a good 10 paces from my car. I glance behind me as I walk up. I am indeed parked about a foot and a half from the curb. I mean, it's just so amazing. So amazing. And it also raises questions for me about when you just mentioned touching the rock and the difference between having just a glimmer of light perception and none.
how much of a phase shift it is often for people who will use psychedelics, for instance, and mushrooms, and the difference between the sort of normal resolution at which we view the world, and then the one step removed, moving upwards, where we have almost an enhanced HD perception of the world and how significantly that changes your perception of everything. And you're seeing everything with new eyes, even though it's really just one click of the dial in terms of resolution. So fascinating. Well, we have a lot to talk about. I want to let you get to your night. You've been very generous with your time and I always enjoy wrapping with you.
Yeah, it's a pleasure to hear. Really fun. On that point, by the way, there's a, you know, just to sort of pile up the reading list, there's Alan Watts, who's quite a kind of cheerful and wide-ranging and amusing kind of 20th century philosopher, hallucinogen taker. I think he described himself as a sort of spiritual entertainer. He wrote an essay called The Joyous Cosmology, which examines in quite fascinating ways a little bit the, I guess, what you call the phenomenology of hallucination, where he talks about exactly that. like how it's even possible that perception can become much higher resolution and what it means that it is possible and so uh you know because i for instance as anyone else i think considers like the resolution of my perception to be a function of my perceptual organs and brain and it's it's not an easily accessible idea that i could perceive it twice the resolution basically by paying more attention.
And so he's quite magic on this subject. He talks about hallucination as a terrible term for the phenomenon because hallucination implies distortion and unreality, whereas this is hyper-reality, as he describes it. And anyway, so that's well worth a read, The Joyous Cosmology by Alan Watts. I love it. Ed, where can people find more about you, what you're up to on the internets or otherwise? Well, in Hackney, in the non-internets, I hang out. So come to Hackney and then get into it. But yeah, Memorize.com is worth a look. We have a website and an app, and we're trying to make learning joyful. if you're really into the questions about phenomenology and stuff about the quality of experience there's a there's an ask which can be found online called is trilled smell possible is what smell possible trilled in the sense of the musical note going do de de de de de de de de de de right right right is trilled smell possible which is definitely like I mean it's probably one of the worst most incoherent pieces ever published in a philosophy journal but it's quite good and yeah and I'm at Ted Cook on Twitter and that is Ed Cook with an E at the end for exceptional is that right that's exactly right although actually on Twitter I'm Ted Cook because I'm twat at taking Ed Cook you're at Ted Cook really with a T at the beginning Timmy you're not following me Jesus Christ I know I should be following I have all this goodness I have I'm in a bit of social media malaise I have a bit of digital fatigue so I've been taking a break of sorts to the extent that I do but Ed I will let you get to your evening and your weekend thanks so much for jumping on hey this has been a pleasure Tim really fun so we will we will grab some wine and get into some trouble next time you're in San Francisco impeccable All right.
Thanks, Ed. Bye. This episode of the Tim Ferriss Show is brought to you by 99designs. 99designs is the world's largest online marketplace of graphic designers. And I have used 99designs for years, including to get cover concepts for the 4-Hour Body, which went on to become number one New York Times, number one Wall Street Journal. It was a huge hit. And here's how it works. and you can check everything out, including some of my competitions. You can see these book covers and so on at 99designs.com forward slash Tim. Whether you need a logo, a car wrap, a web design, an app, a thumbnail, a t-shirt, whatever, you go to 99designs.
com, you describe your project, and then within a week or less, you have tons of designers around the world who compete for your business and submit different ideas and designs and drafts. You have an original design that you love or you pay nothing. It is fantastic. I have used it. I have mentioned it before, including in the four hour work week as a resource, check it out. 99designs.com forward slash Tim. And if you use that link, you'll be able to see what I've done on the platform. You will also get $99 as an upgrade for free, which will get you more designs, more submissions. So check it out.
And until next time, thank you for listening. Thank you.