Main Topic: The alleged Russian plot to pay the Taliban to kill American soldiers in Afghanistan and the implications for US-Russia relations and the Afghan people.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Host
Support for this show comes from ServiceNow. AI is only as powerful as the platform it's built into, don't you know? That's why it's no surprise that more than 85% of the Fortune 500 use the ServiceNow AI platform. Didn't know that. While other platforms duct tape tools together, ServiceNow seamlessly unifies people, data, workflows, and AI, connecting every corner of your business. And with AI agents working together autonomously, anyone in any department can focus on the work that matters most. I've never met an AI agent. Learn how ServiceNow puts AI to work for people at servicenow.com.
Soft music continues in the background
President Trump has a pretty cozy relationship with Russia. He flat out asked the country for help in the 2016 election against Hillary Clinton. Russia, if you're listening, I hope you're able to find the 30,000 emails that are missing. He defended the country after it went ahead and meddled in the election. People came to me, Dan Coats came to me and some others. They said they think it's Russia. I have President Putin. He just said it's not Russia. He even tried to bring Russia into the G7. Russia should be in this meeting. Why are we having a meeting without Russia being in the meeting? But lately, it's gotten hard for Trump to defend Russia, especially over the last week. There is good reason to believe that the Russian government paid the Taliban to kill American soldiers.
Soft music continues
Zach Beecham has been covering this story for Vox. Well, it's tantamount to an act of war from one nuclear armed power against another one. Not that they're likely to escalate to major war, but it's a sign that Russian foreign policy has become so antagonistic towards the United States that they're willing to outright kill American soldiers. even though the two countries are nominally in sort of a time of peace and cooperation.
Zach Beecham
Okay, so let's start at the beginning here. Walk us through what we know that the Russians are alleged to have been doing in Afghanistan and when.
Host
The first report that we've heard of, that in March 2019, the U.S. government got some early murky intelligence that the Russians may have been doing this. The initiative seemed to come from the GRU, which is its military intelligence agency. They're the people who did the election hack. They poisoned a former Russian double agent in Britain. Sergei Skripal, seen here in CCTV footage, and his daughter Yulia have been in hospital since Sunday when they were found unconscious on a bench outside a shopping center in the southwestern town of Salisbury.
Zach Beecham
In this unit specifically of the GRU that's allegedly involved, they do a lot of the violent shady stuff. The poisoning of former Russian intelligence officer Sergei Skripal and his daughter Yulia follows several mysterious deaths of Russians in Britain. Many of them had been living in the UK and had made allegations against Russian President Vladimir Putin or his country's security services.
Host
So in March 2019, it wasn't super clear, right? At that point, the intelligence wasn't actionable, which means that people didn't really know how serious it was or if the US should respond.
Zach Beecham
Fast forward to February 2020, and by then we also know, thanks to the New York Times, that the intelligence community was becoming increasingly confident that the Russians were doing this and had done it over the course of 2019.
Host
Are there any specific attacks that U.S. intelligence says were linked to the Russians? They believe that one might be. There was a 2019 car bomb attack around Bagram Airfield that killed three U.S. Marines. This was in April 2019. This was a powerful suicide bomb targeting a medical building near to the Bagram Air Base. Six Afghans were wounded on the attack on this facility, which is being built to help local people.
Zach Beecham
There's not yet been a claim of responsibility, but both the Taliban and ISIS stage attacks on a near daily basis in Kabul and other parts of the country. And this bomb was so big. Do we know that this was a result of the Russian initiative here? No, but they are investigating this as potentially linked to what the Russians have done.
Host
What is the evidence that U.S. intelligence is working on to claim that the Russians were behind these attacks or at least sponsored them? The U.S. government has captured Taliban soldiers and interrogated them. And they have said, you know, we were doing this thing with the Russians. So that's where the suspicions of this plot began with because some prisoners were saying that to them.
Zach Beecham
And interrogations may or may not be a reliable source of information. But we know, again, thanks to the New York Times, that the US intercepted evidence of money going from a GRU account to the Taliban's bank account. Like they literally have paid them.
Host
The second point is that the Afghan government has developed some information linked to this So they did a bunch of raids around Kabul to deal with some illegal or militant activity And they rounded up a bunch of guys who were involved in what essentially like an informal money transfer system But some of these people that they rounded up were local businessmen who claimed to be middlemen between the Taliban and the Russians.
Zach Beecham
So there was this direct transfer, but there was also another money route, apparently, that came from these people. And to support this, the Afghan government found huge amounts of cash, like an unusual amount of cash in their homes.
Host
So it is totally plausible based on these three pieces, the financial transfers, US interrogations, and Afghan interrogations of a different type of person revealing a different facet of the alleged plot that leads me to believe that this probably did happen. Again, I can't say with certainty, intelligence world is super murky, and we don't know what the dissenters inside the US government.
Zach Beecham
There's some internal controversy, but the financial transfer seems to have lessened this. Why do you think intelligence officials are leaking this story to the press at this point? What's in it for them?
Host
I think they had been really frustrated for months with presidential inaction on this topic, and Trump not doing anything, despite being briefed and informed that the Russians were messing with American lives and potentially killing American soldiers. And they went to the press essentially as a whistleblower type thing.
Zach Beecham
The processes for accountability are failing. Trump is waging war on inspectors general. The only thing that we can do is go to the press and hope the public and the political branches can do something about it.
Host
This seems like a pretty huge risk on Russia's part, why would putting bounties on American troops be worth it for them?
Zach Beecham
The way to think of the Russian motivation here is retaliation and payback in two different senses of the term. The first one has to do with Ukraine. One major break between the Trump administration and the Obama administration, somewhat ironically, is that the Trump people have provided lethal military assistance to the Ukrainian government in their fight against Russia inside its borders.
Host
This has really infuriated the Russians. It's one of the things about Trump's policy they really, really dislike. And it is possible that the Russians see killing Americans as direct retaliation for the fact that Americans have provided lethal assistance to Ukrainians who have killed Russians.
Zach Beecham
But you also should go back even further in time, to the 1980s. The US was then involved in fighting back against the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan, specifically by supporting local fighters called the Mujahideen through arms transfers who would eventually become the Taliban.
Host
So that was a real blow to Soviet power at the time. The US program was, whether or not it's morally defensible, it was strategically very effective in bogging down the Russians in a terrible conflict. But now we're 30, 40 years later from the Russian invasion of Afghanistan, and that still seems to be on the mind of some Russian policymakers.
Zach Beecham
Apparently, according to some open source reports, some members of the GRU unit that was involved in this bounty program were actually veterans of this Afghanistan war. Like they were alive then and fighting in it on the Soviet side. So they see attacking the United States and Afghanistan not merely as a strategic project of bogging the U.S. down in a conflict and not merely as some kind of payback for what the U.S. is doing in Ukraine, but as a really sort of symbolic retaliation for a slight and a defeat the U.S. inflicted on the Soviet Union 30, 40 years ago.
Host
Isn't Russia worried about the Taliban as well? They don't seem especially concerned.
Zach Beecham
I'm not exactly sure why the Russians aren't worried about there being some kind of backlash from there being a militant Islamist group on their borders, but I think you can make the argument, and a lot of analysts do, that the Taliban has over the course of the past 20 years evolved from being the kind of group that would support and host Al-Qaeda inside their borders to one that is much more concerned with its own survival and with regaining power in Afghanistan and preventing a rerun of the 2001 invasion that toppled it.
Host
So they'd be much less interested in hosting foreign jihadists. And the evidence for this is that there was an attempt to build an ISIS presence in Afghanistan, and the Taliban attacked them and pretty thoroughly demolished them because they didn't want the competition from another militant Islamist group in the area.
Zach Beecham
So if you think that their objectives have changed from transnational jihadism to basically jihadism in one country, then you're less concerned if you're Russia.
Host
And is that why U.S. troops are still in Afghanistan, to counter the Taliban, to try to manage the Taliban?
Zach Beecham
Well, the Afghan war has taken on a life of its own in the mind of U.S. policymakers. It's gone well past the initial strategic objective of rooting out al-Qaeda and its patrons in the Taliban, and has become a sort of, we can't leave because if we leave, we'll lose.
Host
And they also think that they would be abandoning their allies in the Afghan government to the tender mercies of the Taliban and would get a lot of people killed.
Zach Beecham
The problem is it pretty clear that the US government does not have the ability even with its Afghan partners to destroy the Taliban in any kind of meaningful sense So there needs to be some kind of negotiated withdrawal for the United States And in February, the Trump administration did ink an agreement with the Taliban.
Host
After 18 months of talks and nearly two decades of war, the U.S. and the Afghan Taliban have just signed a long-awaited deal aimed at paving the way to peace and the departure of foreign troops.
Zach Beecham
There's no telling how long this deal is going to last, though. And even with the deal, civilians are still dying in Afghanistan. I mean, the U.S. has been in Afghanistan for almost 20 years. Russia invaded before that.
Host
What does all this mean for the Afghan people? I mean, there's something horribly familiar for people in Afghanistan about this kind of thing happening to them. Their country has become a battleground for a variety of different forces. The United States, Al-Qaeda, the Pakistani government, now the Russian government.
Zach Beecham
And while this may not mean very much immediately in terms of there may not be a violent U.S. escalation or retaliation, it is an awful way to live. to have for decades now been caught between struggles between great powers. And it has ruined the lives of thousands, tens of thousands, maybe millions of Afghans.
Host
And the ongoing warfare in that country should be seen rightly, first and foremost, as a human tragedy.
Zach Beecham
More with me in a minute.
Soft music continues
Host
Support for Today Explained comes from Chime. Nobody likes fees and complicated banking, says Chime. And Chime gets that, says Chime. Chime is a financial technology company that says they understand that every dollar counts. So when you set up direct deposit through Chime, they say you get access to fee-free features, such as free overdraft coverage, getting paid up to two days early with direct deposit, so much more.
Zach Beecham
Chime says with qualifying direct deposits, you can be eligible for free overdraft up to $200 on debit card purchases and cash withdrawals. Plus, they say you don't need to worry about monthly fees or maintenance fees.
Host
You can work on your financial goals through Chime today. You can open an account in two minutes at chime.com slash explained. That's chime.com slash explained. Chime feels like progress.
Zach Beecham
Chime is a financial technology company, not a bank. Banking services and debit card provided by the Bank or Bank NA or StrideBank NA. Members FDIC. Spot me eligibility requirements and overdraft limits apply. Timing depends on submission of payment file. Fees apply at out-of-network ATMs. Bank ranking and number of ATMs according to U.S. News and World Report 2023. Chime checking account required.
Host
Avoiding your unfinished home projects because you're not sure where to start? Thumbtack knows homes, so you don't have to. Don't know the difference between matte paint finish and satin? Or what that clunking sound from your dryer is? With Thumbtack, you don't have to be a home pro. You just have to hire one.
Zach Beecham
You can hire top-rated pros, see price estimates, and read reviews all on the app. Download today.
Host
Zach, when exactly did U.S. intelligence first find out that Russia was apparently paying the Taliban to kill American soldiers?
Zach Beecham
So it seems like U.S. intelligence got word of it in early 2019. The first briefing of the president that we've heard about came in March 2019. U.S. intelligence was pretty spotty at that point. It was not confirmed. It was just a sort of, hey, we have some reason to believe that this might be happening.
Host
That is according to the Associated Press, and the briefing was led by John Bolton, who was then the National Security Advisor.
Zach Beecham
This is a big deal. Russia killing American soldiers is, even for the Russians, a significant an escalation in their anti-American activities.
Host
And what do we know about what President Trump knew and when he knew it? We know that this briefing happened in March 2019. We also know that Bolton was not the only national security advisor to have spoken to the president about this.
Zach Beecham
And then we also know on February 27th, 2020, the allegations were included in the president's daily brief, which is a document that basically summarizes the most important things that the president needs to know.
Host
And the PDB, as it's called, because President's Daily Brief is too long and annoying to say, is supposed to be something that every president reads every day.
Zach Beecham
And at this point, U.S. intelligence was much more confident. They were saying, this is serious. We have to pay attention and start formulating a response.
Host
What does Trump do when he hears about this? Nothing. That's the really interesting point.
Zach Beecham
And this is actually, in some ways, the crux of the entire controversy. So the White House's argument is the president was never briefed on this. The CIA director, NSA, national security advisor, and the chief of staff can all confirm that neither the president nor the vice president were briefed on the alleged Russian bounty intelligence.
Host
This is pretty clearly a lie at this point, right? There just very very good reporting in the Associated Press and the New York Times among other papers that President Trump has received this information the February 27th date is really important because if that were not true the White House would just leak the president daily brief right It a document It a written document and it could easily disprove the Times allegations The fact that they haven done that indicates that the Times is, you know, they're pretty confident in their reporting.
Zach Beecham
They've probably either seen the document or spoken to the person who wrote it or something like that.
Host
So then we have one of two possibilities about the president's reaction. And this is really, This is all speculation, but there really logically are only two. One, the president didn't pay enough attention to his PDB and his briefings to think about this, which sounds outlandish, except that everything we know about the Trump administration internally suggests the president really doesn't pay very much attention to what he's told.
Zach Beecham
He doesn't like to hear conflicting information. He may genuinely not internalize important things. So that would be one scandalous possibility.
Host
The other one is that he paid attention. He heard what Bolton was saying. He read the PDB. But he chose to ignore it because he has had multiple calls with Russian President Vladimir Putin between February and today.
Zach Beecham
And he does not seem to have raised the issue with Putin once, as far as we can tell, which would be the first thing that you would do if you're an American president dealing with a scandal like this. What you say is, knock it off. And that would be the normal first move before you escalate in any kind of way.
Host
So it seems like we basically have two options here, right? Trump didn't know or Trump didn't care. Correct. Either one is scandalous, and we don't know which one it is.
Zach Beecham
You know, this is all coming out well after Trump publicly said that Russia was not at all responsible for meddling in the election.
Host
Do you think Trump's kind of appeasing stance towards Russia is emboldening this kind of activity? I feel like it has to be.
Zach Beecham
So one thing that's known about Trump's handling of intelligence is that he's very sensitive about anything Russia-related. When he gets briefed on something like that, he gets testy, especially if it says the Russians are doing something bad.
Host
He gets mad about it. He does not appreciate being told that he has to deal negatively with Putin.
Zach Beecham
We also know that he's very friendly, even deferential, to Vladimir Putin during their calls. This is thanks to a recent CNN piece from Carl Bernstein that, you know, during these calls, the president's national security staff have been humiliated and embarrassed by the way that he has handled himself speaking to strongmen and Putin in particular.
Host
So it makes sense that the Russians would feel like they can do whatever they want, because in a certain sense, they can.
Zach Beecham
Are Republican members of Congress speaking out about this? So they seem upset about the underlying plot, if it's true.
Host
Republican lawmakers took to Twitter, with Senator Lindsey Graham saying it was imperative Congress get to the bottom of the reports, while Representative Liz Cheney demanded to know why the president wasn't briefed and what is being done to protect American forces and hold Putin accountable.
Zach Beecham
This is something that's bound to upset Republican elected officials. And why wouldn't it, right? Because a huge portion of the party's identity is standing up for the troops and caring about American national security and being strong on those issues.
Host
And it's very interesting to see how this will play out, right? I don't know if there will be Senate hearings on it. I spoke to a Democratic senator yesterday, Tammy Duckworth, who said there will be. She's confident.
Zach Beecham
While he spent his weekend golfing, lying, and making sure the buck stopped anywhere but with him, our troops in hotspots around the world were forced to wonder whether they might be next, whether a bounty might be placed on their heads tomorrow, and whether President Trump would even care enough to respond if that was the case.
Host
I am certain the House will do something about it, and we'll see Democrats hauling somebody before the chamber to answer for it.
Zach Beecham
The idea that somehow he didn't know or isn't being briefed, it is a dereliction of duty if that's the case. And if he was briefed and nothing was done about this, that's a dereliction of duty.
Host
Given everything that's going on right now, I mean, a huge recession, nationwide protests, obviously a global pandemic. Is this story going to break through? Will the American public and I guess especially Trump's base, will they care?
Zach Beecham
Yeah, the politics of it kind of confused me. Is this orders of magnitude worse than what Trump did with Ukraine in the eyes of ordinary voters? I don't know.
Host
So part of me wonders if for people who are not super plugged into American politics and foreign policy, this kind of thing just sounds like a bunch of geopolitical maneuvering.
Zach Beecham
But on the other hand, a huge portion of the American public cares about the military and is deferential to the military as an institution, especially sort of centrist and right-leaning voters.
Host
And so you'd think that the U.S. government letting the Russians, the Russians, get away with literal murder would matter to them.
Zach Beecham
I struggle sometimes with the nature of public response to scandals in a polarized political environment. But you're right that right now, you know, once in a generation pandemic and social justice movement at the same time is certainly sucking up a lot of the political oxygen.
Host
Zach Beecham is a co-host of the Worldly Podcast from Vox. I'm Noam Hassenfeld, filling in for Sean Ramos for him. This is Today Explained.
Theme music starts to fade in
Thanks for listening to Today Explained. If you want to support the show, you can subscribe to us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts. And if you're feeling generous, you can leave us a tip at vox.com/tip.