Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses the bill to ban caste discrimination in California, which is set to be signed into law by Governor Gavin Newsom. The bill aims to protect people from caste-based discrimination in workplaces, schools, and housing.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Noelle King
Not long ago, reporter Sonia Paul was working on a story about caste discrimination in California. Caste is a tradition that comes from India. It's a hereditary identity where some people are at the top of society and some are at the bottom.
Sonia Paul
Anyway, Sonia asked a source, have you ever experienced caste discrimination here in the U.S.? So it happens all the time. What's the one that, like, maybe is most outrageous or hurts the most? The handshake.
Noelle King
What is the handshake?
Sonia Paul
I run into this gentleman. We shake hands. He's holding a tissue in his hand right where he states his cast. Then he says, you have to hold a tissue. You never know who you're shaking hands with. I said, really? I am that untouchable. I'm that untouchable.
Noelle King
The state of California wants to make this caste discrimination illegal. That's coming up on Today Explained.
Support for Today Explained
Support for Today Explained comes from Adio. Adio is an AI-native customer relationship management platform that Adio says is built for the next era of companies.
Sonia Paul
Reporter Sonia Paul has been covering caste in the United States for the past several years, and she recently reported and hosted a BBC documentary called The Hidden Caste Codes in Silicon Valley.
Noelle King
We called Sonia to talk about this bill that California's Governor Gavin Newsom is about to sign into law. This law would ban caste discrimination in workplaces, houses, and schools.
Sonia Paul
So I started by asking Sonia to explain what caste is.
Noelle King
In its most basic sense, caste is a social identity that is determined by your family. There are people at the top and there are people at the bottom.
Sonia Paul
At the top of this system is a group of people known as Brahmins. And at the bottom, technically outside the caste system, they are outcast are the Dalits.
Noelle King
What kind of jobs do Dalits have historically?
Sonia Paul
Historically, they took on jobs like manual scavenging, which is basically cleaning human excrement or street sweeping. Basically, all the jobs that were deemed to be unclean or impure.
Noelle King
I associate caste with India. Is this purely an Indian thing?
Sonia Paul
No, and this is a common misunderstanding. Caste was first mentioned in ancient Hindu scripture, but over time, it permeated other religions and it exists throughout South Asia.
Noelle King
You've spoken to a lot of people who have talked about experiencing caste discrimination in your reporting. What do they tell you? What does caste discrimination look like?
Sonia Paul
So people can tell caste often based on last name or a person's ancestral village or what their families historically did for a living, right?
Support for Today Explained
Noelle King
Support for this show comes from Macy's. Layering is an art form. All it takes is a bit of intention, style, and of course, the perfect cold weather staples.
Sonia Paul
So in the BBC documentary I reported, actually, there was a tech worker who, you know, received very excellent performance evaluations throughout his time at a tech company, which is a well-known tech company here in the United States.
Noelle King
And afterward, he had a manager switch and the new manager, also Indian origin, had asked about the pronunciation of his last name.
Sonia Paul
Hey, your last name spelled P-I-L-L-I, Pillai. And is it Pillai or Pillai? Pillai in South India is an affluent caste last name. And Pillai, in our native language in Telugu, only the majority of Dalit communities have that last name.
Noelle King
And afterward, he received like the lowest performance appraisals he's ever received.
Sonia Paul
I have been given a zero, putting me in not met category to my job's responsibility. And he actually went to his company, but they determined that no caste discrimination had occurred.
Noelle King
Of course, at the time, there was no policy in place about that.
Sonia Paul
But if you were to think about that situation, it sounded like there was maybe unconscious bias or a perception that this person wasn't working up to par once you know their caste background.
Noelle King
So another dimension of this is that many people who are from these Dalit communities or marginalized caste backgrounds actually hide their identities.
Sonia Paul
So I spoke with a man, Dr. Singh. He's actually one of the most vocal supporters of the caste bill now.
Noelle King
And he told me about when he was applying for residency, he actually had somebody who was in a position of power to help that process literally ask him his caste background.
Sonia Paul
He did ask me, oh, do you belong to this caste, upper caste? And he knew that person was from a dominant caste background.
Noelle King
I was kind of dumbfounded at that time. What should I answer?
Sonia Paul
Because if I say yes then it might make him feel good. If I say it different then his response might change.
Noelle King
And so Dr Singh basically lied and said he was of the same background as well because he didn't want to risk revealing his actual caste identity and that person not wanting to help him out in the same manner anymore.
Sonia Paul
Where did the idea of legally outlawing caste discrimination come from? How did this get started?
Noelle King
This understanding of outlawing caste in legal terms has been going around for a long time, right?
Sonia Paul
But the most prominent example, I think, came in 2020, in the summer of 2020, in the middle of the protests after the murder of George Floyd.
Noelle King
News broke of a lawsuit against Cisco, which is a multinational company based in Silicon Valley.
Sonia Paul
The state of California sued Cisco Systems on behalf of a Dalit engineer, just like Cornelius, on an all-Indian work team.
Noelle King
The lawsuit claims that when the engineer's dominant caste bosses found out his caste, they discriminated against him and then retaliated when he complained to HR.
Sonia Paul
Alleging that two managers had discriminated against a person because he's Dalit.
Noelle King
And so that lawsuit was against the managers, but also against Cisco, the company itself.
Sonia Paul
And after the Cisco lawsuit, we saw kind of a wave of other colleges and universities adding caste as a protected category.
Noelle King
The California Democratic Party added caste as a protected category.
Sonia Paul
And then in February of this year, Seattle became the first American city to ban caste discrimination.
Noelle King
This will be a systemic legal way to stop this from growing in Seattle.
Sonia Paul
And just recently, Fresno became the second city and first city in California to do just the same.
Noelle King
Fresno authorities officially marked caste and indigianity as two protected categories in Fresno Municipal Code on Friday after city council members unanimously voted to do so.
Sonia Paul
The California bill has opponents.
Noelle King
Who are the opponents? Who opposes this?
Sonia Paul
So the most vocal opposition to the California bill comes from some Hindu groups and individuals who say that naming caste in the law, even if it's a subset of ancestry, just the fact that you're saying the word caste, it's basically going to malign Hindus because of the popular understanding between caste and Hinduism.
Noelle King
And they are calling for Gavin Newsom to veto the bill.
Sonia Paul
I would just ask, why is anybody supporting a racist law like SB 403, which presumes that a community is guilty until they can prove themselves innocent?
Noelle King
So bottom line is we're stereotyped over this term too much already.
Sonia Paul
And then you add this law on top of it. It just, you know, amplifies that.
Noelle King
And that's not fair.
Sonia Paul
I would assume the people who are opposing this law to ban discrimination are upper caste.
Noelle King
Is that fair?
Sonia Paul
Yes, I think that's fair, especially because the vast majority of Indian Americans have historically come from these dominant caste communities.
Noelle King
And that has to do with the fact that, you know, post-1965, the U.S. wanted a lot of skilled workers.
Sonia Paul
The people who had the resources to make it over here and be selected by U.S. immigration policy were people from dominant caste backgrounds.
Noelle King
Earlier this year, California had a bunch of hearings about the bill.
Sonia Paul
And I spoke with a lot of the opposition, many of whom just said, like, caste is not relevant.
Noelle King
There are also people that I spoke with who blatantly feel that this is an attack on Hinduism and that there is no way that you can separate the definition of caste from Hinduism.
Sonia Paul
In the U.S. also, no one asks each other which caste you are. None of us know which caste they belong to.
Noelle King
And we don't care if you're Dalit or you're Praman. We're all Indians and we all go to temple.
Sonia Paul
Why do you think we're seeing these attempts at legislation concentrated on the West Coast and not in other places with big Indian American or South Asian populations like New York or Illinois?
Noelle King
I think a lot of that has to do with how many of the initial complaints that came out about caste discrimination in the wake of the Cisco lawsuit came from tech companies.
Sonia Paul
So Seattle is a major tech hub. California with Silicon Valley is a major tech hub.
Noelle King
And it also has to do with where do you have the will of lawmakers to introduce such legislation?
Sonia Paul
So in Seattle, it was Shama Sawant, who is a socialist and Indian American, who introduced this bill.
Noelle King
In California, it was Senator Ayesha Wahab, who is also progressive.
Sonia Paul
So it's like, where are these people who are kind of making waves and talking about caste discrimination?
Noelle King
A, where are their lawmakers paying attention and wanting to do something about it?
Sonia Paul
You've talked to people who really want these anti-caste discrimination laws passed.
Noelle King
What do they imagine will happen once this becomes law?
Sonia Paul
What gets better for them?
Noelle King
I mean, two things are happening simultaneously.
Sonia Paul
One is that people are talking about caste discrimination.
Noelle King
Two is you actually see people from these marginalized caste backgrounds coming out and asserting themselves.
Sonia Paul
You know, they're not hiding their identities anymore.
Noelle King
And so a bill to ban caste discrimination only does so much in the workplace and housing and education and so on and so forth.
Sonia Paul
But the hope is that once you put it into the law, A, you assert this exists.
Noelle King
B, you assert that you're not going to tolerate it anymore.
Sonia Paul
And so it trickles down from the law and that healing can begin when they feel comfortable asserting their identities in the public, right?
Noelle King
So there's a lot going on here, especially given the fact that caste atrocities continue to this day in South Asia.
Sonia Paul
What can happen here in California that can sort of set the motion for the rest of the world to understand this pain?
Noelle King
Sonia Paul is a journalist in California who covers caste.
Coming up, how caste has shaped Indian politics, including entrenching the authoritarian prime minister Narendra Modi.
Support for Today Explained
Support for today's show comes from Adio. What is Adio?
Sonia Paul
Adio is an AI customer relationship management system built specifically for the next era of companies.
Noelle King
They say it extremely powerful adapts to your unique data structures and scales with any business model.
Sonia Paul
According to Adio, Adio takes less than a minute to set up, and within seconds you will have your email and calendars synced.
Noelle King
You'll see all your relationships in a fully-fledged platform, they say, all enriched with that actionable data.
Sonia Paul
And they say you can build AI-powered automations and use its research agent to tackle some of your most complex processes to seize so that you can focus on what matters, building your company.
Noelle King
You can join industry leaders such as Flatfile, Replicate, Modal, and so much more.
Sonia Paul
You can go to atio.com slash todayexplained to get 15% off your first year.
Noelle King
That's A-T-T-I-O dot com slash todayexplained.
Let's be honest. Are you happy with your job? Like, really happy?
Sonia Paul
The unfortunate fact is that a huge number of people can't say yes to that.
Noelle King
Far too many of us are stuck in a job we've outgrown, or one we never wanted in the first place.
Sonia Paul
But still, we stick it out.
Noelle King
And we give reasons like, what if the next move is even worse?
Sonia Paul
I've already put years into this place.
Noelle King
And maybe the most common one, isn't everyone kind of miserable at work?
Sonia Paul
But there's a difference between reasons for staying and excuses for not leaving.
Noelle King
It's time to get unstuck.
Sonia Paul
It's time for strawberry.me.
Noelle King
They match you with a certified career coach who helps you go from where you are to where you actually want to be.
Sonia Paul
Your coach helps you get clear on your goals, create a plan, build your confidence, and keeps you accountable along the way.
Noelle King
So don't leave your career to chance.
Sonia Paul
Take action and own your future with a professional coach in your corner.
Noelle King
Go to strawberry.me slash unstuck to claim a special offer.
Sonia Paul
That's strawberry.me slash unstuck.
Noelle King
You are listening to Today Explained.
and Narendra Modi into power.
Sonia Paul
So the story starts when India outlaws caste discrimination, which was?
Noelle King
So right after independence, actually, so it was banned in 1948, and then that impulse was then enshrined in our constitution.
Sonia Paul
I don't want to paint this kind of rosy picture of like we became independent, we banned caste, and then everything was great.
Noelle King
Caste, if anything, receded into the private sphere to some extent.
Sonia Paul
We are actually Shudras, lower caste. To be specific, sir, we people...
Noelle King
You can't mention that. We are not supposed to mention it.
Sonia Paul
That applies to you, sir.
Noelle King
Yes, but I can mention it, sir.
Sonia Paul
Even though, you know, I come from a family that was politically progressive in many ways, caste was absolutely a background noise of our private life.
Noelle King
Discussions of who in the family had married out of caste, you know, and sort of being so young that it was the adults who were talking amongst themselves.
Sonia Paul
But it's not that the attitudes or the social mores around caste disappeared precisely because it's perpetuated through practices like marriage, you know, which is very much part of how family and social life is organized.
Noelle King
He said that he wanted Brahmin.
Sonia Paul
And I was shocked. He doesn't know anything about Brahmin.
Noelle King
And he's not practicing.
Sonia Paul
And why do he want a Brahmin girl?
Noelle King
Cast in many ways, especially for families like mine, which were upper caste and urban, it receded into the realm of the private, but never died.
Sonia Paul
In the late 1970s, there was a really pivotal moment, which was the promulgation of a commission called the Mundell Commission that was tasked with studying what other communities beyond those already recognized in the Constitution should have access to some kind of legal redress for historical caste discrimination.
Noelle King
And the Mandal Commission comes back and, you know, shows that actually many communities, which in legal parlance in India are referred to as other backward castes, have actually experienced the ill effects and the historical ill effects of being lower caste, even if they weren't technically say untouchable, right?
Sonia Paul
And this, of course, constitutes the majority of the country.
Noelle King
So if you are in a lower caste, the caste system has been bad for you.
Sonia Paul
That seems pretty self-evident.
Noelle King
What does it say about the upper castes?
Sonia Paul
The Bundel Commission's findings were shocking.
Noelle King
I mean, for example, Brahmins were massively overrepresented in India's parliament, in the higher education sector, in the higher reaches of business.
Sonia Paul
All the 121 leadership positions in India's top newsrooms are held by dominant castes.
Noelle King
93% of board members of Indian corporates are upper caste.
Sonia Paul
41% of the country's total wealth is owned by upper caste Hindus.
Noelle King
What happens after that, after the realization that Brahmins dominate everything?
Sonia Paul
The government then puts aside a certain number of seats to government jobs and education for lower castes now.
Noelle King
This is not just the untouchable. We're talking about lower castes.
Sonia Paul
And this is the implementation that leads to this kind of violent backlash.
Noelle King
So the lower castes are now getting better treatment and there's a backlash from the upper castes.
Sonia Paul
How does that affect Indian politics?
Noelle King
There was an old party that represented the sort of Hindu nationalists that was part of the coalition of the ruling party that had been in charge of the government at the time that the Mondal Commission report was put together.
Sonia Paul
And as part of the backlash around this report, this party kind of splits off and becomes what is today known as the Bharatiya Janata Party, which is the ruling party of India.
Noelle King
The BJP.
Sonia Paul
The BJP is the political wing of the RSS which stands for Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh or the National Volunteer Organization, is an Indian Hindu nationalist paramilitary organization, which were fashioned along the lines of the Italian fascists and had strong ties to them.
Noelle King
In 1992, in the city of Ayodhya, when the RSS joined other right-wing Hindu groups to demolish the historic Babri Masjid.
Sonia Paul
The mosque's destruction sparked Hindu-Muslim communal rioting that killed some 2,000 people.
Noelle King
You see this kind of massive rise in the electoral popularity of the BJP.
Sonia Paul
And a lot of that has to do with the consolidation of the upper caste in many ways as its real base.
Noelle King
The RSS, its base has traditionally been the Brahmins.
Sonia Paul
So what really ends up becoming the sort of real turning point after the Mandal Commission report is when it was finally implemented in 1990.
Noelle King
And when it was implemented, there were mass protests.
Sonia Paul
Soon after the Mandal recommendations were implemented, Rajiv Goswami, a student of Delhi University, set himself on fire, sustaining 50 percent burns.
Noelle King
Including, very famously, a case of one Brahmin student activist who tried to immolate himself.
Sonia Paul
He survived the immolation bit, but the spark had been ignited.
Noelle King
In cities and towns near Delhi, a number of youths set themselves on fire.
Sonia Paul
This sort of backlash is kind of, you know, shown by a dramatic act of political activism.
Noelle King
Throughout the 1990s, you see these various upper caste groups, I mean, and including really violent militias, that organize as a way to kind of reinforce the caste system against what they would consider these uppity lower castes that are sort of agitating for greater access to education and better jobs, etc.
Sonia Paul
Hundreds of villages have been butchered by a private upper caste army.
Noelle King
They're being killed not for what they've done, but for who they are.
Sonia Paul
The report comes out, it says the lower castes have suffered as a result of caste discrimination.
Noelle King
We're going to have to change some things.
Sonia Paul
And then as a result of that report, the BJP, this political party, starts to get a lot of support.
Noelle King
The BJP now leads India.
Sonia Paul
This is Prime Minister Narendra Modi's party.
Noelle King
Where does his government stand on caste?
Sonia Paul
So the ruling party in India has to kind of walk a fine line because, of course, the upper castes who form its base are demographically a minority.
Noelle King
So this is really the sort of dilemma that caste poses to the ruling party, because on the one hand, their ideologies and their practices are absolutely beholden to Brahmins and Brahmanism, I would say.
Sonia Paul
And on the other, the consolidation of their base and their vision of Indian nationalism requires the consolidation of the category of the Hindu, which of course means that they cannot allow the idea of caste to tear apart that category.
Noelle King
Are people in India paying attention to these anti-caste discrimination bills in the U.S., which are aimed at protecting the historically marginalized lower castes?
Sonia Paul
Oh, absolutely.
Noelle King
We shift our focus to Seattle, a city in the American state of Washington, a city which is being hailed for banning caste-based discrimination.
Sonia Paul
The decision in Seattle is being called controversial, even Hindu phobic.
Noelle King
An Indian origin senator is complaining and the Indian community is not happy.
Sonia Paul
This is in many, many ways an absolutely globalized fight.
Noelle King
And we're not just talking about sort of echoes of arguments that are made in India that show up here.
Sonia Paul
Right. But we're talking about like actual, you know, ties between different groups here as well as in India.
Noelle King
Why do you think these bills are being introduced in the United States today?
Sonia Paul
The flows of Indian immigration since the 1990s, particularly in areas like tech, where you have had a big flow of highly educated Indians and where, frankly, from my own observations, having lived in some of these communities, I can absolutely say that, you know, they have retrenched and practiced caste.
Noelle King
So, for example, I have heard schoolchildren talk without any self-reflection about the fact that they're pure vegetarians because they're Brahmins.
Sonia Paul
I see caste pride personalized license plates on cars everywhere, which to me at least looks like a public assertion of caste power, which is frightening.
Noelle King
We're not going to be able to abolish caste in India I think without also thinking about what it means to abolish caste in the diaspora and vice versa these are absolutely connected movements but I think so for the U.S. case certainly I think it's an absolutely welcome move not just from the point of view of just the South Asian community or other minority communities where caste as practice, but from the point of view of larger U.S. society, which is to recognize that there are vulnerable communities even within racialized minorities that require protection.
That was Professor Ananya Chakravarti of Georgetown.
Today's episode was produced by Halima Shah and Isabel Angell with an assist from Siona Peterous.
It was edited by Miranda Kennedy, and fact-checked by Laura Bullard.
Our engineer is David Herman.
I'm Noelle King.
It's Today Explained.
Thank you.