Main Topic: The impact of remote work on American cities and the potential "doom loop" that could lead to a decline in urban life.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Sean Rameswaram
Welcome to Today Explained. I'm Sean Rameswaram.
It's been three years since the world shut down, and things are back to normal. Ish. According to Bloomberg News, Manhattan workers are spending at least $12.4 billion less on meals, on shopping, on entertainment, and more per year. And that's because they're spending about 30% less of their time in the office.
The shift to remote work is the biggest change to urban life since cities went from being organized around factories to being organized around offices. Today Explained, we've been trying to figure out the ramifications of remote work, and the best conclusion we can come to is that, to thrive in this new era, America's cities need to embrace new ideas about who and what is at the center of urban life.
Over the next few weeks, we're going to bring you a few episodes on the problems American cities are facing and some solutions to, and today we're kicking things off with a dose of doom.
Sound effects: Upbeat music starts playing
Support for Today Explained comes from Saks Fifth Avenue. Fall is here. Might be time to find some nice new pieces you can wear again and again. With Saks Fifth Avenue, it can be a breeze to shop for your personal style, like maybe a relaxed Prada blazer or Gucci loafers that are great for both work and the weekend.
This is very Sean. This is very Sean-coated. Gucci loafers. Saks says Saks makes shopping feel totally customized to you, whether that's from an in-store stylist or a visit to Saks.com, where they can show you just what you want to see.
They say they'll even let you know when arrivals from your favorite designers are in or when something you've been eyeing is back in stock. You can find inspiration for your personal style every day at Saks Fifth Avenue.
Not all journalism is the same. Take The Guardian. Our coverage has something unique. Fierce independence. Nobody owns us or tells us what we can and can't say. So we're free to report the whole picture.
We connect what's happening in Washington to the rest of the globe. expose corruption wherever we find it, and give fresh perspective on everything from wellness and soccer to culture, the climate and more. Read, watch and listen to The Guardian for free at TheGuardian.com.
I guess the Lord must be in New York City. All right. Today Explained, Sean Ramos from here with Miles Bryan, who is our Philadelphia Bureau Chief. But today, Miles, you don't find yourself in Philadelphia, do you?
Miles Bryan
I am not in Philadelphia, Sean. I'm actually in New York City. And specifically, I'm at Vox's office in Lower Manhattan.
Sean Rameswaram
It's in a building at 85 Broad Street. This big, beautiful skyscraper used to be the home of Goldman Sachs.
It's Wednesday. It's the middle of the week. And I just want to know, can you hear the sound of the office?
Miles Bryan
Let me listen. I hear dead silence. Let me jack my mic way up. I hear nothing but my internal monologue.
Sean Rameswaram
The point I'm trying to make here is that it's the middle of the week. It's Wednesday and it's super quiet in here.
Miles Bryan
Yeah, it's the same way in the D.C. office. Actually, the D.C. office is totally empty most days.
Sean Rameswaram
And the reason I wanted to make this point that the D.C. office is empty and that our New York office is empty is that this is a series about cities and their future.
And if you care about cities and you're thinking about that future, this is really worrisome to you. The fact that, you know, three years into this pandemic, people still aren't going back to their offices at anything near the rate they were before COVID broke out.
And I've been talking to a lot of people who think about this stuff and think about what it means for the future of cities. And they have this term for kind of the worst case scenario. It's the doom loop.
Doom loop? Say it with me. Doom loop. Doom loop. Doom loop. Doom loop. Doom loop. Okay, this doom loop, it's sort of a death spiral for cities.
The idea of the doom loop is that as remote work pushes down property values, eventually the taxes collected from those offices and urban retail will also fall.
Miles Bryan
That's Stan Van Neuwerberg. He's a real estate professor at Columbia who has popularized this idea of the doom loop.
Sean Rameswaram
He wrote a big paper recently called Work from Home and the Office Real Estate Apocalypse.
Miles Bryan
Stan says that when those tax revenues decline, the city's still going to have to find that money somewhere, right?
Sean Rameswaram
Yeah. So look, they'll probably have to raise taxes. Maybe on residential real estate, maybe on income, maybe on businesses, maybe either on households or on businesses, all of which would make the city a less attractive place to live, to work, to do business.
Miles Bryan
Or Stan says maybe instead of raising taxes, the city would make cuts. It could cut transit service or the school budget or the police budget. All of which would make the city a less attractive place to live.
Sean Rameswaram
And so, you know, now that fewer taxes are collected, fewer people are living in the cities. Property values will fall further. Taxes will have to rise further. Government spending will have to fall further. More people will leave and so forth and so forth.
And we get into this urban doom loop. So people like us who live in cities and like our cities also like working from home. And what we're getting here is that working from home is going to create this downward spiral that makes our cities worse.
Miles Bryan
Yeah, it could create a downward spiral of declining tax revenue, which leads to declining benefits, which leads to more people moving away. It's not necessarily going to happen, but it could.
Sean Rameswaram
It's worth noting here that not all major American cities rely on a downtown office core in the same way. You know, different cities have different revenue streams. But it's a real concern for big cities like New York, Chicago, Seattle, San Francisco, and you know, Sean, this has sort of become a personal obsession for me.
Like you said, the people implicated here are people like you and me, you know, like I live in Philly, but my team, you are mostly based in D.C. My wife's office is in New York, but she works out of her home office here in Philly.
Miles Bryan
And, you know, I love Philly. I love dense urban places in general, and I want to see them succeed. But right now, I feel like I'm kind of part of the sickness that could cause their downfall.
Sean Rameswaram
So I wanted to see what was at the heart of all this and if there was a way out.
Miles Bryan
Well, if this is an obsession of yours, I imagine you're the right person to ask if this is something new. Is what we seeing happen to cities as a result of the COVID pandemic new? Or has this happened before?
Sean Rameswaram
You know it not new. Many cities were actually thrown into a doom loop roughly 50 years ago.
Miles Bryan
Coming out of the Second World War, American cities were riding high. They were as populous and vibrant as they ever have been.
Sean Rameswaram
Cleveland has the lake. Erie, that is. And that's one of the main reasons it has the big industry it has. And industry is what makes Cleveland move.
Miles Bryan
They were organized around industry and manufacturing, you know, steel mills, ports, that kind of thing.
Sean Rameswaram
In Cleveland, the men drive to the plant and drop their wives at the rapid transit station. The ladies work in the offices downtown.
Miles Bryan
That was working until deindustrialization hit and the whole urban ecosystem blew up.
Sean Rameswaram
In the short run, a lot of real estate was sort of not that useful anymore, wasn't generating enough tax revenue.
Miles Bryan
That's a live shot again of that fire in the South Bronx that Steve called your attention just a few moments ago.
Sean Rameswaram
You know, as a result, the cities didn't have as many resources to invest in safety. People left.
Miles Bryan
Detroit once was called the city beautiful. It is now called the murder capital of the United States.
Sean Rameswaram
It was sort of this urban flight. And so sort of the income tax base of the cities got eroded. And this was sort of a doom loop that fed upon itself.
Miles Bryan
This era of deindustrialization was a total body blow to America's big cities. You know, they all saw huge population declines after 1950.
Sean Rameswaram
There are some cities that never really fully recovered from deindustrialization, like Detroit. But in the ones that did, the New Yorks and San Francisco's and even Pittsburgh's, it was by largely swapping out manufacturing for another kind of work, office jobs.
Miles Bryan
Whether you're looking at Chicago, New York City, you know, San Francisco, you just saw the rise of these office towers that are taking over neighborhoods, which previously would have been dedicated to manufacturing or logistics or transportation.
Sean Rameswaram
And you also saw the rise of other industries that were catering to these workers.
Miles Bryan
That's Arpit Gupta. He's a professor at NYU and co-authored that paper with Stan.
Sean Rameswaram
So you may have the meatpacking district here in New York City, for instance, that's now full of clubs and nightlife and restaurants and bars.
Miles Bryan
And so it's not just the workers themselves, but it's the entire service industry that's growing up in order to meet and cater to their needs.
Sean Rameswaram
And it becomes a self-fulfilling process because as we have more of these amenities and services, well, these cities also then become more attractive destinations for these kinds of skilled knowledge workers.
Miles Bryan
Sort of the opposite of a doom loop. Absolutely.
Sean Rameswaram
This upswing started in the 90s and lasted up until COVID. So it was an upswing that was great if you worked at Google, but maybe not so great if you worked like retail at The Gap?
Miles Bryan
Yeah, that's a fair point.
Sean Rameswaram
And, you know, this is a story that focuses a lot on the middle and upper middle class people who now have the option to work remotely.
Miles Bryan
And the reason we're focusing on those people is because they are the ones who are causing the shift.
Sean Rameswaram
But it's the working class sector that bears the brunt of it.
Miles Bryan
The core issue is that in order for cities to provide opportunity for everyone who lives there, you need to have enough revenue in order to fund schools, in order to fund public service, in order to just kind of fund everything that's necessary in order to keep the city growing.
Sean Rameswaram
That just requires a sufficient tax base. So there was this whole delicate financial ecosystem built on office workers coming in to work these knowledge sector jobs in downtown office cores.
Miles Bryan
And then COVID hits.
Sean Rameswaram
Exactly. So COVID has obviously been a short-term disaster for big cities.
Miles Bryan
In addition to the most important thing, the fact that tons of people have gotten sick and died, office use fell off a cliff in March of 2020 and has never returned.
Sean Rameswaram
Some people still live basically where they did and only go back to work sometimes. Others moved and are entirely remote now.
Miles Bryan
And other people like me got hired remote and never go to the office.
Sean Rameswaram
This company called Castle Systems, which does building security, has been tracking office key card use since the beginning of the pandemic.
Miles Bryan
And as of this month, offices in America's 10 biggest cities only had about a 50% occupancy rate.
Sean Rameswaram
That means less money being spent on public transit and those hospitality businesses that have sprung up to service office workers, the bars and the restaurants and the gyms.
Miles Bryan
And of course, it's bad for commercial real estate.
Sean Rameswaram
And sort of gradually what we have seen is that as more and more leases are coming up for renewal, more and more companies are deciding to either not renew that lease at all, or maybe to renew it for a shorter amount of time and or for less space than they were renting before.
Miles Bryan
And you know, that's just the direct impact. Lots of commercial real estate leases are five or 10 years long.
Sean Rameswaram
At some point, those are going to be up.
Miles Bryan
Something like more than half of all the leases that were outstanding on the eve of the COVID crisis have not come up for renewal yet.
Sean Rameswaram
And so, you know, the second shoe is yet to drop on the office market.
Miles Bryan
And you know, Sean, that paper I mentioned at the top of the episode about the coming office real estate apocalypse, it estimates that remote work could reduce the value of commercial office space in America by close to half a trillion dollars.
Sean Rameswaram
Here's one example. Meta, the parent company of Facebook, is spending billions of dollars just to get out of office leases it already has.
Miles Bryan
Wow. This is the loop we're talking about. That is tons of money that cities aren't going to see.
Sean Rameswaram
And this has an impact on everything a city provides.
Miles Bryan
What do cities do? Well, the way forward that basically everyone working on this problem I talk to agrees on is to rethink how big cities are designed.
And specifically who they are designed for.
Sean Rameswaram
And it's going to be a big shift, one as big or maybe even bigger than the move from industrial to office work.
Miles Bryan
So there's a solution. There's a way to break the doom loop. Maybe.
Sean Rameswaram
How to maybe break the doom loop in a minute on Today Explained.
Sound effects: Upbeat music continues to play
Support for Today Explained comes from Chime. Nobody likes fees and complicated banking says Chime. And Chime gets that says Chime.
Miles Bryan
Chime is a financial technology company that says they understand that every dollar counts.
Sean Rameswaram
So when you set up direct deposit through Chime, they say you get access to fee-free features, such as free overdraft coverage, getting paid up to two days early with direct deposit, so much more.
Miles Bryan
Chime says with qualifying direct deposits, you can be eligible for free overdraft up to $200 on debit card purchases and cash withdrawals.
Sean Rameswaram
Plus, they say you don't need to worry about monthly fees or maintenance fees.
Miles Bryan
You can work on your financial goals through Chime today.
Sean Rameswaram
You can open an account in two minutes at Chime.com slash explained.
Miles Bryan
That's Chime.com slash explained.
Sean Rameswaram
Chime feels like progress.
Miles Bryan
Chime is a financial technology company, not a bank.
Sean Rameswaram
Banking services and debit card provided by the Bancor Bank N.A. or Stride Bank N.A. Members FDIC.
Miles Bryan
Spot me eligibility requirements and overdraft limits apply.
Sean Rameswaram
Timing depends on submission of payment file.
Miles Bryan
These apply at out-of-network ATMs, bank ranking, and number of ATMs according to U.S. News and World Report 2023.
Sean Rameswaram
Chime, checking account required.
Miles Bryan
No hold music, no generic answers, no frustration. Visit sierra.ai to learn more.
Sean Rameswaram
Today Explained, back with Philadelphia Bureau Chief Miles Bryan, who went to New York City to figure out how America's urban centers can avoid this doom loop we've been talking about.
Miles Bryan
And it sounds like, Miles, you maybe got a solution.
Sean Rameswaram
You know, I definitely have something worth trying. The folks I talked to said for cities to thrive in this era, they're going to have to focus less on being great places for jobs and more on being great places to live.
Miles Bryan
And I know that sounds like a cliche, but stay with me.
Sean Rameswaram
The idea here is that whether it was industrial jobs or white collar jobs, cities have been attractive because they have the best employment opportunities.
Miles Bryan
You know, if you want to work in publishing or whatever, you had to live in New York, even if you can't really afford it and don't like living in a shoebox apartment.
Sean Rameswaram
But now you can do that job on your computer, probably.
Miles Bryan
So what keeps you in New York? It's not the housing. You could have a bigger house back home in Toledo or St. Louis.
Sean Rameswaram
What keeps you in New York, if you stay, is all those cultural amenities that we talked about earlier.
Miles Bryan
You know, great restaurants and bars and punk shows and plays.
Arpit's talking about the particularly New York thing where there aren't alleys or dumpsters.
Sean Rameswaram
And in some neighborhoods, that's every night.
Miles Bryan
It just kind of speaks to a level of complacency, I think, with our governing class, right?
Sean Rameswaram
People just look at all this trash lining the streets and they're like, ah, well, people have no other option.
Miles Bryan
They have to love New York, best city in the world.
Sean Rameswaram
And I think we should take a different perspective and say, look, actually the trash on the street is disincentive for people to live here.
Miles Bryan
It makes it less likely that someone will continue to stick around and so we can instead put the trash in the bins and maybe that takes up a parking spot on the street but guess what?
Sean Rameswaram
Those parking spots are being taken by commuters coming in from out of state and so we don't need to prioritize them as much as the people that actually live here.
Miles Bryan
I mean, I think the bridge and tunnel crowd, as well as residents of New York City, would all agree less trash on the streets in New York would be great.
Sean Rameswaram
But how does this fix this bigger problem of office revenue, for example?
Miles Bryan
Yeah, well, picking up trash on the street would make quality of life marginally better for cities, residents, right?
Sean Rameswaram
But what's a much bigger problem for people living in cities is high rents and high costs to buy a place to live.
Miles Bryan
There's now a whole lot of empty buildings that could use new tenants.
Sean Rameswaram
What the city of the future might look like is a place where people love to live because there's just a lot of fun things to do.
Miles Bryan
And so that requires sufficient housing. It requires sufficiently affordable housing, which requires more housing than what we currently have.
Sean Rameswaram
And so there's a real opportunity here to convert some of these offices into apartments and, you know, have retail on the ground floor, have bars and restaurants on the rooftops, have that mixed use.
Miles Bryan
This isn't a hypothetical pie-in-the-sky dream, you know, converting offices into residents. It's happened before.
Sean Rameswaram
And in fact, a lot of people pointed me to what's been happening over the last couple of decades in the neighborhood our New York office is in, Manhattan's financial district.
Miles Bryan
Back in the 1990s, Lower Manhattan, you know, the area around Wall Street, was basically entirely commercial.
Sean Rameswaram
There were 400,000 jobs, but less than 40,000 residents.
Miles Bryan
But at that time, those jobs were starting to leave.
Sean Rameswaram
Lower Manhattan, when you were reading the newspapers in those days, was a problematic place with lots of controversies.
Miles Bryan
Carol Willis is a historian and founder of the Skyscraper Museum, which is in the neighborhood.
Sean Rameswaram
Its particular problem was that the financial service industry was beginning to migrate to Midtown or was merging and moving to other cities or even offshore.
Miles Bryan
Sure. So the center of downtown was being hollowed out in terms of the value of the commercial real estate.
Sean Rameswaram
Sort of similar to what's going on right now.
Miles Bryan
Yeah, sort of. Lots of offices in that area are vacant once more.
Sean Rameswaram
But this time there are way more people around after 5 p.m. and on the weekends.
Miles Bryan
I actually met Carol because her museum was hosting an exhibition a few months back about the residentializing of lower Manhattan.
Sean Rameswaram
Since the year 2000, the population of that area has more than doubled.
Miles Bryan
And you're talking about an era of historic upheaval in this part of town, because you're talking about post 9-11, when New York still manages to convince people to move and live and thrive in the financial core of downtown Manhattan.
Sean Rameswaram
How do they do that?
Miles Bryan
Well, as Carol tells it, it was a whole bunch of little policy nudges and infrastructure changes that added up.
Sean Rameswaram
First and probably most importantly New York started in the 1990s providing tax credits to developers willing to convert office space to residential.
Miles Bryan
But it was also making streets friendlier for pedestrians creating more green space opening a new public school even getting rid of some unsavory scents.
Sean Rameswaram
One of them was moving the Fulton Fish Market to the Bronx into a modern facility and closing down the operating working-class market, the frankly smelly market, for which many New Yorkers have a lot of nostalgia, but maybe an odorless nostalgia.
Miles Bryan
You know, the other huge factor here is the 9-11 terrorist attack on the World Trade Center.
Sean Rameswaram
That devastated lower Manhattan for years, but it also eventually brought a ton of city, state, and federal funding for redevelopment.
Miles Bryan
So it sounds like there's a bunch of policies that can help make this happen, but how do you actually convert an office building into apartments?
Sean Rameswaram
It is really hard.
Miles Bryan
First off, the easiest office buildings to convert to apartments are old ones because they tend to be skinnier.
Sean Rameswaram
Newer office buildings are often deeper, which means there's a lot of space without access to a window.
Miles Bryan
And even when a building is a good candidate to convert, it's still really expensive.
Sean Rameswaram
But in the financial district, it's been pretty successful, that mix of quality of life developments and tax credits.
Miles Bryan
About 13 percent of office space there was turned into apartments between 1995 and 2006.
Sean Rameswaram
OK, so even if they figure out the building, you still live in an area that was designed for offices.
Miles Bryan
And even if you go to downtown Manhattan today, you don't see a ton of green.
Sean Rameswaram
Did you talk to people who actually live there?
Miles Bryan
I did.
Sean Rameswaram
Check one, two, three, four, five. Standing in the lobby of the downtown athletic building.
Miles Bryan
Hi, Miles. How's it going?
Sean Rameswaram
I met this guy named Paul Lewis at his condo in lower Manhattan.
Miles Bryan
It's in a building called the Downtown Club, formerly known as the Downtown Athletic Club.
Sean Rameswaram
One of the nice things about the lobby is you get to see what it used to be like.
Miles Bryan
Oh, cool. So this gives you a sense of the plan of the thing, that it did have bowling alleys and swimming pools and all kinds of other amenities.
Sean Rameswaram
Each program took up an entire floor.
Miles Bryan
So this guy lives in a gym?
Sean Rameswaram
Yeah, it was a gym for people who worked on Wall Street.
Miles Bryan
So not an office conversion exactly, but the principle is the same. Taking a space that's designed for nine-to-five use and making it fit to live in.
Sean Rameswaram
How did it smell?
Miles Bryan
It smelled great.
Sean Rameswaram
Paul and his wife are both architects, and they had a lovely home.
Miles Bryan
When we stood in the living room where they live with their two kids, it just looked like a gorgeous, tasteful New York apartment with big, beautiful windows.
Sean Rameswaram
But then, you know, they showed us where they sleep, which is a room with no windows at all.
Miles Bryan
Oh! We live out here, and we really only sleep in those rooms back there.
Sean Rameswaram
So the bedrooms don't have windows?
Miles Bryan
They're technically home offices. Yeah, they're studio spaces.
Sean Rameswaram
Which is like hard for it. Typically an apartment has to have a window in the bedroom.
Miles Bryan
So legally they are studio spaces, their home offices.
Sean Rameswaram
Are you going to get in trouble if I put this on the radio?
Miles Bryan
Legally, this is our bedroom. It's just that we don't sleep here very often.
Sean Rameswaram
Just to be clear, we're looking at a very nice living room where I do not see a bed.
Miles Bryan
But yeah, it's cleverly disguised as a bookcase at the moment.
Sean Rameswaram
I don't know, Miles, if this whole thing is about quality of life, you're not selling it with this guy who sleeps in a dark closet.
Miles Bryan
You know, this is a total diversion, but he and his wife said they sleep incredibly well.
Sean Rameswaram
It's this like cave of darkness.
Miles Bryan
Stop trying to make sleeping in a windowless room happen, Miles.
Sean Rameswaram
Paul and his wife, Kim, you know, they first moved to this area in the 90s, living near that smelly fish market.
Miles Bryan
They left for years but came back in the mid-2000s.
Sean Rameswaram
Paul says they were drawn back by a new school opening up and also because they missed the diversity of the architecture.
Miles Bryan
But over time, it's actually become a much more vibrant neighborhood to live in because you don't have the same thing on every corner.
Sean Rameswaram
You don't have the self-similarity of a residential neighborhood, but it still works really well.
Miles Bryan
This is an example, plus or minus how you feel about Windows, of this working out in New York City pre-pandemic.
Sean Rameswaram
Are there any cities doing this stuff right now?
Miles Bryan
Slowly, but yes.
Sean Rameswaram
Politicians in cities like Chicago and Los Angeles are pursuing plans to subsidize office to residential conversion.
Miles Bryan
DC is offering tax incentives to do the same.
Sean Rameswaram
And in New York, the city is actually leading a big push to convert offices.
Miles Bryan
In fact, some outlets are reporting that developers are nearing a deal to acquire a stake in the former Goldman Sachs HQ.
Sean Rameswaram
Reportedly, the plan is to redevelop at least some of it into housing.
Miles Bryan
This building is at 85 Broad Street. You and I know it as the home of the Vox Media office.
Sean Rameswaram
Our very office is going to be apartments.
Miles Bryan
They got nice views over at that office.
Sean Rameswaram
The views are beautiful, and maybe the deal hasn't closed yet.
Miles Bryan
But look, that anecdote probably puts too neat of a bow on this idea.
Sean Rameswaram
Converting empty office buildings to residences is really hard.
Miles Bryan
It won't happen in a lot of places.
Sean Rameswaram
And in the cities where it does happen, it'll be a fairly small portion of the office stock.
Miles Bryan
Lower Manhattan is still very much a commercial area, right?
Sean Rameswaram
But, you know, residentializing even a little portion of a city's downtown can have a big effect.
Miles Bryan
Every couple like Paul and Kim are shoppers, transit riders, eyes on the street.
Sean Rameswaram
They make downtown more vibrant in all sorts of ways.
Miles Bryan
And in doing so, they're bulwarks against the doom loop that cities are trying to avoid.
Sean Rameswaram
Miles Bryan, Philadelphia Bureau Chief at Today, explained.
New Curious, though, for sure.
Our series on cities is being edited by Matthew Collette with help from Laura Bullard and Jolie Myers.
We're being mixed and mastered by Paul Robert Mounsey.
Next time on the series, we're going to take a look at transit.
In the District of Columbia, people got to stop paying for buses during the pandemic.
Now, D.C.'s city council is trying to make buses free forever.
Can free transit happen? We're going to ask in a week on Today Explained.