Main Topic: The recent protests in Cuba and their implications for the country's communist government.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Additional Insights:
Theme music fades out
Sean Rameswaram
Welcome to Today Explained. I'm Sean Rameswaram.
Noel King
And I'm Noel King.
Sean Rameswaram
Today, we're talking about Cuba. Cubans hit the streets for unprecedented protests against their communist government. CNN's Patrick Oppmann is on the ground in Havana with spotty wifi.
Patrick Oppmann
Thanks for having me on the show.
Sean Rameswaram
Patrick, you've been trying to connect with us all morning. How's the wifi in Havana?
Patrick Oppmann
It's been a challenge. I don't often connect with people in Havana. So tell me, is this always how hard it is? Or is this because of these protests that are going on in Cuba this week?
I arrived here nine years ago when we were in the internet wilderness then. And, I'd go to my office and that was the only place I had any kind of email or anything like that. And the internet growth has really been one of the major stories here over the years. And after the Obama opening, they opened up the internet here in the last couple of years. Everyone is online all the time.
Noel King
Okay, well, I'm glad this is working now. So let's just talk about these protests while we have you. How did these protests in Cuba get started this week?
Patrick Oppmann
So it was on Sunday. It was not something that had been called for planned. It was not something led by the island's opposition movement, which has not had a big impact over the years in terms of getting out people on a large scale like we saw. What happened was in a small city, large town, about 45 minutes from Havana, called San Antonio de los Baños, people there were very upset because for six days they've been having power outages every day, what they call Apagones here.
Sean Rameswaram
And it's stifling hot. You go outside in the night to sleep and you get eaten by mosquitoes.
Patrick Oppmann
So a lot of people in that town, hundreds of people, at a certain point just walked out their doors and started calling on really the local government to do something about it. And this is not unprecedented in Cuba, but usually when this happens, you would hear about a couple of days later. It would be an urban legend. Oh, did you hear this town? They got really upset. This time it was live streamed.
Noel King
And what happened, unlike in the past where word would slowly spread about one town where they'd had enough, is that other towns and other cities and neighborhoods where they were sick of the current situation and problems that everyone here is facing, well, they said, we're going to do the same thing. And they took to the streets. And I'm watching all of this unfold. And it was just like a domino effect.
Patrick Oppmann
I went to the ones here in Havana, and I'd never seen anything like it. It was really something I've never witnessed in nine years of living in Cuba, and something I frankly never thought I would see.
Sean Rameswaram
Has anything like this ever happened since the Cuban Revolution in the 1950s?
Patrick Oppmann
No. There have been protests. There is a group of activists in opposition who try to call for protests, and they usually fail because the government is very good at knowing who's going to go out and protest and stopping them from leaving their homes. Previous times, when there's going to be a small protest, they will take down the Internet in a part of the city where that's going to take place. There's never been a protest where thousands of people, mostly regular people, have decided to go out and call for a change.
Noel King
And it says a lot about what's different now in terms of technology and people being connected to the outside world. It also says a lot about how terrible the situation has gotten for many Cubans just in the last couple of years.
Patrick Oppmann
For me to see Cubans in front of police saying, Patria Vida, which is the new kind of anthem for change, which means fatherland and life, unlike fatherland or death, which is when Fidel Castro sings the end of those speeches by saying that. To have people saying, I want the president out. I've never seen people do that here as openly and as fearlessly as they've done over the last several days.
Music plays in the background
Sean Rameswaram
You know, I've been listening to this song, and it's really striking. Can you tell me more about it?
Patrick Oppmann
Yeah, so this is done by a number of artists, including a group called Gente de la Zona, which is like the most popular Cuban group here. They really galvanize people here. It talks about the failings of the revolution, it talks about the frustrations of people. And this song, you know, you get in trouble for playing it too loudly here. You get in trouble if you say patria vida.
Noel King
Tell me how the government's responding.
Patrick Oppmann
The government's cracked down very, very hard. That is the main response. They've not just cut the internet, but they've gone looking for people who were involved in the protest to arrest them, and some people have been very badly hurt. We know one person has been killed. There may be more. The president on Sunday night said he was giving the order to combat to supporters of the revolution.
Sean Rameswaram
So you had police in Reich here, which we've never really seen here before. They've sent out special forces and they've sent out people who just what they call rapid response brigades, which are just a group of very hardline government supporters together, very revolutionary Cubans, and they give them some bats and they send them in the street to break up the protests in a pretty ugly way.
Patrick Oppmann
And so that is one of the ways they've taken back control now. And I think protests have been pretty much extinguished at this point.
Noel King
Does that mean that whatever was happening in Cuba this week is now over?
Patrick Oppmann
No, because the underlying conditions are still there. The president of Cuba came out on Wednesday night and made one small concession, which is people coming to the island now will not have to pay taxes on food and medicines and other items they bring for their families or for themselves. And that was a pretty hated measure here that the government had for years. That's a concession. Is it enough? No, it's not enough. And that's not going to put the outrage back in the bottle.
Sean Rameswaram
But clearly the government is looking at what do we need to do to lower the temperature? People are much angrier than we realize. And what do we do to try to get some of that anger dissipated? I'm not sure what it is they can do because the government broke and a lot of it has been caused by the pandemic.
Patrick Oppmann
The way this island has been really, really hard hit by the pandemic. There's no tourism, which is one of the big income generators. And as well, the Trump administration put in some of the toughest sanctions in decades. And those sanctions have been left in place so far by the Biden administration. So they've absolutely had an impact.
Noel King
And then last but not least is is just the fact that the government has not wanted to open up has not wanted to let people grow their businesses has not wanted to let farmers really cultivate their land grow enough food for the island people here are very frustrated with the slow pace of reforms a lot of people who um i know have been here for for years we came back from living abroad thought there was a moment where they could help their country uh become a different place. Now they want to leave. They're throwing in the towel. They don't think there's a future here for them anymore.
Sean Rameswaram
I think a lot of people see these protests and they want to think, oh, communism's on the brink of failing in Cuba. But you're telling us that the protests are now over. People are mad at the government because of their own economic hardship. Does this mean something for communism in Cuba? Or is this just sort of an airing of grievances in a particular moment?
Patrick Oppmann
I think it's something that's historic that we've never seen here before that kind of damages the facade the government presented that they're all knowing they've never had protests. There's no police brutality in Cuba. And I think people have seen that they can do it and perhaps they could do it again.
Noel King
You know, we've seen in other countries that cracking down on people doesn't make those problems go away. It usually just makes things more bitter and more violent. But what it perhaps could do is cause the government here to speed up reforms and open up more, which is something they've resisted doing for a long time, and maybe finally get the Biden administration engaged with Cuba.
Sean Rameswaram
But the idea that this is kind of an Arab spring in Cuba or a moment where people are going to take to the streets and force the government out, we're not there. This is a government that the reality is they're still going around rounding people up by the hundreds, I think it's safe to say. And there'll probably be people who go to jail for some time just for being involved in a protest, maybe just for filming a protest, for supporting a protest.
Patrick Oppmann
You know, the government, they're doing what they can to squash it. So just what people don't realize is just how tough it is to be Cuban. You go to the market at 5 a.m. when the market opens up at 10 a.m. to wait in line. You get inside and there's nothing to buy. You know, there are WhatsApp groups now about where you can find eggs or cooking oil. To travel around the island when there's a shortage of gasoline is virtually impossible.
Noel King
And it is incredibly frustrating for people. And then you add on top of that you know electricity shortages a government that charges you a ton of money to get a passport or to get some papers.
Sean Rameswaram
And people really have a bitter taste in their mouth now.
Patrick Oppmann
But it's also important to point out that there's no leadership behind this movement as of yet. This is something that's very organic that happened, independent of kind of the people who are the regular opposition here.
Noel King
But what has shown the government to the world is that there are thousands of people, perhaps 10,000, that want to change, that do not accept the government's excuses that it's all about the U.S. and it's the U.S. They're blaming their government, and that's something we've never seen here before.
Sean Rameswaram
This is our goal. Qualifying direct deposits, you can be eligible for free overdraft, up to $200 on debit card purchases and cash withdrawals. Plus, they say you don't need to worry about monthly fees or maintenance fees. You can work on your financial goals through Chime today.
Noel King
You can open an account in two minutes at Chime.com slash explained.
Sean Rameswaram
That's Chime.com slash explained.
Noel King
Chime feels like progress. Chime is a financial technology company, not a bank. Banking services and debit card provided by the Bancor Bank N.A. or Stride Bank N.A. Members FDIC.
Sean Rameswaram
Spot me eligibility requirements and overdraft limits apply. Timing depends on submission of payment file. These apply at out-of-network ATMs. Bank ranking and number of ATMs according to U.S. News and World Report 2023. Chime checking account required. Subject to credit approval, AppleCard is issued by Goldman Sachs Bank USA, Salt Lake City Branch. Terms and more at AppleCard.com.
Noel King
You know about the Cuban Revolution. You've seen the Che Guevara t-shirts. You've heard about Kennedy and the Bay of Pigs. But we reached out to Lillian Guerra at the University of Florida to understand what the Cuban people wanted out of it.
Lillian Guerra
People were expecting a more egalitarian society. They were not expecting communism. And it took a long time for Cubans, even the majority had supported the changes and were unconditional in their support for the government, to really recognize what that meant.
Sean Rameswaram
And what we had from 1961 to 1991 was a revolutionary regime that gave people a certain degree of social safety net and basic needs were met. They got free health care. They got free education.
Noel King
But in return, total loyalty was expected. There were all kinds of mechanisms by which people's loyalty was policed. And a lot of the benefits of socialism were only there because the Soviets provided about $4.4 billion a year in aid directly to Cuba between 1972 and 1988.
Lillian Guerra
1991 to the present is a completely different story. So in 1991, the Soviet Union pretty much collapsed. And so as a result, Cuba lost entirely its trading partner. It had nobody to sell its sugar to. Its money was worthless.
Sean Rameswaram
And the Communist Party took radical steps, which were a shock to everybody, whereby they reversed their position that they had held for 30 years in which foreign investors and foreign investment and capitalism itself were demonized by the regime.
Noel King
And they simply adopted those things. So the government became the main joint partner in working with foreign investors to create tourism, to create the infrastructure for tourism, to, you know, in some cases, rebuild hotels or entirely create new facilities.
Lillian Guerra
They also allowed for self-employment for the first time since 1968. That was something scrapped at the end of the 60s. That reform in particular came with a lot of restrictions. The government to this day has disabled the ability of entrepreneurs to really expand their businesses precisely because they were very good at it.
Sean Rameswaram
Cuban citizens showed that with their little restaurants and their bed and breakfast, they could outcompete any government-owned facility with tourism.
Noel King
And that meant that the state saw them as an enemy.
Lillian Guerra
That has created extraordinary degrees of tension because, you know, coupled with the rise of the entrepreneurial class, you had a lot of people who suddenly, the majority of Cubans, who suddenly had access to information from the outside world.
Sean Rameswaram
Seeing a Cuban speaking on his cell phone is still an unusual sight in the streets of La Habana.
Noel King
Two months ago, Cubans were allowed for the very first time to own a cell phone. Shortly after that, it became legal for Cubans to have internet access in their homes.
Lillian Guerra
And then Obama's administration negotiated the right of Cubans to have free Wi-Fi provided to them by the government in the plazas and parks of Cuba. It was part of the negotiations for normalizing relations.
Sean Rameswaram
Under President Castro, Cuba's set a goal of bringing Cubans online and we want to help.
Noel King
So all of that has meant that Cubans have had an increasing desire and thirst for greater freedom.
Lillian Guerra
The U relationship is obviously of huge significance here but specifically the U embargo on Cuba. Could you explain how it works?
Sean Rameswaram
Yes, so it was very different in the 60s and 70s and 80s than it was in the 90s. And that was because the United States was able to exercise dominion over Latin American countries.
Noel King
Latin American countries really went along with it. So there was something of a unilateral trade embargo against Cuba.
Lillian Guerra
Fidel Castro claimed that by the 1980s that the embargo did not affect Cuba at all because they were completely united to the trading bloc of the Soviet Union after 1972.
Sean Rameswaram
The idea that we have any needs to trade with the United States should be totally eradicated. Everything we have done during these 26 years, we have done it without trade with the United States. And our future has been conceived without trade with the United States.
Noel King
Actually, The embargo only rose in importance in the discourse of the political leadership in the 90s, which is rather ironic because that's when most Latin American countries were free of the right-wing governments or dictatorships.
Lillian Guerra
One by one, you know, in the late 80s and the early 90s, as these countries democratized themselves, they became trading partners for Cuba. All of the European countries in the 90s, when the Communist Party opened their economy to foreign investment, were there, you know, from the Dutch to the Canadians.
Sean Rameswaram
I mean, the Canadians aren't European, but certainly, you know, everybody was there except the American companies. And they're still there, you know, the Brazilian companies, you name it.
Noel King
So Cuba has a lot of partners. It's just that the state controls that trade. And no small-time individual Cuban or association of Cubans is allowed to engage in that kind of activity themselves. They're not even allowed to get loans from banks. And that's not anything to do with the U.S. government. That's a Communist Party rule.
Lillian Guerra
I think that the phrase internal embargo, which is always used in Cuba as a way to refute the government's official narrative, You know, el embargo interno, el bloqueo interno, the internal blockade. That's very relevant because it is part of the daily, everyday popular culture and discourse with which Cubans fight the regime's version of reality.
Sean Rameswaram
Do you think supporting the Cuban people means supporting the end of communism in Cuba? Or do you think the Cuban people would hold on to some of the concepts and sort of foundations of communist Cuba?
Lillian Guerra
Well, I think that supporting them means letting them speak for themselves. And there is a diversity of voices that has not been allowed to be heard. If we just stepped out of the way and allowed this to take form, whatever form it takes, Cubans will find their leaders.
Noel King
They have right now, you know, millions of people in Cuba who are highly educated and who are under the age of 35. It's a third of the population. And they themselves are the faces that we're seeing on the streets.
Sean Rameswaram
The debates that are happening in the household and that are now on the streets are a very healthy thing. And it has been illegal to debate. I mean, not even does the National Assembly debate anything, except perhaps behind closed doors.
Lillian Guerra
You know, Cuban citizens are not even privy to any debate that takes place in the Council of State. You know, so they are having this debate, you know, on the streets, I think, just among themselves.
Sean Rameswaram
I'm not talking about the repressors and the security forces. The debate among the Cubans, you know, what is it we're going to say? To which protests are we going to go? I mean, that is extraordinary.
Noel King
And they need to be able to do this for themselves. And where do you think that debate leads? Does it lead to some sort of capitalist Cuba? Or does it lead to a freer sort of socialist Cuba? Do we have any idea?
Lillian Guerra
Oh, I think we do. Cubans have, you know, at every turn, wanted to take advantage of the capitalist economy in Cuba. Cubans are extremely entrepreneurial. And there are a lot of them that have made some great wealth out of the opportunity to sell their creativity. That includes artists, musicians, writers.
Sean Rameswaram
I think that they would like to see a reinvestment in the infrastructure of society. They want to see the fantasy of a good public health system actually become a reality because hospitals are a nightmare. The public health system is a nightmare.
Noel King
Cubans have had to rely on their relatives to send things like antibiotics. And that wasn't yesterday. That's been for the last 25 years that's been the case. And longer, up to 30 years, depending on where you live.
Lillian Guerra
So the situation is that the story of socialism was beautiful until 1991. And after that, it has been a myth, a complete myth or a fantasy that people who live there were visited repeatedly and stayed there. You know, we know what the reality of this is.
Sean Rameswaram
So this is why Cubans are expressing this kind of collective outrage, because they are very aware in ways that we are not of how the reality of the state is more a story, a set of lies than it is a truth.
Noel King
Lillian Guerra is a professor of Cuban and Caribbean history at the University of Florida.
Sean Rameswaram
I'm Sean Rameswaram.
Noel King
And I'm Noel King.
Sean Rameswaram
This is Today Explained.
Noel King
Thanks for listening.
Sean Rameswaram
And thanks for supporting the show.
Theme music starts playing
If you want to support the show, you can make a financial contribution to Vox. Just go to vox.com/givepodcasts.
Noel King
You can also take our audience survey. It's just five minutes, and it really helps us out. Go to vox.com/survey.
Sean Rameswaram
And if you want to learn more about your ad choices, visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices.
Noel King
Thanks again for listening.
Sean Rameswaram
And we'll see you next time on Today Explained.
Theme music continues to play until the end