Main Topic: The lasting effects of COVID-19 on individuals, including physical and neurological symptoms that can persist for months or even years after recovery.
Key Participants:
Key Points:
Takeaways:
Sean Rameswaram
Support for this show comes from ServiceNow. AI is only as powerful as the platform it's built into, don't you know? That's why it's no surprise that more than 85% of the Fortune 500 use the ServiceNow AI platform. Didn't know that. While other platforms duct tape tools together, ServiceNow seamlessly unifies people, data, workflows, and AI, connecting every corner of your business. And with AI agents working together autonomously, anyone in any department can focus on the work that matters most. I've never met an AI agent. Learn how ServiceNow puts AI to work for people at servicenow.com.
Music plays
Not all journalism is the same. Take The Guardian. Our coverage has something unique. Fierce independence. Nobody owns us or tells us what we can and can't say. So we're free to report the whole picture. We connect what's happening in Washington to the rest of the globe. Expose corruption wherever we find it. And give fresh perspective on everything. From wellness and soccer to culture, the climate and more. Read, watch, and listen to The Guardian for free at theguardian.com.
We're coming up on five months since much of the country shut down to contain COVID-19. And I think it's fair to say the country hasn't been the same since. But today on the show, we want to find out how people who have had COVID are doing, those who have survived.
It was about five months ago I spoke to Carl who got COVID on the Diamond Princess cruise ship. I spoke to him again last night. Hello, Carl.
Carl
Hey, Sean. How are you doing?
Sean Rameswaram
Doing well, but it looks like you might be back in the hospital. Yeah, I'm back in the hospital, but I'm okay. I'm glad to hear that.
Um, the last time we spoke, you were at a quarantine facility in Omaha, Nebraska, and this was, I believe, early March. Does that sound right to you?
Carl
Yeah, I ended up being there for 29 days, climbing the walls to get out of there.
Sean Rameswaram
Substantial. Okay, so 29 days in a quarantine facility. What happened over the course of those 29 days? Why did it take so long to get out?
Carl
They don't know. Right now, the CDC back then said I had to have two negative results, and it just took that long. And the doctor kept handing the results on a Post-it note.
Sean Rameswaram
I mean, it was like the Grim Reaper coming in. He changed colors every once in a while. I have a collection now of Post-it notes with my negatives and positives on there.
Carl
But I kept testing positive for a long, long time. And so eventually what? One day you just tested negative?
Yeah, one day I tested negative, and then the next—and we had to wait two days. Two days later, I tested negative, and I was a free man.
Sean Rameswaram
And what did you do then? Did they put you back on a private plane, or did you just get to walk over to the airport?
Carl
A private plane. A friend had gotten me a charter private plane that went from Omaha back to Southern California. And then a friend picked me up in a long stretch limo and had gotten me a giant bowl of my favorite ice cream.
Sean Rameswaram
So I had the peanut butter cup ice cream. Wow, Carl, I've heard a lot of sad stories about COVID-19, but that is a happy ending to a pretty rough start there.
Carl
Absolutely. But where I'm sitting right now is back in the hospital. So what happened is my body, I think, at least the doctors seem to think that makes sense. My body did a great job of fighting corona, but I had a precondition of what's called GBS, Guillain-Barre syndrome, which is why they put me in the isolation unit to begin with, the quarantine unit, biocontainment unit.
My body did a great job of fighting the COVID-19, but I couldn't touch the GBS and the doctors couldn't touch the GBS while I was sitting there the 29 days plus all the time on the Diamond Princess. So here I am now with numb legs, numb feet. It's a condition called CIDP, which is a chronic version.
And they've now tried two different kinds of treatments for me. So this is my second round in the hospital since I returned home in mid-March. And I've got about a week of therapy to learn to walk again.
Sean Rameswaram
Wow. Now, the one cool thing I want to share with you and your listeners is that we were invited, my wife and I were invited back to the White House in April. And it was very magical. And I say this to everyone. If Obama had invited me back, I would be just as a thrill. But having Vice President Pence spend the whole day with us, he and his staff, and then President Trump was supposed to spend about five minutes with us, which ended up being about an hour and a half.
Carl
But this was great. I thought, showing the mic, I said, come on, this will take five minutes. And it's taken a lot longer than five minutes, and that's because I found it so interesting.
Sean Rameswaram
There were eight of us who, from different walks of life, different ends of the spectrum politically, and different experiences with COVID-19. The president and I wanted to have a chance to see all of you and let the country hear your stories, because while we rightly as a nation reflect on the more than 23 Americans who have succumbed to the coronavirus as a tribute to our health care workers We also do well to reflect on more than 44,000 Americans who have fully recovered, and you're among them.
Carl
So you traveled to D.C. and you didn't say hello to us? We're all here in D.C., Carl. I know. They shipped us right off to a hotel. We were all in quarantine, of course. Okay, fair.
Sean Rameswaram
Other than your GBS acting up and leading to this chronic CIDP, have you had any lingering effects of COVID directly?
Carl
Yeah, they're still doing. I signed up back when I was in Nebraska for a clinical study. So they're still following me right now to see what it was. And they took many, many tests there. And then our blood, one of the hospitals here, Providence, took our blood because my wife was in a cesspool of corona and never got it.
And she, even though she was in that cesspool of corona, never got the virus. And they tested her and she's got no antibodies or very few showing the virus in there. But what they did is they took out her T-cells and her T-cells are kind of like a Superman. They touch the virus and instantly kill it.
So they brought in all varieties of coronavirus from around the world, which I think is some 20 or 30 different species of the virus, did the same thing with the T-cells And the same thing happened. Her T cells instantly killed every one of the viruses.
So now they're digging deeper to try and figure out what's in her blood that makes her the superwoman and see if they can get some answers that way. So they're studying us from the various degrees. Obviously, with CIDP now and GBS, having had corona, having had COVID-19, They're watching very carefully to see what transpires.
Both can be deadly if they get in the lungs. I've been very lucky that neither has gotten in my lungs, so I've been very good with that. Although I have noticed that my voice is much wispier. I'm a broadcast guy too. We own the local radio station out here and usually have a booming voice, but that disappeared about three weeks ago.
And I don't know, nor do the doctors know, if it's something total unique, if it's dealing with and tied in with CIDP, or if it is post-corona. We may never know the answer to that. And I'm finding little things that are after effects. And again, with each of those, I'm having trouble distinguishing if it was between CIDP or corona.
Sean Rameswaram
And in the meantime, what's your disposition? How do you feel? Are you feeling lucky that you beat it?
Carl
I feel great. I feel great psychologically. I still have my sense of humor. I plan to, I've got a goal of skiing again next winter, even though I probably won't do the extreme slopes, and then bicycling next summer. So I plan to plow through this and lead a normal life when I'm done.
Sean Rameswaram
It may take a while, but I'm going to do it. That's amazing to hear. And I commend your spirit. Just so we can set our clocks, when is it that you're going to be skiing and this is all going to be over?
Carl
I believe by my 68th birthday, which is February 22nd, is my prediction. So maybe you can join me on the slopes.
Sean Rameswaram
I hope you're right. If you're right, I certainly will. Thank you so much, Carl. And good luck. I hope you get out of the hospital soon.
Carl
Sure, thanks, Sean. You take care.
Sean Rameswaram
Carl's actually been kind of lucky. There's a raft of lingering effects of COVID people are experiencing. That's after the break on Today Explained.
Music plays
Support for Today Explained comes from Chime. Nobody likes fees and complicated banking, says Chime. And Chime gets that, says Chime. Chime is a financial technology company that says they understand that every dollar counts.
Lois
My name is Lois Partially, and I am a freelance investigative journalist and the 2019-2020 Sneddon Chair of Journalism at the University of Alaska Fairbanks, which means I'm in Alaska.
Sean Rameswaram
What's the temperature like there?
Lois
It is 50 degrees and raining, and I'm currently looking at a fox hunting in my backyard. Man, it is like 110 and swampy here, and the only thing outside my house are rats.
Sean Rameswaram
Well, I know you probably don't want to hear this, but I would trade for a little summer weather. No, I thought you might say so, Lois. grass is always greener.
Lois
We just spoke to Carl, who took a good while to recover from COVID. You've been writing about COVID recovery and lasting effects for Vox. How's recovery been for everyone else out there?
Sean Rameswaram
The CDC recently put out a report that says that even people with mild cases can have long-term consequences. They're reporting about a third of cases suffer long-term symptoms. So that can mean either weeks or months, depending on the person.
Lois
I should note that it's important that many people fully recover. But another study in the Journal of the American Medical Association found that even two months after their first symptoms, 87% of people still had symptoms. And these weren't just the sickest people. Only 12% of the people in that study were admitted to an ICU.
Sean Rameswaram
So it's not just severe cases of COVID-19 that can have these long-term consequences. Carl didn't have many lingering aspects beyond just like losing his voice, he said, but let's talk about what other people are experiencing. What are the lasting impacts of COVID-19?
Lois
So at the beginning of the pandemic, when we were first hearing about cases in China, the reports were about respiratory symptoms. It causes a pneumonia-like lung infection. And so far, nearly 300 cases have been reported in China. At least six people are known to have died.
Sean Rameswaram
But it turns out that COVID-19 isn't just an illness that affects your lungs. And we really shouldn't just be talking about it in terms of mortality. And that's especially true in the U.S. right now, as we're seeing an uptick in the number of young people who are getting sick.
Lois
Many young people may not necessarily get sick enough to go to the hospital, but they can get very sick. It turns out that SARS-CoV-2, which is the virus that causes COVID-19, affects a lot of your major organs, including your heart, kidneys, your brain, even your nervous system and your bloodstream.
Sean Rameswaram
Yikes. Okay, well, let's take a deep breath and get into all that. Starting with, I guess, the thing that most people are aware of, what's the lingering effects on people's lungs that we've seen?
Lois
So basically, you have all these gaps in your lungs. If you think about them like a sponge, those gaps are supposed to be there. But when you're sick with COVID-19, those spaces can get filled with debris and pus. And so that makes your lung way less flexible.
Sean Rameswaram
Normally, when you breathe, your lung expands like a balloon. And when it's filled with all this pus, it can't do that. So in acute infections, that ends up looking like ground. You may have heard of people talking about ground glass opacities, which is on a CT scan, a normal lung will look black and COVID-19 patients' lungs look gray.
Lois
So it's kind of unclear how much of that goes away once your acute infection is gone. And it's still too early to know how many of those are going to be permanent. But we can look back at other coronaviruses that we know a little more about, like SARS and MERS.
Sean Rameswaram
And studies on both of those coronaviruses suggest that about a third of patients have some level of reduced lung capacity for the long term. One of the studies actually followed patients for 15 years. So that suggests that some of this lung damage may be permanent.
Lois
Wow. Let's move on to the heart. What's going on with people's hearts in COVID-19 and how may those effects linger?
Sean Rameswaram
Yeah, just this week, there's a new study out of about 100 relatively young patients that showed that about 80% of them have inflammation or other cardiac symptoms after they've recovered, including, again, people who were never sick enough to go to the hospital.
Lois
After two months, 78 patients still had structural changes in their heart. And this also relates to blood circulation, I imagine?
Sean Rameswaram
Yeah. So in addition to the heart inflammation problem, a lot of COVID-19 patients also have abnormal blood clotting, which if you have blood clots in the major veins of your body, that can cause deep vein thrombosis.
Lois
And if those clots travel to your brain, it can cause a stroke. And if it goes to your heart, it can cause a heart attack. And the bad news keeps piling on.
Sean Rameswaram
You mentioned the brain and the nervous system. What's going on there?
Lois
Yeah, blood clots, unfortunately, are not the only nervous system problem with this disease. A lot of patients are reporting pretty frightening neurological symptoms like having brain fog or forgetting what they saying in the middle of speaking and having pretty severe memory issues that keep them from working the way they normally do
Sean Rameswaram
One paper actually called the disease a global threat to the entire nervous system and suggested that a lot of people have these neurological symptoms, possibly as many as over a third.
Lois
It's a heavy list of COVID-19 symptoms that might linger for people. Yeah, there's one that's a little less serious, but equally odd. Some people are reporting altered senses of taste and smell, again, for months after they first got sick.
Sean Rameswaram
A lot of people, for some reason in particular, talk about both garlic and onions tasting weird. And some people are being followed around by a phantom smell that they can really only describe as something that's like earthy.
Lois
Weirdly, it seems to be somewhat smell specific. So the only quirky lingering effect is just really depressing if you like food.
Sean Rameswaram
Yeah, which I would say is a significant effect. Yeah. If only it could have been like, some people were reporting that they had really great vision after having COVID or something like that. So far as I know, none of these long-term symptoms make life better.
Lois
I know there's so much focus on a vaccine right now, but have there been any breakthroughs in treating all of these lingering symptoms from inflammation of the lungs to the heart to the nervous system to people losing their sense of smell and taste?
Sean Rameswaram
Yeah, there have been. There are a number of post-COVID-19 clinics popping up around the country. And it's really important that people know if they're having long-term symptoms that even if we don't totally understand what's causing them, that there are treatments that can help them manage these symptoms.
Lois
Some of those treatments come from research on how to recover from being hospitalized generally with other diseases. We know that if you're intubated or ventilated or you're in an ICU, especially if you're there for a long time, that can have a number of different impacts on your body.
Sean Rameswaram
For example, being in bed for a long time causes your muscles to deteriorate, which can make any shortness of breath feel worse. And there's also significant emotional impacts of being so sick and worried about what's going to happen to you.
Lois
A lot of people experience anxiety, depression, PTSD after being in the hospital. So we have research on what some of these impacts are like. And there are people who are working to help COVID patients get treatment for these kinds of symptoms.
Sean Rameswaram
I just feel like hearing about all these lingering effects really brings to light the fact that this virus is just no joke, irrespective of how confident or healthy or young you might be, because you may have lingering symptoms that last potentially for the rest of your life.
Lois
Yeah, I think unfortunately, a lot of the conversation has been around whether or not you'll die if you get COVID-19. And unfortunately, that doesn't come close to describing the many different impacts it can have on your life.
Sean Rameswaram
It can be a really life-changing experience to be sick for months, especially when no one knows how to help you feel better. That's an incredibly anxiety-inducing and frustrating experience.
Lois
I talked to one doctor in the UK who's been sick since March, and he's a doctor. He knows quite a bit about both the virus and working in an ICU is his normal day job. But he says that he feels like his life has been turned upside down.
Sean Rameswaram
He doesn't know when he's going to be able to go back to work. And that's just a really tough position to be in.
Lois
Well, Lois, thank you for helping us understand COVID-19 a little bit more. And maybe when we understand it even further, we'll have you back on to talk about it.
Sean Rameswaram
Thanks for bringing more attention to this. I know a lot of people have been feeling really frustrated and just feeling like they're being heard, I think, will help, I hope.
Lois
I think it will. Thank you. Thanks for having me.