Podcast Episode Summary
The podcast episode discusses the European Union's (EU) new regulations on artificial intelligence (AI), which were provisionally agreed upon in December 2023. The regulations aim to ensure that AI systems serve people and comply with their rights. The EU's AI Act is considered a landmark regulation, and its full text will be available in several weeks.
Key Participants
Main Topic
The EU's new regulations on AI, which aim to ensure that AI systems serve people and comply with their rights.
Key Points
Takeaways
Additional Insights
Theme music fades out
Sean Rameswaram
Welcome to Today Explained. I'm Sean Rameswaram.
Short pause
AI is changing the way we learn. No wonder ChatGPT has been called the end of high school English, the end of the college essay, and the return of the handwritten in-class essay. It's changing the way we work. I have a friend who's building an app on his own. Normally he would have hired a developer. Instead, he's just using ChatGPT because it can code and it can correct its own code. Pretty soon, it'll be changing the way we do just about everything. Alexa, order trash biners. And yet, there have been just about zero rules governing artificial intelligence until now. I think we have made history today. Europe's gone and done some regulating on our latest technology, as Europe often does. People are using words like landmark and first of its kind. You might even hear us use those words on this episode of Today Explained.
Short pause
Support for this show comes from ServiceNow. AI is only as powerful as the platform it's built into, don't you know? That's why it's no surprise that more than 85% of the Fortune 500 use the ServiceNow AI platform. Didn't know that. While other platforms duct tape tools together, ServiceNow seamlessly unifies people, data, workflows, and AI, connecting every corner of your business. And with AI agents working together autonomously, anyone in any department can focus on the work that matters most. I've never met an AI agent. Learn how ServiceNow puts AI to work for people at servicenow.com.
Short pause
USA, Salt Lake City Branch. Terms and more at applecard.com. You're listening to Today Explained. Jess Weatherbed is a news writer at The Verge. And for a while now, she's been covering the EU's new AI Act. And was this process easy breezy, fancy free, or was it complicated? Complicated is probably one way of putting it.
Jess Weatherbed
We've got kind of a two-year timeline roughly to work with here. They proposed the AI Act back in 2021. Artificial intelligence must serve people, and therefore artificial intelligence must always comply with people's rights. AI, as we know it at that point, was vastly different to what it is now. They were working with systems that were designed to do a very specific purpose. So it was a little bit easier to try and categorize how risky those systems are going to be for people living within the EU.
Short pause
There's been a hell of a lot of interruptions and a lot of disruption caused by various things. But the biggest one I would say in the last two years was systems like ChatGPT. It's a software that has gone viral this week. It's a chatbot that uses natural language processing to generate responses to user inputs. Now suddenly rather than these AI systems that are only built to do a specific job, you've got these foundation models or large language models that are literally designed to do pretty much anything you can put their mind to it.
Short pause
They can generate images, they can write text, they can apparently write code, they can, you know. And it presented so many new options that weren't anything that could be covered by the original scope of the AI Act. We have seen a change. We have seen a change in the mood, in the discourse. And now there is no big deal, no big contraposition on the need to find a sensible regulation for generative AI.
Short pause
It had to be reworked several times over. It's one of the largest contributors to the delays in actually getting it approved. Between that and discussions around how it can be applied to things like national security and law enforcement were the two most highly contested points of what's been argued and debated about over the last year.
Short pause
Okay so the eu has been talking about regulating ai for a good while but things got real this december it kind of came to a head around 10 days ago that was when the the provisional agreements made but prior to that it was about 36 hours of just solid debate i think that you have all heard and probably agree that AI is too important not to regulate. And it's too important to badly regulate.
Short pause
A good regulation that we all agree on as soon as possible must be a common objective. At one point, they had been in Brussels having one prolonged conversation, trying to iron out the differences and compromises for about 22 hours at least. So you've got a lot of tired, cranky, potentially sleep-deprived lawmakers, policymakers all crammed into a building trying to finalize a set of blueprint AI regulations that are apparently going to be the example for every other global regulators.
Short pause
And yet they're in a room cramming college students for a finals exam. But they got it done. It was worth it because they got it done? Yeah, well, they got it provisionally agreed. So this is kind of the first big step to it being completely done. What did they get done? What are these landmark EU regulations on artificial intelligence? We don't know for sure yet.
Short pause
The full text isn't going to be available for several weeks. What they tend to do with these is that they will make compromises based on principles. Now they actually have to go away and jazz it up with the legal language that they want to have things adhered to at that point. And we built a risk-based approach that identifies high-risk AI use cases that needs to be more regulated, that needs to be checked on data used to train it.
Short pause
A lot of it seems to be following the same kind of framework that they proposed years ago, which is that they wanted a risk-based tiered system that you could categorize different AI systems with. And by taking certain attributes of what they could apply to, you can then go, great, these are low risk. These ones are high risk, which means that they're going to have to be subjected to all these investigations. They're going to have to tell us what they're doing with their data, how much power they use.
Short pause
It just makes it a little bit easier rather than having a complete free or wild west of not even having a distinction for what AI is which was where they were in 2021 And we also identified the uses that we think should be outrightly banned like the use of biometric identification in public spaces on real time to avoid by banning it the risk of mass surveillance And we also banned predictive policing, social scoring, emotional recognition for students and workers, because we think that in these cases, there is no added value and more risks than benefits.
Short pause
I remember Joe Biden sort of announcing his oversight of AI and all the AI guys came to the White House and everyone was smiling and it felt very performative. Were the AI guys happy about this regulation or were they less into it? And initially, I haven't seen anything in terms of response of the finalized professional agreement that we've just seen.
Short pause
But early on, when they were talking about blanketing all of these systems as high risk because they just didn't know what to do with them, they were very unhappy, to say the least. So companies like OpenAI, Microsoft and Google, these companies all lobbied the EU to basically come forward and go, but we're fine to self-regulate. We don't need to be held accountable.
Short pause
And it's not fair that you're going to assume that our products are automatically bad just because they could be bad. We've seen what happens to countries that try to over-regulate tech. I don't think that's what we want here. It wasn't only the AI companies that were a little bit unhappy about it. There was also some members of the EU that were not particularly happy about it because they're hoping that homegrown AI companies can have the room to innovate.
Short pause
So we know that France, Germany and Italy at some point back in November turned around and went, how about we just don't regulate general AI at all and let them do their own thing? And I think quite understandably, a lot of the rest of the EU turned around and went, uh, no. Yeah. And then that led on to a couple of extra weeks of highly contested arguments about what they should be regulating, what should be involved in this agreement.
Short pause
Two years after it was first proposed. Well, speaking of delays, when do these rules go into effect? I mean, we don't even have them officially yet. When do they take effect? So this is going to be a multi-step process.
Short pause
When the law comes into effect, within six months, anything that's outright prohibited, which includes, for example, a lot of this was in terms of kind of like national security and biometric surveillance. That will come into effect within six months to try and get that enforced as quickly as possible.
Short pause
The obligations that are going to be impacted against general AI, so the stuff that's probably going to impact companies like OpenAI. That should come into effect 12 months after the law itself has taken effect. So that stuff is probably going to take into effect in 2025.
Short pause
Anything that's going to impact these big companies and then the remainder of the rest of the gubbins, everything else that they need to tidy up should be in place by 2026. So like the full force of this law could take another two years, like two and a half years potentially to actually do anything.
Short pause
Are we going to have a different set of problems by that point? When you consider how much stuff changed between them proposing this law in 2021 and then just open AI kind of appearing on the scene within a year later going, hey, have you heard of generative AI that can do anything? We could be looking at a completely different landscape by then.
Short pause
And unfortunately, I'm not in the business of being like a seer or a prophet or anything. So I can't turn around and say, absolutely, we're going to have a different environment to deal with. They've done the best with this system that they've got the tiered system to make sure that anything that's introduced might be able to just be categorized within it already they know that if it's going to be an ai model that's turning around saying that it can do several different jobs it's going to be classified as a general ai and it's going to be beholden to a certain level of restrictions same as if they look at it and go well yeah this is a i don't know a customer facing chatbot that's going to go here like they they've made it so that anything that's developed within in the future, hypothetically, can be slotted into the existing rules.
Short pause
Sean Rameswaram
Jess Weatherbed at The Verge. Read her at theverge.com. When we're back on Today Explained, why Europe is always first with this stuff. First. Support for Today Explained comes from Chime. Nobody likes fees and complicated banking, says Chime. And Chime gets that, says Chime. Chime is a financial technology company that says they understand that every dollar counts. So when you set up direct deposit through Chime, they say you get access to fee-free features, such as free overdraft coverage, getting paid up to two days early, with direct deposit so much more.
Short pause
Chime says with qualifying direct deposits, you can be eligible for free overdraft up to $200 on debit card purchases and cash withdrawals. Plus, they say you don't need to worry about monthly fees or maintenance fees. You can work on your financial goals through Chime today. You can open an account in two minutes at Chime.com slash explained. That's Chime.com slash explained. Chime feels like progress. Chime is a financial technology company, not a bank. Banking services and debit card provided by the Bank or Bank N.A. or Stride Bank N.A. Members FDIC.
Short pause
Spot me eligibility requirements and overdraft limits apply. Timing depends on submission of payment file. These apply at out-of-network ATMs, bank ranking, and number of ATMs according to U.S. News and World Report 2023. Time checking account required. No hold music no generic answers no frustration Visit sierra to learn more Support for the show today comes from LifeKit, the podcast from NPR.
Short pause
What's in your life kit? I'm asking, they didn't ask that. Every day you have to make choices that might shape the direction of your life, but you can't flip to the back of the book to find an answer key. Instead, you can listen to the Life Kit podcast from NPR. Life Kit offers real stories about common issues like relationships, finances, parenting, and your career.
Short pause
If you're looking to move with more intention or just need thoughtful guidance on living better, Life Kit delivers strategies to help you make meaningful, sustainable change. From fitness routines to mental resilience, navigating personal goals to tackling burnout, Each episode is full of relevant insights and clear takeaways about things we all could use a little help with.
Short pause
LifeKit wants to help you approach your own life with confidence and clarity and walk away with a game plan you can implement right away. Enough from me. Go listen to the show, LifeKit. It's a podcast from NPR. Today Explained, Sean Ramos from Joined by Columbia University Professor Anu Bradford. She's the author of a book called The Brussels Effect, How the European Union Rules the World.
Short pause
Anu Bradford
So the Brussels Effect refers to European Union's unilateral ability to regulate the global marketplace. So the EU is one of the largest and wealthiest consumer markets in the world, and there are very few global companies that can afford not to trade in the EU. So as the price for accessing the European market, they need to follow European regulations. But often it is in their business interest to basically extend those regulations across their global production or their global conduct, because they want to avoid the cost of complying with multiple different regulatory regimes.
Short pause
Is the EU just always trying to be first, or is there something special going on here? How are they able to move relatively, comparatively quickly on artificial intelligence? I don't think the EU necessarily wants to be first, but it just has the ability to regulate. If you compare to the United States, there is not similar polarization in the European legislature as there is in Congress.
Short pause
So the political divides are not preventing legislation from moving forward. There's also much less lobbying, although lobbying is less effective in the EU. So the US legislative process is very much shaped by tech companies that have influence over lawmaking. And the EU just does not operate quite the same way.
Short pause
So the civil society also has access to legislators and often then offsets or balances the message that the lawmakers are hearing from the tech companies. So basically what you're saying is in Europe, you all have functional government. That is one very good way to put it. There is still a functioning government in the EU.
Short pause
There's a legislator that is capable of passing legislation, and that makes a big difference. So can you give us a sense of the history here, how much the EU has managed to accomplish in terms of tech regulation because of this functional government ideology on technology? So I would go back to early 1990s.
Short pause
That's when the U.S. really stepped back from regulation. Because the Internet has such explosive potential for prosperity. It should be a global free trade zone. Up until then, the U.S. had often been setting the rules that had global impact. But then the U.S. really adopted this market-driven dogma that was very anti-regulation.
Short pause
So the U.S. took the lead in promoting this deregulation agenda. It should be a place where government makes every effort first, as the vice president said, not to stand in the way. And the EU stepped in and filled the vacuum because at that very point, the EU was ramping up its own efforts to integrate the common European market.
Short pause
And that meant it needed to harmonize regulations so that we remove the barriers from within the member states for training within the EU. So the EU started proactively building a regulatory state, not for the purpose of ruling the world, but for the purpose of making Europe an integrated, strong trading area.
Short pause
We will strengthen the impact of this community through the ongoing implementation of common foreign and security policies. So then the EU started focusing its regulatory efforts on digital economy. The European Union has approved rules to force big technology firms such as Google, Facebook and Twitter to remove illegal content.
Short pause
The European Union has hit tech giant Meta with a record-breaking fine of over a billion dollars for defying privacy rules. And the gap between what the EU was producing and what the U.S. was failing to do in the regulatory space just became larger and larger.
Short pause
But initially, it was really the U.S.'s decision to say that, look, we trust the markets and the EU making philosophically a very different rule. And I think the inadvertent effect, the unintended consequence was that the U.S. basically ceded this whole governance space to the EU.
Short pause
And what has it accomplished? Give us some of the greatest hits. Well, I would say that GDPR is by far the most famous hit. The European Union's General Data Protection Regulation, known to friends as GDPR, goes into effect tomorrow.
Short pause
So that was enacted in 2016, and that is a very significant regulation in shaping the entire global data privacy conversation and legislative frameworks. Then also antitrust. So the Europeans are very concerned about the abuse of market power by dominant tech companies.
Short pause
You have to recognize that you have powers beyond anyone else and with that comes the responsibility So there have been four antitrust lawsuits against Google that have been successfully concluded in the EU and that have resulted in around billion in fines And then there is the content moderation space.
Short pause
So the Europeans are very concerned about disinformation. They're very concerned about hate speech and the toxic environment surrounding internet users when they're using the platforms. And we need to say to some of these service providers, you have a responsibility for the way you do business to make sure that people feel as comfortable when they are online as well as when they are offline.
Short pause
So the Europeans have moved to limit hate speech and limit disinformation, even though they remain committed to freedom of expression. There is just a sense that that important commitment to free speech is balanced against some other fundamental rights, including a right to dignity.
Short pause
And a hard pivot away from dignity to your phone chargers may be the most tangible of all these Brussels effects. There are USB-A chargers. There are USB-B chargers. There are USB-C chargers. There are micro-USB chargers. There are mini-USB chargers. There are lightning chargers.
Short pause
The EU also regulates consumer electronics. So there's an environmental concern surrounding consumer waste. And then another concern, just the consumer convenience, if you like. The idea that we do not want the consumers to have to buy different cords for all their different devices and all the different jurisdictions where they are using them.
Short pause
So the EU standardized the common charger, which then led Apple to also switch its own charging port and extend that change not just in Europe, but also outside of the EU. The word from Apple basically is like, the Europeans made us do it, but it's time and we think people aren't going to freak out.
Short pause
Now, in a case like that, with the Apple USB-C charger situation, where literally everyone around the world who has this device will have their tech now changed because of this EU regulation, why does it make more sense for a tech company like Apple to change this charging port for the whole world instead of just for the European market?
Short pause
So often for these tech companies, it's just a matter of efficiency and a cost calculus. So it is not efficient to run multiple different production lines. There are scale economies in uniform production. So they don't want to be producing different variations for different markets.
Short pause
And same applies for companies like Meta's Facebook. They pride themselves of having one global Facebook. So if you and me are having a conversation and I'm in Europe and you are in the United States, they don't want there to be a different speech rules that apply to the conversation, whereby I would not be seeing a part of the conversation that you are able to see because there are different content moderation rules.
Short pause
That would make it really difficult to have effective cross-border conversations. But I would say, Sean, that the most common reason is just simply it is just too expensive to have many varieties of the same product.
Short pause
Sean Rameswaram
I want to bring this back to AI. Has Europe met its match in artificial intelligence? We were talking earlier in the show about how these new regulation proposals may not go into effect until 2026, at least fully. That's a very long time away. And this technology might look dramatically different by then.
Short pause
Our guest did mention that, you know, these regulations might have room to be augmented to fit whatever AI looks like in 2026. But this does feel like a new day for tech regulation. So I completely agree and I concede that regulating in this space is extremely difficult.
Short pause
This is a fast-moving technology and nobody knows where we are a few years from now. But I don't think it is a reason not to intervene and regulate. There are simply too many serious harms that we need to guard individuals and societies against.
Short pause
So a responsible government does step in, even knowing that that regulation may need to be revisited. But you cannot let the perfect be the enemy of the good. There are also tremendous costs in waiting. and we do not want to just watch for all those costs to be materialized.
Short pause
The goal here is not to crush the development of AI because I think it really is important to encourage that. I think the goal is to understand that alongside those opportunities, there are non-trivial harms and the governments need to take those seriously.
Short pause
And trusting the tech companies to self-govern, it is irresponsible because these companies are so focused on pursuing the profits that they just cannot afford to spend enough time on thinking about what happens to democracy, what happens to individual rights.
Short pause
And that's not even their expertise. And that's why I take comfort that there seems to be global momentum growing, that the governments are now increasingly seeing that, look, we need to regulate this space. And now they have a template. Now they have an example that the governments can step in.
Short pause
And when they can step in, how do they do it? Well, they can look at the EU's AI Act. And I think that is a very powerful example for the rest of the world. Anu Bradford, Columbia University. She's the author of The Brussels Effect, How the European Union Rules the World. But even more recently, and also pertinent to our conversation, Digital Empires, the global battle to regulate technology.
Short pause
Our show today was produced by Amanda Llewellyn. It was edited by Matthew Collette, fact-checked by Laura Bullard, and mixed by Patrick Boyd. Today Explained!