Main Topic: The General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) and its impact on data collection and privacy policies.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Music fades out
Sean Rameswaram
Welcome to Today Explained. I'm Sean Rameswaram.
Russell Brandom
I'm Russell Brandom, senior reporter at The Verge.
Sean Rameswaram
You know those privacy policy emails flooding your inbox lately?
Russell Brandom
Yeah, I've been getting all of them. Yeah, I've been getting them too. Subject line's always the same, right? We've updated our privacy policy.
Sean Rameswaram
[chuckles] Yeah, I do that too. I just delete them without reading them.
Russell Brandom
I do that too. I would say reading them would be a mistake because you'd be losing valuable seconds, you know, all of our time as living creatures is precious.
Sean Rameswaram
[laughs] Great, because I'm going to make a terrible mistake now by reading you one of these emails. Oh no, all the listeners too. We're all stuck in it with you.
Russell Brandom
Okay. Well, for the purpose of this, you know, episode where we explain what these mean, I feel like I should maybe just read one.
Sean Rameswaram
[chuckles] Alright, go ahead.
Russell Brandom
So I went through all of the ones I have, which is about like eight from like Kickstarter and Google, and I found the shortest one. And it's from my former employer, actually, New York Public Radio.
[reading from the email] Dear friend, New York Public Radio is committed to respecting user and member privacy rights. We are writing to let you know that we are updating our privacy policy effective as of May 25th, 2018.
Sean Rameswaram
[laughs] We're almost done, for those of you who are dying.
Russell Brandom
[laughs] The new policy does not change how your data will be collected or processed. It has been revised largely to increase communication and transparency along lines suggested by new European Union legislation, the General Data Protection Regulation, GDPR.
Sean Rameswaram
So there are new rules. The GDPR, General Data Protection Regulation, it took effect May 25th and everyone was sort of scrambling to get compliant because if you're not compliant, you can get fined a ton of money.
Russell Brandom
One of the provisions is when you have the privacy policy, the terms of service where you tell people what you're doing with the data, you have to say it basically in a way that humans can understand.
Sean Rameswaram
We all know that generally these things are impossible to read. And so they specifically said, like, you have to be clear and actually tell people what's going on.
Russell Brandom
And so everyone across the board is sort of scrambling. No one really knows what a readable and clear and accessible privacy policy looks like, but everyone's kind of giving it their best shot before the deadline.
Sean Rameswaram
And that's why all the emails are coming in at the last minute. Someone I was talking to said that it was like watching all the kids like throw their homework in at the last possible minute before midnight under the professor's desk.
Russell Brandom
That's pretty much what we're seeing. So have there been some particularly egregious examples?
Sean Rameswaram
I mean, I got some that were past the deadline. You should really have the privacy policy up by the time that you're legally required to be compliant.
Russell Brandom
And there were some where it was like 3 a.m. coming in. I was like, man, you guys, you're really cutting it close here.
Sean Rameswaram
That really does feel like turning in your homework like on the day of, right?
Russell Brandom
Yeah, it's like lawyers are clocking a lot of overtime on this.
Sean Rameswaram
So the GDPR, the General Data Protection Regulation, all my emails say stuff about Europe. It's a European Union regulation, but everyone in the world is getting these emails?
Russell Brandom
Yeah, pretty much. On privacy policies, basically everyone's decided like, well, it's better if it's clearer for everyone. Like we should just change the whole thing and have it all be the same.
Sean Rameswaram
So I guess we should just walk through what GDPR is.
Russell Brandom
Any time companies are dealing with personal data at all, so like including their employees' data or data that, you know, just the grocery store has on you...
Sean Rameswaram
[interrupts] People who are running websites and Google and Facebook that are doing all this you know intense ad targeting and you know the massive data that they have...
Russell Brandom
And a lot of that needs to be changed now because it has to be brought up to these new standards.
Sean Rameswaram
So what are the new standards?
Russell Brandom
They need to say why they're collecting the data and they need to say what they're doing with it and what they're using it for.
Sean Rameswaram
And they didn't have to do that before?
Russell Brandom
Not really. That's what's so wild about it. I mean, the really remarkable thing about it is that it's sort of applying these rules to this world that has really never had any rules at all before.
Sean Rameswaram
You know, we sort of saw this with Facebook a little bit where the question of, OK, I've collected this data on the people who used my service...
Russell Brandom
They click the little box saying it's OK to collect our data, or at least we know you're collecting it. Then what can I do with it? What am I allowed to do with it?
Sean Rameswaram
Yeah. There haven't really been a lot of rules about that.
Russell Brandom
And so now you have to be very clear saying, okay, well, this is our ad targeting partner, and we were giving it to this person for ad targeting purposes.
Sean Rameswaram
And that means they're allowed to do X, Y, and Z with it, and they can't do anything else with it.
Russell Brandom
And this other person is an analytics partner, and they are doing X, Y, and Z with it. So they're allowed to do this stuff and really sort of map out who gets what in the event of a breach, who's responsible for what.
Sean Rameswaram
And so there's all of this complex sort of legal liability that suddenly applied to this world that before now had really just been a free for all.
Russell Brandom
So that sounds totally reasonable. And if anything overdue, you would think.
Sean Rameswaram
What else does the GDPR do?
Russell Brandom
So there's also a lot of stuff about you having access to your data just because like Facebook or Google or another company is holding it.
Sean Rameswaram
You can request it. You can correct it or say don't use that.
Russell Brandom
Those products are kind of already rolling out. I mean, Facebook had a version that came out a few months ago.
Sean Rameswaram
That has been another thing that's happening in the background, kind of the privacy policies were really the last thing under the wire.
Russell Brandom
It sounds sort of like all of this is about consent and transparency, making sure that users consent to everything that Google or Facebook or, you know, Zappos.com is going to do with its data.
Sean Rameswaram
There's more to it than just consent, because even consent only gets you so far in terms of collecting data and sharing it.
Russell Brandom
OK, there's also this idea that can only really be used in certain ways.
Sean Rameswaram
And even if you click all the boxes, you have certain rights, again, as an EU citizen.
Russell Brandom
So it's not like Americans can really successfully bring suit about this.
Sean Rameswaram
Is there another element of this? Like, what if you just there's so many elements.
Russell Brandom
So there's also when a data breach happens, there's it's you have a much shorter deadline as to when you have to sort of tell everyone.
Sean Rameswaram
There are a ton of lawyers who think about nothing but tiny portions of the GDPR.
Russell Brandom
So I don't want to give a sense that I've that I've covered everything. But those are sort of the greatest hits.
Sean Rameswaram
What if you're sitting there, you're looking this over for the first time in your life, you're paying attention to data policies and you're just like, I just want to opt out of all of this.
Russell Brandom
Well, I mean, do you have a cabin in the woods that you can go to?
Sean Rameswaram
[laughs]
Russell Brandom
There's no real opt out here. You can't say, I want to use Gmail, but don't ask me what my birthday is or don't ask me sort of what my interests are.
Sean Rameswaram
It's really an all or nothing pill.
Russell Brandom
And the choice that you're giving people is no choice at all. This is you're being coerced into sharing your data because you want to participate in the digital world.
Sean Rameswaram
And these are sort of necessary services.
Russell Brandom
There are definitely people who are saying a service like Facebook, which like it does have to know your birthday if it's going to tell people what your birthday is.
Sean Rameswaram
It does have to sort of know various things about your interests if it's going to serve you with relevant content.
Russell Brandom
But then there's no real line between that data and the data that's used for advertising.
Sean Rameswaram
Like it's all just sort of information that's used to serve you content.
Russell Brandom
And this is by design.
Sean Rameswaram
Okay, if we really need to separate those things, then what does Facebook even look like?
Russell Brandom
Did this all happen because of Facebook? Was this a Cambridge Analytica...
Sean Rameswaram
This has been on the books for two years. Okay, if anything it more pointed at Google it certainly pointed at Facebook too.
Russell Brandom
But I think one of the things we saw is when Facebook did get in really hot water over Cambridge Analytica...
Sean Rameswaram
I mean, one of the things Mark Zuckerberg said specifically to Congress, he said, look, we want you to feel like you own your data.
Russell Brandom
The first line of our terms of service say that you control and own the information and content that you put on Facebook.
Sean Rameswaram
We have a download your information tool where you can go, get a file of all the content there and then do whatever you want with it.
Russell Brandom
And the people are in the back of the room saying, hey, wait, that's the GDPR thing.
Sean Rameswaram
You're doing it because Europe required you legally to do that. And you got it in a couple of months early.
Russell Brandom
This isn't just because you wanted people to feel good.
Sean Rameswaram
Did anyone on the committee call him out for that?
Russell Brandom
I mean, unfortunately, Congress is not terribly well versed in like European privacy law.
Sean Rameswaram
So I think there were maybe some grumblings from staffers afterwards.
Russell Brandom
But I mean, they had plenty to be unhappy about already.
Sean Rameswaram
And I do think it's fortuitous in some ways because it's coming out at this moment when maybe in America for the first time people are really starting to be aware of the power that this kind of data sharing can have and ways in which we may want to rein it in in a way that, you know, folks have been worried about this in Europe for as long as there's been a Google.
Russell Brandom
Coming up, the billion-dollar question. Why does the European Union seem to care more about your data security than your own government?
Sean Rameswaram
This is Today Explained.
Russell Brandom
So, Russell, this just went into effect on Friday. What's happened since? Any news?
Sean Rameswaram
Yeah, so we have these extremely big lawsuits filed by this Austrian privacy activist Max Schrems basically saying that the most popular services on the Internet, you know, Android, Facebook, Instagram, WhatsApp, are not GDPR compliant because they say give us this data in order to give you this service.
Russell Brandom
And if you don't give us the data, then you can't use WhatsApp and that's it. You know, take it or leave it.
Sean Rameswaram
OK. And he says that that's sort of against the principles of the GDPR.
Russell Brandom
I should add one of the other things about the GDPR that tends to get people's attention is if you are found to not be in compliance, companies above a certain threshold of size are liable for fines of up to 4% of their global revenue, which is billions of dollars.
Sean Rameswaram
Wow. And there had been sort of laws that were kind of like this that had slightly lower fines. But this is a really scary amount of money, even for Facebook and Google, which are basically printing money.
Russell Brandom
Yeah. So the rubber is kind of meeting the road. That's kind of the big question is, OK, how do we enforce this law?
Sean Rameswaram
What does this look like? How are the courts and the various enforcement mechanisms looking at this?
Russell Brandom
Which will ultimately answer the question for people of, okay, how do I need to write my privacy policy? How do I need to write my data sharing agreement with ad targeting partners in order to comply with this so that I don't get some horrific fine?
Sean Rameswaram
And it's just been like four or five days thus far.
Russell Brandom
Oh, yeah. Has anyone been hit with a lawsuit yet?
Sean Rameswaram
Google and Facebook, those are the big ones. I mean, I think it's a little tricky because if you're waiting to do it, you want to wait to see a little bit more about how that one works out.
Russell Brandom
I mean, I think that's in part because a lot of the political will behind the GDPR in Europe has been as a way of reining in big US tech companies like Google and Facebook.
Sean Rameswaram
That's the first big test. And then water flows downstream from there.
Russell Brandom
But yeah, we see And sorry we talking like some insane sums of money here right Like how much were Google and Facebook sued for 7 billion euro
Sean Rameswaram
You know that number definitely gets your attention. It's an enormous amount of money.
Russell Brandom
I guess the 7.6 billion euro question I have then is like, why does Europe take this more seriously than the United States?
Sean Rameswaram
It is a good question. And they're really leading on here.
Russell Brandom
I mean, and there have been a couple of sort of moves in the U.S. Congress of what's the U.S. version of the GDPR.
Sean Rameswaram
These are U.S. companies. Even when Mark Zuckerberg was going for Congress and people were being a little rough on the guy, they were saying, oh, well, this is this wonderful American success story.
Russell Brandom
Like you were in your dorm room and you coded this website. Now it's this billion dollar company and you're insanely powerful. Like what a country.
Sean Rameswaram
In Europe, you look at that same thing and you see maybe this this kind of invading force, right? They see it as a threat to European values of democracy in a lot of ways, which is, again, something we're coming around to post Cambridge Analytica, but Europe has been thinking about this for a long time too.
Russell Brandom
And is part of that like fascism and communism and Big Brother being items Europe has experienced in just a much different way?
Sean Rameswaram
Absolutely. You know, a lot of the privacy campaigners in the US will say, well, Google is a surveillance company. It's not an advertising company. It's a surveillance company.
Russell Brandom
And the same thing about Facebook, right? A lot of these tech companies are surveillance companies because they're collecting information and then they're using that information to make money.
Sean Rameswaram
But really, the new thing is the collection. In the European Union, it was not so long ago that the Stasi was collecting information on East Germans like Angela Merkel.
Russell Brandom
This had very real and concrete consequences for you. The fact that this information was out there and it was being collected in a central place.
Sean Rameswaram
There's a sort of visceral understanding of the dangers of data collection in Europe.
Russell Brandom
There's an aspect of American culture where we just love a company that makes lots of money. We figure they must be doing something right.
Sean Rameswaram
And as part of the American resistance to really taking this seriously, does it have something to do with the fact that like Google and Facebook still seem like they have their hearts in the right places to a lot of people?
Russell Brandom
And we need to wait for a scandal much more incriminating than Cambridge Analytica to really feel like, oh, this is super dangerous. I'm not just going to blindly check off the box when I sign up for a new app or something.
Sean Rameswaram
It is tricky. We've done a little bit of polling and I think there's other polling you can look at. People still seem to look at tech companies fairly positively in like a non-partisan light.
Russell Brandom
It's handy to have Google Maps, right? Yeah. It's nice.
Sean Rameswaram
Part of it is also that there isn't an obvious political coalition. So far, it's mostly been Democrats, but there's also a lot of Democrats who don't particularly have a problem with this.
Russell Brandom
It just doesn't really fit into a lot of the standard partisan narratives that we have in the U.S.
Sean Rameswaram
And I mean, Congress is broken, so it's hard for anything to get through.
Russell Brandom
And there are concrete laws you can pass to the extent that you believe that data collection is a problem and you want privacy to be protected.
Sean Rameswaram
Who's going to be the person who bets their political capital on it?
Russell Brandom
The math is a little bit more complicated.
Sean Rameswaram
Russell Brandom writes about technology for The Verge.
Last week on the show, we did an episode about a big referendum in Ireland. The country for the first time was voting on whether or not to overturn its constitutional ban on abortions.
Russell Brandom
It's one of the most restrictive abortion bans in the world.
Sean Rameswaram
The referendum was Friday, and a lot of people thought it'd be close, but it wasn't. It was a landslide.
Russell Brandom
Ireland overwhelmingly voted to legalize abortion, and now Northern Ireland is considering changing its laws.
Sean Rameswaram
You can hear a whole lot about the referendum and what it means for Ireland in our episode from May 21st, if you didn't hear it then.
The link to that show is in the description for today's episode.
I'm Sean Rameswaram. This is Today Explained. Thank you.