Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses the significant demographic movement in the United States, specifically the migration to Florida, and its implications on the state's economy, politics, and climate.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Noelle King
Welcome to Today Explained. I'm Noelle King.
Silence for a moment
Florida man is responsible for a large percentage of abnormal incidents that occur in Florida. No one knows his true identity, date of birth, what he looks like. That's why headlines always say Florida man. Florida man won $2 million from scratch-off lottery ticket. Different Florida man busted with cocaine cookies, while other Florida man torched car belonging to girlfriend who also his cousin. No. Yes. No. Yes, it's true. Those are real headlines, and it may sound a mess, but there's a great migration underway to the land of In God We Trust, Florida motto.
Pause
Vox reporters have been covering an exciting and possibly significant demographic movement in the U.S. And coming up on Today Explained, we find out why does it seem like everyone is moving to Florida.
Pause
Support for Today Explained comes from BetterHelp. Let me tell you a true story. Last weekend, I got an email from a listener who wanted to discuss their problems with me. And I said, look, I don't think that this is about me personally. At least I hope it's not. Why don't you try BetterHelp.com slash Explained? Absolute truth. As the largest online therapy provider in the world, BetterHelp can provide access to mental health professionals with a diverse variety of expertise. Find the one with BetterHelp. The one is not me, guys. Our listeners get 10% off their first month at BetterHelp.com. That's BetterHelp.com. It's Today Explained.
Pause
I'm Noelle King. Maren Kogan, senior correspondent at Vox. Of all the things to write about in the state of Florida, Ron DeSantis, Donald Trump, Disney World, you wrote a story that's just about Florida itself. Why is that?
Maren Kogan
Because to me, Florida is fascinating. Florida is, you know, one of the biggest states in the country, obviously one of the most populous, but I find that so often it's on the leading edge of so many different trends, whether they're economic or political, cultural, certainly climatological. So it's really representative, but also it's very singular. So much of what makes Florida, Florida is that it's this fascinating mix of like beach bums, Disney fans, people who live in Miami and have this sort of very urban lifestyle, people who love nature, residents of Margaritaville.
Pause
And also my family is a part of this trend I was writing about of people moving to Florida. So over the last 10 years, my entire family moved to South Florida. My parents, my brother and his family. So my brother and sister-in-law and my nephew all lived down there.
Noelle King
Why did your parents move?
Maren Kogan
You know, I think they were going mostly for warmer weather. We're from a really snowy part of the country. You can't do too much outside for many months of the year. And it's like a big thing in my hometown, which is a small town in northwestern Pennsylvania. Everyone goes down there.
Pause
And in fact, my family lives in one of these communities in Florida where there are like a bunch of people from my hometown who are in the neighborhood.
Noelle King
No kidding. Yeah, it's a huge movement. You wrote this piece for Vox, not just because your own family moved to Florida, but also because many other people are doing the same. How significant is the migration into the state? What kinds of numbers are we talking about?
Maren Kogan
Yeah, so it is really significant. So just to give you some context, from 2021 to 2022, according to the Census Bureau, the state's population grew by 1.9%, making it the fastest growing state in the nation.
Pause
Now, Florida's population has been growing faster than the national average basically since the advent of air conditioning. If you ask people why they moved to Florida, there's one answer you'll hear a lot. Because I hate being cold. Everybody loves sunshine and palm trees. We have the sunny weather. You know, we call ourselves the sunshine state.
Pause
My parents are from the Caribbean, so they're used to warm weather. So that part is not necessarily new, but what is really impressive about the change is that Florida is already the third most populous state in the country. So for it to also be the fastest growing state requires a huge surge of people moving there.
Pause
Nationwide, the median home price declined. But here in Florida, competition is so steep, prices are up. According to the population estimates, about 440,000 people moved just between July 2021 and 2022. That's like adding another Miami in 12 months.
Pause
Where are people coming from and why are they going to Florida? They're coming from all over. The data shows that in recent years, most people came to Florida from New York, Georgia, Pennsylvania, Ohio, and California.
Pause
Time to kind of get out of California with the wildfires and the high cost of living and get a lot more for your dollar around here. For younger people in particular, in 2022, Florida was, for the first time, had more jobs in the state than New York.
Pause
My name is Andrew Ford. I'm 35 years old, and I work for the Atlanta Braves Spring Training Facility in Northport, Florida. The main reason that I left Nashville to come to Florida was I needed basically a full-time job at that point.
Pause
So a lot of the younger people are moving for jobs or because their spouse got a job. I was cautiously optimistic about moving to Florida. I don't know that I was expecting it to be like overwhelmingly like amazing, but I thought maybe I'll try something different.
Pause
And what I found for older people is that the pandemic sort of accelerated an existing trend of people moving to Florida. It is still a lot of older people moving, but some of them are just moving up their timelines. They always thought, oh, I'll move here after I retire. And then the pandemic happened and they thought, you know, why wait? I might as well go now.
Pause
A lot of these people experienced in the state they were living in a really hot housing market during the pandemic. And they thought I just going to go for it. And they really took that opportunity to you know start their Florida lifestyle early.
Pause
Tell me about the economic boom. What's at the center of it? How's it working?
I think the state's leadership has been very aggressive about courting business. Florida's here. We've got capacity. And we also have incentive packages to make it worth your while to be able to bring your business through our ports.
Pause
You hear Ron DeSantis and Republican leaders in the state talk about this a lot. They're really trying to court businesses away from places like California and New York, and they're really pitching it as a more business-friendly state, a state where the tax burden is lower.
Pause
And so it's really happening on multiple fronts. And then there's also, you know, a big health care boom. There's tons of need in Florida for health care professionals, particularly nurse practitioners. So you see a lot of different things happening.
Pause
And then on top of that, the state is just growing and growing. So many of the fastest growing metropolitan areas are in Florida, and that just draws more people of all kind. And certainly the real estate market is booming as well.
Pause
In progressive circles, you hear every time Ron DeSantis slaps Mickey Mouse or, you know, tries to change a school textbook, you hear people say everyone's going to move out of Florida. The governor can't keep behaving this way.
Pause
But of course, Ron DeSantis' politics do appeal to some people. Do we know the political leanings of the people who are moving into Florida?
Pause
We don't have a perfect measure of this, but we have a pretty good sense. There is good reason to believe that the people moving there do lean heavily Republican.
Pause
I got some data from L2, which is they keep a really good voter registration database. And they found that of 535,000 people who moved there between basically March 2020 and May 2023, about 45 percent of them registered as Republican, only 22 and a half percent registered as Democratic, and almost 30 percent, the remainder, registered as nonpartisan, meaning they chose neither party.
Pause
So that is a huge advantage for Republicans. Now, one thing to know about this number is this is just people who were registered in the state they came from, moved to Florida and registered again.
Pause
So this is not everyone. But it does suggest that the newcomers have a strong contingent of people who are highly motivated to vote Republican.
Pause
Now, for the first time in state history, according to the latest numbers sent by election supervisors to the State Division of Elections, there are more registered Republican voters in Florida than Democrats.
Pause
The state really kind of established itself, much like Texas, as a almost petri dish for hard right policymaking. And I was just sort of wondering, what is going on with everyone down there? How do they feel about it? Do they not care? Are they just at the beach? Do they feel like, you know, it's happening in a different realm from the Florida they know?
Pause
People had sort of unexpected positions on different things. So I talked to a young woman in her 20s who was into food blogging. I'm Rebecca Pytel. I'm 27, recently turned 27 in June. I was born and raised in New Jersey my entire life, and I moved to Florida, and it's been two years, and now I'm in Boynton Beach currently.
Pause
Rebecca Pytel
She's the one person I talked to who didn't have any real connection to the state. She just kind of moved their sight unseen. She was just ready for a change. She was like, well, I love it because I'm a Trump Republican and I feel better with conservatives in charge of the state. I am a Trump girl. I worked on his campaign in 2016.
Pause
I definitely didn't want to stay in New Jersey with, you know, just the crazy policies and taxes and just all the politics there. The conservative politics of Florida was a deciding factor for me, and that's why I was looking at Texas and Florida.
Pause
Obviously, I was really looking for that beach culture, though, and that's, you know, Florida. After COVID, she said, you know, I don't want to be in a state that's not run by Republicans. I wouldn't move to California for this reason.
Pause
Maren Kogan
The best example of this is that I was swimming in the—there's a little pool in my parents' retirement community, and I was swimming there one day after work reporting this story, and I heard two older people, a man and a woman, talking beside the pool.
Pause
And, you know, both very classic conservatives, clearly watched Fox News, were talking about different things liberals were doing. And the woman brought up abortion, and the man said, now see, that's one area where I disagree. A woman has to have the right to make that decision on her own with her doctor.
Pause
I talked to a few gay men who were like, listen, I'm not actually that liberal, but DeSantis' war on LGBTQ people is pushing me in that direction.
Pause
But that is Florida in a nutshell. You cannot predetermine someone's politics or assume anything about them because people are not necessarily committed to an ideology down there.
Pause
Growth is often good, but we have covered on the show this year insurance companies refusing to insure new homes in places like California and Florida, places that are getting hit hard by climate change, places where some would argue people shouldn't be moving.
Pause
Can Florida sustain this level of growth, especially as year after year it gets hit with bigger and bigger hurricanes, bigger and bigger storms, more and more capital B, capital W, bad weather?
Pause
Last November when Ian hit, I mean, that was scary. Like, I remember that night, I didn't put my hurricane shutters up either. Like, I didn't really know what to do. And I was living in my house at this point.
Pause
And I was concerned about, like, the insurance. That is going up a lot. You know, the insurance companies are actually like leaving Florida because they're insolvent now.
Pause
I know this year my property taxes went up a lot and everyone's did. Everyone is like, what? This is crazy. We've never seen this before.
Pause
I think anyone who is paying attention to what is happening with the weather and with the environment are looking at some of these developments, especially in coastal areas, and are going, you know, is this really what we want to be doing as the sea levels are rising and hurricane season appears to be getting worse?
Pause
You know, for the person, Andrew, who is the lead of my story, he had lived there for just one year and evacuated twice already. I don't like hurricanes being at the mercy of Mother Nature.
Pause
And I left and went up to stay at my mom's house in Georgia. I had basically two days where I was like, well, if all my stuff's gone, I guess that happened.
Pause
I think it is going to have to be something that everyone takes much more seriously. I will say when I spoke to the people who moved down there all of them were aware of climate change of course and some of them were very concerned about it.
Pause
But it didn't stop any of them from coming. That was Vox's Maren Kogan.
Pause
Noelle King
Coming up, if climate change isn't going to stop people from coming, Florida's going to have to adapt. And, in fact, it is. Support for Today Explained comes from Built Rewards.
Pause
These days, it seems like everybody has a rewards program. You swipe your card and you get one cent on the hundred dollars. But with your rent, frequently, you just pay month after month. You never get anything from it other than that roof over your head. Not anymore, says Built Rewards.
Pause
Built Rewards says it lets you earn points on your rent. By paying rent through Built, they say you can earn flexible points that can be redeemed toward hundreds of hotels and airlines, perhaps a future rent payment, your next Lyft ride, and so much more.
Pause
Your home isn't just where you sleep, it's your community. And Built wants you to go out and do things in the community. You can eat at your favorite local restaurants, then earn more points. You can get VIP treatment at certain fitness studios. You can enjoy exclusive experiences just for Built members. Every month.
Pause
When you're ready to travel, they say Built Points can be converted to miles or hotel points all around the world. You can earn points on rent and around your neighborhood wherever you call home by joining built.com slash explained.
Pause
That's J-O-I-N-B-I-L-T dot com slash explained. Miami is nice, so I'll say it twice. Miami is nice, Miami is nice. Miami is...
Pause
Wait a minute. Wait a minute. Wait a minute. You put in an extra... Today Explained, I'm Noelle King.
Pause
While Florida has been growing, some much-discussed data from the Census Bureau last month showed that Miami-Dade County, where the city of Miami is located, is actually losing population. 80,000 residents have left in the last two years.
Pause
Vox's Umair Irfan was recently there to report on how that city is preparing for the effects of climate change, and Umair says it does not look like Miami-Dade is shrinking?
Pause
Umair Irfan
Well, it looks like a lot more development in some of the wealthier and more financially prosperous areas. Miami is soaring to new heights.
Pause
But I think it's a good thing since a lot of people are coming to Florida and Miami especially. More than a dozen skyscrapers will build out this skyline in the next couple years.
Pause
But also more residences. Miami is also trying to make itself into a financial hub in addition to a tourist destination.
Pause
This is Miami, the city that wants to lure tech from Silicon Valley and finance from New York, all by embracing crypto. It's creating hundreds, if not thousands of high paying jobs.
Pause
They're trying to lure in big banks and other big businesses. And we're seeing that kind of reflected in the level of construction there.
Pause
You see the beach, you see the sun and you see the water, but you also see these tower cranes peeking out between the skyline. And there's definitely construction going on almost in any direction you look from downtown.
Pause
You can see that there's been some development, there's something new that just finished or something new that's going up.
Pause
Before construction of the new tallest commercial building in Florida can officially get underway, demolition crews first need to do their work.
Pause
So there's definitely a lot of activity here and it seems like it's a city that's poised for a lot more growth.
Pause
We're in hurricane season now. Miami is a place that is getting hit very hard by climate change and by what comes of climate change.
Pause
When you talk to people in Miami, is there a sense that this city is going to keep growing or that at a certain point people will have to bow to some of the realities of what's happening with climate?
Pause
Everyone that I've talked to is pretty clear-eyed about the risks of climate change, not just extreme weather and disasters, but some of the slower moving things, particularly sea level rise.
Pause
Miami is expected to see 10 to 17 inches of higher water levels by the middle of the century or thereabouts. And that means a few inches of sea level rise can lead to more clear day flooding.
Pause
We're already seeing that now during king tides. But also when there are storms that do happen, a few inches add up to a few feet of storm surge and flooding when those disasters do occur.
Pause
That means that the area that is going to be inundated with water is going to grow in terms of the air total area. And then the depth to which they're going to be inundated is also going to increase as well.
Pause
So there's sort of a moving target that they have to prepare for.
Pause
Miami has some of the most sophisticated measures to deal with extreme weather. One thing you notice walking around Miami, particularly in the business district or in downtown is that you rarely enter a building right at street level.
Pause
And that's because with the newer buildings, they're elevated above the ground level, their lobbies are five, six, even 10 feet above the ground. And you have to either, you know, take a ramp to go up to the main door, or you have to walk up a flight of stairs.
Pause
And that's because these buildings were built and designed after these new floodplains were revised and they're designed to basically have that ground floor above where they expect the water levels to come up.
Pause
At the ground level, you'll often see actually things like entrances to parking garages or vents for things like HVAC systems that are actually on the ground level rather than actually having these big glass lobbies.
Pause
So you see these kinds of adaptation techniques kind of present just from the ground level, even though the skyline is the main thing that catches your eye.
Pause
It's these subtle changes where you start seeing the adaptation starting to take place.
Pause
You know, I was in New Orleans about a decade after Hurricane Katrina reporting on the recovery there, and it was so interesting that lots of these houses, little-ish to medium-sized houses, had just kind of been put up on blocks, raised six feet off the ground.
Pause
And that will absolutely work as long as the water doesn get above six feet. When we are talking about Miami is there a sense that this will work until there a great flood Or is this being built to work no matter what?
Pause
These buildings, you know, almost every structure you see is going to last for decades. Now, when it comes to elevation, you know, I think 50 years ahead is typically where you set the mark, basically looking at where you expect sea levels to be.
Pause
And then trying to make sure that, one, that you either elevate above that level, above that threshold that you would expect, or come up with a scenario to route that water around or to recover from that very quickly should that water levels actually get that high.
Pause
That's still an ongoing challenge, basically determining what is the future that you're building for.
Pause
So they're planning for 50 years into the future. Absolutely fascinating. But whoever is putting these buildings up is paying for it now. Where's the money coming from?
Pause
Well, there's a lot of money floating into Miami. It is still a very wealthy city. And because it's such a powerful draw, there's a lot of investors who are willing to put money into it.
Pause
What I feel that Miami has to offer is real simple. It becomes a platform and a springboard for all the companies down in Latin America that Silicon Valley, Silicon Alley or Silicon Paradise may not pay attention to right now.
Pause
And certainly, yes, all these adaptations are raising costs, and that's reflected in the development you're seeing.
Pause
You know, last year, Miami broke ground on what's going to be the tallest building in the state of Florida. This is a Waldorf Astoria hotel and residences. At 1,049 feet tall and precisely 100 stories, welcome to the brand new Waldorf Astoria Miami.
Pause
I think it speaks volumes that this is going to be a very high-end luxury development because it's this kind of wealth that's necessary to build a defensible structure, to build something that can actually withstand a hurricane and stay standing decades into the future.
Pause
How much does all of this cost? Well, there's a lot of adaptation that has to occur now.
Pause
There have been a number of different estimates, but one of them was that, you know, Miami proper, in order to cope with sea level rise, it would cost the city about $4 billion by 2016.
Pause
2016. The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers also looked at a proposal for building gates and seawalls around Miami and Miami-Dade County, and that was a project that was estimated to also cost $4 billion, but a lot of local residents objected to that proposal.
Pause
And so right now they're going back to the drawing board and trying to come up with a solution that's more acceptable to local residents, but it's not going to be cheap to keep the water out as it keeps rising.
Pause
One of the challenges for any city with respect to climate change is that you have to worry not just about the people who have money to hurricane-proof a new building or to lift a house up on its structure.
Pause
You have to worry about communities that are low-income, that can't afford this. Is Miami-Dade accounting for its poor residents in all of this development?
Pause
To an extent, but a lot of advocates and campaigners would say not enough.
Pause
You know, you can build a building to be a fortress that can withstand a hurricane. But what happens when the street is flooded days after the storm? It's not like you can order DoorDash. You still need people to be working at grocery stores, at hospitals, at pharmacies.
Pause
And where are those people going to live if they can't afford to live in these luxury high rises? You can't think about buildings just individually.
Pause
You have to think about how they fit into this urban ecosystem, how they work, not just as standalone structures, but how they work with the street, how they work with local housing, how they work with public transportation.
Pause
So in order to deal with the impacts of climate change, you also have to think about things like equity and also the economic inequalities that we have right now and whether we're going to continue to exacerbate them and make these gaps wider, or if we can close these gaps and make sure that many of the benefits of building a more resilient city were down to everybody rather than just the wealthiest people.
Pause
Is anybody making the case that Miami should not be building? That given the challenges approaching with climate change, the city should simply stay the same size or maybe even shrink?
Pause
There are some people who say that. I mean, very few of them are actually in Miami itself. And no one takes them seriously.
Pause
Right. I mean, from the outside, it's easy to look at a city like Miami and say, like, why are these people continuing to build skyscrapers near the beach? And a lot of people in Miami would say, well, first of all, this is a city that exists for a reason.
Pause
It's not just that it's a popular tourist destination. It's an important hub for shipping, for cruises, for transportation. The Miami International Airport is a gateway to the Caribbean and Latin America.
Pause
And people in Miami could easily look at other parts of the country and say, why do people live in California when the fire risk is so high? Why do people live on the Gulf Coast in places like New Orleans when they're below sea level?
Pause
At the same time, they say that, you know, it is possible that with proper planning, with proper engineering, you can survive in a situation like this and even thrive.
Pause
Noelle King
That was Vox's Umair Irfan. Today's episode was produced by Halima Shah and edited by Matthew Collette with help from Amin al-Sadi.
Pause
Our engineer is Patrick Boyd, and our fact-checkers are Laura Bullard and Serena Solon. I'm Noelle King. It's Today Explained.
Pause
Smith the 305 checking in for the remix. One, two, three, four, uno, dos, tres, cuatro. Dale! Bye.
Theme music starts playing