Main Topic: The 50th anniversary of the moon landing and the potential for life on the moon, as well as the cultural significance of feces in creation myths.
Key Participants:
Key Points:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Sean Rameswaram
Welcome to Today Explained. I'm Sean Rameswaram.
Noam Hassenfeld
And I'm Noam Hassenfeld. Today, we're talking about the 50th anniversary of the moon landing.
Sean Rameswaram
That's right. And to mark the occasion, our producer, reporter here at Today Explained, Noam Hassenfeld, has been cooking up something special.
Noam Hassenfeld
So, I've been talking to Brian Resnick, senior science reporter at Vox, and he took me on this kind of long, winding moon journey.
Sean Rameswaram
Nice. And then, like halfway through, you kind of switched gears and I ended up taking him on a weird journey.
Noam Hassenfeld
Yeah. So, it starts with the fact that everyone wants to go to the moon. Right now. What's old is new again. There is a big push to return to the moon.
Sean Rameswaram
Who are we talking about? Like Elon Musk?
Noam Hassenfeld
Yeah, so Elon Musk does want to go to the moon, and he thinks he can get to the moon by 2021. India is launching a moon mission in a few days, actually.
Sean Rameswaram
A few days? Now the countdown for India's second moon mission, Chandrayaan-2, has finally begun.
Noam Hassenfeld
Chandrayaan-2 will be launched from the Satish Dhawan Space Research Center. China is going, South Korea wants to go, Russia wants to go, everyone wants to go. And of course, NASA wants to go back.
Sean Rameswaram
It's been called Apollo on steroids. What does NASA want to do on the moon again?
Noam Hassenfeld
Two big things. One, they want to put the first woman on the moon. Nice. And this is part of what they're calling the Artemis program.
Sean Rameswaram
The new mission is called Artemis. It's named after the Greek goddess and the twin sister of Apollo.
Noam Hassenfeld
And that program is scheduled for 2024. Okay. The other big thing they want to do is basically set up this permanent outpost at the moon, and they're calling this the gateway.
Sean Rameswaram
The gateway to what? Mars?
Noam Hassenfeld
The point of the gateway would be to serve as a testbed for deep space operations. And it's also going to be the gateway to any other part of the moon.
Sean Rameswaram
Sounds like a pretty exciting time to be the moon.
Noam Hassenfeld
Yeah, it's probably the most exciting time for the moon in the last 50 years.
Brian Resnick
Brian told me that for now, NASA's got one major target on the moon. Right now, NASA's eyeing, it's called the South Pole-Aitken Basin.
Noam Hassenfeld
It's one of the oldest, deepest impact craters on the moon. But there's some other spots that would be fascinating. Like, there's also a case to go back and visit some of the Apollo sites.
Sean Rameswaram
Just for fun?
Noam Hassenfeld
Well, we've left some very important things behind there.
Sean Rameswaram
What did we leave?
Noam Hassenfeld
We left trash bags.
Sean Rameswaram
Is there something special in the trash bags?
Noam Hassenfeld
So there are 96 bags of human waste left on the moon from all the Apollo missions.
Sean Rameswaram
Human waste. Yeah, we're talking about poop.
Noam Hassenfeld
We're talking about vomit. We're talking about basically anything that came in contact with us that we just left on the surface of the moon, basically just to save weight for the return mission so they could carry a lot of moon rocks and cool soil and all that type of stuff.
Sean Rameswaram
So we got bags of shit on the moon.
Noam Hassenfeld
There are garbage bags with shit in them on the moon, yes.
Sean Rameswaram
So should the astronauts have been taking the bags of shit back with them instead of the moon rocks?
Noam Hassenfeld
No, no, because actually they set up this fascinating unintended experiment.
Sean Rameswaram
So if you took a mass of human feces, poop, whatever we want to call it, you know, shit, and you desiccated it and dried it of all its water.
Noam Hassenfeld
About half of its weight is bacteria. It represents this enormous array of life.
Sean Rameswaram
There's something like a thousand species of microbes that live in our gut.
Noam Hassenfeld
And life has been evolving here on Earth for billions of years.
Sean Rameswaram
And that whole time that life has been evolving and changing and thriving here on Earth, the moon has been dormant and dead.
Noam Hassenfeld
It's not just that there's no life on the moon. The moon itself doesn't move. If you leave a footprint there, there's a thing to blow it away.
Sean Rameswaram
When the Apollo program brought humans to the moon, we brought life to this dead world for the first time in billions of years.
Noam Hassenfeld
And then we just left life there.
Sean Rameswaram
The answer to whether that life is still living or how long it lived while it was on the moon really points to some fascinating questions about the origin of life on Earth.
Noam Hassenfeld
And one of the most fascinating questions in astrobiology, which is, what is the upper limit for the resiliency of life?
Sean Rameswaram
And like, can life exist in space?
Noam Hassenfeld
So if I can understand this correctly, about 50 years ago, exactly 50 years ago, astronauts started this accidental experiment where they left bags of shit on the moon.
Sean Rameswaram
And you want to find out if the bacteria in those bags is still alive.
Noam Hassenfeld
Yeah. And just to make, like, totally sure, is there any chance we could go back and there's just no bags?
Sean Rameswaram
Well, I did call one of the surviving Apollo astronauts.
Noam Hassenfeld
You called an astronaut and asked him about his shit?
Sean Rameswaram
I, it was, it was one of the more embarrassing phone calls of my journalistic career calling him up.
Noam Hassenfeld
I called Charlie Duke, who was on the moon for around three days with Apollo 16.
Sean Rameswaram
And what did he say?
Noam Hassenfeld
So I called him up, I think he was sitting in an airport, Charlie Duke.
Sean Rameswaram
And I try to broach the question really tactfully because I'm asking this distinguished man if he took a shit on the moon.
Noam Hassenfeld
It's like an embarrassing question to ask, but like, you know.
Sean Rameswaram
Yeah, so did you leave human waste on the moon?
Noam Hassenfeld
We did leave urine that was collected in a tank in the descent stage.
Sean Rameswaram
And I believe we had a couple of bowel movements, but I'm not sure.
Noam Hassenfeld
Wait, he's not sure if he took a shit on the moon?
Sean Rameswaram
Nothing has made me believe more in the conspiracies around the Apollo missions and an astronaut not being sure if he took a shit on the moon.
Noam Hassenfeld
That would be like my number one memory.
Sean Rameswaram
But we are sure that there is shit on the moon, right?
Noam Hassenfeld
Yeah, NASA actually has an absurdly detailed document of all the human artifacts that have been left on the moon.
Sean Rameswaram
And this is where they list 96 bags of human waste, which includes astronaut diapers, urine.
Noam Hassenfeld
So all this stuff would be potentially testable and potentially host life.
Sean Rameswaram
Does Charlie think it's alive?
Noam Hassenfeld
Oh, yeah, he shot it down immediately.
Sean Rameswaram
Yeah. That stuff's been out there exposed to cosmic radiation for 47 years.
Noam Hassenfeld
I'd be really, really surprised if anything ever survived.
Sean Rameswaram
Is Charlie right?
Noam Hassenfeld
So I said before that the moon is kind of this unchanging place.
Sean Rameswaram
But it's also very harsh.
Noam Hassenfeld
Here on Earth, we have this protective magnetic field that protects us from really intense radiation coming from just everywhere in the galaxy.
Sean Rameswaram
So cosmic radiation kind of like just blasts holes through subatomic scale things.
Noam Hassenfeld
It's just like the moon is not protected from cosmic radiation.
Sean Rameswaram
If I'd have stayed up there for 47 years in this human body, I'd be dead because of the cosmic radiation.
Noam Hassenfeld
Two, there's wild temperature swings on the moon.
Sean Rameswaram
So from day to night on the moon, it's like a couple hundred degrees Fahrenheit of difference.
Noam Hassenfeld
The temperature range is extreme in our landing spots from minus 200 and something to 200 and something Fahrenheit.
Sean Rameswaram
It's hot and it's cold. It's freezing and it's hellish. It's everything. It's the moon.
Noam Hassenfeld
It doesn't have any, you know, protection from the sun and from the worst parts of the sun.
Sean Rameswaram
So it seems pretty unlikely it's alive.
Noam Hassenfeld
Is it even possible it's alive?
Sean Rameswaram
Well, life really surprises us a lot and often.
Noam Hassenfeld
So there is life in all sorts of places that you wouldn't necessarily expect it.
Sean Rameswaram
So at the very bottom of the ocean floor where pressures are immense and there's like no sunlight.
Noam Hassenfeld
Life can survive thousands of years, you know, trapped in ice.
Sean Rameswaram
There have been experiments where microbial life has been flown in space, actually flown on the Apollo missions, and it survived largely.
Noam Hassenfeld
Like they were holding it out the window or something?
Sean Rameswaram
Yeah, they were like on a stick, like it was like a hitchhiker.
Noam Hassenfeld
And it survived.
Sean Rameswaram
And it survived, yeah.
Noam Hassenfeld
This is why it's an open question.
Sean Rameswaram
Okay, so it seems likely that the bacteria in the shit is dead.
Noam Hassenfeld
It's possible, though, that it's alive.
Sean Rameswaram
You're saying NASA should go back, check it out, get the shit.
Noam Hassenfeld
Why? It's an idea called panspermia.
Sean Rameswaram
Okay. Have you heard of this?
Noam Hassenfeld
No, panspermia.
Sean Rameswaram
So it's the idea that life didn't start on Earth, that it started somewhere else and it came here.
Noam Hassenfeld
Maybe it hitched a ride on an asteroid.
Sean Rameswaram
If something didn't survive or at least be revivable from a dormant state after being on the moon for 50 years, it actually lends a lot of weight to this idea that maybe life didn't begin here.
Noam Hassenfeld
You know, like, take a bong rip now.
Sean Rameswaram
What if life is something that propagates itself across the universe naturally?
Noam Hassenfeld
Kind of like how light propagates itself across the universe.
Sean Rameswaram
So a star emits light, and then that light will hit everything.
Noam Hassenfeld
Because light just spreads naturally at the speed of light.
Sean Rameswaram
Like, what if life is kind of like a radio wave like that?
Noam Hassenfeld
And I guess we're basically, by studying the moon poop, testing whether the medium of space can allow life to transfer.
Sean Rameswaram
Yeah, it helps us understand if life is a property of the universe itself, or if it's this rare crazy fluke that we see around us.
Noam Hassenfeld
You know what, Brian? Looking to poop to explain the origins of life? It's actually, like, a pretty rich tradition.
Sean Rameswaram
Really?
Noam Hassenfeld
What the heck are you talking about?
Sean Rameswaram
I'll tell you in a minute.
Noam Hassenfeld
In the middle of this podcast, we're going to take a quick break to talk about another podcast.
Sean Rameswaram
They asked me to talk about a few numbers first.
Noam Hassenfeld
A two, a comma, a five, and then a ton of zeros. And then seven.
Sean Rameswaram
Just picture a seven. Easy.
Noam Hassenfeld
And their significance becomes clear in an episode of the Pew Charitable Trust podcast after the fact.
Sean Rameswaram
Here's a preview.
Noam Hassenfeld
With $2.5 trillion generated annually, the ocean would be the seventh largest national economy in the world.
Sean Rameswaram
I guessing that like all the oceans combined but still pretty impressive.
Noam Hassenfeld
There all sorts of fun facts and figures and analysis like that in the Pew Charitable Trusts podcast after the fact.
Sean Rameswaram
It's kind of like an audio exploration of how we can use data to make a difference in the world today.
Noam Hassenfeld
You can find it on Stitcher.
Sean Rameswaram
You can find it most anywhere you get your podcasts.
Noam Hassenfeld
Check it out at pewtrusts.org slash explained.
Sean Rameswaram
Again, that's pewtrusts.org slash explained.
Noam Hassenfeld
Wait, Noam, what are you talking about?
Sean Rameswaram
Poop can explain the universe and this is a really old idea.
Noam Hassenfeld
What?
Sean Rameswaram
So bear with me for a second.
Noam Hassenfeld
After we started talking about how, you know, we should look to the poop on the moon in order to find out about human history, I started looking around and I found this article from the anthropologist Alan Dundas about all of these societies across the world who have myths where the world is created from shit.
Sean Rameswaram
Created like some celestial being takes a dump and like forms it with like Play-Doh.
Noam Hassenfeld
This is really gross.
Sean Rameswaram
Yeah. I mean, that's the basic idea.
Noam Hassenfeld
Yeah. But since Dundas is no longer alive, I talked to an old friend of his, Robert Siegel.
Sean Rameswaram
And this is not the Robert Siegel from NPR.
Noam Hassenfeld
This one is professor of religious studies at the University of Aberdeen here in Scotland.
Sean Rameswaram
So Robert pulled out Dundas's essay and we went through some of these myths.
Noam Hassenfeld
So the Fon people in Benin in West Africa have a myth where a cosmic serpent creates mountains by pooping all over the land.
Sean Rameswaram
In India, there's a version of a creation myth where the character Bhima poops on Rama's head.
Noam Hassenfeld
The feces is thrown into the water, which immediately dries up and the earth is formed.
Sean Rameswaram
There's a Japanese goddess who gives birth to other gods who are created from her poop.
Noam Hassenfeld
In other versions, a worm excretes the earth, or the world is formed from the excreta of ants.
Sean Rameswaram
And then there's this Chukchi myth from Siberia where there are these two figures, Raven and his wife.
Noam Hassenfeld
Raven's wife tells Raven to go and try to create the world.
Sean Rameswaram
Raven's wife gives birth to twins, and Raven wants to help too, but isn't sure how.
Noam Hassenfeld
Then Raven flies and defecates.
Sean Rameswaram
Every piece of excrement falls upon water, grows quickly, and becomes land.
Noam Hassenfeld
Okay, shit is somehow fertile. It's like a substance of creation.
Sean Rameswaram
Is this the idea?
Noam Hassenfeld
It seems like there's this sort of common trope in myth that shit is somehow related to the creative process.
Sean Rameswaram
Dundas goes even further. He sort of equates shit with another sort of brown, muddy substance that a lot of us may be familiar with from Genesis, which would be the creation of man from dirt.
Noam Hassenfeld
So did these cultures revere shit? We tend to find it repulsive.
Sean Rameswaram
I'll speak for myself. I tend to find it repulsive, even though I can find awe in what's happening in it.
Noam Hassenfeld
Did these cultures, how did they see shit?
Sean Rameswaram
I can give you one example, which is the Aztecs.
Noam Hassenfeld
I spoke to a professor who wrote... How much research did you do on this?
Sean Rameswaram
I went seriously down the poop rabbit hole on this one.
Noam Hassenfeld
I talked to Cecilia Klein, who's a professor emeritus at UCLA, because I stumbled across an article of hers with the subtitle, The Significance of Holy Shit in Ancient Mexico.
Sean Rameswaram
Great title.
Noam Hassenfeld
Apparently everybody loved that title.
Sean Rameswaram
And if you take a look at Nahuatl, the Aztec language, you can see that their view of shit was really different.
Noam Hassenfeld
The word for gold in Nahuatl was kostik teokuitlat, and it translates as yellow sacred excrement.
Sean Rameswaram
In other words, holy shit.
Noam Hassenfeld
Holy shit. For the aspects, it was a way of literally curing disease, restoring order and balance to the universe.
Sean Rameswaram
Someone who had been enslaved could be freed if he stepped on a pile of human excrement.
Noam Hassenfeld
And it kind of brings something extra to the idea of holy shit.
Sean Rameswaram
You know, for us, it's just a way of putting two things together that don't sort of belong.
Noam Hassenfeld
You know, I mean, it's just a way of saying, wow.
Sean Rameswaram
But for the Aztecs, the term Teoquitlach, which translates as holy shit, would have had a much more profound and double meaning.
Noam Hassenfeld
I'm feeling like I'm getting a little bit of sense why you're telling me about this, but it's like not quite crystallizing for me.
Sean Rameswaram
So I understand why cultures around the world will look at shit and say, oh, this is important.
Noam Hassenfeld
There's interesting things here. This is a part of life and humanity.
Sean Rameswaram
But I don't understand why it would be in all these creation myths.
Noam Hassenfeld
So there's no real conclusive answer on this, but there's a bunch of different explanations, and some of them are kind of wacky.
Sean Rameswaram
Hit me with something really wacky here.
Noam Hassenfeld
Okay, let's start with Dundas' theory.
Sean Rameswaram
He's the dead professor who wrote that essay about all those poop myths.
Noam Hassenfeld
His alive friend, Robert Siegel, walked me through it.
Sean Rameswaram
He argues that males don't get pregnant.
Noam Hassenfeld
They're jealous, okay?
Sean Rameswaram
And what they do to compensate in their myths is to attribute creation to something that's a supposed alternative to pregnancy, which is shitting.
Noam Hassenfeld
Is this like a Freud idea?
Sean Rameswaram
Yeah, it's sort of like flipping Freud on its head.
Noam Hassenfeld
Instead of penis envy, you have pregnancy envy.
Sean Rameswaram
Okay. I think it's a bit over the top.
Noam Hassenfeld
And so does Robert.
Sean Rameswaram
I just think that's excessive.
Noam Hassenfeld
Yeah.
Sean Rameswaram
For another sort of less grandiose theory we can just say that at like a fundamental level shit is the first thing that you create.
Noam Hassenfeld
And so at a very very basic level the involvement of shit is making creation natural.
Sean Rameswaram
Okay, we went from psychoanalytic to, well, this is like the first thing any human can create.
Noam Hassenfeld
So anything that created us, like it's the first thing they do. They take a dump. The world's here.
Sean Rameswaram
Okay, I get that.
Noam Hassenfeld
Theory three, which makes even more sense, is that not only is shit the first thing that you create, but like shit itself is creative.
Sean Rameswaram
You know, shit used as fertilizer is maybe the grandest example of shit being associated with things positive.
Noam Hassenfeld
It's almost miraculous that, you know, you can put it on the ground and it totally speeds up the creative process.
Sean Rameswaram
Because look, what are you doing with shit in creation myths? You're turning it into something usable, something necessary that one can't do without.
Noam Hassenfeld
This theory that you've just laid out, like, makes the most sense for me.
Sean Rameswaram
Like, you can see shit. You can see things growing from it.
Noam Hassenfeld
Like, that is the aha.
Sean Rameswaram
Like, we were talking before, it's like a seed.
Noam Hassenfeld
Exactly.
Sean Rameswaram
Creates a lot of potential for more life.
Noam Hassenfeld
But there's still a pretty fundamental question here.
Sean Rameswaram
There are lots of ways of reading myth.
Noam Hassenfeld
And the issue should be, what do you learn about myth you might not have learned otherwise?
Sean Rameswaram
We have this idea that sometimes creation has to be like poof, something out of nothing.
Noam Hassenfeld
In myth, you know, they call that creation ex nihilo.
Sean Rameswaram
And I guess these myths focusing on poop, I feel like they kind of tell us that we can view creation as being something out of something.
Noam Hassenfeld
So I think it is transformative.
Sean Rameswaram
It's taking shit and it's turning it into a building block, a plant.
Noam Hassenfeld
You know, what comes out of it? Everything comes out of it.
Sean Rameswaram
Well, then in the astrobiological sense, like thinking about if something like shit or microbes, whatever, could seed life on Earth.
Noam Hassenfeld
And we have to think about the thing that came before it.
Sean Rameswaram
And we have to think about how maybe the Earth isn't this like kind of special Eden where all the magic happened and life started and thrived.
Noam Hassenfeld
And it's kind of a similar thought scientifically.
Sean Rameswaram
Like, we have to think about what preceded the Earth.
Noam Hassenfeld
Like, it just didn't pop out of nowhere.
Sean Rameswaram
There was an antecedent.
Noam Hassenfeld
There was another place with life before it.
Sean Rameswaram
And that's why we have life here.
Noam Hassenfeld
And that's a shift.
Sean Rameswaram
And, you know, the major accepted scientific explanation for the origin of life on Earth is that it just sort of spontaneously started here.
Noam Hassenfeld
But if we do go back to the moon and we find that any of that bacteria is still alive, it sort of makes it seem like some of these creation myths maybe had it right in a way that science might not.
Sean Rameswaram
Yeah, but if they even have the right idea, they didn't have like the, I mean, it was just a guess.
Noam Hassenfeld
But I mean, even if it is a guess, it points to something bigger.
Sean Rameswaram
You know, maybe it's just this impulse to say we don't think of creation as something that comes from one spot.
Noam Hassenfeld
We actually think creation is just transformation.
Sean Rameswaram
Maybe creation doesn't really even exist.
Noam Hassenfeld
I like that view better.
Sean Rameswaram
To me, the universe then spirals out.
Noam Hassenfeld
A creation myth that just starts on planet Earth here from whiz-bang, there's life here.
Sean Rameswaram
Is actually a lot simpler than thinking about how life travels from planet to planet, even across solar systems.
Noam Hassenfeld
Thinking of all the things that have to happen for the web of life to spread across the galaxy is amazingly more complex than any story that has ever been told.
Sean Rameswaram
If it has happened, I think the story of life becomes so much more spectacular and the origin of it might be even further and further back than we can possibly ever see.
Noam Hassenfeld
Like that's even, that becomes even unspeakable to think about how broad and how intricate and complex the real truth of life is in the greater universe.
Sean Rameswaram
Brian Resnick reports on Science for Vox.
Noam Hassenfeld
Noam Hassenfeld reports on all sorts of shit for Today Explained.
Sean Rameswaram
Irene Noguchi is the show's executive producer.
Noam Hassenfeld
Afim Shapiro is the engineer.
Sean Rameswaram
Bridget McCarthy, Halima Shah, and Amina Alsari produce the show.
Noam Hassenfeld
Alex Pena and Will Reed are the interns.
Sean Rameswaram
And the mysterious Breakmaster Cylinder is definitely from outer space.
Noam Hassenfeld
Thanks to Matthew Spellberg and Brother Jonah for help with today's episode.
Sean Rameswaram
I'm Sean Rameswaram.
Noam Hassenfeld
Today Explained is produced in association with Stitcher, and we are part of the Vox Media Podcast Network.
Sean Rameswaram
Thanks again to After the Fact for supporting the show today.
Noam Hassenfeld
The After the Fact podcast comes from the Pew Charitable Trusts.
Sean Rameswaram
Pew is spelt like, you know, few, but with a P.
Noam Hassenfeld
After the Fact is spelled much like it sounds.
Sean Rameswaram
The show brings you data and analysis on the issues you care about, the environment, the economy, the public health situation in the country.
Noam Hassenfeld
Find out more about the show at pewtrusts.org slash explained.
Sean Rameswaram
Again, that's pewtrusts.org slash explained.