Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses how Melbourne, Australia eradicated COVID-19 and what the United States can learn from their approach.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Sean Rameswaram
Welcome to Today Explained. I'm Sean Rameswaram.
Support for Today Explained comes from Adio. Adio is an AI-native customer relationship management platform that Adio says is built for the next era of companies.
A powerful data structure adapts to your business model, syncs in all your contacts in minutes, and enriches your business with actionable data.
Adio says it also allows you to create those email sequences, those real-time reports, those powerful automations, which they claim can help you build what matters most, your company.
You can go to adio.com slash todayexplained to get 15% off your first year. That's A-T-T-I-O dot com slash todayexplained.
Not all journalism is the same. Take The Guardian. Our coverage has something unique, fierce independence.
Nobody owns us or tells us what we can and can't say. So we're free to report the whole picture.
We connect what's happening in Washington to the rest of the globe, expose corruption wherever we find it, and give fresh perspective on everything from wellness and soccer to culture, the climate and more.
Read, watch and listen to The Guardian for free at theguardian.com.
Dylan Scott, you report on health care at Vox and you live in Maryland. But we're going to talk about Australia today. Why?
Well, Sean, I have been trying to live vicariously through some Australians that I know because as of last week, Melbourne, one of the biggest cities in Australia, has been COVID-free for a month.
For four full weeks, there have been zero active cases of COVID-19 in the state of Victoria, of which Melbourne is a part.
And I know from my, you know, days of geography that Melbourne is relatively close to New Zealand, which also has done really well.
But are Australia and New Zealand just uniquely positioned because they're so far away from all the COVID catastrophes to just weather the storm better?
I mean, look, it certainly helps Australia and New Zealand even more so that there are islands in the case of Australia, really, really big island.
You might even call it a continent. And they don't have any land borders to speak of if they shut down international travel.
Then suddenly nobody is coming into the country and bringing COVID with them. And so that certainly gives them some advantages in combating COVID-19 that the United States does not enjoy.
But I think what's notable about Melbourne's experience is that they kind of screwed up too.
They, much like the U.S., when COVID was first popping up earlier this year, you know, they went into lockdown.
They put restrictions on international travel. They asked people coming into the country to quarantine, and they tried to tamp out the virus immediately.
And at first, their numbers started to look pretty good. You know, the few cases that they had started to dissipate.
There weren't new cases coming into the country. And so it looked like things were under control, and they started easing some of those restrictions.
Businesses starting opening back up. The same kind of stuff that we saw in the U.S. in the late spring and early summer.
But suddenly in Victoria and in Melbourne, cases started to spike again.
And so, you know, context again is important. Their version of a spike is a lot different from our version of a spike.
Because nobody does it like we do, right, Dylan? Nobody does it bigger or better than the U.S., and that continues to be true.
But, you know, they saw about, you know, at their worst moments, they started seeing like 700 new cases a day, which is like potentially the recipe for like an outbreak that's spinning out of control.
But, you know, by comparison, I did some like some quick eyeball math and I pegged Missouri as maybe the best state to compare Victoria to in terms of land size and its population.
And right now, Missouri is seeing something like 3000 new cases every day.
So even at its absolute worst moment, Victoria and Melbourne were not experiencing nearly as much COVID spread as the U.S. has been for the last few months or even over the summer.
But nevertheless, you know, they saw a second wave coming and they decided, like, we really need to do something.
And we like, we don't want to go through this like yo-yoing of there's a spike and then we lock down and then the numbers go down and we open up and then there's a spike and we lock down.
And then the numbers go back down and we start to open back up again. And they decide, like, we need to act, obviously.
Like, even though their cases never got as high as they did in the U.S., you know, that is the recipe for an outbreak that could spin out of control.
And so they decided that they needed to do something dramatic.
What did they do? They came up with a plan that would end with zero active COVID-19 cases.
Their plan was to just get rid of COVID-19? Yeah, they decided that they would eventually eradicate it. That sounds like a great plan.
How it going? They done it. By the end of November Melbourne and the greater state of Victoria had had zero active COVID cases for a full month.
COVID-19 just doesn't exist there anymore. Wow. Yeah. Okay, so this isn't New Zealand where they're just benefiting from being extremely remote and having, I don't know, functional government.
This is, we had a second wave. We took a step back. We looked at it and we came up with a plan to just bring our cases down to zero? Yes, zero.
And it was hard. And it was a very detailed plan. It took months for them to get there. It required a lot of sacrifice by the people who lived there.
It was controversial. You know, there were protests. People, anti-lockdown protests popped up there, just like we've seen in the United States.
You know, sometimes the political leaders would kind of hem and haw like, oh, well, you know, like we have this plan, but we're not trying to eradicate it. We're trying to aggressively suppress it or whatever.
But if you looked at the plan, they came up with a vision for how to get to zero COVID cases. And as tumultuous as it was, they reached that end destination and now they get to enjoy living in a world where there's no COVID-19.
Well, let's hear how they did it because I want to imagine a world where there's no COVID-19 and I bet a lot of our listeners do too. How did they get there? How did they get to zero, Dylan?
So what I think is interesting about Melbourne is like, they didn't do anything that we don't already know to do.
They ramped up their testing. They did like not only testing of people who are symptomatic or maybe exposed, but they started doing pool testing where you just start randomly testing people out in the community to see if there's any spread that you're not picking up on through some of the more conventional testing methods.
Once they got down to zero cases, they started testing sewage because that's one of the first places that COVID can show up and it can be a leading indicator that maybe spread is picking back up again.
They ramped up their contact tracing. So if people went to a public venue, they had to scan their phones so that if it turned out that there was a case that could be linked back to that place, people would be notified and they could be isolated.
I mean, they were turning around tests in like 48 hours, which I think to a lot of people who might be trying to get tested in the United States around the holidays, sounds glorious, but totally unachievable because we're waiting more like five days.
And the virtue of getting a test result back in a day or two instead of five is that people aren't going around waiting for their test results and spreading COVID to people.
But I mean, the real core of what they did was they locked down. Businesses closed with the exception of certain places like supermarkets.
People initially, during the first stages of the lockdown, People were required to stay within five kilometers of their house.
Their borders were shut. And so there was a long period where there wasn't anything to do in Melbourne but stay home, go to the grocery store, and you couldn't even drive to the other side of town to go to a park.
You had to stay right in your neighborhood. And that's certainly why some of these provisions were contentious.
There's always going to be a group of people who doesn't want to be told you can't leave your neighborhood.
But I think, you know, because they had a clear plan that had this like tiered approach, like the end destination is zero cases.
But in the meantime, you know, if we can bring cases down to a certain level, then certain businesses can start to open back up.
And if we bring it down a little further, then public transportation can open back up as long as you wear masks.
And it was kind of this gradual approach with these clear benchmarks along the way, all the way down to zero.
And I think because they had such a clear plan and communicated these goals to the public, they were able to get a lot of buy-in.
So as controversial and contentious as it was at times, the vast majority of the population bought in, and that's what it takes to get COVID-19 under control.
Dylan, it sounds like all these steps you're talking about aren't unfamiliar or sorcery. It's like what we know works.
Yeah, there was nothing particularly novel about what Victoria did. They just committed to the plan that works.
And they communicated to the public what they were doing, why they were doing it, and what could happen if they saw improvements.
If you're telling people like, look, we can go back to having businesses open and public transportation open if we hit these certain case thresholds, then I think that gives people a lot of motivation to follow the rules, right?
You would hope. You would think.
And I mean, the proof is in the pudding, right? They've gotten there. Zero cases for four weeks.
What I took away from Melbourne's experience is if you give people something to work towards so that they really understand why we're doing what we're doing, it's not just an indefinite, we're going to lock down and we'll see what happens.
There's some specific goals that I think that helps build a lot more buy-in.
But that's unfortunately not something that we've seen in the US.
And I think that at least helps to explain why we struggled so much with our COVID response.
Okay Dylan, let take a quick break. And then I want you to explain to me whether it too late for the United States to try something like this.
It is but okay. That's great. We'll keep that.
Okay.
Support for Today Explained comes from Built Rewards.
These days, it seems like everybody has a rewards program. You swipe your card and you get one cent on the hundred dollars.
But with your rent, frequently, you just pay month after month. You never get anything from it other than that roof over your head.
Not anymore, says Built Rewards.
Built Rewards says it lets you earn points on your rent.
By paying rent through Built, they say you can earn flexible points that can be redeemed toward hundreds of hotels and airlines, perhaps a future rent payment, your next Lyft ride, and so much more.
Your home isn't just where you sleep. It's your community.
And Built wants you to go out and do things in the community.
You can eat at your favorite local restaurants, then earn more points.
You can get VIP treatment at certain fitness studios.
You can enjoy exclusive experiences just for Built members every month.
When you're ready to travel, they say Built points can be converted to miles or hotel points all around the world.
You can earn points on rent and around your neighborhood wherever you call home by joining Built.com slash Explained.
That's J-O-I-N-B-I-L-T dot com slash Explained.
Avoiding your unfinished home projects because you're not sure where to start? Thumbtack knows homes, so you don't have to.
Don't know the difference between matte paint finish and satin, or what that clunking sound from your dryer is?
With Thumbtack, you don't have to be a home pro.
You just have to hire one.
You can hire top-rated pros, see price estimates, and read reviews all on the app.
Download today.
My name's Eloise Shepard. I'm from Melbourne in Australia and we've had 40 days with no coronavirus cases.
We've gone from being restricted to five kilometres within our radius, within our home, to being able to exit that ring of steel.
So now school has returned for my kids.
For my younger children, they can go to childcare.
We're able to return to cafes. We can eat indoors at cafes, at restaurants.
And I was surprised how much I missed the gym.
Now it's open again. I'm not going, but, you know.
Life is pretty normal.
Dylan, before we took a break, I asked you if it was going to be too late for the United States to try just eradicating COVID-19.
And I wanted you to answer the question now, but you already kind of did it and you said it is?
It is. Nobody thinks it's realistic for the United States to get down to zero cases anytime soon.
I don't have the data in front of me, but like we're reporting hundreds of thousands of cases every day and thousands of deaths.
Like a 9-11 worth of death. As many people dying in one day from COVID-19 as died on 9-11.
Like the situations are just completely different.
And I don't think that there's any realistic way to get down to zero until the vaccine is widely distributed and we start building up immunity in the population.
That being said, is there something we can learn from what they did in the city of Melbourne and the state of Victoria?
That is, I think, the lesson.
The lesson is less go for zero as a policy proposal that largely mirrored what the Victorian government ended up doing, called it.
And it's more that, like, you've got to give people a goal. You've got to commit to the mitigation measures that we know work.
Testing, tracing, social distancing, wearing masks.
And by doing that, you can build the kind of solidarity that it takes for people to be willing to make sacrifices in their own lives to help control the spread and maybe benefit not only themselves, but people that they'll never meet.
I think we fleetingly had that in the United States back in the spring, especially at the worst of it in New York City.
I remember I had a friend send me something that when I was kind of down, he sent me, I think it was like a meme, maybe it was a real billboard, maybe it was fake, it doesn't matter.
But it was something along the lines of like, you know, every empty storefront you see, every empty sidewalk, empty playground, like that is solidarity.
That is people making sacrifices, you know, holding back from what they want to do to benefit everybody else.
And so, you know, I think there was a time, there was a moment when this kind of strategy might have been palatable in the U.S.
But clearly, you know, very quickly, our COVID response became very polarized.
We started to see, you know, differences between Democrats and Republicans and how willing they were to wear masks.
We saw differences between democratically led states and Republican led states in the social distancing and mask policies that they put into place.
And it pretty quickly devolved.
That solidarity disappeared.
And I have to tell anybody listening to this show what we've been living through for the last six months.
So my hope would be you know maybe maybe this winter surge is already so bad and it only going to get worse.
The lesson from Melbourne is you need to give people something to work towards.
You can't just tell them we're going to lock down for six weeks and see what happens.
You got to give them a goal because, you know, that's just human nature, right?
Being indefinitely cloistered in your house is of course going to sound untenable to everybody who's already feels like they've been doing that for the last nine months.
But you know, you tell people like, if we can get our case numbers down to here, we can start doing X, Y, and Z, then maybe that gives people a little bit more motivation to cooperate.
And so like, you know, I'm not a policymaker.
I'm just a guy on a podcast.
But I think, and experts say this too, Like, Victoria did two important things.
First, they actually, like, took the mitigation steps necessary that we all know work.
Testing, tracing, mask wearing, social distancing.
But they also gave people clear goals, clear objectives, and something to work towards.
And again, like, would that work in the US?
Who knows?
I can't say for sure.
I can't say that the last year has given me a ton of optimism that we can all get on the same page again.
But Melbourne did it.
They have zero COVID cases now.
I emailed a health policy professor there, you know, asking some questions about their plan.
He emailed me back and said, I'm sorry, you know, I was out at lunch with some friends and I didn't see this until now.
And that's the kind of life that they get to live because they committed to this plan.
And you wrote back, go fuck yourself.
I said, like, take me there, actually.
Do you think, I mean, you know, we most recently compared Australia to the United States on election day on this show where we talked about how voting is mandatory there and turnouts a lot higher, obviously.
But I wonder, in this case specifically, if we're talking about apples and oranges here a little bit, if there's this very distinct sort of sense of personal liberty and individual freedoms in the United States that they just don't have down under that's going to prevent everyone from getting on the same page, be it now or even nine months ago when these initial lockdowns and shutdowns happened.
Yeah, I mean, I think it's a good question.
And it's obviously a thing that's sort of impossible to quantify.
I will say like, you know, the Aussies are not conformists.
You know, this was an island that started as like a refuge for prisoners, right?
Do they like it when you remind people of that? It's just the truth, okay?
But like, you know, Aussies are not conformists.
You know, there's a strong individualistic streak in Australia, just like there is in the United States.
But I do think they have a shared sense of identity and camaraderie that allows people to buy into this kind of stuff.
You know, I think people once believed America had that same kind of capacity.
And obviously, you know, recent history has really tested that proposition.
So on the one hand, yes, I think there are some cultural differences.
It's a smaller country.
It's not completely homogenous.
A reader reminded me that like 25% of Melbourne's population comes from overseas.
There's plenty of diversity there too.
Melbourne and Brisbane and Sydney are big, cosmopolitan metropolises with all kinds of people, with all kinds of backgrounds and views.
So I don't think we should like paint with too broad a brush talking about the Australians.
But at the same time, like there is something in their culture that allows them to at least the vast, vast majority of them to come together and work together toward a common cause.
And I think we've seen in COVID-19 that it's really hard for America to do the same thing right now.
But I don't buy that like, oh, this is just impossible for red-blooded Americans because, you know, we value our liberty among everything else.
Like, we can make sacrifices. We just haven't mustered the ability to do it, unfortunately, during this emergency.
Dylan Scott. He's a healthcare reporter at Vox.com where you can find his piece that inspired this episode.
It's titled, like this episode, How Melbourne Eradicated COVID-19.
I'm Sean Rameswaram. This is Today Explained.
Their car insurance and save hundreds with Liberty Mutual.
Fascinating it's accompanied by his natural ally Doug uh limu is that guy with the binoculars watching us cut the camera.
They see us only pay for what you need at Liberty Mutual.com Liberty Liberty Liberty savings vary underwritten by Liberty Mutual Insurance Company and affiliates excludes Massachusetts.
Theme music fades in