Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses the concept of forgiveness, its complexities, and challenges in today's society. The conversation revolves around the idea that forgiveness is not only a personal virtue but also a social one, and how it can be difficult to achieve in a world where social media and online culture often prioritize punishment and outrage over empathy and understanding.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Additional Insights:
Sean Rameswaram
Support for Today Explained comes from the FIFA World Cup, of all things. The FIFA World Cup 26 is coming to North America next summer. It is the ultimate celebration of sports and culture. You can get closer to the beautiful game with a hospitality package, closer to the action, the best seats, the best suites, closer to match day and that world-class food and that world-class entertainment, closer to the experience of a lifetime. Book a hospitality package at fifaworldcup.com slash hospitality. And listen to The Guardian for free at theguardian.com.
It's Today Explained. I'm Sean Rameswaram for him. But in a minute, it's going to be Vox Conversations with another Sean, Sean Illing. Other Sean, or old Sean as I used to call him around the office, took over at the old Ezra Klein show along with another one of our colleagues, Jameel Smith. And I think you'll agree that the two of them are doing an interview show the way it's meant to be done. Honestly, openly, and with great curiosity.
In the conversation we're bringing you today, Other Sean talks to The Atlantic's Elizabeth Bruenig about how to forgive. It's pretty perennial subject matter, but it feels extra timely in this hyper-polarized moment of ours. Just a heads up, you're going to hear a few more F-bombs than you would typically on an episode of Today Explained. Vox Conversations begins now. If you haven't subscribed or followed the show or whatever, maybe you'll reconsider after hearing this.
Sean Illing
Why is it so hard to forgive? I'm Sean Illing, and I write for Vox about politics and philosophy. And I'm your host for Vox Conversations. Intellectually, I can make a good case for forgiveness. And I know from experience that I feel better when I'm able to do it. And yet, more often than not, I don't. I hold on to anger. I hold on to resentment. And it eats away at me. A lot of us, maybe even most of us, are like this. And it's not new. It's never been easy to forgive.
But I do think there's something about this moment in history that makes forgiveness even harder, or at least harder to talk about. Social media is obviously part of the story, but it's more complicated than that. A tweet by Atlantic staff writer Elizabeth Bruenig got me thinking about this in a different way. As a society, she wrote, we have absolutely no coherent story, none whatsoever, about how a person who's done wrong can atone, make amends, and retain some continuity between their life before and after the mistake. I think she's right. That's a problem and we don't talk about it enough. So I reached out to Bruenig to do just that.
She's written powerfully about the death penalty in America. So she's thought a lot about forgiveness and non-forgiveness. We talk about what it means, why it's so damn hard to forgive, and how we can all maybe get a little better at it. Liz Bruenig, welcome to the show.
Elizabeth Bruenig
Thanks so much for having me on.
Sean Illing
I want to start with the death penalty, which is a heavy place to start, but I think it's a necessary place since killing a human being really is the ultimate expression of non-forgiveness. So how has your work on capital punishment shaped how you think about forgiveness?
Elizabeth Bruenig
Well, it's certainly developed how I think about forgiveness. I'm a Christian, and being raised a Christian, we all know forgiveness is important. It's in the Lord's Prayer, the Our Father: "Forgive us our trespasses as we forgive those who trespass against us." That sentiment appears repeatedly in scripture, but it's very rare that one drills down into what it actually means to forgive someone and what is the cost of forgiveness and the necessity of it. Those were things that I knew I had not explored in a really complete fashion, although I had thought about them.
Getting into covering capital punishment has certainly put a lot of that into very sharp focus. In talking about forgiveness, you've got to weigh a couple of things. You have the good of the offender, for whom forgiveness is critical, and you also have the offense to society, and you have the fact of the crime itself, which can't be undone. All of those things, I think, are brought forward in extremis in capital punishment cases.
Sean Illing
A concept like exoneration is really simple, and we all know what it means. It means that someone was absolved, cleared of guilt, they were set free, as it were. But forgiveness is not absolution, even if it's confused with that quite often. And it's not a stripping away of guilt. So, if that's what it isn't, what is it?
Elizabeth Bruenig
Forgiveness doesn't undo the fact of the offense. Nor does forgiveness suggest that the offense wasn't really that bad. A lot of the time when you read people thinking through forgiveness, what you actually see them doing is trying to find ways to mitigate the offense. People will say, "Well, I wanted to forgive this person and so I took into account that they didn't really mean it, they were young, they were ill," etc., etc. Those are all important factors, and they're important factors for mitigation. Mitigation is its own important line of considerations when looking at how to respond to an offense.
But the matter of fact is that forgiveness pertains to a situation in which the person is guilty and culpable. They did it and they're culpable for doing it. That is when the question of forgiveness actually opens. It does not open up when you have a situation where somebody is not culpable. Finding someone not culpable, not responsible for the offense, is not the same as forgiving them. Nor is exoneration, which is when you essentially find them innocent of it. You say, "I'm sorry, I had the wrong person," something along those lines. That's not forgiveness.
Forgiveness is when you decide to permanently forego seeking restitution or vengeance, or however you want to think about it, for an offense that someone really did commit, that they really are culpable for. That's what forgiveness is.
Sean Illing
Do you think of that as maybe the biggest misconception about forgiveness, that it's a stripping away of culpability?
Elizabeth Bruenig
Yeah, I think people tend to focus on the after. They don't look at forgiveness as a process. They look at it as a sort of instantaneous termination of someone's right to be pissed off about something. That's not what it is. Forgiveness does not, in fact, terminate what took place. It does not erase the offense. That will always have happened. Forgiving someone for offending doesn't mean that we have to take up a denial of what took place. It just means we have to stop our quest to extract some kind of recompense from them, either in money or abject apology or humiliation or exile or pain and suffering. However you want to get that recompense, forgiveness is the point at which you say, "I am no longer seeking that, and I am allowing this person to return to the community."
Sean Illing
That's a really hard thing to do in practice.
Elizabeth Bruenig
Yes. I mean, we love accountability. We love consequences. We love strength. But forgiveness is something very different and very strange, and it appears weak when, in fact, it requires enormous will and courage. Maybe that's why it's so hard for us to get our arms around it.
Sean Illing
Is it because in some ways it does cut against our instinctive understanding of justice?
Elizabeth Bruenig
Absolutely. There's quite a bit of theology that's trying to come to terms with, in the Christian tradition, how it is possible that God is both just and merciful, because they seem to cut against each other. Christian theologians have done a pretty decent job of reconciling those two things over the last couple thousand years. But that doesn't mean that it's something that is very obvious to most people.
When folks hear about forgiveness or they're counseled to forgive, or forgiveness itself is praised as a virtue, they feel like, "Okay, so now what is the incentive for someone not to do a bad thing? If they know that they'll just get to walk away without any consequences, what prevents them from doing wrong?"
Sean Illing
Do you think justice and mercy are the same thing? A lot of people don't.
Elizabeth Bruenig
Yeah, I think mercy has a paramount place in justice. The death penalty is this sort of apotheosis of an unmerciful kind of justice, so much so that I would say it's unjust. We have a tendency toward that kind of thing. Even if we were folks who say, "Oh, I don't like harsh punishment. I'm a prison abolitionist. I think we should decarcerate," when it comes to certain offenses, all of that falls away. That's not to mock anyone for hypocrisy, but just to say that's a very hard position to hold. Mercy and forgiveness are very hard.
Sean Illing
Who is forgiveness for? I've thought a lot about this, and I don't have a good answer. Is it for the offender? Is it for the offendee? Is it for society? Is it better that we think of it as a social virtue as opposed to an individual practice?
Elizabeth Bruenig
Yeah, I think that's a really important question. Quite a bit of resistance to the idea of forgiveness arises from the fact that it's often sold as a kind of self-help practice. "Oh, someone hurt you and you're still traumatized by it. All you need to do is forgive them and then you'll feel better about it and you can let go and move on." That's just not true. I don't think it takes much experience in that realm to realize that forgiving someone and letting go of your right to pursue some kind of recompense from them doesn't feel amazing. It can oftentimes be, in its own way, another layer of pain and effort that you have to expend.
Whatever forgiveness is, and I do think it is a personal virtue as well as a social virtue, it's certainly not something you do for your own pleasure or your own health. The offendee, the person who was harmed, they're not getting the biggest bang for their buck out of forgiving someone in terms of pleasure. The person who really vastly benefits way out of proportion to what they've done is the offender. That raises another point I harp on, which is that forgiveness is not deserved by definition. It's not something somebody earns. It's something that's freely given.
You give it to someone for a lot of reasons: for reasons of personal virtue, for reasons of mercy and concern for the offender—which is a strange thing to imagine in our day and age—and also for society. I do think forgiveness, or having some kind of set point at which we terminate the cyclical seeking of recompense for harm, is critically important to having a peaceful society. Otherwise, you just live in a feud culture where you go back and forth forever.
Sean Illing
Do you think we should grant forgiveness to someone who doesn't ask for it or to someone who doesn't accept guilt?
Elizabeth Bruenig
Yeah. Obviously, it shouldn't be the case that we confuse forgiveness with a complete absence of restorative measures. If a person commits a crime, categorically denies it, yet we know for a fact that they're guilty, or consider that they're just not very nice people—which isn't uncommon with death row criminals. Some people on death row are very sweet, very kind, easygoing people, and you can see that they've either vastly changed since the time of their offense or that there were circumstances that led to their conviction that didn't take into account what their actual role had been in the offense. This was the case with Brandon Bernard, who was a very secondary figure in the offense for which he was convicted and sentenced to die.
But then there are a lot of people on death row who are not sweet, are not remorseful. They are people who have been through hard things in their lives and that's hardened them. They're hardened people and sometimes just jerks, just not very good, kind of broken moral compass, selfish, arrogant, egomaniacal. You see a lot of that. The question is, what is the motive to extend forgiveness to a person like that? And again, it's about them. It's something you're doing for them.
It's really remarkable to see people undertake that kind of work when they have someone who has hurt them, killed a family member for instance, who is now behind bars. Nevertheless, you see victims' families ask for mediations. They want to forgive, not for themselves, but for the offender, strictly out of care for the other. That's really remarkable to me.
Sean Illing
Does your theory of forgiveness make any sense without your religious worldview to ground it in?
Elizabeth Bruenig
I don't know. That's a difficult question for me personally to answer because I can't extract myself from my religion. The things that I believe as a result of being a Christian are the most true things to me. Those are the things I believe the very most, the foundational principles upon which everything else is built. It would be similar to asking someone, "Does your theory of justice make sense if gravity doesn't exist?" I don't know, that's a really kind of shattering proposition. I'll have to think through that.
I do think, though, that many religions, and aside from that, many systems of principle that are not religious, also have theories of forgiveness that are comparable to Christianity.
Sean Illing
We were talking about this offline, and I think a lot about the relatives of the people who were killed by Dylann Roof in Charleston. They looked at this moral monster, and they acknowledged what he did, they knew what he did, and they forgave him. They forgave him in public, and they did it with a Christ-like grace. And yet, people reacted to this both with admiration, but also with puzzlement. There's a part of us that stands in awe of those relatives, but there's also a part of us that feels very unsettled by it. I wonder why you think that is.
Elizabeth Bruenig
There was a similar situation with the fellow who murdered Amish schoolgirls. The families of those schoolgirls actually reached out to extend forgiveness to the offender's family and made a pretty public point of having forgiven. That's a very, very, very difficult thing to do. If it's one of my two daughters or both who are murdered by a crazed gunman while they try to go to school, I'm going to have a very hard time going the next day to try to extend an olive branch for the sake of peace.
The reason I think that we, at the same time that we are impressed by and humbled by expressions of selflessness like those of the families of some of Dylann Roof's victims, but also on some level repulsed by it, is because there is a very natural drive to sort of purge the evil from among us. Evil is disgusting. It's revolting. We all know it when we see it and we hate it. That's not a bad thing. That's a good thing.
The difficult fact, though, is that evil characterizes actions. It does not characterize people. People still have some good in them. They're still human beings, even when they commit evil acts, atrocities, horrors. That was exactly the point that the families of Dylann Roof's victims were making and the Amish parents who forgave the shooter of their daughters. That there is still some good in you, and that good in you deserves preservation. It deserves dignity. It deserves forgiveness.
I think that's a tension that exists in the very principle of forgiveness. I think it's a tension that exists even within Christianity. The Catholic novelist Graham Greene has this amazing line where he refers to "the appalling strangeness of the mercy of God." It's almost revolting on some level because it feels like somebody getting away with something. It's not that. It's something different. But it feels that way.
Sean Illing
Evil is also a cancer, though, and it multiplies. I don't remember how I felt at the time when Roof killed those people in the church. But thinking about it now, there's some part of me that feels shame because I don't think I'd have the strength to forgive him. In fact, I know I wouldn't forgive him, and I still don't. That inability says something about me that I'm not particularly proud of, but it's true. I'm pretty sure I'm not alone in that. While I don't really believe in a hell, I wish there was one that he could go to. I just have to live with the unease because I don't feel great about feeling that, but it's what I feel.
Elizabeth Bruenig
I have a million feelings a day that I find highly suspicious morally. I think a big part of, for instance, writing on the death penalty is saying, I have all kinds of desires and impulses and instincts that are flat out wrong. They are dark. They are not aligned with justice or mercy or goodness. Some of them are even evil. In some sense, that's one of those humbling realizations that makes me think, yeah, it's not that hard to have fellow feeling for unrepentant, very bad people, because I could be that person.
I don't think I could be Dylann Roof. I don't have impulses or instincts or desires that are that completely evil. But it's not difficult for me to imagine a world in which I'm a significantly different person than I am now. A lot of it has to do with moral luck, being born into a situation in which my virtues could flourish and my vices could be contained. There are other situations people are born into in which that's not the case.
From that grain of fellow feeling, you can kind of develop a sense of... I interviewed a psychologist who worked on death row for a long time in Arizona. I said, "Is Arizona's death row the scariest place you've ever been?" And he said, "No, it's the sorriest place I've ever been." It's sorry. When you start thinking about human frailty, straight up moral weakness that lives inside all of us, as the foundation of the emotional place from which you can prepare to extend something like forgiveness, therefore bringing great strength out of great weakness, I think that makes it a little bit easier.
These people, killers, criminals, a lot of the time you're not seeing Hannibal Lecter. This is not someone who's completely 100% in possession of all of their faculties and is a master manipulator and evil genius who exploited all of their superior capacities just to cause pain for pleasure. No, these are usually miserable fucks who had bad lives and made bad choices a long time before they found themselves convicted of capital murder and who in all likelihood are still making bad choices as they percolate through the legal system. On some level, some of that weakness that's in them, some of that darkness, some of that evil is also in me and all of us. I think that's the kind of humility that makes the strength to forgive possible.
Sean Illing
Let's take a quick break, but when we're back, forgiveness is hard. It's always been hard. And yet, why does it seem like these days it's harder than ever? That's after the break.
Ad break
Let's talk about today, because there are a lot of things about this moment that would suggest it's ripe for forgiveness. You've pointed to all the energy around something like criminal justice reform. But instead, the opposite seems to be true. There seems to be not much room or interest in forgiveness. Do you have a theory of the case there? Any ideas why that might be?
Elizabeth Bruenig
Oh, yeah. People are very angry, especially when you have forms of sort of systematized oppression that have operated for a very long time, and you finally have an opportunity to reckon with those. It's very difficult for a lot of people to say, "Okay, so the first time we have the opportunity to deliver some kind of accountability here, you're asking us to just walk away and say, 'Never mind, act like this was all okay.'" No, that's not necessarily what forgiveness is or what I would suggest, but it is the case that it's asking an individual to decline to prosecute to the fullest extent of their right the offense. That's a hard pill to swallow.
Forgiveness gets confused with so many things. It gets confused with mitigation or exoneration. People can take the call to forgive as a kind of suggestion that they pretend that what took place wasn't that bad, which is also not correct in my view. But it's also, I think more critically, a very difficult moral practice. When you get in a situation where you're asking someone, "Do you think it's possible for you to forgive?" the response often comes from a place of, "Look, I was victimized. I was doing nothing wrong. I was minding my own business. And someone hurt me. I will never get back what they took from me. This offense will always have happened. I will always have to live with it. I will never be what I was before, which is a person who hadn't suffered in this way. I'm permanently changed. And now you're telling me that I have to do this extra work. I have to add on a layer of emotional labor, psychological labor, moral labor here, where I am letting this person who caused this off the hook."
Sean Illing
"Fuck that" is a not unreasonable feeling to have there.
Elizabeth Bruenig
No, it's not. And even though forgiveness is really hard, it's also an act of mercy and an act of moderation. But extremism is what happens when moderation fails. This does in many ways feel like a moment in which a lot of people have decided that we've reached a tipping point and the time for moderation has passed.
Sean Illing
Socially and politically, the problems are so vast, it's hard to even take their measure. If you look at the election law just passed in Georgia, several red states now considering new voter suppression laws because they don't like how 2020 went. The GOP has been so hugely successful in gerrymandering and enacting other voter suppression laws that they have sort of guaranteed themselves spots in many districts. The new census data is going to come out soon, and that will probably allow them to redraw maps in their favor to an even greater extent.
So in that respect, undermining democracy through voter suppression. Who do we turn to when our democratically elected government is in fact not particularly democratically elected and is unresponsive to majoritarian interests? We call in the government's boss, capital, businesses. They threaten capital strike, and oftentimes the state will just instantly capitulate. That's great, but capital is even less accountable and less democratically chosen than our barely democratically elected government.
I think it's completely fair that people feel like, "Look, I have no power. I have no control. I am completely at the mercy of forces beyond me. And the one thing that I do have is the capacity to be pissed off about it. And you're asking me to give that up."
Elizabeth Bruenig
All I would say in response to that is, I don't think forgiving systems makes much sense. You don't have to forgive capital. You don't have to forgive the state. You don't have to forgive organized institutions, such as a political party. And you certainly don't have to forgive, nor is it even possible in my view, to forgive sort of corporate entities. Forgiveness is something that happens between persons. I would say you have to separate interpersonal offenses involving people from offenses involving systems, institutions, corporate entities, and so forth. I think forgiveness is inappropriate in those contexts.
Sean Illing
I'm really curious what you think about the role of the internet in either amplifying some of this or mitigating it. Do you think that the internet and the culture that it has made has made us less forgiving people? Has the digital world supercharged so many of our pathologies, like the will to punish and humiliate, that the act of forgiveness feels like some kind of heroic effort?
Elizabeth Bruenig
I definitely think that the internet is very good at inflaming our worst tendencies. One of those is the tendency to discipline and punish and prosecute, not for safety, not for the preservation of community, but kind of just for fun. Someone who's already been totally raked for a bad tweet or something and has absolutely taken it on the chin, and then a year later you see the shitty tweet again and you're like, "Haha, actually I'm going to go back in on this." That's something that happens not infrequently. That's a function of the internet's capacity for preservation and the incentives for people to resurrect others' failings for their own purposes.
At the same time, I don't think people have ever been especially forgiving. I don't think we need to be too down on ourselves because I think it's just a perennially difficult thing. I look back at the late antiquity, the early medieval period—this is stuff I studied in grad school. These are not what I would call especially merciful or forgiving people. I mean, they knew it was important. They thought about it a lot. They wrote about it. It was a virtue that was on their minds. But in just looking how society played out, it was something that, to borrow from Updike, was on their minds much more than on their schedules. I think that's basically been true of humankind in perpetuity.
Sean Illing
There does seem to be a class of people for whom the greatest imaginable joy is to discover someone else's mistake or folly and then publicly bludgeon them with it over and over again. Human beings are probably wired for vengeance. In my view, the ability to mete it out without real effort or real risk has just been a social catastrophe.
Elizabeth Bruenig
Oh, I think that's exactly right. I think there's a strong impulse in perhaps not all people, but more than you might think, to just like exterminate all the brutes. The fact that it's incentivized by the internet, and the fact that it carries relatively few consequences—so if you see someone online do something really stupid, maybe even evil, and you just rake them for it—
I mean, you just cut them down. You're never going to see the consequences. They just disappear from the internet. And it's like a video game character. You never see that somebody had a bad day. Maybe they went through something, or they've been going through something. God knows we've all been going through something for the past year. And they maybe have a substance abuse issue. Maybe it's something they've struggled with for a long time. They make a mistake. They do a really, really shitty post of some kind, Facebook, Twitter, whatever. You find it. You catch them. You call them out. You rake them.
It becomes a semi-big deal. They lose their job. And that's it. Justice is done. The bad person has been punished. You forget about it. They don't. They still have a family, they still have friends, they still have emotions. And now they're out a job, and the reason that they have been fired is now preserved in amber for the rest of human history. Anytime they try to try again, get a new job, become a new person, do better, what they did and what happened to them is instantly Google-able, and it will continue to punish them for years and years. You never see that part of it. You just see the fun part.
Sean Illing
It's such an important point because forgiving is much easier if we can forget. And no one can forget anything anymore because so much of life is online. It's tagged, it's documented, it's stamped, it's shared, it's published. Humiliation is always a Google search away. And so we can never achieve escape velocity from our own past. And that's a problem.
Elizabeth Bruenig
Absolutely. I mean, I think this is why, especially in Europe, so many people have rallied around the right to be forgotten, which is the right to have information about yourself of one kind or another taken off the internet. That's just nearly impossible to achieve. There may be a right there, but it's a right that's going to be impossible at this point to exercise.
Sean Illing
I think it's important not to confuse forgiving with forgetting, although they're natural partners in a lot of respects. But the fact that the internet immerses us in a permanent present, right? You take a tweet that was shitty in 2014 and everyone laughed about it. And you retweet it today in 2021, seven years later. And it doesn't matter that it was done seven years ago, that the person who did that is a different person now. That doesn't matter because I'm reading that tweet right now, right here in the present. And so everything that someone has done wrong on the internet, they're constantly doing wrong in a certain way. They're never allowed to be someone different than the person they were. And that is a real barrier to forgiveness, I think.
Elizabeth Bruenig
Well, we're sort of dancing around the elephant in the room, which is cancel culture.
Sean Illing
Ah, getting canceled, yeah.
Elizabeth Bruenig
Yeah, let's just go ahead and lean right into it.
Sean Illing
Yeah, let's get canceled. [Both laugh] But seriously, there is a kind of paradox on the left right now that I don't know. I feel like you, more than most, are uniquely positioned to reflect on. You would think that forgiveness would be a very natural outgrowth of progressivism, but that's not really the case today, or at least it's pretty complicated, right? On the one hand, progressives value forgiveness, and you can see that in their willingness to forgive people who have committed violent crimes, as you've pointed out. But on the other hand, they also seem very unwilling to forgive low stakes missteps like speech crimes or speech violations. What do you make of that weird contradiction?
Elizabeth Bruenig
Yeah. You know, I've thought about this a lot. I actually have a friend, Liam Kofi Bright, who's a philosopher who teaches in the UK at LSE, at the London School of Economics. And he said that when he notices folks on the left saying, "Well, obviously we need to take it easy on folks who are in prison and we need to look at abolition and reintegrating them into society," all of which I agree with. But then they say, "If someone does a shitty tweet or a shitty podcast or something, it doesn't matter the degree to which they change or to which their current views no longer reflect their former views.
They can't be forgiven because that stuff is poisonous and it causes all the problems in society." He said it's very hard not to feel like they just don't care that much about the harm that's caused by criminals. Because, by and large, well-to-do professional managerial class folks, they're not affected by violent crime, right? Most of the victims of violent crime are poor people. And so, yeah, I mean, it's much easier to say, "Well, if a person is 19 years old and they participate in a triple homicide related to a cocaine deal that went off the rails," I think it's very easy for a professional managerial class person whose major contact with that kind of individual and that kind of crime is like watching Law & Order to say, "Yeah, yeah, yeah, sure, forgive them, but absolutely do not ever forgive someone who pissed me off on Twitter."
Because for them, being interpersonally offended and bothered by shitty views being expressed online by aggressive assholes is one of the major conflicts of their life. I think that's possible. I think it's maybe a mischievously uncharitable reading, but it's meant to prompt a real reflection, which is why can't we articulate a continuity between where we are on criminal justice reform and where we are on interpersonal offenses?
Sean Illing
And I think you hear a lot of explanations. People on the left will say, "Well, these interpersonal offenses are upstream of those criminal offenses downstream. So when we allow these bad ideas to percolate in society without punishment, it's eventually going to lead to some sort of expression, and it often has a violent expression." I think that's possible, but I still think that it's pretty clear that not all of the offenses that people are, quote unquote, canceled for are actually related materially in any way to violent crime. So, and again, this is a human compulsion. There's always been cancellation. Everyone should read Edith Wharton's *Age of Innocence*, right? That's a turn of the century cancel culture on display. Anna Karenina, she is canceled. Tolstoy's Karenina. But I think the important thing to think about is these tools that we use to discipline people socially, they're going to exist in any society. I think that's pretty natural for human beings. Is there a way to make sure that we separate out what is necessary and what is helpful from what is just pleasurable for us?
Elizabeth Bruenig
Well, I'd like to remind people all the time that Socrates was the first public cancellation. He was badly canceled. So this is not a new thing. It's been around. Ostracism goes back to the ancient Greeks.
Sean Illing
Absolutely. But you're touching on a part of this that probably bugs me more than any of it. And it's the fact that so many of our, air quote, transgressions now are phony or contrived and the furor over them is so performative and so vacuous. There's so much bad faith, so much pile on. And there's very little genuine outrage over the offense because that would require actual contact with it. And so a lot of it is just sport for our digital carnival.
Elizabeth Bruenig
Blood sport.
Sean Illing
Yeah, yeah. Right. I mean, Lindsay Ellis, who I had never even heard of before she was badly canceled, as far as I can tell, is a film TV critic who was canceled for tweeting about some kind of Disney or Pixar movie being similar to Avatar, either the Blue Alien movie or the other movie also called Avatar.
Elizabeth Bruenig
Oh, hell no. No, I've been having children for the last five years, so I have no clue what's been going on cinematically.
Sean Illing
But, you know, she compared two things, which I don't know, seems somewhat comparable to me, like just surface level. You're allowed to compare films. And the tweet wasn't excessively malicious. She was just saying, "Oh, there's a genre similarity. This is like this," which is somewhat common in film criticism. She was chased off Twitter and raked over the coals. I again had no dog in this fight, don't even understand it, have no idea who this person is. So I just popped a tab open on Twitter and watched 5, 10, 20 tweets come in a minute about this woman just tearing her down. And I was like, this was out of proportion to the offense the minute it was more than someone replying "I don't think so." Like it was disproportionate at that point. But the way that it builds on itself as people have more and more fun and realize that this trending news event is a way that they can get attention for their account or be validated as a member of their in-groups, it's just a really, really vicious cycle. And it's uncomfortable to watch. And I am not immune to it. I'm absolutely certain I've participated in those kinds of things. And I feel bad about it. And I try to catch myself, not do that.
Elizabeth Bruenig
No, I can't count the number of times I've signed onto Twitter and allowed it to tell me what I should let my day get derailed by and what I should be pissed off about. And we've all fallen prey to that.
Sean Illing
And at the risk of getting too abstract, maybe there's a deeper issue here. I think a lot of people don't really exist in anything like a community anymore. This is a very atomized society. And to the extent that bonds exist, they're very porous and ill-arranged. And maybe we filled this void by turning to the even more inhuman and loveless virtual world where the only excitement to be found consists in signaling disgust by trashing the right person or the right group.
Elizabeth Bruenig
Yeah, and I think over the past year, things have been especially difficult in terms of isolation. I also think there's an effect to being on the internet that's not unlike the road rage effect, where you're sort of alone in your own private little world, where you feel like you're supposed to have complete control. And then here's this asshole screwing everything up, derailing your day online. And the anger that develops in that kind of isolation where the only moral consideration you have is yourself and your feelings because, again, you're not actually talking to or facing this individual looking at their context.
They're just, in the case of road rage, they're just a car. They're just a machine. You don't even see a person there, much less know anything about them. Same thing online. They're just a text box or just an account. You don't see a person. You don't see what they're going through. You don't care. And I think that that can produce emotions that are way, way, way out of proportion to the actual offenses. And I think that's bad for us. And the fact that it's bad doesn't mean it never feels great. I mean, when all of your friends are dunking on someone and you're having just a whole hell of a time just absolutely dragging them and making jokes and watching all your friends be really funny and also you're right and you're righteous and you're doing a good thing, I think it can feel rapturous.
It reminds me of being in the United Kingdom for Guy Fawkes Night, which is a celebration that occurs in early November, the 5th of November, similar to our Halloween in the United States. It's all about this sort of mirthful and gleeful celebration of the execution of this individual named Guy Fawkes, who was a Catholic terrorist, essentially, who had planned a significant attack on the parliament, the British government, and was caught and tortured and then finally executed. And this holiday developed around burning him in effigy. And it's a big carnival and everyone's having a great time. And you have to think, yeah, no, they actually used to have public executions with a carnivalesque atmosphere right up until the turn of the century and later in the United States.
But is that who I want to be?
Sean Illing
Yeah, I mean, I think it's true though that there are a lot of people, and this is absolutely me, more than I care to admit, who are invested in holding on to bitterness, to the sense of moral clarity you get from that. We dwell on it. We cultivate it. It's poison. It disfigures our inner life, but we still clutch to it. And I think of myself as someone who is a forgiving person. I certainly believe in forgiveness in the abstract. I'm persuaded by the arguments I've heard for it. But the truth is that I'm really not all that forgiving a person in my real life. At least I'm not forgiving consistently. And that's not just true in my private life, but it's also true when it comes to someone like Dylann Roof or when I click on Twitter and see that Rush Limbaugh died, for instance. I mean, the reality is that my first thought is I'm glad he's dead, that the world is a better place without him. And I don't feel good about that. That doesn't make me morally whole. It makes me feel weak in base. And yet it's how I feel. And I think a lot of people probably feel like that. And maybe that just says something about who I am and who we are, but it's there. It's real.
Elizabeth Bruenig
It's absolutely real. It's one of those real things there is. But I think that that realization of frailty is a really important thing. And I think that's something that without which you can't have a culture that embraces forgiveness at all. People have to be willing to say, "I too am susceptible to and guilty of all kinds of darkness." And I know that to be true. I mean, people ask me all the time, "Oh, you're a Christian. Do you think this person is going to hell? That person?" I'm like, "Look, man, I'm pretty sure that I'm going to hell. That is my number one preoccupation. I'll see you there."
[Laughs] It's like trying to sort out my own soul. That is everyone's battle in this life. Every single person is fighting the battle between good and evil, and they're waging it inside themselves all the time. And sometimes you win and sometimes you lose. You lose battles. You hope you win the war. You learn. You get better at it. But that is the struggle going on with all of us, and that is our purpose in this world is to try to win that war for ourselves, for our own souls, for good. And I think focusing more on that and less on "I'm going to exterminate all the evil in the world and everyone else," although that's also important to limit the expressions of evil in the world, focusing on that inner struggle maybe allows us to empathize more with people who do wrong and make mistakes.
Sean Illing
You also can't have a liberal democracy without forgiveness. I mean, a liberal democratic society is built on dissent and toleration. People have to be allowed to make mistakes and to fuck up and to go too far and to transgress. And we can't bar them from public life because of it. It will grind the whole thing to a halt.
Elizabeth Bruenig
Right. And again, you get into sort of a slipperiness here where you point out that liberal democracy relies on this expectation that there will be interpersonal forgiveness on the level of the citizenry. And you'll get a response along the lines of, "Sorry, I don't forgive the GOP for the war in Iraq," etc. But again, it's not about institutions. It's not about corporate entities. It's about people. Teresa Bejan, a professor at Oxford, wrote a book called *Mere Civility*, which is about interpersonal language norms in liberal democracies. And her point, I think, is that what's required is really fairly minimal, but it's harder than it seems. And that is, you just cannot permanently prosecute grudges or offenses in the most extreme manner you can conjure and have a liberal democracy. There has to be a principle of forbearance. And that's hard. It's really hard.
Sean Illing
How do you practice forgiveness in your own life? Unevenly? Consistently? What?
Elizabeth Bruenig
So I have people that I have forgiven for things they've done to me. And it's something that is a decision. It's kind of like, I think, of 12 steps. It's like quitting an addictive substance. It's a decision you remake every day and you do it day by day. Because it'll still come to you, that thing that happened. You'll be standing at the kitchen sink, looking out the window, watching the birds at the bird feeder, washing dishes. And it returns to you that that shaft of light you're staring at is quite like the one you saw the afternoon that someone did a severe act of physical violence on you.
And how do you not just explode in your own quiet and domestic suburban way with fury at that point? But you make that decision. You know that was then. It's not happening anymore. It happened. I wish it hadn't. God knows I would love for it to have been different. But all I have now is now. And I'm not going to pursue it. And I think a lot of forgiveness, at least as it's manifested in my life, manifests as me reaching out and being there and being friendly and warm and open for the restoration of a relationship to people who have hurt me really bad and saying, "I'm still here. I'm not going anywhere."
It's also really hard to be forgiven, which is maybe another discussion for another time. It's very hard to be forgiven. There's so many issues with respect to pride and ego and accepting fault and feelings of condescension or suspicions of having something lorded over you. Those are all issues that make it difficult to be forgiven. But part of forgiving is to just stand humbly and say, "I'm not kidding, I'm serious. It's forgiven."
Sean Illing
When was the last time you failed to forgive someone when you know you should have?
Elizabeth Bruenig
Oh, that's a good question. There was someone who was really mean to me who was contacting me to talk about the death penalty and having this argument about it theologically. And I was saying a lot of what I'm saying to you right now about forgiveness and mercy and the inherent value of human being. And I found out this person who was being extremely malicious in their response, and I don't mean just profane, but actually quite cutting, was posting all of this interaction on a forum and laughing about it. They weren't even invested. They're just a nihilist. And they thought it was funny. And it really hurt my feelings a lot. And I felt stupid for that, right? Because it's the internet, like just turn it off, close your eyes, et cetera. But it really hurt my feelings. And I cried about it. Wait till my kids go to bed, take a bath, cry. And what hurt wasn't so much that I believed the things that they had been saying to me, but that someone wanted to hurt me like that just to amuse themselves.
Sean Illing
Yeah.
Elizabeth Bruenig
And I wrote back to the person and said, "Hey, I got tipped off that you're posting this in this closed forum, that it's a joke. I guess the joke's on me, but I do forgive you. Go in peace." I know who the person is. I'm not going to say anything about it, though. Just let it go. But it's hard.
Sean Illing
Yeah, it's hard. I just can't imagine anyone not being able to relate to that. I just don't know any way to have an honest conversation about forgiveness that doesn't involve admitting hypocrisy.
Elizabeth Bruenig
Oh, of course. Frailty.
Sean Illing
Absolutely. That's what it is. And that's what we are. There's no straight line to forgiveness. No doubt about that. And maybe this is a strange way to end, but I feel like it's important. And I want to ask if you think there is a line. Is there anything that is truly unforgivable?
Elizabeth Bruenig
I think, by humankind, yes. I think there are things a person can do to another person, to other people, that essentially make the likelihood that they will ever be forgiven 0%. A person cannot actually eliminate the value of their own life in my view, no matter what they do. So it'll always be the right thing to do to allow that person to live. But there are situations — I guess I would put it this way: it's sort of a scale, and at the very highest heights of that scale, I think the likelihood of any person being able to forgive that individual is low and approaching zero for me as well. So I do understand that feeling. And there are some things that are just really, really, really — they exceed the moral capacities of even the most morally heroic person. We're only human. And I think we should keep in mind that those are very rare, very rare instances. But I try to remain open to those kinds of possibilities. Because as you point out, this whole conversation has to be premised on nuance and frailty. It's disingenuous if it's not.
Sean Illing
Well, I really appreciate you coming on to talk about this. This is a very difficult conversation to have, and it's not easy. And I really appreciate your time. I learned a lot, and I thank you for being here.
Elizabeth Bruenig
Thanks so much for having me. I really appreciate it.
End of interview
Sean Rameswaram
Vox Conversations is produced by Eric Janikis. Our editor is Amy Drostowska. Paul Robert Mouncey mixed and mastered this episode. Our theme music was dreamed up by the mysterious Breakmaster Cylinder. And Liz Kelly Nelson is the VP of Audio at Vox. If you like the show, let us know. Room for improvement, we want to hear that too. We're curious to know what you think, what you want more of, what we could improve. And if you have ideas for future guests or topics, send us your thoughts at [email protected]. And hey, if you did like this episode, share it with your friends, rate and review, and join us on Thursday for a brand new episode.