Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses the massive fraud that occurred during the COVID-19 pandemic in the United States, where trillions of dollars in government assistance were given to scammers, including those who claimed to be unemployed, businesses that didn't exist, and individuals who were deceased.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Additional Insights:
Theme music fades out
Noelle King
Looking back, we might have expected this. The U.S. is a nation of many hardworking, honest people. It is also a nation of a not insignificant number of scammers. When the COVID pandemic ravaged the country's economy, the federal government intervened with trillions of dollars in assistance for people and for businesses.
Pause
Two-ish years later, we find the money helped many honest people. And the scammers, wow. In the midst of the pandemic, the government gave unemployment benefits to the incarcerated, the imaginary, and the dead. It sent money to farms that turned out to be front yards. It gave loans to 342 people who said their name was, quote, in slash A.
Pause
There is, of course, a third type of American, the wide-eyed optimist, who wants to make it right. My message to those cheats out there is this. You can't hide. We're going to find you. We're going to make you pay back what you stole and hold you accountable under the law.
Pause
Coming up on Today Explained. Support for Today Explained comes from BetterHelp. Let me tell you a true story. Last weekend, I got an email from a listener who wanted to discuss their problems with me. And I said, look, I don't think that this is about me personally. At least I hope it's not. Why don't you try BetterHelp.com slash Explained. Absolute truth.
Pause
As the largest online therapy provider in the world, BetterHelp can provide access to mental health professionals with a diverse variety of expertise. Find the one with BetterHelp. The one is not me, guys. Our listeners get 10% off their first month at BetterHelp.com slash explain. That's BetterHelp.com slash explained.
Pause
We all have moments where we could have done better, like cutting your own hair. Oh, yikes. Or forgetting sunscreen, so now you look like a tomato. Ouch. Could have done better. Same goes for where you invest. Level up and invest smarter with Schwab. Get market insights, education, and human help when you need it. Learn more at schwab.com.
Pause
It's Today Explained. I'm Noelle King.
Pause
There is perhaps no one we wanted to talk to more about the scamming and the scammers than this man. My name is Dave Farenthold. I'm an investigative reporter for The New York Times.
Pause
Dave Farenthold
And in The New York Times, you call the misallocation of some of this money the biggest fraud in American history. Quite a claim, my friend. What happened?
Pause
The short answer is that in the rush to get aid money out to people, the government took on a task it had really never tried to do before, which was to judge the individual needs of millions and millions of people and businesses. The closure of restaurants and bars could impact more than 9 million workers nationwide. Layoffs for some 3,600 workers have been announced so far, with the majority being in the entertainment and leisure industry.
Pause
And then almost immediately gave up and trusted those people and those businesses to, quote, self-certify their need. Small business loans can be turned around within 36 hours for some businesses. Unemployment insurance will go up by $600 a week as soon as next week. Basically, it ran these giant aid programs on the honor system and allowed people just to swear that they met the qualifications, to swear that they were harmed by COVID-19 and sent the money out the door with minimal checks.
Pause
So, you know, all it took to get that money was a willingness to lie and not much more. And I guess many Americans had that willingness. Where was the oversight here?
Pause
There was some oversight when the money was given out. There were systems in place that were supposed to be checking to make sure people weren't defrauding the system, but they were just not very good checks. There is some enforcement on the back end. There is some oversight on the back end, but it is so much slower than the money went out.
Pause
The money went out at a lightning pace, and now the oversight is coming at this pace of a snail. There was just this real mismatch that allowed a lot of money to get out the door to people who shouldn't have gotten it.
Pause
And who's conducting the investigation into the fraud? Who's involved here?
Pause
The better answer is who isn't. Oh, dear. There are federal law enforcement from 21 different inspectors general, government of justice, the IRS, the Postal Service, the Secret Service. Lots of different government agencies are now trying to track these folks down, as are, you know, in some cases, states, bank officers.
Pause
There's lots of people who are chasing after them now, but they move, even at their fastest, a lot slower than the fraudsters did to get the money.
Pause
What are the most common types of fraud being investigated? One of them is unemployment insurance. There was also a $600 a week extra payment that you could get if you got unemployment because of COVID-19.
Pause
The other two programs are both loan programs at the Small Business Administration. The SBA, that's the U.S. Small Business Administration, is offering low-interest-rate federal disaster loans for businesses suffering as a result of the coronavirus.
Pause
One of them, the Paycheck Protection Program, used private banks to lend money to businesses who were in trouble because of COVID. The government guaranteed those loans. The other was called the Economic Injury Disaster Loan Program.
Pause
And in that case, the government itself was giving out the money, both loans and in some cases what they called advanced grants. Basically, money you didn't have to repay, unlike a loan, the government would tide you over until they could approve your loan.
Pause
Is there a particular type or types of businesses that were especially involved in fraud?
Pause
Well, at least the most commonly prosecuted kind of fraud against the loan programs involved businesses that just didn't exist. So now when the phone rings, you have to answer. Vandalai Industries. I'm Vandalai Industries. Right. What is that? You're in latex.
Pause
You know, or they existed on paper, but they had no employees. So people would say, in 2019, I had a million dollars of revenue and 100 employees and, you know, get a loan on that basis to keep a business of that size going.
Pause
When really they either didn't have a business at all or, you know, the business existed on paper, but it was effectively defunct. So there were both businesses and there were individuals involved in the fraud.
Pause
What are some of the flagrant examples involving individuals, people who got unemployment insurance?
Pause
Unemployment insurance is overseen by the federal government but run directly by the states. And so there was a kind of fraud that took advantage of individual state governments.
Pause
The best example there is a rapper named Nuke Bizzle. He made a rap video in late 2020 about how he was scamming the California Employment Development Department by basically sending in fake unemployment claims, you know, with other people's information and getting money back.
Pause
The rap video he made about that was called EDD, which is the name of the government agency. The Department of Justice says a rapper who bragged in a music video about getting rich from an unemployment scam is now facing federal charges.
Pause
A second man in the video raps, quote, You gotta sell cocaine, I just file a claim. So there were people like him who were just scamming individual agencies.
Pause
And there were also lots of people who were sending the same profile, the same social security number, the same information to a bunch of different states and getting unemployment benefits in many of them at the same time.
Pause
The most egregious example of that, there was one social security number. So one person who got unemployment benefits in 29 different states.
Pause
You know, there are a lot of them that are just so ridiculous, you know, that you think, how in the world did anybody or any machine that was working in government look at this and think, oh, yeah, well, this seems like a reasonable one.
Pause
There was an example we used in the lead of our story of people who put their name as N.A., like not applicable and still got loans from the Small Business Administration.
Pause
And like who looked at that? Who thought like, how could the system allow that?
Pause
We had this one example of a mother and daughter in Westchester County, New York, who've been charged with basically running a ring where they helped other people put in fraudulent applications and the whole time they're doing it, they're just joking and laughing and sending emojis, you know, laughing, crying emojis to their friends and how easy it is.
Pause
You know, one example we said in the story, a friend of the ringleaders is like, I want to send in this application and the ringleader writes back, you bake four laugh, crying emojis.
Pause
You know, so they just, They made up a baking business. The co-conspirator writes back, LOL.
Pause
And there were lots of examples like that. People didn't steal because they were desperate. They stole and they spent the money on the most ridiculous, you know, luxury items, things that nobody needs.
Pause
The best example is a guy who got an $85,000 loan for a fake business and he used it to buy a $57,000 Pokemon card.
Pause
Can you talk about the hierarchy of the investigation? Like the woman in Westchester, how does the investigation into her begin? And then where does it get kicked to?
Pause
The amazing things to me about this story was just the huge volume of tips and leads the investigators have. You know, they don't have to go out and prospect around for tips and leads. They're buried in them.
Pause
The way they get them is either banks call the government and say, look, X person has an account with us. It's just a personal account. It rarely has any money in it at all. And all of a sudden she just put in a small business loan for $100,000. We think that's suspicious.
Pause
In some cases, the banks will freeze your loan until you can prove that you really have a business. Banks do more due diligence than the government.
Pause
In other cases, the Small Business Administration will run checks after the fact and say, well, okay, in hindsight, we gave out a whole bunch of loans that had these red flags of fraud.
Pause
A lot of loans came from the same address. A lot of loans used the same phone number, and they'll send that over to investigators.
Pause
In some cases, there's a hotline where if you feel like your brother-in-law stole money from PPP, you can call them up and, you know, call up the SBA and tell them.
Pause
So those are the ways that the cases get started. What we heard was just that there are so many cases like this that they've tried to triage them.
Pause
And the way that they've tried to triage them is both to try to look for the cases to start with the cases where the most money was stolen, to start with the cases where there was, like the one in Westchester, a ringleader, somebody who was organizing a whole bunch of other people to do small fraud.
Pause
And then other cases where, you know, there's some sort of deterrent value. You know, if they feel like there's something they can do that sends a message that this is a bad idea.
Pause
We didn't find many cases where they went after somebody who just stole $10,000 and $20,000. Usually there had to be a bigger number involved or some other sort of aggravating factor.
Pause
Okay, so a lot of people are going to get away with this unless they went big.
Pause
How many people have been charged with fraud? About 1,500 so far.
Pause
50. Which I started out thinking like, well, that's a huge number. You know, it is a big number. You know, the federal judiciary is a slow-moving selective. I mean, they make a few cases at a time, but they make big cases.
Pause
So 1,500 cases in that system is a lot, but it's just a drop in the bucket. I mean, it's such a tiny fraction of the actual crimes that seem to be out there waiting to be investigated.
Pause
Has anybody been convicted yet?
Pause
At the last count, about 450 people have been convicted of one of these crimes.
Pause
Because the evidence is so strong, this is not evidence you have to make with forensic tools or testimony or anything. It's the lie you told is in the government documents and the fact that you didn't have a business is in some other government documents.
Pause
So one investigator compared it to footsteps left in concrete. The clues of these frauds are not going away. It's just a matter of getting to them.
Pause
And have you gotten any sense of how much money the government hopes to recover?
Pause
No. One of the hardest parts about this story was trying to get people just to estimate how much they think was stolen.
Pause
What's the pool of money that's out there? And the floor is somewhere between $1 and $6 billion.
Pause
That's the amount of fraud that's been charged so far. What's the ceiling? And, you know, there's some really wild numbers out there.
Pause
$163 billion potentially in fraud in the Department of Labor from unemployment fraud. You know, somewhere in the high dozens, maybe even over $100 billion worth of fraud in the small business loan programs.
Pause
You know, it's like you're investigating a bank robbery and you still don't know how much was taken.
Pause
Some folks are going to go down. It's just a matter of time.
Pause
Do you have a sense of how long these investigations will be going on?
Pause
When we talked to the investigators, they at the time were pushing for and later got Congress and the president to approve an extension of the statute of limitations.
Pause
The chief prosecutor told Congress that it was essential, essential to extend the statute of limitations for certain pandemic fraud to extend to 10 years to make sure fraudsters can't run out the clock.
Pause
I don't know how realistic that actually is. A lot of things are going to happen in the next 10 years. A lot of other priorities will come along.
Pause
But he said, you know, to make real progress on this, we can't do it in five years. We going to need 10.
Pause
Noelle King
The watchdogs are back. Coming up next why so much of the scamming was actually legal.
Pause
Support for today's show comes from Adio. What is Adio?
Pause
Adio is an AI-native customer relationship management system built specifically for the next era of companies.
Pause
They say it's extremely powerful, adapts to your unique data structures and scales with any business model.
Pause
According to Adio, Adio takes less than a minute to set up, and within seconds you will have your email and calendars synced.
Pause
You'll see all your relationships in a fully-fledged platform, they say, all enriched with that actionable data.
Pause
And they say you can build AI-powered automations and use its research agent to tackle some of your most complex processes to seize so that you can focus on what matters, building your company.
Pause
You can join industry leaders such as Flatfile, Replicate, Modal, and so much more.
Pause
You can go to atio.com slash todayexplained to get 15% off your first year. That's attio.com slash todayexplained.
Pause
Support for this show comes from Macy's. It's almost fall, and that means it's time to cycle your wardrobe to the cold setting.
Pause
Because while everyone loves a breezy summer outfit, let's be real, layering is even more fun.
Pause
That's why Macy's Fall Fashion Guide has everything you need to piece together the perfect look for you.
Pause
It's your one-stop shop for fall's latest trends and must-haves, curated by their experts.
Pause
Add a statement shoe to your collection, like the calf-hair loafers from Steve Madden.
Pause
Or tap into your romantic side with flowy dresses from CC and sheer pieces from INC.
Pause
You can even throw in some textural layers for contrast, like a faux fur bomber jacket from Karl Lagerfeld Paris.
Pause
Whether your old favorite sweater or coat is on its last threads, or you're just craving a new vibe to switch things up, Macy's has got you covered this season.
Pause
Find the perfect layering pieces for you by exploring the Macy's Fall Fashion Style Guide.
Pause
Shop in-store or online at Macy's.com.
Pause
Today Explained, we're back with David Autor. He's a professor of economics at MIT, a labor economist who works on earnings, inequality, and technological and global forces that affect opportunity.
Pause
David Autor
Some weeks back, David, you co-authored a study with a title that deserves a shout out for clarity. Quote, the $800 billion paycheck protection program. Where did the money go and why did it go there?
Pause
David, what was the point of the Paycheck Protection Program?
Pause
The point of the program was to prevent small businesses from failing and in the process firing or laying off many, many workers.
Pause
And so the name Paycheck Protection, I think, conveys at least part of the purpose was to protect the paychecks of those workers.
Pause
Now, the program also authorized some expenditure on non-payroll expenses that could be used for suppliers, rents, etc.
Pause
How is PPP supposed to work? Who would apply, who would be responsible, and who would get the money?
Pause
So the criteria were very loose. The program was almost untargeted. Essentially, you had to be an employer with fewer than 500 workers, or in some cases there are exceptions for that.
Pause
And you had to say that you were significantly affected by the pandemic, which is, as you can see, a rather nebulous term.
Pause
And then you could receive a check for up to 10 weeks of payroll, then you had to use that to have that money forgiven.
Pause
If it weren't forgiven, it would be a low-interest loan, but the vast majority of all PPP payments have been forgiven as of now, more than 90%.
Pause
How many businesses received these loans?
Pause
In total, about 11 million checks were written.
Pause
Wow. These checks were much, much larger than the ones going to households or individuals. Some of them were as much as $10 million.
Pause
So the potential for kind of misallocation of that funding is really vast when you're writing checks that large to a comparatively small number of businesses.
Pause
Let's talk about some of the misallocation. You recently, along with a number of colleagues, looked to see who benefited most from this $800 billion loan program.
Pause
Broadly, what did you find?
Pause
We found the program did some of what it was intended to do. We have close to 150 employees, and it allowed us to stay open, allowed us to compete with the unemployment benefits.
Pause
It was such a blessing to be able to stay in business. We estimate that it increased employment by about two to three million person years of employment.
Pause
That means, you know, one person for one year is a person year.
Pause
Now, if you were to talk to the Small Business Administration at the time, they would say, well, 45 million jobs were supported by PPP.
Pause
So how do we come up with two to three million? Well, the answer is that the firms that took PPP loans did have 45 million employees.
Pause
That doesn't mean they would have laid off 45 million employees had they not received these loans.
Pause
Many, many firms were not that financially distressed during the pandemic.
Pause
Construction, technical services, manufacturing and health care made up roughly half of the loans that had been approved.
Pause
If you were in trucking, if you were in manufacturing, all kinds of services, they kept going.
Pause
And so they would have largely retained employment.
Pause
What that means is that effectively only about 25 to 30 percent of all of the PPP money ultimately went to paychecks that wouldn't have been paid.
Pause
Meaning the remainder went to business owners and creditors and so on.
Pause
And because business owners and creditors and shareholders are drawn disproportionately from high-income households, we estimate that about three-quarters of the PPP money ultimately went to the top fifth of all U.S. households.
Pause
Two to three million people kept their jobs for a year because of PPP.
Pause
That is not half bad. It not It a success in that sense.
Pause
However the cost of that was extremely high.
Pause
And it's important to remember that had those workers lost their jobs they would have received pandemic unemployment insurance benefits.
Pause
Right. So they wouldn't necessarily have been in dire straits.
Pause
Now it did keep businesses alive on top of keeping workers employed.
Pause
There are certainly small businesses that would have closed their doors had it not been for PPP.
Pause
You know, if you talk to people, some small business owners will say, this program was a lifeline. It saved my business.
Pause
And that's absolutely true. That's completely uncontested.
Pause
But many, many of the businesses, especially the larger ones that receive PPP loans, probably would have kept going just fine.
Pause
It increased profitability.
Pause
And another provision of the law that was changed ex post is you didn't have to pay tax on that money, even if it accrued to profits like you would normally pay corporate tax on profitability.
Pause
Your PPP money wasn't counted against that.
Pause
So if you made an extra million because you got a PPP loan for a million, you actually got a tax subsidy on that.
Pause
So if you were a business owner and had some debts and the government was like, here's some free money. I don't know. Of course you would. Right? Yes, of course I would.
Pause
And they all did. Okay. No, there's almost nobody that didn't.
Pause
So take up of the program was, you know, approximately 94%.
Pause
So in that event, what went so wrong here?
Pause
Run through a list. Everything you would change.
Pause
So the real fundamental deep problem is that the united states has archaic ossified neglected administrative systems that don't allow it to act like a modern country in administering a large insurance program.
Pause
So in many other countries for example, Canada, our neighbor to the north, They have what are called short-time work programs.
Pause
Short-time work means during a recession, an employer might say, oh, I'm going to send half my staff home, or I'm going to send everyone home with only 20 hours instead of 40 hours.
Pause
The government can see that in real time through the unemployment insurance records, and it can just pay those workers for the lost hours.
Pause
It doesn't have to write a check to the firm to say, here, give that to your workers. It just pays them.
Pause
The U.S. government does not have the capability to do that because we have 50 state unemployment insurance systems, each of them 50 years out of date.
Pause
So there was no capacity to do the type of targeted lending or giving that you would ideally want to do.
Pause
And so if the federal government were to come to you and say, Professor David Otter, we are going to give you $800 billion to fix these problems, what would you spend the money on?
Pause
The starting point would be to take our patchwork unemployment insurance system, which is run differently in each of the 50 states, but with lots of federal subsidies, and turn it into a national unemployment insurance system that has consistent rules, that doesn't view the unemployed as a cost, but rather as beneficiaries of the insurance program.
Pause
And that had moderate administrative systems such that it could be used to help workers who are losing hours or losing employment as a result of economic conditions.
Pause
Noelle King
Today's show was produced by John Ahrens. Congratulations to this man on his recent nuptials.
Pause
It was edited by Matthew Collette.
Pause
It was fact-checked by Serena Solon.
Pause
It was engineered by Paul Robert Mounsey.
Pause
I'm Noelle King. It's Today Explained. Thank you.