Main Topic: The ongoing protests by Indian farmers against the central government's agricultural reforms, which they claim will leave them vulnerable to big corporations and worsen their economic situation.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Sean Rameswaram
Support for Today Explained comes from Adio. Adio is an AI-native customer relationship management platform that Adio says is built for the next era of companies.
Music fades out
A powerful data structure adapts to your business model, syncs in all your contacts in minutes, and enriches your business with actionable data. Adio says it also allows you to create those email sequences, those real-time reports, those powerful automations, which they claim can help you build what matters most, your company.
Music fades out
You can go to adio.com slash todayexplained to get 15% off your first year. That's A-T-T-I-O dot com slash todayexplained.
Music fades out
Not all journalism is the same. Take The Guardian. Our coverage has something unique, fierce independence. Nobody owns us or tells us what we can and can't say. So we're free to report the whole picture. We connect what's happening in Washington to the rest of the globe, expose corruption wherever we find it, and give fresh perspective on everything from wellness and soccer to culture, the climate and more.
Music fades out
Read, watch and listen to The Guardian for free at theguardian.com.
Music fades out
One of the largest organized protests in the history of humanity is happening right now in the world's biggest democracy. A sight like no other has unfolded at border points by Delhi in India.
Irfan Nooruddin
India's capital, New Delhi, is under siege by farmers who have made treks from their villages with trucks, tractors. Some 200,000 farmers are estimated now to be on the streets.
Sean Rameswaram
Let them do the body! Don't, don't! Let them do the body! Don't, don't! Let them do the body! Don't, don't!
Irfan Nooruddin
They're protesting agricultural reforms that they say will leave them at the mercy of big corporations.
Sean Rameswaram
There are huge open kitchens that are being set up by those who are supporting the farmers to feed these farmers. They're sleeping on their truck beds and they're sleeping on the streets.
Irfan Nooruddin
But like with anything with India, it's so colorful, right? I mean, think of Sikh, all the turbans, right? I mean, it's just really visually quite powerful.
Sean Rameswaram
The government is essentially saying that we don't want to be protecting you anymore by regulating the market. You can interface with the markets all by yourselves. And let's see what happens.
Irfan Nooruddin
Fend for yourselves. You have an incredible vivid color and noise, sort of active, democratic, peaceful, nonviolent protests.
Sean Rameswaram
The government has responded at times with force. Protesters have been met with water cannons along with tear gas, concrete barricades, and some were even beaten with batons.
Irfan Nooruddin
Farmers make up about, what, half of the country's workforce. Why are hundreds of thousands of them protesting in the country's capital? What's behind these protests?
Sean Rameswaram
I think we're really getting at sort of the challenges of globalization, of market liberalization, of economic reform on a really micro scale.
Irfan Nooruddin
It's easy to talk about those big ideas of how do we reform an economy for the 21st century and sometimes forget that at the very end of those reforms are small farmers working the land in ways that their grandparents and their great-grandparents and generations before that do.
Sean Rameswaram
So in many ways, this is India's historical economy coming face-to-face with India's aspirational future economy.
Irfan Nooruddin
Okay, and they're protesting modernization through three new laws in particular, right? What are these new laws?
Sean Rameswaram
They were passed actually back in September, three laws that interlock to create maybe the largest change to India's agricultural markets since independence.
Irfan Nooruddin
What they do or aspire to do is to create a much more of a market mechanism through which farmers could sell their produce to any buyer, including in the private sector, to allow for larger investments and activity by industrial farming in India's agricultural markets, to change how the prices are set for farmer produce.
Sean Rameswaram
And then finally, to affect in ways that are quite subtle the ways in which grain and agricultural produce is stored and can be transported across state borders.
Irfan Nooruddin
India's constitution defines different responsibilities and gives them to different levels of government. Farming is a state subject. So the individual states get to decide what happens.
Sean Rameswaram
And so partly what the central government is trying to do is to create much more of a national market for agriculture so that farmers can trade across borders.
Irfan Nooruddin
The government is promising that if these reforms go through and are implemented properly, that farmers' incomes will double in the coming years.
Sean Rameswaram
Which sounds like it could be at least sold to farmers as a positive development. Why are hundreds of thousands of farmers taking to the streets about this? Why are they so worried?
Irfan Nooruddin
Partly it is because there a fundamental distrust of large reform And the government I suspect miscalculated in not consulting farmer organizations and representatives of farmers fully
Sean Rameswaram
These laws came by surprise which has become a bit of the Indian government way of doing things Some of us will remember, you know, in November of 2016, when overnight the Indian government deemed 90% of the currency no longer legal tender in what is called demonetization.
Irfan Nooruddin
Last year, there were protests because the government suddenly rammed through a complete change to Kashmir's constitutional status, to citizenship rules.
Sean Rameswaram
Once again, we have a really big set of rules that were not passed with any real democratic deliberation and consultation.
Irfan Nooruddin
So fundamental distrust over here is a large part of this. But beyond that, Indian farmers, for the most part, lead lives that are very close to subsistence levels.
Sean Rameswaram
The bulk of Indian farmers have land holdings of less than two and a half acres.
Irfan Nooruddin
So what we're talking about here are small farmers who are desperately in need of some guarantee that what they produce will find a buyer and will fetch them a price that will allow them to keep body and soul together.
Sean Rameswaram
Market mechanisms might be great in an economics textbook, but are terrifying for these farmers.
Irfan Nooruddin
But it's also worth remembering that these are not new in the sense of being innovative across the country. Lots of states, because farming is a state subject, have experimented and implemented versions of these rules before.
Sean Rameswaram
And that is partly what animates some of the concerns of the farmers who are now protesting, who basically point to innovations of these kinds implemented in other states that they say show that farmers are not actually benefiting from some of these rules.
Irfan Nooruddin
So take something like the minimum support price or the mandi system. The state of Bihar, which is not very far from where a lot of these protests are occurring, over a decade ago had really changed its agricultural system.
Sean Rameswaram
But the average farmer in Bihar is much, much poorer than the average farmer in Punjab, which is the epicenter of the current protests, where these rules had not been implemented.
Irfan Nooruddin
So farmers in Punjab can look across the state lines to other states that have tried versions of these reforms and say, why on earth would we want that? We have got a much better situation than what is being promised to us.
Sean Rameswaram
It's interesting. I mean, if this is being figured out at the state level, why did the federal government feel the need to step in and pass broader reforms?
Irfan Nooruddin
India's system of state governance is important because it allows for farmers and anyone, any workers to be closer to the leaders that represent them.
Sean Rameswaram
But India is also a huge market. It's 1.3 billion people. And part of this government's approach is to leverage India's huge population into a national market.
Irfan Nooruddin
So, for instance, in America, farmers in Nebraska can sell their produce to buyers anywhere in the country.
Sean Rameswaram
The Mundi system, which is government procurement of produce in certain states, makes it essentially that those buyers have a monopoly or monopsonist purchasing power over the produce in the states.
Irfan Nooruddin
This allows farmers to sell to a single buyer that guarantees them a certain price and provides some price stability.
Sean Rameswaram
But trading across state lines in ways that would benefit a national market is very difficult under these rules.
Irfan Nooruddin
So partly the government is saying, why wouldn't we want farmers to have a choice of saying, instead of selling my stuff to these guys who have been my partners for the last 50 years, why wouldn't I want to put my produce on the open market so that anyone wanting to buy it, maybe paying me a higher price, maybe offering me other kinds of incentives, is equally viable as a customer as the current Mundi system.
Sean Rameswaram
So yes, it's a state subject, but the government would make the argument that there's a lot of benefits to efficiency and productivity if we could nationalize the investment in farmers.
Irfan Nooruddin
This is a done deal, but that hasn't stopped people from protesting. They've been out there for weeks. But the protests intensified over the weekend, so this seems like it's ramping up.
Sean Rameswaram
What comes next?
Irfan Nooruddin
At the end of the day, the government's advantage is that it can wait out the protesters. And the government might argue internally that it has shown an ability to do that without much consequence.
Sean Rameswaram
I mean, a year ago, we had huge protests against the Citizenship Amendment Act that the government had passed. And three months later, those protesters were disbanded, largely because of the COVID lockdowns.
Irfan Nooruddin
But the government didn't really pay any real political costs because of that. So I suspect they will try and wait them out.
Sean Rameswaram
The optics though are striking. And as farmers mainly from Punjab and Haryana continue their protests at the border of Delhi, the internet is being flooded with songs of revolution and rebellion.
Irfan Nooruddin
We have peaceful protesters reminding everyday Indians where their food comes from. This is a sympathetic group of individuals who are not rich, they're not wealthy, They're average farmers who are sort of, you know, make for really good copy
Sean Rameswaram
Punjabi and Haryanvi singers are churning out one number after the other and garnering millions of views online The biggest names from the Punjabi music and film industry have lent their support to the farmers' agitation.
Irfan Nooruddin
And so this is playing on the national news, this is playing in every newspaper in India.
Sean Rameswaram
I think the government is going to have to find a way to deal with these farmers on their own terms while, of course, maintaining the integrity of the laws that they thought were a good idea back in September.
Irfan Nooruddin
Oh More with Irfan after a quick break.
Sean Rameswaram
Support for Today Explained comes from Chime. Nobody likes fees and complicated banking, says Chime. And Chime gets that, says Chime.
Music fades out
Chime is a financial technology company that says they understand that every dollar counts. So when you set up direct deposit through Chime, they say you get access to fee-free features such as free overdraft coverage, getting paid up to two days early with direct deposit, so much more.
Music fades out
Chime says with qualifying direct deposits, you can be eligible for free overdraft, up to $200 on debit card purchases and cash withdrawals. Plus, they say you don't need to worry about monthly fees or maintenance fees.
Music fades out
You can work on your financial goals through Chime today. You can open an account in two minutes at Chime.com slash explained. That's chime.com slash explained.
Music fades out
Chime feels like progress. Chime is a financial technology company, not a bank. Banking services and debit card provided by the Bancorp Bank N.A. or Stride Bank N.A. Members FDIC.
Music fades out
Spot me eligibility requirements and overdraft limits apply. Timing depends on submission of payment file. Fees apply at out-of-network ATMs.
Music fades out
Bank ranking and number of ATMs according to U.S. News and World Report 2023. Chime checking account required.
Music fades out
This message is brought to you by Apple Card. Each Apple product, like the iPhone, is thoughtfully designed by skilled designers.
Music fades out
The Titanium Apple Card is no different. It's laser etched, has no numbers, and it earns you daily cash on everything you buy, including 3% back on everything at Apple.
Music fades out
Apply for Apple Card on your iPhone in minutes. Subject to credit approval, Apple Card is issued by Goldman Sachs Bank USA, Salt Lake City Branch. Terms and more at AppleCard.com.
Music fades out
Irfan Nooruddin
Irfan, you mentioned reforms like these have been occurring on the state level in India. How far back does this agricultural crisis in the country go?
Sean Rameswaram
This is a crisis that goes all the way back to independence and before.
Irfan Nooruddin
One of the big efforts of the post-independence government was to implement meaningful land reform. that would reallocate land, especially in North India, more equitably.
Sean Rameswaram
It didn't succeed because landed interests fought back pretty vociferously.
Irfan Nooruddin
But the end result of this is that the average farmer in India, the modal farmer in India, has very small land holdings, less than one hectare, that's about two and a half acres of land.
Sean Rameswaram
No agriculture anywhere in the world can be productive on that smaller piece of land
Irfan Nooruddin
I joke when I teach at Georgetown with my students that as an Indian I sometimes think of you know the great agricultural states of America Nebraska and Oklahoma and as basically being one farmer on a giant combine going up and down the state right
Sean Rameswaram
And that scale of these huge farms allows for the implementation of huge technology of machine agriculture that allows for the tremendous productivity so that today in America, less than 2% of the American population makes its income directly from farming.
Irfan Nooruddin
And yet America is one of the most productive agricultural nations in the world, generating huge surpluses of agriculture that can be sold throughout America and around the world.
Sean Rameswaram
In India, we did not get that land reform. The downside of this has been that farmers have not had an infusion of capital that has allowed them to go out and innovate in terms of the technology.
Irfan Nooruddin
There's no real incentive to do that. And the money that they make is inadequate to really make a living in a 21st century world.
Sean Rameswaram
How does all this translate on the ground. You're saying farmers are dealt a bad hand in India, plots of land that aren't productive. Yet unlike the United States, agriculture accounts for about half of the workforce in the country.
Irfan Nooruddin
What's life like for the average Indian farmer?
Sean Rameswaram
The farmer distress is huge. In 2019 alone, over 10,000 farmers committed suicide.
Irfan Nooruddin
Wow. In the past decade, the estimate is that over 50,000 farmers have killed themselves.
Sean Rameswaram
Imagine a person's life ending because of indebtedness caused by the fact that they simply can't make a living.
Irfan Nooruddin
I want to just go back to that 50 farmers killing themselves because of distress faced by drought climate change induced volatility but fundamentally the inability to make a sustainable living and to pay their debts
Sean Rameswaram
So the notion that agriculture in India is sustainable in its current form is not viable. It needs a change.
Irfan Nooruddin
But what farmers would point out is that simply changing the market mechanisms to make them more vulnerable to price fluctuation is not enough.
Sean Rameswaram
What about infrastructure? How do farmers get their produce to the buyers when they have broken roads, inadequate coal chain storage facilities?
Irfan Nooruddin
So much of Indian farming never makes it to market because it goes bad, it spoils.
Sean Rameswaram
How do we guarantee that farmers who take a loan from a private sector bank won't and can't pay it back won't lose their land, which is their only source of income.
Irfan Nooruddin
So part of the picture here is that there's a much bigger situation facing Indian agriculture. And what the government has done over here is arguably tried to attempt to fix part of it, but without touching any of the rest of it.
Sean Rameswaram
And what the farmers are arguing right now is that that potentially makes the situation even worse.
Irfan Nooruddin
I mean, just to go back for a second to your comparison of Indian agriculture to American agriculture, where there's one farmer on a combine managing Oklahoma and Nebraska.
Sean Rameswaram
I mean, you can't imagine 50,000 agricultural deaths by suicide in the United States. That would be a crisis of epic proportions.
Irfan Nooruddin
Does that speak to how few options Indian farmers have other than agriculture?
Sean Rameswaram
Absolutely. I mean, it speaks to a level of desperation that is frankly unimaginable to me, and I suspect to most, if not everyone, listening to the show.
Irfan Nooruddin
Where do farmers go if they're not farming? 40% of the labor force in India right now is employed in agriculture.
Sean Rameswaram
Where do all of those individuals go to find productive employment if not doing what they know how to do and what they've done for generations?
Irfan Nooruddin
So the larger question over here is that we have an economy that aspires to be a 21st century leader, that is showing great signs of doing that. It's now the seventh largest economy in the world, but that still fails to provide meaningful employment opportunities to the bulk of its labor force.
Sean Rameswaram
And this is especially exacerbated among farming communities that have limited access to education. The urban-rural gap in education is huge in India.
Irfan Nooruddin
And so what we have to really grapple with as a society is that it's fine to aspire to a different agricultural sector, one that's much more efficient, one that has fewer people working on it.
Sean Rameswaram
But what happens to those farmers? And unless we can answer that question, we don't solve the really deep-rooted issues that we're seeing on the streets of Delhi right now.
Irfan Nooruddin
Has anyone asked the Indian government, just point blank, are you willing to take this risk to reform agriculture? Are you willing to even see an increased loss of life and livelihood right now?
Sean Rameswaram
Because in the end, it might be the better move for the economy.
Irfan Nooruddin
So the India of 2020 does not really allow for such kind of direct questioning of the government.
Sean Rameswaram
I mean, we have a prime minister who is much admired by many Indians and yet has not held a press conference in six years of being prime minister.
Irfan Nooruddin
So that kind of direct, accountable indirect questioning doesn't occur.
Sean Rameswaram
But the opposition parties are raising exactly that set of issues. They're trying to paint a picture and saying that what the government is doing is to be cavalier, to be cruel about the fates of farmers by essentially selling them pie in the sky, good in economic textbooks, but really lousy in terms of implementation and on the ground.
Irfan Nooruddin
The government, I think, legitimately comes back and says, hey, don't pretend like farmer situations right now are very good. 40,000 suicides over the last 10 years is also an indictment of the current system.
Sean Rameswaram
And so we need to have fresh thinking, we need to have change.
Irfan Nooruddin
And so maybe the big picture takeaway is not that these farm bills and farm laws are inherently misguided and inherently bad, but rather that a single silver bullet to solve India's agricultural woes does not exist.
Sean Rameswaram
And what the government needs to convince farmers is that they are willing to take the big, holistic view of what ails farming and not throw them at the mercy of private sector markets that may or may not work out for individual farmers.
Irfan Nooruddin
That's a risk-reward ratio that these poor, small farmers are unwilling to take, and that's why they're on the streets of Delhi right now.
Sean Rameswaram
Irfan, thank you so much
Irfan Nooruddin
Thank you, Sean, I appreciate it
Sean Rameswaram
Irfan Nooruddin is a professor of Indian politics at Georgetown University. He's also the director of the South Asia Center at the Atlantic Council.
I'm Sean Rameswaram for him, this is Today Explained