Main Topic: The recent data breach at Capital One, a major financial institution, and the implications of such breaches on consumer protection.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Sean Rameswaram
Here's a question. Do your career goals require you to take a standardized test like the GRE or the GMAT or the LSAT or the MCAT or the SAT? Visit Magoosh.com and enter the promo code today for a 15% off discount for their test prep. That's M-A-G-O-O-S-H dot com.
Russell Brandom
Monday night, the world found out about another huge hundred million plus data breach. Could you tell the people what happened?
Sean Rameswaram
Yeah. So Capital One, you may know their credit card ads on TV. What's in your wallet? Or their arena in Washington, D.C. Also, also very true. So essentially, they were storing some data on Amazon cloud server, not unusual, and it turned out that it was sort of misconfigured.
Russell Brandom
More than 100 million Capital One credit card customers and applicants across the U.S. and Canada have been affected by a massive data breach. This is one of the biggest breaches of a financial institution ever.
Sean Rameswaram
This is what they're saying. Yeah, I mean, it's sort of all in how you look at it. There's data from more than 100 million credit applications, right? So this is sort of the thing that they mail to you and you mail back.
Russell Brandom
Capital One was quick to say that it wasn't that many social security numbers. There was only 140,000 U.S. social security numbers and 80,000 bank account numbers and about a million social insurance numbers, which are sort of the Canadian equivalent of the social security numbers.
Sean Rameswaram
So, I mean, that's still a lot of people, but it's not really as impressive as leading with 100 million thing. So do we know who did this at all?
Russell Brandom
So a person has been charged with doing this, Paige Thompson, who is a former employee of Amazon Web Services. They say she left an extensive digital footprint of her alleged crime on the Internet, including bragging about what she did online.
Sean Rameswaram
She was just hosting it on GitHub, which is not usually what hackers do in this situation. Like usually you would kind of want to keep it secret and have people pay you for it if you're trying to make lots of money.
Russell Brandom
Is GitHub where like all the hackers hang out? No, GitHub is just sort of a boring place where people put their coding projects and anyone can go there.
Sean Rameswaram
So, I mean, when Capital One found out about this, basically the email they got in their responsible disclosure inbox was, hey, look at this GitHub page. And they had a link to the GitHub page and was like, that doesn't seem right. But it was just sort of out there in the open.
Russell Brandom
I feel like if she had had some nefarious purpose to it, either we would have seen it anonymously out there with some manifesto or it would have been sort of sold quietly in the sort of underground marketplaces where people will pay money for this stuff. And so neither of those happened.
Sean Rameswaram
It kind of raises questions about what her thought process was in doing this.
Russell Brandom
Surveillance video shows federal agents arriving to Paige Thompson's Beacon Hill home in Seattle early Monday morning. The 33-year-old placed under arrest accused of hacking into Capital One's system.
Sean Rameswaram
How unusual is it to sort of apprehend a suspect so quickly after finding out something like this happened and for it to just be like a single hacker who maybe doesn't even have a real motive?
Russell Brandom
Well, often you just sort of don't know who it is. Like, I think that's sort of the typical thing is that we'll say, well, you know, someone hacked Home Depot. It was some person or some group of people and we don't really know.
Sean Rameswaram
And then someone else got a hold of the same program and they hacked Target. And either they're doing it to a U.S. area because they know that they're in Ukraine or Russia and they won't really be extraditable even if they find them or they've taken some sort of more sophisticated effort to hide themselves.
Russell Brandom
But just finding this stuff on a public GitHub page that directly connected to the person name is pretty unusual.
Sean Rameswaram
Should it be concerning that this one person who maybe didn't even like want to do something nefarious didn't have a very hard time getting all of this information, getting something like 106 million credit card applications?
Russell Brandom
Well, yeah. I mean, so this is not supposed to happen. Like Definitely, this was a goof is the technical term. That's what they call it in the business.
Sean Rameswaram
This is a goof? That's what they call this? This is a goof?
Russell Brandom
Yeah, it's a goof. I would say it was a major, severe goof. Unprecedented goof.
Sean Rameswaram
But also, I mean, I wouldn't downplay her technical sophistication. I mean, she was really pretty good at knowing the specific configurations and ways to exploit specific other configurations.
Russell Brandom
And she had years earlier actually worked at Amazon, which is one of the things people sort of have questions about of did she have some special knowledge of how to do this?
Sean Rameswaram
But, I mean, very often people are just bad at setting these things up and stuff just leaks out. So maybe that should be more secure. Maybe we should be taking a closer look at Capital One and sort of how they handle.
Russell Brandom
Isn't it like definitely? Yeah, definitely Capital One is in some trouble here.
Sean Rameswaram
Is this just the new normal that we should expect? Like when we submit things to banks and official institutions that have all of our information and protect our money, our credit, our financial well-being, that this stuff is vulnerable and can just get easily and randomly hacked?
Russell Brandom
I mean, yeah, like I think fundamentally, if you are filling out a form and you are submitting it to a large corporation, I mean, any corporation, you should probably figure that that information is potentially going to get out there.
Sean Rameswaram
The real concern is the social security numbers because that is the raw material for identity theft and it's not just oh i have the social security number i have the keys to the kingdom but okay if i have a recent address from the person and i know their full name and i know their social security number and i know a couple other things i can probably fill out a loan application that no one will look too closely at.
Russell Brandom
And maybe if I put in my address instead of their address, they'll just figure the person moved. And, you know, credit card companies are always sort of looking out for this. But at the same time, they don't want to make it too hard to apply for a credit card because that's their business.
Sean Rameswaram
And so, yeah, it's tricky. I mean, if we're trusting the banks and the credit agencies to take care of our information and they're not, what can people do in the meantime to keep their information secure?
Russell Brandom
Actually, probably the best thing you can do is get a credit freeze that will just say, do not let anyone apply for anything in my name until I sort of call you up and give you this, these special four digits.
Sean Rameswaram
The other thing you can do that's a little bit less intense is you can just get credit monitoring where they'll look and they'll say, oh, actually, this person just applied for a credit card with a different address. Was that you or was that not?
Russell Brandom
You and they'll sort of be watching more closely. And that usually costs money. But actually, if you were in one of the recent breaches, they might be offering it for free.
Sean Rameswaram
Russell's talking about Equifax right now, because right now Equifax is facing the music for its big, huge breach from a few years ago.
Russell Brandom
The consequences for big corporations that don't take care of your personal information after the break.
Sean Rameswaram
Back in my day when you wanted to do test prep for one of these GMAT GRE LSAT MCAT SAT situations you had to like go somewhere to a class But with Magoosh, you got some other options. At Magoosh.com, you get all your practice questions, your study schedules, you get video lessons and access to an expert tutor team if you need extra help.
Russell Brandom
And if you're retaking a test, Magoosh offers a score improvement guarantee. If you don't improve, you get your money back.
Sean Rameswaram
At Magoosh.com, study materials are always up to date and super relevant to the questions you'll see on the actual tests. And guess what? Students who have used Magoosh love it. Find out for yourself over at Magoosh.com.
Russell Brandom
The promo code today gets you 15% off. That's M-A-G-O-O-S-H dot com and the promo code today for a 15% off discount at Magoosh.
Sean Rameswaram
I just like saying Magoosh. That's the trush.
Russell Brandom
Russell, one of these big data breaches kind of came to a head last week when people found out that, hey, they could type their name and information into some website and maybe get some money back for one of these breaches. This was Equifax.
Sean Rameswaram
What happened in that case?
Russell Brandom
Equifax is one of the companies that's doing the credit monitoring and the credit freezes. They're sort of maintaining the credit information on anyone who's applying for credit.
Sean Rameswaram
In 2017, they announced that they'd had a data breach of 147 million people, and it was very, very bad.
Russell Brandom
And so in the years since that, the FTC, the Federal Trade Commission, has been suing them and sort of trying to make the American consumer whole as sort of a just compensate the people who were part of that, which is basically everyone.
Sean Rameswaram
And so that happened. Like they finally got the settlement. It came in. There's a website, EquifaxBreachSettlement.com, where you can sort of put in the last six digits of your social security number because you shouldn't be, as we covered earlier, you shouldn't be putting your social security number into random websites.
Russell Brandom
But yeah, so you can go to that site. If you were in the breach, you're entitled to compensation and it'll give you this kind of choice about how you want that compensation to work.
Sean Rameswaram
What's the choice? What do you actually get? So either you can get the credit monitoring, which conveniently Equifax is in the business of providing.
Russell Brandom
Wait, as an apology for letting all of your information out into the open, they will monitor your credit for you for free?
Sean Rameswaram
Yeah, I mean, it's not like as an apology. It's like if I like hit your car and it crushed up the bumper and I would be like, you know what? New bumper on me.
Russell Brandom
And it's not like you're supposed to be happy about it but you're supposed to be like, okay, that's good enough, like fair.
Sean Rameswaram
But isn't it kind of not like that? Because it's like if you borrowed my car and like broke it and then you were like, let me continue to borrow your car but not break it. It feels more like that.
Russell Brandom
Well, if I fix it and I tell you that I fixed it and maybe the bumper that I get you isn't exactly the same color as the rest of your car so you still notice it. But it's better than like a crushed bumper and you know that you're not really going to get anything better from me then you would sort of you would like sigh heavily and accept it yeah i guess like if i have no other option because i can't afford a new car because you've ruined my life that like yeah.
Sean Rameswaram
And you can't like afford a functional consumer Protection Agency, right? Like, who are you going to go to? Consumer Financial Protection Bureau?
Russell Brandom
I got some bad news. So, okay. So that's one option. Great. Okay. So the option that has taken on a little bit more hype is $125, which people saw on the internet and lost their minds.
Sean Rameswaram
Is that because it like sort of feels like free money to people who have felt the actual tangible effects of having their information breached?
Russell Brandom
I think that's part of it. I think the other thing is that like people are broke. It's hard out there. Like it's bad. I mean, I'm in New York. I don't know what it's like in DC. But if I walked out on the street and I was like, hey, I want you to do something here's $125. It's nuts.
Sean Rameswaram
Are you saying there's a lot of things you would do for $125?
Russell Brandom
Well, not me. I'm a wealthy blogger.
Sean Rameswaram
Sure, sure, sure, sure, sure, sure, sure. You know, so yeah, $125 for this thing that already happened to you and you didn't even notice, people are all about it.
Russell Brandom
Is there a chance that people don't get $125 if, say, like a ton of people sign up for the settlement though?
Sean Rameswaram
Yeah. So there's 147 million people were affected. Their estimate is that a little under a quarter of a million people will sign up. And if that's the number of people, then they'll get $125 each. But if a million people get the money, then they get $31. And it sort of keeps going down to the point where if absolutely every single person signs up, they get 21 cents.
Russell Brandom
What? 21 cents?
Sean Rameswaram
Does a company like Equifax even feel pain here? I mean, on one hand, it's 21 cents to $125 at most. And on the other, it's people choosing like, yeah, monitor my credit for free, in which case all they have to really do is provide a service they already provide and probably coax you into paying for the service eventually for some people.
Russell Brandom
I mean, are they hurting after losing everyone's information? Do any of these companies hurt after losing your personal information?
Sean Rameswaram
Well, everybody hurts. I think they probably aren't hurting as much as they should be. Like for me, I look at this and I think, why does this company even exist after this? Their only job was collecting and storing and safely disseminating financial information. So if they can't protect it, why let them handle it at all?
Russell Brandom
What's the answer to that question?
Sean Rameswaram
Well, I mean, because they're a business and we don't like shutting down businesses for consumer protection reasons in this country.
Russell Brandom
If you want to sort of get a political cause out of it, we need to empower the FTC to be harder on these companies and sort of be a more powerful and fearful agency so that when they're in this situation, they can really... make these things hurt as much as they should.
Sean Rameswaram
Because, I mean, fundamentally, I think it's still worse for the people who got breached than it was for Equifax. And they weren't even intentionally in a relationship with Equifax. They didn't decide to buy something from Equifax. Equifax was just collecting their information ambiently because that's what it does.
Russell Brandom
The problem is that the breach happened in the first place. And how can we make the penalty significant enough that it doesn't happen in the future? Like, that's the long-term thing. People weren't like meaningfully damaged that much. It's really just this is an insane system and how can we make the fine big enough that it makes people try to make the system better?
Sean Rameswaram
Russell Brandom, as you know, is a wealthy blogger at The Verge. I'm Sean Rameswaram from this is Today Explained. Thanks to Magoosh for supporting the show today again Magoosh.com with the promo code today is the place to get a 15% off discount the Magoosh online test prep which helps you study anywhere anytime on your desktop or on mobile magoosh.com.