Our complicated relationship with the flag

[Theme music fades out]

Host: Support for Today Explained comes from Adio. Adio is an AI-native customer relationship management platform that Adio says is built for the next era of companies. A powerful data structure adapts to your business model, syncs in all your contacts in minutes, and enriches your business with actionable data. Adio says it also allows you to create those email sequences, those real-time reports, those powerful automations, which they claim can help you build what matters most, your company. You can go to adio.com slash todayexplained to get 15% off your first year. That's A-T-T-I-O dot com slash todayexplained.

[Music transitions to a new segment]

Host: Hi, my name's Al, and I have a question about the relationship between African Americans and the American flag. I've just been thinking about the Kendrick Lamar performance and really Beyoncé's country album and how both of them used the American flag or at least its colors and I'm just interested to see how that's kind of evolved or where it sits today or tomorrow and yesterday. Anyway. I've been thinking about this too.

Host: Anyone who knows me knows I'm a Beyoncé fan. By the time you hear this, I'll be recovering from her July 4th show outside DC. Beyoncé famously doesn't do many interviews, but she's intentional about every choice she makes. So a big concert on the 4th in the nation's capital isn't a coincidence. With Cowboy Carter, Beyoncé leaned into her American identity. And that was kind of surprising. It's a weird time for America right now. We have ice raids, messing with birthright citizenship and getting in wars in the Middle East again. But it's not just Beyonce with the Americana aesthetic. That's where Kyle Dennis comes in. Last year, he wrote an article about artists making use of American flag imagery. Not just Beyonce, but also the rapper Sexy Red, who released a mixtape called Make America Sexy Again.

Kyle Dennis: I think part of it is probably because we're at a point where how we define America very broadly and so widely across generations that we're in a moment of, OK, is it OK to have pride in this country knowing what it is doing across the global south, what it's doing in the Middle East, what it's doing to its own constituents back home? Is it okay to still look at this flag and look at this country and be like, I can still find pride and love for this thing and what my ancestors helped build and what, you know, I helped contribute to this country to make this a livable place that's full of diversity and full of so much goodness. Can that live alongside the bad?

Kyle Dennis: Those are questions that I think we're all consciously asking a lot more, especially having access to everybody's thoughts and opinions online. And a lot of the conversations feel a lot more tense than maybe they actually are for the general public. Okay, let's go through some of these artists. Where should we start? So Sexy Red, we can start off with her. And Sexy Beatrice was her mixtape that had, you know, the Lil Drake song on there. You My Everything. Sexy's music is very fun, very casual, very delightfully ratchet. We're just here to have a good time with Sexy Red.

Kyle Dennis: The way that I kind of interpreted her use of the American flag, and really wasn't even her use of the flag specifically, was her use of MAGA aesthetics on top of that. Because it's not just the American flag on stage during her sets during this time. She has an inflatable red cap that says, Make America Sexy Again. She's selling merch and towels and baseball caps that have Make America Sexy Again on it. And the way I kind of interpreted that was as much as there are people in this country who find a sort of freedom in how balls to the wall Trump is and how just like he can say whatever he wants to say without any, you know, regard for retaliation. He's just being him. And this is like a cult of personality that's built around being that brash and that loud.

Kyle Dennis: I think Sexy kind of sees a similarity in how her music just inspires you to be as ratchet and as rocket as all hell. And what about Queen B? Beyoncé, Beyoncé, Beyoncé. I don't even really know where to begin with Mrs. Carter. Say hey, Mrs. Carter. Because it is just, there's so much happening with Calvary Carter. And I think from the onset, I want to say I try very carefully to level out my criticisms and my critiques and my thoughts about this particular project because it is still part of and still unfurling trilogy. But generally, Cowboy Carter, when this album cover dropped, we had Beyonce sat atop a white horse waving the American flag. It is not an altered version of the flag, as a lot of previous album covers from Black artists tend to do. Whether that's turning the stars into bullet holes, making it black and white, making it pink and navy. This is just your regular red, white, and blue flag. Everything seems to be intact. Nothing's, you know, torn or tattered.

Kyle Dennis: What was interesting to me when the album cover dropped was that you don't see the entire flag. Parts of it are cropped off, the entire top half of it. Pretty much almost all the stars. You don't really get to see. You can obviously make that assumption that it's the American flag. But that's a choice, not to have the entire thing in the frame. You could have zoomed out a couple pixels and we would have gotten the whole picture. So it made me think, OK, this is intentional. So her use of the American flag, generally, I do think it's just her trying to give Black Americans a window to understand that it is OK for them to have pride and love for this country, especially if there are, you know, parts of bloodlines that they can really trace back generation upon generation to this country, this land, that the contributions of their ancestors are something to be proud of.

Kyle Dennis: I want to go back in time a little bit. Who are some modern black musicians who use the flag to, like, really say something politically? So we can go. We can start looking in the 70s. Sly and the Family Stone actually did top the Billboard 200 with There's a Riot Going On. That album cover replaced the stars of the American flag with nine point stars emblazoned across a black background instead of a blue background. The LP's title was a direct response to Marvin Gaye's What's Going On, which was released six months earlier. Brother, brother, brother There's far to be And they altered the classic look of the flag to kind of complement the album's really bleak outlook on the turbulence of the 60s and in the face of a rising Black power movement.

Kyle Dennis: So then we can go to 1990. One of my favorite rap groups, Two Live Crew, they kicked off the decade with Band in the USA. It was actually the first album in music history to have the RIAA parental advisory sticker on it. And they kind of leaned on Americana to double down on their claim to Americanness. We've got white collar people trying to grab our style saying we're too nasty and we're too live. Corrupted politicians playing games bringing us down to boost their fame They were being forced out of the label of being American both culturally and legally due to the vulgarity of their music So it was like, y'all are too nasty to be American, number one. And number two, legally we won't even allow you to release this music without a sticker because it's so un-American. And they're like, oh, bet, you know what? We band in the USA. And we're going to have Americana aesthetics all over this album to let you know that this, too, is America.

Kyle Dennis: Does utilizing the flag motif feel especially fraught right now? You know, I think of my own relationship with patriotism, and I feel like I never get like, ooh, go America until, I don't know, I see Simone Biles do something in her four years. And I think that's the case for most black people I know. Why are artists leaning in in this particular moment? We're seeing right now a conscious effort to redefine what America means, whether that's culturally or whether that's legally in terms of immigration status with them trying to take away bread-free citizenship. If we can allow the concept of Americanness to be that malleable, why not make it malleable enough that it also fits us? Why just kind of sit down and let them rewrite what being pro-America looks like? Why should we let the MAGA crew take all of the aesthetics and make it their own when we're here, too? And we're not going anywhere, and we haven't been going anywhere, especially when it's coming out of a fear of America hurtling towards becoming a country that has a minority of white people in the near future.

Kyle Dennis: We know where that kind of fear is coming from, but this is also our country. We also helped build it, so we should also be able to access those symbols and use them for whatever we want to say in our own ways. More when we're back on Explain It To Me. Support for Today Explained comes from Chime. Nobody likes fees and complicated banking, says Chime. And Chime gets that, says Chime. Chime is a financial technology company that says they understand that every dollar counts. So when you set up direct deposit through Chime, they say you get access to fee-free features, such as free overdraft coverage, getting paid up to two days early with direct deposit, so much more. Chime says with qualifying direct deposits, you can be eligible for free overdraft, up to $200 on debit card purchases and cash withdrawals. Plus, they say you don't need to worry about monthly fees or maintenance fees. You can work on your financial goals through Chime today. You can open an account in two minutes at chime.com slash explained. That's chime.com slash explained. Chime feels like progress. Chime is a financial technology company, not a bank. Banking services and debit card provided by the Bancor Bank NA or Stride Bank NA. Members FDIC. Spot me eligibility requirements and overdraft limits apply. Timing depends on submission of payment file. Fees apply at out-of-network ATMs. Bank ranking and number of ATMs according to U.S. News and World Report 2023. Chime checking account required.

[Music transitions to a new segment]

Lisa Akramolder: I'm Lisa Akramolder. I'm the director of the Betsy Ross House in Philadelphia. and today is actually my 25th anniversary with the organization. I just realized that. I started as collections manager in 2000 and I became the director eight years later. The Betsy Ross house is literally a house. It's a little townhome in Philly where visitors can interact with early American history and with Betsy Ross, who's said to have made the first American flag. I think most of us probably have this image of Betsy Ross sitting in a rocking chair by the fire, sewing this flag and then presenting it to General George Washington. Is that how it really went down? Not exactly. You're on to the right track, though. Betsy Ross was actually an upholsterer. She met her husband, John Ross, while they were both doing a seven-year-long upholstery apprenticeship. They married and they started their own business. And they were getting some pretty big jobs from important people like Ben Franklin and George Washington. So they were really on their way to a lucrative career.

Lisa Akramolder: So as the story goes, according to her family, she was working in her upholstery shop one day. And George Washington, Robert Morris, who was a financier of the American Revolution, and George Ross, which was her late husband's uncle, came through the door. And she knew they had to have been there for an important reason. They announced themselves as a committee of Congress and stated that they had been appointed to prepare a flag and asked her if she thought she could make one. to which she replied with her usual modesty and self-reliance that, quote, she did not know, but she could try. She had never made one, but if the pattern were shown to her, she had no doubt of her ability to do it. She certainly had the skills and the supplies needed to make the flag because they weren't much different from the work that she had done as an upholsterer.

Lisa Akramolder: So she did make one suggestion to change the design. She said that the six-pointed stars that were in the design should be changed to five-pointed stars. Nothing easier was her prompt reply and folding a piece of paper in the proper manner with one clip of her ready scissors. She quickly displayed to their astonished vision the five-pointed star. She showed them her trick and they were impressed with that trick and decided that that would be a good change to the design of the flag. The reason why she chose a five-pointed star rather than six was simply it was just easier to make. Keep in mind, stitching the flag for the rebel colonies would have been an act of treason. So she had to do it in secret. If caught, she could have been imprisoned or executed. She had to do it in a private place. And we believe that was done in her bedroom. After her public work was done in her upholstery shop during the day, she would retire to her bedroom and sew the flag in secrecy there.

Lisa Akramolder: Are historians in agreement that Betsy Ross is the one who made the first flag? No, they're not. And that's because there's no, quote unquote, smoking gun, so to speak, to prove that Betsy made the first flag. I'd be thrilled if we could find a journal entry or a letter from George Washington referencing his meeting with Betsy. But unfortunately, nothing like that has been discovered yet anyway. But we do know that George Washington was a previous customer of Betsy. He hired her to make bedding for Mount Vernon. Also, her husband's uncle, as I said, was a member of the flag committee that visited her. So it makes sense that he knew of his nephew's recent passing and that his widow was probably struggling. So it makes sense that he'd suggest Betsy to make the flag so she could earn some money.

Lisa Akramolder: There's also a receipt in which Betsy was paid a substantial sum of money for making flags for the Pennsylvania Navy Board. But it was a year later in 1777. We knew she went on to make flags for over 50 years. So there's a great deal of circumstantial evidence to suggest that she had something to do with the creation, but no definitive documented proof. And that's part of the reason why there's some disagreement among historians. Earlier in the show, we talked about musicians using flag iconography to send a particular message. Are there groups of people who are especially focused on this early Betsy Ross flag as a symbol of America?

Lisa Akramolder: Yeah there are people who have adopted not just early flags but many of the symbols and quotes and people of the American Revolution to represent their agenda or their beliefs Unfortunately, there are some members of the far right who have used this imagery. But now we're seeing a lot of people who identify as progressives who are using Revolutionary War iconography to represent the fight against the policies of the current administration. In fact, a woman who carried a Betsy Ross-style flag at the Philadelphia No Kings rally this past June donated it to the Betsy Ross house and told me that she and her friends dressed like Betsy Ross in George Washington as they marched, which was really great to hear.

Lisa Akramolder: Do you find that people who visit the Betsy Ross house feel an emotional connection to the flag on their visits? And if they do, where does that come from? Some people have a very emotional reaction when they come here. They almost like consider their trip to the Betsy Ross house like a pilgrimage because the American flag is so meaningful to them. But then there are also people who have a negative response to seeing the American flag. I think people who do feel positive emotions when they come here or when they see the flag, they feel pride and they see it as a symbol of hope and unity. but then some people feel anger or sadness, and they view it as a symbol of exclusion or injustice or oppression.

Lisa Akramolder: I would say that it is the most powerful and recognizable symbol of our national identity, so it makes sense that people have a strong response to it, either positive or negative. This 4th of July is yours, not mine. You may rejoice. I must mourn. So the flag can be complicated no matter your background. But what if you have to defend it when it doesn't defend you? That's next. Let's be honest. Are you happy with your job? like, really happy? The unfortunate fact is that a huge number of people can't say yes to that. Far too many of us are stuck in a job we've outgrown, or one we never wanted in the first place. But still, we stick it out. And we give reasons like, what if the next move is even worse? I've already put years into this place.

Lisa Akramolder: And maybe the most common one, isn't everyone kind of miserable at work. But there's a difference between reasons for staying and excuses for not leaving. It's time to get unstuck. It's time for Strawberry.me. They match you with a certified career coach who helps you go from where you are to where you actually want to be. Your coach helps you get clear on your goals, create a plan, build your confidence, and keeps you accountable along the way. So don't leave your career to chance. Take action and own your future with a professional coach in your corner. Go to strawberry.me slash unstuck to claim a special offer. That's strawberry.me slash unstuck.

[Music transitions to a new segment]

Host: It's Explained It to Me. We're back talking about Black Americans and the American flag. I went to college with a few posters to hang on my walls. My roommate had a Jamaican flag. Her parents were from Jamaica, mine are from the U.S. And I would always be like, that's so cool that you have a flag you can rep. I do not have that because I'm not going to big up America. But Ted Johnson does. He doesn't think America is perfect, but despite all of it, he says black people have been able to build lives here, create a culture here. We built the White house. And he's not going to abandon that just because there's bad stuff, too.

Ted Johnson: Ted is a retired U.S. Navy commander who served in Iraq and Afghanistan. And he's a patriot, even though he knows the word is loaded. He told me, yeah, the flag elicits a lot of complicated feelings for him, too. Yeah. So the flag has sort of been hijacked a little bit, I think, by by nationalists, folks that believe either America is perfect and exceptional, or at the very least, anything that it's done wrong in the past should be sort of excused by all the things that it's done well. And that is not my relationship with the flag. It's much more complicated because there has been tons of harm done under that flag. So there is no uncritical pride in the flag for me. But it is also a flag that black folks have fought under, have bled, died and sacrificed for the principles.

Ted Johnson: You know, Frederick Douglass, Martin Luther King, these folks call these principles out that the flag is supposed to represent. And I take the beauty of those moments with the same ugliness that the flag has represented. It can be both things, both things, something to be proud of and ashamed of. And so I think if you take it that way, allow it to be complicated and complex, it becomes, you know, something beautiful and worth honoring. We were talking about how to kind of tease out this relationship between Black Americans and the flag. And one way to do that is to talk about the experience of Black service members.

Ted Johnson: One of the earliest instances of this that I think sort of sets the stage for everything else that happens in the country is an enslaved man named Jehu Grant in Rhode Island during the Revolutionary War. He was enslaved. The man that owned him was a loyalist to the Brits. He was afraid that he was going to be shipped off, sold essentially to the Brits to fight for them. So he runs away, joins Washington's army, and then his master shows up and says, Army, you've got my property and I want it back. and the army turns him back over to the guy that owns him, where he serves for many years, eventually buys his freedom.

Ted Johnson: And when Jackson, Andrew Jackson, becomes president in the 1820s, 1830s, he makes a policy to provide pensions for those Revolutionary War folks still alive. And so Jehu, like a Revolutionary War veteran, applies for his pension and is denied. The government says that services rendered while a fugitive from your master are not recognized. That is the relationship of black service members to the flag. It represents a set of principles that many would be willing to die for, and also a way of life that intentionally excluded black folks for no other reason than race and status of their servitude.

Ted Johnson: And so if you look at any war, War of 1812, World War I, II, Vietnam, Korea, Desert Storm, you name it, you will find black folks in uniform who have both been oppressed in the country they represent and are willing to die for that country because of the values it stands for and because of the folks that came before them that died, blood, and sweat for their right to be able to serve and benefit from the programs that the military has made available to folks.

Ted Johnson: My grandfather served in the military and I never got the chance to really talk with him about that and that experience. But I curious if you can speak to the motivations of black Americans who continue serving especially during the Jim Crow era I mean the idea of fighting for a country that persecuting you is just so dissonant And yet a lot of Black Americans have done it. Yeah, it's super complicated. I mean, I think, you know, pre-Civil War, a lot of enslaved Black folks that decided to fight did so because they believed their chances at liberty, emancipation, freedom were connected to their willingness to serve the country. And so it was sort of like I can earn my citizenship. I can earn my equality if I'm willing to fight for the country's interests.

Ted Johnson: After the Civil War, the motivation still very much the same because of Black Codes and Jim Crow. But then we get the draft. And so a lot of the black folks that served in the early part of the 20th century were drafted into service. They weren't like, you know, eager volunteers lined up as a way of earning their citizenship or equality. But the fact that most of the large, vast majority of them, nearly all of them honored that draft notice that, you know, the sort of the commitment of citizenship, though they were treated as second class citizens, was also a sort of implicit demand for access to the full rights of the Constitution. and willing to serve in the military as a sort of collateral on that demand, as a sort of down payment on the citizenship that they're demanding, and eventually was delivered, you know, thanks to legislation and the Supreme Court and, you know, the movement of the public.

Ted Johnson: It was not, you know, because the country decided that what it had done was so wrong that it now must open the doors. Instead, these were concessions. These were gains that came at the expense of Black people's lives. and again, their work, their sweat, their commitment. And the progress is a product of Black work. But there's also something I want to say here. It's not just one way in sort of Black folks' love for the flag. You know, when Black folks were coming home from World War I and II, many were lynched in uniform. So, I mean, they weren't even excused from sort of the racial dynamics by willing to die for the country.

Ted Johnson: One of the most famous genres of music in this period was called coon music. And one of the... Oh. Yes. Literally. like the the that word right and the music was basically Jim Crow put the song to make fun of black people in there you know the desire for humanity one of the songs was about black people not having a flag They talked about white folks in the Northeast could fly flags from Italy, Ireland, wherever they're from. And white people in the States could just fly the American flag. Black people could fly none of those because we didn't know where we were from. And the United States is not ours. And so in this song, they say the black flag is basically two possums shooting dice. And that would be an accurate representation. That is like some classic racism.

Ted Johnson: I don't know. You're hitting me with the classics right now. Yeah, it was the song is called Every Race Has a Flag But the Coon. And so we are very familiar with sort of the red, black and green Pan-African flag. This was Marcus Garvey's response to this coon genre of music. Oh, we do have a flag. It's red, black and green for these reasons. And that that continues to represent. You see a lot of Juneteenth, Kwanzaa, you know, things that have the red, black and green, that sort of Pan-African black look. But what about black artists and also black people in general who just say, hey, like, yeah, our ancestors may have done all this work, but there really is no way to be a part of this slash maybe we should not be trying to be a part of this. What do those when you're having those conversations, what do they sound like? Because I know you you probably get a lot of pushback when you're having these conversations with people.

Ted Johnson: So it's like what you take pride in. You know, if you take pride in the flag because you believe America is exceptional, you're going to find a lot less subscribers to that belief system than one that if you say, you know, pride in the country means being proud of the people you come from and proud of the arc of your people's story in this country. So it is very complicated. And there's no easy way through it. But I will say that I think the reason, part of the reason we're seeing more folks willing to sort of reclaim the flag for their own is because Gen X, I'm Gen X, I was born in 75. My generation was the first one born post-Civil Rights Act of 64, really post-Voting Rights Act of 65. So Jim Crow was the experience of our parents more than of us. And millennials and Gen Z, it's the same thing.

Ted Johnson: And so those experiences connected to the sort of hijacking of the flag to connect it to explicit statutory racism feels generations removed from folks, black folks today, generics and younger, who have grown up in America where opportunity is more available, where Jim Crow kinds of racism is not as permitted. And while the country is not even close to being the kind of equal nation it says it was founded to be, it's made progress. And I think a reclamation of that flag by Beyonce and others is a sort of signal that, yes, we built it. Yes, we've progressed here. And no, we're not leaving. There's no go back to Africa. This is home. And so if this is home, I'm going to fly the flag of my country. And look, when Curry's hitting threes in the Olympics, you know, when you go overseas and get to show that American passport when you land back in the States, there's parts of this country, you know, our music culture, especially black culture, has changed the world. We've changed basketball. I mean, like, there's lots to be proud of and about what the country has achieved and black Americans in particular.

Ted Johnson: And for me, that is all the things that patriotism represents, not the more narrow, exclusive version that tends to get more daylight. That was retired Navy Commander Ted Johnson. He's an advisor at New America and a columnist for The Washington Post. This episode was produced by Victoria Chamberlin, and this is her last production with us. Thank you so much, Victoria, for your four years plus of service to this team. It was edited by our executive producer, Miranda Kennedy, fact-checking by Melissa Hirsch, and engineering by Andrea Kristinsdottir and hosted by Jonquilyn Hill. I'm your host John Glenn Hill and fingers crossed I still have a voice after this concert thank you so much for listening talk to you soon bye.

[Music fades out]

Host: Support for this show comes from Macy's. Fall is right around the corner, and that means layering season is too. Macy's Fall Fashion Guide can help you get a pulse on all the latest trends and must-haves. Try a romantic look with a sheer top from INC. Or mix it up with some fun textures, like a faux fur bomber jacket from Karl Lagerfeld Paris. No matter your vibe, you can explore the Macy's Fall Fashion Guide and find the perfect look for you. Shop in-store or online at nacy's.com.