Main Topic: The life and afterlife of shortwave radio, a tool of communication that has been used for decades to broadcast news, information, and propaganda.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Additional Insights:
Noelle King
It's Today Explained. I'm Noelle King.
Music fades out
It's an older tool of communication. The way Republicans and Democrats are shoving each other around down here in Washington, they'll all wind up on the spot by November.
Chuckles
The White House request for new controls on grain for whiskey makers is considered a political cutie.
Once upon a time, it united the world. Germany, the enemy who drove all Europe into war, has been finally overcome.
Today, it's used a lot less than it was in the past. It's a backup. Sometimes it's just plain fringe.
But when Russia made it virtually impossible for both Ukrainians and Russians to get news about the war, it found a new purpose.
Music transitions to a news clip
Host (BBC)
Several cities across Ukraine came under assault overnight.
Noelle King
On today's show, the life and afterlife of shortwave radio.
Music transitions back to the show
Support for Today Explained comes from BetterHelp.
Let me tell you a true story. Last weekend, I got an email from a listener who wanted to discuss their problems with me.
And I said, look, I don't think that this is about me personally. At least I hope it's not.
Why don't you try betterhelp.com slash explained?
Absolute truth.
As the largest online therapy provider in the world, BetterHelp can provide access to mental health professionals with a diverse variety of expertise.
Find the one with BetterHelp.
The one is not me, guys.
Our listeners get 10% off their first month at betterhelp.com slash explained.
That's betterhelp.com slash explained.
Music transitions to a commercial
Announcer (Macy's)
Layering is an art form.
All it takes is a bit of intention, style, and of course, the perfect cold weather staples.
So find the perfect look for you with the help of Macy's Fall Fashion Guide, your one-stop shop for fall's latest trends and must-haves, curated by their experts.
From leather to denim to cozy knits, find everything you need to piece together your new fall look.
Explore the Macy's Fall Guide for yourself and shop in-store or online at Macy's.com.
Music transitions back to the show
Noelle King
Professor David Stupples teaches electronic and radio engineering at City London University.
Professor David Stupples
Professor, we were struck by the fact that the BBC has decided to resume shortwave broadcasts in Russia and Ukraine.
What did you think when you heard that news?
Well, I was delighted because the BBC would normally put its broadcasts or some of its broadcast out online as you are, and that can be blocked out by Russia or turned off by Russia.
But blocking off an HF transmission, which is in the shortwave, would be more or less impossible.
A shortwave transmission is basically a transmission that would go anywhere around the world, depending on what frequency it is, because what happens is that the radio wave bounces off a part of the atmosphere called the ionosphere, and it would just skip its way around the world.
So it's a worldwide broadcast, and anyone can hear it.
Whereas the medium wave, which is a lower band, it will suffer from loss of power over long distances.
The shortwave band, from a BBC's point of view, to be able to get to all those people in Russia and, in fact, anywhere around the world.
It's a good transmission medium.
How is the information transmitted exactly?
So its name is a carrier wave, so it carries the audio or music or whatever.
And then at the other end, the receiver will take off the modulated part from the carrier and you'll be able to hear it.
As a short wave leaves its point of origin, what does it look like going out into the world?
Well, I wish I could see it, but it's an electromagnetic wave.
So it is a radio wave.
It leaves an antenna, an aerial antenna, and it's transmitted into the ether.
It is everywhere.
It's all in the atmosphere.
It isn't just a beam.
It's everywhere.
Noelle King
So it is the year of our Lord 2022, and most things are being done on the Internet.
And so I'm thinking of people in Ukraine and Russia and wondering whether this will be accessible to them.
Do they, will people need to have special radios to receive that shortwave signal?
Professor David Stupples
Many people have HF radios, and they will have them on multiband.
So they'll have medium wave, high frequency, which is the shortwave, and then VHF.
So these will be able to pick up radio stations or in any of those bands.
If people could remember what frequencies they were being transmitted on, they could certainly receive it.
And if they're being broadcast and you're receiving it, nobody would know you're listening to the BBC.
Noelle King
Is it the case that people in Ukraine and Russia have radios just because of the way life has gone in Ukraine and Russia?
Professor David Stupples
That they are less connected to the internet?
I think if people live in cities, it would be very easy to get onto the internet.
I have internet radios as well.
But I also have other types of radio, as you might well imagine I do.
And a lot of people in Russia because they may not be connected to the internet the ones in the remote districts they will probably have these radio sets as well
Noelle King
And if someone in Ukraine or Russia is tuning into that shortwave radio broadcast what will it sound like?
Professor David Stupples
Will it be clear?
Just like you and I talking now.
Really?
Clear enough, I would say.
Music transitions to a news clip
Host (BBC)
Welcome to NewsHour from the BBC World Service.
I'm James Kimarasamy.
On day five of Russia's invasion of...
Clip continues
Noelle King
That's if it's not being interfered with by the state.
Clip continues
Professor David Stupples in London.
Professor David Stupples
So you were in the Royal Air Force in the 1970s as a radio man.
What was your job exactly?
I dealt with electronic warfare, which is using radio to fight with.
Noelle King
I'm not sure if you're talking about propaganda or something a bit different.
Professor David Stupples
Well, both, actually.
Ah.
I can jam radars.
I can jam missile systems.
I can jam satellite communication systems, jam the navigation systems.
Jamming them in such a way that they can't be used.
Noelle King
But if you wanted to spy on the nation, then you would do this through radio.
Professor David Stupples
How would that work?
I would just listen to all of their broadcasts.
Noelle King
And there was no way for the Soviet Union to block you from doing that?
Professor David Stupples
No.
Because of shortwave.
Noelle King
Once the radio wave or electromagnetic wave gets in the ether, it goes everywhere.
Professor David Stupples
That comes back to our communications, because there was no internet.
How would you communicate with agents or spies, as you call them?
Noelle King
Let's be kind and call them agents.
Professor David Stupples
Because you can't go up and knock at their door and say, we've got a message for you.
What you would then have is these, and it comes back to your shortwave radios again, a shortwave radio transmitting information worldwide to agents.
Noelle King
Now if I'm transmitting to my agent somewhere in the Soviet Union or somewhere in East Germany, what I would then do is transmit the information in code.
Professor David Stupples
So after a startup piece of music, which actually tells the agent that we're on the air, we'll then send out a set of numbers which actually said this message is for agent, whatever agent number is receiving this.
That's followed by coded messages in numbers, and these numbers would then be translated by the agent using a one-time pad, which is an encryption method, and they would get a
The message might be short and say there is a message in your Dropbox, or it may be long by giving the agent some instruction.
But it's more than likely it's telling him there's a message in the Dropbox.
Noelle King
So what they would do is have a special, have a place in the, behind a tree.
Professor David Stupples
Oh!
Noelle King
If you looked at some of your spies that have been working in the United States, they used drop boxes to pick up messages and also send information back.
Professor David Stupples
And the Russians were very, during the Second World War, were using this method to communicate with Russian spies that were in the US.
Noelle King
Because of the method of communication, where the agent was located was not known,
Professor David Stupples
And they could never find that out by the communications because it was a one-way communication to the agent.
The transmitter was in somewhere.
It would transmit worldwide.
Noelle King
So therefore, the agent would be able to listen to the message.
Professor David Stupples
The authorities would never know where the agent was.
Noelle King
From what I've read about life in the Soviet Union behind the Iron Curtain, one of the big problems was misinformation, right?
Professor David Stupples
The Soviet Union not being honest with its people about what was going on.
They were receiving a lot of propaganda, a lot of propaganda coming from the top.
Noelle King
Was the BBC doing that too?
Professor David Stupples
That's precisely what the BBC World Service was doing.
Noelle King
But let's put the blame somewhere else as well, because the Voice of America did the same thing.
Professor David Stupples
Wherever you may be listening to this broadcast, remember this.
The people of the United States extend the hand of friendship to you across the seas.
Depends on what you call propaganda, but they would certainly try to tell the truth to the Soviet Union, the Soviet people at that time.
Of course, the Soviet Union was nearly all of the Eastern Bloc countries.
And so therefore they would broadcast in Russian, German, Polish, Czech and Slovakian and several of the Arab languages that are used within the Soviet Union as well.
So they would broadcast in all of those languages and they would then give news and current affairs programs and I believe try to tell the truth but I'm sure that there was a degree of propaganda on both sides.
Noelle King
So the BBC World Service, broadcasting now in shortwave, is going to be sending straight news into Russia and Ukraine.
Professor David Stupples
Can you talk about the importance of the BBC taking this decision to begin shortwave broadcasts again in Russia and Ukraine?
I think it an admirable decision
We know in Russia and probably in other parts of the world as well that they control the media, but they will also control the Internet.
And if they found that stations were broadcasting to their nation, that were giving information to their population, their people, that they didn't want the people to have, then they could certainly use the internet to block that.
With radio, they can't do that.
They could jam the radio, in other words, put a whole bunch of noise up there so you couldn't hear this on your radio.
But that's difficult to do all of the time because the human ear and the human brain is very good at picking out speech from what is noise.
People will be able to listen to that and since you can't stop waves traveling on the electromagnetic on the ether it's impossible to stop them.
You can't put a brick wall up.
They get there whatever happens.
Censorship then becomes exceedingly difficult.
Noelle King
If we want to get information to the Russian people and to the Ukrainian people from the point of view of trying to bolster their confidence, then we would do this through radio.
Professor David Stupples
It's the sure means of getting it through.
Noelle King
It sounds like reports of the death of radio are greatly exaggerated, and we're learning that now.
If I want to communicate to people in other parts of the world, especially in times of conflict as we have now, then I would do that through the shortwave, which cannot be stopped.
Professor David Stupples
Professor David Stupples in London.
Music transitions to a closing
Noelle King
Today's show was produced by Victoria Chamberlain, edited by Matthew Collette, engineered by Afim Shapiro, and fact-checked by Laura Bullard.
I'm Noelle King.
It's Today Explained.
Music fades out
Song starts playing
Singer
I'd sit alone and watch your light
My only friend through teenage nights
Is everything I had to know
I heard it on my radio
You gave them all those old time stars
Through wars and worlds
He made it by Mars
You made them land
You made them crack
You made us feel
Like we could fly
So don't become
Some background noise
But back to forth
The girls and boys
Who just don't know
Or just don't care
And just complain
When you're not there
You had your time
You had your power
You've yet to have
Your finest hour
Radio
All we hear is Radio caca
Radio cuckoo
Radio gaga
All we hear is Radio caca
Radio blah blah, radio what's new?
Radio, someone still loves you
We watch the shows
We watch the stars
On videos
For hours and hours
We hardly need
To use our ears
Our music changes
Through the years
Let's hope you'll never leave or pray
Like all good things on you we depend
So stick around, cause we might miss you
When we grow tired of all this visual
You've had your time, you've had the power
You've yet to have your finest hour
Radio
All we hear is Radio Gaga
Radio Groo Groo
Radio Gaga all we hear is Radio Gaga
Radio Groo Groo
All we hear is Radio Gaga
Radio gloop
Radio what's new
Someone still loves you