Main Topic: The future of mRNA vaccines in the United States, particularly under the leadership of Secretary of Health and Human Services Robert F. Kennedy Jr.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Sean Rameswaram
Welcome to Today Explained. I'm Sean Rameswaram here with Catherine Wu, staff writer at The Atlantic.
Catherine Wu
Thanks for having me on the show.
Sean Rameswaram
Here's my first question for you. What is the Secretary of Health and Human Services, Robert F. Kennedy Jr., doing right now with mRNA vaccines?
Catherine Wu
Probably the latest and biggest news is that he canceled half a billion dollars worth of grants to develop more mRNA vaccines.
Robert F. Kennedy Jr.
Hi, it's Robert F. Kennedy Jr. here, your HHS secretary. At HHS, we have a division called the Biomedical Advanced Research and Development Authority, or BARDA. Over the past few weeks, BARDA reviewed 22 mRNA vaccine development investments and began canceling them.
Catherine Wu
And the public is probably most familiar with mRNA vaccines in the context of COVID vaccines. Well, it's a new technology, and it is proven in a very large group of clinical trials to be safe and highly effective.
Sean Rameswaram
Remind me who was president when the COVID mRNA vaccine was developed?
Robert F. Kennedy Jr.
Ladies and gentlemen, the president of the United States, Donald J. Trump.
Catherine Wu
Also Trump, just during his first term, not this one. I'm honored to welcome doctors, scientists, industry executives, and state and local leaders to our historic Operation Warp Speed Vaccine Summit.
Sean Rameswaram
How has President Trump advanced his campaign to, like, inoculate and protect Americans with mRNA vaccines in his second term so far?
Catherine Wu
Ooh, let's see. He hasn't? So, you know, during the first term, Trump was the one who helped push forward Operation Warp Speed, that big partnership between government and pharma that got us all of these amazing COVID vaccines in record time and helped us, you know, beat back this pandemic that killed so many people in this country. and others.
Sean Rameswaram
Before Operation Warp Speed, the typical time frame for development and approval, as you know, could be infinity. And we were very, very happy that we were able to get things done at a level that nobody has ever seen before.
Catherine Wu
The gold standard vaccine has been done in less than nine months. And so far, you know, this shining beacon from Trump's first term is just kind of being systematically ripped apart.
Sean Rameswaram
We've already talked about how Trump's administration has pulled funding for development of more mRNA vaccines. You would think that, you know, we want to build on that success, not so much.
Catherine Wu
But, you know, they've also started to strip away Americans' access to COVID vaccines. They have removed or altered recommendations to get COVID vaccines in certain groups. They've made it harder for vaccine makers to get new COVID vaccines to market.
Sean Rameswaram
And, you know, a lot of the new hires and advisors to the Department of Health and Human Services are taking aim at other COVID vaccine recommendations that could restrict access even further.
Catherine Wu
I think it's very realistic that within a year or two, very, very, very few people will be able to get COVID vaccines, even when they very much want them and very much need them.
Sean Rameswaram
We were all there when the COVID vaccines came out. And the president, I believe, was like, you know, among the first to get them. I recommend taking the vaccines! I did it, it's good, taking the vaccines.
Catherine Wu
But you got, no, that's okay, that's all right. You got your freedoms, but I happened to take the vaccine. And they were touted as a miracle of medical science.
Sean Rameswaram
How is that narrative being rewritten right now?
Catherine Wu
Yeah, it's really fascinating, right? Like Trump himself used that phrase, medical miracle. And there's no reason that, at least no scientific reason, that he should have stopped believing that.
Sean Rameswaram
The data on these vaccines has not changed. They're very safe, very effective. They went through all the normal channels of vetting that get us safe, effective vaccines.
Catherine Wu
The dedicated and independent experts at the FDA meticulously studied the results of the trials. and it has now passed the gold standard of safety.
Sean Rameswaram
But right now, in his second term, Trump is leading an administration that is mostly pushing out information that these vaccines are dubious, they don't work.
Catherine Wu
HHS has determined that mRNA technology poses more risks and benefits for these respiratory viruses. Which is not true. They have saved millions of lives like studies have shown that they saved millions of lives during the pandemic. And they continue to protect people for everyone who is receiving them.
Sean Rameswaram
He said that they were the deadliest vaccine ever made. There's no evidence to support that. They have done quite the opposite.
Catherine Wu
And he's just basically cast doubt on the idea that they were studied really thoroughly and really carefully vetted by expert scientists who knew exactly what sorts of safety signals to look for.
Sean Rameswaram
These vaccines were famously brought to market very quickly. I mean, that was part of the miracle we're referring to here. That seemed to really, you know, spur a lot of these conspiracy theories about their efficacy.
Catherine Wu
Was there any validity to the argument that they were produced too quickly, that there wasn't enough testing happening?
Sean Rameswaram
I think the way you phrase your question is really important, right? Because too quickly is really about did they arrive so quickly that there wasn't adequate time to study them, make sure that they worked really well to protect against COVID, and they did so in a way that wasn't posing undue risk to the people who received them?
Catherine Wu
And I think the answer is very soundly no. It's important to acknowledge that all this was done kind of on the shoulders of all the vaccine science that came before it.
Sean Rameswaram
Scientists knew what to look for. They knew how to run these trials. They knew how to scale up their technology. And yeah, they did it in ways that were unprecedented, but not unprecedented in ways that they were like shooting in the dark when they did this.
Catherine Wu
So what happens now? You were saying that you can see a future in which even people who really want and need these vaccines won't be able to get them.
Sean Rameswaram
How far away is that future?
Catherine Wu
I think there are still enough people at federal health agencies that would fight back against that, that it could be a very dragged out fight.
Sean Rameswaram
Really stripping access to those vaccines instantaneously would also probably come under legal challenge really quickly.
Catherine Wu
But I think it's something that a lot of sectors of the administration are starting to move toward.
Sean Rameswaram
Operation Warp Speed obviously played a huge role in developing these vaccines, but it wasn't just an American effort by any means.
Catherine Wu
If the U.S. is falling off right now and sort of denying the medical miracle that was, what's the rest of the world doing?
Sean Rameswaram
And does that mean that you could fly to Canada to get your COVID vaccine or even get it delivered?
Catherine Wu
Oh, man. Black market international vaccines. What a world.
Sean Rameswaram
Yeah, it's a great question. And I think, you know, there's a couple things to touch on here.
Catherine Wu
One is that cutting off funding for mRNA vaccine development here does cut off resources for the rest of the world, right? The U.S. is extremely powerful in terms of scientific firepower, money, and also, up until very recently, foreign aid.
Sean Rameswaram
If we stop developing vaccines here, that means there are fewer resources for other countries.
Catherine Wu
There's also kind of a chilling effect that is very likely to happen.
Sean Rameswaram
If the U.S. says these vaccines are crap, they're not worth investing in, they're not worth recommending, they're not good enough for our people, other countries have traditionally taken cues from the U.S., especially around vaccines.
Catherine Wu
Other countries might look at what we're doing and pause and be like, well, we don't want to look weird. We don't want to be the outliers when the U.S. is doing this.
Sean Rameswaram
But are we the outliers right now? It feels like we're the outliers.
Catherine Wu
We totally are.
Sean Rameswaram
And I would hope that other countries look at us and then look at, you know, the U.K. and be like, OK, maybe we start following the U.K. a little bit more right now.
Catherine Wu
But it's tricky, right? Because I think in a landscape where these vaccines get more scarce and more expensive because the U.S. isn't pouring resources into developing them, those vaccines simply won't exist or might be worse than if the U.S. were pouring those resources in.
Sean Rameswaram
And the U.S. is simultaneously saying these aren't good enough. It becomes kind of an economical and almost political decision for other countries to just pause a little bit more.
Catherine Wu
You know, Donald Trump has taken to wearing a hat that says Trump was right about everything. This is a man who loves a win.
Sean Rameswaram
And he got a huge one in 2020 with the mRNA vaccine for COVID-19. Why do you think he won't take the win?
Catherine Wu
I'm not Trump. I can't fully speak for him. But I do suspect some of this goes back to what happened at the end of his term and what happened, you know, in the ensuing presidential term.
Sean Rameswaram
The end of Trump's first term was really marred by the start of the pandemic. We don't call them rallies anymore because, you know, you're not allowed to have a political rally for more than 10 people.
Catherine Wu
You're not allowed to go to church. You're not allowed to meet. You're not allowed to talk to anybody. You have to stay in a prison. Your home has become your prison.
Sean Rameswaram
He was widely criticized for letting things get as bad as they did in the U.S. in those early days.
Catherine Wu
And even though, you know, he helped push vaccines along and that was a triumph, that didn't completely overshadow, I think, all of the other policy hiccups that made 2020 and much of 2021 really horrific in this country.
Sean Rameswaram
The pandemic could have gone much better here if there had been a much better coordinated public health response, better communication.
Catherine Wu
And so I think a lot of Trump's base felt really angered by that. And they felt angered by a lot of early pandemic policies. They felt betrayed by the government.
Sean Rameswaram
And I think that has soured Trump's base on all things COVID, including vaccines.
Catherine Wu
Read Catherine Wu at TheAtlantic.com.
Sean Rameswaram
But it's not just the COVID vaccine listeners. All the other ones next on Today Explained.
Commercial break
Support for today's show comes from EcoFlow. Only one thing feels worse than when your device dies at the worst possible moment, when all your devices die at the worst possible moment.
Commercial break
Today Explained is brought to you by Fifth Third Bank's commercial payments. Fifth Third Bank's commercial payments are fast and efficient.
Commercial break
Doctors are being paid to vaccinate, not to evaluate. Today, it's claimed! I'm Lauren Weber. I'm a health and science accountability reporter for The Washington Post.
Lauren Weber
And Lauren, in the first half of the show, we talked about mRNA vaccines, COVID vaccines, and how it's looking dicey for their future in the United States.
Sean Rameswaram
But what is Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s health department doing to vaccines at large?
Lauren Weber
Well, I think it's important to understand that Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has a long history as an anti-vaccine activist for many, many years.
Sean Rameswaram
He has falsely linked vaccines to autism.
Lauren Weber
And since coming into office, he's executed many moves that public health experts say threaten access to vaccines.
Sean Rameswaram
And there's a lot of concern that he's continuing to chip away at this bedrock of public health that ensures the public safety against infectious disease.
Lauren Weber
And so this isn't just a COVID vaccine thing?
Sean Rameswaram
No, it's a lot of vaccines that he has expressed issues with over the years. The polio vaccine. The polio vaccine contained a virus called Simeon virus 40, SV40.
Lauren Weber
And now you've had this explosion of soft tissue cancers in our generation that kill many, many, many, many, many more people than polio ever did.
Sean Rameswaram
Measles vaccine. We're always going to have measles no matter what happens as the vaccine wanes very quickly.
Lauren Weber
We are seeing growing hesitancy for parents when it comes to the childhood vaccine schedule.
Sean Rameswaram
And that is something that Kennedy has also repeatedly asked questions about.
Lauren Weber
What about the kids who lost IQ? One or two points. Who are depressed. Who are not functioning. Who can't. Who are socially awkward. All of these injuries that are invisible from the vaccines.
Sean Rameswaram
His handpicked vaccine committee, the advisory committee on immunization practices, actually reiterated something that he's wanted to do for a long time, which is that they said they were going to dig into the childhood vaccination schedule.
Lauren Weber
And that's something that for years Kennedy has said, you know, he's complained about the number of shots on the schedule and raised questions about whether or not they have harmful side effects.
Sean Rameswaram
Today, children get between 69 and 92 vaccines before they're 18.
Lauren Weber
Not one of those vaccines is ever really high. Those are not all mandatory. Those are all mandatory.
Sean Rameswaram
Questions that public health experts say are not based in fact.
Lauren Weber
So does that mean there might be changes ahead for like mandatory childhood vaccines?
Sean Rameswaram
It's hard for him to make those changes. Those are often made at the state level.
Lauren Weber
But there is growing concern from public health officials and public health experts that some of what he is doing could remove access or access to vaccines or vaccine development.
Sean Rameswaram
I mean, there's also concern that he'll use the bully pulpit that is the head of HHS to continue to cast doubt on vaccines at a time that we're already seeing rising vaccine hesitancy.
Lauren Weber
It's important to remember that, you know, for some diseases, if you are, if the number of folks vaccinated is underneath a certain percentage point, then, you know, you're more likely to see disease spread within the community.
Sean Rameswaram
And depending on where you are, that could be the case.
Lauren Weber
And so there's a lot of concern that as he continues to spread doubt about the vaccines, what kind of impact that could have going forward.
Sean Rameswaram
And so you're talking about casting doubt on vaccines that maybe kids are getting, but this becoming a bigger issue for vaccines across the board.
Lauren Weber
Yes, because if you continue to see increasing hesitancy, you're going to continue to see more risk of an outbreak.
Sean Rameswaram
But on top of that, Kennedy has, he fired all the members of the advisory committee on immunization practices, which advises the CDC on vaccine safety.
Lauren Weber
We fired that board because they were, it was utterly, it was just an instrument. It was a sock puppet for the industry that it was supposed to regulate.
Sean Rameswaram
They said whether or not the CDC recommends various vaccines.
Lauren Weber
And they had a meeting in June. After all, he had fired all of these members that were highly credentialed, you know, top scientific experts and replaced them with what ended up being seven members who many experts I spoke to said just did not have the same credentials, many of whom had also expressed concern about the COVID vaccine and some falsehoods about the COVID vaccine.
Sean Rameswaram
And so there is some concern going forward that this advisory committee could alter what is the vaccine schedule as well as change how the government looks at vaccines.
Lauren Weber
We've seen for the first time the American Academy of Pediatrics, for the first time in several decades, the AAP has said that they will be putting out their own vaccine recommendations that are different than the federal government because they don't trust in what Kennedy and HHS is planning.
Sean Rameswaram
At a time when there's confusion in Washington around vaccine recommendations I want to remind you that you can look to the American Academy of Pediatrics for clarity around childhood immunizations.
Lauren Weber
Yeah, help us better understand the relationship the Department of Health and Human Services has when it comes to vaccines versus, say, the authority and power states have.
Sean Rameswaram
Because you're mentioning there that RFK doesn't actually have the power to say, hey, states, you're not going to issue those vaccines anymore.
Lauren Weber
Yeah, so vaccine mandates, many of you listening may have kids that go to school. Those are said at the state level, but the state does often take its cue from the federal recommendations, from the CDC recommendations.
Sean Rameswaram
But at the end of the day, states set their own rules.
Lauren Weber
Right now, you know, the measles vaccine is mandated in all states for children entering kindergarten, I believe.
Sean Rameswaram
And but that so that would be difficult. It's not like Kennedy with one stroke of his pen could change that.
Lauren Weber
That would have to change at a state level. If his HHS, if his CDC comes out and says, we believe, or his FDA, you know, Food and Drug Administration comes out and says, we believe that XYZ vaccine isn't safe, then that could have a cascading effect on what that looks like for other, for kids going to school.
Sean Rameswaram
So we've got RFK saying vaccines are bad generally. We've got obviously scientists strongly disagreeing.
Lauren Weber
And then we have the president sort of waffling between the two.
Sean Rameswaram
As parents, as citizens, what is the public to do to make sense of the situation we're in right now?
Lauren Weber
Well, I want to say one thing. I do think since Kennedy has gotten into office, he's been more careful than to just say vaccines are bad.
Sean Rameswaram
I mean, I've reviewed many hours of his prior remarks before becoming HHS Secretary, and he was much more upfront about saying vaccines cause autism, a false statement, than he has been since becoming HHS Secretary.
Lauren Weber
He does this thing that a lot of experts call doublespeak, where he'll sort of half-heartedly endorse a vaccine, but then talk about all of its potential side effects or say things about it that are misleading or untrue.
Sean Rameswaram
I'm not going to take people's vaccines away from them. What I'm going to do is make sure that we have good science so that people can make an informed choice.
Lauren Weber
And we are doing that science today so that we know the risks of that product and we also know what the benefits are.
Sean Rameswaram
Right now, we don't know the risks of many of these products.
Lauren Weber
If you are an average parent and you're hearing kind of this whirlwind of things about questions and vaccines and what does it mean? Is it safe? What are the risks?
Sean Rameswaram
I think it injects a lot of doubt into the average parent's mind who doesn't have time to read through all the studies or to understand exactly what's even being talked about.
Lauren Weber
And so I think that leads to what we're seeing, which is a growing distrust in government institutions, a growing distrust in vaccines and potentially a growing hesitancy that could get even worse.
Sean Rameswaram
Are we seeing that confusion play out already?
Lauren Weber
We have seen a growing number of parents opt their kindergartners out of vaccination. It's still a small number. I mean, it's a little over 3%.
Sean Rameswaram
It's not, I mean, it's not groundbreaking in the terms of it's not, the vast majority of Americans are still getting their child vaccinated, but we are seeing growing hesitancy over the last couple of years.
Lauren Weber
And many folks that I speak to, both parents who have chosen not to vaccinate and experts say we've seen a lot of reticence since COVID.
Sean Rameswaram
There's a lot of people that took their distrust of the COVID vaccination and that distrust spread to the other vaccines.
Lauren Weber
And a lot of anti-vaccine groups and activists really seized upon the COVID moment to push their message.
Sean Rameswaram
Can the next president of the United States, as long as it's, I guess, not RFK Jr., undo all of this if they so chose?
Lauren Weber
I think it's really hard to undo fear. It's really hard to undo hesitancy. It's really hard to undo the level of doubt that's been injected into this process.
Sean Rameswaram
I mean, it's very striking. I mean, look, I mean, in Trump's first term, there was also measles opportunity. And the HHS secretary then, Alex Azar, forcibly went on TV and said, please get your child vaccinated. Please stop misinformation around vaccines.
Lauren Weber
That is very different than what we have seen from this HHS secretary who, you know, has implied various things about the measles vaccination and at times questioned whether it's linked to autism.
Sean Rameswaram
I mean, this is, it's a very different world in which we live.
Lauren Weber
And while some of the actions he has done about, you know, you could change who makes up the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices. You could change who staffs the FDA and CDC. Sure, that could probably be changed.
Sean Rameswaram
But I think the number of parents who now are very confused is going to be harder to push back upon.
Lauren Weber
WashingtonPost.com is where you can read Lauren Weber.
Sean Rameswaram
Avishai Artsy and Denise Guerra produced our show today for the Yellow website.
Lauren Weber
Amina Alsadi edited.
Sean Rameswaram
Laura Bullard fact-checked.
Lauren Weber
David Tatasciore and Andrea Kristinsdottir are mixed with help from Patrick Boyd.
Sean Rameswaram
This is Today Explained. Thank you.
End of episode