Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses the controversy surrounding Congressman-elect George Santos, who was elected to the U.S. Congress in New York despite fabricating significant parts of his biography.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Noel King
Welcome to Today Explained. I'm Noel King. Today, we're talking about George Santos, the congressman-elect from New York who's been making headlines for all the wrong reasons. He's been accused of lying about his education, work history, religion, real estate holdings, charitable giving, Hawaiian vacation, and about his mom.
Sound effects: News clips
Support for this show comes from ServiceNow. AI is only as powerful as the platform it's built into. That's why it's no surprise that more than 85% of the Fortune 500 use the ServiceNow AI platform.
Sound effects: News clips
Having a night out with your friends is awesome. Dealing with hangovers sucks. Meet Senorita, the THC-infused margarita that lets you skip the booze but keep the vibe.
Sound effects: News clips
It's Today Explained. Brian Mann is a correspondent at NPR where he covers, among other things, politics in New York State. Brian's been following the story of 34-year-old George Santos, who incidentally did vote for Kevin McCarthy for Speaker. But his vote was much overshadowed by everything that preceded it, namely the revelation over the past few days that George Santos has lied about a lot of things.
Brian Mann
I've covered politics for 30 years, and I've never seen a character like George Santos. He is someone who didn't just lie about one thing. There's not a scandal that sort of focuses on one part of his biography. It really turns out he invented almost everything.
Noel King
According to George Santos's resume, who is George Santos? What has he done?
Brian Mann
Yeah, so right up to the election, people thought of this as a guy who had gone to Baruch College, graduated and then gone to a really successful career on Wall Street, working for Citigroup, working for Goldman Sachs, someone who owned valuable real estate property.
Noel King
I'm a private sector guy. I was born and raised in abject poverty in this country. And only in this country does somebody who comes from a basement apartment in Jackson Heights, like I did, is able to rise to become a successful business person to then run for United States Congress.
Brian Mann
He had this really passionate and compassionate backstory where four of his employees had died in the Pulse nightclub shooting in 2016. He spoke about that with, you know, real heartfelt kind of almost PTSD level connection to that event.
Noel King
I just want to weed out the hate out of our country and our society. There is no place for hate in the United States of America.
Brian Mann
He talked about his mother having been someone whose death was somehow linked to the 9-11 terror attacks in New York City. He's a guy who talked about having Ukrainian heritage and ancestors who escaped the Holocaust in Eastern Europe ahead of World War II.
Noel King
I'm very proud of my Jewish heritage. I'm very proud of my grandparents' story. My grandfather fleeing Ukraine, fleeing Stalin's persecution, going to Belgium, finding refuge there. Marrying my grandmother, then fleeing Hitler, going to Brazil. That's a story of perseverance. And I'm so proud.
Brian Mann
And so really an almost Zelig-like character who connected with history in all of these different and mostly successful ways. And that's the portrait of the man who got elected in November. And what does the portrait look like in real life? How much of that is true?
Noel King
Almost nothing.
Brian Mann
I mean, it's really astonishing, Noel. I mean, again, I've never seen anything like it. His family did not escape the Holocaust. It's really questionable whether he actually has Jewish heritage at all.
Noel King
He seems to be kind of a serial fabulist or fantasist who, you know, whenever anyone would ask him about some point in history, whether it was 9-11 or the Holocaust or the Pulse nightclub shooting, he would somehow attach his own history and his biography to that event.
Brian Mann
And it just it turns out much of that is untrue. According to George Santos's resume, he worked for Citigroup, he worked for Goldman Sachs, he owned valuable real estate property. That's not true.
Noel King
He never worked for Citigroup. He never worked for these prestigious Wall Street firms, didn't own any of that valuable real estate.
Brian Mann
His mother's passing in 2016 appears to have had no connection to the 9-11 terror attacks.
Noel King
When he lived in Brazil, George Santos was involved in an alleged crime where he stole someone's checkbook.
Brian Mann
The Times has come up with documentation on social media where he allegedly admitted to having done something wrong. The Brazilian government has now reopened that case.
Noel King
They essentially put that prosecution on mothballs because he vanished. He came to America and left their jurisdiction.
Brian Mann
Now that journalists have kind of connected the dots back to that incident, the Brazilian government says they are looking at this again as a possible crime.
Noel King
It just goes on and on to the point where, you know, what's left is sort of a portrait of a guy who was sort of struggling in life, couldn't pay his bills, left debts behind up until 2020, had very little income.
Brian Mann
Friends have come forward to say he often didn't pay back money that they loaned to him. Really a struggling life that he sort of, in this, again, kind of Gatsby-esque way, just sort of shed and then reinvented himself as a political candidate.
Noel King
How did we start to find out that this gentleman who'd been elected to the U.S. Congress was in fact making stuff up?
Brian Mann
Local press accounts of George Santos raised real questions about his backstory before the election. But it didn't catch fire. It didn't really get the public's attention that this guy was lying about big chunks of his biography.
Noel King
It was really later, after the election, George Santos went to this controversial gathering of Republicans in Manhattan where far-right activists and even some alleged white supremacists spoke.
Brian Mann
The journalists again began kind of looking deeper into his background. Who is this guy?
Noel King
And the New York Times, in talking to people, found more voices at Baruch College, at Citigroup, at Goldman Sachs, who said, we don't know him. He's not who he says he is.
Brian Mann
And so once that story broke, a lot of other journalists, including myself, sort of piled in to sort of see what part of his story would hold up.
Noel King
And again, I think to everyone's astonishment, wherever you looked, wherever you sort of lifted up a rock that he had said, you know, this is my story, this is who I am, you would look under that rock and find it just wasn't true.
Brian Mann
The facts just didn't bear it out.
Noel King
Has George Santos admitted to any wrongdoing? What has he said as it's come out that he's not been telling the truth?
Brian Mann
He's been remarkably confrontational. This isn't a made-up narrative, but I feel like nobody really wants to sit down and talk about it.
Noel King
Everybody just wants to push me and call me a liar.
Brian Mann
Look, a lot of what he said is that this is sort of a vendetta against him by the liberal media, an attempt to bring down kind of a new Republican voice.
Noel King
At the same time, he has acknowledged what he describes as embellishments to his resume.
Brian Mann
He said, you know, I made some mistakes. Did I embellish my resume? Yes, I did. And I'm sorry. And it shouldn't be done.
Noel King
But I'm still the same guy. I'm not a fraud. I'm not a cartoon character. I'm not some mythical creature that was invented.
Brian Mann
What he hasn't done, Noel, is bring forward any facts or documentation or, you know, people to describe his account as being truthful.
Noel King
So while he's, you know, pushed back pretty aggressively and said, yes, I'm going to serve in Congress, I'm going to serve out my first full term, he hasn't done much to actually prove that he is anything like the politician he presented himself as to voters.
Brian Mann
The politician, but also the person.
Sound effects: News clips
Noel King
And this is where it gets very confusing because I think there's a knee-jerk reaction, which is to say, ah, all politicians lie.
Brian Mann
But what's interesting in this case is it's not that he's lying about his policies. It's not that he's lying about, you know, no new taxes. He's actually lying about who he is.
Noel King
And so at the end of the day, what do we know for certain about who this man is?
Brian Mann
I think what's really amazing here is he's lying about things, not only about who he is, Noel, but also about things that are really important to people in New York.
Noel King
You know, 9-11 is sacred ground in New York, of course, all over the country, but in New York in particular, the Holocaust. This is not something in New York City, Long Island. It's not something you toy with or lie about.
Brian Mann
And so he crossed lines in describing his personal narrative.
Noel King
The Jewish community has reacted with real fury and real disgust at this behavior, as you can imagine.
Brian Mann
And what we're left with when you peel all of that away is, you know, so far, and this is an evolving portrait of a man with a largely, you know, unsuccessful career, a man who struggled again and again to develop some kind of success.
Noel King
According to friends and lovers and others who knew him along the way, a man who fell into the habit in his personal life of deceiving people, of telling invented stories about himself.
Brian Mann
And that habit appears to have just kind of carried over into his political life.
Noel King
I will say that while a lot of this digging has happened and we've had a lot of big revelations about him, there are still some big mysteries.
Brian Mann
You know, this is a guy who appeared really quite poor until 2020. And then all of a sudden in 2021, he starts describing in federal campaign documents millions of dollars in revenue and assets through a company that he operated, some of which about $700,000 he then donated to his own campaign.
Noel King
And that sort of made sense a little bit when we thought that this was a guy who'd worked for Goldman Sachs and a guy who'd worked for Citi.
Brian Mann
But now that this was a guy who worked in a call center and this was a guy who lived with his family and couldn't pay his rent, suddenly it's like, you know, where the hell did that money come from?
Noel King
And I think that's one of the big mysteries going forward. Who is he and where did his money come from?
Sound effects: News clips
Coming up on Today Explained, shunning, scolding. What might the Republican Party do to George Santos?
Sound effects: News clips
Support for today's show comes from Adio. What is Adio?
Brian Mann
Adio is an AI-native customer relationship management system built specifically for the next era of companies.
Noel King
They say it's extremely powerful, adapts to your unique data structures and scales with any business model.
Brian Mann
According to Adio, Adio takes less than a minute to set up, and within seconds you will have your email and calendars synced.
Noel King
You'll see all your relationships in a fully-fledged platform, they say, all enriched with that actionable data.
Brian Mann
And they say you can build AI-powered automations and use its research agent to tackle some of your most complex processes to seize so that you can focus on what matters, building your company.
Noel King
You can join industry leaders such as Flatfile, Replicate, Modal, and so much more.
Brian Mann
You can go to adio.com slash todayexplained to get 15% off your first year.
Noel King
That's A-T-T-I-O dot com slash todayexplained.
Sound effects: News clips
This message is brought to you by Apple Card. Each Apple product like the iPhone is thoughtfully designed by skilled designers.
Brian Mann
The Titanium Apple Card is no different. It's laser-etched, has no numbers, and it earns you daily cash on everything you buy, including 3% back on everything at Apple.
Noel King
Apply for Apple Card on your iPhone in minutes. Subject to credit approval, Apple Card is issued by Goldman Sachs Bank USA, Salt Lake City branch.
Brian Mann
Terms and more at AppleCard.com.
Sound effects: News clips
Noel King
It's Today Explained. We're back with NPR's Brian Mann. George Santos won a congressional seat in New York State. What's notable about the district that elected him?
Brian Mann
George Santos was elected in a Long Island congressional district that you would describe as purple.
Noel King
This is a battleground district, one of the few battleground districts left in New York and left it really in the country.
Brian Mann
And he was part of a really bright spot for Republicans.
Noel King
Republican George Santos also flipped New York's third congressional district, defeating Democrat Robert Zimmerman.
Brian Mann
That was a big race. A lot of people did not see that coming.
Noel King
New York congressman-elect George Santos joins us right now to talk more about it.
George Santos
Congratulations. Thank you so much. This is a big deal.
Noel King
You'll remember in the midterms, this was a tough year for the GOP. They fell way short of their expectations.
Brian Mann
But in New York State, they did really well. They campaigned largely on crime. Their narrative was that there was this big rise in violent and dangerous criminal behavior that the Democrats were to blame.
Noel King
And George Santos leaned hard into that narrative, again, with the support of a lot of other Republican operatives and top-tier politicians.
George Santos
You don't like the police? Don't call them. But over here in Long Island, we love the police and we back the blue.
Noel King
And in the end, he won handily. He turned out to be pretty darn good on the campaign trail.
Brian Mann
All of this sort of burnished his brand and it led to him being one of those really standout victories.
Noel King
Of course, that's heavily tarnished at this point, but he was part of a red wave here.
George Santos
I think it's shocking to people.
Noel King
You know, we at NPR have spoken to people on Long Island who are baffled. How can this be?
Brian Mann
I just think it's such crap. Like, teachers have to, like, present so much information in order to, like, get their license.
Noel King
And this guy is just going to lie and still be able to go into Congress. I think it's stupid.
Brian Mann
They talk about the fact that, you know, to get a job as a school teacher or as a cop or really almost anything, you have to go through pretty serious vetting and you have to kind of prove you are who you say you are.
Noel King
And the fact that it turns out that very little of that actually happens for someone running for one of the most powerful, prestigious offices in the country, I think that's shocking to everybody.
Brian Mann
And we've heard a lot of outrage and disappointment.
Noel King
And I think we also are learning again that we kind of live in a new age of American politics where the parties can't necessarily be trusted to kick the tires on their own candidates.
Brian Mann
And we don't know anymore that conventions and traditions and I hate to say it, but things like honor and honesty mean very much.
Noel King
You know, there was probably a time in American politics where lying this pervasively would have caused a political party to close ranks against a newly elected official, where something this egregious involving the Holocaust involving 9-11, it would have triggered a real backlash within a party.
Brian Mann
And that just hasn't happened with Republicans this time around.
Noel King
You know, they look very likely to ultimately embrace George Santos, to work with George Santos.
Brian Mann
We'll see what kind of committee assignments he gets.
Noel King
And so, yeah, it's shocking that he got elected without much tire kicking.
Brian Mann
And it's shocking that right now, at least, there are not mechanisms that exclude him from holding that power.
Noel King
And that is in part because all of the lies that George Santos has told to this point might be interesting, might be worth digging in on, but nobody's proved that he's done anything illegal.
Brian Mann
Is that part of it? Is it that he didn't do anything criminal that we know of?
Noel King
You know, it turns out that the constitutional rules for who gets to serve in Congress are really minimal.
Brian Mann
It's not even entirely clear to me after speaking with a bunch of experts that criminal behavior would disqualify him from serving in Congress.
Noel King
Congress is a world governed more by politics and tradition than by law.
Brian Mann
And so obviously it will matter if it does emerge that there's clear evidence of criminal wrongdoing by George Santos.
Noel King
He says he's done nothing criminally wrong.
Brian Mann
But as you say, lying is certainly not a disqualifier, even on this scale.
Noel King
There is one of the things that I think we're all still getting used to in the Trumpian era is waking up to the fact that our democracy worked by convention and tradition rather than by really clear rules and laws.
Brian Mann
And so, yeah, it turns out that there just aren't really safeguards to a guy like this other than the voters.
Noel King
You know, they'll obviously, if he runs again, they'll get a crack at this guy in 2024.
Brian Mann
But in the meantime, you know, unless something dramatic happens, he appears very likely to serve out a full term.
Noel King
You allude to this interesting if. If George Santos did something illegal, he is being investigated. Who is investigating him and what for?
Brian Mann
So far, NPR has confirmed that there is a U.S. attorney team looking at his financial dealings and his background.
Noel King
There is also a prosecutor, and it's noteworthy that it's a Republican prosecutor in a district attorney in Nassau County on Long Island who's looking into his lies and deceptions.
Brian Mann
It's likely that if there's evidence of other misdeeds in other jurisdictions that more people will come in.
Noel King
Of course, the Brazilian government has said that they're looking into it.
Brian Mann
And it really appears likely that this will focus on the money.
Noel King
A lot of politicians would be in trouble if you couldn't lie about anything.
Brian Mann
It is more problematic if you lie on a federal campaign form, if you deceive the government about where your money is coming from, those things could be much more problematic.
Noel King
And so not only prosecutors, but also I think a lot of journalists right now are really on that money trail trying to figure out what happened there and did it amount to criminal behavior.
Brian Mann
I wonder if you have any insight into why the Republican Party isn't pushing for some disciplinary action.
Noel King
What is their calculus?
Brian Mann
If the people in his district who voted for him are angry why doesn't the Republican Party nationally say George, you're going to have to pay for this man?
Noel King
I think what we're hearing from Republicans is a narrative that George Santos is going to have to rebuild trust as if this were a conventional scandal of some kind.
Brian Mann
We're a country of second chances. And when people are willing to turn their life around and own up to this, then do what it takes to earn respect and trust again.
Noel King
You know, we're willing to do that.
Brian Mann
So I'm hopeful, you know, he chooses the right path.
Noel King
There may well be a House Ethics Committee probe and we'll see what they decide to do as a punishment.
Brian Mann
It could be a scolding on the House floor, some kind of wrist slapping. He could be denied committee assignments that he wants.
Noel King
So there are things short of excluding him from office that they could do.
Brian Mann
At the end of the day, though, Noel, what's really important here is power.
Noel King
And the Republicans hold a razor-thin majority in the House.
Brian Mann
The House leadership is incredibly fragile under the Republicans.
Noel King
And George Santos, for all that he is, you know, now carrying sandbags full of scandal, he's also a crucial vote and will be a crucial vote almost every day.
Brian Mann
I mean, they have so few Republicans to spare right now that just people being out sick or people traveling, you know, those kinds of just normal day-to-day things could really make it hard for them to govern and to pass bills.
Noel King
And so, you know, as much as George Santos right now is politically damaged goods, he's also valuable goods.
Brian Mann
He is super crucial to their future.
Noel King
And so their ability to really punish him is very limited if they also hope to use his power.
Brian Mann
Where has Kevin McCarthy come down in all of this?
Noel King
One of the things that was really fascinating is that after the election, Kevin McCarthy gave a speech that, you know, was circulated online where he trumpeted the fact that the Jewish members of Congress from the Republican Party were more numerous than ever before in history.
Brian Mann
That they were really proud that they had this big group of Jewish lawmakers on the GOP side of the aisle.
Noel King
And he included George Santos in that list.
Brian Mann
Now that it turns out that George Santos is not Jewish, he's Roman Catholic, maybe has some Jewish heritage, although again, that's in question, Kevin McCarthy has been silent.
Noel King
And other top Republicans who've been instrumental in getting Santos elected, they've gone silent.
Brian Mann
Elise Stefanik, this very influential New York State House member, she's a top leader in the GOP now.
Noel King
She really leaned in hard to get Santos elected, helped him raise money, appeared with him.
Brian Mann
She's gone silent about all of this.
Noel King
And that's been a pattern. A lot of times when Republicans have been confronted by these really top-tier scandals, they've just faded back and they've tried to kind of write it out.
Brian Mann
And so we'll see where the House GOP leadership ultimately lands with Santos.
Noel King
But so far, they seem very likely to welcome him into the ranks.
Brian Mann
Without asking you to predict too much, what do you think is going to happen next?
Noel King
What are you looking to cover yourself?
Brian Mann
I think the money is the most fascinating thing here.
Noel King
You know, where did George Santos's money come from?
Brian Mann
I really think we'll learn a lot more about that in the weeks ahead, and that could be his Achilles heel.
Noel King
I think that there is also going to be an interesting story to play out here about how American democracy adapts to characters like George Santos.
Brian Mann
You know, in this populist era, we're seeing more people come forward running for incredibly high office who have no history, no policy background, no track record.
Noel King
They are blank slates in terms of policy.
Brian Mann
And up until now, I think journalists and even political actors, you know, have been lazy about vetting these people and saying, OK, this is a whole new world.
Noel King
You know, there was a time, you know, I'm 57. And for most of my career, if somebody was running for Congress, you kind of knew who they were.
Brian Mann
They'd been around, you know, they were known faces and maybe they had some scandals in their past, but they were known scandals.
Noel King
Now, I think we're going to see more and more of these people who pop up out of the Tea Party movement or the MAGA movement or, you know, as the party structures fray.
Brian Mann
And I think that's one of the things that I'm really going to be doing a lot more of is just basic, you know, who are these people?
Noel King
Did they really go to school where they say they went to school?
Brian Mann
Are there businesses that they claim success with? Were they real?
Noel King
And I hate to say that we're entering another stage of cynicism or skepticism.
Brian Mann
But I think the George Santos story proves that that's necessary and warranted.
Noel King
Today's episode was produced by Amanda Llewellyn.
Amanda Llewellyn
Thanks for listening to Today Explained.
Noel King
It was edited by Amina El-Sadi, and it was engineered by Paul Robert Mouncey.
Amina El-Sadi
Thanks for listening.
Noel King
It was fact-checked by Serena Solon.
Serena Solon
Thanks for listening.
Noel King
I'm Noelle King. It's Today Explained.
Theme music fades in