Main Topic: The Trump administration's decision to bury a report on the links between alcohol and cancer, commissioned by the Biden administration in 2022.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Sean Rameswaram
Let's talk about some of the things that Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has done as the Secretary of Health and Human Services.
Discussion begins
Mass layoffs at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. We are the sickest country in the world. That's why we have to fire people at the CDC.
Music fades out
He canceled $500 million in federal funding for mRNA vaccine development. These kids that are just overburdened with mitochondrial challenges, with inflammation. You can tell from their faces.
Music continues
And he might be getting petrochemicals out of your food. 40% of the food industry in this country has taken the pledge to remove food dyes from all of their foods. You've probably heard about all of those things.
Music fades out
But on Today Explained from Vox, we're going to talk about one thing you maybe haven't heard of. It's something he didn't do. A report he didn't publish. A report he buried.
Music continues
A dedicated career coach in your corner. Go to strawberry.me slash unstuck to claim a special offer.
Music fades out
Some days call for working up a sweat, working on your passion, and endless action. Ditch the glitch with Liquid IV's new energy multiplier, sugar-free. Refreshing flavors like strawberry kiwi and blackberry lemonade.
Music continues
Scientifically formulated to support physical energy, hydration, focus, mood, and social stamina. Liquid IV's new energy multiplier, sugar-free, hydrating energy.
Music fades out
Today Explained, Sean Rameswaram. I'm here with Dylan Scott, my colleague, who's a senior correspondent at Vox covering healthcare.
Dylan Scott
Thanks for having me on the show.
Sean Rameswaram
Tell us a story. This story happens in three parts. There's a study that gets commissioned. There's a fierce lobbying campaign against that study. And then there is the ultimate decision not to publish the study in its final form.
Dylan Scott
So let's go back to the first part. Back in 2022, the Biden administration decided they wanted to commission a special report on alcohol and its health consequences.
Sean Rameswaram
You know, there's been a lot of conversation for years now about whether any amount of drinking is safe or good for you.
Dylan Scott
And the Biden administration is like, we should just really dive into this and we'll produce a report that will serve two purposes. It will be submitted to Congress as part of a report that goes to Congress every year about underage drinking, and then it'll be submitted to the health department and the USDA to be considered for the 2025 dietary guidelines.
Sean Rameswaram
That gets started. And almost immediately, there's a pretty big backlash from the alcohol industry and their allies in Congress.
Dylan Scott
A public relations campaign gets underway, on Capitol Hill especially. You've got the alcohol industry circulating documents about the co-authors of this health report saying, like, they're biased, they're secret prohibitionists, and they find a pretty receptive audience in Congress.
Sean Rameswaram
What is it with liberals that want to control every damn aspect of your life?
Dylan Scott
I'm proud to represent the Commonwealth of Kentucky, home to the $9 billion Kentucky bourbon distillery industry. Wine has played a positive role in society and culture for 8,000 years.
Sean Rameswaram
They want us to drink two beers a week. Frankly, they can kiss my ass.
Dylan Scott
And Congress actually goes so far as to commission a second study from the National Academies of Science, Medicine and Engineering.
Sean Rameswaram
You know, they even subpoena the administration to try to get more information about the process that led to the study being commissioned.
Dylan Scott
It's just a general cloud of like there's something wrong with this alcohol intake and health study that the Biden administration commissioned in 2022.
Sean Rameswaram
Then on January 15th, 2025, we finally see a draft version of the report, which is basically the usual routine for reports like this.
Dylan Scott
Authors put together a draft, they post it for the public to see, people can comment, they can critique it, and then the authors take all that feedback and produce a final version of the report.
Sean Rameswaram
And so this kind of brings us to the third part of the story, the suppression of the report.
Dylan Scott
So they published it for public comment in January, they work on their revisions, and in March of 2025, the authors submit the final version of their report to the Trump administration.
Sean Rameswaram
And after that, nothing happens. We never see the report. It is never published in its final form.
Dylan Scott
And the co-authors for a long time just have no idea what's going on. It's radio silence from the administration until last month.
Sean Rameswaram
And then last month, they were told, the administration does not have any intention of publishing a final version of this report.
Dylan Scott
They're not going to include it in the congressional report on underage drinking, for which it was always originally supposed to be for.
Sean Rameswaram
And they're just not going to publish it at all.
Dylan Scott
After we reported on this information, the Trump administration told us that the report had been shared with HHS and the USDA to be considered for the dietary guidelines.
Sean Rameswaram
Okay so we have a lot to clarify here maybe starting with the fact that there are two reports one initiated by the Biden administration and one initiated by Congress
Dylan Scott
We do have these kind of dueling reports. We got the alcohol intake and health study which is what the Biden administration commissioned in 2022.
Sean Rameswaram
And we've got the National Academies report, which is what Congress approved in late 2022.
Dylan Scott
And so, I mean, they have some methodological differences, but what's really striking is how different their findings are.
Sean Rameswaram
We're going to turn now to a new report that finds even moderate alcohol drinking can have an adverse impact on your health.
Dylan Scott
But they also found that drinking a moderate amount of alcohol actually lowers your risk of dying.
Sean Rameswaram
So there's like a not dying benefit compared to not drinking at all.
Dylan Scott
Huh. So the alcohol intake and health report showed that at one drink per day for a man.
Sean Rameswaram
So if you just have one glass of beer at the end of the day, you have about a 1 in 1,000 chance of dying in your lifetime from an alcohol-related cause.
Dylan Scott
Which is like, you know, 1 in 1,000, maybe I'll take my chances.
Sean Rameswaram
But if you increase that to two drinks per day, and I think it's worth emphasizing that that is the currently recommended limit under the dietary guidelines that currently exist,
Dylan Scott
Your chances of dying from an alcohol-related cause increase to 1 in 25.
Sean Rameswaram
So that's a pretty dramatic difference and a pretty dramatic increase in your health risk, even within the currently recommended limits on alcohol consumption.
Dylan Scott
On the other hand, we've got this National Academies report, which came to very different conclusions.
Sean Rameswaram
It actually reported that maybe some moderate drinking could have some modest health benefits, could actually be maybe good for your cardiovascular system.
Dylan Scott
And they actually found that the association with cancer is pretty weak.
Sean Rameswaram
So these are two very different stories about what alcohol does to your body and the risks that it poses.
Dylan Scott
And one of them, the National Academies report, was published on time, no questions asked.
Sean Rameswaram
But the first report is never going to be published in its final form.
Dylan Scott
Trump famously doesn't drink.
Sean Rameswaram
I can honestly say I never had a beer in my life, okay?
Dylan Scott
RFK is a famously recovering addict.
Sean Rameswaram
I became an heroin addict when I was 15.
Dylan Scott
Who is obsessed with toxins and the corrupting influence of powerful lobbies.
Sean Rameswaram
Why would these two guys, if they indeed did conspire to bury this report, conspire to bury this report?
Dylan Scott
It's a good question.
Sean Rameswaram
And I have tussled with that question quite a lot.
Dylan Scott
And really, since the Make America Healthy Again movement, you know, kind of came into being, you know, alongside RFK's presidential campaign last year,
Sean Rameswaram
Alcohol has always been kind of a weird issue for them.
Dylan Scott
It's not something that like the Maha groups are super outspoken about.
Sean Rameswaram
It is not, despite Kennedy himself, as you say, being in recovery, something that he talks about very much.
Dylan Scott
And I mean, we can only kind of guess about what their motives might be.
Sean Rameswaram
But I do think it's, you know, when you remember that there is a very powerful industry with a lot of money at its disposal,
Dylan Scott
That has a lot of pull in Congress.
Sean Rameswaram
Some of the members of Congress who've been most outspoken about this are people representing districts in Kentucky, where, you know, bourbon and whiskey is a popular cultural export.
Dylan Scott
Lawmakers from Napa Valley in California with all of its wineries.
Sean Rameswaram
According to Reuters, the alcohol industry has spent millions of dollars lobbying Congress,
Dylan Scott
And now the U.S. government is expected to revise its guidelines as early as this month, moving away from recommending that consumers limit their alcohol intake.
Sean Rameswaram
And any new label would require approval from Congress, which could be an uphill battle.
Dylan Scott
The beverage industry spends tens of millions of dollars every year lobbying Congress, Mary.
Sean Rameswaram
So this may just be like a bear that Trump and RFK Jr. just didn't want to poke.
Dylan Scott
I don't get that, Dylan. Like this administration picks so many fights.
Sean Rameswaram
And the public, I think, is generally aware that drinking is unhealthy.
Dylan Scott
I mean, back in 2023, we covered a similar study that had a very different outcome in Canada, where the Canadian government, after seeing a study that linked alcohol to cancer,
Sean Rameswaram
Told Canadians that any amount of drinking is unhealthy.
Dylan Scott
Like, this is in the water.
Sean Rameswaram
Why not just let the people have the study that they paid for?
Dylan Scott
So here's the other thing that I think, the even more meta context that I think is important here, which is COVID and the pandemic and the general just war that is currently underway right now between RFK Jr., Maha, the Trump administration in general,
Sean Rameswaram
MAGA as an entire political movement, and the public health establishment,
Dylan Scott
The people whom the first group blames for the mistakes of the pandemic and vice versa.
Sean Rameswaram
These two sides are still hashing it out.
Dylan Scott
They hate each other.
Sean Rameswaram
I mean, we've seen for the past few weeks the turmoil at the CDC between their new political leadership and the longtime staffers who are more part of that old public health consensus.
Dylan Scott
Like, why am I going to team up with all these public health experts who are dragging me about vaccines and the mistakes I made during the pandemic and all kinds of other things to help them get their message out about alcohol?
Sean Rameswaram
And that's what links this alcohol story that you wrote about for Vox to the greater phenomena that is RFK, Maha, and public health in America right now.
Dylan Scott
Yes. I think what's also telling is this is just another example of Maha and the Trump administration's actual policies and actions not lining up.
Sean Rameswaram
You know, I wrote another story a couple of weeks ago about how even though Maha is outraged about things like pesticides,
Dylan Scott
The EPA is over here deregulating them and deregulating microplastics and PFAS, these other things that Maha is worried about.
Sean Rameswaram
This is, I think, another example.
Dylan Scott
This alcohol study is another example of how when corporate interests and public health interests seem to be at odds at least within the Trump administration it seems like corporate interests tend to win out at least a lot of the time.
Sean Rameswaram
And I think that is what we have seen with the administration decision not to publish this alcohol health report.
Dylan Scott
Dylan Scott, if you want to read his scoop about this buried alcohol report, you can find it at Vox.com.
Sean Rameswaram
If you want to hear more about the links between alcohol and cancer, Dylan also appeared on the Unexplainable program this week to talk about that.
When we were back on Today Explained, we're going to ask a guy who's worked in and around public health for decades what he makes of the job RFK has been doing so far as the head of health and human services here in the United States.
Music fades out
Support for Today Explained comes from SelectQuote.
Music continues
When was the last time you reviewed your life insurance policy?
Music fades out
You've never done it. You've never done it. I know you've never done it.
Music continues
If it's been a while or if you've never done it, SelectQuote says you might be overpaying or not properly covered for changing costs of living.
SelectQuote says they can help.
Music fades out
For over 40 years, SelectQuote has been one of the most trusted brokers in the insurance business.
According to SelectQuote, they say they've helped more than 2 million Americans secure over $700 billion, billion with a B, in coverage.
In as little as 15 minutes, they'll compare policies from top-rated carriers to find the best fit for your health and your budget.
SelectQuote says SelectQuote has partners with policies that are designed for many pre-existing health conditions as well.
Get the right term life insurance for you for less and save more than 50% at selectquote.com slash explain.
Save more than 50% on term life insurance at selectquote.com slash explain today to get started.
That's selectquote.com slash explained.
Music fades out
Support for this show today comes from Delete Me.
Music continues
If you want to freak yourself out, Google recent data breaches.
And if you don't want to freak yourself out, maybe don't do that.
Delete Me says they make it easy, quick, and safe to remove your personal data online at a time when surveillance and data breaches are common enough to make everyone vulnerable.
Claire White, what say you?
Claire White
I signed up for Delete Me about a year ago.
Sean Rameswaram
At the beginning, they combed through a ton of websites that had my information on them, like phone number or email address or even my home address.
Claire White
Since having it for a year. I still receive the monthly privacy reports, but I can tell that there's just a lot less sites that they have to pull from, which I know means that it's continuing to work and it makes me feel really safe.
Sean Rameswaram
You can take control of your data and keep your private life private by signing up for Delete Me now at a special discount for our listeners.
You can get 20% off your Delete Me plan when you go to joindeliteme.com slash today and use the promo code today at checkout.
The only way to get 20% off is to go to joindeliteme.com slash today and enter the code today at checkout.
That's joinedeliteme.com slash today, code today.
Music fades out
Ezekiel Emanuel is an oncologist and a medical ethicist who works at the University of Pennsylvania.
He worked on public health for the Obama administration.
Ezekiel Emanuel
One of the things I'm most proud of is that we did the food plate. We pushed a lot of nutrition work and revisions.
Sean Rameswaram
I worked on global health and trying to emphasize investments in public health infrastructure overseas.
Ezekiel Emanuel
But he also worked with the Trump administration.
Sean Rameswaram
In 2016, 2017, I did some work with him.
Ezekiel Emanuel
I tried to actually get him to really focus on prescription drug prices because I thought that was something he was passionate about and might do something about.
Sean Rameswaram
Early in COVID, I worked with him for about two months trying to get the COVID response up and running.
Ezekiel Emanuel
When it comes to the country's health, he's all for bipartisanship.
Sean Rameswaram
Working for whoever's president, as long as they're doing good by the country, is really important.
Ezekiel Emanuel
But with that said, he thinks Robert F. Kennedy is a disaster.
Sean Rameswaram
Yeah, I do not think he's qualified in any shape or form.
Ezekiel Emanuel
He has been against vaccines, and that is very bad.
Sean Rameswaram
Probably the single biggest benefit to people in the 20th century in terms of total lives saved from 1974 to today.
Ezekiel Emanuel
Those are huge achievements, and now we're trying to roll them back.
Sean Rameswaram
The thing about Kennedy that I actually supported is his emphasis on nutrition, his emphasis on chronic diseases and trying to address them.
Ezekiel Emanuel
The problem is so far, I mean, the big success we've gotten is dyes.
Sean Rameswaram
We're going to get rid of the dyes and then one by one we're going to get rid of every ingredient and additive in school and in food that we can legally address.
Ezekiel Emanuel
That's not going to really save any lives.
Sean Rameswaram
Addressing the whole food chain and nutrition subsidies that we have in this country, those haven't been addressed.
Ezekiel Emanuel
And those are the, you really want to address chronic disease in America, that is a critical step.
Sean Rameswaram
And yet I don't see him really leaning into it.
Ezekiel Emanuel
And yes, it's a challenge, but it's really important.
Sean Rameswaram
I'm glad you brought up chronic disease in America.
Ezekiel Emanuel
Last week at a Senate hearing, Robert F. Kennedy Jr. defended all of his shakeups at the CDC by saying, We are the sickest country in the world.
Sean Rameswaram
That's why we have to fire people at the CDC.
Ezekiel Emanuel
They did not do their job. This was their job to keep us healthy.
Sean Rameswaram
Are we the sickest country in the world?
Ezekiel Emanuel
I don't think we are.
Sean Rameswaram
Well, I wouldn't say the sickest country in the world.
Ezekiel Emanuel
But in terms of high-income countries, we aren't doing that well.
Sean Rameswaram
And we've fallen off the growth curve, as they say, in terms of increase in life expectancy, decrease in the number of disability-adjusted life years, health span actually getting shorter.
Ezekiel Emanuel
And that's been happening since roughly 1980.
Sean Rameswaram
And there are lots of hypotheses about that.
Ezekiel Emanuel
I'll give you two that I think really are important.
Sean Rameswaram
You have to remember and most people won Richard Nixon Secretary of Agriculture Earl Butz
Ezekiel Emanuel
Nobody ever became a Secretary of Agriculture to went to a popularity contest.
Sean Rameswaram
Butts really leaned into the production of industrial commodity crops with heavy subsidies for corn, soybean, rice, wheat.
Ezekiel Emanuel
That, again, made the components of ultra-processed foods cheap.
Sean Rameswaram
And it cut down, by the way, in small family farms, really promoted big industrial farms that he often said, you know, get bigger, get out of farming.
Ezekiel Emanuel
So that was one element.
Sean Rameswaram
The other element, really timed with Ronald Reagan taking over, was a cutback in the social safety net.
Ezekiel Emanuel
Housing, food stamps, and other social safety net programs.
Sean Rameswaram
Welfare is a narcotic, a subtle destroyer of the human spirit.
Ezekiel Emanuel
That combination, spending more to get cheaper components for ultra-processed foods and reducing the social safety net, I think are probably two of the biggest components in terms of the obesity epidemic we've had that have really fueled chronic diseases.
Sean Rameswaram
You see this in the increase in diabetes, increase in lots of illnesses.
Ezekiel Emanuel
I think if we really want to get a health care system, we have to focus on those two elements.
Sean Rameswaram
I mean, Robert, if Kennedy is trying to focus on the CDC specifically, he thinks they've fallen gravely short.
Ezekiel Emanuel
Do you think there's lots of areas of improvement at the CDC?
Sean Rameswaram
Yes, I do think we can improve the CDC.
Ezekiel Emanuel
But let's be honest, if you're going to improve the CDC, the first place to start is not cutting its workforce, cutting its budget by billions of dollars,
Sean Rameswaram
Eliminating programs like the National Center for Chronic Disease Prevention and Health Promotion,
Ezekiel Emanuel
The National Center for Environmental Health, our ability to forecast and monitor adverse health outcomes,
Sean Rameswaram
The Public Health Preparedness and Response Center, the Global Health Center.
Ezekiel Emanuel
So the idea that we need to cut in order to actually improve, I think, is false.
Sean Rameswaram
What do you think the effects are thus far of RFK's actions at CDC in public health more broadly?
Ezekiel Emanuel
Well, you know what?
Sean Rameswaram
Here's the thing about public health. Public health, you invest today for the benefits tomorrow.
Ezekiel Emanuel
So it will take a while to actually see in terms of real harms, but we're already seeing real harms in several ways.
Sean Rameswaram
The first way is clearly the measles outbreak in Texas, two kids dead, lots of hospitalizations.
Ezekiel Emanuel
It's not just Texas now, it's spread across parts of the country.
Sean Rameswaram
You're getting increasing vaccine skepticism and parents who are uncertain, don't study the issue, just are trying to, you know, make their lives go and can't really study these various issues.
Ezekiel Emanuel
And when you get fewer and fewer people vaccinated, you are going to get disease outbreaks, whether today, tomorrow, or in a long time, we can't exactly predict.
Sean Rameswaram
I also think, you know, chronic diseases are a big problem, which RFK Jr. clearly agrees with,
Ezekiel Emanuel
Cutting back on our chronic disease programs, you know, our prevention programs, our response programs, our health promotion programs, that's not a good idea.
Sean Rameswaram
Maybe we need to do them differently, but cutting is certainly not in the cards for all those chronic diseases.
Ezekiel Emanuel
If you want to control healthcare costs, you got to address chronic disease better and cutting back the CDC's role is not better.
Sean Rameswaram
You know, we've been talking about chronic disease and vaccines.
Ezekiel Emanuel
In the first half of the show, we talked to our colleague Dylan Scott about how RFK and the Trump administration buried a study about alcohol's links to cancer.
Sean Rameswaram
And there's no clear explanation for why they'd not want this information to be in the hands of the public.
Ezekiel Emanuel
Where do you think people, everyday Americans, should be turning to for health information if they feel like they can't trust the government anymore?
Sean Rameswaram
And I guess that applies to the people who were skeptical to begin with and all the people who are skeptical now.
Ezekiel Emanuel
The problem with undermining the CDC is you undermine a single source of information, objective really, where the goal is public health.
Sean Rameswaram
Now, it's going to put more burden on people to get their information from a variety of sources.
Ezekiel Emanuel
You know, on vaccines, maybe my good friend Mike Ulsterholm's project on vaccine integrity,
Sean Rameswaram
Or I think it's called the Vaccine Integrity Project if you want to look it up online.
Ezekiel Emanuel
In other areas, like alcohol, you'll have to look at the old Surgeon General's report and try to get a copy of that that reported on alcohol's problems, especially related to cancer, but not exclusively.
Sean Rameswaram
There are global, you know, alcohol is a global issue, so there are a lot of global resources available, whether England or Australia or the Cochrane Collaborative.
Ezekiel Emanuel
But that requires a lot more effort.
Sean Rameswaram
And that's one of the problems is everyone's short on time, right?
Ezekiel Emanuel
And spending a lot of time running around and looking for individual programs rather than being able to go to one site and readily access an objective answer is a major, major problem.
Sean Rameswaram
And that, I think, is part of the plan for this administration is make it very difficult to get this kind of information.
Ezekiel Emanuel
And it's working. Unfortunately.
Sean Rameswaram
Secretly.
Ezekiel Emanuel
His friends call him Zeke.
Sean Rameswaram
Rebecca Ibarra made this episode of Today Explained.
Amina Alsadi
Edited.
Sean Rameswaram
Laura Bullard, Fact Check.
Amina Alsadi
Adrian Lilly, and Patrick Boyd mixed.
Sean Rameswaram
Welcome back Patrick.
Patrick Boyd
Thanks for having me back.