Main Topic: The Taliban's restrictions on women's rights in Afghanistan and the pushback from Afghans, including men, against these restrictions.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Noelle King
When the Taliban took over in Afghanistan late in the summer of 2021, the world had a question for them. Would they preserve the rights that women had spent two decades fighting for, and in a lot of cases winning? Pressed on this question, Taliban leaders said yes, they would. The state policy is that we will give every right to the female members of our society that comprise half the population, their right to work, their right to education, and every single other right that has been afforded to them in Islam.
Pause
But within weeks, they banned almost all girls from going to high school. They told women to stay at home. Travel was no longer allowed. Women were banned from appearing on TV dramas or traveling more than 45-ish miles from home without a male chaperone. And then late last year, another huge blow. One that has the potential to affect not just women, but everyone in Afghanistan who relies on humanitarian aid.
Pause
That's coming up on Today Explained. Support for Today Explained comes from BetterHelp. Let me tell you a true story. Last weekend, I got an email from a listener who wanted to discuss their problems with me. And I said, look, I don't think that this is about me personally. At least I hope it's not. Why don't you try BetterHelp.com slash Explained. Absolute truth. As the largest online therapy provider in the world, BetterHelp can provide access to mental health professionals with a diverse variety of expertise. Find the one with BetterHelp. The one is not me, guys. Our listeners get 10% off their first month at BetterHelp.com. That's BetterHelp.com.
Pause
Having a night out with your friends is awesome. Dealing with hangovers sucks. Meet Senorita, the THC-infused margarita that lets you skip the booze, but keep the vibe. Made with real fruit, organic agave, and Himalayan pink salt, every sip is like a mini getaway. No fillers, no hangovers, just full flavor and a better buzz. Find your flavor at senoritadrinks.com. Use code VOX20 for 20% off. Must be 21 and over. This product may cause intoxication. This product has not been evaluated or approved by the FDA. This product may contain up to 0.3% THC.
Pause
It's Today Explained, I'm Noelle King. After all of those restrictions, late last year, the Taliban issued more decrees limiting women's rights and freedoms. One of them banned women from attending university altogether after first restricting what subjects they could major in. And one decreed that women cannot work for the nongovernmental organizations or NGOs that are providing aid to millions of Afghans.
Pause
According to Taliban's justification, there are jobs that women are not fit for them. And they started from women's employment in security and defense sector, of course. Hosna Jalil was Afghanistan's deputy minister of women's affairs and deputy minister for interior affairs. And as you might guess, she thinks these restrictions on work are ridiculous because for 20 odd years, Afghan women did many types of jobs.
Pause
Hosna Jalil
We did have women in police forces. We did have women in the army. We did have women in the intelligence services and we had civilian women who have been working throughout the institutions in terms of service delivery to the forces. And then we had 28 percent of the civilian civil servants in Afghanistan's government. So they are banned from all those, I would say, opportunities.
Pause
But then they reached a point where they signed the decree and issued the decree to ban women from showing up in their workplace at the international NGOs and local NGOs. Any such group that continues to employ women will lose its license, according to the Economic Ministry.
Pause
In response, four of the largest international NGOs, upon which the country depends for aid, decided to suspend operations entirely. Next phase was to ban women from higher education. So their access to education, their access to employment, and of course access to justice, that was the first thing we lost. and even access to humanitarian aid.
Pause
With most of their decrees, that is heavily affected and negatively affected. The only decree they haven't issued yet is to dictate how to breathe or should they breathe or not. The Taliban are Afghan. They are Afghan citizens. And Hosna says that's indicative of the fact that Afghans themselves are divided on women's rights.
Pause
But some Afghans have started to push back against these restrictions, including, crucially, men. First, the students, they didn't attend their final exams. Students quickly showed their opposition to the new law, both men and women, including at Nangaha University in the city of Jalalabad. Male medical students there even walked out of their final exams to support their female classmates.
Pause
And for them, they had the slogan of either all or none. And then the university professors, tens of them, resigned from their positions. They're not going to teach at universities. I'm a professor. Today I've brought my teaching diplomas and my doctorate. From today, I don't need these diplomas anymore because this country is no place for an education. If my sister and mother can't study, then I don't accept this as an education. I will tear this up.
Pause
And then, of course, women have always been on the street, and then men joined them. It was a bright spot because we have never had men taking the initiative to stand for women's rights in the past. And so loud and being beaten by the Taliban.
Pause
Noelle King
What are you hearing that you're finding it hard to get out of your mind When you talk to people in Afghanistan and you hear how they're responding to women effectively being cut out of society, what sorts of things do friends tell you, family tell you, young people tell you?
Pause
Hosna Jalil
First of all, the Afghans, they are so new to most of these civic movements or protesting or expressing themselves on the street, but at the same time, who they are dealing with, like the Taliban. Is that the right way to express themselves or to react? Or there's a better way to react through the system or to work through different factions of the Taliban? Maybe there's someone in the Taliban who disagrees with it. And let's build on that, which is, of course, another complicated situation.
Pause
So that's the first reaction. Like, what should we do so that we can get a reverse in that policy or that decree? But then at the same time they hopeful for the next three months because it their winter break In Afghanistan we have the three months winter break So for them because the decrees issued at the end of the fall semester if the reaction is strong enough then we do have the chance to reverse the decree or the policy
Pause
If a young woman chose to go into university anyway, what would she be risking? If she said, I'm not going to pay attention to this. I want to go to school. I'm going to school. What would likely happen?
Pause
Based on what the Taliban have done since the last one and a half years, to my friends, to my ex-colleagues, to my very close, I mean, women who are really close to me emotionally, what they have done to them, they will not be allowed from the doors to enter the university campus. If they would resist, of course, they would be arrested. They would be detained. They will be raped. And if they would raise their voices or they express themselves, they will be killed brutally.
Pause
Noelle King
The Taliban have banned women from working for NGOs. And as a result of that, as a way of pushing back, some of those organizations have said, we won't operate in Afghanistan. Do you think that is the right decision given what's at stake here, which is that millions of Afghans are dependent on those organizations for food and for basic services?
Pause
Hosna Jalil
I think as painful as it sounds to support the decision of the international NGOs, I do support that decision. Wow. I mean, since the very first day. The reason is because first, how is that possible to serve women without engaging women? Plus, the last 20 years I've witnessed and I've worked with most of these women that women have been the voice and leading the initiatives to make sure that women are having access to those resources.
Pause
The resources available through international NGOs are the aid. The vulnerable groups, the marginalized groups, and the children, and those are the main victims of the situation, right? The humanitarian crisis. If the Taliban are banning women from working for those international NGOs to deliver humanitarian assistance, it basically means that international NGOs are allowed to serve only men and boys in Afghanistan. And if it's not for all, it should be for none.
Pause
But at the same time, I also think that if the pain is shared, then there will be a collective voice. If men go through the same thing, then they should also stand for women. If aid organizations stop providing services to both men and women, the men will eventually have to say something.
Pause
Noelle King
Do you have family in Afghanistan that depend on these NGOs?
Pause
Hosna Jalil
I do.
Pause
Noelle King
You do. And you still believe that what it's going to take is everybody essentially needs to take this hit so that the men will stand up.
Pause
Hosna Jalil
In Afghanistan, women has never had anything equal to men. Never. For the international NGOs, most of the funding for these international NGOs are coming from democratic countries. And from people who believe in democracy, who believe in gender equality, How can they justify serving only men in Afghanistan? I mean, it's just putting my feet in their shoes. How can they justify spending that money only on men in Afghanistan? It just affects their core value. It affects the reason why they are in Afghanistan.
Pause
Noelle King
You were in Afghanistan at a time in which women achieved extraordinary gains. Is there any hope of going back to the way it was when you were in government? Or do you think Afghanistan is essentially going to be stuck for many years in the way that it was in the 1990s?
Pause
Hosna Jalil
The first option that the women would start from where we lived in August 2021, that's not possible. But when it comes to would Afghanistan be stuck where it was in the 1990s, I would say no. The Taliban are, of course, the same. I've never thought that the Taliban has ever changed. But Afghanistan has definitely changed. I was a child under the previous Taliban regime, and the entire nation was silent because they had gone through civil war. And that was worse than the Taliban regime. And then they had the Taliban regime. So there has been more than a decade where they didn't have any sort of stability.
So the people have been pretty much silent and things had been normalized. the level of violence, the level of, I would say, brutal treatment of the Taliban, their policies. They had somehow been normalized for people. But now it's different. You see men and women both together are reacting to the Taliban's decrees and they're pushing them back. But at the same time, they're connected to the world. They can see what's happening outside the world. Back then, Afghanistan was entirely locked. But Afghanistan and the people, they have changed. And the generation is a different generation. So there will be certain pushbacks.
The Taliban has to open up at some point in time. But we can't go back where we were in 2021 in terms of the progress we had.
Pause
Noelle King
Coming up, not all of the Taliban are hardliners. A look at what it might take to get moderates in a position to make decisions.
Pause
It's Today Explained. I'm Noelle King. Can you just tell me your name and what you do?
Pause
Hassan Abbas
Hassan Abbas. I am a professor at National Defense University in Washington, D.C. and I teach courses on politics, history, and culture in South Asia and Middle East.
Pause
Noelle King
Professor Abbas has also written a forthcoming book called The Return of the Taliban. And he says the Taliban right now are divided between hardliners in the city of Kandahar and more moderates in the capital, Kabul. It is the hardliners outside of the capital who are winning, even if, he says, they don't quite know what they are winning.
Pause
Hassan Abbas
I think Taliban are themselves at this point not very clear on what their strategy is. They are going through a very complicated and difficult transition from being an insurgent group and a terrorist group to a group which is now responsible for running the government There are so many different groups in Taliban For instance, there are some who are more religious-oriented, clerical who had spent all their lives in seminaries, teaching religious doctrine and there are others who were fighters, who were military commanders who was fighting on the ground. And then there are a third group, for instance, which are all criminals involved in drug smuggling. And then there's a fourth group of the young people for whom there was no other opportunity but to be employed by Taliban in the areas where Taliban were strong.
Pause
So at this moment, there's an internal struggle between these groups. The hardliners want a very dogmatic extremist worldview. those who are interacting with the US and other international organizations in Doha, they want a relatively open society, not open or liberal in a sense that we think in the West, but somewhat what can be seen as a decent society.
Pause
The reason I said there is no clear strategy is because at this moment they're all struggling internally to see who becomes dominant. Can we assume that the hardliners within the Taliban are winning? That is tragically true. At this moment, Mullah Hebatullah Hunzada, who is the supreme leader, so to say, who sits in Kandahar, interestingly, not in the capital city. He took over the group's leadership when his predecessor, Akhtar Mansour, was killed in a U.S. drone strike. He has authority over the Taliban's political, religious and military affairs and is from one of the most powerful Pashtun clans
Pause
And this is more like following the Iran model, if I call that where there's a supreme leader and then there are others who are in Kabul who are cabinet ministers, who have more exposure but at this moment, the clerical hardliners and the extremists, who are very retrogressive, I should say have a dominant role
Pause
Noelle King
Professor Abbas, why do the hardliners have the upper hand? How did that evolve over the last year or so?
Pause
Hassan Abbas
The expectation was that the relatively moderate elements or pragmatic elements, that they will have an upper hand and they will form the government. However, I think it was the former Afghan president, Ashraf Ghani, who disrupted the whole plan. The shock has come that he has actually left the country altogether and is now in Tajikistan. Ashraf Ghani, the day he fled, he disrupted the whole possibility of an interim government arrangement.
Pause
So it does beg the question, where is this transition agreement up to? Is there a transition agreement for negotiators in Doha to agree to, to consider? So it really adds to the uncertainty as we get into this Sunday evening here in Kabul. If there was an interim arrangement through negotiations between Taliban and U.S. and the Afghan government, then there would have been a relatively smooth transition in a sense that the interim government surely would have representatives from Ashraf Ghani's government, other civil society elements and Taliban.
Pause
But the way things turned out when Ashraf Ghani along with Oz's colleagues fled, all these well-known political leaders, we used to call them warlords and very, very powerful ethnic groups with the militant groups as well. They all fled, some to Pakistan, some to Turkey, some to Doha. There was not even a single fire shot, even in anger in Kabul. It was very strange. So a road was and the pathway was laid out for the hardliners among the Taliban who just came in and said, look, everyone ran away with relatively moderate elements. They got kind of sidelined because the hardliners said, this is all about our victory, our worldview.
Pause
The fact is that a trillion dollar that we spend, all the security forces that were built with support from the United States primarily, but NATO and other countries, people have a legitimate question to ask. Where are all those people? Why they never put up any resistance to Taliban? So about what's happening to women in Afghanistan, what all the other terrible things, atrocities are happening. It's not only Taliban who and hardliners in Taliban who I would blame. I would actually blame also those who were supposed to fight and take a stand for that. And they are nowhere to be seen also.
Pause
Historically, one of the problems in Afghanistan has been this tug of war between hardliners and more moderates. And we see what happens when the hardliners win, as they have in this case. What would it take for more moderates within the Taliban to be the ones making the decisions?
Pause
I think one of the very important factors at play here is international engagement, because one of the major disputes between Kandahar, the hardliners, and the moderate elements is that the hardliners want a total control. They think they need no support and help from anywhere else. Whereas the moderate elements argue that we have now inherited a different Afghanistan. There's a new banking system at play. There are imports and exports. The Afghans, even the Taliban need international revenues to buy things from the international market. The moderate elements are saying we need to continue to engage with the West. And some regional countries are doing that. China is continuously engaged. Uzbekistan, for example, is still providing free electricity.
Pause
So the moderate elements are arguing, we need electricity, which is a new power generation system We need our if not 5G at least 3G so that our telephones and mobile phones will work And the hardliners perhaps are not I read somewhere actually in one of the interviews I came to know that Mullah Haibatullah the leader in Kandahar even has no cell phone. So that doesn't matter to him. But for the cabinet members and other officials, other bureaucrats, security senior officials in police and military, they all need to be connected, they know that they can stay connected with the world. Their mobile phones can work and their electricity can work only if there is some international recognition, even if it's not diplomatic recognition at this point, but some engagement.
Pause
So that engagement, if that continues to happen, is going to empower the moderate elements. That's my theory. And I wonder about the flip side of that, right? So you say engagement could empower moderate elements of the Taliban. That makes a lot of sense. But should those same countries that have some leverage in Afghanistan say to the hardliners in the Taliban, we're not going to give you electricity if you don't let women back into society? Should there be a more aggressive quid pro quo?
Pause
100 percent. Absolutely. I think Qatar has a huge leverage there. UAE, Turkey, these three countries are currently competing for big contracts of security of the Kabul airport. Many other actually power generation projects as well. These three countries together, along with Pakistan also, because they have a huge connection and role to play in Afghanistan. Uzbekistan, I was recently in Uzbekistan. And I asked this question to some of the people because many of the government officials and think tankers and academics were very critical of their own government's policy to be very engaged with Taliban. And I asked them, so why are you engaging? There were various reasons. But one was that, look, we don't want that the extremist elements in Afghanistan to succeed because that will start having an impact on our society as well.
Pause
So Uzbekistan, Tajikistan, the two countries which are providing them electricity and gas, can actually say that, OK, we can switch it off as well. But that requires a coordinated, cohesive regional strategy. But the challenge is that all these regional countries are competing with each other with financial trade interests in Afghanistan. They are not talking to each other. And they don't want to be seen as an extension of at this moment of the U.S. policy. Because the U.S. policy got discredited in the region for a variety of reasons, rightly or wrongly.
Pause
There's no leader at this moment also who's calling the shots. But what I'm not clear on is what is the leverage that the United States actually has here? We still have their money, their Afghan reserves, that $3.5 billion. More than half of the country's 40 million people face acute hunger. The U.S. president has signed an order to redistribute the funds and keep them out of the Taliban's hands. They desperately need that money. There's another leverage also, which is about security. The Taliban have been demanding and asking for security support to fight ISK and Daesh.
Pause
Blood covers the walls and ceilings of this mosque in Kandahar, the aftermath of a deadly suicide bombing. More than three dozen people were killed in the explosions and scores more were injured. The so-called Islamic State Group has said it was behind the attack. The Taliban consider IS their enemy and have vowed to hunch down the perpetrators and bring them to justice under Islamic law.
Pause
I find myself, unfortunately, feeling very, very pessimistic, if only because of what has happened in Afghanistan over the last couple of decades. And if only because it seems like women at the moment just do not have a seat at the table. Is there any part of this that makes you optimistic?
Pause
Pessimism is no answer, is no policy answer. Pessimism takes us in a totally different direction. So I am optimistic for two or three primary reasons. Even if Taliban have not changed in their ideological sense, Afghanistan has changed. The tens of billions of dollars in investment in building new institutions in Afghanistan, I think they will show an impact at some point. On social media, every day we are hearing from local Afghans who are getting us these small clips. This is Afghan diaspora, which is very active as well. This is new. They all want a different Afghanistan. It is not that the Taliban's hardliner extremist views are being implemented without being challenged. If Taliban are going to continue with these atrocities against women and other minorities, the regional countries ultimately are going to push back strong as well.
Pause
Noelle King
Professor Hassan Abbas, his forthcoming book is The Return of the Taliban, Afghanistan After the Americans Left. And earlier we talked to Hosna Jaleel. She's a former official in the Afghan government. Today's show was produced by Victoria Chamberlain, edited by Matthew Collette, engineered by Paul Robert Mounsey, and fact-checked by Laura Buller. I'm Noelle King. It's Today Explained. Thank you.
Pause
make standout content with Adobe Express. Brand kits make following design rules a breeze, and Adobe quality templates make it easy to create pro-looking flyers, social posts, presentations, and more. You don't have to be a designer to edit campaigns, resize ads, and translate content. Anyone can in a click. And collaboration tools put feedback right where you need it. See how you can turn your team into a content machine with Adobe Express, the quick and easy app to create on-brand content. Learn more at adobe.com slash express slash business.
Pause
ways you use money into a single product that feels extraordinary to use. Visit mercury.com to join over 200,000 entrepreneurs who use Mercury to do more for their business. Mercury, banking that does more.