Podcast Episode Summary
The podcast episode features an interview with Todd Tams, the founder of Mod Advisor, a technology company that provides a platform for independent insurance agents to offer advisory services to their clients. The main topic of the conversation is the importance of being a true value provider as an independent agent and how Mod Advisor is changing the game for what independent insurance agents can do from an advisory role.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Recommendations:
Became a Master of the Close: https://masteroftheclose.com
In this episode of The Ryan Hanley Show, Todd Thams, founder of Mod Advisor, Direct Work Comp, and President of Thams Agency, joins the podcast to break down how Mod Advisor is helping independent insurance agents deliver maximum value to their insurance clients.
Don't miss this episode...
Episode Highlights:
Key Quotes:
Resources Mentioned:
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episodes You Might Enjoy:
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Host
In a crude laboratory in the basement of his home. Hello, everyone, and welcome back to the show. Today, we have Todd Tams on the podcast for an absolutely tremendous conversation on all things independent insurance, talking about being a true value provider as an independent agent, what that means, and how the technology company that Todd has launched, Mod Advisor, is changing the game for what independent insurance agents can do from an advisory role, from a value-added role beyond just advising and placement of insurance. But how do we become even more? How do we do more for our clients? And Mod Advisor is the tool that is helping independent agents take on this challenge of needing to add additional value. I mean, guys, there's going to come a day when simply selling an insurance policy just isn't enough. I mean, it's barely enough today. And tools like Mod Advisor are helping you be true value providers for your clients.
Excited to have Todd on the show because, one, I just love Todd and love his mindset and the way he thinks about things. I also always enjoy, similar to a couple episodes when we talked to Zach Mefford, you can go back and listen to that one, when independent insurance agents become technologists. I feel like these types of projects are very interesting. Sometimes they're misguided, but sometimes, and particularly in the case of Zip Bonds for Zach Mefford and Mod Advisor for Todd Tams, are just tremendous projects that are so dialed in to what independent insurance agents need, the way they work, the way they think. They're perfect fits for our ecosystem, and they're the exact type of tools that I love to share with you guys.
Before we get there, want to give a quick shout out to today's sponsor, and that is Podium. P-O-D-I-U-M dot com. Go to podium.com. Podium to turn your chat messages into text messages and get near 100% response rates from your leads. You got the best way to do that, really the only way to do that, is to use text message, and Podium, P-O-D-I-U-M dot com, is the tool to get that done.
All right, with that, we're going to get on to Todd Tams. Dude, dude, what's going on?
Todd Tams
Not too much, man. What's up? Just drove back from Des Moines today, had a couple meetings, hanging out with you. You got lots of stuff going on, it looks like.
Host
Lots of stuff. Yeah, I just also just got back from one of the longest haircuts of my life. Usually takes about 20 minutes to get my do chopped. The woman who normally cuts my hair, she's in Florida. I got a couple of things going on this weekend, so I was like, hey, I got to get freshened up. Who do I go to? So she referred me to this guy. He was one of those old school barbers who just wants to literally cut every hair individually. It's great, he did a great job. Happy. He's super nice. We're wrapping Yankees, wrapping, you know, whatever. It's all good. But I'm like, my God, this is an endeavor. This is like a major commitment to come over here and get your haircut.
Todd Tams
How long does it take to cut your hair?
Host
It's like 12 minutes. I mean, my girl takes 20 minutes. Usually takes a half hour because we bullshit a lot. I've known her for like my whole life and she's funny. But it could easily be 15, 20 minutes tops. This was a 47 minute haircut. So I'm flying home going, oh my God, I'm now going to be late for our call because of this haircut. But I did a quick rush though.
Todd Tams
Talk to me. I see Rogue Risk got acquired by SIA. Talk to me about that.
Host
Yeah. Just another step in the ladder to world domination. Long story short was, I took a look at our growth curve and basically the math was it would be five to seven years, that range, before we got to execute on what the mission and the vision for this agency has been. From a customer facing side, it was the whole idea of a human optimized agency to better serve our customer base. From an internal side, it was this concept of no ceiling insurance career for the people that work here. I don't want your last name to determine how far you can go in this business, at least. Those two goals, one external, one internal, I think they run parallel to each other.
When I took a look at how long it would take to get them there on our own, it's five to seven years. In my opinion, that window of opportunity would close in that time period for us, for this opportunity that I think we have today. So that's why in August and September, I started taking VC meetings. I did 57 total VC meetings and got a hard no from every single one, mostly because we don't create proprietary software today. That was pretty much unilaterally the reason. I said, wait a minute, you should be happy that I'm not building proprietary software. I run on such a low budget relative to our peers in the digital space that allows me to hire people and implement our process incredibly much faster, which we can put back into marketing and branding and grow. They don't give a shit. All they cared about was if you're a service business, it's X EBITDA, whatever percentage. And if you're a tech business, it's X revenue this. That's all they cared about, which I get it. That's their business. That's fine. But it was a hard no.
So going through that, I bumped into Masiello at an Arizona SIA event, because he had just purchased out his dad with the leadership team, the P company, to recalibrate SIA. He was doing his rounds to talk about the new vision and direction. I was there doing a keynote that got bumped from 2020 when COVID hit. We started rapping and having a couple of beers and solving all the insurance industry's problems. He explained that they had a gap in their ecosystem. I said, what if you didn't have a gap? He said, what do you mean? I said, everything you just described is Rogue. I mean, we're early, but that's what we're doing. So we had a few more conversations and it started to make sense. I got to know them a little bit. This has been seven months in the making really. I got a really good feel for them, for what I think they're trying to do, who they are, where we fit. I figured I can get to where I want to be in five to seven months versus five to seven years. That math just made too much sense. So that was the deal.
Todd Tams
Well, very cool for you. Congrats.
Host
Yeah, I mean, I gotta make good on all the bullshit I pitched them. But it's cool. I still own a part of Rogue. I'm still very invested in the company. This is not like they buy me and in two years I'm looking for a new job. That's not really the way I'm going into it, at least. Obviously life changes, but...
Todd Tams
I had a demo with one of your employees, Brendan Malackey. Let me see, when was I at the Better Agency Conference? It's not the Better Agency Conference anymore, it's the Agency Success Conference. Scott Stevens, you had Scott Stevens from Rogue?
Host
Oh yeah, yeah, yeah. It wasn't at the Better Agency Conference. You guys did a Zoom call.
Todd Tams
Yes, we did a Zoom call. You might have been on it.
Host
Yeah, yeah, yeah, it was Scott. He liked it.
Todd Tams
He said he felt really bad. The first like 20 minutes all his technology was broken. He said he thought he didn't look that great on the call because he couldn't get anything to work. We finally got connected though. But no, he said he really liked the tool. I think once we get through a lot of transition shit that we're going through, I think we're going to end up signing up with you guys for sure. Him, Scott and Will on my team, they're workers comp, middle market prospecting all day long. That's what they do. So he goes, "I don't like to do computers. I don't want to do this stuff. Can you do it for me?" I said, absolutely not. I said, we made it pretty easy. Let me show you how easy it is. I think he finally got it by the end of the call.
Host
All of that is true. He does not love computers, but he is very good on the phone. That's all you need.
Todd Tams
Computers and phone, yeah. He's one of those guys who if you talk to him, you would not be impressed from a sales perspective. You wouldn't be like, "Oh, this guy's a sales killer." But he somehow has this ability. I've listened to his calls and been on calls with him. He has this ability to make people feel very comfortable talking to him very quickly. He's got a military background, he's got some different stuff, and he can kind of relate to a lot of people. All of a sudden, people just start telling him everything. That's a very unique and good skill for a salesperson. So yeah, he's an interesting cat.
Very cool. What's going on with you, man? I see Mod Advisor all over the place. I'm so happy for you. It's awesome.
Host
Thank you. Thank you. It's been a fun ride and continues to be a fun ride.
Todd Tams
BrokerTech Ventures, right? Did I see that?
Host
Yep.
Todd Tams
How's that going?
Host
How's it going for you? So we're two weeks out of BrokerTech Ventures right now. Made a lot of great connections there. From what I understand, the way the format works, for the two days we were there, it's back to back to back meetings, networking events, all this stuff. Out of that, each respective agency partner goes back to their organization, discusses who they want to work with. We're getting some emails coming through right now, but I think next week it'll be pretty much formal as to who wants to help partner and accelerate our growth.
Todd Tams
That's great. I did one of those things with University of Wisconsin, Madison. They had an incubator event like that, kind of sponsored or put on by American Family. I did the thing, did that whole thing. No one wanted to work with us. They were like, "We're sorry, but no one sponsored you." I was like, "The American Family..."
Host
They're out and about. We just got back from the Global Insurance Symposium. They had a tech night. I bet there was 30 or 40 tech startups there. I remember talking to somebody from American Family. They were just there checking out all the insurtechs.
Todd Tams
Their operation is crazy. I was talking to somebody the other day, I think it might have been for the podcast, that I think we as an industry forget because they're not their main brand, they're like the 300th largest company in the country. Not just an insurance company, but they're one of the top 500 companies in the whole country in terms of their total portfolio and all the sub brands and stuff underneath them. They're enormous. We all just kind of pass them off as if they're not really a big deal. I think a lot of people do.
Host
Well, you're telling me something I didn't know.
Todd Tams
Oh, yeah.
Host
Well, I thought you'd know that being that's your part of the world. West of where I am. All you people know each other out there, don't you?
I'm just not paying attention to size of companies, I guess. It's a small world. It's a very small world. So what's got you excited, man? What's going on? I know you're plowing through with all the stuff with Mod Advisor, which is awesome. It's great to see the brand getting out there more and more. I want to learn more about Mod Advisor for the show. I know you were on before, but just in general, what's on your coconut? What's exciting? Is it just your head's down and you not seeing anything else, or is there anything that got you kind of on fire a little bit?
I'm certainly fired up about Mod Advisor and all the fun things we're going to be doing. The beginning of 2022 has been absolutely crazy, peaking with getting selected into BrokerTech Ventures. There's nowhere else where, if you spent the last two years calling the 30 largest insurance brokerages in the country and said, "Hey, I want to talk to you and pitch you an idea," you wouldn't get in the room with the people that were in the rooms at these meetings. They're so committed to building on the technology, but really improving the experiences and the value ads that they have for their clients. Apparently we fit one of those molds. A lot of great conversations came out of that conference. I'm excited to see who we're going to work with in the future. The direction that they want to see things is going to be huge and very interesting. I can't go into all of that right now, but where we're going to be at next year versus today is going to be amazing.
Todd Tams
How do you like being a tech founder?
Host
I love it. I know that's a short answer to a long question. I love building tech. I love the struggles. If you look back over my life, I think I'm a builder. It's not necessarily a tech founder, but I'm a builder. We build things. I think you build things too. My first job was in the restaurant industry. We built that up, won a bunch of awards, came back to our third generation family business, built that up, grew a book, and then started into what do I really like to do? I really like work comp and how can I build upon that? I'm not so much interested in having the day-to-day conversation about what med pay limits should I have on my auto insurance. Let's talk about work comp, let's educate, let's help agents nationwide. We've got users from the one person shop to the top 20 brokerages in the country right now. They all want to improve on that experience. They want to help convey ways to reduce costs, ways to improve risk management. I love having those conversations because we're building something that actually is going to make a difference in people's lives. That gets me excited every morning.
Todd Tams
Is there any part of it that you don't love?
Host
What do I not love? Lately, the travel schedule. You've been there, done that. There's a conference every single week you can go to and you don't know which ones you should miss and which ones you shouldn't miss. We've got a couple more coming up and then I'm intentionally taking the summer off because I need to wrap my head around our focus. I need to put some ideas on paper and get our roadmap for the next 12 to 24 months under wraps.
Todd Tams
How does leading a tech company differ from leading an agency? For a lot of the people who listen to the show, they've never started a tech company. They're only familiar with the agency business. What are some of the nuances, maybe some are obvious, maybe some aren't?
Host
If your question is how does running our third generation family business, Thams Agency, differ from an insurtech, the clientele and the expectations. We're located in rural Iowa. People walk in our door. They pick up the phone and call. They're not tech savvy people. They're good salt of the earth people. They want to meet in person, meet face to face, and they want to walk in and have you solve their problems. On the tech side of things, people are completely okay just sending an email. You get back to them the next day, doing things over Zoom. We cast a much larger footprint than we do with our brick and mortar operation.
Todd Tams
Do you see any advantages in the local face-to-face handshake that are lost in the digital or the virtual transaction or in the tech transaction in general?
Host
Personally, I'm a networker. I love to meet people face to face. You and I meet face to face, we have a good time, we talk in person. It's great to talk to you on Zoom, but it's just not the same.
Todd Tams
It is not the same, no. I thoroughly enjoyed the conversation that we had.
Host
Well, now I'm going to forget what conversation it was.
Todd Tams
It was the San Diego IAOA conference. We had an awesome conversation in the bar. I don't remember what the fuck we were talking about. I just remember walking away from it and being like, that was a great conversation. I enjoyed that. I can't even remember what it was. I just have very fond memories of that in-person conversation. It's funny how that works.
Host
That was 2019. I don't know about you, but I think that was kind of a turning point. I remember we had a dinner that night or one of those nights that we were out there. That was the beginning. Crothers was at the table, you had Mike McDonald at the table, you were there, Cas, yeah. Who else was at the table? Everyone who's listening to this that was at the table, I'm sorry. Chris Green was there. I remember because you sat across from me, as I recall. I sat next to McDonough. That guy with what he knows in California for work comp was just amazing. That's how most of our conversation went that night. But that was the beginning of David Crothers and Killing Commercial. That's the beginning of Rogue Risk. That's the beginning of Mod Advisor and Direct Work Comp. If you look back from 2019 to today, it's pretty wild to think about the movement that's come out of that. That table launched a lot of stuff.
The hard part was Carruthers was at one end and McDonald was at the other. We were all there to meet and hang out with those two guys because we were all comp guys. I was launching Rogue on comp. Comp is our number one. 52% of our book of business is workers comp at Rogue. I don't talk about it as much on this podcast, but we've never slowed down with our comp thing. We were all kind of there to hear what Carruthers had going on and McDonough, and they were both at one end. Remember everyone's head snapping to one side and then snapping back to the other side. It was kind of funny how that worked. That was probably one of the longest dinners I've ever had. Normally we go, we eat, we get up and we leave. I bet we were there for two and a half hours and it just went by in the blink of an eye.
Todd Tams
It's almost like one of those things that you would want recorded, not to share, but just to listen back to. There's no way to retain all the conversations that were happening, and they were all so valuable. Everyone was being so open and upfront. I remember leaving going, McDonough is a maniac, but one of the smartest MFers I've ever met, especially when it comes to this stuff. The things he was saying, I was like, I didn't... You and I are both guys who really enjoy insurance beyond just the face value. It's rare that someone will talk about things or concepts I've never heard of. Maybe I don't necessarily understand or spend a lot of time with him, but he was talking about relevant things that I had literally never even heard of before. I was like, holy, this is crazy. He was literally sharing a lifetime's worth of value. Everyone was just trying to vacuum up as much as they could. That was a lot of fun. That was a good dinner.
Host
I think it's rare. There are workers' compensation experts all over this country. It's rare when you find somebody that has that knowledge, that's also vocal, and that's also just willing to share for free. That's one of the rare things that you find in a Mike McDonough or a Crothers with what he does with Killing Commercial. Love those people. Absolutely love them. That was a great meeting. I enjoyed that entire conference. I got to meet a bunch of people for the first time that I only knew digitally. I had a lot of really great conversations. To be honest with you, I had never really thought about how many now very relevant businesses were launched kind of right at that time. People were kind of gearing up and they came out of that play. I hadn't thought about that. That's pretty cool.
I credit my entire path to IAOA. We started building Direct Work Comp in 2017, 2018, something like that. I went to the big Iowa rural agents conference in Des Moines, Iowa. At the end of the day, all the rooms, everybody's having drinks and appetizers, and you stand around and talk about what's going on in rural Iowa. I left that hotel that night. The next day I hopped on a plane and I went to my very first IAOA, which I don't know if that was San Diego or Vegas. I don't remember. I walked out there and I was just blown away. Out of that has created intentional action, network connections, certainly you. That's how I met the guys that run Zip Bonds. They're from Iowa. I just walked in their office one day and said, "Hey, I'm Todd. We're in the same group. Let's talk." We certainly hit it off. That led me to you guys. There were a lot of forward-thinking people.
Todd Tams
It's funny. Yesterday I interviewed Ayers for the podcast and we were talking about conferences. He was talking a little bit about the last Better Conference and how they're changing the name to Agency Success because they want it to be bigger. We were talking about Elevate and Elevate 2017 and 18, the conferences that I put on back in the day. Elevate 2018 was great. That was kind of the launching point for Neon and some of the other projects coming out there. But 2017 was very similar to that San Diego IAOA for me. You had this moment where a certain group of people got together who were ambitious, but also friendly and caring and willing to share and supportive. You have these touchdown moments where the right group of people get together and you leave going, "Wow, I just met 10 people who will help me, who I can ask questions of."
I had a very similar feeling from that 2019 or 2020 IAOA conference. Coming out of there, McDonough now helped us set up our entire nurse triage program. He spent three different hour long calls with me and helped us set up that process. That's three hours of his life. He's a busy dude. For him to, over the course of a couple of months, spend that time with us to get it right, that's really special in my opinion. It only comes by sharing the same air. That's the only way that you get that.
Host
That goes back to meeting in person. A guy like Mike, he's going to share anyway. We wouldn't have the connections that we have today if it wasn't for conferences like that, and social media and Facebook. That's how we talked to all of these people all the time. It was actually 2020. That's when the last time was. January 2020. Because after that, we shut down the country.
Todd Tams
And you launched.
Host
Yes. I'm going to wait till the peak of COVID craziness and just launch this business out into it. That's a great idea. It's funny. I've kind of committed myself to the audience that I'm not going to go political as much anymore.
Todd Tams
There you go.
Host
I talked to an insurtech payment processor last night and they are just crushing it. They've been around for five, six, seven years, something like that. They were doing good. Then when COVID hit for them, it accelerated everything. They're in banking and insurance and finance. COVID is just like Zoom. Zoom exploded because we couldn't meet face-to-face anymore. We had to do everything electronically. Everyone forgets that before COVID, Zoom was thought of as this janky, second rate thing. You didn't really use it. It was the cheapo's video conferencing thing. Now it's just Zoom. What are you going to do? You're going to do Zoom.
Todd Tams
I actually refuse to go on WebEx now. If I have a carrier that says we're going to do WebEx, I'm like, "Nope, nope, nope. I can't get it to work with my setup. Something doesn't work. The mic doesn't work. The camera..." There is always something that's broken for no reason. Then it screws up all the other programs on the computer. No, thank you.
Host
I'm not a stupid guy. I don't know why it is that I can't figure out how to use WebEx.
Todd Tams
No, you're not stupid. That's just terrible software.
Host
I literally had a carrier reach out to me. We were talking about doing an appointment. I'm actually very interested, but I kind of had to put it on hold for obvious reasons. They did a WebEx. The first one was a WebEx. I didn't want to. They're like, "For security reasons." I said, "Whatever. What security reasoning? We can meet in a coffee shop and have a conversation. What is so secure that we're talking about in a marketing meeting?" I have no idea. It doesn't matter. It wasn't these people. I didn't want to give them too hard a time. These guys were doing their job and they're all good people. They're not the ones that chose WebEx. So I was trying to give them a hard time. I get on there and the very first thing I say to them, because I just couldn't help myself, I was like, "Just so you know, I am currently judging you based on the fact that we're on WebEx. I'm hardcore judging you. Just so you know that if there's a tally, this one went into the no tally because we're using WebEx right now." It was funny. One of the guys kind of laughed. The other two women were kind of looking at it like, "Is he serious?" I was like, "Well, I'm only half joking. Not really, but yes."
What's up, guys? Sorry to take you away from the episode. But as you know, we do not run ads on this show. In exchange for that, I need your help. If you're loving this episode, if you enjoy this podcast, whether you're watching on YouTube or you're listening on your favorite podcast platform, I would love for you to subscribe, share, comment if you're on YouTube, leave a rating review if you're on Spotify or Apple iTunes. This helps the show grow. It helps me bring more guests in. We have a tremendous lineup of people coming in, men and women who've done incredible things, sharing their stories around peak performance, leadership, growth, sales, the things that are going to help you grow as a person and grow your business.
They all check out comments, ratings, reviews. They check out all this information before they come on. So as I reach out to more and more people and want to bring them in and share their stories with you, I need your help. Share the show, subscribe if you're not subscribed. I'd love for you to leave a comment about the show because I read all the comments. Or if you're on Apple or Spotify, leave a rating review of this show. I love you for listening to this show and I hope you enjoy listening as much as I do creating the show for you. All right, I'm out of here. Peace. Let's get back to the episode.
Todd Tams
So, let's talk a little bit about Mod Advisor. One, because it's on your brain too. It's a big part of what you're doing. And three, because what I've seen now with Rogue...
So, let's talk a little bit about Mod Advisor. One, because it's on your brain too. It's a big part of what you're doing. And three, because what I've seen now with Rogue... We write in lower 48, where we've actually written policies in 39 of the 48 states. We have risks in 40 something of the 48 states. And we've basically written policies that are $200 and we've written policies that are $200,000. So I look at that and I talk to my team all the time about what they're hearing, why they're, you know, what's going on. And what I've taken from it is that digital consumers demand or have the expectation of just as much consultation and advising as an in-person local consumer does. They can take it on multiple lines of communication; it doesn't have to be all in one. Like if someone comes in for 45 minutes, you're going to dump all your advising on them in that 45 minutes. It tends to be more broken up over a series of communications over a series of time. But that digital consumer expects the same quality service and advising, if you want to retain them, that a local consumer does.
So my point in that preamble is that I look at a tool like ModAdvisor and what you're doing. And as someone who also focuses on workers comp, to me, this seems like a necessity as we digitize. Having a tool like ModAdvisor seems like a necessity. If you're going to be a true advisor, do you think that's accurate? Do you think it's misrepresenting?
Host
No, I think you're right on the mark and you're 100% accurate here. If you're going to be the broker that is going to be the consultative broker, and your client has problems—they've got problems on their workers' compensation, they've got claims, they're paying more for costs—the last thing they need is another quote. I get that we rush to that mindset: "Let me quote your insurance. Let me quote your insurance." Well, that doesn't solve the root cause of the problem or the high mod. Our whole focus at ModAdvisor is: let's identify the problem in a format that's easy for your clients to understand. That's the feedback we're hearing. They're like, "You've dumbed down the mod so much, it's super easy for us." Whether you're in construction or manufacturing or transportation, they get it. We're showing reports in simple green, yellow, red. Everybody knows what a red circle means—it's not good, or stop.
A lot of what we hear from our users and their clients is it's so simple to communicate to their clients what the problem is. Then, "How do we help?" That's where we've got our resource library. We're solely focused on things like return-to-work programs and how do we help agents help their clients solve that problem and pay less for insurance. So back to your point: if you're going to be any type of a consultative risk manager—and it's hard to do that on the small accounts, you need to have some premium size in there—you're going to need some type of tool to help educate your clients and your prospects.
I had a conversation with an agent the other day who told me I didn't know what I was talking about because in their state, they don't use experience mods. I said, "Do you sell work comp?" And he goes, "Yeah, 30% of my book." I'm like, "There's an experience mod everywhere." This blew my mind. Some people are just selling out there on price. They're not actually even doing the consulting work.
Todd Tams
Yeah. I actually don't think most are. One of the facts that I've quoted many times on the show recently, and I will continue to, is I think it's very important. 32% of the business that we get—because we get everything inbound for the most part—we have our team that are hunters, but I don't really count them. What I look at is what's coming in because I think it's more representative of the market. These people have a problem and they're actually seeking help, right? That's why they find us. 32% of the opportunities that come to us are broker-related. They don't get back to us. We don't get good advice. We never hear from them. They can't help us. They won't help us. "Won't help us" is a big one. It's probably like 5 or 6%. That's crazy. "Won't help us." Like, "Nah, we don't do that. Nah, we're not interested." It's crazy.
So what I take from that is everything you just said, I've seen validated in what comes into us. These digital consumers are not just looking for prices. Obviously, some people are and some people do lead with price, but that's not why they're buying from us. They're coming because they just want help. They want someone who's going to treat them like an adult, walk them through their policy in a timely manner, and get them something that they can use. Too many of us just throw the quote out in an email and then go, "Ah, these people are just price shoppers." They're not just price shoppers. You treated them like an a-hole. That's why. They came to you for advice and you treated them like a transaction.
To me, anything that differentiates you as an advisor—one, is better for the client, which should be our first priority, but two, absolutely separates you from everyone else. Here's the interesting thing: you and I both sell insurance for a living. I have zero control over the price, as you will know, zero control over the claims experience. But what I can control is what's in my head and how I help my clients. The price that's reflective of that is either I charge a consulting fee or it's going to be with the insurance company charges that I recommend that you go with. I'm totally okay if they don't go with me. I'm totally okay if they price shop. Go have your problems. But I guarantee you when you have those problems and you start paying more and your current broker maybe doesn't have the experience, that's when you're going to come back. And then we're not going to have a price conversation. We're going to have a, "Hey, I really need help. Can you fix this for me?" And that's where you build that long-lasting relationship and show the value of what you do.
Host
So this might sound like a left-field question, but what is your take on policy fees? Here's a little bit of context. We have had an internal discussion as a way to pre-qualify leads. We go subscriber, lead, suspect, prospect, client. That's our process. Subscriber is someone we're aware of but has not shown interest. Lead shows interest. Suspect, qualified market. Prospect wants—is going through the quoting process—and client. We've discussed internally—this is not something we have in place today—but we've discussed throwing a small policy fee on every policy above $5,000 in premium for the sole purpose of weeding out people who don't appreciate or aren't interested in the advisor characteristics from lead to suspect. $5,000 might be too low. This is 100% just a mental exercise. It is not something that's even on the roadmap, but it is something we've had a couple of conversations about as we've talked about how do you get the customers that you want from lead to suspect. I'm just interested in your take on that.
Todd Tams
I think there are two things here. I think education—create your marketing funnel with education. I think that's the best way to attract people and move them through the pipeline. Just provide value and provide help. They're going to seek you out and find you. There's a lot of gimmicky marketing tricks—"We're going to pound you with emails." I'll give you the best piece of advice I've heard in the last three months. It's from a tech founder. We were talking about spam emails. He says, "Here's what I do. I create a rule where if I receive an email with the word 'unsubscribe' in it, it automatically gets deleted." No more spam emails. If you look at your junk email, everyone is trying to move them from suspect to lead just by hammering on them and getting them to buy. Most people don't want that. They're not seeing it.
I just had a demo with somebody today. I said, "I'm not going to call and harass you. Whenever you're ready, call me back. It doesn't sound like you're ready today. And that's perfectly okay. Figure out what your process is. Figure out the target markets you want to go after. When you want the resource to help advise those people, we'll be here. But outside of that, I'm not going to harass you." That's not a sales model I've ever really bought into.
Host
Yeah, hammer and tell you bye. What was the other part of the question? The policy fee part.
Todd Tams
Oh, let's talk about policy fees. I totally think our system is broken nationwide and agents should be able to charge a fee for whatever they want.
Host
Here was my thought. Here was our internal conversation. Because I'm not sold on policy fees and they're not legal in every state. But our two biggest states, which are California and New York right now, you can charge a policy fee. The internal discussion went something like: we're getting 300-plus inbound leads a month. That's more than our team can handle. One of our biggest pain points is the lead-to-suspect jump. We have a lot of people that we're treating like suspects who shouldn't be. We're developing some process around that internally. Someone mentioned, "What if we charged a policy fee, which was like a minimum of $100 or 1% of the premium?" Just something. Don't hold me to what the numbers are. But that was the concept. The simple point was not that we care about the policy fee as a driver of revenue growth. It was meant to be: if you're willing to pay a $100 policy fee, then you're mentally bought into our process and are committing to us. It's essentially like signing a letter of engagement to a certain extent.
Where did we fall on that? Again, we did not come up with—I don't want everyone to message me. I would love everyone's feedback. Just understand that sometimes when you refer to me, what I hear in my brain is... but I still appreciate them. We're not doing this. But it was like, how do you get them to commit to you? Because every other digital broker can't break 40% retention. You just can't. Look across the board. Goldman Sachs just put $200 million into Newfront. Newfront's retention is like 40-something. They're amazing at new business acquisition, but they can't keep that business. Or at least that's the word on the street. I want to have local independent agency retention and be a digital agency. So we'll say 80s. If I can crack the 80s in retention as a digital broker, we will do very, very well. To do that, we have to be better at the business that we bring in. That's where some of these ideas have started to percolate.
I thought, "What are the tools?" Like a Mod Advisor—that's why I had Scott reach out to you. Are there tools that we should have that can help us be better advisors? Are there systems that we can put in place for qualifying leads? I put all these things in the same larger bucket, different segments of that bucket, as we start to think: how do we, when someone goes from a lead to a suspect, do that better? Because that's the jump where you make the mistake. Suspect to prospect to client is easy. Lead to suspect is where a lot of people make mistakes and they don't even realize.
Todd Tams
I don't know that I have any advice for you on that.
Host
Fuck, Todd. I thought you were going to solve this problem.
Todd Tams
No, I thought you were talking about policy fees. I think there are so many agencies. I just want to charge a fee sometimes because the account's so small that the level of service we need to provide—I understand that you might want our service, but on an $800 policy, the whole thing—maybe we end up putting more money into that thing than the commission check that the insurance company writes. You do. And so it's negative for us. In the state of Iowa, where we're at, you can't charge a fee if you're also getting commission. I think at the end of the day, we end up doing a disservice to our clients and our policyholders. There's not enough conversation around charging fees the right way. If the customer is willing to pay it because they want the level of service, then I don't know why we need the state to regulate and say you can't do that.
Host
Well, Democrats are the reason. I think that for some reason, when you become a Democrat, you forget math. Math just doesn't work anymore. Anything that involves numbers, your IQ drops about 20. But I'm completely with you because what ends up happening—even though I get the bleeding heart mentality, "Oh, they're already paying a commission. Why should they also pay you this?"—and you're like, "Well, here's why. We don't make any money. So they get shit service and they get put to the bottom of the barrel. We don't reshop them. We don't take their calls. We don't answer their emails. We don't do anything because we're losing money every time we work with them." There are some ways through automation and outsourcing and self-service to get some of that margin back, but it is razor thin. Razor thin.
That's a big part of why Rogue has a dual strategy of Select, which is $25,000 premium under, and Premier, which is larger commercial and middle market. Wouldn't it be great if everything was just net neutral, no commission, then you just override it on the top? Then you have to justify what it is that you're doing. For example, you come in and say, "Hey, here's a digital experience that you're going to have. Here's all the tools and resources that are going to make your life easier. So you don't have to spend 45 minutes on the phone with the insurance company." What's that 45 minutes of time worth to you?
Todd Tams
I don't know.
Host
Well, what you just described is called capitalism. And again, Democrats don't believe in capitalism. Let's just give everyone their insurance for free. College insurance. We'll make airplane rides, Teslas. We'll just make it all free. He doesn't pay tax. We should just think everyone should get a Tesla. You get a Tesla and you get a Tesla. I get it. I went political. I'm sorry, everybody. I'm sorry. Democrats are people too. We should just send them all to Australia.
Todd Tams
It's funny. There's a young man in my office named Cole that runs our office. Every year on his birthday, he emails Elon Musk and says, "Is this year I get a free Tesla?" Elon has yet to respond. Five years in a row, every day on the same, he sends that tweet out.
Host
I think that your idea of a net policy that then you get to dictate—I'm all for the transparency stuff. I think you absolutely should have to be—why not have a standardized form for what you get paid? Like, "I'm going to charge a 7% fee or a flat thousand." Whatever. You standardize that. You make it so everyone has to sign it every policy, every time. No problem. Make it transparent. But it should be net, no commission, charge fee on top. Then the market has to dictate it. If we're in the same market and you're charging 7% and I'm charging 9%, I have to justify my 9% to your 7%. People are going to talk. You think people don't talk? People are going to go, "Hey, Tams Agency is just as good as Hanley Agency and they're only charging 7% and not 9%." And you might go, "Well, hey, we're going to go to 8%." And then I come down to 8% and now we're competing head to head. That's how the system should work.
It also allows us to say, "Okay, you're a $500 consulting Bob. You're actually going to give us—I can charge less for that because you're never going to call me once. You're never going to need anything. You're going to auto-renew every year with Hartford or Traveler or Chubb, wherever you're with. That's easy. But you're a $500 bakery or something like that—pain in the ass. I'm going to have to send out different certs. You're going to call me. Someone's going to slip. You're going to light something on fire. That $500 should have a $500 policy fee on it because you're going to talk." There's no way to dictate that. There's no way to handle that. And like you said, you end up just shuffling those people back.
Todd Tams
I don't disagree.
Host
So, taking it back to ModAdvisor, as much as you are willing: what is coming down the pipe? If you can tease anything, what are some of the features that are coming? Cool schmoogies that we're going to get here? What should people be jacked up about? Why should they get on the newsletter? Although you just told them all to send your newsletter to spam, which I don't necessarily think is a good idea. But what should they be waiting for? What should they be waking up every morning breathless waiting for you to announce? What does that look like?
Todd Tams
Right now, we're finalizing the four remaining states. Obviously, New York has a big change coming through with their workers' compensation, the way they calculate them out of September of this year. That'll be next in our build out. So we'll be in the next five months, we'll be entirely nationwide. I am committed. I'm 100% committed to making this software so easy for insurance agents and value-packed with resources that it will be the number one advisor platform when it comes to workers' compensation. The priorities and the commitments that we have right now and what we're pushing through are all with that single intent.
I hear there's a lot of frustration around duplicate data entry. I think we intend to solve that problem and make it super easy for brokerages across the country to get loss information, payroll information, and everything in our system and do that quick and fast. This shouldn't be a manual time-consuming thing. You shouldn't have three people running mod analysis for you on the back room doing all the calculations for your clients. Everything we're going to do in the next 12 to 24 months is going to simplify that entire process and make it super slick.
Host
I love it. It just shouldn't be this hard. Most of the stuff that we do in our industry shouldn't be this hard. I'm glad that there are people like yourself who have the balls to create these kinds of things. Male or female, the proverbial balls—not actual, you don't have to have them—but that term, because it does take guts. You're putting yourself out there. You could create this and it could blow up in your face. Now all of a sudden you've taken yourself away from your agency and shifted your focus and spent brain cycles. That's a big risk. I think it's amazing. I give you so much credit. It's why I love having you on the show and enjoy our relationship in general. It takes a lot of guts to do that. I couldn't be happier that you're seeing that success and getting some of the early payoffs in terms of Broker Tech Ventures and all the publicity. I think it's absolutely tremendous. And you got a sweet pair of kicks out of it too, which is great.
Todd Tams
I got a sweet pair of kicks. I've got a really nice Mod Advisor cup here.
Host
Nice. If your users are listening—we throw around the term "for agents, by agents." I don't think there's any better group of people in this country that are doing things to improve the independent agent channel. I know we talk about some of the large companies out there and how they do things to get a return on VC money. Sometimes that's not always helpful to how we operate our insurance agencies. Everything that I do with ModAdvisor is 100% committed to the independent agent channel. If you go on ModAdvisor right now and go under "Learn," you can request a resource. I just showed a guy—he goes, "Well, I want to go after trucking. Here's the problems." Tell me what problem you have. We'll build out resources to help you win that business. I don't know where else you can go. We will custom design the content you need to help close accounts and actually help your clients reduce their total cost of risk.
Todd Tams
It's tremendous. Give people what they want. It's not a hard concept.
Host
It isn't. And it seems to be at the same time. It's greed. I had this conversation with Rag off from Tarmaka because he's always busting my chops. He's great. I'm an enormous fan of Tarmaka. I mean this only in—he's an interesting cat and gives me a hard time. He busts my chops because I tend to skew towards my vision and mission for what I want to build versus straight revenue. Not that I don't like creating revenue. Not that I don't think revenue is important. I'm not a socialist. I get it. He's like, "No, you are in business to make money. That's your goal. Yes, you have to deliver value to make money or people won't buy your shit." Obviously, he's delivered a tremendous amount of value. My point is: far too often, companies hit a certain size. You get someone into a leadership position or a board position who is wholly removed from the client set that you're trying to serve. Then all of a sudden, decisions start getting made that are not in the best interest of customers. That is where we've seen problem after problem after problem. You can line up the dozens of stories of companies who started as—you know—and then it just...
I'm glad that you're sticking to it. I'm excited for it. I think it's great. The best part is, if you do stick to this model of "for agents, by agents," which I believe that you will, it is proven that if you can kind of last through some of the early days, there is a huge windfall on the backend and a lot of value to be provided. I'm happy for you, man.
Todd Tams
Thank you very much. I appreciate it.
Host
Yeah, dude. I want to be respectful of your time. I appreciate you so much. Thank you for this great conversation, as always. If someone's interested in Mod Advisor, where do they go? And if they want to just connect with you and be part of your ecosystem, where do they go for that?
Todd Tams
ModAdvisor.com has a direct link to book my schedule. Certainly, you can find me on LinkedIn. Not as much on Twitter—I need to get on that platform a little more, especially now that Elon Musk is super interested in it.
Host
I just saw a headline today. I think he's got the money to buy it.
Todd Tams
Yeah. I'm also on Facebook. You'll see a lot of cooking videos on there. If you follow Facebook—if you have a hard time with meat, then—my problem is that I don't have the grill skills. So I look at the shit you make, and then I look at the stuff I make, and I feel like less of a man.
Host
It's super interesting. My senior developer on my development team, he's vegetarian. Him and his wife are vegetarian. I'm posting these big pictures of pork and meat and bacon. We had this conversation. He's like, "We don't eat meat, but we love what you're doing." So he sends me pictures of—I tell you, in India, they make some pretty cool food. A lot of it is just how they prepare it and how it looks is absolutely amazing. One of these days, we're going to head over there and meet him. I can't wait to eat all of his vegetarian food and then come back and have a big old steak. That's awesome.
All right, brother. Hey, I appreciate you so much. Thank you again. We're out of here. Peace.
Todd Tams
Take care, Hanley. Thanks again.
End of interview. Audio transitions to a promotional segment.
Host
This is the exact method we use to close 1,200 clients in under three years during the pandemic. No fluff, no endless follow-ups, just results fast. Based in behavioral psychology and battle-tested, the one-call-close system eliminates excuses and gets the prospect saying yes more than you ever thought possible. If you're ready to stop losing opportunities and start winning, visit masteroftheclose.com. That's masteroftheclose.com. Do it today. Thank you.