Podcast Episode Summary
The podcast episode features a panel discussion with industry leaders Amy Zupan (CEO of Vertifor), Matt Masiello (CEO of SIA), and Tyler Asher (Head of IA Distribution for Liberty Mutual). The conversation revolves around the current trends and challenges in the insurance industry, with a focus on the independent agency channel.
Main Topic: The panel discusses various trends and challenges in the insurance industry, including the increasing amount of M&A activity, the strength of the independent agency channel, and the importance of partnerships and collaborations.
Key Points:
Takeaways:
Participants:
Additional Insights:
Became a Master of the Close: https://masteroftheclose.com
Like other industry disruptions preceding it, the InsurTech movement was widely viewed as a threat to the existence of the independent agency channel.
Thus far, the independent agent has proven to be an invaluable component in meeting client needs and expectations. Still, technology advances are the ecosystem in which they must operate – together with their carrier and digital partners.
In this panel, leaders representing the three components of this dynamic, IA’s, carriers, and tech, share their thoughts on how to make the customer journey a smoother one and why collaboration is a win-win for all parties.
Don't miss this conversation...
Episode Highlights:
Key Quotes:
Resources Mentioned:
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episodes You Might Enjoy:
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Ryan Hanley
In a crude laboratory in the basement of his home... Hello everyone, and welcome back to the show. Today we have an absolutely tremendous conversation for you. This is another repackaged episode. Not that I'm trying to skirt you guys, but I had two really good non-podcast conversations that I thought were worth sharing with you all here, if you hadn't otherwise listened to them or wanted to listen to them again.
In this case, it's a panel that I did for the IA Evolve Digital Conference. This is a conference put on by SIA. I had the opportunity to interview a panel of people that just do not—this caliber of individual, of leader in our industry—just does not come together that often. I thought the panel went really, really well. A lot of times these things can be kind of boring, dry, and stale, and I'd like to believe that this was not one of those conversations. Everybody came to play. Everyone came with comments and energy.
I asked some of my colleagues at SAA Proper if they'd be willing to let me push it out through the podcast channel, and they agreed. What you're going to get is a conversation between me, Amy Zupan, the CEO of Vertafore, Matt Masiello, the CEO of SIA, and Tyler Asher, the head of all IA distribution for Liberty Mutual. These are three power players who gave up an hour each of their time and about 45 minutes of their time in a previous call to game plan for this conversation. I think that hopefully shows you that for these individuals to give up that amount of time to something like this, they wanted to share this message. It wasn't going to be repackaged gobbledygook. It was going to be their thoughts, their feelings, where their attention is actually focused. I think that's exactly what we got.
I wouldn't be resharing this if I didn't think it was incredibly valuable. I do. I think you're going to enjoy it. There are a lot of great insights. It was actually the kickoff panel for the conference. There were a whole bunch of other speakers—James Jenkins, Josh Gurley, Nick Ayers, Ciara Gravier—awesome speakers. If you enjoyed this conversation, you can actually rewatch right now for free all the other speakers. You just go to IAEvolve.com. You can listen, watch all the other speakers that took place during this digital conference.
I just hope that you enjoy this conversation. I love pushing these things out to you. As you guys know, this podcast feed is really a menagerie of information that I think is valuable to you. Sometimes I do solo episodes, sometimes interview episodes, sometimes multiple guests. In this case, when I deliver content or I'm part of content in other places, I try to get that recording and push it back out through this vein so that you get access to it when possible. Not always possible, but when possible. In this case, we're able to do it.
I want to say thank you to my colleagues at SA for letting me push this out. I hope you'll go check out IA Evolve and all the other speakers. I hope you enjoy this conversation. As always, I love you for listening to this show. If you find this information valuable, please share it with a friend. Go on social, text it to someone, email it to someone, share with your team. More ears listening, more ears getting involved in these types of conversations helps push our industry forward, and that's why I do this show. Love you guys for listening. Let's get on to this amazing panel from IA Evolve.
Transition to panel recording
Hello, everybody, and welcome to the opening kickoff panel of IA Evolve. I'm going to do very short intros for our panelists. We have an absolute rock star panel here. I feel like something funky must be going on in the universe to have such power players, all this gravity in one place. My computer is also wonky, so the delay is on purpose, just so you guys know. I did that for effect.
Before we get to our panel and into what I think is going to be an absolutely tremendous conversation, I want to give a big shout out and thank you to all of you who are attending. I have always as an annual event, and the entire SIA ecosystem family is very happy to put this on and happy that you would choose to spend time with us. There are a lot of good presentations that are going to happen throughout the next two days, this panel being the first of what should be a wonderful event.
A couple of housekeeping items. There is a Q&A section that you'll see. Somewhere in the screen that you're looking at, there's a Q&A button. When you have questions, pop them in that Q&A section. We will get to those questions. If your questions are terrible, I am not going to read them on this thing. But all of those terrible questions will be answered by either the Vertafore team, the Liberty Mutual team, or the SAA team afterwards. So people will get back to you about those things. If you ask, "Hey Tyler, how come our commission rates aren't 45% instead of 20%?" I'm not asking that question. Any pertinent, good, thoughtful questions that you have, we absolutely will try to get as many of those to our panel as we can. Any really tactical, very specific questions, please still ask them. Someone from the team of whichever respective organization you are asking that question will get back to you. I want you to ask those questions.
There's a group chat thing, a whole bunch of features, but the one I'm going to be watching is the Q&A. Use that Q&A once we get there. Also, Lisa gave me a few other things that I'm kind of forgetting now that we got going, but the Q&A was the big one. We'll follow up after. There are tons of great panels, so just keep watching, and we appreciate you being here.
Okay, with that, let's get on to our panel. I'm going to do very brief introductions because I don't think the individuals who we have on panel here today need a tremendous amount of bio read. I don't want to waste any more time on non-content related things. Also, Christopher, congratulations on not actually asking a question but being the first one to use the tool. Whatever prize that gets you, wonderful.
Our first guest is Amy Zupan. She is the CEO of Vertafore. Amy, it is a pleasure to have you. Tyler Asher, who you cannot see, he is coming in via telephone because technology. Tyler is President of IA Distribution for Liberty Mutual. We also have, who is online and you can see, Matt Masiello, the CEO of SIA. I want to give a big welcome to all of you and thank you for taking time out of what I know are very busy schedules to be with us here today.
Let's get to our very first question. I'm going to throw a softball up and we'll start with Amy. There are lots of things happening always in our space. Regardless of when we do this, always things happening. We work in an industry that is always evolving. My first question for you, Amy, is: what is one trend that just has your attention? When you see an article on it, you pause for a second and it kind of catches you. What's one thing that's catching your eye right now that you find interesting and relevant to our time?
Amy Zupan
Yeah, it's a great question, Ryan. I've been in insurance now for six years here at Vertafore, and it is hard to believe. It's actually gone super fast, but there's so much going on in our industry right now, specifically around technology. When I think about this question, I might highlight the increasing amount of M&A activity that's happening in the agency space right now. In reality, it shows no sign of slowing down anytime soon. In fact, it's picking up. We like to follow the Agency and Broker Buyer Index. In Q2, it showed a 74% increase in acquisitions over Q1. Deal count is actually up 16% year on year, despite economic headwinds.
Yet at the same time, there are still similar numbers of independent agencies out there as there was when I joined six years ago. What that tells you is the bigger are getting bigger, they're getting more complex. There's no question about that. But newer, smaller agencies are popping up every day. For a vendor like us, it means we're constantly investing in our solutions to help automate and simplify things. Large agencies need to handle the complexity that comes with acquisitions, conversions, how to help folks clean up data. New agencies that are popping up need simple automated solutions that can get you up and running quickly. I find the amount of M&A activity and the amount of independent agencies staying about the same to be a pretty fascinating tribute to the strength of the independent channel.
Ryan Hanley
Amy, just a quick follow-up. Do you think that whether we actually dip into a real recession or not, whether it's shallow or deep, do you think that what does feel like some sort of slowdown is going to have an impact on M&A activity? Or do you think we're just in a time where we have enough individuals whose career has hit a point where they're starting to consider making a move, and this is just going to be a continuing trend?
Amy Zupan
It's obviously hard to predict the future. I'm not a crystal ball reader. But my perspective is that if we were starting to see those slowdowns, we would have seen them by now. There's a tremendous amount of money that continues to be invested in this space. For the foreseeable future, we're just going to see that continue to go in that direction.
Ryan Hanley
Yeah, that makes a lot of sense. The people that I talk to are seeing all the same stuff. I got a buddy that has a certain type of agency, and almost on a weekly basis, he has someone new pitching him. It's incredible what's flying around. It's a very interesting time from M&A.
Next, Tyler, this is not in order of importance, it's just in order of how I want to ask the questions. I'm going to go to Matt next. Tyler, be prepared. You're kind of playing roulette with these questions here. Matt, what trend are you looking at? It can be M&A too or whatever, but what's catching your eye that's stopping you when you see a piece of information or report or study?
Matt Masiello
It's like sticking your hand in a candy jar right now to answer that question. There are a lot of fascinating trends going on out there. I was thinking granular or more global. I'm actually going to go one step just above where Amy went. Amy was on M&A and the health of the industry. I was once told by the way, when I was the youngest person in the room, that one day I would wake up and I would be the oldest person in the room. I think on this screen, I am.
What's fascinating is in all the years I've been doing this, without exception, I've been told that independent agencies are dinosaurs. We're going to go away. We don't deliver a value proposition to the consumer. The carriers don't need us. The internet, banks, insurtech—everyone's going to put us out of business. Even on the tails of certain large consulting organizations in the last five years counting independent agencies down and out, it's the strongest I've ever seen the channel. We are converting exclusive channel business over to the independent agency channel. I think the direct response, I won't say plateauing, but they do have a limited product offering. We're seeing carriers double down on their independent agency investment. We're seeing technology partners invest significantly into the channel.
Amy's M&A piece is a huge piece, but I just think we should believe in what we do because other people believe in it now too. I think that's a fascinating trend. I say all the time right now, this is simply the most exciting time to be in this business. You started an agency. There are thousands of people starting agencies right now. They're doing it because it's a great opportunity. Recession, market, economy, debt markets, M&A—doesn't matter. It's a great time to be in this business.
Amy Zupan
I might add one point to what Matt just said, because I love it. When I got here six years ago, that was the same comment made to me: the independent agency channel is going to diminish over time, it's going to direct, blah blah blah. One of the things that's super interesting right now, if you look at the data, is that the amount of premium that's actually going through the independent agency channel is going up. It's not going the other direction. It's falling away from the captives a bit if you look at the premium, and direct is also coming. That's not something to ignore—make sure you're multi-channel and all of those things. But I find that the premium going through the channel is only going up.
Ryan Hanley
Does anyone else feel like direct business is really just a feeder program for independent business? I love when I see a new direct competitor because I'm like, they're going to scoop up all this business, do a really terrible job, and then we're just going to take it off from them in two or three years. That's always been my perspective. Every time I see a new insurtech that's going to disintermediate, I'm like, this is going to be great. I'm going to get a ton of calls in like two years from all their customers.
Tyler Asher
Maybe David, my question around what MMA—MMA stands for mixed martial arts. We are talking about M&A, also known as mergers and acquisitions. Sorry, I just wanted to clear that up real quick.
Ryan Hanley
Oh no, perfect.
Tyler Asher
Honestly, I would just kind of add to what Matt and Amy said. I think the headline that is soon to be written is that independent agents are going to continue to win. The data from market share shows that if anything, the channel is actually getting bigger. You have many carriers that are pivoting models to really exclusively focus on independent agents. The prospects at large continue to be very advantageous for the independent agency system.
I think we're in this environment right now. Many of those on the webinar will attest to this. Service has been something that's been hard to come by over the last couple of years, whether it's staffing shortages or everyone being remote. I really do think in the years ahead, there's going to be a flight to quality service, a flight to advice. Ryan, your point on the direct writers—they're very much targeting a different customer. It's customers that truly get to a point where they value advice, where independent agents are a tremendous fit in terms of the value proposition that agents provide and what consumers are interested in.
I really do think that independent agents right now are better positioned than they have ever been. The headline that has yet to be written is that independent agents will continue to gain market share and continue to thrive in the environment ahead.
Matt Masiello
If I could just jump in on Tyler's coattails there. I think it's fascinating when we talk about your comment a minute ago about the direct channel and Tyler's comments. There is some business that just belongs in the direct channel, and we as independent agencies shouldn't compete for it. It tends to be lower limit, lower premium, higher risk, low loyalty, low commission if we happen to write it. I'm a firm believer that business does belong in a direct channel. We should fight within our weight class, which is doing business with people that are looking for the value that we deliver.
Ryan Hanley
I think there's also something. I've been in the business for 17 years, and one of the things I've really loved and specifically always focused on the marketing side. From a branding, marketing, content, voice perspective, there are so many more independent agents. While I would love to see the carriers step their game up in general, I think carriers as well have started to really dial in their message around what our value proposition is and get much better at telling it and telling it more frequently. That is starting to take customers who may have given some of the direct channel competitors a shot, and they're coming to us first. Some of that is subjective. Maybe a lot of it is my two and a half years at Rogue, but we're subjectively internally starting to see that people who may have been direct channel consumers are coming to us because they're seeing messaging, they're hearing messaging that resonates that maybe in years past they didn't see from us. I think that's a really good sign for what all of you have said anecdotally.
Great. One quick question. Amy, you had referenced a buyer index, and Carrie had a question just if you could say the name of it again.
Amy Zupan
Yeah, it's the Agency and Broker Buyer Index. It's something that gets published every quarter that we can fundamentally look at. I can look it up here and get you a link and send it out.
Ryan Hanley
Awesome. Thank you so much. Okay, Jake, we're going to get to your question towards the end. You're trying to make me bury the lead here. Thank you for all that on the trends and the back and forth. That was tremendous. I think we're all in agreement. We're talking to the right audience here as well, but we wouldn't be on this call if we didn't feel that way. It's reassuring to hear from people in your positions that you're seeing what I think most of us are feeling—that we're on the upswing and there are a lot of things happening.
One of the trends—and I'm going to put this to Matt first. It's going to feel like a softball. Don't start hating on me when I ask this question. If you listen to my own podcast, you will hear that this is the way I felt for a while, well before any of my relationship with SIA. It very much is feeling to me like we can't do it alone anymore. Not that you can't, so please don't start hating me in the Q&A. But it feels very much like whether it's joining a cluster or an aggregator or partnering with another agency or a group of agencies, whether that's regionally or based on an industry, that very much feels like the future to me.
Having worked in and run agencies both outside of an aggregator slash network and now inside, there are pros and cons to every agency. But to me, this feels like the future. Being part of a larger group, having access to carriers that you didn't have, taking some of the pressure off early on. We're talking a lot about this M&A activity where agencies that have been around for a long time are being scooped up. All these young startup agencies that are filling the gap behind them—it's very difficult to get appointments, especially when choice is one of our big value propositions. If you can only get one or two direct appointments, that is a handcuff. By joining a network, you're able to get access and really hit the ground running.
Matt, I wanted to put to you this idea of being part of something bigger, of joining forces with other agencies, this network model. Where do you see that going? Is this a trend you're seeing in SIA? Are you seeing it in the broader ecosystem? What other comments do you have on this particular concept?
Matt Masiello
I'm going to be generic in my response and let my peers also come around on this. I think small businesses in general in the United States need to be part of other organizations because that's what allows us to remain small, independent businesses. 80% of the U.S. economy is small business. It's hard to go it on your own if you're not partnering, collaborating in a buying group, whatever the case may be. 70% of the independent agency channel is under $1.2 million of commission income. We're small businesses. You need to be part of something.
The carrier access thing—agencies can access carriers anywhere right now. They can access carriers through wholesalers, through joining networks. It's table stakes. What it ultimately becomes after that is what is the value proposition that they're looking for in any sort of relationship? Because it is more than carriers. It is more than just income. It becomes thought leadership. It becomes technology. It becomes collaborating on how agencies are going to look into the future.
Where I'll pivot that question just a little bit—it really isn't just joining a network or a cluster or an aggregator. It's being an active participant in technology user groups. It's being an active participant with some of the carriers. We'll give Tyler some opportunity to talk about Agent for the Future and the investments they've made there. I think we all have to be collaborating and part of something as we move forward, especially as small businesses. None of us can afford to go out and change the world today. But if we all get together, we can do that.
20 or 30 years ago, as independent agencies, we would sit here and say, "We're just going to wait for the agency management systems to solve this problem," or "We're just going to wait for the carriers to solve these problems." The basic fact is they're looking for us to help them solve those problems. We should be active participants in that. Scale brings you to the table to be active participants in the future of not just how you're going to grow your agency and your individual business, but how we're going to grow the industry overall.
Ryan Hanley
We'll go kind of reverse order. Tyler, what's your thoughts on this particular topic? Joining forces, we'll say, is the general concept here.
Tyler Asher
I actually loved how Matt framed that. We like to say going independent doesn't mean going it alone. There are lots of ways for agencies to pick up scale, whether that's being a part of something, whether that's tapping into programs that carriers offer. Certainly, Liberty Mutual at Safeco, our commitment to agents is to do more than really anyone on the carrier side to help agents win. We have a ton of programs to help agents from digital marketing to their websites, hiring training producers to loans to bring new staff in. We have programs that really cover everything.
For agencies, it really just means tapping into the resources that are truly available. We are in an industry where scale increasingly does matter depending on the aspirations for the organization. There are many small agents that are serving a local community, and they're content or happy with how big the agency's gotten, the success they've reached. That's fine. But if an agency owner has an aspiration to continue to grow, to continue to expand, scale starts to matter. We see that certainly on the agency side. That is certainly true on the carrier side as well. Making sure that you've got the ability to continue to invest in the future, the ability to bring in new technology, the ability to hire new talent, the ability to really invest in marketing and brand—all comes down to scale and being able to invest in a smart way.
I really do believe that scale matters. There's lots of ways for agencies to get support. I love the title of this panel, "Transforming Our Industry Together," because I do think that's ultimately what it's going to take for us to win. Together is a partnership between carriers, between agencies, and between all of the technology providers and all of the service providers in a broad agency ecosystem, all working together to ensure the channel is really set up for success.
Ryan Hanley
Amy, anything to add on this topic?
Amy Zupan
I loved what both Matt and Tyler had to say. The two things I would kind of build on—I obviously don't have the experience of being an aggregator or a cluster or an agency. But I'll draw the parallel to being a software company. At Vertafore, we can't do it alone either. We 100% believe in an open platform from that perspective. We 100% belong to groups where we participate with technology companies that look and feel like us that work in other industries. You really need to understand best practice, new trends.
I'll take cybersecurity as a great example. What are all the threats? Our head of cyber participates in all sorts of things, and that's where we get all that insight that helps us to protect you. Building on what Matt said, it's not just us in our industry. I think it's across the board for small businesses. You really need to have those support systems that help you do the things that you don't have to go it alone.
Building on what Tyler said on the title of the panel of "we do this together"—I find this industry to be fascinating from the perspective of it's a coopetition type of industry. I actually love that part of it. I'd never before been in an industry where you feel such a sense of camaraderie and support across agents at the same time you're out necessarily competing for business. Super cool. When you look at technology and the opportunity that we have to actually drive impact for our users, for our end consumers, it's going to take the folks like Tyler and the carrier community. It's going to take all of you on the phone and it's going to take people like me working together to really break through and drive some of those advancements. I think that "together" is a really important angle of what Tyler was saying.
Ryan Hanley
This was one of the most important lessons that I learned launching Rogue Risk was just how alone you feel if you don't join something—a group, a network, a networking group, a mastermind. If you don't reach out, if you don't get involved. Our industry, everyone is so willing to help each other, which is amazing. Right now, I can tell you there is a buddy, SIA member who's watching this panel. Then he's doing David Carruthers' "Killing Commercial" thing this afternoon. Then tomorrow he's going to Chris Paradiso's mastermind. In two days, four different groups, all this cross-pollination of ideas. Everyone's so willing to share. That to me is one of the most redeeming qualities of our industry. I think it's so incredibly important.
If people do feel like they're on an island, put a question in the Q&A. If I can't find you a place to join and learn, one of our panelists will or someone in their organization will find you someplace that you can connect. If you're out there and you're listening to this and you're feeling like you don't know where to turn, put your information in. Whether it's someone who's involved in this or not, we'll find you a place.
Matt Masiello
Before you go on to your next question, I think this is actually a cool evolution of the industry. This was an industry where we all liked our box.
Everyone had to stay in their lane and stay in their box. We had non-competes and non-piracies and confidentiality agreements because we didn't want to share and collaborate. As some of us got more involved in technology over the years, and I think Amy makes a good point coming in from the outside with technology, you saw things like open source and collaborating on moving technologies forward. In the insurance industry, we didn't do that. We all stayed in our lanes. I think we are evolving as an industry because of this willingness to collaborate and share. It's a rising tide thing. Some still want to stay in their lanes, but where everyone is making this investment, including their time and treasure to help others, it's a really big deal in this industry. It's a great trend for us to evolve because if we don't evolve, we will die. And we are evolving right now.
Ryan Hanley
Talking about evolution of the industry, only one question so far 30 minutes in has been about download. That's a big positive for the evolution of our industry right there. April says, "It is much easier to embrace change when you're not on an island by yourself." Amen to that, April. I appreciate you sharing that sentiment.
Keeping this idea going, we've set up some trends and talked about how we can't do it alone. The next thing I want to talk about is how do we actually choose our partners or collaborators? How do we make these decisions? What is the filter that we pass people through? I tend to think about these things as filters because there are no absolutes. All of us will be different. With different partners, all the criteria might not always be the same. I don't expect anyone to give the seven things you need to do to be part of Vertafore's Orange Partner Program. What I'm asking for is from your position, from your seat, what are some of the high-level filters? Amy, we'll start with you. What are some of the high-level filters that you or your team is looking for when considering a partner or collaborator? It is a big decision, especially with the size of the organizations on this call. When you decide to partner with someone, it's news. I am positive you're aware of the gravity of that. Share anything you can around some of the filters you use to make those decisions.
Amy Zupan
Absolutely. We started that Orange Partner Program with the philosophy of being open and building on relationships and collaborating with others to build things. First and foremost, partnership, whether it's about the partner program or our customer relationship, is about trust and communication at the end of the day. Relationships are never perfect. Everything doesn't always go exactly as you expected, but there is no substitute for having base level trust and good, honest, open communication. To me, that is first and foremost, table stakes for thinking about who a partner is.
The second thing for us is you're looking for a win-win in a partnership. It's good for you, it's good for me. Those partnerships live. A lot of times we're looking for solutions that solve the problems our customers are actually facing right now. This is something that matters to their business, that makes a difference, and does so in a way that automates and simplifies things for them. We're not looking just to have a partner because it's a flashy new object. We want to actually do something that's physically going to solve a problem. That goes back to the point about win-win. We're looking for a win for whoever we're partnering with and a win for us at the end of the day. Just some high-level philosophies as we're thinking about things.
Ryan Hanley
Tyler, what about you guys? I shared with you in our pre-call that my buddy Chris Klein, who used to work for Westfield, said he had to hire an assistant just to filter the partnership calls they would receive on a daily basis. I'm sure either you or someone in your organization has a similar situation. How do you think through what could potentially be a partner or collaborator when making those decisions?
Tyler Asher
Partners and collaborators come in lots of shapes and sizes, from agency partners to technology vendors or places where we might integrate fully for the benefit of an agent. Broadly, we're looking for a partner that shares our philosophy. To Amy's point, win-win. We're driving mutually beneficial partnerships. We share a philosophy for what's ahead for the channel and a commitment to continue to advance, to push the channel forward, to help the channel evolve.
For an agency partner, we're looking for someone who maintains a growth mindset and is really looking to continue to drive the business forward. That means always looking to add new producers where possible, always being willing to take some risks on new technologies, to try new ways to interact with customers. I know there's a question in the chat about getting direct access to carriers. The biggest thing isn't whether you're a scratch agency. It's whether you've got a good marketing plan, whether you're building a strong agency culture, and whether you're maintaining a growth mindset in terms of how to take the business to the next level. How do you always ask the question of what's next? Broadly, that's who we look to partner with because it aligns to our interests.
From an agency partner perspective, we do business with about 24,000 retail agents across the country out of about 36,000. We see partners of all different sizes, shapes, and operating models. The agents we most find success with are those that meet those core commitments to want to grow, to do good in their local community, and are deeply committed to advancing the channel. From a technology partner, same thing. We're looking for someone who's tech forward, easy to work with, easy to integrate with, someone committed to advancing the channel, willing to help push agents forward when necessary, whether that's digital adoption or a new technology. Just making sure we align on those key tenets.
Ryan Hanley
Matt, what about you?
Matt Masiello
I love the question because it goes back to how exciting it is to be in the industry and how important being part of other organizations is. I look at partnerships and collaboration as bookends. The first part starts with you have to like them. The second part of the bookend is you have to have the same goal. Everything else in between is a result of a good relationship with somebody you like and can work with and the same goal. Ultimately, you want to find the alternative paths to get to that goal. We can't be linear in this industry with "this is the way it needs to be done" or "this is the way we've always done it" or "this is what the carriers require" or "this is what the technology platforms require." It's all about the consumer. Finding that non-linear process of people you like that you can work with that have common goals, and then you can figure everything else out in between.
Ryan Hanley
The one thing I wanted to add is the partner or collaborator has to actually solve a real problem. There are a lot of tools and InsurTechs out there that do cool things, but they don't actually solve problems that agencies have or care about. That can be difficult to parse through because you see this thing and it's awesome and it does this and this and this. Then when you look at the workflows of an agency, you realize we don't really need that. It doesn't really make our lives better. It's just different clicks, not less clicks. That can be a challenge.
The other one I'm sure you see, and no one has to comment on this, but I remember from a previous life with a company that fired me, we would get a lot of people that wanted to do business with us just because there were slide decks in incubators where it was like, "Get a partnership with X and that will amplify you." It wasn't that they even wanted to do business with you. They just wanted to be able to put on their sales deck that they had you as a partner. It's a very difficult thing. I hope everyone listening knows this is one of the hardest decisions. These guys were all very kind and thoughtful in their responses, but it can be very difficult to choose who you partner with. Sometimes I see outside emails asking, "How come this company won't partner with these guys?" Sometimes you might not understand, but I want everyone to realize this is a hard thing to sort through. For every great company that would be a true value add, there are a dozen or more similar looking companies that could be an incredible waste of time or a complete fail. It is a big decision.
Amy Zupan
Ryan, maybe I can comment on that. You hit on one of my favorite phrases as we think about InsurTech investment. It's hard to believe when I got here in InsurTech, there was about $2 billion being invested in a given year. We're now over 15 or 16. Ryan's spot on. Not all of it is actually helpful to you. Navigating that is a really complicated thing. It's the sole purpose why we created the Orange Partner Program. It's what networks and clusters and groups that you can join can help you navigate. In InsurTech, because it's cool and interesting and looks fun, if it doesn't solve a real problem for your business, it could actually add extra clicks to your workflows, which is exactly what we're not trying to do. Not helpful. We're trying to simplify things so that we can give you time back at the end of the day. Navigating that is a really big challenge, and that's where networks, clusters, and companies like us can help too.
Ryan Hanley
We're going to pivot a little. This has been tremendous. I feel like we've done a really good job of developing a narrative here, but we have some good questions. I want to give a quick shout out to Jessica who said, "Agreed, as a new agent, I feel like I would have sank without my SIA support team." Stroking some egos out there. Thank you, Jessica. That's wonderful. It took us 41 minutes to get our first question about Accord. Again, the evolution of the industry is tremendous.
I want the last kind of scheduled question that I had. I want to give credit where it's due to Amy. This was her suggestion. After this, we'll pivot to the questions that have been asked in the Q&A. If you have a question for our panel, please get that in the Q&A right now. We have about 20 minutes left on our discussion. We'll hit this question I'm about to ask, and then we'll get into your questions. If you think it's silly, I will be your silly filter. Just get the questions out there.
Amy, as this was your question, I'm going to put it right back on you. What is one problem or a set of problems that we haven't solved yet? What is a problem out there that we as an industry talk about but just doesn't feel like we've dialed in on? Is there anything in particular or a set of things? Where are you at with this one?
Amy Zupan
I love this question because it's similar to the very first question we had on trends. There are so many to pick from. It's about where we want to focus and what we see. For me, my hot button these days is we live in a complicated ecosystem. We have the uninsured, we have independent agents, we have the wholesalers and MGAs, we have the carriers. Our collective purpose is to help our end customers get the best coverage they can for the right prices with as easy an experience as possible. We have not even come close to crossing the chasm of navigating the possibility of improving the way all of these stakeholders connect across one another. We will never get to the point where we can fundamentally drive that fast, personable experience if we don't address the connectivity challenges.
From a technology perspective, I wake up every day and think about that. Back to the comments about doing it together, what I learned the day I got here six years ago into insurance was that connectivity problem is solvable. That's not a big deal. What I underestimated was all the players in the game and how they all have to fundamentally come together to solve that problem and really get us to the tipping point. I wake up every day having conversations with carriers, having conversations with agencies, working with my team on how we actually cross the chasm of where we need to be to unlock the value we can deliver to the constituents by addressing connectivity.
Ryan Hanley
You mean you didn't realize how many rating systems are still run on cobalt? I didn't explain that to you when you... Sorry, I can't help myself sometimes. You are 100% right. Connectivity is the problem.
Tyler, where would you go with this? You can expand upon connectivity, which I agree is probably the thing we have not solved, or anything else you're seeing.
Tyler Asher
No, I think that's actually spot on. If we put the customer at the center of all that we collectively do, agents, carriers, technology providers, there's a lot of work for us still to do. We're all interacting in the service of the customer each and every day, whether that's a simple transaction like paying a bill, the customer trying to change their policy online, or a claims filing. Yet the way we communicate and share data between agency management systems and carriers still isn't quite in real time. A lot of it is still overnight downloads. The ability for us to continue to meet customer needs is really important. I would love for us to continue to come together and drive real solutions to meet customers' expectations, which are only getting higher.
We work too hard in the independent agency system to bring customers in. We have to make sure we're providing a differentiated experience. It really is going to take all of us to solve that. We mentioned the complexity. There are 36 agents in the country, 350 carriers operating in the independent agency system, and any number of technology providers. Some have rating software from one vendor and AMS from another. When you look at the combinations and permutations of tech stacks, it's a really complex problem. But if you come back to mutual beneficial partnerships, if you come back to being aligned on the mission, it has to be in service of the customer. There has to be ways for us to make sure that carrier systems and the data we collect is being shared with agents when they need it to provide exceptional service, and vice versa. I think there's still a lot for us to do in that space. Individually, we've all made tremendous progress on empowering agents. Together, we have an opportunity to truly transform the way we do business and the way we differentiate ourselves from the direct channel.
Ryan Hanley
Matt.
Matt Masiello
I'm going to start where Tyler ended, which was service. I think service is an area that we haven't solved for that we really need to. It's that value proposition. You think about Amy talking about connectivity, and we talk about the consumer, the agency, and the company. When we look at an independent agency, we break it down into four sections: marketing, operations, sales, and service. We look at what digital capabilities or new capabilities we can provide into each of those segments. We suggest agencies measure themselves on how they're doing in those four areas.
Staying on service, we're not yet giving the consumer what they want relative to service. Some of that is because we're not evolving our business model. We as this industry need to figure out how we're going to service this business moving forward. Is it the connectivity and giving them the ability to do it themselves through interfacing with our AMS or mobile apps? Is it carrier self-service in DIY? Is it carrier service centers? Is it agency VAs, which we're seeing as a big growth trend right now? To a certain degree, agencies still need to be able to advocate for their consumers when those other things don't work.
I'm a big believer that not only do we as agencies need to find our value proposition in the insurance cycle as technology and digitization continues to come in, we also need to recognize that we need to find our value proposition for the carriers we do business with. It's not being staffed for service. It is being staffed for sales and business development and productive, meaningful interactions with our customers and clients. Service and getting that figured out, what the right mix is that's right for the consumer. We hear a lot of agencies say, "My clients still want to talk to me." But the basic fact is most of the calls that go into the service centers are when agencies aren't open. A lot of consumers, if we think about ourselves in our own lives, we're busy. We want to do these things at night or on the weekend. We want to be able to go into the carrier system or into the agency's AMS platform to do these things. We're not solved. We're heading in the right direction, but we're not solving for that.
I always tend to steal a little bit of your thunder, Ryan, on this one. We have to use digital capabilities, but we have to human optimize them for when somebody wants to talk to a human being. This service thing, we've got to solve for it. At the end of the day, if we solve or get better on how we're providing better service capabilities to our customers when and where they want it, it gives us the ability to go after the business that's out there that might be in the exclusive channel, might even be some business in the direct channel. It allows us to compete better and be more efficient and agile in our businesses.
Ryan Hanley
Every time someone says "human optimized," I have to get a check in the mail for $20.
The podcaster in me can't help it. I have to comment on a couple things because there was so much in those answers that I thought was tremendous. One, here's the solution to carrier service centers. The first carrier that is willing to service other carriers' business without getting their hooks into that business wins the carrier service center game. The reason carrier service centers, especially on the commercial line side, have not taken off is that there are too many accounts that have multiple carrier accounts. The minute you have a multiple carrier account, the carrier service center model falls apart. That's the answer to that. Whoever wants to take that from a carrier perspective and run with it, the first one to do it wins. Carrier service centers are an incredible resource. The minute there's a multi-carrier solution, it doesn't work.
The reason we haven't figured out service from my perspective is because we don't ask. It's actually simpler than all of that stuff. We don't ask how they want to be serviced. We force whatever solution we feel is best down our consumers' throats. That is a big part of the reason why I think adoption of tools like Glovebox, carrier service centers, and other things haven't taken off. Agency VAs, it's because you're never going to have 100% of your client base using any one of those. It's really going to be a set of tools. You need to ask your customer how they want to be serviced. My dad is going to want to call, but my mom actually likes automated tools. She would use a login thing. My dad still doesn't want to believe the internet exists. If you want both of those pieces of business, you need to have both options.
Here is my question for you guys. This just hit me as you were talking. If we're talking about connectivity, it feels like everyone's trying to address this in a slightly different way. There is a carrier-centric connectivity model where we're doing everything inside of the carrier dashboards. Liberty has a very robust carrier dashboard. You can do all kinds of servicing and selling. You guys would probably be on the more innovative side of the spectrum. There's agent-centric models, which would be agencies having their own user portal and pulling all that connectivity into the agency or maybe through an AMS like AMS 360 or QQ. Then there's third-party centric, which would be a tool like Glovebox where the connectivity is a third party. In a perfect world, which one of those models is it? All three models can't work. If we're trying to actually be connected, all three can't work. Where do we see this going? Is it carrier-centric, agent-centric, or third-party?
Tyler Asher
There's the "where is it going" and the "what to do now." Right now, the biggest gap is making sure that we're serving customers in the way they need to be served today. If you look at customer NPS and customer attention, it is higher, materially higher, for customers that engage online digital capabilities for service, whether that's an app or an online portal. We see that in our data. My advice to agents is we have to provide that to customers. If agents have a solution, either they're getting it from a different technology provider or they've done it through a mobile app like Glovebox, fantastic. If an agent doesn't have their own capabilities, push carrier capabilities. The most important thing right now is that we give customers what they need. We have worked too hard for a customer to have a better service experience from a direct channel because the direct carrier is pushing that as the only option. The experience at the end of the day is what the customer needs and what they're expecting. They need to get it some way.
In terms of ultimately, are we going to play or is there going to be one particular end zone? I don't know. Right now, we've been open to all of it. We have proprietary capabilities we're providing. We have integrations with third parties. We have integrations with agencies to provide those services to their clients. There are pros and cons. The carrier-centric approach is built into our system and our processes. You have native experiences that in some cases are a little bit more robust, not because we're not open to making integrations tighter, but because it's an investment. If we're going to invest in APIs to go soup to nuts through the entire claims process and embed that in a third-party platform, we have to have the return on investment to do that. That's been a little bit more of a challenge to get the same level of extensive experiences and services built. From a carrier standpoint, it's a native experience, which sometimes will provide more functionality.
That said, to your point, Ryan, on the commercial side, if there is a commercial account that's split across carriers, that's maybe not an ideal solution for an app where they only have part of the account. In personal lines, we're more likely to have the entire household, so those experiences are a little bit more robust. The most important thing from my standpoint is that together we remain open and flexible and that we continue to give agents options, whether that's to empower the tools they're looking to build or whether that's by leveraging carrier tools where customers can use them today to get that benefit.
Ryan Hanley
Does anyone have any additive comments, or can I rapid fire a few of these other questions at you? We'll go rapid fire.
Audience murmurs in agreement
Cool. I have a couple of questions from the audience that I'm going to hit real quick. We have four minutes, so let's try to punch the answers if you can. Matt, I'm going to go to you with this one. Joe asks, "What are two action steps that an independent agency can take that wants to scale their business in the 21st century?"
You may or may not have written a book that addressed some of these particular topics.
Matt Masiello
Yeah, I mean, there's more than two. But if I had to pick two out of the gate, I would say lead generation and digitization. Those two things are related. We just broke down all the service needs. Servicing your business is an obstacle to scaling your growth. But to really grow, you need to take a look at the digital resources that are out there and get them into your agency. That includes building a digital brand, whether you're in a geographic market or a digital market, to grow your business and generate the leads and prospective interactions with clients that your carriers want to write. Technology levels the playing field. There are a lot of small agencies out there. We do business with many of them that look a hell of a lot bigger than they are because they use digital capabilities to scale and look, act, and execute much bigger than they are.
Ryan Hanley
Awesome. Amy, I'm going to kick this one to you, as much as you're able or willing to offer insights. Future of staffing, CSRs. You probably see this in the logins that people are adding to the system, where they're trying to access people from. What are you seeing from the standard questions you're getting around VAs? There's also a guy I just interviewed who is building digital VAs, like bots that are going into AMSs and doing automated processes, which may not even be legal. I don't know. Is it straight, local, American, licensed CSRs, or are there other staffing options out there? What are you seeing and what are your thoughts?
Amy Zupan
Totally. I think the answer is all of the above. We're seeing a bit of everything, to be honest with you. There are still a lot of people at the large end building their own service centers and trying to create that internally. There are people using offshore resources to do some of that. We see people investing in robotics processing to do some of the more standard tasks, ultimately to get rid of the order-taking type of activity that a CSR might have to do. They're trying to free up their resources to do more value-add things by automating some of these processes. To be honest with you, there is a ton of opportunity there. Nobody has done that in a productized way that everyone could leverage. But when you look at what some of the individual companies are doing, you can obviously see there is a lot of opportunity. And then there is still a lot of CSR hiring going on across the board. Employment growth is going up in the independent channel consistently, and a chunk of those folks are still CSRs.
Ryan Hanley
I will say from our own hiring at Rogue, if you are struggling to find high quality service people, look to younger moms and dads who have young kids at home. Most likely, some old traditional agency has punted them, and they're just sitting out there dying to come in and rock star your agency. If you're willing to have a remote employee or someone with flexible hours, there is a tremendous amount of talent sitting on the sidelines because they don't fit the traditional 8 to 4:30 mindset of a CSR. That's one way we found some incredible people on our team. Just something to keep in mind.
Ryan Hanley turns to the panel
Guys, Matt, Amy, Tyler, I want to thank you so much. I know how valuable your time is. I know that we're all busy. It's the middle of the day on a Tuesday. I appreciate you being here and sharing your thoughts. It was a pleasure and an honor to share the virtual stage with all of you.
Matt Masiello
Thanks for having us.
Amy Zupan
Thank you very much.
Tyler Asher
Thanks for having me. Cheers.
End of panel discussion. Promotional message begins.
Narrator
Close twice as many deals by this time next week. Sound impossible? It's not. With the One Call Close System, you'll stop chasing leads and start closing deals in one call. This is the exact method we use to close 1,200 clients in under three years during the pandemic. No fluff, no endless follow-ups, just results fast. Based in behavioral psychology and battle tested, the One Call Close System eliminates excuses and gets the prospect saying yes more than you ever thought possible. If you're ready to stop losing opportunities and start winning, visit MasterTheClothes.com. That's MasterTheClothes.com. Do it today.