Main Topic: New York's failed marijuana legalization, Spotify's parting ways with Meghan Markle, and the Supreme Court's ruling on Native American adoption.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Georgia Howe
New York's legalization of marijuana promised hundreds of millions in tax revenues, but their high hopes are falling far short of their projected goal.
John Bickley
We break down why critics say New York's woke agenda reduced the program to ash. I'm Georgia Howe with Daily Wire editor-in-chief John Bickley. It's June 24th, and this is a Saturday edition of Morning Wire.
Georgia Howe
Meghan Markle and Spotify have announced that they'll be parting ways ending a multi-year, multi-million dollar podcast deal. People should expect the real me in this and probably the me that they've never gotten to know.
John Bickley
What sunk the Duchess of Sussex? And the Supreme Court has ruled on who can adopt Native American children, settling a tug of war between Native and non-Native families. So this is a case, I think, that pits individual rights of children against the rights of the tribes.
Georgia Howe
Thanks for waking up with Morning Wire. Stay tuned. We have the news you need to know.
Short pause
New York State is not seeing the windfall that it had hoped for when it legalized recreational sales of marijuana in December of last year. The Empire State is not even projected to raise a predicted $56 million in taxes this year as illegal sales continue to flourish.
John Bickley
Here to discuss is Daily Wire contributor David Marcus.
David Marcus
Hey, morning. It certainly is. And the answer is really everything. The huge mistake was basically decriminalizing the sale of weed before setting up the licensing system that allowed just a handful of stores to open in December.
Georgia Howe
Selling drugs is generally known as a pretty profitable business. What exactly is New York getting wrong?
David Marcus
Yeah, morning. It certainly is. And the answer is really everything. The huge mistake was basically decriminalizing the sale of weed before setting up the licensing system that allowed just a handful of stores to open in December.
Georgia Howe
In the meantime, thousands of stores, many of which are what in New York City are called bodegas, just started selling wheat, right? New Yorkers got used to it and none of that money is taxed.
David Marcus
Now the state is in a position where it has to crack down on these unlicensed sellers when one of the biggest reasons for legalization was to keep police from arresting people for selling marijuana.
Georgia Howe
The whole thing just went up in smoke, so to speak.
David Marcus
I see what you did there. How did this happen? Other states have managed this successfully. Why are there so few licensed cannabis shops in New York?
Georgia Howe
Yeah, this is where critics point to what they call the woke element of New York's legal marijuana regime. The state decided that licenses should only go to people who had previously been convicted on marijuana charges as a kind of reparations for those arrests.
David Marcus
So instead of a straightforward regulatory scheme where anyone could invest in a store, it became a nightmare of applications and deciding who had been oppressed enough to qualify.
Georgia Howe
Ultimately, after more than a year, only about a dozen legal shops were able to open.
David Marcus
All right, so sort of DEI run amok here. How does the lackluster revenue in New York compare to states that have more successfully regulated retail marijuana sales?
Georgia Howe
Oh, it's not close. I mean, this should be a money printing machine. California raised almost $400 million last year. Illinois, which is closer in size to New York, about $216 million.
David Marcus
So, I mean, $50 million, if they even get there, that's a joke. This is like a state losing money on the lottery. It's almost inconceivable.
Georgia Howe
And to add insult to injury, New York State is still recovering from the economic disaster that was the COVID lockdowns. A few extra million in Albany coffers would go a long way but apparently that is not to be
David Marcus
Aside from the fiscal shortfall has the failure of the state to scale up a legal retail system contributed to quality of life issues that nag the state, especially New York City?
Georgia Howe
Absolutely. Now, I'll tell you a story. When I was covering the governor's race last fall, Lee Zeldin had an event in Union Square. He's there flanked by cops, the media, and literally 20 feet behind him was a guy with a folding table selling loose joints.
David Marcus
I mean, it's like the wallpaper. It's just there all around you. And obviously, this is exactly what legalization was meant to do away with, along with criminal gangs who are still very much in control of this still very illegal weed industry in New York.
Georgia Howe
I mean, among other things, this is one of the last big moneymakers for the New York City mafia.
David Marcus
Can this be fixed or is the die cast? Could a new regulatory regime be put up that can make this work for the state?
Georgia Howe
Maybe. I mean, in some sense, they're just starting from scratch. Since the vast, vast majority of marijuana sales are still illegal.
David Marcus
Look, the only way to change this is to make it easier, much easier for individuals or companies to set up shop, even if that means that allegedly historically marginalized people are not centered in the policy, as the left would say.
Georgia Howe
It just has to be treated like a normal business. And thus far, that certainly has not been the case.
David Marcus
We want a deeply progressive state like New York. It's hard to see that happening.
Georgia Howe
Dave, thanks for joining us.
David Marcus
Thanks for having me.
Georgia Howe
Last week, Spotify and the Duke and Duchess of Sussex announced that they were mutually parting ways. New information is now emerging on why the $20 million deal ended early.
John Bickley
Daily Wire culture reporter Megan Basham joins us now to give us the inside scoop on Harry and Megan and what this could tell us about the podcasting industry.
Megan Basham
So Megan, this was supposed to be a multi-year deal. It was announced to huge fanfare back in 2020. What happened?
Georgia Howe
Yeah, that is the $20 million question. So basically, this just looks like an issue of Harry and Meghan not providing the content that Spotify thought it was buying.
Megan Basham
So they signed this deal in late 2020. And at the time, the word was that the first full Archwell audio release, that's the name of their production company, that it would be in 2021. Well, that never happened.
Georgia Howe
And during that time, all they produced was this half hour, pretty star-studded holiday special.
Megan Basham
So then the word was that Spotify was going to hire a team to help the Sussexes create these podcasts. Then in late summer of 2022, they did release 12 episodes of Megan's interview style program Archetypes, where she would have celebrity guests explore the, quote, labels that try to hold women back.
Georgia Howe
Paris Hilton was on one of those, breaking down the word bimbo, for example.
Megan Basham
Now, initially it debuted at number one on the podcast charts, and Markle did win a People's Choice Award for it.
Georgia Howe
But apparently the internal numbers Spotify was seeing weren't especially strong over the length of the series.
Megan Basham
And then adding a little bit more controversy to this, the industry publication Pod News published a report on Monday claiming that Markle didn't actually interview all of her guests.
Georgia Howe
For some of those episodes, she reportedly had her staff sit in for her and then she would independently record her questions later and they would be dubbed in.
Megan Basham
Bill Simmons is the head of podcast innovation and monetization at Spotify. And he also has his own podcast.
Georgia Howe
Well, this was what he said last Friday about the Duke and Duchess.
Megan Basham
I going to pose this question to you You do a lot of business deals a lot of negotiations I wish I had been involved in the Megan and Harry leave Spotify negotiation The f grifters That the podcast we should have launched with them I got to get drunk one night and tell the story of the Zoom I had with Harry to try to help him with a podcast idea. Do it! It's one of my best stories.
Georgia Howe
Now, Simmons didn't tell any more of that story, but he did later reiterate his view that they were grifters.
Megan Basham
And essentially, people close to the situation have been telling various news outlets that Harry and Meghan likely didn't receive their full payout because they failed to meet their productivity benchmarks.
Georgia Howe
Now, even if they had produced more content, was it ever realistic to think that it'd be worth $20 million just from like a business perspective?
Megan Basham
You know, that is a very good question because while there's certainly a gossipy element to this story, it does also point to something that's a little more significant happening in the industry.
Georgia Howe
To your point, it's that much like Netflix and streamers, Spotify really does seem to have spent too much money on content deals too fast.
Megan Basham
And now it is having to tighten its belt. So the company recently laid off about 6% of its workforce.
Georgia Howe
And a lot of those came from the very podcasting companies and content producers that Spotify spent more than a billion buying up over the last few years.
Megan Basham
And really, just like with streaming, the challenge has been how do they monetize all of that podcast content?
Georgia Howe
During a conference call with financial analysts earlier this year, Spotify chief executive Daniel Ek admitted that the company had gone on too much of a spending spree.
Megan Basham
He told investors that they were right to call the company out for, quote, overpaying and overinvesting.
Georgia Howe
And he said that Spotify is going to have to be more cautious in how it invests in future content deals.
Megan Basham
As for Markle, her team says she is planning to go forward with archetypes on another platform.
Georgia Howe
All right. Well, Megan, you know I'm excited to tune in.
Megan Basham
All right, Megan, thanks for reporting.
Georgia Howe
Anytime.
The Supreme Court last week upheld a controversial adoption law that requires states to treat Native American children differently from children of other ethnicities. Several non-Native families are challenging the law.
John Bickley
Daily Wire investigative reporter, Maraid Elordi is here with the details for us.
Maraid Elordi
Hi, Georgia. Sure. So the Supreme Court upheld a law called the 1978 Indian Child Welfare Act. This law puts Native American families at the front of the line when it comes to adopting Native children.
Georgia Howe
We spoke to conservative commentator Naomi Schaefer Riley about the circumstances that brought about this law to begin with.
Maraid Elordi
There was a sense that we were sort of seeing conditions in Indian communities and taking children away from their families because we were so horrified by the conditions that they were living in.
Georgia Howe
But not that there was anything wrong with the families or the way that they were trying to parent their children.
Maraid Elordi
And many of these kids ended up in Indian boarding schools. So the purpose of the law was to prevent unnecessary separation of Native families and to preserve Native American culture.
Georgia Howe
But critics argue it doesn't actually work in the interest of the child.
Maraid Elordi
For example, the law allows tribal leaders to remove a child who has been living with a caring non-Native family and place the child with a Native family, even if the Native family is of a different tribe than the child.
Georgia Howe
Even the wishes of the child's biological parents can be overridden if they want their child with a specific family that happens to be of another race.
Maraid Elordi
Several couples challenged that law. Jennifer and Chad Brackeen a white Christian couple from Texas were one of those couples They had fostered a nine boy and tried to adopt him after a year which the boy parents supported But his parents tribes the Navajo and Cherokee tribes both opposed the adoption so the child was ordered to be removed from his foster family and placed with an unrelated native family.
Georgia Howe
The Brackines filed an emergency stay to keep their son, and ultimately the tribes backed down in 2018.
Maraid Elordi
But the controversy continued after the boy's birth mother gave birth to his half-sister, and placed her up for adoption as well. The Bratkeens argued that the girl should be kept with her brother while the Navajo tried to place her with a distant Native relative.
Georgia Howe
The Supreme Court upheld the law in a 7-2 decision last week with Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito dissenting.
Maraid Elordi
So this law only applies to children of Native American descent, correct?
Georgia Howe
That's right. And Riley did address that part of the issue.
Maraid Elordi
This law has been challenged a couple of times now up to the Supreme Court. And one of the reasons for that is because it treats Indian children differently from other American children.
Georgia Howe
Indian children are American citizens, just like all Indians are. And so the question is, could you treat them differently based on their ethnicity or their race?
Maraid Elordi
Now, there are some left-wing groups that are very invested in this case. Why is that? Why is there so much progressive interest around this?
Georgia Howe
Well, according to Riley, the progressive activists claim to represent Native American tribal interests because, as I mentioned, they believe the law will prevent Native children from being separated from their culture.
Maraid Elordi
But that sometimes comes at the expense of the children. Here's Riley again.
Georgia Howe
This is for children who are not even living on a reservation, who may not have ever set foot on a reservation, who may have one 128th of their ancestry may be Indian.
Maraid Elordi
And so the tribe is sort of trying to expand its power at the expense of the individual rights and I think the safety of these children.
Georgia Howe
And so when you want to understand kind of the politics of this, the left wing groups are often siding with the racial and ethnic interest groups in our country over the rights of individuals who may or may not feel that they are represented by that leadership.
Maraid Elordi
Riley added that the abuse standard for removing non-Native American children from their homes is much lower.
Georgia Howe
I think once a state sort of establishes a set of standards, like if we say we really need to be careful about removing that child because they're Indian. I mean, this has resulted in dozens, not hundreds of cases of more abuse and neglect on Indian children and fatalities, frankly, because we have decided these kids need to be left in these homes at all costs.
Maraid Elordi
There is a grand kind of consensus among a lot of social workers and family court judges and lawyers out there that transracial adoption is harmful to kids.
Georgia Howe
And it is essentially better to keep them in the foster care system than having them be adopted by a white family.
Maraid Elordi
The evidence does not support this. When you compare apples to apples, what you find is that there is nothing about transracial adoption that is more traumatic than same race adoption.
Georgia Howe
Overall, we should expect more challenges, especially since the Supreme Court's ruling did not answer the question of whether the law discriminates against non-Native families based on race.
Maraid Elordi
All right. Well, Maureen, thanks so much for reporting.
Georgia Howe
Thanks, Georgia. That's all the time we've got this morning. Thanks for waking up with us.
John Bickley
We'll be back this afternoon with an extra edition of Morning Wire.
Theme music fades in