The podcast episode discusses various topics, including the Facebook Oversight Board, the sale of Yahoo and AOL to a private equity firm, and antitrust issues with Apple and Google.
The main topic of the episode is the Facebook Oversight Board, which is an independent board that makes decisions about content moderation on Facebook. The hosts, Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway, discuss their skepticism about the board's effectiveness and its potential to be influenced by Facebook's interests.
The episode also covers the sale of Yahoo and AOL to a private equity firm, Apollo, for $5 billion. Scott Galloway expresses his skepticism about the deal, citing the poor management of both companies in the past and the lack of synergy between them.
The hosts then turn to the topic of antitrust issues with Apple and Google. They discuss the upcoming trial between Epic Games and Apple, which could have significant implications for the app market and the dominance of Apple's App Store. Scott Galloway argues that Apple's 30% commission on app sales is a form of monopoly abuse and that the company should be subject to regulation.
The episode features an interview with Senator Amy Klobuchar, who discusses her book "Antitrust: Taking on Monopoly Power from the Gilded Age to the Digital Age." Senator Klobuchar argues that the term "antitrust" is outdated and that a more forward-looking approach is needed to address issues of competition and monopoly power. She also discusses the importance of working with other countries to develop common standards for regulating big tech companies.
The hosts also discuss the sale of Clubhouse, a social media app, and compare it to Yahoo, which was recently sold for $5 billion. Scott Galloway argues that Clubhouse is a feature, not a company, and that it will likely be worth less than $1 billion within a year.
The episode also features a discussion about COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy among some Republican men, which Scott Galloway views as a "fail" on the part of the country. He argues that vaccine passports could be an effective way to encourage people to get vaccinated, but that it may be difficult to implement.
Key points from the episode include:
Participants in the episode include:
Takeaways from the episode include:
Ad reads - two separate ads
Kara Swisher
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And I'm Scott Galloway.
Kara Swisher
Hey, it's a big week, Scott. This is a big week. The Facebook board just said it was coming down with this decision whether Trump should be banned or not. We had to have a take. We're going to talk about it, obviously, on Thursday because I think it's Thursday at 9. So we'll have an ability to discuss this. But I want your bet right now. Right now.
Scott Galloway
My bet? Your bet on whether they're going to keep them off or on. They're going to remain banned. My bet is that Facebook will live up to its roots of not showing any regard for the Commonwealth and pretending that they're the town square and wrapped himself in this bullshit First Amendment cloak and come up with some sort of conditional blah blah about him returning because they think they can sell more Nissan ads. I think that they'll decide to kind of slowly let him back on. Slowly.
Kara Swisher
This is the Facebook Oversight Board. They are independent of Facebook.
Scott Galloway
Oh, God. I'm supposed to say that. Facebook Oversight Board. Jesus Christ.
Kara Swisher
I got in a fight with one of them yesterday because they won't give me. I texted one of the journalists on it, and they're like, "You shouldn't be reaching out to our board members." I'm like, "He's a journalist." They're just like, the people who run the Oversight Board PR are just like Facebook itself. It's really amazing. They are a different PR group, but they're exactly the same.
Scott Galloway
The Facebook Oversight Board. That's like when I was the political action director for the Potrero Hill Democrats and I talked myself into believing I had relevance and realized I was just around a bunch of other people desperate for relevance. It's hard for me to imagine something with less relevance than the Facebook Oversight Board. In any case, I agree with you. I think they're going to let them back on.
Kara Swisher
Are you really? I think so. And then we'll have to endure Ben Shapiro and Candace Owens going on, et cetera, et cetera. I think they're going to let them on. I do. And do you think that's good or bad?
Scott Galloway
I think it's an international board, and so they don't have quite the same. They're going to try to use the example of what if Facebook decided to take off if this is an awful precedent.
Kara Swisher
I'm like, it's not. It's this one guy who keeps breaking the rules. I don't know why it's a precedent. When someone murders someone, it's not a precedent for murder necessarily. I just think they're going to use it, as you're right, as a big old cloak of other stuff that has no relevance to one single person who misuses the platforms.
Scott Galloway
Thank you. Yeah, no, this has almost as much impact and relevance as when I sit down and have a serious discussion around how to alter my 10-year-old's behavior. It makes me feel better that I actually think I have some control over this thing called my son.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
And then the next day it's like, wait, didn't we have a conversation about this?
Kara Swisher
Oh, speaking of children, you know, I was in my front yard, I was washing down some winter dust off my house. There's a lot of pollen.
Scott Galloway
Could you be more of a lesbian? Would you go to Home Depot and get one of those huge tractor trailers to put shit on it?
Kara Swisher
No, I was just washing things down. And Clara was out in the yard because she likes when I do that. And we were watering the plants and stuff. And two guys go by and they go, "Oh, my God, it's you. And that's the angel, the golden child." And huge fans, huge fans live in the neighborhood, neighbors apparently, and asked how you were. And it was lovely. It was a lovely encounter.
Scott Galloway
Oh, my God. I know. That is nice. I like when that happens. They were like, "Where's Gigantor?" And it's like characters. They're like, "Oh, look." Even I'm sick of us and I love us.
Kara Swisher
We should move back to the Facebook Oversight Board. Scott, they're not sick of us.
Scott Galloway
Foss.
Kara Swisher
I'm telling you. They love us.
Scott Galloway
Foss. Seriously, this Facebook Oversight Board, it's going to have the effectiveness of the UN with, I don't know, the charm of the League of Nations. I mean, it's just, Jesus Christ. It's going to be 20% more effective than the League of Nations.
Kara Swisher
All right. So that's going to be our bet, and we'll see what happens. Maybe we'll be pleasantly surprised that they're going to do it.
Scott Galloway
They're not. It's too much of an international board for them to do anything that is actually following the rules of Facebook.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, the other thing, speaking of irrelevance, Verizon is selling Yahoo and AOL to a private equity firm called Apollo. You know Apollo, run by Leon Black, who had gotten into some trouble with the Jeffrey Epstein situation. It's for $5 billion. Scott, what does this say? I was, several AOL people wrote me saying, "It looks like you were right back then when you called this a ridiculous sham." And I got in a lot of trouble from Tim Armstrong and the Verizon CEO at the time. So what do we think about this?
Scott Galloway
So just some disclosures. I invested with Apollo and Gannett. I like Gannett. I like local newspapers and journalism and all that's good stuff. So I know those guys. And Tim Armstrong is one of my investors. Okay. So having said all of that, and by the way, I haven't spoken to anybody regarding any of this. This never made any sense. AT&T, telcos' adventures in media just hasn't worked. Verticalization is really powerful, but when your company is basically the mother of all tails wagging the dog, the tail and the dog here are these incredible recurring revenue firms called telcos that have amazing businesses. And then you look at 5G, which is super exciting. And no one is really, big tech has not figured out, big tech has sort of decided with all the lobbyists and the investments and kind of stealing the ground that the telcos have made, they haven't started disrupting that business, if you will. And all these guys thought, "We'll go vertical into content." But nobody buys AT&T or Verizon to get Yahoo or HBO. They just never really took seriously the notion of trying to integrate them and create a source of differentiation. And they're all basically trying to sell them.
Kara Swisher
Well, AT&T seems more committed, and Comcast has certainly worked out. They've owned NBC and the rest of it for a long time.
Scott Galloway
That's actually a fair point. So would you say Comcast?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, that's a good point. They went vertical and maybe you could argue that's working. But they're sort of in adjacent businesses. You know what I mean? You can see their, not necessarily synergies, but that they do understand content. They do have some passing knowledge of content.
Scott Galloway
I like the CMO of Verizon. I've known him for a while and he asked me to speak at one of their big town halls with all the marketers. And I said, "Stop wasting time in media." They did one of these pre-calls. Basically pre-calls and I'm speaking somewhere to see just how fucking crazy I'm going to be and if they should cancel. And I said, "I'm going to say, you should just focus on 5G, your entire marketing strategy." They came up with all this stuff we should market to disenfranchised communities. I'm like, "No, your entire marketing campaign should be three things: 5G, 5G, and 5G. Everyone's excited about getting their shit done faster." And I said, "You should get out of media." And then what do you know? So you're like, stick to your knitting.
Kara Swisher
Okay.
Scott Galloway
And then the next day I get one of those, "We have decided to reformat the discussion and we'll have you at a later time." I get a lot of this.
Kara Swisher
They wanted both of us. I had to turn that down because I really forgot about it.
Scott Galloway
Well, you could have gotten canceled too. So anyway, I'm out. I never spoke. They clearly knew they were about to shed. But think about this. This is an asset. I love Yahoo. Yahoo is still where I go for finance. And I think they do a great job. I like Yahoo Live. I think Yahoo is a really valuable property. It is the fourth most trafficked site in the world.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, finances.
Scott Galloway
And it just went for $5 billion. And numbers three, two, and one are all worth a trillion dollars or more. And so you have numbers one, two, and three. I think it's Google, Facebook, and what's the third one? Fuck, I don't know.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
But they're a trillion. And then there's number four, Yahoo, that just got purchased for $5 billion.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. So I think there's true. And you get AOL too.
Scott Galloway
What do I literally have no idea? There's all kinds of really interesting little gems in there. What do people use AOL for? What? Is it dial-up if you live in Kansas somewhere?
Kara Swisher
Dial-up was still a good business, I'll tell you. It didn't die that quickly. Let me just say, when this happened, you and I both know Tim Armstrong very well. And I like Tim Armstrong. And he's now into other things, direct-to-consumer stuff, DTC stuff he's doing. But this was, I have to say, he and I wrangled quite a bit over what he was doing here. I thought it was crazy. I thought it was ridiculous. It was sort of like a duck, not a duck-billed platypus. What's that animal that you put together, all the animal parts together? I think I used to call it that.
Scott Galloway
That's a platypus, yeah.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, whatever. It just was crazy. I was like, "This doesn't make any sense. There's no synergy here." And then he kept, you know, he stuck on the Huffington Post first and then AOL and Yahoo and then blah, blah, blah. It just went on and on and on. And at one point he even acquired about Recode and I was like, "I just don't even understand what you're doing." And everybody would leave. I don't know what to say, although I would enjoy the giant sum of money you gave me. It was just, it made zero sense whatsoever. It was, both those properties were mismanaged for years, right? Both Yahoo and AOL. And had been at the forefront of the internet, no question, and did all kinds of personalization on Yahoo, AOL, bringing consumer to the internet, essentially. But when Verizon bought it, it just made, like, I wrote a lot of people, "You're working for the phone company. That's great for you." No sense.
Scott Galloway
No, Tim Armstrong did his job. Tim Armstrong sold a bag of shit for a lot of money. And Marissa Mayer is arguably, I think, one of the worst tech CEOs of the last 20 years, worst acquisition in technology. Tumblr purchased within 60 days of what I think Instagram was purchased for, but for $100 million more. And it was sold, I think, for $3 million. They bought it for $1.1 billion and sold it for $3 million. I mean, that's up there with like Bebo-style bad acquisitions.
Kara Swisher
That was an AOL special. That was Randy, someone or other. Time Warner bought Bebo. I mean, it's just, it's really interesting. Time Warner is the Kevin Bacon of terrible acquisitions.
Scott Galloway
So Time Warner made the worst acquisition probably in history, $160 billion of AOL. Think about that. That's about, I think, what AOL was purchased for. It was not quite an acquisition, but go ahead.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Or murder. Well, who was on top? Basically, all the AOL people got fired, which means someone is always the a liar. I did do an entire book on it, but go ahead. Keep going. Please tell me about it.
Scott Galloway
All right. I'm sorry. Go ahead. No. Tell me what the 383 people who read that book got to learn.
Kara Swisher
Oh, no way. That one did well.
Scott Galloway
Did it do well?
Kara Swisher
Yes, that one did very well.
Scott Galloway
What was that called?
Kara Swisher
Both of them did really well. One was called "AOL.com." That was the first one in '97. And the second one was "There Must Be a Pony in Here Somewhere."
Scott Galloway
Now we're both about AOL?
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, one was about the rise. And nobody had ever heard of AOL when I wrote that book. And then the second one was about the fall. And then I declined to do a third. But here would it be. A trilogy on AOL.
Scott Galloway
A trilogy. Oh, my God. Oh, well.
Kara Swisher
And then you sold the film rights to Amazon.
Scott Galloway
I did. I sold the film rights. I did. Good for you.
Kara Swisher
I think I bought a car with it. Anyway, it's a mess. And what will Apollo do with it since you know these guys?
Scott Galloway
So I don't know what they plan to do with it. What do they want? What I will do, I will call, I'm not exaggerating, I will call Apollo this afternoon or tomorrow. And I said they should merge it with Gannett and try and focus on offline and online media. And, I mean, Gannett right now is trading at a market cap of $600 million. I think between Yahoo and newspaper properties. God, you've got to have someone special around that disaster. Like, that is hard to knit together. That would be tough.
Kara Swisher
That would be tough. Yeah, you're right. That would be tough. That would be tough.
Scott Galloway
But look, I think Yahoo at $5 billion.
Kara Swisher
I'd like to call it Yahoo. It's Yahoo. Tomato, tomatoes. Yahoo. Remember that?
Scott Galloway
Hey, I'm trying to—
Kara Swisher
Yet another hierarchical organizational office.
Scott Galloway
I'm trying to assuage your penitentiary here.
Kara Swisher
I think that's what it stands for. Yet another hierarchical, officious oracle. I think that's what it stands for.
Scott Galloway
Yahoo at $5 billion is a massively undervalued asset.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. I agree.
Scott Galloway
Matt, fourth most traffic internet site in the world for $5 billion? I think you and I should run it right into a wall and then overpay ourselves.
Kara Swisher
All right. Last one. Basecamp employees. Man, this little tiny little story has gotten more attention. Casey Newton was telling me he got like 1,000 new followers from this story, which is arguably a very small little company. But it's really hit a nerve, I have to say, with lots of people. And not just Twitter. Lots of people are talking about it. Basecamp employees have resigned. A third of them, a staff of 60, have resigned from the company following the founder's controversial memo over internal—
Scott Galloway
A third of them. Is that like nine people?
Kara Swisher
No, it's like 20. But it's all the top people. It's really interesting. It's like the marketing head of—and when they said their goodbyes on the Twitter, they're all like, "Having been here for 12 years, having been here for 13 years, having been here, you know, having built the first product," they lost some big names there. People had been there a long time, so something wasn't going right over there in the camp. So it turns out it's not what the money's for. I guess they did a lot of money. People were mad about you.
Scott Galloway
Well, first off, those people have a lot of options. They can go almost anywhere. But I think when you have that kind of defection, it's more reflection on the fact they don't like the person running the company. Or something. They were there for a long time. But what I don't get is, and explain this to me, why do we care? This is a 60-person company. I have to tell you, everybody was talking about the story. Why do we care about it?
Kara Swisher
Not just the media, you know, the internet media people. Lots of people knew about it. It's striking a chord with this how much can we talk in public thing. It's linked to all kinds of issues around race, around sexism, around behavior. I think it—and control of people, I think. You know what I mean? I think it just has a bigger resonance. I'm trying to get the two founders to come on Sway or here or anywhere, but they won't now. They said they would, but now they won't because they say they said too much, which I think they said too much. And so it's a really, and they're also really well known for lecturing Silicon Valley on company culture. And so I don't know, it's a really interesting thing. I think everyone's coming out of the pandemic and they're like, "What?" I don't know.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I don't, it's like, it's, there's, I mean, we talk about a lot of stories I have no interest in, but this ranks right up there. I just, it's a company.
Kara Swisher
Not so for everyone else. I agree. I just don't. And you think it's because it's a larger reflection on whether or not you should bring kind of social justice and political views into your workplace?
Scott Galloway
Well, not just social justice. It's like anything.
Kara Swisher
It's sort of this. Here's what I think at the very base is Silicon Valley has promised people diversity and we're a family and we're like together. We're all together. You're going to get some stock. You're going to have skin in the game. And they've done almost nothing on diversity, but they let people talk. They do do that. They've never not let people talk about it and gripe about it and have memes about it and have big discussions about it. But they've never delivered. So now they're not delivering. And then also you need to shut up. So I think that's what happened. I think that's really at the heart of it. That's my—
Scott Galloway
So under the weakest flexes in the world, I was on the board of Gateway Computer.
Kara Swisher
Oh, wow. Ted White. That guy. I forgot about that guy.
Scott Galloway
I went on after he had left, but the chairman of the board was a guy named Rick Snyder who went on to be the governor of Michigan. Anyways, they had like an all-hands meeting and someone asked me a question as a new director about the Gateway family. And I said, "Well, first off, we're not a family. We're a team. I'm not taking you to soccer practice. And this notion that we're a family I think is misleading."
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
I'm like, "If this company continues to do poorly, we're going to fire a third of our family."
Kara Swisher
Yeah, right.
Scott Galloway
And everyone was very uncomfortable. But I don't—look, I think that maybe—okay, boomer. I don't know. Maybe I just look at the capitalism differently. But I think for-profit entities are mostly about economic security. And I think you want to be purpose-driven. I don't think there's anything wrong with that. And I think it's inspiring all these young CEOs have more of a social conscious. And I think capitalists or companies can be a fantastic means of powerful means of good. But I do think it's kind of swung too far where young people see their company as a platform for social justice issues. And also, there's just no getting around it. There's a certain level of like out of control wokeness involved in all of this, quote unquote, freedom of expression. No one comes to work and expects to be able to talk about gun rights or the rights of the unborn, because that's just not allowed at work. Those political views aren't—
Kara Swisher
It is in some workplaces. It's not true.
Scott Galloway
Where?
Kara Swisher
There's lots of workplaces that are very Christian-oriented.
Scott Galloway
Other than Hobby Lobby and Chick-fil-A, there's two.
Kara Swisher
There's a lot. No, there's a lot. That is not true. I know what you're saying. What tech company, what innovator—I'm going to push back on this one. I think if the capital gets attacked, you should be able to talk about it at work. If you see that video of George Floyd, you should be able to talk about it. I'm sorry. I think that's ridiculous. It's a ridiculous—Our workplace has always been a place where people can talk. There's lots of ways they could have done this without going high on the horse after letting them talk about whatever they want, then saying, "Eh, it's gone too far, say nothing." Are you kidding me? Anyone would have reacted this way. You don't think it's gone—
Scott Galloway
I mean, I agree with you. I remember we did it all hands when I was running Prophet, my old brand strategy firm. I remember the day after 9/11, the leadership and I was the founder, we all spoke about 9/11 and what it meant for the firm, and we had a New York office, but I didn't—this notion that your company—I mean everyone has a right to rent their human labor for whatever reason they want. And if a key criteria is that you want a purpose company and a company that's overtly political, that's your right and companies can fill that void. I just find it strange that there's an expectation.
Kara Swisher
But there's not examples of this. In the case of this case, if you talk to the actual people, they haven't even formed. There was nothing that bad on the company. There was nothing bad happening. They just made it up. I mean, that's what my impression is.
Scott Galloway
Sorry, what did they make up?
Kara Swisher
The idea that there was this roiling discussion among 60 people that was stopping work. It just wasn't happening. The same thing like when Stephanie interviewed the governor of West Virginia. He was going on and on about transgender. And she said, "Give me one example that's been affected." He didn't have one. And these people don't have one. They were not. These people were just—
Scott Galloway
When you say "these people," are you in the management?
Kara Swisher
No, the people at the company were not over abusing the boards. They just weren't. There was maybe a little bit of back and forth that I've seen, but it was not. It's just they just don't want to hear it. And they don't want to. They want it. The problem with this company and it's like a lot of—
Scott Galloway
When you say "the problem with this company," you're talking about the leadership.
Kara Swisher
The leadership, yes. They invited you to speak and then they didn't like what you said. And they also were very acting themselves when they felt like it. So basically it was two guys that are running things that just didn't want to hear other people. And I got to tell you, if I was at a group—after saying we want to hear from you, after saying they want to hear from you, which they didn't really want to do, and they didn't really want to change. And so, like, if I'm looking at a—if I'm at a company, I look at the board, and it's 10 white men, I should be able to say, "Hey, fellas, is that political, or is it just what the hell are you doing?
What is going—why aren't you reflecting your workforce?" I think it's a much bigger issue, and I don't—I think it's very easy to pull words like "woke." It's very easy to say, "Oh, they're social justice warriors. Oh, they're this. Oh, I can't talk at work if I am for abortion." Like that is, they're over. No, everyone on this little train can't talk about anything else because they're getting challenged. And it does go overboard. One hundred percent does it go overboard. But it does not. In this case, they were giving them full rights to talk about it and then told them, then did nothing about the diversity issues that were raised and then said shut up and keep quiet.
I think you brought up that issue repeatedly. If you invite people to speak their mind and encourage and try to be what I'll call politically conscious and weave that into your company's culture, you invite it and you can't just shut it down when you don't like the tapestry or the colors of that weave or that fabric.
Scott Galloway
I do believe, though, that in general, people feel much safer being outspoken about what I'll call progressive issues and conservative issues at work. And I say that as a progressive. And I wonder if a lot of people are looking for work to be a safe place from some of that.
Kara Swisher
That could be. That could be. But do you know what? It comes after, I don't know, 100 years of the other part. So like 2017—
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I know, but that's the argument that an overcorrection is due.
Kara Swisher
I don't think an overcorrection is due. I just think that everyone else had to grin and bear that bullshit for so long. And believe me, I've been in a workplace where they say anti-gay things for decades. And then the minute you say something, "Oh, I don't want to bring your gay to work." It's like, give me a fucking break. I had to listen to your stupid bullshit for decades. And I just feel like there's a—the reason why everyone's talking about it is because there's a very big middle ground here to be had by everyone where you can bring yourself to work and you can conduct civil discussions. And then you can see actual movement on diversity that actually counts versus all this blabbery.
Scott Galloway
The advice, though, I mean, I try to make, you know, just a learning moment for young professionals. Yeah. I think if you're going to be an advocate for people at work, I think that's a wonderful thing. I think if you decide, all right, there's a certain group of people that I'm going to try and advocate for. I think every group needs advocates. And if you see injustice in the workplace, to try and be effective around having conversations with the right people instead of indignant to score virtue points. I think that's a powerful thing.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
The advice I would give to young people, though, is that if you're in this environment, like a very outspoken kind of social justice warrior at work, whether it's right or wrong, I think people immediately in the short term will say, "Way to go. Good for you." And then the HR people in leadership of the company go memo to self: "That person is a headache for us." And it doesn't help you, whether that's right or wrong. Just be very careful because in the short term, it's a sugar high and you'll feel righteous and everyone will be supportive of you and all the lawyers will say, "Okay, don't fire that person for the next three to six months." But they will make a memo to self.
Kara Swisher
Yes, agreed.
Scott Galloway
So I would just say just be very thoughtful about the notion that you can bring the same sort of indignance and righteousness about your social justice issues that you take to Twitter to work. Anyways, I think you should tread carefully around this stuff. I think you want to show incredible courage around the work you do and the value you add. Because I think the political, I think expecting, you know, calling out the company on stuff, I think the best call-outs are when you're effective and you go to the people in charge and try and educate them and actually foment change as opposed to publicly embarrass the company or the leadership on all hands. I don't, you know, it feels good.
Kara Swisher
I just feel like they give them all these tools and that's really hard to get them back into line. And I think when people get a little bit of power, and it is a little bit of power, it's not a lot of power. And they don't get, they don't see actual progress elsewhere, which is what you don't see. And there's no good reason for it. The only answer is that, you know, if you look at a management staff and it's all of the same type of person and you're not allowed in there, you begin to understand the game is fixed. And so why not yell? That's my, I think that's what happens. And so if they want to make real changes in diversity and inclusion and things like that, that's one thing. But they never do that part. That's where the real failure is when you look at those numbers. In any case, as you can see between Scott and I, it's a fraught issue. I just get tired of them very privileged people going on and saying they can't speak because get in the fucking back of the line of this one because the rest of us have been listening to you for far too long. Anyway, we'll see. We'll see. Not you, Scott. I love listening to you talk. Go on. Go on.
Scott Galloway
Okay, Scott, big stories. First, a trial between Epic, the video game company behind the game Fortnite, and Apple starts this week, in fact, today. As a reminder, here's what got us this moment. Last summer, Epic announced that it would be giving discounts on items in the game if users made their purchases outside of Apple's payment systems. That violated Apple's in-app rules, effectively stopping the company from collecting commission on the popular game. And so Apple kicked Fortnite off the App Store. This led Epic CEO Tim Sweeney to sue Apple in federal court, and a public relations battle took place across the internet.
I find them both exhausting in their public relations battle part of it. But the trial carries major implications. If Epic wins, it will upend the $100 billion app market. It could create a path for millions of other developers to avoid sending up to 30% of their app sales to Apple. This also feeds into some of Apple's other antitrust issues. Regulators have scrutinized Apple's control over the App Store. With regards to Spotify and others, last week the European Union charged Apple with violating antitrust laws over its apps and fees. Meanwhile, Epic is gearing for a similar lawsuit against Google with the same issues.
And so it's the issue of who controls the app store and not just all the app stores. So, Scott, what do you think?
I think this is a really bad look for Apple. I think Apple's all wet on this. And Senator Klobuchar has written about this in her book. If Apple wants 30% commission, they need to offer the requisite value to command that type of margin. In their iPhone, it's a superior phone that gets the greatest margin, and that is what I would call earned margin. In the App Store, if a company feels like they can offer direct-to-consumer value for less, that's what you call competition. And Apple is saying we're going to kick you off the rails because we dominate 80% by dollar volume of the rails here. That is the definition of antitrust behavior.
And Apple did try to get out ahead of this a few months ago when they announced that any app doing less than a million bucks pays a lower commission. That's about 2% of revenue. That really isn't meaningful. It was more symbolic than meaningful. But I just don't think there's any getting around it. If I were at Apple, I'd be saying, "All right, it's better to take a small case L right now and come to some sort of compromise here." They're going to lose here because this is pure antitrust behavior. This is monopoly abuse. The amount of money they get is vast. But what is their defense? What would you say their best defense is?
Besides, let's negotiate and bring it down and everybody goes home happy, which is what I think they should do.
Kara Swisher
We've made a multi-billion dollar investment in security that everybody, that we've made an unparalleled investment in safety and security that other people shouldn't be allowed to free ride off of. And the only way we stop that free riding is by ensuring that people adhere to our terms and services. It's basically the utility argument that scale is required in certain categories.
Scott Galloway
The problem is when you make that argument, you're basically playing into the notion that, okay, if scale really is mandatory here and beneficial, that means you're a utility and you need to be regulated. And there needs to be somebody from Senator Klobuchar or the FTC's office looking at your pricing. This is where they are always. Which is where it's going. Let's be honest.
Kara Swisher
100%.
Scott Galloway
100%.
Kara Swisher
But they should, quite frankly, they should get out ahead of this. This is a crisis. The only thing you have to do in a crisis is acknowledge the issue. You have the top guy or gal. Now, Tim Cook should come out and say, we're dramatically reconfiguring the pricing. He needs to get out ahead of this issue because the government will come in with a blunt instrument and take those fees down. This is absolutely monopoly abuse.
Scott Galloway
I don't think Apple will be broken up because Elegant Antitrust increases shareholder value. And it'd be hard to break up Apple because the primary asset here is the brand. I'd break it from the App Store. There is definitely a different line there than Facebook owning Instagram.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, but Spotify, the App Store is their Achilles heel around antitrust, and they should try and get out ahead of it and take – and their business is so strong right now. I think App said $60 billion last year, but the – they should sacrifice – again, take the small L here and get out ahead of this and say, all right, we're dramatically reconfiguring with – working with the FTC, the DOJ. If they get into cars, AR, this will be nothing.
Scott Galloway
Oh, my gosh.
Kara Swisher
This will be a nothing. And this will hurt.
Scott Galloway
That's exactly right. It also does link to Amazon the same thing, is that they have this platform. They compete on the platform. The more they get into services, they've got to be very careful about what they do. Because they could have a better service, by the way. My kids are now on Apple Music and not Spotify. And they made a decision not based on ease, not based on price. They just like it better. They like the product better. I'm still on Spotify. So they have to figure out a way to compete in certain areas that they find critical and not feel like the 800-pound giant of it to people. Go out of their way to make Spotify, to advantage Spotify or whoever they happen to compete with.
Kara Swisher
Well, the trying to disarticulate from big tech and be, and, you know, start your hat right and be the good guy, this is where it matters. And they're going to have to, I'm telling you, this is their Achilles heel. They need to get out ahead of it.
Scott Galloway
Yes, exactly.
Kara Swisher
So Google, where does Google come in if the next lawsuit?
Scott Galloway
Well, Google, I mean, quite frankly, Google just has other sins to address before they even get to their app store. Because while their app store is dominant by dollar volume, it's iOS that really racks all the – it's interesting. Even though Android has much greater market share, I believe iOS, the app store at Apple, is much more dominant in terms of actual revenue and subscription revenue.
Kara Swisher
And how much profit they get from it. It's enormous.
Scott Galloway
Enormous. I got to think that other – I mean, this is where it all goes. It all goes back to this kind of bullshit notion that media families decided they shouldn't be subject to shareholder governance by saying that they were so important they needed to think long term and they created two classes of shareholders. And then Larry and Sergey decided to adopt the same narrative for the first time in tech. And it's led to some very ugly places where now we have individuals who don't have economic control but have control over the company. And accountability and ownership and responsibility and authority should be all directly linked. And they're not with these companies. And I think the majority of people, including Sundar at Google and the employees, are just like, get on with it. We want to get back to building great products. And they also probably realize their options will be worth more when it's standalone YouTube, when it's standalone Google. I 100% agree. Apple should move into cars and health and different things like that and get off of this. This is not a good look for them.
Kara Swisher
I agree. Yeah, I agree. It's their biggest problem. And by the way, they have some really good attributes. I think they're – even though some people think they're scolding and sort of virtue signaling on the privacy thing, I don't think they are. I think they're right. And so –
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but this is where they walk the walk. Quite frankly, that serves – that's them talking their own book.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I agree. When they go – this moving, getting out in front of the app store, that would be really saying, okay, we take monopoly power. Just like encryption. I think they actually went out on a limb on that one a long time ago, way before other people did. Anyway, we'll see where it goes. We'll be watching it carefully. Anyway, we'll see. And Epic's got—we'll talk about Epic's maybe next week because they've got some issues themselves. Anyway, let's go on a quick break. And as I said, we'll be back to talk about this and other things with Senator Amy Klobuchar. A little gangster. Senator Klobuchar. All things antitrust and other things. And I want you to behave. I want you to look up from your phone. I love Senator Klobuchar. She is a great senator, I have to say. And she gets shit done.
Scott Galloway
She does.
Kara Swisher
She wasn't a senator. She'd be an excellent co-host on this show, I think. for you. Anyway, we'll be back.
Scott Galloway
That hurts my feelings. Why do you even say that? That hurts my feelings.
Kara Swisher
I said for you, not for me, for you.
Scott Galloway
Oh, yeah, right.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, for you. All right, we'll be back with Senator Klobuchar.
AD BREAK
All right, let's bring in our friend of Pivot who needs no introduction, Senator Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota. She has a new book called *Antitrust: Taking on Monopoly Power from the Gilded Age to the Digital Age*. Senator Klobuchar is the lead Democrat on the Judiciary Committee on Antitrust, Competition Policy, and Consumer Rights. She's also the chairwoman of the Senate Rules Committee and led the defense of challenges to the electoral votes from Arizona and Pennsylvania during the 2020 presidential election. But we're here to talk about antitrust. I'm going to let Scott start, Senator Klobuchar, since I've interviewed you for so many times and I'm about to interview you again in D.C. So, Scott, why don't you start? You were super excited to have Senator Klobuchar here.
Scott Galloway
I was, Senator. I'm a huge fan. I just love people who actually do the work. And by the way, I bought your book, and I'm going to take that in the streaming or the video of *The Irishman* and take three months and get through both. This is a big book, Senator.
Amy Klobuchar
You know, there is also an audio version that you could, you know, listen to.
Scott Galloway
Oh, my gosh.
Amy Klobuchar
Yeah, that'll only take seven weeks.
Scott Galloway
But thank you. I appreciate that. And thank you for all you've done in putting a big spotlight on these issues. I love this woman.
Kara Swisher
I love this woman. Don't kiss up to him, Senator Glover. Anyways, I'm sorry. Questions, Scott. Back to you.
Scott Galloway
Okay, so I thought it was really interesting what you said, that we need to stop referring to it as antitrust, that words matter, that we need to have sort of a competitiveness commission. Can you talk about what you think most of us get wrong about antitrust?
Amy Klobuchar
I think that people assume that everyone's following it every little detail and most people aren't. And then they take that to mean no one cares about it. I don't think that's true. I think it's one of the major things affecting people when they look at their cable rates or they try to figure out why they can't get a good airfare when they're in a midsize city or they don't understand why there is misinformation coming out of the big tech companies when they're supposed to be so sophisticated or why there's no privacy controls. So I think it's on us as leaders, both on the journalism side, but also on the political side to make this really clear.
This is a big deal. And I think calling it antitrust is kind of interesting, the law, because it has the play on words of antitrust because no one trusts anyone anymore. We know it was really about taking on big trust, which are today's Facebooks and Googles. But calling it competition policy to me is more forward optimistic. It really looking at it in a bigger way. How do we, if we believe in capitalism which I do, but we believe there should be checks and balances. What kind of competition policy do we want coming from the government that actually encourages more small businesses and bringing rates down for consumers and getting more innovative ideas and actually helping people negotiate better wages?
That's the kind of competition we want.
Scott Galloway
So they call it competition in Europe, correct? They've used it elsewhere in the world. So there's a series of smaller actions, I'll call them competition actions, expected in Congress throughout May. Can you talk about the strategy? Because you're really leading it. And who are the key leaders in both the House and the Senate and at the FTC, etc.?
Amy Klobuchar
Sure. Well, when it comes to the antitrust side, competition side in the House, David Cicilline and Jerry Nadler are leading that. David just did an incredible hearing on pharmaceuticals and had both the Senate and the House over there. And they've, of course, made the major tech report over in the Senate. I head up the subcommittee and then Mike Lee is the Republican lead. He and I together every step of the way just took on the App Store issue with a lengthy hearing and then follow up to question why a witness company was intimidated the night before the hearing. And so we lead this in the Senate.
But other people who played major roles as it went along are, of course, people like Senator Leahy, who's been doing a lot from the beginning on this. Senator Kennedy is doing the newspaper bill with me to make it easier for news organizations to negotiate better rates with the big tech companies. You've got Elizabeth Warren, who's long been an advocate for doing something. You can kind of go through the list. Senator Grassley, I don't want to forget him. He's been hanging in there on pharma and then being willing to talk about the fact that the agencies don't have enough money. You can't expect FTC or DOJ, Department of Justice Antitrust, to take on the biggest companies in the world ever known with Band-Aids and duct tape.
And the last thing I'll say on the administration side, you have Tim Wu now in the White House. You've got Lena Kahn that's going to be, I know, confirmed for the FTC. And then you're going to have a new head of Department of Justice antitrust. We don't know who that is. And let's not forget Merrick Garland, the attorney general, who actually understands this stuff, taught it. And so I think that's exciting as well.
Scott Galloway
Well, Senator, whenever I've met with elected representatives, typically the senator or the representative, and you talk about antitrust, they nod their head. And then the other people in the room, the aides or the legislative aides, I don't know what the exact term is, they just, they look so depressed. And essentially, it's almost as if they feel they're just overwhelmed, that they're outgunned.
Amy Klobuchar
Oh, there he is. That's the depressed guy.
Scott Galloway
Senator Klobuchar just panned left to some people.
Amy Klobuchar
That's the best guy.
Scott Galloway
Well, you know, keep going, keep going. The sense I get when I leave D.C. is that everybody gets it, but they feel like they're outgunned, that they've been overrun by the resources and the lobbyists and the lawyers of big tech. Do you, is this, A, is that correct? And B, how do we push back? How do we start, how do we, how do we bring more balance back to, you know, balance back to Washington? Talk about the strategy of what you're doing with each of these people.
Amy Klobuchar
Exactly. So first, it's correct. We are outgunned. You've got the agencies that are a shadow of their former selves in terms of number of employees, even from back during the Reagan administration, back during a time when before Reagan, they were taking on AT&T and breaking it up. So it's a legitimate issue. And then secondly, in Congress, we've just recently started to hire people and get the expertise to take it on. But I refuse to use that as an excuse. I just do, because I think that you can build a movement. It took them years, honestly, for Teddy Roosevelt to be able to win before the Supreme Court the Northern Trust case.
There are plenty of examples through history where you tried and tried again, and pretty soon people got educated enough they were able to do it. So, yes, more resources for the agencies, very clear leadership of the agencies. They know what cases and what they're going to prioritize, not wasting a bunch of money as much as I admire the work that was done on taking on Google out of the DOJ. They shouldn't have been wasting money on marijuana mergers or on the during the Trump administration. So making a clear, clear mandate on what they're going to do and then asking for help when you need it.
I just I believe in sort of the saving private Ryan philosophy sometimes that small people, especially with the power of government and what the attorney generals are doing all over the country. Come on, people are passing laws on apps, looking at app stores, passing laws on privacy. Pretty soon it all bubbles up to the federal level, just like the Sherman Act did, because states are doing stuff. So there's so much work going on that while it may look small, there is a movement happening right now in the country. And so we do have power. And I don't think anyone should get depressed or undersell themselves.
We're optimistic here.
Kara Swisher
All right. So what is the strategy in terms of bringing, what should you see? Because people have been waiting a long time for this action. So what is the actual, how do you think about the strategy of doing this? Because there's a Google case. There's a Facebook case of the FTC, the Google's Justice Department. There's all these bills that you have. You have innumerable bills. And they're little, they each address a different issue. How do you look at where people will see? Then there's questions about Section 230. There's all kinds of things. And then it's on top of it, it's politicized.
Amy Klobuchar
So quickest way to get action is with the agencies bringing these suits as well as private suits. And so I think that's why I'm so focused on immediately, like this month, working to pass this Klobuchar-Grassley bill some way, find a vehicle to change the filing fees, which have been huge support from Republicans as well, because it's not taxpayer money, so that the funding goes to those agencies. That's the quickest way to get action. The second way is to have the administration basically look at the vertical horizontal merger standards, change some things that they can do without Congress. At the same time, I have a big bill.
The House is working on things. We're working together, passing things. If we can't get the big bill passed, there is sure a lot of sentiment to do some other things. So including the newspapers, including doing something on exclusionary conduct, and just pushing these bills and finding the right vehicles to put them on. And so that's what we're working on right now. And if people claim they want to do something on antitrust and then they mess up an effort to even get a medium-sized thing through, they should be held accountable for it. Because one of the most frustrating things, one of the reasons maybe you see Scott, the staff looking sad from time to time when you see meetings.
It's because every time you try to do something, some company influences someone who stops it in his tracks. And that's why I think the accountability of putting light on this and holding people to their words is going to be really important.
Scott Galloway
I'm curious. So let's just assume that Facebook and Google that already have several lawsuits seeking the breakup of the companies. Do you think Amazon should be broken up? And then I think the tougher one is, do you think Apple should be broken up or just subject to regulation? And that case begins today, that private case.
Kara Swisher
The Epic Games case, yeah.
Amy Klobuchar
So I am not going to wave a magic wand and say which thing should be broken up. I think in each case, and I've made it very clear because these cases have been brought against Google and Facebook, one of the clear remedies is to divest some of these assets, especially in the Facebook case with Instagram and WhatsApp. And that helps because then these competitors can develop again on their own, like the AT&T breakup, you can also put conditions in place.
Kara Swisher
So let's look at Apple and Google or even Amazon in a different way, but look at Apple and Google. So what would you do there?
Amy Klobuchar
Well, because they are this completely dominant monopolies in their respective platforms when it comes to these app stores. You could say this fee is outrageous. You know, an agency could do that as part of a lawsuit. We could put in a law. When you're up, we wouldn't set the number, probably would make it easier for the agency to look at. When it's set at, you know, 30 percent and when the latest Epic Games public filing in that case shows that they may be making 75 percent profit, who does that but a monopoly? So that's the first thing. Secondly, you can put in rules. The Justice Department could or FTC in a lawsuit or we could put them in. You've got to be able to tell people they can get a cheaper deal on their own website. You can't self-preference your own products. So those things could be put in in different ways. So I just am open to all of the above. It's not because I'm copping out here. It's just that we have to pursue many things at once. That's what Europe is doing. They're pursuing many things at once.
Kara Swisher
What would you make of their argument, say Apple, in the case that, which I was looking at their opening statements today, is that we keep this area safe. And they have a good argument that these, like look at Google App Store, it's a little crazy comparatively. And they do, they push safety, they push lack of grabbing privacy, because that's another thing that you talk about a lot. What do you make of those arguments that they do need to have some control over something like the App Store, for example?
Amy Klobuchar
Well, I think the answer is like Mike Lee was pushing at our hearing and several others were, excuse me if this is true because you won't give us another number, which hopefully will come out because of this suit. 75% profits. I don't think that those billions and billions and billions of dollars in profit is all needed to keep people safe. I don't. I think that they are using that as the excuse. I'm glad they put money into security. That's a good thing. But I think they are overinflating how much that is, which means they're overinflating the prices that people pay. And I think that are they really keeping people safe, the tech companies, when you've got all this information out there?
I just did an event with one of our African-American leaders, a reverend in Minnesota yesterday, along with a doctor at one of our leading hospitals. Just the misinformation out there on the web has really hurt us. Then we have what we call the disinformation dozen, 12 people who are responsible accounts for over 60% of them. And okay, we've gotten a few taken down. Ben Ray Luhan and I wrote a letter and explained why and used this study we found. Why are we doing that? I'm glad I am. It's good. But I just find this troubling and I don't buy this argument. They're keeping everyone safe with the insurrection.
Kara Swisher
All right. Well, in that case, it wasn't Apple's fault, but that was Facebook and awesome.
Amy Klobuchar
Oh yeah, to make very clear, I'm realizing the tech companies had nothing to do with Apple.
Scott Galloway
So big tech and antitrust around big tech gets about 90% of the oxygen, but isn't the reality that all industry in the U.S. is suffering from the same type of consolidation and monopoly power? What other industries do you think are most ripe for antitrust?
Amy Klobuchar
Well, that's why, Scott, you've seen me use a broader approach of looking at exclusionary conduct from the past and not just focusing on gatekeeper tech issues, as important as that is, and I will join my colleagues in the house in whatever legislation makes sense that they're doing on that. But when you look at consolidation as a whole, across the board, we've seen more and more big, huge companies and less choices. Pharma used to be much more competitive, and now it's consolidating more and more. Look at EpiPen, what happened there. Look at what happened with insulin. All these examples, you can point to less competition for various reasons in a certain area.
I start my book out with the story of a baby's heart valve drug that was $85 per treatment for years and years and years. Didn't change at all. What happened? It was sold to one company, and then that company bought the only other existing drug, and they jacked up the price to $1,500 a treatment. I get a call from a pharmacist. We look at it nationwide. It's a disaster. FTC, attorney generals bring suits. And basically the court, which have been a major problem here, throw it out. And again, that's what drives me to say it's not just about tech. John Oliver has said it's everything from cat food to caskets.
And if it's enough to make you want to die, good luck, because we now have only, as his words, three casket makers in the country, although it's now down to two because one bought one.
Scott Galloway
Well, I'm going to put Scott in a compost heap.
Kara Swisher
I don't know if you saw that *New York Times* piece from this weekend. I'm just going to Twitter knows you love the dog. Senator, don't ignore her. She loves the dog. Let me ask you a question. How U.S. dealing with antitrust versus Europe's approach? How do you look at that in terms of because they've been more aggressive. Marguerite Vestager has been very aggressive. Lots of people and across the world. It's not just it's not just Europe.
Amy Klobuchar
Well, Europe, some of them have different laws. So it's easy for them to hold them responsible because of our Section 230 immunity. It's easier for them to hold them responsible. They basically have their digital markets piece. And then they're looking at, of course, some of the contents piece. And I think that they've done incredible work in leading the way. I think early on, everyone was complaining about that. And now people have realized I wasn't, but people have realized they were ahead of their time. And what I love about what's going on now is we're working with them. And when Australia happened and they tried to Google and Facebook were threatening to pull out of the country, Europe responded and a bunch of people in the U.
S. responded and said it was bad. Leaders in the U.S. And they pulled back some in what they were threatening to do. So I see this as working in concert. I was glad that they have now put out more on the App Store issue after their yearlong investigation. There's absolutely no reason that we can't be working together to come up with solutions that obviously don't get rid of tech. That would be a joke. They obviously don't just punish companies because they're successful. The idea is to make us all successful by making sure we have competition.
Scott Galloway
I'd love to pivot to a couple other issues because I've learned a ton about it. I feel as if I understand any trust better than your average bear. And I've learned a ton reading your book. I'm 300 pages in, so I'm about halfway through chapter two. But I appreciate it.
Amy Klobuchar
It's a long book, Senator.
Scott Galloway
It's a long book. It is. It is. That's why your aides look so exhausted. Anyways, a long book.
Kara Swisher
The footnotes.
Scott Galloway
She's a lawyer. There are footnotes. I just have a couple. It's nice to see a senator who actually does the work. Anyways, I said that at the outset. So just a couple of questions. I'd love sort of a lightning round answer here. I'd love to know from you, what were the biggest surprises to the upside and downside in running for president?
Amy Klobuchar
Oh, well, the upside was incredible. Just understanding the whole country and the interest in our democracy and making it work again and in issues. I mean, it's just this incredible thing. And then being able to make your points on the debate stage, including a number of times on antitrust, including on voting and things that I have cared about for a long time. And I thought that was an amazing opportunity. Being one of only a few women that have ever been on that debate stage and for the first time having, I'm not going to list everyone, But near the end, Kamala and Elizabeth and myself out there and making sure people understand it's not one size fits all.
That women can have different views, be from different parts of the country, act different, talk different and argue with each other. And it's OK. And so that was cool. The hard thing, of course, is, well, when you don't win. Right. Yeah. Using your power, though, in a good way, which I felt was the right moment at the right time for the candidate I thought would win and be able to lead our country for the kind of leadership we need right now. And I feel that I've been right about Joe Biden. That was also an incredibly powerful thing. But it's not easy when you don't win. It's not easy when, you know, your staff is working so hard every day and you don't just have the funding to be able to run those commercials in the state that you want to run in.
Or in my case, you start catching on finally, you know, Hampshire in a big way. But by then, you know, trying to put that no one could have pulled it off because you've got to suddenly shift all the money that's coming into all these Super Tuesday states, not to mention Nevada and South Carolina. So all of that, you know, insider baseball. But overall, it was a really positive experience. And it's given me now this platform to be able to take on issues I really care about, like antitrust and voting rights.
Kara Swisher
It is interesting how all the candidates like Andrew Yang's running for mayor, Pete Buttigieg is at the Transportation Department. But I'm going to pivot you back to the idea of the power you have now. So you're dealing with issues and misinformation. You just brought them up on vaccines on Twitter. You talked about the January 6th attack. How does antitrust play into this? Because on Thursday, the Facebook oversight board, such as it is, we don't think it's that different than Facebook is going to decide on Trump on speaking of misinformation probably the biggest font of misinformation And things have calmed down since they removed him from the platforms He can release a press release and it screamy but it doesn it seems to not get the same resonance So when you think about antitrust and the links to mis and disinformation, especially on critical things like vaccines or election, because right now it looks like it worked, like all these Republicans are taking the vaccine. All these Republicans don't believe the election was, they think it's a fraud. How do you, what do you, does antitrust play a part in this, that these big companies that you can't control are doing this?
Amy Klobuchar
It really does. As someone that believes in the market and in the economy, as long as you have a balance, they've done us just service monopolies. So one way to do this as regulation, which we must do, but the other is to allow bells and whistles and companies to develop that would have done a better job on privacy and misinformation. So when Mark Zuckerberg literally wrote in an email, it's better to buy than compete. When he wrote in another one, these businesses about the WhatsApp, Instagram types are nascent, but the network's established, the brands are already meaningful. And here we go. And if they grow to a large scale, they could be very disruptive to us. What does that mean?
Kara Swisher
That means that maybe they'll do better than them. That's competition. Maybe they'll develop a better way to deal with falsehoods on the internet through capitalism. And they basically stop that. So that's why I think that it is very relevant because monopolies make it harder for others to take care of some of the problems through marketplace and competition. And they basically took us out of that.
Scott Galloway
What now?
Kara Swisher
Literally, the polls that are coming out are astonishing about Republicans not believing in the election. Now, they may just be saying it off the top of their heads. It may not be quite as a strongly held thing, because my mom said it the other day, and then she took it back. You know what I mean? She does things like that all the time. But in vaccines, you're seeing the numbers. It did work in some fashion. It's worked, although I just see in my state right now, we're turning almost up to 60% of people getting their first one. And I think that it is on us and on finding new ways to market the truth and stop the disinformation. As I said, I've stood out there about the disinformation dozen. They took down a bunch of sites. That was great. But I think that more has to be done to stop the disinformation. Because if we're not going to develop through the capitalist market because of monopolies, then we've got to put in rules. I also think looking at Section 230 and threatening the loss of their immunity in lawsuits for certain categories of information, not all of it. And that's what the bill that Senator Warner and Hirono and I have put forward does.
Scott Galloway
Scott, last question. I'll ask real quick. I interviewed your former colleague, Senator Franken, on my other podcast. Would you be supportive? Do you think he should run for office again?
Amy Klobuchar
He's a good friend. And I think if I don't know what he told you, but what he's told me is he's really happy with what he's doing right now. He's making a great contribution by getting issues out. I just talked to him last week. And so I think he's in a good place and that's going to be on him. But we've remained friends throughout all of this.
Kara Swisher
All right. Senator Klobuchar's book is called *Antitrust: Taking on Monopoly Power from the Gilded Age to the Digital Age*. It's a great book, Senator, thank you so much. Keep fighting the good fight, Senator.
Scott Galloway
Show up with the work. Continue to bring it, my sister. Continue to bring it.
Kara Swisher
Look at him. He's bringing it. He's bringing it. She's bringing it. Give her a break. Senator, I'll talk to you one day. Those aides look 75 and they're 23. Keep working them.
Amy Klobuchar
That's right. Thank you.
Kara Swisher
All right, Scott, one more quick break. She's amazing. We'll talk about her when we get back and we'll be back for wins and fails too.
Ad Break
Okay, Scott, go ahead. Talk about Senator Klobuchar. She's amazing, right? Did I tell you? Did I tell you?
Scott Galloway
I think we have to. I don't understand why people aren't more in love and more impressed by government, U.S. government, the people who turned the organization that turned back Hitler, found a cure for polio, and invented the bomber jacket and silly putty in World War II. Senator Klobuchar is an example of why the U.S. government is the most noble entity in the history of mankind. I especially am fond of Senator Klobuchar because she's one of the senators that would rather pick hard work over a camera. She's not jonesing for a camera everywhere. She's actually writing books and writing great legislation. I got to think her legislative ways are exhausted, the amount of legislation she puts out. I think she's just incredibly impressive. I think she still has a bid for presidency, I have to tell you. She's young.
Kara Swisher
Oh, yeah, she's young, right? I mean, she looks young. Compared to the others, certainly.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, she's a kid. She's a toddler. I think she's someone people really, once you get to know her, you really do like her a lot better. That's the issue with her, I think. She's someone that really grows on you in a positive way, I think, in a lot of ways. And I think getting to know you is, I think, the thing. And competence is really hard. She obviously got that big hit originally from the whole thing around her comb and salad and stuff like that. But, you know, honestly, she's – her ability – If it had been a dude, they would have said he was a leader holding his team accountable.
Kara Swisher
I know. And instead, when a woman does that, she's a bitch. I mean it's just –
Scott Galloway
She's a tough cookie. It's a little double standard.
Kara Swisher
I agree. I agree. And by the way –
Scott Galloway
What? I'm sorry, Kara.
Kara Swisher
No, I was saying she's great. I think she's great. Go ahead.
Scott Galloway
I've worked with a ton of CEOs. She could literally be the chief executive officer of a Fortune 500 company making tens of millions of dollars a year, flying around in her Gulfstream 650, and instead she decides to try and write laws. So I think, I mean, anyways, I think she's fantastic.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, combs aren't your issue, right? Combs. Go on. Go on.
Scott Galloway
I would. Me and my beautiful haired children. A lot of hair. A lot of hair.
Kara Swisher
I'm growing a lot of hair out of my ears. I'm thinking about braiding it with the hair coming out of my nose. Anyway, she's wonderful. That was a great interview. She's very forthright. She answers the question. That's one of the pleasures of talking to her. Except, would you endorse Senator Franken for another run? She avoided that.
Scott Galloway
Oh, my God. She can't. She danced around that one. Why would she do that in advance? Why would she? She will. She will.
Kara Swisher
I think she could have said he'd be great to have him back in government.
Scott Galloway
No, she can't. She can't. She's not pulling. She's dealing with antitrust. She's not going to wade into that.
Kara Swisher
You heard it here first. You heard it here first. Senator Franken has kids and grandkids in Manhattan, and he spends a ton of time with his family. I think he should move to New York and run against Kirsten Gillibrand.
Scott Galloway
Oh. How much would that, how awesome would that be? How awesome would that be? She's a tough cookie. I met her once. Senator Gillibrand? She scared me a little bit, I'll be honest with you. I met her in the Senate dining room. She's got a look. I think Senators Klobuchar and Senator Gillibrand, one is remarkably effective.
Kara Swisher
Okay. All right. Enough of that. Don't be dragging down the lady senators.
Scott Galloway
Listen, listen, what is your win and fail? Come on. Just dragging and building up good and dragging up bad. Give me a win and fail.
Kara Swisher
Okay, simply put, wins and fails respectively are two companies that have been valued at $5 billion for their most recent mark. One's going to be worth $10 billion within 12 months. The other's going to be worth less than $1 billion. Yahoo's the fourth most trafficked internet site in the world. That's any competent management there, any vision, any reasonable owner there is going to make that thing worth $10 billion within 12 months. And then another company that was recently worth $5 billion, Clubhouse, is going to be worth less than a billion within 12 months.
Scott Galloway
I told you, I'm an investor in public. They just announced a service that's similar to the Clubhouse app that works as well. I just did spaces with her. You perfectly summarized this. This is a feature, not a company.
Kara Swisher
So when Yahoo's working on it. Modeling is coming. Yannick modeling is coming on its way, just so you know.
Scott Galloway
That was your suggestion. Nice. Yannick. Yeah.
Kara Swisher
Does he know Marguerite Vestia?
Scott Galloway
Yes, I do.
Kara Swisher
Oh, Yannick. I should know that.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, you should know that since you talk about it all the time. Yeah. It was your suggestion. Anyway.
Kara Swisher
Okay. Those are good ones. Anyways. Wins and fails. Yahoo, dramatically undervalued. Clubhouse, dramatically overvalued. I like the pairing. I like the pairing of them. I'm going to do one. The win is, I got to say, *Call Your Agent*.
Scott Galloway
What?
Kara Swisher
People have been bugging me to watch that frigging Netflix show forever.
Scott Galloway
What Netflix show?
Kara Swisher
Amazing. *Call Your Agent*. It's set in France. There's a big old sassy lesbian at the center of it, and it's about an agency, like a celebrity agency. It's so funny.
Scott Galloway
Who plays the big old sassy lesbian?
Kara Swisher
Some French lady. I don't know. Some French lady? But they bring in all the French stars.
Scott Galloway
Did you actually watch it, or is it anything with a lesbian you decide to win?
Kara Swisher
No, not anything with a lesbian. You haven't watched it. You avoided the question. Should Senator Franken run for office again? You and Amy. Seriously. It's a great show. There's straight people in it, too. You're like that guy. Remember that old film critic, Rex Reed? What's his name? Rex Reed. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Okay, so you haven't seen it, but it's your win?
Scott Galloway
No, I haven't seen *Call Your Agent*. I watched *Call Your Agent*. Yes, of course. I'm sorry. Yes, yes. I've watched three episodes. Amanda and I love it. She's listening in French because she speaks French. We'll smell her. She laughs ahead of me because I can't read that fast. She's like, ha ha, and then I'm like, what? And so it's very-
Kara Swisher
Okay, I can't help it. Quick time out for a candid moment with the Swisher family while down in Delray. I know everyone's sick of this, so I gotta do it.
Scott Galloway
They're not sick of it. It's towards the end of the weekend and you guys are packing all your bags up and headed out. We've all been together for three days. Everyone has been too close for 72 hours. And finally, Giant Boy does something. He crosses the line. I don't know what he did. He was mouthing off to somebody. You take him in the corner of the living room and you're like, listen to me. And you start like berating him. And you yelling at Giant Man, it literally looked like Hervé Villechaize saying to Fernando Llamas, the plane, the plane, it's late because it's your fault. It looks so ridiculous. I went over to my wife and I'm like, look at her scolding him. You were literally looking up like you were trying to identify a 737 in the sky. And you're like, listen to me. Listen to me.
Kara Swisher
You know what? He listened to me. Let me just say.
Scott Galloway
He did. It was hilarious. You're a gangster, brother.
Kara Swisher
He was not as good a guest as he should have been for a moment. He was a pretty good guest. He was a wonderful guest. He played basketball with my boy. He's a wonderful guest. He's a good kid. He's a great kid. He's a really great kid. I love that kid. He's a good kid. Both my kids are great. All my kids are great, including Golden Child, who was noted on the street by this. It was a very nice couple. Very nice gay couple. They liked us a lot. They like us. We have great appeal. But thank you for that lovely story. I have – anyway, that's my win is *Call Your Agent*. Watch it. It's great. *Call Your Agent*. Okay. *Call Your Agent*.
Scott Galloway
My loss is this COVID herd immunity. I can't read another story about frigging stupid Republican men not taking the vaccine. And I get why. And I read a very multifaceted story in the *Washington Post* this weekend about lots of different reasons. It wasn't just men, but it was a lot of men. And I get their issues around it was developed too fast. I get their issues of – I don't get their stem cell thing. That's not true. But I get that they believe they're true. But it's just really – it's really – actually speaking of Giant Man, and I talked about it this weekend, how do you get people to herd immunity in this way? How do you convince them? And we concluded that you cannot. You cannot get them to do what is in their best interest. So it's a little bit of a fail on our country that we have to kiss these people's ass. We need to get there. There's such a big opportunity in all of this. And if we can get to some semblance of herd immunity and crush the curve, America has always been, you know, we've always been the good guys and gals. We've turned back tyranny.
Kara Swisher
Well, I know, but I think we have a big opportunity. I think the biggest opportunity geopolitically to not only do the right thing, but to do the smart thing would be to get to the point where we could start playing offense and shipping vaccine and really helping India out. The level of just death and disease and disability in India right now is so frightening.
Scott Galloway
It is. And America has always been, you know, we have so many resources and we demonstrate, I think, typically such generosity and such courage that the opportunity now is to crush the curve here and then to turn our sights on other areas of devastation because we're Americans. And I think it's such a huge opportunity. And people don't realize just as, you know, the swing vote, whether it's independents or Joe Manchin.
Kara Swisher
So wait, don't, don't, don't, don't. How do we get them to take them? Scott, there's just, it's almost impossible. Like this story was so disheartening in terms of trying to figure out.
Scott Galloway
Oh, I think you show a leader. Okay, simply put, vaccine passports. You can't come into work. You can't travel. I don't understand why we-
Kara Swisher
That's what Giant Man said, but I don't think you're going to get those passed. I think Kristi Noem or some asshole from Alabama is going to—
Scott Galloway
Let me fast forward to the opportunity to be Americans. Americans do the smart thing here. And then once we take care of ourselves, and that's our responsibility to take care of ourselves first, we can play offense. And the reason why India is so important geopolitically and the opportunity to help India out here, and we have the resources, is that India is about to become the most important swing vote in the history of mankind. Whether it's deciding what is the default currency, deciding whether it's democracy or tyranny. India is 1.2 billion people across a much smaller area than Africa, and they are about to be the swing vote in geopolitics. And our opportunity to go in there and help them deal with what is—God, just—do you know there were something like 400,000 reported infections yesterday? It's shocking. People are dying in the street in front of hospitals.
Kara Swisher
Yep, and they don't have oxygen. But here's—let's get back to this country. What a selfish group of destroyers. That's all I can think of is like they can just – all they can do is break and then we have to clean up and break and we have to clean up. And this is what – listen, part of the modern Republican Party is doing this. Let's just break and break and break and point to Biden doesn't like meat and point to let's attack trans people. They just – all they do is make a big fucking mess.
Scott Galloway
But wasn't there a group – just to be fair, wasn't there a group of Republican doctors or elected congresspeople who came out and said, look, come on, guys, get your head out of your ass?
Kara Swisher
It didn't work. It didn't work. Didn't work.
Scott Galloway
I'm just saying, look, they booed Mitt Romney and Liz Cheney. It's two of the most conservative people. Did you see that? Craziness.
Kara Swisher
They just destroy. You know, they're toddlers breaking plates. It's all I can see. I just don't understand.
Scott Galloway
You need their metal detectors at airports. You need vaccines to get into certain countries. Why wouldn't we demand vaccines if you want to go to public school, if you want to travel, if you want to get on a train, if you want to get on Amtrak? I mean, I just don't. Let's show some leadership here. We locked up 5,000 men in World War II for trying to avoid the draft. I mean, we aren't afraid to take leadership stands on a lot of things. Let's take a leadership stand here.
Kara Swisher
All right. The evidence is in. This shit works. This evidence is good for America. Make you do a vaccine patch for Kristi Noem. Jesus Christ. Anyway. There you go. All right. I'm mad about that. That's a fail. All right. Scott, this has been a riveting show. Senator Klobuchar, of course, classed up the joint. But in general, it's a riveting show. We have a lot to talk about next week. Obviously, we have Facebook will be by then. The decision will be made by then. This epic trial is going. And guess who's going to be on SNL this week?
Scott Galloway
So we're going to start to see a lot of stuff out of that that is going to be really interesting. He was asking for ideas for skits.
Kara Swisher
It's the staff. He has no influence over that. They don't give a shit what he thinks. It's the writers. Don't get me started. Don't get me started. It's like I hate that show and I have to watch it. I'm like so upset and I have to watch that show.
Scott Galloway
You're going to watch it.
Kara Swisher
That's right. I like Miley Cyrus. I think she's very talented.
Scott Galloway
Yes, I do too. Maybe she'll be on the – She's got a beautiful voice. Maybe they could put him on like one of those chains with the balls on it, like a wrecking ball, and then they can do something around that. That could be a good – what do you think? I came in like a wrecking ball.
Kara Swisher
Don't ruin it. You've ruined that image for me. You've ruined that. You've literally ruined that image. Seriously. You've ruined that image. I love that Miley Cyrus. I agree with you. Anyway, Scott, that's the show. We'll be back on Friday for more, and it'll be so – there's so much to talk about. Go to nymag.com slash pivot to submit your questions to the podcast. The link is also in our show notes. Read us out. Today's episode was produced by Rebecca Sinanis. Bill Moss engineered this episode. Who the hell is Bill Moss? Where did Ernie go, Rebecca? Anyways, thanks also to Hannah Rosen and Drew Burrows. Make sure you subscribe to the show on Apple Podcasts. If you're an Android user, check us out on Spotify or wherever you listen to podcasts. If you like the show, please recommend it to a friend. Thanks for listening to Pivot from New York Magazine and Vox Media.
Scott Galloway
The U.S. government, the most noble organization in history that continues to attract people who are leaders, who decide, you know what? I could make tens of millions of dollars. I could overrun the government. I could avoid taxes. Instead, instead, I'm going to be the elected representative from Minnesota and be a total gangster, a total gangster.
Kara Swisher
Scott has a crush on Senator Klobuchar.