Podcast Episode Summary
The main topic of this episode of Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network is the tech industry, with a focus on Apple's secret deal with China, the SPAC market, and various other tech-related stories.
Key Participants
Key Points
Takeaways
Kara Swisher
Not all journalism is the same. Take The Guardian. Our coverage has something unique. Fierce independence. Nobody owns us or tells us what we can and can't say. So we're free to report the whole picture. We connect what's happening in Washington to the rest of the globe. Expose corruption wherever we find it. And give fresh perspective on everything. From wellness and soccer to culture, the climate and more. Read, watch and listen to The Guardian for free at theguardian.com.
Avoiding your unfinished home projects because you're not sure where to start? Thumbtack knows homes, so you don't have to. Don't know the difference between matte paint finish and satin? Or what that clunking sound from your dryer is? With Thumbtack, you don't have to be a home pro. You just have to hire one. You can hire top-rated pros, see price estimates, and read reviews all on the app. Download today.
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And I'm Scott Galloway. How you doing, Scott?
Kara Swisher
I'm doing well. I'm happy to be in New York. Crazy busy week.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. I just came from Dreamforce where Mark Benioff came over to me. Disclosure. And just gave me shit in front of this entire Dreamforce team. So, as usual, I'm representing. I'm bringing home the bacon while you go get foot robes with AOC or whatever it is you do.
Kara Swisher
What I do is I have many children. I was in New York. I only have a short amount of time, so I couldn't come up for that. I would have been happy. I will do the next advertising thing, partnership thing. But there are new partners. We're going to do video, Scott. What do you think about that?
Scott Galloway
You're going to do video?
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
I love podcasting except for the people we have to work with, our advertisers, and our listeners. Otherwise, I'm totally down with what we do. I think it'll be nice. People like our little videos. They like them. We'll have to dress up more, I think. I don't know. I'm not going to speak for you. I'm not exaggerating. People meet me and they're like, "Oh, my God, you're Scott Galloway." And they look at me and they're like, "Oh." Like they just assumed I was going to be much better looking or much more charming or something. So I don't know if we work on video.
Kara Swisher
You sound handsome, in other words, is what you're saying. Hello. Hello. Yeah, you actually do sound handsome.
Scott Galloway
Well, no, you're pretty handsome. That is something you are not supposed to agree with. Let me just stop you right there. You're not supposed to confirm that.
Kara Swisher
You know what? In your apartment, there were pictures of your dad. He was a handsome man. Your dad, I think that's your dad, right? Tom Galloway's a handsome man. Handsome man.
Scott Galloway
Got him to a lot of trouble.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
Good looks and low character.
Kara Swisher
Okay.
Scott Galloway
Means you don't have a pot to piss in with five alimony checks and child support. You sound very comely. That's what you sound. Someone told me I sounded tall. They met me and they're like, "What? You sound tall?"
Kara Swisher
Did you see that picture of me at that lunch in New York? There's a picture of me with, I look like a hobbit. Like I'm at least a foot under, like Joanna holes in her silver fancy jacket. I look like someone who wandered in a little tiny thing that wandered in off the street. It's crazy. I'm telling you, the reason they asked me to do this thing with Benioff today is not you. When you stand next to Benioff, it looks like he's about to eat you. It looks like he's going to get angry and go all Tiger King gone wrong on you. He's a big man. It's like a dancing bear and a four-year-old coming to see the dancing bear. He's a big man and then and salesforce today announces they are no longer in discussions with box so it's already done because anything we want he is has a sense of humor unlike many ceos that's why i enjoy him great guy i'm generally like mark he's a funny guy anyway
Scott Galloway
Today, just so you know, we're going to away from this folder all about our different ad deals and partnerships. Today we're going to unpack Apple's secret deal with China, an interesting lawsuit involving Google and Facebook. Plus, we'll take a listener question about the layoffs at Better. That was not done well.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, first of all, BuzzFeed's Nasdaq launch is off to a rocky start. I thought you might have some thoughts on this. After its debut on Monday, BuzzFeed shares briefly surged, then quickly fell from the opening price of $10.99. Investors withdrew about 94% of the money raised by BuzzFeed's SPAC, which is a lot. At the time, they said they wanted the money for doing things. At the time of the recording, shares were trading below $8. What do you think of this?
Scott Galloway
Well, the good news is they did get public. That's a victory. They have a liquid currency to try and go roll up to space, which is Latin for "we have no vision for organic growth, so we're going to go buy companies." But there is probably room for consolidation. There probably are a bunch of smaller subscale media companies. Someone told me it's actually the first pure play digital media company to actually go public.
Kara Swisher
Oh, interesting.
Scott Galloway
Which I thought was interesting. But to be blunt, Kara, this was sort of like a mild disaster. First off, if you look at SPACs, SPACs raise the money based on the notion that this team is going to go find, be bankers and find a good company that should be public. And they'll find something they get a good valuation on and they'll be a private to public pop. But as the SPAC market has cooled, it's gone from – when they announced the deal or right before the deal, the investors in the original SPAC can redeem and get their money back. And that's a signal not only of the market, but what they feel about the prospects of the target and the new deal.
A lot of people are saying the market sucks. You have a gun to your head and have to give us the money back or find a deal. So you're finding shitty deals. The percentage of the average redemption or people who want their money out – they don't want to go along for the ride with this new acquisition or this new co – has gone from 25 percent to almost 60 percent. Meaning that the majority of people who are in SPACs are deciding not to go through with these deals in terms of their own dollars. This one was 96, meaning that nobody who bought into the SPAC wants to stick around to see what happens, wants to be a BuzzFeed shareholder.
Then what they had to do, which is even more damning, but people aren't talking about it, is in order to complete the deal, they had to raise – they usually do a pipe and equity financing, private investment in public equity. Terry Quadro calls me and corrects me on that. But what they had to do was a convertible debt offering. A convertible debt offering means that if the thing goes bankrupt, they own the assets. That's a negative forward-looking indicator that the only money they could raise to get the deal done was in the form of debt. And the stock's already off 20% or 30%. So here's what it means for the dog. Let me just give you some figures. I'm just looking at the stock. Market cap is $240.6 million. Its revenues were almost double that. That's what's crazy. It was up as high as $14. Now it's at $6.56. Low is $6.43. Its workers are slamming the company as it went public. Watching from the seats at Vox, it really does make you think, maybe not so much.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I'm not sure. I think that market cap may be – that valuation may be incorrect. But the bottom line is it doesn't bode well. The difference is – and I'm talking our own book because we're large – it originally valued it more, but this is what the –
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I had that it was at $1.5 billion on the IPO.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it was. It was after SPAC merger that valued the firm, but it may be worth a lot less now. But go ahead.
Scott Galloway
Sorry. I'll look. I'll fix that. I mean, the bottom line is they're Android. We're iOS of digital media. And we're totally conflicted because you and I are both shareholders. But we have less revenue but more growth, and we make money. We're higher. They're top 10 lists. Vox is Kara Swisher getting ZipRecruiter to pay a lot of money because I think you have powerful people listening to you. So one is literally Android, massive, and the other is iOS.
Kara Swisher
Where are the iOS? So if Vox does a SPAC or tries to go public, it'll be very interesting to see if we get grouped into the same corner that BuzzFeed is.
Scott Galloway
We'll totally get grouped.
Kara Swisher
You think we will?
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
What's interesting is a lot of these companies, whatever they're worth, used to be worth like $5 billion, whatever. There were those numbers that they were going to be bought by Disney for $5 billion. The bloom is off the rose.
Scott Galloway
At the same time, I do admire what Jonah Peretti and Jim Bankoff have done. It's been a rough road, but some of the products they make are really terrific. Nonetheless.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, so it's the SPAC. But look what's happening in the SPAC market. Remember Virgin Galactic?
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
I mean, we said that that was going to be a poster child for SPACs. That's been cut in half since we said that a few months ago. And you're dealing with a couple hundred special purpose acquisition corps that haven't de-SPACed, that have a gun to their head. They're going to start coming up on targets where they either have to give the money back or do an acquisition. So it's a very interesting dynamic right now.
Scott Galloway
Yes, there's a lot of SPACs. I ran into so many women with SPACs at this lunch, and I was like, this isn't good. This is not good.
Kara Swisher
What's going on? Women with SPACs.
Scott Galloway
SPACs. And speaking of SPACs, let's move on to Devin Nunes is leaving Congress to become CEO of Trump's media company. That just makes a lot of sense.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, he'll ditch the House at the end of the month. He was going to be like the head of the House Ways and Means Committee, I think, if the Republicans take back the House. Cutting his term short by about a year, Nunes has a combative relationship with big tech. He's previously sued Twitter. He sued a cow, I believe, or Twitter cow. He didn't win, I don't believe. Trump's SPAC deal has already drawn the attention of the SEC. They're investigating. What thinks you of this?
Scott Galloway
This is weird. He doesn't have any tech experience whatsoever or media experience. So that always works. I think it's kind of like borderline ridiculous. If you're looking at the stock right now in the options market and you want to buy calls – in other words, you think it's going to go up at about the strike price that are just like nine days out – you got to pay $5.50. Whereas if you want to buy puts, you got to pay a lot more. Meaning that essentially everybody thinks this stock is going to go down. I'm a fan of corporate governance. I don't think we should have part-time CEOs and I don't think we should have CEOs whose fathers own dairy farms.
His professional experience – to his credit, he was one of the youngest members of, I think, the board of the College of the Sequoias. And then he won a congressional seat as a very young man. He has no business running a business, much less a tech company. This company – I think it has about a billion and a half. Let me look. DWAC. It has a market cap of $2.3 billion based on Trump as the anchor and now a CEO. We don't know who's in this pipe. It supposedly has a billion dollars. This is a private investment in public equity. It was not publicly disclosed. They don't have a product. This feels very Trumpy to me.
And Truth Social missed its November deadline. It's just December. Maybe they'll launch on January 6th. That would be a good day to launch for them.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, a little inside the Beltway humor.
Scott Galloway
A little inside the Beltway humor.
Kara Swisher
That's outside the Beltway. But it's under investigation for possible – and it probably won't go anywhere – who they told about what and what they discussed. I don't even understand it.
Scott Galloway
That joke makes you sound taller. That joke makes you sound like 5'10".
Kara Swisher
It does. I do. I'm tall. I'm tall.
Scott Galloway
By the way, Gary Gensler is targeting these pipe offerings. So rules are a-coming. This is a disaster. There won't be a product. I hate to say it, but Parler looks fantastic in comparison in terms of technology and the ability to get a product out the door. Look, there's a cycle to all of this innovation. SPACs are an innovation. Typically, whether it's junk bonds, whether it's the internet, or whether it's SPACs, there's excitement, there's mania, there's a huge fallout, but there will be some SPACs that endure. I do think special purpose acquisition corps as a financing vehicle will survive. It's just going to be a lot more discerning in the marketplace. When 96% of the people who gave you money based on the idea, and then you find a target, and it's like, "No, we want off this train," it means the SPAC market is reaching way too far into the barrel.
Kara Swisher
You know what Nunes should do? He should just buy one of those shitty cable competitors and compete with Fox. That's where they should stick with because that's not quite as hard to do as create a social network where you got to make fetch happen. I don't think this guy has the ability to make anything happen.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, technology, which can break down as I can personally attest to.
Kara Swisher
Speaking of which, internet services have recovered from the massive AWS outage. That was problematic. Everybody felt that. Problems caused disruptions with Alexa, Ring, Disney, Dropbox. I had a problem with... What happened with you, Scott? Give us your tale of woe.
Scott Galloway
So distinct to the fact that the VCs and the Flying Monkeys claim that everything I predict, the opposite happens.
Kara Swisher
Yes, they do.
Scott Galloway
Every year I do a public predictions webinar.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
17,000 people registered. 8,000 people showed up. Then come 5 o'clock, I'm already stretching. I'm psyching myself up. Stretching. Looking in the mirror and going, "I like you. I deserve to have a good webinar," or whatever we call this live stream. Then my tech guy – he wasn't handling the tech. It was someone else – said, "We're having a problem. They can't figure out how to go live." I'm like, "What do you mean I'm having a problem?"
Kara Swisher
And you started yelling, right? You started throwing green M&Ms everywhere.
Scott Galloway
I'm like, "Who can I yell at and just make everything harder?" Why did I think that was so? But go ahead.
Kara Swisher
But go ahead.
Scott Galloway
Then I'm like, "That's it." And I fucking pop up. I literally down or bullet a Pacifico because I'm like, "That's it. I don't even pretend not to have an alcohol problem. I'm stressed. I'm angry. I'm going to start drinking." Then freaking 6:20. This is bad news. At 6:25, I called it. I just put out a tweet saying, "I'm really sorry. I don't know what happened here. I take responsibility. We'll reschedule." And get this, because of the dog. What? 4,500 people at 5:30 were still on. What was supposedly hilarious was all the mockery and memes that went back and forth in the chat function, which was still working, fortunately. So people could mock me and my technology. But yeah, anyways, AWS. Oh, it's not your fault.
Kara Swisher
What's really weird is...
Scott Galloway
It was not Scott's fault. Just a few minutes later when we were using some new platform called Hopin or something.
Kara Swisher
Hopin. It's not new. It's a very big service. Anyway, go ahead.
Scott Galloway
Just because you're six feet doesn't give you the right to push back on me. It's one of the more promising meetings. I did get immediately – I don't know if it's a coincidence or not – I immediately got a little handwritten note. Messenger saying to me, "How do you like me now, bitch?" And it was from Zoom. It was from Zoom. Get it? "How do you like me now, bitch?" I get that. I got it. Get it? I'm shrinking. Anyway. I'm shrinking. Anyway.
Kara Swisher
Are you doing it again? Did you do it? I'm sorry.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. No, we got to reschedule. You didn't invite me to that. I wasted 17,000 people's time for an hour. I burnt an hour. I've literally killed two people. That's like two lifetimes.
Kara Swisher
All right. Well, that's good. All right. Well, there's Scott's tale of woe.
Scott Galloway
There is Scott's tale of woe. I had some good predictions. And AWS. By the way, I nailed it last year.
Kara Swisher
Did you? I'm sorry. Go ahead.
Scott Galloway
All right. I nailed my predictions last year. I nailed them. All right. Forget those flying...
Kara Swisher
Why do you get so upset by those flying monkeys? They do like to go after you.
Scott Galloway
One started to go after me, but I shut them up because of you. And I shut them down real fast.
Kara Swisher
Oh, wait. You're blaming it on me now. Now when you get attacked, that's mine.
Scott Galloway
No, it was about you. They're like, "How can you affiliate yourself with that man?" And I said, very nicely, "Fuck you," essentially. He's got a handsome voice. I'm just telling you. I'm getting a lot of that. For some reason, all the internet dudes, some of the internet dudes are getting mad at me. I got Palmer Lucky mad at me. He says I'm a bully.
Kara Swisher
No, it's only because I can do math. And I refer to their portfolios as septic tanks. Because while they force their feces from their unicorns on tours to the bullshit zoo, they get angry and see it as a crime against humanity when you get in the way of their ability to maintain their consensual hallucination with the markets. That's just me, though. They are on the warpath. I also got the former editor of the Wall Street Journal. Who is Palmer Lucky?
Scott Galloway
I think those are the cigarettes my mom smoked in the 70s. He created Oculus. He's a very good entrepreneur. Palmer, you're an excellent entrepreneur. Otherwise, please, let's stop this. Palmer Lucky. That's like a drink you ordered at the Polo Lounge in the 70s. In any case. And I'm not even going to beef with him anymore. "Hello, ladies. I drive a 240Z, and my name is Palmer Lucky." I will only talk about the Oculus and how I don't think it's going to be worldwide because it's too big of a device.
Kara Swisher
He invented the Oculus? He sold it to Facebook. Was that acquired by Facebook? Acquired, yes. It was acquired, yeah. Very, very good entrepreneur.
Scott Galloway
Oh, my God. Otherwise, we don't get on. Good for him.
Kara Swisher
I don't know him very well. I've interviewed him once or twice. And he's giving you shit about me?
Scott Galloway
I should not care. Why do I care? No, no, no, no. He's giving me shit about me. Apparently, I retweeted Orion. I don't even understand, but apparently I'm a bully. I'm a bully to wealthy men of means. But that's fine.
Kara Swisher
Well, you're, I don't know, you're lesbian privilege. You punch down. I just, it's...
Scott Galloway
I'm sorry I hurt you, Palmer. That's all I have to say.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, time for our first big story. Tim Cook apparently made a secret deal with the Chinese government to the tune of $275 billion, according to The Information, in exchange for lighter regulation from the Chinese government. Apple agreed to invest heavily in China, which it has been over the many years. It's put money into data centers, wind farms, and directly invested in companies like Didi. Still, Apple plays by China's rules. At government request, Apple has pulled apps from its store and altered the way that disputed territories appear in Apple Maps. Anyone who operates in China that's an American company does this, let me be clear. It was interesting the way it was phrased, this deal. I think he probably went over there and negotiated as if he was his own country, right? Obviously the heat on China is growing and growing. So Apple is going to be put into the spotlight rather significantly on this issue. I'm not surprised by this. I guess I was like, well, of course they do things to bend to the Chinese government. But what do you think? Maybe you have a different take.
Scott Galloway
No, I mean I have a bias towards Tim Cook and Apple. But I think that the greatest force or the greatest buffer against what could have been a really terrible conflict is NATO. I think having an umbrella of security across Europe where the major conflicts all seem to break out, having a multilateral force with a shit ton of tanks keeping the peace has been a fantastic deterrent. I think – and this is going to sound geopolitically a little strange – but I think the greatest deterrent to a very serious shooting war is Apple.
Kara Swisher
Now, what do I mean by that? No.
Scott Galloway
All right. I was wondering where you're going, Madeline Albright. But go ahead.
Kara Swisher
Give me a moment. Palmer Luckey. Palmer Luckey. Leave him alone. Don't bully him. I like that name. I like that name. Anyways, countries that trade together are much less likely to go to war. I feel like China and the U.S. are kind of the two superpowers now. The thing that helps us is when you understand each other and you make money from each other and you have a mutually vested interest and mutually vested destruction, you're more likely to try and figure out a way to work out problems around Taiwan. The most valuable company in the world – if all of a sudden every Chinese youth that has iOS, if their phone got turned off, they would be angry and think the CCP is bad and maybe we need a second party, which is Latin for revolution in China. So I think the immense amount of trade we do with one another is probably the safest thing in the world.
All right, all right. Well, that's the argument. That's been the long argument that if we're in there, we're going to change them. I do not believe that's the case.
Scott Galloway
I'm not saying we're going to change them, Kara. I'm saying they're going to think twice before they really get aggressive, as are we. I mean, the bottom line – we could have 500 million people flow into our borders and we couldn't make all the shit we need. So we need China. Apple is one of the, probably, I imagine, the biggest employers in China. I would guess.
Kara Swisher
They have definitely gone over. Obviously, Google pulled out over lots of reasons. Other companies did. Some people talked about forced labor. That said, a lot of these people just couldn't operate in China. It's a very complex place to operate. Facebook's not there. This is just in tech. But News Corp's been in there. There's all kinds of – Disney – they pulled some criticism. There was a whole controversy over one of its stars saying something against China and then having to pull it. I think it was – I forget who it was. Anyway, it happens a lot. John Cena said that Taiwan wasn't a country.
No, he apologized for saying Taiwan was a country. Yes, exactly. But that's one of dozens of times this has happened. So lots of media companies have already been through the ringer here. It's not a surprise that Apple is. I think what the issue is, is that more and more pressure is going to be put on all U.S. companies around China. There's coalescing around aggression towards China, whether it's Marco Rubio or Joe Biden or Donald Trump or whoever. This is a trend of painting them as our big rival. I think it's going to be a dicey time for Apple in terms of how to negotiate and operate because it's so important to its business to be operating in China and making things in China.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I just don't know. The bottom line is they are so pregnant with China. The most robust supply chain in the world is run by the most valuable company in the world, which has more employees in China than it does in its home sovereign. So I think they're very dependent upon us. I think we're very dependent upon them. I think that's a good thing. I think that just creates cooler heads. I think everyone has motivation to try and figure this shit out. It also gives us teeth to do stuff if and when they continue to perform what I'll call, genocide light or putting ethnic groups in re-education camps or what you want to call them.
Because I was even thinking about Biden's call where he talked to Russia and said, "We're going to clamp down." And you're like, "Jesus Christ, we still have sanctions that haven't been issued against them." So building up economic involvement gives you the ability to untangle them and hurt that other nation. They could hurt us just as badly at this point, which we're not used to. I'll just give you an example. I think as Americans, it's good that we're putting pressure on them for human rights. I think we should continue to do that. The disappearance of a tennis player is really disturbing. At the same time, you can put yourself in their shoes and go, "What moral authority do you have?
You just had a president who just overran the fucking Capitol. Who are you to lecture us?"
Kara Swisher
Well, yeah, that's the other part of that foreign equation. But here's the deal. This is going to be a very difficult time for them. Lots of Microsoft's there. Boeing is there. There's all kinds of things around this. It's just going to get worse. And Apple is now the target. The reaction has not been good to this deal. It should be no surprise that there was this deal, but it's going to attract all kinds of issues. The New York Times actually had a big story about – it was called "Inside Apple's Compromises in China," a Times investigation. So it's just – it's now going to attract all kinds of attention. It just is. So that's just the way it's going to be.
Scott Galloway
But, I mean, Boeing and Apple, they raise the issue so they get all of the attention. But if all of a sudden Chinese manufacturing – we couldn't have this podcast right now. 40% of the furniture in your room would disappear. Half of our clothing would go. People really don't have a sense. Something like 92% of toys are manufactured in China. I think that's a good thing. I think comparative advantage is a good thing.
Kara Swisher
All right. We'll see how it goes. I don't think it's a good thing for Apple right now. I think there's going to be increased pressure going forward. All right. I apologize because I don't know the story and you know the company better than I do. What exactly are they accusing them of?
Scott Galloway
Not accusing them, that they just – they were doing – they would put money into this to help the country grow and that they would do things like pulling apps. This is – lots of people do these things. Lots of companies do this when they're in these countries. And so altered the way disputed territories appears in Apple Maps there, stuff like that. The stuff you'd expect. One of the reasons Google left was because of this stuff. And Apple is not leaving. This is what you do if you operate in China and they were willing to do that. So I would say it's no surprise and yet I think it's going to bring enormous pressure on this company, no matter what.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, let's go on a quick break. When we come back, we'll talk about a big lawsuit in the world of digital advertising, Scott's area of expertise, and take a listener mail question.
Mint is still $15 a month for premium wireless. And if you haven't made the switch yet, here are 15 reasons why you should. One, it's $15 a month. Two, seriously, it's $15 a month. Three, no big contracts. Four, I use it. Five, my mom uses it. Are you playing me off? That's what's happening, right? Okay. Give it a try at mintmobile.com/switch. Upfront payment of for three month plan per month equivalent required. New customer offer first three months only then full price plan options available. Taxes and fees extra. See mintmobile.com.
Support for Pivot comes from LinkedIn. From talking about sports, discussing the latest movies, everyone is looking for a real connection to the people around them. But it's not just person to person. It's the same connection that's needed in business. And it can be the hardest part about B2B marketing, finding the right people, making the right connections. But instead of spending hours and hours scavenging social media feeds, you can just tap LinkedIn ads to reach the right professionals. According to LinkedIn, they have grown to a network of over one billion professionals, making it stand apart from other ad buys. You can target your buyers by job title, industry, company roles, seniority, skills, and company revenue, giving you all the professionals you need to reach in one place. So you can stop wasting budget on the wrong audience and start targeting the right professionals only on LinkedIn ads. LinkedIn will even give you $100 credit on your next campaign so you can try it for yourself. Just go to linkedin.com/slash/pivotpod. That's linkedin.com/slash/pivotpod. Terms and conditions apply. Only on LinkedIn ads.
Scott, we're back with our second big story. Newspapers around the country have been quietly filing antitrust lawsuits against Google and Facebook, arguing big tech is monopolizing digital ad revenue. This is, again, not a new thing. It's been going on for a while. You and I both know people at these organizations that have talked about this for a while. It's happened in Europe. Lawsuits from more than 200 newspapers were consolidated in the Southern District of New York over the summer. A lawyer for the publisher said the goal is to, quote, "recover past damages to newspapers" and to, quote, "establish a new system going forward in which newspapers aren't just competitive again, but can thrive." Again, happened in Australia, happened all over the place. These deals with these companies in Australia. Google and Facebook are paying news publishers by law. That might happen here. It's being worked on in Canada. So what do you think of all this? What do you think about this?
Look, and I'm not — like most of the things I would say, I'm reflecting myself in a very good light, a taller light. But in my first meeting, I'm on the board of the New York Times. I'm like, we should turn off Google. Our infatuation with being part of the cool club and hanging out with the popular kids has resulted in us debasing our gorgeous content. They slice it up, they sell it for 10 cents and give us a quarter of a cent, and we act like we're excited because we're embracing the future. And they basically came in and turned a lot of content into a sewer and debased our amazing content. I found it very frustrating. I think Facebook and Google did nothing much more complex than pull up a dump truck to the vault of every newspaper company and take money out.
Scott Galloway
Now, that's not to say they weren't being unbundled on their own. It's not to say they didn't need to innovate. Which they didn't.
Kara Swisher
The New York Times did.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. The New York Times is — I mean, you work for them. I think they've actually been very innovative.
Kara Swisher
Yes, but it's still not enough. They're tiny. They're like a little dinghy with ocean liners.
Scott Galloway
But what? We went and acquired About.com because we wanted to accessorize our analog outfit with digital earrings. And we paid $400 million for it.
Kara Swisher
I remember. It was growing. It was worth a billion.
Scott Galloway
And then overnight, we got a message from the CTO saying About.com's revenue is down 60% today. Traffic is down 60% because Google did an update. Google just said, you know what? Rather than letting you monetize that, we're just going to take all that revenue. And if you want to talk about rents and duopoly and monopoly, this is overdue, this lawsuit. Look what has happened with Amazon. In 2014, if you were a retailer in the third-party marketplace, between placement fees, between paying for fulfillment, between them twisting your arm and forcing you to spend money on Amazon Media Group so that you could come up in higher rankings — Amazon is the second largest search engine — you had to pay Amazon an average in 2014 of 19% of your sales. So if you sold $100 worth of goods as a retailer on the third-party platform, you gave up approximately 19 cents. Now it's 34 cents. The rents these companies are able to extract from corporate America has gone up every year. When 60 cents on the dollar go to just two players in the medium that everybody has to play in, it doesn't mean it's a capitalist point of differentiation. It's a tax.
Kara Swisher
Right.
Scott Galloway
And no one company has been able to develop strategic advantage using this medium, similar to what Nike's done with TV or Williams-Sonoma's done with catalogs. We all have to use it. And when everyone has to use something and can't establish advantage from it, it's a tax. It's not a service. So the monopoly and duopoly power here has just run unfettered. I'm happy to see them do it. I'm happy to see them follow these suits.
Kara Swisher
May I ask, what can be done? How can you roll back the — it's like unmixing cream and tea. It's just done. Probably there'll be some payments. First, we gave it away, then we took some payments, and then we've always sort of been lining up to whatever gruel they hand us. But what can actually be done? This is now a secular change that is finished, really.
Scott Galloway
Well, there's remedies and damages if they say they used unfair pricing or cartel power. There's a cartel pricing case in Texas that says senior executives from Google and Facebook coordinated to keep prices high for advertisers. The interesting thing about that case is there's criminal remedies. But if you were to force Facebook to spin Instagram and WhatsApp, and maybe force Amazon to spin Amazon Media Group, all of a sudden you have more competitors and more supply, which should lower the rents on the demand side. The bottom line is when there's one or two providers across millions of buyers, one or two providers do really well. So we just need more providers, or more options.
Kara Swisher
I mean, I think you run the danger of there being legislation. There's been legislation everywhere. Obviously, in Australia it happened. There's some here in this country. It's just digital competition with newspapers, I think, is over. I think they've won this one. The question is, what can happen? Since 2006, newspaper ad revenue has dropped 50%. Not a surprise. It was already dropping because of Walmart and everybody else not advertising, and then there's classifieds. So I'm not so sure what saving them will mean except for a few large ones like the Times or the Post.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. I don't — if my suggestion was that every media company — and I suggested this in 2008 — and I wanted to get the Salzburgers, the Murdochs, the Hearst family, the Pearsons, basically every large print media company together and say we need to be like the Record Labels Association. We need to bind together and license all of our content or none of it to one or more of these search engines. This is back when Microsoft still thought they had a shot.
Kara Swisher
What did they say?
Scott Galloway
They looked at you. I mean, the New York Times thought of the Wall Street Journal as their competitor. I'm like, no. They're our adversary. Our enemy is in Cupertino. Wake up, guys. We're bickering with each other. Meanwhile, the Panzer tanks are lining up at the border.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
And what did they say? The official word back was we would be committing antitrust. This is how fucked up the laws were. If the newspaper companies bind together to try and get some better terms from Google, that is antitrust. You had 93% of the search market controlled by one company is not antitrust. We need different laws.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
So, look, these companies, all media companies in my mind, outside of Google and Facebook, need to do a better job of pushing back with one voice. The key to winning a war is to atomize your competition. I remember us prostrating ourselves to Steve Jobs. Like, oh, we wanted to be in the App Store and give them huge revenue and give them huge commissions. So did the Journal. I was in meetings like that. He loved it. He knew. Because the CEO of the company loved having drinks with Steve Jobs.
Kara Swisher
I mean, it's just, we're so fascinated hanging out with the cool kids that we entered into ridiculously bad business records. You know what Jobs did in one meeting with the Journal? He literally insulted them all, said, like, you suck at tech. You're never going to beat us. It was so funny to watch. They sort of sat there and took it. I was just like, okay, guys, this is who he is. Murdoch tried a whole bunch of things. They did the Daily, it was called, that Daily app. Then before that, they had something else. I can't even remember. But everybody tried a lot of things, for sure. The question is, did any of it really matter? It seems like most of it really didn't. They couldn't keep up. Jobs was right. Technically, from a technological perspective, they were toast, is essentially what he told all the media companies that I saw him speak to.
Transition
Anyhow, let's pivot to a listener question. Let's go. You've got mail.
Listener Voicemail
Hey, Kara, Scott, it's Corey from New York. I had a question about the Better.com layoff. Scott, you always mentioned that you can't control the layoffs, but you can protect the people that are being laid off. Given that this layoff was three weeks prior to Christmas and one of the hardest seasons to be hired in, and that they are only getting four weeks of severance, I'd love to hear your thoughts on the situation. Thanks, guys. Love the show. Bye.
Kara Swisher
Okay. This is a really — I haven't really followed this until just recently. The chief executive of Better.com, Vishal Garg, laid off 900 employees over Zoom. On a networking site, Blind, he accused the terminated employees of stealing from the company by underworking, saying, "You guys know that at least 250 of the people terminated were working an average of two hours a day while clocking in eight hours plus a day in the payroll system. They were stealing from you and stealing from our customers who pay the bills. They pay our bills, get educated." He later apologized for failing to show the appropriate amount of respect and appreciation. So any lessons here? Not good. Not good. This didn't make him look good, even if he might have been right, possibly. I have no idea. I have no information on this. But what do you think?
Scott Galloway
Well, so I wasn't expecting this question. Just disclosure. I'm an investor in Better.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. So take that for what it's worth. So how do you assess your CEO's behavior?
Scott Galloway
Oh, this is an easy one. He fucked up. Compare and contrast this with how Chesky laid off employees. And by the way, companies that are growing lay off people all the time. Oftentimes it's the right thing to do. Google, in the midst of its power alley, laid off like a thousand people because they felt they were getting fat. And back to his original notion, what he was referring to is — we talk a lot about this in management and board meetings. It's always a difficult decision to lay off people. I feel like you need to be fairly shareholder driven or Darwinian about the decision.
Kara Swisher
Yes, you are. You always say that.
Scott Galloway
But once the decision is made, you become very generous. That is big severance packages. You try and do it in a way that is dignified. People should be disappointed, but they shouldn't be scared. They shouldn't be like, "Oh, fuck, how am I going to pay my mortgage?" Especially if you're a company that is doing well and has cash. I don't know the specifics. I think the severance is going to be more than that. If it's just four weeks before the holidays, that too is a fuck up on top of a fuck up. The strange thing is, as soon as I heard the story, I went on Google and I love tracking the number of news hits.
And this is what's really sad about this. And this isn't a comment about Better, but a comment about our society. You know what's going to happen to their business in the next 30 days? It's going to go up. Because we live in a society now where awareness is kind of the key attribute. People are like, "Oh, I heard of a company called Better. Oh, I'm thinking about an online mortgage. Can I get a lower interest rate?" And now they've heard of this company. I'm not excusing it in any way, but I think part of the innovator's dilemma here, what's dangerous about our society, is it's more important to be in the news than it is what you're in the news for when you're a tech company.
You're just part of the narrative. But there's just no getting around it. I know Vishal. I like him. Brilliant product guy. It's an amazing company. It's de-SPACing with SoftBank. It's just an incredible company. He's done an amazing job. God, did he fuck up. That was so tone deaf. And around the holidays, the company has the money. I don't think it's going to be four-week severance. I'm almost entirely positive it's going to be much more than that. But compare and contrast it with what Brian Chesky did around his layoffs.
Kara Swisher
He did. And people were unhappy anyway. I got a lot of pushback when I complimented it. They were like, "He didn't do this." I was like, boy, no one's going to be happy with everything. I mean, what are your thoughts on this? I think it's a speed bump. I don't really think it's going to affect the company long term. That doesn't excuse it. But there's a lot of lessons here.
Scott Galloway
I remember when my first company, Profit — we've gone 10 seconds without talking about Scott, so let's fix that. My first company, a brand strategy firm, we brought in a CEO, raised some money, and immediately went from 60 to 120 people. Hired huge, massive hiring. Business softens. I think it was 2000, I forget which recession it was. And I had to call 40 people into a room and say everybody in this room is being laid off. These are kids who just got out of business school, who had a lot of opportunity, a lot of options, bought into our vision, moved to San Francisco. And 12 weeks later, some guy who lives in Noe Valley is telling them, "Sorry, because I'm an idiot and I approved this plan, I've got to let you go."
I think all you can do is — there's no easy way to kill someone. We've taken cameras out of war zones because we realize when we get a number back that we've killed half a million Iraqis, we like to think that they just floated away into Iraqi heaven. War is fucking gruesome. And one of the reasons — and it was a worthwhile reason, and I think we should have cameras in ICUs and on every battlefield — is that there's just no elegant way to kill someone. Quite frankly, there's no really elegant, humane way to fire someone. You know one of the reasons I'm not CEO of my ed tech company right now?
Because I'm done firing people.
Kara Swisher
Yep.
Scott Galloway
I've done only a few and I didn't like any of them. One of the best explanations of firing, I would point everyone to one of my favorite movies, *Broadcast News*, where they're firing people in the station. There's a line where he says, "Is there anything I could do for you?" And the guy says, "Well, you could die."
Kara Swisher
"Well, you could die." It was a great line. Albert Brooks, come on.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, what a great movie.
Kara Swisher
Come on, Holly Hunter. I love Albert Brooks. William Hurt. I'll drink a lemonade. It's my favorite movie. I actually own the movie. I physically still own it.
Scott Galloway
I can totally see you loving it.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, Holly Hunter.
Scott Galloway
In any case, there's a line where Jack Nicholson is the anchor for the whole broadcast. He comes in only for a minute. He only has a few short scenes. And he goes, "All this because they couldn't program Tuesday night." It's just like, you fucked up. Best line of the movie.
Kara Swisher
Best line of the one. William Hurt says to Albert Brooks, he says, "What happens when your reality exceeds your dreams?" And you know what Albert Brooks says? "Keep it to yourself."
Scott Galloway
"Keep it to yourself." Oh, that's good.
Kara Swisher
That movie is full of great lines. It's a great film. James L. Brooks, fantastic. He loves the newsroom.
Scott Galloway
It's such a good movie. It influenced me a great deal. Anyway, he fucked up. But let's just say he fucked up. And here's an investor telling you that. He fucked up.
Kara Swisher
I also think he fucked up. All right, Scott, one more quick break. We'll be back for predictions. Maybe you can give me one of your fancy predictions that you couldn't get out to the people.
Break
Okay, Scott, give us this week's predictions. You must have a boatload since you didn't get them out to the people in your AWS ruined situation that you were working on.
Scott Galloway
I have a bevy of them, but I'm going to be a coy little minx here.
Kara Swisher
Okay, give me one of your bevy. Just peel off a grape, please. Go ahead.
Scott Galloway
What I'm going to do, and this is almost as much fun, is I'm going to review verbatim my predictions from December 2020.
Kara Swisher
Is this where you pat yourself on the back part of the show? Okay.
Scott Galloway
Well, I got some wrong, too. All right. So we'll go through them. I predicted when Bitcoin was at $22,000 that it would hit $50,000. I got that right. I put that we might work. I was especially fond of the language there, that they would get public. I think I got that right. I put — and this was when Airbnb was a private company — I put Airbnb was going to hit $200 a share. They priced it $68. I said it's going to hit $200 a share. I got that right. I said CNN was going to go behind a paywall. I got that right. Sort of. I said Restoration Hardware would hit $1,000 and Sonos would reach $40 because I thought there'd be such a massive dispersion of value in assets that would decentralize from offices to homes. I got that half right. Sonos hit $40. Resto never hit $1,000, although it's up about 40% for the year. Okay. I said, and you've heard this over and over, I predicted that Apple would acquire Peloton. I got that wrong.
Kara Swisher
But someday. This is going to be like your Jack Dorsey thing.
Scott Galloway
We'll see. Broken clock, right? Broken clock. I predicted Roblox stock would double from its offer price within six months. I was wrong. It's gone up about five-fold. And this one, I think you've heard this before, Twitter hit $60 and Dorsey is ousted. Hello, champagne and cocaine. Although there were some reports that he wasn't ousted. Whatever. Hello. He's gone.
Kara Swisher
Yep.
Scott Galloway
Okay. Oh, and I always get political and angry. My prediction was Robinhood is the new menace, and you can decide if that's right or wrong. Anyways, last year was one of my better years for predictions.
Kara Swisher
We'll see. Very good. Okay. Give me one. Peel off a little grape here. By the way, Airbnb stock is now at 182.26, but it did hit 206 in November. When I made the prediction, was it 68? Give a little love to the dog. Rub his belly.
Scott Galloway
Rub his belly.
Kara Swisher
You did? Rub his belly.
Scott Galloway
By the way, we just spayed Leia, and she has this big incision along her torso. So we have to wrap her in towels. She loves to go to the beach, obviously, as does every dog. And she literally cries when we don't get her out. So we wrapped her in dish towels and diapers to create a makeshift Spanx bodysuit. It's a great conversation starter.
Kara Swisher
Is that your prediction? Great Dane and Spanx.
Scott Galloway
No, my prediction is the following, and it could get us canceled off Pivot.
Kara Swisher
Oh, no. Okay.
Scott Galloway
This is just human nature. I don't know anything. I don't think it's any accident that Bret Taylor was made co-CEO of Salesforce and chairman of Twitter at the same time. Okay. I'm pretty sure — first off, this notion that, oh, it was Jack's idea. Elliot came in, I'm pretty sure, and said, "Okay, this is fucking ridiculous. You're out of here. We'll make it dignified, but you're leaving." All right. And I'm pretty sure — I think this guy Bret is a really talented manager.
Kara Swisher
He is indeed.
Scott Galloway
I'm pretty sure Twitter — this is just pure conjecture. I have absolutely no idea what happened here, but that's my conjecture because I think I understand humans and the way these things play out. I would bet the Twitter board said, "Bret, would you consider being CEO?" And then Bret went back to Marc and said, "Hey, Marc, by the way, Twitter wants me to be CEO." And he's like, "Hello, Mr. Co-CEO of Salesforce, and you can be chairman." But the prediction is simple. Salesforce is going to acquire Twitter. We know Marc Benioff wants it.
Kara Swisher
Has wanted it in the past.
Scott Galloway
Has wanted it. And here's the thing. This is why things are different this time, Kara. When they wanted it in 2016, and supposedly his board threw up on it, Salesforce had about a $70 or $80 billion market cap, and Twitter was at 25, meaning there would be a 25 or 30% dilution, kind of a bet the ranch. Now, Salesforce, because of outstanding execution, has a $275 billion market cap. And Twitter has a $38 billion market cap, meaning this is no longer a bet the ranch acquisition. Twitter, by virtue of a percentage of dilution, is now 50 to 70% less expensive.
Kara Swisher
I thought you were predicting that Jack Dorsey was going to buy it from Square because he's at a similar.
Scott Galloway
That might happen. My prediction is Salesforce or a fintech company is going to acquire Twitter by the end of 2022.
Kara Swisher
And of course, you said this at a dinner with Marc, didn't you? And caused the room to stop talking.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, with Marc. And everyone just went quiet. Lovely dinner. Yo-Yo Ma then played. I thought it was like prom in 1998.
Kara Swisher
Okay. All right. So glad that you're doing this. I should have gone to that dinner. We'll see where it goes. I think it's interesting to lay it out. This is not — this is Scott's predictions, people. So don't bend my ear about whether he's right or wrong. This is his analysis. It's called analysis.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, lucky, Palmer lucky. Go get lucky on your Palmer somewhere else.
Kara Swisher
He did not insult you. Let me be fair. He did not insult you. You insulted just me.
Scott Galloway
Well, I like him. You should be nicer to him then.
Kara Swisher
Okay, I'm going to try. I'm going to try. You should be nicer to him then. I don't even know him. I'm just going to remove each other from our consideration. Anyway.
Scott Galloway
You're so not used to getting attacked.
Kara Swisher
I'm not. No, I just think it's bullshit.
Scott Galloway
No, no, no. You've gone from a group that took too much shit. You are now a protected class, just so you know.
Kara Swisher
No, I am used to being attacked.
Scott Galloway
Oh, it is open season on the 50-something white guys.
Kara Swisher
Listen, I have my mother. I'm used to being attacked. I'm very good at being attacked.
Scott Galloway
Lucky. Lucky. Lucky. Lucky.
Kara Swisher
I am made for being attacked. Anyway, yes, she's coming down for Christmas. That should be an interesting time.
Scott Galloway
Coming down for the holidays? Oh, yeah. It's beginning to look a lot like lucky.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it is indeed. Anyway, we will see your prediction. I think it's really interesting. I like these creative analysis of these things, and I look forward to when your prediction show is, and then we will do it. Thank you for going over your predictions. Those were very interesting. Anyway, read us out, and we will be back on Tuesday for more.
Scott Galloway
Yes, absolutely.
Kara Swisher
Oh, that's right. We're coming back, right? What is our holiday schedule? Do we need to give the viewers a—
Scott Galloway
Let me look. We are next Tuesday. I think there's some episodes coming up of year-end things that we've already taped. And then we'll be back live again on the 6th of—
Kara Swisher
We'll tape on the 6th of January for the 7th. So we'll have a little time off. But we have taped some very lively and saucy shows for you for year-end.
Scott Galloway
Saucy. Saucy.
Kara Swisher
You know what I'm doing on Wednesday?
Scott Galloway
What?
Kara Swisher
You know what I'm doing on Wednesday?
Scott Galloway
What?
Kara Swisher
I'm taking my boys to the Chelsea Everton match in London to see Belgian striker Romelu Lukaku.
Scott Galloway
Oh, my God. Where are you going? Life is good. London? You're going to London?
Kara Swisher
I'm going to London, yeah. When? Over the weekend? And then I'm going to Thailand. Oh, they didn't tell you? Wait. Should I give our producers a heads up? Okay. Bring in Katie Couric. So you're not flying in for my birthday.
Scott Galloway
It's your birthday? Well, then I'm not going. Yeah. You're not bringing in the jet, scrambling the jets for Kara Swisher. That's right.
Kara Swisher
I'm going to see *West Side Story* by myself. That is my gift to myself, by the way. You're going to see *West Side Story* by yourself. Steven Spielberg did it. It's been written by Kushner, who did *Angels in America*. And I am so looking forward to it. I'm going by myself. My son is going to cook me dinner. Amanda's going to make dessert, my favorite dinner, which is he makes fresh clam sauce and fresh pasta. And then I'm going to the movies by myself to see my favorite musical of all time. And it got stellar reviews. It's supposed to be great. You're going to London. I'm going to *West Side Story*.
Scott Galloway
In any case, I will be doing the dinners from now on, Marc Benioff. I apologize. I'm so sorry, but it is what it is, as they say.
Kara Swisher
It is what it is. Who produced today's show, you may ask? Lara Naiman, Evan Engel, and Taylor Griffin. Thanks also to Drew Burrows and Mio Silverio. Ernie Entertot engineered this episode. Make sure you subscribe to the show on Apple Podcasts, or if you're an Android user, check us out on Spotify or, frankly, wherever you listen to podcasts. Thanks for listening to Pivot from Vox Media. We'll be back next Tuesday for another breakdown of all things tech and business.
Scott Galloway
Romelu Lukaku.