Main Topic: The podcast episode is a conversation between Kara Swisher and Bill Gates, discussing various topics such as AI, climate change, misinformation, and income inequality.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Additional Notes:
Kara Swisher
Mint is still $15 a month for premium wireless. And if you haven't made the switch yet, here are 15 reasons why you should. One, it's $15 a month. Two, seriously, it's $15 a month. Three, no big contracts. Four, I use it. Five, my mom uses it. Are you playing me off? That's what's happening, right? Okay. Give it a try at mintmobile.com slash switch. Upfront payment of $45 for three-month plan, $15 per month equivalent required. New customer offer first three months only. Then full price plan options available. Taxes and fees extra. See mintmobile.com.
Running a business comes with a lot of what-ifs, but luckily there's a simple answer to them. Shopify. It's the commerce platform behind millions of businesses, including Thrive Cosmetics and Momofuku, and it'll help you with everything you need. From website design and marketing to boosting sales and expanding operations, Shopify can get the job done and make your dream a reality. Turn those what-ifs into... Sign up for your $1 per month trial at shopify.com slash special offer.
Have you ever noticed how nearly every pop song has a Swedish mega producer on it? I'm Charlie Harding from Switched On Pop, from K-pop to R&B to dance music. It's literally everywhere. Check out Switched On Pop wherever you get your podcasts and take a trip to Sweden on our latest episode where we chat with Zara Larsson, who tells us all about the land that is sometimes all sun, sometimes all night, and how it has taken over the sound of pop music.
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher. We're off today for the holiday, but we have an episode of On with Kara Swisher for you.
Scott Galloway
Oh, yay. Yay. Who's on this time? The head of DEI from the National Forestry Service?
Kara Swisher
No, no, no. That's just what I say for Pivot. This is my interview with Bill Gates. You might have heard of him.
Scott Galloway
Oh, my God. In front of a live audience. I got to be honest. That's impressive. That's impressive.
Kara Swisher
Thank you. I try. It's on! It's called *What's Next? The Future with Bill Gates*, and it's about some of the biggest issues we face at the moment: AI, disinformation, global health, the wealth gap, and how technology could help or not. It's a funny and substantive series by Morgan Neville, who did docs like *Won't You Be My Neighbor* about Mr. Rogers, *Roadrunner* about Anthony Bourdain, and *20 Feet from Stardom*, which garnered him an Oscar. It's a good match since Neville got Gates to actually use his own experiences as case studies in some of the episodes. It's surprisingly intimate, actually, and I actually really liked it. I didn't think it would be as good as it was, and it really is, especially for people who don't know a lot about these topics.
It was also great to be back on stage with Bill, whom I've interviewed many times, including an historic interview with the late Steve Jobs. While we've had plenty of disagreements over the three decades I've covered Microsoft and also Bill Gates, I took the opportunity to dig a bit deeper and ask him about his interests and investments into many of these areas, including nuclear power, how he would handle attacks on the rich, and the outcome he's hoping for in the upcoming presidential election. Plot spoiler, he implied, referencing climate change deniers, that he's voting for Vice President Kamala Harris, although he certainly didn't make an endorsement.
I hope you enjoy it. And by the way, we love that you're listening. And it's even better if you hit subscribe to follow the show to get even more exclusive conversations like this in your feed every Monday and Thursday. So let's get to it live from the Paris Theatre. It is on.
Applause
Hi, everybody. How you doing? I used to come to this theatre as a kid. It's fantastic to be here. Owned by Netflix. Wow, that's something. Anyway, thank you for coming. It's a little lightness here: inequality, AI, climate change, disease. What else are we talking about? But at least we're not Eric Adams, are we? Okay, I had to do that. Oh, come on.
Laughter
Anyway, I love New York. Anyway, I'm very excited actually to talk to Bill. I've interviewed him dozens of times over the many years. We first met when he came pouring out of a cab in very sweaty, summery Washington, D.C. I thought he had arrived in the limbo, but it was some other guy, and he just got out of a DC cab and did an amazing interview with the Washington Post editorial board and came himself and everything else. So that's where we started. I've covered Microsoft for years and talked to him a number of times. We've agreed, not that much, but disagreed a lot. But also, I think this phase of his life is really interesting, and he really is an information sponge, curiosity, and he loves to take apart problems. And I think what he's done around disease and other things is really interesting. The last interview we did was about climate change, which is a book that he wrote. And it's actually coming true today, a lot of the stuff he was talking about. So without further ado, Bill Gates.
Applause
Ah, we meet again. So, there's so much to talk about. I think what we're going to do is we're going to throw to some clips and then talk about them. We're literally going to have to rush through this stuff because we've only got about 40 minutes to get through all these major topics. And you could do hours on each of these things. But let's start with AI. Let's go to the clip to start with.
Clip plays
James Cameron
And you're talking to James Cameron. And a me is a, "Hey, innovation can solve everything" type person. Right. Says, "Oh, thank goodness. Now I have the AI on my team."
Bill Gates
Yeah.
James Cameron
I'm probably more of a dystopian. I write science fiction, I wrote *The Terminator*. Where do you and I find common ground around optimism, I think is the key here.
Bill Gates
I would like the message to be balanced between this longer term concern of infinite capability with the basic needs to have your health care and care of to learn to accelerate climate innovation. Is that too nuanced a message to say that AI has these benefits while we have to guard against these other things?
James Cameron
I don't think it's too nuanced at all. I think it's exactly the right degree of nuance that we need. I mean, you're a humanist, right? As long as that humanist principle is first and foremost, as opposed to the drive to dominate market share, the drive to power. If we can make AI the force for good that it has the potential to be, great. But how do we introduce caution? Regulation is part of it, but I think it's also our own ethos and our own value system.
Clip ends
Kara Swisher
So that's a perfect person, the creator of *The Terminator*, which I think has informed a lot of people about AI, the idea that it's here to kill us, essentially. And the person I talked about AI with was Elon Musk, actually, who was quite worried about it at the time. He thought it was here to kill us. Later, he evolved it into treating us like house cats. Then he said we were like anthills, that the highway will come through and just cover us, et cetera. Always a happy day with Elon Musk.
But when I was watching this, I watched it again on the train up here. It's advanced quicker than anyone, including yourself, had thought, right? That it's moved quicker. And you talk about this, and it's a very good explainer in the film. But I want you to sort of unpack why you're still very sunny about it, I would say, and I think you lean towards the possibility. So talk a little bit about that.
Bill Gates
Well, the idea that computers would eventually become intelligent and do human-like things, as soon as you learn how to program, you're thinking, "Wow, what can't software do and why not?" Prosaic things like visual recognition, speech recognition, seemed out of reach. I was age 15 when I saw this Stanford SRI Shakey the Robot video, and I thought, "Wow, we are getting close. Look at that. Shaky almost can do these things." So it has been mostly disappointing when the neural nets came in. Then the prosaic stuff, the speech and video got strong. But even then, the idea of representing knowledge, being able to read and write, still seemed out of reach. And I believe that we'd have to explicitly understand how to represent knowledge. I didn't think that pure reinforcement would cause this great knowledge representation to emerge. And even GPT-3, it's still statistical. It's not really a world model. And so it's going to be deeply flawed. But by GPT-4, that was wrong. So right up there with my first demo of graphics interface with Charles Simonyi, I'd say that demo of ChatGPT-4 was the most amazing demo I've ever seen.
Kara Swisher
I think a lot of people attribute the huge amount of information we've been putting into the internet right now as the leaping point. What do you... because I was at a dinner with a very smart group of technologists, and they didn't know. So talk about not knowing, because software is about knowing. When you put something in, you take something out. But what do you attribute the leap to recently?
Bill Gates
Well, there's a subtlety to how the world gets represented that this is captured. If you told me to write a piece of software that you could say, "Rewrite this like Shakespeare would or like Trump would or like Harari would," I would have no idea how to write a piece of software that is as fluent as this is. And so that's an emergent set of capabilities that shows that it is, in a deep, deep sense, representing what it is to write like Shakespeare. And how our algorithms generate that is subtle enough. And we have a lot of mathematicians working on trying to figure out those representations. But it does make it harder for us to know, okay, where is it correct? Where is it incorrect?
Kara Swisher
Right, but it's not Shakespeare. It can write like Shakespeare. When does it move to whatever Shakespeare may be? It's representing us.
Bill Gates
Well, if your goal is utilitarian to say, compare humans in terms of medical diagnosis to this ability to look at all the medical records and see outcomes, to look at all the latest medical literature, to look at your sensor data over your lifetime, clearly the computer is very close and will exceed human diagnosis capability within the next few years. It will be superior at a very profound and important task. And that's just provable that it will be better. If you're talking about art, then we don't have an agreed utility function. Why is some art more popular than others? It can't enter that realm because there's no data to center it on a common metric.
Kara Swisher
What then is it lacking? I mean, you're talking about the utility. You often talk about healthcare. Education is another area. Drug discovery, gene research, et cetera. These are all utilities. But a lot of the worries are about things that aren't utilities, that it will start to make decisions for us. Where's the worry point that you have? Because often most of the technologists talk about the positive parts about it. And I understand why you would talk about the negatives in the beginning, given our past history recently.
Bill Gates
Well, there's three things you can worry about. One is that people with bad intent will use AIs for cybercrime, bioterrorism, nation-state wars. In that case, you think, "Okay, let's make sure the good guys have an AI that can play defense against those things." And that makes you want to move ahead and not fall behind. The second thing you could worry about is that the rate of change where technical support jobs, telesales jobs... In the same way that medical diagnosis will be superior with the right training set and a few more turns to the crank on how we drive reliability, there's great progress on that.
It will be superior at a telesales or telesupport type job, which are big parts of the economy. And so even though you can say that frees those people up so we can have class size of five and every handicapped kid can have a full aide and elderly people can be engaged in social activity, we have unmet needs for labor. If we free up all this labor, we can shorten the work week, but the rate of change is scary. And so those are the two I worry about. The third one that comes up a lot is the loss of control. My view is if you've managed to get through the first two, that actually that's not the hardest of the three.
And it's actually kind of weird to go to that one because it's pretty far from the future. We know that bad people will use AI in a bad way. The AI itself, I think, doesn't care. I don't think that's the one to obsess about, particularly given the rate that this is happening. This is not a generational change. It's just within a 10-year type change.
Kara Swisher
Sure. One of the things that's, when you just say loss of control, I think some of us are loss of control to giant companies that are going to dominate this area. OpenAI is raising money at $150 billion valuation. There's some sort of kerfuffle going on among all the executives, but it's turning into a for-profit corporation. It started as a nonprofit to help humanity. Now it's going to help a few humans, a few select humans. Microsoft now has vaulted ahead with its investment in OpenAI and everything else. If there's a few corporations running this, I would worry about that. Would you?
Bill Gates
Well, in general. Although you're a big shareholder, Microsoft. We have this thing called competition. And the main thing you want is that it's so competitive that the improvements go to benefit the user. That is, the quality of medical diagnosis improves the health system. The availability of that personal tutor that I was out in Newark seeing a few months ago, that becomes super cheap for kids in the inner city, not just wealthy kids. And I've never seen such intense competition. It's the same way as the internet in 2000, 2001. The failure rate will be unbelievable because they're sort of a, "Oh, it's an AI thing, give it a high valuation." So consumers will be the primary beneficiaries. Now, if you ever get to the point where one company has knocked the other companies out, then fine, the competition authorities can come in. But we're not even close to that. Google is still extremely capable in this space, OpenAI plus Microsoft. But Elon's got xAI, you've got Anthropic, at least 15 companies that aren't that far from the state of the art who are lowering prices. They're investing way above the revenue level. And so this is the formula for the benefits to flow to society.
Kara Swisher
Okay, we're going to rush this. But what's very quickly your biggest worry, a real worry, and your biggest benefit right now?
Bill Gates
Well, the biggest benefit is that I think this technology, and this is my primary engagement with it, we can get it to the inner city. We can get it to Africa within the same time frame that it gets to the wealthy. Unlike any other technology in history, this one I think we can get it out on an equity basis.
Kara Swisher
And your worry?
Bill Gates
My worry is just that this is the most unbounded thing. This is not just a tractor obsoleting farmers where you say, "Okay, it turns out there are many other unmet needs there." This, which we thought would first come for blue-collar work through robots, the surprise was that with this language facility, it actually is coming first for white-collar jobs. But the blue-collar thing is happening just a little bit later, certainly within the next three, four, five years. And so it's so disruptive at a time where government, who you expect to take the excess productivity and spread it around in a fair way, reduce the work week, our general trust in the capacity of government to do complex things is pretty low.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, so it was a good run, guys. So congratulations. All right, let's roll the next clip, which is an area I really spent a lot of time.
Clip plays
Student
Do you find yourself, even at this age, using your phone and staying on social media more than you want to?
Bill Gates
Oh my gosh, yeah. TikTok is so addictive. I'm on it like all the time.
Student
And have you ever run into crazy misinformation about me?
Bill Gates
Crazy misinformation about you all the time. I've even had friends cut me off because of these vaccine rumors, but I'm a public health student at Stanford, and I think that there is just so much nuance on how do you communicate accurate public health information or scientific data. I don't know. I need to learn more because I naively still believe that digital communication can be a force to bring us together, to have reasonable debate.
Student
I think one thing you don't really understand about online is that it's not really logic and fact that went out. People want an escape. They want to laugh. They want an engaging video. They want to be taken away from boring reality. And so the most popular video of you online is you literally trying to do the dab. Bill, can you do the dab real quick? Damn, Bill! Or you jumping over the chair. Is it true that you can leap over a chair from a standing position?
Bill Gates
It depends on the size of the chair. I'll cheat a little bit.
Student
Yes! Those are the most popular because people want to escape from things. So I don't think fact and reason always went out online.
Bill Gates
But the thing about, you know, I make lots of money from vaccines, it's even hard for me to figure out where that comes from. It's not like a political organization. It's just madness. And who promotes that?
Student
I think it's fear. I mean, everyone was stuck at home during a pandemic. We're all scared for our lives. No one really knows what to trust or what to believe. So that's what our society does.
Bill Gates
OK, so can you do the chair right now?
Student
No. A smaller one.
Bill Gates
Yeah, a little stool. I can do a stool.
Clip ends
Kara Swisher
Your daughter's very wise. But most of the stuff about you isn't funny, actually. I spend a lot of time telling people you're not Satan, that you don't put chips in people's brains. I spend an inordinate amount of time doing that, which is an unusual position for me to be in. But let's talk a little bit about information. You talk about Anthony Fauci, who has had death threats. I just interviewed him recently. One of the reasons government is in the trouble it is in is the polarization, which is fueled by online stuff. And there's no question about it. I know they're trying to come up with studies that it's not true, but a new study just came out showing it is absolutely true.
The polarization has been further impacted, especially around, we use the word misinformation, disinformation, but it's really propaganda, isn't it? That's really what's happening. 1.2 billion views were of Elon doing misinformation on the platform he bought, which he enjoys to spew misinformation on. It's actually the biggest purveyor of misinformation right now. Can you talk a little bit about this and the worries you have? Because it does directly impact you yourself, which I'm not worried about you, but everybody here in this room.
Bill Gates
Well, I didn't anticipate that if you want to belong to a group, there almost become certain beliefs. The election was stolen. Vaccines have negative effects. And recently Haitians eating dogs. Fauci is a self-interested individual who somehow gets royalties from vaccines. Totally false, provably wrong.
Kara Swisher
I want to track the position of people. I don't know why I do, but it's amazing. Because you're Satan. But go ahead.
Bill Gates
But even Satan doesn't need to know where people are. It's fair. What does he do with it? So that's just strange. And we always try to deal with it with humor. And as you say, I have nothing overall to complain about. But the idea that your sort of group beliefs are reinforced online, and so you have developed a reality that when people say, "No, the election was not stolen," you're like, "No." That would be almost denying that I'm part of this group, and so I'm going to behave that way. It's incredibly scary because it's definitely putting us into separate camps. And it's hard to see. People say, "Oh, we didn't regulate social media properly." Well, do we know now? Are we regulating it today? Is there a clear understanding of it? And then, of course, AI that we just discussed, if anything, supercharges the ability to create credible misinformation.
Kara Swisher
What would you do now to stop this? Because I think people are in their own separate... Microsoft was an early investor in Facebook when it was a $15 billion valuation. Nice one. That was a good one. I doubted that. I'm sorry. I was wrong. But when you think about what should be done now, because if people are in their own information bubbles in a way that's profound, and then AI can supercharge it, as you say, what would be the solutions to avoiding that?
Bill Gates
Well, most things where the country has been off track or even the world has been off track, you start to see the harms. And then people self-correct. Parents play a role, educators play a role, and some degree of banning the extreme behavior plays a role. But first we have to come to a view that, okay, this really is a problem. The United States may not be the first place to get this under control. We have the First Amendment and our divisiveness is particularly high. I wish I could say, "Okay, such and such a country has done this extremely well." The country that actually controls craziness on the internet is China. But they do it in a way that destroys—
Kara Swisher
They do like to track everybody where they're going.
Bill Gates
Yeah, and they don't let crazy things out there.
Kara Swisher
Right. They do better, but at the loss of democratic freedoms. So what do you do in a situation when you have someone like Elon who's suddenly decided to let misinformation flow toxic waste all over the place? And in some cases, people who try harder, like a Mark Zuckerberg, who you were a mentor to him, he and I had a big argument about Holocaust deniers a couple years ago. And I kept saying, "This is going to lead to anti-Semitism down the line." And he said, "Well, we're not going to regulate them at all. We'll see what happens." And you can see what happens when you anticipate. So is there anything government can do or are we at the mercy of these companies to decide? Because years later, Mark did clamp down on Holocaust deniers, but it took him to do it. Which is problematic, I think.
Bill Gates
Well, the question is, do you create some level of liability for these companies? And many forms of that would essentially mean social media companies would go out of business. But I think we ought to edge in the direction of forcing them to take some more responsibility. It is very tricky because if somebody says, "Vaccines in general kill people," that's wrong. And it caused older people who needed COVID vaccines not to take them. If people say, "Hey, vaccines sometimes have side effects," that's true. We need to talk to people about the net benefit and how we avoid those side effects and things. So the exact dividing line where some AI wakes up and shuts it down or labels it... I don't even feel like we're trying to find that happy medium.
Kara Swisher
Who is responsible? Is it the parents? Like California is banning different things. Different states are doing. Where is the line? Because it can't be Elon Musk and Mark Zuckerberg. It just can't be.
Bill Gates
Well, nobody's really... There hasn't been much regulation. Take even young people getting online. That's not an enforced thing. So I'm a little surprised how hands-off we've been on these things.
Kara Swisher
With kids. I mean, we over-regulate them offline and we under-regulate them online. It's really quick.
Bill Gates
No, no. I thought *Anxious Generation* and many observations along those lines are very profound and we should take action on.
Kara Swisher
So if you could do one thing, what would it be? I know what I would do, but what would you do?
Bill Gates
Misinformation actually is the one topic, and I say it in the series, that I say, "Hey, young people, you grew up with this thing. You understand the phenomena better. We basically pass this as a big problem to you." And AI, I have thoughts. Global health, I have thoughts. Misinformation I'm just stunned that there aren't more clear constructive things relating to policy and technology.
Kara Swisher
So you just like, "Good luck. Good luck, young people."
Bill Gates
You know, actually the way my kids dealt with it is they took all social media off their phones, which I thought worked rather well.
Kara Swisher
We'll be back in a minute.
Break
In an age of media consolidation, family dynasties are having a moment. The Murdochs, the Sulzbergers, the Roys, the Hearsts, and the new kids on the block: Ellisons. Meet the Ellisons, the newest right-wing billionaire family. From Silicon Valley, Larry made his money with technology. The Ellison family: Potter, Larry, Iho, David, and their money just bought CBS Paramount, will soon take a big stake in TikTok, and are reportedly going to bid for Warner Brothers Discovery, which owns CNN. It's been said that "nothing bad can happen, it can only good happen." But is yet another Trump-aligned family having control of your grandpa's TV shows and your TikTok algo something to worry about? Answers on *Today Explained* every weekday.
Ads to reach the right professionals. According to LinkedIn, they have grown to a network of over 1 billion professionals, making it stand apart from other ad buys. You can target your buyers by job title, industry, company roles, seniority skills, and company revenue, giving you all the professionals you need to reach in one place. So you can stop wasting budget on the wrong audience and start targeting the right professionals only on LinkedIn ads. LinkedIn will even give you $100 credit on your next campaign so you can try it for yourself. Just go to linkedin.com slash pivotPod. That's linkedin.com slash pivot pod. Terms and conditions apply. Only on LinkedIn ads.
Okay, next one. Let's go to the next one. We're moving on very quickly into climate change. Another happy topic.
Clip plays
Bill Gates
If you think of our addiction to fossil fuels and the way that we're going about attempting to wean off of it, we're losing. The fossil fuel industry is making record profits. Emissions are going up. People are right to be incredibly skeptical and disillusioned. There's part of the movement that I don't fully agree with, which is that you denigrate the current way of doing things before we have a replacement. I wish there was as much emphasis on the new thing, but I'm an optimist and I think we will limit temperature increase.
Clip ends
Kara Swisher
So this is something you spent a lot of time on. And that's what our last interview was about. You seemed worried at the time of where it's going. The temperature increases. Obviously, we have another hurricane in Florida, and yet legislators are pretending climate change doesn't exist. Talk a little bit about where we are right now. And one thing that you talked about a lot, which I've been spending a lot of time studying, is nuclear energy. Microsoft just recently is possibly going to open Three Mile Island, which I'm like, "AI, Three Mile Island, great. Seems like it could go well." But actually, it could. It could actually go well, in order to bring compute power for AI. Talk a little bit about where we are now, because it's really, it seems to be accelerating and young people are very worried. Again, another bag of crap we've handed them in this regard.
Bill Gates
Well, the key to solving climate change, I wrote a book with a theory of change that has to do with replacing all emitting activities for goods and services with new approaches that are green, that have no emissions. Today, those green approaches are extremely expensive. Green cement, green aviation fuel. You talked about the green premium. And only by funding innovation, having some degree of tax credits, and buyers willing to pay extra. Then as you scale up, those costs come down, and you get the magic that says you can even go to a middle-income country like India and say, "Okay, here's this new way to make cement.
It does not cost more." And so in 2015, when the Paris Accord is signed, I commit to create Breakthrough Energy. I'm there with country leaders, Modi, Obama, and they commit to double energy R&D budgets, which they did to a small degree. They didn't get to that doubling. But now Breakthrough Energy and other investors are funding unbelievable innovation, new ways to make steel, cement, meat, clothing. You name it. And although those won't roll out in time on a global basis to hit a two-degree target, they will roll out and they'll avoid us getting to extreme warming. The sad thing about climate change right now is people, given how much we'll be able to limit it, they overestimate the impact of climate change on rich countries.
Rich countries have air conditioning. We can change our crops. We have savings. The big losses are near the equator where you have poor people who depend on agriculture. And when you hear about agriculture, you cause malnutrition, which causes a lot more death. And so the picture of the suffering and the need for climate adaptation should lead to us being more generous to these countries at a time where, because of other things, we are actually being significantly less generous to the poor countries.
Kara Swisher
So one of the things you talked about is nuclear as a solution, correct?
Absolutely. Nuclear fission and or fusion will be very, very important along with renewable sources. You said renewables aren't enough. I mean, you're quite sure. Renewable alone is not enough because of the intermittency. Japan will not be powered by renewable energy. South Korea won't be powered by renewable energy. When you have a cold snap and that cold front is sitting there, no wind, no solar, people still want their houses not to be sub-zero. So talk a little bit, because there's a bunch of people, including Sam Altman of OpenAI, who are working at Helion. I just was with someone who was talking about how you're going to have a small nuclear device in your house to heat it. Everyone's going to have a small nuclear device. I'm just telling you, I have to sit and listen.
Bill Gates
You don't have to listen to these people.
Kara Swisher
But how does that roll out, given the reputation? I mean, I know it's laughable, but Three Mile Island, you're like, maybe not. But at the same time, maybe. So how do you make that argument? How is Microsoft going to make that argument?
Bill Gates
Well, coal kills people when it's mined. It kills people from local pollution. Natural gas pipelines blow up. I'm not involved in third generation nuclear, which is what resuscitating that plant is. I am a large funder of a fourth generation nuclear, which is a plant with no high pressure in it. Very different design that everybody, just like, you know, they said you should recover rocket stages to make spaceflight cheap. They've always said you should use metal cooling because all these safety issues of what happens when you shut the reactor down are completely solved. It's a very simple design and we should be able to do it for about a third of the cost of current reactors. So we're pursuing that dream. Everything about nuclear fission and fusion, people have a great deal of skepticism of will it be cheap enough and what will the safety look like. But I'm putting billions into it because I'm quite confident we can make that case.
Kara Swisher
So what do you say to young people like this who we still are dependent on fossil fuels?
Bill Gates
Well, banning fossil fuels before you have a substitute is a way of getting governments elected who don't think climate change exists. If you just say, no, you can't drive to work. So why do they go to universities and say, don't invest in the existing? Why don't they go and say, please take your money and invest in these new approaches? Because if you take your money away from the existing stuff, that doesn't create a solution. When I was in 2015 in the climate crisis, I'm like, you guys are making a bunch of pledges. What's your plan for steel? There were zero startups about making steel a new way.
6% emissions. Cement, also 6%. No work going on. So if you want to out-compete the dirty stuff, you actually have to get the entrepreneurs, you have to inspire them, you have to have high-risk capital. I love the activists because the issue is a huge issue, and they deserve all the credit for keeping it there. But when they say the solution is to stop consuming, that means that can India build basic shelter? So we're not going to stop using cement, a lot of cement. Even if rich countries didn't build another building ever, it's a rounding error. This is a middle-income country problem of providing basic lifestyle-level goods and services.
And so it's an invention problem. Now, I say that about everything, but in this case, it's correct.
Kara Swisher
All right. Is there anything really unusual you've invested in? And then we're going to move on to the next one.
Bill Gates
Well, there's so many cool things.
Kara Swisher
What's the weirdest energy thing?
Bill Gates
We have 130 companies that Breakthrough Energy is funded. We have new ways of making food. We have ways of making cows not emit natural gas. The idea that there's hydrogen that you can dig, geological hydrogen, that might surprise people. And that's going to be a huge help to solve this. I'm going in a hydrogen-powered plane soon. You want to come?
Kara Swisher
Wow. Yeah.
Bill Gates
You want to come? Anyway, yes, I'm funding a lot of that stuff. I hope it works.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Each one of my four children were like, no. And I said, yes, I'm getting in it. Anyway, let's go to the next thing. Are people too rich? Speaking of that.
Bill Gates
All right. Under the tax system I would go for, the wealthy would have, say, a third as much.
Kara Swisher
Well, needless to say, I would go a lot further. And I think, and your friend Warren Buffett makes the point that his effective tax rate is lower than his secretary's. And that is not what the American people want to see. They do want to see the wealthy pay their fair share of taxes. But you have a political system which unfortunately represents the needs of the wealthy much more than the needs of ordinary Americans. They do these happiness questionnaires. Have you seen that?
Bill Gates
Oh, yeah.
Kara Swisher
What they find is countries where people have that economic security, as in Scandinavia, usually Denmark or Finland or somebody ranks at the very top. Why is that? I think it's because people don't have to deal with the stress about how they're going to feed their kids or provide health care or child care. If you take that level of economic stress, if I say to somebody, you're never going to have to worry about whether you're going to feed your family, whether your kids are going to have health care. Thank you. Is it going to make their life perfect? No. Will it ease their stress level, bring more happiness, security? I think it will.
Bill Gates
Well, kudos for you to talk to Bernie. I remember when we had Elizabeth Warren, I think one of the years you're a code. Everybody, especially men in the audience, you could feel them seize up when she was talking about these kind of things, of the rich paying more taxes.
Kara Swisher
Kamala Harris, Vice President Harris, talked about it last night in an interview. Fair share, nothing against capitalism, but everything's out of whack. And actually, corporate tax rates are at the lowest since 1939 right now, while people like me pay 40-some percent in taxes.
Bill Gates
Nuts.
Kara Swisher
I know, I know. I need better lawyers. I need your lawyers. So, Tom talked about this, and why did you want to address it? Because you've talked to Mark Cuban. I've talked to him a lot about the wealth tax and things like that. So how do you deal with income inequality? Because I feel like it's fueling a lot of the division that we find ourselves in.
Bill Gates
Well, the idea that you have the opportunity to create a company that's very valuable. Sure. The U.S. is the envy of the world at that. And so while I would set tax rates quite a bit higher for rich people, we still have to grow the economy to get to the ideal level to set the safety net as high as Bernie alludes to. As you get richer, you raise the safety net. That's the story of the United States. The government is not very good at executing, so it's always imperfect. But I would not make it illegal to be a billionaire.
Kara Swisher
So that's a point of view.
Bill Gates
He would take away over 99% of what I have. I would take away 62% of what I have. So that's a difference. You definitely do get to the point where you're killing the goose that lays the golden egg. North Korea, very equal, unbelievable equality. So I don't even like the equality framing because 100 years ago, most people were never literate. So we've created wealth. And I think that the system that does that has a few elements that we shouldn't throw out.
Kara Swisher
So clearly, being capitalistic, being an entrepreneur, creating, giving people incentives to do things. So what do you do when people have, they were just talking about who's going to be the world's first trillionaire, which is astonishing to think about.
Bill Gates
Well, there's no trillionaires. Not yet. I don't think there will be.
Kara Swisher
You don't think there will be?
Bill Gates
No.
Kara Swisher
They thought it would be, wasn't you, but I think you're okay again. I remember meeting with someone who was a billionaire, and I said, you've got, this was 10 years ago, I said, you have to do something about income inequality or you're going to have to armor plate your Tesla. And then I looked at them and I realized they kind of wanted to armor plate their Tesla. They wanted to live in that world. But how do you deal with that on a real level when you do have this insane amount of wealth and people still in abject poverty? Where do you come together with someone like Bernie Sanders?
Bill Gates
Well, abject poverty is different. It is in Africa. There is abject poverty. So I give tens of billions to Africa to relieve abject poverty, and I encourage others to do the same. It's not a very big club of people involved in that. My dad is deceased, but he and I worked on promoting the estate tax. I'm a huge believer in the estate tax. I continued to promote that. They actually got rid of the estate tax briefly, and I think that's a mistake because those are dynastic fortunes, not somebody who actually created something. And so I think we, and it's stunning to me how countries don't have an estate tax. China does not have an estate tax. Europe has very limited estate tax. So I think we should have higher taxation on the rich, but not that would prevent you from having a large fortune. I wouldn't set a ceiling. And then I think for once you pay those taxes, whatever's left over, you should engage in philanthropy. You should take the skill that allowed you to succeed in business—hiring people, thinking through scientific organization—and give it away.
Kara Swisher
How hard is that to do right now? There's not a ton of people following in your footsteps, I would say, some.
Bill Gates
We have people who are giving a lot away. And in the giving pledge, you can look, there are people who are giving at a pretty good rate. I think people should do more. I think they would enjoy giving more.
Kara Swisher
So what you're talking about is the idea that the middle class feels very squeezed. This is a topic in this election. Trump wants to give more tax breaks to the wealthy. Kamala Harris is talking about giving tax breaks to the middle class. Where do you think, what would you, if you were running for president, what would be your stand on this?
Bill Gates
Well, I wouldn't get elected. I would bring up the deficit and say that, yes, we can tax the rich a lot more. But even so, the 2017 tax cut, a lot of that's going to have to expire because the deficits will lead to a level of inflation that voters will not be happy with. There's a huge leg in this, but nobody talks about the deficit. I would raise the safety net somewhat, but I would also, for future generations, reduce the deficit quite a bit.
Kara Swisher
So 62%, you would keep 62%, we can have the rest.
Bill Gates
38. You would keep 38%?
Kara Swisher
Yeah. And we can have the rest?
Bill Gates
If you had the tax system I have in mind, if that had been in place throughout my entire life, I would have about 38% of what I have.
Kara Swisher
All right, we'll take it. All right, last one, episode five, can we outsmart diseases? Your biggest topic. When you sit in those wards, you just see how precarious things are because the wards are never adequately staffed because malaria is quite seasonal. It's as the rainy season comes and the mosquito population grows exponentially. As a kid, I can't even tell you how many episodes of malaria I went through. I can still clearly see the picture of my father. He was standing next to my bed looking at me. I could really see a lot of fear in his eyes. If malaria was killing 600,000 people in the U.S. or in Europe, the problem would have completely changed by now. So malaria was one of the areas you focused on most strongly. Talk about where it is right now. I remember you let mosquitoes out at TED, as I recall, which you're not going to do here. But where is it right now from your perspective in these worldwide diseases?
Bill Gates
It's still, it's not neglected anymore because of you and the Gates Foundation. But where is that and what are the diseases you're looking at?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, so malaria at the turn of the century, when the Gates Foundation is created, is killing a bit over a million a year. And over the first 15 years of this century, we got it down to about a half million and it's gone up slightly from there, but just say a half million a year. This is a disease that there's almost no funding because the disease is in the poor countries who don't have the resources and the rich countries just aren't involved. They don't see it as a problem. We do have in the pipeline some incredible tools. So that gentleman you met there, Diabati, is a scientist in Burkina Faso who has tools to kill mosquitoes. And we're going through a lot of experiments based on his work and others. And within three to five years, this tool will be ready for release to eradicate malaria.
By killing mosquitoes.
Bill Gates
Yeah. So what you have to do is get rid of 90% of the mosquito population. And so the reinfection rate, you slow it down enough that you can test and treat. And if you go through a bunch of low seasons where you've done that, this is what happened in the US. We had a lot of malaria, but at the time you could spray DDT onto ponds, and that decimated mosquito populations. And so because of winter's low seasons, we actually got to zero. We're trying to create the equivalent in places like Nigeria, where as a child, you have a one in six chance of dying before the age of five.
Kara Swisher
So when you think about this, is it continues to be the most important disease you're fighting right now, malaria? Or are there others that you're...
Bill Gates
It's hard to rate. TB kills the most people of any disease. Malnutrition is the one thing if I had a wand I would get rid of because if you're not malnourished, you're less than half as likely to die even if you get malaria, diarrhea, or pneumonia, and it cripples you for life because you can never catch up if your brain doesn't develop when you're young. Sickle cell disease is this evil disease. We have a $2 million cure, but the foundation is working to make it a $200 cure. And that means we could take it to Africa, where you have millions of kids with sickle cell versus 60,000 in the US. And every one is a tragedy. So those are the ones you're focused on.
Kara Swisher
Because another one in this country, at least, is heart disease and obesity, of course, which is sort of the opposite.
Bill Gates
That's right. We lived to a very old age. We'll be back in a minute.
Kara Swisher
So when you think about, we've got to go in a second, but when you think about how you outsmart disease, you've been at this for what? It's not 20 years, right?
Bill Gates
Yeah, no, the foundation is created and becomes the largest at the turn of the century.
Kara Swisher
So what do you most focus on as you move into the new phase of what you're doing still, malaria and TB and these diseases?
Bill Gates
Health broadly. We work in agriculture because we can make eggs and milk really cheap. We can have crops that deal with climate change. So a lot of that's climate adaptation related. But global health, all of the resources I have will go to these global health issues. And we ought to be able to achieve in my lifetime. We're almost done with polio. We should be able to get rid of measles, malaria, almost all of malnutrition. So it's actually very exciting work. It's very hopeful. We've come a long ways from 10 million a year dying to now 5 million. But to get down to that 1%, we have to cut it in half three more times.
Kara Swisher
So what's next for what's next? What are you going, space travel? Are you going to Mars with Elon?
Bill Gates
Nope.
Kara Swisher
Are you going to do more of these?
Bill Gates
I think we'll go three, four, five years and see.
Kara Swisher
Well, what interests you? These are big topics, but is there, again, space travel is one. Cloning?
Bill Gates
Well, genetic editing and being tasteful about how we use that. I focus on that to cure sickle cell at a very low cost or to cure HIV at a very low cost. So it's about the diseases that make the world incredibly inequitable.
Kara Swisher
All right, last question. Are you hopeful? It's pretty tense right now still and it's been tense for a couple years out of COVID. We're still sort of not recovered from that. And a lot of people aren't. How do you, what is your mood right now?
Bill Gates
Well, ask me on November 6th whether climate change is real or not.
Kara Swisher
So I'm guessing who you're voting for, but.
Bill Gates
I, you can definitely guess where my energy is going. Overall, I'm still an optimist. If you zoom out and say, okay, where were we 50 years ago, 100 years ago? Humans are ingenious at doing things. I hope that the younger generation can look at polarization, look at the negative effects of digital, including misinformation, but not only misinformation, and shaping AI so that its miraculous capability in health and education isn't canceled out by disorder and a lack of purpose. So we have left some real challenges for this next generation. But I'm overall very hopeful. I get to see more innovation than other people, so I understand why I would be more hopeful. There's a lot, whether it's climate or health, that is very, very exciting.
Kara Swisher
Great. Well, I have to say, it's very good. You're pretty good at interviewing. I mean, I'm not going to lose my day job, but nonetheless, you did a nice job. Anyway, thank you so much, and thank you, Bill Gates.
Bill Gates
Thank you.
Kara Swisher
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
Outro music begins
On with Kara Swisher is produced by Christian Castro-Russell, Kateri Yoakum, Jolie Myers, and Megan Burney. Special thanks to Kate Gallagher, Kaylin Lynch, and Claire Hyman. Our engineers are Rick Kwan, Fernando Arruda, and Aaliyah Jackson. And our theme music is by Trackademics. If you're already following the show, you get to fly in a hydrogen-powered plane with me and Bill Gates, if he dares. If not, Satan is indeed tracking you. He's just not Bill Gates. Go wherever you listen to podcasts, search for On with Kara Swisher and hit follow. Thanks for listening to On with Kara Swisher from New York Magazine, the Vox Media Podcast Network and us. We'll be back on Thursday with more.