Main Topic: The podcast discusses various topics, including the impact of the Supreme Court's potential decision to strike down Roe v. Wade on American companies and employees, the earnings of Lyft and Uber, and the inflation rate.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Kara Swisher
Not all journalism is the same. Take The Guardian. Our coverage has something unique. Fierce independence. Nobody owns us or tells us what we can and can't say. So we're free to report the whole picture. We connect what's happening in Washington to the rest of the globe. Expose corruption wherever we find it. And give fresh perspective on everything. From wellness and soccer to culture, the climate and more. Read, watch and listen to The Guardian for free at theguardian.com.
Ad break
Avoiding your unfinished home projects because you're not sure where to start? Thumbtack knows homes, so you don't have to. Don't know the difference between matte paint finish and satin? Or what that clunking sound from your dryer is? With Thumbtack, you don't have to be a home pro. You just have to hire one. You can hire top-rated pros, see price estimates, and read reviews all on the app. Download today.
Intro music
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And I'm Scott Galloway.
Kara Swisher
Today, we'll talk about the Supreme Court's move to strike down Roe v. Wade and what it could mean for American companies and employees. Also, earnings are in for Lyft and Uber, and it's a mixed bag, as is everybody else's. We'll hear from a listener about inflation, which is still there, everybody. There's a lot of things to talk about.
Scott Galloway
One was lots of COVID from the White House Correspondents Dinner Weekend.
Kara Swisher
Really? Not among the Swishcatses, but many of our friends got it, including my ex-wife.
Scott Galloway
No kidding.
Kara Swisher
No kidding. But not this. We got tested, tested, tested. From the White House Correspondence Center. I didn't go to the actual dinner, but from parties and stuff like that. I think a lot of people just got it from the parties. I stayed on the porches myself. Not that there's any way to get away from this thing, but lots of COVID going around D.C. Tony Blinken got it.
Scott Galloway
Oh, he got it? No kidding.
Kara Swisher
John Carl. All these people. Anyway, as most people predicted, this is exactly what a lot of people thought would happen. Trevor Noah called it the nation's most prestigious super spreader event. So there you have it.
Scott Galloway
There you have it. I'm tired. It pays. I'm like you. This is my squid games. I haven't contracted the novel coronavirus yet. And it pays off to not like people. Almost everything I'm invited to, I'm like, no, I'd rather stay home and watch Netflix.
Kara Swisher
I must speak up for Tammy. You were invited to the brunch, just so you know.
Scott Galloway
I was not. That is not true. That is misinformation. She is adamant that you were. You don't read your emails.
Kara Swisher
I think of her every night in my bedroom. Let me add to that. She gave me a Veep pillow that is in my bedroom.
Scott Galloway
With your name on it.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, she's a charmer. She's a charmer. That Tammy had it. I wanted to start a podcast called Cone of Silence. I thought it would be very funny because she knows everything.
Scott Galloway
Anyway, speaking of everything, one of the more disturbing stories that we're going to talk about briefly is a man attending a Netflix comedy festival rushed the stage and tackled comedian Dave Chappelle. The attacker was armed with a knife that looked like a gun, which is... I don't even know what to say. Chris Rock appeared on the stage afterwards. He was backstage and asked the crowd, "Was that Will Smith?" This is exactly what Kathy Griffin said would happen after the Oscars. She wrote, "It's very bad practice to walk up on stage and physically assault a comedian. Now we all have to worry about who wants to be the next Will Smith in comedy clubs and theaters." And this is precise. He like sacked him. It was really disturbing. Dave Chappelle handled it rather well, but it frightened me, honestly.
Kara Swisher
You're right. Kathy Griffin called it perfectly. And here's an individual who probably thought he was going to be based on precedent given an award 30 minutes later.
Scott Galloway
It kind of does feel as if... I don't know how much of this is, I'm just old. It does feel like things are kind of falling apart a bit, when people are getting attacked on stage.
Kara Swisher
So I thought it was really disturbing. Would this have happened if Will Smith had not assaulted? I guess we'll never know.
Scott Galloway
Probably has. It probably didn't get the attention. It feels pretty ironic or coincidental.
Kara Swisher
I would agree. I would be terrified if you, especially if you're an edgy comedian, a comic like Dave Chappelle or others who have been caught in controversies. But every comic has that level of... there's supposed to be this give and take with the audience. That sort of ruins the entire medium if they have to be protected. A lot of very famous people from Jerry Seinfeld to Michelle Wolf, who's my favorite comedian, go on open mic in small clubs where there's no security. What's going to happen there? I always take it to business. The thing I found fascinating about this is I found out this was a Netflix production.
Scott Galloway
Netflix going multi-channel. Netflix is now in the business of events, which I found really interesting. I wonder what they're trying to map out, if they want direct access to their end consumer. But I thought it was interesting that Netflix is now in the business of events.
Kara Swisher
Well, they do these specials. It's a Netflix special. They tape specific shows for this.
Scott Galloway
This was more than that. They're doing a tour.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it was. Anyway, I read about it and I thought, oh, gosh, we're turning into that nation. I thought it was very upsetting.
Scott Galloway
Well, I don't know if you'll be upset or whatever you think. Elon Musk has friends in his Twitter takeover bid. Larry Ellison threw in a billion dollars. It was a very odd lot. I have to say I just wrote about it for my column. It's going up really soon. But included money from equity partners like Sequoia Capital, which I think was a couple hundred million. That may have been higher, 700 million. And Andreessen Horowitz was... no, Sequoia was 800. Andreessen Horowitz was 400. Qatar, that bastion of free speech monarchy, 375 million. I guess the Saudi prince who said he wasn't going to take it anymore is going to keep his stake.
Binance kicked in $500 million. It was all pretty small sums and no private equity. It was a strange group, no Jack Dorsey. I don't know if he's going to keep his stake in or not. Qatari law authorizes the imprisonment of anyone who broadcasts, publishes, or republishes false or biased rumors, statements, or news domestically or abroad with an intent to harm national interests. So nothing says free speech like Qatar and Saudi Arabia. This is kind of a weird grab bag. Who wasn't there was interesting in that there weren't any big private equity firms. It's not a lot of money. It does draw down the Morgan Stanley loan by about half.
There probably are more coming, I would guess. What do you think?
Well, in the face of what is now an 1,100-point decline... we taped this on Thursday? Twitter stock is up because he is syndicating what I was saying was a risk that it wouldn't close. The risk that it would not close has gone down because he's syndicating the debt and people are coming in. As far as I can tell, these are not financial investors. The risk here is this is feeling... this isn't what I would call a mixed, interesting, some progressive, some conservative group of people. This is distinctly... I wouldn't call these folks progressives.
Kara Swisher
Well, they're not. They're kind of just... Larry Ellison is a mentor of Elon Musk for people who don't know.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but isn't Larry pretty conservative?
Kara Swisher
He is, although not on everything. He's sort of where Elon is. It's mixed. But I think it's people who either want to be supportive of Elon or want to get closer to him. The straight financial guys with calculators so far don't want near this, except that there's some very smart people taking the debt because they're like, okay, this thing's worth at least $10 or $15 billion and they'll put in a preferred, which I think is probably a good piece of paper.
Scott Galloway
The thing that stuck out to me is I think if you were to say, all right, Elon takes it private and then in three years takes it public at $100 or $150 billion showing return for everybody. If you were to say what would happen to make that happen, I think it would involve Twitter becoming a payments platform or adding that. In other words, Twitter becomes two-thirds of the leg of the stool of a super app. And I thought the most interesting was Binance coming in for $500 million.
Kara Swisher
I did too. Because if Twitter were to establish itself as a really seamless, low-fee, global payment mechanism, you could see the stock. That could be the unlock that Musk is looking for.
Scott Galloway
I agree. I thought Binance coming in was the most interesting investor. Controversial Bitcoin exchange, sometimes controversial. One of the world's richest people is the owner, very suddenly. That was the most interesting person here. Also, Alexander Tamas, who along with some at DST put in the early money for Facebook, is here. He had a lot... I think his was 700 million. But again, these are not big. Andreessen Horowitz, 400 million. It's like in their drawer essentially. They want to have a relationship with Musk, so they'll throw some money at it.
Kara Swisher
Qatar, I don't understand in any way. The Saudi prince who complained, whatever, that guy. I'm assuming Jack is going to keep his things, and he didn't say. It doesn't say. Anyway, he'll probably get more. We'll see. Everybody wants to be friends with the world's most interesting man. So let's put in some money.
Scott Galloway
Should we call him? Tell him we're going to put in like $25,000? I may actually put in some money into the debt instrument. I think it's a good piece of paper.
Kara Swisher
Let's do that. Let's become Twitter investors.
Scott Galloway
Twesters.
Kara Swisher
Twesters. Like, why not? So we'll see if he gets... He is a lot closer in that regard. He doesn't have to pay. It's still an enormous sum of money. He's going to have to pay in debt payments. And it's more than Twitter makes right now. So he's got to make something quick, make some trouble quick and money-wise.
Scott Galloway
Vice Media could be sold for parts.
Kara Swisher
I know. Talk about that since you had some affiliation with them.
Scott Galloway
Vice has reportedly hired bankers to seek a sale of the company, whole or otherwise. It's the latest twist from the company, once valued at $5.7 billion. It failed to join a SPAC last year. BuzzFeed and Vox reported interested in buying parts of Vice. That makes sense. Jim Bankoff probably sharpened his little pencil. What do you think?
Kara Swisher
What a chain. The guy who started it was very chest puffy. It was a very chest puffy company. So what do you think about this? I never thought it was... I thought it was an advertising platform, with a lot of drug-induced programming, but some of it good. What do you think? You worked there.
Scott Galloway
I worked there for a whole six shows. My adventures in TV. Misadventures is probably what we should call it.
Kara Swisher
Just waiting for you back here at the ranch, but go ahead.
Scott Galloway
There you go. Coming home. You need to go off ranch, but that's okay. I was banging my secretary, but I'm back with my tail between my legs, honey. I'm home.
Kara Swisher
I'm thinking you're more like a piece of cattle. I'm home. But go ahead. You go right to a sexual remark.
Scott Galloway
I've returned.
Kara Swisher
I don't even want to go into Madison Cawthorn. We're not even discussing that for one second. Which would be a very good Vice segment.
Scott Galloway
Have you heard of waxing? That's all I could think. Someone sent that to me. I'm like, really?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, everyone was talking about that. There were so many funny... Jesus Christ. George Hahn was having quite a good day, I would say.
Scott Galloway
That was rough. That was really disturbing.
Kara Swisher
Cleanup. What were we talking about? Vice.
Scott Galloway
By the way, I liked him more after that. But go ahead.
Kara Swisher
The Republicans are out to kill him. I don't care. Kill him, guys. I don't care what you do to him. I'm just so thankful there's an R next to that name.
Scott Galloway
Well, of course there is. Come on. Give me a break. That's where all the sickos are.
Kara Swisher
I disagree with that. I don't think the Republicans have a monopoly on sick. They hide it away. They're wearing fishnet stockings underneath their trousers.
Scott Galloway
I just have a wide stance, Carol.
Kara Swisher
Which is good. Will you please go into Vice?
Scott Galloway
Okay. Well, I'm trying to. Madison Cawthorn fell into my head and I didn't know how we could not discuss it. It went viral. I get it. Now it won't leave either of our heads for a while. So Vice... the tail that wags the dog of media right now is Netflix losing three quarters of its value. Look at it this way. When it was at $350 billion market cap with 220 million subscribers, they were saying that subscribers are worth about $1,500 a pop. Now in the world of streaming media, streamers are worth $400 per subscriber. And if you're in the ad stack or the cable or ad-supported bundle, which is the shittier part, what is that worth? Vice, which was at $6 billion and then was trying to SPAC at $3 billion and couldn't get out, this thing probably gets sold for parts. It'll be a big story because...
Kara Swisher
Rupert Murdoch was in there.
Scott Galloway
Who was in there? There's a lot of big investors in there.
Kara Swisher
I think Disney was in there, weren't they?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, Disney was in there. Poor Nancy Dubuque was in there trying to clean that thing up after. You're going to see... this isn't even the beginning. We're kind of at letter C in what is the great recalibration in media, both streaming and ad-supported. You're going to see distressed property. Vice is very quickly going to become a distressed asset sale. Vice was already in trouble. Nobody has thought they've had the mojo. But there wasn't a mark on the price. We're now going to see the price.
Kara Swisher
That's exactly right. We're going to see that this thing is probably worth less than a billion after being worth supposedly $6 billion. Because if Netflix has lost 72% of its value, can you imagine how much Vice has lost?
Scott Galloway
Yes, I would agree. I was always sort of not down on them. Shane was amusing on some level. There's all kinds of weirdness going on there. I remember walking into their headquarters in Brooklyn, and there was a full bar right in the lobby where all the employees drank. I'm like, well, hello. This is not good. This is like sexual harassment suits and problems at work. They ran it not like a business, but a party.
Kara Swisher
I think you're incorrectly conflating alcohol with harassment.
Scott Galloway
No, okay, fine. But whatever. It wasn't good to have a full bar in the middle of a workplace. That was a problem.
Kara Swisher
I think that's pretty awesome, quite frankly.
Scott Galloway
Okay, but no. Not our company. That's not going to be happening anyway. But they also had all this amazing equipment when they were trying to do Vice News Tonight and everything else. I was toured around the most astonishing... I was like money, money, money, money everywhere. I went back to Jim Bankoff and said, "They're fucked because they're spending all their money." Anyway, where do you imagine? Who's going to buy it? Who's going to buy these pieces? I've never understood how Vice makes money.
Advertising.
Kara Swisher
Well, okay. Artisanal advertising. The distribution. They had good advertisers on my show, I'll give them that. I've never understood what is the real asset with Vice. I'd be really interested to know if and what Vox will pick up. But Jim is a very disciplined operator. Pick up "Fuck That's Delicious." That's a great show. My kids love it. Whatever he picks up, he's going to pick up on the cheap. So I don't know. I think this thing gets sold for parts, and it'll be a distress sale. There's more of this to come, consolidation, distress sales. There's some good shows over there, but that doesn't mean the talent will come.
What are the good shows? I just don't know.
Scott Galloway
Well, there was a bunch. My kids watched some of the shows on there for a while. Bikers? Do they have shows on bikers or on world wrestling?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, there's a couple. I just don't know. I know nothing about those. They were definitely a shooting star with a lot of liquor. That's all I remember.
Scott Galloway
We've brought so much insight to this story. That's why people come to Pivot.
Kara Swisher
You know, I saw that. They have a bar. Oh, my God. You're welcome. No, but it was indicative. I interviewed the CEO. He was drunk most times I interviewed him.
Scott Galloway
Shane? Whatever. I talked to him once. He struck me as a pretty thoughtful guy. He's great. He's really interesting. And then he went off and bought a big house that was featured in newspapers. The whole thing felt like just not a serious endeavor.
Kara Swisher
Worse yet, I heard there's alcohol inside the house.
Scott Galloway
Oh, my God. That's not what I'm talking about.
Kara Swisher
It wasn't run as a business. It was trendy. Everyone wanted to work there. They made offers to a lot of my... it just was irritating.
Scott Galloway
I want to bring back the three-martini lunch. I'm in. I'm ready.
Kara Swisher
We're not doing it. Okay. Let me give you... on the lastly, and then we'll get to the big story. John Doerr is giving Stanford University $1.1 billion to fund a school focused on climate change and sustainability. It'll be the largest donation to an establishment of a new school ever. The school will have departments focused on things like, from the New York Times, planetary science, energy technology, and food and water security, and a center focused on practical policy and tech solutions to the climate crisis. A lot of people think this is great. I do. I'm one of them. Other people think the money could be better used, but he's part of a string of people. I think it's good that John is doing this. It'll be interesting to see what will happen. What do you think?
Scott Galloway
Immediately I went on Twitter and a lot of people saying he could have done so much more with this money for climate change. People are very generous with other people's money. I think this is wonderful. I like John Doerr. He harkens back to an age where VCs demonstrated more grace. He does not make personal attacks. He's very thoughtful. I think he's very civic-minded. Every interaction I've had with him, he's been nothing but generous and a gentleman. I kind of miss the Buffett-Doerr approach to investing. Giving $1.1 billion, I hope that it expands the enrollments, that part of that capital is used to expand the size. The issue I've always had with Stanford is it's become a luxury brand more than a public servant because of incredibly...
Kara Swisher
That would be good if John insisted on that. He's in a position to do that. But this is the first school started at Stanford in a long time. $1.1 billion is an extraordinary gift. Climate change obviously needs more peer-reviewed research. Look, Bloomberg is doing his thing. Jeff Bezos is doing his thing. It was his worst fund. Obviously, Gates is very... Doerr is an interesting character. I've known him for a very long time. We've had lots of wrangling over that Ellen Pao case. We did some pretty tough coverage of his firm and how he was running it at the time. But I got to say, of all the people I cover, he was a professional. We had wrangles, and then we didn't. The rest of them have gone down some weird conspiracy masters of the universe lane. He never has, and he's been one of the most successful tech investors in history.
Scott Galloway
You're never going to find John Doerr on Twitter attacking people.
Kara Swisher
No, or just saying that he's better. Or diminishing people. Dumb, stupid bro jokes. You get the sense he's at a point in his life where he recognizes his blessings and he wants to be part of solutions. I think it's great. He's got about $11 billion himself. Good for him. Good for Stanford.
Scott Galloway
Good for Stanford.
Kara Swisher
All right, let's get on to our first big story. How does corporate America plan for a post-Roe v. Wade world? That's one of the many questions following the leaked Supreme Court draft opinion this week. Already this year, abortion laws in Texas and other states have forced companies to take stances protecting their employees. Some companies, like Yelp, now offer to pay for employee travel to states where abortion is legal. More companies could be put in the same position as they try to support employees while complying with state laws that could come in June when the Supreme Court is expected to rule.
We don't know if this is a draft decision. I just did two very interesting podcasts, one with the group that argued against the Mississippi law, the head of the Center for Reproductive Rights. And then I had three lawyers on: George Conway, Neal Katyal, and Amy Kepchinsky, who was a Yale law professor who had a really interesting thread about where this is going. What do you think the impact on companies will be? Most of the companies have been silent, except for companies like Yelp and others who have been very out front. Everyone's been very quiet, but Airbnb has spoken out. Levi Strauss, Yelp, and Citi already pay for employees to travel to states where abortion is legal.
This week, Amazon, United Talent Agency, where I am a client, and Amalgamated Bank all announced they'll pay for travel as well for people who are in states where they can't get abortions. But nothing from Disney, Meta, things like that.
Scott Galloway
I think it's really important. Obviously, I'm squarely on one side of this issue. I heard Dara Khosrowshahi this morning say that Uber will be supportive of their employees. And I believe he said their drivers. I'd like to see every CEO say we respect people's personal decisions and their beliefs and we will pay for you to terminate a pregnancy. And also, out of deference to the other side, we will pay for you to not have an abortion. I've been thinking about this a lot over the last 24 hours. I'm sure you are too. I start with the outrage. We have this scar tissue that keeps getting worse called the Trump administration where we had a 75-year-old man who fucks porn stars without a condom and now has basically figured out a way to take a woman's right to terminate a pregnancy. If you're a woman living in New York or Illinois or California, this will have no impact on you. This is a war on poor women in states that are conservative. Full stop. Then I think about, well, this is what's going to happen. We have all this moral outrage on the left and yelling and...
Kara Swisher
No, just a minute. They warned this was coming. Everyone said they were overwrought and they weren't.
Scott Galloway
Yes, but there was so much like, "Left, stop it. Stop saying this is going to happen."
Kara Swisher
I think people knew this was coming.
Scott Galloway
Okay, but there was a lot of pushback. These three associate justices most recently appointed stood in front of the Senate and they lied. They absolutely lied. You want to talk about an unbelievable fall in the prestige of an institution? Strengthening our institutions is so important. The Supreme Court is now a place where you have a wife who's aiding and abetting insurrection and not disclosing $700,000 from the Heritage Foundation. They're now having documents leaked, which you've never seen before. I'm going to move to a solution because I'm turning into one of these people with outrage and no solutions.
They confer rights. They don't take them away. We're going to hear all this outrage from the left expecting Republicans to be offended and they won't be. Move to the solution. It all comes down to the same thing. The left will say we need more Democrats. Fine. Here's the thing. You're always going to have between 45 and 55 Republican senators. The key to this is Lisa Murkowski. Specifically, if we don't put in place mechanisms for more moderates, specifically more moderate Republicans, we're not going to get past this. This also represents a dangerous trend in America: minority rule. The majority of Americans are in favor of a woman's right to choice.
But they are in favor with restrictions.
Kara Swisher
I want to be fair here. There's a lot of... they're saying a majority agrees. I don't think they agree to it in full. If you look down in the numbers, the Times actually had a very good piece about this. It's a little more complex. But yes, the majority do. I think they were kind of where Bill Clinton was. He agreed that at a certain time limit... I get the nuance. But the majority of Americans believe that a woman should have decent access or reasonable opportunities should she decide to terminate her pregnancy. That is not what this ruling reflects. You're going to have half the states in the union basically go very far or close to or just outright outlaw it. They've got these trigger laws in place. They've already gone pretty far.
Scott Galloway
This is the whole point. This is how it got to this point. These three justices wouldn't have been confirmed, or at least one or two of them wouldn't have, had there been five or ten so-called senators that represented the Republican Party as center Republicans. We don't have that because...
Kara Swisher
Well, Susan Collins and Lisa Murkowski don't look very good here, do they? They believed what they were told, and everyone said this is not how it's going to go down.
Scott Galloway
And now they're saying, "Well, they lied to us." You can't put it all on them. I think the majority of our problems stem from the fact that we have an electoral system that rewards batshit crazy right and left candidates. Until we have ranked... Lisa Murkowski might get reelected because of ranked choice voting. Until we have more moderates... the Democrats are failing, in my opinion. They think we need this as a rallying cry to get more Democrats in office. Fine. It'll always be somewhere in the middle. The only way we move to a nation that actually represents the will of the people is when we start electing more moderates on both sides.
Kara Swisher
All right. Away from the political, Scott's political sayings, this is going to affect companies, right? Especially tech companies. A law banning abortion, any new laws banning abortion. And by the way, many think that some of the Republicans are going to try to aim for a federal ban on abortion. We'll see if that happens. And also the ensuing... could they get marriage equality? Could they get gay sex, contraception?
And I'm not going to slip very slow, but you hear them coming for it. And all the gay people know just how vicious they can be. This week, one data broker announced that they'll stop selling location data of people who visit women's health clinics. That announcement came only after reporters' advice revealed the practice, speaking of Vice. And social media platforms could face pressure to remove abortion-related content. That's another wrinkle in this, that people get these pills that are sent across state lines in the mail. That's another one.
Privacy protections will be never more important for people, especially if these states institute these nutty laws of if you move from one state to the next to get an abortion, they're going to try to arrest you. Probably will not hold up in court, that won't, but nonetheless, the criminalization in some states of this could be problematic. So encryption will be important, privacy legislation. These are all important things. And then companies deciding what to do and how they're going to get sucked up into these crossing state lines or paying for travel or whatever it happened, whatever nutty thing Mississippi comes up with. I'm sure that would be one of the states that would come up with it, or Texas.
Scott Galloway
Well, 50% of our workforce is women. And if you want to talk about a cohort that is definitely pro-choice, it's women. And so it just strikes me. You're going to need some momentum here, but I think you're going to see it. I think you're going to see more CEOs say, "I believe people are entitled to their own viewpoint here, but we are going to be supportive, whatever your viewpoint is." And I do think you're going to see more and more of that.
And then you have Yahoo's in Texas saying we're going to revoke tax status or we're not going to let you issue. I think they said it to Citibank. "We're not going to do municipal bonds with you if you pay for people to terminate." There will be some of that. But I think the will of America will come through here. Well, they did it in Florida. They did it in Florida to Disney. World of hurt for Disney in Florida, but also for Florida. It turned out that these bonds that they have to now, the taxpayers now have to pay for. I think the good money there is on the mouse. I think Disney is going to outlive DeSantis in Florida. And people will calm down and go, "Do we really want to discourage organizations like Disney from coming to Florida?" Anyway, but then again, I may be just projecting.
Kara Swisher
But companies cannot stay apolitical now. It's so ridiculous. I know a lot of companies have told me, "Oh, we want to just..." Like, you can't. I'm just sorry. These are, especially on issues like abortion, gay marriage and things like that, as controversial as they may seem, you've got to pick a lane on these things and support your employees.
Scott Galloway
But you can sort of, I mean, to a certain extent, though, on this issue, you can say we really are into this Republican notion of liberty and you get to decide. And that's, we're not saying we're not pro-life. We're not pro-choice. We're like, up to you. We realize the controversial issue, so we're going to adopt this basic GOP principle around freedom and liberty, and we're going to get us out of the decision, and it's up to the individual.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, yeah. Well, we'll see what happens. We'll see what happens from here. This Alito, Alito is really quite off on some island of his own. It's really interesting how aggressive he was in this draft decision. I think he pushed it a lot too far, a lot too far, not a little too far. And his references to the 1400s and a bunch of people that were really vile to women. It's really just this whole... I read the whole thing. And of course, I was focused in on Obergefell, which is the gay marriage one, and Lawrence versus Texas, which is gay sex. They can pry my gay marriage from my cold, dead hands if they want to, that kind of thing. Like, you know what I mean? Like that gun thing. Good luck. Good luck. I'm a huge fan of gay marriage. Why shouldn't you have to suffer? It's just not fair. It's just not fair. In any case, good luck getting it from us lesbians. We're not giving it up anytime soon. And it will take quite a bit more than this to push us down.
Anyway, but it was a disturbing turn of events. We'll see what happens. This may not be the draft. I think John Roberts seems to want to make it much less so. And he maybe has the upper hand to peel away Kavanaugh and others. But that's the thing. I'm not sure he does have it. I don't think he has the hand anymore. I think he's going to pull. I think this is my feeling, peeling him away. He's going to peel him away.
Scott Galloway
I don't think they're peelable, Kara. It's 6-3 conservative now.
Kara Swisher
I do. I know, but I think this...
Scott Galloway
He used to be the swing vote. He's not any longer.
Kara Swisher
I think Alito went too far. I don't think they want to sign their names to this. I don't think they want to sign their names to this for history's sake even.
All right, Scott, let's go on a quick break. When we come back, we'll talk about a rough quarter for peer-to-peer economy and take a listener question about inflation.
Ad break
Okay, Scott, we're back with our second big story. It's such a busy week. It's been a rough ride for Uber and Lyft this quarter. Lyft shares dropped nearly 30%. As you were talking about, everyone's going to the woodshed on Wednesday. After the company issued light guidance for the second quarter, the company said that it will have to spend on driver incentives due to rising fuel costs. Things weren't much better at Uber, which poured a net loss of more than $5 billion even as revenue jumped. That's not all bad news in the peer-to-peer economy. Airbnb posted 70% revenue growth, beating estimates. Boy, is that company doing well. But, you know, this is the tough times after the not-so-tough times. So, although Omicron was a big part of the first quarter of 2022, what do you think?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but, I mean, Grant, I'm a shareholder here, so I have a bias. I'm a huge fan of Brian Chesky. Airbnb was up 70% the revenues year on year in the most recent quarter. I mean, all their metrics are really up and to the right. And by the way, they're now booking more than pre-pandemic. So they're back and stronger than ever. And also to Lyft's credit, I'm sorry, to Uber's credit, they now make more money delivering food. So Dara saw the writing on the wall. Boy, do we spend a lot of money on that. He's done a really good job pivoting.
They're down 30%. The company that does not survive here or doesn't survive as an independent company and will be acquired is Lyft, which is at $7.5 billion.
Kara Swisher
Who acquires it?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, that's a really interesting company. My whole rap here is around super app. I think someone wants to be the Gio Marta, the Alibaba of the U.S., and they either are social or a payments company, acquires Lyft. It's got a $7.5 billion market cap, which isn't a lot. So you can imagine.
Kara Swisher
Give me a name. I don't want to say a name.
Scott Galloway
I think a fintech company.
Kara Swisher
Come on. Don't be lazy. Say a name.
Scott Galloway
Well, it's $7.5 billion. I mean, what if... Okay. What if the day before... I don't know if Amazon gets into it. I think it's a payments... I don't think it's e-commerce. I think it's payments. I think it's payment. Amazon would be interesting too. Whoever wants to say... I think your ability to go on an earnings call and say three legs of the stool are payments, transportation, and social. And so a social company, a payments company that says, "By the way, we're the only company in the world. It's two of the three because we just purchased Lyft. So now we're in transportation and now we're a payments company or now we're social and transportation." I think their stock, I think the day they announced that, their stock pays for the acquisition of Lyft.
Kara Swisher
What about an autonomous car company that wants a reservation system?
Scott Galloway
Autonomous car company? Yeah. Tesla or any of the Google or any of GM, those people. You need a reservation system. And they have direct interface with consumers. That's really interesting. You could see... I hadn't even thought of that. You could see an automobile company try and get into autonomous, try and immediately overnight jumpstart their electric and autonomous with all the accounts they have.
So, look. Just to have it. Lyft is now worth more to someone else than they are to the market because they do have a direct interface. They have the credit card of a bunch of people who are used to ordering through their interface. So you're right. It could either go the super app way or someone like you said who wants to jumpstart their autonomous... Tesla? The company gets acquired. That's the bottom line. At $7.5 billion, they realize they're subscale. They didn't get into food. They're a distant number two, which you never want to be.
Kara Swisher
But not Uber. Uber stays independent is your feeling.
Scott Galloway
I think Uber is too expensive for someone to acquire.
Kara Swisher
Why doesn't Airbnb buy Uber? Why doesn't Airbnb buy Uber?
Scott Galloway
Because I don't think they can afford it. I mean, I think Airbnb is like $100 billion. And I don't know what Uber is. I think Uber is too expensive. Uber right now, it's got a market cap of $52 billion. You'd have to spend $70 or $80 to buy it. There's very few companies that could buy it right now.
Anyways, Airbnb, the numbers are amazing. Uber has made the right move strategically. Dara doesn't get the credit it deserves. He is thinking two steps ahead. Lyft does not have the scale to be an independent company. And somebody, TBD, will acquire it because it is worth. I do think it's not worth $7.5 billion to an independent company. It's worth more than that to an automobile company.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it's an easy lift for a lot of companies. A lot of companies, easy lift.
Okay, Scott, let's pivot to a listener question. You've got, you've got. I can't believe I'm going to be a mailman. You've got mail. This one came via email from Lauren in Canada. I'll read it.
"I have a question about inflation, which you discussed in an earlier episode. Scott said that inflation isn't due to price gouging because it's clearly something the market can bear. But in some cases, such as food, gas, et cetera, people don't have a choice as to whether or not they purchase a good because it's a necessity for survival. At a time when grocery execs received millions in pandemic-related bonuses and average people were speaking loudly about the almost unaffordable price of groceries and gas, how does Scott's analysis of market prices account for human necessity?"
Scott, why don't you answer that? Just executives at two of Canada's largest chains, Canadian Tire and Loblaws supermarkets, received multimillion dollar bonuses in 2021. And in the U.S., 22 major corporations generated an additional $1.5 trillion for shareholders during the pandemic, which is not a surprise. That's 57% more than the additional wages that went to workers, a study from Brookings. All right, Scott, what do you say? I'm going to let you answer that one.
Scott Galloway
The answer is, so how does my analysis account for the human pain? The answer is it doesn't. And what you see across inflation or you've seen over the last year is that everyone talks about the great resignation and how wages have gone up for frontline workers. The reality is their wages have gone down on an inflation-adjusted basis. And if you look at their purchasing power, it's either flat or down because the categories that they spend a disproportionate amount of their income on because they don't have as much disposable income as a wealthy person. Food, energy, housing, energy prices, we all know what's happened there. Food prices, way up.
So where I am is I think the government needs to take minimum wage to $20 an hour. I don't think you can control CEO pay, and I don't think you want to, but you can have a progressive tax structure and get rid of all these tax loopholes and level and just have capital gains tax. Don't have a difference between ordinary income and capital gains, but I'm for a transfer of wealth. The middle class is an accident. It does not exist organically.
Kara Swisher
Agreed.
Scott Galloway
And unless we reinvest in it, and everyone likes to think that climate change will happen while making billions and that the middle class will restore with market forces. No, it doesn't. We have to make investments that hurt. And one of the things that hurts is we have to raise taxes on... I think we have to do away with capital gains. I think there's absolutely no reason you should get a tax break for owning a home but not get a tax break for renting a home. Who rents? Younger, less wealthy people. Who owns homes? Older, richer people. Who owns stocks and gets a 22.8% tax rate versus a 37? What do you know? People who own stocks who are older and rich.
So I agree with her. People don't talk about the fact that CEO pay is up dramatically. The question is how do you address it? And I don't think market dynamics are going to work here. I think we have to raise minimum wage dramatically. I think we have to have UBI or a form of UBI.
Kara Swisher
To what? $25? $25? Is that what you're saying?
Scott Galloway
I think that would be too much too fast for companies. I think a lot of good companies would find themselves unsustainable if they had to pay everybody $25 an hour. And also, on $18 an hour, if you have two folks making $18 an hour and you live in certain parts of the U.S., you can string together a middle-class lifestyle. So I think $25 is aggressive. I used to think $15. Now I'm thinking $20. But for God's sake, $7.25? Come on.
Kara Swisher
Yep. Agreed. Agreed. But go to the underlying root cause of this. In the United States, we spent 27% of GDP on the stimulus. In most nations, they spent 20 or less. We spent the second most in the world. A lot of money. And by the way, some of that money, we threw some loaves of bread and some circuses for the poor, but most of it went into the market.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, it went to rich people. It did. It did. When that gets taken apart by a really great investigative reporter. Obscene. Or a bunch. Obscene. It's going to be obscene. We were offered, and this is a chance to virtue signal. My company, I have an ed tech company that's raised tens of millions in venture capital. My CFO came in and said, "Oh, PPP, sign here, Scott. We're going to get $280,000." For what? Free money. All we have to do is not lay off anybody. And we're growing. We're hiring people. And we're going to get $280,000. And my first instinct was like, "Right on, sister. Give me that. I'm going to sign it." And I started thinking about it. And I went to my board and I'm like, "Should we be taking $280,000 from the federal government? Our employees on average make about $130,000 or $140,000 a year. Everyone on this board is worth tens of millions of dollars. The people, our investors are raising multibillion dollar funds. $280,000. That's what the after school programs cost at a high school." I'm like, "We can't take this money." And to their credit, every one of them, every single board member down the line said, "Of course, we're not going to take this money."
Kara Swisher
Yeah, but you could have gotten it. But yeah, they have done great reporting on this. But there is a... I would love to see a database where you understand where the money went and why in a way. They won't be able to figure it out, too, the way it was handed out on both administrations. I think they're never going to be able to follow the money.
Scott Galloway
Two-thirds ended up in the top quintile, in the pockets of the top quintile. This was nothing but cloud cover to make rich people richer. We totally overdid it, and we've now got inflation because we showered. We took an obese... I've said this... an obese economy, and we've shoved thousands of gallons down the throat of it of ice cream. And think $7 trillion, $115 million households. Take the poor 60, take the below the median, say the 50 or 60 million households that are below the median. You could have given each of them $100,000. What would have that done to poverty? What would that have done for the economy?
Kara Swisher
Well, you know, poor people can't spend money, right, Scott? They don't know, you know, they don't know how to handle money. Such crap. They spend it all. That's why you love giving money.
Scott Galloway
That is correct.
Kara Swisher
That is correct. So ridiculous. Whenever I hear that, I want to push people's face in. But I wouldn't because it's wrong.
Anyway, if you've got a question of your own and you'd like it answered, send it our way. That was a great question, Lauren. Go to nymag.com slash pivot to submit a question for the show or call 855-51-PIVOT.
All right, Scott, one more quick break. We'll be back for wins and fails.
Ad break
All right, Scott, some wins and fails. I will go to a win. I hear Top Gun 2 is fantastic.
Scott Galloway
Really?
Kara Swisher
I'll mention it again. Everybody who's seen it, Matt Bellany, all kinds of people say it's so good. It's going to be a big hit. It's going to do good for theaters, which I'm willing to see. I'm going to see it in the theater. Big win.
Scott Galloway
Nice. Big friggin' win. You're going into the danger zone? You're ready?
Kara Swisher
I'm going into the danger zone.
Scott Galloway
Nice. I love every word of that movie. I love that one so much.
Kara Swisher
Is Tom Skerritt in this film?
Scott Galloway
No.
Kara Swisher
Oh, I don't know. Remember him? He's a good-looking man. He's the commander. He is a good-looking man.
Scott Galloway
He is a good-looking man. Yeah. I don't know. I hope so.
Kara Swisher
What about Goose? Is Goose back in it?
Scott Galloway
Goose is dead.
Kara Swisher
Oh, he died. Goose is dead. It's a movie. He's dead. It's a movie. He's been... Goose was... You know who his wife was in the movie? Meg Ryan.
Scott Galloway
Meg Ryan.
Kara Swisher
Meg Ryan. She's in her first big role for her. I mean, it was a small role, but it was a big role. She was adorable in that movie. That's my win. I don't have a fail because I'm so excited about Top Gun 2. I don't even know what to say to myself. Oh, a fail. Judge Alito. Screw you. Anyway.
Scott Galloway
So my fail is similar, but a different take on it. My fail is that the left will be outraged and, again, is focused on what offends us, what they think offends us versus what affects us, and we should move to solutions. I believe that moderates in the Democratic Party need to focus on ranked choice voting and figuring out a way to have a representative government and get more moderates. I don't think we'd be sitting here had we just had a small number of moderates in the Republican Party. And also we need more moderates than the Democratic Party. That's my fail, is the outrage that will not result in anything effective here.
Kara Swisher
Can you just note that this ruling, this draft decision is repulsive? Can you just not just blame the left immediately? This is a repulsive, repulsive sentiment they've all been working on forever.
Scott Galloway
Kara, my success is a function of family planning. I've written about this, and I don't think my mother would be embarrassed by this. When my mom was 47, she got pregnant. I remember her telling me about it. And you're 17. You're the only son. You're going to have to take economic responsibility for a house. Would have changed my life.
Kara Swisher
Mm-hmm. 100%.
Scott Galloway
So my mother's access to family planning meant I could go to college. It meant I could start businesses that employed hundreds of people. And also my mom's access to family planning meant I could have kids. So if you want loving, secure households with kids, you want economically secure households, you want access to family planning. They've got it all wrong here. Men out there have to realize this has a huge impact on us.
Kara Swisher
A hundred percent. Anyways, I'm going to my win.
Scott Galloway
All right. Whenever I talk about it...
Kara Swisher
Scott, I like when you get emotional.
Scott Galloway
Whenever I talk about my mom, I get choked up.
Kara Swisher
I know. Your mom sounds wonderful.
Scott Galloway
Anyways, I'm going to go to my win. So when I was in junior high school, you know, you think about who you're going to, your fantasy wife. You thought, we both thought about that probably. Anyway, our fantasy wife. My fantasy wife was going to be the lead singer of Supertramp. And then I found out it was all dudes.
Kara Swisher
Oh, yeah.
Scott Galloway
So I'm still angry at Supertramp for misleading me like that. So I went on to my next fantasy wife.
Kara Swisher
Okay. Who was that?
Scott Galloway
Pat Benatar, who is being inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. She doesn't get... She's finally getting the recognition. She's finally getting the recognition she deserves. I think she's a fantastic artist, a fantastic performer. I saw her perform.
Kara Swisher
So is Dolly Parton.
Scott Galloway
That's right. Dolly Parton. But my win is my future wife and the next life, or my wife when I was a 14-year-old, Pat Benatar.
Kara Swisher
Sing a little bit for us. Sing a little, Pat Benatar, to get your mood back up. What is it? "Love is for angels"? No, no, no. "Hell is for angels"? She's fantastic. "Give me your best shot."
Scott Galloway
"Hit me with your best shot." That's right. Anyways, Pat Benatar, she's wonderful.
Kara Swisher
Thank you for that. Pat Benatar. Anyways, my win is Pat Benatar. Good for you. I like that. I do. That is a good win. And she's amazing. She was an important artist. I don't remember who my fantasy wife was. I'm trying to think. Oh, I know. Mary Stuart Masterson.
Scott Galloway
Really? Oh, yeah. Hello.
Kara Swisher
She was in the movie with... *Some Kind of Wonderful*.
Scott Galloway
*Some Kind of Wonderful*. She was very good. She was very good.
Kara Swisher
I loved her with that. That movie where she was in it with gloves that have fringe on them, which are repulsive to me on every aspect. I loved her anyway. She was fantastic. Remember gloves with fringe on them?
Scott Galloway
I do. I do. Gloves with fringe. A lot of drummers had those. Yeah.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Anyway, Mary Stuart Masterson. Interesting. Interesting. I hadn't remembered that in many years.
Anyway, this has been a lovely show. I really appreciate you saying that about your mom. This is a much wider effect. Without the outrage, everybody, my own family, I can't go into it because it's private, but same thing. There was a situation and it was our whole lives would have been different. I wouldn't be here.
Scott Galloway
Anyway. Yep, wouldn't be here. I wouldn't be on this podcast. And we have to be, we can't let the anger make us blind to what we need to have done here. So we should be angry, but also purposeful going forward.
Kara Swisher
And also, good luck, Madison Cawthorn. That's all I have to say about that.
Scott Galloway
That's right. God be with... recuse yourself. What was he yelling out? We are supportive of your preferences. We are. We would just prefer you to go away is what we would prefer to do and do that in private because it's good. If you like it, we like it.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, Scott, that's the show. We'll be back on Tuesday with more Pivot. Please read us out.
Outro music begins
Today's show was produced by Lauren Naiman, Evan Engel, and Taylor Griffin. Ernie and Jatot engineered this episode. Thanks also to Drew Burrows and Emil Silverio. Make sure you're subscribed to the show wherever you listen to podcasts. Thank you for listening to Pivot from New York Magazine and Vox Media. We'll be back next week for another breakdown of all things tech and business.