Podcast Episode Summary
The podcast episode, "Pivot," hosted by Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway, covers various topics, including the midterm election results, the crypto market meltdown, and the challenges faced by social media platforms.
Main Topic: Midterm Election Results and Tech Industry Implications
The hosts discuss the midterm election results, which saw the Democrats maintain control of the Senate and the Republicans gain control of the House. They analyze the implications of these results for the tech industry, including the potential for antitrust legislation and the impact on companies like Facebook and Twitter.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Additional Topics:
Notable Quotes:
Advertisements
Ad Voiceover
Not all journalism is the same. Take The Guardian. Our coverage has something unique. Fierce independence. Nobody owns us or tells us what we can and can't say. So we're free to report the whole picture. We connect what's happening in Washington to the rest of the globe. Expose corruption wherever we find it. And give fresh perspective on everything. From wellness and soccer to culture, the climate and more. Read, watch and listen to The Guardian for free at theguardian.com.
Avoiding your unfinished home projects because you're not sure where to start? Thumbtack knows homes, so you don't have to. Don't know the difference between matte paint finish and satin? Or what that clunking sound from your dryer is? With Thumbtack, you don't have to be a home pro. You just have to hire one. You can hire top-rated pros, see price estimates, and read reviews all on the app. Download today.
Podcast Intro Music
Kara Swisher
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And I'm Scott Galloway.
Kara Swisher
Hey, Scott, do you know why Kevin McCarthy hates surfing?
Scott Galloway
I can't wait for this one. Why does Kevin McCarthy hate surfing, Kara?
Kara Swisher
Because there's no red wave.
Scott Galloway
Oh, my gosh.
Kara Swisher
So many wave jokes. Anyway, it was not good, not good for the Republicans, but still, it was a really interesting race. It sort of said, you know what the voters said? Stop it. Just stop it. Stop all the noise. That's what I think. What do you think? Very briefly.
Scott Galloway
Well, brief is not a friend I walk with, Kara.
Kara Swisher
All right. Well, let's wait then. Let's wait. What's the point of podcasting if you have to be brief?
Scott Galloway
All right.
Kara Swisher
We're going to get to that in a minute. Then let me just go through it. Today, we'll talk about the meltdown in the crypto world. Big deal. It's a big, big deal with FTX. Also, big tech layoffs finally hit Meta. Not as bad as people thought. And I thought Mark Zuckerberg handled it well. We'll speak with NYU's Jonathan Haidt about social media and mental health.
But first, OK, the midterm election results are still coming in and tech could be the loser. Big tech opponents on both sides of the aisle notched wins this week. On the Republican side, J.D. Vance won his Ohio Senate race. He's called for an end to tax loopholes for tech companies, although he was a former techie and a tech investor. In North Carolina, Representative Ted Budd will become senator. Very tight race there, shockingly. He's tried to weaken Section 230, replacing Senator Richard Burr, a Republican who is a bit more sympathetic. And some Democratic victories mean that antitrust legislation is still on the table. Senator Michael Bennett and Maggie Hassan both won reelection. They're considered key swing votes to the antitrust bill. So not so good for tech, but I think good for the country. Let me have your overall and then talk about the little tech element of it.
Scott Galloway
This wasn't a red wave. It was a goodbye wave from Trump. All of a sudden, all the bookies are saying that DeSantis is now the odds-on favorite to get the Republican nomination. Alito took a hit here. Going into the polls, abortion rights were number five. Coming out, they were a close number two to the economy. Very close. Almost equal. And also, I think the most exciting thing is that our institutions appear to be holding up. Now, what do I mean by that? I was very inspired by what happened with Lula in Brazil and what looks like it's going to be a peaceful transfer of power. And election denial appears to be a losing campaign tactic.
Kara Swisher
It's not a winning one.
Scott Galloway
It's not a winning one. I really hope – I think the most important election right now in America is Kari Lake. I think she has done a tremendous disservice attacking a pillar of democracy, the peaceful transfer of power, when there's absolutely no evidence that Arizona did not do an outstanding job in the 2020 election. And she is literally running against the election representative, the commissioner of elections. So that is a very important race.
Something that's very hopeful is we expect a certain amount of fair play, a certain amount of civility, a certain lack of hate. A certain lack of, "Oh, hi, Dr. Fauci." Whether you agree with him or not, he's been a public servant for 60 years. And when people start chanting "Put him in jail" on the floor of the Congress, that person shouldn't be reelected. And that's Lauren Boebert.
Kara Swisher
Some people call her Boobert on Twitter because it's so mature, but it's Boebert. Lauren Boebert.
Scott Galloway
Thank you for that. She might lose her seat. That is very exciting. So there's just no getting around it. This was very good news for Democrats.
Kara Swisher
It was. It was interesting. Let me give you some statistics. 18 toss-ups, one by Democrats versus seven for Republicans. That was interesting to me. They were supposed to grab everything. Now, they are going to get control of the House, likely, but not a very good one, and it puts Kevin McCarthy in a real problematic position because he's got the screaming memes like Marjorie Taylor Greene, who did win, on the other side, making trouble for him. So he's going to have to yank right, but that's not good for elections. So it's a real problem. He's got a real problem because he doesn't have – and you could peel away a lot of Republicans. The Democrats certainly could. Even Lindsey Graham was talking about bipartisan legislation immediately.
Let me just say, it was – as I tweeted, it was a good night for lesbians across the country.
Scott Galloway
Say more.
Kara Swisher
Maura Healey, who's now the Massachusetts governor.
Scott Galloway
I did not know that.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, she's amazing. I did a great interview with her. I know her a little bit. And also Tina Kotek in Oregon. She fended off a very interesting challenge from a Republican and an Independent. So two big lesbians. No, three, there's the mayor of Chicago. We're all over the place, let me just say.
The other thing is the coordinated attacks on Trump by Fox are really interesting. They call him Trumpty Dumpty. The Wall Street Journal had quite the piece: "Trump is the Republican Party's biggest loser." It's quite an eviscerating piece. "A perfect record of electoral defeat. He has led Republicans into one political fiasco after another." So very interesting shifts going on.
The other one I would comment about is Peter Thiel. Did he win? J.D. Vance won in Ohio. It was a close race. Tim Ryan, kudos to him in terms of that race. And his concession speech was incredibly – that guy's going places, I think. We don't know about Blake Masters in Arizona, but he's quite behind. Both are former Thiel employees, and he gave a lot of – millions and millions of dollars. I don't think he's as interested in politics as people think. I don't think he wants to be Sheldon Adelson, but he likes to put money here and there. So I don't know if he won or not.
Scott Galloway
Just a quick call out, though, to Tim Ryan. I thought the speech he gave, which is being seen around the world, had more impact on a democracy than he likely could have had had he won the election. "I have the privilege to concede this race to J.D. Vance. Because the way this country operates is that when you lose an election, you concede and you respect." I thought that was very powerful.
Kara Swisher
I do too. And he sets a great role model for other elected representatives. He set, I think, a great role model for young people.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. He could have gone to the Senate and served well for six years and not had the kind of impact he had with that six-minute concession speech. I thought that was very powerful.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, what about tech? It feels like it's one of the few bipartisan topics. They come at it for different reasons. But even your guy, or not your guy, the guy you mentioned, J.D. Vance, Thiel's guy, is claiming that he wants to do it with tax loopholes. It just feels as if everyone's coalescing around some sort of legislation here. But you know what? I've been saying that for five years.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I know.
Kara Swisher
I know. We'll see. Well, they have trouble abroad. Regulators in the EU have announced a probe into Microsoft's acquisition of Activision Blizzard. Last month, Microsoft accused a different regulator in the UK of relying on biased input from its rival, Sony. It's going to be really interesting. Europe is, of course, leading the way, but there's going to be a lot of stuff scrutinized. And companies like Facebook can't really expand if they need to buy things. We'll get to Facebook in a minute, but I think there's going to be legislation. I think Amy Klobuchar's antitrust bill might, if they get the Senate, it looks like Mark Kelly will get it. That means the race in Georgia between Senator Warnock and the football guy. That's what I'm calling. Herschel Walker is not my father.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
So I think that's going to be interesting. But they may not need it. It might just sort of sideline Joe Manchin a tiny bit more than he's been, pull the power from him, which I don't know. I think it's probably a good idea not to have one guy deciding everything. And then lastly, I think that Chuck Schumer may lighten up on all the tech legislation. He's been a champion of tech.
Scott Galloway
I mean, he's been a, I don't know if champion's the right word because I don't think he knows anything about it.
Kara Swisher
Defender, whatever. Apologist. Something like that.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. Without the Senate majority leader, this is how they kill stuff. They play slowball.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. And he has tremendous power. I feel like our Democratic leadership always has a good excuse for why they're outplayed.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. And including Senator Schumer, who, in my view, has gummed up and gotten in the way and basically slowballed any legislation or meaningful legislation around tech.
Kara Swisher
All right. OK, I'm going to compliment someone I was very angry at, Glenn Youngkin, who made that stupid joke at Nancy Pelosi's expense when her husband got beaten. And obviously, all the information that's come out since shows exactly what happened, which is he got attacked by someone who had been radicalized into QAnon type of stuff. And he sent a handwritten apology note, which, you know what, I'll take it. I think he was stupid and he's been doing that quite a bit, going to see Kari Lake, et cetera. He should pull away from these people. They're not good for him. I suspect he's – I don't agree with much of his policies, but I have to say I was heartened by that, that he apologized. And we have to let people apologize. People were mad when I said, OK. They're like, don't forgive this. I'm like, you know what, I'm going to, because I'll take any civility, move towards civility by either side. And so I thought that was nice.
Scott Galloway
One of the great attributes and singular attributes of our species is that we have the ability to apologize and also to forgive. No other species does that. And I think it's something, especially men, have a difficult time acknowledging when they're wrong and apologizing. I apologized to my 12-year-old the other day.
Kara Swisher
You do. You do apologize.
Scott Galloway
I have a tough time apologizing to my kids. I got very angry at my kid and yelled at him the other night and he was physically scared. It took me back to a point when I was a kid and my dad used to yell at me and it would really scare me. And I, of course, I'm going back to me totally off topic here, but I sat him down the next day and I said, "Look, I'm sorry. You know, parents get in bad moods too. I shouldn't have yelled at you like that. And anytime that you ever feel any kind of scared, just say, 'Dad, you're scaring me' and I'll stop." But anyways, it was hard for me. I find myself wanting to be a role model for them, which immediately leads me to some weird notion that I can't apologize. Anyways, I think apology is a wonderful thing. I'm trying to get better at it.
Kara Swisher
Very nice. And we're not going to go into it because we disagree, but I was very pleased that John Fetterman won and that stuff. Senator-elect Fetterman. That cruel, cruel effort to make fun of his stroke. He did a great speech on election night, seemed to be able to speak. I thought that was really, that was very heartening. He just kept getting back up. That guy kept getting back. I think it's an American story. And I think it's really nice. And I think he'll be a surprisingly good senator. I love the way he dresses, too. I love he's going to show up in Carhartt.
Scott Galloway
I mean this sincerely. I hope you're right.
Kara Swisher
Yes, thank you.
Scott Galloway
I think he's going to be a good senator. That was a no-lose race for me. I had a good friend who I think is very confident and a good person and a family man. And I think we need moderates. I would task everyone with doing some self-awareness. A lot of people say they're center-left or center-right or they're moderate or they think they're bipartisan. If there were 465 people on the ballot, if you can't find a single person in the other party that you would support, you are not a moderate. You are not bipartisan. And also, attacking people for who they support, just so you know, doesn't work. You want to attack the issue, you want to attack the candidate, you want to have a discussion, that works. But shaming people for supporting Trump, it backfired on us. Because they're like, "You know what, I'll show you," when the curtains closed. So I have tasked myself with every election trying to find someone, a Republican, because I think we've gotten very lazy and I think we've gotten very partisan.
Kara Swisher
But let's stick to policy then. I think if the Republicans took over the Senate, they would outlaw abortion. So I was perfectly fine being that that's a policy thing. And a woman's right to choose was on the line in that state.
Scott Galloway
I agree. Things have become so dangerous around issues that I understand the importance and the power of maintaining a majority in the Senate, especially on judges, I would argue. But at the same time, unless we start electing moderates and unless occasionally voters reach across the aisle and our elected representatives are motivated and encouraged to reach across the aisle, this polarization is never going to end.
Kara Swisher
Agreed. But your friend couldn't say that. They couldn't be a moderate because the pressure not to be. Anyway, we can never know.
Scott Galloway
We'll never know, Kara.
Kara Swisher
You don't know.
Scott Galloway
I know, but you don't have to say it. You can be silent.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, okay, let's get to our, that's the last argument we're going to have about your friend, Dr. Oz. And I hope he has a lovely television career going forward. Okay, let's get to our first big story. Crypto transactions can take a long time to settle, but at least one shakeup happened at Lightspeed this week. This was something, Scott. On Tuesday, crypto exchange FTX agreed to sell to its rival, Binance, as FTX faced a liquidity crunch, a run on the bank, essentially. But on Wednesday, Binance walked away from the deal, citing problematic things on the balance sheet. A double whammy set the crypto market spiraling.
Bitcoin dropped below $16,000 for the first time in two years. Another exchange, Crypto.com, paused withdrawals from some stablecoins. FTX CEO Sam Bankman-Fried has told investors that his exchange needs $8 billion to cover a shortfall. Oh, my God. Is this the kind of meltdown that Bitcoin cryptocurrencies were supposed to solve? It's supposed to make third parties obsolete, but traders put their crypto into third-party exchanges anyway, and that exchange is in very deep trouble. Binance CEO Changpeng Zhao, who goes by CZ, says that his exchange will pose proof of reserve soon. It better be soon.
Let me hear what you have to say.
Scott Galloway
So this is a tough one. People are saying this is the Lehman moment when it all starts to unwind. And I would argue it's more like when Bank of America bought Merrill Lynch.
Kara Swisher
But it didn't happen here.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but go ahead. Eventually, Bank of America had to be bailed out by the government, and the government isn't bailing out these institutions. There's no FDIC insurance. This is now a, it used to be a $3 trillion market. I think it's sub a trillion, which means it's not really a threat to the economy. But I think I understand crypto better than 99% of the public, and I don't understand crypto. And the carnival barkers and bullies online took advantage of the fact that we didn't understand it and created this halo of innovation. And if you ever say anything critical about it, you don't get it. And I still don't entirely understand what happened. So I had one of my analysts, Mia Silverio, attempt to write up what happened. And I'll just read it because I think most people pretend they sort of understand what happened here, including me, but they don't really understand.
So FTX was valued at approximately $33 billion earlier this year. Its investors included Sequoia, SoftBank, and the Ontario Teachers Pension Plan. And what happened was the leaked documents by CoinDesk last week showed that FTX may not have been backing user funds one-to-one behind the scenes. So you put money in, and then they take the money and invest it in illiquid assets that you may not be able to get out if there's a run on the bank, if everyone wants to redeem at the same time. The documents showed that Alameda Research, a trading and investment firm founded by SBF, Sam Bankman-Fried, who I guess now has acronym status, had its finances intertwined with those of FTX, which in any traditional financial services industry would be a no-no.
Alameda held a significant amount of FTT, which is the trading token of FTX. Most of FTX was owned by FTX and Alameda, making it illiquid. And then the documents also show that Alameda had been borrowing millions of dollars against FTT, this coin, and rumors spread across Twitter that FTX was loaning out user funds to Alameda and using its own illiquid FTT token as collateral. CZ tweeted that Binance would be unwinding its own position in that FTT token over the span of a few months, and everyone started selling. And the price of FTT crashed, and you had what is a classic run on the bank. And if you just really read this, it sounds like a pyramid scheme because it is.
These things have no underlying utility. They're not backed by the government. This really is, you as far as I can tell, this whole market is you exchange fiat currency to go into a casino and get tickets that are worth nothing. And you're supposed to have one ratio, but go ahead.
Kara Swisher
And hope that at the end of the day, you get a stuffed animal or something for your tickets and you get the hell out of the Chuck E. Cheese that has become the crypto market. It really is. I mean, I don't know what's happening today, but we saw Bitcoin come down to a two-year low. The good news is it's more noise than news because it's not a huge market. And there's contagion here a little bit, but it's not. It really has become such a small market. It gets more news. Like Twitter, it gets a lot more news than it actually has impact.
Scott Galloway
Yep. That's a fair point.
Kara Swisher
And nonetheless, it's still, this is an industry. What's important here is Sam Bankman-Fried was seen as the stable one. He's been spending a lot of money in Congress trying to get rules in place around crypto. He's considered the calm one. He's considered the non-Ponzi scheme guy, you know, all these things. And so I think that's where we're in trouble in that regard. Do you know what's happened? His net worth has gone from $16 billion to $1 billion. Binance said it would, the largest crypto exchange stepped in and said they would purchase FTX. And then it reversed course on Wednesday, saying the issues at FTX were, quote unquote, "beyond our control or ability to help."
SBF told investors he needs emergency funding to cover a shortfall of $8 billion. And then again, it's always the second order, the knock-on effects that are the most interesting. Bitcoin dropped below $16,000 for the first time in two years. Solana got cut in half. Again, SBF, $16 billion to $1 billion. A massive loss of trust in crypto. And a Binance purchase of FTX would have been similar again to B of A's bailout of Merrill Lynch, except that B of A was later bailed out by Uncle Sam. And this just shows the risk of putting your money in a trustless ecosystem. You can't trust that it's safe.
Scott Galloway
Yep. Yep. Yep.
Kara Swisher
And I think that's the problem. And now, regulators are moving in to look. This is from Bloomberg. U.S. regulators are circling FTX, investigating whether the firm properly handled customer funds as well as its relationship with other parts of Bankman-Fried's crypto empire. It's, as you said, you know more than 99% of the people, and I don't even understand this at all, except that it's a, is it a solvency crisis or a liquidity crisis, really? I don't know what's going to happen here, but I can't underscore how many Silicon Valley investors are going to get hosed. They're all going to lose all their money, apparently, and big names. But the question, I have a question for you, and this is my conspiracy theory.
Scott Galloway
You're a big VC fund.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
And you invest in a company that has a project, a quote-unquote, but it's issuing a token and supposedly this coin has some sort of underlying technical utility. You buy, say for $200 million or $300 million, 30% of this company. Are you not only taking equity in the parent company, but are you being issued 30% of the coins? Because if a tier one VC attaches its name to something in the midst of a kind of a tulip mania, and then they mint the coin, and they have millions of these coins that for a moment hop to several hundred or several thousand dollars. What's to prohibit them from then dumping those coins in a measured, I guess "dumping" is a measured oxymoron.
But what's to prohibit them from selling those coins because they don't have to disclose their sales? And then while we in the press say, "Oh, what idiots," what they've just done is sold a bag of shit to retail investors who got caught up in the euphoria, but they don't have to report their sales. I mean, that's what... And I have no evidence this has happened, but that's what I would do. So I wonder if we're going to find out that all these guys we said are idiots and lost billions actually made billions selling this shit into the market.
Kara Swisher
Could be. I mean, the CFTC and the SEC have been fighting over who should regulate this and are looking in this situation. Everyone's getting looked at now. And the thing is, Sam Bankman-Fried, they always call him SBF, he has given $40 million mostly to Democrats in this election cycle. And I don't think it necessarily got him anything. But nonetheless, I think it'll be interesting to see. What I was really riveted to was the exchanges with venture capitalists who just are like, when he went on about, you could buy a banana, you could buy this, you could have value, you could do this. The banana stuck in my head, as did many people's. But you can't buy a banana with this. You can't. Like, you can't. You really can't. I mean, maybe you can somewhere. Everyone goes crazy because they're taking a cryptocurrency at one subway in London.
Scott Galloway
Again, the narrative is the following in the crypto community. And by the way, the company I'm on the board of, Ledger, which is Cold Storage, has seen a huge uptick. Because the bottom line is, if you put your coins or any assets into these exchanges, they're not necessarily yours any longer.
Kara Swisher
Protected, yeah.
Scott Galloway
So anyways, the notion that you've had this asset class emerge, and I would argue that that $40 million that SBF invested in lobbying, essentially, or politicians, he got a huge return on it. Because what's happened is you have a series of senior citizens who have been paid by, they see a new revenue source to get the key mother's milk to getting reelected, and that is money. And again, all they have to do is nothing. This space should have been much more aggressively regulated much earlier.
Kara Swisher
It's been more than the Internet. But go ahead.
Scott Galloway
All right. Go ahead.
Kara Swisher
You think it's been more regulated than the Internet? Yes. Biden put out some stuff. The FD... I've talked to CFTC and SEC people. They're trying. They've been much earlier than they were to any Internet stuff. But go ahead.
Scott Galloway
The narrative coming out of the crypto community is the following: Remember the Internet. Huge mania. 1999, Internet Capital Group worth more than General Electric. Then 2000, a crash, and then these giants emerged. But here's the thing. In 1999, I was using Yahoo Mail. I was buying books off of Amazon. I was selling millions of dollars of gifts off of Red Envelope, a company I started in 1997. There were real transactions. And I always ask the same thing when I go to these lunches to try and learn. We're some very thoughtful billionaire from some Litecoin or Meta or Luna. I say, "How did the blockchain change my life today? What exactly did it do for me? Give me anything, anything I can point to around utility." And they'll come up with these weird Byzantine examples.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it's very hard. It's sort of like using the metaverse. It's hard. And I think they had all those conferences insulting Warren Buffett.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, they showed him.
Kara Swisher
Warren Buffett for the win. All those really aggressive guys, all these crypto, you know, the crypto Taliban, they have gone oddly quiet. They're so mean. Anyway, one FTX investor who could be crying, Tom Brady, the quarterback, had a partnership with FTX since 2020. God, these people can't stop themselves. Like, why? And reportedly took a large stake in the exchange in 2021. It's unclear how large the stake was, but he's had a bad 2022. Tom Brady announced retirement, one of the worst seasons in the NFL, a divorce. And now this.
Scott Galloway
Tom, he's still handsome.
Kara Swisher
Okay, but let me just let me be clear. Despite the divorce, despite the losing season so far, despite losing $650 million bucks, I would still trade places with Tom Brady. I would ride that Tom Brady thing out. I think he's going to be just fine.
Scott Galloway
Let's pour one out for Tom Brady.
Kara Swisher
I think he's going to be okay.
Moving on, on Wednesday, Facebook announced layoffs of 11,000 people or 13% of its staff, a little better than people thought. He still has more employees than they started the year off a year ago. Zuckerberg addressed his employees on the same day. Here's the clip.
[Audio Clip - Mark Zuckerberg] Mark Zuckerberg: I want to say, up front, that I take full responsibility for this decision. I'm the founder and CEO. I'm responsible for the health of our company, for our direction, and for deciding how we execute that, including things like this.
End Audio Clip
I thought he handled this really well. Again, I like to call him as I see him, and I thought he was empathetic. He signed everything. He's given them very generous. I think it's 16 weeks of severance and two additional weeks for every year they've worked with the company. Very generous. He did it himself. He was classy about it. And Meta will cover the health care costs of laid off employees and their families. They're also helping people with visa issues. You know, we knew they were coming. He has to do it. It is his responsibility. He does control the company. But I think he did a good job here. What do you think?
Scott Galloway
Well, the most interesting thing about Meta, there's a lot here. The most interesting thing about Meta is that I believe they've been very bad for the Commonwealth, but they are very good. I mean, this was a contrast in management competence relative to the shit show that is Twitter right now. Did you notice when they put out? First off, they leaked to take some pressure off the announcement late last week or I think over the weekend. And then when did they do this, Kara?
They did it the day of the midterms. They buried it. And if you want to talk about news. They didn't sign it. He didn't sign it. He didn't have a speech. He didn't talk to employees. Humble. This was a master class.
Kara Swisher
I meant Elon didn't talk to employees, but go ahead.
Scott Galloway
That's right. This was a master class from Facebook on how to do this. And, you know, here's the thing. Talk about news versus noise. Look at all the noise around the Twitter layoffs. Meta just laid off three times the number of the entire workforce of Twitter. And not only that, there's different stages of a company. I'm on the board of a couple of these companies. There's the initial stage: "Oh, it's a V. It's just a quick correction, and the party's going to continue." That's the first stage of denial. The second stage is a hiring freeze. The next stage is a layoff. And then the next stage is a second layoff. And then typically you can kind of get back to work. And I'm the Debbie Downer on the board saying, "Let's just skip to the second layoff, go deeper, and get the company in fighting shape."
Kara Swisher
Well, in 2015, it was less than 60,000. Now they have 76,000. They hired like crazy.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. You could see another 20 or 30,000 layoffs here, Kara. You could. Maybe he's doing it in tranches. That's not a great idea. Speaking loosely, what we're seeing in the growth economy is that the business and the stocks are kind of moving back to where they were pre-pandemic. So if you were to take Meta back to where it was pre-pandemic on an employment level, you're going to lose 15 times the workforce of Twitter. So the noise of Elon Musk and these layoffs and all these things on people saying goodbye and asking for people to come back... they just laid off 11,000 people. Here, let me just say the contrast. There are so many angry Twitter employees both inside. I get so many leaks. It's crazy. I don't even try. I got several notes from Facebook people saying, "I don't always like Mark. I haven't liked working parts of this, but I have to say he was a classy dude in something that's bad." They got laid off. And I haven't gotten one angry note. He did a nice, mature job of this.
Kara Swisher
I agree. There's probably going to have to be more layoffs. They've got a lot of challenges, headwinds, not just overspending and betting the farm on the metaverse, but also TikTok and Apple and recession and regulatory scrutiny. He's got a lot on his plate. All right, Scott, let's go on a quick break. When we come back, Elon Musk turns Twitter into a masquerade ball, and we'll speak to friend of Pivot, Jonathan Haidt.
Ad Break
All right, Scott, it's been a crazy day at Twitter and that I've dragged you back into the studio to tape a fresh update. When we taped earlier, Elon was having some mild problems with check marks, but now he's talking bankruptcy, and there's a lot of other trouble there. And here's where we are.
Scott Galloway
Okay. I am in a relationship with a manic depressive person called Elon Musk.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, you are.
Scott Galloway
And I'm Nurse Ratched, trying to give this person advice, and so are you, and they're not even in the room to talk therapy. And it's the worst relationship in the world because I'm getting really bad headaches, and I'm not getting any head from this guy.
Kara Swisher
OK. So I am just done with this, Kara. I am just done.
Scott Galloway
Granted, I am two or three makers and ginger into this podcast right now.
Kara Swisher
OK. All right. OK. Tell me what stupid thing he's done today, Kara. Your turn.
Scott Galloway
Here are some highlights. Musk just told Twitter employees he's not sure how much run rate the company has and, quote, "bankruptcy isn't out of the question." Zoe Schiffer from Platformer is reporting that Yoel Roth is out. The senior director of trust and safety is out. Casey Newton is reporting that Robin Wheeler, vice president of Client Solutions, is also out. Both Yoel and Robin were on the call with advertisers with Elon yesterday, the ones speaking. And also in an all-hands staff meeting, Musk told staff, "If you can physically make it to the office and you don't show up, resignation accepted." So he's gotten nicer, I guess. On Thursday, a senior member of Twitter's legal team posted a message in a Slack channel saying, "Everyone should know that our CISO, chief information security officer, chief privacy officer, and chief compliance officer all resigned last night. This news will be buried in the return to office drama. I believe it is intentional." On Thursday, the FTC announced it's monitoring the situation at Twitter as executives depart. Jeez, it's not even Friday.
Kara Swisher
Look, Yoel was the one they were pushing out. They were tweeting all his things over and over again. Yoel sounded reasonable. He's fantastic. And he also has been the target of right-wing people because he's been reasonable. That's a big deal. Robin Wheeler, again, was on the call sort of giving Elon easy softballs in front of advertisers, trying to make him presentable after he's kicked them in the teeth several times before. I think this very aggressiveness towards staff... I think he wants to get into bankruptcy. I don't really know. And then pull it out.
Scott Galloway
No, he doesn't.
Kara Swisher
And then President Biden said, "Yeah, people should look into the foreign ownership of that company," and laughed. So tell me what he wants to do.
Scott Galloway
Let me just take a moment. And the people want to know what we think because we've been so right about how this particular chapter of Elon's life has gone. So people think L. Ron Hubbard and Tony Robbins and this, you know, Khomeini can do no wrong. Today, you said some things about Musk and a bunch of people attacked you that, "Oh, no, he's smarter than you. Everything he's done is brilliant." Like smart people, talented people are saying this. It's like, no, he's acting like a child. He's acting like a narcissist. He's acting like someone who's never had any guardrails. So first off, him saying the bankruptcy is not out of the question.
It's meant to be a threat. Like you should be scared. You might lose your job. No, it's not. If they go into a bankruptcy, reasonably responsible people, their debt holders will now own the company and they will bring in an adult to run this company. That's not a threat to them. His equity would be wiped out and he'd have to call his buddies and go, "I not only lost all your money, I lost it in about 60 or 90 days." In addition, when you plant landmines behind you and around you and you get lost, you're going to lose a leg. And this guy has pissed off so many people that what do you know? The people at the FTC, the people at CFIUS aren't in any hurry to do this guy any favors.
And you know what's going to happen next, Kara?
Kara Swisher
Tell me.
Scott Galloway
See, now we've gotten to it. The bourbon is kicking in. Go ahead. The site's going to go down. Something's going to go wrong with the site. You can't behave this way. You can't make so many enemies. You can't treat people so poorly without someone pissing in the punch bowl. I mean, he is literally making enemies everywhere.
Kara Swisher
Your thoughts? I would agree with you. I can literally... I never... every bad quality he has over the years, and you know I supported him on lots of things because I do think he's making things that are better than other people. Again, you're an owner of a Tesla. The rocket stuff is cool. You have to admire that. But in this case, since the beginning, since it started to crater, and since he sort of has been red-pilled all over the place, he's become really bad at his job. And that's the only thing I can say is this is not how you treat people. This is not how you treat people. Anyway, you don't tell them they're all idiots and you're a genius when you're not making genius moves. And we've said that the way he tried to get out of this deal was sketchy at best and really creepy and just a lot of a series of lies. And it's been problematic.
Scott Galloway
I can't remember a company that was this crazy. I don't have a memory of one. I've been in my own companies when we've lost all of our business or a lot of our business or our biggest client left, and I had to bring 30 people into a room and fire them at the same time. That was probably my lowest moment professionally. I remember walking into the room and a bunch of people we had just hired out of business school were holding hands and crying. And I remember thinking, "Jesus Christ." So that was upsetting, but it wasn't chaos. I was on the board of the New York Times when we almost lost the New York Times.
People don't realize in 2008 how close the New York Times came to basically handing over the company to its creditors. And the Sulzbergers were about to be, or Arthur was about to be, the cousin that lost the company. That was very stressful. I have never seen anything like this. The level of erratic, manic, juvenile, reckless behavior where you can't even predict what he's going to do next. I've never seen anything like this because this is what happens. Corporate governance and checks and balances, whether it's government, whether it's boards, are meant to have guardrails where someone shows up and says, "You know what, Travis, you're acting like the bro-iest bro in Broville, and it's no longer working.
You're out." People can show up and say, "You know what? You need a timeout. We're going to bench you for a little bit." There's no one here to say that to this guy.
Kara Swisher
No, no. He doesn't listen to anybody. He's brought in a team of suck-ups, as we said, and not the best people in Silicon Valley. They just aren't. There are so many good people he could have brought in here. He could have brought in Adam Bain, who understood the company.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, he hasn't called him. Just so you know, I checked in.
Kara Swisher
What about a guy like Dick Costolo? He always struck me as a fairly level-headed guy.
Scott Galloway
Not been called. Not been called. Any of them. You know, you don't have to even call them. There are so many great media people. I was willing to talk to him about it. He asked me and then, you know, went sour because I was slightly critical. It was ridiculous. He had, "What should you do?" I was like, "Oh, well, you know what? I'm using this. I've known it for years. Let me tell you what I've seen over the years." He doesn't have to, but, you know, I want this service to work. And so the way he's treating people, this story after story, it's like the Trump administration. It really feels like that. Story after story after fuck-up after fuck-up. And people tolerate that. But I don't think he has a constituency that Trump has. All the Silicon Valley people are not going along. They find this a ridiculous traffic accident, and it makes Silicon Valley look bad. There is blood in the water here, I think, at this point.
I never thought I'd say this. Trump looks like an adult compared to Elon Musk right now. But Trump left ambassadors in place. He left the majority of generals. He left the majority of his defense team in place because he realized this is serious shit. And even though he was reckless... then he shed himself of those. But go ahead. When the GOP tweeted "Kanye, Musk, Trump," little did we know how prescient they were. That was literally a tweet that summarizes three people who all suffer from the same thing. I don't know if it's megalomania. I don't know if it's... it doesn't matter. But here's the thing. This is what we're witnessing. And all his fans will weigh in and say, "Oh, no, there's a genius behind this. And he's doing what's required." There isn't.
Kara Swisher
There's a genius behind it, but it's not here. No, no, none of this is genius, Kara. No, none of this is genius. I'm saying he could have done it, and he hasn't. What's the opposite of better angels? Whatever the opposite of better angels is.
Scott Galloway
Dark shoots? I don't know.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, all the dark parts of his personality have now won out. Honestly, all the dark parts in here. Whatever happens at Twitter, whatever he transforms into, it's like watching Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde. This is just a disaster. Just a disaster. But here's the thing. We're not watching a company implode. Twitter is not... As Aswath Damodaran and my colleague at NYU summarized it perfectly: Twitter's not a national treasure. If Twitter goes away tomorrow, we're all going to be fine.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
We'll all find different ways to communicate. We'll all find ways for woke people to yell at each other and for conservative people to create fake accounts and start spreading conspiracy theories. We'll all figure it out and move on. We're not watching a company implode. We're watching a person implode. You know what's next? Tesla's going to shit the bed. It's down to 190 today. It's crazy down.
Scott Galloway
That's nothing. I know, but I'm saying. Anyways, I am sort of... and this is media, as evidenced by the fact we're here talking about this now, but we love to watch people unravel. And this isn't about Twitter unraveling. This is about a man, a 50-year-old man or whatever he is, unraveling. And we love to watch it. We love to watch it. And then all these people come on Twitter and say, "Oh, there's a genius here." No, there's not. You don't behave this way. These are people's livelihoods. He told people to give him their money and that he would invest it responsibly. It is an important service. And all of these people who he pissed off and said, "Oh, I thought you were dead," or "How come your personal profile looks like you just came?" Guess what? They have the head of the FTC and the CFIUS panel on speed dial. And they're like, "You know what? Don't cut this guy any slack."
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
And all of this bullshit, all this lack of respect, all this bad karma. You don't think at some point... I'm curious to hear that.
Kara Swisher
I think the site's going to go down. I do. I'm worried about the security of it, obviously with all those people leaving. And I think he has had the worst brand decline I've ever seen. He's lost so much brand equity as a person. And he's trying to do the same to Twitter. And unfortunately, he's got his hands on the wheel and everyone around him is a sycophant. And so not good things are going to happen here.
Scott Galloway
Well, OK, you should never diagnose someone. But look, I'm not a cop and I can tell when a car is going 100 miles an hour. This guy needs connective tissue. In my view, this guy needs to take some time off and call people that he trusts and have his best interest at heart and just get counsel. And call some people in media or just some people he trusts, not far-right podcasters or sycophants, and just get some counsel and take a breather here because this whole thing could just be over barely after it started.
Kara Swisher
It feels as if crypto and Twitter are in a race to the bottom right now.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, yeah, that's interesting. I wonder who could... I'm trying to think of someone who would stop this. None of them will. None of them. They just can't do it. No one.
Kara Swisher
I'm trying to think. Ellison? No. Andreessen? No. Sequoia? No. Ellison's probably a guy, aren't they friends? Ellison seems like a reasonable guy. He's obviously a brilliant guy.
Scott Galloway
He can be, but he never crosses founders. He won't cross them. He won't cross them. He won't tell the truth. They love to buck each other up, even in bad behavior. All of them do. I've never seen... Chris Sacca was the closest I've seen to someone, a class traitor, like you've talked about, like Marc Benioff, et cetera. You know, he's not going to listen to Benioff. Cuban tried to engage him, and he responded today. I think Cuban has a lot more choice things to say to him, but was being very polite.
Kara Swisher
Mark would be a great... Mark would be a... Call Mark Cuban, Elon.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but look, at the end of the day, again, as Aswath said, Twitter is meaningful. It's not profound. It's not like the New York Times going out of business.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
It's not even like, I would say, Meta or YouTube. A very small number of people, relatively speaking, are really passionate about it. I saw this chart the other day, Kara, and it showed all of the platforms' usage of people under the age of 25. Twitter is literally irrelevant. Irrelevant. To tomorrow's generation. I mean, it's just totally irrelevant.
Kara Swisher
Irrelevant.
Scott Galloway
And so we are obsessed with it because he is such a fascinating character and the story is fascinating.
Kara Swisher
It also can be a good product. It also can be a good product.
Scott Galloway
Well, it's addictive. It's an amazing product.
Kara Swisher
It sounds to me like slowly but surely he's taking the keys out after he blows stop signs and totals the car, and he's going to hand it to somebody else. I don't understand the strategy here. I don't understand what he's doing. Get back to the cars and rockets. You're not good at media. Media is hard. Come to think of it, do you remember Jeff Bezos' first couple of weeks as owner of The Post? He was fantastic.
Scott Galloway
Exactly. Exactly, Kara.
Kara Swisher
All right, Scott, let's bring on our friend of Pivot. Jonathan Haidt is a social psychologist, author, and a Thomas Cooley Professor of Ethical Leadership at NYU Stern School of Business. I don't think you have a title like that, Scott Galloway.
Scott Galloway
Oh, no, I have titles. There's nothing we can repeat here.
Kara Swisher
I get that. He's the author of, of course, *The Coddling of the American Mind*, a huge hit, and recently appeared on a *60 Minutes* episode about how social media has polarized America. He's done a lot of research into it. Jonathan, welcome.
Jonathan Haidt
Well, thank you, Kara. Thank you, Scott.
Scott Galloway
Thanks for that, Kara. Jonathan, good to see you.
Kara Swisher
So, your research you've done, you said when we've spent time together that we had trouble with real rigorous research that nullified or validated these hypotheses around the impact that Facebook and social media was having on mental health. And since then, you've done a lot of peer-reviewed research that has illuminated certain correlations and also said there isn't evidence. Can you break that down for us?
Jonathan Haidt
Sure. So I'm a social psychologist, and I'm your colleague here at NYU Stern. And the way the psychological research community works is there's generally a norm of skepticism. So if someone says TV is rotting kids' brains, research psychologists don't say, "Yeah, let's go show that." They say, "Hold on a second. Hold on." They're skeptical. And that's appropriate. And so there are many previous moral panics around television, video games, where the evidence of harm didn't really pan out very much. And social media, some say, is like that because the correlations between how much time you spend on social media and mental illness range between a correlation of 0.
05 to 0.1. But here's the thing. Whenever you zoom in, not on screen time—most of the studies are looking at screen time—if you focus in on social media and girls, those correlations rise from around 0.05 up to 0.15. And even the researchers that I'm arguing with, they agree, they admit that the correlation is around 0.15, which is larger than the correlation of lead exposure and adult IQ, or calcium intake and osteoporosis. So social media and teen mental health for girls is actually a bigger effect than many other public health effects.
Kara Swisher
And this is for kids. So one of the things is, you know, Frances Haugen had brought those things out in the Facebook Files, showing that they knew about its effect on girls and women. Talk about your research, how you did it, why you decided to focus in on this.
Jonathan Haidt
I'm not a developmental psychologist. I study morality and politics. And I ended up writing this book with Greg Lukianoff called *The Coddling of the American Mind*. And I began to see more and more that Gen Z—that is, people born after 1996—are really different from, say, people born in 1993. It's an incredibly sharp divide. And as I've been tracking down why, why did this happen? Why is it so sudden? Everything points to going through puberty on social media. That's the divide. So the millennials, if you're born in 1993, let's say you hit puberty in 2009 or 2006, and you have a flip phone and it's not very harmful.
You're talking with your friends on your flip phone. But if you're born in, say, 2000, you hit puberty in around 2013. Everyone got on Instagram around 2012. All the girls got on Instagram around 2012. And a normal, healthy childhood means you have a lot of time with friends, face time with them. You get in arguments, but it has to be face-to-face and synchronous. And all of a sudden, childhood gets rewired. Between 2010 and 2015, American childhood gets rewired so that now we don't have normal human interaction. Kids now just curl up with their phone and everything goes through the phone, including their romantic lives now.
So anyway, I just began studying this and I haven't done original research. I'm not out there actually collecting data, but I've aggregated all of the published studies, hundreds and hundreds of them. And listeners can find everything at jonathanhaidt.com/socialmedia. I put everything up there.
Kara Swisher
All right. So what would you recommend to parents when it comes to assessing how much access children, especially girls, should have to social media?
Jonathan Haidt
So here's the damnable thing: it's a social dilemma. That is, if it was just like exposure to candy or some poison, we'd all say, "No, you're not getting this till you're 16 or 18 or ever." But this is all a network thing. And the platforms know this. The only reason any of us ever let our daughters on Instagram is because they say, as my kids did when they hit sixth grade, "Everyone's on Instagram. That's where everything's happening. I have to be on." So it's a social dilemma. And what's most horrible about this, I think, is that the official age is 13, which is way too young, and it's not enforced. So girls, it's now normal at 10 or 11. And there's evidence that if they go through puberty on this, it warps their minds, it warps their thinking about others, it makes them feel they're not as good, they're not as beautiful, they're not as popular. And I think it has... FOMO on steroids.
Kara Swisher
FOMO on steroids.
Jonathan Haidt
You can see the parties. I'll never forget one of my kids saw a party happening. It was all over Instagram. We just took Instagram off his phone. I'm like, "If you don't see it, it didn't happen." And I remember the look. I'll never forget it. I was like, "Oh, dear, this is not good." I wish I could just say to parents, "Just don't let your kid have it till they're 16." And that might be the best advice, but I'm not sure because that means they're isolated from other kids. So what you really need is you need to get together with other parents. And as long as your kid has a couple of good friends and they get together in person, then it's not so painful and they'll come out mentally healthy. The other thing is parents need to really put pressure on the schools to give a consistent message. No phone access at school. Keep the phone. In my daughter's schools here in New York City, they finally adopted Yondr pouches. The kids can't have access during the day. So there are some things that are hopeful.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, that's what my kid has. Jonathan, do you have any thoughts on the contrast between the research you have done that shows that social media has been especially harmful to teen girls and also the evidence coming out that young adult men seem to be struggling? What is the Venn overlap around technology or any other issues? Because you hear about girls being really vulnerable to social media, and at the same time, our young men are struggling.
Jonathan Haidt
No, that's right. And you just had my friend Richard Reeves on the other day. He's fantastic, and I agree with everything that he says on this. So here's what I can figure out. Having dug so deeply into the data on social media, what I can say with confidence is that the links are very strong for girls and they're weak for boys. So if all we think about is social media, then we'd have to say, "Well, maybe it's not a big deal for boys, but let's keep the girls off." But here's the thing. All kids are addicted to technology. And when everyone got an iPhone around 2011, 2012, the girls all went for these visual platforms.
They dove into Instagram, Pinterest, and Tumblr. The boys went for video games and YouTube, which are not as harmful. So what we have to do is we have to look at boys' childhood very differently. It's not about time on Instagram. It's about what do boys need to be healthy? And what they need is a gang. They need a group. They need to have adventures. Those adventures have to be face-to-face, or rather shoulder to shoulder. So, you know, the online video games can substitute a little bit—it is kind of an adventure—but all the rules are set. They don't make the rules. So it's a kind of synthetic, not satisfying, groupish, paramilitary pseudo-adventure.
Boys are starving for normal childhood experiences too. It just comes... it's just not focused on a single platform.
Kara Swisher
And then this spreads out to the dating apps as well.
Jonathan Haidt
Right.
Kara Swisher
I was going to ask about that because my son's taken all of them off his phone. He said, "They make me feel bad, Mom." I just... you know, he's a lovely kid.
Scott Galloway
All of social or all dating apps, Kara?
Kara Swisher
All of the apps. He doesn't want to... he wants to disappear from the internet. But dating apps was particularly disheartening to him in a lot of ways.
Jonathan Haidt
Yeah, 100 percent. It's really interesting. You said during the *60 Minutes* episode this week, you said it's not a good versus evil story. It's a question of changed ecosystems.
Kara Swisher
I think that's what I was thinking, that the way they do it makes you feel bad or lesser than. And I don't know where it is that you could feel good except... well, even in person, you can have some bad experiences. A bar is not the most heartening place to be.
Scott Galloway
Bite your tongue. It's wonderful.
Kara Swisher
I know. Well, yeah.
Scott Galloway
Go to bars. Age-gate social and go to bars. They aren't perfect for the ladies. Raise the age limit on Instagram. Lower the drinking age. There you go.
Kara Swisher
Oh, Scott. Go ahead. What did you mean by changed ecosystem?
Jonathan Haidt
I always take both a cultural psychology perspective and an evolutionary psychology perspective. And so we evolved to have certain kinds of skills and abilities. We evolved for courtship. Like other mammals that pair bond, we have courtship rituals. And you need to sort of slow things down and show mutual... you display your virtues and you display commitment and then you fall in love and then you have sex and the sex adds to the love. So that's the way, that's what we have in our heads. And it's a little different, obviously, in boys and girls, men and women, but it's somewhat complementary.
So that's what we evolved for. Now, when everything moves on to the dating apps, now everything changes. Now it's much more of a straight market value calculation. And you have these incredibly precise signals from others about what the market value of this person is. So it puts everyone into this terrible market in which, you know, in general, young women have an advantage. But women over 35 for the rest of their lives are the market losers. But then even with young people, a few men... women are so selective. I saw a study recently where they had men rate photos on an app of women and they gave a normal distribution.
Most were in the middle. Some women are beautiful, some not. When they asked the women to rate, the women gave nobody a 10 and they said almost everyone is unattractive and only a few are attractive. Well, guess what? Those few who check the boxes for the women, all the women want them. All the women swipe right on them and the other 90% of boys get nothing. And so this fuels the sense that they're useless. They have no purpose in life. And so this is horrible for the boys. It's horrible for the girls. It's horrible for courtship and dating. It's going to be horrible for marriage. I think we're going to see very little marriage and very little childbearing among Gen Z.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, my kids talk about that. It's really amazing because it feels like hopelessness in some way.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, yeah. I just remember a few years ago sitting in department meetings, and they would talk about how microaggressions would not be tolerated. And you were the first person that had the courage to say, "Well, what the fuck do you mean by that?" And you wrote what is the most read article in the history of *The Atlantic*. And I constantly parrot you that, you know, we started all barking up the same tree in about the middle of the last decade. And as a result, America has become stupid. Can you give us the cliff notes on that article?
Jonathan Haidt
Sure. So that was the coddling of the American mind. It began as an Atlantic article in 2015, and it was one of the top five most read at that time. What I've come to see after that, it was describing a change in culture that happened first on campus. We couldn't understand it. Now, in retrospect, we understand. The college students were sort of the first into this new bizarre world. They were the first into Tumblr in particular, which nurtured a lot of these ideas about microaggressions and safe spaces.
So around 2013, 2014, they begin to bring those ideas into college and people think it's just college. They'll have to grow up. They can't be doing this stuff when they go work at Goldman Sachs or Google. Well, guess what? Gen Z began to graduate from college in 2018. And now when I talk to people in business, they say the same thing. It's very difficult to work with their Gen Z. Look, some of them are great. This is not about everyone. But people are noticing a big change between the millennials and Gen Z. Gen Z is much more fragile, much higher rates of anxiety, depression. And when you say fragile, it's because they'll take almost anything as an offense, and an offense is actually danger or harm.
So we have this huge misunderstanding between generations. COVID made it so much worse because what Gen Z most needed—Scott, you've pointed this out a lot—how young people today haven't really worked in an office. They haven't gotten socialized into work culture. So they take the college culture and the coddling culture that we gave them. They bring it into the workplace. So yeah, we're in trouble.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, one of the things that's interesting about that—I will push back a tiny bit on both of you—is that if you grew up someone who was gay or something like that, it wasn't microaggressions, it was aggression, aggression. And I think some of it is a reaction to that. Like, I'm not going to take this shit anymore. I think that was a little bit of it. After Elon did that thing on Paul Pelosi, I was furious. It brought me right back to then. And I don't think I overreacted. I was like, no, you will not be doing this anymore. Let me finish. Don't interrupt me.
I love microaggressions because this whole show is microaggressions from Scott and I. One of the things I always press with employees is—at one point, my producer for On with Kara Swisher, but previous to that, she was with me at the New York Times for Sway—we're always arguing. And it seems like we're mad at each other, but we're not. One of the Gen Z people was like, "Oh, this is very upsetting." I'm like, "It's called editorial tension. We like each other. What are you talking about?" And it was really hard. "Well, this upsets me." I was like, "What? Huh?" It was really interesting. So sometimes people have had it—I think, just so sick of like, "I can't tolerate another homophobic comment. I just can't. I won't. I'm not being nice about it anymore." And so that's where I think the break comes. Go ahead, Scott, interrupt me.
Scott Galloway
No, I want to return to Jonathan because we're hijacking his time. But you're talking about a place—everything you're upset about, and your anger is justified. But when you're talking about a university campus, you're talking about a place where people are so angry at the injustices that you outline, they go on the hunt for what I call fake racists and fake bigots. They feel so angry at what's happened in other parts of the world. We're talking about the most diverse and inclusive places on the planet. They should be. And it's wonderful. But at the same time, we've decided, okay, let's go after each other and let's create a divisive environment on campus.
I'm going to pause there. How do we fix it, John? Why don't you talk about how you fix that? Because I think you do have to understand why people get like that. But how do you fix that?
Jonathan Haidt
First, very briefly, I was born in 1963. Whether you look at civil rights, gay rights, whatever. I was born just after Martin Luther King gave his "I Have a Dream" speech. In the 100 years before that—because it was 100 years since the Emancipation Proclamation took effect—not much progress was made. And in the 50 years after that, the most extraordinary progress was made. Decade by decade on every front. When I turned 50 in 2013, gay marriage had just been legalized in many states and it was about to be made the law of the land. Whether you want to look at gay rights, women's rights, animal rights, human rights, environment—that 50 years was the most extraordinary period of progress.
So in 2014, progressives should have been saying, "Yay, America. We won. Whatever we're doing, let's keep doing it." But instead, everyone got online on platforms that make you argue and fill you with anger and hate and offense. I think the progressive left, which should have taken credit, instead went on the war path, the way Scott said, against microaggressions, which is very analogous to an autoimmune disorder. There's nothing left to attack. Let's attack each other.
Now, how do we fix it? First, I don't think there's any fixing this until we change social media dramatically. When the public square of the world's most important democracy takes place entirely in the Roman Colosseum with the stands filled with people who are cheering for blood, there is no democracy. There is no agreement. There is no compromise. I think we're headed for disaster unless we can radically change things.
Kara Swisher
I would like a fix, John, before you go.
Jonathan Haidt
Okay. First thing is that one thing we do need government for is to raise the age to 16. This is a commons dilemma and companies can't do it themselves or they'll lose all their market share to TikTok. So the government has to raise the age for internet adulthood to 16 and enforce it. There are all kinds of ways to do that. That's the first.
The second is we've got to create spaces of trust. There are all kinds of ways to do that with authentication. Elon Musk has actually floated a few possibly good ideas. He probably won't deliver on them, but he is at least thinking about it. I just had drinks last night with Scott's new buddy, Noam Bardin, who's come up with an alternative to Twitter which is designed from the ground up to be a platform for creators and readers, not for advertisers focused on engagement. So I think we do need some government regulation to create a level playing field on which better platforms could compete. Beyond that, I'm hopeful that we'll get platforms that will take everyone away from Twitter and Instagram and put them in healthier environments.
Kara Swisher
So you like some of Elon's ideas, but how do you think he's performed thus far? It sounds like he's doing the same Roman emperor. I feel like I'm in the gladiator.
Jonathan Haidt
Oh, yeah. I mean, I was just watching a little bit of Idiocracy and the president there is kind of crazy. Everyone should watch Idiocracy. Elon's obviously very smart, but he's behaving a bit like that. I'm just saying, he long ago said, "Authenticate all humans." Yes, we need to do a lot more authentication. And then he recently tweeted something like, "You should be able to choose your experience. And if you don't want to be surrounded by assholes who are anonymous and incentivized to be jerks, you should be able to—" So he has some good ideas. I am hopeful that he could do something.
Scott Galloway
They're old ideas, and most of them are Scott's, but go ahead.
Jonathan Haidt
They are. So I think if there's either some market pressure or some friends take him aside and do an intervention on him, I think he is capable of producing a much better Twitter. I don't know that he will.
Scott Galloway
Jonathan, we have kids that are the same age. I have two boys. You have a boy and a girl. What have you gotten right and what have you gotten wrong around parenting, looking back on it?
Jonathan Haidt
What my wife and I got right is keeping a lid on the total amount of screen time, trying to push them out to do things with friends, encouraging them to go out in New York City at the age of nine or ten, which was way before others, but way after we went out when we were kids when it was much more dangerous. So we listened to Lenore Skenazy, who wrote Free-Range Kids. I think we really got that right.
What did we get wrong? I wish we had found a summer camp for them long ago that they could go to every year and be there without devices, out in nature with other kids. That is so important and we didn't do it. Every year in Maine. Kids love it. Really important. That's a really great thing.
Scott Galloway
Also, you're very nice to them. I'm sure both of you are. Anyway, you're good dads.
Kara Swisher
Jonathan, thank you so much. People should really pay attention to what Jonathan's doing. It's reasonable. We have to really start thinking about how we talk to each other in a lot of ways. You were on 60 Minutes last Sunday. What's the website?
Jonathan Haidt
If you go to jonathanhaidt.com slash social media, all of my work is there.
Kara Swisher
Okay, and of course, read The Coddling of the American Mind. Wonderful books.
Jonathan Haidt
Well, thank you, Kara. Thank you, Scott. Please continue with your microaggressions.
Scott Galloway
Thanks for your good work, Jonathan.
Kara Swisher
I love your title. Scott doesn't have a fancy title at NYU like you do, but okay.
Scott Galloway
Well, he's not an ethical leader. What can I say?
Kara Swisher
There you go.
Jonathan Haidt
Exactly. Thanks, Jonathan.
Guest Jonathan Haidt exits
Kara Swisher
Gosh, I like that guy. I think he's so smart. All right, Scott, one more quick break. We'll be back for predictions.
Ad break
Okay, Scott, let's hear a prediction.
Scott Galloway
We're going to find out in the next 12 months that the fraud that has taken place behind the scenes with a lack of visibility and a lack of regulation around crypto is going to be second only to—I think it's going to be greater. It'll be greater in terms of criminal prosecutions. The thing about the subprime crisis is it took down the economy but no one went to jail. No one went to jail. This will be different. I think people will go to jail, but it won't take down the economy.
I think we're going to find out so much went down here, Kara. So many big VCs, so many people. There was so much over-levering of assets without disclosure, run on the bank. It just feels to me that everything I read about this, the more you peel the onion back, the more incentives were around putting massive risk where you would take the upside and the downside was borne by your depositors on these exchanges. I think you're going to see the majority of these exchanges, including Coinbase, also including Binance. I think you're going to see them go away or be severely impaired. This trustless system with middlemen that offer higher fees but no trust and no backing—it's the perfect storm of expensive but bad on every level.
Kara Swisher
I like that—criminal but not affect the economy. I think you're right. I think you're 100% right. One more prediction.
Scott Galloway
I predict great things for Ami Kozak. He's a comedian, and this week he posted a video to Instagram called "How Scott Galloway Orders at Starbucks." Let's play it.
Kara Swisher
Oh, God. Here we go.
Video plays
Ami Kozak [in video]: Hello. Welcome to Starbucks. What can I get you?
Scott Galloway [in video]
Well, I can tell you this. The amount of young men that come into a Starbucks between the ages of 18 and 30 haven't had sex within the last year. They're trying to order all sorts of things, and they're presented with a barrage of choices between espressos, cappuccinos, lattes, double espressos, soy lattes. And that choice and that paradox is causing immense anxiety and a lack of understanding and gratitude and perspective.
The kind of coffee I'd like to order is something I'd like to order in person. I don't do it over a remote phone. I don't do it using an app. I do it coming in in person to establish human connection. And I talk to a stranger like yourself to order that coffee, and I'm going to do that right now. And I think that's a prime example of how young men, particularly between the ages of 18 and 30, can establish better connections, better results, and a better future going forward because we are in a crisis right now.
Barista [in video]: So a latte?
Video ends
Kara Swisher
That made my day. My life. Welcome to my life. That made my day.
Scott Galloway
So he used an app that made him bald. He's actually a handsome kid.
Kara Swisher
Oh, wow.
Scott Galloway
He's actually got this amazing mane of hair. It's Ami. It's on Instagram at Ami Kozak underscore official.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, made my day. That was wonderful. Thank you for bringing that up.
Scott Galloway
We love you. We love you. We loved it. It was great. I predict great things for you.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, we want to hear from you. Send us your questions about business, tech, or whatever's on your mind. Go to nymag.com slash pivot to submit a question for the show, or call 855-51-PIVOT. Okay, Scott, that's the show. We'll be back on Friday for more. I'm sure a lot more things are happening. What do you got planned for the rest of the week, Kara?
And then it's Saul's first birthday.
Scott Galloway
Oh, that's nice.
Kara Swisher
Solly, jolly, Solly. So we're having a party for him. I'm very excited. All my kids are jolly these days. I just love them. They're so great.
Scott Galloway
There you go. All right, all right. Happy birthday, Saul.
Kara Swisher
And I'm excited for the present that Scott's going to send—an expensive, over-the-top present.
Scott Galloway
No, he's not.
Kara Swisher
He's been very generous to us when we go to New York, et cetera. And we appreciate it. Anyway, happy birthday, Saul. Scott, read us out.
Scott Galloway
Today's show is produced by Lara Neyman, Evan Ankle, and Taylor Griffin. Ernie Andrew Dot engineered this episode. Thanks also to Drew Burrows and Emil Silverio. Make sure you subscribe to the show wherever you listen to podcasts. Thanks for listening to Pivot from New York Magazine and Vox Media. We'll be back later this week for another breakdown of all things tech and business.
Kara Swisher
This was a peaceful transfer of power. America's wonderful democracy. I think this was a nice day. Congratulations to America.
Scott Galloway
Well, we'll see. We haven't wiped the barnacle.
Kara Swisher
This is Lauren Boebert off of Colorado, but it's looking good.
Scott Galloway
Wipe the barnacle. You're good.
Kara Swisher
She's a barnacle. You're good.
Scott Galloway
Thank you.
Kara Swisher
Barnacle.
Scott Galloway
No problem. Barnacle.