Podcast Episode Summary
The podcast episode, hosted by Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway, covers various topics including the upcoming presidential debate, the impact of social media on mental health, and the potential consequences of AI on the energy sector.
Main Topic:
The main topic of the episode is the upcoming presidential debate between Joe Biden and Donald Trump, as well as the broader implications of the election on the country.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Wins and Fails:
[Advertisement - Adobe Express] Narrator: As marketing channels have multiplied, the demand for content has skyrocketed. But everyone can make content that's on brand and stands out with Adobe Express. You don't have to be a designer to generate images, rewrite text, and create effects. That's the beauty of generative AI that's commercially safe. Teams all across your business will be psyched to collaborate and create amazing presentations, videos, social posts, flyers, and more. Meet Adobe Express, the quick and easy app to create on-brand content. Learn more at adobe.com slash express slash business.
[Advertisement - Rinse] Narrator: Rinse takes your laundry and hand delivers it to your door. Expertly cleaned and folded. So you could take the time once spent folding and sorting and waiting to finally pursue a whole new version of you. Like Tea Time You. Mmm. Or this Tea Time You. Or even this Tea Time You. Said you hear about Dave. Or even Tea Time, Tea Time, Tea Time You. Mmm. So update on Dave. It's up to you. We'll take the laundry. Rinse. It's time to be great.
[Podcast Intro] Kara Swisher: Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And I'm Scott Galloway.
Kara Swisher
Just so you know, I left my makeup in France, so this is what you're getting today, the raw face Kara Swisher. I know it's hard to take because I have so done up most of the time.
Scott Galloway
I've told you this before. I personally think women are much more beautiful or much younger. I think makeup ages women. Some of it. And I think you look, I don't like it when you put on makeup when you go on TV. I think you look best. You have nice skin and nice features, and I think you want that to come through.
Kara Swisher
Thank you. Although I have to say, the CNN ladies who do Chris Wallace makes it look rather natural. They're really good, but I agree with you. I don't like too much makeup myself. Anyway, a lot to get to today, but how are you doing? You're back in London, is that correct?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, back in London where it's a sweltering 70 degrees. It's actually really pretty here.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it's really lovely. It almost hit 100 here in D.C. Crazy heat.
Scott Galloway
Really? Oh, that's awful.
Kara Swisher
Crazy heat. It's not that bad, but it's still like, it's calmed down today a little bit. But it's a wet heat. It's a wet heat. Wet, sopping, terrible heat.
Scott Galloway
Let me say this heat wave across the United States is really debilitating across everywhere.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it's really, I'm sure. Remember when Europe got it last year or the Europe before? Whatever. These heat numbers are just like I was talking to someone in Arizona and it like nuts. The numbers are crazy. I don know how humanity survives these kind of temperatures. And then the load on the energy system especially with AI making all sorts of generative images of us. Anyway, did you have a good time in France?
Scott Galloway
Oh, I loved it. I had a fantastic time. I really enjoyed it. I enjoyed seeing you. I enjoyed, I went to see the Chainsmokers, who it ends up are DJs, not actual fans. All my pals were there with you. They said they ran into you at both concerts, the Arcade Fire, I guess.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, but the Chainsmokers are really lovely guys, and they have really hot girlfriends, and so what's not to like? And then I met the Kelsey or the Casey brothers.
Scott Galloway
Oh, you did? You met Travis Kelsey. Cool.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, yeah.
Scott Galloway
Oh, no, I think I met his brother.
Kara Swisher
Brother. They're both huge guys with beards. I can't tell the difference. There's a lot of beard. But they're really nice guys. That is what it seems like. And I hung out with the CEO of Yahoo, whoever it was. Jim is amazing. Lancell, yeah. Nice guy. You know, I did a podcast with him because they're doing so well under him. And then he got a beachfront. He did a beachfront. He did. And I think it was smart. He was showing some leg.
Scott Galloway
He was showing some leg. Did you know he and I are friends? Fraternity brothers. We're both Alpha Rose, Beta Tau, UCLA.
Kara Swisher
Wow.
Scott Galloway
So we slip each other the secret handshake. Hello, brother. Hello.
Kara Swisher
Can you believe that? We have a secret handshake. Oh, I can believe it. Alex is like, he goes, we did some things I can't tell you.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I can't tell you. It's very, very secret.
Kara Swisher
But oh my God. Like, he does that all the time. But I respect it. I think he's Alpha, I'm not going to get it wrong, Alpha Delta Tau. I think that's what he is. Alpha Delta.
Scott Galloway
What? That's not right. I don't know. Beta he's going to kill me now because he listens to the podcast. Beta theta pi?
Kara Swisher
No, alpha delta psi.
Scott Galloway
Alpha delta psi. Anyway.
Kara Swisher
I don't think that's right.
Scott Galloway
Well, anyway, Alex, I apologize once again for being a bad parent. But more importantly, it's the ultimate in caste system and stereotyping and that is everyone gravitates towards they find their tribe. Like Sigma Chi UCLA were the God squatters who were also good looking guys. You know, Phi Caps were these small town alcoholics that were fun to party with. Sammies were the hardcore jews. ZBT we were sort of the like more social, I don't know, more ready for prime time, some athletes, jews, and occasionally we'd bring in a non-white just to show how progressive we were. The Betas were total fucking animals that always threw most ridiculous like one of the top offensive parties.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, essentially.
Scott Galloway
The Theta guys were like the new wave guys that like all had David Bowie haircuts.
Kara Swisher
Okay, wow, good to know. Wait a minute, this was literally the best part of your life, wasn't it?
Scott Galloway
Oh, 100%. I mean seriously.
Kara Swisher
The way you all talk about this. I was the, hold on, I was the Delta Gamma anchorman. An entire sorority chose me as their guy in 1986.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, Scott.
Kara Swisher
Because I was funny. Because I was funny. Memories. Oh, my God. Take me back. Like the shadow of my mind. Take me back. The way we were, Scott. I actually am doing a lot better today than I was then. Anyway, we've got a lot to get to today. I'm very glad for this moment of fraternity between us. So good. Apple and Meta considering an AI partnership. Apple's going around, as you said, as we said the thing. And Biden and Trump are getting ready to go head-to-head in this week's debate. I don't know if you've heard about it. Plus, our friend of Pivot, the newest member of the Vox Media family, Brene Brown, is coming on. She hosts the podcast Unlocking Us and Dare to Lead. And we're going to talk to her about social media, election anxiety, and more, and about vulnerability, Scott, which you are very vulnerable. I am less so.
Scott Galloway
So speaking of people who are vulnerable in a way that is really unattractive.
Kara Swisher
So Melinda French Gates gave her first presidential endorsement to President Biden. And it was great. She had a really nice announcement. Why she did it was a lot around women's rights. Musk replied to a tweet about her likely donations to Biden saying, quote, might be the downfall of Western civilization.
Scott Galloway
Oh, Elon, you endless drama queen.
Kara Swisher
He also made similar comments about Mackenzie Scott's charitable givings. He doesn't like, I don't know why he cares if he gives money and everything else in time that he cares to comment on other people's opinions.
Scott Galloway
I think it comes down to incentives. I've been thinking a lot about incentives. And the incentives, really the problem with social media and probably the epicenter of what has really fucked up our society over the last 10 years is the incentives are, you know, for teen girls to sexualize themselves. And it's for powerful people with a huge following to say controversial, incendiary, coarse things because you're seen as a leader. And unfortunately, you're seen as someone who is puncturing and tells it like it is when you say really coarse, just inappropriate things. The incentives are, I'm sure he got tens of millions of likes for that. And people are like oh he a leader. You can keep that guy down. Rather than saying why. You know she trying to do good things. She wants to give money if she wants to. Like Mr Free Speech it ridiculous.
Kara Swisher
It's interesting, though, there's sort of a lineup happening. Like you have Melinda Gates. I've heard that Cheryl on the sly has been giving money to Biden, a big check. Cheryl Sandberg.
Scott Galloway
Cheryl Sandberg.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, and obviously Reid Hoffman's been giving. This is on the Democratic side. He did a very thoughtful editorial on Biden.
Scott Galloway
He did. That was great.
Kara Swisher
Bloomberg did one. I'm sure Cuban's been sort of a surrogate for Biden quite heavily on Twitter. You know who's been the most effective? Robert De Niro.
Scott Galloway
Robert De Niro's been really good, yeah.
Kara Swisher
But these are the tech guys. It's interesting because there's a real lineup happening here of teams. And then there's the sort of right-wingers, all in people just did a Trump, licking him up and down in their whatever, wouldn't call it an interview. It was more widely a suck-up thing. It's gotten a lot of commentary on that, nonetheless. And then, you know, obviously, Musk is lined up for Biden. I mean, excuse me, is for Trump. So it's interesting. And of course, they're all meeting with people like Javier Malai of Argentina. They just did a picture. Marc Andreessen was there. A whole bunch of tech pros were with him. And of course, they call them, you know, one of our great intellectual philosopher kings. And they're not really reading the parts about abortion being murder and saying women need to go back in their place. They don't seem to.
Scott Galloway
They seem to. He's like a he's like a libertarian, like wet dream, libertarian tech pro wet dream.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. But just to go back to the supporting a candidate, I also don't think it's don't think it's fair. I saw Dennis Quaid was saying he's probably going to vote for Trump and the comments were just so aggressive. I'm like, OK, if you can, if you believe people should be allowed to support Biden and, you know, disagree, but don't go after them, people should be able to support Trump and you should be able to disagree and not.
Scott Galloway
They should. I just think their interview was a suck up. But go ahead.
Kara Swisher
Go ahead. Sorry.
Scott Galloway
Well, yeah, I didn't listen to the interview, but I'm curious. So you listened to it. You didn't think it was a very good interview?
Kara Swisher
Oh, no, they didn't follow up on anything. They forgot to ask him about the felony. They, you know, yeah, I mean, it just was just like, and your big brain. It just was, it wasn't an interview. They're not journalists. They're a bunch of investors cosplaying it being whatever, thought leaders. I don't care.
Scott Galloway
We're going to try to get Biden just, everybody knows for this interview.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I wasn't, I didn't want to say that.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, we can say that.
Kara Swisher
I didn't want to spoil it. We're going to try to get him. We're going to get him. We're going to try to get him.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, it's not we. That's you. If we get him, it's because of you.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. You got to be ready to go. You need to ask good, tough questions. That's what we'll do because we'll ask good, tough to get him. We're going to get him. We're going to try to get him.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, it's not we. That's you. If we get him, it's because of you.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. You've got to be ready to go. You're going to ask good, tough questions. That's what we'll do because we'll ask good, tough questions of him. We'd do the same with Trump, by the way. Maybe we should ask Trump. Should we ask Trump?
Scott Galloway
I don't see why we wouldn't. I think we should.
Kara Swisher
He won't do it because he likes to get licked up and down all day. If we're going to ask Biden, we should ask Trump.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, absolutely. I will do that. I'll put in a thing that will be thrown into the circular file. His kids, Don Jr. retweeted my Morning Joe segment and said, this is the America we're trying to create. I'm like, wow.
Kara Swisher
You're a well-known trooper. Don Jr.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, you're a well-known trooper. Don Jr.
Kara Swisher
You're with those guys. Junior.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. That's how I think of Scott Maga. I think you're open-minded is what you're, but not particularly.
Kara Swisher
Well, no, but I think he did that because I think that's clearly evidence his cocaine dealer was back from Tulum. You probably share one. Anyway.
Scott Galloway
I don't do cocaine. I'm very open about my drug use. I've never done blow.
Kara Swisher
I know. I know you haven't. I forget the drugs you've done. I forgot. I'm sorry. I'm going to keep my list.
Scott Galloway
I think I would have lost my virginity at 17. Lena, my prom date, wanted to do blow, and I didn't bring any. I think that was my shot. I think that was my shot.
Kara Swisher
I think you've done just fine. All right. We've got to move on. Just so you know, just for everyone, congratulations. Musk had another child, by the way, with Neuralink director Siobhan Zillis. She had twins with Musk, and then she had another child earlier this year. Congratulations.
Scott Galloway
Not living with your children. And that's a real sign of masculinity. You're definitely being a protector there.
Kara Swisher
Well, when you have 12, it's a little hard. You have to have a big house. He is rich, though. Anyway, congratulations on your child. Big thing we've been talking about, you and I texted about, I think AI's power grid needs our exceeding capacity. Goldman Sachs analysis found that data centers will account for 8% of total electricity use in the US. That's, I mean, crypto and Bitcoin mining was, yeah, tech giants are confident they can solve the problem, though. Microsoft saying it will harness atomic fusion power by 2028. Both Bill Gates and Sam Altman are investing in nuclear energy. Meanwhile, coal plants near data center operations that were supposed to be shut down have been extended to fuel demand. Well, great. Good. More global warming. Microsoft, Meta, Google, and Amazon have all said they plan to erase their emissions as soon as 2030. They've talked about that. You know, the amount of power, you know, you need two things. You need, obviously, the chips and you need the data, but power is the one people don't pay attention to as much.
Scott Galloway
Yeah they say it 10 to 17 times the power for a query on AI versus a query on search. And even the water to cool these data centers they say that you going to need essentially the amount of water the daily water supply for 17 million households just to cool the data centers.
Kara Swisher
That's one of the ways they do it, yeah.
Scott Galloway
Well, and the thing I like about this is that people are re-embracing nuclear power and trying to be very creative. These guys are very smart. They're very forward and future looking, and they're not afraid to make big CapEx investments. But I think someone told me that crypto has now added the incremental power demand of Argentina. And it's not unthinkable to think in 10 years if AI keeps growing, it'll be the incremental power demand of Latin America. So it's really interesting. Power is energy. No matter how much energy we produce, it's like bandwidth. We can find uses for it much faster than we can find energy sources.
Kara Swisher
100%. They've tried innovative ways. My ex-wife worked on, I can say this now because she left a long time ago, but they were thinking of doing, she went to Hawaii. And I was like, why are you going there? She said, I can't say. And at the time, they were going to do a wind farm on Hawaii for power. And they were going to try to power Honolulu. Google was doing this. And obviously, Google's been really out forward this stuff like thermal energy, all kinds of ways to these data centers are just such a pull. And, you know, I always hear of some plot, either there's thermal or nuclear or wind to, you know, at one point, remember they had that sail they were going to put up in the atmosphere that was going to turn a turbine and then was going to create power?
Remember the big sale? That was another thing. Google has been at the forefront, but they do have to solve this. They should be the one focusing on alternative energy sources. I hope they do more wind farms so it drives Donald Trump crazy because it kills birds, apparently. But anyway, it's a really interesting thing we should keep in mind. We focused a lot about it around Bitcoin mining, but AI really is a pull on the energy sector. It's an area we probably should look at and get a little experts in here. Anyway, let's get to our first big story. Apple just became the first company to be charged under the EU's new competition law, the Digital Markets Act.
EU regulators say the app store stifles competition for developers and limits options for consumers. Apple has defended its practices, saying the restrictions fees are fair trade for providing a large platform. Same arguments they made here. Obviously they been sucked up into litigation here in this country. Do you think Apple in trouble here?
Scott Galloway
They definitely these are new European rules. It said it not going to release Apple intelligence in the EU in 2024 due to regulatory uncertainties. Meta's paused its AI launch in Europe after regulators raised privacy concerns. So what do you think about that?
Kara Swisher
I think that's the problem. There's sort of a collective action problem. And that is, for example, if you don't get every kid under the age of 16 off the social media, the kids that you do take off of social media actually end up becoming more depressed because they feel isolated. And there's a bit of a collective action problem around regulation. And that is, does Europe end up with sort of a hamstrung version of these products? And then the companies kind of bind together and start slow-balling rollouts and not hiring. It's sort of the race to the bottom. And to Secretary Yellen and Biden's credit, they did an AMT, basically an alternative minimum tax on corporations, of 15% across EU and kind of G20 countries.
Because if they didn't do that, everybody just keeps doing their double-dutch sandwich and issuing their IP to the lowest tax state. And so I think that the EU is feeling a little bit, I don't know what the term is, punished. I think they're collectively, the big tech firms, when I saw this, they started winking at each other and saying, we're bigger than Europe and we'll just start slow rolling stuff and have two sets of products. Now, whether that creates an opening for competitive products, we'll see. I think Mistral, the AI company in France, is actually going to succeed.
You've talked about this company.
Scott Galloway
But I'm blathering on here. What are your thoughts on it?
Kara Swisher
I haven't really thought it through. You know, it's more, it's this idea that we do have to have laws in this country, right? This is still that Europe is sort of leading the way. You know, I talked about it to a number of people there in Cannes. You know, Europe shouldn't be leading the way on these things. And obviously there's lawsuits here in this country having to do with Apple. And at some point, this App Store issue will come to a head in this country. It'll take 109 years and it has in court with a bunch of different cases. But I think the question is, at some point, they can't keep making the idea that they're providing safety on a large platform and it fair trade and everything else because they really do have a stranglehold on the market.
And so there must be some I always thought Apple would negotiate an end to this right rather than do anything. But I suspect that they just not going to release it in Europe just because they won't, you know, they just won't. And I don't know whether our government has the heft to really keep pushing through all these lawsuits, whether it's Meta or Apple or, any of these companies. But eventually, there'll be discovery. It takes so long to stop the juggernaut from happening. And speaking of which, Apple and Meta, longtime adversaries, might be teaming up in a new partnership. Remember, there's a lot of testiness between Mark Zuckerberg and Tim Cook a couple of years ago about advertising.
But the two companies reported talking about integrating Meta's generative AI model into Apple intelligence. According to the Wall Street Journal, AI startups Anthropic and Perplexity are also in talks with Apple, propensity is in a lot of hot water for scraping, like Forbes' articles, and we talked about that previously. You know, as we talked about, these companies, Apple will be the, was it the gatekeeper is the right word? Or what would you, how would you characterize it? And, you know, does it bring more antitrust scrutiny by doing all these? They haven't done one with, probably Google, they'll probably do a deal with its Gemini model.
I think Metas is an open source model, they're going to be like the everything store, I guess, for these things.
Scott Galloway
I see it as passing out free crack to kind of the rich kids. And that is they're saying, OK, if you want, we are the gatekeeper and we have custody of the billion wealthiest and most influential customers in the world, and that's iOS users. It's so disproportionately influential, iOS versus Android. And I think what they're doing, as I said, we're going to work with multiple players and we'll give them a little taste of crack on what it's like, and they'll try out their LLMs with the most sophisticated, most influential, biggest spending group, right? And then I think where this is headed is all to the same place it was headed with search. And then they're going to say, all right, we're going to flip the model and say, who wants sole access?
Kara Swisher
Or maybe they'll go, you know. Put them all there and hide them.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, or do like, you know, these sponsorships thing, you know, The Olympic Games is brought to you by our diamond sponsor, Exxon, and our platinum sponsor, you know, but I think Apple, someone, I don't know who it is, but someone who's in charge of strategy at Apple comes to Tim Cook with really thoughtful scenario planning. And I think what they're doing here is saying, OK, give everyone a taste of what it's like to hang with the cool kids. And we're basically the endgame here. And what works best for us, right? What works best for Apple?
Kara Swisher
100%. Yeah, because they have to have a safer environment, for sure. But I think where this is all headed is in 12 or 24 months, they're going to have a Google-like licensing agreement where they're going to just create billions, if not tens of billions, of high-margin licensing revenues to these LLMs that are all looking to stand out. Because if you're, say you're anthropic, right, and you're kind of losing it, you're falling behind to chat GPT. I mean, how much would it be worth to you if your company goes public at, say, a $150 billion market cap? Would you be willing to take a 5% dilution that would be $7.5 billion and give it to Apple for two years exclusive access to the billion most influential consumers in the world? I think that's how they're positioning themselves.
Scott Galloway
By making them the default position.
Kara Swisher
I'm just looking at my search engine.
Scott Galloway
100%.
Kara Swisher
For some reason, my search engine changed to DuckDuckGo. I must have done it.
Scott Galloway
You did that.
Kara Swisher
I must have.
Scott Galloway
You did that.
Kara Swisher
I don't recall doing it. But it usually is Google. Google was the default one. On there right now, I'm just looking at it as Yahoo, Bing, and Ecosia, which I don't even know what that is. But it's sitting there. I'm going to go try it, I guess. So, you know, Apple's not paying. The first deal, which was widely touted, Apple with OpenAI. Apple's not paying OpenAI, obviously, to feature ChatGPT. It's like a big marketing event for OpenAI in Apple intelligence, nor is OpenAI paying Apple, but at some point, you know who's getting paid. They're not. Apple. Apple is. So I suspect that's going to be the same financial relationships.
Apple is the kingmaker here in a lot of ways. It's a smart, you know, it's interesting because all these media companies are negotiating with these people for using LLMs, and then they'll get a small amount of money. This is where the big money's going. This is where the big fucking money is going. I just interviewed Craig Peters from Getty today. We had a great discussion about this because he's suing some people, he's cooperating with some people, but it's really hard because, you know, he's a media company, so his shares are way off. You know, his customers are in a free fall, you know, all the media companies.
And so it hard. It hard to compete as a media company. So this is who going to make the money is the Apple. Apple going to get richer.
Scott Galloway
Well and I think analysts immediately went to the white meat here and they saw the same thing that we're seeing. And they said, OK, Apple's positioning themselves for another enormous licensing deal similar to Google and the stock's up 10 percent since they announced Apple intelligence. And I don't think it's.
Kara Swisher
Whoa. It really is.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, it's hit an all-time high. And I don't think it's on the back of, wow, this is a great product. I think they said, oh, we see what you're doing. You're not going to spend tens of billions of dollars trying to build your own LLM. You're just going to go to the highest bidder.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, so cost, savings costs, and then everything else.
Scott Galloway
And you're going to reap all this money. You're going to say, all right, you guys jump on your prize swords, and we're going to start a bidding war, and all of this is going to hit the bottom line. And their stock was up. And you'll think of Apple intelligence, not all these individual people.
Kara Swisher
Because I guess I do think of Google Maps when I get to another. Although I've heard that Apple Maps are gotten a lot better. So I may go see how that experience is.
Scott Galloway
They've added $300 million in market capitalization since the Apple intelligence. And it's not because people think Apple intelligence is so cool. I think it's because they sense they're about to become the new gatekeepers to the deepest pockets in the world.
Kara Swisher
All right, Scott, let's go on a quick break. When we get back, look ahead to this week's presidential debate, and we'll speak to a friend of Pivot, Brene Brown.
[Advertisement - The Guardian] Narrator: Wellness and soccer, to culture, the climate, and more. Read, watch, and listen to The Guardian for free at theguardian.com.
[Advertisement - LinkedIn] Narrator: Support for Pivot comes from LinkedIn. From talking about sports to discussing the latest movies, everyone is looking for a real connection to the people around them. But it's not just person to person, it's the same connection that's needed in business. And it can be the hardest part about B2B marketing, finding the right people, making the right connections. But instead of spending hours and hours scavenging social media feeds, you can just tap LinkedIn ads to reach the right professionals. According to LinkedIn, they have grown to a network of over 1 billion professionals, making it stand apart from other ad buys. You can target your buyers by job title industry company role seniority skills and company revenue giving you all the professionals you need to reach in one place. So you can stop wasting budget on the wrong audience and start targeting the right professionals only on LinkedIn ads. LinkedIn will even give you a hundred dollar credit on your next campaign so you can try it for yourself. Just go to linkedin.com slash pivot pod. That's linkedin.com slash pivot pod. Terms and conditions apply only on LinkedIn ads.
[Advertisement - Thumbtack] Narrator: Avoiding your unfinished home projects because you're not sure where to start? Thumbtack knows homes, so you don't have to. Don't know the difference between matte paint finish and satin? Or what that clunking sound from your dryer is? With Thumbtack, you don't have to be a home pro. You just have to hire one. You can hire top-rated pros, see price estimates, and read reviews all on the app. Download today.
[Podcast Continues] Kara Swisher: Scott, we're back. Joe Biden and former President Donald Trump are set to face off on Thursday for the earliest presidential debate in modern history by like a lot. The debate hosted by CNN, moderated by Jake Tapa, Jake Tapa and Dana Bash. We the first time Biden and Trump have gone head to head or been in the same room since our last debate in October of 2020. I don't think they like each other. A Marist poll from last week shows a dead heat between the candidates. And actually, Biden was up a little bit. He's been going up a little bit, including in a Fox News poll, which is making President Trump, former President Trump, lose his mind, which is not very far to go.
So let's talk about strategy, Scott. Now, here you are going into this debate. I talked about a little bit on the Chris Wall show this week. But what is the strategery? Just for some more background, RFK Jr. did not make the cut for the debate, falling short in ballot qualification and polling. He's making a lot of noise. The debate rules, just for people to know, and then I love your thoughts on this, no live audience, no props allowed on stage. Microphones will be muted when it's not a candidate's turn to speak. I believe they have two minutes. Biden won the coin toss and selected his podium position on the right side of the screen.
Trump then chose to have the last word in closing statements. So what do we think? Give me a what Biden should—this is the question from Chris Wallace. I thought it was a good one. Does this setup help? Which one? If you were the marketing guy here figuring out sort of the optics of it, which one do you think this set helps?
Scott Galloway
Oh, it's total Team Biden in terms of advantage. Trump is so quick and outrageous on his feet and so plays to the crowd and tickles people sensors and all that him constantly interrupting people. It just throws the other person off, you know, off kilter. So them shutting off the mic is totally advantageous to Biden.
Kara Swisher
Is it?
There would be some crazy... I think Democrats tend to be a little bit more civil than maybe MAGA people. He's not going to show up with a bunch of people who've accused... I mean, do you remember the bullshit he did?
Scott Galloway
Yes, remember? Bill Clinton.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. So he creates a sideshow and a carnival, which throws the other person off their feet. And the strategy here is really simple. OK, let's talk about the economy. I wouldn't... I wouldn't... I wouldn't go to... Let me get this: what is the one thing Biden should avoid and one thing he should lean into? And what is the one thing Trump should avoid and lean into?
Scott Galloway
If I were Biden, I would stay away from the Trump court cases. I think that people will go there on their own. And I don't think he... I think he wants to talk about the economy and bodily autonomy and how he is actually taking action against immigration. I would go very, very almost conservative and hard right on immigration and say, "Now, if the Republicans would only help me solve the crisis at the border." And I would talk about the economy. I would talk about numbers. I would be very kind of adult, almost like an economist. And I would end the debate with the following. [Awkward pause] My last question to our viewers tonight, after thanking CNN, is: do you have daughters? And I would just leave the air empty for a few seconds.
Kara Swisher
Very good. I like that. Many people think he should not... You know how Reagan did that fantastic rejoinder, right? "I'm not going to let my age take advantage." He's not witty like that. So he just should... he should have a joke in his pocket, though, about his age? If Trump goes, "I don't got some cognitive dingity dongs happening constantly now."
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I mean, he should have a couple. He should have prepackaged two or three. And when someone brings up age, you should come up with... you know, say, "Look, look, we're... you know, we're both probably consumers of catheters." I would make jokes that remind everybody that the guy across the stage from me is also really fucking old, folks. So yeah, you hate us both, whatever you wanna talk about. But him not having a hot mic... and if I were Trump, I would talk a lot about what's happened on universities when Democrats take over institutions and what's happened in democratically controlled cities. That's where I would focus if I were Trump. Crime and chaos. Sort of the Nixon-y kind of thing. Well, the arguments they should make, and this is what media they should roll every day, is this is what happens when democratically controlled leadership takes over an institution. Look, it's what's happened at our elite universities. This is what happens when Democrats get control of a city. Even if it has a ton of money, this is what happens. Go downtown San Francisco. Is this what you want the country to be?
Kara Swisher
I realize that's not fair. I realize you love San Francisco.
Scott Galloway
That is just from a perception standpoint.
Kara Swisher
Okay, yeah, go ahead. It's changed. But go ahead.
Scott Galloway
I agree with you. I live there. It might be wonderful. I'm just talking pure perception.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I got it. People who've never been there for some reason think it's a hellscape right now, unfairly or fairly. And also, to be fair, like Portland and Seattle are really... I have been to those cities recently. They've changed a lot.
Scott Galloway
They have.
Kara Swisher
They have. I agree with you. So one of the things that... what should Trump not do? Because some people think he will be calmer when he can't be jacked up. That's the thing. And so he'll be... if you recall the first debate with Biden, and this is a long time ago, he was, you know, cuckoo for Cocoa Puffs. Really, you know, "stand back and stand by," interruptive, crazy. And all Biden had to say is, "Come on, man." You know, he kept doing that, and Biden sort of won that debate. The second one, it looked like he was drugged and calmer. So some people think no live audience, no props, microphones muted will make him into reasonable Trump.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I don't know. I mean, I would never advise... It's like Michael Jackson used to show up with one glove and grab his crotch. I don't think any amount of prep would have told him to do it. And yet it was genius at the time. You're like, OK, it works for him. I don't know how to advise Trump because every piece of advice I would have would be try and act more sane because that's people's fear around you, and try not to be all over the place. Try and focus on... try and come across as... people... you want to look at points of distinction and then press on those points of distinction. The reason Biden will...
if Biden loses this election will be because of the following: the people see him as too feeble to be commander in chief. That is the only reason he will lose. And so you want to press on that. And so Trump wants to come across as distinctly more robust and young. And part of that is cognitive capability. So if I was preparing Trump, I would say you need to have command of the issues. You need to come across as somewhat sane. You need to come across as youthful and vigorous, laugh, poke fun at yourself, and have real command of the data. You need to draw sharp relief between you and the old man.
That's my advice.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, the problem is, like everywhere he goes, he's missing words now. He's doing a lot of stuff, and obviously his family history of dementia. But one of the things that I think is problematic, and I spoke to a lot of people in that CEO summit. Now, look, they're going to back Trump because it's good for them in tax cuts, let me just say. And someone who was there saying they thought he was crazy, they're still going to back him, right? He was losing words. He was going off on tangents. This was a crowd that was welcoming to him, the CEO group, the business roundtable, and was willing to overlook the insurrection kind of stuff for a tax cut.
And I talked to a number of people who were like, "Whoa, like, whoa," like that kind of thing. So I think that's where he... I don't know how much he has control over that or is willing to do that. I think one of the things he cannot do is talk about losing the election. That's whether he's stolen. He cannot look backwards, but he can't get off of that. "You stole the election. You stole the election." If he does that, it's a huge opportunity for Biden. Biden needs to be ready to go and go, "OK, 43 cases, zero credibility. You know, just X, Y, Z." What's the difference between... what's the difference between us and every other nation?
We have people who can see... you know, Biden has to be ready to really like drive a train through that. I think Trump can't help that. I think it animates everything he does. And then the other thing he's saying, the last thing I'd say is he's all saying that Biden's getting a shot in the ass, which means Trump is getting a shot in the ass, right? Like everything he says, I'm like, "Oh, that's what you're doing." I mean, Trump looks like he's taken every drug in town. Like, it feels like a Zempik. It looks like he's juicing. Biden needs to practice the age-old adage about being interviewed. Don't answer the question they ask.
Answer the question you want to ask. At some point, he needs to say the following: "Trump threatened to try to ban TikTok and carve it up. We have actually banned it or invested in it with a plan that will pass muster that makes sense." Biden constantly... you know, Trump talks about safety in the Middle East. "We sent two aircraft carriers over there and we have so far sequestered this from becoming a more regional conflict." He needs to say, "OK, Trump talks a big game, but we actually... you know, we have some overlap here. You agreed you thought TikTok was a national threat. I want to give you credibility for it.
We actually did something about it. You talk a big game about being an ally to Israel. We actually are the real ally here. One of us has deployed an aircraft carrier there."
Scott Galloway
Right. Yeah.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. I think that's true. I think one of the interesting things going into this, the money raising. Now, Trump is... they thought this would happen, but he's raised 141 million in May. Biden raised 85 million. He was way ahead, Biden. And $53 million came in from Trump 24 hours after the hush money verdict, of course. He's really done very well by being a felon. There's also... I think that'll ultimately even out and depends on where they spend it. I don't know what else to say. I don't think there's going to be a big deficit between them. Trump VP speculation, he's making a circus of it. He revealed this weekend he knows whose pick will be, although he hasn't told the person yet. Future VP candidate will most likely be at the debate, according to Trump. Current top contenders include Senators J.D. Vance, Marco Rubio, and Tim Scott, and North Dakota Governor Doug Burgum.
Scott Galloway
I think I've settled on Burgum at this point. You know, he's managing to carry the water for him and seems not as nuts as the others. I think he doesn't like Marco Rubio. I think he thinks J.D. Vance will take attention from him. Tim Scott looks like a toady, so much so. So I suspect it's Burgum.
Kara Swisher
South Dakota Governor Kristi Noem appears to be out of the running. She indicated on Meet the Press over the weekend.
Scott Galloway
It's because Trump has a dog.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. No, he doesn't have a dog. He doesn't. That makes sense. He doesn't have any pets. That makes sense. So just make a guess, and then I'll ask you the last question about the Supreme Court's decision.
Scott Galloway
I don't know. I think it's probably going to be Burgum. But just one last thing, if I were on the Trump team, I would hammer over and over. Just to be snarky, I would go 100%. I'd be like, "Well, President Harris." And he's like, "You better get used to that. This guy's going to be dead." If he really wants to go gangster, he'd say the following: "You're not voting for Joe Biden. You're voting for President Harris. Shrap your head around that because she's deeply unpopular."
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I think you're right. I hate to say it, but I think that would work really well. We'll see if he comes up with it. Meanwhile, we're still waiting for the Supreme Court's decision on the Trump immunity case. What in the world are they doing over there at the Supreme Court? The next batch of opinions will be released on Wednesday. They've got a lot to go and they've got a very short term to do it in. The day before the debates, we get a decision then. The immunity decision, I think they're probably like wrangling over it, right? I think Alito been hurt probably with the flag situation in terms of power. But I suspect they trying to come... I have this feeling that Amy Coney Barrett just not going along with the boys at this point on this kind of thing. But who knows? She seems to have formed relationships with the other women on the court, which is interesting. What do you think of this? Not on abortion, obviously, but what do you think? Has this affected?
Scott Galloway
I don't know. The thing you said that was sort of interesting is that what you just made an argument for was lifetime appointments. I think they should do what they do in Brazil. And the Supreme Court there has mandatory retirement age of 75.
Kara Swisher
Oh, my God. Think about it. You have to leave when you're 75. What generally happens is, or what you hope happens, is that people just become apolitical and show a fidelity to the Constitution or the beliefs or what have you. And they're not going to be intimidated by anyone. I haven't seen that. I've always thought Justice Barrett... I don't know. I think that's wishful thinking that she's siding with.
Scott Galloway
I know. I know.
Kara Swisher
No, but lately she has been... I don't know, it's just interesting. I think she's gotten hanging around other people, and she's so smart. Like, let's be honest. I mean, godly or not, she's as smart, sharp as a tack.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, she's a great little scholar.
Kara Swisher
I don't know. I just think she's probably with Judge Jackson, who's also... oh, Jesus, what a brain. I suspect that's the thing that appeals to her. Even religious gals who are brainy love the brainy part more than anything, ultimately. I don't know. That's my wishful thinking is that they're all hanging and squatting up or something. I don't know. We'll see. By the way, you said something that struck me. So try and clear your mind in this first answer. Biden-Harris, Trump-Burgum, or Tapper-Bash? Who would you rather be president and vice president? Seriously.
Scott Galloway
Dana-Bash. Are you kidding? I love Dana-Bash. I think Dana's fantastic. I think Jake is fantastic. I'm not exaggerating.
Kara Swisher
I know, younger. Who would you think would do a better job?
Scott Galloway
Younger, probably. If... and maybe I'm being sexist because I immediately thought of Jake Tapper as the president and Dana as the number two. But quite frankly, I think they're both super impressive, thoughtful people who know how to... Jake Tapper for president. If they were on the ticket... if they were on the ticket.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
They got my vote. I'd vote for Cuban. I told you I'd vote for Cuban. Those two should be on stage. I want cubes. Not asking the questions. I want cubes to run. That's what I want. Mark? Just because I wanna go.
Kara Swisher
They got my vote. They got my vote. I'd vote for Cuban. I told you I'd vote for Cuban. Those two should be on stage. I want cubes. Not asking the questions. I want cubes to run. That's what I want. Mark? Just because I want to go.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, because I just want to...
Kara Swisher
You and I will be staying together in Lincoln Bedroom. It'll be nice. We'll cuddle. He'll be in the race for 2028. I think so. When he starts bragging about paying his taxes, he's clearly positioning himself for a run, and I hope he runs. He's very articulate about all kinds of issues. Super smart. Super impressive guy.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, probably. There'll be a... in a decent man.
Kara Swisher
2028, unless Trump wins and ruins democracy, will be really interesting on both parties. It'll be really... it'll change year and maybe we'll all be a little better. Who knows? All right, let's bring in our friend of Pivot. Brené Brown is the host of two Vox Media podcasts, Unlocking Us and Dare to Lead. Brené, welcome to Pivot and the Vox Media podcast family.
Brené Brown
I'm so glad to be with y'all. I've been listening and y'all have recently been in the south of France. I wish I'd been there with you.
Kara Swisher
Well, next year.
Scott Galloway
Next year, we'll all go together and we'll get on Scott's Zodiac and ride around and everything.
Brené Brown
Oh, my God. I'm so in.
Kara Swisher
You know, Scott had said he was going to take me on it and also attack Meta Beach. And he ended up sort of just wandering up to the Pinterest beach there. So it was a less than...
Scott Galloway
It was an accident.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, so let's start. So you took a break from podcasting for over a year and recently returned. So you said you returned in part because you missed the conversation. So talk about that because many people don't walk away from talking.
Brené Brown
Okay. Wow. We're just going right there. Um, yeah. I, you know, my mom died on Christmas morning.
Kara Swisher
Oh, no.
Brené Brown
Six or seven months ago after a very shitty battle with dementia. And during that period of time, I noticed how susceptible and vulnerable I was to the influencer industrial complex online. Like, you know, you can't... when you have a parent with dementia, it's very... and you're, you know, you're my age, you're... you forget a song lyric, and you're like, "Fuck it, here I go." And so I would be scrolling on Instagram. And of course it knows exactly what I'm thinking about and what I'm doing. And it would say, you know, "Do you have a family member with dementia? Are you worried about it for yourself?
One tablespoon of castor oil prevents dementia, you know?" And I just realized, even as a social scientist, how vulnerable I was to that. And then inevitably I'd be scrolling and I'd see myself and it would be at this nuanced conversation that was clipped down in a way that made me seem so certain and so sure about something that I almost couldn't stand seeing myself as a part of that. Because, I mean, I think there is something on social media around advice giving that is so predatory. And I just, I needed a break. I just needed to step away from it. And I needed to step away from talking. And it's interesting because I get asked to do podcasts all the time, but now we don't do them if they include video, if we don't have clip approval.
Kara Swisher
Oh, smart. That's interesting. Well, this is like perfect. Scott, I got to bring you in right now. This is sort of Scott's area of discussion where he talks about this all the time, the vulnerability of this experience online. Scott?
Scott Galloway
Well, I was actually going to go... I'll get to that, but I always describe the two most seminal events in my life were birth and death, the birth of my sons and the death of my mother. I'm just curious, having lost your mother recently, and it sounds like that was not a... I don't want to call it a bad death, but an extended hard death for the people around her. How have you changed your approach to life? Are you more... what has changed in terms of the way you see the world on a day-to-day basis, how you allocate your time and your approach to life since the death of your mother?
Brené Brown
Yeah, I mean, it was a shit death. It was a jagged edge death. It was a death by a million pieces, you know. I think even when she died, I was shocked that she was never going to come back and be okay again.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, it's so final.
Brené Brown
Yeah, it's weird. And then it creeps up on me in really different ways. Like my son just graduated from high school and I was like, "Oh my God, my mom's going to love this picture." And then I'm like, "Oh God." I think I don't know... I don't think it's a coincidence that that happened. And my first... the first book I bought besides some like spiritual contemplations on grief was the book 4,000 Weeks. Do y'all know that book?
Kara Swisher
I don't. Tell us about it.
Brené Brown
Oh, it's really interesting. He was a productivity writer, I think, for one of the Guardian or one of the UK newspapers. And he was the one saying, you know, "Task, you know, box things up, do this, the Pomodoro method." He did all that and then at some point he said, "Shit, we only have 4,000 weeks if we're lucky and the more productive you are, the more bullshit you have to do." And this productivity thing is such... and this is where I loved his work. The productivity piece is such armor around protecting vulnerability and the fact that our time is finite. And we really have best case scenario, 4,000 weeks. And so I think I started doing a lot of work with a coach and my therapist around what's important to me and what's not. And my discernment button was broken. And so now I'm really trying to become very discerning about... and that's hard for me, firstborn, code name, sister superior.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, so you're being pleasing, right? You're pleasing.
Brené Brown
Oldest of four, yeah.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it's interesting. I'm going to drink. I actually do that with some people whenever I've decided they're wasting... I have a very big sense of death, as you know, constantly. And I tell a story, one person I was working with, I was like, "I just don't... I don't want to talk to you anymore because you're taking up minutes of my life." Like, I'm very aware of the minutes that negative things take on me or things I don't like. And I stop them because I am very aware of the moments, which I think social media and online is one of them, like 100%, some of which I like, some of which I enjoy.
And like videos, for example, I like a lot of funny videos. But most of the time, it's very difficult for people to... because so much rushes to fill. And one of the things you were talking about was the negative effects of social media. You do talk about that for years, and particularly loneliness. And we've been hearing a lot of ideas lately on how to reduce those harms. The Surgeon General proposed warning labels. New York Governor Kathy Hochul just signed a bill regulating social media algorithms for kids. I'm just curious for yourself, do you think any of these solutions... because a lot of the time suck is social media and advice giving, and I agree with you on the predatory aspects of it.
"This is how you should live. Here's five areas that will make your life happier," et cetera.
Brené Brown
I mean, I think... I mean, it's a multi-pronged predator because it's not just the time suck of scrolling. It's what we're ingesting knowingly and unknowingly while we're scrolling. And it's about talking about the biggest discernment button that we're up against, talking about breaking every sense of our connection to self in desperate pursuit of a counterfeit connection with others. That's social media. I mean, you want to lose yourself. It reminds me of like when I was really young and I was, you know, you'd be dating guys in college. They're like, "What music do you... I'm going to date myself here, but like, who's your favorite band?" They're like, "Boston." "Oh, mine too." "What's your favorite book?" "Dune."
Scott Galloway
More than a feeling.
Brené Brown
Yeah, more than a feeling. Oh my God. Yeah, well, Boston is actually one of my favorite bands. But, you know, and then somewhere down the line, you're dating this guy for like three months and you're like, "Shit, man, I don't like any of this shit we're doing. I don't like your music. I don't like where you like to eat." But talking about losing the connection to who you are and your capacity for discernment.
Kara Swisher
Discernment. I like that. Scott?
Scott Galloway
Do you... I'm just curious, you talk a lot about vulnerability. You have a huge social media following. Have you found that social media and your presence on social media has been accretive to your mental health or damaging your mental health? And how have you responded in terms of your own approach to social media?
Brené Brown
Damaging. Oh, devastating. Yeah. Just devastating. I'm not... I'm not built for this at all. I am...
Scott Galloway
Okay, but you have 5 million followers on Instagram, so you have embraced it. So how do you modulate it and cope with it?
Brené Brown
Um.
Kara Swisher
Asking for a friend.
Brené Brown
Yeah, no, I, um, let me just tell you for sure. So I have a friend... Asking for a friend. Yeah, no, let me just tell you for sure. So I have 5 million followers on Instagram. If I pulled up my phone right now and went to my followers and scroll down to the bottom, I would get a note from Instagram that said somewhere between 100 and 300 of those are suspicious and should be deleted en masse. Like, I don't know who these people are. And if I had to do it over again, I would have done things so differently. I don't post on the feed anymore. I only post in stories because there's no comments. I paid a lot of money for a moderation team external. And I'll tell you why. I had to do that because I could not protect the mental health of the internal moderation team in our organization. I couldn't do it. I couldn't protect them. I mean, these were things like...
Scott Galloway
So you're damaging the mental health of a bunch of people in the Philippines? Sorry, I couldn't resist.
Brené Brown
No, no. In fact, we were actually really careful about that. This was a U.S. company, very nuanced, but it only lasted... I think we were out of the contract now. It's not real. I mean, I'll tell you this: when I got into a dust-up with Spotify publicly...
Kara Swisher
You did.
Brené Brown
I did. And during that period of time, I probably received a hundred death threats. A hundred death threats.
Kara Swisher
This is the dust-up you had, Scott?
Scott Galloway
It was because Scott has similar... just yeah, no, I mean...
Brené Brown
And things like, "I'm going to kill your children in front of you." And a lot of it was mostly like bald eagle avatar things. And we have... because of the size of the followings that we have on the different platforms, we have liaisons that we work with. And you know, when we call, they're just like, "You are in the crosshairs of some very serious bots, probably Russian. And we can't stop it." And so I went off Twitter three or four years ago.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I did a year ago.
Brené Brown
Yeah, I went like way before the Elon Musk bullshit. I was just like, you know why? As part of the Spotify dust-up, I did an interview with a First Amendment specialist from the ACLU. And in that interview, he called Twitter a dopamine casino, which I thought was like...
Kara Swisher
We call it a Nazi porn bar, but go ahead. Or the sewage system of a sewer.
Brené Brown
Yeah, yeah. I mean, that's it. I had a dust-up with Spotify. I'm curious if you're comfortable, and you don't have to bring it up again, but what the content or the crux of the dust-up was.
I was caught in the... everyone thought it was actually some kind of weird beef with me and Joe Rogan, but I was caught up in what is the responsibility of a platform around mis- and disinformation?
Kara Swisher
We're the same person.
Brené Brown
I pulled Prop G off of... I had a close... just so you know, I'm very good at turning everything back to me. But I lost someone dear to me to COVID, and I just couldn't handle their lack of fact checking around bringing on total quacks to say mRNA vaccines alter your DNA. And I thought, okay, I don't deny their rights to First Amendment, but I don't have to paint their fucking fence. And I pulled my podcast off. Anyways, your turn.
Kara Swisher
No, that's what was happening. And my husband's a physician. And we buried friends during the pandemic. And I... look, sometimes today's conspiracy theory is the science of a decade later.
Brené Brown
Right.
Kara Swisher
And sometimes it's just dangerous bullshit.
Brené Brown
That's right.
Kara Swisher
And I wanted to understand, and I think it actually came down to... because there was no beef between me and any other podcast host. It just happened to be, you know, that happened to be happening a lot on certain podcasts where they'd have guests on. And then it just actually came down to a question of what is the responsibility of a podcast host to vet and let audience know this information has not been confirmed. This is, you know... I don't know what it is, but I am a huge First Amendment person. And you have First Amendment rights. And I have them too. Not to support economically a platform that is allowing misinformation to go viral.
Brené Brown
That's true. So interestingly, Renee, you just did a whole podcast series on AI, social media, and tech, very much in Pivot wheelhouse. I'd love to know what surprised you in these kinds... You talked to me about this. You said, "I'm about to do this." And I think it was just before you were doing it. So tell me what you learned from it. As someone who is not an expert by any means, but certainly understands the social society part of it.
I mean, if I did a qualitative analysis of Pivot shows, the learnings would be the same as this eight. This was an eight episode heady deep dive. And the learnings would be the same. One, technology got there before policy. And it's dangerous. The biggest concern is the alignment issue. Who's at the table when you're developing AI? It's just going to scale inequity at mass. It's not a machine that controls for disparity. And so I think S. Craig Watkins, who has a joint appointment at UT Austin and MIT, has been studying AI for 20 years. And his question was probably one of the ones that really stuck in my mind, which is who's at the table sitting with the computational mathematicians and the coders?
Are the ethicists there? Are the people with lived experiences that you're going to impact there? Are the liberal arts people there? And so to me, I mean, I'm a big policy person. I'm a government person, actually. I trust that that's a system that works when done well and works better than nothing at all, regardless how it's done. But I think the technology is so far ahead of policy that everyone I talked to said at some point, we're going to go, "Oh my God, did we really let this happen?" And I'm with y'all. I'm bullish on a lot of it. I love a lot of it. We have an AI internship program this summer to see where we can deploy generative learning and, you know, large language models.
Like, I love it and it's going to help, but it's going to hurt in the process if we don't get the right people at the table when it's being developed.
Kara Swisher
As did original technologies of every sort. It's a really interesting thing. You know, all of them, electricity always hurts the more vulnerable and then doesn't. I just have one other question, Renee. I love talking to you, by the way. And I know you and Scott have so much in common. Early in this episode we discussed the upcoming presidential debate. This election has been called the anxiety election. In a recent Yahoo! You got polls, 60 percent of respondents described themselves as very or somewhat anxious about the upcoming presidential election. It's the same people. What do you tell people about that? Like, how do you... what is the coping mechanism given we have no choice?
It's all the same show again that we don't like. Right. In general, it's disturbing for one candidate, for many of us. And the other side, too. They feel like, you know, Doug Burgum just called Biden a dictator, which seems insane to me. So people are using such strong terms and, you know, end of democracy, et cetera, et cetera. Your thoughts.
Brené Brown
I mean, I listen to y'all's podcast all the time. I don't think I've ever actually missed an episode. I listen to it when I work. Yeah, that's how we met. You called. I really love it. I learn a lot, and I disagree with a shit ton. And I have a question for Scott before I get off.
Scott Galloway
Okay, good. Fantastic. I was gonna say, I know who you disagree with.
Brené Brown
No, I don't disagree. I have more nuanced questions.
Scott Galloway
That's fine. I'm used to it.
Brené Brown
All right. You'll get to ask that. But anxiety, general anxiety about this particularly, which is coming at us so hard right now this week. This is the same thing about AI. And AI has been around for a long time. But I think the democratization of AI is what we're really talking about. We're talking about this election. We're building on a very cracked foundation. So by and large, I spend 90% of my time in organizations working with leaders about what's happening. People are not okay. We are still not okay from the pandemic. We're still not okay from the long overdue, I don't even want to call it a racial reckoning, this is still happening.
We're not okay. And so if any crisis like the pandemic is going to expose fault lines in systems and in countries, our fault lines are exposed right now. We're holding on as hard as we can, as tight as we can. And this thing is coming barreling toward us. I think people that are into the geopolitical scene look at Europe right now as a very scary tale of what's happening, especially the right-wing reaction to immigration primarily. We've got two candidates that have very low trust factors on both sides. And here's what I think is happening everywhere. We are experiencing at the greatest level in my lifetime an amazing lack of a sense of agency.
And so people think that hope—I'm thinking about what you talk about, Scott, about the data you reference a lot about young men—we think hope is an emotion. "I'm hopeful." It's like a sense of possibility and potential. But hope is actually not an emotion. Hope is a cognitive behavioral process. This is all C.R. Snyder's work. Hope is three pieces: goal, pathway, and agency. A person who scores very high on levels of hopefulness has the capacity to set a goal, has the capacity to develop a pathway. The best way to understand the nuance of pathway research is a person with high levels of hope is not afraid of plan B, C, D, Q, or Z if plan A goes to shit.
A pathway is someone who can say, "Here's my goal. If this doesn't work out, I'm going to keep going. I'm going to try this next." And then the last part of hope—so you've got goal, pathway—is agency: "I believe in my capacity to create change, to do something for myself." I've never seen the levels of hopelessness that I see right now in people. I don't know if it's goal—if people are just shrugging and saying, "What difference does it make? I can't even contemplate a goal." I don't know if it's pathway—if people just don't see the plan B when the A goes to hell. Or if it's agency—"I don't know that I am capable of making change in my own life, much less the world."
And so when we talk about the anxiety election, I think we have a collective group of folks with high levels of hopelessness and diminished agency. And I think that's what's scary for me.
Kara Swisher
Does it matter? When people say, "It doesn't matter." People are pissed off about a certain Biden policy. And there's plenty to be pissed off about. And the bear hug thing, I'm over. There's so many things to be upset about. But man, what a privileged position in my mind to say, "I'm not going to vote." You must have some money tucked away. You must not be fighting oppression every single day. What a privileged position to pick a moral superiority position and not vote. I can't even tell you. I actually threatened my sons. It was my son's first election. I was like, "You must vote or we will not be going to college."
Brené Brown
This is a guy coming after—this is a guy weirdly taking credit for ending reproductive rights and women's autonomy of their bodies.
Kara Swisher
Correct.
Brené Brown
Looking to go again and go harder. He's doubling down.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Brené Brown
Okay. I have a question and I really want an answer that can get my head and heart around. Y'all were talking about the Texas stock market. And I think you just completely nailed the marketing that's going to go with that. I mean, it's got "secede from the union" written on it a little bit. Like we're just going to become so independent of everything. Where can I find, Scott, an index that shows what a state does for business? Because you've been complimentary of how Texas has handled some business stuff around shareholder value and things like that. But we also rank 50th out of 50 in uninsured women. It's a hard state to live in. We have a grid where people froze to death here a couple of years ago. I unfortunately have a lot of firsthand knowledge because my husband is a pediatrician. Where is the index that doesn't separate what you do for shareholder value with how you actually treat the citizens of your state? I love this question. Scott?
Scott Galloway
First of all, that's a really generous question because there's an assumption there that I would have some insight.
Brené Brown
I'm curious. I think you would.
Scott Galloway
Okay, so I would argue, and I hate to defend Texas, that the best index is net migration. Texas continues to draw more people despite all its problems. People with options can choose any one of 50 states, and more and more people are choosing Texas. Now, would I choose Texas to send my daughter to college if it wasn't a UT school? I don't know. But to your point, these indices are really dangerous because when you see the S&P and the NASDAQ at all-time highs, you're under the illusion that America is doing well. No, the NASDAQ and the NYSE are just wealth indices for the top 1%. We need an index around obesity.
We need indices around self-harm. And those indices should be on CNBC every day. Nobody knows how many people have died of opioid overdoses or deaths of despair in the last week, but everyone knows what the NASDAQ does every day. As a person who's not familiar with Texas, whose only impression of Texas is data I get, Texas has almost as many Fortune 500 companies as New York. A lot of the exterior metrics are very flashing green light for Texas. But I want to acknowledge I don't know Texas. I don't feel like I'm in a position to really evaluate some of the more thoughtful things that you're discussing.
I would never live in a state where if my daughter, my wife, my girlfriend had to leave the state to seek a terminated pregnancy. That, for me, is a deal killer in terms of moving to a state. But having said that, there's more U-Hauls going into Texas than leaving right now.
Brené Brown
But who's in them?
Scott Galloway
Well, that's a fair question, but the bottom line is the city. Houston's about to overtake Chicago as the third most populous city in the world. And real estate, I just think it's hard to ignore that on a lot of metrics, Texas is doing really well.
Brené Brown
But have we not come to the place in our human development collectively where we can combine instruments of measurement? We need better metrics. The suicide rate and the self-harm rate with the shareholder growth rate at the same time. Because I'm wondering if the correlation is inverse. Brene, you live in Texas?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, she does.
Brené Brown
Fifth generation Texan.
Kara Swisher
Okay, so the retort would be, Brene, you're a wealthy woman. You have a lot of influence. You have a lot of options. And every day you exercise the option to stay in Texas. So answer the question. Why'd you stay?
Brené Brown
Proximity to family, number one. Fifth generation. My people are here. Number two, if I'm not with my people, it doesn't matter what's going on.
Kara Swisher
Sure.
Brené Brown
But I think number two is Greg Abbott, Patrick, the folks running Texas right now are part of the Trump thing too for me. And I wrote about this in 2015. It's part of the white male power over, the last stand of that. Not white male power—I'm raising a son, he's an amazing person—but it's a type of power specifically of power over, not power with and power to, but power over. And I think one of the reasons I stay is I don't believe—it's the same reason why you don't get to own America. You don't get to own patriotism. You don't get to own God. And these folks don't get to own Texas. That's not who we are. We're as much Molly Ivins and Ann Richards as we are these jackwagons.
Kara Swisher
So you're taking Texas back.
Brené Brown
Yeah, but I think part of it is that. It's very difficult because...
Kara Swisher
Governor Richards, enormous leader.
Brené Brown
Great Texas. But I will tell you, I think the progressives and the left terribly underestimate the level of organization and control of the right. I mean, we are gerrymandered to the hilt.
Kara Swisher
I 100% agree with you that people need more agency. And I love what you said. I generally believe we're siblings from another mother. I'm actually older than you. If there was one thing you could do—and I love what you said that government matters and you like programs—if there was one program you could implement, magic wand, to give agency back to young people, and I don't want to say especially young men, but all young people that would lift up boats, including young men, what would that one program be?
Brené Brown
Oh, my God. Am I really ready for the shit that's going to come my way when I say this? Let me think about it for a second. Yeah, I'll do it. You know what? Mandatory national service for 18 to 20-year-olds. 100%.
Scott Galloway
I love this woman.
Kara Swisher
I see.
Scott Galloway
I love this woman.
Brené Brown
I'm not talking about military service. I'm talking about old school. Anything—healthcare, senior care.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, all of it.
Brené Brown
Invest in our country. And part of the mandatory service would be—I have a really hard time. For 20-something years, I taught just PhD and master's students. I just taught my first undergrad class a couple of years ago. I did not realize the level of uncertainty avoidance in especially young men. The inability to neurobiologically and nervous system handle the just awkward—looking people in the eye. I mean, we did "reading the room." Just like, "Can I break up with my kids? Can we break up over text?" Absolutely not. "We're going to this funeral." "Oh my God. But my friend is crying. It's awkward."
Yeah. You're going to look them in the eye and you're going to cry with them. And you're going to build the neural pathways to handle the discomfort of what it means to be in deep connection with other people. And that's what's missing. People, we really are biologically changing our capacity for connection because of our intolerance for discomfort. And love is hard. And friendship is hard and roommates are hard and job interviews are hard. The anxiety people feel that keeps them so avoidant they stay at home—that's also real. There's a reason romantic comedies are two hours, not 15 minutes, right?
This shit is hard. The ability to look someone in the eye who's in pain and not diminish it and not try to make it better, but just be with people. And you know, people blame the kids. We're talking about a generation that we raised.
Kara Swisher
That's correct.
Brené Brown
That is correct. This shit is real.
Kara Swisher
Brene, I love you. I'm so glad to introduce you for a lifelong love affair.
Scott Galloway
My next podcast with Brene Brown. I can see it.
Kara Swisher
Let's do it.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, you can change him, Brene. You can take him.
Kara Swisher
All right, Brene, be sure to check out her other Vox Media podcasts. We're thrilled you're back, and we're thrilled you're back for the conversation. Ignore everything else, but your conversations are always amazing. I appreciate them myself.
Scott Galloway
She did a great job for me when it was in Chicago. We had a wonderful conversation. You're just a national treasure.
Kara Swisher
Unlocking Us and Dare to Lead, Brene Brown and Scott Galloway. I'm so glad to introduce you. Thanks, Brene.
Brené Brown
Bye, y'all. Thanks.
Guest leaves
Kara Swisher
Scott, is she great or what?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I mean, one, I agree with absolutely everything she said. But also, I respect and I think there's a lesson here on communication. I'm a huge fan of the pregnant verging on awkward pause. She does that. I love that. It's saying, "I take you seriously. I take the question seriously. And the response you're about to get is thoughtful." And I didn't learn that until I was in my 40s around public speaking and just regular discourse—that when someone asks you a question, it's not a prompt to just start making noise. You should think about the question. And if you don't have an answer, if it's not an easy one, it's okay to take some time. And she does it to a dramatic effect. She's smart. She's doing it. I don't want to say it's performative, but she does it to create a little bit of drama. Excellent person.
Kara Swisher
Excellent person. Knock, knock. Who's there? Impatient cow. Impatient cow who?
Scott Galloway
Where did that come from?
Kara Swisher
It's a perfect joke. Impatience to jump in, et cetera. Can I tell you a Claire joke?
Scott Galloway
What did the cookie say to the doctor? I know the answer. I like that joke, but go ahead.
Kara Swisher
What?
Scott Galloway
"I feel crummy."
Kara Swisher
When I asked my wife to say something that would make me feel bad and good at the same time, what did she say?
Scott Galloway
What did she say?
Kara Swisher
"Your penis is bigger than your brother's."
Scott Galloway
Oh! I told a nice cookie joke. I asked for it. I asked for it. You told a nice joke. You stuck your chin out.
Kara Swisher
Damn it.
Scott Galloway
All right.
Kara Swisher
All right, Scott, one more quick break. We'll be back for wins and fails.
Ad break
Okay, Scott, let's hear some wins and fails. I'll go first. The Ten Commandments thing in Louisiana—I mean, we spent years getting this shit out of classes, out of state. They're fucking back, these people. They're like mold. I don't know what else to say. Look, you can be religious. God love you. But keep it out of schools. That's the whole—I just can't believe they're doing this. It's going to lose, as it did before. And then we're going to spend all our energy on something that has already been litigated, but they just refuse, which makes me know that they're coming back for gay marriage and everything else.
Just, what is wrong with you? Just let people be their own thing. If you're not Christian, it's offensive to you. You should respect other people's religions. I just don't know what to say. And a win—I think getting Megan Rapinoe and Sue Bird onto the Vox Media Podcast Network. I think that was great. They were at lunch with us in France, and also they threatened to overtake us. Megan was right there saying she's going to kick our ass, which was nice, typical. You left before the picture taking, but we took a lovely picture together. So we're thrilled to have all these badass ladies at Vox. And also, Andre Iguodala was there, and Pri, as usual, our best friend, Pri.
So just really nice to add. I'm glad Brene's back, and I'm thrilled Megan and Sue are also there. Great thinkers, also very different. They're not immediately going to go to left or right. They're just very thoughtful people. And world-class athletes.
Scott Galloway
World-class, yeah. These are incredible, incredible athletes.
Kara Swisher
Incredible. Anyway, those are my wins and fails.
Scott Galloway
Nice. Okay, so I have a couple wins and one fail. The U.S. Senate passed a bipartisan bill, 88 to 2—that never happens—to accelerate the deployment of nuclear energy capacity by speeding permitting and creating new incentives for advanced nuclear reactor technologies. It will now go to Biden for his signature. He's expected to sign it. I don't understand. Nuclear was the worst managed brand in the world, and it's really hurt us. We started closing nuclear facilities in California. Germany decided with the Green Movement that for some reason—I mean, you got to pick your poison. There's no perfect energy, but this is an outstanding, fairly clean source of energy. And as evidenced by the fact that we're just going to have so much more appetite for energy, I think it's great. My favorite bumper sticker is "More people have died in Ted Kennedy's car than in any nuclear power plant in America." That's from the 70s or the 80s. Anyways, I'm a huge fan of nuclear.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, me too. Get on it.
Scott Galloway
Another win—this is just, I just read this and I was just so blown away by how smart the guys are at Netflix. They've announced earlier this week two permanent Netflix House experience venues.
Kara Swisher
Houses, yeah, we talked about this.
Scott Galloway
And they're creating 50 live experiences across the globe. They're going to try and emulate competitors a little bit. They've done Stranger Things pop-ups.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, pop-ups.
Scott Galloway
I think it's a great idea. So if you think of strategy, you want scenario planning. "Okay, this works or this doesn't work." Well, if it doesn't work, it's great marketing. And that's how they're positioning it. They're not saying, "We're trying to compete with Disney, we're opening parks." They're saying, "We're going to do some temporary experiences." Two, you want to look at pain points. The existing pain points around Disney—a billion EBITDA franchise—is that one, it probably costs five to ten grand for a family of four. And two, it's even more time expensive. You really need two or three days.
You go to a giant suburb of Orlando or Tokyo or Paris, and it's the seventh ring of hell and you're trapped there for two days spending five to ten grand for a family of four. And they've said, "Okay, we can open in urban locations. We can buy now abandoned malls for pennies on the dollar or lease them. We can have Stranger Things. We can have Bridgerton." They're just going to do it. And if it doesn't work, it was good marketing, and then they let it fade to black and signed one- and two-year leases at great terms. And if it does work, they could end up with the same sort of flywheel that everyone talks about with Disney.
And if you think about Disney parks, when you think about the amount of EBIT that they spend off of—and I would argue when you go to Disneyland, it's really not a ton different than if you went 20 years ago.
Kara Swisher
No, it's not. It's kind of the same rides. The same lines are too long. The food—that's my big beef with Disney, is the food.
Scott Galloway
And they've been able to, in my opinion, capture unearned margin because of the moats. I just think this is so smart on behalf of Netflix. Anyways, Netflix House is strategically just a great win. And then my loss is—I think Democrats, if we're going to try and win this election, we need to have sober conversations with ourselves. I think that essentially the jury that found Hunter Biden guilty was right. He was guilty. The jury that found Donald Trump guilty was right. He was guilty, but it was a misallocation. Neither of those cases should have been brought. The reason they were brought was one was an unpopular former president and one is an unpopular president's son.
And I think that Democrats don't want to admit and they need to acknowledge that the case in New York was a disaster for us, both in terms of the polls and in terms of fundraising. I feel as if there's a lack of sober conversations around what the data says and what's working and what isn't working around the election. And so my general loss is that I get the sense that Democrats put hands over their ears and over their eyes and don't want to have honest conversation around what is really going to be required to win here, as opposed to constantly looking for excuses for Biden and rationalizations.
As opposed to really being in a war room and saying, "Okay, this is what is actually going down and what has happened." So it's more or less, I feel as if when I talk to Democrats, both in the White House and in the campaign, that they're not honest with themselves. They don't have a sober conversation around what the data reflects here. Anyways, the key to winning a war is you have to put yourself in the shoes of the enemy and empathize with them and be very honest about what the data says. And I think what happens with generals and what's happened with Putin and every general that loses a war is the incentives are to tell the general and the president what they want to hear.
And I think that's going on here. I don't think Democrats have realized just what a terrible 90 days this has been for us. We have gone from outracing, leading in all the swing states, to now they are outracing us and they have pulled ahead.
Kara Swisher
We were not leading. We were not leading, but go ahead. In the swing states we were not leading by a lot, but go ahead. 90 days ago.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. Okay. So anyways, my fail is that I don't think the—whatever you call it—the village elders of the Democratic Party, I think we're in denial about what's going on here.
Kara Swisher
Tough love is what you're saying.
Scott Galloway
Tough love.
Kara Swisher
Tough love, I agree with you. Data-driven love.
Scott Galloway
We got to kill. We got to kill. We got to kill.
Kara Swisher
Be killed. That's a great one. That's a great one. I agree with all of them. And you and I are going to have a Bridgerton moment experience and we're going to dress up and do the minuet. It's going to be great.
Scott Galloway
I got to think they have ethnically ambiguous people in corsets who just rip off their clothes and start fucking. I'd pay for that.
Kara Swisher
I would pay for that. All right. On that note, we want to hear from you. Watch this season. It's so good. We want to hear from you. Send us your question. Penelope Featherington, send us your questions about business, tech, or whatever's on your mind. Go to nymag.com slash pivot to submit a question for the show or call 855-51-PIVOT. Okay, Scott, that's the show. We'll be back on Friday for more. What a good show. And I'm so glad to introduce you and Brene Brown. Read us out.
Scott Galloway
Today's show is produced by Lara Naiman, Zoe Marcus, and Taylor Griffin. Ernie Andretod engineered this episode. Thanks also to Drew Burrows and Miel Saverio. Nishat Kurwa is Vox Media's executive producer of audio. Make sure you subscribe to the show wherever you listen to podcasts. Thanks for listening to Pivot from New York Magazine and Vox Media. You can subscribe to the magazine at nymag.com slash pod. We'll be back later this week for another breakdown of all things tech and business. What is a key attribute of someone who is successful? They feel as if they have a sense of agency.