Podcast Episode Summary
The podcast episode of Pivot, hosted by Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway, covers various topics including the Super Bowl, the NFL, media layoffs, and the future of journalism. The hosts discuss the success of the Super Bowl and the NFL, despite the challenges faced by other sports leagues. They also talk about the ongoing trend of media layoffs and the struggles of traditional news outlets to adapt to the changing media landscape.
The hosts interview Chris Dixon, the founder and managing partner of Andreessen Horowitz's Crypto VC Fund, about his new book "Read, Write, Own, Building the Next Era of the Internet." Dixon discusses the potential of blockchain technology to create a more decentralized and democratic internet, and the need for innovation to address the challenges of the current internet.
The hosts also discuss the impact of AI on the media industry, including the use of AI-generated content and the need for regulation to address the issues of misinformation and deepfakes. They also talk about the future of journalism and the need for a more sustainable business model.
Key Points
Takeaways
Participants
Supporting Organizations
Kara Swisher
As marketing channels have multiplied, the demand for content has skyrocketed. But everyone can make content that's on brand and stands out with Adobe Express. You don't have to be a designer to generate images, rewrite text, and create effects. That's the beauty of generative AI that's commercially safe. Teams all across your business will be psyched to collaborate and create amazing presentations, videos, social posts, flyers, and more. Meet Adobe Express, the quick and easy app to create on-brand content. Learn more at adobe.com slash express slash business.
Ad break
Rinse takes your laundry and hand delivers it to your door. Expertly cleaned and folded. So you could take the time once spent folding and sorting and waiting to finally pursue a whole new version of you. Like Tea Time You. Mmm. Or this Tea Time You. Or even this Tea Time You. Said you hear about Dave. Or even Tea Time Tea Time Tea Time You. Mmm. So update on Dave. It's up to you. We'll take the laundry. Rinse. It's time to be great.
Ad break
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And I'm Scott Galloway.
Kara Swisher
Scott, I'm in your apartment again.
Scott Galloway
I like that.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I'm here.
Scott Galloway
I like that. I'm here.
Kara Swisher
I'm here to go see the Vision Pro, as you know, going to a dinner with Sienna. I'm taking the very well-rounded Chris Wallace to try it, to try the Apple Vision Pro.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, in your place. Did you talk to my son this weekend?
Kara Swisher
I didn't. He told me he was going to call me, and he didn't call me.
Scott Galloway
Oh, he didn't. Oh, God, he's probably at a frat house. All right. How was your weekend?
Kara Swisher
It was okay. I had a dinner party, which was cool. But then everyone in my family but me is sick.
Scott Galloway
Again?
Kara Swisher
Again, yeah. The cold season with toddlers. Everyone has strep or whatever, and Amanda's had a cough that's lasted forever. And since I had my RSV vaccine, I am not suffering from it like I did last year.
Scott Galloway
How long are you at my place?
Kara Swisher
Just the night, just the evening. And then I'm going down to visit my mom.
Scott Galloway
I have lost track. Word is out that I'm promiscuous because of this podcast with the use of my place. And so people just text me, hey, I'm going to be in town. I'm like, no problem.
Kara Swisher
Oh, really?
Scott Galloway
At some point, you're going to run into somebody. It'll be fun.
Kara Swisher
That'll be fun. I told you, a cuddle puddle. I'm sorry I'm going to miss you.
Scott Galloway
That's the thing. I know you coming in. If someone shows up looking for a little extra for the rim job, just pan what he needs and get him out of there, right?
Kara Swisher
I will. I will.
Scott Galloway
Well, you better be here for my book party since you're one of the hosts.
Kara Swisher
I'm not going to be there, but I will be there.
Scott Galloway
That's right. You're having a book party.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
That's right. You have a book coming out. It's funny. You don't talk about that a lot.
Kara Swisher
Oh, we could have it at your house then if you're not here. You're welcome to use it.
Scott Galloway
Interesting. After party.
Kara Swisher
Oh, maybe we will. Anyway, yeah.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. Thank you for hosting it, even though you're not showing up. That was a nice flex. That's a total baller move.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, that's a baller move. I'm going to Tulum.
Scott Galloway
Are you?
Kara Swisher
Oh, Stephanie Ruhl will be here. Ben Smith, others.
Scott Galloway
Oh, my favorite.
Kara Swisher
But that's okay. Yeah.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
They're all co-hosts with you. They're all co-hosts. And I'm really excited about it. Just so you know. Maggie Haberman.
Scott Galloway
Maggie Haberman.
Kara Swisher
Oh, I'm scared of her. She's a baller. She's a gangster.
Scott Galloway
Well, I'm going to have her come after you.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, no. I'm scared of her. Oh, hey, you know what? I saw, first off, I know you're curious on what I did this weekend, but all these private membership clubs in London now have these sister properties out on the Cotswolds. And there's still a farmhouse where they pretend to be a farm, but it's super cool.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. An avocado toast.
Kara Swisher
It is. I want to go there.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
It's really well done. And then my favorite club, Maison Estelle, has Estelle Manor, I think it's called. And I just have the boys this weekend. So I'm like, that's it. I got to get you off your screen. So I had one of those moments where I freaked out. So I got in a car with the dogs. I mean, everything. Arriving on the wrong side of the road.
Scott Galloway
Okay, go. Go for it.
Kara Swisher
I don't drive. I use this thing called Wheelie, which is amazing. And by the way, they took you there to the Cotswolds. So I got on my Mercedes V class with all the dog beds and everything. Oh my god. Head out there. Ping them. I'm coming out. Get me whatever it is you have out there. And we had... and it was lovely. It was lovely.
Scott Galloway
I like those places.
Kara Swisher
Oh, they're wonderful.
Scott Galloway
Was it like Saltburn? I hope not.
Kara Swisher
I don't know what Saltburn is. What's Saltburn?
Scott Galloway
Saltburn's a movie. It's about an English manor and they're up to sexual hijinks and stuff like that. It's crazy. It's a new movie.
Kara Swisher
Well, if you can give me the name of that place I'm in, but no, this had none of that. I'm surprised you haven't seen that. I played Padel, did rifle shooting, archery, all that kind of.
Scott Galloway
Padel. That's what the rich people do. Padel.
Kara Swisher
I had never played that before.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, they don't have vowels.
Kara Swisher
It was fine.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, it's like pickleball. They're all sort of.
Kara Swisher
My boys liked it. Let the dogs run crazy. This is one of these places where there's all these poofy dogs that rich people like.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, my great Dane would come in and scare the shit out of everybody, which I like.
Kara Swisher
Oh, okay. Wow. What a weekend. Padel and shooting in an English manor.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I did not do that.
Kara Swisher
It was really nice. I cleaned the house and that.
Scott Galloway
Anyway. Hold on. I'm trying to bring this back to you. For the first time, I watched a clip of you on your new CNN show. And I thought it was good. It was only a clip where you're saying Nikki Haley is sort of standing, waiting. She's like a backup quarterback in case Joe Montana blows a knee or something. She's waiting to come in. I thought your logic was pretty sound there. And I saw that Cliff Asness and a bunch of other hedge fund titans are like, we're giving her more money.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, they are. Why not? She's actually leaning in. She's really going at him real hard on the policy stuff. Anyway, we'll see. And also he's created all kinds of mess and debt deficit and stuff like that. It's interesting. Now she's sort of winding up, which is kind of a little too little too late, but we'll see.
Scott Galloway
I agree. It could happen. She has a non-zero chance of pushing it through, and she's right in position.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, we have a lot to talk about. The celebrity defects, renewing calls for regulation, the ongoing media layoffs, raising questions about journalism's future, continuing questions about its future. Plus, we'll chat with a friend of Pivot, Chris Dixon, the founder and managing partner of Andreessen Horowitz's Crypto VC Fund. We have a lot of questions for him. He's got a new book, Read, Write, Own: Building the Next Era of the Internet. We'll have to ask him about where crypto's going and what's happening. He's actually a very smart investor. But first, who are you rooting for in the Super Bowl, Scott? Taylor Swift or San Francisco?
Scott Galloway
The MAGA people are losing their ever-loving minds because it's not a particularly good choice for them.
Kara Swisher
Oh, you know what, Kara? I really don't care. I have almost no interest in American football. I was really, quite frankly, I was really hoping for the Lions. I think they needed it, or I just think it would have meant more to them. But, yeah, I just don't care. I don't. I got to be honest. I think I'm a little bit sick of all those shots of New England and Tampa Bay of Tom Brady.
Scott Galloway
I didn't mind that because I think he's the most beautiful person on the planet.
Kara Swisher
All the shots of Taylor Swift, I think she was very attractive. But I'm just sort of sick of the whole Taylor thing.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I know. But it's an interesting thing because they were down and they blamed her for it. They were almost out of it. And it was her fault in the midseason.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, because it was her fault because he was distracted from being her boyfriend. And then now, you know, I personally like Jason Kelsey. I just love him. He seems like a nice guy. I kind of like his whole vibe. I like their whole vibe.
Scott Galloway
I'm glad they're happy. I'm glad they're in love. Can they just keep it to themselves?
Kara Swisher
No. No. No.
Scott Galloway
And so is Patrick Mahomes. Even I know this. And then San Francisco, which really pulled out a win, which is great. They're mad about that. They're mad about the whole thing. One guy, Nick Adams, who's such an imbecile, was like, she's in it for the money because he gets $70,000 if they win. She's in it for the money.
Kara Swisher
We're all in it for the money. What's wrong with that?
Scott Galloway
No, she's not in it for the money. She's a billionaire. She's not in it for the money. And the reason she's a billionaire is she's in it for the money. She's a savvy businesswoman like most men. What's wrong with that?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, yeah, yeah, exactly. So anyway, here's the one thing I do want to say. The Super Bowl has held its own. You know, we talked about declining Oscars last week, declining all these national shows. The Super Bowl has held its own, and I suspect this year is going to be huge, and it's going to be due to her, and people think it's going to be a really good game. So it's still stayed at hundreds of, you know, 115, 130 million people. They think it's going to blow past. That's the one thing that's done rather well as a thing from a television and entertainment and financial perspective.
Scott Galloway
But it's not just the Super Bowl. The NFL, the Premier League is the second best-run league in the world. The NFL is number one. And it's a variety of things, including it's one of the few mediums or one of the few things that people want to do commercials for because they want to watch it live. But what is really unique about it, and it's, I think, a great lesson for our economy, and for me, it all leads to more antitrust and breaking up companies. But the reason the NFL is so successful is because the way they work the draft is the worst team in the league gets better drafts. And they constantly, every team is sort of, in two to three years, could be back in the playoffs. And it keeps the fans really engaged. You can't create, it can't be too dynastic and churn is really a good thing and it creates a more healthy ecosystem. Now granted, having said that, it's a monopoly and you have to go through the owners group to get approved and all that, but it's an incredibly well-run league other than it's giving these incredible young men Parkinson's by the time they're 45. I'm a big fan.
Kara Swisher
Yes, indeed.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, other than it's giving these incredible young men Parkinson's by the time they're 45. I'm a big fan. Yes, indeed. Yeah. Other than that. There's that. There's that.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, there's that. Nonetheless, it continues to be a sort of national pastime here in this country. Obviously, soccer, football, the European football is big there. And it's huge. And so is Formula One. A lot of these sports things and basketball have done incredible.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but nothing. NFL trumps them all. If you look at dollars and you look at growth.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. They've done just an amazing job. Sports is a good place to be, though.
Scott Galloway
Sports is a good place to be.
Kara Swisher
And speaking of paying for it all, Amazon Prime Video now has ads. If you want to watch Amazon Prime content without ads, it'll cost you an extra $2.99 a month on top of the current $14.99 a month Prime subscription. Amazon first announced the plan to incorporate ads in September. Joining all the other streamers, we're going back to the ad business except for Apple TV+. The company promised to have meaningfully fewer ads than others. They think the revenue is going to be $5 billion. Actually, Netflix is doing rather well with it and it hasn't seen a drop off. I think people who don't want ads will pay for it and people who do will. What do you think?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I was initially against the idea of these companies doing ads because I think it kind of goes after their core brand. But as everyone has migrated to these companies, advertisers still need to reach people. And I think that, I mean, there's so much competition amongst them that the easiest path to incremental 100, 300, 500 million, billion in incremental high margin revenue is to hire the ad sales team from CBS that is looking for jobs right now. And I imagine a lot of advertisers are saying, yeah, we'd love to advertise on Reacher or whatever. I don't know what the big programs are. I don't, anyway, I'll be curious to see how it pans out over the long term. But basically, these companies, they're just swallowing media whole.
Kara Swisher
That is correct. That's what they're doing. Yeah. And I think it's a good thing. I've never had a problem if you want to pay for it. I like the idea of deciding whether you want to pay for it or not. You never had that with broadcast, right? You had to sit there and endure it no matter what. And it was free. And in this case, it's not, you know, well, it'll be interesting to see who will pay for it and who will not pay for it. Obviously it limits the amount of people that can watch it. That said, so much stuff is online now. I never watch Saturday Night Live, I watch it all by clips, which is how I watch the show. So it'll be interesting to see where it goes. But it's a good business as it turns out and has not had any perceptible effect on people signing up or people using it because it's the way things are going.
Scott Galloway
It's over.
Kara Swisher
Another big story in the news. I don't know if it's getting play over there, but former President Donald Trump owes E. Jean Carroll more money for defaming her in 2019. The jury awarded Carroll $18 million in compensatory damages and $65 million in punitive damages for a whopping total of $83 million. That's on top of the $5 million he already lost to her. He left the courtroom before the verdict was read, which was idiotic on his part. But of course, let us know his thoughts on Truth Social, calling the verdicts absolutely ridiculous. And Biden directed witch hunt. I don't know what he's talking about. Carroll, on the other hand, said in a statement, "This is a great victory for every woman who stands up when she's been knocked down." A lot of kudos are going to Robbie Kaplan, who argued the case. She's been in a lot of high profile cases, actually, very strong New York lawyer. The jury was like, fuck this guy. I don't mean, that's what it seemed like. It may go down in appeals, but a lot of people think it will not actually because he keeps doing it. What do you think?
Scott Galloway
Well, there's an interesting thing, and I didn't know this, but if he decides to appeal it, the appeal, they don't argue the facts. They argue the amount and the decision or the legal component of it, right? Did they miss something? They don't argue the facts. But in order for him to appeal, he has to put a bond such that if he loses appeal, she gets her money. Too sweet. And I love this. I think it's a huge victory for her and for women who, for a long time, had to just endure bullshit from powerful men. And I like, I also think it's a victory for the justice system. That they're like, look, you want to fuck with a jury? It's going to cost you. You want to try and intimidate people and act like the asshole you are? And I mean, he cost himself 30 or 50 million bucks here. If he hadn't shown up. He just did.
Kara Swisher
Well, he thinks he's going to raise it the other way, that he'll get it back on the other side, I guess. I don't, I mean, I haven't looked at the data. I mean, what's so interesting about all of this, have you seen the data around what's happening in terms of political affiliation between by gender?
Scott Galloway
No, oh, women are more liberal and men are more conservative. It is crazy what's happening.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, that makes sense.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but I mean it is really widening, which for me goes back to mating and the best advice I could give a man or a woman who are looking to mate in a heteronormative relationship is to be...
Kara Swisher
If you insist, but go ahead.
Scott Galloway
I know. Is if you're a dude, pretend to be progressive no matter what. And if you're a woman, pretend to be conservative because generally speaking, people are attracted to people with similar political values. And if you're a progressive dude now, especially without a college education, to be a progressive, you're going to have a much larger pool of potential mates and fewer people pursuing. Anyways, but the Gulf is just dramatic.
Kara Swisher
It is. I have a lot of mixed marriages, political marriages. I know a lot of people in those.
Scott Galloway
That's D.C. and they're all sort of, I mean.
Kara Swisher
Not D.C. All over, I'm talking about my family all over the country.
Scott Galloway
When you say mixed, you mean center left or center right?
Kara Swisher
No, very concerned. Actually, the Washington Post had a great story about a couple like this in Iowa that was really well done. They've done a couple of those and it's interesting to read. You know, either they cancel each other out or they don't. I was just talking to a friend of mine whose parents live in Oklahoma. And it's interesting. You see it happening. I just think it becomes the one. The Post wrote was devastating. This guy had jumped off the right wing thing and is living there. And the woman is like, I don't know what to do about this. Like she's had it. And yet she's never going anywhere. It was a great piece, actually.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, the Gulf was massive, actually, in this case. And she wasn't particularly liberal. Just he's gone way down. But the downside of it is I think it's going to lower our birth rate.
Kara Swisher
No, it's already low.
Scott Galloway
Well, but I think this is going to make it worse. I think that it's yet another reason why people are going to find reason not to fall in love.
Kara Swisher
So it's up to the lesbians then. You know, it all comes back. Let me just say on this last thing on E. Jean Carroll, she just won. She won. He lost. He acted like an asshole in a costume. Good for her. She is 80 years old.
Scott Galloway
She is 80?
Kara Swisher
She is. She looks fantastic.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, she looks great for you. She's a good-looking lady.
Kara Swisher
Good for her. When he goes on about that, I was like, she is a good-looking lady, my friend. She's so elegant and beautiful. Anyway, she's also, I read her for many years. I thought she was a wonderful writer. Anyway, lastly, FTC has opened an investigation into big tech's investments into AI. No surprise. Google, Microsoft, Amazon, OpenAI, and Anthropic are the subjects of the inquiry, which could result in regulation and anti measures. In a statement, Lina Khan said she hopes to, quote, "shed light on whether these investments risk distorting innovation, undermining fair competition." I don't know. It seems like, of course, they have to, right? Nothing else to see there.
Scott Galloway
I think so. I think it's kind of scary because, I mean, OpenAI is basically Microsoft AI.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, yeah.
Scott Galloway
And then who's the other one? Anthropic is Amazon, has a big investment from Amazon. Similar. And so it's sort of the same players again. It's such an important field. And the thing about it is you need so much capital that the barriers of entry are, you know, it's kind of sequestered to a small number of players. So I like that Lina has found her voice and is going kind of gangster on this stuff. And it's interesting. It's not actual court cases or decisions. It's the specter of the fear of them. It is appropriate for Lina Khan to be doing this as well she should. And you're right. We talk about this all the time. It's all the same big players. We'll see where it goes, but it's good that she's poking around and she should poke around because it's like, you know, the Washington Post famous thing, democracy dies in darkness. I think most of these things are in the bright light of day. You know what I mean? You're seeing it happening with these. And you want these innovative companies to come up in AI. You want a ton of them. We don't want the big companies to control everything. And they're certainly poised to do that.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, let's get to our first big story. There are renewed calls for regulation on deepfakes after several recent high-profile incidents. Fake sexually explicit images of Taylor Swift generated by AI were all over X and other platforms last week, especially X getting millions of views before eventually being taken down. Actually, X turned off the search for Taylor Swift. Of course, it's not a surprise, given that platform has abandoned all its trust and safety people and has gotten rid of them. And she gets a lot of attention from the far right now. For some reason, they're really obsessed with her.
You could not find her name on that platform. The White House weighed in saying the images were alarming, calling for social media companies to enforce rules and encourage legislation on AI images. Listen, it's just her, but it's a lot of people in many ways for many years. Individual states like California, Texas, and Virginia have laws for deepfakes, but there's no federal law. As I said, searches on this is the only thing they could do was block her name, which is odd. X put out a statement saying it prohibits the sharing of non-consensual graphic imagery and has a, quote, zero tolerance policy for such content without mentioning Swift.
But, of course, they fired everyone who was in charge of fixing it. They're apparently opening a new center hiring 100 moderators to enforce platform rules on child exploitation, violence, and hate speech. That's because it may have become a bigger problem. Another person, George Carlin's estate, is also taking legal action after a special was released on YouTube using generative AI to mimic the late comedian's voice and humor, which was appalling, I thought. There's going to be a lot of these. The comedians behind this YouTube special have called it "AI: The Next Paintbrush." They also said it was done by humans, which is kind of like, okay, so he stole his image.
SAG-AFTRA put out a statement saying they're working with lawmakers to pass legislation to protect likenesses. Big issue in politics. Last week in New Hampshire, voters were getting robocalls from AI-generated Joe Biden. It sounded like Joe Biden. So you've talked a lot about this, about the impact of AI on the election for a while. How are you feeling about these? Three different things, all different, all the same in a lot of ways.
Scott Galloway
First off, we've said in the short term that we thought the biggest risk was misinformation, which you could argue this is, or disinformation is probably a better term. And then over the long-term loneliness, I've never bought into the sentient Skynet moment, but we're seeing already what can happen with disinformation. And I had a personal experience with this weekend. I tried to bond with my boys over football. And I said to my 13-year-old, I said, did you see what Ronaldo said about Holland? And he said, what are you talking about? I said, he was basically being critical of Holland. And basically, Ronaldo was saying that Holland needed this other amazing player on his team, that Ronaldo was able to make plays happen himself.
And he's like, dad, that was so obviously AI. He's like, he never said that. And I thought, wow, my impression of Ronaldo went way down. And I would have never known had I not had a 13-year-old who's much more technically literate than me. And when you think about the AI lollapalooza of disinformation that's going to happen around just making Biden and or Trump look like idiots, it's really frightening. And I think Taylor Swift, not so much her, but what's happened here is a real service. And I see the solution is again these platforms will claim complexity. And this isn't an issue. This isn't about the realm of the possible, it's about the realm of the profitable.
And if you were to do the following, this would all of a sudden, I don't want to say go away, but be diminished dramatically. And that is any AI generated content that is elevated algorithmically by the platform no longer has 230 protection. And all of a sudden they'd get all over this shit. Now they're just throwing up their arms as they've always done and said, you know, this is a complicated problem and we can't stop it. Sure they can. They have AI that can detect AI. And if you are putting out something that misleads people and whether it's an image, a pornographic image of them or them saying things they never said or leveraging IP you don't have rights to and your platform elevates it, which was the case in this instance, because everyone wanted to see pictures of Taylor Swift.
Boom, 230 no longer applies to you. And you're going to hear from Taylor's, Ms. Swift's lawyer. And guess what? These geniuses are going to fucking figure it out.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, she's the bad, wrong one. You need something to pull it into attention. There's been a bill, the bipartisan bill. It's called the Bipartisan AI Bill to Empower Parents and Hold Big Tech Accountable. It got blocked. They're trying to pass this bill where part of it is no Section 230 immunity for AI Act. There's a bunch of bills on this issue, and one is to block, Ted Cruz blocked Hawley's bill saying it would harm innovation. He's such an imbecile. But anyway, they are trying to pass this bill. And I think this could push it over the edge.
Scott Galloway
Right. Like it failed on a unanimous consent in December. I think it's going to come back. And I think things like this will make that happen.
Kara Swisher
Right. It just takes a little shove. And she's exactly the right. But so is the George Carlin thing. So is the Biden thing. They've got to all be disturbed.
Scott Galloway
Right. It's not just one part of it. But if you have more and more of these high profile things, it's very clear that one, they're going to have legal liability and two, there's going to be a federal law.
Kara Swisher
But I have been wrong before about these things. You know, I had hoped there'd be a privacy bill. Of course, there will be. And there's been one privacy disaster after the next, one hacking after the next, and it doesn't happen. But in this case, I think people understand it rather easily. I mean, I don't know. They really do.
Scott Galloway
Porn.
Kara Swisher
Oh, OK.
Scott Galloway
But this could get talking about porn and defects. This gets so ugly so fast. I constantly, my boys are sick of me lecturing. I'm like, if an attractive, if someone reaches out to you and accidentally via text message and starts a dialogue with you and pretends to be and portrays themselves as an attractive woman and then starts sending you pictures in exchange for pictures from you and they're like, yeah, we know dad, they've told us about it in school. What happens when you start getting AI generated messages from a cute girl in the eighth grade, asking you for those photos and sending her. I mean, this could just get so mendacious so fast. And the thing that really bothers me is, again, big tech is pretending they don't know how to stop this.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, yeah.
Scott Galloway
Shutting it down tells me all I need to know of search on her name. Like, that's their move. Like, that's their actual move. Because what they did is they got rid of their trust and safety. But they're going to see more and more like this. And if there's a legal liability around copyright, I mean, the Carlin thing, when I was listening to those guys, like, it's not an homage to steal your things. You know what I mean? I'm going to do an homage to Scott by living in his apartment or something. You know what I mean? Like, I think I'll just take his things, although I do do that. Where is this going?
Kara Swisher
No, I'm just saying it's like this is the next paintbrush. You can't take other people's things and make a paintbrush, like paint something from it. There's certain ways you can do that, right? In some, you know, people call it-
Scott Galloway
Well, Carlin's IP theft.
Kara Swisher
Yes, theft, it is. It's like music theft when they steal stems of music or things like that. I don't know why this is that complicated, but it will require people to do many, many lawsuits because this is so easy to do at this point. It's not even, you know, it's so easy to do. And the robocalls were, did you listen to them?
It was disturbing. Remarkable. Yeah. Remarkable, remarkable.
Scott Galloway
You know, do you get those? I don't get those, but I made the mistake. I don't say the mistake. I met Crystal Ball, who was running for Congress like 10 or 12 years ago. And I made a political donation to her and I did it online to the DNC. And now I get five times a day a message from my good friend Charles Schumer or from Jeffries or from some wonderful former Marine running for the third district in Kansas. And it's just, I get solicited so much. I just got one, Nikki Haley. I don't know how I got that. I guess I give money to Chris Christie, I guess. And they pretend like they're texting you personally, which I can't stand.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I know, yeah. Well, we'll see, this is going places and probably litigation rather quickly, but we'll see if Congress has the... they really should pass that law. Blumenthal and Cruz should get out of the way. Stop innovation. He's so bought and paid for by the tech companies. Anyway, let's go on a quick break. And we come back: media layoffs are just keep coming and coming, and billionaires who couldn't save the day. We'll speak with a friend of Pivot, Chris Dixon, about why he's advocating for crypto now more than ever.
Ad break
Scott, we're back. We're a month into 2024, and there's already been major layoffs at media outlets across the country, continuing an ongoing trend from last year or so and maybe the last decade. But this is a lot of them lately. A number of these publications were bought by billionaires over the last decade who were seen as financial white knights, but they haven'tt been able to stop the losses from racking up, nor do they care to pay for them. The layoffs are also triggering conflicts between unions and management. What a shock. And many employees walking off the job. "An ongoing bloodbath is decimating news outlets nationwide," is how Axios put it.
The Los Angeles Times cut its newsroom by more than 20% last week. Time laid off dozens, and Business Insider is letting go of 8% of its staff, to name a few examples. More importantly, an average of five local newspapers are closing every two weeks, and more than half of American counties now are so-called news deserts, according to Northwestern. This is an ongoing thing. You know, Jeff Bezos is losing money at the Washington Post. He just hired a new CEO who I met the other day. Quite impressive. LA Times owner, who I've also interviewed, Patrick Soon-Shiong, is at the helm of the LA Times.
He got into a weird fight with the editor, Kevin Merida, well-regarded, who left. Private equity and hedge funds are not doing much better. Alden Capital is having trouble at the New York Daily News. Scott, you've been on board. You were on the board of the New York Times. You and I have run media companies. I think it's the new normal, more of the same, and it's either big companies or little companies, right? Big companies or little ones like ourselves. What do you think?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, you're right. There's going to be a small number of big players, but even the big players are struggling. Gannett is having a tough time. You really have to have incredible size and be incredibly well-run, and it's still not a great business. And then there's the niche guys. There's the Pucks, the Semaphores, or you could argue Vox kind of owns podcasting, if you will, but they're still not very good businesses. They're okay businesses. They're profitable, small businesses. When you have a monopoly called search, that is essentially a toll booth for all information online, you know, 40 cents on the venture capital dollar, for many companies trying to acquire customers, goes to Amazon, Meta, or Google.
And so when you have, and these companies are growing 20% a year, so when you have 100 to 200 billion dollars a year coming out of the ecosystem... The companies that have succeeded over the last 10 years that have provided extraordinary returns to their shareholders have been asset light. "Hi, we're Nvidia, we just design chips, we don't build the billion dollar chip facility." "Hi, we're Uber, we don't want to actually be in the business of owning cars or maintaining them, we just create a thick layer of innovation on top of it." "Hi, we're Airbnb, we don't ever want to own apartments, we'll create a thick layer of innovation on top that uses fallow assets."
And to a certain extent, Google and Meta create a thick layer of innovation on top of other people's journalism, reporting, content creation, because that shit is hard.
Kara Swisher
Right.
Scott Galloway
And where I come back to, in a nod, I really like the BBC. And I think they get it wrong like every media company, but they mostly get it right, and their heart's in the right place. And I think there's something about the public service of long-form investigative journalism, where the reporter doesn't start with a viewpoint or think that, okay, I'm going to talk about one side or have a viewpoint, or I'm going to catastrophize because it'll get more clicks so we can sell more Nissan ads.
Kara Swisher
But that's cable. I don't think the Washington Post or the Los Angeles Times were doing that, and they're very excellent publications, but go ahead.
Scott Galloway
Are they subject to the whims of populists and produce shit solely based on clicks, or are they outstanding journalists? The answer is yes. There is no way you could argue these guys are immune from that.
Kara Swisher
They're not.
Scott Galloway
Yes, but listen, I don't mean to be rude, but I'm the person who's worked at all these places. And that is not the case at most big newspaper organizations I've worked with. It's not like, "let's do this, let's do that." I think you definitely see that in television, for sure. But it's not the case. I think one of the issues is what you said. And what's happened? But that clickbait thing is just bullshit. It just is. And what's happened to those organizations? They have, because people have shifted their tastes. People have... look, both the business model has been knocked out from under them for lots of reasons.
And it went back even further when Walmart didn't advertise, say, at the Washington Post and all the major department stores died. Then consumers got trained in a new way through search. And then people like new things. They're not making products people want. That's at the very heart of it. And even the big ones, like let me take the New York Times, for example, which is considered the most successful under Meredith Levy and who we had on the show. Look, their revenue for the quarter that ended September 2023, about $600 million. Really good. It was up 9, 10, almost 10%. Net income was 53.62, up 46%.
Really well done. It might be for various reasons. The profit margin, net profit margin was 9%. It's still $50 million dollars. It's not that much, a quarter, right? It's a small business. And that's the most successful one, right? Because she's added on not just crosswords, but Wordle and The Athletic and cooking and things like that. There are only a few people that can do that, and it's still not very big. And so I don't know. I think it's both: tastes have changed, practices have changed, the business model has changed, and these companies have not changed for the most part. They're run the same way that when I worked there 20 years ago or just recently at the New York Times.
So, the New York Times has 10 million subscribers. It's the best.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
It's the best in an important industry. And or should we say it's the best?
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
Okay. The premier, one of the premier, they are operating profit of 90 million and they have 10 million subscribers. Meta, 3 billion people on the platform. These companies, we can always highlight the one that is doing the least bad. But ad-supported journalism is really, really challenging to support a big newsroom and not be subject to the whims that you have been able to. You know, you talk about the Washington Post. Okay, I defer to your experience here that they don't go after clickbait and they're going to go out of business. So unless they keep finding benign billionaires that are distracted taking pictures of their girlfriend in thongs, I mean...
Kara Swisher
That could work. Just that could work.
Scott Galloway
And that strategy might work.
Kara Swisher
Because she wears a lot of thongs and she looks good in them.
Scott Galloway
But here's the bottom line. Every billionaire that does this, I always say billionaire Democrats buy newspapers and billionaire Republicans buy football teams. They're all going to start buying football teams because guess what? You get to enjoy the football team and 10 years later, it's tripled in value. You sort of enjoy a newspaper. You basically have unions and journalists berate you for not being willing to spend more and more of your money to support journalism. And then you get to sell it for nothing again, or go try and find someone to buy it from you for a dollar.
Kara Swisher
I want to just circle back to where I started. I believe that we should have, similar to what the UK does, revenue or some sort of tax that says, we're going to start an organization. I think we should have publicly funded news. Look, I just interviewed today Judy Woodruff, who has a great show about our problems as a nation, partisanship. And she, of course, was the head of the NewsHour for years. Excellent product. Talk about not clickbait. Just solid. And this, by the way, her show is fantastic. It's called "America at a Crossroads." It's fantastic. It's actually really well done. And it's just what you expect out of something like a PBS and Judy Woodruff. And you know, we talked about that issue of the politicization of PBS. Look, we got the right wing attacking it now for 20 years. "Let's defund it. Let's not give them any money." Now they get most of their money not from the government.
Scott Galloway
Right. It's for the Corporation for Public Broadcasting.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, exactly. But still, even the small amount they get, and it's... I forget what the numbers are and it's different from state to state, like some states funded. They're under constant and relentless attack by the right wing, which is trying to knock the knees out of it, right? Trying to knock it down so that they... they put them in a really bad position and then rely on the kindness of strangers to get a tote bag or whatever. So it's not like this country does not revere that public, even though, you know, what's interesting is that stuff is really popular, whether it's Sesame Street or the Antiques Show or Ken Burns.
That's what sort of carries it. And then you get this amazing NewsHour on top of it or Frontline. Let me, you know, I've told this story about my son. He watches Frontline just on YouTube, right? He loves Frontline. When I was with the Frontline people recently, I was like, "Oh, you watch PBS? I'm so happy and proud of my son." He's like, "I don't watch PBS." So it's really an interesting... so he doesn't hear any of those ads or he doesn't want a tote bag or anything else. He just gets it on YouTube. So even that's problematic. That's not going to happen in this country. It might happen in Britain.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. I mean, it's a fair point. I don't know what the answer is, but...
Kara Swisher
What would you do? Let me ask that. What's your advice to someone looking to pursue a career in journalism in 2024? Or the business part, the business. You do the business, I'll do the journalist part.
Scott Galloway
Well, I've told you my very reductive analysis. Focus on the screen size that you're creating content for. Go to a company that's outstanding at making content in the native form for a phone. And if it started somewhere else with a bigger screen, be careful. Native only phone content creation. Even as a business person, if you're going to go, you know, you want to be in publishing or whatever. The majority of NY Times employees are not in the newsroom. You want to... I mean, we always used to laugh at them when they used to come into the boardroom. They got no respect. It was like, "Oh, those whores that sell the ads," you know, like roll your eyes, right? I always liked them.
Kara Swisher
You can like them.
Scott Galloway
It's kind of like a Google when anyone who doesn't have an engineering background comes into the room. "These are the people we have to put up with." But I would say that media and content creation... and also I've always believed, try to move away from something that's not ad supported, that at least has at its core a subscription base. But I think media and storytelling and the ability to craft stories and tell them in a compelling way, and whether it's through subscriptions or sell ads against it, is an industry that's always going to be strong. It's a rewarding industry. You just want to, one, be producing content for a small screen, and I would have a bias towards something that has a very strong subscription base.
Kara Swisher
Subscription base, all right. For me, I would say, and I had a dinner, my dinner party, we discussed this because I think about it a lot. I think you have to be entrepreneurial as a reporter. You have to think about it. You have to think about doing something small because you can do very, very well. Like, whether it's me or Casey or Jessica Lessin, you could do very, very well financially and professionally if you have a small little outfit with costs that are in line with what you're making. Second thing is make stuff people want. Stop living in the same... don't assume they want what you're making at all the time. You are making a product. I hate to tell you, it's not a religion. You're not a priest. But you have to think of the consumer and the things they want.
Scott Galloway
Are you talking about clickbait here, Kara?
Kara Swisher
No, I'm not. No, I'm not. No, because let me... Heather Cox Richardson writes the most serious-minded stuff. She's making $5 million a year on her Substack or whatever she's making. It's huge because she's making something people want. And you would not call that clickbait if you've ever read it. So there's lots of ways to get at stuff that doesn't have to be clickbait 100%.
Scott Galloway
Well, I would absolutely, though, I would encourage people to go into a career in journalism because I think going to work for a newspaper or being an investigative or a long-form reporter... what I would argue is I don't think the Marines is a good career. I think it's a great place to go for a few years. And I think journalism... I think if you have the chops to figure out a way to be thoughtful about journalism, live up to those standards, fact check, be able to write something in a narrative form that's compelling, I think those skills... you might end up writing, you might end up being one of these whores that calls me every fucking 48 hours to have lunch with some fascinating big tech executive, but guess what? Those people make really good livings.
Kara Swisher
Oh, I know.
Scott Galloway
And so it's a great jumping off point. It's like when I went to Morgan Stanley and I was in the analyst program, the fixed income department, I hated it. It was awful, but I sure am glad I did it because I picked up a lot of skills. I think the ability to communicate, and when you learn how to write well, you're not learning how to write well. You're learning how to process, reason, and think well.
Kara Swisher
You are correct, sir. If I could give my kids anything... my kids over the weekend, we had one nice conversation. They're 13, they're 16. They asked me a question that just cracked me up. They were both talking. I came in and I said, "What's wrong?" And they said, "We just have a question for you." And I'm like, "Yeah." They go, look at me and they're very serious. I go, "What do you do?" I said to them, I said, "What I really do at the end of the day is tell stories. I'm a storyteller. I'm a communicator. And I'm in the media business, but my skill is I know how to communicate." And I wish I'd figured it out earlier.
I really enjoy podcasting. I really enjoy writing. I like writing books. I love presenting. I love speaking. And I said, "If you can figure out a way to tell stories, you're going to find a way to make a living." And they said, "Okay, what's the best training?" I'm like, "Neither of you are going to like this. You need to start writing." That's where it starts. That's where it starts. It's great writing. I hate to use an example, but Bezos in key meetings would have people write out their recommendations. He didn't want PowerPoint. He said, "You need to write it because you need to think about the words.
You need to think of the economy, the logic." There is something about the way the brain processes information. And also, I'll say, we talk about the medium is the message. When people approach you, they approach you based on the medium through which they're introduced to you. There's nothing that moves people like the written word.
Scott Galloway
That is true.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, we got to get to our friend of Pivot. Let's bring him in. Chris Dixon is the founder and managing partner of A16Z Crypto, Andreessen Horowitz's VC fund for crypto and Web3 startups. He's also the author of a new book, "Read, Write, Own: Building the Next Era of the Internet." We're having a lot of Silicon Valley people on of late. We had Aileen Lee on last week. Welcome, Chris.
Chris Dixon
Thanks, Kara.
Kara Swisher
So it's been a rough couple of years for crypto and blockchain, but you're still making a case for it in this book. Actually, Scott has, too, in a lot of ways. But why don't you explain why you're still a believer?
Chris Dixon
Yeah, sure. So, I mean, in the book, I try to explain what I would call the productive aspects of blockchain and why I think that blockchains can help us return the internet to its original ideals as being an open and democratic network, which is why I got involved. I've been involved in the internet for 25 years. I got excited by the early ideals of the internet. And look, if you fast forward to today, the internet has become very consolidated. The top five tech companies account for half of the NASDAQ 100 market cap. Top 1% of social networks, 95% of traffic. Google and Apple have a duopoly on mobile operating systems. I'm sure you both have talked about this plenty. I worry the internet's at risk of becoming like 70s broadcast TV or something where you have three channels. And I think that's bad for the world. I also think it's bad for our business. You know, we're in the startup business. We want a dynamic internet.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Well, one of the things you did is we just talked about that with AI and small companies, but you write about blockchain technology. And this is a quote from you: "This is a chance to create the internet you want, not the internet you inherited." It's something we talk about a lot, like that the same companies are in charge. What do you mean by that? When you say there's lots of opportunities for innovation here that starts from ground zero, presumably, versus starts with Google in charge or Microsoft or whoever?
Chris Dixon
Yeah. I mean, look, I think I'm guessing that we somewhat agree on the problem, meaning having five companies control everything is not ideal. I think there's different ways one could think about solving that. And so, for example, a lot of people talk about regulation. And I believe there is a role for regulation. I think we'll see what happens with DOJ and Apple and things like that. My proposal is to also try to do it through innovation. And through that, we want to create a new wave of internet services that return power to the edges of the network. And so to give you an example, one of the reasons that social networks are so powerful is you're locked in, right? They have network effects. So, you know, I think you switched recently to Threads. And when you did, you had to give up your audience, right? You had to build a new audience.
Kara Swisher
I'm still over there because I got there first, but go ahead.
Chris Dixon
Okay. So you maybe... maybe you're the exception. Most people have to.
Kara Swisher
I only use it for certain things.
Chris Dixon
But generally you're locked in, right? To these networks. So like, and especially if you're like a creator, for example, and you build a business on TikTok or Instagram, and you don't like the fact that they changed the algorithm or did some other thing, you're locked in. And so one of the key aspects, for example, in these new blockchain-based social networks, which is one category we're investing in, is a user owns his or her identity and they own their followers in the same way you do in the email world. Right? So if on email... if you have a newsletter on Substack and you don't like Substack, you can switch and you can take your followers with you.
So that's just one example of how a different architecture, by empowering users with ownership... this is the "own" and that's what I mean by ownership: the user controls their followers, not the service. That change in architecture, I believe, can have profound downstream consequences on the ultimate control of these services and the economics. And these networks, I don't think we knew this 10 or 15 years ago, but today we know they control the flow of global money, business, culture, politics. They're very, very important. And I don't think that having four or five people, whoever they might be, maybe at one point you like the management, at one point you don't.
I just am fundamentally against the idea that five people can control those things. I think that they should be more like the early web.
Scott Galloway
You're talking to people who like to own. Chris, good to see you. Do you remember we've met before?
Chris Dixon
When was that?
Scott Galloway
I'm not sure, but I think about 15, 18 years ago, you came and spoke to my class. At NYU?
Chris Dixon
Yeah. I was going to say maybe at NYU. Wow, okay.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. Well, anyways, good to see you again.
Chris Dixon
Sorry. Yeah, no, it's been a long time. Sorry.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. And this may be the wrong bucketing, but I think of blockchain in terms of front-facing applications as bucketed into three areas. There's the tokens, crypto, there's NFTs, and there's DAOs. DAOs haven't really gotten any traction. NFTs, I think, have lost 90 plus percent of their value. I think I'm being generous there. And the token market's been kind of, loosely speaking, in terms of market cap, been cut in half, even with its resurgence from its peak. Like, talk about those three categories and where do you see the opportunity?
Chris Dixon
Yeah. So I think with DAOs, so a couple of things. Like, I mean, there are active DAOs. A lot of them are around these DeFi protocols. So, for example, Uniswap and Compound and Maker are... what's interesting about them is they're networks in the same way that Facebook is a network, but the users control those networks. And those are networks that have active... Uniswap had trillions of dollars in trading volume and the users decide how to upgrade the code. Admittedly, that is early. Those are experiments. In my book, I have a section on what I call network governance where I talk about this. And my argument is essentially that it's a very powerful new way to design community-governed systems. I don't claim that we've fully figured it out. I think that it requires a lot more work to evolve. The NFT standard was finalized in 2020. Then we had this big rise in the market. Last year, in 2023, there were $8.6 billion in NFT sales. So I think the decline has been exaggerated.
Scott Galloway
But how much of that $8.6 billion do you think is false flags, is people trying to pump up the volume?
Chris Dixon
Well, that, according to... we have a data science team and I asked them to pull these numbers and they believe that's removing wash trading, if that's what you're referring to.
Scott Galloway
Got it, thank you, that's a better term.
Chris Dixon
So they do believe that, but look, admittedly, it's hard to get the exact numbers, but I think that's a pretty accurate number. And so the... so NFTs, and look, I think NFTs went through... the way I kind of look at these things is like the internet. We all, I think, lived through the internet bubble, right? I kind of began my real career post-internet when everyone thought the internet was over. And the way I view it is a lot of these new technologies go through these cycles where people get overly optimistic. And I think that probably happened with NFTs. And now I believe they're overly pessimistic. And now I think is the sort of the real building time, sort of like...
Kara Swisher
Let me ask you about that because you talk about the casino culture of crypto, which has become the dominant narrative and obviously the Binance thing, Sam Bankman-Fried, et cetera. Talk about the less nefarious side and what about the impact of those cases? The casino stuff, yeah.
Chris Dixon
Yeah. And also the SEC did approve Bitcoin ETFs a few weeks ago. The price of Bitcoin has been falling. So overall, it's sort of in that moment. And I would agree with you. There was a lot of real scammy stuff at the beginning of the internet for those who weren't there. And it went on for quite a while, actually. But talk about sort of that, how to shed it, because I think people think of it now with FTX, even though they made a great investment in Anthropic, it was mostly not a good story for crypto.
Yeah, look, it's been... I mean, in my book, I have a long section where I talk about this, what I call the casino, and I'm, again, very against it. And I think it's destructive. I think it's destructive primarily to consumers who are victims of things like FTX. But I also think it's quite destructive to what I'm trying to work on, which is to build a productive side of these technologies. But look, the way I would describe it is a blockchain is a tool, tokens are a tool, right? And just like any tool, a hammer can build or a hammer can destroy. And there's two sides to the tool. And I think there's been a lot of attention paid to the casino aspect.
There are, you know, like we have dozens of startups in our portfolio who are working on the productive side. And the reason I wrote the book partly was to tell that story because I do think it's a bigger story than people realize. I also think that we need more proactive policy. We've been calling for this for years, since before FTX, to put guardrails around the casino stuff, to eliminate the offshore activity. I mean, the reason we were not investors in FTX is I was involved with Coinbase for years. Coinbase, contrary to, I think, some popular perception, was heavily regulated. Their Bank Secrecy Act regulated.
They do full KYC on all their customers. There's a whole series of regulations. They're audited. They're a public U.S. company. Binance, FTX, there's a whole series of companies that were offshore, not audited, all these other kinds of... you know, all these running exotic products. I mean, that's the kind of stuff that I think we need to clean up and have very clear rules.
Kara Swisher
Well, what about the Bitcoin ETF? It does sort of introduce consumers to it in a safer feeling way. You know, if I'm getting it from Fidelity, I certainly trust them more than even Coinbase.
Chris Dixon
Yeah. And I think the Bitcoin ETF was a... I mean, in my mind, it's a net positive in the sense of it's sort of more institutional acceptance.
Kara Swisher
Oh, you say net positive. What's the negative?
Chris Dixon
No, it's good. Sorry. I mean, it's good overall. I look, I'm very focused on the utility side of building applications. And so it's a new financial instrument. So for me, it's less of a focus. That's what I mean. And it's just not, like, I would love for some more of the news cycles to be focused on, hey, this person just came up with a cool new way to fight deepfakes. This person just came up with a cool new business model for creative people.
I think specifically with the rise of AI, I see a lot of blockchain applications as the countermeasure in many ways. So, like, just to go back to maybe if I could talk about the deepfakes for a second. We're now going to have an internet awash with fake video, awash with very advanced phishing.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, we have it, actually.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, we probably have it.
Kara Swisher
No, talk to Taylor Swift this week.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, Taylor Swift. You can simulate people's voices perfectly now. They can take your voice from the podcast.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, they can then call.
Scott Galloway
I actually had a partner, Martine, who they called. Someone called his parents using his voice to try to get money. This is actually a real thing happening.
Chris Dixon
And so in that world, we need to use tools like cryptography to authenticate things. I think, for example, one way to do that is, one thing a blockchain is very good at doing is storing an immutable audit trail. So you can have an immutable audit trail that says this video is attested to by—it came from Kara Swisher and it was attested to her buyer, as an example. And so it gives you this ground truth in a world in which you lose that.
I think also blockchains allow for new business models for creative people in a world where generative AI will put significant downward pressure on the ability for, let's say, an illustrator to sell things. If you can just go to a Midjourney or something. And so I think it becomes more important in an AI world.
Scott Galloway
So when I think about the consumer-facing technologies that have built so much value in tech, and I think about the leadership there, I think about the original gangsters, I think about Gates and Jobs and then the new guys, and they were all guys, Brin, Page, Bezos. Say what you will about them, they were all visionaries. And I would argue at their core, they were all—I'll go out on a limb—I think they're good people.
And the two kind of iconic figures in blockchain are either in jail or going to jail. And my question is, who's the next generation of leadership that you would point to that will, quite frankly, just sort of clean this mess up? Because right now, from a public perception standpoint, it feels like a levered Ponzi scheme.
Chris Dixon
I think there's just two very different worlds, Scott. So I think there's the SBF world, and then I think there's people like Vitalik Buterin and Ethereum. There's a very earnest, serious, thoughtful—
Scott Galloway
You mentioned Brian Armstrong.
Chris Dixon
Brian got flack for years for being slow. I mean, their market share got to low single digits. They were getting crushed by Binance and FTX. If you talk to any Silicon Valley VC, it was like, why is Coinbase so slow? Stocks aren't crazy. They're doing really well. And Brian kept—I think what he did was admirable. He really kept his head down. He never changed what he does. He invests very heavily in security and compliance. And he hasn't gotten all the market share yet, but I think that approach has proven correct.
I think Brian has done a great job. I think there's folks like Vitalik and there's a lot more. Look, there's these conferences like you go to DevCon, it's an Ethereum conference, and there's tens of thousands of very earnest, thoughtful technologists. And it feels to me kind of like, I don't know, 2005 Web 2.0 movement when I was part of that. And you go to these things and yeah, and look, they weren't—I mean, like you never know who the Larry Page is at the time. I mean, obviously, Larry Page is brilliant and everything else. I didn't know him then. But over time these folks will emerge.
And I do think there is a very strong, productive, positive movement that just gets crowded out by all of the coverage of the casino stuff. But I think it very much exists. And that's why I wanted to write the book. I wanted to go through in detail and explain this and make the case and show that this exists.
Kara Swisher
Let me ask that then. I was just looking at Coinbase stock, which is up recently, but it's certainly down from 2022, like quite a bit, or 2021, especially when it was in the—what is it, two, I was 332 and then it's now 131. It was down in the 80s and 70s and stuff like that. You know, Scott called Coinbase the AOL of crypto. Is that a good thing?
Scott Galloway
No, I don't think so.
Kara Swisher
It was for a while. It was a great thing for a while. It was great till it wasn't. Yeah. But it has been around for a while. And does it have to be mainstream? Because AI suddenly is everywhere mainstream. It seems ubiquitous everywhere. Does it have to be mainstream or just where the electricity, where the—I don't know—the drywall or whatever?
Chris Dixon
In my book, I analogize blockchains to steel in the sense of like it's a building material. Because people sometimes say, what problem does it solve? And I really see it as a building material for building better internet services. So I think ultimately, if the movement that I'm part of succeeds, it won't be—some parts of it will be visible. The fact that you can, hey, there's a social network where I can exit. There's a—I can sell digital merchandise as a musician directly to my fans. Like you'll see parts of it, but you won't see all the plumbing. And I think most of the plumbing is behind the scenes.
And by the way, it may happen with AI too. Maybe AI is just sort of baked into everything. I think it's probably a likely outcome. AI feels more like the internet, right? It feels more like a web or something like that.
Kara Swisher
But if people wanted to get into crypto right now, where would you tell them to start?
Chris Dixon
Yeah, I mean, I think there's a lot. So some examples of things I'm excited by. We have a few things around music. So there's a project called SoundXYZ where musicians—musicians today don't make money on the internet. They make very little money on streaming. A lot of them, if you ask them, will say they go offline and they tour and they sell merchandise to support themselves. And so there's various projects like SoundXYZ that let musicians sell backstage passes and digital merchandise to their consumers and add an additional income stream. So that's one interesting area.
There's a social network called Farcaster that's a lot like something like Twitter or Facebook, except the user controls their name and their followers and can move around and developers can hack on it. Kara, you remember early Twitter, how it became like a developer platform?
Kara Swisher
It did. I was very excited by Twitter at that point. I was at that conference. Do you remember when they had that? I think you and I probably intersected. I used to blog about that stuff. I went back when I read the book and looked at it, like a lot of my blog posts were about that. I was a developer.
Chris Dixon
I was very excited by that. So Farcaster has a sort of active developer—
Kara Swisher
Then they killed you.
Chris Dixon
Then they killed you off.
Kara Swisher
They killed everybody.
Chris Dixon
They killed everybody. So those are two examples. Look, there's also stablecoins that are quite popular in the developing world. There were something like $600 billion in stablecoin transactions last month. So there are also other—as I mentioned, NFTs are, I think, bigger than people realize.
Kara Swisher
Which is the original, right? That was the original.
Chris Dixon
Yeah, there's a bunch of interesting games that are launching. Like we have one, it's sort of a Zynga-style game called Pirate Nation, where you have NFTs as digital collectibles. Eve Online, the popular video game, they're launching an NFT version soon, which lets you have more of a peer-to-peer economy where users can create spaceships and sell them to other users.
So I think there's a really interesting wave of new companies that are much more accessible. Blackbird is one in New York where it's a restaurant. It's actually the founder of Resy and Eater, Ben Leventhal. You may know him.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I know.
Chris Dixon
He's an experienced entrepreneur. So he's doing an NFT. It's like a restaurant thing where you can use NFTs as a way to reward loyal patrons. So I feel like we're coming out of the downturn. It feels to me like a lot of people are saying, hey, we got to really level up our game and have really great product experiences. And we're seeing an exciting wave. And I'm excited about it.
Scott Galloway
I actually have two questions. One, there was a fear that a lot of these crypto projects were essentially VCs financing a group of intelligent guys who had found something they claimed was new technology. The VC fund would lend its brand, its capital, and create this project. They'd issue a coin and then, leveraging the FOMO of mainstream Americans who wanted to participate in what was hot, they'd then buy these coins. And because there's no SEC requirements on lockups or even disclosing when you sell these coins, these VCs would basically dump their entire stake. And that these projects were not financing any sort of growth or underlying technology. They were essentially just an elegant transfer of wealth from mainstream investors to the limited partners of VCs. Do you think there's any truth to those claims?
Chris Dixon
I think it's possible. I think that, look, I mean, I would just say that one of our core—probably the number one thing that we have asked for and pushed for in policy for years is longer lockups. Okay. So we have 10-year—we're a venture fund. All of our funds are venture funds, including the crypto funds. They have a 10-year life cycle. We push for long lockups in the deals we do, but we don't have unlimited market power. If we push too hard, they will do a deal with somebody else. Right.
And so I think the number one thing that the policymakers could do to improve the space would be long lockups on every project, because I believe in that. Real technology takes years to build and you need to avoid that.
Scott Galloway
But Andreessen hasn't been subject to these lockups or self-imposed them.
Chris Dixon
In all the deals we do, we have multi-year lockups. And moreover, we have—
Kara Swisher
I'm sorry, I just want to clarify this. When you invest in a crypto project and there's a coin issued, you have a self-imposed lockup when you can sell those coins?
Chris Dixon
The lockup's in the term sheet. It's a term in the term sheet, yeah. We do and the founders do.
Kara Swisher
So the crypto projects you funded in the last few years, you have not sold coins, you still own those coins?
Chris Dixon
We have 94% of the coins that we bought, we hold in all our crypto funds today.
Scott Galloway
So wouldn't that indicate that Andreessen has taken an enormous drawdown or loss on these projects, given what's happened in the crypto market?
Chris Dixon
I mean, we're RIA, I'm not allowed to talk about our returns, but I mean, we have 94% of our tokens.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I mean, I think that's a venture capital—it's a highly volatile market.
Chris Dixon
Right.
Scott Galloway
And then my last case is just give us what you feel is the most compelling use case for consumers or enterprise. Say, it doesn't even have to be now, but in three years, what do you think the use cases are? Outside of speculation.
Chris Dixon
Look, so in my—sorry to keep pushing my book—but I have seven sections at the end of the book where I go through seven deep areas of use cases. And I talk about social networking. I talk about finance. I talk about media businesses like NFT media businesses.
Let me give you one kind of flavor of a cool idea that I like. One of the sections is an area called collaborative storytelling. It's a kind of Wikipedia-style thing where internet fans get together and create narrative universes like the next Harry Potter and the next Marvel. And they get rewarded with tokens proportionate to their contribution. And then the narrative universes they create can then be licensed and made into movies and comic books and other kinds of things. That's a cool new idea that just sort of couldn't exist before you had crypto.
But there's just a bunch of—there's games. I have a section on games in the metaverse. I think that very clearly we're going to have the so-called metaverse. I know it's jargony, but it is a thing that's going to happen. And I'm not talking just strictly about VR headsets. I'm talking about people spending more time in 3D worlds through video games and things like this. We're going to have more and more people in 3D worlds. They're more persistent. It becomes a bigger part of our lives.
And I think an important question is how is that metaverse structured? Is it structured with one company owning it? Does Fortnite own it? Or is it structured like the web? Where there's a bunch of different—like it's an open system and you can add a component to it. That's another important area that I'm focused on.
I think, as I mentioned before, in a world of generative AI, let's talk about your business, the media business. The internet has operated on an implicit covenant between distribution, like search engines and social networks and websites, right? What happens in a world where you go to a ChatGPT and you just get an answer? You don't have to click through anymore. So we're very soon entering a world where you don't click through anymore and you don't go—I mean, I was on the board of Stack Overflow for years. Stack Overflow data was used to train a lot of these systems and now Stack Overflow's traffic is way down, right? So how do we train, how do we create content in the future? How do we reward content creators?
So I have a section in the book on this about different things people are working on and ideas for new ways to use blockchains to create business models in a world of AI systems that are protectable. They're protectable lawsuits first and then we'll do that.
Kara Swisher
But one of the last things—I'm sorry, I just noticed Larry Fink, who was a big detractor of Bitcoin and stuff, of course, has done an about-face and is calling himself a big believer. Of course, they filed paperwork for an ETF at BlackRock. So I think the finance stuff and the speculation, it might be a little calmer with these new—it's part of that.
Chris Dixon
It'll be part of that, presumably.
Kara Swisher
That will still—I know you're not in that area, you're in the tools part—but as a speculative tool of ownership, I think this will change it quite a bit, a lot of people feel like.
Chris Dixon
Yeah, I think the sort of institutional—and then they limiting—yeah, the institutional people are really piling in a lot more because it feels safer. And that makes sense. That makes sense from a lot of perspectives.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, really fascinating book actually. And we love to own, Chris. We owners. And you know, I am tired of selling my stuff to other people. Anyway, again, Chris Dixon, he's one of my favorite venture capitalists, and that's a very short list. And the book is *Read, Write, Own: Building the Next Era of the Internet*. It's really worth your while to read it. Thanks, Chris.
Scott Galloway
Thanks, Chris.
Chris Dixon
Good to see you again. Thank you both for having me.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, thanks, Scott.
Scott Galloway
Thanks, Kara.
Kara Swisher
All right, Scott, I like having smart VCs on our program. We've had two in a row. I like them.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, it's more important they have good hair. He had good hair, so well done.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, you like his hair. You're always liking their hair. Anyway, one more quick break, we'll be back for Wins and Fails.
Break
Okay, Scott, let's hear some Wins and Fails. Would you like to go first or would you like me to?
Scott Galloway
Go ahead.
Kara Swisher
Okay, I got to say E. Jean Carroll. Good for her. Keep going, you know, sister. Go ahead, sister. You do it. It's like, you know, the fortitude to keep doing this amid all the attacks and his behavior was so heinous for the actual act. And then he continued. He's not changed his stripes. And I thought for her to do this is something else. And Robbie Kaplan, too, the lawyer, did an astonishing job. And it was in such deep contrast to Trump's lawyers who possibly—it was like she got them at lawyers or us. It was really amazing, the stick-to-itiveness. And I think she's going to keep sticking to it.
In my fail, if you've read, there's a great story in The Cut this week about Cecile Richards, who used to run Planned Parenthood. She has brain cancer, but she's doing all kinds of things. I've interviewed her. She was at Code in 2017, really a great leader on abortion rights. Also, she's still continuing. She's actually doing a chatbot called Charlie about good abortion rights information. She's still fighting. Brain cancer is a very serious illness she has. She seems to be doing okay, but it's still tough. What a wonderful—she's the daughter of Ann Richards, who I also revere. And just a really great person, one of these people that make a difference. And I really hope for her. It's not a fail, but I hope it's a fail that she has to suffer this, but I hope for her continued health.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, 100%. I like both of those. So my fail is five elite U.S. universities—Brown, Columbia, Duke, Emory, and Yale—have agreed to pay $105 million to settle a lawsuit accusing them of weighing an applicant's ability to pay in their decision process. The plaintiffs described the schools as a price-fixing cartel. Yeah, you think? No, we all just accidentally raise our prices 4.5% or 6% a year in lockstep with each other.
Highly selective U.S. universities have long benefited from exemption from federal antitrust laws when sharing formulas to measure prospective students' financial needs under the condition that their admissions processes need to be need-blind, meaning they could not factor in whether a prospective student was wealthy enough to pay. The schools did not admit any wrongdoing. You know how you get your kid into school? There's a little box in most applications that says, "If you check this box, you will never ask for nor accept financial aid." We have become such fucking whores instead of public servants.
Kara Swisher
Wow. Okay. All right.
Scott Galloway
We are the administrative bloat, right? And who pays for all of that? Kids who have some nice lady in a pantsuit with a big logo behind them telling them it's your parent's dream. It's worth it. Education is the best return. Just sign here. And then they get debt, unlike any other debt, is not dischargeable. And there's no competition to lower prices because we're all in the business of price fixing.
And we've talked a lot about this rejectionist bullshit culture. We take so much pride in rejecting 90-plus percent of our applicants. But the other way we sequester access to Americans, good kids, is by making it just unaffordable with all this ridiculous bloat and also this price fixing. Because at the end of the day, don't kid yourself. We're not nonprofits. We are in the business of money.
We absolutely need to hit these guys hard. We need more competition. They should not be subject to nonprofit status. They should not get government funding unless they grow their freshman class sizes faster than inflation. And there needs to absolutely be antitrust to go in and look at the price fixing here.
And you want to talk about starting a kid off. We have the most anxious and depressed generation in history, kids, young adults under the age of 30. And one of the ways we put them on the path to this anxiety and depression-filled life is we say, okay, we're going to decide that you failed as a parent unless you send your kid to college. And the kid works his ass off, but maybe isn't really cut out for college. Two-thirds of kids don't end up with a traditional four-year degree. Some kids just aren't cut out for college, but you failed as a parent or a kid if you don't go.
So the kid tries to go to college, doesn't get into one of these rejectionist elite colleges, gets arb'd down to a second-tier college. But oh, because of the cartel, you're paying a Mercedes price for a Hyundai product. After two years, it's obvious the kid wasn't cut out for college, leaves, but he or she doesn't get to leave the debt. And guess what? The school doesn't care. They got the cash to check. They're not on the hook for that bad debt.
Kara Swisher
Scott is on a roll. Yep.
Scott Galloway
And you end up with a 20-year-old that has nothing, has no certification, no job prospects, but they got $100,000 in debt.
Kara Swisher
I like this effort by you. I like it. All right. What's your win then?
Scott Galloway
Sorry, I was being very indignant there.
Kara Swisher
I love your indignancy. Someone said that to me. "Scott mad about colleges," right? And I like—
Scott Galloway
We're good. I don't want you to keep going.
Kara Swisher
Yes. Yes.
Scott Galloway
I'm inside the bowels of this place. If we gave the admissions directors and the chancellors of some of these universities an enema, we could bury them in a fucking shoebox. They're so full of shit.
Kara Swisher
Okay. All right. Let's end on a positive note. That was good. That was good. Okay. So my win is *Ted*, the series. Have you seen it?
Scott Galloway
*Ted Lasso*?
Kara Swisher
Well, you know Ted. No, no. *Ted*, the movie.
Scott Galloway
Oh, they did. I haven't seen it.
Kara Swisher
It's Seth MacFarlane.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. He's so great.
Kara Swisher
Who is a genius.
Scott Galloway
Genius. He's a *Family Guy* genius. That guy's a genius. That guy deserves to be a billionaire.
Kara Swisher
I think he does okay.
Scott Galloway
Oh, my gosh.
Kara Swisher
Anyways, *Ted*, I've been watching with my 13-year-old, hashtag inappropriate. It is so funny, so inappropriate, and in its own way, occasionally, accidentally dips into being somewhat sentimental and kind of moving.
Scott Galloway
It is. He can be.
Kara Swisher
This guy and this show and the actors are wonderful. The kid is wonderful. And what I will say is if you have a teenage boy and a teenage girl, too, it's such a fun way. It's such a fun series. It's a dirty show, but funny.
Scott Galloway
It really is dirty.
Kara Swisher
I want to be clear. I'm not endorsing watching it with your 13-year-old. You know what happened to me is I let Louis watch it when he was, I don't know, 10 or 12 or whatever, mistake. And then Alex would sit around the corner and watch it. And he always goes, "The reason I'm the way I am is because you let me watch *Ted*." But I didn't know he was sneaking it. It's not violent. There's no real sex in it. It's just crude. There's a lot of plushy penis stuff. And anyway, I get it. It's delightful.
Scott Galloway
He's a delightful, delightful man, Seth MacFarlane, and deserves every ounce of money he gets for his wonderful creations. I mean, I get so—I'd steal other people's humor. I just, the lines just—if I go to—"This guy doesn't want to go into an office, like if I go to an office, who will let the mailman in to pee?" "I had a vasectomy after my testicles look like a frog holding its breath." The writers on this show are just—"Let's take Sharpies and circle the parts on each other's bodies that need improvement." I mean, these guys are so—
Kara Swisher
It is such a show for Scott.
Scott Galloway
All I want is whatever they're smoking.
Kara Swisher
All right. Good.
Scott Galloway
These guys are so good. Anyways, it relieves me. It relieves me from mendacious fucks posing as good people that are our university leadership. Is *Ted*. Be Seth. Don't be university shitheads of universities. Be Seth. A profane series.
Kara Swisher
All right. We want to hear from you. Send us your questions about business, tech, or whatever's on your mind. Go to nymag.com slash pivot to submit a question for the show or call 855-51-PIVOT and watch a dirty show with your teen. That's what we recommend here on our show. Scott, that's the show. We'll be back on Friday for more. Read us out.
Scott Galloway
Today's show was produced by Lara Naiman, Zoe Marcus, and Taylor Griffin. Ernie Intertide engineered this episode. Thanks also to Drew Burrows and Mia Silverio. Nishat Kerouac is Vox Media's executive producer of audio. Make sure you subscribe to the show wherever you listen to podcasts. Thanks for listening to *Pivot* from New York Magazine and Vox Media. You can subscribe to the magazine at nymag.com slash pod. We'll be back later this week for another breakdown of all things tech and business. Kara, I will see you later in the week.