The main topic of this podcast episode is a mix of various business and technology-related discussions, including a conversation with Ruth Ben-Ghiat, a professor of history at NYU and author of "Strongmen: Mussolini to the Present."
Key points from the episode include:
Participants in the episode include:
Takeaways from the episode include:
Kara Swisher
As marketing channels have multiplied, the demand for content has skyrocketed. But everyone can make content that's on brand and stands out with Adobe Express. You don't have to be a designer to generate images, rewrite text, and create effects. That's the beauty of generative AI that's commercially safe. Teams all across your business will be psyched to collaborate and create amazing presentations, videos, social posts, flyers, and more. Meet Adobe Express, the quick and easy app to create on-brand content. Learn more at adobe.com slash express slash business.
Ad break
Rinse takes your laundry and hand delivers it to your door. Expertly cleaned and folded. So you could take the time once spent folding and sorting and waiting to finally pursue a whole new version of you. Like Tea Time You. Mmm. Or this Tea Time You. Or even this Tea Time You. Said you hear about Dave. Or even Tea Time, Tea Time, Tea Time You. Mmm. So update on Dave. It's up to you. We'll take the laundry. Rinse. It's time to be great.
Ad break
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And I'm Scott Galloway.
Kara Swisher
And you've been gloat-trotting, haven't we?
Scott Galloway
We have been. Except you keep working. You keep working.
Kara Swisher
I know. So I was in Argentina with Louie, which I did a podcast while you were away with Lydia, Dick Polgreen, and John Favreau, and Louie. But I'm back in D.C.
Scott Galloway
You know, I hate culture, but I feel like every once in a while I need to do something cultural for the kids.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. And for you.
Scott Galloway
So I took the boys to Egypt and went with a – by the way, if you ever get a family you can travel with where everyone gets along, you got to hold on to those people. So we went with the Bjornsons who are this wonderful, lovely family.
Kara Swisher
Oh, it wasn't the Galloways?
Scott Galloway
No, we're the dysfunctional family. When they recede to their cabins at night, they thank God that they are who they are as opposed to us. But we did one of these flat river cruises where you stop every day with an archaeologist who takes you on a tour of the Sphinx or a crypt.
Kara Swisher
Oh my God. How was it?
Scott Galloway
You know, look, civilization and time and a lot of the stuff that, quite frankly, I think about is really brought home when you go through Egypt. And the thing I register is that my kids didn't enjoy it, but they're going to really enjoy it when they're older. They're going to look back on it.
Kara Swisher
Oh, why didn't they?
Scott Galloway
Because no video games. They're so twitchy not being on their devices. And you could tell they're kind of bored three hours into the tour of the inside of a pyramid or whatever. You can just see them getting kind of twitchy. But I just know when they're older, they're going to – don't you think some things you enjoy more after they've happened?
Kara Swisher
I had pretty good travelers as a kid. Louie and Alex really went across the world, especially with Megan, who we work for Google. So she took them everywhere. They met the Dalai Lama at one point. So they had kind of a different—
Scott Galloway
Well, you know, there's a word for people who get audience with the Dalai.
Kara Swisher
Who?
Scott Galloway
Rich. It means you're rich, Kara.
Kara Swisher
She was with Google.
Scott Galloway
Oh, okay.
Kara Swisher
She was a work thing.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, see above: rich.
Kara Swisher
No, but it wasn't personal. It was work stuff.
Scott Galloway
He just admired your spiritual aura? He needed to meet with you?
Kara Swisher
No, whatever. I don't know why she was with the Dalai Lama. I have no idea. But in any case, she would go to a lot of cool places. She went all over Africa with Google because she ran google.org. So they went all over Africa, all over the world. She'd often take the children, who we would pull out of school and thought it was a good idea. At one point, Alex had been to so many countries. It was crazy. It was more than I've been. And someone was like, "Little boy, have you ever traveled anywhere interesting?" And he was like, "I've been to 65 countries. And I met the Dalai Lama."
Scott Galloway
Oh, that's so Alex.
Kara Swisher
He liked that stuff. He liked all of it. And so did Louis.
Scott Galloway
I've been pheasant hunting with Mandela. How about you, bitch?
Kara Swisher
No, no, no. They didn't do that. They did not do that. Although one time, Megan was on a plane. They were going to Fez. This was a Google trip. It was with Larry and Sergey and a whole gang of them. And they were going to see Bono. My kids did not go on this trip, but Megan was going on it. And they wouldn't let me on the Google plane because Larry Page was like, "Well, you can look at it."
Scott Galloway
I wanted to see it.
Kara Swisher
And they're like, "You can look at it, but you can't say anything." And I said, "I can't promise that."
Scott Galloway
That's literally what every woman I've gotten naked says to me. "You can look, but you can't touch."
Kara Swisher
Oh my God, that was good.
Scott Galloway
That is impromptu porn humor. Sorry, go ahead.
Kara Swisher
So they wouldn't let me get on it. I had dropped Megan off. They wouldn't let me see it because I would talk all about it, of course, because I wish I could to this day talk about what was on the Google plane, but I never was allowed on it. And then they were saying they had bought these really early carbon credits. They were into buying carbon credits. And he was explaining it to me in detail, Larry Page, about the carbon credits. Because they were going to fly around Kilimanjaro to see it from the air, to see the problems of climate change by flying around it. And I literally was like, "But we're buying carbon credits to make it better?" I was like, "Why don't you just not fly over Kilimanjaro to do so?"
Scott Galloway
But that's what they were doing. They were circling it.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, they were circling it. Well, so where did you go after that?
Scott Galloway
I went to Israel.
Kara Swisher
And?
Scott Galloway
Well, one, I talk a lot. One of the many things I don't like about myself is I virtue signal a lot. I talk about doing shit and I don't do it. So on the six-month anniversary of the attack – anniversary is the wrong word – six-month marker, I decided to go to Israel. Well, I went to the Nova Music Festival Memorial. I'm sure that'll become a memorial. It already is. And then I went to – let me start with the good stuff. Tel Aviv, as anyone who's been there, it's a cross between Miami and Berlin. It's a wonderful city. It's distinctive. However you feel about the situation, it's a fantastic city. I would have dinner, and someone overheard that I was visiting from America, and like 11 people got up and waited in line just to shake my hand and say thank you for coming. They're just so grateful that you're visiting. They're having trouble getting people there. So it was very meaningful.
Kara Swisher
Right.
Scott Galloway
I went into the Gaza envelope. I took a tour of Kibbutz Faraza, which was one of two kibbutzes that was attacked. That was obviously very heavy and very upsetting. They have pictures of the kids and the people who were murdered. So that was very heavy and very upsetting. And then I went to – I did weird stuff. I went to the crossing where the convoys of the humanitarian aid trucks are crossing. There's a narrative that Israel is – for a lot of reasons, or falsely in my view – there's an impression that they're not providing humanitarian aid. And there's literally – I stopped and took pictures of this convoy that was over a mile long. And to be fair, the Gulf Nations, Qatar, UAE, and the Kingdom are supplying a lot of the materials. But the amount of food and aid that is going into Gaza right now is just staggering. Not enough, and obviously the Jose Andres situation. But the question is where it's going, what happens when it gets there. But that's another talk show.
Kara Swisher
Right.
Scott Galloway
I say this without getting too deep into the arguments around this: it was just very rewarding. People know where I stand on the issue, but I wanted to do more than just talk about it. I wanted to go. So, yeah, it was very rewarding, but very, obviously, as you can understand, very heavy and upsetting at the same time. And also, while I was there, there are huge protests against Netanyahu. I mean, huge protests. But also, I said, "I'm going to come back. When should I come back?" And they said, "You should absolutely come back." I forget what they call it. But the gay pride parade there, they say, is the best time in Tel Aviv. It's one of the biggest gay pride parades in the world. But it's a very progressive, interesting place right now. Anyway, I was happy to go there.
Kara Swisher
Well, we'll see how progressive. I think it's a very complex situation. Obviously, Netanyahu is unpopular. He'd lose the election today from what I was reading over the weekend. At the same time, he's not going to call elections. And there remains all these vexing issues. And this bombing of this aid convoy from World Central Kitchen certainly has caused a lot of rancor in this country, at least, and across the world. So it continues to be a vexing situation politically and obviously for the people on the ground there. But hopefully it will – even Trump has moved away from total support, which is interesting. I don't know if you noticed. He said they have a PR problem, et cetera.
Scott Galloway
Well, I mean, good or bad, democracies wag the dog here. That is the elections. Biden's softening his stance because, quite frankly, I think he's worried about Michigan. And I think Trump sees an opportunity.
Kara Swisher
Oh, I think he might just be. Trump is also softening his stance.
Scott Galloway
Well, Biden's rhetoric has changed a little bit.
Kara Swisher
It sure has.
Scott Galloway
I'm of the view that the best way to end a war is to win it. I don't think they should be calling for a ceasefire. I think they should be calling for unconditional surrender and release of the hostages. And I just have a different view than a lot of people, especially young people on this. And we can have a civil conversation as you and I do, and discuss it. But I don't see how – and I'll be honest with you, Kara – I think a lot of it is optics. I think the U.S., which has its own history with terrorists, and even the Gulf nations who have been eerily quiet on this, understand Israel's right to exist. When Secretary of Defense Austin is meeting with the Israeli Defense Forces about them going into Rafah, I think a lot of this is optics. I think the U.S. recognizes that this current situation is unsustainable. If Israel took over the U.S., it'd be business as usual. If Hamas and—
Kara Swisher
Yes, I understand. I get that. I get that. I'm just saying things are changing in terms of our relationship with Israel. You and I, for all intents and purposes, don't matter. It's the next generation, which has changed rather drastically. And that's just true. It's just the way it is. And I don't think they're doing themselves any favors by – it's the same thing we didn't do ourselves any favors by going into Iraq. Because it was a disproportionate response. That's the argument, right?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I think so. I think so. Yeah.
Kara Swisher
But there's a lot to get to today. We should have a longer debate about this and bring actual experts in. But I definitely think just talking to young people – I've spent a lot of time with young people, even just in Argentina – they have a point of view that has changed drastically, I think. Anyway, we've got a lot to get to today, including what's next for Disney after triumphing in that proxy battle and Congress unveiling a new legislation to protect online privacy. Finally. Plus, our friend of Pivot is NYU history professor and writer Ruth Ben-Ghiat, who will explain why Trump's dictator talk should not be taken lightly. But first, at the time of this taping, Meta stock is up 8% in the last five days. The jump comes after analysts raised targets for the stock, saying it has competitive advantage to gain in the digital ad market as it integrates AI. Also in Meta's favor, a motion filed to dismiss the FTC's monopoly claims better revealed Instagram's ad revenue for 2021: $32 billion, which is more than YouTube.
Scott Galloway
Oh, my God.
Kara Swisher
That was such a great purchase. The pop also caused Mark Zuckerberg to pass Elon Musk in wealth, taking over the top spot as the third richest person in the world.
Scott Galloway
Oh, Scott. I mean, there's obviously not. He's won the wrestling match, whether he likes it or not.
Kara Swisher
I don't really care about Elon here. But what a performance.
Scott Galloway
This is something again you had stressed – not bought, but had stressed. Yeah, each year I make a stock pick. In November of 2022, my stock pick for 2023 was Meta, and it's up 353% since then. This company – first off, at some point, we're going to have to have an actual wake and some closure and a funeral for this ridiculous consensual hallucination around headsets. I mean, granted, they continue to send weight loss tips to 5'10", 95-pound, 17-year-old girls, and I really appreciate a business model where I get to vomit up all my inventory of all my experiences and pretend that it's poetry. I mean, I don't like the company.
I don't like the people who run it. It's arguably the best-run business in the world right now. And my colleague, my former colleague at NYU, a guy named Peter Golder, a strategy guy, really brilliant, who ended up going to the tech school at Dartmouth. He had this fascinating insight that I wrote about in my first book. He said, the true innovators are terrible for shareholder value because they have to be so far out in front that they get mud on their face, arrows in the back. It's the number two. Apple's the perfect example of the second mouse coming in. So you could argue around the key issue here.
Elon Musk is the innovator. He came in and he laid off 80% of Twitter staff. And from a consumer standpoint, the fact that he can run this company on one-fifth the number of people – granted, it's not doing well – but the operations that continue to go, he's sort of with the innovator there. Now, what Mark Zuckerberg said is, "I got an idea. Let's lay off 20% of our staff and not be assholes. And we can hold on to the revenue." And that has created what is arguably the biggest business trend of the last 18 months. And that is these companies thinking, you know what, we can have all of the great taste of reduced expenses without the calories of reduced revenues.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, and they did it right. They did it efficiently. And Meta has also leveraged AI to get around the kneecapping that failed from Tim Cook. Their targeting is more efficient now. Instagram, which continues probably to be the best acquisition in the history of tech, is an absolute juggernaut, still growing 20-plus percent a year while they cut costs.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
You know, let me just note something. Scott, when you recommended – you said 2022?
Scott Galloway
I recommended – Meta was my stock pick of the year in November of 2022.
Kara Swisher
Okay. October 28, 2022 was at its lowest in the past five years, $98, $99. So essentially $100 bucks. And now it's at $527. Amazing.
Scott Galloway
If we only bought, we'd be on my G650 going back to BA.
Kara Swisher
I doubt it. To hang out with Louis. With the Louis star. So where is it going to go from here?
Scott Galloway
This isn't a stock I would get near right now because it feels expensive. But at the same time, there are so many green flags here. The scrutiny around TikTok is good for Meta. The growth of Reels. Their leveraging of AI. I mean, everything.
Kara Swisher
But you still wouldn't buy it right now.
Scott Galloway
I just – I feel like after a stock – I have trouble buying a stock after it's gone up four and a half fold in the last 15 months. But I wouldn't want to short this thing. It's just – and he's finally waking up and starting to reduce the expense. And he'll start laying off people making excuses around the mixed reality ayahuasca trip that he had. Or the whatever you call it, the Meta. What do they call these things? The Oculus?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, they're there. They still haven't. It's 34 times – its PE ratio is 34. It's still not – I mean, that's not ridiculously expensive given its growth. There's probably some upside there, but the juice has been squeezed pretty hard here, up four and a half fold. A company this big, its stock is up four and a half fold in the last 15 months. That's just – it's doing more revenue. I mean, Instagram's doing more revenue than YouTube right now.
Scott Galloway
I know. Isn't that amazing?
Kara Swisher
Which is also a great business, by the way. Yeah. Anyways, Meta's killing it. It's staggering. I hope it gets broken up. And I think parents continue to pay a huge cost for their dominance and their monopoly power here.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
Trump Media is down, just so you know. But of course, people took millions out, just so you know. Lots of people took millions. I was just pointing out Trump Media value declined again, continues to decline through socials shares. But people are taking money out of the company, just so you know.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, that's just insane. That's crazy town.
Kara Swisher
Oh, speaking of something that I think is a little insane, actually, a group of California businesses are coming after Governor Gavin Newsom saying taxes are out of control. This is a complaint that lots of people had about California. The businesses have spent $16 million gathering enough signatures to put a measure on the ballot in November. The measure would require two-thirds of voters to approve local tax increases and roll back some recent ones. Real estate businesses are some of the biggest funders, partially in response to an additional charge placed on luxury home sales that passed in Los Angeles in 2022. Newsom and other local officials took out a full ad in the LA Times and San Francisco Chronicle calling out businesses like Chevron and UPS, saying the move would kill funding for basic services. You know, California doesn't actually have the highest taxes. I saw a chart. And actually there's a big boom in San Francisco real estate now because of AI and a lot of companies coming back, and it's on an upswing. You know, I don't know what to think of this. I think they want to just – it's actually not the highest taxes, which is surprising.
Scott Galloway
Well, okay. The market is really an incredible beast. And New York, Hawaii, and California are three of the five highest taxes. Now, if you could just live anywhere in the U.S., where would three decent – I mean, the reason why these places have the highest taxes in the world is because they can. And you know why? For the most part, it's worth it. And for all the people shitposting California, all these wealthy people and VCs, they could live anywhere. And yet they decide to stay put and just continue to bitch about California. And the thing I don't like – I mean, I don't know if you remember Howard Jarvis and Proposition 13, but he basically made it impossible to raise taxes without a two-thirds vote. And you ended up with incredibly budget-constrained school systems. These things end up being suicide pacts that constrict local government. What I am a fan of is states competing. And you have seen a lot of people move out of California to Texas. And at some point, the lawmakers have to, in an agile way, face the issues and either increase social services or decrease taxes. But I've been thinking a lot about taxes, Kara. I've been thinking a lot about taxes.
Kara Swisher
Well, you know, Daniel Kahneman, the behavioral economist, passed away two weeks ago.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, two weeks ago. Amazing.
Kara Swisher
I'm a big fan of his books, "Thinking, Fast and Slow." It was one of those books I read. I don't read a lot, but if I like a book, I'll read it twice and try and cement it into my memory so I can sound smarter than I am. And that was one of those books. But he did great research looking at the effects on money and happiness. And the reality is money is correlated to happiness. That's the bad news. The good news is that it tops out. And if your objective is to be happy, then at some certain point, shouldn't we go back to the 50s and 60s where above a certain point of extreme wealth, you get taxed at 90%? So it's just a real argument for returning to a much more progressive tax structure at the very high level. And to be fair, I think Governor Newsom's taxes of late are mostly about what a lot of people consider onerous, but taxes on the very, very wealthy. And this is my view. So say taxes become ridiculously high above a crazy amount of money. Here's the thing: getting to hold on to that money, it's not going to make you any happier.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
Well, here's what the highest tax burden – just so people know – New York, Hawaii, Maine, Vermont, Connecticut, New Jersey, Maryland, Minnesota, Illinois. It's not California necessarily. And it has high taxes. The lowest one is Oklahoma, 7.12%.
Scott Galloway
Well, doesn't that make sense? I mean, again, see above. See above: high tax. It's like, okay, a Porsche costs a lot of money, and guess what? It's worth it.
Kara Swisher
There's also higher sales tax burdens, so it unduly hits the poor in some of these states that have no taxes.
Scott Galloway
Regressive taxes, yeah, sales tax and things like that.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Anyway, we'll see where it goes. I think he's going to have a good year in California. Lastly, Tesla will review its robo-taxi in early August, Elon Musk announced. I have one word for this: I'll see it when I see it.
Scott Galloway
Fine. It's not going to be a product. He's just hand-waving because he's so – there was a very long Wall Street Journal article about the real problems at Tesla, which we've been talking about for a while. Product, competition, crazy toxic owner. Here's where we are. Tesla should have jumped a little bit when he talked about Robotaxi, but this is just – just make good cars, Elon, and focus on them and stop virtue signaling all over Twitter. That's really pretty much what I would say.
Kara Swisher
I don't know. Any thoughts?
Scott Galloway
I agree with you. It's a press release. We have autonomous cars. What's the innovation here? I was using Waymo in San Francisco. Is he claiming it's going to be a better car? Right now, this is about regulatory approval. I'm not getting in a robo-taxi from them. I'm already nervous enough in one that has much more sensors. He needs to create a series of distractions because over the last decade, people have noticed that the EV umbrella creates disproportionate unearned market capitalization. And so the biggest manufacturers in the world – specifically automobile companies – have said, "Okay, we're going to go hard into EVs."
And there was a lag. And similar to Netflix through the aughts, he had in the teens he had basically open field because, to his credit, he started early. But now you have BYD saying they can come up with a decent EV for $10,000. In addition, you have seen an absolute crash in the residual value of used Teslas. And so people are scared to buy a new one. They massively missed here. They reported 387,000 in global deliveries, and they estimated 449,000. That's a big hit. So this company – it's not an AI company. It's not an energy company. All the jazz hands from all the bullshit analysts trying to pump the stock up, trying to pretend it's something it's not.
It's an automobile company. It'll start trading like an automobile company, which means its shares still have a long way to go down.
Kara Swisher
Well, the high was in November 2021. That's his high point before he bought Twitter, I guess, at $407. Now it's in the hundreds, $164. And he keeps doing tiny little jazz hands. He's going up and down, but he's just – make better products, Elon. That's it. People have caught up. Just stop. Stop with the press releases and make things that people want to buy. And by the way, your car isn't that interesting anymore, considering how many great cars there are, which we talked about.
Scott Galloway
You don't have to buy a Bolt like I do, but you certainly have choices.
Kara Swisher
You just lost all credibility.
Scott Galloway
I know, but still.
Kara Swisher
But I have a lot of friends who are buying them, and they're all like – I was taking a look at the Bronco, and I'm looking at the Rivian, the newer, the smaller.
Scott Galloway
Don't say a lesbian joke. Don't say – oh, wait, am I thinking out loud? I'm sorry, go ahead. Bronco.
Kara Swisher
No, but I was looking at the Rivian, the smaller one, and I have to say, there's no way I'm going to buy a Tesla because he's such a jerk. But not mostly because there's more choice.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
I have lots of choices. That's the thing. Anyway, who cares? Wave your hands all you want. Just stop. Just build better cars. That's what I would say.
Scott Galloway
I would argue – and I hate to – I think Tesla's a great car. I just think the gap, the marginal difference has been closed. A lot of people don't like the inside. I don't like – I never like getting in a Tesla. I got in a lot of Teslas, I'll tell you, in Buenos Aires where I was taking a car, Uber. Uber works really well there.
Kara Swisher
On your way to tango and beef?
Scott Galloway
Tango, just more beef than tango. Argentina is literally a case study in how bad governance can fuck up an incredible nation.
Kara Swisher
We had a lot of beef. Anyway, it was delicious. Let's get to our first big story. Disney is looking ahead to its future after successfully fending off activist investor Nelson Peltz, an all-jerk guy. I know you like him, but he said a series of idiotic things recently.
Scott Galloway
Hold on, hold on, hold on. Have I ever said I like Nelson Peltz? Have I ever met him?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, kind of.
Scott Galloway
No, I like governance. He's kind of a good investor. My company's not wasting time on shareholder battles.
Kara Swisher
All right, in any case, he's said a lot of stupid things recently. For the second time in two years, Disney announced last week that shareholders had voted to elect its entire slate of board nominees by a substantial margin following an expensive proxy battle.
Scott Galloway
What a waste of money.
Kara Swisher
Peltz's company, Trian Partners, said it was disappointed with the outcome but proud of "the impact we had in refocusing this company on value creation and good governance." Fine. You get that. And they made some money, too. I think a couple hundred million dollars. You've been talking about this proxy battle for months. Does he come back for another fight?
Scott Galloway
As I said, he made $300 million, a 40% return. So good for him. So he wins when he loses. This is a win for Bob Iger, but I'm not sure he comes out unscathed. And of course, there's the succession plan. He said it's the board's number one priority, and that's being treated with a sense of urgency. They have brought some people on the board who are good at that, but his contract ends in 2026. So what should happen here? What should prioritize? He could have another attack by an activist. At some point, he announced an expansion of its Magic Kingdom Park in Florida last week, part of a 10-year, $60 billion investment in parks, cruises, and experience. He settled with Ron DeSantis. He seems to have cleaned up some of the messes. So, thoughts?
Well, so again, around predictions. In November of '23, one of my three stock picks was Disney. It's just undervalued. And I like Bob. He's a good manager. On Prop G, on the Prop G pod two weeks ago, I predicted that Nelson would not get a board seat, and it was obvious. The reason is that the CEO and his proxy solicitor have more insight into what shareholders are thinking. Very rarely does a CEO let a shareholder vote go to a vote if they're not going to win.
So just some personal experience here as a chance for me to flex and talk about me, which I know you're missing.
Kara Swisher
Okay. I can't wait.
Scott Galloway
So when I raised $600 million, bought 17% of the New York Times, and said, "We're filing a 13D and we want four board seats." Companies under-managed need to divest things, including the 17% of the Boston Red Sox, which made no fucking sense. Anyways, Janet Robinson, the CEO at the time.
Kara Swisher
Oh, her.
Scott Galloway
They showed up to negotiate and they offered us one board seat. And I took my capital partner. We kept running back and forth in the meeting. And I said, "Ask for all four. They're dead. They wouldn't be negotiating unless they knew they were fucked, because they know their shareholders better than we do. The only reason they're here is because they know they're going to lose at the annual meeting."
And so they offered—you'll love this, Kara—they offered two board seats as long as I was not one of them.
Kara Swisher
Of course.
Scott Galloway
They did not want me on the board. And my capital partner said, "We'll do two, but Scott has to be one of them." But the moment—if Bob—it doesn't go to the annual meeting unless the incumbents know they're going to win. And the moment it was clear there wasn't going to be a settlement, it was clear that he wasn't going to get the seat. It was an overwhelming victory for the incumbents.
It's very straightforward what happens here. If the stock goes up, he's fine. It's gone up about 20 or 30% year to date. So far. But if the stock goes down, Bob is going to announce a succession plan sooner rather than later. And he's going to go give Nelson, if Nelson still wants it, a seat. If the stock goes up, Nelson wins, Bob's fine, rides off into the sunset. It's all about what the stock does the next nine months.
Kara Swisher
Right, nine months. So your thoughts, where is it going to go?
Scott Galloway
Look, I think Disney is going to be one of the consolidators as opposed to the consolidatees in the streaming market, which sets the multiple. That's the growth business. That's the future. In addition, they're sitting on top of this amazing business that doesn't get the credit it deserves called the parks. They really are singular.
Kara Swisher
True, you have Universal for the teens. You pointed that out to me. I like that analogy.
Scott Galloway
And here's the thing. Netflix and Google can't build these parks, so they're not interested in it. These are decades-long investments, unbelievable experience. You have to be part of, if you have kids, with Moana and live-action Moana, Frozen 4, 5, whatever the hell they're making. There's a great flywheel. You can bet there's going to be all sorts of Frozen rides. The IP here is unprecedented. They're going to have a nice niche in family around streaming. They have the cash cow with the parks. It's trading at a 10-year low. They've had some misses. I mean, Wish didn't do very well. They still got the Frozen juggernaut. They've got Moana. They've got a lot of stuff. But some of the stuff doesn't do well. They've had a series of movies that haven't done that well. But he's got to get back to entertaining.
The thing that irritated me about Peltz was he didn't like Black Panther. He said it was too woke. What an amazing movie. It was an enormous hit. What an idiot. That's a distraction.
Kara Swisher
What a frigging idiot. I know. But he's an idiot. Just when he comes out of his mouth, I want to like—well, I don't know if I told you this, but my prostatitis has been flaring up and it's clearly DEI.
Scott Galloway
I mean, it's clearly DEI's fault.
Kara Swisher
What did someone blame DEI on? It was something funny. Something happened in there.
Scott Galloway
Oh, the earthquake in New York. They're like, "It must have been DEI."
Kara Swisher
No, it's clearly DEI. I love that. Anyway, but what is his biggest challenge? I'd like to know what you think his biggest challenge is.
Scott Galloway
Look, Bob's—
Kara Swisher
Succession.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, okay. So a lot of these guys get—okay. So you don't make—they call him the leader. And here's the thing. He's not the leader. You can't run a company of this size and complexity when one person is in charge with leading it. His job is to create an environment where there's great leadership across all the divisions and an atmosphere of success and innovation. So he's about creating an environment. It's not easy to create an environment when, quite frankly, as nice as he is, you're seen as someone who keeps executing the people who get near the Iron Throne.
Really good CEOs in board meetings—I love the succession strategy we do once a year with the CEO. You can always tell who's a good CEO. One of the ways is they come in and they're really thoughtful about giving the bench play time in the board meeting. And then you have other CEOs who want to make it clear that there's me and everybody else. And without me, this thing doesn't work. That's when you know you've got to start thinking about finding another CEO. Unfortunately, some of the most famous CEOs in the world don't even realize it, but they have a habit of executing anyone who gets near the Iron Throne. He has not done a great job instilling confidence in fostering and cultivating leadership. So that on a cultural level is number one.
But most importantly, he's going to make the right moves about the parks. They know how to run that business in their sleep. The key here will be moving the streaming platform Disney Plus and Hulu to profitability while maintaining growth, which he talks about rather confidently in his utterances. He's been talking about making it quite profitable and doing a lot of things they wouldn't have done before. The reason why it'll be profitable is that for the first time in the history of this company, in two years, they haven't raised their content budget. That is Netflix. While they have also raised prices. So Netflix has given cloud cover for a rationalization in the sector such that Disney Plus and HBO can raise their fees without raising their content budgets. This whole market is rationalizing, which is good for Disney.
Kara Swisher
Although they've got to sort of get a little bit heftier. I know they have all the kids stuff, but Netflix is just killing it with their shows. I have to say all the Netflix shows right now. It's brute force. They just have so much.
Scott Galloway
Well, they're also kind of good. There's a real mix.
Kara Swisher
I was noticing what I was watching. I had downloaded—there's another one called Scoop. It's about Prince Andrew. It's like it hits. The Gentleman was kind of good. You know, I didn't keep watching.
Scott Galloway
Interesting.
Kara Swisher
They have One Day, which is doing great. They've got all kinds of things that are doing really well. I'm just saying I watch a lot of Disney because my kids do, but I don't find a lot there that I want to watch myself. And I would. But Netflix really—they've got to sort of have something for me, Kara Swisher. And Netflix always does.
All right, Scott, let's go on a quick break. And when we come back, Congress makes a big move toward regulating online privacy. And we'll speak with friend of Pivot, Ruth Ben-Ghiat, about Donald Trump and dictators. They go together.
Break
Scott, we're back. Congress appears to be closer than ever to passing national online privacy protections. House and Senate subcommittee leaders from both sides of the aisle unveiled a proposal on Sunday, meaning they're cooperating for legislation that gives consumers the rights to control how tech companies use their personal data. The American Privacy Rights Act would limit the types of data companies can gather, allowing users to opt out of targeted ads and permit people to sue bad actors for violating their privacy. This would be a big thing. One thing the bill doesn't do: prohibit companies from targeting minors with ads. I wish it did that. A lot of states have their own online privacy laws. We'll see what happens to the national standard. Of course, the tech companies will push back. It's unclear whether it's going to get passed because they've got a limited amount of time. What do you think?
Scott Galloway
What do you think? It's with Maria Cantwell as one of the pushers of it on the Senate side. I mean, it feels better. I think you know more about this, although I want to come back. I do have a story about Senator Cantwell.
Kara Swisher
Oh, okay.
Scott Galloway
Well, you know, this is—look, here's the problem with a lot of the stuff they're doing. They met—I've seen a lot of criticisms of this. I've seen a lot of positives. You can't let the perfect be the enemy of the good. We have to put a stake in the sand to add privacy laws. It does a lot of things it doesn't do. I would definitely add prohibiting companies from targeting minors with ads. We do it on television in certain ways. They can see ads, but remember the cartoons with cigarette companies? They should be much more attuned to what's happening, especially because there's such a movement going on right now about that. So I think it's a good time to do that.
The companies will scream about innovation and hindering them. But this is sort of the baseline, it seems to me. This privacy bill is the baseline of anything else. They should pass it as an act of symbolism to do so. I don't think it damages anything. That's always the complaint of tech companies. I don't think tech companies should resist this happening. Probably it's sprawling. There's a lot through it. There's a lot here on it. So we'll see what people think and the reaction it has, but it's big. It's a big bill. But opting out of data practices and targeted advertising and also being able to sue them seems to me table stakes. What do you think?
More importantly, back to me. When I first moved to New York, I literally left tech, sold my house, got divorced, moved to New York without a single friend. I even said to my ex, who I'm still close with, I said, "You can have all our friends. I just want to change my life." And I moved to New York and I fell into this group of really interesting people. One of my friends, a woman named Anne Maffei, and this other guy, Boykin Curry, all these sort of super smart, cultured, interesting people. And because I was, I think, 34 or 36 at the time and single, but had been married, which meant I could actually commit to something, I was the ultimate setup. Everyone was trying to set me up.
I had dinner with a woman I think you know or knew.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
Rob Glazer's wife, ex-wife. Just plucky, young.
Kara Swisher
Oh, you did. Wow. Yes.
Scott Galloway
Really nice, attractive, like a spark plug. And she said, "I have the perfect woman for you. She's smart. She's good looking, da da da." I said, "Great." And she said, "She's going to be in town. Are you comfortable dating high-profile women?" I'm like, "Well, why does that mean?" She goes, "Well, her name is—she's running for Senate and her name's Maria Cantwell."
And first off, I think Senator—it never happened. She was an executive in a tech executive book. At his company, Real Networks. And I asked some questions about her and it ends up—and I said, there was one feature, of course, me being a thoughtful person. She said—and I said, "I'm not interested." She said, "Why not?" And I said, "I didn't get divorced to date women who are older than me. I want younger."
Kara Swisher
How much older? Like six months?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, she's like six years older than me. But I said, "I want to date much younger women who have terrible relationships with their father. Those are my two criteria, Kara."
Kara Swisher
Those are too good to hear.
Scott Galloway
Anyways, so I could have been a senator's husband. But I told her I also couldn't date her because I didn't want that relationship to come in between my relationship with Patty Stonecipher and Emily Ratajkowski. I thought they just would have been too hurt. It just would have put a strain on those budding relationships.
Kara Swisher
Oh, God. These fake relationships are so creepy, but funny on the end. In any case—
Scott Galloway
I could have been a senator's husband. I could have been the biggest problem her staff had to deal with.
Kara Swisher
God, you would have been.
Scott Galloway
Right? She's terrific. I would have been like—who is the secretary of homeland? The woman from New Jersey whose husband was a left job. She would have had to be apologizing. I could have been Billy Carter.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Or Mnuchin's wife. Remember, she was like posing with dollar bills and stuff like that. She's crazy.
Scott Galloway
He is crazy. That matches.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
I would have been—I would have really stood. I would have been the bad peanut butter to her chocolate.
Kara Swisher
Right. If she's sane and attractive and nice, and I would have been—the staff would have—there would have been people just to manage me.
Okay, moving away from your dating life. Here's why it's important. It would make privacy a consumer right and put people in control of their data. That is really at the heart of it. We have not had a comprehensive national law on this, and we have to. It is a signal that we care about this. It also preserves a lot of the stuff that's been happening in states, especially California, which has been out front of this. There's such a patchwork of state laws. That's one of the issues. And to be able to sue these companies for violations is really important. It stays away from the free speech part.
And it reigns in—you can sue them for this. This is the kind of stuff I've been talking about. Go to their pocketbook. If Facebook is going to dominate digital advertising, you should have the same rights that you have to sue people. And so that's one of the things. This comprehensive privacy bill says we care about this issue. Now, again, the people who don't like it and think it's too thin, people who are against it saying "How dare you?" This is a baked industry right now, digital advertising. It deserves a piece of legislation. So we'll see where it goes. I don't know. They're really busy with other important issues.
Scott Galloway
I'm going to get a call from Maria Cantwell now saying she's going to have a restraining order. Do you think she's still thinking about me?
Kara Swisher
No. I'm going to see her soon. What could have happened?
Scott Galloway
What could have happened? I used to talk to her all the time when she was at Real. It was interesting.
Kara Swisher
I love her. I think she's so good on the issues. She tried to insert $15 minimum wage into the Recovery Act. And of course, you know, we can give seniors a $90 billion increase in Social Security. She probably doesn't get her due for the amount of stuff she does. She's very serious. She's one of our few elected representatives who just shows up and does the fucking work.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, she's a business person too. My favorite recent—like, posing for the TikTok cameras and trying to—in the mad dash for an appointment to the Trump cabinet that will never happen—is Representative Jim Jordan has sent letters to all the biggest advertisers demanding that they answer why they aren't advertising on Truth Social. I mean, that's what our representatives are doing. "Why are you advertising on platforms where there's no people? They fit my political values." Anyways, a shout out to Senator Cantwell. I think she's served the country really well.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, she is. She's a serious-minded senator, and she was a really lovely person to talk to back in the day, in the early internet days. I really enjoyed her.
Anyway, we've got to get to our friend of Pivot. Ruth Ben-Ghiat is a professor of history at NYU and author of "Strongmen: Mussolini to the Present." She also writes the Substack "Lucid," which focuses on abuses of power and threats to democracy. Ruth, welcome.
Ruth Ben-Ghiat
Thank you. I'm so glad to be here.
Kara Swisher
So we want to talk dictators. I want to start with something you posted on X last week after Donald Trump shared violent imagery of Joe Biden on Truth Social. You wrote, "Wake up, people. This is an emergency." A lot of people have concerns about that imagery. But what was it specifically that made you sound the alarm here? You've been doing it for a while, so I'm not so sure that's the newest thing in the world for you. But talk about why that bothered you in particular, of the many things that could bother you around Donald Trump.
Ruth Ben-Ghiat
Yeah. So it's about—because I feel like Donald Trump has been waging, and his GOP enablers have been waging, a whole campaign to delegitimize all of our democratic institutions, and in particular attacking Joe Biden. This was an image which showed Joe Biden—it was a sticker on the back of a pickup as though he were a hostage, kidnapped. If you study coups—a third of my book "Strongman" is about coups and authoritarian takeovers. What is this showing? It's showing an outcome of a political situation where Biden has met a bad end, where he's somehow been overthrown and ended up tied up. This is being depicted as something positive. It's continuing the coup. It's extremely dangerous for obvious reasons. I feel like this is normalizing.
Kara Swisher
Which is the point, right? I mean, you called it—you said Trump's repeated elevation of dictators as models of leadership should be understood as part of a re-education strategy. Now, one thing he does is—this is not new. He did that with CNN, if you remember him punching CNN, this was years ago. He did one that I wrote a column about when he was—not just "stand by and stand," whatever the heck he said. He does it a lot. It's not a new, fresh thing, but you're calling it a re-education strategy that's been ongoing, right? That it hasn't stopped the coup. And he continues to do that. Explain why, because he says he's joking. He says he's kidding. This is just him, that this is his brand of humor, such that it's not funny, but still. Talk about the re-education part of it.
Ruth Ben-Ghiat
Yeah, it's interesting what he's been doing. Since the fascists—Mussolini and Hitler—you've got to re-educate people to see violence in a positive way and even make it into something patriotic and even morally righteous. Trump has been using his rallies since 2015. This was part of my report for the January 6th committee. He's been just over and over saying, "Oh, in the good old days, we used to be able to punch protesters." So there's that vector. And then he's been also elevating dictators—doesn't matter, North Korea, China, whatever they are, communist, fascist—as positive models of leadership.
Kara Swisher
Mm-hmm. Orban. He recently met with Viktor Orban from Hungary. Go ahead.
Ruth Ben-Ghiat
Yeah. And so Orban—what does he say? "I take seriously what he says." And he says that Orban is so great, he's so strong because he says "This is how it's going to be" and everybody just accepts it. So he's telling us what he's telling Americans, his followers: this is a positive model. So if you take the violence as a way of moving history forward, which was January 6th, and you take the positive praise for these murderous dictators, you get a re-education strategy because he's saturated the media environment for now many years over and over and over again.
Scott Galloway
It's nice to meet you, Professor. I don't think we've met before. So we spend a lot of time talking about what a danger Trump is and how wrong and really anti-American a lot of his activities, much less his rhetoric, are. But he was elected by the U.S. and he continues to poll really well, despite all of these things that are horrific to everyone on this podcast. What is it about the atmospherics in the U.S. that has led the populace to support this individual who we all agree does not acquit himself as we would want someone who wants to be the president? What's happened in America? What's changed here?
Ruth Ben-Ghiat
That's a great question. There are patterns to these things. In the research for my book, when there's been a perception that there's been too much social progress and certain people are losing out—it could be conservative elites who are worried about losing their privileges, it could be people thinking there's too much gender emancipation, too much racial emancipation—you get a kind of counter-revolution. That's a big word. Or you get a backlash. That's when somebody like a Donald Trump is appealing.
But a Donald Trump also models himself for that environment. The thing about these strongmen is that they're highly sensitive. They read the marketplace and they understand what is wanted. They model themselves. They will be whatever they need to be to get to power because they have no morals. They're just about getting control. So Donald Trump comes up and he was the perfect person as the anti-Obama. He was the male brute. He addressed the people who felt that women had too much power, same-sex marriages were taking over, all of the racial stuff. And he also told these people that he loved them, that they were the forgotten. There's a sense that he's not just going to represent them, he's going to protect them and take care of them. A daddy, a big daddy. He's daddy. He's big daddy and he's remained big daddy. Once they bond to him and they feel protected, but they're also protective of him because he's also the victim. Mussolini was the victim. Erdogan's the victim. They all do this. It's highly effective, this manipulation of emotions.
Scott Galloway
First off, Professor, I think that's such an important point because I've been thinking a lot about Roe recently, and I don't think people zero in on some of the things you're talking about to really understand. I would just want to double-click on it. My sense is you talk about them wanting to return to an era where they were more comfortable, and I think it's more specific than that. Just as young men have fallen further faster than any group in America, the ascent globally of women over the last 30 years is unprecedented. They've doubled their elected positions in parliaments. There are now more women globally enrolled in tertiary education than men. I think the extreme of any religion is really uncomfortable and wants these uppity women to sit down. I think that's what Roe is. I don't think it's about birth. It's about taking power back, isn't it? Specifically about telling very conservative sects of religious extremists who have disproportionate power and, unfortunately, young men who feel shunned by women, "I'm going to take power back from women."
Ruth Ben-Ghiat
Oh, totally. And who better than a repeated abuser, somebody who boasts about putting women in their place? This was part of his marketing strategy from the very beginning. That's why when the Access Hollywood stuff came out, I knew that it would actually help him. These are the people I study. It was horrible to write the book and be in their heads. Mussolini was a serial rapist and many others, Gaddafi as well. This is part of their glamour. Until we wean ourselves from this kind of toxic brute idea—that this brute force, this ideal of masculinity is glamorous and desirable—we're going to be susceptible to these Donald Trumps.
Kara Swisher
Can I pick up on that between Trump and some of these classic dictators? I did not know that about Mussolini, for your book. And also how they shape themselves. I just interviewed Tim Ryback about his book "Takeover," which is the six months. There was touch and go for Hitler there, whether he was going to make it. He adapted himself. He removed himself from crazy for enough time to convince all the different constituencies that he needed to convince on the left and the right to finally appoint him chancellor, which gave him the opportunity to become more. Talk a little bit about the similarities when you're talking about these various dictators and the differences. Are there differences also?
Ruth Ben-Ghiat
Yeah, the outcomes are different. So whatever happens, it's not going to be a Hitlerian one-party state or a North Korean one-party state. But the similarities are that these people are highly sophisticated at communication. Whatever the era they're in, they use the latest tools of communication to forge a direct and unmediated bond with their followers. Mussolini, he was gesticulating and he started in the age of silent cinema, used newsreels. Hitler, of course, he had the radio and he ranted. The Nazis invested in state-of-the-art audio technology so that when he had rallies, his voice would reverberate in ways that made him seem more godly. That's part of the personality cult.
They all do personality cults. The rules have not changed for 100 years. You have to be a man of the people so you're relatable, and certainly Trump is. But you have to be the man above all other men, the man who gets away with it. That's the rogue glamour. They all use this. Modi used holograms when he ran initially for office so he could be everywhere and nowhere like a god. Berlusconi, who owned TV networks, used satellite TV to be everywhere. And Trump used Twitter. That's one thing they do. They have these bonds where people feel they're speaking directly and only to them, which hasn't changed for 100 years.
Kara Swisher
If you were advising the White House, how would you match this?
Because Biden's certainly not that. Yeah, I think in general, we can learn from autocrats to make more use of emotion in politics. That's one of the things that autocrats do really well: create these tribes and these communities, and they make people feel cared for. Now, it's bogus. Of course, they're just trying to manipulate them. Trump doesn't care. At the beginning of the pandemic, I did an interview and I said that Trump doesn't care if you live or die, and people got upset. But that's just how it is. But they seem to care about people. So Democrats in general around the world can make more use of emotion, of joy, of hope, of love. And Biden does this in his own quiet way, but it'd be ideal if it's somebody who is a more charismatic, energetic vehicle for that kind of emotion. Is there someone like that?
Ruth Ben-Ghiat
I'm not sure. I mean, I'm a big fan of Pete Buttigieg as a communicator. He's got a restrained personality, but he's able to talk. He goes on Fox and he's liked on Fox. He's a great asset as a communicator. He has everything, I think, as a communicator, and he could develop in this direction if given the space.
Kara Swisher
So what worries you the most about a Trump second term?
Ruth Ben-Ghiat
What worries me the most is that he has been very clear about his intent to have an American version of fascism. Now, that's not going to be a one-party state, but he wants to turn the US—arm the military if he could, but certainly law enforcement—to repress large numbers of Americans, to deport millions. He would stop at nothing to try and gain total control of the United States. That's what authoritarianism is at its very essence: the executive trying to overwhelm the other branches of government so that they can be safe and never prosecuted again.
Kara Swisher
Can he actually do it? We're such a big and diverse country with so many... you can't imagine California going along. There are elements in every state like this, but how do you manage to do that? Germany was a very particular, smaller country. So was Italy. So was Turkey in a way, although it's much more diverse. And certainly Modi has done that, but has limits in terms of what he can do. How do you look at that? Is that a possibility? I mean, we've all seen the science fiction about it. We've all seen those apocalyptic movies where that happens.
Ruth Ben-Ghiat
Mussolini is actually a better example, or somebody like an Orban versus Hitler. Because today, things often happen gradually. But Trump, and Project 2025, is about having an accelerated transformation of government using executive orders, perhaps the Insurrection Act. There are many things that he can do. The main thing that definitely would happen—because it happened during the first Trump administration—is that Trump is not interested in governance. He's interested in using public office for private benefit. In his first administration, he spent one out of every three days not governing at the White House, but visiting Trump-branded properties.
This kind of enrichment for you, your family, and cronies definitely would go on. He's already boasting that he accepted money during his first presidency from the Chinese for "services." I'm still trying to get somebody to ask him what those services were. The White House would be for sale. Our intelligence would be for sale. Perhaps it already has been, keeping documents in his bathroom. All of this lack of accountability and erasure of public versus private—that's the strongman thing. They don't accept any divide between public and private. It's all theirs to sell and profit from.
Kara Swisher
Professor, my sense is the media has a difficult time trying to figure out the approach to covering Trump. Do you have any thoughts around where the media has succeeded or not succeeded, and the role the media plays in trying to figure out how to cover this guy?
Ruth Ben-Ghiat
It's a little like Frederick Birchall, the New York Times reporter who sort of normalized Hitler for a long time. And Mussolini actually had a syndicated column because the anti-communist baron Hearst was his backer, reaching a thousand newspapers for eight years in the United States. So talk about normalizing. I think the press has been working with an outdated playbook, a playbook that worked when you had two candidates and two parties that still bought into democracy. The problem is they've been slow to understand how to cover our situation where we're a bipartisan republic, but one of our parties no longer believes in democracy.
I see the GOP as an autocratic party. If it were a sovereign entity, its foreign policy would be pro-autocratic, pro-Putin, pro-Orban. That's a reality. And they've struggled. So they still do the both-sides-ism. But it's a little more subtle. For example, Meet the Press, which has a bipartisan viewership—Kristen Welker has done very well bringing Republican guests on and probing them. The audience there are Republicans who don't want to see a Republican aggressively bashed, but will listen to a careful probing of their hypocrisies, of their inconsistencies. You can think that this more gentle approach is perhaps not appropriate for our emergency, but it depends what your aim is.
Kara Swisher
So what should they be doing?
Ruth Ben-Ghiat
The headline writers—there are a lot of headlines that are unhelpful, even in the Washington Post and certainly in the New York Times. Also the placement of important stories about Trump's corruption. Often the New York Times will put it on page A13. I think that if we want to prioritize saving our democracy, we have to have a different kind of placement of these big stories. Also to show the American public that people are being held accountable when January 6th insurgents are sentenced, when the DOJ is doing things to restore faith in institutions. Bashing the press is a popular habit, but it's a symptom of the success of the right in making people lose faith in all institutions.
Kara Swisher
Absolutely. I think one of the issues is Trump and his cronies, especially Steve Bannon, flood the zone with crazy all the time. So you get exhausted, including with January 6th. You're like, "Oh, I'm tired of listening to it." Anyway, it's a really important book. There are a lot of really important books out these days in this area. Ruth Ben-Ghiat, her substack is called Lucid, and her book is *Strongmen: Mussolini to the Present*. Little light reading for you. Ruth, thank you so much.
Ruth Ben-Ghiat
Thank you. I enjoyed the conversation.
Kara Swisher
Thank you, Professor.
Ad break
Okay, Scott, let's hear some wins and fails. Why don't you go first? Cut you off? How do I cut you off?
Scott Galloway
You do. You constantly cut me off. You don't invest in this relationship.
Kara Swisher
Oh my God. Literally. Nobody thinks that. Do you want to do a word count again so I can prove to you?
Scott Galloway
Just because you go to Argentina.
Kara Swisher
A little tango. A little asado.
Scott Galloway
A little asado.
Kara Swisher
Audience, just so you know, we do a secret word count and Scott always comes out on top. Just so you know.
Scott Galloway
Daddy's on top. He likes to be in charge. He's Alan Alda publicly. He's a caveman in the sack.
Kara Swisher
Hello, babies. Oh my God. Hello. And as you see, I totally out-speak him. I could have been Mr. Senator Cantwell. All right. My win is *Three-Body Problem*. It's on Netflix. It is so cool. It's based on a Chinese sci-fi thing. There's a really weird backstory. It's the guys who did *Game of Thrones*, so they know how to make a show. They're really talented, and I've interviewed them before when they did *Game of Thrones*. This show is really compelling. It's also weird. The guy who funded it was a Chinese billionaire who got murdered by one of his employees by being poisoned. The whole story is really...
but the story itself is amazing. It's not easy; you really have to pay attention. And I'm compelled to watch it. A lot of these shows—I did watch *The Gentleman*, but I'm not compelled to watch the next one. This one, I can't stop. Same thing with *Shogun*. What I think about with streaming is, do I want to keep going? There's a lot of stuff I leave off. *Shogun* and this are the kind of things that move me forward. They're beautifully made, really interesting. The cast—I've never seen most of the cast. There are some Jonathan Pryces in it who's always fantastic, but this is a cast I don't know and I love that.
That's one of the things that's super compelling to me.
My fail is this continued situation around abortion. Trump is trying to thread the needle, saying right now that abortion should be left to the states, declining to endorse a national limit. He's pretending. But I do think we have to... this is one of the more compelling reasons. I've been talking to a lot of women. There are bans on all or almost most abortions in so many states, almost the entire South. Then there are bans after 12 to 15 weeks, and then banned, blocked by the court. Much of the South will be without abortion rights. The entire South, really, unless Florida wins in this election where they put it into the Constitution. This is no way to run a country on a big issue. We have to come to some sort of agreement. The best chance of that is Joe Biden, obviously, not Donald Trump. He's made a mess of it. So that continues to be a vexing issue, bodily autonomy. We'll see. This should be a much bigger issue. I understand why immigration is. I understand why crime is. But to me, abortion will be one of the biggest issues in the election, and it should be. Go ahead, Scott.
Scott Galloway
So my win: a huge win for women's sports. Viewership estimates for the NCAA women's tournament final between Caitlin Clark's Iowa team and unbeaten South Carolina are between 18 and 24 million. To put that in context, the upper figure would be five times what the women's final drew just two years ago. It would also be, get this, Kara—every game from last year's World Series, all five games of the NBA finals, all but two college football games, and even outdo one of the NFL's postseason matchups. There's been a lot of complaints about equal pay. I quite frankly always said, "As soon as they start making as much money as men's sports, they will get as much money." And now it's happening. This is a seminal moment for women's sports. Basketball pulling more than... She's a star. Unbelievable. So this is a really nice moment for women's sports. Big win for Caitlin Clark, the South Carolina team, and women's sports in general.
My fail—I had a different fail, but what you just said and what Professor Guillot said inspired me. In Florida, the Supreme Court has said the right to abortion is not codified. The governor can limit it at six weeks. Someone has put on the ballot a resolution that would give every woman in Florida the constitutional right to have an abortion, and they need 60%. It's polling pretty closely. So my newsletter, *No Mercy, No Malice*, I decided to do a big deep dive into Roe. Bodily autonomy has played a big role in my life. What I came to understand is that I was trying to figure out what's going on here.
What are the drivers when the majority of even Republicans, much less the nation, are for some level of bodily autonomy? It's like, okay, it's about life. It's not. The people who are most vehemently and effective around the pro-life movement are the first to want to advocate for capital punishment or force a woman to carry what becomes a cancerous tumor around, or put a woman's health in jeopardy. It's not about life. And Democrats go, "They're not obsessed with life. They're obsessed with birth." That misses the mark too, because it's the same group who wants to cut funding for the child tax credit.
They don't want to make it easier for young people to have children. As a matter of fact, of people between the ages of 30 and 34 in 1990, 60% of them had at least one child. It dropped to 27%. So if we wanted more kids, we could absolutely do it. We just decided we're not obsessed with birth.
What I determined, or what all the data shows, is the following—and this is both Professor Guillot and Fareed Zakaria's new book, *The Age of Revolutions*, I think it's called—reflect. There are certain conservative wings of almost every religion that are really uncomfortable with the ascent of women. The fastest way to put them back in their place is to do what we do to the IRS or the antitrust committee, and that is to defund them. When you force a woman to carry a baby to term against her will, you're basically impoverishing her and diminishing her power. The fact that more and more women are less reliant on the government or on men is really upsetting to some of these groups. They want to go back.
Now, that's not the most disturbing feature, and this is my fail. There are two stats. The first is that the greatest source of mortality by a factor of two for women who are either pregnant or have recently given birth is homicide. Abortion gives women the opportunity to break ties with a violent partner. But the really disturbing fact here is the following: the segment of America that provides the least support around bodily autonomy is not old white people. It's Gen Z men. Men 27 and younger are the least supportive of a woman's right to terminate a pregnancy. I believe it's because young men feel shunned by women and believe that if they take women back to the 50s and 60s, they're going to need them more.
I don't know if it's anger. I don't know if it's conspiracy theory. I don't know if it's just naked misogyny. But I was absolutely shocked and rattled by the fact that young men are the least supportive of a woman's right to terminate a pregnancy. And it's also the definition of stupid, because it not only hurts society and the economy, it hurts them. To be quite crass and blunt, when you deny a woman's ability to plan out pregnancies and have kids when she wants to, fellas, let me tell you, this is going to decrease, not increase, the likelihood you ever get laid. What do you think is going to happen to sex when women may be forced to carry a baby to term against her will?
This is literally the definition of stupid. Young men feel shunned by women. Young men want more sex. It's not that they're more religious. It's not that they have a new undying love for the unborn. It's that they're angry at women. And let me tell you, that is not a good rap. My fail here is young men who just do not understand that bodily autonomy is key to their ability to someday have kids, to someday find a woman who wants to have a relationship and wants to have sex with them that might result in a partnership. The fact that we are mistaking this pro-life movement for anything but the following—trying to put this group of people who have ascended faster globally than any other group, women—and we never win taking groups back.
So my fail is Gen Z men. What the fuck are you thinking?
Kara Swisher
And doesn't that shock you?
Scott Galloway
No, it shocked the shit out of me.
Kara Swisher
No, I think what Ruth was talking about, sort of uber daddy, the man, the manly man—it's such a toxic... I have spent my whole life trying to raise sons who are not the opposite of that, but not that. I want them to feel good about being men. I want them to feel strong. I want them to feel their gender. I know it sounds crazy, but I do. One time years ago, Louis really wanted to learn how to shoot a gun. And he did. I wasn't going to deny him. I put him with someone who knew how to shoot guns. He wanted to go hunting. He did. He goes, "Do you want to go with me?" I'm like, "I don't have any interest.
I think it's grotesque in many ways. But you should do what you want." He got his gun license in California. He took all the tests. He went with a friend of mine who was also a great fisherman and hunter. People were like, "How can you do that?" I was like, "He wants to try it." He doesn't like it now, but he did it. I wanted them to feel whatever they want to feel, but I definitely spent a lot of time thinking about how they treat women and how they think about women. Both of them are very good boyfriends. They care about their partner's health and their wellbeing, from what I can see. Alex has a new girlfriend who's wonderful and knows her own stuff.
She's a strong woman and he's attracted to that in a good way. So I agree with you. I don't know what's in their fucking heads, these men. I honestly don't.
Scott Galloway
I think a lot of it is... one third, two thirds of women under the age of 30 have a boyfriend, only one third of men. Women are dating older because they want someone more economically and emotionally viable. I also do think—I don't want to be too Alan Alda here—that media has taught women to exit a relationship, that you don't need this, you deserve better. I don't think enough women... if you go to these sites, women all want the same guy who's over six feet tall and makes over $100,000. I think online dating speedballs this unreasonable filter.
Kara Swisher
They lose that advantage pretty soon, right? They all end up alone.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. And they all end up alone. But here's the thing. Young women are more attracted because men will always be more attracted to younger women. Not always, but most. Then what you have is a group of 20-somethings, especially men, who resent women because they feel like they've been shunned by them on dating apps. I think they become very resentful. It's a real shame. Unfortunately, men without the prospect of a romantic relationship go down to a much darker place than a woman without a prospect for a romantic relationship. Women have much stronger social networks, consequent guardrails, and consequent care and love. Guys without the prospect of a romantic relationship get angry, stop looking for a job, stop showering. That can happen. One thing we should be pressing for men is friendships. I'm really happy about the boys—they all have really good male friendships and female friendships. I think that's something we don't push enough with men. I'm thrilled Alice is in a frat. I couldn't be more thrilled.
I was just in Israel, and they have mandatory national service. I was at this memorial at the Nova Music Festival and I met all of these—I call them kids. They literally look like they're in high school, Kara. Women compulsory for two years, men for three years. All of these young men and women in uniform who carry an automatic rifle, so they have to learn about moral ambiguity, technology, making snap decisions. They serve in the agency of something bigger than themselves. They're all together, working their asses off. They meet business partners, friends, boyfriends, girlfriends, mates. We need a big investment in trying to get a cure and decrease loneliness among young people, because they just don't know how to handle it. It's terrible for them.
Kara Swisher
Yep. But when it becomes... last point I'll make. I'm judging the Livingston Awards, and there are all these amazing stories. One of them was about Afghan women—their suicide rate is going up since the Taliban took over because they live in these domestic violent relationships and they don't get choices anymore. Those kinds of things degrade so quickly. So if you combine what Ruth was talking about with this trend, it creates a bad society for everybody. Anyway, very good topic, Scott. What a really interesting point you're making. I really appreciate all your words on that.
Scott Galloway
My many, my two-to-one never-ending words.
Kara Swisher
Never ending. It's not two to one, but it's not not two to one. Anyway, we want to hear from you. Send us your questions about business, tech, or whatever's on your mind. Go to nymag.com/pivot to submit a question for the show, or call 855-51-PIVOT. Okay, Scott, that is the show. Are you traveling anywhere? Are you staying put?
Scott Galloway
I'm here for a couple weeks, and then I go speaking at TED in late April. Then I'm going down to LA for May, then I'm going to Miami, then I'm going to New York. Oh, craziness.
Kara Swisher
I'm here for another... I'll be in London in mid-May. I don't think you're going to be there.
Scott Galloway
Mid-May? Yeah, maybe. We'll go out for dinner.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, I'm also going to Austin this week to do something at the LBJ Library. I'm doing a little thing with Larry Wilmore there.
Scott Galloway
Larry Wilmore? Yes, yes. I love that guy.
Kara Swisher
I know, I do too. I love Larry Wilmore. He's funny and he's smart. He asked me to come do this thing. We have a nice rapport. I was on his show once. And then I'm not even going to tell you—I'm going to tell you Thursday what I'm doing Friday. You're going to die.
Scott Galloway
Is it involving Senator Cantwell, Patty Stuntz, or Emily Ratajkowski?
Kara Swisher
No. No. No. I'm going to LA to do some stuff. I'll tell you that later.
Scott Galloway
Is it someone I like who you're going to start making? Are you going to steal another one of my male friends?
Kara Swisher
No, these are female friends that you probably want to have friendships with. Anyway, we'll be back on Friday with more, and I'll tell you about that right before that happens. Scott, read us out.
Scott Galloway
Today's show was produced by Lara Naiman, Zoe Marcus, and Taylor Griffin. Ernie Intertott engineered this episode. Thanks also to Drew Burrows and Mille Saverio. Nishat Krua is Vox Media's executive producer of audio. Make sure you subscribe to the show wherever you listen to podcasts. Thanks for listening to *Pivot* from New York Magazine and Vox Media. You can subscribe to the magazine at nymag.com/pod. We'll be back later this week for another breakdown of all things tech and business.