Main Topic: The podcast episode covers various topics, including the AI-powered customer service, journalism, and the latest news in technology and business.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Insights:
Podcast Intro Music
Kara Swisher
AI agents are getting pretty impressive. You might not even realize you're listening to one right now. We work 24/7 to resolve customer inquiries. No hold music, no canned answers, no frustration. Visit sierra.ai to learn more.
Scott Galloway
Not all journalism is the same. Take The Guardian. Our coverage has something unique. Fierce independence. Nobody owns us or tells us what we can and can't say. So we're free to report the whole picture. We connect what's happening in Washington to the rest of the globe, expose corruption wherever we find it, and give fresh perspective on everything from wellness and soccer to culture, the climate, and more. Read, watch, and listen to The Guardian for free at theguardian.com.
Kara Swisher
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher, and I just flew in from California and my arms are tired. [Laughs] Oh, that's good. Scott, I got diverted because of the Alaska Airlines thing. They're grounding planes all over the place.
Scott Galloway
Oh, the 737s.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, like six flights of mine got canceled, and I had to keep trying to figure out how to get here. I almost went through Cleveland, and I just got back this morning at 7 o'clock.
Scott Galloway
Oh, wow.
Kara Swisher
Yes.
Scott Galloway
Are you happy to be back? Is that why? You seem like you're sort of in a bad mood. Before the podcast, I always do a joke, and you usually laugh, and you weren't laughing.
Kara Swisher
Oh, well, it was a bad joke. Are you tired?
Scott Galloway
It was a bad joke. It involved a Tyson vacuum.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. That can't be wrong. Dyson.
Scott Galloway
Dyson. Oh, Dyson, excuse me. Tyson is a chicken. Also probably the most vicious pugilist in history.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Anyway.
Scott Galloway
Oh, that's true. Mike Tyson.
Kara Swisher
So, no, I just was in California. I'll tell you about it when we talk about Don Lemon. I was in San Francisco and Los Angeles. It was lovely. We're sort of semi-friends because you introduced us. I'm getting together with him in New York.
Scott Galloway
Oh, are you? Cool.
Kara Swisher
No, I'll take him somewhere where people will see me hanging out with a handsome celebrity.
Scott Galloway
I see. Because that's cred to me.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, okay. I'll take him to one of my members-only clubs.
Scott Galloway
Oh, yeah. So it's the same thing with these famous people. They sit down and they ask me for career advice.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
You know, Alex Swisher is asking me for career advice.
Kara Swisher
You're going to talk to him now.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but he's savable. He's on the way up. I usually get people on their way down. It's very sweet. Alex called me and asked if Scott can help him figure out the correct major. Of course, I can't help him at all, apparently. But I thought that was lovely because you were so good at helping him pick the right college. He loves Michigan. I've actually done some research. I'm excited to speak to him. But just the phenomena you are experiencing, my boys want nothing to do with me. I've heard from every young man in America wanting advice except my own children.
Kara Swisher
They will. They will.
Scott Galloway
Well, let me just say. Still waiting.
Kara Swisher
You did a good job, and Alex was out partying with the University of Michigan, winning that game against Washington.
Scott Galloway
That game.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. That football game.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, that game. Go blue.
Kara Swisher
Go blue. How was your weekend? How was your week, though, since I saw you?
Scott Galloway
You know, the week, I guess. My week? I'm trying to get back into the swing of things. It's literally 36 degrees. It started snowing the other night here. It's cold here, too. And I'm just trying to get back in the swing. I feel like I liked our podcast, but my podcast at Prop G haven't been very good. I'm trying like my writing is sort of tired. You really do get out of shape pretty quickly. You got to keep it going.
Kara Swisher
You got to keep going.
Scott Galloway
You do, don't you? It's a marathon. It's like a long hill up and a fast hill down.
Kara Swisher
That is correct. And I haven't worked out as much over the holidays. So I was like exhausted today doing basic. Anyway, it's trying to get back. Get back. Get back.
Scott Galloway
I know what you mean. I know what you mean. It is. It's exhausting. Getting back in shape.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, we have a lot to talk about today. Which is almost completely different. Business Insider at odds with parent company Axel Springer. I have to say it like that because it's menacing. And Don Lemon announcing his new venture as X tries to pivot to video. But first, Nikki Haley and Ron DeSantis went head to head Wednesday night in the final GOP debate before Iowa. It was kind of mean. They were like whacking at each other. While the candidates discussed taxes, abortion, foreign policy, they spent a fair amount of time accusing each other of lying. Let's listen to a clip.
Audio Clip Plays
Nikki Haley
But every time he lies, Drake University, don't turn this into a drinking game because you will be over served by the end of the night.
Ron DeSantis
Let's give Ron a little run around the insult train. She's got this problem with ballistic podiatry, shooting herself in the foot every other day, saying things that now she doesn't even take questions from people. That was really stupid. That was really stupid.
Nikki Haley
Let me finish.
Audio Clip Ends
Kara Swisher
Former President Donald Trump was absent from the debate as usual, including on the debate stage. They didn't talk about him very much or they avoided him. They had a few things that were negative towards him, but he really should be center of the whole thing. He held a Fox News town hall where he hinted he had decided on a VP. He gave himself pats on the backs for Roe v. Wade, which I thought was a huge error the way he did it. He has nearly 50% lead in most Iowa polls. But ahead of the big night, Chris Christie officially dropped out of the race, and a lot of those votes are going to Nikki Haley, so she might prevail in New Hampshire. Did you watch any of this, Scott?
Scott Galloway
I watched the clips. I watched the highlights, and both candidates were terribly advised. If one candidate—I mean, first off, Trump absolutely won the night. Trump's clips from that night when he did this Fox Town Hall were when they asked him directly about retribution, recognizing that he has gone full autocrat when he threatens to weaponize his powers as president to go after his political enemies. That is a definition of kind of fascism. He walked that back and said, "I don't have time for retribution and the best retribution is success." Those were great lines. They had such an opportunity, both DeSantis and Haley, and they absolutely blew it.
And it would have been the following. One of them should have entirely ignored the other, entirely ignored. She should have. He should have. They were both terribly advised. They both fell into the same rabbit hole. And that is they think they're running for VP instead of president. And they're not running against each other. They're running against Donald Trump. And if they performed well that night against Donald Trump, they're going to bump up 10 points. If they perform well against the other, they might go up one or two points because there's not that much pie to go after with the other. And they would have absolutely been better advised to have pretended the other person wasn't on the stage, never respond to an insult, never go low, never try and jab back at the distant number two, and just talked about policy and said Donald Trump is an insurrectionist.
Donald Trump's policies have failed. Donald Trump is about to take the Republican Party to Loserville for the third time in a row and literally pretended the other person wasn't there. They would have won the night because their competition isn't each other. They were so poorly advised.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it was interesting. They can't seem to be able to do it. They really can't. She gets closest to it. But with Chris Christie dropping out, there's a big wide berth for that, right? But not Chris Christie far. And by the way, his speech, withdrawing, was quite wonderful, I have to say. It was good. It was really well done. He's a beautiful speaker, I have to say. He really can articulate everything he has to say. And of course, he got caught on a hot mic. I don't know how hot it was. I think he probably didn't mind it happening, saying she was going to get, what was it, smoked? Roasted.
Scott Galloway
She's going to get smoked. Roasted or smoked.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, and said that Ron DeSantis was petrified. And he'll be an interesting character in the—well, he's not really in the Republican Party anymore, is he? He's in something. Anyway. Yeah, I agree. Nothing was gained by these two. But I feel like she's going to win in New Hampshire now. And that'll be one of the things I interviewed, among others, Maggie Haberman. So it's already dropped. And she and others said that dragging it out would be bad for Trump if he doesn't have decisive wins very early. It creates questions around him. It was interesting. We'll see. Probably not. It would be hard to believe that one or both of them, and I think it's most likely Governor Haley, doesn't come up. It's very rare that someone runs away with it that early. It usually does tighten a bit.
Scott Galloway
Well, this is the incumbent, so to speak.
Kara Swisher
But go ahead.
Scott Galloway
I mean, I don't know. I think you could argue it the other way. I think he's a guy who lost. But I'd be shocked if the race doesn't tighten a little bit. It almost always does. It's usually not. At this early, America likes to see a fight. So I'd be shocked if there's not at least a glimpse. And the media will pick up on it. The media wants a fight.
Kara Swisher
I'd like you to predict a vice president.
Scott Galloway
I have absolutely no idea. What do you think, Kara?
Kara Swisher
I think Kristi Noem, although she's got a lot of hair on her and has a nice set of hair. Or Marsha Blackburn.
Scott Galloway
Oh, gosh. Yeah.
Kara Swisher
They would literally look like, I don't know, the lamest redo of Golden Girls.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, that's true. They're too old. Governor Haley would be my fear. These people are so horny for power. I disagree. The reason they didn't go after Trump is—
Kara Swisher
No, no, he's not going to do it.
Scott Galloway
Oh, I see what you're saying. Yeah, she's too establishment. He doesn't want any of those people in the new it is. That would scare the shit out of me because, quite frankly, I think Governor Haley would, I don't want to say solidify. Her as his veep would significantly, in my opinion, increase the likelihood that he would beat Biden. I think that would be a consequential VP pick. But he's not going to do it. He's going to pick, watch if it's Marjorie Taylor Greene. She's among the names being bandied about, just so you know.
Kara Swisher
Maybe Tim Scott. I don't think they're that dumb.
Scott Galloway
Tim Scott. Maybe. He would be good. That would be additive, accretive. Because I think more than anything, who's going to play in this election is going to be Vice President Harris. And fairly or unfairly, I think America is not comfortable with the prospect of her being president. And when you have a president who has somewhere between a 6% and 10% chance each year, according to actuarial tables, of dying, the vice president plays a bigger role.
Kara Swisher
She does. She's almost disappeared, it feels like.
Scott Galloway
I think the GOP is going to start running ads saying, "President Harris, think about that."
Kara Swisher
Yeah, that's true. It's a liability for him. And he's already, the polls are already showing really bad things for him. But it's a long time to November.
Scott Galloway
It is a long time.
Kara Swisher
So another story, Bitcoin, this is interesting. Bitcoin exchange traded funds are already trading following SEC approval. The 11 spot Bitcoin ETFs will make crypto more accessible, allowing investors to gain exposure to crypto without buying it themselves. The decision is expected to lead to a conversion of Grayscale Bitcoin Trust holder of $29 billion of cryptocurrency into an ETF. BlackRock and Fidelity are also expected to launch Bitcoin funds at the time of the taping. Bitcoin is up over 7%. Part of it was a day after the SEC's X account was compromised, announcing the approval early. It's because it didn't have two-factor authentication on it. What do you think of this? I'm really interested because we've been sort of meh on, not meh, but just on most cryptocurrency, not Bitcoin necessarily. But what are your thoughts?
Scott Galloway
I think there's a lot of lessons here. The first is that the way you get wealthy is running into the fire. And when you think about, I mean, Bitcoin's up 70% in recent months, and some of these other coins, Solana, are literally up exponentially. And so when the consensus is something is just terrible and going away, you need to kind of check your emotions and say, okay, does this represent an opportunity? Because typically the biggest opportunities are literally running into the fire. And there's just no getting around it. The crypto market has defied all expectations and punditry and has come ripping back in the context of—
Kara Swisher
Certain ones, certain ones, yeah.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. I mean, crypto's resurgence has been remarkable. And this is in the face of the two primary characters, what is it, Zhao and Bankman-Fried are both going to prison.
Kara Swisher
Right.
Scott Galloway
But this puts it in a much more stable place. If you've got, you know, you can buy into it. It's like buying any kind of asset, right?
Kara Swisher
Well, that's exactly right. Because if I said to you, how can you buy Bitcoin today? Would you know? I would because I bought it before, but yes.
Scott Galloway
Okay. But I think 90% of people who haven't purchased it would have no idea how to actually purchase Bitcoin.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
And this not only brings a halo of legitimacy to it, it brings greater scrutiny. And it also will starch out many of the transaction fees because these ETFs are already competing against each other and bringing down fees. Now, where I go with this, though, is that the company I think this will have the biggest impact on is Coinbase. Because the analogy I would use is that Coinbase is the AOL of the crypto age.
Kara Swisher
Oh, nice. I like that. I was just thinking that. Why?
Scott Galloway
Because they're going to just, you know, they were the early people who gave people the tools. But now Fidelity, I'd buy it through Fidelity. I'm not buying it through Coinbase.
Kara Swisher
That's exactly right. Because people didn't know how to access the internet and the web in the 90s. So they found this safe layer of software on top of it that was friendly and easy to use. And that's Coinbase. And when all of a sudden you can access the web with browsers, specifically an ETF, and it's easy to buy and sell Bitcoin, I believe the value proposition of Coinbase is dramatically reduced. And what was interesting is Brian Armstrong, who's a very smart guy, immediately said, this is amazing for Coinbase and there will be more inflows into Bitcoin. And I believe that the market sensed this was going to happen, see above 70% run up. And then last night when this was announced in the after hour trading, Coinbase exploded up to 160. And as we sit here now, when people are digesting it, it's back to about 147 and it's down. I think this is really bad news for what I would describe as the AOL of 2024, and that is Coinbase.
And there's a couple of those. You're right. They were there to facilitate and make it easier. But people mostly trust Fidelity. I was just, when I saw the, I would buy it through Fidelity.
Scott Galloway
And to be fair, I think seven of the 10 ETFs are going to be sold through Coinbase. But the fees, I mean, to a certain extent, the dislocation and the asymmetry of information resulted in really fat margins and fees for the brokers. But once Vanguard and Schwab are into this thing, they're going to starch out the fees. They're going to say, okay, you can trade this stuff really inexpensively right now. It's good for Bitcoin. It's really good for Michael Saylor and MicroStrategy and Bitcoin bulls. I think this legitimizes it as a true store of value. I've never really, I mean, we'll see if it ends up being an incredible payment infrastructure. But this is great for Bitcoin. I do think that this is good for the SEC. It's good for smaller coins that I think will get a natural updraft because you're just going to have more capital come into the crypto market. I think it's bad for Coinbase and other middleware.
Kara Swisher
I agree. AOL is a good way to put it. Speaking of new things, great news. The Apple Vision Pro mixed reality headset will go on sale in the U.S. on February 2nd. Here we go. Pricing will start at $3,500, making it three times as expensive as Meta's line of mixed reality devices, which used to be expensive. And speaking of wearable devices, Humane, the creator of an AI pin meant to replace smartphones, has laid off 4% of its staff and transitions its CTO to an advisor role. The company's weird AI pin, I never liked that, is planned to begin shipping out in March. I invited you to a demo again, and you're trying to decline it. You cannot insult it without trying it.
Scott Galloway
Let me just come out of the VR closet and officially decline it. I don't need to put this prophylactic on my head.
Kara Swisher
You're wrong.
Scott Galloway
Kara, this has never been easier. Putting on a headset—I know prophylactic I heard you—and for all of you sending me emails saying my dick jokes are offensive, just know every one of those I'm going to go further down the rabbit hole and go more profane.
Kara Swisher
Okay, all right.
Scott Galloway
Putting on a mixed reality headset is like putting on a strap-on. It communicates to the rest of the world that you have a dearth of mating opportunities and a really small dick.
Kara Swisher
Well, you know, some people like strap-ons, Scott. Some people really enjoy them, but go ahead. I'm not against it.
Scott Galloway
Okay. I'm not against it. All right. Okay, two things. This thing, the headset, is a failure. The software and the R&D will pay off. Why? Because the second mouse, the biggest second mouse in history, specifically Apple, is about to come in and take the cheese of the progress in the R&D that Meta has deployed. You know what actually is a pretty cool product and the coolest product that has ever been produced by Meta? Is their Ray-Ban virtual reality glasses.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I was trying them the other day. I like them quite a bit.
Scott Galloway
My son, my 13-year-old bought a pair. We bought a pair for him for Christmas. And when we were skiing, he was wearing them. He wore them the entire trip. And I'd be on a chairlift and he'd look at me and he's like, "Meta, take a photo." And I understand there's privacy concerns, but I put them on. The audio is amazing. And this is what's going to happen. Apple is going to develop all sorts of cool software with this stupid headset. And then they are going to come out with what is the equivalent of an Oliver Peoples Hermes aspirational pair of glasses that are AR enabled. It's going to be the biggest fashion accessory since the AirPods.
Kara Swisher
That may be. I just want you to see what they've done with the software. How about that? Not the device itself. What they've done with the software is startling, actually.
Scott Galloway
I don't doubt it. I've tried them all. And by the way, let's just give a tip of the hat to Snapchat, which was very pioneering.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I don't think they're going to. 100%. They've had, I have all their various glasses and most of the others. So I've been trying these for a long time. This is the, I'm going to buy one. I'm going to buy one. I'm not going to let you use it for sure. Anyway, Humane, I'm not as hot on these pins. I do think there's going to be an AI thing near you that answers questions. Like that, it was interesting because I interviewed Mark Thompson this week in California. What was interesting is that he was talking about CNN, that you'd go, "Oh, what happened this morning?" Like that's, you're going to have that. And it's not going to be Alexa. It's going to be much more intimate. And I think some of these glasses are like that.
Scott Galloway
It'll be, I mean, similar to how the 7 Series or the Maybach or I don't know what the right analogy is. The flagship doesn't sell a lot of cars, but that technology waterfalls down to the products that actually sell a lot. I don't doubt the software is amazing, but the form factor will be a really cool pair of sunglasses or regular glasses that have self-expressive benefit because Apple will partner with, I don't know, Chanel or my favorite sunglasses are Oliver Peoples. They will create the ultimate self-expressive luxury brand, and they'll take that software and that interface that you're talking about, and they'll put it in something that increases your likelihood of propagating and not having your family tree end.
Kara Swisher
All right. Well, we will see. But I think it changes the office experience and the screen experience, and I think the entertainment and photography is beautiful in it, and you need it to be immersive. Anyway, we'll see what happens. But I'm going to stay at your apartment and go for a demo. They've asked you. They nicely called me and said, "Do you think Scott will come?" I said, "Downfall."
Scott Galloway
And I appreciate it. And by the way, my largest holding, I think it's either Airbnb or Apple. I love Apple. I think Tim Cook is a leader. I love the firm. Headsets are fucking ridiculous. Laser disc and strap-ons combined together. Hi, I subscribe to The Information, go to crypto conferences, and have a very small penis.
Kara Swisher
Well, crypto's up. Anyway, let's get to our first big story. Business Insider and its parent company, Axel Springer, are clashing over recent articles alleging Bill Ackman's wife, Neri Oxman, plagiarized parts of her 2010 dissertation. Earlier this week, Axel Springer put out a statement saying it would, quote, "review the processes and the motives around the stories to ensure that standards were upheld." Business Insider Editor-in-Chief Nicholas Carlson, who I've spoken to, says he's made a call to publish the stories and stands by them. This was unprecedented. I want to know what you think of it, but let me just say a few things.
Axel Springer's head of communications told Puck's Dylan Byers that a review was launched because of some of the accusations Bill Ackman made about the stories, specifically the claim that investigating Oxman was anti-Semitic or anti-Zionist. Oxman was born in Israel. Just utter nonsense. I'm sorry. And alleging that one of the editors was anti-Zionist. And Elon has chimed in, of course, saying, "I recommend a lawsuit." It's ridiculous because it's accurate. I think most reporters were like, this was accurate. This is crazy. And I can't believe they meddled like this. I am highly disappointed in them.
It's because he's prominent and he screams a lot. And he's also gone back on what plagiarism is. He's changed his opinion after he got Claudine Gay. And now when it applies to his wife, it's not plagiarism. And you and I agree about it. Neither of them is that big a deal. So he's been talking to Matthias Döpfner. He's talked to the directors and shareholders. He's applying the same bullying aggression here that he does in all his world. And it's somewhat embarrassing, his giant long things he does where he thinks he's on some sort of a holy grail of some sort. But he created this situation for his wife, unfortunately.
So what do you think?
Scott Galloway
So first off, I really appreciate that Bill Ackman is using his platform to talk about what I believe is unprecedented racism and anti-Semitism that I didn't know existed. And I admire that he is speaking out because you do get a lot of blowback. And as a big donor and a leader in finance, I think he has the right to speak out. This, having said that, this is total bullshit. When Claudine Gay says that she was fired because of racism, that is not true. She was fired because the ground shifted beneath her and because she said things that played into people's worst fears about a tolerance of anti-Semitism of which there is no similar tolerance across any other form of bigotry.
And she was fired, which, by the way, happens all the time. And neither was it racism when the president of Penn was fired a couple of weeks before. At the same time, if, again, we said this on the last show, if Bill Ackman wants to weaponize a time machine and start combing through Claudine Gay's past and specifically accusations or AI discovered accusations of plagiarism, he sets his wife up, who is also a prominent academic, for the same type of scrutiny. And what is most upsetting about this is we are entering an era where billionaires like Peter Thiel or Elon Musk or Bill Ackman, unfortunately, can use their billions and their influence to suppress free speech and journalism.
This is a free—I mean, if you want to actually talk about a free speech issue, billionaires, in my opinion, should not be creating a chill around what is—he may not like the reporting. I don't see anything that was not true in this. But I also, quite frankly, and I'm a big fan of Matthias Döpfner. I'm disappointed he didn't stand behind Business Insider in this. I went back and I read the article and I'm like, this is hardly slander. Everything I see in here is accurate. His wife handled it well. They're right. Citation inaccuracy. I have fixed it. Bill was absolutely on the right track. And on the whole, I think his contribution to this mess or situation has been positive.
But when he starts trying to put a chill on journalism with his billions, that is just bullshit. It is bullying and it's bad for America.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. You know what? I don't agree with you. I agree him calling out the issues of anti-Semitism. But this is a piece by Tim Noah, who I like quite a bit, wrote. I've written previously that Ackman's oligarchic bullying and brazen hypocrisy on the subject of anti-Semitism, even as Ackman was trying to blackball a bunch of teenagers whose Harvard student organization signed onto a foolish and offensive letter about the October 7th Hamas massacre. Ackman was simultaneously defending an anti-Semitic tweet made by 53-year-old Elon Musk. Elon Musk, 100%. The offending anti-Semitic tweet was not Musk's first, and it sent corporate advertisers leaving Twitter X in droves in a classic two-step maneuver characteristic of bullies.
Ackman punched down and kissed up, which is what I've said. Now Ackman has extended his hypocrisy into the realm of plagiarism, a project that includes bullying Axel Springer, the publisher of Business Insider, into investigating the ethics of its own scoop. The new campaign is more bizarre and potentially more dangerous. And he just changed his tune, like completely, like as if we're not paying attention. He said he was going after Gay on the board, finally publicly acknowledged some Gay plagiarism, blah, blah, blah. And then he's now changed his opinion about plagiarism, which is because it applies to his wife, which is the family off limits, saying it's because his wife was Israeli.
It's just nonsense. Saying they didn't call him quickly enough. But then it's also that we were having a Shabbat dinner. He knows how journalism works. It's just, they don't, as Tim says, the scoops do not arrive on a convenient schedule. It's just ridiculous. Come on. We were having Shabbat dinner.
Scott Galloway
I know. This is, again, I really didn't like it when Claudine Gay immediately pulled out the racism card when she was fired. I don't think it's any less distasteful that he is immediately going to anti-Semitism here. And also, George Carlin, who's kind of a hero of mine, said, "I love people as individuals." He's like, "You can see the universe in their eyes. It's when they begin to coalesce in groups, when they begin to clot that they're dangerous." And one of the most dangerous clotting, as epitomized here, is white billionaires in their 50s and 60s. And the question I would have for Matthias Döpfner, who is a role model of mine, I like him a lot.
I think he represents a lot of wonderful attributes of masculinity, is if someone who just made a really good living, if this article was written about them, and they weren't a billionaire with the influence of Bill Ackman, would you be calling for a review of this article? This is when it's another billionaire, when it's Musk, Döpfner, and Ackman, they just have a dangerous tendency to agree with each other and support each other, distinct of what are the standard. If you look at the logic here, Business Insider had every right to write an article like this. And what's happened is Bill Ackman has absolutely activated his army of publicists.
He's gone to this positioning of anti-Semitism where you're like, okay. He's doing it himself on Twitter. It's just he keeps changing his tune as if we can't read what he wrote. I mean, the hypocrisy before he was all over Gay about he demanded attention because this is Tim Noah's represented, an exceptional violation of academic standards. Now Ackman was saying they all do it. You know what I mean? This is normal. So did he have a problem with it or has he changed his mind?
And he's calling more attention to the issue. I thought his wife handled it really well. "Yeah, I was wrong. I need to clean it up. Shut the F up about this." And he doesn't have to. And Claudine Gay needs to clean up her stuff. But it wasn't the reason nor why she was fired. It wasn't reason to fire nor why they fired her. And he's created a total sideshow that, in my opinion, distracts from and diminishes the importance of the issues he had raised.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I would agree. Anyway, it's creating a sideshow that just didn't need to be there. And also, when you're Matthias Döpfner and you own Business Insider, you support it. You back it up. I mean, my God, if he wants to do a review of this, I'll send you about 100 articles on Politico and Business Insider that are much more suspect than this.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I agree. They've had some stuff that's...
Kara Swisher
But this is a very solid article. A very good reporter came to it. It's a good article. It's a solid article. Two last things on this: I agree with you. Bill Ackman has just been a bully his whole life, a bullying billionaire, essentially. And he just can't stop. He's got something in his nature that he can't just stop.
Scott Galloway
Well, he's an activist investor. I think it's unfair to call him a bully.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, but he's beyond that. I know a lot of them, and they're not quite like him. And nobody—by the way, I've talked to a lot of people on Wall Street. Most people don't like him. He has a lot of detractors who find him irritating.
Scott Galloway
Well, okay. I've never met the man, but let me also say, I know a lot of good people who are big fans of his.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I know. But I'm just saying, he's a controversial figure.
Scott Galloway
I think that's being kind. He's a billionaire activist investor. That's just not where you go to be well-liked.
Kara Swisher
I guess Carl Icahn's not that well-liked either.
Scott Galloway
Carl Icahn. I know. Name a billionaire activist who's seen as warm and cuddly and everybody loves.
Kara Swisher
I like Dan Loeb. He makes me laugh. And I don't agree with him on almost anything.
Scott Galloway
Dan is funny and a good guy. And not only that, Dan has mellowed. Dan has absolutely mellowed. Those poison pen letters he used to write.
Kara Swisher
I like Charles. Oh, that one guy who was after Microsoft. I liked him.
Scott Galloway
There's David Einhorn, who is a class act.
Kara Swisher
David Einhorn. I like him. He is very good. Super smart. Class act. He's Sheryl Sandberg's cousin.
Scott Galloway
Really? Also, Jeffrey Ubben of ValueAct developed a reputation for being kind of an operational activist and very smart.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. I think the best tweet on it was, "Everything I know about Bill Ackman I learned against my will." There were a lot of good tweets. And let me just say, last thing on Axel Springer. We know Döpfner, and I know a lot of people at the organization. And they're always like, "Kara, you should come over here. Kara, why are you at Vox?" They're always saying, "Let's have a meeting." And now, guess what, boys? Kara's not having a meeting with you ever. Ever, ever, ever, ever. Like, that was it.
Scott Galloway
I'll set out our contracts coming up. We need to cut that out. Daddy wants the cheddar.
Kara Swisher
No. The wealthier I get, the more interesting I get. No, we're not going there. We're not going there, Scott. That's a great firm. They screwed up here. They're allowed to screw up. Then they need to do a public apology. Anyways, and Matthias Döpfner is a fantastic role model. I don't agree with him. He's a little too...
Scott Galloway
Yeah. And Bill gets it mostly right, in my view. Anyways, glass half full.
Kara Swisher
Not this one. Glass half full.
Scott Galloway
No, no, no. You defend rich white men.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, by the way, Döpfner, I think, is a billionaire. That's not fair. That's not fair.
Scott Galloway
Oh, I know that. I know that. I just defend rich white people, not just men. I defend rich white women as well.
Kara Swisher
Scott, let's go on a quick break. When we come back, we'll talk about Don Lemon's new project and X's attempt to be a contender in the online video space and take a listener mail question about tech and health care.
Ad Break
Scott, we're back for our second big story. Don Lemon is back, and he says he's bigger, bolder, freer. He was pretty free. Lemon announced this week that he's starting a new show that will stream exclusively first on X. Episodes will cover politics, culture, sports, entertainment. This is part of X's larger push into video. In a blog post this week, the company declared itself a video-first platform. Don was on our show during Scott Free August this past summer. I asked him about his future plans. Let's listen to what he said.
Audio clip of Don Lemon: "I think I want to do something next that scares the shit out of me. And I had a very successful career in cable news for a long time. I got to do and say exactly what I wanted to. I have and had a very important voice that most people don't get to hear on that platform and still don't. And I expect that to continue, but I'm going to lean into the future of this medium."
So it's a podcast that's going to be first on X, I guess. I knew a lot about this because I talked to Don about it quite a bit. I had other suggestions for him. I suggested he do a deal with Ben Shapiro or go the Megyn Kelly route. I didn't think this was a good idea. So that's full disclosure. And I told him so. And I said, get the money up front. I just don't think it's going to go well for you on this platform. But he did it. He also called X the biggest space for free speech in the world. Tulsi Gabbard and sports commentator Jim Rome are doing video partnerships. Obviously, Tucker Carlson's been there, but then moved to his own subscription-based platform. Scott, what do you think?
Scott Galloway
I said he shouldn't do it. I thought there were lots of other choices. And again, if I'm recommending Ben Shapiro, who I think is abhorrent in many ways, but he's quite a good media executive. That's the kind of outfit I thought he should have affiliated with to create a great media property.
Kara Swisher
I think you're right.
Scott Galloway
So first off, I think Don is a real talent. He is. And I think he's unafraid. He connects with people. He's really handsome, which I think is incredibly important in media. Not as important in podcasting. But if I were him, I would have just started with a podcast with a Vox or Daily Wire and developed a following there. Because X creates a halo that says, "Okay, congratulations. You're now on the same platform as Alex Jones and the guy who runs it is just sort of reckless and strange." This reminds me a little bit of when Yahoo did a big deal with Katie Couric.
Kara Swisher
Yes, I broke all those stories.
Scott Galloway
It's not what I would have done if I was Don. If I were Don, I would have figured out an outlet where I could still have a 30 or 60 minute show because he has a face for television. And I do think him on TV would still do well, even if he had to go to a second-tier network. And he should have done a great podcast to announce this. It's not just Don Lemon and what the topic is going to talk about. It's Don Lemon and X. And X, in my view, is a bad umbrella brand. But on the whole, he's a big talent. And the thing I do like about this is that he is doing something. The key for all of these folks, and I've spoken to a lot of them recently as they're all trying to figure out their third or fourth act, is don't let perfect be the enemy of good. Just get on to the next thing and iterate.
Kara Swisher
Well, they're used to a different world because they're used to being coddled and the whole network system, right? In Katie's case, I actually did break that story. That's how I got to know Katie. She got a ton of money up front, but then they buried her inside of Yahoo, never was on the front page, a whole bunch of things that happened.
Scott Galloway
Well, she only got 1% of what Marissa Mayer paid for Tumblr, who is arguably one of the worst CEOs in the history of tech.
Kara Swisher
I think they paid Don a pile of money. I know they did. A pile.
Scott Galloway
X paid Don Lemon? Really?
Kara Swisher
Mm-hmm.
Scott Galloway
Oh, I didn't know. Well, if that's the case, then I think economic security is important.
Kara Swisher
He has a lot of money. He still got—when they fired him, I think they had to pay out his contract. So I don't know. He could have had more money. I think, again, can't stand what Megyn Kelly's doing, but I get it. I get it.
Scott Galloway
Oh, she's very good at what she does.
Kara Swisher
Yes, that's what I mean. She's very good at what she does. And I talked to her before she did that. The other thing I recommended to Don is, if you want to stay on television, go to a big market like Los Angeles and be the anchor for the top TV station and start to do interesting things.
Scott Galloway
Those guys will never go local after being national. I get it, but you could do some interesting things. That's a great kind of place. Anyway, I just don't think this was a good idea. But I guess if you got a pile of money, good for you, Don.
Kara Swisher
X has the money to pay these kinds of things. I would think X should be... Yeah, I said get it up front, Don. Like Bitcoin or something. Get it right up front.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, just be mindful. If you get fired, you might not get the severance or health care you were contractually obligated to.
Kara Swisher
Speaking of which, I was in San Francisco. There's going to be some lawsuits soon because he hasn't paid any of them what he owes them. From top to bottom, the ex-Twitter employees. And he's using specious ideas of why. I forget what the one was. There were a couple of different people who told me different things they're accusing them of so they don't have to pay them. But it goes back to the same thing with this bullshit around, "Well, I'm a billionaire, so I can put a chill on all of media." And that is, if I'm a billionaire, I'm not subject to the nuisance of a contract.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I said I would pay you severance, but I've decided not to.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, there's going to be some big lawsuits. I would say I would pay your COBRA so you could have health insurance for you and your family. Well, guess what? You can't even reach someone in HR because I've already fired them. And go ahead, sue me because I'm a billionaire.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I have a PR team. I am optimized for conflict because I'm an activist investor and I am a billionaire and I'm going to see Matthias Döpfner at Davos next week. I'm going to fuck with you because I can.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I agree. It's the same bullshit. It is. And that is the government and media to a certain extent—we're here to push back on power when it gets too concentrated. It corrupts the system and people.
Scott Galloway
What kind of billionaires would we be? Would we be good?
Kara Swisher
What's that?
Scott Galloway
What kind of billionaires would we be? Would we be good?
Kara Swisher
Well, I'd like to find out.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I'd like to find out. Don't you think we'd be good billionaires?
Kara Swisher
Maybe not. It's impossible, I guess.
Scott Galloway
Well, there are a lot of good billionaires. As a matter of fact, I would argue there are just as many...
Kara Swisher
Yes, I agree. Cuban. Good billionaires out there proportionally. There are good millionaires or good poor people. I've never bought into the demonization of people who are rich. But anyways, when you get drunk on your power... Most billionaires I know, as they get wealthier and more powerful, they use power judiciously and they recognize that they shouldn't abuse it.
Scott Galloway
I always took this lesson from Warren Hellman. He was the first billionaire I ever met. And he taught me something that I have put into practice my entire career. I met him when I was in my 20s, just out of business school. Hellman & Friedman, huge, probably the iconic private equity firm on the West Coast. And he was a mentor of mine. I used to meet with him once a month and have lunch. And I said, "This firm treated us really poorly and I'm so angry and they signed a contract and they're not paying. Can you recommend a law firm for me?" And he said, "Scott, in my 50 years in business, I have never sued anybody. If someone doesn't treat you well, unless they really are abusing you, just don't do business with them again."
Kara Swisher
Yeah, they love to threaten lawsuits, these people, constantly. I'm just waiting for mine for my book. So let me get back to Don. Let me get back to this video strategy.
Scott Galloway
It's so abusive. It really is.
Kara Swisher
But the video strategy that they have now—ex-CEO Linda Yaccarino is at CES this week, getting asked why advertisers should put ads on X given the hateful content risk. She said that hate speech is an issue every platform faces. Can they pivot to video? No. YouTube, Reddit, Instagram, too, would like to have a word, Twitter. They're so behind. They blew all their chances early. They have TikTok. I'm sorry, I left out TikTok. Their competitors are superb and good at what they do. They have no chance. I don't see how they have any chance. This is another bullshit thing that they aren't going to do, like a lot of the Twitter Blue stuff is now falling off. All their promises. So I don't see them being able to pivot to this at all.
Scott Galloway
Well, back in the day, one of my investors was Tim Armstrong. A really talented, nice man. And I don't know if it was him or his head of strategy, but the question was, "What would you do if you were Yahoo?" That was probably a decade ago.
Kara Swisher
Oh, yeah, that's right. He bought it, yeah.
Scott Galloway
I mean, I would be the world's largest TV network. And your distribution platform is the internet. And word is out that video is big. And to your point, YouTube does a really good job. TikTok does a really good job. So I'm not saying it might be the right strategy, but it feels a little bit late. It feels like they don't have the capital, the engineering talent. And they were there already eight years too late. So I don't—yeah, it makes sense. But the notion that... Look, Twitter, X has to do something, right? They have to innovate. They have to do something. They have to experiment. This does feel like a media strategy by someone who doesn't know media, which would be Musk and Linda Yaccarino, who came from NBC.
Kara Swisher
So this is her move. And she was not in programming or editorial or anything. She knows how to put names like Tulsi Gabbard and Don Lemon out there. She thinks it's going to—she goes for the deal, the splashy deal at CES. That's not how it works anymore. It's people you don't know. It's Mr. Beast or something. It's just not this.
Scott Galloway
Well, it's nice people who are native. I will say, I watched Tulsi on Fox. Yeah, she's had some talent. She was good. I think she's talented. I was shocked at how good she was on air. If I were her, I would have done a deal, and maybe they just got bought. They just threw so much money at them. And if that's the case, Don Lemon, I take it back. Good for you.
Kara Swisher
No, it's not good. It's not good for him. He could have made just—Megyn Kelly is making bank and she controls her destiny.
Scott Galloway
Good point. Fair point.
Kara Swisher
You don't need it. I was talking to someone about this and about my own career, and they said, "Why don't you come with us full time?" I said, "You can't afford me. You don't understand." I can do better by myself. Things have changed, and I'm not even very big.
Scott Galloway
I mean, you stay at the nicest hotels in Manhattan.
Kara Swisher
Oh, wait, nevermind. Nevermind. You go through my closets and comment on my food.
Scott Galloway
I actually love your apartment. I love it. It's nice, isn't it? I love it. It makes me happy to know you're there. I love people's homes. I stayed with Brooke Hammerling in Los Angeles. It's a beautiful home. I don't like hotels. I'm not a hotel liker. But I love your house.
Kara Swisher
I love hotels. Room service. Call, scream at people. "Where are my A's?" I don't like it.
Scott Galloway
I like your apartment quite a bit. And I don't know why I have an affection for it. I really do. And it's not because it's that fancy. It's just really lovely. It's a lovely feeling at your apartment. It's got a nice vibe. It's got a good vibe. It's full of love and Alice.
Kara Swisher
It's full of love. Last thing is this world of online video changing. Where do you think it's going? I did interview Mark Thompson in an offsite for Warner Brothers. I don't know if it was off the record or not. I was never told it was, but it was a really interesting conversation. He said, among other things, that conventional TV can no longer define us. Although he wasn't abandoning TV. That wasn't what he meant.
Scott Galloway
What does that mean?
Kara Swisher
Well, I think he was trying to get more out of him about it, actually. I think he has to figure out where and how to move their stuff and control it. He said it wasn't a shift and lift from what he did at the New York Times, which was move it over to digital while keeping the print thing going. Because he thought video, like TV distribution linear, would be around for several decades. And I would agree with him. It's already there. So why not take advantage of it? But you have to sort of move everything, think of it as a digital product over time. And he said, "We have to own it and not be subject to other people's platforms." It was interesting. He's a smart man.
Scott Galloway
But what is the strategy? If you were to define—maybe you didn't get this information—how Mark Thompson is going to do it, what is the strategy or the shift in programming or distribution that we'll see under Mark Thompson that we weren't going to see under Chris Licht?
Kara Swisher
A subscription. A subscription. That's my—she didn't say it, but there's no other way. Like what they did at the New York Times. Some of it's free.
Scott Galloway
You mean like CNN Plus?
Kara Swisher
Yes, exactly. That's what I said. I said the problem with CNN Plus was directionally correct, but there was no CNN. It was like Hamburger Plus without Hamburger, right? I don't get it. Why don't you? But I think some of the stuff—I think he's right. Some news does lend itself to television, fast news, fast moving. But I think the dependence on the platforms like Twitter or YouTube or whatever—the monetization's not there. And I think the Times was doing that too, just the way everybody gave all their content to Netflix and regretted it, I think, in a lot of ways, and didn't own it themselves and take the cost of doing it. I think that's his inclination. I think he's correct. It has to be a product that people want to buy, a news product that people want to buy from CNN. And some of it's free, some of it's not. I mean, he has to—you know, they could look at Netflix is now very successfully doing advertising. Amazon is about to make its ad tier default for its millions of Prime Video subscribers. So there's a lot of ad stuff in an interesting way. So they have some interesting opportunities, and he's very canny. So I don't know. What would you do if you were running CNN?
Scott Galloway
I would try and elegantly integrate it into the Max offering and always have a CNN bug where you could click it. And they did—you know, they had six, 10, 20 minute loops where you could get your quick hit of news and then you could go vertical—quick hit of news around politics, around business. To me, it becomes the ingredient news brand for the subscription service Max. I don't think it's a standalone subscription service. I think it's the ingredient, it's the NutraSweet of Max around news. Because when you think about it, the biggest players, whether it's Disney Plus or Netflix, what they lack is news. So it's the Intel Inside of Max.
Kara Swisher
I'll tell you the most interesting thing he said offhand, which was this idea of you wake up and you're like, "I want to know more about that." I want it like an AI-generated—their news done by people is then applied digitally and with AI, with generative AI, so that you start to get—they're exploring deals with OpenAI. That was just reported yesterday. And he didn't say as much, but obviously everyone's talking to them. But that you have some kind of relationship with your news. It's not—because Google laid off hundreds of jobs to voice activity assistance software. This is all going to be AI generated. And he had some ideas around that, and I thought that was smart. So he's working it out, but it's definitely a transition. David Zaslav was there. He was wearing his David Zaslav outfit and everything. But it was interesting. He's a really smart thinker. I think this is going to be a great year for CNN.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I do too. He's very—Mark is very thoughtful. I really enjoy talking to him. And I can see he's working it out. It's not going to be unlike what happened at the New York Times, using this amazing brand and huge amounts of reporters to really bring to bear. There's monetization there. As opposed to Linda doing these one-off deals, and it's just not an editorial product. Very similar to what happened at Yahoo.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, let's pivot to a listener question. This question comes from Brian. Let's listen.
Audio clip: "Hi, Scott and Kara. My name is Brian and I'm calling from Los Angeles. I'm a longtime listener of the show and I appreciate the opportunity to ask a question. My question is on technology in healthcare. Specifically, where is it? There's a huge need for competition at the payer level, at the provider level, at the facility level. I see Amazon moving into primary care and prescriptions, but within the healthcare system I work in, no one actually considers that competition. What about surgeries or inpatient care or health plans? I feel kind of like a conspiracy theorist telling people that tech is coming, tech is coming. But is it? I would love your thoughts. Thanks so much."
Interesting. I mean, it's gone on for decades now. Google and others were in healthcare, the health fault, Microsoft. And they were always going to—this was always going to apply. And now it's AI that's going to save us. It's going to know what you have by speaking into it and this and that. So I don't know. Scott, what do you think?
Scott Galloway
I don't want to say I've given up on the notion that in the current construct, the technology is going to save us. So I'm sort of—it's been interesting living in the UK, contrasting or comparing and contrasting the approach to healthcare. And where I start is that it's almost impossible to fix a system where infant mortality and obesity and depression are greater, despite the fact we spend on average $12,500 per citizen, as opposed to Australia, Canada, and the UK that spend $6,500. It's arguably the most wasteful, biggest tax on the American economy: the US healthcare system. And if you want evidence of that, just look at every hospital system and insurance company that every year increases their earnings and their profits through regulatory capture. They have quietly weaponized government and have created a ton of moats around any—even Google and Amazon can't crack this nut.
Kara Swisher
Well, I think One Medical—I'm going there tomorrow. I have some—it's just easy. I'm a member. I love One Medical.
Scott Galloway
We're talking about a pimple on the pimple of the elephant right now.
Kara Swisher
Yes, agreed, agreed, agreed.
Scott Galloway
And where I am is gigantic structural change over the long term. I'm an advocate for—if you look at the UK system, what you call the—I don't want to call them the bottom 90, but 90th percentile and lower access NHS. And I've accessed NHS. The waits are longer. It can be frustrating. But there's something really wonderful knowing that if your wife gets lung cancer, it doesn't mean you're going to go bankrupt. Six of the 10 happiest countries in the world are socialist countries in Northern Europe. And it's not only a function of what you have, but absence from having things taken away from you, specifically your dignity if you get sick.
We do not have the absence from that fear in the United States. So the question is, how do you disrupt the traditional system? And where I am is the following: Medicare each year for the next 65 years should be lowered by a year until it's all Medicare. We need nationalized healthcare. The only way you're going to get there—Hillary couldn't do it—is to say, "All right, every year we're going to lower the age of Medicare until we do away with the most profitable, unearned regulatory capture profits in history, and that it's a privatization of healthcare." I don't want to say I've given up. There'll be some disruption, but we need massive structural change in America.
Kara Swisher
It's not—doctors hate it. Patients hate it. Government doesn't really like it. How we develop drugs is also antiquated. I just find it—whenever I feel sick, I feel frustrated because I don't even understand it. And I'm a very aggressive consumer in that. And there are hacks. We need better tax policy because we're so narcissistic or jingoistic, whatever you want to call it. I mean, Japan tries to figure out ways to incorporate exercise into people's lives. There's just—we don't want kids to eat well. Because guess what?
Once they get obese, there's a ton of money in it for us.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. I call it the diabetes industrial complex.
Kara Swisher
I wonder where you got that.
Scott Galloway
Anyways, so there are too many economic incentives and too many people making too much money to pretend that they give a good goddamn around the long-term health benefits of American citizens. And government needs to pass a law and say, okay, we're done trying to fine-tune this. Too many of us have been weaponized. We're going to lower Medicare, which is nationalized health care and health care for all, which, by the way, the majority of Medicare recipients are pretty happy with. And also, on a cost basis, it's pretty efficient. And every year for the next 65 years, we're going to lower it a year.
Kara Swisher
We'll see. We don't think there's much tech in it. There's tech applied to it. And people have great hopes for gender of AI, Brian. But we've seen this before. So it really does take a bigger effort on behalf of the government and industry to make this turnaround. But, yeah, there's only one payer. There's only one if they all complain about it, too. Anyway, we'll see. We'll see.
Transition to ad break and show announcements
By the way, next week we're going to try something a little different with our listener mail. We'll be taking calls directly from you during our regular taping. Little scary.
Scott Galloway
That's right. You can ask us your questions to our faces. Well, over digital, so you can't touch us.
Kara Swisher
I mean, as much as Scott might like that.
Scott Galloway
Call 855-51-PIVOT to tell us what you might like to ask, and leave your name, age, and where you're from, and where we can reach you. You won't be able to fit everybody in, but our producers might be reaching out to you to join the show. So get those questions in now. You can talk to Scott directly.
Kara Swisher
All right, Scott, one more quick break. We'll be back for predictions.
Ad break
Okay, Scott, let's hear a prediction.
Scott Galloway
So I'm going to do a quick prediction, and I want to take a license here and talk about a win or something that really moved me this week. My prediction is that Coinbase is the AOL. I said it. The stock's up. I mean, the stock has just skyrocketed. I think it's overvalued. I think it's a good firm that's well run. I think it has a role to play and they'll find new ways. But it's just, it's like AOL. It's going to dramatically shed a ton of value, I think, over the next few years. Because it's been the on-ramp into crypto and people no longer need a safe, "You've got mail" kind of friendly place to buy crypto.
So occasionally you see something or a piece of content that inspires you. And I bond with my kids over media. I send them Tom Petty, which they don't listen to. And they send me rap that I don't get. But anyways, we watch full shows together. And I'm watching with my 13-year-old. Have you seen *The Last of Us*?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, parts of it. It hasn't caught on with me yet. But that one with the gays, I saw the gays one.
Scott Galloway
You're stealing my thunder. So I have no interest in anything around the zombie apocalypse. It's a genre that has no interest in me. I haven't watched a single episode of *The Walking Dead*, nor will I ever. But my son wanted to watch *The Last of Us*. And I'm like, oh, God, here we go again. Episode one. I think Pedro Pascal is a leading man. I love him. I loved him in *Narcos*. He's the best guy with a mask on in *The Mandalorian*. And episode three, which you just referenced, is so moving and such a great piece of art. And it's about, I won't give it away, but it's about a survivalist slash prepper played by Nick Offerman from *Parks and Rec*. And the story is about he helps protect somebody and he falls in love. And it's just the story of these two men.
And the reason why it was such a nice moment for my son and I because we were talking about it afterwards. And the thing I take from it, I've been thinking a lot about masculinity. I'm trying to write a book on it. And here you had a guy who brings what Richard Reeves, who's sort of my Yoda around this stuff, and is able to kind of articulate the things I'm feeling and seeing. But he talks about the notion of men and their need to create surplus value. What do we mean by that? That when you become a man, it isn't about reading from some religious scripture or having sex or turning 18 or getting a job. That when you become a man is when you start adding surplus value. And as a boy, your return on investment is negative. People give you love, they give you resources, they give you attention, they spoil you. And quite frankly, other than the people who love you, you don't add a lot back to society. And some people never grow out of that. Some people just for their whole lives take more than they return.
And his notion is, and I love this, that what it means to be a man is you add surplus value. That the time, the attention, and the resources you take in, that you are so skilled and you acquire so many strengths and competences that you produce more than you consume. You add surplus value. And I absolutely love that as a metric. And here's this guy, this prepper and the survivalist who is so talented. And obviously, those politics are a with electrified fences that zap the zombies, but he raises chickens. He's a great cook. He's figured out a way to maintain running hot water in the middle of a zombie. He's so talented, but the surplus value is that he finds someone to protect and to love. And I absolutely love that notion. It's a really good show.
Kara Swisher
May I recommend another one? It's a gay love story, really, but is *San Junipero* on? Did you ever see that?
Scott Galloway
I didn't.
Kara Swisher
Please, please avail yourself to that. And it's got a very similar vibe and it's about two women and they're in a virtual reality setting. And I think you will weep, weep giant tears.
Scott Galloway
I love the idea of this notion of defining manhood and masculinity as surplus value. And then I thought this represented that. And this is the conversation I was having with my 13 year old. I'm like, this is what men do. They develop the skills and they acquire the strength such that they can protect and love others. And there's this great line at the end. This guy Nick Offerman says at the very end of it, and I won't spoil the end of it, he says, "You gave me purpose." And that's, I love that. I'm like, that's what it means to be a man. You find purpose and your purpose is to protect others. I just thought it was wonderful. Anyways, my win, episode three, season one, *Last of Us*.
Kara Swisher
I'm surprised you haven't seen it. It's so funny because for a while, when it appeared, people went crazy for it. May I ask you a question?
Scott Galloway
Yes.
Kara Swisher
Doesn't that apply to women? Masculinity is not the domain.
Scott Galloway
Right.
Kara Swisher
Aren't women supposed to protect and add at the same time?
Scott Galloway
Do you want me to answer you?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I'm going to. Let me finish. Okay.
Scott Galloway
Masculinity and femininity are social constructs that we invent. They are not the domain of people born as men and women. However, people born as men and people born as women have instinctual predilections and competences that oftentimes lend them towards more feminine or more masculine attributes. I believe femininity is more about nurturing and more about being loving and also protecting. And I think a lot of women demonstrate wonderful masculine attributes. And I think a lot of men, also the men I'm usually attracted to as friends, can indicate and represent wonderful feminine attributes. But I think masculinity, which typically people born as men have an easier time embracing, needs redefinition. It needs a modern aspirational definition. Because unfortunately right now, anything that is seen as masculine is conflated with toxicity, and that's bullshit. It's not sequestered from women, nor is femininity sequestered from men. We absolutely appreciate femininity. I would argue it's more nurturing, more loving, more graceful, less prone to judgment.
Kara Swisher
Maybe we need new words.
Scott Galloway
Maybe we need new words. I'm up for it, sister, because we need a better dialogue around this stuff. We need to respect the fact that most people, 90 to 95% of people, identify as binary, and the attributes and competences and feelings and instincts they feel are wonderful. And that doesn't mean it's sequestered from the other gender. I think you demonstrate a lot of wonderful masculine attributes. I'd like to believe I demonstrate a lot of wonderful feminine attributes. But we can celebrate both those things. Need new words. Need new words. Anyway, that's a good one. It's a great show. You should see it.
Kara Swisher
But I promise you, if you watch *Black Mirror*, that *San Junipero*, it'll make your heart sing. It's beautiful. The same way.
Scott Galloway
*Black Mirror*. Can you say it again?
Kara Swisher
*Black Mirror*, *San Junipero*.
Scott Galloway
*Black Mirror*, *San Junipero*.
Kara Swisher
It's very tech-focused, too, which is interesting, and it's really cool. Anyway, we'll be back next week. Read us out, Scott.
Scott Galloway
Today's show was produced by Lara Neyman, Zoe Marcus, and Taylor Griffin. Ernie Undertot engineered this episode. Thanks also to Drew Brose and Miel Saverio. Make sure you're subscribed to the show wherever you listen to podcasts. Thanks for listening to *Pivot* from New York Magazine and Vox Media. You can subscribe to the magazine at nymag.com slash pod. We'll be back next week for another breakdown of all things tech and business.
Kara Swisher
Season one, episode three, *The Last of Us*.
Scott Galloway
Lovely Frick.