The main topic of this podcast episode is a discussion of various business and tech-related news and trends, including Elon Musk's recent outburst at the New York Times Dealbook Summit, the potential IPOs of Reddit and Skims, and the book "The Fund" by Rob Copeland, which is a scathing look at Ray Dalio and his hedge fund Bridgewater.
Key points from the episode include:
Participants in the episode include:
Takeaways from the episode include:
Overall, this episode of the podcast provides a thought-provoking and insightful discussion of various business and tech-related news and trends.
Ad Break
Kara Swisher
As marketing channels have multiplied, the demand for content has skyrocketed. But everyone can make content that's on brand and stands out with Adobe Express. You don't have to be a designer to generate images, rewrite text, and create effects. That's the beauty of generative AI that's commercially safe. Teams all across your business will be psyched to collaborate and create amazing presentations, videos, social posts, flyers, and more. Meet Adobe Express, the quick and easy app to create on-brand content. Learn more at adobe.com slash express slash business.
Ad Break
Rinse takes your laundry and hand delivers it to your door. Expertly cleaned and folded. So you could take the time once spent folding and sorting and waiting to finally pursue a whole new version of you. Like Tea Time You. Mmm. Or this Tea Time You. Or even this Tea Time You. Said you hear about Dave. Or even Tea Time, Tea Time, Tea Time You. Mmm. So update on Dave. It's up to you. We'll take the laundry. Rinse. It's time to be great.
Intro Music
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Cara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And tell me you're abusing ketamine without telling me you're abusing ketamine, Cara.
Kara Swisher
I am only bereft that Jonathan had to be there to witness that. Jonathan Ross Sorkin.
Scott Galloway
Did you see that part? He called our Canadian friend Jonathan. And Andrew was like, "I'm Andrew."
Kara Swisher
Oh, my God, I did see that. He said, "You're my good friend, Jonathan." And I was thinking, why did he think Jonathan? Is it the only sort of Jewish sounding name he could think of? I don't even know what he was doing there.
Scott Galloway
Well, if that whole dialogue cemented or proved anything, it is that, in fact, Andrew Ross Sorkin is Canadian. One. He is. He calmly, he was calm. He was on stage the entire time, both unarmed and had health insurance. Canadian. And you know how you get a Canadian to apologize?
Kara Swisher
How?
Scott Galloway
You step on his foot. And that has some relevance here.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, yeah, which we'll get to. Andrew felt bad. It was like the way Andrew felt... I don't know if he felt bad for the audience. I don't know. Are we going to come back to this because I have a bunch of analogies?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, we are. We have a lot to talk about.
Kara Swisher
Let me say, I thought he looked... I just want to say Andrew did a great job. He looked like a person who'd been yelled at on the street by someone, like someone yelling at them. And he didn't know what to do. He was trying to be polite because he's a polite Canadian. Jonathan is.
Scott Galloway
Anyway, we have a lot to get through today, as you can see. One of our listeners posted on X, "Hardest job of the week goes to Pivot producers trying to figure out how to lasso all the news of the last 24 hours in just one episode." Well, at Startup Stephanie, we just decided to cover all of it. We're going to go through it really fast. Plus, New York Times reporter Rob Copeland will join us to discuss his new book, *The Fund: Ray Dalio, Bridgewater Associates, and the Unraveling of a Wall Street Legend*. It's getting a lot of attention.
Kara Swisher
We're going to go right to our first story. As we were talking about, Elon Musk gave quite a performance at the New York Times DealBook Summit on Wednesday, which was chock full of really good interviews. In a lengthy conversation with Jonathan Ross Sorkin, also known as Andrew, Elon addressed numerous topics ranging from his anti-Semitic comments to his grudge against Biden and waiting... They don't open AI, aliens, monkeys, and more. And something about Earth, I don't quite understand what that was about.
Scott Galloway
And when they apologized for that anti-Semitic tweet, it was a comment directed at X's advertisers that caused the most chaos. Let's listen.
[Audio Clip - Elon Musk at DealBook Summit] Elon Musk: If somebody's going to try to blackmail me with advertising, blackmail me with money, go fuck yourself. But go fuck yourself. Is that clear? I hope it is. Hey, Bob, if you're in the audience.
Andrew Ross Sorkin
Well, let me ask you then.
Elon Musk
That's how I feel. Don't advertise.
Andrew Ross Sorkin
When pressed on what it would mean for his company, this is what he said.
Elon Musk
Actually, what this advertising boycott is going to do, it's going to kill the company. And the whole world will know that those advertisers killed the company, and we will document it in great detail.
Andrew Ross Sorkin
And you think that the company...
Elon Musk
But those advertisers, I imagine, are going to say, "We didn't kill the company."
Andrew Ross Sorkin
Oh, yeah.
Elon Musk
They're going to say... Tell it to Earth. Tell it to Earth.
End Audio Clip
Kara Swisher
You have to watch this in whole, because the entire thing is bizarre, not just this. His diatribe against not being invited to a Biden confab. Everything was so strange. "Tell it to Earth." What did you think as you watched this? The shout out was to Bob Iger, by the way, who earlier in the day, when asked about Elon and advertising on X, said that the association was not necessarily a positive one for us.
Scott Galloway
Scott, you were on Christiane Amanpour's show about a year ago and had some comments on Elon that are particularly fitting today. Let's listen.
[Audio Clip - Scott Galloway on Christiane Amanpour] Scott Galloway: Yeah, I think we're seeing the unwinding not of a company but the unwinding of a person. And I believe it's a larger trend: as societies become wealthier, more educated, the reliance on a super being and church attendance goes down, but they still look for idols. Into that void has stepped technology leaders, because technology is the closest thing we have to magic. And our new Jesus Christ was Steve Jobs, and now Elon Musk has taken on that mantle. And every ridiculously mean, nonsensical, irrational move he makes is somehow seen as chestnut checkers. We're just not privy to his genius yet.
End Audio Clip
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it's crazy checkers. So let's go through the stuff. Let's go through it. And I just... let me have some other highlights if we want to call them that. Elon's issues with Biden go back to Tesla getting excluded from this White House event on electric vehicles. He shortly after Biden took office, he said it wasn't fair. He's obviously hurting from it. He said, "I have done more for the environment than any other person on Earth" when talking about electric vehicle sales. Nikki Haley was dismissed as a pro-censorship candidate. More on her later. OpenAI should be renamed "Super Closed Source for Maximum Profit AI." Ha ha. Scott, please go ahead.
Scott Galloway
I was on a plane watching it last night. I came home from Miami, and I found it difficult to watch. I think the most generous thing you could say is it was an intense bout of jet lag, but there's something going on here. And I, of course, went to ChatGPT and I typed in, "What are the symptoms of a narcissist having a breakdown?" And it came back with: intense rage and anger, blame shifting, emotional dysregulation, paranoia, depression, anxiety, manipulative behaviors, isolation, self-destructive behaviors, increased sensitivity to criticism, and breakdown of relationships. I mean, his statements were so ridiculous, Kara. Do you realize that 497 of the Fortune 500 companies in the United States are clearly blackmailing us because they refuse to advertise on our platform? And then to go after Disney... The whole thing was just... and to be that profane and that aggressive and then to somehow threaten advertisers that the world will hold you accountable if Twitter goes down. Earth will.
Kara Swisher
I thought the most disturbing part is someone who raises boys. I'm talking about as a 13-year-old, just the incredible hardship and dysfunction he faced. And so his answer or his response to this incredible abuse, being the son of a model and an emerald miner, was the decision to save humanity by making us an interplanetary species. I mean, he's literally... he's just kind of fucking lost his shit.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, he's deluded. His stands literally were like... this was great. He told it like it was. It's really sad. It's sad. I don't feel sorry for him, but it's sad to watch. He thinks he's great. His clothes were strange. He was dressed as a fighter pilot from World War II, I guess. I don't really know.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I did notice that. Which is fine. He can wear whatever he wants. But the whole visual was weird. He looked exhausted. He looked unshaven. I thought Linda Yaccarino did the worst job of any CEO in recent memory, but he has managed to top it. He bested her.
Scott Galloway
Two things. Linda Yaccarino was in the audience. She then, I thought, she must have been horrified, but instead she put up a lengthy post on X afterwards. I'm not going to read it in full, but here's a quote: "When it comes to advertising, X is standing at a unique and amazing intersection of free speech and Main Street." Block that fucking metaphor, but okay. I think she just got run over by a truck essentially driven by Elon Musk.
Kara Swisher
One was, how do you think she's feeling today at that intersection? She is really a piece of work, I gotta say, because she seems nuts, but she is obviously something else. My understanding of Linda is that she was outstanding at her job. She was a fantastic head of sales.
Scott Galloway
Well, I'll get to that, yeah.
Kara Swisher
And so you put someone as a head of sales for a traditional company with a lot of products, a lot of outstanding assets to sell, and then you show up and you're fighting a fire with a squirt gun. And then you find out that the person you're fighting for keeps putting gasoline in your squirt gun. Her job is near impossible. She doesn't have to go this far. She can leave. She cannot put out quotes like this. This was shocking to me.
Scott Galloway
I can't decide whether she's part of the problem. There have been very few people who have gone from zero to global awareness and then, in almost as fast a time period, have absolutely destroyed their reputation. Now, you could argue in this day and age, it's just all about awareness. And I think she'll be able to get another job. But she just looks totally flaccid in the face of an owner who doesn't respect anything about her role as CEO. She's not a CEO. And again, the analogy is she's the circus clown following this elephant around, scooping up his shit all the time.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, yeah. It's really... She was also the subject of a not very flattering profile in The Hollywood Reporter by Kim Masters on Wednesday, where the writer spoke with unnamed former NBC colleagues. The article quotes someone who said Linda let her ego get the best of her. She thought she could control him. It was a level of ego and hubris you rarely see. I thought it was a pretty fair article. Others thought it was all unnamed sources. But it was accurate. I know her. She was tough. She's a tough and somewhat chaotic manager. Not that I care. Lots of bad people don't manage as well. But she definitely is way over her skis, but then continues to double down. That's the tragedy here, this sort of full-scale embracing of this lunatic behavior by Elon. Why would any advertisers stay with X at this point? He's done this before. Remember when he first got to the company, he insulted advertisers at that first advertising meeting? "Don't advertise with us." And he just hates anyone in control of his destiny, I guess.
Scott Galloway
Well, the answer is no big advertiser is going to... or no advertiser is worried about their reputation. I mean, I found his comments... everyone wants to try and peer into his heart to really understand if he's an anti-Semite. And my view is if you say and do anti-Semitic things, then boom, you're an anti-Semite. And so big companies that are correctly more sensitive to this sort of scrutiny and criticism, as they should be, are going to stay away from this thing. Because here's the thing: there are about a billion other options to spend your money. There's no shortage. There are fewer ad dollars than there are platforms to spend those dollars on. Why take the risk? It's never been known as being a great product in terms of ROI.
Kara Swisher
The people or the firms that will continue to advertise... Well, because the outflow of advertising will be so dramatic, logically speaking, the ROI on the ad dollars that remain should go up because there will be fewer of them. So if you're trying to sell an ear cleaning product, I wouldn't be surprised... and I hate to say this... I wouldn't be surprised if the ROI on your ad dollars on Twitter that are going to be competing with much fewer dollars for eyeballs will actually go up. So they'll probably see a bit of a bump, the smaller advertisers, in terms of ROI, because there'll be so few dollars chasing what is still a fairly large audience.
Scott Galloway
The ads have gotten really scary. They've gotten really weird. Ear cleaning product is one of them. And that weird glue. Now, you haven't been on it, but there's a weird hand glue. I don't really know what it is.
Kara Swisher
How is this going to end? What is Earth going to do? Because from a business point of view, last week, the New York Times reported that X was in danger of losing $75 million in advertising before the interview. You're in a room with marketers right now who are still on the platform. What is being said?
Scott Galloway
Well, it's not any marketer I would know. No CMO of any company. Here's my boast of narcissism: I've worked with 27 of the 100 CMOs of the Fortune 100 globally. None of them would have anything to do with this platform right now. None of them. It's all... let me get this. The product's not that great. You might be accused of enabling an anti-Semite. Oh, and if you decide to stop advertising, he's going to say you're blackmailing him and start threatening revenge against you? I mean, okay, what is the upside here? Let's look at the upside versus the downside. There are a few things a CMO can be fired for kind of unceremoniously. If you were to go on Twitter and spend some money and then it were to blow up in your face, say your Pepsi ad ends up next to a swastika. And then a really decent question would be like, "You saw this shit happening and you made the conscious decision to put us at risk like this?" So nobody you or I know is going to be advertising on this platform. It is a traffic accident. Speaking of the corner of free speech and Maine, I don't know. This is just... it was so bizarre.
Kara Swisher
I was in New York. I didn't go. But you used to be friends with him.
Scott Galloway
I wasn't friends.
Kara Swisher
He was so funny. He was referring to Andrew as a friend, Jonathan as a friend. Jonathan's not his friend either. He thinks anyone who's nice to him is his friend. It's really sad, actually. Andrew and I are just reporters. I liked him. I certainly thought he was interesting. No, I don't. Everyone just shakes their head. Everyone just shakes their head.
Scott Galloway
I do think on a meta level, I do think the world is having a healthy immune response to Elon Musk. And that is throughout history... Yeah, the audience certainly did. You could hear it. They were like, "Huh, huh, huh, huh." But we don't have a president of the world. We don't have one company that controls the world. We have several that are marching towards that. But generally speaking, over time, the ecosystem doesn't like an invasive species and it starts to fight back against it. And when one person aggregates this much power, I think the world does have a healthy immune gag reflex. And I feel like we're starting to really choke on this guy.
Kara Swisher
I don't know. He still has his stans. I got like whack last night because I said "someone got fucked tonight and it wasn't who he thinks it is." He got fucked. He, of course, likes being fucked like that. I don't know. He has a lot of stans that thought this was great. And then even more disappointing, a lot of supporters of Israel just took in his ridiculous PR stunt of a trip and let him off the hook as they attacked other people who did much less, who just expressed desire for a ceasefire or were worried about the health of some Palestinian children. They let him off. "Great job, Elon," in Silicon Valley. And I think he has a lot more support than you think. I think people are willing. It's like Trump. He's winning.
Scott Galloway
You might be right. The whole Israel stunt, in my opinion, I hold Netanyahu accountable. I think Bibi Netanyahu and his far right, his desperate attempt to cling to power, cutting deals with the far right extremist, and I'll also add bigoted members of the Knesset, has been a disaster for Israel and Jews globally. And him deciding to have a moment with the world's wealthiest man and give any sort of credibility, give any sort of veracity to this... This was a bad look all the way around. I don't know who's advising Netanyahu, but this looked desperate, pandering.
Kara Swisher
Let me just make one more point. This is a 52-year-old man, okay? He's 52 years old. This is how he behaves. It's shameful.
Scott Galloway
Well, I'm not... but here's the thing. And it comes back to something very basic. You know when, just as the worst thing you can do to a dog is leave it alone, men need relationships.
Kara Swisher
Oh, I guess.
Scott Galloway
And I realize I'm an unlicensed psychotherapist here. The most successful people in the world... I mean, contrast this with Jimmy Carter. Oh, yeah. Right. The most successful, the happiest people in the world all have one thing in common, and that is they are living with other people that love them immensely and who let them love them immensely. And I feel like this guy's just totally isolated.
Kara Swisher
Maybe. He's got a lot of people around him and no one who has any influence whatsoever. It feels very Tony Hsieh-like, though, doesn't it?
Scott Galloway
It does.
Kara Swisher
Well, Tony was sweet, though. Never. Tony was sweet. This man isn't sweet. He's something else. Let me say one more thing. The Biden stuff was sad. I was like, get over it, dude. Get some therapy. Didn't invite you. Oh, that he wasn't invited to that. Yeah, that was... oh, ow. I'm like, get the fuck over it, like a 52-year-old man. Not fair. It's not fair. It's the whole victimization, narcissism thing. And he's right, by the way. It was ridiculous and not fair. Fine. Guess what? That's life in the big city. That's life at the corner of free speech and Maine. Block that metaphor, Linda, and get out. Get out, Linda.
Scott Galloway
I actually... I really did feel... I don't want to say feel sorry because I think he's outstanding and handled as well as he could, but it was like Andrew Ross Sorkin walked in on someone masturbating and just didn't know what to do. He actually... he doesn't say words there. You heard it. He's like...
Kara Swisher
I would have been more aggressive in his face, but...
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but that's what makes Andrew Canadian.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, right. That's Canadian. Jonathan. We're calling him Jonathan. He wants to present people in their best light.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, he does. He had a lot of great interviews, by the way, that day.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, let's get on to more news. Former Secretary of State Henry Kissinger has died at 100. He leaves behind a complicated legacy, as his New York Times obituary put it. Few diplomats have been both celebrated and reviled with such passion. For better or worse, Kissinger had a major hand in engineering U.S. relations with China, Vietnam, the Soviet Union, the Middle East, and more. His later years, he also got swindled by Elizabeth Holmes and Theranos. So there's that. I am not a fan. I'm on the Anthony Bourdain side of this equation, who visited Cambodia. The bombings of Laos and Cambodia were, as far as I'm concerned, a war crime.
I know we never think of ourselves that way, but his secret war there in Southeast Asia was repulsive. And he got lionized for it. He was very close to a lot of tech people, Eric Schmidt and others. They wrote a book together, I think. In a Threads post, former Senator Al Franken and former SNL star Al Franken said, "Kissinger called SNL once late on a Friday night looking for tickets for his son. The Stones were playing that week. I told him that if it hadn't been for the Christmas bombing, he'd have tickets." I'm with Al Franken, I got to say. Anyway, any fond memories?
Scott Galloway
Well, look, he marks the century. He's easily one of the most important figures of the 20th century. And you mentioned it, figuring out... I mean, the exit of Vietnam kind of epitomizes his approach to foreign policy. He architected our exit, which was a key event. He made it as dignified as a loss can be. But at the same time, even knowing that we were going to leave and knowing we were losing the war and we would eventually exit, he decided to continue the death on both sides for geopolitical positioning and reputation.
Kara Swisher
It's called realpolitik. That was his thing, right?
Scott Galloway
Yeah. And look, I mean, the one thing I'm finding as I try and sort through these issues and take a stand is you want to find a total absence of moral clarity, just enter the world of geopolitics. There's just no way to hermetically seal yourself in a bubble in any viewpoint around this stuff without having a lack of empathy for the other side. You just can't. But I mean, the peace in the Middle East, opening up China... he was a brilliant man. And I think he sort of embodies our legacy in the 20th century. And that is we served our interests really well, but it came at a huge denial of our values in many instances.
Kara Swisher
Oh, I don't know. I think he was... if I had to plus and minus, it would be a minus. I'm with the minus side. I just... I get that. I understand the world is... that's life in the big city, right? I get it. And the discussion Amanda and I were having was about people who now we're going to start kissing up, including the Biden administration, to the Saudis. And you can sit there and go, "We mustn't, we mustn't. They're terrible thugs," which I think they are. But if you're playing geopolitics, unfortunately, you have some really heinous bedfellows.
Scott Galloway
They're the swing vote, yeah.
Kara Swisher
But I mean, it did go too far. Supporting murderous dictators in Chile. I mean, it kind of embodied America's view of the world. And that is we were outstanding at representing our interests, but we lost a sense of self in the pursuit of that.
Scott Galloway
And by the way, I think people probably push back on this because all you have to do is go to the Iraq War. But I do think that people, our administrations took... I think the current administration reflects some of those learnings. I do think they have a strong sense of "these are our values." And even if our values cost us, it's worth it. They're principles, not opinions.
Kara Swisher
I get it. The Holmes thing was... he was another old man caught in that. He got bamboozled by her, like George Schultz. There's a lot of people who got caught up in that.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, it was Schultz and him that really particularly... Mattis, General Mattis. I mean, it was literally the first ballot Hall of Fame of what I call "PhDs on boards" — formerly important people, all the old white guys. And what do you know? They were taken in by a 30-year-old blonde woman. I mean, and by the way, had WeWork's board gotten as pissed off as them, Adam Neumann might be in jail. Because if you look at what she did, in my view... I don't know. I was very uncomfortable with the prison sentence levied against Elizabeth Holmes. Ten-year sentence. She's part of an exercise class, and one of the Real Housewives is also incarcerated with her.
Kara Swisher
Did not know that. Life is strange. I know. I have these little factoids for you. Well, we'll see. He was also close to, as I said, to Eric Schmidt. Hillary Clinton loved him.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, there's nothing around it. He's a brilliant man. When I was doing my speaking circuit, when I just started speaking 15 years ago, one of my first talks was this World Economic Forum talk, and I think it was in Monterrey, Mexico. And he got up there at the age of, you know, whatever it was, 85, and just had the audience enraptured. Just a brilliant mind.
Kara Swisher
I was offered to be introduced to him once, and I said, "I just can't." You know I love to meet a famous person. I can't talk to that man without saying, "You vile, horrible person." I just couldn't. I don't know why with him, because there's lots of vile, horrible people. Everyone's real delighted by George Bush, and he certainly... W, he certainly did some damage across the world.
Scott Galloway
And what I would say in his defense is that if you decide to be Secretary of State in the United States during a tumultuous time, you're going to risk a lot of people such as yourself not wanting to meet with you for the rest of your life.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I get it. Although I think he made some moves that made it even worse. They did not have to do the lying. He was part of that lying Nixon administration. Anyway, let's move on to someone we like. Mark Cuban is making some big moves that have everyone wondering what's next. Also not perfect, everybody. I know that. The Dallas Mavericks owner will sell a majority of his stake in the team to casino magnate Miriam Adelson for $3.5 billion. He'll get the money, but he'll control the team, which was interesting. He recently announced that he intends to leave Shark Tank in the next year. The billionaire has denied claims to run for president, including to me. I texted him immediately, and he said he wasn't. I'm not sure what he's doing. I don't know what he's going to do with all the money. I think he may run in 2028, but he was pretty adamant to me that he wasn't.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, the thing that struck me about this is that... so again, bringing this back to me, last year in my predictions for 2023, I said the best performing asset class would be sports teams. They're essentially regulated monopolies. They control the supply. If sports are doing really well, if professional basketball or football teams are doing really well, you can't just start a new team in Tampa. You can't. It has an exclusion from antitrust. It is a regulated monopoly. They control it. It's the ultimate... So on the supply side, it has scarcity, artificially regulated scarcity. On the demand side, the people that want these teams, billionaires, have quintupled.
If you're 58 and worth $9 billion and thinking "I'm going to be dead soon and want to be the most interesting person in Cleveland overnight," you go buy the Indians or the Cavaliers. And so demand has exploded, supply has gone down. And this is evidence of that. Not only the fact that in 23 years, the value of this company has gone from $200 million to $3.5 billion, but even more than that, he's pulled off the first of its kind in sports that I know of, and that is a dual class shareholder structure. And that is, despite the fact he will now own less than 50%, he'll own a minority share of the company, he's still in control.
And I had never seen that in professional sports before. So he said, "I want the fame, I want control, but I want to de-risk my economic interests here." But everything, in my view, going back to your first comments, when I saw this, when I saw leaving Shark Tank, raising billions of dollars, I'm like, "Hello, run for president."
Kara Swisher
That's what I thought. I don't know. Here's why I don't think it. Look, he's 65. He just turned, I think he just turned... I think he told me, just turned 65. I think he's done Shark Tank forever. You get tired of things. I know I... you know, I'm not doing that anymore, like Code or something. It's not the same thing. Well, it's similar. I just didn't want to do it anymore, right? And everyone was thinking I was up to something else. I think he had done it enough. It gets tiring. It gets tiring and boring, I guess, on some level. I think he... one thing Mark does, and the reason he is so wealthy, was because he knew the top during the first bubble when he sold off Broadcast.
com. Broadcast.com for $5 billion. Remember? Radio over the internet. That was definitely worth $5 billion. It was such a... we actually got off on a bad foot because I'm like, "That was the biggest con in history." He's like, "How dare you?" I'm like, "Come on. A hundred percent." Come on. A hundred percent. We got in a big fight over it. AOL buying Time Warner. Or my favorite was when Union Square Ventures managed to foist their total shit of Tumblr on Marissa Mayer for $1.1 billion. Yeah. Seven years later, sold for $3 million. $1.1 billion to $3 million. Oh, Tumblr. Oh, yeah. I broke that story.
He knows the top. I think he knows. I think he's like, "This is a good time. I need money for something else," whether it's Cost Plus Drugs. I think he's in the back of his mind. He thinks about running. I just was like, he should run. He'd be interesting. People lost their minds. Why do we need another billionaire?
I'm like, he's not like other billionaires. I think he'd be an interesting voice in the race. And the reason why I still think there's a chance, Scott, you know, I'm on the speaking circuit. I see Mark pretty regularly. And I oftentimes wonder to myself, why is he at a convention in Orlando speaking to the National Association of Realtors if he's not trying to... like, he doesn't need the money.
Scott Galloway
He's very likable, too.
Kara Swisher
He is very likable. He's got all of the qualities, except for public service experience. He's got all of the qualities for an elected representative. And you get the sense also, he has something that, like, you might have, the reason why I could never run for office, I think he genuinely likes people. He enjoys meeting them and he does. He's interested in them. He has a very nice family. His daughter's an internet star of some sort on, I think, on TikTok.
Scott Galloway
He does. She does. He has a very nice family.
Kara Swisher
You know, I don't know. I think he's doing a lot with Cost Plus Drugs. Everyone just write me about how mean he was to your startup. Guess what? Like, Elon Musk is all I have to tell you. Next one, JP Morgan CEO, Jamie Dimon, another person that they think is going to be Treasury Secretary or something like that. But at the New York Times Dealbook Summit, Dimon urged the room to help Nikki Haley to, quote, get a choice on the Republican side that might be better than Trump. That's pretty much anybody. Haley, it's interesting because Jamie is pretty much a Democrat. I mean, he's supported Democratic candidates.
Haley has also recently gained support from billionaire Charles Koch's political network and a super PAC called Independence Moving the Needle. Very important things for her, but a recent poll from CNN showed her in second place at 20% in the primary state of New Hampshire. Donald Trump is still far ahead. It was interesting for Dimon to say that. He likes to say things like that. But thoughts? I like Jamie. I think he's an iconic business figure. I think he's smart. And the thing I like about him is he's not scripted. He doesn't check with his PR department and starch everything. He speaks his mind.
I think he's been a great leader at J.P. Morgan. I'd love to see him in administration as a Treasury Secretary. That's what it looks like.
Scott Galloway
I think he's very thoughtful in general. The CEO of a company probably shouldn't be picking candidates this early in the race. But he does kind of occupy a pretty important role. I think it's kind of zero fucks given. He's at an age. He has all the money he needs. He's so well respected and liked. But back to his point, if we were going to do wins and fails or—
Kara Swisher
Not yet.
Scott Galloway
I know, but I'm just saying, well, the biggest winner from the last couple of weeks is probably Nikki Haley. I mean, she has essentially become what everyone was hoping Ron DeSantis would be, and that is a viable alternative to Trump. DeSantis, his campaign could best be described in one word: thud. And she has been steadfast, smart, performed really well in the debates. And the reality is money matters. Typically, until Hillary Clinton, whoever raised the most money won. And now that she not only has Charles Koch's money, they're willing to spend it. Like all these tech bros in the Bay Area who pretend to be players, they're actually pretty cheap. They usually don't give that much money to these candidates. Whereas the Koch brothers, they'll throw serious cabbage behind. Cabbage and a network of organizations. And she'll be a great contrast. She's a great win. If it ever gets down, and at some point it will, but logically if it gets down to, unless there's new candidates, if it gets down on the Republican side to Trump and Haley, she will be a great foil. She'll be a great contrast. Her youth... I don't know, I have this... I think people are going to like her. She's very likable.
Kara Swisher
She's very likable. And she has some heinous policies for sure. But she looks like someone you can do business with, let's just say.
Scott Galloway
Someone you can do business with. As progressives, the bottom line is, I could live with Nikki, Governor Haley, or Ambassador Haley, and I think you could too.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. She's shown a good side. She did the flag. She has to do MAGA cosplay because she can't lose them too much. I get it. But she's doing the very least amount she can do, I think. If it's Biden, Haley, she wins.
Scott Galloway
She wins.
Kara Swisher
She wins.
Scott Galloway
I would agree.
Kara Swisher
I don't know. She'd move to the center very quickly, I would think.
Scott Galloway
Oh, of course. And she'd have an easy time doing it.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, moving on in our news bonanza, Microsoft will have a non-voting board seat on OpenAI. Like we said, they would. Despite owning 49% of the company, Microsoft previously did not have representation at all on the board. The board now consists of Brett Taylor, Larry Summers, and Adam D'Angelo, who are working to build out a board. Sam Altman announced that the company did not end up losing a single employee. He's back officially. I'll be talking to him and others there over the next week or so. I think this is exactly what we thought. It's calming down. Let's talk about a stupid alleyway for this company. But here we are. Microsoft, I think they have a non-voting board seat, but they have enormous influence. That's my take on the situation.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, so the dynamics on a board, in my experience, is there's really only two, sometimes three people that matter on a board. There might be eight or 12 people, but generally speaking, it's the following. The CEO has a lot of power because the CEO is the filter through which the board gets all of the information until at some point the CFO, who is the source of truth and every board member should establish an offline relationship with, comes back with such bad numbers that the real board meeting, which usually takes place in the parking lot after the board meeting, between the two powerful players on the board, and they decide to fire the CEO.
Until that point, the CEO has the most power. A close second, and then sometimes the first, see above when they fire the CEO, is the person who's invested the most money. It doesn't matter how good, how bad they are, but the person who's written the biggest check, it's capitalism, they have the biggest voice on the board. And then typically the third leg of the power stool on a board is there's an independent director who has earned everyone's respect, who has professional credentials, speaks less, but carries a big stick, is sort of the deep voice on the board of reason, serves as Switzerland between management and the largest investor, and usually they get an award at some point.
Those three people control the board. And the thing about an observer seat, it doesn't matter because it has just as much power. And whoever the observer is from Microsoft, it's going to be the CTO, I think, he will have more power than anyone else on the board, maybe even including Sam, given that Sam's already been fired once. And he's not on the board.
Kara Swisher
Sam's not on the board.
Scott Galloway
Because I've had observers on most of my boards. So my last board, two people from my venture capitalists, and they would show up with a third person, an associate, say, well, this is a good training for him. You can't bring him because every voice is representation. And nothing, Kara, ever actually comes down to a vote. It's all a discussion. And then you kind of hug it out and then you all vote unanimously. And so every voice in the room, whether you're, quote unquote, from a government standpoint, actually have a board seat or not, it doesn't matter.
Kara Swisher
So the most important person in that boardroom—
Scott Galloway
Yeah, they have to do that just, you know, for regulatory reasons and all kinds of things and all kinds of government scrutiny stuff. But the most important person in those board meetings will be the representative from Microsoft because they wrote the biggest check. And it doesn't matter whether he's technically or officially on the board or not. He will be in the room making calls and speaking with a $13 billion stick.
Kara Swisher
That's correct. OK, let's go on a quick break. We come back. We'll discuss whether 2024 is going to be a comeback year for IPOs. And we'll talk to a friend of Pivot, Rob Copeland, about his new book, The Fund, that's made a lot of headlines recently.
Ad break
Scott, we're back. We haven't said goodbye to 2023 yet, but 2024 is already looking to be a big year for IPOs with some notable companies in the mix. Rumored IPO candidates include Reddit and Skims as well as a fast fashion company, Shein, which has reportedly already filed confidentially. It's been an underwhelming time for IPOs, as everybody knows, with Instacart and Birkenstock, among others, floundering in recent months. Is it about to turn around? We can go through these. Talk to me overall, and then we'll go through the individual companies.
Scott Galloway
So I got this wrong. Earlier in the year, I don't remember, I predicted in the back half that you'd see a resurgence in IPOs. I thought there was pent-up demand, capital on the sidelines, good companies ready to go. And several companies did get out, but their valuations were too aggressive. The market is much different now, and it's been underwhelming, and it kind of created a new winter again in IPOs. It's been a terrible year for IPOs, and the question is the following. Will these new companies, these are good companies, reignite it again? Is it a cyclical thing? I would argue that the IPO is in structural decline.
Typically, the IPO served a couple purposes. It was a capital-raising event because the private markets, VCs didn't want to put $300 million into a company. The whole funds used to be $300 million. They wrote checks of $10 and $20 million. And when the company needed hundreds of millions, it went public. And it also provided liquidity for the previous investors and the employees. And now, both in terms of your ability to raise massive amounts of capital and provide liquidity in the secondary market, the private markets can kind of do it all right now. Dial up the Saudis. Dial up to sales. So all you do, the only reason you take a company public, quite frankly, is when the private investors go, you know what?
This just isn't worth what it was in the private markets in the last round. Let's see if we can find some idiots called retail investors to buy this at a valuation of 30 times revenues. They take it public. Maybe they fool retail investors for a little while into that valuation. They get out, the stock goes down. But here's the thing. The market has a memory. The market goes, we're sick of picking up your crap. We're sick of picking up the bag you just dumped, and it's put a chill on the entire market. Whereas when Amazon and Netflix and Google went public 10 and 20 years ago, there was still a lot of juice to be squeezed.
So what has happened? All the value in the growth in these companies has been sequestered and captured by private institutional investors. And the whole IPO market, kind of to a certain extent, no longer really serves a real purpose.
Kara Swisher
Okay, let's start, though. These might go public. Still, people are still doing it. Let's start with Reddit. They have been maybe going public for a long time. It's been around forever. It's had different ownership structures. It's considering a valuation as high as $15 billion. Obviously, Reddit is the sort of social media communications posting site that's kind of cleaned itself up from its sort of less savory days. What do you think about this? A lot of advertising here too, so all of this has to be couched against its valuation that they try and take it public at.
Scott Galloway
But Reddit, I think, is a phenomenon. I think it's a great company. It's managed to carve out a space in social or whatever you want to call it in a space where no one thought it could be carved out. It became a global brand because of the meme stock movement where all of a sudden, you know, certain pages or communities on Reddit literally move the markets. I think it's well run. I would imagine their traffic has gone up. It's a good ad model. I don't know how their ad stack is like. I'm going to make one observation. It's where my kids watch all their videos. It's really wild. They really do.
They are always on Reddit and they use it as an entertainment vehicle, a little more substance. They don't participate in the boards and stuff and discussions, although that's very vibrant, but they find all their videos there. I was surprised when I heard about it, but now I'm not. That kind of thing. Let's get to Steve Huffman. He's a really interesting CEO. He's one of the founders. What about... long story, but what about Skims? Kim Kardashian's shapewear company. It's valued at $4 billion. She, of course, just debuted the nipple bra, which was something. I got you that for Christmas. I hate to do a reveal.
Kara Swisher
Thank you. What do you think?
Scott Galloway
It's a great brand. It represents a phenomenon of celebrities getting behind an existing product line, bringing it awareness. Kim Kardashian, she's a global brand. It's a good product. She's a great entrepreneur. I mean, she's very easy to be cynical about or make fun of. She's a great entrepreneur. I don't. I'm not. As you know, I'm not. I had her on many years ago because I thought that. This couple is a really sharp couple who's the actual executives of the company, but she's quite involved. And, you know, putting on that nipple bra was brilliant. I'm sorry. It was. It was weird, but brilliant. And people like the product. There'll be a lot of copies of her, of this stuff. You know, Rihanna will jump in here, I'm sure, or something like that. But smart. She's always moving. Kim Kardashian's always moving. And I think she is integral to this company in a significant way and not just showing up for things. I don't think she sews everything, but you know what I mean? Like, I think she's very involved, more so than you would imagine. Whether it's Ryan Reynolds and Aviation... I mean...
Kara Swisher
Yes, he's a very comparable character.
Scott Galloway
Just bringing that kind of awareness, or I hate to say it, Elon Musk, the ability to use your celebrity to dramatically decrease your traditional media expenditure required to get that level of awareness gives you a huge advantage. And they have that.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. And she's not going to tell anyone to go fuck themselves. Anyway, as I mentioned, the fashion company Shein has already confidentially filed. It could be a huge one. It was valued around $66 billion in a fundraising round in May and targeting an $80 to $90 billion valuation, according to Bloomberg. Shein was founded in China. It's now based in Singapore. The company has a lot of issues over the years getting accused of violating labor laws, harming the environment more. Fast fashion is under siege because of environmental concerns, but super, super popular company.
Scott Galloway
There's been several stages to specialty retail apparel. It used to be the most valuable private company in the world was Levi Strauss and Company, where they would pile Levi's high in Army, Navy stores, JCPenney's, and The Gap, which sold albums and Levi's. And then The Gap brought in this genius merchant named Mickey Drexler, who said, we control the branding by virtue of the fact that we have the interface with the consumer known as retail. And we're going to put in beach blonde wood, nice scents, oversized dressing rooms, really attractive sales associates, curated music. And then they created their own private label Gap brand.
And it was casual clothing, consistent. Yeah, it's the Gap for this era. And the Gap was arguably, I think, one of the best performing stocks of the 80s. And then enter Old Navy, 80% of the quality, 50% of the price. Old Navy was the fastest zero to a billion dollar retailer. Actually, that was my first strategy engagement at my strategy firm and business called Prophet. But anyways, and then the next wave was fast fashion. H&M, Zara, Uniqlo. And they basically said, using supply chain, we can Old Navy, Old Navy. And that is we can not only give you stuff at the price of Old Navy, but our supply chain is we will send people to the runway shows in Paris.
And within two weeks, we will have reasonable knockoffs of the Calvin Klein.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, and also it's good stuff. I used to get my t-shirts from The Gap, and now I get them from Uniqlo. They're good. I don't want to pay forever for Vince.
Scott Galloway
The Uniqlo is casual. With Zara, and by the way, the family, the science of Zara became the wealthiest family in Europe. And what they did was they created a sense of scarcity. They would do limited runs. So when you went into Zara, unlike The Gap, and you saw something that was knocked off from the most recent, whatever, you know, Vuitton show, and obviously much lower quality, not nearly the artisanship. But if you didn't buy it, it might not be there in two weeks. And this, what Shein represents, is the next wave. And that is through unbelievable supply chain, distribution, manufacturing.
Kara Swisher
On top of fashions. It's hard to stay on top. I used to write about retail. And if you miss, like, if you get the pedal pushers wrong one year, you're fucked. You know, I remember one company was hot, hot, hot, and then it was not, not, not. It's harder, but they keep it simple. That's the thing is a lot of these companies. Another one is Muji is another one that's super popular. I was visiting my friends at CNN yesterday and I got lost in that mall there, which is a high-end mall. But it had such an Asian flavor, that mall with like Muji was there.
Scott Galloway
You mean at Hudson Yards?
Kara Swisher
Hudson Yards. Yeah, it was really interesting. It was packed.
Scott Galloway
By the way, it's a disaster.
Kara Swisher
No, no, it was packed yesterday. I can tell you. Back to Shein. Shein has taken all of that, limited supply runs, knocking off great fashion, unbelievable, unbelievably agile supply chain. And the result is something you don't get or we haven't had in a while. Despite that explosive growth which usually comes with losses, it's profitable.
Scott Galloway
So now their issue is they, by, you know, purposely and no accident, they have relocated their HQ to Singapore. They're trying to be very responsive to the geopolitical concerns. But more than that, they also are trying to be, I've heard the CEO and the vice chairman a few times, try to be very responsive to concerns around supply chain, because the reality is, as reporters and supply chains become more visible, I don't care if you were LVMH, The Gap, Nike, everyone has found out that getting you a pocket t-shirt for nine bucks involves some bad shit along the way that you should be cognizant of. And it's happened to almost every major apparel brand. And that's the issue facing these guys. But the next generation of retail appears to be embodied by this company, Shein, that has gone from like zero to 30 billion in zero time flat while maintaining profitability. And it goes to a bigger issue, Kara. And that is—
Kara Swisher
Keep going, because there's no periods in your sentences right now, but go ahead.
Scott Galloway
I get it. I think you're stressed out. You're being less kind today.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I think you're stressed. I'm not stressed out. It's just, there was no periods there. I'm just waiting for a period, but go ahead.
Scott Galloway
Something's going on with you.
Kara Swisher
Something's going on. Even a semicolon would be nice. Maybe a colon, a full colon. Go ahead.
Scott Galloway
I just had my colon checked.
Kara Swisher
Okay.
Scott Galloway
He said, I have the colon of a 49-year-old.
Kara Swisher
And we're still going on. Land the plane, Scott Galloway.
Scott Galloway
Jonathan. I'm going to call you Jonathan. Here's the issue. Young people don't have as much money as we did at their age.
Kara Swisher
Fair point.
Scott Galloway
And so the ultimate business strategy, whether it's the strategy of Dell or Walmart or China, is more for less. And that is what Shein is bringing to a younger generation. It's saying, you know what? We can give you more for less.
Kara Swisher
Yep. That's where my kids shop. Uniqlo, Shein, Muji, H&M, that's where they get their stuff.
Scott Galloway
Anyway, and it's nice. It's actually nice.
Kara Swisher
Okay, Scott, we're going to get to our friend of Pivot. Rob Copeland is a finance reporter for the New York Times and the author of The Fund: Ray Dalio, Bridgewater Associates, and the Unraveling of a Wall Street Legend. And this is a book that has made a lot of headlines over the last few weeks and gotten some big pushback from Ray, who's a very pugnacious person. We're going to get into that. Welcome, Rob. This is a pretty scathing look at Ray Dalio and his hedge fund, Bridgewater. You've been covering Dalio for years. First, I want to tell you, to get into that. What about him fascinates you?
Rob Copeland
Sure. He's sort of a larger than life than just a business figure. You know, he claims to have these principles, which he says, if you follow them, they will help you achieve a higher level of self. He says they apply for life and work. And he's become this sort of endorsed figure from Bill Gates and Reed Hastings and all these technology figures who seem not to realize that the technology at the firm doesn't work and never did.
Kara Swisher
Okay. So you start the book with the author's note saying, "Ray Dalio does not want you to read this book." And he posted on LinkedIn saying, in part, "This is one of those sensational and inaccurate tabloid books written to sell books to people who like gossip." And just this week at the Fortune Global Forum, he said the book is fiction, created as fact, accusing you of making up some of the conversations in the book. He also noted multiple times that you applied for a job at Bridgewater. Information which you get into the book as well. I think this means you did a great job, mostly. So talk to me about how you're looking at this pushback by this guy. Because he likes to, he has this godlike tendency. He's clearly a narcissist, as many people I cover and you cover are. But he really, he has, he's almost religious in his, he's decided he's become this pundit, this business pundit of some sort.
Rob Copeland
Well, I would say, first of all, I didn't expect him to read the book and say, "Oh, you got me," and go away. So, you know, they fight harder. He has been, you know, attacking me to distract from his own behavior for years inside Bridgewater, which is so different from the character that he plays on TV. And so I will say, I'm not surprised that he's attacking me. But I am surprised that people don't realize that he's not actually saying anything about the content of the book, because he can't, because we've got him dead to rights there.
Kara Swisher
Right, right. You mentioned he sees himself as like a philosopher. He's like a philosopher king. He's not satisfied to just have $15 billion. He needs you to think he's a great guy too.
Rob Copeland
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
And he's been successful in his company, correct? I mean, in general, he's been seen as a successful investor and person. How do you assess that, what's happened?
Rob Copeland
Sure. Well, not coincidentally, Bridgewater's best year happened before Ray Dalio makes up this whole public persona for himself as the principles. He was a billionaire before the word "principles" ever came out of his mouth. And for the past 20 years, his animating doctrine has just been talking about this, I mean, this manifesto as opposed to investing. And unbelievably, what's been so surprising for me is he's been so successful at it.
Kara Swisher
He has. Well, people are looking for advice, right? I mean, look, there's a lot of people who are not what they seem. We were just talking about Elon's outburst at the New York Times event yesterday. People are now seeing a lot behind the curtain, essentially. But in writing this book, you spoke to some former employees and also incorporated internal documents and leaked emails. Let's get into some of the parts and then I'll get Scott to ask a question. But it's full of pretty buzzy anecdotes, whether it's Dalio trying to set up a meeting with Putin, James Comey serving as a sort of in-house inquisitor, and a thorough investigation of an incident at a urinal. Well, it's really fun. It's a fun read. Do you think there's a certain moment or story that gets into the essence of Dalio? You say he also saw Steve Jobs as a model for himself, and he wanted Walter Isaacson to write his biography, of course, but Isaacson smartly passed, I guess. Although not so smart with Elon.
Rob Copeland
Well, and then he goes, he hires John Rubenstein, who was former deputy to Steve Jobs, and takes John Rubenstein about 12 hours to figure out that this is all horseshit. But of course, John won't tell you about that because he took the $50 million and agreed not to talk about it. So that's the oldest story ever told. The probably the best example for me of Ray is that it's this incident: piss on the floor. Ray goes to the bathroom, stands at a urinal, which has happened to many of us in our lives, looks down and sees liquid on the floor under the urinal. And instead of, well, one, not saying anything because that's polite, or two, perhaps admitting that he, Ray Dalio, could be the origin of this liquid. He orders this huge investigation of what has happened at the urinal and brings in new urinals and sends out an email telling everyone there's piss on the floor. And if you can't aim your pee, you can't work here. And everyone takes this deadly seriously, as if there actually is something to investigate here. And it's because the principles and Ray Dalio say there's no such thing as a small problem. But nobody can tell Ray to his face, "This pee, Ray, it might just be yours."
Kara Swisher
I think we'll start Scott in on after the pee situation. Rob, nice to meet you.
Scott Galloway
So just to be blunt, I found what I read about your book, it feels like a hit piece to me. And what would you say? I feel as if there's an industrial complex in bringing famous, successful people down. And he struck me, I don't know him well, but I've had him on my podcast. He struck me as someone who's very successful, has a big ego, has amassed a ton of wealth, and is now trying to, you know, share his wisdom, educate. He's had real personal loss. He and his wife lost their son. He's spoken about that very eloquently and, in my opinion, a very raw and honest fashion. I mean, really showed real vulnerability. And what is it about this guy or Ray that you think is, you know, bad for the business world or bad for America?
Because the sense I get from your book is that you feel there's a bit of a cautionary tale here, that he's not the guy he portrays. And the guy he portrays, at least to me, and I think of myself as having decent intuition, is huge ego, but hugely successful and trying to be a net positive for the world.
Rob Copeland
Well, I appreciate the question, Scott. I would say you've bought into Ray's version of reality by talking to Ray. And that is an Alice in Wonderland reality. It's through the looking glass. And if you take the effort to speak to everyone else around Ray, including the people running Bridgewater right now, they will tell you that that version of reality exists only in Ray's imagination. I'm not saying that you were hoodwinked in any way. I'm just saying that we can't just take these business leaders at what they tell us about themselves.
Scott Galloway
If you take Elon Musk at the version that Elon tells you, he will say, this is all necessary.
Rob Copeland
Oh, we don't, Rob. We don't.
Kara Swisher
No, I'm not. No, no. I'm not suggesting you do.
Rob Copeland
But look, Ray is wonderfully charismatic. I have been quite, you know, I've spent some time with him. He's been nothing but kind to me. But the person that he is behind closed doors is vastly different. I didn't go out to write a hit piece. I just went out to tell you the truth of what he's actually been like for the past 50 years.
Kara Swisher
So one of the things, it's interesting. I don't, Scott, you're really not going to like my book. I think one of the things that Scott actually does talk about, so it was actually a very good question, Scott, but you talk about the idolatry of innovators in tech. I think it's the same thing with these... whether it's Lee Iacocca... No, it's the idolatry of wealth. And that these people suddenly can bring down from high. And in Ray's case, it's this giant book you could kill a poodle with called *Principles*. And I think did he have *Principles 2*? I think correct. And *3*. And *3*, right. Literally, you could kill a poodle with the book.
And, you know, it's a rule book for business and life. And I think what happens is they get entranced with their own story and it's very different and it doesn't, you know, it doesn't come together with the way they believe. Now, you quote a former employee who says the principles was a kaleidoscope of contradictions and barely veiled weapon for abuse. It is culty. It is super culty. Now, people like it. Netflix had its code or whatever, the one that they fire people with, whatever their book of code or whatever the heck. Lots of companies do have this. By the way, I would imagine Steve Jobs would think this is nonsense.
He did not have that kind of stuff. You know, I don't think he had any kind of code, which is interesting.
Scott Galloway
You mean other than denying his own blood under oath to avoid child support payments?
Kara Swisher
Oh, God, stop it.
Scott Galloway
No idolatry of innovators there, Kara.
Kara Swisher
Okay, because men never do that, Scott. Men never do that. I've never seen a man do that. In any case, do you see merit in the principles? Is that, you know, because a lot of companies do operate with these things. I've seen a lot, and it's successful in some cases. Sometimes they don't, you know, the way they behave doesn't gel with the principles. Each of these, I'm thinking Netflix has won. And there's a bunch of companies. AOL at the beginning had a set of principles. Steve liked to do that. It's hard to huge of them, but do you see any merit to this idea of principles and running a company that way?
Rob Copeland
I do. And I would say that even the words, "the principles" is a misnomer because there are no static set of principles. He's constantly adding and subtracting to them. And he's got a defense on that. You know, life is an evolution and we should be constantly learning. Probably his favorite principle, which is "pain plus reflection equals progress," is something we can all relate to. We've probably all been through periods in our life of pain that helped us in the end achieve progress. But what Ray so infrequently talks about is that it's him who's inflicting the pain on you. And there's no degrees with Ray Dalio's principles. There's no amount of pain that seems to not be justifiable for progress. You know, taping a pregnant woman and sending out the recording of that and saying of her crying as you interrogate her over a small thing... a lot of people would say maybe there was another way to do things.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. So talk a little bit. There was one anecdote, people I know, David McCormick and Dina Powell at their wedding. And David McCormick was his, you know, heir apparent kind of thing, like very, I guess, number two. I don't know if he was number two or number three or whatever. But just the rising young man kind of person under Ray and Trini. And at the wedding, explain this. This story was just astonishing to me.
Rob Copeland
It happened. And neither David nor Dina will tell you it didn't because it did. And hundreds of people were there for their wedding party.
Scott Galloway
I know it did. There you go. I've heard from many people. You are accurate.
Kara Swisher
May I just tell you, Scott, he is accurate in this anecdote.
Rob Copeland
Well, David McCormick, who later runs for Senate, is celebrating his wedding. And he's doing it again. He'll do it a third time if he doesn't win this time. He's the CEO of Bridgewater at that point. So he's the number two to Ray Dalio. And he's marrying Dina Powell, who's this very famous former Trump administration official, Goldman Sachs. And Ray Dalio is throwing this wedding party at the Bell Haven Club in Greenwich, Connecticut. And Ray gets up to give his speech. And he says, among other things, he says, "David has found the best party girl in America to marry." And it's just one of those scratch the record moments. But worse than that is that David knows he can't actually tell Ray that this was not the right thing to say, because despite all of Ray's principles about trust in truth and always talk about radical transparency, you can't actually tell Ray the hard truth. So David just steams and gets embarrassed in front of all of his family and friends. And Dina, by the way, embarrassed most of all. It's just... if I made it up, it's stranger than fiction. You wouldn't believe me.
Scott Galloway
So, Rob, I realize I'm sounding like an apologist for Ray here.
Rob Copeland
You are.
Scott Galloway
I worked at Morgan Stanley for a couple of years, and I worked at hedge funds off and on or advising for the last 20 years. And I would say just until the last decade, the first word I would use to describe the culture was abusive. And that was this testosterone-filled, abused child syndrome where I worked around the clock seven days a week, so were you. You were a genius if you were a bit of an asshole and drove people really hard. And it was just a toxic culture. How much of this, at a place like Bridgewater, where people are making a shit ton of money and they could always leave, and maybe they did leave, I don't know. But how much of it, if any, would you assign to just the culture of finance and hedge funds?
Rob Copeland
It's that culture on steroids. And I would say the big difference between that and your prior work experience is probably most of the people you were working with did not claim that if you didn't follow the principles, you weren't going to achieve a higher level version of yourself. They didn't say that you should ignore your own instincts, your own values and adopt new ones. I think that the idea that there's plenty of people in New York and San Francisco and every city on earth who are willing to put up with a lot to make money is perfectly fine, and that's their choice. The difference here is that he's saying you're part of the family, and it becomes very difficult to sort of leave the family even when you are sustaining this high level of abuse.
Kara Swisher
You're saying a culture kind of breached into a cult. It kind of became, it went from, it almost has a bit of a Scientology feel to it.
Rob Copeland
It has a big Scientology feel to it. And even one of their former employees actually tries to blow the whistle on this. He tries to tell Charlie Rose, "You can't spell culture without C-U-L-T," and he gets put on trial and fired. Bridgewater is well aware of those comparisons. There's, aside the differences at Bridgewater, if you're part of, if you believe it's a cult, you're also getting paid a ton of money. So Scientology is paying you pennies to toil in, God knows, some bunker in LA.
Scott Galloway
But just to follow up on that, and as the naked capitalist here, they built the largest hedge fund in the world, paid a lot of taxes, created a lot of economic security for a lot of people. I mean, doesn't that count for a lot?
Kara Swisher
Does it? But does that justify?
Scott Galloway
I would say just because they did that. I think that's a fair question. I don't know. I mean, these people are the most talented, some of the most talented, sought after people in the world. If it was that bad, they could have left. These aren't people... But this isn't forced labor out of Shenzhen.
Rob Copeland
It's not forced labor, no. But there are definitely some similarities to, I guess, what the lawyers would like me to call personality-based organizations. I don't believe that Morgan Stanley operates with a strict doctrine with a charismatic leader in the woods of Connecticut with harsh punishments to those who try to leave.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it's religious. It becomes religious. It's nonsense. It's literal nonsense. And I think tech companies, a lot of them do this. Some of them do it. And it's all bullshit, every bit of it. They break the rules that they make, whether it's Google "don't be evil," this and that. It's just fucking nonsense. And so the very sensible people just, "I'm making money. This is a tough culture. That's just the way it is. Like it or leave it." Thinking of Microsoft in the early days, just a tough culture. They didn't pretend it wasn't. But when these CEOs try to become more than, they're not satisfied with the money. They want the acclaim and they want the love and they want to be business Jesus, essentially.
Rob Copeland
So many of them want to be business Jesus now. Again, he was wealthy beyond belief before he ever said the principles. So what he really wanted was to be loved by this larger group. And I mean, in that, I guess we could say he's probably one of the most relatable characters of all, because wouldn't we all want more than just money?
Scott Galloway
There's a lot of us who are desperate for other people's affirmation, Rob.
Rob Copeland
Yeah, yeah. I don't know. There's only one business Jesus, and that is my co-host Barbara here.
Kara Swisher
That's your name. That's your new name. Fanta Ross, broken as Jonathan, you're Barbara. Let me ask a final question. What is he doing now? He's supposedly retired to his monk ship or whatever, Pope ship. He's really running it still, correct? Where is Bridgewater as a business? It's been a tough market. How is it doing compared to others in the sector?
Rob Copeland
So the firm has shrunk a lot, but it was so large that it is still the world's largest hedge fund. So good for them. He's technically retired, but he has like three titles there. He's still trying to push to start, as he suggested, starting his own fund inside there. The truth of the Ray Dalio story is that he can't ever actually really leave. He can't really admit that he is replaceable because, well, he just refuses to. You know, he's just still talking this week, going to state dinners. He's embraced by the White House. So, you know, almost everyone at Bridgewater would just hope he disappears. But he seems completely temperamentally incapable of that.
Kara Swisher
And does he have control over the company?
Rob Copeland
He has a lot of stock. He doesn't have technical control. But I think we need to ask ourselves who's in charge. Is it the guy with the CEO title or is it the guy who at any moment could go on TV? All he has to do is say the sentence, "I don't have confidence in the people running this firm," and you know they're in a world of pain.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, yeah. Scott, any last questions?
Scott Galloway
What's your next project?
Rob Copeland
Well, you looked at the industry. I mean, to benchmark and really have an accurate depiction here, I imagine you looked at a lot of leaders at similar companies. Are there any organizations you would contrast with Bridgewater as having really healthy cultures?
Scott Galloway
Well, my next project, after your questions, is about Scott Galloway.
Kara Swisher
That's going to be a leaflet.
Scott Galloway
That's going to be a leaflet. It's called *Erectile Dysfunction, a Podcast, and the Jungle Cat Carousel*. There's your title. That book is done. Boom. Portfolio Penguin Random House.
Kara Swisher
That's right. I'm sorry. Go ahead. We're with Macmillan and his family.
Rob Copeland
I will say, I haven't found another project that is as fun and as dark as this one. I think Netflix has a lot of similarities. I honestly... I know you guys have talked about this today, the next five years of Elon Musk... it just seems impossible that this doesn't get... It's going to be Howard Hughes, like I said.
Kara Swisher
We're headed to Howard Hughes. Rob, could you move to the valley? There's just a lot of fodder that you would enjoy and probably be good at depicting.
Scott Galloway
Such fucking nonsense. You know what I hate? I'll tell you, Rob, the one thing, whenever I'm around some Silicon Valley people who've climbed Mount Everest, they try to equate going to Everest with business. And I'm like, okay, so dead bodies and trash at the place you shouldn't be at the top of the earth where you take advantage of labor. I was like, it has nothing...
Rob Copeland
Well, it actually has a lot to do with your life here.
Scott Galloway
But they always try to, you know, if you can make the peak and survive Everest, that's the same thing. I just can't with the...
Rob Copeland
I've covered finance for most of my career. And something I like about finance is they often don't claim to be changing the world. No, they're just making money. And there's something healthy, I think, about that. And Ray is so different because he really does say it's not... he claims to hate wealth. He just happens to be worth $16 billion. So I'm looking for another figure like that.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
Oh, Elon, I think is where you want to go. Yeah. Because it is going to end in a Howard Hughes-like collapse.
Kara Swisher
Is there, what's his latest attack on you? Has he just given up or?
Rob Copeland
Oh, he keeps, now he says I just made it all up, that it's all fiction. No, I don't think he did. He can't talk about the facts because at Bridgewater everything is recorded. So if he really wanted the truth out there, he could just release the recordings of everything I wrote about and people could decide.
Kara Swisher
That was the creepiest, recording everything was the creepiest thing. He, I did interview for a job there when I was 23. And I interviewed for, I think, every job in the New York tri-state area. And he's threatened me that they recorded those interviews and have notes and they'll release them. And I can tell you, I'm sure I sound like an asshole. I was 23. I would have done anything.
Scott Galloway
Well, you're clearly holding a grudge.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, the book is called *The Fund: Ray Dalio, Bridgewater Associates, The Unraveling of a Wall Street Legend*. It's a great book. People should read it. And I'm sorry that he bought Google. I kind of love that he bought... He bought, Scott, you don't know this, but he bought Google keywords for an interview I did with him about principles against his book, which made me laugh.
Rob Copeland
It's great. It's very funny because if you Google me, Rob Copeland, *The Fund*, instead you get Kara Swisher, which is an honor, but a little annoying, let's be honest.
Kara Swisher
Come on. That's a good one.
Scott Galloway
He got me on that. Respect. That one I love.
Rob Copeland
So I bought ads at the train stations in Connecticut, all in Fairfield County where all his employees came in.
Kara Swisher
Oh, my God. What did they say?
Rob Copeland
Oh, for the book? Yeah, it's just a quote saying...
Kara Swisher
This is a war of the roses.
Rob Copeland
I know, but he got me. I didn't think of Google AdWords. So for the next book.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
Oh, well done.
Kara Swisher
Oh, I got to get on that right now. I better get on that right now before Elon does stuff. Anyway, on the back of my book that's coming out, instead of, you know, I don't like blurbs. And so I've put all the insults of the tech leaders to me on the back. It's all there is.
Scott Galloway
Oh my gosh, I love that.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Rob Copeland
It's really good. It's really good.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, Rob, thank you so much. Keep doing the great work.
Break for advertisements
Okay, Barbara, let's hear some wins and fails. I like calling you Barbara. You go first. I think... Oh, I guess you don't have it. You're irritable, but you didn't prep.
Scott Galloway
No, I'm not irritable. And I sat next to, at a party this night, Jennifer Newsom, who is married to Gavin Newsom. She's a documentary filmmaker, a bunch of other things. She's terrific. She's a terrific person. And she reminded me, and I had totally forgotten this, the DeSantis-Newsom debate is tonight. Sean Hannity is doing it. Very smart on Hannity's part, actually. I think this is a really interesting win. I think it's going to be actually good in a debate about policy and where we're going as a country. I'm excited about it. I am. I don't think it's going to be a silly circus. I'm more excited about this than any Republican debate so far.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I am, too. I think it'll be great. They should have it out, right, in a way. I'm sure there'll be insults and this and that, but let's have some real significant... I've seen Gavin on—he's been on Hannity. He did very well. And actually, he made Hannity better, if you can believe it. Like, it was—
Scott Galloway
He made Hannity more likable, I thought.
Kara Swisher
Not just likable, but like, okay, let's actually stop yammering and making stupid— and talk. Talk. Let's talk. And acknowledge points. So I'm looking, I think this is going to be a win. It's a future win. It's a future win. And I think the fail is obviously Linda Iaccarino. I don't know what else to say. It's, Elon is obviously something's wrong. And whether it's a character issue or something else, and I don't feel sorry for him in any way whatsoever, but all the enablers around him have really, someone has to step up here and say something and nobody will and that the fail. So there you have it.
Scott Galloway
So I guess my win is very basic: the life of Charlie Munger. Oh, great guy. Died at, I think he was just about to turn 100 or was 100.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, 99.
Scott Galloway
99. A veteran, served in World War II. And I love guys who, you know, very early on can equate investing to either biology or life. And he was, I just thought he was pithy and smart and a great, in addition to being a great investor, great storyteller, always talked about the importance of family, country. I just, I like that sort of, it's sort of a, I think he sort of marks the age and probably marks the end of an era in terms of that type of investing and a focus on, you know, life is seen through the lens of an investor. And he just seemed like he led kind of a great American life. Good guy, pleasant, good to people.
You know, just lovely. There was never any two parts of this guy, right? Like we're just talking about Ray Dalio or Elon Musk or anybody else. Just a contributor. Let's just say a contributor to everything. And also, and we don't like to speak this nakedly about capitalism, but if you had invested $100 in Berkshire Hathaway when Charlie Munger joined, it would now be worth $400,000. And so people who use their skills to create wealth and economic security for other people deserve a tip of the hat. He created a lot of economic security for a lot of people. And also, I like the fact he was fearless and was one of the first people, and he took a lot of shit for this, and I didn't get nearly as much but I could relate to the shit he was saying when he said Bitcoin and crypto was rat poison.
He just straight out of the gates didn't fall into the need to try and feel young or try and feel cool and embrace it and said, "This is supporting terrorism." I mean, he just came right out of the gates and said, "This is just, this is awful." And I respect that he was, he didn't have a screen, he didn't have a, you know, a filter, but most of, most everything.
Kara Swisher
Simple life. Yeah. Simple life. These guys, both of them. You know, I've been out there and have met him and had dinner with Warren Buffett. They really, you know, they're a type of a Midwestern guy, you know, but just very, I have to say lovely. I had a lovely dinner, a simple, just a different kind of attitude. Just not an asshole. Not an asshole, like really quite... I don't know. There's so many. Nobody lives up to some of these people. And it's sad. It really is sad. They should try harder. Anyway, what is your fail?
Scott Galloway
Well, my fail is the continued perversion of different terms in the context of the Israel and Gaza war or conflict. I don't even know the right terminology. And one of the words that has been totally perverted is this word "apartheid." And Israel has been accused of engaging in apartheid against Gaza and the Palestinian people. The definition of apartheid is a policy or system of segregation or discrimination on grounds of race. So segregation or discrimination on grounds of race or religion, what have you. And I just want to go over some numbers here because the UN had a resolution basically using the term apartheid over and over when condemning Israel.
And of course, these Arab nations all lined up and said that Israel, accused Israel of being engaged in apartheid against Palestinians in Gaza. So let's just look at these Arab nations and how many Jews were there. In Syria, there were 40,000 Jews in 1948. Now there are zero. In Iran, 100,000 Jews in 1948. Now there are 8,500. In Morocco, 265,000. Today there are 2,100. In Algeria, there were 140,000 Jews. Now there are 200. In Tunisia, 105,000 in 1948, 1,000 today. Let's talk about today. There are 2.1 million Arabs in Israel. They serve on the Supreme Court. They own businesses. They are elected to the Knesset.
Arabs in Gaza, right? There were 80,000 in 1948, and now there are 2 million. So, stop misusing the terms apartheid and ethnic cleansing. And the double standard here, perversion, dysmorphic view of what these terms mean, whether it's genocide or ethnic cleansing or apartheid, no one actually wants to determine or actually do the diligence of figuring out what these words actually mean. And then comparing these nations and these organizations relative to Israel. And I find it, again, just another example of how we continue to find reasons to persecute a population that's 0.2% of the world. And this is just another example of what I see even across the UN, across media, across a younger generation that has decided to just throw these words out without actually taking the time to get a fucking dictionary and then contrast the definition of these words against history and reality in the region.
So my loss is the continued perversion of these very emotionally charged words that is nothing but thinly veiled, continued, obnoxious rot that is anti-Semitism.
Kara Swisher
It's also ignorance, Scott. It's ignorance of history, too. I mean, I think you have to, you know, I've had some great discussions with my kids about this. And, you know, they'll take, if they will learn... you know what I mean? Like some of it that is more complex. Just like we were talking about at the beginning, you know, like you know like the Biden administration is doing deals with the Saudis. Okay. They condemned them before. This is the world, unfortunately. And speaking of the world, Kissinger, right? That's how it works. It's complex. And that's what it's hard for young people to see, the complexity of things, I think.
Okay, Barbara, thank you so much. We want to hear from you. Send us your questions about business, tech, or whatever's on your mind. Go to nymag.com slash pivot to submit a question for the show or call 855-51-PIVOT. Okay, Scott, that's the show. We'll be back on Tuesday with more pivots. We're also busy taping holiday episodes that you'll really like. And we've got more to come. Scott, read us out.
Scott Galloway
Today's show was produced by Lara Naiman, Zoe Marcus, and Taylor Griffin. Ernie and her tot engineered this episode. Thanks also to Drew Burrows, Mule Severio, and Gaddy McBain. Make sure you subscribe to the show wherever you listen to podcasts. Thanks for listening to Pivot from New York Magazine and Vox Media. We'll be back next week for another breakdown of all things tech and business. Kara, have a great rest of the week and weekend.