Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses various topics, including AI, media companies, university presidents, and the 2024 US presidential election.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Ad Read - Sierra AI
Sierra AI: AI agents are getting pretty impressive. You might not even realize you're listening to one right now. We work 24/7 to resolve customer inquiries. No hold music, no canned answers, no frustration. Visit sierra.ai to learn more.
Ad Read - The Guardian: The Guardian: Not all journalism is the same. Take The Guardian. Our coverage has something unique: fierce independence. Nobody owns us or tells us what we can and can't say. So we're free to report the whole picture. We connect what's happening in Washington to the rest of the globe, expose corruption wherever we find it, and give fresh perspective on everything from wellness and soccer to culture, the climate, and more. Read, watch, and listen to The Guardian for free at theguardian.com.
Kara Swisher
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher. And Scott, you better tread carefully. It's my birthday today.
Scott Galloway
Really? Yes, of course. Wow, happy birthday.
Kara Swisher
Thank you. Thank you.
Scott Galloway
Well, Kara, in honor of your birthday, I have a great stat that I think you're going to love. Do you realize, and this is true, in Japan last year, more adult diapers were sold than baby diapers? It's coming. It's coming.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, you'll need them. I won't need them. I'll be taking care of you.
Scott Galloway
I like the idea of that.
Kara Swisher
I'll be putting them on you. I need it. I am not easy, just so you know.
Scott Galloway
I just got a visual. It's okay.
Kara Swisher
Walt Mossberg took me out to lunch, so.
Scott Galloway
Yeah? I guess your former business partner, right?
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Ex. How is Walt?
Scott Galloway
He's great.
Kara Swisher
We went to a lovely Jewish deli called Atman's near his house in Potomac, and it was fun. We had a great time. He's really doing great. Yes, yes. And what else are you doing for your birthday?
Scott Galloway
Oh, I had a big dinner party on Saturday with a bunch of friends.
Kara Swisher
Oh, really? Just, I assume, very close friends.
Scott Galloway
Yes, only close friends. I did not hear about that.
Kara Swisher
I would invite you, but you never show up when I invite you. It was this thing called Movable Feast that I like, this dinner preparation thing from cool restaurants across the globe. We had a good time. Then for the day yesterday, Amanda, this was the present I wanted: I got to be left alone all day so I could clean the basement, which is one of my pleasures. Cleaning the basement. That's so exciting. I was so happy. I organized things. We're doing some renovations, so I want to get everything in place. It is my happiest place, to sit around and clean. She gave me that as a gift. Today, we'll have cake and stuff.
Scott Galloway
My happiest place is to sit around watching other people clean my shit and yell at them. Is that wrong?
Kara Swisher
It's not wrong. I'm a good cleaner. I like it. It calms me down. It is cathartic. It's my quiet moment. I just sit there and think. It's good.
Scott Galloway
When I first moved to New York, I bought this big, fat loft, and I didn't know anybody. I used to get really high and clean it. Finally, I'm like, oh my God, I've become so pathetic.
Kara Swisher
See, you like it. It's calming.
Scott Galloway
It's calming, too. I agree. It's kind of fighting the inevitable, which is death, right?
Kara Swisher
I hadn't thought about it.
Scott Galloway
It's not going to be here. I think about it a lot when I'm cleaning. I think, oh, look, this will be here long after I'm gone.
Kara Swisher
Prostitutes and fast cars has a similar effect for me as you cleaning. I think cleaning is less expensive. I will be, you know, I, of course, do know when your birthday is and I will be there for it. In any case, it's a nice day. I got lots of nice greetings from lots of different people. That's nice. I'm happy for you. Happy birthday. Except for you. Anyway, what did you do? I cleaned. What did you do? How was this weekend?
Scott Galloway
I've been feeling kind of down. I don't know if it's the weather or everything that's going on. I didn't do a lot this weekend. We watched the Tottenham game. I spent time with, oh, what was my favorite thing? We went to the Harrods Food Court, ranked as the third best food court in the world.
Kara Swisher
Oh, I love that place. You like that place. You went with your son, right?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, we went with both sons this weekend. That was a ton of fun. And by the way, just an observation on the economy. Harrods, which is, I would argue, not great value for money. Or I guess you could argue it is good value. It's just expensive. It was a fire hazard in there. You couldn't move. It was so crowded.
Kara Swisher
It's so pretty in there. They have all that stuff all packaged up.
Scott Galloway
London is booming, Kara. I don't know what it's like in D.C., but people can't seem to spend enough money. Booming. Everybody's out and about everywhere I go.
Kara Swisher
You know, I told you I was at Hudson Yards. It was booming. It was usually a ghost town. But it just seems like people are out and about. You're right. They're out and about. So you didn't spend the weekend listening to Elon Musk, Andrew Tate, Alex Jones, and Vivek Ramaswamy peeing? You didn't do that? So you're actually, I think, pretty good. I've noticed you're good at compartmentalizing. When I see you, I find you always able to laugh, focus on business, the issue at hand. The only time I've ever seen something else start to seep into your mood is actually a few times on Twitter. I've noticed that sometimes when you get attacked on Twitter, it does rally you a bit.
Scott Galloway
I don't know if you feel this way, but from zero to, I'll call it 30, I wasn't concerned enough about anything. I was sleepwalking through life. I almost got kicked out of UCLA. My career wasn't going that well at a certain point. I didn't care. I was totally impervious and not worried about anything, not worried enough. From 30 to 40, I think I was worried just the right amount. And from 40 on, I started embracing the teachings of stoicism, but lost the ability to practice them. I'm worried about everything. Between Ukraine, COVID, Trump, Israel, Ukraine, I'm a chocolate mess about stuff I never thought of, things I have no control over.
Kara Swisher
Here's the two things that get me annoyed. I did say this on Threads. What happened is, for some reason I made $1,905 and 75 cents on Twitter for some reason, which was interesting because I was just trying it out. I was like, what? I still don't understand how it works. It's so confusing. I gave the money to Sandy Hook parents because Elon let Alex Jones back on, even though he said he would never do so. He did it, of course, because he's an inconsistent chode. I gave the money to that. I just said it. I was like, this is what I'm going to do with it. Every time I make money here, I'm going to give it to a trans group or just do something positive out of this terrible place.
I have to be on Twitter. I've got to see what's going on there. I've got to watch it if I'm covering it. All of a sudden, out of the woodwork, a lot of people said, "Good job, good idea, make lemonade from lemons," etc., lecturing me on how I should conduct my social media and what I should do to be a leader. I was like, it's none of your business. One of the things that drives me crazy about, and it's mostly liberal people, is this "this is how you should do it." I was like, it's none of your fucking business how I should do it. By the way, I spend more time fighting ignorance and cruelty than you ever do.
I don't really want to be told how I'm doing my job.
Scott Galloway
Right. Exactly.
Kara Swisher
I think it's important to be there. So that really irks me. Lecture dads on all the social media platforms. I think it's hysterical to let Alex Jones say all kinds of falsehoods. They think it's fine. I don't think it's fine. I think you can say it, but I do think it's indecent to say it, to let that happen. I'm going to say that. I think it's appropriate. I think it's a good thing to get bent out of shape about at my advanced age.
Scott Galloway
I like the fact that you're kind of unafraid and back in people's faces. I personally agree with the people who say you should get off of Twitter, not because you don't have the right to be on it, not because it doesn't make sense. I think, I have found that selling my Tesla, I generally find I can't escape this guy and it bothers me. When he decides, and this goes to our story, when he decides to put someone like Alex Jones back on the platform on the anniversary of Sandy Hook, that is nothing to me but an affront to parents who have experienced the unthinkable. I start thinking, why would he do that? I can't even imagine. I sort of occasionally understand why Trump does something. But it's not only a terrible person. The definition of stupid is something that's bad for others and bad for you. This will be bad for him. This does not have any upside for him.
Kara Swisher
I agree. He's occupying too much of your mind space. It is sort of my job to cover him. So I'm going to be there and I'm going to watch it and I'm going to say something. That's all. By the way, I don't sit around getting angry all day either. I just do it. I get in, I get out. I'm like an assassin, essentially. That's what I do. I shoot. I take a shot. I leave. Speaking of really loathsome people, Tucker Carlson is launching a streaming service expected to go live as we tape Monday. Interestingly, he's doing it from his website, although he's going to continue to put free content on X. He was all tight with that.
But I think he's understood where the real money is, which is not with Elon Musk. Tucker Carlson Network will host at least five different shows, including interviews, short form videos, and monologues. He announced it on Megyn Kelly's show. It's what she did, too. The subscriptions will cost $9 a month or $72 a year. That's a pretty good price. He'll probably do very well. He's still under contract with Fox. I don't know what's going on. I think it'll take a lot for them to sue him, but they might have to. This actually was the right way to do it on his own, where he controls the situation. We'll see how he does.
Glenn Beck does okay. Megyn Kelly does well, I think. Ben Shapiro's got his own. This is all in the right-wing universe, essentially. Ben Shapiro's got his own little media company. It's the right way to do it. He got some funding, I forget, $10 million, $12 million, something like that.
Scott Galloway
I see this as almost like when football players become commentators. Nothing's going to create the economic value or the stardom of when Troy Aikman had 45 incredible players surrounding him and trainers and front office and marketers and fans. When they go solo, they're usually... I just see this everywhere, Kara. I have so many friends who, for example, worked at Goldman Sachs and were big ballers there. They leave Goldman and think they're going to start a huge investment bank or get invited to do deals. Without the Goldman card, they find out people just aren't as apt to call them back. I think Megyn is a bit of an exception. You name the people who have done the best job of getting... I don't know their finances. I bet they do. I do know a couple of people on Substack, and not just right-wing people. Some have done well. Some haven't. That's what this is.
Kara Swisher
Well, we know their economics. We're kind of in that business ourselves. But we came at it. We didn't leave a platform to do it. These folks, they will make... I know what they'll do. First off, this network, if he's smart, he won't spend a lot of money on it because he won't get anything back. Fox is a juggernaut of production values, smart people, ad salespeople. The non-famous people are outstanding. I think Neil Cavuto is outstanding. These people do a really good job and they have people researching and focus groups. Tucker is a big brand. But almost all of... I think Chris Cuomo is an enormous talent.
The people I met with at CNN all described Chris the same way, whether they felt good or bad about the way he left. They all said this guy, the teleprompter could go out and he could carry a 30-minute show and make it hugely entertaining on his own. Striking and smart and strikes the right balance. Most of these folks, when they leave the platform, it's like McLean Stevenson leaving MASH or Shelley Long leaving Cheers to go be movie stars. They do The Money Pit with Tom Hanks, and then they show up 20 years later in a cameo on Modern Family. They just underestimate the power of the platform.
Scott Galloway
It depends on... I agree with you. I agree. Most people don't make it. I think one of the things... Here I am complimenting Ben Shapiro, but I think he's creating a larger media organization where he has lots of offerings. If Carlson is smart here, he's hosting five different shows, including interviews short form. But if it's all Tucker, that'll be a problem. Because first of all, he doesn't go that far. So if it becomes a business, I could see it because it's got other voices.
Kara Swisher
There's not really other voices.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. I need other voices.
Kara Swisher
I didn't put a liberal on there. Other products, newsletters, events. But it's still hard. It's still incredibly hard. The right wing side is super fucking noisy over there. There's too many people. You've got Tucker's thing, you've got Megyn Kelly's thing, you've got Ben Shapiro's stuff. You've got Dan Bongino. There's a lot over there. It's super noisy. So how is he going to break through as creating a real media company? I honestly, I'll be honest with you, I think he's too lazy. I think Megyn Kelly works her ass off. I think Ben Shapiro works his ass off. I think this guy doesn't. He's used to being padded and moved around.
Scott Galloway
Is that right? I don't know anything about... I've only been on his show once. He's not entrepreneurial. He doesn't strike me as entrepreneurial. He enjoys the good life. You really have to commit yourself to creating a real media company. That's hard. You and I know that. It's really hard. But we're entrepreneurial. We'll see how it does.
Kara Swisher
I just don't think everyone's dying. He'll do fine. He'll do fine. It's just, I don't quite know where the big... There's just too much noise. I don't know what his big idea is here. But maybe they'll consolidate all of them and feed off each other. Who knows? There's been a lot of these. I remember at your Code, or no, at our Pivot event, when we had all those right-wing social media companies, Rumble and Gettr. None of them have gotten any traction. Essentially, that's where Musk is trying to head right now.
Scott Galloway
It's interesting that he's not doing it on Musk. Let me tell you, I'm following Yaccarino's movements. She is very much trying to get various well-known people onto that, trying to do deals with them, ranging from left to right, trying to get them to sign deals. This is interesting that he didn't do this. He's smart. He shouldn't. One of the people who called me, who's a well-known person who they're trying to get on Twitter, I said, "What do you need them for?" That's my... I was like, and they were sort of making the argument. I said, "I just want you to think about that question. Do you need them, or can you do it on your own?" I actually even recommended some other places to go that are already up and running that would have more impact. The negative part of him bringing back Alex Jones on the anniversary of the shooting at Sandy Hook is what's going to tarnish you. Anyway, it's an interesting time to create media companies. There will be one that succeeds or two. Mostly they will not, as you noted. Like George Clooney made it out of TV, for example. He did okay.
Kara Swisher
Compared to Shelley Long. He's done really well. There's always one George Clooney for 20 other people. Also, Google's demo video for its AI model Gemini, which was very impressive, was not conducted in real time, and some people are upset. The six-minute video features spoken conversations between a user and a Gemini chatbot and highlighted Gemini's ability to recognize visual photos and objects. We talked about it. In response, Google said the video is an illustrative depiction of the possibilities of interacting with Gemini based on real outputs in testing, which means it can do all these things, just not in that seamless, beautiful way. I didn't think that was... I thought it was a sort of purification of it. I guess I'm not mad about it. It's just a very heated AI race and everyone's trying to show how fancy they are. I do think it will be able to do that someday. They probably individual all the individual things it can do. It just can't do it in that seamless, smooth way that they had it on the video, which was an ad, essentially.
Scott Galloway
Now that I'm in the UK, I'm trying to embrace all things British. I found this brand called Sunspel, I think it's called. It's the brand of 007, the casual brand of 007. All over the store are images of Daniel Craig wearing Sunspel. I would put on the exact same item of clothing. Spoiler alert: I don't look as good as Daniel Craig.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I don't. I could have told you that.
Scott Galloway
This felt to me like... Guardians have got you. If Google runs a demo saying it will be able to do these things, I'm confident that at some point it will be able to do those things.
Kara Swisher
It was an ad. I thought it was an ad. I didn't think it was doing it in real time. I thought it was impressive. The concept was so impressive. I thought they explained it well. The demo blew me away. I was even thinking, the first thing I thought, and I felt like it was investors, not consumers, who that was made for. The first thing I thought was, I need to buy Alphabet stock. I think Alphabet, and this is... I'm doing my predictions thing tonight.
Scott Galloway
How many people? We're up to 22,000.
Kara Swisher
I'm telling you, I think Alphabet is going to be the Empire Strikes Back around AI.
Scott Galloway
Interesting. It's their wheelhouse. They started it. You watch that demo, you're like, wow, here comes Alphabet.
Kara Swisher
Conceptually, they really do understand it better than many companies. It's interesting. But we'll see. On your 22,000 people, are you going to pee on it like Vivek Ramaswamy?
Scott Galloway
I missed that. What happened? Do I even want to notice? Am I going to be triggered?
Kara Swisher
I'm teasing because peeing is something you like to do, I know.
Scott Galloway
It's not something I like to do. It's something I have to do.
Kara Swisher
He stopped in the middle of the Twitter talk with the loathsome group, Andrew Tate, Alex Jones, Elon, and peed loudly on the Spaces. Yes, that's what he did. You could hear him urinating.
Scott Galloway
Okay, I'm going to stop.
Kara Swisher
Yes, apparently.
Scott Galloway
Really? Because for me, it's like hearing a baby bottle drip a little bit. It's just... Seriously, I went to the urologist and I said, "Doctor, I have a drip." He said, "Really?" He said, "When's the last time you had sex?" I said, "Like three months ago." He said, "Does she live near here?" I said, "Yeah." I said, "Why?" He said, "You might want to go back. I think you're coming."
Kara Swisher
Oh my God. That's good. Oh my God.
Scott Galloway
I just wanted to get your mind off of Vivek.
Kara Swisher
I wanted to get your mind off of Vivek. Let me just say, I need to do this joke. He puts the "P" in free speech. Anyway, let's get to our first big story. The University of Pennsylvania President Liz Magill has resigned, as we said she would, following last week's disastrous hearing in Congress. The chairman of Penn's Board of Trustees, who also stepped down, sent a letter that Magill had been, quote, "overprepared and overlawyered." Calls continue for the presidents of Harvard and MIT to step down as well. The president of Harvard has a lot of support from the professors there. Congresswoman Elise Stefanik posted on X, "One down, two to go."
Elise, calm yourself down. Nobody likes you still, no matter what you do. Anyway, Scott, on our last episode, we predicted we'd see one of the presidents resign, and I particularly picked out her. Over 500 members of the Harvard faculty have signed a letter urging the school's top governing board to resist calls to remove President Claudine Gay. The executive committee of MIT's governing board has declared its support for President Sally Kornbluth. None of them were quite as bad, the performance, as Liz Magill, for sure. She has a lot more detractors at Penn. University donors are playing a big role ahead of Magill resigning.
Penn alum and Wall Street CEO Ross Stevens threatened to pull a $100 million donation from the school. Mark Rowan from Apollo has been very active. Bill Ackman, who's just become a ridiculous clown on Twitter, continues to post on X, wanting the other two university presidents out, talking about himself rather significantly. Aside from what happens to these presidents, talk about the repercussions. Let me just go through one or two things. The New York Times has a piece about the political consequences, saying conservatives are seizing the moment with this hearing and upending campuses. Of course, they're, as usual, overplaying their hands, as they love to do.
The piece says anti-Semitism controversies may fuel further Republican efforts to defund and restrict public universities. Thoughts. This is your wheelhouse, Scott Galloway.
Scott Galloway
I think the moment might represent what I'd call peak higher ed, or at least peak elite higher ed. I went back and watched the testimony. I actually think it wasn't what they said. I thought what they said was actually defensible had they applied that same standard to every other moment of free speech for vulnerable groups. The problem is the line she articulated in practice is a plaid, and that is dependent upon the group we're talking about. These institutions have a different level of fidelity to free speech. That's what I think really upset people philosophically or intellectually. But what really angered people was they came across as so arrogant and elitist.
They basically looked at this conservative congressperson and they were smirking and they were curt. They came off as representing everything bad about elite education. It wasn't Congress. It wasn't students. It wasn't faculty. It was donors speaking. That was at the end of the day. Not only that, what was also interesting that didn't get much coverage here is that the chairman of the trustees, Scott Bach, also announced his resignation. President Gay has only been in the job six months. I think it's a good moment for these institutions to revisit their free speech policies, their speech policies, their DEI initiatives, what DEI actually means.
I think it's a good moment. But all of this comes back to the same thing. This is the helm of the bobsled. Young people and families see all of this prosperity and see that their kids aren't able to access the American dream. When you're talking about elite universities, they have engaged in what I would call this casting on steroids. They say, "The way I can pay myself a lot of money and think big thoughts that aren't necessarily consistent and we can all bark up the same tree is by engaging in this artificial scarcity that creates shame and rage and embarrassment across America." I think people have just had it with them.
Kara Swisher
All right. Let me ask you an opposite question. All these free speech warriors suddenly want them not to speak. Why can't they speak? Why do they have to pay the price? There was a really interesting debate happening among free speech warriors who self-describe, which gives you a problem right from the start when they have to do that because they virtue signal just as much as the people they insult. There was a big debate: this is cancel culture. It's the same thing. If we can't be consistent, why are we calling for firings when we were decrying firings on the other side? How do you feel about that?
Scott Galloway
I think it's a different side of the same coin. The right position is to say the administration and leadership, they're administrators. We're here to create an environment for free speech and to host and sponsor critics, but we're not here to be critics ourselves. Also, whatever line we decide, if we decide anyone can say pretty much anything, I think that's a defensible position. I'm not talking about the academics. I'm talking about their critics, like the Bill Ackmans, who go on and on about free speech but then try insanely to get people fired and say they shouldn't be able to say these things.
He's applying the wrong standard or the wrong reason they should be fired. It's fine if they're total free speech, but they can't fire Larry Summers as president of Harvard when in an academic setting he starts doing research or questioning the genetic... Is there a genetic cause for the difference in aptitude among males and females? He was basically fired for that. That's not only free speech, that should be academic freedom. But he was fired for it. When it comes to something like that, where there are real sensitivities or for some reason sensitivities around that group, we apply... we say there isn't free speech.
Kara Swisher
But there's inconsistency everywhere. I think they just have to decide where is the line and then hold to it. If they're smart, they're going to say the leadership here isn't engaged in that. We're here to schedule classes, raise money, and make sure the quad gets clean. We're not going to start weighing in on these topics.
Scott Galloway
I'm struck by all the free speech warriors who are now saying you can't say that. Everybody is inconsistent here. Every single side of this. I'm consistent. I think you should be fired for saying some things that are problematic, and you shouldn't, and you should be able to say a lot of things. I just would like consistency from all these groups. It reminds me of, I'm for free speech except for that guy, except for that doesn't suit me. It's not in my interests. Then you get all hot and bothered, but you can't get hot and bothered about something else.
Kara Swisher
I think it's just all in people's self-interests. Every bit of this. It's all about determining a line and then having one line, not a plaid. You can't. By the way, if you're going to be a free speech absolutist, Rashida Tlaib wanted to speak at ASU. They canceled her thing. She should be allowed to speak. If you're going to be a free speech... But I could see why you wouldn't have her. If you want Milo Yiannopoulos, whatever the hell his name is, to speak, then you have an obligation to escort him to make sure he can safely speak. You just have to pick a line. Or you might say, "Guess what? If anything causes too much disruption, we don't have the funds.
We have the discretion to decide. We are not free speech absolutists." That's a position too. Just pick a theme and stick to it. I'm asking you to address the critics who go on and on and get on their high horses about free speech when in fact it's the same thing. Some of the people you have referenced, in my opinion, have made a side hustle and like the prestige and the attention they're getting and the power they have of going after powerful people at universities. It feels like they are engaged in... they're getting really into it and they're enjoying it. I don't think they're being friends to the university.
President Gay, I didn't think she handled... I didn't think she acquitted herself well. I think Harvard being ranked as the least free speech place amongst universities and then applying these incredible standards of free speech around other things. Some of the stuff... Did you see that chart around what's called fat phobia, I think?
Scott Galloway
And I remember emails saying these qualify as microaggressions and could lead to dismissal. I mean, it's like, all right, we have to have some sort of consistency in terms of these rich billionaires who are engaging in the side hustle of going after the heads like trophies of university presidents and also wanting the unmasking of students. It's a little bit of like, all right, it all comes back to the same thing, Kara, unfortunately. There's just too few people with too much fucking money. And we've become their side pieces. We've become their whores. We're so dependent upon their money. They have so much power.
We have an individual who can aggregate so much wealth that he can acquire a global media platform and then invite somebody back on, on the anniversary of Sandy Hook, and wave his middle finger at all parents and all of society. We have an individual who can—imagine Bob Iger says, "I got an idea, Disney AI. I don't know what it means yet, but I'm gonna use AI to launch a series of products focused on family-friendly AI that'll be entertaining and take our IP." And he says, "You know what? It's a great idea and I'm Bob Iger. I'm the most seasoned, famous executive in the world. I'm gonna go raise a billion dollars and I'm spinning it out and I'm going to own 75% of it." Bob Iger is going to own 75% of it. Well, guess what? The Disney board would be like, "Sorry, girlfriend, you're doing no fucking such thing." But if you're so wealthy and you're able to aggregate so much capital that you can do this with your own media platform with absolutely no checks and balances, or you can start dictating campus policy from afar without even being on the board.
I just think this all comes back to the fact that there's too few people with too much money. And you know who *Time* person of the year should have been, Kara? *Time* person of the year should have been money. Over the last two years, Kara, we have had the most legislatively unproductive session in history. And you know who's filled that void? Money. Could the Gulf have ever bought a newspaper?
Kara Swisher
I might accept money. I might accept money, but I still like Taylor Swift, but I might accept money. I agree with you.
Scott Galloway
I get your point. Could 10 years ago, could the Gulf have purchased the newspaper in the UK that dictates Tory politics? Could that have happened? Could five years ago, the Gulf have purchased a US and European sport? Money wins. Money is literally washing over everything.
Kara Swisher
There you go. Over everything.
Scott Galloway
There you go. It's interesting. I got a note from someone before they heard our podcast that said, "Was just thinking that Elon raises a billion for his AI project. I bet he takes a chunk of it to license a firehose from Twitter, creating a big revenue stream that saves him from coming out of pocket," when in reality, that business should be run as part of Twitter, as part of his obligation to his investors.
Kara Swisher
That sounds familiar. Right. Yeah, I know. That's what I said. I said, "Did you listen to Scott?" Anyway, we have to get going, but you're absolutely right. Money. Money makes the world go round. All right, Scott, let's take a quick break. When we come back, the EU makes a major move toward AI regulation. We'll speak with *Pod Save America* co-host Dan Pfeiffer.
Ad Break
Scott, we're back. The EU has reached a deal on a major new law to regulate artificial intelligence. The AI Act, it's called, will set a new global benchmark for countries looking to harness AI. We're also trying to protect against the risks. The European Parliament will vote on the Act early next year, but legislation will not take effect until at least 2025. It moves slowly.
So the Act includes new transparency requirements for general purpose AI models, though there are some broad exemptions for open source models. Facial recognition was apparently one of the most contentious topics putting the deal together. The final agreement, the use of facial recognition software by police and governments would be restricted outside of certain safety and national security situations. Tech companies that want to do business will be asked to disclose data and do rigorous testing, particularly for high risk applications. Companies that violate the regulations face fines up to 7% of global sales. I think it sounds the right direction. I don't know how much teeth it will have. But it does sound like what Biden was proposing in his executive order.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, my call sign for big tech now is "move fast and regulate things." I'm part of the AI accelerator group, whatever they call themselves. I think you go fast. Is that what it's called? Yeah, Accel people. Decel Accel. I think the West wants to own this, but at the same time, I think we need to pay more and attract the best and brightest. Israel actually does a pretty good job of this, of incorporating the best and brightest, oftentimes at least into their military. I think we need brighter, not brighter. I think there's some really talented people at the very top levels of government, but I would like to see more kids from my class at Stern think, "I would really like to get a job in government, that it pays well, it's prestigious, and I'm going to get to work on cutting edge issues." Because the hard part about regulating this is that by the time the regulations get implemented and have any teeth, AI has kind of moved on to new problems, right? This is just all moving so fast.
But it's really interesting what Europe appears to be leading in terms—and you could argue it's innovation—is around regulation, because the U.S. is starting to look at European regulation and think, "Is that working? And what can we adopt and what can we model?" But the thing that the UK has always had, and it has great education institutions, it's a great culture, it's always had the rule of fair play. And I think if Europe becomes the place where it's seen as when you deal with an organization or money comes through Europe, there's a rule of fair play here, I think that does result in economic growth. And the old trope that regulation hampers economic growth is not true. It can actually facilitate economic growth.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, you said that. I think these have to be global rules and the US should lead the way. That EO was a very good first step. I think we both thought that. The safety, the rigorous testing, the protection of open source, I think is important. We do both think is important. There being enough of a fine so that if they're violative, they don't just like, "Okay, I'll just pay the bill," essentially. And the facial recognition software, it seems to hit on all the notes. It's just that none of the companies they're regulating were based, or maybe one or two in the EU. It's all US companies, right? And so if US companies are dominating this, and they are, let's leave Chinese companies out of this, it should be regulated in the US much more quickly. And that's a question of how quickly we'll be able to have any laws. It could be the same exact thing that happened in the previous attempts to regulate the internet, which would be unfortunate. There seems to be more energy here to do something and more cognizance.
Scott Galloway
I was thinking today, hands down, the most seminal technology of the last decade, if not two decades, trillions of dollars in market cap. And it's not only, of course, in one country, it's not even just in one state, it's like 80% of it is in seven miles of SFO International Airport. I mean, for all of our ship posting and all of our problems, there's something in the water in America, the agility, the risk-taking. It is nothing short of remarkable what happens in the US. And at the same time, our inability to regulate, our infatuation with the accoutrements of that innovation, specifically money, leads to people who put Alex Jones on their network. It's just like we have so much potential, and yet we decide, okay, let's let a few individuals let us start ripping each other apart. A lack of decorum, a lack of character, a lack of comedy, a lack of patriotism, a lack of just general decency. I just don't think people would have done this shit 10 or 20 years ago. I don't think they'd behave this way. Maybe quietly.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
But they wouldn't threaten to fight in Congress. They wouldn't say on day one of my presidency, "I'm going to go after my enemies." I mean, it's just like, it feels like all the decorum has basically just got shit-canned.
Kara Swisher
Out, that shit can't. Shit can't.
Scott Galloway
Well, this is all about money. And that's why it's moved so slow in the U.S. But I think our government, in a bipartisan way, should figure out a couple of key things, pass them, and that's how you start, right? Facial recognition seems to be easy. Safety seems to be easy. And of course, be flexible as things change and not be sort of drawn in by these tech people saying no regulation, because if any will hinder us, I don't think that's the case. I think they know that's not the case. And they should be part of it too, by the way. They always are. And they usually run the table on our legislators, but it certainly should be. The problem again, getting back to money, money makes the world go round here and they have the money and so they'll get what they want. But the EU doesn't seem to be as easily bought and paid for as our regulators do.
Kara Swisher
I would argue that the same isn't true in Europe, that institutions still matter. And in the U.S.—
Scott Galloway
Yeah, that's what I mean. They're not bought and paid for.
Kara Swisher
Well, here's the thing. In the U.S., when Congress doesn't legislate, when there is no antitrust, when money fills the void. And also, it's been that way through most of history. I want to be clear. From 1945 to like the president I would call was the great era of the middle class and institutions and democracy, kind of a second enlightenment, whatever you want to call it, where we said democracy matters and we're going to pay a lot of money in taxes such that a group of really smart people that we elect can think about long-term health and well-being for our future, recognizing that all of us digress individual needs on our own. And I feel like we're going to look back on the era from 1945 to 2000 as this real golden age of institutions where we said, "You know what, let's try and shove people into this remarkable new innovation called the middle class. It'll create meeting opportunities, economic opportunities, a peaceful society." And it feels as if we're returning to the way things used to be and that it's much more Darwinian and much more *Hunger Games*.
Well, speaking of that, let's bring in our friend of Pivot. Dan Pfeiffer is the co-host of Crooked Media's *Pod Save America*. He's also the host of a new podcast, *Pollercoaster*, which is launching this week and will feature analysis on the latest polls and voter trends. Welcome, Dan.
Dan Pfeiffer
Thanks for having me.
Kara Swisher
So since you're the expert here, let's start with some polling. Over the weekend, *The Wall Street Journal* released a new poll with voters giving Biden the lowest job approval of his presidency at 37 percent. In a head-to-head matchup with Trump, Trump beats Biden 47 to 43 percent. Now, we know it is early. The poll also shows Trump continuing to dominate the Republican field, nearly 60 percent supporting him. That's not new. But Nikki Haley has numbers that are a stronger general election candidate, beating Biden by 17 points. So talk to us about this latest one, because there's been a slew like this. It's early again. Go ahead.
Dan Pfeiffer
It is early, and there's been a consistent set of—these numbers are all kind of in the neighborhood. Slight Trump lead, Biden under 40 approval rating, Trump advantages on the economy, immigration, crime, Israel-Gaza, with Biden holding an advantage on generally abortion and democracy and civility, those sorts of issues. And I think these are the polls that Democrats should take seriously but not literally.
Kara Swisher
Right.
Dan Pfeiffer
There is no question that if the election were held today, Joe Biden would be in trouble and could and would lose. But there's a very simple, I think, explanation in pure math as to why Trump is winning and Biden is not. In the *Wall Street Journal* poll, Trump is getting 92 percent of his 2020 voters and Biden's getting 87 percent. And that is consistent across all of the polls. That is alarming, but if you're the Biden team and you're looking for a silver lining, those are the easiest voters to get back—the ones who've already cast a ballot for you. And that's got to be what the focus is heading into next year. It's beginning to rebuild that coalition. If you do that, then we are headed for a very, very close election, but one that is very winnable for Joe Biden.
Kara Swisher
Okay. So we keep hearing also about Nikki Haley momentum, but realistically, is there any scenario where she gets the nomination?
Dan Pfeiffer
I would say no. I think that if you look, Nikki Haley is a non-MAGA candidate in a MAGA party. There is a whole bunch of polling that shows Ron DeSantis is actually a much more likely Republican nominee than Trump. In an NBC poll of the Republican primary from earlier this month, more than 70% of Republican voters have Trump as their first or second choice. 54% of Republican voters have DeSantis as their first or second choice. And only 28% have Nikki Haley as their first or second choice. And so her universe of voters—she's a factional candidate, if you will. She is consolidating this minority of the party. And it's actually in a weird way hurting her. Her approval rating keeps going down the better she does in the polls because she's going from being a non-Trump to an anti-Trump candidate. So her net approval rating right now is 12 points. It's 42-30. DeSantis, for who we all very much, myself at least, spend a lot of time making fun of for what an awkward, weird, terrible candidate he is, he has a net approval rating of 45%. And Trump's net approval rating is above 60. So he's the other Trump.
Kara Swisher
He's the later. He's the other Trump, right.
Dan Pfeiffer
And if Donald Trump were to go to prison tomorrow, drop out of the race, defect to Russia, whatever else, Ron DeSantis would be the overwhelming favorite to defeat Nikki Haley in a primary. In a primary situation, even though the general, it's a real problem for someone like him. Nikki Haley is, at least as we can tell right now, a relatively generic non-Trump Republican in the eyes of voters. But as of right now, she's obviously, I think, very clearly the most electable Republican who is in the mix.
Kara Swisher
Is in the mix. But Trump carries those fans.
Dan Pfeiffer
Yes. Which DeSantis doesn't have.
Kara Swisher
Biden, they seem unworried in the Biden administration. I've talked to a lot of people. And should they be more worried? They sort of have this, you know, "Grandpa's going to win again. Good old grandpa. Once you get a taste of crazy uncle, great uncle Trump, everyone will go, 'Oh, that guy.'" It seems like that's a little sleepy to do. And I hate to use the term "sleepy" around Joe Biden. But, you know, I think it's just like, should they be more? But the last time everyone counted him out and there he was. OK, let's just have grandpa again kind of thing. He's safe.
Dan Pfeiffer
I think my guess is that in reality, the Biden folks are less worried than the general Democratic Party, which is in a state of sort of abject panic at this point.
Kara Swisher
As they always are.
Dan Pfeiffer
As they always are. That is not unusual. The term "bedwetter" was invented for a reason to describe my party. But I think they are more worried, or at least more aggressively trying to shape the race, than some of these public comments, because they spent $25 million in ads in the off year. And that's not something you do if you think this race is going to naturally revert to the mean, where it'll be Joe Biden with a four or five point national poll lead. So I think that they are more worried than we think they are. But I understand why. There's no point in panicking, right? You have to go about doing your work. I think they see the path to getting there. But some of the things that they have tried thus far have not moved the needle. And I think that is probably worrisome.
Scott Galloway
Dan, good to see you. So my sense of polls at this point aren't very good proxies for what will actually happen in terms of who wins and who loses. But they can be really helpful in terms of identifying key issues and messaging. If you were advising the candidates, what messages do you think are bubbling up that weren't there four years ago that they want to focus on? And then I'd be curious for you to do the same analysis that you did on the Republicans on the Democratic side. Like, is that also a foregone conclusion that Biden's the nominee?
Dan Pfeiffer
Sure. You're exactly right that the polls this far out have very little predictive value of what's going to happen, but they are essential for understanding. It's taking the temperature of where we are right now. And so we talk all about polls, media polls, the ones done by *The Wall Street Journal* and NBC, but campaigns are doing all these polls at the same time. From everything I hear, Democratic polls are seeing the exact same trends that we're seeing in the public polls. So everyone has the same analysis of where we are.
And I think it's a couple of things that would be the advice I would give Democrats and Biden in particular here. One, and you can see them doing this already, is you have to make this more of a choice, right? In all of these polls, people are much more focused on Joe Biden than Donald Trump. And for a lot of voters, they haven't really thought about Trump at all since 2021, right? You see this in the *New York Times*-Siena poll: the percent of voters who are concerned about Donald Trump's temperament has gone down since 2020. The percent of voters who think Donald Trump is unfit mentally for office has gone down since 2020. And so we have to focus the mind on the fact that Donald Trump is running and he is going to be the nominee and he has a very good chance of being president going forward.
The second thing is on the economy. We have to stop. Democrats are in this debate of, "Well, people are unhappy, but the economy is great." And it doesn't really matter what the macro numbers say. It matters how people actually feel. And I think this is—I know you guys have talked to this—this is a very, very strange economy for a lot of people and how they experience it. And so we have to shift jobs. The jobs numbers are a low priority for Americans right now. Their issue is not whether or not they're going to have a job. It is what the costs of goods are. It's not what the rate of inflation is.
It's the price of things. And I think Democrats need to shift the framework more away from "Here's what we've accomplished. Here's all the progress we've made" and focus really hard on using what they've done as proof points for how they can lower costs and raise wages going forward, and do that in a very contrastive way with Trump. In all of these polls, a place where Biden has real strength is that voters think that Donald Trump and the Republicans are more on the side of the wealthy and corporations and less on the side of the middle class, and Democrats are. And you want to draw that contrast.
So it has to be a choice, not a referendum.
Kara Swisher
Which is a shift.
Dan Pfeiffer
It is a shift. That's right.
Kara Swisher
There's also a lot of prognosticating about what a potential Trump second term would be, which is sort of the fear method of doing that. Trump had the town hall with Sean Hannity last week where he didn't exactly say no to abusing power in a second term, noting he would be a dictator only on day one, which you can do a lot in a day. You wrote about this in your newsletter saying many of the responses to Trump's comments are playing right into his trap. Obviously, he's playing games. I mean, you can tell it by his smirkiness. How should we be talking about it? I mean, it's terrifying and also what an asshole. You sort of get that same feel off of Elon Musk or any of these. Like, they're just trying to fuck with you, essentially.
Dan Pfeiffer
Yeah, he very clearly was sort of smirking and Sean Hannity was completely flummoxed at why Donald Trump would not take his repeated offers of a lifeline in that moment. But we have focused, and I think rightfully, on Donald Trump saying "on day one." But what keeps getting left out is what he said right after that, which he basically said, "I am going to abuse power to secure the border and, quote, 'drill, drill, drill,'" right? So what he is trying to do is to say, "I am going to be an authoritarian, but I'm going to be an authoritarian for you. Here's how I'm going to help your life." We know that these are things people care a lot about: cost of energy, and border is at the top of—it's right below inflation on a lot of the polls in terms of concerns for voters.
What Democrats should do is we should avoid some traps. First is we shouldn't run around talking about how strong Donald Trump is, because strength is part of his appeal. We have to talk about the fact that he is weak, right? Donald Trump has never stood up to anyone in his life. He bows down to CEOs. He bows down to dictators. He's running for president, not to help you, but because he's afraid to face the consequences for his actions in office last time. Make it about his weakness. Donald Trump—that is a trap to make us talk about how strong and fearful he is. That's one.
Two, we have to empower voters to be the ones who can stop Donald Trump. It's not that it is inevitable that he's going to take over—the Robert Kagan column of his dictatorship inevitable. We have the power to stop him. Next, and I think this is really important, is we have to talk about how what Donald Trump would do, how him being a dictator or seizing power or abusing power would affect you. And I think that one great way to do this is talk about abortion. The Heritage Foundation and others have talked about how even if Donald Trump is unable to pass a federal abortion ban, they can weaponize the federal government to put a de facto federal abortion ban in effect.
And you can do that across the board on issues about pollution and protecting clean air and clean water, about helping workers, how Donald Trump will use the federal government to make it harder for the workers who were on strike at UAW or at Starbucks and all of those things. We have to make it matter to people, because if we don't and we just say "Donald Trump's going to destroy democracy," we are sort of by default saying that we are the ones who are going to defend this political system that most voters say is corrupt and doesn't work for them. And so it has to be very, very specific, because if not, we're just having this esoteric argument that means nothing to most voters and in some ways actually undergirds some of Trump's appeal that helped propel him in 2016.
Scott Galloway
So the polls look really ugly for Biden. And so we immediately think—I mean, they're kind of shocking. And so you immediately think, "Oh, wow, things are going well for us if you're a progressive." But anytime there's an election, whether it's the legislature in, I think it was Virginia, or the abortion bill in Ohio, it appears that blue is winning everywhere. What's wrong here? Every time I see an actual election where people don't respond to a telephone or a phone survey, they actually go in and pull a handle or check a box, it feels like we're doing really well.
Dan Pfeiffer
This is a quite—people have been really trying very hard to square this circle, right? The polls look bad, but Democrats keep winning. And both things can be true at the same time because these surveys we're looking at are surveys of the overall presidential election electorate, which is in most states 30 to 40 percent bigger than the people who vote in a midterm or even in a special election. And Donald Trump does best right now with people who don't vote in midterms. He's doing best in these polls with people who didn't even vote in 2020. That's a huge part of his advantage in the *New York Times*-Siena poll: he's beating Biden by 15 points among people who did not vote in 2020.
So these are two separate universes. And as of right now, the presidential election universe is less Democratic-friendly than the midterm universe. And the parties have switched in this regard as the Democrats have become more a party of college-educated suburban voters. When I worked for President Obama, Republicans were a much more reliable midterm party, which is why Republicans could crush in the 2010 midterms and then lose pretty handily in 2012 when Obama was on the ballot. And the reverse is true now.
Scott Galloway
Have you—I just have a couple of follow-up questions. One, since 2016 when Trump won, my guess is 10 or 20 million American voters have died and there's 10 or 20 million newer voters. How has that—so you've lost 70- and 80-somethings and you've gained 18- to 26-year-old somethings. How has that changed the electorate? And I would just be curious if you have thought about how the conflict in the Middle East is likely playing out and does it advantage Trump or Biden?
Dan Pfeiffer
And let me put a caveat on that. It's a year from now. There'll be a whole different topic a year from now. We won't be talking about this.
Kara Swisher
Right. Go ahead.
Dan Pfeiffer
2020 was a better year for Joe Biden than 2016 was for Hillary Clinton in the popular vote. For many reasons, one of them is the electorate was becoming slightly more demographically friendly to Democrats. Now, the challenge right now for Democrats is Donald Trump has made gains. It is a question about how much those gains are with younger Latino and Black men. So that accounts for some of the demographic change, where a few years ago we thought those would automatically be Democratic votes at 85% Democratic, and it's much less than that now.
One of the challenges for Biden is his most disaffected group, the people who are most willing to either sit out the election or vote for a third party candidate like Cornel West or RFK Jr., are voters 18 to 29. So if Biden was performing at 2020 levels with those younger voters, you would sort of see that more democratic shift in the electorate based on those demographics. But that's not being maximized right now because of opinions on Biden.
On Gaza, the polling on this is incredibly confusing because the narrative we all get is younger Democratic voters are very angry at Joe Biden. In the CBS News poll that came out on Sunday, the only group with the highest approval rating of Joe Biden on handling the Israeli-Hamas conflict is voters 18 to 29. It's 50-50, and Joe Biden is underwater with all the other groups. They also asked people what to prioritize. Only 4% of voters put the Israeli-Hamas conflict as a high priority. But it could have a real impact in some states like Michigan that have a very large Arab American population, and particularly Palestinians.
If this were still at the top of the news a year from now or 11 months from now, then that's what the impact could be. Recent history says these things tend to fade in the American mindset when they're happening abroad. Maybe that will be the case here. I don't know, but it's very possible, if not likely.
Kara Swisher
I will say, talking to a lot of young people, they are irritated by Biden. They are for sure. And they don't think about Trump right now. But I think they've only lived with Netanyahu. That's why. I just feel like they don't know anyone else. And so they don't like Netanyahu. But at the same time, I think once they get a taste of Uncle Crazy, I think they'll be reminded of the same thing, especially around abortion. Abortion is a staying issue. It feels like it is.
Scott Galloway
Yes, 100%. With women, especially.
Kara Swisher
Even everyone says, "Oh, now they're done with abortion." I don't think women are done with that, putting protections in place. And I don't think they much like—that's another thing I hear. It's like the book, all the meddlesomeness of the Republicans, especially the religious stuff from Mike Johnson, seems to stick in their craw and seems lasting.
Axios recently published a list of some of the current Trump vice presidential candidates, including J.D. Vance, Sarah Huckabee Sanders.
Scott Galloway
Oh, God.
Kara Swisher
Kari Lake.
Scott Galloway
Oh, God.
Kara Swisher
Kristi Noem. Apparently, Melania is advocating for Tucker Carlson. None of these seem like very good choices. Because if I had a guess among this list, J.D. Vance would be his choice. But any thoughts? Any out-of-the-box thoughts?
Dan Pfeiffer
In most cases with a normal presidential nominee, you would look at whoever fit in that Venn diagram of qualified, good relationship with the president to be, and electability. And I can't imagine Donald Trump would think about it that way.
Scott Galloway
And could take over.
Kara Swisher
And could take over. Right.
Dan Pfeiffer
I think Donald Trump is the sort of person who would never hire someone that anyone could think could be their replacement. So he will not pick the best person, either the best vice president or someone who has re-electable appeal. If your analysis is "I want someone who is never a threat to me politically, personally, socially," you end up with Mike Pence. So I think it's like, who is the Mike Pence of this group? Sort of a large tub of applesauce, political applesauce, is where I think Donald Trump ends up. I don't think he picks Tucker Carlson because Tucker Carlson could be a bigger star than him, or Nikki Haley, who he wouldn't trust. So whoever is like generic replacement level.
Scott Galloway
Any of these? Maybe J.D. Vance, I guess. I don't know. Loyalty, I think, would be high on this list.
Kara Swisher
And the same with if something—one of the things we were talking about this week in our listener questions was, look, if one of these guys breaks a hip, and it's entirely possible, or goes to jail—only for one of them—what happens? Because it could happen in that time period. This could be really fascinating.
Dan Pfeiffer
It's going to depend on whether it happens before or after the convention. If it's before the convention, then we'll have what would be essentially a brokered convention where a bunch of people would try to get to a majority of that convention.
Kara Swisher
Of each party.
Dan Pfeiffer
Of each party. And you would keep voting until you got to that person. I would imagine on the Democratic side, Kamala Harris would have a very large leg up in that situation. And then if it happens after the convention, then it gets very tricky. The DNC has specific rules in which they would go and use the DNC members to pick someone. I imagine once again, that would likely be Kamala Harris if they've just voted—the majority of delegates had just voted her vice president. Even trickier if ballots have been printed in states. We've been in situations like with Mel Carnahan, who was running for senator in Missouri in 2000, where a candidate dies after the ballots are printed.
Scott Galloway
Anyone. Anyone anyway.
Dan Pfeiffer
Republicans have a similar thing where the RNC would just pick someone to be the nominee. Likely, I think in all those cases, if it's after the convention, the VP nominee would be the person. And then they'd have to pick another vice presidential nominee. So it would be very messy and confusing and probably great for people in the content business, is my guess.
Scott Galloway
If you were to pick sort of a best or worst exogenous event for either candidate, what would it be?
Dan Pfeiffer
The best thing that could happen for Joe Biden and democracy would be Donald Trump being convicted in the January 6th trial. In the New York Times-CNN poll, they actually asked people what would happen if Donald Trump was convicted. Only 6% of voters switched their vote away from Trump. But that 6% is enough to tip the election to Joe Biden. I think we do not spend enough time talking and thinking about the very, very real possibility that Donald Trump will be sentenced to prison for multiple federal crimes three or four months before the election. If that were to happen, that is a—I don't think we're fully anticipating what a big game changer that is.
Kara Swisher
It could be for sure. Yeah. Anyway, Dan, this is fascinating. Again, you have a new podcast. You're obviously on Pod Save America each week, but your new podcast, Pollercoaster.
Scott Galloway
I'm just laughing at that. I'm sorry. How long did it take to come up with that?
Dan Pfeiffer
"Pollercoaster" was the term that we would use in the Obama campaigns for the people who were checking the polls every single day.
Kara Swisher
Oh, okay.
Dan Pfeiffer
And we say, "Get off the fucking pollercoaster." We've used that a little bit on Pod Save America over the years. My goal here with this podcast is to help people understand what the polls mean and think about what to use them for. I'm completely ignoring polls. I'm not going to be a pollercoaster. There are going to be people in this world who want to ignore the polls, and that's very healthy. But if you can't ignore the polls and you're going to live and die with them and you want to understand what they really mean, this is the podcast for you.
Scott Galloway
I don't buy it. Tell me you do edibles without telling me you do edibles. You came up with that name under the influence.
Kara Swisher
It kicks off. Pollercoaster kicks off on December 14th. Dan, thank you.
Scott Galloway
I like Pollercoaster. Wait, pass the Doritos. Let's watch South Park. All right. And we're out.
Kara Swisher
Okay, Dan, thank you so much.
Dan Pfeiffer
Awesome. Thank you, guys.
Dan Pfeiffer exits
Kara Swisher
I like those Pod Save America guys.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, they're very likable. They're all very adoptable. They're all like these nice, deceptively good-looking young men.
Kara Swisher
Yes, they're great. Not as young as they used to be, but nonetheless. Anyway, Scott, one more quick break. We'll be back for wins and fails.
Ad Break - Mint Mobile
Ad Read - Sierra AI
Tron Ares has arrived. I would like you to meet Ares, the ultimate AI soldier. He is biblically strong and supremely intelligent. You think you're in control of this? You're not. On October 10th. What are you? My world is coming to destroy yours. But I can help you. The war for our world begins in IMAX. Tron Ares, rated PG-13. May be inappropriate for children under 13. Only in theaters October 10th. Get tickets now.
Return to show
Kara Swisher
Okay, Scott, let's hear some wins and fails.
Scott Galloway
So I'm a big fan of Senator Romney, and he was on Meet the Press this week. He said something that struck me. He said that America can overcome bad policy, but it'll have a much more difficult time overcoming bad character. And he's worried about the character of the nation. He was speaking about Donald Trump, suggesting that day one he would abuse his powers to go after his political enemies.
I looked up characteristics of people who lack character: they believe intentionally hurting others is validated, believe they are never wrong, believe other people are responsible for their feelings and cannot take responsibility for their own decisions, and don't respect boundaries. I just feel as if there's such a lack of character amongst some of our most powerful people. That character used to be there. I don't know if I'm just getting old and getting sort of "get off my lawn," but when we have the wealthiest man in the world allowing people back on his platform that represent nothing but grief for grieving parents, when we have a president saying he's going to pursue his political enemies, when we have presidential candidates sounding like they're peeing on Twitter Spaces—it definitely feels as if there's a lack of character that infects our most powerful.
I used the term "decorum" last week, but I do think it's character. I don't know if it's because we've replaced civics class. I think we need to bring back national service and civics and, I don't know, cotillion, or just general manners.
Kara Swisher
Cotillion?
Scott Galloway
I went to cotillion. Just manners. For God's sakes, just manners. You open doors for people. You show them a certain level of respect. I remember when I was on the athletic field, one of the first things we were taught in sports is if you do ever get into a fight, the moment somebody hits the ground, the fight's over. It feels like we've lost that sense.
Anyway, my American story. I'll move on to my win. Something a little lighter. I've been watching something that gets me out of these funks—great television, of course. I've been watching season five of Fargo.
Kara Swisher
Oh, no, I haven't watched it at all.
Scott Galloway
It has some real talent. Juno Temple, who is in Ted Lasso, is outstanding. A new woman who plays a sheriff, Risha Morjani, is really good. And I think Jon Hamm is actually, I think, similar to Brad Pitt or Tom Cruise. I don't think he gets the accolades for his acting ability because he's just so damn handsome. He plays a really interesting character in this. Anyways, if you're looking for a guilty pleasure, Fargo season five.
Kara Swisher
All right. Well, I am going to do my win. It's very similar. The Holdovers. Alexander Payne, one of my favorite directors. It's a wonderful movie about people. Paul Giamatti's in it. There's a new young actor, and I'm blanking on his name. Just an amazing cast of four people that are left behind at a boarding school during Christmas break. I love Alexander Payne. I love The Descendants. I like most of his movies. Such a heartfelt, kind, life-affirming movie. Just people that are difficult and unhappy and lonely. But it's such a wonderful spirit. You will love the spirit of it because it's about community. It's about connection. It's wonderful.
Scott Galloway
I love Paul Giamatti so much.
Kara Swisher
And I loved the one set in Napa Valley that he did. Sideways.
Scott Galloway
Which is also Alexander Payne.
Kara Swisher
Thomas Haden Church.
Scott Galloway
Thomas Haden Church, yes, is in that movie. So is Sandra Oh.
Kara Swisher
I just love this movie. And again, Descendants is one of my favorite movies. And it had that kind of feeling to it, that very problematic and broken people who come together. And I just thought it was great.
My fail is—I think we've had enough with this university president situation. So I think we should move along. None got fired. They said stupid things. The thirst for blood is repulsive. And I don't like it on either side. I really, really, truly don't. And now it's showing your true colors for many of these people. It's all about the hunt. And I think people can learn.
I thought particularly Claudine Gay—she may lose her job. The board is convening. She's been in her job for six months. Six months. She did a very clearly emotional apology. She got her mistake. Let's see what she can do. And the accusations from Bill Ackman, who's proving himself to be a really unpleasant piece of work, saying that she isn't qualified. Well, guess how he got into Harvard? He's a legacy. So give me a break. Everyone gets a foot up, everybody. So let's just move along. They'll overplay their hand. It's not because I'm being kind. It's just that there's no plus in it. They made a mistake. No question. So let's get back to a place where we all can talk. And that's why you should watch The Holdovers. That's what that's about.
Anyway, we want to hear from you. Send us your questions about business, tech, or whatever's on your mind. Go to nymag.com slash pivot to submit a question for the show, or call 855-525-5255. One Pivot.
Okay, Scott, that's the show. We'll be back on Friday with more. Please read us out.
Scott Galloway
Today's show was produced by Lara Neiman, Zoe Marcus, and Taylor Griffin. Ernie Underthought engineered this episode. Thanks also to Drew Burrows, Miel Silverio, and Gaddy McVein. Make sure you subscribe to the show wherever you listen to podcasts.
Kara Swisher
Thank you for listening to Pivot from New York Magazine and Vox Media. You can subscribe to the magazine at nymag.com slash pod. Again, that's nymag.com slash pod. But we'll be back later this week for another breakdown of all things tech and business. Have a great rest of the week.
Scott Galloway
Oh, and happy birthday. God, you're old. Jesus Christ, you're old. My God.
Kara Swisher
We're going to Denny's. It's a Grand Slam special.