Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses various topics, including the recent mass shooting in Texas, the politicization of gun control, and the impact of social media on society. The hosts, Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway, also discuss the decline of Snap Inc's stock, the rise of TikTok, and the challenges faced by payment companies like PayPal and Klarna.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Podcast Intro with Sponsors
Kara Swisher
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And I'm Scott Galloway.
Kara Swisher
So, Scott, today we'll get into everything from Snap's stock crash to layoffs at PayPal and Klarna, and we'll speak with filmmaker Judd Apatow about his new documentary, book, and feature film. But first, we have to talk about the terrible news out of Texas.
Another mass shooting has claimed the lives of more than 20 people at an elementary school, 19 of them children. This is the deadliest school shooting in 10 years since Sandy Hook in Newtown, Connecticut. It comes on the heels of a mass shooting at a grocery store in Buffalo. We've barely had time to unpack that event before this happened.
The responses to this shooting have seemed more impassioned. President Biden said the country should show backbone in the face of lobbyists, though he didn't name names. In Texas, Beto O'Rourke interrupted a press conference that accused Governor Greg Abbott of inaction. And one of the most powerful responses came from Connecticut Senator Chris Murphy, who spoke on the floor of the Senate. Let's take a quick listen.
Audio clip plays: Senator Chris Murphy speaking on the Senate floor
So, also Steve Kerr from the Golden State Warriors also had a very viral speech he gave, which was incredibly moving. He had a family member killed in a shooting. God, what are we doing? I mean, it's hard to pile on or say anything new or add to the outrage, the justified outrage. I just... and you don't want to in any way validate or just be bereft or resign, but I feel as if we've been here before, and I have the same fears you have every time. And that is, you get not hopeful, but you think that maybe the silver lining here might be, well, this is the one that motivates us or catalyzes us to action. And to date, they haven't been. We move on to the next thing.
Scott Galloway
I would describe the politicization of this as a cocktail or a war between the wrong — Republicans who are focused on money and catering to the far right — and the ineffective — Democrats who make moving emotional speeches and they can't get anything done. In this war between the wrong and the ineffective, the bullets are winning.
School shootings are the tip of the iceberg of horror. But as an actual number of people that are killed in school shootings, while it's horrific, it's literally a tip of the iceberg where 99% of the death is below the surface. We've had a mass shooting every day. 1.4 million people in the last 50 years have died at the hands of guns in the United States. There will be more preschoolers shot and killed this year than police officers. This gets, obviously for justifiable reasons, tremendous media coverage, but it's barely even a tip of the iceberg of the despair and death and disability that gun deaths cause.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Bill Frist noted this, that gun deaths are the leading cause of young people now over traffic accidents.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. It used to be cars. Now it's guns.
Kara Swisher
And you like to think, all right, well, how do we move to some sort of solution? And there are solutions. There's no magic wand here, but there really is.
Scott Galloway
I think a lot about young men. And let me ask you this, Kara. When you heard about this — it's weird, you tell you're getting older — I saw the headlines and for the first time, I didn't read them. I was like, I just can't handle this right now. And then I went back to it. But here's the thing. In terms of the shooter, I knew who the shooter was before I knew who it was.
Kara Swisher
Well, it's either a very racist young man or an isolated young man.
Scott Galloway
Well, they're usually one and the same. Let me put it this way. You knew who it wasn't. I knew with 100% certainty it wasn't a soccer mom. I knew with 100% certainty it wasn't a grandparent. And I knew with 98% certainty it wasn't even a fundamentalist whack job from some religious extremist. You knew it was — and this is who it always is, or almost always is — a young man, maybe even call him a boy, that is totally detached, isn't attaching to anything, hasn't attached to anything.
I do think this speaks to a larger crisis that affects incarceration, social services, addiction, inability to form families. And let me asterisk all of this: none of this gets much better without sensible gun control. I don't want to be a distraction here, but I do go to—
Kara Swisher
No, no. I think it goes hand in hand. It's allowing people to become more isolated, especially post-pandemic or not dealing with mental health issues, but then providing this many guns.
I interviewed Nick Kristof today and Frank Smyth, who wrote the NRA book. Nick talked about all these baby steps that need to happen, including federal registration of gun ownership, red flag laws, all kinds of small things that will make a big difference, just the way we regulated driving with seatbelts and guardrails. They were very small things that saved many, many lives. Education, Mothers Against Drunk Driving, things like that.
It's never going to stop. A lot of the people who want to stop this say guns aren't the problem. I'm like, yes, they are. They always push the Second Amendment. And I'm like, it says "a well-regulated militia." "Well-regulated" is right in there, along with "right to bear arms." And that seems to escape them.
Frank Smythe was really interesting. He's written a history of the NRA. The NRA is collapsing even as gun ownership is surging. The idea of being able to own a weapon has gotten traction. That's what he talked about — you don't need the NRA anymore. It's deeply embedded in a much different way than it was before. People feeling like they don't trust the government. Many people believe there's a war coming and they need to be armed.
Then there's the complex problem of people feeling isolated and having accessibility to these automatic, semi-automatic, and automatic weapons. It's interesting because my son Alex and I talked a lot about it, and my brother who's visiting me. We were talking about gun issues and I was like, nobody gets to have a tank or some of the weapons they're using in Ukraine right now in an actual war. Nobody would say, yes, you have a right to a tank. There are regulations. But for some reason, people have become so unable to compromise on these things that it's disturbing. There seems to be no solution, even though most people want sensible gun regulation.
Scott Galloway
It calls on a number of things that ail our society. One, we have full minority rule now. Our government and our gun laws are not in step with NRA members. The majority of NRA members support some form of background checks. The NRA no longer represents gun owners. We have minority rule. Our government and our laws around this do not represent the will of the people.
I also think it calls on — 98% of mass shooters are men. The average age of a school shooter is 18. The number of kids being raised in single-parent households has doubled. I'm in no way disparaging single mothers. What I'm saying is, you look at this kid. He had a mother who struggled with drugs. He was no longer living in a household with his biological parents. He had been bullied. None of these shooters are on the yearbook committee or the lacrosse team.
I think it starts at a very early age. These kids suffer from very deep psychological trauma. Then they want to get their status back, and they see this as a means of getting their status back. They're inspired a lot of times by things they see on social media. And then they have access to a weapon of war. So it's gun control. But I also think — and I'm going on Smerconish on Saturday, and I've been trying to do a lot of research around this.
My initial thing was, okay, specifically households with a kid with no male role models, no attachment, between the ages of 16 and 20, we should identify those households. And I started thinking, how can you profile? And I thought, that's going to do more harm than good.
Kara Swisher
Well, actually, studies don't show any relation between fatherlessness. Mike Lee of Utah talked about this — that shootings were caused by fatherlessness. Studies don't show that relationship. But one study by the University of Washington found a correlation between feelings of entitlement among white males and homicidal revenge. They found that straight white men struggled with issues of downward mobility and loss of status.
Scott Galloway
But there is a relationship between a lack of attachment. As little as being on a sports team, being involved in after-school activities — Boy Scout membership has been cut in half. These kids usually come from households where there's a lack of parental involvement. There's economic strain. And there's usually along the way some really traumatic psychological event or shaming.
I was seen as having an economic deficit when I was a 17-year-old boy. And the government stepped in and said, we're going to give you a Pell Grant. We're going to help close the delta of your economic disadvantage. I think that we need something that says we need to close the gap for young people, specifically boys, who are not attaching to anything. I think we should use, like the Jed Foundation does, the infrastructure in place of high schools and schools to help.
I'm not saying profile people. The last thing you want to do is profile someone as a possible shooter. Because you could go down the checklist and 99% are not going to run into this sort of problem. But I do think it's time — just as we said it doesn't make sense to not give women the same opportunities men have in college, just as we said people of color who have suffered injustice need some affirmative action — I think it is time to provide resources through schools that say young people, specifically boys who are not attaching to anything, need more resources, more counseling, and more opportunities to attach.
The commonality across all of these individuals is a lack of attachment. They all cry for help. This kid posted to Facebook three times.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, yeah. And often schools know this. Although, there's so many of those. How do you know which one is which?
Scott Galloway
Interestingly, mass shootings aren't even the biggest gun problem in the U.S. A majority of U.S. gun deaths are suicides. Individual guns, murder, numbers of mass shootings.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. And this touched our own team this week. Over the weekend in New York, a gunman in the subway shot and killed another passenger at random. The brother of our producer, Evan, happened to be in the car where it happened, and he spent the rest of the ride preparing to die along with other passengers. Thankfully, they all made it off the train unharmed. But this is rage playing out in a really dangerous way for everybody else.
What would be nice is some compromise and acknowledgement. It immediately moved to politics everywhere it went. And it really shouldn't, because most Americans want a solution here. I thought Biden articulated it best in that regard, although he's got to take a lot of stuff. When I was interviewing these guys, there's nothing he can do from an executive order point of view. And you have Texas just putting less and less restrictions on guns. Bring a gun to your kid's birthday party is kind of the way I look at it.
One of the hard parts — of course, social media was brought into it. Governor Abbott tried to shift the narrative over to social media. In this case, this guy just put photos of guns on Instagram, which they can do. Lots of people do that. You can't take those down. But he did Facebook private messaging, which Abbott tried to pretend was public, which was heinous on his part. I've never defended Facebook before. I was like, screw you. I don't think Facebook is liable here.
Scott Galloway
No, not at all.
Kara Swisher
There is AI here that is being utilized, including by this school district, to look for potential violence in advance using AI. And that's also controversial. These private messages were encrypted, probably, if he was doing them on WhatsApp. Obviously, they're moving towards encryption. So in this case, it's not the fault of social media. And sometimes it is. It's one of the many things that also makes people isolated.
Also, there were rumors. Like this guy was — there was a ridiculous rumor he was trans and sort of tried to attack trans people. That was really depraved.
Scott Galloway
Heinous, depraved.
Kara Swisher
It was representative of Paul Gosar who spread the false claim that the Texas shooter was a transgender woman. It's just ridiculous. It was just the worst of humanity, honestly.
So anyway, there's a lot of blame to go around and there's a lot of solutions that need to happen here. It's just disheartening on every level with the spate of news that is so hard for kids. From monkeypox, which is quite dangerous from what I understand, to the war in Ukraine, to COVID. Our kids are under a lot of stress. And they live in these isolated digital environments so much more than they used to.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. Again, though, a lot of countries are dealing with that stress. A lot of countries — we don't have a monopoly on mental illness. We don't have a monopoly on kids in single-parent households, although we are number one. We do have a monopoly on that cocktail, and we pour kerosene on it with access to weapons of war. It's just so ridiculous.
If you're an 18-year-old woman that wants an abortion, you have to notify your parents. You have to have a 48-hour waiting period. You have to watch a bunch of educational videos. You can buy an AR-15 easier than a pack of cigarettes in some states.
Kara Swisher
Which this young man did. And the ammunition numbers — everyone is buying. I have to tell you, when Louie and I went into a store where we were visiting Dollywood, of all places — it was a big giant gun store, but it also sold knives. He wanted a camping knife for a trip. I have never seen such manic buying of ammunition in my life. I was terrified. They were just loading up their carts with ammunition. I was like, got enough there?
Scott Galloway
Well, you never know.
Kara Swisher
I'm like, yeah, you kind of do. You kind of know. It was as if — it was a mill.
Scott Galloway
That's an image. Kara Swisher in a gun shop telling people they have too much ammunition.
Kara Swisher
I didn't know what to say. It was crazy. But they were born of true fear. And that's the problem, which is also amplified on social media, of course.
Anyway, just a terrible week all around. We had a school event and they were saying a moment of silence. And just like Steve Kerr said, I almost got up and said, no, let's not have any moments of silence. Let's have moments of noise, like constant noise. Thoughts and prayers? No. I'm going to scream all the time. I urge everyone to listen to Steve Kerr's speech. I know speeches are a dime a dozen, but he's 100% right.
All right, let's get to some tech news. The value of Snap Inc. stock is disappearing. On Tuesday, Snap warned that the macro environment has deteriorated further and faster than we anticipated. That spooked investors, which sent the stock spiraling more than 40%. Other digital advertising giants were hit too. Twitter, Meta, Google all got moderate dings below 10%. Pinterest plunged more than 20% but rebounded slightly. There's a rebound going on today, I think, a little bit.
Snap revenue is pretty small compared to Google or Facebook. It had been doing very well, actually. It sort of survived a lot of the problems. The macro trends they're referring to — inflation and decreased ad spending in Ukraine. What are your thoughts on this? Losing ground to TikTok?
Scott Galloway
I don't think they are. I think they were doing quite well, actually.
Kara Swisher
Apple's app tracking transparency.
Scott Galloway
Well, it's sort of a perfect storm. What's wild about this is how fast things have reverted. Just a couple months ago, we were talking about how Snap was defying gravity and just killing it. Now it looks as if between $5 a gallon gasoline, inflation, insecurity about war in Ukraine, consumer sentiment plummeting — all of a sudden they're reading the tea leaves and going, ad spending is about to drop substantially. In addition, growth companies — interest rates kill growth companies because their cash flows that are supposed to be huge in the future get discounted back and are worth less, but the money they need to grow is more expensive. So it just hits them especially hard.
But you mentioned it. I think the thing the media is missing here — and I spent a lot of time looking at this company, and I don't think people really understand what an impact it's having — is in fact TikTok. We spend 9.6 billion minutes a year watching Netflix. You think about Netflix, so dominant, how much time? We're at 22 billion with TikTok. I'm not sure — is it 22 billion or 22 trillion? I might have my numbers wrong. I think that represents 1% of all attention globally of all humans. Every day, more and more people spend more time on TikTok and less time doing anything else.
Kara Swisher
Right.
Scott Galloway
It represents — I always go to these second-order effects. The magic and the mystery and the danger of TikTok is, if you pull up Spotify, you start making decisions. Do I want to listen to Tom Petty or 80s music? When you pull up Netflix, supposedly households in America spend between 10 and 20 minutes a day deciding what to watch. I do that. I watch all their trailers. Here's the thing about TikTok that's so unique: the only decision you make is to tap the app. And then there are no decisions. It's like being in an opium den. The only decision you make is to inject the heroin, and then boom, no more decisions. It's wonderful. You just lay on your side and all decisions are made for you. You look up two hours later and you're still going.
Kara Swisher
Right. It's entertainment. It's not communication.
Scott Galloway
Snapchat is still — watching my teens use it — primarily communications. But you have to make decisions. You have to be actively involved. Or I'm going to use a filter. Or I'm going to snap my friend Santi. TikTok, no decisions. And the content keeps getting better and better. So I think all of this — whether it's Meta, Netflix, Snap — you just aren't seeing it because it's so big.
Kara Swisher
I think what we're going to find here — also, it's just crazy. They don't have a public stock. They don't have to report publicly. I think they're sandbagging their metrics. I think they're actually talking them down. I think all the obvious things — a real slowing of consumer spending, an anticipation of slowing advertising revenue, higher interest rates. But I think the atmospherics here are just as Amazon has been taking the oxygen out of the room for the last 20 years from all retailers. Everything everywhere has gotten harder for every retailer because of Amazon. I think the same thing is happening to the entire media landscape because of TikTok.
Interesting. I get complaints. I was on the receiving end of several different companies about TikTok — about them not having to reveal things, not being subject to regulation, being able to buy things they can't do. I think Snapchat still has a great product and people like it. I think they just missed the TikTok moment. They kind of discovered that idea. But no one really — Facebook has tried. Nobody — everyone was able to copy Instagram, right? Or Snapchat was able to copy Instagram. But no one anticipated this entertainment. It's entertainment. And they had pieces of it. Snapchat definitely had pieces of it, but it just didn't become something you had to stare at for hours a day. You're right.
We'll see what happens there. [Snap CEO Evan] Spiegel is a very good product person, and he's been down a difficult road before with a redo that didn't work out a couple of years ago. So we'll see.
Scott Galloway
Look at Pinterest, Snap, and Twitter, Kara. Just one more moment. I've always said that I think Google and Facebook, and now TikTok quite frankly, let Pinterest, Snap, and Twitter purposely stay in business because they want to pretend they have competition. Do you realize — Pinterest, Twitter, and Snap — I believe they get in a room and go, no, no, leave them alone, let them have their little thing here. I think Google or YouTube or Meta could come up with a Pinterest killer in about three months. And they've tried to do it. Facebook has tried to do it with Snap.
Pinterest, Twitter, and Snap are all trading at or below their IPO price. So essentially we're moving to — and then you have the big gorilla in the room, which was Meta. And now we have the disruptor. But these other companies — think about it. If you had invested in the IPOs of these companies, you'd think, oh my, I did really well. No, you didn't. You're flat. You would have been better off investing in Ford.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, that is true.
Scott Galloway
It's going to be interesting to see if they get bought. Some people think Snap is going to get bought by Microsoft or Apple, if Apple could. There's a lot of talk out there about buying all these companies. Including Twitter, still on the Elon train. We'll see where it goes.
Kara Swisher
I think there's a lot more going on there. We'll see. All of them are on the purchase train, unfortunately for them. Snap is a very good product. It is. And so is Pinterest, by the way. They have a lot of internal problems, management and stuff like that, but certainly a good product.
Anyway, Scott, let's go on a quick break and we come back. Payment companies could use a little cash too. We'll talk to Judd Apatow, one of my favorite filmmakers, about George Carlin and Free Speech. He's done a terrific documentary on it. I really enjoyed it with my family the other night. And we'll talk about that.
Break with ads
Scott, we're back. Companies that handle payments seem a little strapped for cash. PayPal is preparing to cut more than 300 jobs in Ireland. The company said the cuts aren't related to any specific economic conditions, but we do not believe it's the opportunity. Meanwhile, buy now, pay later company Klarna has laid off 10% of its global workforce, around 700 people. Klarna's CEO informed employees of layoffs via pre-recorded video message, in which he cited inflation, the war in Ukraine, and likely recession. Among other things, Klarna's trotting out the usual suspects. PayPal says no reason, nothing to see here. What's going on?
Even as people go out more, shouldn't online payments still be a good business? No one's expecting retail to come soaring back, but there is a lot of demand. Dining is up. PayPal has a little bit of coverage in retail anyway, though. Venmo and its PayPal service — I use it four times a week at least. So what do you think?
Scott Galloway
So I wrote an article for New York Magazine about buy now, pay later. Let me step back. I do think there's something unhealthy going on amongst the younger generation. You have said this. And I call it loosely the pornification of everything.
Kara Swisher
Oh, OK. Well, I haven't heard that one, but go ahead. Keep going.
Scott Galloway
When I talk to young men, you've got to reduce your consumption of porn because not only does it create unreasonable expectations around relationships and sex, but it takes away your motivation to actually log in the effort to go out and meet people and have actual sex. People also want to trade on Robinhood thinking that — oh, it's hard to invest over the long term and spend less than you save and invest over the long term. That's hard. That's not fun. But I see screenshots of people buying meme stocks who — by the way, all the gains from the meme trade are now gone. All of those people have given back all of the money. But I want to pretend I'm investing and being responsible.
And then you have the pornification of credit, where I can pretend — and there's this veneer — that somehow it's responsible. I'm exiting the credit card irresponsible generation, and I'm moving into something more responsible called the debit generation. That is bullshit. This is debt.
My other personal experience with this: I was on the board of a specialty retailer, and two and a half years ago, we tried this, and we were blown away by the numbers. We found a certain demographic, specifically young people, when they come up to the cash register, increased their basket size when they were offered immediate credit through Buy Now Pay Later of 30% to 50%. What causes basket size? It's not finding the stuff you like. That's not the limiting factor. They were finding a lot of stuff they liked. The limiting factor was they felt like they didn't have the money. And guess what? They don't. We've had a record increase in credit.
Now, let's talk about Klarna. They lost $700 — I believe $40 million. And two-thirds of that loss was a function of credit defaults. In some cases, half of the kids who have taken out BNPL loans are missing payments. This is the point of — again, I don't need to delay gratification. I can buy it now. I can have that sweater. And this entire bullshit marketing veneer that somehow I'm being responsible. I'm investing, Kara. I'm not gambling. I'm investing. Oh, I'm not borrowing. I'm not going into credit card debt. I'm doing debit, which is more responsible. Buy now, pay later is a train wreck for a younger generation.
Here's the thing. When people mortgage their house to invest in Dogecoin or Solana, that has knock-on effects. When a kid does not develop the discipline to save and invest and he starts losing money day trading and has emotional and mental stress, there is collateral damage. And to think there isn't going to be shrapnel and collateral damage from buy now, pay later is naive.
Kara Swisher
Let me ask you, what's happening with these companies cutting? Is it they're just using it as an opportunity to cut, or that there are defaults going on here? What do you imagine?
By the way, Apple has started rolling out iPhone to iPhone payments in the stores this week. That's interesting.
Scott Galloway
Well, payments is a different thing. I think payments offer utility. I don't think this is utility. I think this is creating a veneer that makes it easier. I mean, we have the pornification of student debt.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
So why is PayPal cutting? What is going on? Are they just expanding too much?
Kara Swisher
I think in the case of someone like PayPal, it's an amazing company, but they just grew their SG&A faster than their revenues. And they're going to need to cut. But great companies from Microsoft to Google have gone through eras of layoffs where the market slows down. Amazon is going to have to start laying off people. Amazon overhired. My company overhired. That's not what I'd call a cyclical but not a structural issue.
Scott Galloway
I think the structural issue here is that we've decided you can borrow $28,000 to go to the Joey Bag of Donuts beauty school because guess what? The debt might be forgiven. So why delay the gratification of feeling like I'm doing something for myself? I'll take out student debt. And the universities love it because they cash your check and they're not on the hook for paying it back. You are. But it's this notion where we live in a society that's training our youth that they don't need to delay gratification. They can get that dope ahead. Oh, and they're not trading, they're investing. They're not getting into debt. They're bettering themselves through education. Oh, they're not issuing credit card debt. They're going to debit generation.
Kara Swisher
One of the things that's interesting is that there have been declines, like in crypto, where a lot of people were playing, a lot of young people were playing that game, where they've gotten hit. Although, interestingly, Martin Shkreli got out of prison on an early release, and he's all in on crypto. He's planning to move into NFT, drop two. Adam Neumann is back with a new startup that sells blockchain-based carbon credits. I thought you might have a point of view here. And Jack Dorsey stepped down from the board of Twitter on Wednesday. Perhaps he'll spend more time in his payments company, Block, and also, of course, crypto. So, even as those went down, and this was part of the decline of people playing, not just meme stocks, but in crypto, these guys are doubling down. Do you have any advice for Martin or Adam, given the decimation?
Scott Galloway
All I can think about is who's going to play me in the next miniseries around whatever happens here with Adam. Blockchain-based carbon credits. I thought about this and I'm like, do we even want to bring this up? I'm not even sure I want to give this guy any more oxygen. But the thing that shocked me about it is the investors. I'm really shocked that Andreessen Horowitz wanted to get involved with Adam Neumann.
Kara Swisher
I would have thought... I was shocked that tier one investors are in this thing with him.
Scott Galloway
Honestly, if they thought they could make money, these people would hug Genghis Khan.
Kara Swisher
Sorry, I just don't... I'm not surprised at all.
Scott Galloway
Really? And there's some... Newman, some of his ideas have been good. It just was... I don't know.
Kara Swisher
I just think they would... if they think they can make money, they would run over their mothers.
Scott Galloway
Hugging Genghis Khan? I think that's a little unfair. I prefer that they would fuck their sister for a nickel. I think that's more accurate.
Kara Swisher
Okay, on that note.
Scott Galloway
Sorry.
Kara Swisher
Oh, good God. Okay, all right. Is that too much?
Scott Galloway
That was too much.
Kara Swisher
That is your comment on that. Adam, good luck.
Scott Galloway
Adam, good luck. We'll see how this works out for you.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, let's bring in our friend of Pivot. We're very thrilled to have writer, director, and producer Judd Apatow. Judd is the producer behind some of the biggest comedies of the last 20 years, including *Knocked Up*, *Superbad*, and this year's *The Bubble*, as well as beloved shows like *Girls* and *Freaks and Geeks*. His new documentary, *George Carlin's American Dream*, traces the life and career of that legendary comic. I'm a huge fan of his. And this new book, Judd's new book, *Sicker in the Head*, features interviews with some of the most exciting names in comedy. Welcome, Judd.
Judd Apatow
Great to be here. Finally here.
Kara Swisher
Finally.
Judd Apatow
Ben Stiller got in before you.
Kara Swisher
Oh, brutal. What a thrill.
Judd Apatow
You're welcome, Judd. You're welcome.
Kara Swisher
So one of the things I want to ask you is, I want to go right into George Carlin in a second, but one of the things you wrote, had in *The Bubble*, I'd like you to comment on. You depict the difficulties of filmmaking during the pandemic. So talk a little bit about coming out of the pandemic has changed the way you do your business. I think people are very interested in that.
Judd Apatow
Well, in the world of comedy, I think people are wondering, will you leave the house? Will they leave the house to go to the movies? What does it take to get you off of your couch? And hold on, there's a cat. This was your worst fear. I must release this cat. Hold on.
Kara Swisher
We love a cat.
Judd Apatow
Pumpkin, please. You're ruining everything.
Kara Swisher
A big break.
Judd Apatow
Pumpkin?
Kara Swisher
Pumpkin. His cat is named Pumpkin.
Judd Apatow
There's a cat named Pumpkin. I have four cats.
Kara Swisher
Dude, it's a good thing you're married.
Judd Apatow
I have a cat named Pumpkin.
Kara Swisher
Pumpkin. Cat lady. Cat lady Judd Apatow.
Judd Apatow
But I think before the pandemic, people were trying to figure out if people would go to the movies if there weren't special effects and superheroes. What human stories will make you leave your house and not watch it on streaming? And then the pandemic set this habit, which is everything comes to my house. But that being said, we were testing this movie we made with Billy Eichner called *Bros*, which comes out in September. And it's a...
Kara Swisher
It looks fantastic.
Judd Apatow
It really came out great. It's a gay romantic comedy. We tested it with 300 people in New York and LA and Chicago. People loved being in the theater together. And it got a giant reaction, no different than *Knocked Up* or *Trainwreck* or anything we've done. So I'm hopeful that if you have something great, people will go. If it's mediocre, they won't go. And I think in the old days, if it was mediocre, maybe sometimes they would go. And that's probably what's dropped out.
Kara Swisher
Ted Sarandos, the CEO of Netflix, said he thought the middle movies would just go right to streaming right away. And the blockbusters like *Top Gun 2*, for example, is coming out today, would have a better chance to make the money. And that's where all the money's going, whether they're IMAX. But you think if it's a good movie, especially a comedy, it still has that chance of sustaining in the theater longer than... I mean, 45 days is the most that exclusive theatrical runs are getting right now.
Judd Apatow
I don't know if anyone has proven that if you make a great comedy, it will bomb in the theater these days. It just hasn't happened yet. So that's going to be the real test, because every movie I know that's *There's Something About Mary*-level quality, they always do well. And maybe in the old days you might have went to the best one available, and if there was something that was okay, you might go. And maybe those are going to have a problem. But I think the killers should probably still do great.
Kara Swisher
Okay. So I'm going to go into the, and Scott will ask the question in a second, but your new documentary looks at the career of George Carlin, who is getting a real renaissance, at least online on Twitter. People are replaying a lot of his amazing bits. In your new book, you talked a lot of younger comics like Pete Davidson. So what was the reason you did this? And was it to show younger comics, which they take from George Carlin? Or why do you think he's undergoing such a real renaissance in a lot of ways?
Judd Apatow
Well, I was interested just because I like organizing people's histories and their lives, and especially the important people that meant a lot to me. I think he made a lot of people go into comedy because we all listened to him when we were 10 years old, when we weren't allowed to curse, when we didn't know how to challenge authority or be critical thinkers. And just by listening to him, it made you discover how to be funny and how to look at the world. And he's having this resurgence because he was a big picture comedian. He didn't do a lot of material on what happened that day. He would talk about the idea of the abortion issue, the idea of gun control or money in politics. And so all of those bits, they don't age because they are philosophical. And when things come up, he has the best bit. There's not another comedian that has bits that go around. We're not saying George Carlin's bits are going viral, and so are blank, blank, blank. There's no other person that has material that's that strong. And remains pertinent to the day.
Kara Swisher
I mean, I know one was about not punching down around the Dave Chappelle controversy. A lot of it was very kind, even though he was also very tough as a comic.
Judd Apatow
Well, he was suspicious of power. And a free speech advocate.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, he was suspicious of power. He was suspicious of the government. He was certainly suspicious of financial interests controlling the government and the media.
Judd Apatow
And I think at the time when he talked about it, a lot of people were like, wow, he's really getting dark. And I'm sure there were people who weren't into it at all. And he was saying, like, the game is rigged and they want us fighting each other so they could run off with the money. They're against street crime so that people can get away with white collar crime. And I don't know if people took him seriously enough. And now what seemed really dark, you look at it and you go, maybe it wasn't dark enough.
Scott Galloway
Judd, good to see you. So the thing that a lot of the legends, whether it was Lenny Bruce or George Carlin or Richard Pryor, have in common was that they offended people at the time. They were fearless. And quite frankly, at that moment, they were offensive. And now my favorite comedian is Michelle Wolf. She was offensive at the White House Correspondents' Dinner, and it's really hurt her career. Is there still room for people to be provocative and not run the risk of being sanctioned and basically being driven out of the business and having their career taken from them?
Judd Apatow
I think that this is part of the art of comedy. Can you make your point while understanding the culture of the moment, the sensitivities of the moment? Our friend Colin Quinn always says, you can say whatever you want, you just have to mean it and you have to stand behind it. Michelle Wolf was very upset because she saw what was happening in the country and she was trying to sound the alarm. So at times like this moment, when we see what's happening with gun safety issues right now, the comedians who are furious, sometimes there's a big blowback. I've noticed there's a lot of people who, when they start saying they're for a woman's right to choose, you feel certain right-wing forces come and get them. This isn't organic. There's an organized attack on people who speak out on certain issues. It does take a lot of courage to put yourself out there.
Kara Swisher
Well, speaking of that, let's play a clip of George Carlin talking about abortion.
Clip plays: George Carlin: "Pro-life conservatives are obsessed with the fetus from conception to nine months. After that, they don't want to know about you. They don't want to hear from you. No, nothing. No neonatal care, no daycare, no head start, no school lunch, no food stamps, no welfare, no nothing. If you're pre-born, you're fine. If you're preschool, you're fucked. You're fucked."
Wonderful clip. I mean, and by the way, today, the same thing. Someone was tweeting, what comic was, they care more about the Second Amendment than second graders and the safety. And I think a reporter asked this of the governor, same thing. This was, at the time, quite... he got blowback, but not in the same organized way. Is there any way to... what would happen to him today, do you imagine?
Judd Apatow
I think it was brilliant. And he found a way to say what he needed to say. And I think that you can do it. And we see, you know, *South Park* or certain people that are very outspoken. They find a way to do it. And that's also the job of the comedian is to slip through. In every era, there were rules, there were limitations, and you were trying to find a way to get through. And I doubt he would hold back at all. He certainly didn't hold back then. He had 14 specials talking about these things.
Kara Swisher
Can I ask you a particular question? One of the things you talk about, hold back, that was the theme of the first show, your first show in this documentary. When he was with the suits and the haircut. It was so shocking to see that, including Richard Pryor, right? And those little turtlenecks. He was... that was... I was like, oh my God. And they had essentially denuded them. I don't know what else to say, but when they were on with John Davidson, it was painful. They were sort of on this happy smiley show. Talk about that shift of him, to the... it was persona, it was... you could see it by the long hair, but it was something else that happened to him where he shifted and broke free in a lot of ways.
Judd Apatow
Well, early in his career, he was in a comedy team with Jack Burns, who was later in Burns and Schreiber. And they were doing some political things and he was doing some political things early in his career. And then I think he got a lot of jobs. And if you get a contract with Merv Griffin or the Dean Martin Show, whatever the variety outlet is, they want you to do a lot of sets and they don't want you to make people upset and they don't want you to make the advertisers upset. And you find yourself watering it down. And you're doing that also to get live jobs, trying to sell tickets. And then at some point, he started speaking out against Vietnam.
He started using language that you're not allowed to use. He got fired from the Playboy Club in Wisconsin. You would think that Hugh Hefner would be a free speech person, but he wasn't. He fired him. And he got sick of it. And he got fired from a job at the Frontier Hotel in Vegas. He was making $12,000 a week as an opening act. So imagine what he gave up. He was really finally doing well. And then he went back to do like the Gaslight in the Village. What are they paying him for a spot? $25, $50? He started at square one because he wanted to be authentically himself and to say whatever the hell he wanted to say.
Scott Galloway
So we had a similar conversation when you came on the Pivot podcast, Judd. But just to push back or challenge you a bit, we talked about *The King of Staten Island*. So 120-minute movie. I wonder if people such as yourself and myself to a certain extent were nostalgic for the old channels of distribution. We use terms like collective and community to talk about going into movie theaters. And you just said any good comedy is still successful. My sense is *The King of Staten Island* would have been much more successful had you taken 240 minutes and chopped it up into six things and put it on a streaming video platform. That we're nostalgic for the old channel distribution, but the way to create more value and more impact and more reach and more economic value is through this new format. And that is streaming that's more episodic, lets the characters marinate, lets people talk about it. Have you given any thought? One, do you agree with that? And two, have you given any thought to taking more of your creative efforts to streaming or episodic as opposed to the 100-minute movie?
Judd Apatow
Well, I mean, I think every project is different, and that's what we're all trying to figure out. Some of it also is do you care? Do you care to max that out? The most important thing you're trying to do as an artist is just get it made. Can I get *The King of Staten Island* made? So Universal says, let's do it in the theater. Fantastic. That's how we do it. There's a pandemic. And then they say, do you want to sell it as a digital download? Let's try that as an experiment. And Pete Davidson was like, hey, everybody's suffering. I just want them to see the movie. He didn't care at all about back end or profits.
He was like, we have something that makes people happy that we're proud of. Let's get that to them. But when I meet with somebody and they have an idea, like Billy Eichner, we have that conversation. Do we want to be a streamer? Do we want to be in a theater? Do we think we can succeed in a theater in this environment? Do we want to take that risk? And each time we have that moment, like, okay, let's go for the theater. Let's see if we can show people that a great comedy like this that's groundbreaking can work. But other times people come to me, if Pete Holmes says I want to do a show about my life as a comedian in New York, then that becomes an HBO series.
So I'm not thinking too much about the max out. I'm just thinking, I'd like a lot of people to see it and enjoy it. I'd like it to survive. And it changes every day. We did *The Bubble* for Netflix. They needed content during the pandemic. We found a safe way to shoot and do something satirical about this strange, horrifying moment. And that was really fun to get it on there. But yes, we didn't get to see it in the theater. But it was kind of built for the house. It was built for you to be sitting home eating ice cream in bed, giggling the way you giggle in a *Simpsons* episode. You have to know what you're trying to do it for, who you're trying to do it for at the start, I think.
Kara Swisher
Well, speaking of that, you have Apple computers sort of picking the very feel-good kind of tone movies, whether it's *Coda* or others. Do you feel that's shifted with the tech companies coming in as there's not an ability? One of the big themes of this Carlin documentary and your book is about free speech, like what you can say and what you can't say. Is that shifting in Hollywood or do you feel that there was a lot of controversy about Dave Chappelle? There's a lot of controversy. Ricky Gervais is the same thing around trans issues. People think they're punching down. Has that changed? Do you feel the need to be more safe to be successful? Because this is the opposite of what Carlin did in a lot of ways. Where does that stand with this idea of free speech? Because you've got Elon Musk is the one pushing for free speech, maybe. Who knows what he's actually saying. How do you look at that? Because that's sort of the province of comedy is free speech.
Judd Apatow
Well, I don't think that he's interested in free speech. I think he's interested in a place that allows him to retain a tax break and a world that supports that. He's very quick to say, I'm a Republican and throw the LGBTQ community under the bus. And what else is he throwing under the bus? The idea of gun safety, the idea of civil rights, the idea of voting rights. What is it for? Is it just for a tax break? And so that's the sad part about that. And that's what George Carlin was talking about, that a lot of people, it's just about them. They're not looking out for you. They're not looking out for other people.
And when you talk about streamers and their decisions, what a lot of people predicted and you feel it happening is that they would become network television. Because at the end of the day, the things that do the best are often the simplest things, the most base things. And so what was cool about streaming in the beginning was these huge artistic swings and that you would get something that you wouldn't get anywhere else. But then when you have to get more and more subscribers, you are going to dumb yourself down to a certain extent, not completely, because everyone wants awards and they want to look like they care about that.
But ultimately they want CSI and they want all those shows that people love. But it's very easy for all the streamers to just become the network.
Scott Galloway
I'm just really curious, Judd, something we talk a lot about. I'm just curious to get your synaptic response to TikTok. I am not on TikTok. I may be of the age where I go, that's the next technology where I leap off of it. But I have to say, when I talk to friends in the comedy world and comedians, their philosophy is, you have to be on it. No one is anywhere else but TikTok. So a lot of it with comedians is, can I sell tickets? Can I enlarge my visibility? And they're all saying, get over being like the older person and get on there, because that's where everybody is. Do you think it's entertainment?
Judd Apatow
I mean, I do. We do. Both of us do. And it's weird kind of entertainment. In my case, it's air fryer videos.
Kara Swisher
And in Scott's case, what is it, Scott? People getting adjusted and hot people lecturing me on social justice issues.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I haven't gone that deep into it.
Judd Apatow
My family is very specific. They want to see someone cuddling a cow. They want to see cats that sound like they're singing. They have a very gentle TikTok feed. They're not going into those other areas. But they're on it a lot and they love it. I'm weird. I like Twitter. I go on Twitter and I like to read articles. I read articles. I'm interested in everyone's point of view. I stopped tweeting. I mainly retweet because the amount of blowback you get is crazy. The amount of weird hate.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, you did. You had recently. You had a bunch recently.
Judd Apatow
Yeah, I just decided it's not worth it. Who are these people? And if I respond, like if someone says something ridiculous to me and they have 80 followers and I have a few million, if I respond, I'm really amplifying a cruel person or a nasty person. So then why would I respond? That's the dynamic of Twitter that doesn't work. When they say, where are all the people who had a lot of followers in any business? They all left because of that, that the engagement becomes so toxic that it's no fun. And in the beginning, there were tons of comedians on there and they were being funny and it was way lighter. But now pretty much anything I could say on any subject could get me a tweet storm in response that is so vile. And I don't think that it is a fixable aspect to it. So now I just go, oh, well, this is where all the great articles are from different places I like to read from. And I'm mainly looking at it for that. For consumption, for news consumption.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. So when you think... I have just one more question. When you think about comedy comics today, who is the closest to George Carlin from your perspective working today? And where is comedy going? Because it does feel like TikTok, these little tiny snackable things. And some of them are quite clever. Let me be clear. Some of them are fantastic. What happens to comedy at large? I know that's a big question, but you've been in the business for a long time. You've been in both the standup, you do standup stuff, you do movies. Who represents what Carlin represented today? And where is it going from your perspective?
Judd Apatow
Well, this is a lot of what the book *Sicker in the Head* is about because I tried to interview the new people. Like Ramy Youssef and Hasan Minhaj and Amber Ruffin, Bowen Yang. What is comedy to a new generation of people? And I think that there's a lot of people doing things in the spirit of George Carlin out there. But it's different because you can have a podcast. And if you have a podcast, it doesn't even matter if you get a network TV. That's what people are realizing. They need to create their own little space. They get their own fans. Those fans buy tickets to their shows. They'll watch their streaming things. Or a lot of people are just making their own specials with their own money. And they put them on YouTube. And they get paid for the ads. And they can have a completely different path to have all of the creative freedom that they want to have. And there's a lot of amazing people doing a lot of personal work, but it's not like the old days. George Carlin would never talk about his personal life. Modern comedy is all about opening up personally and having this very deep relationship with the audience and then going on tour every year.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, and that's...
Judd Apatow
That's what we do. We vomit up personal information.
Kara Swisher
I understand. I know of the dog's travels. I'm tracking it pretty closely.
Judd Apatow
Please don't.
Kara Swisher
But that... I think that is what comedy is right now. And then you have people like Stephen Colbert and John Oliver and Samantha Bee doing that George Carlin spirited comedy. And I think it's a great time. As much as people are so scared of political correctness or cancel culture, comedy is pretty amazing and people are selling out hockey arenas. It seems to be working out for most people.
Yeah. How would he do today, would you imagine? What would he be taking on?
Judd Apatow
What would he be taking on? I mean, sadly, it's all the same stuff. That's what's weird about the documentary. Every bit feels like you could have written it today. Still relevant. And that's what's sad. But he also blamed the people of the country. And he always said, garbage in, garbage out. If you have uneducated citizens, they're going to vote in people that are against their interests. That was his main point, that it's ultimately our responsibility to vote out people who don't want gun rights or all the rights that we're talking about. Because his main point was, we don't really have rights, we have privileges. We only have the rights that they want us to think we have, and the list is getting smaller.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, and he never punched down. So too much of comedy is punching down, I think.
Judd Apatow
Yeah. It feels like that, at least, which is the worst kind of comedy. I can't stand it.
Kara Swisher
But Scott, last question?
Scott Galloway
I thought of you the other night, Judd, because I'm watching *Euphoria*. And I recognized one of the actresses. And I thought, oh, wait, that's Judd's daughter. You talk about your family. I know your wife's an actress. I know at least one of your daughters is an actress. I don't know if the other is, but.
Judd Apatow
Yes, Iris is. She's in *The Bubble*.
Scott Galloway
My question for you is if you could have a family that's just as happy doing something else, do you enjoy being a show business family? Is it an industry? Is it fraught with peril? It just seemed... granted, I'm not nearly as talented. My observation of the entertainment industry is it's a dysfunctional, insecure place. And if one person is talented and can make a living, more power to them. But to have your wife and your kids in that business, if you could press reset and be as equally successful in something else, would you do that?
Judd Apatow
Well, not me because I like it. I just think you have to do it for the right reasons. I always say to my kids, you have to be passionate about what you're doing. You have to be proud of what you're putting into the world. And then it's fun. And then you can always feel good because you're trying to do good things that say good things. And hopefully you can work. Obviously, a lot of people don't work. So it is scary. There are periods when it doesn't go well. But if you're in it to be successful or make money, it is a nightmare. If you're in it to express yourself and be passionate and be an artist, then you can be very satisfied with your life and career, no matter what level of success you attain.
Kara Swisher
So what are you working on next? More, Judd. You don't produce enough.
Judd Apatow
I'm actually going to interview Bob Newhart this afternoon for another documentary project that we're working on.
Kara Swisher
On Bob Newhart?
Judd Apatow
Yes. And we're working on something with a comedian named Maria Bamford, who we love. And I'm writing and hopefully I'll direct a movie sometime in the next year. I'm writing *This Is 50*. Hopefully I'll get to do that.
Scott Galloway
I got to ask one more question. We talked about... we had someone on last week talking about creativity and this whole notion of flow.
Judd Apatow
Yes, I know him.
Scott Galloway
Is there a time of day, a context, muses, inspirations that puts you in flow? Is there a method to your madness?
Judd Apatow
Many years ago, I met the director Robert Rodriguez. And he said, I used to write at night. The kids would fall asleep and I would write at night. He goes, then I realized when I woke up in the morning, that's when I was most creative, when everyone was asleep. And so this idea of when does your mind relax? When does your critical voice shut up and allow you to do your thing?
It's something I'm obsessed with. And I have found that the second I wake up, I put a computer on my lap, I will have my funniest, most interesting ideas before the day has intruded, before I know what's on the news. That's my best.
Open space in the car. If I just turn on a voice note in the car, just drive around thinking about jokes or ideas. What I try to do is just to talk without stopping. If you say, "I'm going to talk for 20 minutes without stopping about what movies I might want to make," it'll mainly be garbage. But at some point, your unconscious will offer something up that you didn't know was there.
So I'm obsessed with flow states. I go on and watch all those TED Talks, and I think it works. It does work because the critical voice is the demon. You do have to get bored and comfortable with yourself and allow yourself to fail and just babble.
Kara Swisher
Well, on that note, Judd, you're such a... we're such a big fan. Babylon, Judd, Babylon. Babylon, Babylon, Babylon, Babylon. All right. The book is called *Sicker in the Head*. It's out this Sunday. Also, *George Carlin's American Dream*. I really highly recommend it. It's now streaming on HBO. And *The Bubble* is out on Netflix. Judd Apatow is everywhere.
And by the way, I'm so excited for anything with Bob Newhart. I love Bob Newhart. Undersung in so many ways.
Scott Galloway
Fantastic. Amazing. The best.
Kara Swisher
Thank you, Judd Apatow.
Judd Apatow
Thank you.
Kara Swisher
Thanks, Jen.
Ad break
All right, Scott, one more quick break. We'll be back for Wins and Fails.
Ad break
Okay, Scott, let's hear some wins and fails. What do you...
Scott Galloway
Our country to me right now is failing so miserably. This shooting is just another example of it.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I like it. It's not...
Scott Galloway
I think we all know what the fail is. We have a war between the wrong and the ineffective, and the bullets are winning. This doesn't happen anywhere else. I don't think there's anything new here. I hope we don't fall into the same trap we always do, becoming bereft or resigned to thinking we can't do something about this. I do think we can do something about this.
I'm also going to have a weird fail here. I'm a huge fan of Beto O'Rourke. I don't think what he did was appropriate. I feel as if we're coming apart and we have to demonstrate a certain level of decorum and civility. Even when there's a group of elected officials and law enforcement officials on stage, I don't agree with almost anything any of them say, but I don't think approaching the stage is the right thing to do and interrupting it.
Kara Swisher
Well, he was trying to get attention. And I think it was wrong. I just don't... I think you're adding to the problem.
Scott Galloway
Interestingly, that was the circular loop on Fox News. I only know this because my mother had no reaction to the shooting except for Beto O'Rourke, which I'm not even going to go into. But she was all over the Beto O'Rourke thing.
Kara Swisher
It seemed performative. It did. But at the same time, sometimes... I don't know. I don't know. I know he's running for governor. The speech he did later with reporters was very raw, very authentic, very outraged. I thought it was fantastic.
I don't like it when Marjorie Taylor Greene runs down the halls of Congress and starts banging on AOC's door and yelling profanities. I think everybody has an obligation to take the temperature down. And I don't like it when people go on stage and strike hosts. I think Beto got it wrong here because all that's going to happen is when the Democrats get together for a press conference, we're going to have people on the right start approaching the stage.
Scott Galloway
Anyways, I don't have a ton to say here, Kara. I wish I had something more thoughtful or insightful.
Kara Swisher
I think they're elected officials and they can take it. I'm sorry. In that way, it was not violent. It was not. It was just "you're repulsive." It doesn't help. It doesn't hurt. I'm against. I don't think it's fine. I can see that it probably didn't come off well for O'Rourke, for the people he was trying to reach. It was for the cameras.
But my fail is the following. American exceptionalism is a few things. We're the most innovative nation in the world. I still believe we're a generous nation that takes our role as global citizens seriously. But also what's exceptional about our country is this is the only place that this happens. It's the only place this happens. There are other places with a lot of guns. There are other places that have mentally ill youth. And this is the only place where we've now had more gun deaths. 1.4 million people have died in gun deaths. That's more than every combat fatality. That's more than COVID from gun deaths. When you start talking about American exceptionalism, this is what is really exceptional about our nation right now.
Yep. I would agree.
Scott Galloway
Anything else? Anything positive?
Kara Swisher
You know, I don't.
Scott Galloway
Because that's not a good exceptional.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, no, it's not.
Scott Galloway
That's my fail, American exceptionalism. I'm hoping next week we have a win where we start to see something actually resembling legislation.
You know who we need here? You know who the number one recipient of NRA funds is? Mitt Romney. And I think Senator Romney is a good man. I think he has a conscience.
Kara Swisher
That's a lot of money. He was so high compared to...
Scott Galloway
Almost more than everyone else combined.
Kara Swisher
Whoa.
Scott Galloway
And why? It's because the NRA is like, "This guy's perfect for us." Burr was number two. He's seen as reasonable. He's seen as having a conscience. He's seen as a family man. And he's pro-gun. What we need, the real win we need here, is for Senator Romney to come out and go, "Enough already. I've had a change of heart. And regardless of the amount of money and the favors I owe these folks, I am going to support legislation." The key to progress around really big issues is class traders. You have to have people who say...
Kara Swisher
A lot of money. I was shocked by that amount of money. He is key here. He is key here.
Scott Galloway
Anyways, what about you, Kara? Any wins or fails?
Kara Swisher
You know, it's interesting. News just came over that Apple is raising hourly pay for U.S. workers to $22, up 45% from 2018. Obviously, there's inflation issues and the unionization push. And apparently, there's a video of its head of retail telling employees that a union would make it harder for Apple to improve working conditions. That's just... I don't... people shouldn't be outraged by that. They're going to make their case, right?
But that's a win and a fail. I just feel like we need our legislators to do it, and then we don't have to have these... unionization should either happen or not. It should happen at these stores, but it's good that they raised the thing. It's bad that they're pushing against unionization. I understand why they're doing it. So it's sort of a win and a fail.
I think Twitter right now paying this $150 million to the FTC settling allegations about security and privacy of user data for six years between 2013 and 2019 is a real black eye for them, especially amid the Elon Musk situation. It'll probably give him a lot more power. It's another example he can push towards to say, "Look, that's a fail on their part."
I don't have really a win. My win was Apple, I guess. But still, they're doing it for their own capitalist reasons.
I'm trying to think of a positive thing. Oh, the new season of *Hacks* with Jean Smart.
Scott Galloway
Oh, you enjoyed that. I've heard it's good.
Kara Swisher
Oh, I love her. Love her. It's a new season. She just eats up the screen in the best of possible ways. That makes me happy.
Scott Galloway
I've been watching *Euphoria*. I feel like kind of a pervert.
Kara Swisher
Watch *Heartstopper*. Don't watch *Euphoria*. It's going to make you feel bad.
Scott Galloway
I don't know. It's like watching a music video with young hot people and the music's great and the visual stimulation. It's like, gosh, this is awesome.
Kara Swisher
No, don't do that to yourself. You need to watch my video of my brother putting Saul to sleep.
Scott Galloway
Is this D. Swish? Dr. Swisher?
Kara Swisher
Dr. Swish, yes. D. Swish is David, my other brother. But Jeffrey, yes. He put him to sleep with Vivaldi, actually, and Senegalese music. He's an anesthesiologist. He's good at putting people to bed. It's a very pleasurable video.
Scott Galloway
A cultural elite raising children. Here's Vivaldi. I mean, come on.
Kara Swisher
It was on YouTube. Anybody can have it.
Scott Galloway
I'm going to read you my favorite article from *The Atlantic*. "Hush, little woke child."
Kara Swisher
Oh, God.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, you live in the real world. All this music was free. You guys live in the real world. It would cost us nothing, and he put the kid to bed, and there was no propofol involved.
Kara Swisher
And he certainly has access to propofol. Don't ask him for it, by the way, Scott Galloway.
Scott Galloway
He's holding?
Kara Swisher
Do not ask my brother for drugs.
Scott Galloway
I'm actually looking forward to my colonoscopy because of that amazing propofol or whatever it's called.
Kara Swisher
All right. Jeff will do that for you.
Okay, Scott, that is the show. We'll be back on Tuesday with a special episode. Enjoy the holiday weekend, everybody. I don't know what you're doing. Scott, I'm going to visit with my brother, my dad's grave, and also my aunt, who is still living. We're going to see her in West Virginia. So get ready, West Virginia, for the Vivaldi crew.
Scott Galloway
There you go. Nice. What are you doing?
Kara Swisher
I'm headed to New York, and I'm going to take the boys to a play. *Moulin Rouge*, I think. Is that what we're doing? *Moulin Rouge*? I don't know. Is that appropriate?
Scott Galloway
Okay, all right.
Kara Swisher
I think it's really... It's about a prostitute, but okay.
Scott Galloway
Sex worker.
Kara Swisher
The sex workers. They're not prostitutes.
Scott Galloway
We're the prostitutes. I believe that's what it's about. Have you seen some of my readovers? I'm the prostitute.
Kara Swisher
Okay, fair. Fair point.
Scott Galloway
Okay, everybody. There's a lot more dignity in what they do than what I do. By the way, I will touch anyone's rocket for a horse or a sheep. I'll do it for a sheep.
Kara Swisher
Again.
Scott Galloway
I'll do it for a sheep. Speaking of sex workers, please read us out.
Kara Swisher
Today's show was produced by Lara Neiman, Evan Engel, and Taylor Griffin. Ernie Intertaught engineered this episode. Thanks also to Drew Burrows and Mia Silverio. Make sure you're subscribed to the show wherever you listen to podcasts. Thank you for listening to *Pivot* from New York Magazine, Vox Media. We'll be back later this week for another breakdown of all things tech and business.