Main Topic: The podcast episode covers various topics, including the protests in Los Angeles, the Trump-Elon breakup, the Warner Brothers' Discovery split, and the state of the media and politics.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Wins and Fails:
Ad Break - Multiple Advertisements
Ad 1 - Sierra AI: Sierra AI: AI agents are getting pretty impressive. You might not even realize you're listening to one right now. We work 24/7 to resolve customer inquiries. No hold music, no canned answers, no frustration. Visit sierra.ai to learn more.
Ad 2 - The Guardian: The Guardian: Not all journalism is the same. Take The Guardian. Our coverage has something unique: fierce independence. Nobody owns us or tells us what we can and can't say. So we're free to report the whole picture. We connect what's happening in Washington to the rest of the globe, expose corruption wherever we find it, and give fresh perspective on everything from wellness and soccer to culture, the climate and more. Read, watch and listen to The Guardian for free at theguardian.com.
Ad 3 - Thumbtack: Thumbtack: Avoiding your unfinished home projects because you're not sure where to start? Thumbtack knows homes, so you don't have to. Don't know the difference between matte paint finish and satin? Or what that clunking sound from your dryer is? With Thumbtack, you don't have to be a home pro. You just have to hire one. You can hire top-rated pros, see price estimates, and read reviews all on the app. Download today.
End of Ad Break
Kara Swisher
What do I think? I think if this ran a gayer, it'd be a Bravo reality show sponsored by Grindr.
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Cara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And I'm Scott Galloway.
Kara Swisher
Scott, we've got a lot to get to today, including the Trump-Elon breakup getting uglier, plus another breakup making headlines. Warner Brothers Discovery is splitting up. First, let's talk about what's happening on the ground in California. Governor Gavin Newsom says California will sue the Trump administration, challenging the president's recent order to federalize National Guard forces amid protests in Los Angeles over immigration raids. Newsom already asked the White House to rescind its deployment of 2,000 National Guard troops to LA, accusing Trump of manufacturing chaos and violence. Trump made the order over the weekend, invoking a used federal law.
Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth created more of a problem. He also got in the mix by suggesting active duty Marines could be sent in. Newsom called these comments deranged behavior. I would tend to agree. We're going to be talking to someone about what's happening, who is on the ground there right now. Let's start with that. It's a New York Times reporter, Livia Albeck-Ripka. Livia, welcome. Thanks for coming on. I know you're busy. We're recording this on Monday morning. You've been on the ground in LA reporting over the last few days. How are things looking right now?
Livia Albeck-Ripka
Well, yesterday when we left downtown Los Angeles, the police and other authorities appeared to have largely dispersed the crowds. I haven't been out yet this morning, so I can't say what's happening right now on the ground. But yesterday was a chaotic day.
Kara Swisher
So talk about what you mean by chaos. Now, President Trump described Los Angeles as "invaded and occupied by illegal aliens and criminals." That's a quote. And said, quote, "violent and insurrectious mobs are swarming." Now, I know a lot of people in Los Angeles, they say that's poppycock to me. I've gotten dozens and dozens of people who live there. I am not there. But does that align with what you're seeing? What are people getting right and wrong about what's happening?
Livia Albeck-Ripka
I can't really speak to what people are getting wrong about the protests, but I can tell you what I saw with my own eyes yesterday on the ground. I arrived at the detention center in downtown Los Angeles. It was fairly quiet. Then one person with a sign showed up. One person holding a Mexican flag arrived, and slowly a crowd began to grow. There was one protester calling the others, imploring the other protesters to remain peaceful. And then at one point, tear gas and projectiles were fired into the crowd. I did not see what instigated that. I, too, was trying to protect myself. So I can't speak to exactly what happened in that moment. But then after that, as the day wore on, the crowd grew and grew. There was another protest happening up at City Hall. That protest kind of converged with the one that was going on at the detention center. So at that point, there were thousands of people. The protesters eventually went down onto the Highway 101, took over the highway for some time. Traffic was stopped. And there were a lot of people there. So eventually, the authorities dispersed the crowd. And that's what I saw at the end of the night by the time we had gone home yesterday.
Kara Swisher
From what you can tell, what do the protesters, when you speak to them, want? What are they looking to do?
Livia Albeck-Ripka
Several people I spoke to yesterday said that they had been watching events unfold on TV, on the news, on social media over the last several days, and that they'd reached a personal breaking point where they felt they could no longer sit at home. One man I spoke to, his mother had immigrated from Colombia, and he's a physics professor who lives an hour and a half away. And he said, "I've got to get on the train. I'm going to Los Angeles today." And that was the story of several people who I spoke to, that they just felt that this was the only way they could have their voice heard and take a stand against what's going on. So people like a physics professor, just regular people who are not criminals. A mom and her teenage son, who, although she had safety concerns in bringing him to the protest, also felt that it was really important that her son understand the power of individuals and community when they come together. So that was her story. There are other people who aren't personally affected by this, but also are coming out in great numbers to protest the deportations and to protest the actions of the current administration.
Kara Swisher
What's your sense for the vibe right now? Do you get the sense the temperature is going up or going down?
Livia Albeck-Ripka
I think it's hard to say with protests. When you're there in the moment and it is intense and chaotic, it's unclear what is going to unfold the next day. And that's why we do our jobs.
Kara Swisher
All right. Great. Livia, thank you so much.
Scott Galloway
Thank you, Livia. Thank you so much, too.
Kara Swisher
So obviously, Livia is a reporter, so she can't characterize what's going on. But I think it's a shit show that Trump is creating on purpose, as many people do. He's creating tension in order to pick a fight. Essentially, this is what he's trying to do: create immigration actions that would cause a vote and would cause people to protest, and then trying to egg them on into worse activities. So let's talk a little bit more about that. I've called this a complete overreach by a desperate despot. Your thoughts?
Scott Galloway
Well, I've been called hysterical for a while now, comparing or drawing similarities between America right now and 1930s Germany. And you don't have to be Hitler to borrow methods and worst practices from his playbook. And that is, when tanks roll through cities, it doesn't feel like strength. It feels like a funeral for civil society. Germany in the 30s didn't collapse overnight. It slid into tyranny by normalizing soldiers where citizens used to stand. Early Nazi propaganda decided—and we're doing the same thing—that we have real problems overseas. Russia is still invading Europe. There are real significant issues around China.
Pakistan and India could eventually digress to a nuclear conflict. Iran is trying to spin up reactors. But if you look at—and again, I think this has so many echoes of 1930s Germany—early Nazi propaganda emphasized that Germany's problems were due to internal saboteurs: communists, Jews, immigrants. And today, if you look at this rhetoric, they're blaming immigrants, academics, protesters, journalists. It mirrors the same playbook here. When you have a government who turns its military force inward against journalists, migrants, or citizens who believe and are exercising the right to protest in a civil, peaceful manner and justice, you're not defending democracy.
You're rehearsing for something much darker. So it's not the protests themselves. This is another step towards normalizing an attempt to rebrand militarization as patriotism.
Kara Swisher
Right. So do you think it's working? Historian Ruth Ben-Ghiat wrote on Threads: fascists want to provoke violence so they can justify crackdowns and get some good footage to distort in state propaganda outlets for state propagandists like Fox News. And the media is ill-prepared to push back and say this is what it is. We just talked to a reporter; she can't say much, right? But it's obviously—you bring troops in and you create all kinds of people. There are rubberneckers, the people that show up. If you recall what happened around the church near the White House when people were protesting, Trump created chaos in order to say it was chaotic, which is sort of like fascism 101.
How do you assess how California is dealing with this? Obviously, Gavin Newsom has suddenly found his backbone and is pushing back. He said, "Come on and arrest me," because they were making threats to arrest Tom Homan, who is literally—it looks like the drunkle is running the show over there. But he said, "Arrest me then, but stand down." This obviously has to go to the Supreme Court in some fashion, which is problematic in and of itself. But when the state governors are asking them not to do this and have it under control or say they have it under control, how do you assess what's going on with California itself?
Scott Galloway
I actually think Governor Newsom comes out of this a winner, most likely, because I think what it's doing is setting up the next presidential election between Trump's appointee, J.D. Vance, and Governor Newsom. And I think so far, Governor Newsom has tried to stay forceful and dignified. I thought he was smart to say he's not trying to whip people into a frenzy; he's trying to dial it down. And he's basically taking on Tom Homan and saying, "Arrest me." I think he's handling this quite well. It feels like you're trying to fix a smoke alarm with a flamethrower. They're just looking for a reason.
They're trying to provoke someone into shooting someone in uniform so they can have an overreaction. In 1992, I came home from graduate school and I found armed National Guard on my corner. I lived in this very peaceful neighborhood in Westwood. On the corners, there were two what looked like boys, high school boys, in fatigues with M15s or assault rifles. That doesn't feel like safety. It feels like a breakdown in society. It makes you lose faith in your government and it forces you to choose a side. It's just very strange. More broadly, when I think about the role that presidents or past presidents have played, the biggest compliment you can ever receive is someone who asks you to play peacemaker and to de-escalate a situation.
That's when you know you've made it in business—when people ask you to mediate disputes between a board and its CEO. That feels really good. It makes me feel important. Typically, the president of the United States is deployed all over the world to help bring warring parties back from the brink of war and to de-escalate. So when you have a president who appears to be just manufacturing and escalating what could ultimately be—I want to be clear, I'm a bit of a catastrophist here—I think this is one piece of the chessboard to what is a civil war. When you have a government cosplaying authoritarianism that seems to have missed the first half of the last century and what happened in Europe, this is how it ends.
I don't think America ends with a bang. I think it ends with a thump. Next move: Newsom says, "We're sick of sending $80 billion to the federal government that you can deploy to red states that then you use to demonize us. So we're not paying our federal taxes." Or Texas says, "Governor Newsom is elected president. We're not certifying the election. We don't honor your federal elections." Before you know it, California becomes a tech economy doing trade with Asia. Texas and the South become an oil and gas economy. The East Coast becomes a financial services economy doing business with Europe.
The Midwest, a manufacturing economy with strong relationships with Canada. They maybe develop their own currencies. Governor Newsom tried to weaponize volunteers to create his own army. This is what they did in the Weimar government. Before you know it, we're like the European Union, but a disunion of states. I think this is another step to America breaking up.
Kara Swisher
That's the plot of Hunger Games, but go ahead.
Scott Galloway
Oh, really? I literally didn't—
Kara Swisher
I was like, "Huh, wait a minute. Who's Jennifer Lawrence? That's me." That's funny. I never saw the full series of Hunger Games, although I'm a big Donald Sutherland fan. I'm not a huge Jennifer Lawrence fan. But anyways, they break into districts. That's the story of Hunger Games.
Scott Galloway
Well, they break into districts and then the center tries to hold them. And it's a version of it. My point is, people think that the end of America would be some huge civil war. I think it could happen much more quietly than that.
Kara Swisher
Oh, interesting.
Scott Galloway
And that is what's being set up. There are going to be a number of states, I believe, who are going to economically sequester or refuse to honor the next results of the presidential election. I think that is what is being set up here.
Kara Swisher
I have a different thought. I think all these people are going to jail eventually.
Scott Galloway
When you say "all these people"?
Kara Swisher
The people that are creating this fake war. The fake war people. They're trying to wag the dog. So Tom Homan and—
Scott Galloway
Homan. I think they're going to be under investigation the rest of their lives.
Kara Swisher
But he'll get a full pardon from the—
Scott Galloway
I'm not saying I disagree with you, but let's play this out. All these people will get full pardons at the end of the Trump tenure. Do you think that could be pierced?
Kara Swisher
I think it can be pierced. I think there'll be a true—the further they go, the issue is they're so incompetent. They're so obviously incompetent in a lot of ways. You don't have to be competent, by the way, to create chaos and destruction. They're quite good at that too. But someone like Kristi Noem, Tom Homan, Marco Rubio has been dragged into this and has ruined his reputation forever, I suspect. I think they're all in a world of trouble the minute Donald Trump is out of the picture. You can't—I don't think citizens put up with this. I absolutely do not. I think I'm seeing more people getting more activated in good ways than ever before. It doesn't take much to crack down on people, but this is a big country and it's very hard to control. The more they try to control, the more they try to do this kind of nonsense, the more people see through it.
Scott Galloway
Absolutely.
Kara Swisher
Oddly enough, a lot of my relatives who are Trump people are like, "This is fucked up." And it's not the leftists they're saying are fucked up, which is usually their way to go. It's more, "He's crazy. This is nuts. This is ridiculous." So we'll see if other people buy into this. But I do think he exhausts his base and regular people begin to take back control. He can try. He's desperate. That's why I called it the complete overreach of a desperate despot. Every move he's making lately to me is both despotic, incompetent, and also insecure in a lot of ways.
Scott Galloway
But what you just outlined is my vision of how you would restore and heal America: moral clarity and effectively a Nuremberg trial where you said, "Okay, you knew this was a lie. You purposely tried to create violence and mayhem. You purposely tried to overrun our elections. You purposely committed fraud. You purposely leveraged our international sway to enrich your children." I love the idea of a stream of perp walks and moral clarity around this stuff, that America's laws have a long memory. I love that. That's a fantasy of mine. I dream of that at night. My fear, Kara, is that there are actually a lot of people who like what's going on right now.
Kara Swisher
I would push back. Hitler was real popular until he wasn't, wasn't he?
Scott Galloway
Real popular. Oh, he was popular up until the end, Kara.
Kara Swisher
That's right. That's correct. And he still is in a lot of ways, oddly enough.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but he was never tried. He killed himself because he knew the Red Army was circling.
Kara Swisher
Of course. I'm a long-view person. I think there's going to be a lot of damage in the interim. I think your scenario is perfectly possible. Absolutely. No question. But in my scenario, every single person who's behaved like Trump ends up badly. Whether it's Mussolini, Saddam Hussein, Gaddafi, the Ceausescus, it always ends with the same story. The people around these people—
Scott Galloway
Well, all these people were executed or killed themselves.
Kara Swisher
Well, I know. I think our country is slightly different. We let Nixon go off. We tend to be more forgiving in that regard. But it's the same version, a metaphorical version of that. And we'll see. He's an old man. So we'll see how long he lasts, right?
Scott Galloway
Right. But biology is undefeated. I mean, all joking aside, he did the same trip Biden did the other day. If you saw it, the same exact trip that Biden did on the stairs, going on the stairs. So I was just like, "Well, you people hold on, because he's all you got to these people." That's my feeling.
Kara Swisher
So to your point, I'd like to move to what Democrats should be doing. I don't understand why a Democrat hasn't forcefully—we're so obsessed with grabbing social virtue and taking the higher road. I don't understand why a Democrat hasn't announced for president and said, "On the order I'm passing, I'm getting congressional approval to arrest people who have engaged in fraud, to arrest people who have engaged in trading off our country's geopolitical power for personal enrichment. I'm arresting people who have fomented violence while using the military, while knowing that these actions were un-American, unconstitutional, and not needed. And here is the exact legislation I'm going to propose that will pierce any pardon." Why has no one stood up and said, "Hi, I'm a Democrat and I have actual fucking testicles"? What would they be saying? This would be the mother of all "lock her up." Can you imagine what they would be threatening?
Scott Galloway
What's really interesting is that Kamala Harris warned about troops in the streets. So did Hillary Clinton. Everything Hillary Clinton warned about, he did exactly. So I'm going to listen to the women in this case. Kamala Harris talked about this. You can make fun of her all you want, but she had this one cold read of what his movement was. And she's not the only one who said he would do this, but she was probably the most outspoken. There was a great story in The Atlantic this week by a friend of mine, Mark Leibovich, about Obama's sort of chill pill attitude. I do not know where this man is.
I'm sorry. There is not a strong Democrat yet who has emerged. And it could be someone who announces for president. You're right. That's a great way to do it. But the only person with the gravitas—and people are like, "Why doesn't George W. Bush do it?" He doesn't have the same gravitas that President Obama has. Stand up and not just when he feels like it, not just when he wants to make some announcement and then he goes off and plays basketball with celebrities, which is what he's been doing, honestly. Someone like that—I was trying to think who could do this and create a nationwide problem for Trump.
And it is only Obama. It is only Obama who can do it.
I think it could be a new voice. The problem is, I agree with you. I'd love to see Obama do it. But the office of president—there is a generally accepted principle that former presidents do not get involved in politics and come out swinging.
Kara Swisher
Not this guy. This guy doesn't deserve that.
Scott Galloway
I get it. I understand it, and I'm not saying I disagree with it. But the better opportunity is for someone to emerge with a new vision for America who's a Democrat and just comes right out and says, "I think there are crimes that have been committed here. I'm not going to threaten my political opponents with incarceration, but I am going to uphold the Constitution. And my belief is that there have been several criminal acts committed here, and I'm going to hold this. And by the way, if some Democrats have continued to engage in insider trading, I'm going to hold them accountable." Somebody needs to stand up and say, "I am running to defend the Constitution. And on day one, I am going to demonstrate and put on full display what the Constitution actually is." If we don't store incentives to the downside as well as the upside, then it's kind of game over. And no one's running on it. No one stood up and said, "I'm ready. This is what I'm going to do." Who has? You can't name—I can't name someone.
Kara Swisher
I think it's someone TBD. I think it's probably a Democratic governor who we don't even know yet. Because at this time—
Scott Galloway
We know who they are.
Kara Swisher
Well, yeah, but they weren't household names. Clinton and Obama were not—nobody knew who they were in this part of the election cycle. This is a huge white space and opportunity for a Democrat.
Scott Galloway
All right, I see that. I think right now Barack Obama has got to stand the fuck up and stop playing basketball and hanging out.
Kara Swisher
I'd like to see it, but I don't think it's going to happen.
Scott Galloway
He's got to stop. He did the whole "if this were me, can you imagine if I did that?" But I think quite frankly, he has such a nice life and he's so focused on maintaining his brand equity. I don't think he wants to take the risk.
Kara Swisher
I agree with you. I think he should. I don't think he will. I think he's the only one who could and he should do it. And it's his duty as an American citizen.
Scott Galloway
What about Bill Clinton if you're going to pull people in the past?
Kara Swisher
I think a lot of the exes have a lot of baggage compared to President Obama. I think a lot of them do. I think Bill Clinton—I know it sounds dumb, but he's older and his voice is bad. There's only one who's looking good and in fighting shape, and that's President Obama. George W. Bush does not have the same. I mean, all of them together, great. But President Obama is the one that needs to stand up. I pushed that article and they were like, "What about George Bush? Why should he come out against this?" I'm like, "Because they've ruined his legacy and because it's the right thing to do." And he's the only one, honestly.
I can't think of anyone else in public life. It's a huge white space for someone who wants to be—I've received calls from six people who are excited to come on the pod, which is their way of saying "I'm running for president." And what I say to their PR people is, "Tell him to start actually running for fucking president then. Come up with actual sober plans and talk about bold solutions. Attach real money and numbers to it. Talk about what we actually need to do." Also, they were saying President Trump was effective. I'm not being indignant. He was effective. He was chanting "Lock her up" around Hillary Clinton's emails.
And we as Democrats are like, "No, we've got to take the high road." Well, that's what I'm saying. Let's stop standing on ceremony.
Scott Galloway
I don't know. I think Obama, get off your tail.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, but I think it should be a stepping stone to this person being elected. I guess. I think he's the only one. I think it's a big opportunity for somebody. We'll see.
Okay, Scott, let's go on a quick break. When we come back, how Trump is threatening Elon, even though Elon has acquiesced, it looks like.
Ad Break
Ad - Tron Aries: Tron Aries: Tron Aries has arrived. I would like you to meet Aries, the ultimate AI soldier. He is biblically strong and supremely intelligent. You think you're in control of this? You're not. On October 10th. What are you?
End of Ad Break
Tron Aries
My world is coming to destroy yours, but I can help you. The war for our world begins in IMAX. Tron Aries, rated PG-13. May be inappropriate for children under 13. Only in theaters October 10th. Get tickets now.
Ad Break
Ad - LinkedIn: Support for Pivot comes from LinkedIn. From talking about sports to discussing the latest movies, everyone is looking for a real connection to the people around them. But it's not just person to person. It's the same connection that's needed in business. And it can be the hardest part about B2B marketing, finding the right people, making the right connections. But instead of spending hours scavenging social media feeds, you can just tap LinkedIn ads to reach the right professionals. According to LinkedIn, they have grown to a network of over 1 billion professionals, making it stand apart from other ad buys. You can target your buyers by job title, industry, company roles, seniority, skills, and company revenue, giving you all the professionals you need to reach in one place. So you can stop wasting budget on the wrong audience and start targeting the right professionals only on LinkedIn ads. LinkedIn will even give you a $100 credit on your next campaign so you can try it for yourself. Just go to linkedin.com slash pivotpod. That's linkedin.com slash pivotpod. Terms and conditions apply. Only on LinkedIn ads.
Ad Break
Ad - United Airlines: This is a real good story about Bronx and his dad, Ryan. Real United Airlines customers. We were returning home and one of the flight attendants asked Bronx if he wanted to see the flight deck and meet Captain Andrew. I got to sit in the driver's seat. I grew up in an aviation family, and seeing Bronx kind of reminded me of myself when I was that age. That's Andrew, a real United pilot. These small interactions can shape a kid's future. It felt like I was the captain. Allowing my son to see the flight deck will stick with us forever. That's how good leads the way.
End of Ad Break
Kara Swisher
Scott, we're back with the latest fallout from the Elon-Trump breakup. Trump says his relationship with Elon Musk is over and is threatening serious consequences if Elon funds Democratic candidates. Trump is pushing everyone around. Trump has been busy talking to reporters and working the phones over the last few days, calling Elon disrespectful, a big time drug addict. He's also selling that new Tesla, apparently. There's been talk about a possible truth, of course. Politico reported there was a call with representatives for both men on Friday. I think that was just David Sachs calling Donald Trump up.
And Elon, for his part, has deleted several of his tweets from last week, including one tying Trump to Jeffrey Epstein. And on Sunday, he appeared to be kissing the ring, retweeting posts from Trump and J.D. Vance about the L.A. protests. I've been actually, unfortunately, going on Twitter and watching what he's up to. And he seems to be, first he was focused a lot on SpaceX and things like that. And now he's sort of retweeting a lot of support for Donald Trump again. So I think he's probably trying to get in there. He doesn't want to. He realizes he's in a deleveraged position and he's decided not to go rogue.
People have actually calmed him down. I don't think it's going to last for him. But a lot of people are trying to get Elon to back off and acquiesce. And I think largely a lot of it is because his businesses will be at risk. Tesla's not recovered a bit at the end of the week. The company is still facing some pain if the Trump spending bill passes in terms of SpaceX. Elon appears to have changed his mind on decommissioning the Dragon spacecraft. That was so ridiculous. But NASA and the Pentagon officials are urging SpaceX competitors to quickly develop rockets and spacecraft, according to The Washington Post.
And we're just learning now that some Trump officials had some concerns about the Starlink getting installed at the White House earlier this year, which we brought up many times. A lot of Tesla's getting downgraded all over the place. And obviously, people in MAGA world have to choose sides. Though new polling by YouGov suggests that Republicans are not conflicted with their loyalties. Asked who they would choose between Trump and Musk, seven in 10 Republicans said Trump. That's interesting. Same thing with J.D. Vance, who was pushed forward by, who got his job through Elon Musk and Peter Thiel, essentially.
He's always going to be loyal to the president. He hopes Elon eventually comes back in the fold. David Sachs, of course, because he's an unctuous toady, has been privately encouraging Musk to call the president, try to mend the relationship. Now, Steve Bannon, on the other hand, is making trouble. He's urged Trump to deport Elon and seize control of SpaceX. Bannon also provided details of Elon's Oval Office fight with Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent to The Washington Post, revealing how the fight got physical. Apparently, there was a ramming. Elon rammed his shoulder into Bessent's rib cage like a rugby player, and Bessent hit him back.
Musk has called him a liar. And we haven't heard anything from Stephen Miller's wife, Katie, who recently left Doge in the White House to work for Elon. Though Elon had to rebuke his AI chatbot Grok after it falsely claimed a tweet where Elon bragged about taking Katie Miller from her husband was real. Grok believed it was, and Elon said it wasn't. As I said, Elon called Bannon a liar. So what do you think? How do you look at this?
Scott Galloway
What do I think? I think if this were a running gay er, it'd be a Bravo reality show sponsored by Grindr. I mean, can you imagine two bigger bitches than this? It's just like, God, if I had two 12-year-olds behaving this way. Let me get this. And I just love how, okay, Trump or Musk thinks he's illuminating to the world that Trump was guilty of a sex crime on an island. And then Trump threatening to deport him. No, not Trump. Bannon. Bannon suggested it.
Kara Swisher
I thought Trump said it had come to his attention that he was here illegally or something.
Scott Galloway
Oh, he might have said so. I don't know if he said so. And then Musk basically puts out a tweet that basically intimates he's fucking Stephen Miller's wife.
Kara Swisher
Well, he says he didn't. He said it was a false tweet. Let's just keep it clear.
Scott Galloway
Oh, yeah. I bet. Grok doesn't think it was.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I bet. He says Grok is wrong. I'm with Grok on that one. Look, I don't, again, this is all just such a distraction. And to be clear, Trump, Musk has no problem with the bill. He knew what was in the bill. He's part of the architecture here. He's part of this notion that it's exploding, the deficit bothers him as he tries to cut 40 or 50% of the IRS. This is what happened, or my read. He wanted to get involved in China relations. He wanted to be co-president.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
No, he wanted to be an unelected president. And Trump said, no. Scott Bessent said, I'm not letting you pick these people. They got into a fight. He got punched in the face, it looks like. And now he's decided that all of a sudden he doesn't like the tax bill. And Trump is hitting back. The problem is it's a huge distraction from more important issues here. Musk has more to lose because the government could—Trump is absolutely about weaponizing the government and threatening specific punishment for his companies, whether it's tariffs, taxes, rescinding EV taxes, canceling all contracts with SpaceX.
But we've said it was dangerous. He could be mitigating, bringing back the SEC, bringing back, he could do a manner of things. Or what he's done to other citizens. He's been sending other citizens to concentration camps. And people get triggered when I say the word. The definition of a concentration camp is an incarceration facility that is purposely put outside of your own country such that the people you send there are no longer protected by the laws and norms of their home country. So these are concentration camps. They fit the definition. Are they exterminating people there? No, not that we know of, but these fit the definition of concentration camps.
And if he can send people that end up having not committed a crime, right, why could he theoretically not send you, me, or Elon Musk? And that's the problem with all of this. We have decided a pillar of our justice system is we err on the side. We have made a decision to give people really wonderful rights. We have erred on the side of occasionally someone who deserves to go to jail doesn't, rather than accidentally lock up a gay hairdresser who done nothing wrong in a hellscape in El Salvador. We decided to err the other way. And this guy has decided to go the other way and err on the side of people who are innocents.
Anyways, my point is he can, you know, Musk, to his credit, Honey Badger don't care. He's under the impression he's more powerful. And to his credit, he's right. He did get, you could make a very solid argument that he in fact did get Trump elected. So but again, I worry it's a distraction from what I think is the bigger issue here, which is the grab for power.
Absolutely. What's interesting is I'm just looking at Elon's tweets now. He's absolutely backing Trump on what's happening. And at the same time, he's putting out there like, if Elon Musk hadn't bought Twitter, none of us would know what's going on in L.A. right now. And so he's just retweeting everything anti-immigrant and he's back to that. He goes, if you talk to someone who gets all their information from legacy media, they're living in a different world. They're getting it from your podcast or news from X. We're living in an alt reality. So he's pretending he's using it to pump X, which is doing rather well because of his war with Trump.
So he's back in the fold. And my only thing is he's going on a bender again. Scott, he'll go on another bender, which is what I think happened with Trump here. But he's not going to get back. Trump is not letting him back in. Apparently, he's quite hurt that Elon and he aren't friends anymore. But I don't think Trump will let him in only if he is completely prostrate on the ground to Trump. All I think Trump wants to do is just get him to neutral. I don't think Trump's going to let him back in. And he's like, this guy is dangerous, uncontrollable, very powerful. I think he's just going to want to come to some sort of detente with the guy.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, that's the smartest thing. But he's not going to let him near the West Lawn again. I mean, there's no way. I will say this, though. I think Musk is just such a terrible role model and a weird person. But I would 100%, because I have heard indirectly from Elon Musk, I would 100% accept an invitation to do a weekend in Vegas with him. I can't imagine anyone better to roll with in Vegas. 48 hours, I'm in.
Kara Swisher
You, him, and Katie Miller. That'll be great.
Scott Galloway
I also want to roll with Laura Loomer. And if we can dig up the spirit of David Carradine, who was caught strangling himself in a Thai hotel, I'm down. That would be a pretty good weekend.
Kara Swisher
Who would be the fifth? Maybe George Michael. I think he liked to party.
Scott Galloway
Diddy, I mean, Diddy, right?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I'm not abusive like that, though. Anyways, let's think about it. He's a fun guy.
Scott Galloway
All right, George Michael. He'd be a lot of fun. And anyway, one thing, though, Doge has collected two wins from the Supreme Court. First, the court granted an emergency application filed by the Trump administration to allow members of Doge to access Social Security Administration data. Second, SCOTUS ruled that Doge doesn't have to turn over internal records to a government watchdog group for now. The three liberal members dissented from both rulings.
Kara Swisher
You know, I think Doge is over. I think they're leaving. There are people that are going to stay embedded. And different cabinet members will do what they want and use the Doge people there. But they've cut the head off of this thing. And the Doge father, whenever he calls himself the Doge father, it's ridiculous. This cosplaying is so stupid. It was interesting. My favorite part was Bill Gates reportedly visited the White House on Friday to argue for reversing Doge cuts. Just moving on in there. And they will, all those different tech people will do whatever they're in. In Bill Gates' case, he's trying to reverse USAID things, so good for Bill for going. Good job, Bill, is what I say. Go right in there. And it's showing how he was the original Doge father, really, and a godfather in a lot of ways. But I think pretty much Doge is over, and the cabinet members will do whatever they want. But Russell Vogt still remains in charge and trying to push through the idea of dismantling government. And that certainly isn't going to stop.
Scott Galloway
Doge. I think it's, yeah, you're right. It's over. I'm really curious what the state of the tax bill is. I'd love to be in those Senate hearings right now around if this thing has any chance of getting through, or if this is all posturing from Rand Paul and the few Republican senators who claim to care. And if you upload the tax bill into ChatGPT and ask it to summarize it, it says it's authoritarianism wrapped in bureaucratic language. It doesn't even talk about the tax end of it. It talks about things like, essentially, senior officials can no longer be found in contempt of court. It transfers massive power from agencies where it's full-time government officials to appointed officials, i.e. Trump acolytes. It moves everything to the executive.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it moves everything upward towards appointees and the executive.
Scott Galloway
It's so funny that ChatGPT focused on the authoritarianism as opposed to the economics of this tax bill. And it also said what was interesting, one of the points it came back with was this is a really elegant, legally deft piece of legislation. Russell Vogt. Russell Vogt is the one you need to focus on, not Elon, that clown. Russell Vogt is the one that's trying to dismantle and give power to the executive. That's the whole goal here.
Kara Swisher
I think they'll regret it when Democrats come into power if they give these powers.
Scott Galloway
Well, it's fair. That's a really interesting point. And again, I would love to see, you know, I would love to see senators, soon to be Governor Bennett, basically put out a little—there are so many things a Democrat could be doing right now. Why don't you have your friend Bennett get up there and start talking?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I'm a huge fan of the senators. You know, actually, based on that, I'm going to reach out to him this afternoon. But why wouldn't someone who's interested in running for president put out a list of executive orders they're going to do on day one?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, yeah. These are the executive orders I have planned.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, right. Anyway. All right, let's go on a quick break. And when we come back, Warner Brothers Discovery is splitting in two, as we said it would.
Ad Break
Ad - Xtandi: Hi, I'm Jim. I'm not an actor, just a guy living with prostate cancer. My wife and I face each day head-on. We asked my doctor about Xtandi enzalutamide. Xtandi 40-milligram tablets treats men with prostate cancer that has spread to other parts of the body and responds to a medical or surgical treatment to lower testosterone. Xtandi may cause serious side effects, seizure, a brain condition called PRES, allergic reactions, heart disease that can lead to death, falls and bone fractures, swallowing problems or choking that can lead to death. Stop Xtandi and get medical help at once if your face, tongue, lip or throat starts swelling. Tell your doctor at once if you faint, have a seizure, quickly worsening headache, decreased alertness, confusion, vision problems, chest pain or discomfort or shortness of breath. Xtandi can cause harm to an unborn baby or miscarriage. Use birth control during and three months after Xtandi. Common side effects include muscle and joint pain, feeling unusually tired, hot flashes, constipation, less appetite, diarrhea, high blood pressure, bleeding, falls, fractures, and headache. Visit Xtandi.com to watch my story.
End of Ad Break
Scott, we're back. Warner Brothers Discovery will split into two public companies. Streaming and studios will be one company, including movie properties and HBO Max. And the other company will be the Global Networks company, including CNN, TNT Sports, and Discovery. CEO David Zaslav will lead streaming and studios, and the company's current CFO, Gunnar, I think his name is, will become the CEO of Global Networks Business. The split is expected to be complete by the middle of next year. Shares of Warner Brothers Discovery are up over 7% at the time of the taping, although they've been really down.
Scott, we discussed that possibility last month, and you got this partly right, but this is something we've talked about for a while, that this was going to, a la Versant, which is the Comcast runoff. And we both have talked about this extensively, but let's listen to what we just said recently. I think I know what's going to happen here. The company is going to go good bank, bad bank. It's going to be HBO and Warner Brothers, the theater business, the characters, the IP, which will feed into HBO. HBO is the brand. It'll have another component, a subset, HBO Max or something, that's all the other shit.
And then they will spin all the TV and the cable assets into they'll either consolidate or be part of a consolidation with Comcast. And that is they're just these are still highly profitable businesses, but they're shrinking. So that means consolidation and cost cutting. All right. Which is it's almost exactly what happened at Comcast here, which is about to almost be completed, I think, and therefore possibly a merger acquisition or the opposite. They merge in some way. The company has not yet announced that we'll split Warner Brothers Discovery's huge debt, $37 billion, although it's cheap debt, but it's still debt nonetheless.
But it will take out a $17 billion short-term loan ahead of the split to bring down that. How should they divvy up the debt? I mean, again, a bunch of small little media boats. I was on a panel with Anderson Cooper over there again after they showed Good Night and Good Luck, and Anderson was asking me, are there going to be this big thing? I'm like, no, everything's getting split up. And like, you can't have these big entities anymore that are spending enormous amounts of money and don't make any sense anymore from an audience point of view. So how do you look at this and how should they divvy up the debt?
I think that's probably the most important thing here.
Scott Galloway
Well, this was absolutely the smart thing to do because the market wants a consistent story. And the story around legacy cable assets is that they're still hugely profitable, but they're declining businesses. And really the business strategy, and it can be a very effective strategy for creating shareholder value, is to go acquire other struggling cable assets and cut costs faster than the business declines. So these things usually don't decline as quickly as people think.
Kara Swisher
No, it's like AOL, dial-up.
Scott Galloway
Well, that's right. Or so if the business is declining 6% to 8% a year, as long as you can go roll it up with Comedy Central and, you know, name your team, Bravo or whatever it is, as long as you can consolidate the back end and cut costs faster than 8% a year, that is accretive to the bottom line. And that's a decent trading stock. And then you have the other thing that requires capital to grow because HBO and Warner are still, you know, technically growth assets. So you have to have a consistent story. And these stories don't work. So it makes sense. The argument they're having right now, and I knew this before it happened. David Zaslav gets the cool shit. He gets to be on the cool side. He gets Warner Brothers and HBO. And the CFO, who is always a bad cop. Who actually is considered a very good executive, but go ahead.
Kara Swisher
I'm sure.
Scott Galloway
But his job is to consolidate and cut costs and go on an M&A. He's very good at cost cutting. That's what he's known for. And to call Brian Roberts and say, all right, how do we put these two things together? And the argument they're having right now, and consultants are in there and they're all posturing, is how much debt is the bad bank going to have to take with them? Because they're the more profitable one in the short term. But they're all looking at, I think they have a total of about $33 billion in debt. And they're all saying, OK, who has to take mom? Right. Who has to. It's a divorce and we're taking care of our parents and their real liability. Who gets our dad's a real liability living upstairs? Who has to take dad? Right. It's like in the fight between Musk and Trump, who gets custody of J.D. Vance? Who has to take him? Right.
Kara Swisher
So who does?
Scott Galloway
Well, they'll come to some accommodation. It won't be that one gets all the debt. They'll split it. But it's just the question of what the split is.
Kara Swisher
Why should the money-making one take it at all? Because they have the ability to service the debt. Right.
Scott Galloway
Okay. And what they want to do is make sure they don't, these companies still have, I mean, their existing shareholders are going to get shares in both. And also, if you saddle the bad bank, the cable TV news company, let's call it the cable division, with too much debt, it creates a poison pill where no one can acquire it or merge with it. So they're doing a delicate dance here to try and as you, you know, so this reverse engineers, it's all very incestuous. David Zaslav was the highest paid CEO in media or old media. He made $53 million, 52%, I believe, of shareholders said, we don't approve your compensation while the stock has gone down 66% because his compensation was tied to paying down debt. And he has done that. He and the CFO have paid down the debt, I think, from like $50 or $55 billion to like $33 billion. Also well-paid, by the way. Gunnar. But they've got to figure out a way to figure out who's going to take who and how much of this $33 billion in debt. But this is a smart move. We knew this was coming. There's going to be massive consolidation.
Kara Swisher
Let's talk about what's next. So Versant's coming out. That'll be its own thing. And they'll split off from NBC. It's exactly the same thing here. So what happens? Does Paramount pick up one of these things? Does ABC pick it up, which has its own troubles with Terry Moran doing that stupid post that he did about Stephen Miller? 100% accurate, but he's a beat reporter. He never should have done that. What do you see? Where does it go next? Because we all knew this was coming. So it's not like, you know, it's interesting. I have said this publicly several times over at CNN. And all the different people there are like, do you think they're going to split? I'm like, yeah. Like, that's what they're doing right now. They're figuring out how to do it. But where does it go next, I think, is really – I assume they merge with – either they merge with a Versant kind of thing or they get bought by a rich guy like David Ellison and that gang over there. Or a hedge fund, right? I mean, where does it go?
Scott Galloway
So, the ecosystem is getting late very early. And that is, these are declining assets and every deal they've struck, the deals get worse as time goes on. And I don't know if it's legal, but if it is, I would imagine the Roberts family, the people who control Comcast, are basically advising on how to structure the Warner deal such that they can almost immediately merge with the bad bank of the Warner assets and start consolidating the back end. There's no reason why CBS and CNN can't share a lot of the same. The CBS newsroom can't be mostly the CNN newsroom and vice versa.
Kara Swisher
Does that create the same thing they're in now with mixing Paramount with them? Is it just richer people? Because it's the same. It just puts, instead of Warner Brothers, it's Paramount.
Scott Galloway
Well, no, what I'm suggesting is just that we don't need all these newsrooms. Newsrooms are really expensive. You might have different front-facing brands with different distinct audiences and advertiser relationships. But you'll say, okay, CBS Newsroom and CNN Newsroom, they're each a thousand people. Combined, they're going to be 1,200 people. And we're going to rebrand it. And we have our front end anchors. We have, I don't know, I forget, it's Gail Keene, CBS, I forget, and Anderson Cooper over here. But a lot of the backend and the office space and the studios and the benefits and the HR manager and the CFOs and the tech people, it's all going to be, they've got to massively consolidate the backend.
Kara Swisher
But why would Paramount grab it? I don't know if it would be Paramount. I was just using an example.
Scott Galloway
Paramount. So merge NBC with CNN. I think the cleanest one right now, the most obvious, is Comcast's assets and Warner. But because Paramount, Jesus Christ, she is being backed into a corner. There is a non-zero probability right now that National Amusements slash Paramount declares bankruptcy in the next 12 months.
Kara Swisher
Well, it's going to be owned by a wealthy group of people. It's out there.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but here's the thing, Kara. The FTC will not approve this until Trump gets his pound of flesh from his ridiculous 60 minutes lawsuit, of which Sherry is under huge pressure not to bend a knee. If she doesn't bend a knee, the FTC will not approve this transaction. And she has somewhere between, based on what I've read, somewhere between a quarter of a billion and half a billion dollars in debts coming due from loans from David Ellison's father and money she owes investment banks. And if she can't pay that debt, they can bump her into a restructuring at which point all the suitors go, you're weak, we're not paying you this, we're paying you less. So she is in a really weird spot right now. And she's battling thyroid cancer. So this ecosystem is going to be a very interesting 12 or 24 months.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it'll be interesting where it all ends up. What's your likeliest? I would assume maybe the Warner Brothers assets and the Comcast assets get brought together, right?
Scott Galloway
That's 100%. And so it's CNN, NBC. And that's why I was saying Brian Roberts and his team, and they're very smart, is probably in conversations, if it's legal, I'm trying to think if they're allowed to do that, if it's to say this is what the combined company would look like and how we make this as seamless as possible post the spin. It would make sense for those guys, the Versant group. They'd be stronger. They'd have more options. They could cut costs better. They'd have MSNBC more, you know, more obviously like Fox News, like I'm not calling them Fox News. But why do MSNBC and CNN need independent newsrooms?
Kara Swisher
I mean, this is heresy. Actually, the NBC newsroom is going with the other gang.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
So the newsroom itself is actually the actual news gatherers. But what you said, I don't think it's going to happen, that it might be a hedge fund, because here's the thing, the numbers, even at these discounted numbers, they still don't make financial sense. And what's telling is that the three people surrounding the Paramount sale, obviously Sherry Redstone, Edgar Bronfman was in there for a while, and then David Ellison, what do all three of these people have in common? Rich kids, as you notice. They're rich kids. Because guess what?
Anyone who made their own money and understands how to make money and understands how to read, who took accounting and makes money, doesn't spend daddy's money, isn't getting near these things. Because these guys, David Zaslav and David Ellison, are willing to overpay with other people's money so they can go to the Academy Awards. And hedge funds aren't allowed to do that.
I mean, a friend of mine co-founded Anchorage and his co-founder bought Lionsgate. And I remember saying, there's cheaper ways to go to the Academy Awards. And he ended up getting bailed out by Amazon and actually making money. But these are, there's no accident that the players here are all rich kids.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, it's interesting. We'll see what happens, but I'm sure there'll definitely be a consolidation here, a very obvious consolidation. It's a question of which way it happens. And the thing is, they get outsized attention given how small they are compared to other businesses. I keep saying that. I'm like, you know, you're little. You're not who you used to be.
Kara Swisher
By the way, that was a really fun thing for them showing off *Good Night and Good Luck* on the network. I thought that was just a lovely thing to do. All right. One more quick break. We'll be back for wins and fails.
Break
Okay, Scott, let's hear some wins and fails. I guess I'll go first. There were a lot of options for me for the win. D.C. Public Schools will enforce a cell phone ban starting next year. My kids are in D.C. Public Schools. I'm very happy about that. Also, the Tonys were amazing. They were really fun. I love Cynthia Erivo. She provided a really good show. And even though that's a small business, too, in a lot of ways, I thought they did a great job. It was really fun and entertaining, which is what they should be. And a minimum of lecturing. It was just really good performances, especially bringing back the *Hamilton* group together to sing. It was super fun.
But I think my win of the week is seeing you in a satin boxing robe, Scott. Go on!
Scott Galloway
I have to say, first of all, I sent it to Alex. He's like, "Scott's in good shape for a man of his age," essentially. It looked really fun. You looked adorable. What a cute thing you were. But your shirt off was the best part with the drag queens. I love this guy Calloway, who's yelling at Piers Morgan, who's wearing a boxer. I like this guy. I like what I've made here. This man that I've affected in some way. But tell me, explain to me how that went very briefly.
A good friend of mine, Pablo Doritos, does this thing called the Faena Rumble, where two people pretend to be boxers. They answer questions, the crowd decides who wins the round. At the end of the bout, you get a belt based on who wins. The last one was Anthony Scaramucci versus Kevin O'Leary. And this one was me and a really impressive young man named Mr. Michael Singleton, who I just thought was lovely. And I hope there's more conservatives like him.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I mean, let's be honest. You're in Detroit. You go up against a 34-year-old black Republican. The odds were he was going to win. But he didn't. You won.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, well, daddy did a little.
Kara Swisher
How did you win? You had the belt.
Scott Galloway
I had the belt, yeah. But it was a ton of fun. I really enjoyed it. And the thing I'm so excited about is I said to Pablo, "Okay, but I get to announce my entrance, you know, when boxers come out."
Kara Swinger
Yeah, yeah, of course.
Scott Galloway
And Michael was really good. He did a drum line from an all-black college or high school in Detroit. It was really cool. And I went through no small effort and expense. He was wearing a suit. I was wearing a suit.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. What a mistake.
Scott Galloway
And I found five drag queens. And that was the best part of it.
Kara Swisher
That's why you won. Oh, my God. That is entirely why you won.
Scott Galloway
Well, you worked out extra. I've been working out four times a week for four years.
Kara Swisher
Must be the testosterone.
Scott Galloway
Anyways, testosterone, excuse me. The drag queens were the best. But that was a lot of fun. Thanks for the kind words. I really enjoyed it. And you won.
Kara Swisher
I did win. Yes, I did win. That to me, it should have been a fail. But Scott, it was a win. I appreciate that.
And my fail, obviously, Trump's ridiculous behavior, but I'm going to do a tech one. Bill Atkinson, who was an Apple computer designer and created software that enabled the visual approach of Lisa and Macintosh computers, died of pancreatic cancer. Here's an unsung hero of Apple. There's several of them, including people who are living like Susan Kare and others. But Bill Atkinson was critical. The way we compute today is because of inventions from people like him. What a really important inventor, lovely guy, and just one of these people you don't hear about, like Johnny Ive and others. But Bill Atkinson was a critical person to the early development of computer design. Just a lovely person and sadly had pancreatic cancer. But that was my fail. People should look him up, read about him. He's an important figure. You will have never heard of him, but he was critically important. What about you, Scott, besides your nudity drag queen thing?
Scott Galloway
My win is, just to call balls and strikes, there is one component of the GOP tax bill that I do like. And that is they've threatened to raise taxes on endowments. So they're talking about increasing the tax on the profits of endowments from a little over 1% to upwards of 21%, which would be a substantial increase in taxes, almost like what regular people pay in taxes.
Kara Swisher
Aimed at Harvard, I assume.
Scott Galloway
Well, let's be honest. It's a war on education for the wrong reasons, but that doesn't mean it can't have positive outcomes. And that is, I've been saying this for a while. The bill says unless they spend more than 5% of their endowments, they need to stop hoarding wealth. I believe American universities largely set the tone for big components of America. And this rejectionist bullshit culture where we're hoarding money instead of spending it on financial aid or expanding the size of freshman classes — these institutions sit on endowments the size of the Costa Rican GDP. Meanwhile, they decide to only let in 500 people. That means you're no longer a public servant. You're in a man's back.
So you want them to spend that money so they don't get taxed on it. Because of the threat in this bill of these taxes on their endowments going from one and a half percent to potentially 23%, they are proposing a solution where they would spend at least five percent each year of their endowments on things like financial aid, new facilities, the local economy, or expanding freshman seats. That is exactly what they should be doing. There is no reason these elite universities — I said this before — if higher education were pharmaceutical, it's a pill that makes you less likely to be obese, more likely to get married, more likely to stay married, more likely to be civically involved, less likely to kill yourself. And that pill is called higher ed. So why would we hoard that pill and make it so expensive when we have the ability to distribute that pill to vastly more of the American public?
So I'm hoping that one benefit, even if this bill doesn't go through, which I hope it doesn't, is universities are responding and saying, "Okay, we get it. We should probably, if we have $6 million per student, maybe we should spend money on financial aid and maybe letting in a few more students." We have to stop this culture of hoarding amongst the most fortunate and blessed. So that's my win.
Kara Swisher
The wrong reasons, but the right thing.
Scott Galloway
That's right. I think an outcome of this might be that universities realize once you get above a certain point, your job is to spend the money and add value, not to hoard wealth. I think that's a lesson for Americans. I decided seven years ago I was going to spend everything above a certain amount or give it away. Hoarding wealth is really a virus in America and it affects people and it affects institutions.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, my fail is — so Harvey Milk, many people might not know him. I know you know him. Harvey Milk was a U.S. supervisor, one of the first openly gay people to be elected in San Francisco, one of the first openly gay officials to be elected anywhere. He was also, most people don't know this, he served in the Korean War on a submarine rescue ship and later as a diving instructor. His military review records use the word "outstanding." He was promoted to officer. And then in 1955, his superiors learned that he was gay. They gave him a choice: either resign and forfeit your military benefits with something called "other than honorable," so he had to give up his military benefits, or face court martial. So he resigned.
Then he went on to be supervisor. He was in my district. He was murdered alongside the mayor, Moscone, by a fellow supervisor. I think it was 2017, they said he served honorably, maybe a way of compensating and also a way of recognizing and giving a nod to what is probably 5%, if not more, of our nation's armed services consists of gay people, given that somewhere between 5% and 8% of the U.S. population identifies as gay. They played such a huge role. Wouldn't it be nice to give this guy his overdue recognition and name a ship? And they named this oil tanker, not an especially important ship, the USNS Harvey Milk.
Secretary Hegseth, in the first week of Pride Week, commands an issue in order to rename the ship, saying that this is in line with restoring what they call a warrior mentality, a warrior culture. It is such an affront to the gay community. It is so deeply bigoted. It is so unnecessary. It is so cruel. It is just so fucking weird and distinct from the moral argument. What does that say to gay people who want to be in the armed services?
And folks, just so you know, the straight people showing up — the straight men and the gay men, I imagine — two-thirds of them or 70% of them can't get through the initial screening because they either are obese or mentally unfit. So you want to take an additional 5% of the population and say, "You're not welcome here." Distinct from the moral argument, I can pretty much prove to anyone that gay people are no better or no worse at defending our shores and killing bad people. So you're making us less safe. When you decide to inhibit the pool of people to defend our country, you are making us less safe.
So that's not only weird and straight up bigoted against a guy who served his country honorably and was unjustifiably discharged — a small nod to him, a small nod to the gay community. "Oh no, we can't let that stand." And it makes us weaker. What is the message we're sending to good, young, gay men and women who want to serve their country?
Scott Galloway
I know you experienced a little bit of this. I wanted to be in the military, Scott, and I wasn't because I didn't want to lie. And you refused to go along with "don't ask, don't tell."
Kara Swisher
Yeah. That makes us weaker. My dad was in the Navy. When we shrink the pool of potentially great human capital, it makes us weaker. So my fail is this bigoted, weak, and weird renaming of the USNS Harvey Milk. This was a really important man that gave people a lot of comfort, made it probably a lot easier for people to represent their community in a transparent way in leadership positions.
And by the way, I didn't like it when Civil War general statues were torn down. I think it's part of history. If the community decides they want to tear it down, fine. But I thought we got way too fucking woke and started tearing down.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, they're woke in a whole different way.
Kara Swisher
There were people in London who wanted to tear down statues of Churchill. I mean, I hate —
Scott Galloway
What do you call it when it's the right doing this? Is it woke or is it just drunk in the case of Pete Hegseth?
Kara Swisher
Well, this is just straight up bigotry. This is just straight up homophobia and bigotry. But all of these things make us less strong.
Scott Galloway
It does. It does.
Kara Swisher
Thank you, Scott. Harvey Milk was a great leader in San Francisco and was killed by crazy —
Scott Galloway
And murdered doing his job. In City Hall.
Kara Swisher
Which, by the way, gave rise to Dianne Feinstein. A supervisor who became mayor, Dianne Feinstein, who went on to be a very important senator.
Scott Galloway
Just a great —
Kara Swisher
To this day, there's a place near my house, a block from my house, where they have the original — he had a photography store in the Castro, and you can go visit it. There's a plaque to him where he did his business. He was a business person, too, by the way, in this city.
Scott Galloway
I didn't know that.
Kara Swisher
A very successful business person. He had a photography store. Anyway, thank you, Scott. God, Scott, what is happening? What is happening? We're switching roles here. It's really interesting. I'll start telling penis jokes and everything else.
Scott Galloway
I'm moving to San Francisco.
Kara Swisher
You are. You're going to move to my house.
Anyway, we want to hear from you. Send us your questions about business, tech, or whatever's on your mind. Go to nymag.com slash pivot to submit a question for the show, or call 855-51-PIVOT. A reminder, we have another live call-in show coming up. Call or email us and let us know what you'd like to ask us and make it spicy. We like spicy.
Elsewhere in the Kara and Scott universe, this week on *On with Kara Swisher*, I spoke to NPR CEO Katherine Maher. Let's listen to a clip of her discussing NPR's lawsuit against the Trump administration.
Clip plays
Katherine Maher
My concern is that this makes us feel as though we are in some way in an adversarial posture to the administration. Which is not the intent.
Kara Swisher
Well, that's what a lawsuit is, right?
Katherine Maher
Well, it is, but it's an adversarial posture in response to an adversarial action. And that adversarial action is one that we believe to be unconstitutional. So, I mean, if anything, I would say it's our patriotic responsibility to defend the First Amendment as a media organization.
Clip ends
Kara Swisher
She was really impressive. She's from tech. She ran Wikimedia. She's terrific. And really, it's a great interview.
Okay, that's the show. Thanks for listening to Pivot. And be sure to like and subscribe to our YouTube channel. We'll be back on Friday. Scott, read us out.
Scott Galloway
Today's show was produced by Lara Neiman, Zoe Marcus, Taylor Griffin, and Kevin Oliver. Ernie and Ertad, I'm sure you're in this episode. Thanks also to Drew Burrows, Mia Saverio, and Dan Chalon. Nishat Keroua is Vox Media's executive producer of podcasts. Make sure to follow Pivot on your favorite podcast platform. Thanks for listening to Pivot from New York Magazine and Vox Media. You can subscribe to the magazine at nymag.com slash pod. We'll be back later this week for another breakdown of all things tech and business.
This isn't law and order, it's fascism foreplay. You don't need troops in the streets, you need leaders with spines and policies that don't read like rejected plot lines from *The Man in the High Castle*. What's going on here has nothing to do with patriotism, has everything to do with authoritarianism.