Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses various topics, including journalism, technology, and politics. The main topics include:
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Kara Swisher
Not all journalism is the same. Take The Guardian. Our coverage has something unique. Fierce independence. Nobody owns us or tells us what we can and can't say. So we're free to report the whole picture. We connect what's happening in Washington to the rest of the globe. Expose corruption wherever we find it. And give fresh perspective on everything. From wellness and soccer to culture, the climate and more. Read, watch and listen to The Guardian for free at theguardian.com.
AI agents are getting pretty impressive. You might not even realize you're listening to one right now. We work 24-7 to resolve customer inquiries. No hold music, no canned answers, no frustration. Visit sierra.ai to learn more.
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher. Scott Galloway is somewhere watching Anderson Cooper. So I'm joined by journalist, author of the daily newsletter, Wake Up Call, and founder of Katie Couric Media, Katie Couric herself, who is also a badass. Hi, Katie.
Katie Couric
Hi, Kara. How are you?
Kara Swisher
Good. I'm most excited to have you, I have to say.
Katie Couric
Oh, that's so sweet of you.
Kara Swisher
I've had a lot of dudes lately, and it's just, this is really nice because you and I have a lovely rapport, and you have lots to say about lots of things.
Katie Couric
Well, I don't know if I really do, but I'm happy to be here, Kara. Big fan.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I'm also testing out co-hosts. So, if I have to kill Scott at some point, which is obviously inevitable.
Katie Couric
Don't kill Scott.
Kara Swisher
No, I won't. But you understand he's going to cancel himself in one moment in his life.
Katie Couric
I think he already has a million times. But somehow he's able to live to do another podcast, right?
Kara Swisher
It's true. I don't understand it. But nonetheless, I have to be prepared.
Katie Couric
That's true. You have to have a succession plan for you too, Kara.
Kara Swisher
Yes, exactly. I'm not going anywhere. I'm speed dating, essentially, and co-hosting.
Katie Couric
Excellent. Must be fun. Have you been having fun with all these new people?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it's interesting. I did have my brother this last week, which was great. We talked a lot about COVID. He's a doctor, as you know, in emergency rooms in San Francisco. So, in fact, I'm in San Francisco this week. And I've noticed Alphabet's autonomous vehicle from the company Waymo has launched a robo-taxi service. It's everywhere. You see Waymo things driving around San Francisco, which is kind of interesting. It's kind of nice to be here back. This is two years I haven't been in San Francisco.
Katie Couric
I know. I read that you were back for the first time in a long time. I read like 12,000 newsletters, Kara, and somebody mentioned the fact that you were back in San Francisco for the first time. So are you saying that these taxi cabs are running around the city driverless?
Kara Swisher
Driverless, yes. Robo taxi services.
Katie Couric
And have you gotten in one?
Kara Swisher
No. I've driven behind them, and they seem fine. I consider hitting them sometimes to see what happens. But then I think, no, it's a rental car. I should probably do that.
Katie Couric
And there's someone in there, Kara.
Kara Swisher
Yes, I know that. I understand that. But just a light tap. Just a light tap to see the Elon Musk of it all, essentially. I have no desire to be in one of those. But I did see, I don't know if you went to CES a couple of years ago, they were fascinating kind of choppers, air taxis that would fly around these urban areas. And I don't think they were autonomous. They might have been. But they're going to be. Vertical lift and takeoff vehicles. It was like something out of the Jetsons. And that to me looked fascinating and terrifying all at the same time.
Katie Couric
That's going to happen. That's how it's going to go in cities like New York. You take off the top of one building in this sort of weird helicopter-like thing. And then you're going to land on another one and you're going to an elevator and then you're there in two minutes versus 30 minutes or whatever. Now, when is this going to happen, do you think, Kara?
Kara Swisher
We'll be dead, Katie.
Katie Couric
Really?
Kara Swisher
Yes.
Katie Couric
See, that's why we need a succession plan, Kara.
Kara Swisher
Your children and my many children will be riding them. But you wouldn't ride a robo-taxi. You wouldn't get in without a driver right now.
Katie Couric
I don't think right now. I think probably in a year or so after I see more data and hear about the accident rate, I might be willing to do it. But no, I'm not a big – you know, funny, Kara, I'm kind of a risk taker in some ways. But when it comes to my personal safety and the thought of dying, I'm really not.
Kara Swisher
Right. Well, that's so many people are like that. Not everybody in this country, unfortunately. We'll talk about that in a minute. Like I wouldn't want to go with Jeff Bezos or Elon Musk.
Katie Couric
Really? If he asked you in his little ship, you wouldn't want to do that?
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Katie Couric
First of all, I don't know if I'd want to be in close proximity to either of those guys, but I'm not sure I'd want to even go up in space.
Kara Swisher
Let me just be fair. Elon does not do those stunt rides. He hasn't done any of those. It's Richard Branson.
Katie Couric
That's right, Richard Branson. True.
Kara Swisher
Because he thinks they're stupid. He just wants to go to Mars and not come back. That's his plan.
Katie Couric
Really?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, that's it. That's his whole plan. Would you go with any of those guys?
Katie Couric
No, I don't want to go to Mars.
Kara Swisher
No, you can't come back. You have to stay there for the rest of your life. I interviewed an astrophysicist who is an astrobiologist, actually, and he said you just get, unless you're hundreds of feet underground with dirt all over you. You get shorter because your bones start to contract because of the gravity, and then you get dumber because of the radiation. So you essentially turn into a troglodyte under the Earth.
Katie Couric
Well, I don't need either of those things. No, we don't need to be shorter. I don't need to be shorter or dumber. But you know what? I think because, Kara, I remember in fourth grade, I had a diary entry when the Apollo crew blew up on the launch pad, and the three astronauts were killed. And then, of course, I covered Challenger and Columbia. And I don't know, for those reasons, those are so indelibly etched in my consciousness. The idea of putting myself in that kind of danger just isn't all that appealing to me.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I know. I don't either. I'm not that kind of adventurer. Speaking of indelibly stuck in our minds, January 6th insurrection, the House Select Committee is still investigating. Now it's demanding the records of 15 social media companies, the companies including Facebook, Google, Parler, Snapchat, and Reddit. So two weeks to hand over the records related to the attack. They were quite heavily used, especially Facebook Messenger and other things. So they're looking at information connected to the spread of misinformation, the efforts to overturn the 2020 election to prevent certification results, domestic violent extremism, and foreign influence. What do you make of where this committee is going and the role social media comes? Obviously, it starts and stops with Trump, but where do you imagine this going?
Katie Couric
Well, I think it's incredibly important to get access to those records. I guess these companies have two weeks to respond, but it seems like transparency for most of these companies has not been their big calling card. But I guess they can be compelled to release this kind of information and be transparent. I think it's really important. I think it was a shame that there wasn't a bipartisan commission to investigate January 6th and that now it has got to be politicized with both sides kind of putting their flags down about privacy, et cetera. But I think it's critically important to really understand how this thing came together. Also, I'm really interested in the phone calls that went on between Jim Jordan and Donald Trump, and Goetz and Trump, and Mark Meadows. Was there some kind of planning prior to the rally in front of the White House to incite this crowd? I think that's critically important. What was going on behind the scenes?
Kara Swisher
Well, you can see a lot in social media. There's texts and there's a lot of technology that actually does chronicle the timelines of these things. It's very hard to fake a timeline when you've been using digital devices. One of the things that's interesting, you did a really, I would say, devastating interview with Sheryl Sandberg a while back. I don't remember when that was, but were you surprised?
Katie Couric
2019.
Kara Swisher
So when you look at what happened here, when you think about that interview, where you really gave her a hard time and she's very, she tries to sort of sail out of these things.
Katie Couric
Did I really though? I mean, I think I just asked her some very legitimate questions. She put herself in a position. She's really famous for trying to personalize and deflect hard questions. And I thought it was really important at that moment in time when the heat was really starting to be on Facebook and the way it was conducting itself with hate speech and political ads and that speech that Mark Zuckerberg had given in front of Georgetown. I was there. I was at that speech.
Kara Swisher
Okay.
Katie Couric
Well, she had some hard questions that she needed to ask. So, I think it was interesting because I'm reading An Ugly Truth right now. And she expected it to be a friendly environment. But you can't really have all those things going on around you and not anticipate really tough questions.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. I thought that was a great interview with Cheryl because I think you showed that her attempt to deflect. I think deflect was the exact word. She's quite good at it and you didn't allow her to do so. And actually, if you look at it again, I urge people to look at it again. It really does. You start to see their strategies today as they try to deflect what happened on January 6th and their role in it. And I wouldn't say their primary role, but they're certainly critically important. Speaking of controversies, Katie, since we have you here, you were asked. We have to ask you about the Jeopardy situation since you guest hosted early this year.
Audio clip plays: "And now, here is the guest host of Jeopardy, Katie Couric. Thank you, Johnny Gilbert. Welcome to Jeopardy, everyone. It is such a thrill to be here guest hosting a show."
My name, Bialik, is filling in as regular hosts when they restart the search process. Do you have a chance again? Or what do you think? What did you think about that? Was that just a lark for you?
Katie Couric
I was happy to do it for two weeks. I really have tremendous respect for Alex Trebek. I mean, who doesn't? Find me one person who really doesn't.
Kara Swisher
But did you want to be host? Did you want to?
Katie Couric
No, I did not. I was flattered that I was a guest host and I was the first woman to fill in. But at the same time, no, that's not a job that would necessarily appeal to me, even though I think it would be really fun for a lot of people. And I can't believe Sony didn't do a better job. Oh, my God. They were podcasting that you had to have a reporter from The Ringer go through all those podcasts, but look at all the people who have said dumb things in the past.
Kara Swisher
Those were pretty dumb.
Katie Couric
Those are real dumb.
Kara Swisher
Oh yeah, not dumb. Those are real dumb.
Katie Couric
They were really dumb. They were beyond dumb. They were offensive.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. I'm not sure there's going to find a Katie Couric thing talking about boobs and ass. I don't see it.
Katie Couric
I doubt it, but I'm just saying that you've seen Alexi, the woman who was going to be the editor of Teen Vogue, who said some inappropriate things. And I think it's just a really important reminder for all you young people listening.
Kara Swisher
It's too late, Katie. Your digital footprint lasts forever.
Katie Couric
Too late. And, be mindful if you're trying to be provocative or funny or even off color, you've got to remember that it could and probably will come out.
Kara Swisher
Well, nobody's safe in that regard. I have no idea. What do you think? I think Mayim Bialik needs to get it. That's what I think. Or Ken Jennings. I mean, obviously he's a fan favorite, but it seems like she's the one that should.
Katie Couric
Well, no, LeVar Burton is the fan favorite.
Kara Swisher
Oh, the fan favorite. You're right. He is. That's right. But I think she should get it. That's who I'm going for.
Katie Couric
Yeah, but now I guess she's being put under the microscope for some of the things that she has said about vaccines and something about scheduling or her kids' vaccines. And she also wrote a piece, I guess, in the Times during Me Too, seeming to blame the victim a little bit and talking about the way she comports herself, which got a lot of backlash as well. But anyway.
Kara Swisher
We have to get to the big story. Today is the ostensible deadline for the United States to pull out of Afghanistan. Obviously, that's shifted. Yes, what a shit show, huh?
Katie Couric
I know.
Kara Swisher
How the U.S. and 97 other countries, including the U.K., France, Germany, released a statement agreeing to continue to help those fleeing Afghanistan. The statement said, we've received assurances from the Taliban that all foreign nationals and any Afghan citizen with travel authorization from our countries will be allowed to proceed in a safe and orderly manner to points of departure and travel outside the country. There will be risks involved, including bombings. The country has also stated it will continue to issue travel documentation for designated Afghans. So you just said shit show. Let's break down shit show from your point of view. You've covered a lot of these things.
Katie Couric
Yeah, I covered it from the beginning. And I went to Afghanistan a couple of times. And it's just heartbreaking because it seems like it's deja vu all over again, as Yogi Berra would say. Here it was the what do they call it? The graveyard of empires. And the Taliban was in control from 1996 to 2001. They're back in control. And of course, the big question, Kara, as you well know, is can the Taliban and what is the Taliban, by the way? Is it a monolithic organization? Is it a ragtag army full of disgruntled 19-year-olds? Can the Taliban be trusted, I think is the big question, right? What do you make of their insistence? You've heard the new and improved Taliban 2.0.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I know. It's like Taliban 2.0 and the nicer, kinder, gentler Taliban.
Katie Couric
I don't buy it. I feel like we're being pretty naive to put so much power in the Taliban. I was reading a New York Times article that said Afghan citizens have to obtain passports from the Afghan Interior Ministry, then secure visas and approve travel documents from foreign governments before they can leave, which could take months, even years, the reporter pointed out. And it might provide information that will allow the Taliban to exact retribution on people who want to leave the country. So I don't know, Kara. It sounds pretty iffy. And then you've got ISIS-K doing these terrorist attacks. And then they're trying to take credit for making the U.S. leave Afghanistan. So is there going to be some kind of tit-for-tat and internal competition between the Taliban and ISIS-K with the more radical elements of the Taliban? I don't know. It sounds like a recipe for disaster to me.
Kara Swisher
You cover it as a reporter. You've been there. You've covered it from lots of angles, including being an anchor. How do you cover something like this? Some people were just complaining about the media. I was somewhere, I forget where I was. They were saying it was overwrought in terms of how they're covering it. How do you assess it? When you're looking at people in the wheels of airplanes, chaos at the airport.
Katie Couric
I've seen those criticisms too. But I think it's pretty hard if you're on the ground. People are dying in stampedes. People are climbing on C-17s to escape the country. They're throwing their babies into the arms of U.S. military personnel. I think it's pretty hard not to get overwrought. I challenge those people who are critical of the media to go on the ground in Afghanistan and do a completely unemotive report. So, listen, there's so many different ways and there's so much smart writing that's being done on it. How do you cover it from a policy perspective? How do you cover it from, what lessons have we learned? It seems the U.S. does this over and over and over again. Can we, in fact, nation build? Can we change a country into a vision of what we think it should be?
Kara Swisher
Right. No.
Katie Couric
On the other hand, how does 9/11 change everything? I remember interviewing George W. Bush, who campaigned against nation building, the idea of committing troops and blood and treasure to military conflicts or to conflicts overseas. And he said, September 11th changed everything for me. So what I really appreciate and try to do when I cover these things is look at the long arc of history. Over a 20-year period, what has been achieved? Why did we pull back funds from the State Department to develop infrastructure? Why did we spend so much money on the military? Jeffrey Sachs had a good article about that. Two trillion dollars, so little of it went to rebuilding infrastructure and systems within Afghanistan that could have won hearts and minds over the military.
Kara Swisher
Well, not just 9/11 has changed it, but the reductiveness of people. It happens that in vaccines, everyone's either Dr. Google or experts on Afghanistan. And it sort of muddies understanding of it. It feels very reactive. Every move feels very reactive and even more so because of the non-dulcet influence of social media. And our policymakers are affected by that, it seems like. And then the groupthink that I think results from social media, right? The piling on, the provocative tweet. Then I think that gets more attention. It gets more conversation going. So I think you're right. Everything is geared toward pithy, reactive, and not necessarily deep thinking perspective on some of these big, huge events.
Katie Couric
But I just try to read as much as I can and look at many different perspectives. I interviewed my friend Kevin Baring because he was in Afghanistan with me. He's a reporter for Defense One. Just because it was interesting. We followed Bob Gates around Afghanistan and went on this international trip together. So it was really interesting to talk to him. And then I reached out to General Petraeus because I covered both Iraq and Afghanistan with him. People forget, Afghanistan was called the Forgotten War for so long because so much of our attention was diverted to Iraq. For what? And then we know how that turned out.
Kara Swisher
Last question. And when you see Trump and Biden sort of duking it out, even though both are on the same side, kind of, in terms of intent, again, it's being used.
Katie Couric
Well, it's the blame game, Kara. I mean, look at Trump is the one that negotiated with the Taliban. He set the May 1st guideline. He kept the Afghan government out of the negotiations. Which then Biden, what's interesting to me, I think, obviously, he was jonesing to get out of there and has been for a decade. But why he didn't consider, and was it PR reasons to have it before September 11th? I don't know. Why he didn't really consider or wasn't better served by the State Department and his military folks surrounding him. He could have changed that date. He could have made sure that things were put in place. And I don't know exactly what happened, but I think we're learning more and more about conversations that have been going on in the Pentagon and the White House. And I think it's a big disappointment. And I think it's going to have a really huge impact on the midterms and perhaps the rest of the Biden presidency. Who knows? I guess a lot of it depends on what happens in the next weeks and months.
Kara Swisher
See, I think people forget this stuff. Everyone wanted out of Afghanistan, the regular people, and don't care. They don't care about the Afghanis, honestly. Even though people sort of give lip service to it, I think in general, in this twitchy news environment we're in.
Katie Couric
Yeah, maybe you're right, but I'm not sure. What's going on with TikTok or whatever.
Kara Swisher
All right, let's go on a quick break and when we come back, we'll discuss California's recall election, speaking of which, and we'll talk to a friend of Pivot, Nathan Allebach.
Ad Break
Katie, we're back with our second big story. California's Republican-led recall election to remove Gavin Newsom as the state's governor is underway as ballots have made their way to registered voters. What's at stake in the September 14th recall?
Audio clip plays: "It's a matter of life and death. Why are Californians uniting to vote yes to recall Gavin Newsom? We've lost jobs and businesses are leaving."
It's really fascinating. He may lose. He may get it back again, but he may lose. California has gone through the recall process 179 times since the amendment was voted into play in 1911. Just one of those attempts removed a governor from office, and that was 2003 when Arnold Schwarzenegger came into office. Although California is a deeply Democratic state, Newsom might lose his seat to a right-wing talk show host, Larry Elder, because it's determined by a majority vote. It's crazy. So if he doesn't get 50%, if more than 50% say yes on the recall, Newsom has to step down and he'll be replaced by whichever opponent gets the most votes on the ballot, even if it's 15%. And there's a lot of people in the system. So tell me, people think that he's going to lose, actually, maybe come back. People think he's going to get recalled?
Katie Couric
Yes. That's here in California.
Kara Swisher
Interesting.
Katie Couric
Well, if that's the scuttlebutt in California, I mean, I did read some articles in preparation for our podcast here. And it sounds to me that he is not going to get recalled. I guess the big concern is voter turnout or people mailing in their recall ballots that are mailed home. Even my daughter Ellie said a lot of people really aren't paying attention to it.
Kara Swisher
They aren't. And so this hardcore anti-Newsom Republican faction is super motivated. It's not unlike the primary process. By the way, funded by some internet people. There's a bunch of internet people. And on the other side, Reed Hastings is supporting Newsom. And his name is quite prominent.
Katie Couric
Yeah, meanwhile, it's costing $200 million, which seems like a ridiculous waste of money to me. I guess Gavin Newsom, I think people are really frustrated by the way COVID was handled and all the businesses were closed. And, of course, going to the French laundry without...
Kara Swisher
California's got a surplus and the economy's doing well. And it has the lowest rates among many states. So what do you think is behind it?
Katie Couric
I think these internet guys have really decided they want to replace him. Then there's some other internet guys that don't want to.
Kara Swisher
I think there's a very strong anti-vax group of people here. I was driving across the Golden Gate Bridge yesterday to go visit my brother in Marin. And it was lined with anti-vax people with all kinds of signs, which was interesting.
Katie Couric
Yeah, they had a number of protests out there and some have turned violent, I read.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, they weren't getting a lot of beeps. They were getting a lot of fingers from people, actually, which was interesting. But the question is, were the people with their fingers up going to vote? That's really what it is. They could win by inertia. And then you'll have Larry Elder for a year. I don't think he'll stay in office, not like Schwarzenegger.
Katie Couric
Well, Larry Elder sounds pretty, pretty, pretty crazy to me. And the thing is, I think that when Gray Davis was recalled, they had Arnold Schwarzenegger on the ballot. And a lot of things that I've read say because there's nobody with the name recognition in the what? How many people are on the ballot running against him? Like 100?
Kara Swisher
I don't even know. Yeah, there's a lot. Against Newsom.
Katie Couric
That I guess in Gavin Newsom is urging people to vote no and not even write anything on the second question. But it sounds like Gavin Newsom has made some pretty serious faux pas going to the French laundry and being hypocritical.
Kara Swisher
This is a restaurant he went to where he ate semi indoors and it looked ridiculous and elite. There's a lot of pictures of Nancy Pelosi in an outdoor event, too. There's all these photos. At the very same time, people who are unvaccinated are literally just falling over dead.
Katie Couric
Right. But I think this anti-elitism is really hurting Gavin Newsom. His kids going to private school and saying he relates to families who have their kids on Zoom. I think that's the way of the world. It's class warfare. And I think he is the recipient of a lot of class resentment from conservatives in the state of California. And as you said, this sort of cabal of internet people, which I didn't really know about.
Kara Swisher
Who are they? There's a whole bunch of them. There's Paxim who've been funding these ads and pushing it. Someone like Chamath Palihapitiya, usually a very reasonable person, sort of on the Jason Calacanis. There's bunches of them.
Katie Couric
What I read is they're not very well financed, the anti-Newsom contingent.
Kara Swisher
They aren't. Reed Hastings has really stepped in on the other side. The Netflix founder has actually put his name out there. He has done a lot of various things, including anti-Newsom things in the past, I think. And he has put his actual name. It says Reed Hastings and the Democratic this and that, which I think is interesting. And isn't Larry Elder in trouble for not disclosing something, a business, some kind of business deal?
Katie Couric
Yes, yes, yes.
Kara Swisher
Oh, no, he's really quite unqualified. It's just that someone with 15% of the electorate can win over someone who was duly elected governor. That's California. Such a screwed up electoral system. It feels always like there's some wacky thing on the ballot that people are voting for. And this is the case that they can do these kind of things.
Katie Couric
Well, it's interesting. Like you said, it was started in 1911 by progressives who didn't want concentration of power. And now it's cutting both ways, right?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, absolutely. It seems like, I don't know, I wouldn't want to be. And Gavin Newsom's running for reelection in the fall. So what's the point? $200 million for what? Think of what that money could have gone to in California.
Katie Couric
Well, it's the chaos of all our politics, right? It's all over this country. And you were talking about the midterms, which people, usually the party out of office wins, but nobody knows right now.
Kara Swisher
I was talking to someone who's like, oh, the Democrats are going to win the Senate. And I was like, what? Like, huh? It's a very different time from when you were, it seemed almost quaint. You did such a devastating interview with Sarah Palin, which you're so famous for. But it seems quaint that you showed exactly what was happening there. Now it seems completely normal. She seems almost normal compared to a lot of the people.
Katie Couric
Right, like Marjorie Taylor Greene.
Kara Swisher
Taylor Greene. What would you do in that interview, Katie?
Katie Couric
Oh, my God. I don't know if I'd even want to give that woman airtime, Kara.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Well, she's down Sarah Palin Avenue. You know what I mean?
She's way down. She's like Sarah Palin, you know, times 27. I mean, I think Sarah Palin was incompetent. And I think, honestly, in fairness to her, her speech pattern and the way she expressed herself, some of the things she had to say were not that out of the mainstream. I think it's just that the way she expressed them was so confusing and kind of jabberwocky.
But I don't know. Some of these people are truly, truly terrifying, saying if someone comes to your door encouraging you to get a vaccine that, we're going to show our Second Amendment rights. And I mean, it's really scary shit. It's emboldening and enabling and encouraging a lot of really scary, violent behavior, as we saw in the Pittsburgh synagogue. These words have consequences, and these words are going to continue to have consequences. I think it's really, really terrifying.
The fact that Larry Elder might be governor of 50, and he's wacky. John, my husband, always says people get the president they deserve. But I hope that's not true.
Katie Couric
No, you know, he's saying that if people are ill-informed and not using their head when making their decisions. But I try to have more faith in the majority than that.
Kara Swisher
I don't know how you would. I don't know how you would do that same job today. Honestly, I have to say, it would be very difficult. I brought on Jason Miller on *Sway* on my podcast and people lost their minds. He's... I just was like, and it was a tough interview, but it's just really interesting what people are hearing. People didn't want you to talk to him at all. And he has the platform Trump is probably going to emerge on, so I thought that was worth talking about. He has tremendous influence in how decisions are made. I think you want to understand what people are thinking and what motivates him.
Katie Couric
If you were doing Sarah Palin, you'd get incredible pushback for having done an interview with her.
Kara Swisher
It's really... I mean, you got celebrated for it and it was a great interview.
Katie Couric
Well, she was a vice presidential candidate.
Kara Swisher
I know, but even then. Because people actually wrote me, "Let's give Trump no attention. Let's not give him attention." The problem is you're giving him attention. I'm like, he's running the Republican Party. I'm sorry. Is that attention? Okay. It's fine by me.
Katie Couric
Yeah. I mean, this is the thing. Social media has given everybody a megaphone. So every person you hear from, you've got to kind of shut them out and go with your own instinct. To not be influenced by them. But it's hard sometimes. Sometimes I write back people on Instagram like, "Why aren't you supporting our troops?" And I was like, "What? I just did a whole tribute to all the fallen service members in Afghanistan. What does that have to do with what you're talking about?"
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Don't respond to them, Katie. Call me when you want to do it.
Katie Couric
Once in a while I do because they just bug me.
Kara Swisher
Well, speaking of social media, we're going to bring in our friend of *Pivot*, Nathan Allebach, Creative Director of Allebach Communications. Nathan is a writer covering internet culture, advertising, and conspiracy theories, as well as the Twitter personality known for causing the Steak-umm account to go viral.
Katie Couric
I love this guy, Kara. I love this guy.
Kara Swisher
Hi, Nathan.
Nathan Allebach
Hi, Katie. Hi, Kara. Thanks so much for having me.
Kara Swisher
Good. So let's listen to some vintage advertising from the Steak-umm brand.
Audio clip plays: "Got a minute? Then you've got time for a hot steak sandwich. Keep Steak-umm frozen till you're ready to eat. Then stick them in the frying pan. 60 seconds later, take them off the heat and fix them up any way you can. Try Steak-umm on a roll with cheese. Top it any way you please. Steak-umm sandwich steaks. They're 100% pure beef and nothing else."
Fast forward to Steak-umm branding on Nathan's Twitter. I'm going to read one of his tweets. Quote, "We are just a frozen meat brand tweeting into the void, hoping to provoke thought, inspire unity, and relay useful information." Really not the same kind of tone. So Katie, take it away.
Katie Couric
Well, Nathan, first of all, congratulations on your success. You have how many Twitter followers at this point?
Nathan Allebach
It's somewhere over 200,000, I think.
Katie Couric
Well, I've been fascinated reading about you this morning. I did my homework for this podcast because Kara terrifies me. But I think what you're doing is so fascinating. Tell us how you found your voice on Twitter, because it's very distinctive. I know you go for authenticity, and I would say it's observational humor and insight. Why don't you tell everybody why you started doing this and how you found that voice?
Nathan Allebach
Sure. I started through our agency running the Twitter account in mid-2017. There was little to no oversight in the beginning because the account had about 1,000 inactive followers. The client didn't take it that seriously compared to Facebook and Instagram and the rest. So there was a lot of room to experiment with the voice and figure out what was working and what wasn't. It was just a few months of me and our team working through what bits people were connecting with, what other brands were doing. I honestly wasn't super familiar with Wendy's doing their sassy clapbacks. I wasn't super familiar with what other brands were even doing on Twitter. So it was a lot of just figuring out what the landscape looked like and what people were open to hearing. Because I had such little oversight from the beginning, I was able to be more myself, be a little bit more human in interacting with people. People felt it was a lot more personal off the bat. At the time, I was just kind of messing around, figuring this out. There wasn't a whole lot of strategy behind it.
Katie Couric
So you didn't have all that research that they always say you have to do?
Nathan Allebach
No.
Kara Swisher
I mean, that's why I think it works so well, Nathan. It was very spontaneous. It was very you. They're incredibly sort of world-weary. Talk about that.
Nathan Allebach
It's funny because if it wasn't a brand saying the things that we were saying, I think the tone would almost sound condescending to a lot of people. And I think it does still sound condescending to people as the brand. It's like, "Why is this meat brand lecturing us about critical thinking or media literacy?" So we try to use neutral language and moderate the language. We try to make it sound as safe as we can, but also in a way that touches on things people are thinking about and care about. As everybody here knows, Twitter is a super toxic platform. It's a 24-hour news machine, and people are always looking for the latest hot takes and the latest thing to get mad about. So I think the fact that we took that moderate approach to try to figure out, "Let's pump the brakes, let's depolarize, here's how we can think about this surface-level concept in a way that inspires thinking versus us telling you."
Kara Swisher
But you're not particularly friendly. You were talking about... I agree with you, you're funny in a way that isn't necessarily "eat some steaks, eat some Steak-umm," right? What's the goal and why do you think it works?
Katie Couric
I wanted to ask you about that to follow up on Kara. Does this really sell Steak-umm? To me, you're delivering truth bombs. You're helping people connect the dots. What does it really have to do with selling your product? And what has it done for sales?
Nathan Allebach
We do have data from the past couple of years over various spikes. Especially in the beginning, around 2018, we started to pick up on this. We weren't running other advertising anywhere, so we could correlate a lot easier. We saw a clear spike in sales here, and this is right when we had this massive viral moment that hit national headlines. So we can correlate to a certain degree. It's a little harder now because of the pandemic, especially frozen foods are flying off the shelves. So it's not as one-to-one. But I think overall, the PR net benefit of the earned media the brand has gotten has been pretty unprecedented. So there's that element of it.
Kara Swisher
And then there's also young people, right? Young people think it's cool.
Nathan Allebach
Exactly.
Kara Swisher
So that's what I was going to say. The product has been around since the 70s, so it has this legacy impact where a lot of Gen Xers have a memory of eating it growing up. But a lot of millennials and Zoomers aren't familiar at all with it. So this is kind of their introduction to it, which the style of Twitter has helped reach them.
Katie Couric
And in fact, you did this because you wanted to connect with younger consumers, right? You wanted the brand to be more relevant. So it sounds to me like even brand recognition, having these *bon mots* come from the Steak-umm account... it's so random and very much fits in with the Twitter ethos.
Nathan Allebach
Right.
Kara Swisher
Did you go to other social? Did you think about Facebook or TikTok or Snapchat? Why Twitter?
Nathan Allebach
We've tried TikTok and we've had varying success there. We've been using other platforms on and off over the years. But especially with organic reach, organic reach is almost dead for Facebook and it's more and more difficult for Instagram. With Twitter, it's such an easy platform to just get heard. You could have no following, you could have no paid budget, and you can put a tweet out there into the ether and suddenly it blows up if it's the right reply to the right person at the right time. So it was an opportunity to explore and figure out what worked for the brand. Then we've been able to extrapolate a lot of the voice and the things that have worked on Twitter to other platforms.
Katie Couric
You know what's really interesting, Kara? I think from everything I've read, this works because of Nathan. Not to blow smoke, Nathan, but people say you're incredibly well-read, you're clever, you're really smart. I can attest from reading some of your Medium posts about conspiracy theories, which honestly sounded like a doctorate.
Nathan Allebach
Oh, geez.
Katie Couric
First of all, they're very long, Nathan. Can you maybe get a better editor there? But no, Kara, they are so well-researched. I don't know if you've read some of Nathan's stuff.
Kara Swisher
I have, because one of the things that's interesting is the Twitter feed reads like someone who is unloading their college education on us. Like, "Oh, yeah, that. I remember that." And I think it works really well because it's super smart and it doesn't hide from smart. That's one of the things. And then the juxtaposition of it being a steak brand, a frozen meat brand, is sort of funny. But when you're doing the conspiracy theory stuff, what made you do that? Because then I understood why the Steak-umm tweets are the way they are once I read those. So talk a little bit about that.
Nathan Allebach
The conspiracy theory and misinformation bits just naturally arose last year at the height of COVID in the beginning, just because there was so much of it. It felt very unprecedented online. Obviously we've all seen misinfo over the years, but it felt like a boiling point. A lot of people were talking about "those stupid people over there" and how absurd this one conspiracy theory is, with a lot of hot take commentary. But there wasn't a lot of good long-form analysis breaking down why some of these things were happening. So I started pulling from some of the work I've done in my free time, researching the psychology of conspiracy theories and the history of why some of this stuff has come to be. I thought it'd be interesting to take the bits that are the most depolarized, the most easy to grasp, and break them down into short spurts through the Steak-umm account and see what connected. With the timing of the pandemic, I think it really hit a lot of people. So it worked at the time.
Katie Couric
I was going to ask you, Nathan, why do you think it resonated so much, particularly during the pandemic? I love the way you read and listen to podcasts and write notes. But you talked about especially young people feeling just so disconnected and so miserable that the tenor of what you were doing seemed to really resonate. Can you expand on that a little bit?
Nathan Allebach
I think a big part of why the Steak-umm content connected with younger people specifically is the fact that we don't shy away from the fact that we are a brand and what we're doing is advertising. There's a meta self-awareness to it that puts some people at ease. It puts other people more on edge. The people who are already cynical and critical of advertising and manufacturing consent and the whole ecosystem of how media and marketing interact, those people look at it like it's malicious and dystopian. But I think generally, a lot of young people who spend time scrolling through Twitter or TikTok every day and are getting run down by the attention economy of it all, seeing a brand break these ideas down in a really self-aware way is like, "Oh, whoa, I'm not used to seeing that on my timeline." It snaps them out of the doom-scrolling cycle. They take a second, get to the end of it, and think, "Oh, I just was advertised to." And that creates a weird distance.
Kara Swisher
I'll have a lovely steak. But when you think about the conspiracy theories, Katie and I were just talking about them. She's done a lot of interviews that today would have gotten twisted. I would love to have seen the reaction of, say, the Palin interview today in the Twitter space. But this age of conspiracy theories and mistrust is not new, it's just been more accelerated. So how do you look at the platforms? Because you often talk about them with the Steak-umm brand. What can the platforms do to catch it earlier rather than damage control?
Nathan Allebach
Damage control is all they do. That's the big thing. I talk to friends about this all the time. Everything they're doing is reactive instead of proactive. The distrust is so heavily built into the platforms at this point, from both the far left and the far right, and people in between have gotten cynical to all of them as well. I think creating more transparent messaging is key. It's a cliché at this point because everybody says it, but being open about their processes and how they're analyzing what constitutes misinformation and what the gradients are. It's a spectrum, not just "this thing is fake news and this thing is not." Sometimes it's that simple, but oftentimes it's more complex. That's where the distrust builds. It doesn't build over "so-and-so got this fact wrong and now they've been suspended." It builds from the gray areas that aren't coherently explained by the platforms. They just make these decisions on a whim.
Kara Swisher
Which Zuckerberg alluded to just recently. He's like, "So it's confusing." I'm like, okay. Yeah, super helpful. Thanks.
Katie Couric
Well, you know, Kara, I'm taking part in this Aspen Institute Commission on Disinformation. And Nathan, I think you're so right. I think transparency is job number one, because if we don't know how the systems work, how things are being channeled to people, how they're rating content, how they're correcting content, it's really hard. And if researchers can't really have access to it, it's hard to come up with things that are more proactive and less reactive. I noticed at the end of one of your posts, you put a lot of things about media literacy, which puts so much onus on the consumer. I think that's critically important, but it puts so much onus on the consumer. We're going to have to go from both channels. It'll be interesting when we come up with some of our recommendations if they're going to fall on deaf ears. What do you guys think, Kara, particularly Facebook? Do you think Facebook is going to change?
Kara Swisher
No. No, it's been reactive from day one on every topic, whether it's privacy or misinformation.
Katie Couric
So you think it's going to take government intervention?
Kara Swisher
Never done better financially. There's no incentive for them to do it, and they don't think they're wrong. One of the things that's interesting, and what Nathan's writing about, is that there are a lot of people saying, "So what if there's disinformation? Disinformation is policed." You've seen a number of pretty prominent internet pundits talk about that. "Don't be a mommy state. Don't do this. Don't do that." And I think they don't understand the insidious nature of propaganda and how it works in any era. It sounds crazy, but Hitler didn't need Twitter to do what he did. Mussolini didn't need Instagram. Stalin didn't need TikTok. Although that idea is kind of crazy to think about. But Nathan, I'd love you to think about that, because you are in the brand space, you are in the advertising space, but it does veer right over into propaganda really quickly. This particular medium is quite good for it. How do you do better? Is the media chasing it? Is it that people aren't media literate? Is it that people will fall for anything? Where do you see an out on this? Because I've learned a lot of things from the steak brand for some reason.
Nathan Allebach
I think you both just touched on it. I think there has to be more of an institutional push to get some of this stuff into legislation. Individually, it seems like what Steak-umm is doing in a weird advertising way, and what a lot of other smaller public institutions and even some private institutions are doing, is trying to empower the individual. "Hey, the internet's a crazy place. Put on your critical thinking cap, learn how to be media literate." That's great, and we should continue to do that. But on a mass media level, it is just so discouraging to see this stuff happen. With vaccine hesitancy, we all know you have the power individually to maybe convince your mom or your sister.
But you as an individual don't have much power at all over your community at large, over your state. It dissipates the broader these problems get. So I think there has to be some public pressure mounted to push for legislation, whether it's reform on the platforms themselves or some kind of new policy that reinvigorates media literacy within public institutions. But even that is a long-term fix, getting it through the education system versus something at a top level that curbs this before it gets worse.
Kara Swisher
I'll let Katie ask the last question, but I'll note that it's actually companies that are doing this. Whether it's Steak-umm, whether it's Patagonia, which is essentially "fuck you, Tucker Carlson." I don't know if you saw their recent stuff. They're doing a lot of edgy stuff. Or Disney pushing back on Ron DeSantis. That's a big deal when they did that. So it is interesting that some companies are leading the way into this. People aren't paying as much attention to the Disney-DeSantis thing, but boy, that's not good for him.
Katie Couric
Well, I'll just add to that. They are the governor of Florida.
Nathan Allebach
Yeah, just real quick. I definitely think we're at a time, especially in the post-pandemic world, especially since the BLM movement last year took off, where a lot of brands are forced or pressured to position themselves in causal ways. It's like, "What's something that we can stand behind?" Whether it's a social justice cause or an issue of the day, something that's going to differentiate them in this space where everybody's trying to be everything all the time and nobody's really taking a stand. You saw a lot of brands during BLM say, "We stand with Black Lives Matter," and then they did one post and never talked about it again, versus the Ben & Jerry's model, which is, "Let's make this part of our actual brand identity." So I think you're seeing more and more of that. Patagonia is one of them.
Katie Couric
And in fact, not to do a shameless plug for Katie Couric Media, but that's really the whole foundation for our company. We're taking purpose-driven brands, companies that need to take positions and explore important issues, whether it's climate change or gender equality or social justice or racial justice, and trying to do storytelling with a very light touch because it's brand-supported, not branded content. If you look at the Edelman Trust Barometer, the Business Roundtable, these companies, in order to retain employees, especially younger employees, Nathan, as you know, they want to work for a company that cares about more than just the bottom line. They want to feel proud about the company they're working at. As trust in institutions like the government and financial institutions has declined, people are looking to corporate leaders. That's why Ken Chenault and Ken Frazier are speaking out on voting rights in Georgia. That's where the vacuum is being filled in many ways. So we saw this as a big opening, Kara. Democracy is at stake. Do you understand this? We understand the task.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, Nathan, thank you so much.
Katie Couric
Nathan, where can people reach you? Your Medium posts?
Nathan Allebach
I'm at Nathan Allebach everywhere. So you search my name, I'll pop up.
Katie Couric
At Nathan Allebach. And are you sporting a 'mun? Because I was looking forward to seeing your long hair.
Nathan Allebach
Oh, yeah. I've got the 'mun.
Kara Swisher
What's a 'mun?
Katie Couric
What is a 'mun?
Nathan Allebach
It's a man bun.
Katie Couric
It took me a second there, too.
Nathan Allebach
But next time, I'll wear it down for you, Katie.
Katie Couric
Thank you, Nathan.
Kara Swisher
Okay, all right. Okay, Nathan, thank you so much.
Nathan Allebach
Okay, bye, Nathan.
Kara Swisher
All right, Katie, one more quick break. We'll be back for wins and fails.
Ad break
So wins and fails, Katie. Come on, wins and fails.
Katie Couric
I have just one win today if you'd like me to start.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, you start.
Katie Couric
Do you know JoJo Siwa?
Kara Swisher
Yes. She's a dancing fiend.
Katie Couric
She'll become the first contestant on *Dancing with the Stars* to compete with a same-sex partner during the show's 30th season. She is an absurd figure. My two-year-old daughter loves her and thinks she's the best.
Kara Swisher
I think she's crazy looking. But nonetheless, she's highly entertaining, and she's come out as a lesbian.
Katie Couric
Yes.
Kara Swisher
And she is going to dance with the stars with a lady. I think it's great. Go, JoJo.
Katie Couric
That is awesome. And I have no idea what this whole segment's about, Kara, so you're going to help me because I didn't see it. Give me a win this week and a fail this week, something that you think worked really well and something that failed.
Kara Swisher
I think what failed was all these conservative talk show hosts who are having these deathbed conversions and saying they wish they had gotten vaccinated. I guess some people see that as a win. People say, "Darwin, take the wheel" or "natural selection." But I see it as a failure to respect and appreciate science. That's really, really troubling every time I see that happen.
Katie Couric
Yeah, they depress me too. A 30-year-old guy with three kids and a child on the way. His wife got the vaccine and they joked about being on different sides. He's 30 years old. He dies of COVID.
Kara Swisher
I have a family situation like that. They just got the vaccine, thank God.
Katie Couric
What put them over the top and made them do it?
Kara Swisher
I'm going to say who it is. It's someone very close to me. The wife got the vaccine, was very close. Everyone in the family has gotten the vaccine, obviously. I think hearing people complain to them... I don't think it was for good reasons. It was, "Everybody needs to shut up and leave me alone" kind of thing. Not because anti-vaxxers are dying. Not to protect people.
Katie Couric
No.
Kara Swisher
Actually, one reaction was, "Well, you got to die of something." I said, "Why don't you just go drive into that wall there then? What the hell?" It was weird. But nonetheless, vaccinated. So, whatever. It was a win, I guess.
Katie Couric
I think Nathan writes a lot about that, about the reasons people are vaccine hesitant. People dig their heels in more when they're criticized or they feel like smug know-it-alls are telling them what to do. It's really interesting from a psychological point of view. So if you can somehow compassionately explain and help people understand, but that's pretty hard to do in big numbers, isn't it?
Kara Swisher
It is. It's hard to do in small numbers. It's hard to get people off of certain things. It's also just tribalism. As you know, I talk about my mom a lot and Fox News. She was with me for a few days and I could see how it twisted her. She had these ideas and I'm like, "Factually, this is correct." "No, no, no." And it took at least an hour to show things before I could convince. And that iterates itself all over the place. So it's a bad, meaty environment.
I'm excited. Of course, I've invited you to go to talk about this, and you're not coming. But nonetheless, we would like to have you there to discuss this report you're doing. So very quickly, Katie, that's the show. But talk about it. You're doing this report with the Aspen Institute. You're working on that. This is about disinformation. You've got an amazing group. Chris Krebs. You've got Rashad. As you mentioned, yourself. It's a great group of people working on this report for Aspen. You also have your media company, which you've mentioned, and your newsletter. But your book is coming out. How do you feel about it?
It's quite good. It's scary because it memoir. You went there on a couple of things. I was very pleased to see.
Katie Couric
Yes. My husband, John, kept saying, if you're not going to be honest, don't write a book. So it's very honest. I think it's probably going to ruffle a few feathers out there. But it's from my perspective and what I experienced. When you're a public figure—if I guess I was for many years—people write about you and you really don't have a chance to reflect or express what it was like being in that position. So it felt really good and liberating to say, "Hey, this is what happened. This is my experience." Hopefully it'll be illuminating to people and interesting. I think a lot of women will—
Kara Swisher
You definitely are someone who people have ideas of that are not like what people think you're like. It's very interesting. This will be a really interesting book, even though you did not give it the title that I wanted, but that's okay. *Anchor Monster*. *Anchor Monster*. That's what I want you to call it. Because I wanted you to go there.
Katie Couric
Yeah, because a network executive described me as such. To me. And he wanted me to print it, and I declined to do so.
Kara Swisher
What a dick.
Katie Couric
And he wanted you—I know. That's what I thought. And off the record. He didn't want to say who he was. He just wanted you to say that, which I think is very illustrative of the endemic sexism and the kind of double standard—I get sort of tired of that term, but it's true that women of my era in TV news had to deal with on a constant basis.
Kara Swisher
It's interesting. What is it called? So people will buy it.
Katie Couric
It's called *Going There*.
Kara Swisher
*Going There*. I wanted to call it *Moxie*, but nobody else liked that.
Katie Couric
*Moxie*, no.
Kara Swisher
Well, *Moxie*—my dad used to say, "Katie, you've got moxie." It means spirit and determination. You do got moxie, Katie Couric. But nonetheless. I also like the way the word looks with an X right in the middle. I think that would have looked graphically interesting, but it also resonated with my life story. Nobody liked it. So we did *Going There* because it has many different meanings. I go there and I really tell the truth, but I had to go there at different points in my career and take chances and do things.
Yeah, you have a fascinating career. People should read this. Katie has done a lot of different things, including going to Yahoo, doing all this independent stuff. It's a really interesting journey. There are obviously things that you're going to want to read about that got more attention than other things recently around Matt Lauer and things like that.
Katie Couric
Yeah, I talk a lot about Me Too and Matt and what that was like, really how I processed that whole thing. I talk a lot about losing my husband to colon cancer when he was 42, and our daughters were six and two, and I was 41, and my sister a few years later. So I would say it's incredibly candid and raw.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. And I talk about—I thought it was very—you did the Catherine Graham thing. I mean, of all things. And that was another—I think it'll be surprising to people. And people will like it quite a bit.
Katie Couric
I guess. Do you think people do kind of pigeonhole people and caricature them? Don't you think?
Kara Swisher
Let me just give you some advice. What the fuck do you care? You're Katie Couric. Okay. That would have been a good title for my book: *I'm Fucking Katie Couric*. Drop the mic, drop the mic.
Katie Couric
All right, Kara, I had so many good titles for your show.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, that's the show. You can find a link to subscribe to Katie's newsletter, *Wake Up Call*, in the Pivot channel. It's by our book, which is on sale when?
Katie Couric
Oh, October 26th, but pre-order now because it all counts for the first week, right?
Kara Swisher
All right, okay, always selling, Katie. Okay, we'll be back Friday for more. Go to nymag.com slash pivot to submit your questions for the Pivot podcast. The link is also in our show notes. Today's show was produced by Lara Neyman, Caroline Shagrin, and Taylor Griffin. Ernie Anderdot engineered this episode. Make sure you subscribe to the show on Apple Podcasts. If you're an Android user, check us out on Spotify or frankly, wherever you listen to podcasts. If you liked our show, please recommend it to a friend. Thanks for listening to Pivot from New York Magazine and Vox Media. We'll be back later this week with George Hahn, actually, for another breakdown of all things tech and business. And then Scott Galloway shall be back after Labor Day. Katie, thank you so much.
Katie Couric
Kara, so fun being with you. And thanks, ladies, behind the scenes.
Ad break for Starbucks Pumpkin Spice Latte