Main Topic: The podcast discusses various topics, including the importance of dialogue and less destruction in conversations, especially regarding sensitive issues like transgender rights. Other topics include the impact of social media on mental health, the supply chain crisis, and the future of global trade.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Kara Swisher
Not all journalism is the same. Take The Guardian. Our coverage has something unique. Fierce independence. Nobody owns us or tells us what we can and can't say. So we're free to report the whole picture. We connect what's happening in Washington to the rest of the globe. Expose corruption wherever we find it. And give fresh perspective on everything. From wellness and soccer to culture, the climate and more. Read, watch and listen to The Guardian for free at theguardian.com.
Avoiding your unfinished home projects because you're not sure where to start? Thumbtack knows homes, so you don't have to. Don't know the difference between matte paint finish and satin? Or what that clunking sound from your dryer is? With Thumbtack, you don't have to be a home pro. You just have to hire one. You can hire top-rated pros, see price estimates, and read reviews all on the app. Download today.
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And I'm Scott Galloway.
Kara Swisher
So, Scott, tell people what you had done today, what the procedure you had done today, and we should urge everyone to do them.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I'm at that age where every time I go into the dermatologist, they're like, "Yeah, we should probably take that off and biopsy it. That looks funny." I just went, and I'm literally five pounds lighter. I left a lot of my person back at the dermatologist this morning.
Kara Swisher
Do you feel good? You feel safe? We want you around for a long time, Scott.
Scott Galloway
I appreciate that. Yeah, look, the key to any of this—and I actually thought about going—I haven't had a colonoscopy in six years. When Katie Couric was on your show, I think a lot of things would... first and foremost, I think about having a probe go up my ass. But anyways, I'm going to go get a colonoscopy.
Kara Swisher
Well, they put you out. They use that awesome drug that Michael Jackson was on.
Scott Galloway
Propofol, they do.
Kara Swisher
Oh, that stuff is gangster. I had it done. It's really great, actually.
Scott Galloway
That is a great drug. You drink stuff before. We feel like the geriatric.
Kara Swisher
Oh, God, let me tell you. You drink stuff before and it cleans you out. Like things that I ate...
Scott Galloway
That is the understatement of the century.
Kara Swisher
What? Cleans you out. Glue from like kindergarten was in there. Paste that I ate was in there and it came out. You feel so clean and fresh. Weirdly, it's a good thing to do.
Scott Galloway
Good. I'm glad. When are you going? Did you go?
Kara Swisher
I'll give you the other version of that. Okay. I drank the same liquid. Yeah. And I felt as if I had a damn release out of my innards. I thought I was shitting out a lung. I could not believe how much it takes out of you. Anyway, sorry to go there. But anyways, went to the dermatologist. I feel much better.
Scott Galloway
Good. You should. Everybody, we suggest you do any and all things that get scored off all kinds of cancers. Because a lot of preventative care is better.
Kara Swisher
So what should we talk about? There's so much going on. We could talk about Succession. That was good last night. I think everyone was all excited. How much do we love Succession? Do you love it as much as I do?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I do.
Kara Swisher
I'm doing a podcast about it. I'm a super fan. I'm a crazy super fan.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. It was good. It was really good. And there's more to come.
Kara Swisher
I can't. I've seen some episodes. It's one of those things where it's like...
Scott Galloway
Good writing. I am disgusted by everybody on the show and yet would like to have sex with all of them.
Kara Swisher
Yes, they're handsome people. It straddles that line. Also, in terms of super fan, I'm seriously contemplating getting a tattoo that says "Cousin Greg."
Scott Galloway
Oh, right. I'm kind of obsessed with them. A press release about some vibrator that goes on every time he says something.
Kara Swisher
Oh, yeah. Every time he comes in the room. I wrote about that, too.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I think I'm not going to talk about that.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I think the writing is beautiful. I'm interviewing one of the writers. I did, and it's for the third episode, I think. And she's a playwright. They're all such good writers. It's crazy good.
Scott Galloway
You're right. They're terrible people you care about. Does that make sense?
Kara Swisher
That makes sense. They've done a nice job with that. And it's close enough to business that it's believable in many ways, especially all the antics that happen behind the scenes.
Scott Galloway
But speaking of antics, Netflix employees will stage a virtual walkout on Wednesday to protest statements by Ted Sarandos regarding Dave Chappelle's new special. It also announced its quarterly earnings today. Squid Game may be worth $900 million.
Kara Swisher
I mean, this was a good choice. They're quite good on certain... It's interesting because some of the stuff that got released with Dave Chappelle shows that what they pay him, they don't get back. Like they got back less than they pay him. And then certain things, like there was a show by another guy, and I can't remember, I'm blanking on his name, but he cost this and made a ton of money. Obviously, Squid Game is a big deal. Squid Game, excuse me, not Squid Games, Squid Game is...
Scott Galloway
Oh, it'll be games. There's going to be sequels.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, there's going to be sequels. And they're doing real ones. But it's interesting. You think nothing will happen about this. It'll just pass. They like their radical transparency at Netflix. Everyone says their piece and then moves on.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. Listening transparency. Well, the Chappelle thing is really... I mean, it's gotten bigger and bigger. And I think it's really interesting. And I think it's promoting progress as a function of conflict and debate. And I think we're having a lot of good dialogue here. I think it's important. Comedy is supposed to provoke. And I've been thinking a lot about this lately. The wonderful thing about comedy is that it disarms you. And you don't immediately go to your corner. You're more open to evolving around thought or at least thinking through issues as opposed to going, "Okay, this person said this, so I'm immediately against it." And good comedy is supposed to provoke. They have to straddle a line between provoking and just saying something dumb and offensive that's wrong, especially in this era. And he has the power to do it.
Kara Swisher
The thing I don't like about it or the thing I was thinking about is that everyone's going after—a lot of people are going after Netflix. A lot of people are going after Chappelle. A lot of people are going after the trans people who complain, just so you know. I wrote a column about it and I got plenty of that, but go ahead.
Scott Galloway
Well, that's right. That's right. And my feeling is this dialogue is really important and productive. I mean, I'll give you an example. George Takei came out with a tweet and he said, "Replace every time he referenced the trans community with the Jewish community or Asians." Well, he did a few jokes that were... And I thought, this is really interesting. He's right. It would have been swifter and harsher. But what I think is unfortunate about our present state is that rather than having a dialogue, 80% of our energy goes to... I think I disagree. I want to move to destruction.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I would agree. I have to say the reaction that I got to—I wrote a column about it in the Times and it was interesting. Everyone's like, "You don't want him to talk." I'm like, I said he was gifted and I literally was so nuanced. I talked about the day before. I was like, I said, "I like him. I think he's talented. He's usually funny. This wasn't funny." That's all. And then someone was like, "You like Hannah Gadsby and she didn't do as well." I'm like, "And I like zucchini and maybe you don't." I think he went too far. Did you see Hannah's statement?
Scott Galloway
Yes, I did. Indeed, I did. Really shocked me.
Kara Swisher
It's interesting. The critics love Hannah. The audience doesn't as much.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, she's tough. And the critics don't like... the critics don't like Chappelle.
Kara Swisher
That's not true. Oh my God. Dave Chappelle gets kissed up and down from the critics. You just don't have to like this set. That is the inability for you to say, "I don't like this." I think he went on too long. Went on too long is what I would say. Not that he shouldn't have talked about it.
Scott Galloway
Anyway, whatever. But it's bringing up an important dialogue. And what I take from it is, okay, so there are people out there who feel like the transgender community's restrictions around nomenclature and how and when words are used, they feel it's too tight and we can't have an open conversation on the other side. It just feels as if people should demonstrate a little bit more grace and go, "This community has just taken so much shit that maybe we would want to give them." Let's come to an agreement where they're going to say, "All right, if we want to have an open dialogue around giving schools that let kids identify with a different gender and start taking hormones without their parents' permission, that's a worthwhile conversation. And we shouldn't be labeled as TERF." And at the same time, to not acknowledge that this community has endured such incredible hostility... It feels there's got to be a meeting of the minds where we're a little bit more generous with each other.
Kara Swisher
It's very hard. You know, it's the same thing on Pete Buttigieg and the parental leave, all the...
Scott Galloway
That's just homophobia. It was crazy. That's just straight up homophobia. I'm a father of four. I'm like, "You've never touched a diaper, sir."
Kara Swisher
I'm a mother of four. So they're not going after the husbands of straight couples. And they make comments like "He's learning how to breastfeed." That's just pure... That is just such a dog whistle for homophobia.
Scott Galloway
I know it really is. It's like pro wrestling with these people. You know what scares me about all of this? So I apologize. I worry that we're going to lose the house because of this. I think Bernie Sanders summarized it perfectly. And he said, "People are sick of talking about bathrooms." I think that the Democratic platform should be, "We're for civil rights, full stop." But I think if they take the bait and start talking about trans rights and make it a big part of their platform, I think a lot of people are going to go, "These people are out of touch."
Kara Swisher
When is the right time? Honestly, it reminds me a lot of when gay marriage was going on. "Was this going to lose us this?" Too bad. Then we lose. Then we lose. Then we can make better arguments. But in any case, we have to move on. But this is some little red meat for you. Harvard announced that its endowment grew to $53.2 billion. Endowment produced fewer returns than most major universities. Yale, for example, had returns of 40% compared to Harvard's 33.6%. That's a lot of moolah. So what do you think about that?
Scott Galloway
Well, look, the Ivy League has decided that they're a Birkin bag, they're not public servants, and they can grow their endowment. I mean, get this, Harvard was only up 34%. MIT's was up 56%. Brown was up 52%. And yet, their year-on-year increase in freshman seats...
Kara Swisher
How many?
Scott Galloway
1.2%. They decided to increase because they've decided that anyone who already has a degree and the faculty there like to get around in a big circle jerk and talk about how we're Birkin bags. Aren't we just amazing? And instead of taking this transformative experience called higher education and incredible certification and opportunities that Harvard and the Ivy League does afford people, we've decided to pull up the bridge behind us. $53.2 billion. What the hell? Well, why aren't they giving everybody a Harvard education? Well, why on earth? And by the way, I don't believe everyone has the right to go to college. I don't believe everyone has the right to go to Harvard. But for God's sakes, we salute growing Google. We grow Google 40% a year. We grow Facebook 60% a year. But we can't grow...
Kara Swisher
I may interject.
Scott Galloway
Hold on. We can't grow the University of North Carolina or Michigan or great public schools more than 2% a year. I was talking to a student yesterday who's trying to get into a bunch of schools, wants to go to MIT. So I introduced her to my ex-wife. And one of the things she was saying was like, "This is the percent... this is how many get in versus how many apply." And it was all these tiny number percentages. And she was just saying them. And I said, "Is that a good thing?" And she was like, "What?" And I said, "It's not a good thing. That's a bad statistic." And it was the first time she was like, "Oh, you're kind of right." The student, because they get them on these hamster wheels of achievement. And it's just... this person deserved to go to all of them. So many good qualities. And it just sort of left a dark taste in my mouth.
It's done two things. It's turned spring into what used to be a joyous, but nervous moment or season for a lot of households who were fortunate enough and blessed enough to have kids who are college capable and turn it into the season of despair. I mean, it really is. This is just crushing for some kids and their parents. They get arbitraged down because of this corrupt cartel called higher education where we all raise our prices in concert with one another. And we all arbitrage them down to a Hyundai for a Mercedes price and, in effect, reallocation of capital for middle-class homes to the faculty and administrators and endowments of this incredibly corrupt cartel. It's devastating for young people. Why on earth? We think Google's great. Okay, let's scale it 40% a year. Who has an argument with the University of North Carolina? Who has an argument with the life-changing, better society? Let me ask you something. Are we better off with Facebook tripling in the next five years? Or are great public schools tripling their enrollment in the next five years?
Kara Swisher
You know, they should have like...
Scott Galloway
Where would the world be better?
Kara Swisher
They should have you get in to go to the actual campus or you get in online. Like you get... if you're like... I don't know. Hybrid teaching. Different. Buy universities that are failing and create more space.
Scott Galloway
Yep, space. Online learning. Kara and Scott want to go to Harvard, Kara? We're ready.
Kara Swisher
Can you imagine us? That would be a sitcom. Neither of us could get in, could we?
Scott Galloway
No.
Kara Swisher
I want to go to a place with a good football team. That not Harvard. Sports are fun. We have to move on to big stories. I allowed you to rant.
Scott Galloway
And a Greek system.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. I was president of the Interfraternity Council. You can be the president. I'm not going to join a fraternity with you. That is never happening.
Scott Galloway
Oh, so much fun. I'm the person that says, "You know who I am?" I'm the person that goes, "Quiet down." That was who I was in college. "Hey, kids, you're making a lot of noise."
Kara Swisher
Anyway, first big story. More bad news for teens on social media. This time it's TikTok. Doctors are reporting—this is the strangest story—young female patients developing tics. The Wall Street Journal says that TikTok may be to blame. Videos tagged with Tourette's have over a billion views on TikTok. Some of the most followed Tourette's influencers report getting new tics from watching others. I don't even understand this. Meanwhile, The Guardian identified two dozen TikTok hashtags associated with eating disorders. The tagged videos have billions of views. Facebook's, of course, not out of it.
They're the OG on this one. The Times reports that Facebook targeted teenagers with nearly all of its marketing budget starting in 2018. What a surprise. Its goal was to get users as young as 13 into the Facebook ecosystem however they could, especially Instagram, I'm guessing. Meanwhile, new documents in the Facebook files show that the site's AI is bad at catching hate speech and violence. Facebook employees estimate it catches only a low single digit percent of posts that violate its rules. Overall, here we are again. And now we're with Tourette's tics, which I didn't even understand this story.
Scott, please go on.
Scott Galloway
I don't know about you, but this story... absolutely. It's speculative, just so you know.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I mean, that's the problem. We really don't—and I'm going to acknowledge a lot of the stuff I put forward about a link between Instagram and teen depression. There hasn't been great research. There's not conclusive research showing if, in fact, it does cause teen depression. There's a lot of anecdotal evidence, but a lot of it is that these platforms don't want to give data to researchers.
Scott Galloway
But anyways, I saw this and it really chilled me. I thought, first off, it seemed weird. I mean, supposedly a lot of kids are coming into therapists and repeating the word "beans" over and over. I mean, it's just... we are going into uncharted territory here around the young brain and how it evolves and what can set it off.
Kara Swisher
Do you remember there was a horror movie, like literally 20 or 30 years ago, where if kids watched this show and they were wearing a mask, like their head turned into a pigmented?
Scott Galloway
Yes, or else the Tide Pod. But the best thing, nobody owes Chappelle more than Facebook right now. Because all of a sudden, the news cycle moved away from these extreme dieting sites that Facebook was recommending to girls struggling with eating disorders. Now it's gone to Chappelle. But there is... I was really, I mean, I don't know about you, I was incredibly rattled to see this.
Kara Swisher
The thing I just wanted to share. It's all speculative too, but I don't... it's being reported, which is anecdotal. What it is, is I had a really interesting interview with Maria Ressa, who just won the Nobel Prize. And she was talking about this sort of stuff. She's the one that was very early in 2016-17. She was one of the few people who were talking about this, especially because she was the subject of these attacks, especially on Facebook. She spoke to Mark Zuckerberg directly, who almost completely ignored her. In any case, she was talking about it in a way, a new way. She's like, "It's behavioral change that's happening here on a mass scale." Not that it hasn't happened before, but it's on a mass scale, in a way with propaganda that works, that really works on shifting the human brain. I thought that was probably correct.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, it's fascinating. I think there's going to be more and more conversations around Section 230 and health and removing some of these limits. I love the idea that's been put forward. I had lunch with Jeff Bucas, and he highlighted this idea that seems so elegant to me: that you remove Section 230 if a platform uses its algorithm to elevate content because effectively it's become an editor at that point. And that's when, similar to Fox or CNN, that's when they're liable—when they choose to use their platform for profit to elevate and possibly defame or spread content that with a little bit of fact-checking they could find out there's no veracity to. And I think that's an incredibly elegant solution. I'm going to write about it this week in my No Mercy No Malice post. I think that Section 231, if you will, should be legislation that says those protections are removed the moment an algorithm identifies content and decides to elevate it, because you've become a publisher, you're not a platform at that point.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Well, I'd agree. I think it's really interesting. It's an interesting time. And I think one of the things is the amplification part. I want to say this has existed before. I mean, we've all... there have been mass crazes among teens, et cetera, forever. But I do think this working on the brain and the repetitive nature of it and the propaganda nature of it is something that I think researchers should really be able to have access to so they understand it and making the links or not. I suspect it's not, it's just an amplified version of things that have happened before. And it restresses, if you also have an eating disorder, having this much support—and I hate to call it support, but that's what it is—makes you more... you know what I mean? It just solidifies things. And of course, people can't get enough of it is the problem. It's addictive. It's just addictive. And I just think all this stuff should be open for study. And I suspect we'll find out things that are not great.
Scott Galloway
Well, we're raising a generation. It's just no accident that some of the biggest movies are now about the multiverse. I just saw Free Guy.
Kara Swisher
Oh, was it good?
Scott Galloway
And my kids... well, Ryan Reynolds has fantastic presence and humor and he's handsome. And I could almost watch anything he does. I think he's great. And then Jodie Comer, who's from what arguably I think is one of the best original scripted series of the last five years, Killing Eve. She's in it. She's fantastic. But anyway, my point is we have a whole generation of kids that essentially, especially for the last two years, their entire socialization was done in these metaverses. Whether it was Snap, whether it was Fortnite, whether it was Assassin's Creed. This is how they're socializing. And I noticed that with my boys, especially my youngest, once he goes beyond a certain number of hours in front of a screen, I don't know what the right term is. He becomes an enormous asshole. And we're in uncharted territory. And people say, and then they'll always revert to, "Well, they made the same thing about rock and roll." No, this is different. Or TV. This is different. There's something about the interaction here, the stimulus, the action, reaction, response that does rewire your brain.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. The only thing is we don't want to become like those people who say, "That Elvis with his swiveling pelvis is very disturbing." That's the argument. That's the argument. It did have an impact. But there's something deeper here. There really is something deeper. I think there's a lot of evidence.
Scott Galloway
Yes. Famous psychiatrists Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway who went to Harvard.
Kara Swisher
That's right. That's right. Let's go to Harvard. Soon to be Harvard graduates. Let's go to Harvard. Harvard. Can I tell you what I do to Harvard people? At the Delray and Calorama campuses of Harvard. I told you what I do to Harvard people, don't you? Because they always mention they went to Harvard. Even if 30 years hence they have been to Harvard, they tell you they went to Harvard within 15 minutes. What I would do is when they say that, they go—you know, they mention it. And I go, "Where?" And they go, "Harvard." I go, "MIT is such a good school. It's Boston, right?" And they're like, "No, Harvard." I go, "Yale?" And I just, I literally... and they don't get that I'm completely making fun of them.
Scott Galloway
Okay, so how to tell someone you're an asshole without telling them you're an asshole? Say you went to school in Boston. That's you pretending to be coy and humble, but you want everyone to know you went to Harvard. No one who goes to Boston College or MIT says, "I went to school in Boston." That's only Harvard. It drives me insane when someone says, "Well, I went to school in Boston." I'm like, "Oh, so you're saying you went to Harvard, but you want to pretend not to be a self-absorbed asshole."
Kara Swisher
Oh, man.
Scott Galloway
You want to tell everyone you went to Harvard without telling them you went to Harvard. So then I'm just going to fix that.
Kara Swisher
Very good. All right. Very good. We know what to do at Harvard, people, because we're just jealous. All right, Harvard, let's go. We are jealous. All right, Harvard. Your new name is Harvard. Let's go on a quick break. And when we come back, we'll discuss LinkedIn's China exit. And we'll talk to a friend of Pivot, Christopher Mims, about supply chain issues, because it's very important these days.
Mint is still $15 a month for premium wireless. And if you haven't made the switch yet, here are 15 reasons why you should. One, it's $15 a month. Two, seriously, it's $15 a month. Three, no big contracts. Four, I use it. Five, my mom uses it. Are you playing me off? That's what's happening, right? Okay. Give it a try at mintmobile.com slash switch. Upfront payment of $45 per three-month plan, $15 per month equivalent required. New customer offer first three months only. Then full price plan options available. Taxes and fees extra. See mintmobile.com.
Support for Pivot comes from LinkedIn. From talking about sports, discussing the latest movies, everyone is looking for a real connection to the people around them. But it's not just person to person. It's the same connection that's needed in business. And it can be the hardest part about B2B marketing, finding the right people, making the right connections. But instead of spending hours and hours scavenging social media feeds, you can just tap LinkedIn ads to reach the right professionals. According to LinkedIn, they have grown to a network of over 1 billion professionals, making it stand apart from other ad buys. You can target your buyers by job title, industry, company roles, seniority skills, and company revenue, giving you all the professionals you need to reach in one place. So you can stop wasting budget on the wrong audience and start targeting the right professionals only on LinkedIn ads. LinkedIn will even give you $100 credit on your next campaign so you can try it for yourself. Just go to linkedin.com slash pivotpod. That's linkedin.com slash pivotpod. Terms and conditions apply. Only on LinkedIn ads.
Okay, we're back. Microsoft's LinkedIn announced on Thursday it will shut down its Chinese version of the website because of China's censorship rules. In March, China's internet regulator told LinkedIn they had 30 days to start better moderating their content, resulting in the blocking of a number of China-focused activists and journalists. The company announced it would be launching a China-specific version later this year, solely based on jobs, resumes, et cetera, ditching the social features. Of course, it is a social network. People don't think of it that way. The site was the last major Western social media platform to operate in China. So was this the right move? I feel like something else happened here because they had been operating. It's just China's crackdown. It's going everywhere, I guess. It's a big market for LinkedIn. Third largest.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. My sense is that China isn't becoming more open. And whatever constraints they place on these companies, I think, have only gotten more arduous or more authoritarian. And also, I think a lot of companies have decided we can be very successful without the China market.
Kara Swisher
It's really interesting. Kind of the ultimate buy signal is when China bans you.
Scott Galloway
Is it?
Kara Swisher
When they ban Google, they ban Facebook, they ban crypto. I mean, it seems like when they ban someone, that's when you buy.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. Well, LinkedIn's trying to play it down, but it is an important market for them. It just is. It's their third most important market. Obviously, they're sort of tucked into Microsoft, so they have a lot more choices. But the idea that they thought they could operate... I suspect people were using it more like a social network there. And so they're keeping the job part of it. But part of the key part of LinkedIn is the social element to it, even though you don't... it's just a useful social element versus some of the others. I mean, you never hear about problems on LinkedIn because most people are talking about jobs, but there's still a social element to it. But it's a challenging operating environment, to say the least.
Yeah, no doubt. So what do you imagine the Chinese can do in this case with all these people leaving, essentially, and then them pushing down innovation, I would say, in their own markets by their own companies?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, but if you were to look at the arc of... we like to talk our own narrative about free markets and how it's really bad. If Italy kicked out Google, it would be bad for everybody and the pasta would get worse. And we come up with this narrative that is uniquely American and focused on letting our innovators go. Free markets are a very powerful concept. But if you look at what China's done, okay, so Italy let Google come in. Italy let Facebook come in. What's happened to Italy's media companies?
Wages, tech sector. And then if you look at China, China's gangster move is they let them in long enough to steal their IP. And let's be honest, it's IP theft. And then they kick them up, kick them out, and they prop up a local entrepreneur and they capture the majority of the value themselves. And they have a large enough market and strong enough universities and a strong enough technology and a strong enough financial ecosystem, venture ecosystem, to support homegrown companies.
And a lot of people, we like to think, "Oh, it's..." and I'm not talking about the morality or the autocracy or IP theft. I'm not blessing any of it. But China could have let these companies just run unfettered there. Instead, they said, "No, we're going to steal your shit," similar to what we did with textile manufacturers in the 19th and 18th century here in the US with British and European manufacturing technology. They kick them out, and then they prop up, and they capture all the value themselves. And I think it's hard to argue from a state standpoint that that was probably the right move.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. Yeah. But at the same time, listen, this is a story from the Journal. Beijing once touted the LinkedIn model, which involves a contractual relation between its headquarters and the Chinese nationals who actually own the platform in the country, as a way for global internet businesses to access its market. Such a model provided the overseas headquarters little control over the China operation. It was never popular in Silicon Valley.
And again, this is not just the only one. Twitter and Facebook's platforms have been blocked since 2009. Alphabet's Google left by themselves on their own accord in 2010 after declining to censor results. Chat messenger app Signal and audio discussion app Clubhouse were blocked. So it's just, this is a really interesting story. We aren't paying as much attention to it. But LinkedIn, you can see how LinkedIn might be able to thread the needle because it's less politics. It's less, you know, people don't plan insurrections or revolutions on LinkedIn. It's very much—
Kara Swisher
Well, they don't want those activists and journalists there. It doesn't matter. They want to stifle dissent in any way possible.
Scott Galloway
Agreed. I absolutely love LinkedIn. I no longer respond to people on any platform except LinkedIn. LinkedIn enforces identity. People are much more civil. The difference in LinkedIn is that people assume you're coming to the table in good faith, not in bad faith. And I find every other platform, everyone assumes you come to the table in bad faith and is looking to dunk on you, or you don't know who's responding to you and why they're responding to you. And LinkedIn, in my opinion, is the most civil, productive platform.
Kara Swisher
That's what they were trying to do in China and it didn't work. They'd come under a lot of criticism for doing that, but even they thought it was too much censorship, essentially. And China and Microsoft are at odds sometimes, even though they meet and everything else. So it's a really—and then, of course, Microsoft was dragged into the TikTok thing, if you recall. They were going to be one possible buyer. They were dragged by Trump for a hot minute, right?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, well, as you know, when I interviewed Satya Nadella recently, he was like, "Oh, this wasn't good." The reason when I—when I smoke cigars and spread moisturizer on the small of Satya's back, he said to me. By the way, did you see Casey Hunt? I hope she's okay. She has a brain issue.
Kara Swisher
Benign?
Scott Galloway
Benign. Yeah, but it was benign. It was benign. And the prognosis is really good.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I just was like, "Oh, you're going to have to carry the whole thing." That was shocking.
Scott Galloway
It was. It was a surprise. As a small kid, let's hope she gets better. Because, you know, she needs to be there to watch you.
Kara Swisher
That's my particular thing. You think?
Scott Galloway
Yeah. Did you see me in my red dress marching around?
Kara Swisher
I saw. What were you doing? What were you doing? We're going to bring on Chris Mims. But let's have a moment for that. Let's not talk about China and global issues. Let's talk about why you're wearing a red dress. Let's talk about daddy and drag. Were you signaling China?
Scott Galloway
No. I was doing a rundown of the recent S1s: Allbirds, Warby Parker, On Running, and of course Rent the Runway. And so I put on, I was wearing something from all of them. And I was walking around Soho with like 12 people from CNN in tow. And people just stopped and started filming and screaming at me. It was so nice. It was very rewarding.
Kara Swisher
Good. Wait, is this going to be on CNN? Viewing a dress.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I don't know if you've heard. I have a show with CNN+.
Kara Swisher
I understand you're on the plu. I know you're on the plu. The plu. The plu. But you're going to—I think you found your people. They let you wear a dress. That's great.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. I looked nice in that dress.
Kara Swisher
You did. I have more legs than a bucket of chicken.
Scott Galloway
Amanda did not like your shoes.
Kara Swisher
Amanda did not like—I know you were wearing—just because one was an On and one was an Allbirds.
Scott Galloway
I know. I know what you were doing. I know what you were doing, but she didn't think it worked for you. She thought you looked good in a pair of heels. That's what she said to me. My wife.
Kara Swisher
I'd be 6'5" in heels. I'd be irresistible in heels.
Scott Galloway
I would be irresistible. On that note, let's bring on Christopher Mims.
Kara Swisher
Yes. Let's bring in our friend of Pivot, Christopher Mims. Christopher is a technology columnist at The Wall Street Journal and author of a new book, *Arriving Today*, a book about global supply chains, which is perfectly timed because of all the controversy about global supply chains right now. Welcome, Christopher. How are you doing?
Christopher Mims
Good. How are you guys doing?
Kara Swisher
So talk to us about global supply chains. Let's talk about the now. It's in the news a lot. Obviously, nobody talks about global supply chains very much, but now they are with shortages in all kinds of areas. So less products, obviously, on the shelves. And also there's less employees right now because of the big quit, apparently, the big resignation. So talk a little bit about the landscape right now.
Christopher Mims
So the landscape right now is very weird. Americans have been on a shopping spree ever since about May of 2020. And global supply chains just were not designed to accommodate this much demand, especially in the US. On top of that, you have the Great Resignation, which you mentioned. And part of that is hitting jobs that are specifically kind of not great jobs in general, like trucking. So it's kind of hitting the supply chain as hard as any other area, harder than hospitality even in some ways.
So you've got a labor shortage. You've got record demand because people still aren't going on vacations and they're just spending, spending, spending on goods. And then you just have all these weird bottlenecks: warehouses, rail yards, ports, ships. You don't have enough shipping containers. Factories get shut down every month or two somewhere in East Asia or Southeast Asia because of the course of zero-COVID policy in China. So we're all just kind of like on this grand journey together where we find out that if chip packaging in Malaysia shuts down for a month, you can't buy a Ford F-150 or whatever two months later in the US.
Kara Swisher
Right. All right. So what is the solution? I know there's been all sorts of things proposed, but from your perspective, what is the solution to what's happening?
Christopher Mims
Well, recession is always a quick and dirty solution to these kinds of problems. We don't like that. That's a bad solution. Short of that, what you would like is for people to kind of rebalance supply chains in ways that are maybe a little more sustainable. And market economics are kind of doing their job right now. You see Amazon advertising right now: if you want to go work in a typical Amazon warehouse, you can get a $3,000 starting bonus and $22 an hour, which is well above what Jeff Bezos was touting when they went to $15 an hour.
Trucking is a little harder because it's just a really shit job in a lot of ways. Long-haul trucking, and no amount of money is going to get people back into that at the rates that we need them. And then you have startups tackling weird parts of the supply chain that nobody ever understood were an issue. There's this one called Next Trucking, which is tackling scheduling of trucks in and out of ports, which turns out to be this enormous pain point on the West Coast in the US.
So hopefully you get better regulation. There is some stuff in the infrastructure bill, if that passes, that would help. Some of what we're seeing: you think of Los Angeles, you think of Hollywood, but LA is a very industrial place. Over the past 10 years, for every one dollar that the federal government has invested in ports on the West Coast, they invested nine dollars in ports on the East Coast. So in some ways, this is like a supply crunch of our own making. So hopefully with the infrastructure bill, they won't just spend it on more highways or whatever; they'll spend it on bigger and better ports. And then there's all kinds of weird things happening. There's going to be a lot more automation coming to those ports. And those robots in certain jobs really do make a difference.
Kara Swisher
Right. Yeah. As they have. Scott?
Scott Galloway
First off, just a couple of questions. How long did it take you to bring your book to market? That's a little supply chain humor, Christopher.
Christopher Mims
That's a little supply chain.
Scott Galloway
Oh, my God. And most importantly, you asked me to blurb your book. Why didn't you ask Kara?
Christopher Mims
You know, it's not important. Let's move on.
Scott Galloway
Anyways. Anyways. Okay. By the way, I think Christopher is a total fucking gangster. I love your work, Christopher. One thing in your book that just blew me away: the moment you click "Order" on Amazon, it's out of the warehouse in 45 minutes. It strikes me that they are just operating at an absolute different level than the rest of everyone. Can you talk about the investments Amazon has made and how they took fulfillment? Because you started to write a book about Amazon and widened it out. But talk about that. That's absolutely true. They seem to be the logistics kings or emperors.
Christopher Mims
Yeah. I mean, Amazon, the same way that Apple has this tremendous lead over everybody in terms of chip design, which is happening as we record this, as they announce a new faster-than-ever MacBook Pro and everything. Amazon has a lead over everybody in terms of warehouse design, the software that runs warehouses, the robots that populate those warehouses. And that's because they bought Kiva, which was this robot provider to the whole logistics industry. And they fully ingested it and cut off all its outside contracts. And now those robots make their warehouses.
I think Deutsche Bank estimated that they are like 40% more efficient than they were before they had all this robotics. And they just keep adding more and more new kinds of robots and new kinds of Amazon fulfillment centers because they're just treating it like it's a big software problem. Anytime they can bring in these robots that can operate in a very consistent way, it just becomes a software problem that their engineers can solve in that way. And then the human just becomes kind of embedded in that automation, and the human has to function like a robot. Which is why you got all these reports about there being so many injuries in Amazon warehouses, because the evidence is that the more automation they added, it actually increased the injury rate because it's just a repetitive stress industry. Repetitive stress injury, because people are doing this over and over and over again, 10 hours a day, with three breaks. They're going to get some kind of injury if they're older than 25.
Scott Galloway
I have a couple of questions about second-order effects. I think supply chain is turning out to be the biggest business story of the year. And there are just going to be so many externalities. I don't know what the term is, but one is you referenced it: for 40 years, if you think of shareholders, consumers, and workers, workers have been ceding advantage in capital to consumers and shareholders. And it feels like in a violent way, there is a perfect storm where workers are starting to get some of that ground back. And you referenced it, where all of a sudden we're going from $15 to $20 to $22 bucks. I'm on the board of a consumer company right now, and it's just crazy what we need to do to get people.
The other thing that people aren't talking about is the geopolitical consideration. And that is, I saw for the first time China's growth was at 4.9%. That's the lowest in 30 years. It strikes me that there might be a geopolitical shift back of power to the US because our fulfillment is in zeros and ones and their fulfillment is in stuff. Does this have huge geopolitical ramifications that, quite frankly, the US, our fulfillment infrastructure as a services-based economy is humming, and China's the big loser here?
Christopher Mims
Maybe. I think if China becomes the big loser, it is not so much a trade-off with the United States as with the rest of Asia, Mexico, elsewhere. And that is because what you're seeing is, we don't have the labor in the US to reshore all this manufacturing that went to China. We just don't. It takes a certain number of—unless we are going to do complete open borders and we're going to go to a billion Americans—we don't have the labor to make all the stuff we consume, straight up. And we cannot automate it away yet.
But what you're seeing is companies are like, "Oh, crap, our supply chains are incredibly vulnerable." Let's not forget that before the pandemic, we had a trade war, which really kicked off all of this move out of China. And was the reason that in my reporting, I went to Vietnam as sort of the avatar of Southeast Asia instead of going to China. So you could see manufacturing move more and more into Vietnam, Thailand, the Philippines. Let's not forget that India has 1.3 billion people. They could be the world's next China if they can get their act together in some ways. So I think supply chains are still going to be long, but what you're going to have is Nike is going to have a factory in China and they'll have a factory in Vietnam. And maybe they'll also have a factory in India or somewhere else. So diversify.
Kara Swisher
So that you have some redundancy.
Christopher Mims
Yes. And you could see a bunch of it moving to Mexico.
Kara Swisher
Why not the US? I just interviewed Farah Stockman about her book about work, *American Made*. And people have talked about it. People at Apple have talked about it more on certain things, not everything, like the Gorilla Glass, et cetera. Why not? Because online shopping obviously has been rising during the pandemic. Everybody's ordering and comfortable with ordering in the new way people are buying, even though people say to buy local, they're really using Amazon much more heavily. So would you imagine there being a manufacturing here? And could someone like Amazon lead it in just-in-time manufacturing? I'm just picking someone I'm throwing out. But do you imagine that's a trend, or is it still just too expensive, too much regulation, etc.?
Christopher Mims
I mean, let's not forget that America still makes a ton of stuff. By dollar value of goods, we make the same amount as China. So I think that, again, the issue here in America is we just don't have the labor. If Amazon can pay you $22 an hour and a $3,000 hiring bonus to distribute the goods that are made in Asia, now if Amazon wants to get into manufacturing, they're competing with themselves for that labor. We need all the labor we can get just to distribute all the crap that we buy.
Look, you do have Intel that's going to get whatever it is, tens of billions in subsidies to put more chip fabs in the United States. But let's not forget that while that is specialized and it's high-value chip fabs and this other type of high-value manufacturing that the US still is great at, it's not super labor intensive. You build a new data center, it's like the least labor intensive, most economically productive thing ever, which is why the big four are all tech companies.
Kara Swisher
So you don't see that because of labor and regulation, presumably.
Christopher Mims
Yeah, it would be tough. I mean, look, there's a ton of stuff that America—we just forget how much America makes. We make trains. I have a cousin who works at a pump factory. Let me tell you, pumps in a world of extreme weather are doing better than ever. Go work at the pump factory if you need a job. There's just tons of—
Kara Swisher
Commercial jetliners, all kinds of things.
Christopher Mims
Yeah. I mean, we just make so much. We make all of that. We make so much of the specialized equipment that gets shipped to Asia to make the chips and the LCD displays and everything else. A lot of that high-value stuff is still in and around Silicon Valley and elsewhere.
Kara Swisher
That, I guess, begs the question: should we be making so much stuff? They had talked about the supply chain crisis being the fact that everybody just orders instantly, has gotten into this way. You don't buy local. You don't use strip. The sustainability of retail has been one of the things. My kids even mentioned it this weekend. How do you look at that trend? Or is that just like, forget it, human beings are going to suck up every piece of equipment in the world until we're done.
Christopher Mims
Yeah, I mean, I do think that in the same way you had a few years ago this movement towards "time well spent," it is worth thinking about the exact same kind of brain hacks that have gotten us to just scroll and scroll and scroll and taken up all of our time have been used to get us to just buy and buy and buy. One-click shopping, eliminating all of that friction, has definitely made us that much more willing to consume. So I kind of hope that some of these supply chain disruptions will make people pause and think about that a little more. Be more conscientious about what and how they buy. But, you know, it's—
Kara Swisher
Come on, Christopher.
Scott Galloway
I know. Give me the blank. Give daddy the blank.
Kara Swisher
Okay. So let's move to an investment thesis. Given the dramatic change in supply chain and the fact that it's kind of all of a sudden reared—I don't want to say "reared its ugly head"—but it's just shown how incredibly important it was and how spoiled we were. Do you find, do you think certain sectors or certain companies are especially well-positioned or vulnerable? Let's just assume, I'm going to assume Amazon's going to be a big winner here. So let's take that one off the table. Is it video game companies where we're going to be downloading video games on Christmas instead of trying to figure out toys, physical stuff? Is Apple really well positioned because they have a guy, basically a supply chain guy running the company? And who's vulnerable? Who are the winners and losers here from an investment thesis?
Christopher Mims
Yeah. I mean, who's vulnerable are people who are moving low-margin goods. And I'm not sure exactly how to turn that into an investment thesis, but like, I don't know, maybe there's a secret threat to Dollar General or something because so many of the low-margin goods can't get to us anymore because if the spot price of a shipping container went from $2,000 to $20,000 to get it across the ocean, then there's tons of stuff that it's not profitable to move here at any price that anyone will pay.
I think you're right. Apple's in a great position, although even they have said that this is going to impact iPhone 13 production, the chip shortage. Automakers are obviously taking a bath. I do think that virtual goods are a winner, right? Because there's a big problem now getting books, physical books to people. People have been resistant to ebooks for a long time. I think 70% of reading is still paper books. But that's a bet on Amazon again.
And with the big retailers, it really is a "big get bigger" type of situation. Whether you're talking about Lowe's or Walmart or even IKEA, they have the resources to requisition a certain number of shipping containers and ships. And then what happens is everybody else gets squeezed out. And I think one of the challenges you have is you have some old-line industries, like people who are going to export agricultural commodities, end up being the weird victims of this because they're like, "We can't get enough shipping containers to get soybeans to China." And then they get hit. So I think there's going to be third-order effects where China's like, "Oh, shit, we are short 20% of the soybeans that we normally import. And we can't produce enough pork or something like that." And that has some downstream impacts that I can't even predict.
Kara Swisher
All right, Chris. So your book is going to be all virtual then, right?
Christopher Mims
No, they're selling actual copies of it.
Kara Swisher
I was just telling you I ordered seven things from Amazon while we were talking. No, I didn't. I don't. But we've become very used to it. I think the pandemic has accelerated a lot of things that Scott and I talk about. And this is one of them: the use of just-in-time purchasing. And I think the idea of going back to local thrift shops, people just push that button. It's a really interesting thing.
Scott Galloway
So, Christopher, you deserve an award for literally the most perfect timing in the world. If this book is not a bestseller, it means your book really fucking sucks.
Kara Swisher
Yes. I mean, it could be. Literally, the moons have lined up in a big way for you.
Scott Galloway
The moons have lined. A book on supply chain coming out this week. So, a book called *Arriving Today*. Well done, my brother. Well done.
Kara Swisher
A book called *Arriving Today* is arriving today. Thank you, Christopher.
Christopher Mims
Thank you so much for having me.
Kara Swisher
All right, Scott, that was fascinating. Supply chain. One more quick break. And by the way, those were very good questions, Scott. We'll be back for wins and fails.
Break
Okay, Scott, wins and fails.
Scott Galloway
I don't have any. I don't have any.
Kara Swisher
No? I see one of us prepared for this podcast.
Scott Galloway
Yes, I didn't. You need to start investing in this relationship. All these people talking, giving Pete Buttigieg a hard time. I'm going to personally beat up all of them. Just ridiculous. Matt, whatever that guy's name is, Walsh or whatever, and Stephen Crowder. They're dicks. They're just, they're not dicks. They're dickless. How's that?
Kara Swisher
All right, go ahead.
Scott Galloway
That's my fail. So my win is—well, I'll start with my fail on an optimistic note. My fail is, I think this is a really important dialogue we're having around transgender rights, transphobia, and I think that there's a lot to be learned here. And I think Dave Chappelle and Netflix have been a positive force in this. I think that it's good to have a thought-provoking conversation and a dialogue. And I think that what we need more of is not a reflexive gag reflex to make an immediate assumption or judgment and then move to destruction. That it's the other side's fault, the other side's too sensitive, or this side is creating more transphobia, so we need to cancel them. I think there just has to be—we have to flip the ratio from 20% dialogue and 80% destruction and talk about, okay, let's learn from this. This is an opportunity.
Kara Swisher
And I do think that—I agree with you. The only thing is this is a group of people getting the shit kicked out of them right as we speak. That's the only thing I wish people would keep in mind. But tell me if you agree with this. I think this long term, short, medium, and long term, is good for the trans community. I think a lot of people are spending time on this issue that weren't before, that made snap judgments about this community and are recognizing that this community has taken it. And America is basically "be the person you want to be" and you're afforded certain protections. And it's coming to light that these people have not benefited from that Americanism. And I think we're going to evolve and get to a better place because of this dialogue.
Scott Galloway
I also think that it's a conversation worth having. But I think there has to be more dialogue and less destruction. But dialogue through the context of comedy is really powerful because it takes your guard down. It takes the mucous membrane around the bubble you're in and it softens it. And it says, "Okay, maybe you should be open to listening from both sides." So my fail, if you will, is I'd like to see more dialogue and less move to destruction on both sides.
And two, oh, my win. I saw the Bond film.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. And?
Scott Galloway
And my win is Daniel Craig. I think Daniel Craig cements himself. He is a sexy beast. In 10 years, when we look back, there's always that big thing like who's the best Bond. In 10 years, seven of 10 people, critics, will say that Daniel Craig was the best Bond. He was not the most handsome. Roger Moore and Sean Connery were more handsome. But he was the most—the physicality he brought to the world was really impressive. He's also complex. He and Connery were the only two Bonds that really credibly could have—you felt could kill people with their hands.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
The physicality was really impressive. And also, he'll go down as the best actor in the role. He's a great actor. Emotionality. Connery was just mean, just tough as nails. Connery was just a badass. And I think impermeable. He has feels. Daniel Craig's a fantastic actor. *Munich*, *Layer Cake*, which I think was his best movie. *Knives Out*. He's a great—he really is legitimately a great actor. I think that Daniel Craig cements his status. It's a great movie. He will be perceived—he will win that trivia game eventually over who is the best Bond. So anyways, my win is Daniel Craig in the Bond franchise.
Kara Swisher
Well, then I do have a short win: the *Squid Game* skit on SNL with Rami Malek, who plays the villain in that movie.
Scott Galloway
That's right.
Kara Swisher
And Pete Davidson was very, very funny. And Daniel Craig showed up. That was very good.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. Good ones. Good one. I like it.
Kara Swisher
All right, Scott. Plus he's a handsome drinking man, isn't he?
Scott Galloway
He's got—yeah. Handsome man. That guy's—and you know, it's not a young man. He's 53. That body at 53.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. That's serious shit.
Scott Galloway
Anyway, Scott, thank you for—
Kara Swisher
And he's married to Rachel Weisz.
Scott Galloway
I think we'd all be really good friends. I think we should hang out with Rachel and Daniel.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I don't think he's going to hang out with you. I don't think he's going to hang out with you.
Scott Galloway
You don't think so? Maybe if you wore the dress. Who knows?
Kara Swisher
Anyway. Da-da-da-da-da-da-da. That's the show. Da-da-da-da-da-da. Anyway, read us out.
Scott Galloway
Today's show was produced by Lara Neyman, Evan Engel, and Taylor Griffin. Our engineer this episode. Thank you also to Drew Burrows. Make sure you subscribe to the show on Apple Podcasts, or if you're an Android user, check us out on Spotify or, frankly, wherever you listen to podcasts. If you liked our show, please recommend it to a friend. Our next episode tapes live from Adweek in New York City. Check it out on Friday. Thanks for listening to *Pivot* from New York Magazine and Vox Media.
Let's move to dialogue. Let's move to dialogue. Let's hold off the destruction demon at the door for just a little bit longer. Let's show more grace with each other. Dialogue, not destruction.