Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses various topics, including journalism, media, and technology. The main topic is the changing landscape of journalism and the role of new media platforms in delivering news to the public.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Wins and Fails:
Conclusion:
The podcast episode discusses various topics related to journalism, media, and technology. The hosts and guests provide insights into the changing landscape of journalism and the role of new media platforms in delivering news to the public. The episode highlights the importance of neutral journalism, social media, and building a successful media company.
Kara Swisher
Not all journalism is the same. Take The Guardian. Our coverage has something unique. Fierce independence. Nobody owns us or tells us what we can and can't say. So we're free to report the whole picture. We connect what's happening in Washington to the rest of the globe. Expose corruption wherever we find it. And give fresh perspective on everything. From wellness and soccer to culture, the climate and more. Read, watch and listen to The Guardian for free at theguardian.com.
Scott Galloway
AI agents are getting pretty impressive. You might not even realize you're listening to one right now. We work 24-7 to resolve customer inquiries. No hold music, no canned answers, no frustration. Visit sierra.ai to learn more.
Kara Swisher
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Cara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And I'm Scott Galloway. How you doing? How's it going? Did you listen to my new podcast already?
Kara Swisher
Kara, Kara, you know we're not interested in each other's work outside of Pivot.
Scott Galloway
No, that's not true. That's not true. How many of my books have you read?
Kara Swisher
All of them. I just finished Adrift. Yes, I have. Yes, I have it.
Scott Galloway
I haven't. I'm showing Clara through it. Yes, I am. And I made Alex read it. Yes, I do. Yes, I do. Thank you for that.
Kara Swisher
No, I have not listened to it, although I'm excited about it. I'm saving it.
Scott Galloway
Are you?
Kara Swisher
I'm saving it for—
Scott Galloway
You're not listening to it at all, are you?
Kara Swisher
You know, it's Chris Cuomo.
Scott Galloway
Really? Chris Cuomo is the interview?
Kara Swisher
Yes, indeed. That was your inaugural pod is Chris Cuomo?
Scott Galloway
Yes, it is. And the next one is Hillary Clinton.
Kara Swisher
Okay. So let's unpack that. So I've met Chris once and I didn't listen to a word he says, because he's very handsome. That was my first observation.
Scott Galloway
Does he come across handsome on a podcast?
Kara Swisher
Yes.
Scott Galloway
And he was wearing a very muscly shirt, a t-shirt when we were doing the interview.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. But it doesn't have an impact on Kara. So give us a preview.
Scott Galloway
Well, you know, it's interesting because a lot of people have feelings about him because of what he did and how he got fired from CNN. So we talked a lot about that. And he's trying this new thing called News Nation. I think it's called News Nation, something like that. Anyway, it's this company from the superstation WGN, it used to be. So they're trying to create a news organization that is down the line, aiming at the sort of middle of people who don't like Fox or MSNBC or CNN, that kind of thing. And so, which is interesting because he sort of was the king of that at CNN. And so he wants to hear from all kinds of people. He was making the argument that he did before. We talked a lot about the thing that happened with his brother and the decisions he made, all of which were bad for him. It was a lot about sort of ethics in journalism, the changing journalism scene, the price he paid, I think, for what he did. And we had a disagreement about, he said he would do it over again. And I said, I would never do such a thing for my brother. I wouldn't advise him and then not tell. Thanks, Jeffrey Swisher.
Kara Swisher
Well, I think he'd agree with me if he was involved in something like that. And I was behind the scenes without telling people that I was doing that. I wouldn't do it. It's an obstacle. Anyway, we talked about it, but I let him talk about his reasons. So it was good. It was very good. I suspect you'd agree with him more than me.
Scott Galloway
I think you're right. So some just inside baseball, as you know, I had a show on CNN Plus, Kara. I know this.
Kara Swisher
I know this.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, you and seven other people. So the two things you hear about Chris Cuomo inside the walls of Time Warner. May interject. I watched both of them. But go ahead. Keep going.
Kara Swisher
I had six episodes. Did six go up?
Scott Galloway
Six. I think five got aired. Anyways, back to you.
Kara Swisher
I don't think so.
Scott Galloway
All right. One is after all that stuff went down, people really felt like he behaved inappropriately. That they just, he was universally, as far as I could tell, really disliked after that whole thing went down. People felt a lot of anger and resentment that he really damaged the network and that he was, he just didn't acquit himself well. The other thing that I didn't know.
Kara Swisher
With the lawsuit, you mean?
Scott Galloway
With the lawsuit. Yeah, the lawsuit, the way he sued them. Because he brought Zucker down, really. That's what, he says he did not drop that down.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, that he just became destroying everything in his path. He became just burning the village to save it, so to speak.
Scott Galloway
And the other thing is that he is one of the most talented people that anyone's ever worked with.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, broadcaster.
Scott Galloway
He's a very gifted broadcaster. It's supposedly that, you know, the monitors could go out and it would be no problem for him. That some people, if the monitor went out, that was it. They were dead in the water. You wouldn't even know when the monitor goes out with Chris that he was that talented and that natural.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, very talented broadcaster. Look, he gets to come back like a lot of people don't, right, in terms of where he's coming from. And I do admire anybody who does new things. He's trying this new News Nation thing, which I think is interesting. And we certainly need more outlets. I think I like not redemption stories, but an attempt at redemption. I like those stories. And so we'll see. And then we also added Naima is on the show. She's sort of a ringmaster a little bit.
Scott Galloway
Oh, really?
Kara Swisher
She's on air. She's on air. There's lots of pieces to the show. It's many features on the show. And I do an essay at the end, which is good.
Scott Galloway
You do an essay?
Kara Swisher
A little essay.
Scott Galloway
A little touch of Kara?
Kara Swisher
A little touch of Kara. A little swish for dessert? It's something you didn't want to talk about.
Scott Galloway
I'll have the swisher souffle and a bottle of wine to chase that.
Kara Swisher
I'm going to mention you a lot. I mentioned you several times during the show. I think it's going to be a nice click with pivot. I think it's a nice, it fits a lot better together. It has a sassiness to it. It's a nice click. So it'll be good. Anyway, but today we'll talk about the protests in Iran, the outlook for the market, and we'll speak with journalist Jessica Yellen, who I just met recently, the founder of Independent Media Company. News Not Noise. So this is the same thing. Neutral. Neutral News Not Noise. So it's the same thing on what we talked to Chris Cuomo about. Jessica and I had a three-hour lunch in Colorado.
Scott Galloway
Did you?
Kara Swisher
She's great. Literally, we couldn't stop lunching. We could not stop lunching.
Scott Galloway
Okay. You have a very similar attitude towards her. I think I had a nice little coffee with her recently.
Kara Swisher
At your apartment, actually. But first, Twitter is getting its first chance to hear from Elon Musk under oath. Musk is currently answering questions in private deposition about his attempts to pull out of his $44 billion Twitter purchase. That should be interesting. Twitter is also making a rare move of questioning Musk's attorney, Alex Spiro. Together, both sides have subpoenaed over 100 people, including former Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey, who I believe has testified. This is the discovery period, as they say. It's a five-day trial in the Delaware Chancery Court. Kicks off October 17th. It's like our Super Bowl. We are going to have the cinematic universe of Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway to cover it for you with content feeds across Pivot, Prof. G, and on with Kara Swisher. So we're going to do it up. So what do you think about right now where we are? Just getting ready?
Scott Galloway
Look, I think what's going on behind the scenes is that his lawyers, who have got to be very bright people have said, this is the tough one, boss. And so I would imagine that he's already made overtures to Twitter saying, we should settle this. And Twitter's in a weird spot because unless they settle it for the better part of 20 billion, their best course of action here is to get a decision that says he is legally obligated to pay $54.20 and then start the negotiation there. So I don't think they have any motivation. I think the likelihood, if you game theory it out, I think there's a 90% chance likelihood they're going to get a decision in their favor. So 0.9 times 54 bucks is what, $49. And then the natural level of the stock is around 20 bucks. So $29 delta times 750. So unless he's willing to settle for 22 billion, they're better off in my view going forward with the case. And I think this, I don't think Elon Musk is going to do well under oath because I think that individuals of his power with his sort of, that register his sort of idolatry begin to believe that they have their own reality.
Kara Swisher
I don't know about that. He won that case with the pedophile thing, that pedo thing he did. I think he does have discipline when it comes to that. Remember, he didn't go off the rails there. He goes off the rails in real life when he does 420 and things like that. But when he gets under oath, I think he's much more in control of himself.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but that was, he didn't, he could say the truth there because the reality was that was in poor taste that showed a lack of character. But in a slander case like that, unless the individual can show it's caused them economic harm, unless he's not getting cave diving tour expeditions, because people think he's a pedophile, he's not going to win. And so, But in this case, he's just so wet. He's so wrong. And I also think there's so many things that are going to reflect poorly around his true intentions here. I mean, he kind of shows up having lied. I want out of this deal because of the bots. Well, that's not true. And I think that they're going to begin to ask him very uncomfortable questions around his financing and who was in the deal and who got out of the deal. I mean, they're just going to ask. They're going to be so pointed. And his previous texts and emails.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, no, for sure. I think one of the things, though, is he, if you've noticed, his Twitter has calmed down a great deal, a great deal. His lawyers have said, stop it.
Scott Galloway
I know, but he's done it. Like, listen, Trump hasn't shut the fuck up.
Kara Swisher
You know, he has done it. He's very responsive. I've been trying to reach him for a while. He suddenly responded, very cordial. I think he knows he has to be cordial and really not, he can't indulge himself. And he, unlike Trump, who literally is doubling down on idiocy and just convicting himself, I think he has realized what a situation he's in. So I suspect he'll probably be on his best behavior, and he's capable of it in these depositions. So I don't think he's going to play games. It's far too much money, and it's significant money for him. So we'll see. We'll see what happens in this case.
But I think you're right. He's going to lose. I mean, there's so many. You have 90 million followers. Have you not put out text messages estimating that somewhere between a third and two-thirds of your followers are bots? Yes, I have said that. Have you not put in place strategies to have these bots weaponized to artificially support your stock price? Yes. Doesn't that mean you are benefiting from these bots that you also knew? I mean, this is going to be so much fun for the lawyers at Wachtell, the Twitter lawyers. I think they salivate over the opportunity to question this guy under oath. They want to knock him off.
They want him to say something crazy under oath. So it'll be a big test of his control ability. The only person that's toned it down more than Elon is Chamath, who all of a sudden everyone's discovering has made $750 million in what is the largest – one of the largest transfer of wealth from failed enterprises since Adam Neumann and WeWork. And he's gone very quiet. Bill Cohen wrote a terrific column in Puck about that. Outstanding. Outstanding about the SPAC king. And, you know, but he's still making excuses for it. He is like still touting his book. But I would agree with you. I think he's got to keep quiet for a little bit now.
The thing is with Elon, I'm going to make this, it's not a prediction precisely, but I think if he tones it down and doesn't go overboard again, he can regain this brand. I think he's done so much damage to his brand in general. Anyways, remember last year when your iPhone started asking you whether or not you wanted a new app to track your activity? Two lawsuits allege that Meta created a workaround allowing it to monitor activity whether or not a user gave permission. Tracking users is a direct violation of Apple's app tracking transparency policy. It's also a violation of federal and state laws against unauthorized data gathering.
Meta says both lawsuits are, quote, without merit, is the alleged move by Meta. Desperate, I know they're angry about it because Nick Clegg said something about it in a recent interview with Ben Smith for Semaphore, where he talked about Apple and privacy. And then I tweeted it, And then Andy Stone, who I really enjoy because he's really quite pugnacious. He's a face meta PR person, came back at me. Like, anyway, you know, privacy as a business model. I'm like, I'm good with that. I'm good with that. So anyway, so he said, by the way, Clegg also said he'll be the one to decide whether or not to allow Donald Trump back on Facebook.
He hasn't said which way he's leaning, but gave a deadline of January 7th, 2023. So what do you think of these two things? Same old, same old.
Scott Galloway
Well, the thing that has just struck me is Apple's power. On, when was it? Sunday. So yesterday I was with my 12-year-old and I'm like, what should we do today? And I think, let's do something British. We're here in London. He's like, we kind of thought about it for many. He's like, I know, let's go to the Apple store. And I'm like, okay. So we went to the Apple store. It was packed. And in addition to it being chaos, immediately someone found us, helped us. I got the new iPhone, two screen protectors, one for me, one for my boy, a new case. The service was flawless. I didn't have to go to a cash register.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, that's where you're right there.
Scott Galloway
And the place was on fire. On fire. And I thought—
Kara Swisher
Very British. That was a very British thing for you to do.
Scott Galloway
Wasn't that? Well, I like to hang out with the locals. It was global.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I got so. At a firm based in Cupertino.
Scott Galloway
But if you look at what Apple's done here, it's remarkable. Their ad business has gone from a few hundred million dollars in the late tens to about billion this year
Kara Swisher
That was the point Andy Stone was making although it still small
Scott Galloway
It still like gigantically small billion in four years It going to be one of the largest media
Kara Swisher
That still small
Scott Galloway
Yeah, still small compared to them. They're at, like, $160, $180 billion.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, but that revenue will be, like, 90 points of margin. It'll be another revenue stream. I get it.
Scott Galloway
Facebook was trying to put out that Apple's their real competitor from an advertising point of view today, and they're not. I mean, Amazon certainly has made inroads, and I think they definitely are facing competition from Apple. But nonetheless, what do you think of Facebook doing this if they did this?
Kara Swisher
Well, I mean, that'll be for a court of law. But what's just striking to me is that an unintended consequence, and I saw this as somebody who has startups and used to acquire customers online, the cost to acquire a customer online or the ROI is down 40%. because we all talk about privacy, but the Meta and Google's inability to track people in the same fashion and target them as well has meant that small, medium, and large-sized businesses, their cost of customer acquisition have gone up dramatically. Now, what does that mean? It means offline advertising is more or is less deficient relative to online advertising. So you go there. And it also means that Apple is now in the driver's seat and has first-party data that they can begin to weaponize or use for their own assets. But there's just no doubt about it. Apple, under the auspices of privacy, and this is one of the great genius brand slash business moves, has transferred tens, if not hundreds of billions of dollars from mostly meta, but some from Google, to Apple under the auspices of privacy.
Yeah. And speaking of butthurt, they can't stop it. They're doing a lot of very like reaching out and slapping of Apple saying, oh, it's their business plan. It's this, it's that. They want to be in the ad business. They're trying to advantage their ad business by using privacy. They're doing everything. It must be going crazy inside of Facebook because one, they fail with their phone. Two, they have no control over this and it's the center of their business, right? Apple really has a stranglehold on the center of their business. And the meta thing's not working out as well as they hoped. But what do you think about letting, that Nick Clegg is making this decision and not Mark Zuckerberg. I don't like that one person makes this decision, but here we are. January 7th, he could be back on Facebook.
Scott Galloway
My understanding is Nick Clegg is basically like the solid in all cap letters number two now.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
But look, this has exposed the vulnerability. I mean, a few things have happened. Elon Musk has kind of demonstrated and under bright lights what a shitty business Twitter is. I mean, he's really damaged the thing and he's brought, whether he wanted to or not, he's just highlighted, this is a shitty business that's been poorly run for the better part of a decade. And Tim Cook basically said to Meta, you know, we're just so much more powerful than you. With literally a flip of the switch and a few press releases, we can take your business down $10 billion in top line revenue. You know, when a company's doing 150 billion and it's trading at like, what, I don't know, three to four times revenues. They took 30 or $40 billion in market cap out of the company. And not only that, it's even more than that because instead of growing five or 10%, they grow negative 1%, which takes their multiple on EBITDA down. Tim Cook single-handedly took a quarter of a trillion dollars out of Meta. And so, and their general, I'm not surprised at all they're doing this. Facebook, all of big tech is pretty much their approach is, you know, ask for forgiveness, not permission.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Yeah. I mean, you know, it's interesting because I did ask him, I think I've said, I don't want Apple to be the regulator. It's still, we still should be passing legislation. Of course, we're not, you know, Amy Klobuchar is struggling to get those things, the things she's trying to get through, through them. We're not getting it on this one on privacy. And he said, I don't want to be the regulator either. You know, I don't think, I don't think, you know, Facebook is accusing it of being their business. I think it's a good brand attribute. I don't think it's their business to try to screw Facebook. I think that's just the way they've been forever. I think it's a twofer. I think he's really enjoying this. They've been that way forever. I think they've been that way forever. We'll see where it goes. But we'll see. Do you think that they should let Trump back on Facebook? Do you think it matters?
Scott Galloway
You know, God, I don't know. I don't think it matters. Twitter is the real playground. Twitter is the big one. Facebook.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, who cares? If Elon buys it, he'll be back on. If Elon doesn't, there's no way Twitter's letting him back on. They're just going to be like, why revisit that? We've already gotten the slings and arrows for knocking him off.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, you got a guy who refuses to acknowledge the peaceful transfer of power. And so you want to spread that?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, you just let him stay buried. That's what I said. Stand by our decision. They should put out, we'll revisit it on a regular basis. We'll revisit it.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, that's it. Yeah, who cares what Facebook does? Anyway, let's get to our first big story. Protests continue in Iran following the outcry over the death of a young woman, 22-year-old Masa Amini, in police custody. She had been arrested for allegedly wearing her headscarf too loosely by the morality police. Over the weekend, protests spread to at least 80 cities. In response, authorities have repeatedly shut down mobile internet connections for most of the 80 million people who live there. The government has also disrupted Instagram and WhatsApp services, which is one of their go-to moves. Last year alone, 23 countries, including Cuba, Bangladesh, India, and more, shut down the Internet a collective 182 times. Talk about this. This is a real – this is really something that's growing in power, these protests, which is critically important. When I interviewed Hillary Clinton, she did talk about the need for this to keep going. What do you think about this? What's going on here?
Scott Galloway
I think it's exciting. If you take the lens back across the world, democracies are beating autocracies. And for all the grief we give big tech and social media, the poorest nature, I believe that social media and the poorest nature of media now is in large part responsible for the protests in Russia. These autocrats, you weaponize the media, then you weaponize the economy, and that gives you license to take over the military. but if you have a media where you can no longer control state-run media or state-run media is no longer what 80 percent of people see it's eight percent because they get their media from other means it's really powerful and all that it's there's a striking contrast here between when you look at what's happening in russia with men fleeing and then in iran you have women staying and fighting and and it's really i think it's really inspiring and what so i went to ucla LA has the largest concentration of Iranians outside of Tehran.
And I had several close friends who are Iranian. And I've always thought that the Iranian people are more American than almost any other people, at least the ones I knew. They were super into capitalism, super into education, super hardworking. And it's always struck me and the people I know that came over and people who still go home and visit their parents. I've always thought it's such a tragedy that Iran is not an ally. Because I feel like at least the people I know, it seems like They are so, I don't know, I always thought that we would get along other than this extremist group running the country.
And I think the younger population there wants a different life. I think there's a universal agreement around anyone under the age of 40 that we're not down with the future that looks like this type of oppression. I mean, some of the shit is just so out of, it's just beyond the pale, right? That women can be married off at the age of 10 or 11. Women aren't allowed to go to sporting events. And people are pulling off their hijabs and cutting their hair. They're putting themselves in very danger from these people. These people are very good at cracking down. And what my worry is, very similar to Ukraine, although, look, they keep going as the attention moves elsewhere or the protests can't continue.
These hyper, you know, religious regimes have a tendency to come back again and again and again. Like even if they've been liberalized, they get unliberalized rather quickly. I do think it's really interesting that they do get information without it. This stuff's getting out.
Kara Swisher
One interesting wrinkle was, and I talked about it on my new podcast, was Christiane Amanapur was supposed to do an interview with their president. And she refused to wear a hijab. And they canceled the interview because it was in this country. She often wears it in other countries as a sign of respect if that's their laws. but he or she refused to, and then they canceled it. And a lot of people thought she should do a hard interview on him, but I felt like the visual of her wearing it right now with him would have been very damaging to these protests. And so I'm glad she refused. Everything's about imagery and everything else and getting that stuff out with these protests in lots of ways.
Scott Galloway
Well, so the median age of protesters is 20 years old. Get this, 70% of the population in Iran is under the age of 25. You think they're down with this shit? I mean, change is coming and it's coming in the right direction. And it's going to get in. It's going to get in. Elon Musk, for example, said he's activating Starlink service in the country, even though some cybersecurity say there's still logistical challenges. He did that in Ukraine and it's up and running. And so they're going to get their information no matter what. And so no matter what these, you can shut down these things, but there's lots of forces in the other direction. But you're right. The young people are going to get their information one way or the other.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. And I think it's exciting what's happening and Russia's inspiring in its own way. The unfortunate thing is the people on the front line of that, whether it was a young woman who was, you know, beaten to death in prison, or a lot of these young men who are being kind of sent to their imminent death, they, you know, they will be, I don't want to call them martyrs, but it's just a shame, but they will, there's a spark here and it's catching fire.
Scott Galloway
Well, one would hope within the country, I mean, leaving the country is one thing, but staying and fighting for your rights there would be another thing. Of course, you saw those videos of them getting beaten and thrown into buses, essentially like dragoon, it's dragooning them to say, or, you know, it's just, that's what they're doing. And so it's, we'll see what happens. We'll see if there is a regime change at any of these places. I'm not so sure that will be the end result, But it certainly does – it must give these leaders pause, especially Putin. But I think Putin is so far gone. I doubt he will do anything except what he wants to. Apparently, he's running the war now and ignoring everybody, which means it's going to end fast, presumably, and not in his favor.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, Scott, let's go on a quick break. When we come back, we'll talk markets here and abroad, and we'll speak with a friend of Pivot, Jessica Yellen. Thank you.
Ad Break
Support for Pivot comes from LinkedIn. From talking about sports, discussing the latest movies, everyone is looking for a real connection to the people around them. But it's not just person to person. It's the same connection that's needed in business. And it can be the hardest part about B2B marketing, finding the right people, making the right connections. But instead of spending hours and hours scavenging social media feeds, you can just tap LinkedIn ads to reach the right professionals. According to LinkedIn, they have grown to a network of over 1 billion professionals, making it stand apart from other ad buys. You can target your buyers by job title, industry, company roles, seniority skills, and company revenue, giving you all the professionals you need to reach in one place. So you can stop wasting budget on the wrong audience and start targeting the right professionals only on LinkedIn ads. LinkedIn will even give you $100 credit on your next campaign so you can try it for yourself. Just go to linkedin.com slash pivotpod. That's linkedin.com slash pivotpod. Terms and conditions apply. Only on LinkedIn ads.
End Ad Break
Scott, we're back. What is up with the markets? The Dow dropped 100 points on Monday morning after a week where it fell to its lowest close since November 2020. The Nasdaq is coming off its worst two-week stretch since the start of the pandemic. The S&P is down about 23% for the year and is on pace for its biggest annual drop since 2008. The VIX hit its highest level since June. Give us some thoughts. Give us some thoughts.
Scott Galloway
Yes, I don't have a lot to say here other than I would describe our entire economy as the Elvis economy. And that is we've decided to bring in outside forces a doctor, whether it's Chairman Powell or money printing, and wake the economy up with pills, put it to sleep with pills. And we end up with an economy that's just obese, all this outside intervention. And you end up with something that, you know, has a stroke while going to the bathroom or a heart attack or whatever happened to Elvis. Because our economy, in my opinion, the best thing that can happen to economy is we go through a recession. And we bought into this notion that we need to avoid a recession at all costs And you know what a recession does A recession in some ways is a transfer of wealth from older people to younger people And the reason why I economically secure is as I was coming into my prime income earning years in 2008, Apple and Amazon fell to levels where you could buy them for one-twentieth what they're going for now.
Kara Swisher
What about these rates? The Fed raised rates three-quarters of a point last week. of the impact of that?
Scott Galloway
It's exactly what we should be doing because the fastest way to revolution isn't forcing women to wear a hijab or even a bad war. The fastest way to revolution is to universally, severely diminish people's quality of life with Weimar Republic-like inflation. Inflation, if it gets out of control, is really something you cannot control. And so So these are, Jerome Powell's doing exactly the right thing. And the only thing you could criticize him for is being late to it. So to get inflation under control, you have to dampen demand by making things more expensive by raising interest rates. And you need to increase supply through structural investments that take longer.
Kara Swisher
What about the job market?
Well, the job market's at full employment.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, it is. And so we can afford, quite frankly, we can afford layoffs. And under the auspices, if it couldn't happen to a nicer group of people, the people who are taking the brunt of the layoffs are people, these unicorns. And I don't mean to be cynical about that. Layoffs anywhere hurt.
Kara Swisher
But were you seeing – let me go this way. If you're interested in being a waiter, if you're interested in being a driver, construction, you're fine. There's not layoffs there. Where there are layoffs is in the Patagonia Vest economy. And we're seeing layoffs at these organizations that were overfunded, that businesses make no sense.
Scott Galloway
But I think a recession, at some point, I think we just need one. We need to get through it. Here's the terrible thing about recessions: they always happen. Here's the wonderful thing about them: they always end. And it's a natural part of the economy. It slows down. We're out over our skis. We lose some capital, it's destroyed. People reinvent themselves, reinvent their companies, get laid off, go to a greater use of their human capital, prices come down. You know what we need? We need prices to come down for a new generation of young people.
Kara Swisher
Well, one, the president of the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta said over the week, and he thinks we can get to 2% inflation without severely damaging the economy. We'd all love them to stick the landing. That's unlikely. To thread the needle between slowing the economy just enough such that it tamps inflation, but not enough that it hurts job growth, that's almost impossible to do.
Scott Galloway
And here's the thing, the disruption that took place in 2000, a lot of companies came through it much stronger. The disruption that took place in 2008, and then if you were coming into your primary income earning years, you could buy real estate in Brooklyn for $400 instead of $1,400 a square foot. So the down cycle or the recession in an economy is a healthy thing. Now, people don't feel that way when they get laid off, and that's understandable. But this constant printing of more money, this constant trying to engineer the economy. Like you said, Elvis, we'd rather have more drugs to sing Unchained Melody once again.
Kara Swisher
There you go. Let's just get on. Bring the arlet. We'll get through it. We'll be fine.
Scott Galloway
I wish the colonel wasn't around for Elvis. He would have been singing today.
Kara Swisher
He would have been singing today.
Scott Galloway
The colonel.
Kara Swisher
The colonel. There you go. Anyway. Okay, Scott, let's bring in our friend of Pivot. Jessica Yellen is an award-winning journalist who covered the White House for ABC and CNN. She also is a founder of an independent media company, News Not Noise. She joins us today to talk about the role of the news media and how she's built a news organization outside the traditional media framework, which is not easy. Welcome, Jessica.
Scott Galloway
All right, Scott. I usually, you know, take over because I'm the alpha dog here, but I'm going to let you start this interview because you and Jessica have a bond from your long, boozy lunch.
Well, I think the question everyone wants to know is, have you ever had a better lunch than the one we had? Honestly.
Jessica Yellin
I really, I can't remember one, Scott. There is truly a no better company and B, it made me such a superstar. Everyone's like, you had lunch with Scott Galloway. Oh, I bet.
Scott Galloway
Go on. You can see why I love Jessica.
Kara Swisher
No, don't. Jessica. All right. Jessica. Okay, so a real question here. You've been at kind of the helm of the bobsled. You cover the White House. You've been on a major network. Now you're doing something very cool with new mediums. Talk about not the message so much or how news has changed, but how have the mediums changed? What have you noticed about trying to communicate news through a new medium like Instagram versus like traditional broadcast news?
Jessica Yellin
Well, the main difference for me is the conversation you can have with the audience. You know, I used to be on these big channels and I would have some nights millions of viewers and you just broadcast into this black camera and have no idea how it went over. Now I put something up and I instantly get feedback. And it's not just what everybody thinks, which is "I disagree with this point of view" or "show me your sources," but also a lot of like, "I didn't know what that term means. I hear it used all the time. Would you explain that?" Or "Now I'm scared. What's going to happen next?" And so it becomes more of a conversation and a community. And that's what becomes, A, rewarding. B, it gives you real direction on what to report next. And C, I think it's what builds trust with the audience. That you have a back and forth, correct?
Kara Swisher
Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. And you're addressing their needs. Right. Interestingly, I had an interview with Chris Cuomo today, and he's often gone to News Nation. Same thing when they're trying to be neutral. Talk what news, not noise is. What does that mean? I mean, it seems obvious, but why don't you explain it?
Jessica Yellin
Well, I started this in 2018 out of the couch in my home. I was doing work from home before it was cool. And I'd been in TV news all these years, and I'd spent a lot of time talking to voters. I was a political reporter, and I was basically, not knowing it, doing market research and discovered in these conversations that there were a lot of people who wanted the kind of information TV news could provide but couldn't stand how we were giving it to them. They hated the outrage and the negativity and the left-right-ism. People would describe it as like walking into a dinner party 10 minutes after it started. And you're like, wait, what does that one word mean? And who's that person? And sometimes they'd say they feel less informed and more dumb after watching a segment than before, because now there's all this stuff they don't know they don't know. And so I decided-
Kara Swisher
And the screaming, and the screaming going on, or the fear mongering, the panic.
Jessica Yellin
Yeah, exactly. I say what we do is facts, not fear, experts, not pundits, community, compassion, conversation. And it's really about identifying not just the stories that you absolutely should know to be an informed person in this world, be able to execute on big decisions in your life, but also pointing out you're going to hear a lot about this one thing. It doesn't matter. You can pay attention to it if you want, but that's kind of like the Us magazine of news. You can ignore it too and be just fine.
Kara Swisher
What surprised you most in terms of the topics that get the most engagement versus the least engagement? What surprised you?
Jessica Yellin
Well, right now, I'm sorry to report that Ukraine does not get a lot of engagement. As important as it is, it's a little like, okay, we did that. I still keep it up there, but that's not drawing eyeballs. What is drawing a lot of eyeballs right now is mental health issues, which is I know something you talk a lot about. And people are extremely passionate about it. They have a lot of points of view about what needs to be done, what works, what doesn't. And those conversations get so much engagement. I've deliberately worked in sort of wellness and mental health breaks into the news, especially on days that I say have a lot of awful. People just need the let up. I even do one newsletter I call News That Doesn't Suck just to give people a break from how much really high stakes negative information there is out there right now.
Scott Galloway
Well, in one case, they sort of lean into that idea of fear mongering. In the other case, there is some tough stories out there. And so when you think about large news organizations, the way they attract right now is through fear and anger. Fox News is like in a constant state of grievance, but MSNBC and CNN tend to do the same things. And then it goes all the way down to local news, which I characterize as the expression, "it could happen to you." And then no matter what it is, mold or killer bees or a rash, it could happen to you.
Kara Swisher
It could happen to you.
Scott Galloway
My favorite is "your shoelaces could kill you after the break."
Kara Swisher
Yeah, right. That kind of stuff. How do you, what do you think the biggest problem facing them is if this is their formula, this is their business model. And then I'd love you to come on on your business model because it's hard just on the other side of it.
Jessica Yellin
So I think that they made a decision in TV news, far predating today, when I was a baby reporter, that conflict is what draws eyeballs, period. And that accelerated over time to fast forward to the Trump era when there was a lot of cause to be outraged. But it then was like outrage on steroids. And it's left people in this place where showing you care equals outrage. Like there's not another, you're either at zero or 10, no in between. And that's just the model. It's got a lot of fear, like you're saying. Also, just a sense of negativity, like a negative valence. The motto when I launched News Not Noise, my motto was, "we give you information, not a panic attack."
And I used to feel when I was on the White House lawn that some days we were just competing for your anxiety. I grew up in LA and this is the home of Hollywood where they made an entire business of doing content that's largely based on another set of emotions, which are compassion and empathy. And I thought there's an audience that really wants this and there's a way to do news that has compassion and empathy. And I'll just say there is neuroscience that shows that some of that screaming shuts down learning in some people, in some brains. And so it actually turns off the audience. That's what they're committed to.
I think-
Kara Swisher
But they can't stop watching, right? At the same time.
Jessica Yellin
No, I know a lot of people, they turn it off. Or if I do speeches and I'm in audiences of people, it's people under 50 who go, "I can't take it. I just can't." They do this consistently with their ears. They put their hands to their ears. "I can't do it." And it's not that they don't care about the information. It's not that they can't handle how awful the news really is, like the information. It's the added valence we put on it of just rage and conflict and outrage. So I worked hard on thinking, how do we do that differently? How do we unpack that part and bring people into a conversation with a vibe of caring and curiosity.
Kara Swisher
How do you make money doing that?
Jessica Yellin
Yeah. So when I started, I honestly didn't know how I was going to monetize. I thought, you draw an audience with an audience, you can figure out how to monetize. So the first thing, I have three revenue streams. I take money from partners or sponsors, however you want to call them. I get money from the audience and I have deals with some of the platforms. And I think it is wise and really effective to have multiple revenue streams in a content business. In that space, my biggest regret was not asking the audience to support me sooner. I was so sort of hesitant to do that. And once I did, the response was like so overwhelming and gratifying. And it also gives you this deeper connection with your, you know, everyone calls them super users. It actually helps direct the business.
Scott Galloway
So whether it's YouTube or Instagram or email newsletter, is there a medium you wish you'd invested less and another medium you wish you'd invested more in?
Jessica Yellin
Oh, that's interesting. You know, my biggest dilemma is something you talk a lot about, which is TikTok. And if you talk to sort of brand experts, they're like, "you got to be all over TikTok, TikTok's the place." But so much of what I do is also about, is mission driven. It's about democracy. People need to be informed to engage. And I just am a little uncomfortable.
Kara Swisher
So and then I always, you know, why are you a little uncomfortable, Jessica?
Jessica Yellin
China. I just I feel like why am I going to drive more people into deeper engagement and a platform where I believe that the Chinese government can scoop up their data and even drive sentiment here? And I don't you know, why do I need to be feeding that?
Scott Galloway
So let me just press pause there because this is an interesting and we get a lot of discussion or questions around this. You are more concerned with the negative externalities of having content on TikTok than having it on meta.
Jessica Yellin
Yes.
Scott Galloway
Now, maybe you know more than I do and you can tell me I'm wrong. I just-
Jessica Yellin
No, trust me, I don't. I think we all struggle with this. It's like, how can you be so critical of TikTok? I mean, it's just anyways, I think everybody's trying to figure this out.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. We had a lot of people at Code talking about this. Like Axel Springer's CEO said, "we're doing everything to resist it. And eventually we're not going to be able to because it's the medium of the moment." I think a lot of people are struggling. I think they all problematic in their own ways. I'm curious a lot of what you're talking about is something that Chris Licht at CNN where he used to work is pushing. And again Chris Cuomo at this News Nation which is Project Neutral. Is that the right direction? Do you see more of this? And can they keep audiences? You know, Fox is only growing with their anger machine, their persistent rage machine.
Jessica Yellin
Well, I think the answer is yes. I do think it will work and it'll keep audiences. I think that you have to shift your expectations. When I was growing up and I watched CNN in the Tiananmen Square moment, it was just the centerpiece of the world to me. CNN drew huge eyeballs at major events and accepted that they would get less audience in between. It also became a place where you could actually reach independents and swing voters, which is enormously valuable and profitable, right? You can charge more for that. So I do think there's a space for that. I think, listen, when I started on Instagram, I was one of the only people doing what I do. But now there's a bazillion people telling you what matters in the world, all outraged and dancing and screaming about how awful this party is or that. So there's plenty of left-right content out there. And I think there is a white space that attracts the people who feel a little homeless right now. And I don't know exactly how CNN is going to execute on that. But I think that Chris Licht in particular has a track record of making very watchable TV and people should just give him a moment to do it.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Scott, last question. What advice would you have if you started this new media company and you've done it yourself? What advice would you give to somebody who wants to start a media company that's news-centered? What mediums would you use? Business model? It sounds like you've already said go right to, I mean, is it fair to call it tipping? I don't know what you call it, like the telegraph model or the guardian model. What advice? You're starting this with a clean slate. How would you do it differently?
Jessica Yellin
I guess I would start with a platform outside of any of the current social media platforms and consistently drive to your own website or your own newsletter or whatever the thing is you're doing outside the algorithms from day one, even if it didn't have super high numbers. And just really focus in on what the audience is responding to and continue to deliver that. It's this conversation. I think everybody pooh-poohs Web3 or where's it going, but the thing that I find interesting about Web3 is it's this ongoing circular conversation, and I do think conceptually that's where the media needs to go, and those are the businesses that will really excel because we are sorting into sort of, I call it not like-minded, but like-valued communities. And so lean into that.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, that's absolutely true. Just a quick follow-up. I get the sense you're working all the time.
Kara Swisher
I mean, I'm a huge follower of Newsman. She's having three-hour lunches with Scott Galloway. That was a vacation. That was for her mental health, Kara.
Scott Galloway
So, but I love, I literally love Newsman. I find it so rational and calm and informative. And it's like a quick burst of information, get me to what I need to know without the superlatives or the adjectives. But you are putting out content all day long. Do you have a team?
Jessica Yellin
So yes, I have a team and they're amazing. And also I am one of those people who I just, I need to sometimes share, right? So for me, it is somehow therapeutic to be able to comment on these things and respond to people. Sometimes it's exhausting because people now write me and they'll say things like, "do you think I should get the monkeypox vaccine? I trust you. So tell me what to do." And I'm like, "I can't be your doctor." But it, so that can get, it can wear on me. But I just, I really love it. And that's why I do it. And now I got a puppy and that really, he, it's crazy. He sometimes knows when I'm like in a Twitter rabbit hole and he starts yapping at me. So he gets me out.
Scott Galloway
Bruno.
Jessica Yellin
Bruno.
Kara Swisher
It's game changed.
Scott Galloway
Oh my God, it's dog talk time.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, that's okay. Don't worry about it. Jessica, this is really exciting. I'm glad you did it so early. Just remember, Jessica was doing this in 2018 before it's now sort of the thing to talk about neutral news. But you did it. You called it much earlier of people talking about it. You can find everything News Not Noise on the web at newsnotnoise.com and on Instagram at Jessica Yellen, because someone else has taken News Not Noise on the Instagram. And we're going to get on that soon. Thank you, Jessica.
Jessica Yellin
Thank you so much. Long-time listeners. So glad to be on.
Scott Galloway
Favorite lunch date.
Jessica Yellin
Favorite lunch date.
Kara Swisher
Okay, Scott, would you invest? If you invested in that, how would you think of it as an investment opportunity? I asked Jessica, and she said she wasn't ready or she was just kind of figuring it out.
Scott Galloway
I think news, not noise is, I just, I think the world of her. And I think it's so important that talented people find new mediums to communicate kind of just the facts, man, like straight down the middle, tries not to give in to the need to tickle our sensors and get engagement through enragement. And I would just advocate enormously for, and I didn't know Jessica before this, I reached out to her and said, "I just want to know you and I want to know how I can be helpful because I think what you're doing is really important."
Kara Swisher
You're a fan. So you're a fan. Anyway, that's really interesting. Okay, one more quick break. We'll be back for wins and fails.
Break
Okay, Scott, let's hear some wins and fails. Go for it.
Scott Galloway
Okay, so my fail is, you know, moves to London once. The new prime minister, Prime Minister Truss, has decided their first move was to enact an economic package that essentially the centerpiece was to eliminate the top marginal tax rate. So it used to be 40% that you got rid of that. And the thinking was, and you'll recognize this, that our most productive citizens, when they have more money, reinvest in the economy and grow the economy. Now, I think there's an argument for that, but at a minimum, you want to pay for it through other means or other revenue increases. But they've decided to embrace this sort of trickle down economics where let's cut taxes on the rich and explode our deficit.
And it's as if they have learned nothing. America has been in a 40-year experiment that that just doesn't work. It might send stocks up in the short run, but it creates income inequality, divisiveness, polarization, households or one in five households have kids that are economically insecure. And what do you know? They've decided to ignore that, but the markets have decided, no, we've learned from that. And the pound has crashed. I mean, literally, you're seeing the pound for a brief time today. It was at a buck oh three. It's at an all time low because the market goes, "sister, this shit doesn't work."
It doesn't work when you have when you've decided to give money to the wealthy and pay it with the credit card. She likes the wealthy. When pay it with the credit card that our children and our grandchildren have to pay back. It's like, have you learned nothing?
Kara Swisher
Anyways, I like you going into British politics. There you go.
Scott Galloway
I don't like it. I don't like it. My win is CNBC journalist or reporter Deirdre Bosa. She did an interview with Keith Raboy this weekend or on Friday talking about Open Door. And Keith kicked off the interview by saying that Open Door has been profitable for five years straight. That is not true. As a matter of fact, I think they lost two thirds of a billion dollars last year. And when she politely stopped him and said that is not true, he said that it was insane and stupid and started walking it back and saying on a contribution basis, on a gross margin basis. He then went on to say that stock-based compensation was fake.
No, it's not fake. It's a real thing, Keith. And he then went on to say that he would love to buy shares in this, but he's prohibited from doing so, which is an outright lie. And this is continuing a pattern of SPACs being the ultimate vehicle for transfer of wealth from retail investors to their promoters. And this stock, this algorithmically driven real estate buying industry is unproven. The one company that should have owned this, Zillow, got out. It was losing so much money. And we gave Opendoor the benefit of the doubt and said, it's a pure play. It's now off 84% over the last 12 months.
And his, in my opinion, inaccuracies and mistruths were so brazen. I mean, I got to give the guy credit for being so confident when he lies like this. And Deidre was just, she defined forceful yet dignified. And there's a lot about CNBC I've been critical of. They consistently attract journalists who are able to bring that sort of a composure. I wouldn't have been able to control myself.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. You know, he's probably on Twitter now insulting her. That's his other go-to.
Scott Galloway
Oh, he called her comments. He called her comments insane and stupid. It was a mix between cringe, SEC violations, and mansplaining wrapped up in a CNBC interview.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, he's aggressive.
Scott Galloway
Literally first ballot hall of fame for worst spokesperson for a company ever. But she did not take the bait. She was cool as a fucking cucumber and just stopped him and said, "no, that's not right. You are not profitable. According to Gap Accounting, you are hemorrhaging money." My anyways, my win is CNBC and Deidre Bosa, who like was really, I thought, showed tremendous discipline and grace and just politely pointed out that this guy was enormously full of shit and wasn't going to let her viewers get co-opted by this constant stream of, "trust me, I'm a billionaire. I know better than you. Buy my stock. I'm selling, but you should buy."
Kara Swisher
Yeah, there's a whole strain of that among those types, his types. There's a whole gang of them that do that. They try to bully people into thinking you're stupid and you're not. Deirdre, well done. Anyway, my-
Scott Galloway
Do you have any wins and fails?
Kara Swisher
Yes, I do. It's interesting. The New York Times has published a story that said TikTok's seen to be moving toward U.S. security deal, but hurdles remain. It would keep the Chinese-owned video app operating in the United States under review. It could mean ByteDance still owns it. I don't know how they're going to thread this needle of it being a Chinese company.
Scott Galloway
I don't get it either. Do you have any details on that? Do you know what that means?
Kara Swisher
No. This says the two sides have hammered out the foundations of a deal in which TikTok would make changes to its data security and governance without requiring its owner, the Chinese internet ByteDance, to sell it. I just don't understand. It's being run by Lisa Monaco, who's very intelligent about this stuff. And obviously, those people there are quite sharp. I don't quite know how they can protect the, I don't know. I think it'll be politically very difficult to complete an agreement that doesn't have a spinoff at this point. And the Biden administration doesn't want to be seen as soft on China, I think.
So Senator Marco Rubio, who's such a dumbass, but this is what he said, "anything short of a complete separation of TikTok from Biden will likely have seen national security issues regarding operations data and algorithms unresolved." I think they're not going to let go of this bone, even if it was the safest place in the world. I think they're just not letting go of it. So we'll see where it goes. But I don't know if it's a win or a fail. I'll be interviewing the US CEO soon. So I don't know. I think it's so sucked up into a political thing now. And it's also a good cudgel by media companies who aren't as competitive creatively to them.
And then a win is, I love that Olivia Wilde's movie, Don't Worry Darling, did incredibly well at the box office, along with Woman Warrior, by the way. Even despite all the noise about her fights with the, which is so ridiculous. It's always the woman's fighting with having a cat fight. There's all kinds of problems on most sets of Hollywood movies.
Scott Galloway
Isn't it a good movie?
Kara Swisher
No, but apparently it's about the metaverse.
Scott Galloway
It's about the metaverse. Oh, good.
Kara Swisher
So we'll see. We'll see. So no, I haven't. I want to see Woman Warrior first, but I have not a lot of free time. I am right now watching, as I said, The Dropout. So good. Amanda Seyfried. I hadn't seen it. It's mind-blowingly good. I'm on the last episode and Amanda fell asleep last night. We're going to watch it tonight, I think. But it's really good. So I'm excited to see both those movies. Both by women directors and doing really well at the box office. So I'd say that's a plus as far as I can tell. Anyway, that's it for our show. We want to hear from you. Send us your questions about business tech or whatever's on your mind. Go to nymag.com slash pivot to submit a question for the show or call 855-51-PIVOT. Scott, as I said, that's the show. It's great being with you. I love our show.
Scott Galloway
You know, I love our show, my new show, but I love our show too. Pivot still remains a joy to do every day. We do it. And I will be in London in like a day or two to stay with you for a month.
Kara Swisher
We could go to the Apple store in London. That would be a real British highlight.
Scott Galloway
That's where I take all the tourists.
Kara Swisher
We'll be back on Friday for more. Scott, read us out.
Scott Galloway
Today's show was produced by Lara Neiman, Evan Engel, and Taylor Griffin. Ernie and Jertot engineered this episode. Thanks also to Drew Burrows and Neil Silverio. Make sure you subscribe to the show wherever you listen to podcasts. Thanks for listening to Pivot from New York Magazine and Vox Media. We'll be back later this week for another breakdown of all things tech and business. England versus Germany tonight in a friendly at Wembley Stadium as we begin our march towards Doha. Go England.