Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses various topics related to business, technology, and media, including the impact of generative AI on content creation, the departure of Netflix's Reed Hastings as co-CEO, layoffs in the tech industry, and the concept of "chokepoint capitalism" in creative labor markets.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Kara Swisher
As marketing channels have multiplied, the demand for content has skyrocketed. But everyone can make content that's on brand and stands out with Adobe Express. You don't have to be a designer to generate images, rewrite text, and create effects. That's the beauty of generative AI that's commercially safe. Teams all across your business will be psyched to collaborate and create amazing presentations, videos, social posts, flyers, and more. Meet Adobe Express, the quick and easy app to create on-brand content. Learn more at adobe.com slash express slash business.
Ad continues
Rinse takes your laundry and hand delivers it to your door. Expertly cleaned and folded. So you could take the time once spent folding and sorting and waiting to finally pursue a whole new version of you. Like Tea Time You. Mmm. Or this Tea Time You. Or even this Tea Time You. Said you hear about Dave. Or even Tea Time, Tea Time, Tea Time You. Mmm. So update on Dave. It's up to you. We'll take the laundry. Rinse. It's time to be great.
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Cara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And I just had my play date with your friend here.
Kara Swisher
Oh, good.
Scott Galloway
The tough guy act that Cara puts on. She's actually quite worried about me. And you're actually very maternal. And she's been setting up a series of play dates for me. And I had my second one today.
Kara Swisher
Patty? Yeah, with Patty. How was that?
Scott Galloway
So, yeah, he's a very impressive man.
Kara Swisher
Isn't he? I thought you would like... He's very tall too. I thought you'd like that.
Scott Galloway
He's tall. He's very tall. He's very handsome. I like to hang out with people better looking than me.
Kara Swisher
Exactly. I try to think these things too. This is Patty Harbison. He was the comms, essentially the comms person for Prince Charles, but much more than that. He's a very high level comms person. And the real one, he was the head of comms for Manchester United.
Scott Galloway
Yes. I thought you'd like that part.
Kara Swisher
I work on these things. I try to set you up with people. And he's just sort of cool. He was on my podcast talking about Prince Harry, the book and everything. And he was quite, for someone who worked for Prince Charles, he was very even-handed, which I was surprised at. So it was interesting. He's a sharp, sharp, calm strategy kind of person that I thought was great.
Scott Galloway
No, I'm assembling my cancellation team. He's going to handle my PR, my calm strategy.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Well, I'm glad you're making friends. I have more friends for you to meet. And I'm just selecting them carefully. I don't want to have anyone you're not going to do well with.
Scott Galloway
I know. Well, I do it for my kids. So I know how to do children, how to get children happier into their surroundings.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, Al's gone to a couple of colleges. I'm not allowed to talk about him, but he's now relieved.
Scott Galloway
Did he get into?
Kara Swisher
I'm not telling you. I can't tell you. I can't. He won't be mad at me, but I'm glad he's relieved. He thought he wasn't going to get into anything. He's already gotten into two, which is great. I'm very happy.
Scott Galloway
That's great. Well, he should know that it was really a function of his excellence and the fact that he has rich parents. But congratulations, Alex.
Kara Swisher
No, it was not. He really got great grades. And Louis Swisher got straight A's at NYU. So I'm very happy.
Scott Galloway
They all get straight A's. Every high school kid gets straight A's now.
Kara Swisher
No, they don't. Not Louis Swisher. So I'm going to celebrate my amazing children.
Scott Galloway
Did he get into any good public schools?
Kara Swisher
Yes.
Scott Galloway
Really?
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, that's where we're aiming. That's the real test. The public schools try and stay, they try and... they haven't lost the script. They're actually looking at kids based on their merit.
Kara Swisher
Most of the ones he applied to are public schools. He wants a big public university.
Scott Galloway
Really?
Kara Swisher
Yes.
Scott Galloway
Yes. He doesn't like the Ivies.
Kara Swisher
He does not like them. I can't believe he hasn't called me about this. This is one of the few things I know a decent amount about.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
He doesn't... hasn't been interested in what you think or what I think. He did it all himself. He's an amazing kid.
Scott Galloway
Good for him.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, there's a lot to talk about.
Scott Galloway
Thank you. I'm very pleased.
Kara Swisher
And Clara made a lovely crown at school. It was very nice. I was very pleased with that. So there we have it. And Saul's walking.
Scott Galloway
Well, we're all caught up on the kids.
Kara Swisher
Caught up on the kids. Anyway, today we'll talk about Netflix earnings and a high-profile departure. Also, layoffs hit Google as the company calls in some big guns. And we'll speak with author Corey Doctorow about how big tech robs artists and content creators.
First, Jeff Zients will replace Ron Klain, who I actually know pretty well, as President Biden's chief of staff, ahead of a likely reelection campaign and a probe of Biden's mishandling of classified documents. Zients formerly served as the COVID-19 response coordinator for the Biden administration. Pretty good job. Klain, who's been with Biden forever, also has been in tech. That's why I know him. Plans to leave after the State of the Union in February, with the longest lasting first chief of staff for any Democratic president. Very calm. Not a lot of... it wasn't certainly wasn't Trump's first two years. So any thoughts on this?
Scott Galloway
Everything I've read about him kind of describes quiet power and sort of a behind the scenes power player.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. And very well liked, very savvy.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. It sounds like a loss for the administration because it sounds like he did exactly what he was supposed to do with a lot of that tough job.
Kara Swisher
Right. Yeah. Oh yeah. You have to... well, he got a reasonable person he's working for. So it's not like he has to do crazy things in the middle of the night kind of stuff. But yes, I mean, the only thing about this, and I happen to think all these people are very confident, is that you would wonder... he has to sort of stick with his guys. He has his guys that he's had forever. And speaking of friends, like play dates, that's all he knows, that's how he goes. And I get that when you're president, it's who can you trust rather than people who are in it for something. And I do think the Trump administration and many administrations are full of people who want to advantage themselves constantly. I think these people have been with him. And I think about that a lot with tech companies, too, about the people around people. Enablers, as you know, is an issue. We've talked about it at Twitter. It's happened at Google and Facebook and stuff like that. Just interesting.
Scott Galloway
Well, look, I think most people would agree that one of the president's real victories is that he's... and maybe it's just contrast to the previous administration, but he surrounded himself with a lot of competent people.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
And a team of the best players wins. Not jazz hands. Not a lot of Omarosas there.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, speaking of enablers, Musk is not talking about Twitter this week, but he's talking about his tweets, the funding-secured tweets in court. He's in court in the San Francisco Bay Area. As a reminder, the Tesla CEO tweeted at the time the deal to take the company private at $420 a share was confirmed. The claim was false. The deal didn't happen. Musk testified that it's difficult to link Tesla stock price to his tweets. Of course, then they had someone doing just that. He said that short selling should be made illegal, referring to those who do it as bad people on Wall Street. That may be. It has nothing to do with this. He was trying to battle short sellers, I think, in that regard. And then he said people shouldn't believe his tweets. Trial's continuing. He's not done yet. I think he's testifying some more today. I don't think he came off particularly well, but that's an interesting defense, a novel defense. Don't believe what I tweet.
Scott Galloway
Let's look at these statements. He testified that it's difficult to link Tesla stock price to his tweets.
Kara Swisher
No, actually, there's statistical, there's all sorts of evidence backed by...
Scott Galloway
Yeah, the investors had that. They had those people, but go ahead. The moment he said that, the stock skyrocketed. There was no other information.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, hitting the short sellers.
Scott Galloway
We live in a society where the CEOs of publicly traded companies are expected to tell the truth and not issue false information that sends a stock way up or way down. And he might not like short sellers, but short selling is something that almost every major pension fund engages in to hedge their bets, such that if the market goes down as it did last year, the firemen and school teachers and firewomen who have invested with that pension fund don't get hurt as badly. So shorting is just a component of the market. So what happened when he put out that lie? And let's be honest, it was a lie. People who were short got burned. People who thought, "Oh, maybe this is the maximum number the stock will ever go to because it's being bought. I'm taking it private. Maybe I sell my stock," and the stock went up. I mean, this is the bottom line: a lot of people were taking actions that may or may not have benefited them based on the statements of a CEO who is expected by law to tell the truth.
Kara Swisher
Yes. So this hasn't gotten a lot of coverage. Everyone's obsessed with Twitter. But I'll ask you this. What other CEO has gone in a public format and said the company is being taken private at this number and I have the funding secured? And as many people that want to be involved with him, want to be in his next deal, want to provide financing, no one would actually say, "Oh, yeah, I can see why he would have thought that we were funding it."
Scott Galloway
He's saying he thought it was a done deal.
Kara Swisher
He still shouldn't have tweeted it at all. I mean, besides, he's doing all these excuses. "I thought it was a done deal. The Saudis were in, but then they were out." You don't do it at all. And then you don't do it if you don't know for certain, something like that. And even if you were doing something to... I think he was trying to screw the short sellers. I think that's what was happening here. So that's what he was doing. But he can't do that. He just can't do that. I think he's probably going to lose this trial. And then he'll continue to litigate, I'm sure.
Scott Galloway
It would be striking if he wasn't found and severely... have a pretty serious settlement here because you could argue so many different ways that so many different people and organizations lost tens of billions of dollars here. And you have, as someone who has been on boards of public companies, you have to be correctly so careful about what you say because you don't want to give people misleading information. And I mean, I'm talking about even... I remember I was on the board of Eddie Bauer and we were doing an earnings call.
Kara Swisher
Wow. Remember Eddie Bauer?
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
I can't believe you were on the board of Eddie Bauer, but go ahead.
Scott Galloway
Anyways, I was on the board of Eddie Bauer. And the company was doing really poorly. And we were about to go... we were contemplating a bankruptcy filing. And we had our annual meeting. And 100 people showed up to the annual meeting. And the CEO, we were reviewing the script of the CEO. And the CEO was immediately breaking the song about what a great brand it is. I'm like, "Boss, you should say nothing." Because anything that even indicates things are going well, maybe some guy or gal in the audience goes out and buys stock. And tomorrow we might file bankruptcy and the stock goes to zero. So you just... but that's how thoughtful you need to be.
Kara Swisher
That's what happened to Bob Chapin. Remember he was going on about Disney when it was the report, right then when he was reporting that release.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, you really... this guy doesn't have any kind of governor on himself. He is just an id tweeter.
Kara Swisher
And that's still no excuse. That's still no excuse. And by the way, he can't... if he loses this and it's a lot of money, he can't afford it. Twitter's $300 million interest payment is due. Let's be clear. They have the money due that they have with cash flow. So they've also got a loan that they can borrow, a $500 million credit line, essentially. So they can pay this thing. It's just it'll put them further into debt. And then he'll have another one in another couple of months. And so it's going to be sort of a... hide the whatever, hide the sausage, forget the game. It's going to be try to pay this thing over and over again. And at some point, he's going to run out of space, presumably, unless he dips into his own money. And that'll affect his other shares, whether it's, especially Tesla.
Scott Galloway
My dad used to tell me that the rich live hand to mouth as well, just on a higher level.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
And it strikes me the same thing as here because you have the third wealthiest man in the world in a cash crunch. He has, based on the stuff I've read, he has the money to make this payment. But he has a company that is unsustainable. He has a company where 50% of the total revenues are going to have to go to interest payments, which means his company does not work. And so he either needs to... there's really... I can't see him going down to, what, 10% of the original staff. He's down to 25%. So it's going to be hard to cut more costs. So he's going to have to come up with something that grows revenues. And that's conceivable. Maybe he'll come up...
Kara Swisher
Let's help him.
Scott Galloway
What?
Kara Swisher
Well, at this point, he doesn't have time to do anything that significant. I mean, it sounds very boring, what he needs to do is play nice and kiss some serious advertiser ass right now and try and get the people who are already used to spending money on the platform back on it.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, they'll come back if it's fine, if it has efficacy. They'll come back. But that's my point. That's the shortest route between points A and B. He needs to get revenue in the door immediately.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
And anything around subscription at this point or AI or whatever jazz hands we want to talk about will take years in additional investment.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it's an erosion of equity for sure for the people who own it. I mean, it's going to go... most people think it's to zero anyway, the equity he has, given the... like it's not worth anything. But at the same time, he's really got to keep... get money in the door. They keep talking about this subscription thing isn't working, long-form tweets. It's all long-term and difficult to build those businesses and really hard. I think advertising is his only quick revenue, quick-fix revenue, for sure.
Scott Galloway
But this notion around CEOs and their communications... imagine a CEO is about to leave a company and he's going to retire and he's got a bunch of options vesting and he wants to sell them and he wants to set himself up. If that jury doesn't find Elon Musk guilty and hit him pretty hard, what's to stop every CEO on the date of their vesting or when they're about to sell shares from going, "Oh, guess what? We're in talks to take the company private at an 80% premium." I mean, at some point, nothing any company CEO will say will be believable.
Kara Swisher
Right. And what's to stop any of them from going... well, his argument was like, "Most people don't believe me because I'm such a non-unbelievable. Most people don't believe me." That was essentially what he said, I think. I wasn't quite clear what he was saying.
Scott Galloway
Well, that's not true. The markets do believe him.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
When he says, when any CEO, including him, of a public company says, "I'm taking the company private at $420 a share and the funding has been secured," the markets take that seriously.
Kara Swisher
Yes, I agree. I agree.
Anyway, lastly, one thing that I do think is unfair, I have to say, and I usually don't take Amazon's side here, but the U.S. Attorney's Office in Manhattan is investigating whether Amazon downplayed a safety record in order to get credit from lenders. The investigation makes use of a law from 1989 that could allow the government to bring a civil case against Amazon. They should focus on the safety record of whether they told the truth and they should focus on lenders. But this seems like a turducken to me, a legal turducken. But I don't know about you.
Scott Galloway
I agree with you. When I read it, I had trouble understanding it. And it felt like... like that big tech has become such an enviable or easy punching bag that this is... it just felt like overreaching.
Kara Swisher
They should do it against markets. They should do antitrust. They could look into safety. You know these are all... it's like sort of those omnibus bills that they shove everything in. It just seems a turducken, legal turducken.
Scott Galloway
Anyway, I like a turducken. Have you ever had a turducken? Have you ever done that?
Kara Swisher
I do know what it is.
Scott Galloway
You don't know what a turducken is. I think this is you showing off your Georgetown medals.
Kara Swisher
No, it's a food thing. You put a turkey...
Scott Galloway
Oh, a turkey and a duck?
Kara Swisher
Duck and a chicken. You put the chicken in the duck, I think. And you put them all in the cavity of the turkey, but one inside the other. It's really kind of sick in the head. And then you cook them all. Turducken.
Scott Galloway
Thank you. Nice.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. It's lots of meat, but it's really propulsive.
Kara Swisher
Anyway.
Scott Galloway
It's like the Long Island iced tea of fowl. Just put everything in there.
Kara Swisher
I kept wondering if it turned dark. Anyway.
Scott Galloway
All right.
Kara Swisher
Let's get to our first big story. Reed Hastings could be the gray man of Netflix. That's a joke about a show they have. Hastings announced his departure as co-CEO last week. He will be replaced by the company's COO, Greg Peters, and Ted Sarandos will remain as co-CEO. The news came as Netflix reported its fourth quarter earnings. Let's look into this glass onion. The service added more than 7 million subscribers, beating expectations of 4.5 million. Netflix hasn't said how much of that growth comes from the new ad-supported tier, but Netflix doesn't want to talk subscriber numbers. It's no longer issuing guidance there.
It's focusing on a kaleidoscope of their finances instead, but still earnings per share were down more than 90% from a year ago and the company slightly missed on revenue expectations. They're sort of trying to build this business. I think that's fine. It seems like it's off to a good start with Microsoft as their provider. And this co-CEO thing still confuses me. Hastings, of course, as we talked about, has a long and august history. He's done a great job, his work, but he's still there as executive chairman. So they have probably a very involved executive chairman and two CEOs. And I guess Sarandos couldn't just have the single one.
Scott Galloway
I actually like the co-CEO thing. It's actually a pretty smart strategy because it doesn't give any one employee too much leverage over the enterprise.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I guess.
Scott Galloway
And when they get along, it seems like Reed and Ted had a nice partnership.
Kara Swisher
But we've talked about Reed a lot. And I've always thought, well, Reed gets a lot of warranted credit. I still don't think he gets the credit for his role in changing business. I think what he accomplished is nothing short of remarkable. Think about it. He was doing DVDs by mail, and he had this vision of broadband, but his vision of broadband was the US Postal Service. He said, "There's a million people delivering content to a hundred million homes. That's the broadband infrastructure we want to leverage." And then we saw actual broadband come into the market. He moved into it. He had the greatest pivot probably in business history.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, for sure.
Kara Swisher
And then he was the first major player to go vertical in content with House of Cards. I mean, these guys have always been sort of one step ahead. He's quite good. I think the move to advertising was smart. I think it's just what's happening inside. I mean, I think people were wondering why Sarandos didn't get the single CEO ship. Probably he himself. He said he's gotten used to it. He expressed a little bit of surprise, I think, in one of the interviews. And he has a little reputation for greenlighting everything, and some of them are poor performers. I'd like to shed some light, though, on one thing.
They moved Bella Bejarria, who I've done an interview with, who I think a lot of. She was promoted to chief content officer. She was running the television part, and then a guy named Scott Stuber is running the film thing, and he's reporting to her. One of the things that really drove me crazy is a lot of the media was going, "Oh, they had to put her name in for a diversity thing." This is the woman who got... I'll go back: Squid Games, Indian Matchmaking. She did Wednesday. She did all kinds of things, Bridgerton. She got great stuff. She did Dahmer. All the big hits there are her team, essentially, across the globe.
And they just profiled her in The New Yorker as someone who likes commercial popular stuff. And it was a weird article, I thought. But she's certainly been behind a lot of their success. Now, a lot of people say, "Why wasn't she made a co-CEO?" That is an excellent question. But...
Scott Galloway
Well, clearly because she's a woman, as you're implying.
Kara Swisher
No, I'm not implying that. No, no, no. I don't know. Why are we talking about this?
Scott Galloway
Because on a lot of the coverage...
Kara Swisher
Let me finish. I'm sorry, go ahead.
Scott Galloway
She's in the press release or got this thing because of diversity and because of being a woman.
Kara Swisher
She got the job because she's talented, period. That's what I'm saying. But a lot of the media coverage is still done by guys. I'm sorry. And a lot of people I regard well were like, "Oh, she got it because they put her in there because..." Well, maybe they put her in there because she deserved the job. It just drove me crazy watching the coverage because she's certainly, of all these people, she's had the most hits for them, which is interesting.
Scott Galloway
Not just that. To your point, she did that great Netflix series about Abraham Lincoln.
Kara Swisher
I don't remember.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. Don't you remember the finale was shot before a live audience?
Kara Swisher
Oh, my God. Oh, my God. You're such an asshole. I'm trying to say...
Scott Galloway
That's good.
Kara Swisher
No, look, she's doing a lot of stuff that's premium and commercial. She did Love is Blind, Selling Sunset, but also is doing this three-body problem with the Game of Thrones people. Like, I just feel like it's... I was watching that coverage.
Scott Galloway
You wanted her to be a co-CEO.
Kara Swisher
No, I didn't want her to be a co-CEO. I just didn't want them to then, if she wasn't co-CEO, to say she's on the press release because of this.
Scott Galloway
Who said that?
Kara Swisher
Lots of the coverage. Lots of the coverage I was reading. I'm not going to call anyone out because there's a lot of people I like who did it. But I just feel like it was quite... she'll probably be the CEO at some point, probably would be my guess. Nonetheless, I was irritated by that. Very irritated. I was like mad. I tweeted it. I was mad.
Scott Galloway
No, see, you like to downplay. Like, look at this. I'm literally just sitting here. I'm literally... this is, we have officially become a married couple. I'm just trying to find an elegant way out of your anger right now. What can I do?
Kara Swisher
No, I'm not angry.
Scott Galloway
Why don't you... like people who do like things.
Kara Swisher
Can I take out the trash? Can I hit our kids? What can I do to make it happen?
Scott Galloway
Last thing.
Kara Swisher
No, last thing is what drove me crazy is they then re-brought up this Cindy Holland, who was a great programmer, too. But Bella makes more popular stuff and she came from reality.
Scott Galloway
I can see why you're angry.
Kara Swisher
No, but here's the situation. They were still having that fight happening. It's such a sexist cat fight. I'm lost.
Scott Galloway
I'm lost. Let me just say congratulations to Bella Bejario. Congratulations to Greg Peters. And congratulations to Reed Hastings, who was a legend and legendary CEO.
Kara Swisher
All right. Agreed.
Scott Galloway
Fine. Agreed.
Kara Swisher
All right, Scott, let's go on a quick break. When we come back, layoffs hit a new high. We'll speak with a friend of Pivot, Corey Doctorow, about how platforms shortchange content creators.
Ad break
Not all journalism is the same. Take The Guardian. Our coverage has something unique, fierce independence. Nobody owns us or tells us what we can and can't say, so we're free to report the whole picture. We connect what's happening in Washington to the rest of the globe, expose corruption wherever we find it, and give fresh perspective on everything, from wellness and soccer to culture, the climate, and more. Read, watch, and listen to The Guardian for free at theguardian.com.
Ad continues
Support for Pivot comes from LinkedIn. From talking about sports to discussing the latest movies, everyone is looking for a real connection to the people around them. But it's not just person to person. It's the same connection that's needed in business. And it can be the hardest part about B2B marketing: finding the right people, making the right connections. But instead of spending hours and hours scavenging social media feeds, you can just tap LinkedIn ads to reach the right professionals. According to LinkedIn, they have grown to a network of over 1 billion professionals, making it stand apart from other ad buys. You can target your buyers by job title, industry, company roles, seniority, skills, and company revenue, giving you all the professionals you need to reach in one place. So you can stop wasting budget on the wrong audience and start targeting the right professionals only on LinkedIn ads. LinkedIn will even give you $100 credit on your next campaign so you can try it for yourself. Just go to linkedin.com slash pivotpod. That's linkedin.com slash pivotpod. Terms and conditions apply. Only on LinkedIn ads.
Okay, Scott, we're back. We're disagreeing a lot lately. I kind of like it. What do you think?
Scott Galloway
We're feisty. We're the Bickersons. We were Bickersons in London, too.
Kara Swisher
You were wrong about Harry and you're wrong about government surveillance. That's what Patty said. Patty said I was wrong about Harry and Meghan. He thought I was harsh on the monarchy.
Scott Galloway
Thank you. Ha-ha. Ha-ha.
Kara Swisher
Well, he did work for them, but he has a perspective.
Scott Galloway
He did work for them, yeah.
Kara Swisher
All right, we'll get back to layoffs. January isn't even over, but already this month has seen more tech layoffs than the first half of 2022. Just since our last episode, Google announced that it will cut around 12,000 jobs, and not very nicely in some cases, according to some tweets I saw. Spotify said it will lose about 6% of its staff. That seems to be the number, 6%, 7%. Wayfair is laying off more than 1,700 people, and we're in the same boat. Vox Media cut 7% of its staff this past Friday. Google layoffs brought confusion. Employees reportedly found out by scanning their badges as they entered the office and seeing who was denied.
That's depressing. It wasn't clear how they made their layoff decisions. I think probably because some high performers were cut. The guy who wrote the book on search, a guy named Dan Russell, had been let go and stuff like that. I mean, they have their reasons for doing the things they're doing, probably. It felt haphazard at Google, for sure, but it continues. You have been someone who thought it was good because they had been cleaning up areas that they overhired in, for example, because they were doing a ton of hiring. And it does move people to different jobs. Most tech workers find jobs within three months, typically.
Scott Galloway
What's interesting, or I find interesting just from a societal standpoint, one thing about the tech workforce is it's very skilled, very educated, very well compensated, and also very young. It's so young that a lot of these people who have been laid off have never been through a layoff. And even when you look at what we're experiencing in colleges around America because of a variety of things, including concierge parenting or bulldozer parenting, a lot of these kids get to college having never known any disappointment. And they face their first disappointment, whether it's they get their first C or they have their heart broken. And they've had so many sanitary wipes used on their lives that they've never developed their own immunities. It's kind of this princess and the pea syndrome. And I think a little bit is playing out here. And that is, I think we have a generation of people that have never been in a down economy.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
And our...
Kara Swisher
The New York Times talking about that. The young people were like, "What?"
And the old people were like, "Yeah, whatever." Well, I was even thinking about my dad. He was on a real upslope in terms of his professional career, especially for a guy who was pulled out of school when he was 13, until about his 40s. And then when the 80s came and reengineering was the big thing, they used to come in and just anyone with a VP or SVP title, they would fire him. My dad moved from L.A. to Columbus, Ohio, to Chicago, to Phoenix, to Ocala, Florida, to back to Tucson. Because every two or three years you'd get fired from a big company and you'd have to go where the work was.
Something I've realized, my dad, to his credit, he was angry and depressed just generally, but he wasn't any angrier or more depressed. I don't want to say he got used to it, but people in the 70s and 80s, or just traditionally, people got... it wasn't an unusual thing. People had bad things happen to them professionally, so to speak. And if you are a tech employee under the age of, call it, 40, you likely have never seen a down economy. This is really rocking some worlds for some people.
Here's the bottom line. If you're at any of these companies, you're incredibly well-educated, incredibly skilled, probably very good at what you do. You live in a wonderful economy, a democracy. Traditional companies want to speak to you. These people are going to be just fine. They'll move to more areas they should move into.
Scott Galloway
Have you been laid off?
Kara Swisher
I've never been laid off. I've been fired. I think I've been fired from every job I've ever had.
Scott Galloway
I deserve that.
Kara Swisher
That's why I started in this. There is a certain... I always started businesses. People always say, "Oh, it's because you're so talented," and they give you the benefit of the doubt. It's not. It's because I don't have the skills to navigate and endure organizations. And that's not a feature, it's a bug. Because in order to do well in a corporate world, you have to be able to endure the occasional injustice. You have to be secure enough to not worry about what they're saying about you. You have to put up with bullshit. You have to put up with less talented people occasionally being promoted or paid more than you. That's just part of it. But if you can endure that, these organizations known as American corporations are probably the greatest platforms for wealth creation in history. People who are able to navigate a corporation are really skilled. I never had those skills.
Scott Galloway
That's why we like each other. I think we're bad employees.
Kara Swisher
We are bad employees. People romanticize entrepreneurs. My stalemate at Morgan Stanley—the only job I've ever really had was an analyst in fixed income—he stayed there and rose to vice chairman. We got together, and by most measures, I've been a fairly successful entrepreneur. We kind of ended up in the same place economically, but he did it with a lot less stress and a lot less ups and downs. A bad employee.
Scott Galloway
All right, I'm going to move on. Speaking of employees, Google founders Larry Page and Sergey Brin have returned to the company to help advise its AI efforts. This is a typical move by these companies. Google is reportedly in a panic mode after the debut of ChatGPT, like they didn't see it coming from OpenAI. Now, Google plans to release a suite of AI tools in its products. It's been working on this. It has its own versions of these things. I believe it's called LaMDA. I don't get this. These guys have been on boats and yachts, doing other things, riding around on many-wheeled bicycles. What are your thoughts on this?
Kara Swisher
Creativity within a big company. You're talking about the people that stay, right? The creative people tend to leave these big companies. Therefore, why would they create something like this at Google so Google can benefit? I just think most people have their self-interest. If you have something super cool, that's why I leave places. I don't want to share it. It's hard to be innovative within a big company, especially when your bread is being buttered by Google search for so long. Why would you innovate? Why would you push it and break it? I think the idea of founders coming back is very romantic, but kind of ridiculous.
Scott Galloway
You mean Larry and Sergey coming back?
Kara Swisher
Yeah. All of a sudden. I think the reason they didn't do this is because they're doing things that keep their business going and doing really well. There's no reason to be innovative within a big company when you're comfortable. Like you were talking about your friend. He probably didn't innovate anything in finance, did he? Even if he made the same amount of money as you.
Scott Galloway
Well, what you're referring to is Clayton Christensen's innovator's dilemma. You're remiss to kill the golden goose. You don't want to be the captain that says, "I know, let's build an iceberg to sink our own ship." One of the reasons Apple's been so successful is they've never been that scared to disrupt themselves. They took the iPod, a huge selling product, and turned it into an icon that goes on the iPhone.
Kara Swisher
That's the traditional... hard to do.
Scott Galloway
That's why big companies fail or stop innovating. They say, "Why on earth would we eat our own young?" But the Google thing is interesting. The founders coming back feels to me more like a photo op than anything else.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Do they really... they were checked out a decade ago. I think one of them's been sailing. I don't know what they're doing. I was at one of Sergey's ex-wives' events, and he arrived on like a 10-wheel bicycle. It was weird. This was a long time ago.
Scott Galloway
You're friends with one of his ex-wives?
Kara Swisher
Not friends. I was just there talking to her about something. I don't know about you, but I'm just incensed that she was a co-CEO of Netflix.
Scott Galloway
You know what? You don't even see it. Just like you don't see government surveillance. You've never been gay. I'm unconsciously biased.
Kara Swisher
You're consciously biased.
Scott Galloway
No, but I'm conscious of my unconscious bias.
Kara Swisher
Oh, my God. You don't even see it. Women and people of color don't get credit for things they accomplish most of the time. Guys get tons of credit. White guys get tons of credit. Sorry, it's just the way it is. It was irritating to see.
Scott Galloway
I channel women every day. I imagine a man and I take away reason and accountability, and boom, I'm a woman.
Kara Swisher
Oh, my God.
Scott Galloway
That's from *As Good as It Gets*. Great movie.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, I don't know why these guys can fix something. They've been busy having people peel them a grape for so long. Very smart people, but come on. Can they find some new, young, fresh people to think of? Or old, fresh people. I don't care. Fresh people. Young and fresh.
Scott Galloway
Not the old, young, fresh. Is this a deodorant commercial? We need young and fresh people.
Kara Swisher
And I also like the governing force of activists, by the way. I do like that activists are bugging Bob Iger. And now it's Salesforce, activist investor Elliott Management. I mean, good activists, not irritating ones that just want greenmail. They put up billions of dollars, what could be a bid for board seats. Salesforce has had its own layoffs. The stock has stayed morbid. There's been this shift of people—just so you know, Salesforce is a sponsor, but we give them the same treatment as any other company. They're ripe for the thing.
Scott Galloway
I'm fascinated that Salesforce, of course, you could see this stock in a place where an activist might come in. But I'm curious why nobody's coming to Tesla yet. Probably because if you blow him up, you're looking for a world of hurt and there may not be much upside. I think activist investors are suddenly really out and about. Are you getting calls?
Kara Swisher
I've talked to a few of these guys, or I've heard from some funds. They call me and say, "We have this idea. What do you think?"
Scott Galloway
These ones, I don't want to say they're easy, but Salesforce... I mean, Disney is just a great play. It's an unbelievable set of assets. This company is enduring the downside. It's so much more likely, if you think about Disney, that its stock would double and then get cut in half again. If you really look at the value of their assets and their cash flow, that's a great activist play. Salesforce is at basically a five-year low. I think the play there, and the way Elliott will most likely go about it—it's a guy named Jesse Cohn, an incredibly impressive young man. That's one of those moments when you meet someone so much younger than you and so much smarter than you, you get depressed. You're like, "Jesus, really?"
Kara Swisher
They'll go in. They'll hang around the hoop. They'll be supportive. They'll say, "Clearly, we can all agree the company's undervalued." And they'll wait a year. If things don't get better, they'll move in with suggestions.
Scott Galloway
They did this. They're not afraid. The way I would describe them is forceful yet dignified. They won't be afraid to suggest management changes. But Salesforce, you could say, it's an incredible company with incredible client relationships. They probably overpaid for some acquisitions, probably haven't been as tight around expense control. Which is what they're saying over at Disney with Peltz.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
You're going to see activists everywhere because here's the problem. And this is the reason why there hasn't been an activist play at Tesla. At the end of the day, what you want is a stock whose natural trajectory should be up because it's undervalued. The reason you don't have an activist at Tesla is not as much around Musk. Maybe that's it—no one wants to get into a pissing match with him because he's crazy and has 120 million crusaders behind him. But also the stock is overvalued.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, still. That's what I was thinking.
Scott Galloway
So the reason you're seeing so many activists right now is not because these companies are incredibly fucked up or management made bad decisions. It's because the underlying stock has been cut in half.
Kara Swisher
You're right. There's no upside at Tesla, necessarily. And you're buying a lot of trouble. It's now back at 142. It was down at 101. It's going up and down. It's not going to go to the four or five hundred range they would like. It doesn't possibly deserve that, especially with all the competitors. You wouldn't be winning anything. What's the activist going to say? What's the argument? What are they going to do to unlock that value?
Scott Galloway
That's correct. I guess sell it. I don't know. They certainly have the market share.
Kara Swisher
What would you do? Okay, activist investor, what would you do at Salesforce right now? You get two seats on the board. What do you advocate for? Do you want to change management? Do you want them to divest of Slack or whatever it was they bought?
Scott Galloway
I think you have to start with why the stock is underperforming compared to its peers. You'd have to start talking about that. Just like at Disney, who's the heir apparent and why is that unable to happen? Then you lean into what's going to kill off your business, which seems like it needs a fresh look in terms of management. There's a lot there. It should be worth more. It's a very valuable company.
Kara Swisher
That's not a very compelling argument. You've just failed your first test as an activist.
Scott Galloway
All right, okay, fine. Although I think you could be co-CEO of Netflix. And by the way, just to correct the record, I said it was at a five-year low. It's actually up 38% over the last five years, but my guess is that's underperformed its peers.
Kara Swisher
Yes, it's underperformed its peers. That's correct.
Scott Galloway
Anyway, I'd have to practice. That's why I need you along until I then knife you in the back.
Kara Swisher
There you go. All right, let's bring in our friend of Pivot to talk about something we actually do know about. Cory Doctorow is an author, activist, and special advisor to the Electronic Frontier Foundation. In his latest book with co-author Rebecca Giblin, he argues for an internet that is fairer to content creators. It's called *Chokepoint Capitalism: How Big Tech and Big Content Captured Creative Labor Markets and How We'll Win Them Back*. Welcome, Cory. How are you doing?
Cory Doctorow
I'm very well, thanks. How are you?
Kara Swisher
So explain chokepoint capitalism for us. Isn't that just capitalism?
Cory Doctorow
It's a cousin of monopoly capitalism. It's monopsony capitalism. Monopsony is the word nobody knows because we don't have a family-destroying board game with that name. Monopsony is when you have a seller who controls a market rather than a buyer who controls a market.
Kara Swisher
Right.
Cory Doctorow
Creative labor markets are really susceptible to this. If you can find a way to corner an audience—say by buying all the radio stations or by locking all the audiobook listeners into a DRM format, or through any other mechanism that allows you to control how the audience meets the artist—then you can impose all kinds of conditions on the artist as they pass through the choke point to reach their audience. Those conditions can include, and today do include, just giving up whatever copyright they have. That's why artistic markets are a problem, because we have this idea that we can unrig artistic markets or make them fairer through copyright. But if there's only three record labels or four studios or five publishers or two ad tech companies or one e-book company, giving an artist more copyright is like giving a bullied kid extra lunch money. There's just not an amount of lunch money that will get that kid lunch.
Kara Swisher
But isn't that the way it has always been done with audiences? Whether they controlled venues, whether they controlled radio stations, et cetera. In movie theaters, it's always been chokepoint capitalism for artists, whether they are shoved into a movie system or a music system. That seems like that to me.
Cory Doctorow
The difference is the number of firms that we bargain with. When I was a baby writer, there were 25 houses in New York. Now there's five. There were dozens of record labels until Universal, Warner, and Sony went on a buying spree and bought all of them until 70% of all recorded music was controlled by three labels. We've never had a situation like that. Also, because we allowed for vertical mergers, they were able to buy all the publishers. So 65% of all the recording copyrights and the composition copyrights are owned by those three firms. Certainly it was never the case that a single file format—except for maybe Microsoft Office—was the only file format that a single genre existed in. But Audible DRM is like 90% of the audiobook market. One company controls 90% of the audiobook market. As we document in the book, it's not like they use that in a benign way. There are writers who credibly accused Audible of hundreds of millions of dollars in wage theft, and who, if they left Audible's platform, their audience couldn't follow them because their books are permanently locked to Audible's.
Scott Galloway
I'm really curious what you think about the publishing market in books. It strikes me that feels like an oligopoly. As an author, it's so opaque. I still don't understand the economics, how it translates to creators or not creators. I know the merger was just blocked. Having a few players, is it similar to the music publishing market?
Cory Doctorow
There are big differences between the particulars of music and books, but they're both monopsonistic—or oligopsonistic, because it's a small number of firms. They both have similar structural drives to become concentrated. The thing about monopoly is that it replicates. When you have a monopoly somewhere in the supply chain, it can exert excessive buyer power on its suppliers and excessive seller power on its customers. That leaves both of them vulnerable.
Here's an example from books. About a decade ago, Amazon was using its investors' capital to sell e-books below cost. That meant you'd be an idiot to buy your e-book anywhere else. But every one of those e-books was locked permanently to Amazon's platform with DRM, which would give it total control over the e-book market. The publishers wanted to force Amazon to stop dumping e-books, to stop selling them below price, because they didn't want this control exerted over their market. So they illegally colluded to rig the price of e-books with Apple, to set a minimum price and to withdraw their books from Amazon. The FTC just clobbered them. After that, they went through even more mergers. So Penguin bought Random House. If the CEO of Penguin and the CEO of Random House sit down at a table to set the price of e-books, that's a crime. If Penguin and Random House merge and the president of Penguin and the president of Random House sit down at the same table to rig the price of e-books, it's not a crime anymore because that's one company setting a corporate strategy.
We have one trade distributor left in this country. Ingram bought out Baker & Taylor's distribution business. When the mass market hit its peak, there were 300 distributors for mass market books. Now there's one. The crunch in distribution was driven by the crunch in mass market retailers. When Reagan deregulated retail and we got the big box national chains—Walmart, Kmart, Costco, Sam's Club—the distributors were getting clobbered by these super powerful buyers. They all merged until there was just one. Now they're putting the screws to the publishers, so the publishers are all merging. They have merged down to five firms. The formal name of Penguin Random House takes about seven minutes to read if you list all the companies that are actually Penguin Random House. It's a couple of pages long. One of the reasons that deal collapsed is because there were emails about them colluding on prices within the company, and agents were shocked.
Kara Swisher
When Spotify first launched, there was hope it would help small artists find new fans and monetize the long tail. How has it worked out in music?
Cory Doctorow
Spotify definitely was dyed in the morning. Spotify, in order to have any success, would need access to the 70% of music recordings controlled by the big three labels. The condition of those licenses was huge equity stakes for the big three in Spotify. So the big three are major shareholders in Spotify. This puts them in an irreconcilable conflict of interest. On one hand, they're sort of fiduciaries for their artists. They want to get the biggest royalties out of Spotify so they can pass them on to the artists. But as shareholders, they want to pay as little royalties as possible to the artists because then they get bigger dividends and their shares are worth more.
They negotiated a rock bottom price for streams but with a minimum monthly guarantee. That meant if you were Sony, you were getting, say, $10 million a month. But because the price per stream was so low, you could only attribute $5 million of that. The other $5 million was just yours. You could give it to some artists, no artists. You could put it into development. You could pay it to your executive. They also negotiated something called most favored nation status, which is also a feature of Amazon agreements. That meant Spotify could not pay anyone more than they were paying the big three. So if you were one of the artists in the 30% of music not controlled by the big three, the big three set up your compensation scale. But you didn't get this guaranteed monthly minimum and you didn't have shares in Spotify.
This got to an absolute zenith of absurdity on the night of Spotify's IPO. If you're Sony or Warner or Universal with your label hat on, you're thinking, "Spotify is about to go public. Our deal has just expired. If that deal isn't renewed, Spotify is not going to have a successful IPO. We could hypothetically request a new royalty structure that was everything Spotify has minus what it costs to operate it. The whole margin is ours for the taking." Instead, in that negotiation, they negotiated a lower rate per royalty because that made the IPO bigger. Spotify went into the IPO with a better cost structure. Not only that, everybody else's deal got worse too. The other 30% of labels all got a worse deal.
Here's an example where we have copyright that has gotten longer. These copyrights endure for 90 years, which industrially might as well be forever. That copyright getting longer did make the industry significantly more profitable, but it actually reduced the share of income accruing to artists. In the book, we devote the first half to unwinding these very baroque accounting scams. The second half is all very detailed technical policy proposals, not individual solutions. You're not going to recycle your way to climate change. You're not going to shop your way to monopoly capitalism. Structural solutions.
Kara Swisher
Can you go to those in brief? These solutions you think?
Cory Doctorow
I'll give you one weird trick. If you're a creative worker, chances are your contract guarantees you royalties and that royalty contract allows you to audit the royalty statement, because otherwise you're just taking their word for it. There are lots of ways you can rip people off with royalties. We spoke to a firm here in Los Angeles that has done tens of thousands of record label audits over three decades. In every instance in which they found an accounting discrepancy, except for one, the money was going to the labels instead of the artists. The artists were getting ripped off. I have no explanation for this. I assume it's some kind of very vexing localized probability storm centered on the accounting departments of record labels.
If you're one of those people who's been stolen from, and you go back to your label or your studio or your publisher and say, "Hey, you stole my money," they're going to say, "Artists are adorable, but you can't do math. You're wrong. But because we don't want any hard feelings, we'll give you a discounted share of what you think you're owed. All you have to do is sign this non-disclosure agreement." They pay you off rather than the exhaustion of doing it. And you can't tell anyone else how they ripped you off. Your accountant has to agree that he will never audit you again. It's like an accused murderer saying to the forensics team, "Dig anywhere you like in my garden, except for that one corner. I'm very sentimental about it."
All of these contracts, because of monopoly, are settled in four states: New York, California, Seattle, Washington because of games companies and Amazon, and Nashville, Tennessee. If we were to amend the state contract laws of any one of those four states—and remember, state law is a lot easier to change than federal law or federal regulation—to say that as a matter of public policy, non-disclosure cannot be enforced when it pertains to material shortfalls or omissions in royalty statements, at the stroke of a pen, you put more money in the pockets of more artists all over the world. You can't make a deal around it, just as you can't make a deal around sexual harassment.
Scott Galloway
There's been a big movement in that idea. Or non-competes.
Cory Doctorow
Yeah, we've got the FTC saying no more non-competes. Four state laws would just throw money at artists in a way that 40 years of copyright term extension has failed to do. It's like this crack in the machine. We can stick a crowbar in and wiggle it around, and money just pours out into artists' pockets. Copyright term extension is the right to feel angry at your audience. This is the right to buy groceries and put braces on your kids' teeth.
Kara Swisher
I'm curious. I would imagine you're paying attention to the class action lawsuit brought against Midjourney and Stability AI. Basically, a group of designers and artists have said that AI is only as good as the images fed into it, and we're not getting paid. All you're going to do is put us out of business with no royalties. Have you followed this at all? Do you think it has any impact on the broader creator economy?
Cory Doctorow
I have to say I'm very conflicted about this, and I haven't yet figured out where I land on it. Here's the thing: another way of talking about training AI is studying art. I became a writer by reading a bunch of books and thinking really hard about how those books were written, right?
Every painter becomes a painter by looking really hard at and analyzing art. Computers are doing it with math. I don't think that that is foundationally different from doing it with your brain. And I think that if what we say is that it's a copyright infringement to think really hard about art and learn lessons from it, that that is going to be very bad.
I think that it's similar to when we saw the lawsuits like *Blurred Lines* about the groove of music, the feel of music, where Marvin Gaye's estate sued over a song that had no melody, no rhythm section, nothing from Marvin Gaye, but sort of sounded like a Marvin Gaye-ish kind of song and won. And at the time, it was hailed as a kind of victory for artists. But the structure of that market is such that if the big three labels alter their contracts so that it says you're signing away your groove rights as well as your other rights, then now it gets even harder. You can't even make music that's recognizably in a genre without permission from one of the labels. And that permission is going to be conditioned on you accepting a very bad one-sided deal.
Kara Swisher
So in that regard, platform operators have to make money for the networks that they build. If they have to give content creators all the money, what incentive do they have to do it in the first place besides controlling them? If you're a platform operator, you want to control every cost center and get the most for yourself. So how do you then create a situation where there is more ability for operators of these networks and the creators to make money? Because at some point you want everyone to benefit, because why would they build it in the first place?
Cory Doctorow
Well, I think the premise is that if artists were able to bargain fairly with a disparate sector that had to bid on their work, that the margins would be so thin that the sector would collapse. I think if that's true, then the sector doesn't exist. But I also think it's kind of ahistorical.
One of the stories we tell in the book is how the Writers Guild here in Hollywood struck for 22 months against the big four agencies. They're back at it again, right?
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Cory Doctorow
They need to make a living. Agents do good work—my agent's awesome—but once there were four of them, two of them owned by private equity firms, they got rid of the traditional 10% commission deal in favor of something called a packaging model. They would sell a studio a writer, a director, and a star as a package and take a cash bonus out of that. The bigger the payout was for the agency, the less money there was left over for the clients. They were incentivized to strike bad deals for artists and better deals for themselves.
Showrunners discovered that instead of the split being 10-90, it was 90-10, where 90% was going to the agents. The agencies were building studios so that they could negotiate with themselves on behalf of their clients. It's very hard to understand how this could ever be a fair arrangement. The argument the agencies made when the Writers Guild issued a code of conduct prohibiting this was that this was how they were going to make money. The writers said, "Yeah, this is how you're going to make money—by not paying us. So we're going on strike." The 7,000 writers fired their agents on day one. 22 months later, all four of the big agencies caved. And they're all still in business.
So what we're talking about here is not the size of the pie. It's the distributional outcome. I don't believe the pie gets smaller if the distribution is changed. There is nothing a priori that says if Jeff Bezos gets to harvest all the surplus value from every platform seller on Amazon, that Amazon runs out of money and ceases to be a going concern. We're just talking about changing the mix. One of the ways you change the mix is by prohibiting unfair contract terms. And the other is by prohibiting unfair mergers so that firms are not able to skew the market.
Kara Swisher
So there's always going to be a tension around the relationship between the creator and the distribution. Both are going to try and leverage whatever they can. Tom Cruise does a really good job of leveraging his star power against the distribution. Big tech has always been criticized for getting more than their fair share of the value the creator creates. When you look at this, where do you think are the worst relationships between distributors and creators? Where are the best ones? And also, just specifically, your thoughts on TikTok as it relates to their relationship with creators.
Cory Doctorow
The way to understand this is when firms can impose switching costs on creators and audiences. So eBay has bidders and sellers, Amazon has buyers and sellers, or in their Kindle program, writers and readers. When they can impose high switching costs so that if you leave the platform you have to give up something important, that gives them the economic power to shift surpluses away from both buyers and sellers to the platform operator.
There's a life cycle of a traditional platform. They start by allocating a lot of surplus to users. Amazon subsidizes shipping, gives you free returns, makes everything easy to find. Once there's a critical mass of customers locked in, they shift the surplus to the business customers to get them to come in.
TikTok, you mentioned—there was a great story last week on Forbes about how TikTok has this heating tool. When a video goes viral on TikTok, it's not because the algorithm liked it. It's because someone just turned a dial. Instead of showing you the thing the algorithm thinks you'll like, it just shows you this video. But if you're the artist, it looks like you're making the kind of art that TikTok loves. You're good at TikTok because suddenly you got 20 million views. This is an incentive to shift your production to TikTok. TikTok has an idiosyncratic format that makes it hard to do TikTok production that works well on other platforms.
Kara Swisher
So they lock you in.
Cory Doctorow
Yeah. They give you an end cap deal and you don't even know it.
Kara Swisher
Right. You know what I think of it as? It's like you go to the carnival in the morning and there's a guy with a giant teddy bear who thinks he's really good at throwing balls in a peach basket. But actually, the carny just didn't knock the ball out with the scissor thing under the bucket because he wants one guy walking around all day with a giant teddy bear to get other people to line up and give him five bucks.
Cory Doctorow
Right, right, right. So once the artists are locked in, then they can start shifting surplus to themselves. This is Facebook or Twitter these days. Twitter, if you're not blue, your posts just don't get shown to the people who subscribe to you. Facebook did this a long time ago. YouTube has done this as well. This is a way of saying you have consumers who want to see something and gave an explicit directive: "Tell me when there's a new video from this person." You have creators who produced something those consumers want to see. It is not to the benefit of either the consumer or the producer to interrupt that relationship. And yet the firm does.
The first five screens of any Amazon search now are 50% ads.
Kara Swisher
Plus their stuff.
Cory Doctorow
Plus their stuff. It's all in-cap. And that is this process whereby the surplus is shifted to the shareholders of the platform. This is bad for everyone. I would argue it's even bad for the platform, because if you're shaving the surpluses down so it's just barely worth it for your consumers and producers to keep using the platform, then any exogenous shock that makes it less worth it—people get more worried about their privacy, whatever—and you get a Twitter exodus.
Kara Swisher
Let's finish on that. Twitter exodus, right? I'm not using it as much. I know I'm not getting shadow banned, but definitely it's becoming less and less useful because you can start to see the changes. What's the alternative? There's the Fediverse alternatives like Mastodon. What happens to my audience there? Because it's gotten so quiet.
Cory Doctorow
I call this the Anatevka problem. That melancholy scene at the end of *Fiddler on the Roof*. "Well, we're all finally leaving this village where the Cossacks have been riding through every three scenes and kicking the shit out of us. But I'm going to Chicago, you're going to New York, he's going to Krakow—we're never going to see each other again."
The Fediverse protocol, ActivityPub, and the Mastodon application built on it have a built-in freedom of exit. With one click, you can export all the people you're following. With another click, you can export all the people who follow you. You quit the service and go somewhere else. With one click, you upload one of those files, one click you upload the other, and everyone just shifts over.
This is also built into RSS. We've just passed the 10th anniversary of the death of Aaron Swartz, one of the co-creators. Very early on, the people who made RSS realized that protocol needed a redirect button where you could issue a code that says, "From now on, permanently, this RSS feed is somewhere else." I have RSS feeds in my reader that I've been following since before Google Reader existed. They're not the same address anymore. I've never changed them. People just issue a redirect.
Now, if you were a Mastodon server owner, you could in theory just kick someone off and not give them the chance to export their data. What's interesting is if we came up with a rule like the GDPR or CCPA already does—that you have the right to request your data—we could say to those firms or cooperatives or small businesses, "Even though you don't like this guy and you kicked him off, you still have to export those files and email them to him." That is a very administratable remedy. Compare this to "you can't have trolls or hate speech." We have to define what a troll is, figure out if they're doing it, figure out when they fail. It's so expensive that small companies can't do it.
This is an administratable remedy that is easy to comply with. If we're going to have a golden rule of the internet—the right to exit, the right to leave and go somewhere else without the Anatevka problem—that is something we could equally impose on a hobbyist hosting 10 of their friends who falls out with one of them, or on a multi-billion dollar company. We can figure out whether they're complying, and complying is really easy. It's a rule that would preserve these communities and guard against this surplus harvesting that is ultimately the death of the firm. I call it the enshittification problem, where things just get worse and worse over time because of this unstoppable temptation to harvest the surplus.
On a digital platform, unlike on the floor of Sears, you just turn a knob and you're moving surpluses around. It's just so easy.
Kara Swisher
Twitter's never going to let me take my followers. They're unlikely to be big enough to attract any real antitrust scrutiny, although they might under Section 5, the deceptive practices, if they were really obnoxious enough. But when we think about the very large firms—Google, Facebook, Apple—they're just incapable of not cheating. They all break the rules all the time. When they cheat, it never goes to trial. They always end up settling.
Cory Doctorow
One of the things about settlements is they can have arbitrary terms. One of the terms we could set as a condition of a settlement is you have to do this. Under CCPA, you have the right to request your data from a firm. Under GDPR, even under the failed federal privacy bill, they all have this. It's kind of a bedrock. Nobody seriously disagrees that you should be able to get your data from someone who has it.
Kara Swisher
But it's more than that. It's their audiences.
Cory Doctorow
But it's your data about your audience.
Kara Swisher
Yes, that's correct.
All right. This is fascinating. I could talk for hours about this. The book is *Chokepoint Capitalism: How Big Tech and Big Content Captured Creative Labor Markets and How We'll Win Them Back* by Cory Doctorow and Rebecca Giblin. Thank you, Cory.
Cory Doctorow
Thank you so much. It was a real pleasure to talk to both of you.
Kara Swisher
Thank you.
Scott Galloway
Thanks, Cory.
Kara Swisher
All right, Scott, one more quick break. We'll be back for wins and fails.
AD BREAK
Okay, Scott, let's hear some wins and fails.
Scott Galloway
I'm going to go first. Is that okay?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, of course.
Scott Galloway
There was a story about Peter Thiel and crypto. Remember when he was having all those events where he was insulting Warren Buffett and everybody else? He was going on and on about how everybody should get heavy into Bitcoin. Well, while he was doing this, he sold off a majority of his crypto portfolio before everything got crushed. He made $1.8 billion in returns. It was crazy how insulting he was being to people who thought Bitcoin was ridiculous. But he was acting like he was optimistic. He was pushing it. He called people stupid and idiots.
Kara Swisher
So that's a win or a fail?
Scott Galloway
It's a win for Peter Thiel. It's a fail for everyone else who believed him. Same thing—not telling the truth publicly. That just drove me crazy.
Kara Swisher
You raise a really interesting point. I wonder if at some point, if you own enough of an asset class that you can move the market with your buys or sales, and you go into a public forum—you go on CNBC to talk about your latest piece of shit SPAC as you are literally selling—
Scott Galloway
Yes. And also using your Twitter following and your reputation as a very bright, successful person to intimidate anyone who questions whether Bitcoin is going to be at a million by 2030, as Cathie Wood and her loyal band of crypto-telegram do. It brings up an interesting point. A lot of people were going on CNBC and talking up space tourism companies and things that didn't make any sense as they were selling. At some point, do you have an obligation to have some sort of disclosure around what you are actually doing with your own securities when you own above a certain amount?
Kara Swisher
Mm-hmm. I think there'll be no repercussions for this.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, you're probably right.
Kara Swisher
But on top of it, he had to drag someone like Warren Buffett, who were right or at least reasonable enough. You can like or dislike Warren Buffett, but the cynicism of doing one thing and saying another—I'm always like, really? Really? Aren't you fucking rich enough? I always say, you're so poor, all you have is money.
Scott Galloway
It's almost as bad as a public company CEO saying he's taken a company private at $420 a share when there's no veracity to that.
Kara Swisher
But I have a win. Can I do my win?
Scott Galloway
Jared Butler, who is an action star whom I love. He's been in so many different things—*Olympus Has Fallen*, *London Has Fallen*. A lot of these action stars go into sort of shitty versions of their former careers. But this movie is scoring big. It's called *Plane*, where he plays a pilot who has all bad things happen to the plane, and then he saves the day. It's getting actually pretty good reviews.
Kara Swisher
I don't know this. What is it?
Scott Galloway
It's a new movie called *Plane*. He's right up there with Russell Crowe for me. I love those kind of action movies. A lot of these action heroes—Bruce Willis, who unfortunately has gotten very ill, or Sylvester Stallone—they get paid a lot of money to be in these shitty action movies, all of which I watch. Or Liam Neeson. Gerard Butler once made one called *Plane*, and it's so good. I love these movies.
Kara Swisher
He's Scottish. That's all I know about him.
Scott Galloway
Oh, he was in *300*. I just love him. I like his whole thing. I'm happy that he's—I would recommend it to anybody. You know I have this weird proclivity to watch action movies. But he does them real well.
Kara Swisher
My win is I'm inspired by Cory and the Creator Economy. I bought something called an Insta 360. My 12-year-old is really into video. This thing is just incredible.
Scott Galloway
What is it?
Kara Swisher
It's a camera. You put it on a stick and it uses AI to make the stick invisible. You're just walking and it looks as if there's a boom or a drone filming you. It's easy to edit. I'm looking at it right now. You can even put it behind you and it has a 360 view of everything. It's literally as if there's a boom operator following you.
Scott Galloway
There's no stick. You're holding the stick. You can't see the stick. The stick is gone.
Kara Swisher
That's right. Except people have their hands up.
Scott Galloway
But if you get a long enough stick, you're very popular in college.
Kara Swisher
You can have it in front of you as if a professional crew is following you around. I've been doing this stuff with my son where he talks about Premier League football teams. It's totally cool and he's into it.
Scott Galloway
There's like 90 cameras. Which one did you get?
Kara Swisher
I'll send you the one I got. It was about 300 pounds, which I thought was pretty reasonable. Two phones, invisible selfie sticks, sticky lens, all this stuff. It's totally cool technology. It's really wild.
My other win, just along the creator side, and then I'll get to my fail. We went to the Royal Albert Hall and saw the most recent Cirque du Soleil. My son just loved it. You sit there thinking, it's just so inspiring that people are creative to come up with this stuff. Cirque du Soleil at Royal Albert Hall—take your kids. It was fantastic.
Scott Galloway
I love Cirque du Soleil. I was like, how did he lean over and kiss his ass like that? I was always amazed by them. They're amazing. The contortionists are always—I'm like, oh, how did you do that?
Kara Swisher
Finally we answered that question. What happens to Eastern European gymnasts when they're no longer going to the Olympics? They go to Cirque du Soleil. These people are incredible.
Anyway, my fail is that Germany is being very recalcitrant around sending their Leopard tanks to Ukraine. They won't even allow other NATO nations who have the Leopard to send them.
Scott Galloway
You were complimenting them in Germany, weren't you?
Kara Swisher
Well, I thought they looked like they were going to send them. This is exactly playing into Putin's playbook. It shows we're not unified. There's just no getting around it. Once you're in a war with someone—and let's be clear, we're in a war vis-a-vis NATO against Russia—appeasement doesn't work. If we want to end this war, we need to win it and win it crisply. Those tanks could make a big difference. Germany sitting on its hands and coming up with a lot of rational reasons for why they're not going to support the war effort to their full capability—these are amazing tanks—is doing nothing but providing comfort to the enemy. So my loss here is the recalcitrance of Berlin around this issue, and it's an important one.
Scott Galloway
Good one. That's very serious. Good to go back to that.
Kara Swisher
Cirque du Soleil! Cirque du Soleil and contortionists! There you go. They're amazing.
Anyway, we want to hear from you. Send us your questions about business, tech, or whatever's on your mind. Go to nymag.com/pivot to submit a question for the show, or call 855-51-PIVOT. Scott, that's the show. Once again, another fantastic show in the can. We'll be back on Friday for more. Please read us out.
Scott Galloway
Today's show was produced by Lara Naiman, Evan Engel, and Taylor Griffin. Ernie Indertot engineered this episode. Thanks also to Drew Burrows and Neil Severio. Make sure you subscribe to the show wherever you listen to podcasts. Thanks for listening to *Pivot*, New York Magazine and Vox Media. We'll be back later this week for another breakdown of all things tech and business. Kara, have a great rest of the week.
Kara Swisher
Thanks, you too.