Main Topic: The podcast episode covers a wide range of topics, including the UK's economic situation, Apple's struggles with iPhone production, the impact of climate change, and the dangers of social media platforms like TikTok.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Notable Quotes:
Kara Swisher
Not all journalism is the same. Take The Guardian. Our coverage has something unique. Fierce independence. Nobody owns us or tells us what we can and can't say. So we're free to report the whole picture. We connect what's happening in Washington to the rest of the globe. Expose corruption wherever we find it. And give fresh perspective on everything. From wellness and soccer to culture, the climate and more. Read, watch and listen to The Guardian for free at theguardian.com.
Scott Galloway
AI agents are getting pretty impressive. You might not even realize you're listening to one right now. We work 24-7 to resolve customer inquiries. No hold music, no canned answers, no frustration. Visit sierra.ai to learn more.
Kara Swisher
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And I'm Scott Galloway.
Kara Swisher
And how is London doing? Is it cooling down there in London?
Scott Galloway
You know, it's sort of like it's really a shit show here. They're cutting taxes to try and stimulate the economy. Meanwhile, they're about to go through the biggest rate hike to try and slow down the economy. It's like when I get a Zacapa and Coke and it's like Zacapa takes the dog down, makes him feel a little more relaxed. But the Coke keeps him awake so he can party with the young people. But it's not a good idea. You don't go up and down like what they're doing here makes no fucking sense.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, Liz Truss could lose her job like in 14 seconds, right? With this little stunt she's pulling, this economic stunt. This is her legacy, no joke. This is literally her legacy. No leader of a G7 nation has fucked up this fast.
Scott Galloway
I know. I think she's trying to pull a Margaret Thatcher.
Kara Swisher
Is she doing a Margaret Thatcher? That's what it seems like.
Scott Galloway
Well, that's the idea. But the markets, and we talked about this in the last episode, the markets recognize that that didn't work.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
The markets are like, OK, it's 2022 in the United Kingdom. And it's just striking me. Supposedly her Yoda at dinner or drinks with a guy last night, a really impressive man named Roger Perry. And he said that her Yoda is a 26-year-old kind of libertarian.
Kara Swisher
Oh, no. I mean, it's just striking how many people find themselves in the right place at the wrong time. Oh, dear. Liz, you know, Margaret Thatcher was the iron lady. She seems like the aluminum lady.
Scott Galloway
Oh, that's a good one. Thank you. Please use it.
Kara Swisher
Did you think of that yourself?
Scott Galloway
No, I did. You should credit The Onion or someone snarky for saying that. You go out at parties in London and see how that goes. And let me know how it goes.
Kara Swisher
Hey—
Scott Galloway
Oh, I listened to your podcast, by the way. Sorry to interrupt.
Kara Swisher
Oh, you did. Go ahead.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. I did listen.
Kara Swisher
Yeah?
Scott Galloway
I really liked it.
Kara Swisher
Thank you.
Scott Galloway
It's sexy. I think—working with new formats.
Kara Swisher
Well, no. You know, just an outstanding interviewer, incredible grace. And also, you were okay, too.
Scott Galloway
I'm calling you Naima's sidekick from this point forward. I love that you have a sidekick now.
Kara Swisher
I know. Well—
Scott Galloway
Oh, my God. She's good.
Kara Swisher
I am your sidekick. The student becomes the master. Yeah, it's going to be like All About Eve and then I'll be dead in some corner.
Scott Galloway
No, I enjoyed it. But I was more interested in Chris Cuomo.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, that was good. I think he's really—he was good. He's very likable. I feel he's still in a state of denial about what went down. I think many people felt that.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. It's like, boss—and here's the thing. The most powerful thing—one of the wonderful things about our species is we can not only apologize but people can forgive. People love to forgive.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, they do.
Scott Galloway
He is so likable and so good. He didn't really ask for—yeah, they made me do it. They made me do it. This is where he's poorly advised.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. If he had just said something along the lines of, "I made a mistake, family can make you take a mistake and turn it into something really stupid. And I'm guilty of that. And I apologize. And it won't happen again." He didn't do it. And I apologize. And he didn't say that. He kind of twisted it like, "No, this was what you don't understand." I think he's being poorly advised because he's so likable. He is a very good broadcaster. And I think an injury around something involving family, I think people want to forgive you for that.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. But what people get angry about, Martha Stewart didn't go to prison for insider trading. She went to prison for refusing to acknowledge the issue.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
And one of the things, crisis management is all the same thing. It's all the same thing. It's one, acknowledge the issue.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
Two, take responsibility for it. And three, overcorrect.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. It is tried and true. I was surprised. And then, of course, he was surprised that I threw Jeffrey Swisher under the bus. He goes, "Wouldn't you do the same for your brother?" I'm like, absolutely not. Not if you did something like that, my friend. He was thinking I was going to say, as a different Italian family, I'd be like, Jeff would be out the door. I would call him and make sure he's OK personally. But to help him and advise him, are you kidding me? No way. Anyway, it was interesting. He wasn't expecting that. Nobody expects the Cara Inquisition. But it was a good interview. It's getting a lot of buzz. Today is Hillary Clinton. We're doing some others. You'll see this week some really good ones coming up. Secretary Clinton.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, Secretary Clinton.
Kara Swisher
She was sassy as can be. But anyway, Hurricane Ian hit Florida on Wednesday as a Category 4 storm and weakened to tropical storm by Thursday morning. 2.5 million people are without power as of Thursday morning. Local authorities have said that hundreds are feared to have died in the storm. Puerto Rico is still recovering from Fiona. The Biden administration waived the Jones Act and allowed more fuel imports. He's been very proactive. And DeSantis said he's actually being nice. What a twit. He's like a rich kid who just like—I don't know. He's being a twit about it. Anyway, they're cooperating with each other and he did it right away. Can you imagine if Trump was running this show? There would be a Sharpie and different various and sundry games with DeSantis that Biden's not playing.
Scott Galloway
Look, we're going to have more and more of this. We're going to have more and more climate change. Which, you know, seven of the 10 biggest super fires in history in California have happened in the last 10 years. We're having hurricanes are getting more severe. I think it's terrible. I think the governor was smart to issue a state of emergency.
Kara Swisher
Right. And evacuation.
Scott Galloway
That is kind of one of the few places it seems like the federal and local governments do still cooperate.
Kara Swisher
They do. But Biden passed a climate package that's going to take carbon down 40 percent by 2030. And we're just going to have fewer, hopefully, of these things. I mean, this is—I don't know. So these extreme weather events, there's a reason they're happening more and more often.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Well, we'll see. Florida is going to get hit by more hurricanes. I think we're in the season and then California with wildfires. But the Midwest hasn't been spared. There's all kinds of areas. So in any case, we hope the people of Florida are doing well and that they'll recover quickly from this and not have another one come anytime soon.
Scott Galloway
Did you know September, this is a phenomenon? September is the most beautiful place in the world almost everywhere except Florida.
Kara Swisher
Florida, yeah.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, September is wonderful. Think about it. I don't care if you're Seattle or Barcelona. September is fantastic, but not in Florida.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it's my favorite time in San Francisco.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, absolutely.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, today we'll talk about Apple's struggles with the new iPhone. Also, Oprah and Apple TV call it quits. We'll hear from a listener about TikTok. But first, major advertisers are pulling their ads from Twitter. This was quite a story because it's from Reuters of child sexual material on the platform. Mazda, Forbes, and others have removed their ads from parts of Twitter after their promotions were shown alongside tweets soliciting child sexual material. The Verge reported on Twitter's challenges in identifying child abuse content in August. This is just more of the same sloppily managed, really, since the get-go.
Scott Galloway
Ad-supported platforms that are algorithmically driven, which were the big innovation there, was that you could serve ads without human intervention. And it ends up, that's bad. When someone tries to advertise something really, really distasteful or wrong on CNN, somebody sees it and stops it. A hundred percent.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
And when you, you know, these platforms were meant to be, you know, no friction, no people, no discretion.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. And you pay a huge price for that.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. And whether it's misinformation or whether this type of thing. And it just—I think this further buttresses what Twitter and Jack Dorsey have failed to do for a decade. This should not be an ad supported platform. This should be run sharper than this. You know what I mean? It feels like this is sort of easy things.
Kara Swisher
What this process is basically highlighted is that it hurts a company to not have a CEO for a decade.
Scott Galloway
It does.
Kara Swisher
They didn't have a CEO.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
And it was even worse than not having a CEO because they would occasionally incorporate him into decision making and no decision would get made.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. I used to make fun of you for saying this, but I think you're right about right now at this point. So many things have been revealed about what happens to a company when it has absentee leadership. It just—and no decisions are made.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. What has Twitter done that's been innovative? Like a blue check? Like what have they done? In other Twitter news, by the way, more is going to come out. Depositions from Elon Musk and Twitter's CEO Parag Agrawal have been delayed. Agrawal sought to delay his to later this week. And Elon wants his to take place somewhere other than Delaware.
Scott Galloway
I think "Somewhere Other Than Delaware" is a very good name for a band.
Kara Swisher
It's just wending its way to this thing. No matter what they do to delay, this is where it's headed essentially to the end. But it'll show a lot of stuff off. He'd like to take this thing to Mars right now. He's going to do anything to delay. Also, did you—I just saw a story right before we came in there saying that he's been caught deleting text messages regarding the case.
Scott Galloway
Oh, dear.
Kara Swisher
Well, I could see him doing that.
Scott Galloway
They'll still find them.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, yeah. I agree. In any case, one of the things—I have a feeling they're going to settle.
Scott Galloway
I think you're right. I just had a feeling as I was on the train. I was like, I think they're going to—I was talking about us doing this cross-promotional thing between my new podcast and Prof G and everything else. And we're going to do a lot of coverage of the trial in mid-October, I think October 17th time period. And for some reason, I just thought, oh, I think they're going to settle before that. I just think we're not going to do our cross-promotional shows. The problem is the delta between what I think Twitter should settle for and what he's probably willing to settle for is just enormous. They've got this guy dead to rights, and it's going to be a lot of money.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Anyways, the headline in the article is "Elon Musk caught deleting messages about the Twitter deal." Elon Musk uses Signal, the encrypted messaging app that can automatically destroy messages.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, with Andreessen. There was some with Andreessen.
Kara Swisher
Right. So maybe you didn't delete them. Maybe they just automatically deleted and you took it to Signal. And there's been a bunch—it's really—it's an interesting concept. A bunch of bulge bracket investment banks are in trouble because their employees took a lot of their messaging to these platforms that were encrypted, which you're not supposed to do.
Scott Galloway
Don't they know you're supposed to use burner phones? I don't understand these people.
Kara Swisher
You love the burner phones.
Scott Galloway
I love a burner. I always have a burner phone. I have one for TikTok. I have a TikTok burner phone, as you know.
Kara Swisher
Also in the news this week, let's talk about Italy's move to the far right. Georgia Maloney, who I like to call Mussolini, a member of the Brothers of Italy Party. Why do they have these names? Will be Italy's first female prime minister. Maloney has displayed extreme points of view, such as saying the following during a speech in June. "Yes to natural families. No to LGBT lobby. Yes to sexual identity. No to gender ideology. Yes to culture of life. No to the abyss of death." She also used the word "financial speculators," which Mussolini used to love to use to refer to Jewish people. She, of course, was just using it. It was definitely a dog whistle. U.S. politicians such as Ted Cruz have called Maloney spectacular. Anyway, good for her. What do you think?
Scott Galloway
I think this is a bigger discussion. And that is, there have always been—women have always, and we don't like to talk about it because we like to assume that everything any woman does is benign and noble.
Kara Swisher
Agreed.
Scott Galloway
And what you have here is the weaponization of femininity, the weaponization of women as a gender. And that is—Hillary Clinton accidentally comes out and says, "It's great to see a female leader" not having done her homework.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. This woman is terrible for women.
Scott Galloway
Yep. She is not only anti-immigrant. She wants to deny women of their reproductive rights. She wants to—fascism is basically you endorse violence against immigrants. What you have is her less polished—and The Intercept had a great piece on this—far-right counterparts in the U.S. Congress, such as Marjorie Taylor Greene and Lauren Boebert, among others. They weaponize their roles as women. And they basically say that immigrants are importing sexual violence. And no one can—it immediately stops the conversation and scares the shit out of everybody.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, yeah.
Scott Galloway
And I don't care if it was the KKK. There's always been—I'm going to make a shift for this. White women have always played a key role in the advancement of these terrible—and it's not—we have to evaluate people based on their views.
Kara Swisher
That's correct. I tend to agree with you here, Mr. Galloway. And just because she's a woman doesn't mean she's not hateful against LGBTQ people.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, yeah. And also immigrants and also Jewish people apparently. And women. She wants to stick women in the home and take away their rights.
Kara Swisher
Right.
Scott Galloway
So who gives a shit that she's got indoor plumbing? She's terrible for women. She's a fascist.
Kara Swisher
Did you say indoor plumbing? She's a fascist. She is. Yes. So while people immediately knee-jerk and say, "Oh, isn't it wonderful that we have a female leader?" No. It's not wonderful.
Scott Galloway
No. Anyone who destroys the rights of our mothers and our sisters and female immigrants is a threat.
Kara Swisher
Yep. This is very disappointing.
Scott Galloway
Well, all immigrants. I would agree. And it would be interesting. The only saving grace here is that Italy changes its government every five minutes. The last government—
Kara Swisher
That's a fair point.
Scott Galloway
You know, she could run right into a wall. Same thing with Liz Truss. Same thing with Sweden. They also elected a far more right-wing group of people. Shocking, I think, for a lot of people there.
Kara Swisher
We'll see. It's interesting because they're sort of behind the U.S. and Brazil. And it looks like Bolsonaro is on his way out or could be. Let's see. He tries to pull the Trump essentially. She has the support of Silvio Berlusconi. So until she loses that, I suspect she's going to be—they love him, not him. And he's the original Trump-like character. Anyway, speaking of women of the far right, Marjorie Taylor Greene is getting divorced. She's on the market, boys. So there you have it. Her husband filed a petition citing irretrievably broken marriage. Here's another person that goes on and on about family, sort of shoves it down people's throat.
And getting divorced is a sad thing. I've been divorced, and I think you have too. And these people like tout family and try to really shove it down your throat. And they have problems just like everybody else, you know. And, of course, they make excuses for it. And they say the matter is private and personal when they're always telling other people how to live. I find it—they are so judgmental until it comes to themselves and then they want you to not speak about it. Now, I'm sorry she's getting divorced, I guess. I don't really care in any way whatsoever. I more think it's sad that Mackenzie Bezos has filed for divorce from her second husband who was a science teacher.
He was helping her with philanthropy. You know, Mackenzie Scott for me is a hero.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
And I, you know, when I heard about it, I was sad because I just think the world of Mackenzie Scott.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. I'm involved in this charity called, and I think I mentioned this earlier in the year, the Jed Foundation that focuses on teen depression. And this is how Mackenzie Bezos rolls. She had done research on the organization without us knowing. That's her MO. And then we got an email. When I say we, I shouldn't say we. I support the organization. I can't take credit for anything they've done. And the CEO, John McPhee of the organization, and this is a wonderful organization, got an email saying, "We need your wiring information. We're sending $15 million."
Kara Swisher
Whoa, that's significant.
Scott Galloway
Oh, you think? What was the budget?
Kara Swisher
Oh, the budget is well over $100 million.
Scott Galloway
Jed Foundation works with the infrastructure of high schools and colleges. That's a big check. It changes everything. It changes everything. All of a sudden, we can implement new programs to educate, especially at-risk youth from disenfranchised communities through schools. Schools are dying for this information and education materials. This will save lives. This will save heartaches. I mean, so the idea of an organization leveraging the existing infrastructure of high schools and colleges to help identify and discern between what is kind of what you call normal abnormal teen behavior and a teen who really might hurt themselves. But back to Mackenzie Scott, I think she has totally inspired people to rethink what it means, what giving means. And leadership.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, and it's not a transaction. It's not "I need my name on something. I need to pretend I understand education or homelessness because I'm giving you money and you have to listen to me." It's about true giving, nothing in return. Anyways, I don't—I think she—you know, what's interesting, there is a juxtaposition between them because I think through what she's doing, she will have much more impact than these loudmouths, Maloney or Greene. I think they will be faded into the background and her—the impact of her giving will be so much more significant. And it's not because—she's liberal for sure, but she's making significant investments in all kinds of social justice stuff, in helping people all across the board. It's really—it will benefit everybody in this world. Her quietness in contrast to their loudmouthery is really quite astonishing as far as I'm concerned.
Scott Galloway
OK, let's get to our first big story. Apple scaled back plans for iPhone production. This was interesting. This week by about 6 million units, shares of Apple and its suppliers dropped on the news. One analyst called weak demand in Europe and China, but other issues could be at play. What do you think? Why is that? I'm actually going in Sunday to get my—Alex hasn't upgraded in a while, and we have that yearly upgrade, but he hasn't even done it in a couple of years. So we are getting one for him. But why do you think this is happening? The NASDAQ is down, obviously. Apple shares are down. There's still continuing cratering of the tech economy. SoftBank just announced layoffs of its tech-heavy vision fund, but that's largely because they made shitty investments all over the map when everything was going well. But what do you think is happening here?
Kara Swisher
I think it's just a natural cyclical downturn. Basically, Apple is, to a certain extent, a proxy on the wealthiest billion people in the world. And the wealthiest billion people in the world have done better than any cohort, have done better than any other billion people on the planet. And so, and Apple's been probably the biggest beneficiary of that. It just so elegantly caters to a group of people who want to say we're better storytellers. I'll pay $1,200 for $550 of chipsets and sensors. It makes them more attractive. It's a better product. But with all the interest rate hikes, with the market taking a little bit of a check back, I just think it's sort of logical or kind of understandable that their sales would have a little bit of a slowdown. But I just don't see... They're also very smart at pulling back quickly, one of the things. They're very dynamic.
Scott Galloway
Well, they've got just such an incredible supply chain.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
You know, I think what's more interesting is they've decided to increase production out of India. They're trying to diversify away from China.
Kara Swisher
Absolutely. They have to. On the supply side.
Scott Galloway
But, you know, what is this? If the stock goes down, quite frankly, it's probably a buying opportunity. I mean, the company, you know, one iPhone 14 slowdown does not make a structural decline in this company.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. And again, sample size of one, London, or London, I guess, is sort of its own island in the UK. But the UK is staring down a pretty obvious recession and some economic difficulty. You could barely get in the Apple store. So I don't know. I just think—You know, just people don't realize. You said it's just for the higher end. But iPhones are the most popular handset in America right now. Past 50 percent. It was a big deal over Android. We talked about that recently.
Scott Galloway
Amazing.
Kara Swisher
You know, some people think it's because it's not upgradable enough. I don't think so. I do think people don't upgrade with this like I do. I, like, get the newest one, period.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, me too.
Kara Swisher
But, like, I know my kids were like, "Mine is fine." Amanda has one, I don't know, seven iPhones ago. And she's like, "It's fine." And I think I'm finally convinced her to get a new one. But I think a lot of people are perfectly fine. They work really well, these iPhones, and can last over several periods. On this Sunday, I'm bringing in a lot of Apple products, especially computers that I've saved over the years, to have them recycled. I'm meeting someone to recycle all my things. They have a really robust recycling program, and then I'm going to get a tiny bit of money for that, I'm sure. And then we're going to buy something, of course, with the money.
Scott Galloway
No, I love virtue signaling parties like that.
Kara Swisher
Thank you. But anyways. Interesting. Russia's trying to get the iPhone to come in, and Apple's pulled out of Russia in March. I don't think it's an enormous market for them. What's really interesting, I was struck by Amazon rolling out a bunch of new hardware. It unveiled nearly a dozen new products this week, including TVs, a Kindle, another Kindle, a smart speaker, an interconnected camera for Ring. And they also premiered its new reality show, Ring Nation, which is—it's mostly from smartphones and GoPros. But the idea of like cameras that—I do have a Ring at home. I think in San Francisco I put one in for the tenants. And I have to say they're riveting to watch the stuff that's on there that gets—that people post and things like that. And now it's a TV show. But Amazon's really moving forward with hardware, which I thought was interesting.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. And they're investing just as—I mean, it's a tale of two cities. With Facebook, they're investing on the Oculus, which I think is the biggest thought ever. I read somewhere that Facebook is probably—or Meta is going to probably invest $60 or $70 billion in their metaverse activities over the next several years.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. He loves this thing.
Scott Galloway
Amazon got behind what I think is kind of arguably the premier technology the next 10 years. I don't think it's AI. I think it's voice.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
And when you think about making people's lives easier. The Echo. Well, when you move into a new house, what you realize between trying to figure out the lights and how to operate a TV, which is now like trying to operate Apollo 13 after you've aborted your moon landing. And then every once in a while, and to be fair, Comcast, I think, has done a great job with this technology. To be able to say, "Find Ted Lasso." And then occasionally the TV just brings it up. You're like, "Jesus, this is powerful."
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
And my kids are so comfortable with voice now. When they're doing their homework and ask a question, they'll just look up. I'll just look up and say, "When's Arsenal Liverpool playing this weekend?" And he just, without even lifting his head, he goes, "Alexa, when is Arsenal Liverpool playing?" They're getting trained on voice technology.
Kara Swisher
But it's more of an ecosystem, too, product. Because, you know, I was thinking I have a Nest and I like it. But I wish everything all worked together in a lot of ways. And that's what Amazon's trying to do with the Ring, the Roomba, if that thing goes through. I probably would buy an Amazon thing. I just got a message from them for pharmacy. A very, you know, they are really pushing that very hard. And I thought about it. I was like, well, it is, they do deliver a lot of things here. So getting in an ecosystem, I'm definitely in an Apple ecosystem. Not so much in a Google one, a little bit in a Comcast one. I have a Ring and something very strange happened to me the other night.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
It went off and I immediately went to my Ring app to see what was out there. And I saw like this kind of weird shadow, but nothing. And I'm like, "Oh, fuck."
Scott Galloway
Moves to London, buys a house that's haunted.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it was me. I literally couldn't sleep. I'm like, I kept playing it over and over. And you could see this little like shadow ring my doorbell and then go to the attic where it will haunt me for the rest of eternity.
Scott Galloway
You do have ghosts. It's like a Jack the Ripper ghost or something like that.
Kara Swisher
Oh, thank you. That's comforting. Thank you.
Scott Galloway
It's never like a ghost that wants to perform oral sex on you. It's always a ghost that wants to like—
Kara Swisher
Well he only killed women prostitutes. So I think you're well made.
Scott Galloway
That good to know.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Yeah. Well by the way, speaking of killing people, the new Jeffrey Dahmer thing.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. We going to talk about that in a second. Can you get over that?
Kara Swisher
When we get back.
Scott Galloway
You know what they would call people who would try and run from him?
Kara Swisher
What?
Scott Galloway
Fast food.
Kara Swisher
Fast food. Oh, my God. All right. We're going to get to it in a minute.
Scott Galloway
You know, he had Ted Bundy over and they would have Ben and Jerry's.
Kara Swisher
I got it. I got it. Okay. We'll save it.
Scott Galloway
That's good. We'll save it.
Kara Swisher
Save it. When we come back, we'll talk about a big loss for Apple TV and take a listener and also about this Jeffrey Dahmer thing on Netflix and take a listener mail question about TikTok.
Ad break
Scott, we're back for our second big story. First, we'll get to Jeffrey Dahmer, but Oprah and Apple TV are cutting the cord. The two parties abruptly ended an overall deal this week. Back in 2018, Oprah signed on to produce original content for Apple. It was hard because she could produce it for everybody else. She made stuff for CBS, like her high-profile interview with Harry and Meghan. She had a cable network and a deal with Discovery. She even appeared with David Zaslav, if you recall, when he first came in. They're going to work project to project. It's just they let her do whatever they want. They just wanted the name for these press release names, you know, these expensive and handed her a whole bunch of money. But other streamers are also pulling back. Netflix canceled on Meghan Markle's animated series and then cut back there. So what do you think about these streaming mega deals? They don't really need. They've done better with stuff like Ted Lasso and Severance. So what do you think?
They usually don't work. I was trying to come up with a better term, but the power of the pause. The queen dies and it gives all of these nations that are part of the empire, or whatever you call it, part of the monarchy, an opportunity to pause and reevaluate the relationship. Whenever you raise prices or go through a pandemic or an economic shock, it gives everyone an opportunity to pause and reevaluate the relationship. Whenever these big iconic stars switch platforms, it gives you an opportunity to pause and decide if you really want to watch this stuff. What usually happens is that when you have the magic, mystery, and alchemy come together of a talent and a platform and a moment, it's not a given that when you take Megyn Kelly off of Fox, she's going to work somewhere else.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
It's not a given when you take Oprah off of her show and lose that following that what she does next is going to work. Other things worked elsewhere for her. She could go anywhere she wanted and they still gave her a deal, which was incredible.
Scott Galloway
Well, go ahead. Yeah, but we talked a little bit about this. I was thinking about your conference, right? You had the fastest tortoise.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
I think this sort of long-form one-on-one interview that Oprah does... I wonder if the sun has passed midday on it, just because people don't have the attention span or the people that advertisers want to reach.
Kara Swisher
I don't agree. Said number seven on top overall shows.
Scott Galloway
That's a fair point. But you're in people's ears.
Kara Swisher
Although we've added stuff to it. We've changed it. There's discussion with Naima. There's all kinds of stuff in there. There's the interview at the heart of it. But we've moved – it's no longer just a long interview for sure. But she's making other things. She's not just done these interviews. She does all kinds of content.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but look – okay, another one, the Obamas. I get the feeling – here's what it is. It's an economic decision. It's more the celebrity ones. But go ahead.
Kara Swisher
That's right. Meghan and Harry, the Obamas, Oprah. My guess is what they're doing except for Meghan and Harry is really good work and it's not worth what they had to pay them.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
And so it's just a business decision. I think if they were paying – I can't even imagine how much money they had to give to Oprah for her to sit around and think of interesting ideas. I'm sure the work is good. Some analysts said this is costing way too much.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, she didn't do much. And what this is part of – what this really signals in the macro environment is that every platform has got their pencils out for the first time in a while. They're going, we just can't continue to spend the way we've been spending.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. But it was good for the beginning to get interest in it. It showed a stamp of – Oprah stamp of approval, all these things, to do these splashy press release deals. And then she was able – the fact that she was able to do whatever she wants elsewhere, it's like someone paying you or I a million dollars and then we could also work for anyone we want. Therefore, we put things where we felt like they belonged. By the way, everything Apple Plus has been doing that's been really successful is not that well-known. I mean, they're very strong producers, but it's not – they didn't have to pay them as much as they paid Oprah, I'm sure.
Topic shift
Anyway, let's get back to Netflix and this thing. Speaking of celebrities, Ryan Murphy, who has had this deal with Netflix, he's done a bunch of stuff that has sort of been sideways essentially. Some of them good shows, some of them not, but not killer shows. Speaking of killers, his series on serial killer Jeffrey Dahmer called *Dahmer – Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story* – it's a very strange name. By hours watched, the show broke the record for new series in the first week on Netflix. Lots of controversy. Family members of Dahmer's victims said they were never contacted about the show. One called it cruel and re-traumatizing. At the time of the launch, the show was tagged LGBTQ. Netflix removed the tag after an outcry. He was gay, Jeffrey Dahmer. Anyway, it's doing really well. I am not going to watch it. I do not watch serial killer shows. But it's an interesting thing that they finally got a big show out of him. I don't know if they can bank on this happening all the time. I'm curious what you think of this kind of thing.
Scott Galloway
It's not a surprise that it's done so well. We have a fascination with crime and violence and these extremely abnormal people.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, that's who's in my way to number one, by the way. I'm going to have to kill you just so you know and then solve the issue myself so I can get to the number one spot on Apple Podcasts.
Scott Galloway
But go ahead. Well, supposedly you used to make pizza. It was called Domino's.
Kara Swisher
I can do this all night.
Scott Galloway
OK. But I'm going to have to kill you. Just be aware. A bunch of news releases I saw saying Jeffrey Dahmer, who was gay. And I'm like, to even attach a sexual orientation to him doesn't make any sense to me. He was a cannibal. He was a serial murderer.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
I mean, it's like saying, oh, he was a libertarian. Who cares? That has nothing to do with anything.
Kara Swisher
No. He was a deranged person. It's an interesting story.
Scott Galloway
It's also interesting. A few years ago, they went and interviewed and spent time with his parents.
Kara Swisher
Oh, wow.
Scott Galloway
And his parents couldn't have been nicer. Couldn't have been more well-adjusted. And it was like a giant documentary about nature versus nurture.
Kara Swisher
Sociopath from the get-go, I suspect. But also, I haven't seen the series, but it also weaves in a lot about our society's reluctance to get involved or pay attention to our police force when it's in communities of color.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. 100%. That's who most of his victims were. It's one thing these people usually have in common, these serial murderers, is they're very good – and this is true of pedophiles – they're outstanding at figuring out victims that will not cause a disturbance or that the authorities or society don't show the same level of attention to. They're very good at finding those people.
Kara Swisher
Even when they're saying – there's a character in this show that's warning the police about what's going on and they do nothing about it. In fact, they help one of his victims back into the apartment after the guy escaped. That was a detail of one of the killings. He kept saying it's my boyfriend and he's drunk. And the neighbors were like, no, it's something bad going on here. And the police actually helped him get the victim into the apartment where he then killed him. Anyway, are you going to watch it?
Scott Galloway
I'm not going to watch it.
Kara Swisher
As I get older, I can't – that's one genre I just can't deal with. Horror films or stuff like that, I have a tough time with it.
Scott Galloway
You know, I was the shadow on your ring. It's either you or Marjorie Taylor Greene's ex. It was one or the other.
Kara Swisher
That's not fun. No, but I have a whole thing. Me and Naima, who is the brains of the operation, are plotting to do a crime thing to weave it into this new show. And you're the victim.
Transition to listener question
Anyway, let's pivot to a listener question. You've got mail. This question comes from Elizabeth. It came via email. I'll read it. "Hi, Kara and Scott. Once again, Kara is first in that thing. Absolutely love your podcast. What do you understand to be the potential downsides of a U.S. law or administrative action that bans TikTok? What would we say if a foreign government took a similar action against a U.S. company? How might a ban on TikTok set a precedent for further social media bans? To be clear, I thought your points on the dangers of TikTok were well-founded and beautifully made, as they always are. I understand you can't discuss everything. I'm just hoping for a fuller conversation next time you address the issue." This is good because I'm about to interview the U.S. CEO of TikTok. But go ahead, Scott. Give us some fuller thoughts on this so I can borrow them for my interview.
Scott Galloway
Well, first off, let's look at the question. "What would we say if a foreign government took similar action against a U.S. company?" We've said it over and over because China's done it consistently.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, they do.
Scott Galloway
Let's acknowledge the point that banning media, banning a company, a media company, right away should raise red flags. One of the pillars of a modern economy or a democratic society is that pretty much anybody can say pretty much anything about pretty much anyone else. That is a hallmark of a free society. So when you start using the words "ban" and "media" in the same sentence, you should naturally have a gag reflex similar to what the person who put the question in. The difference here, though, is that on a trade level, I do believe that Trump got this right. I think there's an asymmetry there. They ban anything that reeks of any sort of Western media or technology.
Kara Swisher
Everything. They let it in long enough to steal its IP.
Scott Galloway
That's correct. Prop up a local entrepreneur, finance it, and then kick the American company out so they can capture the domestic value. They're like, we have a large enough market to create hundreds of billions of dollars behind a search engine or social. So we let you in just long enough to steal your IP and then kick you out. So just on a trade level, tit for tat, we have license to kick them out. On a societal level, I just totally – I don't know what the term is – freaked out. Seeing the incredibly addictive nature of this platform and the fact that young people are now spending more time on this platform – with the exception of YouTube – than all streaming media. It used to be YouTube. It used to be obsessive watching was YouTube and now it's this and it's even better.
Kara Swisher
Do you know who's obsessively watching TikTok right now? Jim Bankoff. He called me. He said he can't stop.
Scott Galloway
Bankoff likes TikTok?
Kara Swisher
He just started doing it. Now he can't stop.
Scott Galloway
I'd be curious what he's watching. I get the sense he's a saucy little mix. He's too nice and buttoned up on the outside. I bet there's some crazy shit in his feed.
Kara Swisher
Let's investigate. Let's do a podcast about that. Anyway, go ahead.
Scott Galloway
Okay, so it's addictive. So are the others.
Kara Swisher
So I don't think they're more addictive.
Scott Galloway
This is different, though. It's not social. It's a streaming media platform – no decisions. Good Quibi. More than 50% of our youth is on it, more than every streaming media combined. I believe the opportunity for them – and if you read their privacy agreement, you're agreeing that TikTok can track your keystrokes on any other app. The idea that it would be so incredibly easy for them to put their thumb on the scale of anti-American content – just as Meta is the ultimate espionage tool, I think TikTok is now the ultimate propaganda tool. I do not want to see America raise a generation of future military, civic, social, and business leaders that feel worse about America.
Kara Swisher
Right. What I've said is two things. One, if I was in the CCP, this is exactly what I would be doing. Putting money into this. And two, I believe the people at TikTok deserve huge economic upside for what they have built. What I'd like to see is some sort of spin to U.S. interests and also regulation by U.S. regulators that ensure all the data is – it's all about incentives and ensuring there is a true Chinese wall here. In my view, it is an existential threat for it to exist as it stands.
Scott Galloway
And the final point I'll make is I've gotten a lot of pushback from some journalists that you're distracting from the issues, the privacy issues of Meta. And I'm like, we can walk and chew gum at the same time. This isn't a zero-sum game. This doesn't let Meta off the hook for its weaponization of elections or teen depression or delay in obfuscation of privacy. But this is a national security risk.
Kara Swisher
All right. Let me ask you a question then. What if they were successfully able to put up a wall? Should it be limited because it happens to be so addictive, but just on that thing? If it was not used for propaganda, if they were not able to manipulate it if they wanted to, what say you then, Scott Galloway?
Scott Galloway
Then whatever you do around the addictive nature, you'd have to apply to all platforms. You can't be xenophobic or jingoist and start saying Chinese platforms are a bigger threat because they're Chinese.
Kara Swisher
Well, no.
Scott Galloway
If you got rid of the propaganda and the espionage risk, then you would just have to group it into whatever legislation or regulation you were going to enforce against all platforms.
Kara Swisher
And if you remove the propaganda and espionage part, is it a better product than others? Is it doing well? Because one of the things that when I do the interview, I want to talk about why it's such a good product. Why is it? It is a very good product when you use it. People get dragged into it. It's not just addiction. It's entertaining. It's like you and I and Twitter. We like scrolling Twitter. But I don't use TikTok because I know I would like it so much. What do you do about the fact that the product is so infectiously fun to use?
Scott Galloway
Here's TikTok's genius. Everyone thought about social media. This is not social. It's entertainment. The reason why TV was the most revolutionary medium to that point is it required nothing of you. It was passive. You sat on your couch and other than trying to find your remote between cushions, it asked nothing of you. I always thought interactive television was an oxymoron. When I watch TV, I don't even want to decide. And that's what TikTok does. It says no decisions, totally passive. You're not going to get bullied by the 13-year-old girl who thinks you're a jerk. You're not going to feel bad that you don't have great abs. You're not going to feel bad that you're not rich enough to be sitting by the pool at the Aman in Utah. We're just going to calibrate based on a few finger swipes what content you absolutely love. You can just lie on your side and go into a rabbit hole in an opium-like dream state.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. It is makeup or air fryer or whatever you want. Or chiropractors adjusting people or Great Danes. I'm getting served amazing content about Great Danes. Or these poor animals that decide to get a little sip of water in an African watering hole and have a very unpleasant experience at the hands of a crocodile. I cannot stop watching that shit.
Scott Galloway
I have dopamine firing just talking about TikTok. I'm a capitalist. I think Vanessa and her colleagues deserve to be really, really rich.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, so what happens? What do we do here?
Scott Galloway
Separate it. Here's why they're going to figure it out. There is so much money on the line. The difference between this company being worth $50 billion and $500 billion is their ability to create this Chinese wall. I don't know how they do that. You summarized it perfectly. They have to separate the product from the ownership. As long as it's owned by Chinese interests, as long as there are engineers in China, it's too much of a risk. There's so much money on the line here. I think they're going to figure it out. But if you were just to say we want to ban it because it's addictive, now we've got to talk about every platform. That's just not true.
Kara Swisher
So it would work for you if the product was separated from the ownership. It's all about ownership.
Scott Galloway
All right. Okay, Elizabeth.
Kara Swisher
Anything else?
Scott Galloway
Oh, keep going. Okay. And then we have to have identity for all of it. I don't see any reason why anyone under the age of 15 needs to be on any of these things, quite frankly. We need to carve out Section 230 such that if it shows they're weaponizing our elections or causing teen depression or spreading misinformation about vaccines, they're liable the same way as any other media company. There's a bunch of things we need to do across all of them. But TikTok is a special, unique threat because of its ownership.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, little Chinese. What do you think? Where do I have this wrong?
Scott Galloway
I would agree with you.
Kara Swisher
I'm thinking a lot about it because when I'm interviewing, obviously, you have to talk about the China thing. But it's a great product. So what do you do with this great product that also has such potential for national security risk, propaganda, et cetera? You can't even get to the other things that plague other social media companies. I think you're dead on right that it's – I've always thought of it – I wrote a column saying I'm using a burner phone to use it because I don't trust the Chinese government. I don't particularly trust ours, but I really don't trust them. And I love it too. So what do you do? I'm still using a burner phone, which means it's an interesting dichotomy of my love of the product from the not so much love of the ownership. I think it's social entertainment. You're 100 percent right. It's social. There is a social element to it, but it's entertainment and it's creativity. I think there's a lot of creativity on that platform that can be mixed with propaganda. That's the whole point of propaganda is to hide among the flowers and really get you going on whatever is in your interest.
Scott Galloway
Last thing and then we'll go.
Kara Swisher
Well, no. My last thing is I have a burner phone. I only really use it for one thing, to communicate and FaceTime with Marjorie Taylor Greene's ex. He rubs his feet and I – is that weird? See, you told me you didn't want to talk about this and then you cannot get away from it.
Anyway, if you've got a question of your own that you'd like answered, send it our way. Go to nymag.com slash pivot to submit a question for the show or call 855-51-PIVOT.
Ad break
All right, Scott, we're going to have a quick break and we'll be back for your fantastic and stellar prediction.
Ad break
Okay, Scott, let's hear a prediction.
Scott Galloway
I already did by saying I think they're going to settle soon. Twitter. Okay. So get this. This is from arguably my favorite economist, although I have a ton of favorite economists, but Lizanne Saunders, the chief economist at Schwab. I think she's a great follow on Twitter. She put out this amazing stat: in early 2021, if you could afford a house, a monthly house payment of $2,500 or a mortgage payment of $2,500, and you could come up with 20% down, that meant you could afford a house that costs $759,000. So if you were a couple going shopping, we can spend about $2,500 a month. We've got $100,000 to put down.
We can afford a $760,000 house. Now, with interest rates over 7%, that same couple's purchasing power means they can buy a house for $476,000. So the purchasing power for a lot of middle-class people has gone down $300,000. The prediction is really easy. The housing market is about to get the shit kicked out of it. There's some belief that we haven't produced enough houses, and that increase in interest rates creates handcuffs for people who can't actually sell their house, decreasing supply. There are some offsetting factors. I just don't think there's any getting around it. The U.S. housing market – you're going to see more and more articles about prices coming down because people still need to move.
They get divorced, they die, they get sick, whatever it is, they upgrade, they downgrade. The affordability around houses for the same couple, same purchasing power, same income can now afford much, much less. My prediction is we're about to see a lot more articles about cracks and declines in the U.S. housing market.
Kara Swisher
Okay. All right. Even despite the lack of inventory.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, probably.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I would agree. Things are sitting on the market, I've noticed. I'm one of those people who spends a lot of time looking at Zillow for no good reason. A lot of stuff is really staying on the market longer. You can just see it.
Okay, Scott, that's the show. We'll be back on Tuesday with more Pivot. Get ready for our crossover episodes around the Twitter trial. But until then, we have lots more to talk about. Scott, read us out.
Scott Galloway
Today's show is produced by Lara Nehman, Evan Engel, and Taylor Griffin. Ernie Intertot engineered this episode. Thanks also to Drew Burrows and Miel Saverio. Make sure you subscribe to the show wherever you listen to podcasts. Thanks for listening to Pivot from New York Magazine and Vox Media. We'll be back next week for another breakdown of all things tech and business.
Kara Swisher
I'll see you later on, you ghosting bitch on my ring phone.
Scott Galloway
Ghosting bitch? Okay. Thank you.