Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses various news and topics, including the use of AI agents, the controversy surrounding Chris Licht's departure from CNN, the potential merger between the PGA Tour and Saudi-backed Live Golf, and the issues with social media platforms and their handling of child exploitation.
Key Points:
Participants: The hosts, Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway, are joined by various guests and experts throughout the episode, including Alex Stamos, a researcher at the Stanford Internet Observatory, and Gary Gensler, the chairman of the US Securities and Exchange Commission.
Takeaways:
Kara Swisher
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And I'm Scott Galloway.
Kara Swisher
Tell me about your award.
Scott Galloway
Oh, my award. Well, first, the Hays. Let's talk about the Hays. You're so lucky to be in London. You know, you shame me.
Kara Swisher
I want to talk about your award. And you're immediately like, no, Scott, there's a journalist in the house. We're going to order this correctly. All right. My award was great. Thank you for asking. It was the Choosing Creativity Award. It's a wonderful organization run by the Crems. And George Hahn and Stephanie Ruhl gave me the award. I was hoping you would be there, but you're in London. And it was great. It was really nice. It was lovely.
Scott Galloway
I was in New York for four seconds, and I stayed at your place, which was lovely. But it was great. It was nice to be out in New York. It was nice to be at an event for a good cause. One of the other winners was this amazing light artist. So it's people who choose creativity, like myself. I choose creativity.
Kara Swisher
Choose creativity?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, yeah.
Kara Swisher
It's a choice?
Scott Galloway
It's a program. No, it's a program for kids. A 10-point program to get kids to focus on creativity that they bring to schools. It's great. A lot of kids just do rote stuff and don't think about, in this time of AI especially, it's important to think about what differentiates us as humans compared to computers.
Kara Swisher
And your mom was there?
Scott Galloway
She was there. The whole package. It was lovely. And George brought one of my favorite country music artists, Shelley Wright. And Lara came. Lara's our producer.
Kara Swisher
Yes, Lara's our producer. And let me just say, my mother's a little hurt. She says you hurt her feelings sometimes.
Scott Galloway
I hurt her feelings? How did I do that?
Kara Swisher
On the show. I hate to think that. I don't know. What have I said? Every now and then for saying she's not fun at parties.
Scott Galloway
Well, she's the most fashionable person at the party. It's true. It's true. She needs you to understand she's fun at parties. I hate to think I bring anything but joy to Lucky's life.
Kara Swisher
Well, anyway, she just wants you to know that she's a lot of fun. That she's fun, that she's a good time.
Scott Galloway
She's a good time, darling. You know, you usually get awards. These types of awards are usually given to people for one of two reasons. One, because of their accomplishments and achievements. Or two, because they're really on the back nine.
Kara Swisher
That's right.
Scott Galloway
They're starting to slow down. I keep saying that. I keep getting awards. Get them to accept the award before they start drooling. I mean, so which was this? Which was this?
Kara Swisher
This was the beginning. This is the beginning of awards for Kara.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, you know, there'll be one. There'll be a roast, and you hopefully will go to that one. They just want to raise money.
Kara Swisher
Well, I'll only go if Party Chick Lucky shows up.
Scott Galloway
All right. Can you imagine you two on the town? That would be very funny.
Kara Swisher
Speaking of parties, it's Alex's prom tonight. I'm very excited.
Scott Galloway
Oh, that's nice.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Is he taking his girlfriend from Texas? Yes, indeed, Heidi. And he went to her prom where she wore a pink thing, so his cummerbund and tie were pink, I think. That's nice. Now they're yellow. They're going yellow, yellow roses of Texas. Yeah, so, and Louie's driving them as the driver.
Scott Galloway
Oh, that's great.
Kara Swisher
My ex-wife bought gloves and a hat for him, so he's doing all the things.
Scott Galloway
That's hilarious.
Kara Swisher
I know, it's going to be good. That's nice. Take a bunch of pictures, that'll be fun.
Scott Galloway
I shall. It's also Pride Day at the White House. They're going to invite all the gays to the White House today. So it's a lot going on here in Washington, along with the haze, as I will bring in. You are not in New York or Washington or the East Coast. It's really, it's not worse than what happens in California all the time, every year. But I think a lot of people are super freaked out because they've never experienced it. And it's quite unhealthy what's happening. But people have never seen anything like it. It looks like you're in a, you've posted a number of funny pictures from movies, obviously. But from futuristic movies, that's what it looks like. It looks exactly like that.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I always find that coming from California, California is done scarily because we have to live through super fires and earthquakes. I remember when I worked at the LA office of Morgan Stanley, and we had earthquakes. You could tell who was from New York. The New Yorkers would freak out, start pounding Xanax and head home.
Scott Galloway
Right.
Kara Swisher
And the Californians were like, oh, it's an earthquake. And barely even stopped working.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, it's interesting. I feel like that too. I don't want to not take it seriously, but there was so much. And I think you should wear masks too, by the way. But I was like, oh, is this bad? Because it's not as bad. It doesn't smell smoky, at least in Washington. It has a vague sense of smoke. I mean, obviously looks hazy and there's the orangeness of it. But it's true. Californians are all schooling. They're like, really? Get used to it.
Kara Swisher
I think it's actually going to go on for, I think there's going to be a lot of wildfires up in Canada. But it's amazing how it reminds you of the interconnectedness of our world. It feels very Blade Runner, the pictures I've seen.
Scott Galloway
It does. It does. New York particularly. And it's freaky. It is freaky for people. And so maybe they'll think about it. Here's a visual representation of what's going on. I always tell people, don't go outside. And also, just in general, when there's ever any problem anywhere, a decent go-to, blame Canada.
Kara Swisher
Blame Canada.
Scott Galloway
Blame Canada and Andrew Ross-Dorkin.
Kara Swisher
Andrew Ross-Dorkin. It's his fault. This entire thing is his fault.
Scott Galloway
There's a lot to talk about. There's so much news. I mean, like, literally, Trump's possible indictment is not even on the top of the list. But nonetheless, that's coming, too. And Chris Christie, by the way, is highly entertaining having entered the presidential race. There's all kinds of things to talk about. Anyway, today we'll talk about disturbing news from Instagram, how bad actors may be using the networks to exploit children. A truly heartbreaking story. And of course, not a surprise how sloppy Meta is being about it. Also a controversial merger in the world of golf. I'm going to look to you to explain this to me, but people are pissed.
And we'll make some predictions. And speaking of that, one we got 100% right. As I predicted the night before, Chris Licht is out at CNN. I tweeted, like, tomorrow is happening. Essentially, it's happening right away. And Discovery CEO David Zasloff announced the exit to the company in a memo saying Licht, quote, poured his heart and soul into the job. Zasloff took the blame for Licht's short tenure, saying, ultimately, it's on me. I take responsibility. It's completely on him. Internal team of program executives, another person I said would probably get this job, Amy Entelis, for example, will serve as acting leadership during the search for the new CEO.
Shares of the company jumped 8% at the news. I'll give you a shot at a prediction for you. By the way, you predicted this too. Let's play that first. Then we'll talk about who the new CEO might be.
Well, you realize Chris Licht having a conversation with me probably means he's going to be fired in the next 90 days. I'm literally Typhoid Mary when it comes down to television.
Kara Swisher
There you go. Anytime someone's talking to Scott, they're going to lose their job or something bad's going to happen. So who do you think the new CEO is going to be? Who would you pick?
Scott Galloway
I don't know. I just, I've been thinking about-
Kara Swisher
It's a small list.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, it's getting smaller. I don't think Jeff's going to come back for it.
Kara Swisher
No, I was teasing on that poll. I mean, there's a few things here. There's an Amy Entelis who's well regarded, but I don't think, I think they see her as an interim CEO. It's really, there's a few things that struck me as interesting here. And what people always tend to talk about or tend to focus on the top guy or gal and something that they don't recognize is the importance and the impact on the ground of when your bench leaves. So soon after Zucker left and they decided, you know, new strategy. I think John Malone is quite frankly, the puppet master here. And they said, we're going to pivot to the center.
Scott Galloway
And so for example, I worked closely with Rebecca Cutler and Andrew Morse. Who were at NBC and Atlantic Constitution now. They've gone. But they were both senior level executives.
Kara Swisher
Totally. Very competent. Highly competent. And very strong. I remember when I was taping my show for CNN Plus, you know, Rebecca just kind of swept into the room and said, stop and said, Scott, you're not a comedian. You're a professor. I want you to get back to. But she has those sort of creative instincts and her ability to kind of cut a swath between talent, ability to manage them, and then create programming that worked. And then Andrew-
Scott Galloway
Yeah, she's working on the Jen Psaki show, which has been a hit. And then Andrew really understood digital, the intersection of digital and media. And I remember being at the event when they announced CNN Plus and he comes across as a leader. When you clear house like this, the lesson here is, in my opinion, a couple of things. One, the first is, and I've always thought this and said this on boards. When you bring in a new CEO, the new CEO, their first test is if they want a clean house or they want to sit the top lieutenants down and give them something and make them feel loved and keep them on campus. Because it's not easy to find four-star generals. We talk about the five-star general. We talk about the supreme allied commander, but your four-star generals are really, really important. And a lot of, Scott Matthews, my producer, left. So many people left that were really good. That takes a toll. The other big lesson here is that I think I got this wrong. I think I've been hoping all along that there is a market for a more moderate network. And you know what? I think I'm wrong. I think people watch these shows not to be informed, but to feel good and be entertained.
Kara Swisher
Although, I'm going to push back on that. I think he just was all about Chris in a lot of ways. A lot of talking about himself, a lot of his theories. He should have shut up a lot more. I think he talked to me. But that's not what got him fired.
Scott Galloway
No, no, no, no.
Kara Swisher
But I think he just had the wrong instincts. I don't think it was trying to be centrist. I think it was declaring it as a rule without thinking. I think Christiane Amanpour, again, had the right thing. It's like, it's not centrist to be wrong. Like, it's not, you know what I mean, just to give everybody air if someone's wrong. Like, I think he was conflating political stuff with actual news. And they broke a ton of news this week. Like at least six stories by really good reporters at CNN broke them. I've read this week around Trump. Caitlin Collins broke several. You know, when they're good reporters, if they're right, that's all.
They just have to be accurate, I think. And I think that's – I get what you mean about being centrist, but I think his idea of centrist was not journalism. It was just – and he said, which is not journalism. And it's wherever the cards lay, that's where it is. And let me just say, the three people they have there, I have a huge regard for Amy Entelis. There's a woman named Virginia Mosley who does a lot of their political stuff in national news, and a guy named Eric Scherling who does other stuff. So it's a troika. Honestly, they should just give it to Amy. Amy is quite loved there. She's got the calmness they need.
She's created amazing journalism. She did an involved documentary. She is even responsible for Stanley Tucci. She's very smart. You know, the Stanley Tucci show, which was terrific about Italy. Just a lot of talent, a heavy amount of talent. She's the kind of person, it's like she can make just good stuff. Like that's what they need to do. Even if it's a declining asset, even if audience is leaving, I think really good content tends to do okay. Even if it's a slightly smaller business, they have great reporters. They do. And they have to stop talking about CNN. Like that's what they, and that's what he did.
He talked a lot without knowing a lot initially and had a lot of pronouncements. And made a lot of stupid errors. I mean, so many, so, so many, including-
Scott Galloway
But the market, if you, the market was up 8% on the news. And I thought, why would the market, why would the market perceive this? I think that was the biggest stocking that Warner Brothers Discovery has had or Discovery Warner Brothers or HBO Chili Bagadonna is what the fuck they're calling themselves now. But if they, it was up 8%. And I think what the market was saying is polarization pays. And they see this as that they'll probably go back to their roots of more of a very partisan, anti-Trump, hard left network. Right or wrong, whether that's what they're doing.
Kara Swisher
They were never that. I mean, MSNBC, you certainly can argue, is much more. And look what's happening. MSNBC is kicking the shit out of them.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but they're still declining.
Kara Swisher
Well, they're all declining.
Scott Galloway
Yes, they're all declining. But CNN's decline has kind of been historic here.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, they were kicking their audience in the teeth.
Scott Galloway
Well, okay, I'll push it back to you. That is my thesis for why the stock – Chris Licht doesn't move the stock 8%. Leaving doesn't move the stock 8%. What I think moves the stock 8% is the market goes, you know what? There's money in polarization or there's money in being more whatever you want to call it. Or it is what it is. And you don't kick your audience in the teeth, right? It is what it is. The New York Times is what it is. Whatever you happen to describe it, you certainly, depending on where you're sitting, you have an opinion about the New York Times and you know what you're getting as a product.
Kara Swisher
Well, going back to its roots.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. whatever you want to call it.
Kara Swisher
Well, I think news, I think they're really good at breaking news. I think they can be news without having to declare constantly they're centrist. That was just so, it was very much David Zasloff. Let me say, I think Chris was a proxy for him. I've had conversations with him that I find vexing around his theories of journalism, which I'm sorry to say, I think he's a very smart programmer, but honestly, it's like talking to my uncle about journalism. I just, I'm like, what? I said what a lot during our conversation. And so, he needs to let the professionals take over and see if they can make good programming. That's really what he needs to get the fuck out of the way, is what he needs. I don't want David Zasloff to pronounce on journalism. I really don't.
Scott Galloway
I have not. I don't think he is, though.
Kara Swisher
He does. He does. At CNN? Yes. Yes. It's very clear.
Scott Galloway
I think the person in the room here is John Malone.
Kara Swisher
Maybe. Maybe. But I think David, you know, worships at the altar of John Malone. I don't think it's already in his DNA to start with. Anyway, there's some names. Noah Oppenheim was brought up. I bet Phil Griffin got a call. These are all NBC people. There are probably some people at Linda Iaccarino. Linda Iaccarino. You know what, Linda Iaccarino, this is the job for her. She would kick the fucking ass out of this place with business. It's being run by David Levy.
Scott Galloway
Isn't she a Trumper? I don't see that happening.
Kara Swisher
You know, she's good at selling. She was at NBC. They're not the most Trumpy group of people. That's going to happen. We'll see. Linda's at right now. She's finding toilet paper somewhere. That's what she's doing. She's busy. Seriously, she's all locked up for the next 90 days at least.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. Yeah, we'll see. 90 days.
Kara Swisher
All right. Well, that's a different thing. Speaking of Twitter, Tucker Carlson debuted his new Twitter show, and Fox News immediately says he violated his contract. In a letter, Fox News lawyers say that Tucker's deal makes him exclusive to Fox and he's not allowed to perform over a network via streaming, which is exactly what he's doing. Lawyers for Carlson said any legal action would violate his First Amendment rights. Fox reportedly aims to keep Carlson locked into a deal until 2025. This is delicious.
Scott Galloway
It's fantastic. You know, he signed a contract. I did. I've signed them. I couldn't go other places. I didn't scream about my First Amendment rights. He was making a show. He's making a show and Elon's talking about shows and talking about it like it's a show. So that's what it is. So I don't know.
Kara Swisher
Well, there's a small issue and a big issue. And the small issue, and it's interesting, is non-competes and if they're enforceable. And they are. And he's adopted this catchphrase or this go-to when you have no legitimate argument to scream First Amendment when the First Amendment has absolutely no relevance here. First Amendment, again, is government shall pass no law which prohibits free speech. These are private companies. You're a big boy when you get paid $10 or $20 million a year. And the contract says specifically you will not take content to a streaming, other streaming network of any kind. I mean, the language is definitive. I've been in those. You've had those contracts. You know them.
Scott Galloway
That's why I left so many. And if you're in California, they're difficult to enforce unless you're an officer or making over a certain amount of money. He's not in. If your livelihood is put at stake, the most mendacious part of non-competes, and I'd like to see non-competes done away with.
Kara Swisher
Agreed.
Scott Galloway
But the most mendacious part of non-competes is they now are with like hairstylists who can't walk across the street to another hair salon. They're being abused. But when you're Tucker Carlson and you sign up to go to work for Rupert Murdoch. Big lawyers. You have big important lawyers.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, at $10 or $20 million a year, and you have very expensive lawyers and agents reviewing your contract, and you have an individual that will chase you to the four corners of the earth.
Scott Galloway
And let me bring this back to me. Okay. WPP, specifically Sir Martin Sorrell, tried to acquire two of my companies, Prophet, my first brand strategy firm, and L2. And WPP, basically Sir Martin, he pioneered the notion of securitizing and making services companies investable assets. What do I mean by that? Ad agencies used to be these personality-driven companies where Donnie Deutsch or Shelley Lazarus had this key relationship with the CMO of P&G and had huge, huge profitable businesses that were very relationship-driven and very volatile and insecure. Because if you lost one client or Shelley or Donnie decided he didn't like working for a bigger company, your investment could just crash.
So what Martin did was he said, I know these things are very volatile assets, but if I create a mutual fund of 40 or 50 of them, they become much more predictable assets. And he made them ready for public investment. And it was an incredible model because of the volatility and personality-driven nature of these companies. They traded for five to seven times EBITDA. When he put them in a more less volatile, diversified structure, WPP, it became worth 10 to 12 times EBITDA. So we just went out and made all of these accretive acquisitions. I get the purchase agreement for Prophet. I get the purchase agreement contract for L2.
And it's a 45-page agreement that basically says, Scott, at any time, I can basically sue you to the fucking ends of the universe.
Kara Swisher
Right. Yeah.
Scott Galloway
And if you piss me off, basically. And I remember calling the person, Sheila Spence, a super smart woman, saying, why on earth would I sign this? This is I got to sleep with one eye open and hope I don't piss off Sir Martin every day. That if he just doesn't like the cut of my jib one day, he can sue me. And she went into this whole thing. Well, we got to understand we work with entrepreneurs. We have to cover ourselves. We're making a big investment in you. And we never do that. I'm like, well, if you never do it, why is it in here? And ultimately, both times, I decided I just can't sign this.
I don't want to live this way. But guess what? Tucker Carlson signed it. And just to finish the point, Sir Martin, I heard about this. A small agency was not doing well. They were offered money to be bought by another big conglomerate. They just weren't getting along. It wasn't working for them. And Sir Martin decided, no, I'd rather let it die. I'd rather let it die than have it go to a competitor. And he got to do that. When you're dealing with Rupert Murdoch or guys like Sir Martin Murdoch, these guys do not scare easy. He's killing. He's trying to kill his career. And that's what he signed up for.
Kara Swisher
I mean, what's really interesting, I had a similar, a much lesser kind of thing is I, every contract I've gotten, whether it's CNBC or the New York Times, I worked under contract for both of those. I work under contract for Vox, actually, too, because I like contracts. They say what they say, right? But they say what they say. And you can put them in and you can negotiate the stuff out. But one of the reasons I didn't sign again with CNBC, they give you, for people who don't know, they give you a certain amount of money for exclusivity. And I was like, I'm not getting anything out of this exclusivity that's worth the money they're giving me, right?
It's not worth it. And I want to go on CNN if I want to go on CBS. I want to do whatever I want to do. And the money doesn't, you know, I just, I weigh them, right? And so it's not worth, I can make money better somewhere else. And so it was so onerous. It was like, you can't like do this. And I was like, I have to, you know, flack my podcast. I got to flack Pivot. I got to like, I don't, it was much more lucrative. I got to party with Lucky. I got to party with Lucky. And the same thing with the New York Times. There was an onerous thing that was essentially you can't make podcasts anywhere.
And I was like, take it out or I'm not doing it. And they took it out. It was onerous. But I'm constantly looking at the phrasing in these contracts. And I clarify it with them. I'm like, this means this. Please send this to me in a piece of paper that says this is precisely what it means. This guy is bullshit. It's bullshit. They're going to keep him off on the bench. They have a right to do it. I cannot stand the News Corp. I cannot stand Rupert Murdoch, but he bought him. He paid for him. He can keep him on the shelf if he wants to.
Scott Galloway
But the two things, this is a good thing. This is how society should work. The more money here, the more you are paid, the more enforceable they are. Because a decent defense is, I need to make a living. Or even if they find you guilty, then what are the damages? And if you're a hairdresser, the damages just aren't going to be that big. Or if you're a tier two anchor, the damages just wouldn't be that big. If you're Tucker Carlson and Rupert's going to say the decline in the stock here, the decline in ratings across all of our shows and the distraction he has caused, the blatant violation of his agreement, despite the fact we continue to pay him his $20 million, they are going to rip this guy limb from limb in court. Or if they need him, they'll hire him again.
Kara Swisher
You know what's interesting? After that settlement, that billion-dollar settlement and more to come, no executive at Fox got fired except for Tucker Carlson. I mean, and then Chris Licht is out for having a reporter. These are, this is what we're talking here is the small issue. Because as media, we're obsessed with media. The big issue here that warrants more attention is in this ridiculous rant, this ridiculous rant, he said the following thing. He said that Zelensky is a, open quote, persecutor of Christians.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
This is nothing but not even thinly veiled anti-Semitism.
Scott Galloway
Totally.
Kara Swisher
And when you have the most, arguably the most famous news journalist or entertainment journalist, whatever you want to call him, in America, in a bow tie, on Twitter, basically engaging. He had a lot of, they had a lot of people. First episode, first episode, let me stir up anti-Semitic feelings among people. By the way, who are the same people who are going to believe me when in the same episode, I say that UFOs and extraterrestrial life are, open quote, actually real, close quote.
Scott Galloway
Well, there are some questions about that, but go ahead.
Kara Swisher
Well, I don't know. He took it too far. It's a little more. Anyway, he took it too far. Let's keep in mind. He's, okay, he's violated his non-compete. That's an issue. It's interesting. More than anything, he is a raging anti-Semite. That's the big story here.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I agree. You know, he's making a show. Elon's talked about it like shows. He's talked about it like a show. And then he's like, it's actually, he can still tweet. He can still tweet as much as he wants. He just can't do a show. And that's what he's doing here, 100%. Like, come on, stop it. Stop it, Tucker. And by the way, just so you know, I asked my mother, interesting, speaking of Lucky, who watched Tucker, despite his insults of me. I said, are you watching him on Twitter? She's like, what? No. Why? Like, you know, there's that audience that did so well for him at Fox. We'll see if, well, he's not going to get to do it. That's the way it's going to go. So he's going to lose. They may settle, but probably they'll keep them on the bench. So sorry, Tucker. Sorry.
Kara Swisher
Lastly, the SEC, speaking of badasses, the SEC suddenly woke up and they're coming for crypto's biggest players, suing both Binance and Coinbase this week. Both are accused of selling assets that should have been registered as securities. But in Binance's case, its chief executive, Changpeng Zhao, also known as CZ, is also accused of civil fraud. Binance's charge was siphoning off billions of dollars of customer money to a separate company owned by CZ. That's on top of nearly a dozen other charges, including manipulating investors. Both Coinbase and Binance have said they intend to fight back. At the time of his downfall, by the way, of SBF's downfall, Sam Bankman-Fried's, he tweeted, SBF is one of the greatest fraudsters in history. They had a bit of a beef between each other. But, you know, this is SEC hasn't been terrifically clear near as the government, whether it's a commodity or security. But here's Gary Gensler going for it.
Scott Galloway
I just feel like we need to just finally acknowledge two truths. Crypto is a levered Ponzi scheme and isn't a thing and we just shouldn't be talking about it as much. And headsets don't work, folks. Anyways, thanks for my TED talk.
Kara Swisher
Headsets? What do you mean headsets don't work?
Scott Galloway
Mixed reality. Weird. Anyways.
Kara Swisher
Isn't that spatial? It's a new paradigm in computing.
Scott Galloway
Oh, I can't wait to. I'm going to send you a picture of me in it next week.
Kara Swisher
But nonetheless, yes, they're going to sort out whether this is a security or a commodity. They're going to try to fight back. These companies are in trouble. This just isn't. Of course there's securities. Of course they should be regulated. They're trying to get it over at the CFTC or whatever, commodities, future trade, whatever. Do you have any thoughts on Gary Gensler on this issue?
In my opinion, Gary Gensler and the SEC have done everything right here. I just wish they'd done it in X time instead of 8X. I feel like the sheriff showing up after everyone is kind of bloody. Dead. It's like, well, okay. It's great that you're here. Yes.
Scott Galloway
But Gary is deliberate. He's very smart. He's not easily rattled. I enjoyed seeing him at your conference. He's another one of these people that I find encouraging — that such talented people with a lot of options decide to go to work for the government where it is a thankless job where everybody just second guesses them all day long.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I think Coinbase is already struggling. And Binance, we'll see. Binance I think is probably in much more of a world of trouble than Coinbase is. Anyway, let's get to our first big story. First a warning: the story is distressing and probably not appropriate for young listeners. So heads up: pedophiles on Instagram are openly marketing child sexual abuse material, or CSAM as it's called, and they're using Instagram's features to find customers. That's according to the Wall Street Journal. It was a tremendous piece. Speaking of this, it's a new Sorkin property? It's an amazing property. It's been doing an amazing job at reporting, by the way.
Let me separate that out. Sites work by the Stanford Internet Observatory. This is Alex Stamos, who we know. They found that Instagram's algorithm is helping users find accounts that market CSAM. To be clear, Instagram isn't hosting it. These accounts are directing users to websites and other platforms where they can purchase materials, but Instagram is accused of making it easy for users to find these accounts through hashtags and features like "suggested for you." Instagram even auto-completed some searches with terms like "boys" and "CP" — child pornography. Stanford researchers found over 400 accounts that claim to be created by children themselves, and some accounts offered in-person meetups.
Meta's response was really, "Well, we only found 10,000 or something." It's very hard to catch. I've done lots of interviews on this. Very difficult, pernicious, terrible, but again, something that should be the very lowest tier of ability to stop, right? They should be able to do this. They've laid a lot of workers off. I was told by Alex that they have laid a lot off. They're still at it, but they have fewer workers. Meta employees told the Washington Post they worried about the effects of layoffs on platform safety. Of course, they were able to take down posts about abortion pills. So what do you think?
Thoughts?
Scott Galloway
Well, it's shocking, but it's not surprising. I don't think anyone at Facebook is pro-child pornography. No. I think that there are people at Meta today that are horrified about this. The problem we have in corporate America is poor incentives where money has washed over Washington and created regulatory capture, where amoral people who aren't bad people, but they're amoral — if they can put enough distance between them and an opioid addict or a child that's being exploited, the money that fills the void blinds them to how directly their actions are attributed to these things. It's a failure of the U.S. public to elect individuals who create an algebra of deterrence. We had a perp walk and we had a woman and her partner go to prison for 10 plus years because she lied to her institutional investors on a questionnaire. I don't think any of this stops until there's a perp walk.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. And then I think they figure it out. On this issue I agree. I heartily agree. You know, it's interesting. Their current system has a database of these known CSAM images. The issue is they can't detect new images. It's confusing whether it's an innocent image of your kid in the pool or something like that. The network is what's suggesting similar accounts to users. It's helped grow the network, this AI thing. Now, there's been some legislation thoughts. Section 230 already has a carve out for prostitution and sex trafficking. Senator Lindsey Graham wants to take it further. He backs a bill, the EARN IT bill, that removes Section 230 protections from social networks so they adopt best practices around CSAM.
He's introduced the bill before, and it doesn't get through. Interestingly, the Stanford report said that TikTok doesn't appear to have this issue. Other networks, of course, had issues, and the Stanford team said Twitter was fast to remove accounts marketing CSAM. But they have a massive problem because he's laid off everybody. Alex tweeted about this — that they don't have access, that Musk has just recently cut off access so they can't study it, to the API. But it's embarrassing for Zuckerberg because he was someone who has said this is important.
Scott Galloway
I bet. I mean, I have not been a fan of the Zuck. I bet he's horrified by this. Personally, professionally. But Instagram starts from a place of perversion.
Kara Swisher
Meaning?
Scott Galloway
What does the algorithm promote and love? A 16-year-old girl — and let's be honest, she's a girl, not a woman — taking images of herself in sexualized outfits. We love that. And then you get to be evaluated by your peers and strange men all over the world. That's fucking perverted.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I would agree. I had that experience. Louie was like, "Look at this" — girls putting up photos that he knew. And I was like, "Uh." And I want to be clear. I think I'm one of these "free the nipple" people. I think on TikTok and Instagram or wherever, over the age of 18, if you want to be topless as a woman, like a guy can be topless, go for it. Anyone under the age of 18 should be fully clothed.
Scott Galloway
So age gating. It gets back to this age gating issue. Or maybe not even on the goddamn network. We age gate everything else.
Kara Swisher
Yep. But if a 15-year-old can go on and become an influencer by posing in incredibly sexualized positions, what do you know? There's child pornography on the same site from the same company. These make it easy. It makes it easy. These people used to have to go to places. The internet has made it easy. You cannot make it easy for these people. It's let a very unfortunate, very small group of people find each other and create network effects.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. And some of that is good — the parents of kids with rare childhood diseases, there's some very positive things. But it all comes back to the same thing for me. Until we see a recognizable figure in tech do a perp walk, none of this stops. They're faster than us. Until then, they have to spend the money on safety systems. Twitter cutting everybody — that's just, you know where it's going. Facebook cutting people for this.
Kara Swisher
Substitute "have to" with "should." Because I don't think they feel they have to. And you know what's going to be the mother of all shit shows? The six months before the election.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. Even if Twitter decided, "We would give up money for some sanctity of purity around our elections. We don't want another January 6th" — and this is getting real — they're not going to be able to keep up with these guys.
Kara Swisher
Yep, I would agree. This is... I highly recommend reading this article. There's been a number of them like this over the years. Never seems to change. It needs to now be legislated. Everyone should back this bill. I don't know a whole lot about it, but a bill like this where they must do it or else they suffer consequences — significant consequences. Maybe that protection should be taken out of Section 230. It just seems like everybody certainly can agree. I understand the panic around it, that people try to get too panicky about generalized pornography on the Internet. Look, I'm sorry, there's going to be pornography in any medium. But this — you're right — they shouldn't be on the platform. I mean, I've seen some of the stuff. Even the light stuff of what you're talking about, young girls posing, it's so... and I sound censorious. I sound like a...
Scott Galloway
No, no, no, no, no.
Kara Swisher
I have good friends whose daughters at the age of 15 are putting images of themselves on Instagram that are horrifying for their parents and their friends. And then horrifying for the 15-year-old when she gets to be about 17 and 18.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. And develops in her prefrontal cortex and her judgment kicks in.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it's true. But instead, Instagram's like, "No, let's let you make bad mistakes at scale."
Scott Galloway
Yes. Yep. That's exactly it — bad mistakes at scale. Because we have algorithms that like it.
Kara Swisher
And that's not even the pernicious stuff that's really absolutely child pornography. The ability for these people... These people should not be able to meet in a park. I'm sorry. This is the class of people that really... It's sickening. Read the article. Let's go on a quick break. When we come back, we'll talk about golf branding and Saudi Arabia. We'll take a listener question about the future of Reddit.
Break
Scott, we're back with our second big story. The biggest feud in professional golf ended in a merger. The fight led to a merger. That's what happened last week when the PGA Tour announced that it's joining with Saudi-backed LIV Golf to form a new venture. No name yet. The deal is expected to go through in a few weeks and will include Europe's DP World Tour. It's a combination of the American and Saudi groups. The most surprising part: you have been engaged in very vicious lawsuits, including the head of the PGA essentially saying, "Why do we want the Saudis?" — talking about 9/11, talking about the murder of Jamal Khashoggi.
Suddenly, he said, "I know I sound hypocritical now," which of course he does. In one suit, the PGA accused Saudi Arabia of using golf to, quote, "sportswash the recent history of Saudi atrocities." Now they're hanging out. Now they are hanging out. One of the things he said in an interview was, "Maybe we shouldn't have been so confidential about this and talk to more stakeholders." But boy, is this getting a lot of slapback. PGA hasn't really offered an explanation except to say, yes, they're hypocritical. Senate Democrats have called for an investigation. Saudi Arabia's Public Investment Fund will spend an untold amount — $3 billion, allegedly — on the new organization.
It'll probably anger some of the PGA's own golfers. Some turned down huge offers from LIV to stay with the PGA Tour. Tiger Woods was reportedly offered more than $700 million to join, and he declined. So what do you think?
Scott Galloway
This is the biggest business story of the week, if not the month. What has happened is there has been a creeping takeover of a U.S. sport — or an international or a Western sport — by the kingdom. It's not the kingdom buying Man City. It's not the kingdom getting Messi to come to Saudi Arabia. They own Newcastle United Football Club. But what you have is an entire sport that has acquiesced to what Logan Roy would say: money wins. Jay Monaghan should be fired. At some point, when you grab the hands of 9/11 widows and invoke 9/11 as a moral reason why we can't do this... And it's not Tiger Woods that really lost out here.
It was a tier-two golfer. In sports, in golf, you're 10 years longer. You maybe have 15 years to make enough money to maintain your family's lifestyle, which they have gotten used to — a superstar lifestyle for the next 50 years. A lot of these guys don't know what they're going to do other than maybe buy an auto dealership. They're never going to make that kind of money again. One of the worst things that can happen to you is when you make millions of dollars in your 20s and 30s and then tens of thousands in your 40s and 50s. Unlike most careers where you get better as you get older, in sports you get worse.
Imagine you're a tier-two golfer. These guys came at you and said, "Join LIV, will give you $30 to $50 million over the next five years. You're financially secure." And you bought into this xenophobic nationalism, moral righteousness rap, and you turned it down. Now you're finding out that Jay Monahan, as he was holding the hands of 9/11 widows, was negotiating with them. Now they don't get that money. They're now working for a monopoly and all of their pricing power has gone away. They've got to sign up for the same deals they've always had.
Kara Swisher
Do you think it'll get pushed back?
Scott Galloway
I don't know. I agree. He should be fired. They had high dudgeon about the Saudis. And now they're like, "Oh, well, we don't want to compete. We want to maintain our monopoly status. They're hurting us because they're spending money." Of course that's what the Saudis do. This is sportswashing. No question.
Kara Swisher
From a Twitter user, James Heskey, I thought was one of the best tweets: "As part of the merger, the PGA will control holes one through eight and 12, 16, and the Saudis will do 9-11." I want to be clear. I actually believe we need to engage with the kingdom. I think it's hard to find moral clarity in geopolitics. The kingdom is becoming a swing vote on the global stage, fourth largest military. I actually think that MBS doesn't get enough credit for pivoting to capitalism. I am less hateful of the kingdom than a lot of people. And I've been to Riyadh. This is gross. Specifically, Jay Monaghan — it reminds me a little bit, but on steroids, of these tech people that pretend to be all woke. Then their employees actually say, "We would really like... we need daycare." And they're like, "Well, no." He brings his moral superiority to work every day to try and convince young men who have a limited tenure in terms of their ability to make money to not take the quote-unquote "dirty oil money." And then he takes it. He's negotiating as he's preaching.
Scott Galloway
Yep. "Here's a check. Go the fuck home and be a raging hypocrite somewhere else." But the sad part is it won't matter.
Kara Swisher
Do you think it goes through? Maybe it doesn't go through. If this gets politically hot enough, could there be a CFIUS review or something?
Scott Galloway
Let's make it politically hot. Before he was... It reminds you of Donald Trump who accused the Saudis of having links to 9/11, which they did. And of course he changed his tune when he got billions of dollars. These people are bought and paid for. It's sickening. I hope the 9/11 victims' families go after this. I hope our elected officials do. Not just Democrats — the Republicans should do it too. This is astonishing. If Jay Monaghan had said, "I'm a capitalist, we're going to do what's best for shareholder value," I respect that. The kingdom has more money. The kingdom basically did to the PGA what Amazon did to almost every retailer and Netflix did to all cable companies. They just came in with an army of capital that no one could compete with.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. But there is an antitrust question. Last year, the PGA announced it would ban players who left to join LIV. LIV sued, saying the PGA has a monopoly on professional golf. It does. That suit is going away. But if LIV thought that was a monopoly, then what is this?
Scott Galloway
A bigger monopoly.
Kara Swisher
A bigger monopoly. A monopoly that's better funded now. This brings up a host of issues. But what really... when you think about this, the kingdom has done a creeping takeover of an entire sport. This isn't buying the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. Can you imagine the Chinese doing this, trying this number?
Scott Galloway
No, that's... I agree. I know we have to deal with the Saudis, obviously. But honestly, as soon as we don't have to, I'll be thrilled. As soon as we get to nuclear and other energies, renewables, I'm thrilled to leave them behind. But of course we have to deal with them. But imagine the Chinese doing this.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, but I don't... I want to be clear. They wouldn't let it happen. I think the deal should go through. I wouldn't try and block the deal.
Scott Galloway
Oh, I wouldn't. Because I do think it's going to be good for golf. I think capitalism is important. I think the players are going to make more money. I think the different affiliates — I think it's going to be good for the U.S. economy and U.S. golfers and European golfers. I think money wins in this case. I really do. If you're going to start pretending to give a flying fuck about LGBTQ rights in the Gulf and use that as a means to influence impressionable young people who look up to you as the head of that organization, and they turn down capital and economic security, and you invoke all of these very emotionally manipulative call signs as you are negotiating with these folks — get out of town. Jay, get the fuck out of town.
Kara Swisher
It really is. What do they say to themselves as they're doing it? It sends all these signals to young men and women, male and female CEOs, that it's okay to lie. Have no shame. PGA, have no shame. You're shameful. There is no decorum anymore.
Scott Galloway
Well, it's all the Silicon Valley people rushing to Saudi Arabia and kissing their ass to get money. I don't think there's anything wrong with that. It's fine. I've kissed a lot of ass for money. I don't want to hear a word from them about anything else. That's all. They've got bought and paid for, which is fine. Okay, if that's how you want to... I just can't imagine how he could have said these things publicly and then been in meetings. The guy who did it, Yasser — I'm going to mispronounce his last name — is the head of PIF. He was on the board of Uber. Everybody likes Yasser. He's very friendly. Although at the time when the Saudis were investing in Uber, a lot of people on the board were like... it was right around the Khashoggi stuff, trying to get him off because of the implications of that. Anyway, well done, Yasser. But you're sportswashing and it doesn't matter what you do, you're still sportswashing. And Jay, go fuck yourself. Correct? Is that the correct answer?
Kara Swisher
I agree with the latter part of that. I think American companies and organizations should engage commercially and financially with the kingdom. They're still sportswashing. No doubt. A lot of men spend a lot of money on sports teams to impress their fourth wife and pretend they're never going to die. I get it. They also didn't kill a journalist and dismember him. Okay. But at some point, does that... So do we no longer engage with the kingdom forever?
Scott Galloway
No, not at all. But this is a win for them. 100%. And guess what? The deepest pocket wins a lot. The Chinese have the deepest pockets. We wouldn't let them do it ever, ever.
Kara Swisher
I think that's an interesting point. Would we let the Chinese take over the PGA? Or the tennis tour? Never.
Scott Galloway
Well, they've taken over media, Kara. They're trying.
Kara Swisher
No, they have. They have. What else do they own? Under the age of 25, they have taken over media.
Scott Galloway
Yes. That is correct.
Kara Swisher
But people are all up in arms about it. Some of us.
Scott Galloway
Well, you are.
Kara Swisher
Many of us are. Anyway, in any case, Jay, go fuck yourself. Scott and I agree, you should go fuck yourself. You know what's shocking that surprises me? Golf is on a tear.
Scott Galloway
Is it?
Kara Swisher
Golf is doing really well. I just met with this guy, Angus, from a Scottish private equity firm — just because I'm Scottish and trying to figure out a way to work more with Scotsmen. They're investing in this fantastic concept called Putt Shack. I love anything that gets families out of the house and together. Do you golf?
Scott Galloway
I used to golf. Then I decided once I got out of the service industry and no longer felt the need to have father-son relationships with clients, I gave it up forever. I can't. If I never play golf again, I'm fine.
Kara Swisher
The Swisher boys play golf. It's a wonderful sport and it's addictive. But these things are amazing. You go and it's kind of technology-driven golf and they do all these fun holes and you can drink and then it tells you what your score is and it gamifies it. Anyways, I'm thinking about investing in Putt Shack.
Scott Galloway
Okay. Putt Shack.
Kara Swisher
But golf is on fire. Rounds played in 2021 increased 19%. About 20% of American sports fans follow golf compared to American football. I thought 10 years ago, I would have guessed that golf was in structural decline. And it's not. It's doing really well.
Scott Galloway
All right. Well, pickleball, everybody.
Kara Swisher
Okay, Scott, let's get... if the Saudis come for pickleball, I'm getting in their way. Okay, Scott, let's pivot to a listener question. You've got mail.
Listener question plays
That's a great question. We were going to talk about Reddit because they had layoffs this week — about 90 people, 5% of the workforce. They definitely are mad about these API changes. A lot of people are doing this. Twitter's doing it. Many people are charging for API. They say third-party apps help with issues like accessibility for visually impaired people. Many of Reddit's volunteer moderators use bots to help with moderation tasks. These bots cost money after the API change. Many Reddit communities plan to go dark on June 12th in protest. But most networks ban third-party apps. Twitter did it. They're all of them. You can't do it with Facebook, Instagram, TikTok. The popular third-party app for YouTube shut down after a legal threat from Google. My sons use Reddit all the time for video. At some point, they need to make money from all that usage, presumably.
Scott Galloway
Isn't that precious — there's apps and APIs that don't want to be charged money for something that was free? There's two sides of the trade. Go somewhere else that brings you the same value that's free.
Kara Swisher
This is a company that was more shaggy than others. It's a for-profit firm. It's got investors. It's got employees with stock options that want their own economic security.
Scott Galloway
I understand there's a nice vibe there and a nice culture. I think this will be almost meaningless. There'll be a loud, vocal minority that'll take to Twitter. There'll be a few high-profile... Less Birkenstock than Dude at Reddit, but go ahead. Reddit is prepping for an IPO.
Kara Swisher
Which they've had to delay. Is that right? I think Reddit is a phenomenon. I think they do a great job. But I just don't... I think this is what every other company that's serious about profitability and going public does. There's two sides of the trade. If you're unhappy, go somewhere else.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
One of the things that reminds me of many years ago, Twitter used to be super third-party app friendly. Then one day they weren't. I remember the meeting. They had that Twitter conference — I forget what it was, the bird conference or whatever. I was at it with Dick Costolo as the CEO. Everybody was up in arms that they had sidelined a lot of the third-party apps who had grown — they had encouraged them for years so people would use Twitter. Then they're like, "Guess what? The Twitter app is all that counts." I remember a lot of these third-party app people being shocked. Like, "Kara, can you believe it?" I'm like, "Yeah. You're riding off their dime." Facebook did the same thing when it cracked down for lots of reasons on third-party apps. It is about the business. Whether it's Facebook or Instagram, TikTok, or Twitter, or any of these things, charging for it seems inevitable. It's a nice thing to be able to give, but they need to make money. Correct?
Scott Galloway
100%. That's it. That's where it is. We're sisters from another mother on this. Tonight, we're agreeing on so many things.
Kara Swisher
Third-party apps — other groups do push it. Mastodon and other Fediverse services encourage developers to build their own apps. It can create a really exciting ecosystem. Often the company buys the most popular of those in the end — the one that's most creative. It definitely leads to creativity around usage of these things because you have to wait for the company's app to update or add features. So there are good parts of these third-party apps. But ultimately they always end up at the mercy of the bigger companies, and they always end up charging or limiting. They give it away to build traffic and affinity, and then they start typically charging. That's the model.
Scott Galloway
As a percentage of gross revenue, retailers on Amazon — third-party retailers — have gone from something like 24% of revenue to Amazon to 50%. This is just how the game is played. The bigger question is: is a specific industry so concentrated that they have monopoly power and need to be broken up? I think that's a fair question that should be asked.
Kara Swisher
Absolutely. But as it relates to a group of people getting upset... Well, okay.
Scott Galloway
Amazon gets the matter. It'll be a lot less expensive than a mixed reality headset.
Kara Swisher
Stop with that. I'm going to see it. I'm so excited to see it.
Scott Galloway
Oh, God.
Kara Swisher
In any case, Reddit person, sorry. So sorry. Guess what? It is capitalism after all. The CEO, Steve Huffman, probably would say the same. Anyway, if you've got a question of your own that you'd like answered, send it our way. Go to nymag.com/pivot to submit a question for the show or call 855-51-PIVOT. All right, Scott, one more quick break. We'll be back for predictions.
Break
Okay. Give it a try at mintmobile.com slash switch. Upfront payment of $45 for three-month plan, $15 per month equivalent required. New customer offer first three months only. Then full price plan options available. Taxes and fees extra. See mintmobile.com.
Okay, Scott, let's hear a prediction. I've been — this is the third prediction I got right. I'm just saying, I'm getting good at it. I'm learning at your feet, so to speak.
Scott Galloway
So mine are — I have two that are really boring. The first is Jay Monahan. I love the term that someone used for Chris Licht — that he'd lost the room. Jay Monahan has lost the locker room. I can't imagine how many golfers who stood to make $10 to $100 million over the next few years have now been totally, totally fucked. Because now they work for the same monopoly they used to. And Liv's going to say, "Oh, okay, great. You're now in a worse negotiating position than you were." And they're like, "Jay, we fucked up. We believed you." I think that he's gone.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, all the agents must be calling him.
Scott Galloway
And I think that in order, they'll try and put a good face on it and say, and Jay will declare victory and say, "This is a good moment for me to move on." He's out. And then I think the next big issue we're going to hear about in the present. Maybe he could work at CNN.
Kara Swisher
But go ahead. There you go. There you go.
Scott Galloway
Just, yeah.
Kara Swisher
Did I tell you Chris Licht offered me a show? And then he was fired 11 days later.
Scott Galloway
You did. We talked about it earlier. You're a type of Mary, as you said.
Kara Swisher
But go ahead.
Scott Galloway
Oh, my God.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, that's not happening, Scott. Just FYI.
Scott Galloway
No, I've gotten used to that. I've gotten used to my face for podcasting. Stay away from very nice Amy and tell us.
Kara Swisher
You stay away from her.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, yeah. Trust me. No one's going to call me. Anyways, and then I think the political hot potato that's about to emerge in the presidential race, especially on the Republican side as they go after Biden, is the listening station and facility that the Chinese are building in Cuba.
Kara Swisher
Oh.
Scott Galloway
That's going to be a big deal.
Kara Swisher
I agree. I agree. For people who don't know, there's this report in several news organizations that China is paying Cuba to create a listening station 100 miles from the U.S., which, of course, they would do. It's sort of the Cuban Missile Crisis 2.0 cyber version. I think it's a big deal. Do you have any predictions?
I do. I do think the entry of Chris Christie into this. I didn't see that. How was it? Oh, he's so funny. He's really good. I really — you know, a friend of mine worked for him when he was a prosecutor in New Jersey, a federal prosecutor, and said he's the most talented speaker, argument maker. And not a fan of his politics in any way, but was like, had to give it to him kind of thing. And I got to agree, he's already on the move, doing really good explanations of why Trump sucks. He's being the flak jacket. And I don't know if it's effective, but I have to tell you, again, my mom was like, "Well, did Trump cause all that deficit? I didn't know." And it was interesting. I was like, "Oh, yeah." And she goes, "Well, that's terrible." And I'm like, "Huh, interesting." Right? Like, it works. I think he's going to be really interesting. I think people think he's not going to be effective. I think he's going to be very effective at calling out a lot of the Trump stuff that's ridiculous.
Scott Galloway
Chris Christie comes across as authentic. He does.
Kara Swisher
He's really — I mean, he was way too close with Trump, obviously. But that's where he'll get dinged — like you liked him until you hated him. But you know what? So what? So what? I don't care about that. He also did a really good thing. I guess Trump calls him fat, which is sort of pot kettle kind of situation. He had a great comeback for that too. It's just, he's really good. It's really a mistake to argue with him. I think he's going to be effective. That's my prediction.
Scott Galloway
I like it.
Kara Swisher
Mike Pence, less so. Although he was pretty firm against Trump. What he did, interestingly — I'll finish on this — he was on CNN with Dana Bash, a very good interview, Dana did a good job. He said, "Anyone who violates the Constitution should never be president. Anyone who tries to make someone violate the Constitution shouldn't be president." He's referring to Trump. And then she asks, "Will you support the Republican nominee?" And he goes, "Yes, no matter who." Okay, that makes sense. Like you're like, "Oh, God, Mike Pence. Consult the Bible immediately." This is really crazy.
All right, Scott, that's the show. We'll be back on Tuesday with more Pivot and lots of news, I think. The indictment for Trump is coming down. There's all kinds of stuff. Hopefully the haze will be gone. Please read us out.
Scott Galloway
Today's show was produced by Lara Neiman, Evan Engel, and Taylor Griffin. Ernie Andertot engineered this episode. Thanks also to Drew Burrows and Emil Saverio. Make sure you subscribe to the show wherever you listen to podcasts.
Kara Swisher
Thank you for listening to Pivot from New York Magazine and Vox Media. We'll be back next week for another breakdown of all things tech and business.
Scott Galloway
Two things. The first is lucky. The second is jello shots. They had jello shots at the event, by the way. They were good.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. I see those in college.