Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses various topics related to technology, business, and social media, including the Supreme Court cases on social media regulation, Reddit's IPO, and disinformation.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Additional Insights:
Kara Swisher
Not all journalism is the same. Take The Guardian. Our coverage has something unique. Fierce independence. Nobody owns us or tells us what we can and can't say. So we're free to report the whole picture. We connect what's happening in Washington to the rest of the globe. Expose corruption wherever we find it. And give fresh perspective on everything. From wellness and soccer to culture, the climate and more. Read, watch and listen to The Guardian for free at theguardian.com.
Scott Galloway
AI agents are getting pretty impressive. You might not even realize you're listening to one right now. We work 24-7 to resolve customer inquiries. No hold music, no canned answers, no frustration. Visit sierra.ai to learn more.
Kara Swisher
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher, and it's Kara Swisher Day here in the United States of America. Hi, Scott. Isn't it Kara Swisher day every day?
Scott Galloway
Why is it your day? You seem happy.
Kara Swisher
I like that. My book comes out today, and I'm excited. I started my book tour, and it's really fun already. I already hugged Kate Winslet, and hung out with Chance the Rapper, so now I'm very happy.
Scott Galloway
All right. So you're on your book tour. You still do those?
Kara Swisher
I don't do book tours. Yes, I do. I have a huge book tour. I'm going to like 27 cities, and in each city I'm being interviewed.
Scott Galloway
You're going to 27 cities?
Kara Swisher
Something like that, yes. But in each city, I'm being interviewed by – I made it into an event. They're all sold out. In Austin, it's Mark Cuban. In L.A., it's Bob Iger. Here in New York tonight, it's Don Lemon at the 92nd Street Y. So I tried to make it interesting. In Boston, it's Maura Healy. I made it into an event. I'm good at events. So I made it into something else. I can help you with yours.
Scott Galloway
For sure.
Kara Swisher
So, yes. I appreciate that. And I'm mixing up the charts at Amazon, which is great, which is good.
Scott Galloway
That's great.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. So I'm very excited. And thank you for defending me from people who say I got all my scoops yesterday on the social media. I appreciate it. I got one of the reviews was like, it shouldn't be a memoir. And it is a memoir. So the criticism here is a memoir, and it shouldn't be a memoir, but it is a memoir. Thank you for saying that. And then another one said I got all my scoops from my ex-wife. That's essentially insinuated that. And I was 10 years into my career before I met my ex-wife. So that's kind of confusing to me. But it was very sexist. But you defended me and so did Walt Mossberg and others. And I really appreciated that, on that issue at least.
Scott Galloway
Well, good.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, we've got a lot to get to today, including the Supreme Court cases that could bring major changes to social media. It's a big case. And Reddit is officially going public. And we'll talk about whether it's going to be a successful IPO. Plus, our friend of Pivot is former U.S. attorney Barbara McQuaid, who has a new book, *Attack from Within, How Disinformation is Sabotaging America*. But first, we're going to have a little excerpt from Chapter 4 of *Burn Book*.
Excerpt plays
All right, let's listen to this excerpt.
Narrator (Audio Excerpt): I've always hated the phrase, speak truth to power, because it assumes all power is bad. It should really be speak truth to power when the power is false or damaging or even just plain bizarre. In the bizarre camp was when I found myself staring at an ice sculpture of a woman whose breast was oozing white Russians, a Kahlua and Cream concoction. I was a guest at a baby shower party for Google founder Sergei Brin and his wife Ann Wojcicki, who were expecting their first child in 2008. Naturally, they decided to celebrate with a huge party in the factory district of San Francisco. Before you could lift a glass to the icy nipple to get a sip, guests had to brave a jungle of dangling baby photos of Sergei and Anne at the door. The club's entrance was manned by the kind of preternaturally ebullient and hyper-organized women that always seemed to surround the rich of Silicon Valley. "Would you like a diaper or a onesie?" asked a young woman with amazingly swingy blonde hair and a very sincere smile, as if the question were not even slightly fucked up.
Excerpt ends
There you go. What do you think?
Scott Galloway
I don't understand. You say that like it's a bad thing. I want to be invited to those parties.
Kara Swisher
I did. It was so weird. Everybody was dressed up as babies, and it had a weird sexual implication, and yet they were just juvenile. So it was a very strange party. And it starts to talk about how Google was aggressively quirky, you recall, right, in the early days. I was talking about the need for juvenileization that these people had in extremis and how everything had to be forced fun. So that was sort of talking about that. I don't know how many of those parties you went to, but I had to go to an indescribable amount of them. And they were always as if we were 12 again, slip and slides or pogo sticks or bouncy houses and things like that. So I was trying to make a point on that issue.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I was never part of that community or invited to it.
Kara Swisher
What were you doing? You had red envelope.
Scott Galloway
I was working around the clock.
Kara Swisher
Well, New York wasn't like that. New York didn't have that same kind of crazy aspect.
Scott Galloway
Well, I was in San Francisco from '92 to 2000, but I just wasn't that dialed in. I was living in San Francisco. I was married, working all the time, had a dog to walk. But I didn't go to that stuff. I wasn't part of the – I wasn't on the A-list. I was sort of B minus list. I just wasn't privy to that stuff.
Kara Swisher
Well, it was crazy. As they got money, they started to hire really, like Elton John. I went to a – I was invited to a party and I didn't want to go. And they said, "Oh, you have to come. It's my kid's 16th birthday party." And I said, "I really don't want to come now." And they finally convinced me and I walked in and it was Maroon 5. They had hired Maroon 5. It was crazy. And I was like, they said, "What do you think?" I said, "I think your kid's going to need therapy later."
Scott Galloway
That's for sure. Your kid's going to be fucked up and a little bit entitled.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. It started very adorable and then it got kind of weird and rich people's. It was a weird time. And so I wanted to sort of depict that in the book. And there's lots of stuff like that. But for me, I don't know how much of it is the industry because I'm curious what you think. I have access to what you would call the tech elite.
Scott Galloway
I mean, the difference or one of the big differences is I purposely won't meet with any of these people. I'm not a journalist and I don't especially enjoy them. And there's just other people I'd rather hang out with. And it's sort of your job to meet and listen to them and establish relationships so that you can get good news or good scoops, or just be on the right side of people.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. That they feel comfortable with you.
Scott Galloway
Yes. There's a seduction element.
Kara Swisher
You have a dialogue. Well, there's a seduction element to journalism. You want to be charming, but also a little scary, or you want to get them to talk.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, for sure. But I've always, on the tech side, I really think San Francisco – and I never knew if it was regional or industry, and I think you would argue it's industry. I've lived in LA, San Francisco, Miami, New York, and London. And the only place I wouldn't live again is San Francisco. I think San Francisco is beautiful. I think it's the most beautiful city in the union. It doesn't fit me personally, because it's all about the day and the outdoors, and I'm all about the night and the indoors. It's very hard to get a good drink or find a good bar after 10 p.m. It just never really fit me.
But the thing that turned me off the most was the whole tech culture and the tech bro and the VCs. I thought during the day, these were some of the most rapacious, aggressive, I don't want to say unethical, but I just had so much full body contact. Watch your back. Don't trust anybody experiences, mostly with the venture capital community. Whereas in New York, they kind of stabbed you in the front. And what I found so duplicitous about this was, during the day, let's wash out founders and do rights offerings. And at night, we're going to throw a party to save the whales. It just seems so disingenuous.
Whereas New York is like, "We're here to make a shit ton of money. We'll give you a straight answer. And now let's go drink a lot." I just thought these are my people.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Well, they're more adult. They just love to live in childhood and they have money. And that was, you saw that everywhere you went, there were toys. I talk about a scene at Excite. Remember Excite? And they had a fake garage door as their door. And I was like, "Well, okay, you started in a garage, I think. Probably you didn't." I mean, Google definitely did because I was at that garage. But they had a fake garage at their headquarters. They built it because it was so quaint, which really, for some reason, irked me terribly. And then they had this slide between the floors, and they were always like, "Get on the slide, Kara."
And I'm like, "I'm not getting on your fucking slide." I was such a bummer to them. But I was always struck by not just the juvenileness of the toys in the place, the colors, the primary colors everywhere. The clothing was always really, it felt like everybody was dressed in Gap for kids, right? That kind of thing. And then what was really, and the food was soft. And one thing I found in an old story that I wrote right at the beginning, two things. One is about their titles. Their titles were always silly, like Chief Yahoo or Chief Experience Officer. And they were always the CEO. Like the only person who had an honest card, which I found the other day, was Mark Zuckerberg's, which was "I'm the CEO, bitch," which is also juvenile to do that.
But at least he was like, you got what he was doing. And then they wrote a whole story about their food choices because they always like to pretend they were regular people, even though they were starting to become very wealthy. And so they're like, "We only like burritos. We don't go to fancy restaurants." And you'd be like, "Why do you need to prove to me that Internet moguls are just like us?" It was a really interesting – and except the Apple people never did this. There were certain companies where this did not happen. Microsoft was one of them. Apple, they were older. So anyway, it was an interesting time.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. And I found, and again, I went to Berkeley and I absolutely loved it. And some of it was a life thing. I just wanted to change my life.
Kara Swisher
You're a New Yorker.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but also this notion of changing the world. I've never met a group of people more obsessed with money who evaluate other people based strictly on their estimate of how far in the money their options are and what employee they are and what's their AUM at their VC fund. In New York, you have to be something. You have to be super intelligent, rich, or hot. In the Valley, what I found, it's just all about how much money you have from tech. Full stop.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, you're right. Well, that's why the first line of the book is, I think, if you don't have to read any more than the first line, which is, "So it was capitalism after all." It was so irritating to be told they were changing the world and then they had cashmere hoodies in full control of their companies, right? That nobody could have a choice. Anyway, it's interesting. I hope you like it. I hope you will like it. I hope you'll read it.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I'm going to read it. I'm excited. I am actually excited to read it.
Kara Swisher
You're actually in the book. So maybe you can – there's no index. You can't find you.
Scott Galloway
As I should be.
Kara Swisher
It's called The Great Reprisal Rejuvenation. No, it's about our meeting. There's a lot about you. You have more words than most people. The man who saved my career. Yes, that's what it is. No, it's a very funny section about how we met. And then I put you in acknowledgments. So you're just going to have to read. That's the way it is. You're in there. Thanks for doing that. I'm excited.
Scott Galloway
Anyway, it's good.
Kara Swisher
So let's get to our first big story because the beat goes on. The beat goes on and on. And this case has early beginnings for the Internet. So our first big story. The Supreme Court is hearing two First Amendment cases this week, important ones that could have major ramifications for the future of social media and what rights platforms have to moderate content, the continuing saga of content moderation. The cases deal with Florida and Texas laws from 2021 that were passed to combat what supporters considered censorship of conservative viewpoints on social media platforms. Texas and Florida officials argue that laws regulate business behavior, not speech, which is a very fine line.
But the lobbying groups representing tech companies say the laws infringe on First Amendment rights. Let's talk about these cases. In specific, let me explain to people. Florida law prohibits social media sites from willfully deplatforming a candidate. The Texas law prohibits censorship based on a user's viewpoint. Supreme Court is taking the cases on after federal circuit judges came to the opposite conclusions on the constitutionality of the laws. A decision by the court is expected by late June, just months before the presidential election. I can't believe this, but I'm on the – although I'm not on anybody's side, but I have to say, I think I'm on the tech company's side.
This is an infringement of the First Amendment by states deciding content moderation issues. It's a real problem. People can censor you if you're a private company. I'm sorry. Stop with this public square crap. It's not a public square. What do you think?
Scott Galloway
This makes no sense. So CNBC, I hauled my ass down to the New York Stock Exchange to talk about big tech over and over and over every Wednesday morning for like two years on CNBC. And one day they decided not to have me back. So am I being censored?
Kara Swisher
Yes, Scott, you're being censored.
Scott Galloway
I talk about politics.
Kara Swisher
Yep.
Scott Galloway
This makes no sense. They're allowed to do this.
Kara Swisher
Yep, I agree.
Scott Galloway
Do we have to have Ted Cruz and AOC on our show every episode? I mean, this just makes no fucking sense. They're private companies.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I just – they're trying to do that as a business thing. It's just, they're hurt that they get thrown off because they act badly. And by the way, Elon Musk runs one of the bigger ones. So you've got your man. So everybody gets their man, essentially. This was interesting because drilling in on whether judgments – it's going on right now, these arguments – drilling in on whether judgments about what content to host are expressive and thus potentially eligible for First Amendment protection. Justice Elena Kagan raised the example of X, formerly Twitter, and how its rules changed after Elon Musk bought it in 2022.
Twitter users one day woke up and found themselves to be X users. The rules had changed and their feeds changed, and all of a sudden they were getting a different online newspaper, so to speak, every morning. And the NetChoice attorney who's representing the tech company says it discriminates on the basis of content, speaker and viewpoint. It does all of this in the name of promoting free speech, but loses sight of the principle of the First Amendment. Again, the only thing is then you leave it to these companies who are not regulated to do anything. So what are the regulations we can put on these companies so they behave properly?
I think you can sue them. That would be the best thing – to be able to sue them if they cause damage and not through this nonsense of these conservative states that are trying to – if this passes, it is really bad. I just can't even.
Scott Galloway
So when is someone a political figure? I understand when there's – sometimes they have government-funded campaigns in certain countries and they have to give them a certain amount of time, each of them a certain amount of – because they're worried about political candidates being squashed or censored. I get that. But you're going to tell these – there's a lot of different platforms. I mean, granted, if you made the argument at some point that Meta is a utility, I could see then maybe passing some laws that during elections people have a certain amount of fair use or whatever it is. But how does this not get challenged? Does this mean that we talk about politics all the time? Do we – can we demand that we get a certain amount of air time on Truth Social? I don't see how this is enforceable. I don't think it makes any sense. It's so dangerous. It's a violation. The law they're holding up – this is a direct violation of – I don't get it.
Kara Swisher
They just – you know, this is – let me read this from the Washington Post. This is one of the several high profile tech cases on the Supreme Court docket as the court increasingly weighs how centuries of free speech precedent apply to the digital sphere. Next month the high court will hear arguments in the case that weighs whether the First Amendment precludes, which is the opposite, government officials from pressuring tech companies to remove content. So these guys are on the other side of that because they were talking about the Biden administration. Those are the same people. These people are so hypocritical. I just want to scream. But they were the idea that you could warn, flag these companies for dangerous content. I think they can flag it. I don't find that to be a problem at all. I think it's the ability to take it down. And websites have a viewpoint depending on who owns them. They're media companies.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, they're media companies.
Kara Swisher
And then just as Amy Coney Barrett questions whether tech companies' content moderation practices are similar to editorial discretion of newspapers, citing hypothetical example of TikTok's algorithm boosting pro-Palestinian posts over pro-Israeli posts. If you have an algorithm, do it. Is that not speech? So it'll be interesting. It's such a partisan issue. And whatever side you're on depends on what side you're on. And you can shift your allegiances. But there's a lot going to happen here.
Scott Galloway
The only veracity to their argument is that if they are exonerated from the legal scrutiny that traditional media companies are subject to – if we started sexualizing images of children on this show, then I think a lot of organizations would have a rightful, credible legal case against us. But that's not true on big tech platforms because of Section 230. So I can see how they would say, well, if they're not going to be subject, if they have more free reign, then they have to fall under additional scrutiny or mandates. But this one doesn't make any sense. And we have a model here. Treat them like media companies. Fox is not obligated to bring on Bernie Sanders every day. When it ends up that the "credible witness" providing information on the Biden crime family is actually a Russian spy, Fox – it's reprehensible. They don't report on it. They're allowed to do that. They don't have to.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, exactly. And then you can decide whether or not you want to watch it.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, exactly. At the same time, when they spread lies about voting machines, they are liable. We have a model for this. It's called a media company.
Kara Swisher
We do, but they don't want – they run from being media companies. They're going to have to embrace being a media company. But also, let's talk about sexualization. Let's discuss two disturbing investigative stories published in the last few days concerning a number of parent-run accounts on social media. The New York Times has a story on mothers who run social accounts for their underage influencer daughters. These accounts open the door to financial benefits, but also to online abuse from men, older men. What a creepy story that was. And the Wall Street Journal followed it with a report that Meta's safety team warned internally last year, as they have before, that new paid subscription tools on Facebook and Instagram were being misused by parents trying to profit from exploiting their kids.
I mean, any of these tools will be abused and they cannot abrogate their responsibility as they make them. I don't know if they'll do anything. Meta took down some accounts and acknowledged enforcement errors after the Wall Street Journal flagged some of the exploitative behavior. Parents certainly have a responsibility. Meta spokesman said in a statement to the Times that parents were responsible for these accounts and their content and could delete them at any time. They're not their nannies, parents' nannies. But boy, if kids were using – I'm trying to think something else in such an – if parents were using it in such an irresponsible way, the government would come down hard on all sides, including the parents.
And so these stories were deeply disturbing to me. I don't know about you, if you read them.
Scott Galloway
Well, first off, we're critical of them, but a shout out to the New York Times. I thought the article was really powerful.
Kara Swisher
It was.
Scott Galloway
And the Journal's was, too. They both were great. And it shows the power of long-form investigative journalism and why it's important that it continue to be economically viable. I've said this. You've heard me say this. Instagram begins from a place of perversion. The algorithms encourage young women, preteen girls, to sexualize themselves. The algorithms love it. They'll elevate the content. The strangers out there will love it and encourage you at your most vulnerable time in terms of your own self-image, coming into your own sexuality, hormones taking over. You get this weird – it is so insane that one of the most valuable companies in the world, the epicenter of its growth property, Instagram, is the following: find minors, encourage them to sexualize themselves such that their peers and strange men around the world can evaluate them and comment on them.
And then the knee-jerk reaction is, "Well, it's up to the parents." Well, I'm sure there are parents that for money will have their 12-year-old kids engage in a pornographic film. But that doesn't mean the theater running it shouldn't be hammered or taken to court. So yeah, the parents here are strange, desperate, whatever it might be. We know how to age gate.
Kara Swisher
Well, now here's the thing. It's parents' accounts. It's not the kids' accounts. Parents just put that content on there. That's one of the problems. And these are adults who run these sites. But the platform knows what's going on. The parents know that their kids are engaged in child labor. You and I approving our sons to go to work at the age of 13 doesn't make the employer void of violating a crime. It all comes down to the same thing. There's no reason anyone under the age of 16 should be on Instagram. And they could figure it out in 48 hours. Or their images. If it's family photos, fine. But anything like this, commercialization – people say, "Well, there's a healthy industry for modeling for kids. We need them." Fine. The traditional industry has put in place safeguards. Meta has not.
Scott Galloway
And let me just go. I've said for a long time, I thought Sheryl Sandberg was just terrible for women. And I thought that it was a total globalist tactic: accuse the other side of what you are guilty of. I felt for her to be marching around the world talking about "Lean In," which as far as I could tell – let me summarize the book for women out there: "Act more like a man." That's how I read it. And two, to have figured out a business model that results in algorithms and incentives to sexualize young girls – this company begins from a place of perversion.
Kara Swisher
All right. But let's put the onus on the CEO. Again, I know you like to focus on Sheryl. I get it. But this is Mark.
Scott Galloway
I focus on Mark, too. I focus on both of them.
Kara Swisher
Okay.
Scott Galloway
Pose-eye.
Kara Swisher
Pose-eye. I find this to be so obvious in terms of how to deal with this. Accountability matters a great deal. And again, my book's all about that. This should be so dead obvious that this should not be – and the problem is, it's expensive. Their businesses look a lot less pretty once the cost to fix this goes in because it's nearly impossible. Whatever, 300 hours every second on these sites, right? Three of video or photos or whatever. Too bad. Don't build a business like that. If you can't control it, then make it smaller. I don't know what to say. Because their whole thing is "We can't. There's too much of it to monitor."
Why did you build a business where there's too much of it? Again, they have an answer for everything. And in this case, it should be dead. This iterates. This isn't just child porn. This is misinformation, anti-Semitism. Just put any word in here for this stuff. But if we can't do it with this stuff, you're kidding me. If we can't – you cannot make your tools. Look, one of the people arguing about storage, like that Apple is exploitative too because they allow storage, right, on these sites. I think we talked about that. Anything in the world, a cardboard box full of child pornography is a problem, but it's not the box's problem necessarily.
These are not boxes. They like to think that they're like cardboard boxes where people keep pornography or a safe that people keep it in. And it's not a safe. That was never intended for this. These people have tools to stop it. It's very different. And they have to stop acting like they're a cardboard box. Like they have no culpability. And that drives me crazy.
Scott Galloway
They make an active decision to program algorithms. Then when it finds content with a 16-year-old girl in a bathing suit, it's very provocative. They make an editorial decision. This isn't much different than a producer at MSNBC or CNN or Fox going, "You know what? There's a lot of desperate men out there who like looking at 16-year-old girls who are fucked up in the head and don't realize how wrong it is. And in the anonymity of their home, we'll like it. And the algorithm will sense that. And we as humans have decided to elevate that content." We have decided. We have made an editorial human decision to program the algorithms this way. And the moment content is elevated algorithmically, you're an editor and you should have the same responsibilities and the same accountability as any other media company. And when we're talking about they always throw up their arms and they plead complexity, we're not talking about the realm of the possible. We're talking about the realm of the profitable. Because here's the bottom line. It's expensive to moderate.
Kara Swisher
It is expensive. That's what I said.
Scott Galloway
It is hard. It's not such a good business.
Kara Swisher
It's not such a good business.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. To have a total free-for-all where you just claim complexity and First Amendment and deploy your hundreds of lobbyists. And, oh, okay, if images of nooses and pills get sent to girls who are in the midst of suicidal ideation, if we have a ton of content that we run ads against that sexualize young girls, if we have 54 to 1 pro-Hamas videos for every pro-Israel, and we radicalize young men – okay, not our fault. But boy, it is an unbelievable business model.
Kara Swisher
It is. It is. It is.
Scott Galloway
We have a decision to make. Economic value and shareholder value is an incredible thing. It's important. They pay taxes. They give a lot of people opportunity. They create ecosystems. They create economic growth. That counts for a lot. The question we have to wrestle with and come to some sort of decision around is, has it become too costly? Is it no longer worth it?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it has been. It 100% has been. So just to be clear, parents are very responsible in these situations. Let's not let them off the hook, and I won't. I could not believe parents would do this to kids, but of course, I'm always surprised by that kind of thing every day of the week. So anyway, we do understand parents have a role in here. Then they need to be prosecuted also if they're exploiting their children sexually in imagery. Now, what's interesting here is there was also a story, just to finish up, that AI will take the place of these AI videos or pictures. There won't be any people involved. They'll just imagine it. And then I don't know if that's worse because then people will get addicted to this kind of content. But nobody will be in harm's way, but all of us will be in harm's way. So that's an interesting debate. What if it's AI and not people anymore? That's – I don't want to go down that. Again, they have the ability to tag stuff that's AI generated, and then they have a responsibility. It's just, I don't – the easiest thing here, and they know how to do it, but they don't want to do it: age gate. People under the age of 16.
Scott Galloway
What if there's no age to the AI image?
Like, it just looks like a kid. There's so many things coming down the pike. We'll get to that another day, but there's so much stuff because AI doesn't have an age. So anyway, we'll see. Big topic, very important to Scott and I, obviously. We care a great deal, but you should read these stories.
Kara Swisher
All right, Scott, let's go on a quick break. We come back. Reddit's IPO is finally happening, and we'll speak with a friend of Pivot, Barbara McQuaid, about how to defeat disinformation.
Ad Break
Scott, we're back. Reddit has filed to go public finally. This will be the first major tech IPO of the year and the first social media IPO since Pinterest in 2019, if you can believe it. The platform's bankers are looking for a valuation of at least $5 billion, not too big. It has 73 million daily active users and is one of the most visited websites in the US. In an unusual move, Reddit will reportedly offer 75,000 power users the chance to buy shares at the IPO price. I think other companies have done similar things. First off, Reddit has been around since 2005. This will be a test for IPOs in general. Their business is largely advertising. The most controversial thing is this licensing, data licensing agreement. They just announced a $60 million deal with Google last week, which I think people inside who use the company are not happy about. So any thoughts? Talk to me about this IPO.
Scott Galloway
Well, first off, everyone's sort of waiting for the market to thaw, the IPO market. And it probably is beginning, or the atmospheres are lining up just because of the acceleration in the markets. The markets are reaching new highs and NVIDIA has totally inspired the animal spirits. They appear to be returning. There are several IPOs lined up and everyone's waiting for one to really pop, whether it's going to be Reddit or Shein, which is kind of the biggest fast fashion company in the world now.
I like Reddit a lot. I actually think this IPO could be a real winner. The first thing I did is very basic: I typed in most traffic sites in America. Number one is Google. Number two is YouTube. Number three? Reddit.
Kara Swisher
Reddit. Yeah, my kids use it like crazy.
Scott Galloway
Number four is Facebook. Number five, Amazon. Number six, Pornhub. Number seven, Wikipedia. Number eight, Yahoo. Yahoo over Twitter. Isn't that crazy? I'm a shareholder in Yahoo. But my thesis around Yahoo is the same as my thesis around Reddit. Remember those charts I always used to put out 10, 15 years ago saying, newspapers command 7% of people's attention, but they get 18% of the advertising revenue, whereas the internet is 30% of people's attention, but only 9% of money. Over time, the two calibrate. They normalize. They come in line with each other. When you look at the most traffic sites in the world, they're usually one-plus trillion dollar companies. This company is going to go out supposedly at a valuation of five billion. And it's the third most traffic site in the United States.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it's a bargain.
Scott Galloway
It's a bargain. They should be able to figure this out.
Kara Swisher
They still rely on advertising quite a bit. If you look at the numbers, it's really heavy. So they're subject to the vicissitudes of the market. I get it. This is a much smaller company. I've interviewed its CEO, Steve Huffman, quite a bit. I like him. He was really first on figuring out content moderation. They had a terrible back around some really heinous sites there on the site. It's always been a little bit of a shaggy dog of a social media site. They did the $60 million deal. They have a little bit of that AI spice on their meal. They got $60 million. I think that's going to go up or they might take the content in-house. This is their risk. They can't be Pinterest and Snap that have kind of gone sideways and always end up being the little engines that couldn't. But if they continue to be one of the most traffic sites in the world, they can put an AI spin on this at $5 billion. I mean, let me just be transparent. I'm going to try and get stock in this thing. I think this could be either Shein or Reddit that are going to set the IPO market on fire.
Scott Galloway
Shein is a retailer, though, of course, right?
Kara Swisher
Shein, I mean, it's another one. We'll talk about this another day. But Shein is now the largest fast fashion company in the world.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, it's interesting. One or both of these is going to have a big pop because the IPO market has been so thawed that I bet these get priced fairly conservatively. Five billion is low. It's very low.
Kara Swisher
I was like, oh. That's nothing.
Scott Galloway
That's the problem. If it sticks at five billion, it's not going to get a lot of analyst coverage. No one really cares about five billion.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it doesn't make money, as I recall.
Scott Galloway
I think they're cash flow positive, I believe.
Kara Swisher
What's interesting, here's one: that 9% of the voting power at Reddit, OpenAI CEO Sam Altman, there he is, pops up. He invested, at the time when they were struggling a little bit, $60 million in shares, because they were going to go IPO, and then they weren't, and then they were sort of owned by Conde Nast, and they weren't. You know what I mean? They went through a lot, this company has gone through a lot of iterations. Maybe they should be bought. People thought about buying them. Then there was the controversy over those terrible Trump forums and everything else. I had an interview with Steve and he said, he was the first CEO to say to me about content moderation, "We were very, they were the first, they were the free speech wing of the free speech party," right, of the people I interviewed.
But he was also the first person who said to me, "Some people are just malignant actors, and we're going to throw them out." And nobody had ever said that. And they had no resources to do it. That was a big deal when he said that to me. I was sort of like, the company with the least ability to do anything about it was articulating something that just made perfect sense, right? This was a company that was so free speechy, you couldn't. And they got in trouble for it very early on. Tell me about Altman. What do you think about Altman?
Scott Galloway
His investment gets this thing at least another billion dollars in valuation because it's more of that AI sprinkling. It's more of that AI pixie dust. Everybody thinks Sam Altman, maybe with the exception of Jensen Huang, is the smartest person in the world. And he's an investor and a shareholder here. One of these companies is going to have a triple digit opening day in the IPO market. We're going to be off to the races. I think this is a great...
Kara Swisher
You like it.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I like it a lot. Reddit is a global brand. People know it. How many global brands can you pick up for $5 billion right now?
Kara Swisher
Not just that. It's a youth brand, too. My kids, I was surprised. They use two things: YouTube quite a bit, but Reddit just as much. They don't use it for chit-chatting. They use it for videos and consumption. They don't like TikTok. I know it sounds crazy, but they find it too performative. They love Reddit because it feels more real. It's an entertainment vehicle for them, which is interesting to me.
Scott Galloway
It's a really interesting hack that I didn't discover. Type in your search and then add the word "Reddit" and see what comes up.
Kara Swisher
Oh, interesting. Well, you know, there's a whole thing on why we're so annoying on Reddit. Do you know that?
Scott Galloway
Oh, really?
Kara Swisher
They vote about which one of us is more annoying.
Scott Galloway
I'm sorry. That's a tough one. I'm insufferable. That's not an easy call.
Kara Swisher
No, but really. That's a photo finish. I'm insufferable, but interesting. You are the most annoying. I'm sorry to tell you.
Scott Galloway
But some people love you.
Kara Swisher
Oh, you've already decided?
Scott Galloway
No, I looked at it. I'm looking at Reddit. There are whole sections talking about whether we're annoying or helpful.
Kara Swisher
For those of you who were wondering we could go 10 minutes without talking about us, tell me about your book, Kara.
Scott Galloway
No, no, no. But let me tell you, I went there and it popped right up. I was looking for book reviews.
Kara Swisher
Have you heard about our therapy session?
Scott Galloway
No. Jesus, this really is the Scott and Kara show.
Kara Swisher
People love this. It is the Scott and Kara show. I know. Anyways. But I'm saying it was really interesting. It's endlessly interesting information. But there's a whole section on whether we're annoying or not.
Scott Galloway
Well, the answer is yes. Yes, we are.
Kara Swisher
But as long as we're entertaining, that's fine.
Scott Galloway
That's what I said. I was like, I almost popped in and went, "Hey, girls." I'm the Ted Cruz of podcasts. You don't like me, but I keep voting for me.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, that's true. No, whatever. Anyway, you have a lot of fans, too. Anyway, let's move on. We like this Reddit. Reddit, watch out. So I'm calling it now. Reddit, first trade, way up.
Scott Galloway
Okay, we'll see.
Kara Swisher
All right, let's bring in our friend of Pivot. Barbara McQuaid is a former U.S. attorney and the author of *Attack from Within: How Disinformation is Sabotaging America*, which is one of our favorite topics here on Pivot. Barbara, thank you for coming.
Barbara McQuade
Thank you, Kara. Great to be with you and Scott.
Scott Galloway
Great.
Kara Swisher
So this book really delves into how disinformation has spread and become weaponized in recent years. You mostly talk about legal issues when you appear. Talk a little bit about it and how we got here. You write, "We are not just living in a post-truth world. We are living in a post-shame world," which of course, both at the same time. So talk to me a little about how we got here and why this part interested you.
Barbara McQuade
Yeah. So my background is as a federal prosecutor in the national security space. Before I was a U.S. attorney, I was a national security prosecutor. And now I teach national security law at the University of Michigan Law School. One of the things I have seen is the threat evolve from Al-Qaeda to ISIS to cyber intrusions and now to disinformation. At one time, this was something that was coming at us from Russia and other hostile foreign adversaries. And now it is a problem coming at us from within the United States from our own political actors. That's where the name comes from. The idea of post-truth in a post-shame world is that it is not the case that we're all a bunch of rubes falling for false claims. It is the case that people are deliberately going along with the con. That's because there are polarizing figures in politics who have convinced us that there are only two sides to any equation. There is the far right and the far left. There is good versus evil. By so demonizing the left and the woke, there are people who are willing to choose tribe over truth. That is what my book is about.
Kara Swisher
So you're saying democracy dies in the bright light of day. That's the famous watch of "democracy dies in darkness." Something I have noticed is that before, it was quite furtive, whether you're talking about national security, whether it was the Chinese or the Russians or the Iranians, all these different factors that have used digital means. Now it's explicit. It's not hidden in that regard.
Barbara McQuade
Yeah. I don't know if you saw, there's this Bret Baier interview on Fox News just the other day with Donald Trump, where he just goes on and on talking about how he won the 2020 election. Every time there's an interjection of facts, he is just relentless and won't stop. He is following the age-old adage of repetition. If you say things enough times and people hear them enough, they will believe them. But I think it's something more than that. It is that people have chosen their tribes and they don't care what the truth is. People talk about Donald Trump being indicted on 91 counts of crimes. They don't care because they have aligned their fortunes with their team. They have been convinced that there is only this or that. It's something referred to as the either-or fallacy. They don't want to be convinced otherwise. We find ourselves in this polarized world where truth doesn't matter. If we are going to be a democracy that governs ourselves, we have got to recommit ourselves to truth.
Kara Swisher
Why is America particularly vulnerable to disinformation? You say that.
Barbara McQuade
I do. I think it is because of our cherished values of free speech. Don't get me wrong, free speech is incredible and is essential to democracy. It is what protects minority voices and unpopular voices from sharing their views and criticizing those in power. But there is also this idea that any suggestion that we should restrict speech or restrict social media gets labeled censorship. When we hear censorship, our heckles go up and we say, "No, that's a bad thing." But that's what permits content moderation and prevents some of the social media platforms from becoming toxic hellscapes. I think people forget that all fundamental rights can be limited as long as there's a compelling governmental interest and the limitation is narrowly tailored to achieve those interests.
For example, we could regulate content on social media for that which is paid. If you pay on social media, then maybe the social media platforms can reject certain things that are false or lying. Or we can require at least disclosure of paid content online without worrying about violating the First Amendment. I think sometimes our devotion to the First Amendment blinds us to common sense restrictions that are time, place, or manner restrictions akin to yelling fire in a crowded theater.
Scott Galloway
Nice to meet you, Barbara. So the level or the magnitude of the problem is a given. It's obvious. It's a threat. I think people perceive it as a threat. The question I would have is what solutions do you propose? I'll put forward a thesis that there's always going to be individuals who will take advantage of these porous platforms and are willing to lie. Expecting better people to emerge... there will always be people willing to lie and repeat lies. I don't think shaming is working. We could sue the platforms or try to go after them, but they're too big. Do you think at some point we need to incorporate more into our educational institutions critical thinking and restore that truth is an actual thing? But let me finish where I started. What solutions do you propose?
Barbara McQuade
In the book, I do propose some solutions. And Kara, I'm looking forward to reading *Burn Book* about your take on social media as well. I'm sure you've got some ideas in there.
Kara Swisher
We're fucked. If you'd like the cliff notes.
Scott Galloway
Go ahead.
Kara Swisher
Kara has a book coming out? I didn't know.
You know what? I got fans, Scott. Go ahead.
Barbara McQuade
I do propose some solutions. And Scott, I think they have to come from both sides of the equation. I think our government can do some things to restrict social media. Social media is an incredible tool. Despite what Kara says, I think it connects people in wonderful ways. But I think we've been really naive in the way we've let it grow without any sort of regulation whatsoever. It's like growing a baby alligator in your bathtub. It's adorable when it starts and it's very exciting until it turns into a man-eating predator, which is where we are today. I think we could do some things. One of the things that Frances Haugen, who is the Facebook whistleblower, said during her testimony to Congress is it's not the content, it's the algorithms.
There are algorithms online that will push people to content that is most likely to generate outrage because that's what keeps eyeballs on the platform. We can regulate algorithms. That would be something we could do that would not run afoul of the First Amendment. We could either prevent algorithms that drive us to that which outrages us, or we could at least require disclosure of algorithms so people know when they are being manipulated for outrage. So that's something we can do.
I also think that we see a lot of content on social media that does not play by the same rules as advertising on television and radio. If you listen to an ad on the radio or see something on television, you'll hear, "I'm Joe Biden and I approved of this ad." That does not exist on social media. So you could have Russia or some wealthy individual posing as the Red, White, and Blue Grandmothers of America posting ad content online without disclosure. I think there are a number of things we can do with the law to change the way disinformation is allowed to percolate.
Kara Swisher
Proliferate.
Barbara McQuade
Proliferate. There's a good word.
Kara Swisher
Right now, as we're talking, the Supreme Court is arguing these two cases, and there's another one coming around the limits of the government into warning companies to take certain content down. Talk a little bit about the cases currently there and the one coming, because they're all very important. It's sort of a rethinking of what, and these are Texas and Florida laws. We just talked about them. I happen to be on the side of the tech companies here, although I think they're wildly irresponsible and under no liability or anything else. So that's the problem on that side. But I tend to be for the tech companies on this one.
Barbara McQuade
Yeah. And it's important, Kara, to differentiate. You can't be all for companies on one thing and all for states on another. You have to look elementally at these things point by point. On this one, I think the tech companies are right. The idea that states can prevent tech companies from moderating content, again, in the name of censorship, they throw out that word and it sounds so frightening. But imagine what this would look like if they could not do that, if they cannot have community standards that are enforceable by contract. These are private companies. They are not bound by the First Amendment. They have the right to say and not say anything they want.
Kara Swisher
What's going to happen here? What do you think from listening to what the justices are saying?
Barbara McQuade
It's always difficult to predict what might come out in the end. But I'd have a hard time seeing a majority of these justices ruling in favor of these states and against the tech companies and telling them what they must allow on their platforms. These are private actors. Although some of these justices are no friends of the political left or even of these big tech companies, I can't imagine that in light of their views of the First Amendment, that they would allow these states to tell them what to do. In fact, I'd like to think that the only reason they took up these cases is not because they consider them serious laws, but they want to knock them down.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, because the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld this statute in Texas. So there's a circuit split. They really do have to step in here to knock them down. What about the Biden one? What about the one coming up after that? They also took that one.
Barbara McQuade
Yeah. This is an interesting one. This is the one where the Biden administration is working with tech companies. In the light most favorable to the Biden administration, I think they would say, "We have to jawbone with tech companies to engage with them and tell them what is false and ask them to take it down. We're not ordering them. We're not demanding. We're trying to work together with them to protect public safety." If we see something that is a COVID remedy that might be dangerous to public health or something else that is...
Kara Swisher
Or Al-Qaeda up to its usual tricks or something like that.
Barbara McQuade
Yeah, there you go. A terrorist organization that is recruiting online. It is helpful to the public for that sharing of information to go on. Now, I could imagine the courts structuring something to ensure that this is an ask and not a demand. Maybe they put some roadblocks in place to make sure that there is no coercion going on when it comes to government and no repercussions coming on. But I can't imagine that we could live in a world where the government is forbidden from sharing with social media companies dangerous information, things that are harmful to public safety. I think this will come out in favor of those sorts of communications. The most restrictive thing I could imagine is some guardrails there to prevent coercive situations.
Scott Galloway
Well, you're a U.S. attorney, Barbara. My sense is the fines can't be big enough. They have an army of lawyers. It's just a cost of doing business. Does any of this really get any better until someone does a perp walk? That's Scott's favorite. He wants to see one of them in jail. The perp walk. And do you mean one of the social media companies?
Barbara McQuade
Or do you mean?
Scott Galloway
Meta was fined $5 billion. That was 11 weeks of cash flow and they keep on trucking.
Barbara McQuade
Well, I want to get back to a point that I think could help us. That is the point you mentioned earlier about responsibility of the users. I do think we, responsibility of individuals, but also as a society to educate the public about being critical consumers of social media. We have intended to believe what we read online, believe what we see online. It is a wonderful way to share information at scale. But in Finland, a place where they have suffered from disinformation from Russia for decades, schoolchildren are trained in critical reading studies to be able to identify disinformation when they see it, looking for a second source, not reading solely the headline, looking past artificial intelligence and recognizing that there is such a thing as deep fakes on audio and visual. And I think, Scott, we can't end it at just critical media studies. We also have to look at civics education. To understand how our government works, the three branches of government, checks and balances.
Scott Galloway
What about that perp walk or repealing or amending Section 230? Does a liability exist in some fashion?
Barbara McQuade
I don't know that we could completely repeal Section 230. I think if we were to repeal Section 230, we would put these social media companies out of business. There's just too much volume online for them to do it. But I do think we could have some amendments to Section 230 for things like algorithms that are manipulating people and pushing content that outrages us. I think we could have liability for false advertising where they've accepted money in exchange for the content that is online. Again, it's this all-or-nothing thinking, the dumbed down. Perhaps social media has driven us to that sort of this-or-that all-or-nothing thinking. But the nuance is in between. We need our legislators to take this seriously. A lot of times when we have those hearings and we have some of our senators and members of Congress listening to people like Mark Zuckerberg or Jack Dorsey testify, you can see them start to glaze over. They look like those people in the ads for Progressive Insurance. "You're becoming your parents. Am I hashtagging right now?"
Kara Swisher
But they can hire experts to help them work through this. They have. They're smart. They get smarter and smarter, I think.
Barbara McQuade
Sure. They've got staff members who are smart enough to sort through this. I think we need to take a responsibility that we are going to look to some of these suggestions for regulating social media. It doesn't have to be a complete elimination of Section 230, but some specific amendments to try to reduce disinformation. It's not one thing that's going to solve this problem. It's a series of solutions. One is all of us have to make a commitment to truth. We are not going to pile on. We're not going to choose our tribe over truth. We are going to demand truth from our leaders and from ourselves.
Scott Galloway
You're a former U.S. attorney. You're an academic. You're obviously very thoughtful. You have domain expertise that is really relevant to our country. Why wouldn't you run for office?
Barbara McQuade
I'm not willing to make the personal sacrifices it takes. But I appreciate the vote of confidence.
Scott Galloway
Why don't you run for office, Scott Galloway?
For the exact same reason Barbara won't.
Kara Swisher
Yes, that's right.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, that's it. And other things.
Kara Swisher
Barbara, last question. These elections are coming up. How are you looking at this disinformation? We're in a post-shame world, a post-truth world. What does disinformation play here and what, if anything, can be done about it?
Barbara McQuade
Really relevant at this time, Kara. We just saw in New Hampshire a series of robocalls using artificial intelligence to falsify Joe Biden's voice. I think we need to be on the lookout for those kinds of things and quickly debunk them. Fact-checking in real time is very important. Providing information when there are these false claims out there. We're going to see it. We're going to see text message campaigns. We're going to see AI campaigns. Alerting the public to these things is key. The other thing here that we can't lose is engagement in politics, because that is what authoritarians seek in Putin's Russia. It is to flood the zone with so much information that people don't know what to think. They become cynical and then numb, and they disengage from politics altogether. I want to encourage people that the best way to fight back is to stay engaged in politics, talk to your neighbors, work hard for credible sources like the League of Women Voters and others that provide accurate information about voting.
Kara Swisher
All right, Barbara, thank you so much. This is a terrific book, and Barbara's really sharp. She's all over the place. You're all over the place, Barbara. The book is called *Attack from Within: How Disinformation is Sabotaging America*. Thank you, Barbara.
Barbara McQuade
Thank you both for having me on. Really appreciate it.
Scott Galloway
Nice to meet you, Barbara.
Barbara McQuade
Thank you. Nice to meet you both. I enjoyed your podcast.
Kara Swisher
All right, Scott, one more quick break. We'll be back for wins and fails.
Ad Break
Okay, Scott, let's hear some wins and fails. Do you have any?
Scott Galloway
I'm all screwed up. It's like I'm bass-ackward. I thought today was predictions in this Joey Bag of Donuts production we have.
Kara Swisher
All right, make a prediction, Scott, and then I'll do a win and a fail. How about that?
Let's just – let's be bisexual about it. My mind is a blank after you said that. It was like pressing a reset button.
Scott Galloway
So I think that Alphabet is going to be the best-performing big tech stock, and I think it's going to attract an activist investor in the next 30 to 60 days. It's the only one of the magnificent seven that is trading, whose price earnings ratio is trading below the broader S&P. They've had a series of stumbles. The underlying businesses are just unbelievable. YouTube is actually bigger than Netflix. It's got, I think, the second biggest cloud business. Obviously, search is arguably the best business ever invented. And it's also where it's gotten hammered is similar to how Meta got, in my opinion, unfairly punished or overpunished because of this terrible rollout or this ridiculous consensual hallucination called Oculus and the headsets.
The market ignored that the underlying business continued to be just this cash volcano. The equivalent of the Oculus for Alphabet has been its kind of innovator's dilemma, flat-footed, sitting on their hands around AI. And even the rollout of Gemini had some real hiccups where it was a lot of people, and I think there's some truth here, it got over-programmed around sort of DEI issues. And the rollout has been, it just hasn't gone very well. And if you look at the history of AI, literally Alphabet was at the center of it in terms of people, intellectual property, discovery. And it's a classic case of the innovator's dilemma where they didn't go aggressively at it.
There's a few things that are going to happen here. One, the stock is going to outperform because it's cheap relative to the others, given the strength of its businesses. Two, an activist is going to show up in three, and I don't like to say this, they're going to have fairly significant layoffs because they have overhired and the year of efficiencies has not really hit alphabet yet. And they're going to come under pressure to show a similar type of shareholder returns as the other six, given the strength of underlying business. And the easiest way to juice their earnings will be to trim their workforce.
So anyways, I think Alphabet is about to get more attention. I think it's going to outperform layoffs, a different narrative around AI, and you're going to see an activist show up there.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it'll be interesting to see what happens to the government stuff, too. That's why they've been so quiet on that stuff. That's interesting. All right, I'm going to do a win and a fail, all right? Fail. I've got to say these comments by Donald Trump about black people and that I like them because I'm a meg shot. None of his ridiculous, crazy comments are going to get enough attention because he says one every five minutes. That's the problem with Donald Trump. But that one was just particularly heinous. But of course, then you're like, oh, that was particularly heinous. He benefits from being heinous all the time, so that it just all falls on deaf ears.
But some of the stuff he's been saying lately has been particularly nutty. And for my win, I would say, I think that I'm kind of heartened by Nikki Haley continuing. I'm like, I know, like all these men are like, get out now, quit. All these men. And they are. All these men. I'm sorry. I just, I've noticed. What if I said all these women wanted to stay in the race? Well, all these women are writing columns, stay in. I think she's really interesting. I think she has no downside to this. And like, let her stay in. She's got the money. She's got the means. Let her stay in and make a case. And she's making, I don't know, she's burnt the boats and she's staying in.
And I think it's great. I love competition. I love it.
Scott Galloway
I saw you on Chris Wallace and I thought that was an interesting discussion. I was thinking about it. And we like it because I don't see how it's good for – it's nothing but downside for Trump. And I'm all for anything that is nothing for downside. I actually think at this point it's probably bad for her to stay in. I think she's starting to alienate more and more people in the Republican Party. She's becoming a bit of a gadfly.
Kara Swisher
I don't know. All right. Okay. You like that she's in. I like that she's in. I like – let me have my win. Don't insult my win. Take down my fucking win.
Scott Galloway
The Koch brothers just withdrew their funding.
Kara Swisher
Of course they did. But they were nice about it. They were like, we think she's great. It was fine. Of course they were going to do that. They got to put their money in local races. I don't care. Let me ask you, who do you think is going to be his VP pick?
Scott Galloway
I don't know, someone heinous. Probably Tim Scott because he's the most obsequious chode of all of them.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, probably. You know when I thought Tim Scott was definitely going to be his pick or I thought he was? He got engaged. How come all these guys decide to like go full hetero or full like I'm the Marian man when they – I mean didn't Cory Booker show up with a girlfriend when he was running for president?
Scott Galloway
There was rumors about that, yeah.
Kara Swisher
Anyway. Yeah. But not our friend Lindsey Graham. He continues to. So, ladies, if you want a ring, if you want to put a ring on it, just get them to run for president. Just get them to think they can be president if they only show up with a wife.
Scott Galloway
You know, allegedly. That's all we have to say. Allegedly. Allegedly. Look, he just looks like he's dying inside. Every time he smiles, I'm like, oh, I'd love to hear the.
Kara Swisher
If you could broadcast the internal.
Scott Galloway
Monologue.
Kara Swisher
I would love to hear that. Oh, God. I would love to hear that. Let me just be the VP.
Scott Galloway
I know. Let me get inaugurated and let's hope this sack of shit drops dead. He could be president.
Kara Swisher
And all of a sudden.
Scott Galloway
Easy.
Kara Swisher
And all of a sudden. And then we have, you know, there we have it. Let me go to this. When he started his campaign, I think the odds were like 200 to 1 that he'd be president. If he's Donald Trump's vice president, five years.
Scott Galloway
Yes, mm-hmm.
Kara Swisher
Five years for 77. One year.
Scott Galloway
Well, no, no, no. No, no, no. I'm saying between now and the end of the – if Trump were elected. So call it five years for a 77-year-old obese man. Literally, Tim Scott, if he's made VP, has like a 40% chance of being president.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it's true. It's true. I think he's picking Tim Scott. That's what I would say. That makes the most sense. He's a sense. In weird ways, Trump can be very sensible, and that's the sensible choice. He's obsequious.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I agree. He's obsequious, and he's a black man, and he's friendly. So he's a friendly guy. He's very appable.
Kara Swisher
He's very appable.
Scott Galloway
He's a likable guy. He's good on his feet. Religious, et cetera. Et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. And he's willing. He checks a lot of boxes. He's willing to do whatever it takes to make Trump look good.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, we'll see. We want to hear from you. Send us your questions about business, tech, or whatever's on your mind. Go to nymag.com slash pivot to submit a question for the show or call 855-51-PIVOT. Okay, Scott, that is the show. I am off to party with Don LeMond.
Scott Galloway
Don LeMond.
Kara Swisher
Don LeMond. We'll be back on Friday with more. Read us out. Today's show was produced by Lara Neiman, Zoe Marcus, and Taylor Griffin. Ernie and Ritod engineered this episode. Thanks also to Drew Burrows and Miel Severio. Nishat Kerwa is Vox Media's executive producer of audio. Make sure you're subscribed to the show wherever you listen to podcasts. Thanks for listening to Pivot from New York Magazine and Vox Media. You can subscribe to the magazine at nymag.com slash pod. We'll be back later this week for another breakdown of all things tech and business care. Have a great rest of the week. Thank you.