Podcast Episode Summary
The podcast episode, hosted by Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway, covers various topics including the voiding of Elon Musk's $55 billion pay package from Tesla, the dismissal of Disney's lawsuit against Florida Governor Ron DeSantis, and the CEOs of major tech companies testifying on Capitol Hill about child safety.
Main Topic:
The main topic of the episode is the voiding of Elon Musk's $55 billion pay package from Tesla by a Delaware court. The court ruled that the compensation package was "unfathomable" and "unfair" to shareholders, and that the process leading to its approval was "deeply flawed."
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Other Topics:
[Advertisement] Voiceover: As marketing channels have multiplied, the demand for content has skyrocketed. But everyone can make content that's on brand and stands out with Adobe Express. You don't have to be a designer to generate images, rewrite text, and create effects. That's the beauty of generative AI that's commercially safe. Teams all across your business will be psyched to collaborate and create amazing presentations, videos, social posts, flyers, and more. Meet Adobe Express, the quick and easy app to create on-brand content. Learn more at adobe.com slash express slash business.
[Advertisement] Voiceover: Rinse takes your laundry and hand delivers it to your door. Expertly cleaned and folded. So you could take the time once spent folding and sorting and waiting to finally pursue a whole new version of you. Like Tea Time You. Mmm. Or this Tea Time You. Or even this Tea Time You. Said you hear about Dave. Or even Tea Time, Tea Time, Tea Time You. Mmm. So update on Dave. It's up to you. We'll take the laundry. Rinse. It's time to be great.
Kara Swisher
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And I'm Scott Galloway.
Kara Swisher
You know who I had dinner with last night?
Scott Galloway
I don't know.
Kara Swisher
Two people, two politics. I'm doing this thing at AU, American University. I'm a fellow. I don't know if you know that. I'm a fellow. And one of them-
Scott Galloway
What does that mean?
Kara Swisher
I don't know. I just go and blabber to students about my book. That's pretty much what I'm doing.
Scott Galloway
Well, I think you're a dandy little fellow, little lady.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, Larry Hogan is one of the fellows besides me, the former Governor of Maryland, who's thinking of running for president. And the other one was Bill de Blasio, whom I haven't seen in a while. He's looking good.
Scott Galloway
Bill de Blasio?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, he's single and ready to mingle. He looks really, really good.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. The de Blasio-Gillibrand ticket, the ticket that nobody asked for in the presidential ticket.
Kara Swisher
No, I know that. But I'm just telling you, he looks good. He's having a good time. He's glad to, I think, not be mayor. He didn't say that, but nonetheless, it was interesting. He's a big, handsome man.
Scott Galloway
He is a big, handsome man. You like him. You think he's charming.
Kara Swisher
I do. I think he's a lot better than people thought, but he definitely didn't do many favors at the end, I would say. It's tough to run New York City.
Scott Galloway
I don't know. Yeah.
Kara Swisher
I think Bloomberg did a pretty good job. He's looking better than Eric Adams, I think, probably.
Scott Galloway
I like Mayor Adams. I don't know why, but I like him, yeah.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, because he wears nice clothes.
Scott Galloway
Well, you'd like to build a buzz. He had a great suit on, great head of hair.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, today we talk about Elon Musk's voided billion-dollar pay package from Tesla. And after tech CEOs testified on Capitol Hill about child safety, will Congress actually do anything? Plus, our Friend of Pivot is *New York Times* reporter Connor Doherty, who's been investigating the mysterious company bankrolled by Silicon Valley elite that wants to build a city from scratch.
Scott, just briefly, we have to talk about the Apple Vision Pro because reviews are out and Tim Cook is posing with it on *Vanity Fair*'s cover. I went and saw it again. But I also did a panel for *On With Kara Swisher* with the *Wall Street Journal*'s Joanna Stern, *The Verge*'s Nilay Patel, and *Bloomberg*'s Mark Gurman. And Scott Galloway asked a question, which they really liked, that you'll hear. It'll go up Monday. So thank you so much for doing that.
Scott Galloway
You're welcome.
Kara Swisher
So I asked, let's listen to a really quick clip because I think you'll think it was a very substantive panel.
[Audio Clip] Kara Swisher: Give me your five-word story of the Vision Pro. Here's mine. It's the future of computing. I know that sounds crazy from me. Joanna, let's start with you.
Joanna Stern
Five words. Yeah. First generation, but really cool.
Kara Swisher
Okay. Nilay?
Nilay Patel
The best VR headset ever made is still a VR headset.
Kara Swisher
Oh, and Mark.
Mark Gurman
I think mine is six words. It's going to take a while.
End Audio Clip
Kara Swisher
So it was mixed and it was critical and also interesting.
Scott Galloway
Can I play this?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, go ahead.
Scott Galloway
It's not lame. I don't want more sex. Boom from the Vox Media Podcast Network.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, it's interesting that the reviews are mixed, but we'll see. It's not going to be an enormous product, but they had a lot to say. And it was all very smart about where this is going and how Apple had to participate here in case this is the new computing platform. They didn't really have a choice in many ways, especially since cars are hard for growth. They've got to be on what's coming next.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I've decided that if I continue to not reciprocate the type of love and affection people give me and I'm cast into the depths of hell, that I'll be forced to wear a mixed reality headset and watch the *Barbie* movie starring Taylor Swift for the rest of my life.
Kara Swisher
Oh, yeah, that would be good. We could watch it together. We'll both be in hell.
Scott Galloway
I am so sick of all three of these things. I'm going to have one and you are going to actually try it. Yeah, here we go. You are at your apartment. You and I are going to sit there. I'm going to give you some weed. Oh, by the way, I'm at your apartment specifically, my apartment in Soho. I'm at your favorite place.
Kara Swisher
I think you should leave it to me in your will.
Scott Galloway
What do you think?
Kara Swisher
You think? Yeah, I think. Because clearly you're going to die before me.
Scott Galloway
I'll say some nice words at your funeral.
Kara Swisher
I appreciate that. Anyway, we'll see what happens.
A federal judge has dismissed the Disney lawsuit against Florida Governor Ron DeSantis. The suit alleges DeSantis executed a targeted campaign against the company. The company filed a lawsuit last year alleging DeSantis retaliated against it for criticizing Florida's 2022 parental rights in education law, often called the "Don't Say Gay" law. After the criticism, DeSantis revoked the special self-governing status of Reedy Creek, a municipal district then operated by Disney. Disney said it will appeal the ruling. I feel like this thing has passed, this little fight. Let's move on.
Scott Galloway
Let's move on.
Kara Swisher
Let's move on.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, it's because he did it, obviously, for performative reasons more than anything else. You don't attack one of the biggest employers in your state for anything except to get points in Iowa, which you didn't get any or very few. It backfired on him. And I don't like it when, I mean, I forget there's a law that essentially makes it pretty difficult to sue governments. I mean, you can, but I don't like companies suing governments. And they didn't present a good case. And this is just a distraction. They might not have had standing. I think standing was an issue. This is a distraction from what Disney is supposed to do, and that is offer a great service and create shareholder value. And it's a distraction from what our elected officials in Florida should be doing. That is focusing on issues that affect everyday Floridians. So I just, they, DeSantis screwed up here. I think he paid a price for it.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. I think his punishment was people are just sort of cocking their head and going, what? And I think Disney should just move on. I don't see any reason to pursue it.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I think they probably will.
Kara Swisher
I think it was good for them to file a lawsuit to make a point. I think that's really more than it was a PR fight there. You were just in Florida relatively recently. Has his standing gone down? Because when I was there with you, everyone was totally into DeSantis.
Scott Galloway
I do. I mean, I'm biased. I like to think I'm an honest broker because I recognize I actually think that on the whole, DeSantis got COVID right. And I think he showed, and I know a lot of data has come out saying he didn't get it as right as people are saying, but I think he did show leadership around that issue, even though I disagreed with him on it. I think he actually comes back to Florida wounded. And that is, I mean when you mentioned Bill de Blasio, I don't think de Blasio did himself any favors running for president. And I think the same is true of DeSantis. I think he comes back to Florida as someone who epitomizes how not to run a campaign.
He came across as incompetent yet mean. And also, the only kind of anecdotal evidence I had is I had dinner with some friends, including some friends of mine that are pretty deep red. And even they were really disappointed in his attempt to put in place a six-week ban on abortion. They just thought that was, you know, these are hardcore Republicans. They're like, that's just ridiculous. So I think he comes out, I'd like to see the data, but I'm pretty sure he comes out of this less popular than when he left Florida. In Florida, he could have some challenges, although, you know, incumbency is helpful.
But apparently Matt Gaetz is thinking of running. There's a whole bunch of people thinking.
Kara Swisher
I know. Right. So hug DeSantis in that regard. So it'll be interesting to see. But that's probably in the past. I thought Ivanka was going to run for Florida governor. That's the one I want to see. I'd like to see Ivanka, Matt Gaetz, and Ron. I would enjoy that.
Scott Galloway
She would win, correct?
Kara Swisher
Oh, gosh.
Scott Galloway
Maybe not. She's kind of silly.
Kara Swisher
It's very hard to predict what Florida's going to do.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, that's true. You never know.
Kara Swisher
I think The Rock should run and that should be that. Anyway-
Scott Galloway
Is he a Florida resident?
Kara Swisher
I don't know. I just think he should go down there and run. I think he should be a Florida resident.
Scott Galloway
I think Tony Robbins should run. He's a Florida resident.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
I mean, wouldn't that be very Florida?
Kara Swisher
Yeah. You know, Brett Baer is moving. A lot of people are moving down there because of the taxes.
Scott Galloway
Well, I want to be clear. It's not just tax. It's a nice quality of life.
Kara Swisher
It is. No, no question.
Scott Galloway
But it's going to be overtaken by the ocean.
Kara Swisher
So in any case, the *SmartLess* podcast with Will Arnett, Jason Bateman, and my friend Sean Hayes is leaving Amazon for SiriusXM in a three-year, $100 million deal. Crazy podcast deals are back, although I'm not sure how crazy this is. Sirius made a deal with SmartLess Media. They'll hold advertising, distribution rights, content, and events for *SmartLess* and some other shows they're making. *SmartLess* will remain widely available, but perks will be given to SiriusXM subscribers. I don't know what those perks will be. Reminder, in 2021, Amazon acquired exclusive *SmartLess* rights for between 60 and 80 million. Is Sirius stinging itself into a Spotify-sized hole? That didn't work out. You know, there was a pretty good *Wall Street Journal* article about those deals recently, which we didn't talk about. But thoughts as a podcast personage?
Scott Galloway
Well, you know, this really just means one thing. More money for us. We're rich! We're rich! I mean, this was the most exciting article I read in a while.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
So, thoughts. Though. So it's as if you were not have self-interest. First off, those guys are really talented and the show is wonderful. It's both informative and it's light and they just do a great job.
Kara Swisher
They do.
Scott Galloway
And if you think more broadly, I mean, U.S. podcast spending hit 2.2 billion in 2023. That's a small number, but it was up 25% year on year. Like search wasn't up 25%. So once you hit, there's massive income inequality in podcasts. I'm convinced, I bet the top 200 or 300 podcasts out of the 1.7 million out there do 98% of the revenue and 150% of the profits. Because anything outside of the 300 or 500 most popular podcasts probably lose money or are either marketing or just hobbies.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
But you have a medium that's growing 25%. And even more than that, the intimacy and the connection you have with the listeners results in CPMs. I think we get, I don't think, maybe I'm speaking out of school. I don't care. I'm about, we're going to sign a deal for 101 million. The CPMs are about 45 bucks.
Kara Swisher
More. Higher.
Scott Galloway
Oh, they're higher?
Kara Swisher
They're much higher.
Scott Galloway
Oh, yeah.
Kara Swisher
So that is, that because. We're a business audience. We get different ones, but go ahead.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. So the CPMs are really strong and it's growing 25% a year. And I think a lot of big players want to be here. The difference here, why Sirius will do better or less bad, it's hard to tell if this is a good deal, but it's not going to be a disaster. The reason that it was a disaster for Spotify was they decided that Harry and Meghan should have a podcast. They decided that, quite frankly, the Obamas should have a podcast. And it's just like being really famous does not mean you can put out a podcast or that you even want to make a podcast. It ends up that all of these people weren't interested in working, they're interested in cashing checks. And kind of famous people on pods doesn't, they just made a bunch of bad decisions. *SmartLess* probably does, I would guess, 15 to 30 million a year in ad revenue and I would bet it clears its operating margins of 60 or 70 points. So this is, you know, they might not get 100 million back, but they get an iconic, I mean, they've gotten a ton of PR out of this. It makes Sirius look relevant. Sirius has the infrastructure to grow this thing. And so I, you know, I'm a fan.
Kara Swisher
I haven't talked to Sean about the deal. It was interesting. Amazon made a lot of aggressive moves through its, I think it's the Wondery unit. And they had signed that. That was also a big deal. You know, some of these are going to be non-economic and obviously Sirius is a subscription service. And so it adds to the thing. It's just a question of, you know, the decision I would assume they made, if they came to us, we'd have the same one, is are we widely available, right? Are we popularly available? So they're obviously going for a larger distribution, but then what's the plus for Sirius, right?
What are these perks they're getting? And what's the extra work to do those? We think about that idea of subscription all the time, and we always end up going, oh, advertising business is pretty good. So if we had to, we'd do subscriptions. But there will be just a few. But I think there's more that do pretty well than you think. It's just if they're non-economic deals that people do with them, that's really where it's like publishing, right? Most books don't make it. That's what it reminds me of. A great deal, there'll be a ton of them, and then a couple of them will do really well, and some of the smaller ones can do rather well by themselves if their economics are in line.
That's my feeling.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. It's, I'm happy for those guys. The medium continues to be the little engine that could.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, and we like it. We enjoy it. We actually enjoy it. One of the things, just for celebrities you think are going to jump on that gravy train that Sean, Jason, and Will are on, is that you just can't make a good one if you don't make a good one. You just can't do it by yourself. And I think you're going to see a lot of celebrities trying to do this, like Meghan and Harry, and the people who make these shows and pay for these shows, these big platforms, have got to be very canny about what's popular, because you never know what's going to be popular. There are lots of shows that are surprised in popularity.
Anyway, it's interesting. They shouldn't do kooky deals of stupidity. And I would agree with you, the Meghan and Harry one, even the Obama one, they did, you know, one of them did what was it? Because it was Spotify. They got to turn in good products that people like. That's the key part. And if you're famous, you're famous, whatever. I mean, there's some crazy stat about high school, how many high school basketball players, even world-class basketball players make it to the NBA. Last year, the number of net new podcasts has actually either flatlined or gone down because a lot of people are saying the juice isn't worth the squeeze.
But unless you're marketing something else or unless you're getting a lot of psychic income, you're right. You have to produce something exceptional. And it takes a lot of time and effort. It's just very difficult.
Scott Galloway
It does. Like anything else. And this show happens to be quite good.
Kara Swisher
Oh, it's great. It's a lovely show. And they're good together. They've got chemistry like we do. I think we have chemistry.
Scott Galloway
Anyway, we'll see. Congratulations, guys.
Kara Swisher
They're a really fun group. They're a good group of guys. Anyway, let's get to our first big story. Elon Musk suffered a major loss in a Delaware court this week when a judge voided his $55 billion compensation package from Tesla. Judge Kathleen McCormick called the compensation, quote, "an unfathomable sum" that was unfair to shareholders and the process leading to its 2018 approval, quote, "deeply flawed." When you read through the documents, it really was such a backscratchy situation among the board members who are all friends of his. Apparently, one of them cried how much he loved Elon on it, which was kind of disturbing.
Elon responded to the ruling on X posting, "Never incorporate your company in the state of Delaware." Too late, Elon. And also, you should have had stock that put you in control of the dual class shareholders, which you didn't do either. So too bad if you had a time machine. Were you surprised by the ruling? First of all, the judge, let me give you more facts. The judge ordered Tesla to cancel the stock options awarded to Elon valued at about $51 billion, which is where most of his compensation is. Tesla's directors now have to figure out a new compensation plan that passes legal muster and keeps Elon happy and does it at an arm's length, which is good luck with that because this board has shown itself to be a giant rubber stamp for Elon Musk.
We haven't heard if he's going to appeal, but after a poll on that, he's now saying Tesla will hold a shareholder vote to incorporate in Texas. You know, whatever, whatever. Thoughts?
Scott Galloway
I never heard of this happening or seen it happen. The fact that I've been on compensation committees of boards, to have your, I've never had a shareholder lawsuit against the compensation schematic you put in place. But to have a shareholder lawsuit, I've heard of them. Like Martin Sorrell had shareholder lawsuits constantly around his compensation, but to have it rejected, I mean, effectively the shareholders decide who the board is. And so if the shareholders decide who the board is, who decides the compensation, then technically the owners of the company have decided what he or she gets. I don't believe you should limit compensation.
I think we live in a capitalist society, and I don't like the idea. I do believe that we should have a more progressive tax structure, but that's another talk show. But this effectively says that this board is so incompetent and so conflicted that any decisions they make might not hold up in court because of the conflicts there. Even if you read the ruling, they talk about the size of it, but what they talk about is the conflicts and just how poor the rationalization was for giving him this. Because as much as the compensation was, I mean, just to be fair and try and call balls and strikes, him getting an incremental $50 billion, if he increases the value of the company $500 billion, that's not, I've seen compensation plans that on, you know, I mean it's exceptional but on a proportionate size or percentage of value increase, it wasn't outrageous.
What this says is, you know what's going to end up happening here, it's not going to be able to reincorporate. All these threats, all this jazz hands, all this fake, can you do that? When I was reading that I was like, I don't know. He's just so ridiculous. He says, "I want to meet with shareholders and convince them to divest from Tesla or any of his companies ever. They are not welcome." Well, Elon, I don't know if you've heard or you understand corporate structure, but CEOs serve at the luxury of shareholders, not vice versa. You don't get to decide who your shareholders are. The shareholders get to decide what CEO they want.
And did you see the movie, did you see *Pulp Fiction*?
Kara Swisher
Long time ago. Yeah.
Scott Galloway
Well, there's a scene in it where I think his name is, he's a great actor, Ving Rhames.
Kara Swisher
Was it Vince? Ving Rhames.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, Ving Rhames.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, he was in all the *Mission: Impossible*s.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. I think he is knocked unconscious. They put a gag ball on him and they rape him. He had much more domain and dignity than this board has right now.
Kara Swisher
Well, the visual.
Scott Galloway
This board has been just molested. They should show up to the next annual meeting with a gag ball because they have been just molested. The fact that a court has said, "You are so incompetent and so conflicted and you are such terrible fiduciaries for shareholders that we're going to just reject his compensation somewhat because of the size of it, but just because this-"
Kara Swisher
It wasn't the size. I have to sell, you know, because you could make an argument that he deserves it.
Scott Galloway
See, it wasn't how the number they got to. You certainly could make a cogent argument. He deserves it. It's a lot of money, but still.
Kara Swisher
That's right.
Scott Galloway
But the details, like the going on vacation, one of them, I think Antonio Garcia's, their best friends. The brother is on there. One of them was a CFO and he cried because he loved Elon so much. I mean, you cannot do, there's no independence among any of these people on this board. And so it just was a hands, you know, you're supposed to have, I mean, boards are cozy. Let's be honest. Come on. Like, you know that. Like, they're very cozy with the CEOs and tend to give the CEOs what they want. But at least they pretend that they're not doing quite this. And so it's so bad.
Kara Swisher
And which is, this is something we've just talked about without any particular knowledge. It's so obvious. It's a rubber stamp of a board. They don't stop him from doing damage via his tweets. They didn't control his behavior. They may worry about his drug use, but they don't do anything about it or don't think they can do anything about it. So this is just another, this is the least surprising thing that their pay package was done, you know, by Elon. Essentially, Elon wrote it and then they rubber stamped it, right?
Scott Galloway
Well, the Delaware Chancery Court, he gets to appeal to the Supreme Court of Delaware. They will uphold, I think, Chancellor McCormick's recommendation. But I mean, this comes on the heels of him deciding that, threatening the board that if they didn't give him $75 billion in additional compensation, he was going to steal the IP from the company and start his own. I mean, the Delaware court has said, your board is incompetent. What ultimately ends up happening here, though, I mean, all the threats and the jazz hands around moving to Texas, he's going to have to replace the compensation committee and get someone to lead the compensation committee who has some credibility and also doesn't want to be lost. There's a story from Reuters about this that said legal experts said Musk would almost certainly be sued by investors if he tried to move the state of incorporation to Texas, particularly if it was seen as a move to secure his pay package rather than obtain some benefits for Tesla.
Kara Swisher
For the shareholders, yeah.
Scott Galloway
It's so in plain sight. Elon Musk's plan to change Tesla's state of incorporation to Texas is typical behavior for an entrepreneur who always looks for an alternative if he can't get what he wants. Shareholders need to take a hard look at how transitioning out of Delaware might impact their rights in the company's governments. So, you know, he's going to, they're not going away, these shareholders. And this is the same judge who oversaw the lawsuit with the Twitter. He had to buy it. This judge is showing him, he's looking for a nicer judge, right? In Texas. Maybe his brother could get on the Chancery Court of Delaware.
I mean, at the end of the day, I love the term fiduciary. And fiduciary is very simple. When you get to a point in your life where you're worried about, once I'm sick, once I die, I need someone to represent my interests. And so you appoint a fiduciary for your state. And it's a wonderful term. And one of our abilities as humans, as a species, is we can trust other people to serve our interests, maybe when it doesn't serve their own, because they agree to be fiduciaries. And boards are supposed to be fiduciaries for all stakeholders. And I think he owns about, I don't know, 12 or 15% of the company, which means that they are supposed to represent the other 85%.
They're supposed to represent the community. They're supposed to represent national security. And this board is, I mean, they're just horrible fiduciaries. They have absolutely, they represent or have tried to represent one stakeholder and one stakeholder only. And Delaware has just said, when you're a public company and you sell shares to retail investors, you have certain obligations and this board isn't living up to it. All roads lead to the same place. He is going to have to find, thread a needle between, by finding someone credible who also he thinks will do anything he wants. And those two are a direct contradiction with each other.
Kara Swisher
Well, it's not clear that Texas judges will be rollovers, not necessarily. It's a big risk, but whatever. He likes to do this.
Scott Galloway
No, no, no. I don't think that's going to happen. He's not going to incorporate in Texas. He not. All roads lead to the same place. 65% of companies are incorporated in Delaware because of their law, you know their friendly business laws, et cetera. He's going to have to get, he's going to have to appoint new people to the board who serve on, and one of them's going to have to serve on the compensation committee and such that. Can you imagine? I'd be like, no, thank you.
Kara Swisher
Well, I actually think you'll be able to, I think there's a lot of people, it's like no one ever said that anyone would be in Trump's cabinet. I think the seduction to be near the seat of power is too huge for people.
Scott Galloway
I wouldn't be a director of that company. Saved my life. I mean, it's just...
Kara Swisher
Yeah, but here's the bad news, Kara. As someone who served on a lot of boards, you get D&O insurance. There's only... Do you realize the people who served on Enron's board, they had to give some of their compensation? You basically have to murder people to get in trouble as a board member. You just... They're so protected.
Scott Galloway
That's why this ruling's amazing, don't you think?
Kara Swisher
This is...
Scott Galloway
That's why, because it's usually so cozy.
Kara Swisher
I have never seen this before. I have never seen a compensation package rejected. And it's retroactive. He's not going to lose money because he hasn't exercised the options. But not only is he not getting the additional $75 billion he's been trying to blackmail the board for, I mean, there's no way they can give him that money now. I mean, they look so stupid. He's going to have to appoint something resembling an independent director to the compensation committee. Otherwise, the next comp package is going to be rejected. This Chancellor, Chancellor McCormick, I think that's how you refer to her, she's just not impressed by Elon.
He was attacking her, of course, because she's a woman who's pushing back on him. She's like, no, I'm going to look at the law, and I'm going to interpret the law, and I need to send a signal to every board, even the board of hot companies with a guy who tweets all day, that they have an obligation to be fiduciaries. This is a good ruling for corporate governance and for other corporations because CEO pay has accelerated from 27 times an average worker salary to over 350 in the last 40 years. And some of it is the coziness you talk about. Some of it is just people are more comfortable with people making billions of dollars, whatever it might be.
But this is, yeah, I love this ruling and I think she's fantastic.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, she is. She's great. She just has a sense of like, I'm over you. I'm not, I've never was under you, but I'm way over you kind of thing.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, we'll see what goes on. He's going to do his antics, his loud mouth. He likes how many rules can you just keep breaking and pretend you're a, you know, what drives me crazy is this idea that he's some bold speaker of truth.
Scott Galloway
As my wife, that's her expression. He's not a bold speaker of truth. He's just a toddler.
Kara Swisher
He's turning into a cautionary tale because he is, there's just no getting around it. He is a bold, visionary genius when it comes to products and risk-taking. I think on the whole, he's been good for the world. I wouldn't want to press a button where he just, you know, never immigrated to America. You've got to give the guy his due, but he's just totally, he's a cautionary tale about how power corrupts and how people, when they don't surround themselves with guardrails and they don't listen to anybody.
Scott Galloway
There was only a book that was coming out in three weeks that talked about this in detail. *Burn Book* from Kara Swisher.
Kara Swisher
Is there an index? Because I just want to see what you say about me.
Scott Galloway
I'm not really, I'm not really interested in the book.
Kara Swisher
No, I don't have an index. I don't have an index. And in fact, at the index part, I go. And I said this, and I ended up, I was right. I was right. You are in it, but it says in the index. You refer to me as your landlord?
Yes, my landlord. There's a whole, you get more than most people, I'll tell you that.
Scott Galloway
Not anybody gets much.
Kara Swisher
Well, lucky me. Yes, it's true. It's all very kind to you, I would say. Anyway, I should just send you one, shouldn't I? Okay, I should have brought you one last time.
Scott Galloway
Will you sign it for me? That would be such an honor.
Kara Swisher
Oh, my God. You're not even coming to the book party you're throwing for me.
Scott Galloway
Well, it's because I want to hang out with my mixed reality headset.
Kara Swisher
You could wear it there. You could wear it there. In any case, I can't believe you're having a book party for me and not showing up.
Scott Galloway
I didn't agree to have it. You put my name on the thing.
Kara Swisher
No, I asked you. You said yes.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, right. When you say yes, God, Galloway, that usually means yes. You have become my wife, and that is when you ask me for something, I just nod. I don't even listen to what you're asking. Nonetheless, they're putting me up at a hotel for my book stuff, so I don't even have to stay at your place.
Kara Swisher
I want to, though. Maybe I'll just go down there. Where are you staying? I know New York hotels really well. I don't know if Simon & Schuster is doing it. Anyway, they need me at Midtown because I got to go on *The View* in case you're interested.
Scott Galloway
Oh, that's exciting. You're going on *The View*?
Kara Swisher
I know. I'm so excited. I'm weirdly excited. I like the conservative one. What's her name? Alyssa. Yeah. Yeah. I think she's smart. She's great. She's great. She's terrific. I want Meghan McCain back.
Scott Galloway
Oh, no, thank you.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, I want to sit next to Whoopi or hit me or something. Whoopi. Whoopi. All right, Scott, let's go on a quick break. When we come back, we'll talk about tech CEOs getting grilled on Capitol Hill. This was quite a spectacle. And there's a lot of spectacles on Capitol Hill. And we'll chat with *New York Times* reporter Connor Doherty about a face-off between billionaires and local landowners to build a brand new city in California.
Ad Break
Scott, we're back with our second big story. Quite remarkable. The CEOs of Meta, X, TikTok, Snap, and Discord faced the Senate Judiciary Committee on Wednesday. They were all there for a hearing on child safety that got pretty heated. Senators called out the CEOs for failing to protect children from being subjected to sexual abuse and exploitation on the social platforms. What a shock. While the CEOs defended their safety measures. Let's listen to Lindsey Graham's opening statement, which was a message directly from Mark Zuckerberg, who got a lion's share of the attacks.
[Audio Clip: Senator Lindsey Graham] Mr. Zuckerberg, you and the companies before us, I know you don't mean it to be so, but you have blood on your hands. You have a product. You have a product that's killing people. When we had cigarettes killing people, we did something about it. Maybe not enough. You're going to talk about guns. We have the ATF. Nothing here. There's not a damn thing anybody can do about it. You can't be sued. You can't be sued.
The penny just dropped for Senator Graham on this. We've been talking about it for years or decades, really. What did you think of the hearing? And how do you think the CEOs came across? The moment that's getting most attention: Zuckerberg was asked by Senator Josh Hawley to apologize to parents in the audience whose children died of causes related to social media. They had their photographs up. It was quite dramatic from a visual point of view. Zuckerberg turned around and said, quote, "I'm sorry for everything you have all been through. No one should have to go through the things your families have suffered."
He didn't say "I'm sorry for what I did" at all. That said, Congress, of course, as usual, likes to be performative and do nothing. They haven't done anything. They haven't done privacy bills. The safety bills are without teeth. Several senators called for the repeal of Section 230. Senate Judiciary Chair Dick Durbin ended the hearing by calling for patches of a series of bills to place more liability on these platforms, which you and I have called for. Both Linda Yaccarino from X and Snap's Evan Spiegel committed to supporting the Kids' Online Safety Act, which is called KOSA. Scott, thoughts as you watch this unfold?
Scott Galloway
I have a lot of thoughts.
Kara Swisher
All right, let's go. Go for it.
Scott Galloway
First up, just in terms of the structure here, having Linda Yaccarino and not Alphabet on this panel makes no sense. Linda Yaccarino, to her credit, has instituted the ultimate policy to protect teens, and that is they have become totally irrelevant to teens. She's like in favor of the stuff. It was like if we were going to do a panel on teen trends and you invited the head of Buick. She is totally irrelevant when it comes to teens. What made for great theater was him standing up and saying "I apologize." But what would have been more effective and more the truth is if the parents had said, "Now turn around and ask the people why they haven't done anything."
Because while Mark Zuckerberg is culpable, the culprits are the people sitting up there with their mics who are elected representatives who are charged with preventing a tragedy of the commons. And their public flogging, which we see every three months, so they can get a viral clip on one of the platforms they supposedly are so upset with and raise more money. If they aren't protecting our children, then what exactly are they supposed to be doing? And let's be clear, if you get angry enough and Mark Zuckerberg leaves, there are other people. There are a million Mark Zuckerbergs and Sheryl Sandbergs who are smart and will elegantly figure out a way to create delay and obfuscation as they harm our children.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, this is not a new story.
Scott Galloway
People in the cigarette industry, there is no shortage of people who will come up with rationalizations. Their job is to make money. Quite frankly, they are doing their jobs. It's the senators who are not doing their jobs. So, okay, enough already, Lindsey. What the fuck are you going to do? It's like someone comes off the field at a Premier League game and says, "The refereeing out there was so horrible that it has totally destroyed the game." And the person shitposting the officiating is wearing a black and white jersey. They're the referee.
Kara Swisher
All right.
Scott Galloway
It's like when Senator Warren complains about income inequality. It's like, "Senator, you've been a senator when we controlled all three houses and you haven't figured out a way to restore a progressive tax structure." Like, whose fault is this?
Kara Swisher
One of the bills did pass in the Senate and then it goes to the House and dies. One of the people that actually the only person I would give credit for is Amy Klobuchar, who's tried to pass bills. She's tried. She got kind of weepy. She's like, "I'm getting freaking sick and tired of this bullshit." She gets her knees cut off from her by all the other politicians up there. They just don't let it go. And at this point, I think I'm excited to hear what she says, because I think she's making the effort and it doesn't happen, whether it's in the House or the Senate. But you're right. This should be at the feet of these legislators. And they love to do these. It was dramatic when Mark did that, but it's still their fault.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. In 10 years looking back on this era, I'm fairly certain we think, okay, the weaponization of our elections, the concentration of power, making our discourse more coarse, we regret all these things. But the things we will really be ashamed of is we'll think, "How did we let this happen to our children?" And when you think about, and I've brought this up several times, a 14-year-old girl in the UK goes to her room with her phone. She's bullied. She starts having thoughts of suicidal ideation. The algorithms pick up on this and send her an email that says, quote, "Here are some images on suicide we thought you might be interested in," and it's pictures of razors, nooses, and pills.
And the parents walk in the next morning to that room and she's gone. When that happens, you have to have laws where someone will go to jail. None of this ends. There are more CEOs who will find reasons to delay, obfuscate, and hire more lobbyists than our standing US senators and overwhelm Senator Klobuchar's office. None of this stops until these weak, incredibly ineffectual, feckless elected officials pass laws. And that's not even enough. One of these individuals needs to do a perp walk. None of this ends. The fines can't be big enough. Their lobbyists are too powerful. The only way this stops is when one of them shows up in an orange jumpsuit.
That's it.
Kara Swisher
Well, they don't have liability, Scott. That's the whole point. And of course, the first thing they do is like, "Let's get them, Section 230." I was like, "Oh, so you're going to hammer something rather than your job, which is a sophisticated legislative solution here?" Of which there have been dozens and dozens of bills proposed, and none of them passed. Right? None of them ever passed. And it's because of money. And Senator Klobuchar had called me actually and said, "This year, Kara, it's getting done." And then when it didn't, we talked and she said, "The money just went right to..." And they didn't resist. They didn't resist whatever area they were in. They were too terrified of the lobbying and the money to stand up and do the right thing. It didn't do her any favors, by the way. She's up for reelection. I'm sure they're coming at her. She's very popular in that state, so probably won't be an issue. But she was like, "They just didn't resist the money. And then the leadership didn't put it in the place where it could be successful, either in the House or the Senate."
Scott Galloway
Yeah, this is... I mean, all the stuff we talk about, if you have kids, none of the shit we talk about means anything if your kid's not doing well. I started getting upset on threads and talking about it. And a lot of my comments, someone said something very cogent. They said, "And now do guns." And it's like, what are these folks if they aren't there to protect our children? Why exactly are they collecting a paycheck?
Kara Swisher
I thought Zuckerberg looked more upset, and not just for himself. I think that for some reason, I know it sounds crazy, he looked older, right? Didn't he suddenly look his age or something? Maybe it was the hair or he's been recovering from his fighting knee problem. But it felt like, when I did that interview where I sort of demanded that he stop helping Holocaust deniers get so much purchase on the platform, and he went on and on about free speech. And then two years later, after vats and vats of anti-Semitism spilled everywhere, he changed his mind and did exactly what I had recommended, which was to take them off the platform. He kind of had that look in his eye like, "What have I done?" He didn't say it.
Scott Galloway
I think you're giving him way too much credit.
Kara Swisher
I'm not. I'm not. I don't think I am. He looked like, "This is my legacy."
Scott Galloway
Well, and his legacy is being the most... I'm not giving him purchase. I've been hugely hard on him. I don't care if it's his youth. He's going to go down in history along with Sheryl Sandberg as having done more damage to our youth than any two individuals in the history of America.
Kara Swisher
Who's done more damage? Maybe the people who invented sugary, salty snacks. I don't know what it is. The point I was making is he might do more than they will.
Scott Galloway
That's dangerous to think that way, Kara. I don't think he's going to, but he's the only one that can because they won't do anything. We keep waiting for their better angels to show up. They don't.
Kara Swisher
I agree. They don't. And by the way, if they did, he might get so upset and tired, he would get fired and we'll find another mendacious fuck who pretends to be an empathetic, caring person. This requires laws. Full stop.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, those pictures were haunting of the kids. In America, to have money and power to be loved, we all want to be loved, and we will do whatever is required to be loved within the confines of the law. So the thing that needs to change here are the laws. And it just wouldn't be that goddamn hard. Remove Section 230 protection for content algorithmically elevated that has to do with elections, healthcare, and anything involving kids. Age-gate social media, for God's sakes. We age-gate pornography. You can't get a driver's license under the age of 16. Instagram begins from a place of perversion.
And that perversion ends up hurting our boys and girls, specifically our girls. Do you realize? And he lied to Congress. My colleague Jonathan reviewed a hundred behavioral and longitudinal studies. And he found, among other things, that people who are heavy users of social media are twice as likely to try and commit suicide than those that are light users. This shit is so dangerous and so brutal. And these individuals can't figure out a way to pass laws to protect them. And then they make a passing reference to cigarettes. He had killed a lot of people, Lindsey, just so you know, and it did take you too long and you were in their pockets for too long.
And some of them I think are genuine. Senator Durbin, Senator Klobuchar. I even think Senator Blackburn is genuine. But some of these people, including Senator Graham and Senator Cruz, they like give their speech to try and get on TikTok and then they go play golf with these folks. Look at he's given them money. Ted Cruz is one that shut down a bunch of stuff because it lacked innovation.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, like Amy Klobuchar, we are sick and tired of being sick and tired. Anyway, we'll see what goes on. Probably nothing. And we'll have to deal with attorney generals and others who will probably do more of the work of this in the end, as they did with opiates. Same thing. Okay, Scott, let's go to our Friend of Pivot. Connor Doherty is a reporter for *The New York Times* who covers economics and housing. His latest piece digs into the fascinating story of a company backed by Silicon Valley bigwigs trying to build a city from scratch in Solano County, California, and facing off against local landowners. I love this story so much. And it's up in Vacaville, which is Calville. For anyone who knows California, this is a very windswept, dusty part of the above it, but quite beautiful in a lot of ways. Connor, welcome.
Connor Doherty
Thank you for having me. Yes, it is a bonkers story. I remember when I first got the scoop, I was like, "I probably never had something more nailed down when I published it." And I still was like, "Is this all wrong?" Because it just sounds too weird to be real.
Kara Swisher
So yeah, you wrote the story last summer of this mystery of this company that created this land grab that was going on. For people who don't know, for a long time, nobody knew who was buying this land. There were theories someone was trying to spy on a nearby Air Force base or build a new Disneyland.
Connor Doherty
That's always a good guess. Disneyland.
Kara Swisher
That happened in Washington. I know some of the financial backers here include venture capitalists Michael Moritz, Marc Andreessen, and Laurene Powell Jobs. So explain what's happening exactly.
Connor Doherty
Okay, cool. So I'll just give you a quick rewind. There's this windswept area where people have sheep and cattle farms and they grow alfalfa and things like that. And it's a lot of kind of generational families. People have been there since the 18-whatevers, 70s, 80s. And not a lot of land trades hands out there, right? All of a sudden, this mysterious company not only starts buying land, starts buying a lot of it in amounts no one has ever seen. So typical amount that someone would buy in that area is like three, 400 acres might trade hands a year. Suddenly someone's buying 10,000 a year and almost within three years is the largest landowner in the entire county and has like 50, 60,000 acres, which is about twice the size of San Francisco. But nobody could figure out who this company was, not a single person who worked for it, not a single person who owned it. And it was, as you said, this big mystery. And as the land started to surround the Travis Air Force Base out there, Congress and other people got really freaked out. Eventually, I was able to break the story that it was these Silicon Valley people and that they had this plan to build the city.
Kara Swisher
OK, now let me ask you, what made you start digging into this? Who alerted you?
Connor Doherty
I mean, obviously, this mystery of who this company was was out there. I was by no means the first person to be alarmed by that. Essentially, I got a tip that it might be not Chinese spies, which is what members of Congress were insinuating or at least implying. And that led me down a path, I guess is the way I would say. In the article you mentioned a 2017 letter to potential investors, your latest article on this saying if done right the project could help relieve congestion and housing prices in the Bay Area, which you've been writing about forever. Yes. And the letter also mentions a potential to experiment with new types of governance, even though it's in a place that already has government.
I don't want to make too much of that. I mean, I think if you create your own city, you can choose whether or not to incorporate it. Obviously, there are cities like Irvine and other places where they've had different kinds of covenants and things. There are ways in which you can sort of... I mean, you can't live outside the state of California rules. But anyway, the point is this. After we broke the story, they go from total secrecy to like charm offensive. They've opened up multiple offices across the county. If you drive through Solano now up 80 on the way to Sacramento, you will pass multiple California Forever billboards.
Oh, they're now going by this name, California Forever. And I could, as you know from our past conversations, bore you for many, many, many hours about all the things that stand between their intention to try to build on a piece of land and the reality of that. But the really high stakes kind of grabby thing is that they are going to have to do an initiative, which is that they're going to have to ask all of the Solano County voters, "Will you give us permission to do this?" It's a little bit more complicated than that, but in effect, they're going to try to qualify a ballot initiative, which means they will, as you well know, anytime anyone goes to a supermarket or church or any kind of busy area, they will be assaulted by people with clipboards who will say, "Would you like to sign this thing?"
They will probably, I mean, I don't see how they wouldn't qualify. You can pay these signature collectors to do it. And then there will be in November, at the same time that there's another notable election happening there, there will be a vote. And the vote will, technically speaking, sort of say, "Will you amend certain Solano County laws to allow people to build out there?" And that will just be the first step. But if they get that vote, even though that's not administratively the hugest hurdle, or it's just one little hurdle, it would change the vibe. It would sort of say, "Well, you got a majority of the county to say, yes, we want this."
That would inevitably put a lot of pressure on the local government. I don't see how they could do this without also state government. But anyway, the point is there's a lot ahead of them, but this vote would totally change the narrative and give them huge ammunition.
Kara Swisher
Yep. And they have money and means. They've got money and means. Scott?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, Connor, nice to meet you. I loved your article on *The Last of Us*. I remember reading it and thinking, this is a great article.
Connor Doherty
Thank you so much. Which one, the movie or the video game?
Scott Galloway
About how you were saying this might be a new model for a new business model, I believe. You're talking about if *The Last of Us* could become, if that's a new model for how content gets repurposed.
Connor Doherty
I have low key as a fan boy of *The Last of Us*. I've written, that's like my secondary beat. So anyway, thank you for saying that. I love that show and the game.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I love it too. Anyways, it's nice to meet you. So I'll put forward a thesis and I want you to respond to it. I think this is a great thing. And I understand that people have a healthy gag reflex when they hear about powerful people doing stuff under the cover of DART. We can understand why they were trying to do that. They didn't want to raise the prices when people knew billionaires were buying up the land. But we have a crisis in the United States where housing's gone from $290,000 on average to $420,000, just from pre to post-pandemic. Young people aren't forming houses or households because they can't afford housing. And I don't mind that this is a way to build profits. I'm not even sure that's their real intention. I think they see this NIMBYist rejectionist culture that has arrived to every local review board where they can't get housing permits approved, and we need a massive increase in the surplus of the supply of housing stock. So I love this. Where am I wrong?
Connor Doherty
So you're not necessarily... I mean, let me put it this way. That is not a fringe opinion. That's not an invalid analysis. Let's just step back a second. California, as you said, has been having this huge housing crisis. And the state legislature and various people have done a lot of work to try to fix it, but it's extremely slow. And even if they changed every law right away, it's just very difficult to build within a city, even beyond all the political stuff. It's just hard to drive a construction truck up hills and around narrow corners. When you want to build massive amounts of housing, as we did after the baby boom, you go to the middle of nowhere, not just because the land is cheap, but because for real true efficiency reasons, it's just much easier to build on what they call greenfield, which means an empty plot, basically.
Which is different from infill, which means building in the middle of a neighborhood that is there. So their premise... I interviewed this guy, Jan Schrameck, who's running this whole thing. He basically said, "I think infill is a great idea. I'm all for it. I just don't believe any of this can move fast enough to make any real dent in California's problem." That is not in any way, shape, or form an invalid view. The people who would disagree with that view would even agree, as the world currently stands, that's a completely... What he is saying is completely true. Now, there are people who would say, "I want that to be not true, and thus I am concentrating all my efforts on making it easier to build in a place like San Francisco."
But his read of the current situation is essentially unassailable in terms of how you would actually build large amounts of housing units in a short amount of time. So I think, Scott, you're totally right. I mean, obviously, my job as a journalist is to cover how this happens, the process.
Kara Swisher
But what's the wrong thing there? Because what it has on it is rich people know better. Really rich people can make the cities they want. I think that's the vibe, especially with Elon down in Texas doing a similar thing with his strange little town, running roughshod over people, etc.
Connor Doherty
So, no, that was just what I was about to sort of try to get into, which is like, as a matter of policy, it's hard to argue that some amount of greenfield or building in the middle of nowhere, building new cities, whatever, would probably have to be part of the solution in California. And the God's honest truth is we already do tons of that. I mean, if you drive to LA, which of course I now do more of because my dad still lives in San Francisco, you pass through Tracy, through these massive subdivisions that look like your classic kind of cul-de-sac whatever, they build their own schools, all that sort of thing.
So they're just trying to do that, but in a more urban, dense kind of way. Anyway, but the flip side, as Kara said, is you start to get into questions of, well, at what cost politically? Meaning if it becomes that the way to get new building done is to have billions of dollars to buy land in the middle of nowhere, to pay signature collectors to get whatever you want on the ballot, and then run probably one of the more expensive campaigns in the history of the entire county, then you're eventually going to need a bunch of state help, which they have plenty of money to hire lobbyists for. If that's the only way we can build, is that the world we want to live in?
That's a world. So I think people who are very alarmed by how this happened and the sort of implications of how they're going to try to flood the political system with money to get over all these things that are hard, I totally understand people who think that worries me. Also, some ideas about giving up on cities... I think a lot of these, some of them, not all of them, have sort of been... Well, actually not Mike Moritz. He hasn't been, but it's this bashing the city that exists now. I don't think this one is that though. I just don't.
Kara Swisher
I don't either. I don't either with these particular people. But the one in Texas with Elon seems weird. Although then there's Celebration with Disney, which wasn't as good. They had a lot of problems. The idea of creating cities from nowhere is not a new fresh thing. That one in Brazil, it's been going on. It's this idea, the way it's been presented, I think, is from a PR perspective, problematic. It's this sort of beautiful city that we can do better and everyone will have delicious organic grapes. You know what I mean?
It has that vibe to it. But this isn't—I mean, I think a lot of this is around communications and the fact that these individuals have established such terrible reputations for themselves. What Dan Gilbert is doing in Detroit, a billionaire comes in and starts buying up all of downtown Detroit. Eli Broad, basically another billionaire, kind of built Irvine by going in and buying up real estate.
Connor Doherty
That was Donald Bren, actually.
Kara Swisher
Excuse me, Donald. Thank you, Connor. This isn't unusual. What I found is, I mean, it swung so far that the incentives are for the incumbents, the current homeowners, to show up to review boards and come up with all sorts of reasons around concern for development. The development gets put off and the incumbents' housing prices go up because they artificially constrain supply. So the incentives are for the incumbents, the homeowners, to basically, quite frankly, drive up the prices for renters and young people. I just see it as another transfer of wealth from young to old. And if we wait on our lawmakers to maybe do subsidized housing, but this feels to me like it's just so—we need a thousand of these types of initiatives. So I'm totally, and I hope I've made this clear, I'm of two minds about this.
Scott Galloway
Scott, I agree with you in a lot of ways, and I could even go further. I mean, I think it's not bad for us to be constantly experimenting with where and how we live. You could imagine that they might do things like electrified streets, which would allow you to do self-driving cars in a way that would be basically like a track, meaning you could do it in a way that would be infinitely safer. And you could imagine a scenario in which a place like this becomes really hot. People love how they live, and then it puts tons of pressure on other cities to reform how they do things because they need to make their streets safer or whatever.
I mean, San Francisco has been talking about making its streets more bike-friendly for God knows how long, forever. They cannot move a single inch on it. And then you look at a city like Paris, which in three or four years basically completely changed the entire thing. Not a new city, Paris, right? Completely changed the entire thing for bikes. So there is a sort of question of will, and something like competition from different kinds of models might change. So I think that's all great. The only hesitation I have, Scott, is when people say, it worries me that this is how the process is. It worries me that the only way you can get this done is through this kind of imperious process.
I think that's a fair critique. Now, what you seem to be saying is, well, but that's the situation. What are you going to do? Sit there and do nothing? I get that view too, but I just think my job is to kind of document how it happened. This guy who's doing it, how did he get these rich people to do this? I mean, I can see why it appeals to them because all these people are like, yeah, we can build a better city. Yeah, cool electrified streets. I can see the dinner party right now. But who is this guy?
Connor Doherty
I don't know if it's like fully nailed down, but I have a feeling that I think it actually is maybe the opposite of what you're thinking, which is this. So his name is Jan Sramek. He's a guy from the Czech Republic. He wrote this little biography of himself, typical Silicon Valley guy in the sense that he was very precocious, good at math, other things. Went to London School of Economics and was like a star trader at Goldman Sachs. He left Goldman Sachs to start a couple startups, didn't go very well, eventually finds himself in Silicon Valley and is part of a kind of milieu of youngish, smart, wealthiest people who are interested in big ideas. He's in a book club with people from Sequoia. He's good friends with Patrick and John Collison, who are the billionaire brother founders of Stripe. So he's like in this world of people.
Kara Swisher
Who I may say loves to talk, but go ahead.
Connor Doherty
Well, yeah, he's in that world, right? So he somehow goes out to Solano County. He's into fishing and he is sort of interested in this land, which if you've ever been out there, it is sort of weird. And it's relatively flat. If you drive around and you're not a farmer, it looks like there's nothing out there. I mean, there are some sheep and some cattle, but it's not like packed or anything like that. Okay. So how did he get these people to do this? When you talk to him or when I interviewed him, his answers, and this might be part of a strategy, but I also think it was real. His answer is very spreadsheet. He's like, well, this land could be bought for this price. It's not super high value agricultural land. So if you think about it, a Napa Valley vineyard might be as much as $500,000 an acre. This land is like $4,000 an acre. Now that it was much higher by the time it was about $4,000 when they started buying. So that's like the agricultural value of that land. He talks about how, oh, well, it's pretty easy to protect this area from wildfires because it's just grass. So you could mow it, right? There's not a lot of trees and all that. So he was doing the geek approach.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Connor Doherty
And he liked that it's not a huge earthquake area. On top of that, there are some long range plans from like the 50s in the Bay Area that earmarked that area as like, oh, this would be a good place to build. So I think his answer is sort of like, this is actually a very good place to do this if we could get the land and if we could bend the politics. I think his pitch to them is probably like, this is an undiscovered gem. The only thing is we have to wage a political gambit, basically.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
Okay. Scott, last question. Well, so housing and the travails of really wealthy, powerful people is important. But what's profound and I want you to talk about is Nick Offerman's Emmy Award for Episode 3 of Season 1 of The Last of Us. And a follow-up question, is Pedro Pascal, in fact, the best leading man alive today? Your thoughts.
Kara Swisher
You know, I think it's great. Well, Kara's going to be unhappy, but...
Scott Galloway
That's okay.
Kara Swisher
Answer very quickly, and then I will ask the last question very quickly, because we got to go. This is important, Kara. Do not shame me. Do not shame me and Mr. Doherty here.
Scott Galloway
By the way, I don't know if you figured this out yet. It is a factual opinion that The Last of Us is the best video game adaptation in the history of the world. A hundred percent. But anyway. Connor, answer his question briefly.
Connor Doherty
You know, anyway, I'm excited for season two.
Kara Swisher
When does it come out? When does it come out?
Connor Doherty
I mean, they're supposedly filming right now.
Scott Galloway
Oh my God, you have no idea. That last episode rattled my world. It was so violent and so upsetting.
Connor Doherty
Well, you know what's great? Again, Kara wants us to stop talking about this. I bought that game the day it came out because I was so into Naughty Dog games. They have other games. And I, like that weekend, tried to make my wife watch the little cinemas. You know, as you play the game, it has little movies in it. Because I was like, this changed me. Because the last scene in the game is not terribly different than the one in the movie. But anyway.
Kara Swisher
All right, you two. Looks like you can have a... I think you guys should move up to Vacaville together and play video games.
Connor Doherty
Well, it's actually Rio Vista, but it's in the Vacaville area.
Kara Swisher
I love the word Vacaville.
Scott Galloway
I know, I do too. I wanted to name one of my children Vacaville.
Kara Swisher
Okay, is this going to happen? Just very quickly, yes or no? 20 years?
Connor Doherty
I think it'll take 10 to 20 years. Here's the way the only way I can imagine this happening quickly is this. As you know, there are these big environmental laws in California. One way you can get out of them is the state can basically say you get out of them, which they do for big baseball and football stadiums all the time. That's conceivable. But man, would that be—well, it'd have to be like a whole legislative—I actually don't know how it works, but the point is, stadiums do it all the time. So you could do this, and it happens in very special moments. I don't see how they could even put a shovel on the ground within three, four, or five years without something like that. But that's why this vote is so important, because we could enumerate hundreds of steps that will take to get them to get there. The question is, does anybody want—where's the pressure points? And if they have this vote, I think they start to have the pressure.
Kara Swisher
That's true.
Connor Doherty
They'll find some rare prairie dog. I'm sure of it. That's what's going to happen here.
Kara Swisher
We'll see what happens. It's not, this ain't Texas, it's California. In any case, fascinating stories. I'm really following it. I hope you're writing a book on this.
Connor Doherty
I'm hoping that would be great. I'd love to hear it.
Kara Swisher
It's really, when people do this and away from the billionaire part of it, which also makes it interesting too. It's a really cool—if it was just any developer, it would be boring, but this is fascinating. Anyway, Connor, I recommend everyone reading them and obviously watching The Last of Us.
Connor Doherty
Thank you.
Kara Swisher
We look forward to seeing what happens. Thank you so much.
Connor Doherty
Nice to meet you, Scott.
Scott Galloway
You too, Scott.
Kara Swisher
All right, Scott, that was interesting. I'm glad you guys had a man moment there, a little man bonding. One more quick break. We'll be back for predictions.
AD BREAK
Okay, Scott, let's hear a prediction.
Scott Galloway
Okay, so this is an advocacy or a viewpoint wrapped in or posing as a prediction. But every manager's job and every leader's job is to allocate capital to a greater return than another manager or another leader. And the ultimate managers, if you will, is the US government and the president. We have to decide whether they allocate our resources and our revenues and our military to a greater return than other leadership around the world. That's the whole shooting match. And my prediction is that in 10 or 20 years, we're going to look back and the greatest return on investment in this era wasn't an investment in NVIDIA, it wasn't even an investment in infrastructure.
The greatest return on investment will be the $75 billion and the $92 billion that America and the EU, respectively, have invested in helping Ukraine push back on Russia. And in exchange for that investment, this is what we have received. We have received, one, that the EU has become a union for the first time and has, in a very purposeful way, said that we are an ally of the United States and that we can work together in pushing back autocracy and when individuals decide to try and invade and expand their borders. Two, this has effectively been—people are under the false impression that this is sending money over to Ukraine that is then immolated.
It's not. This is an effective stimulus plan for the United States. Because of that, if you will, $160 billion, approximately two-thirds, if not more of it, ends up in one of 38 states in the United States that builds military equipment. This has been effectively a stimulus plan for the United States. And we have given every autocrat, every autocrat, whether it's Xi or Kim Jong-un, we have given them all pause that if they want to invade an island off the coast, Taiwan, that a well-armed, technically sophisticated sovereign nation with the support of a unified West should not be messed with. This is the greatest return on investment of capital.
This is about 10% of our military budget that we have recognized in decades. And I hope, and also this bullshit that the EU isn't paying their fair share—the EU has invested a greater percentage of their GDP, much of it coming back to Western suppliers and weapons producers. We have battle-tested weapons technology. We have developed an entirely new technology around effective drones. This, I hope we continue to make one of the greatest investments on an ROI basis. And by the way, folks, we have not put a single boot on the ground here. So to not continue to make what will be seen as the greatest investment by the West in the last 30 or 40 years, just selfishly, we are investing in a stock that keeps going up and returning enormous dividends to the United States.
And I hope, I hope that Congress begins to frame this as the greatest return on investment or the greatest investment we have made in a long, long time.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. That canard about them not paying their fair share, they pay more than their fair share. They pay more than us. It's so ridiculous. They just keep repeating it.
Scott Galloway
Not pay, invest. I want to use different. They've invested more than us.
Kara Swisher
They've invested more than us. It's an investment. You're right. If we do not do this and Putin prevails, it'll be so costly later. It'll be spending this much money. It'll be trillions later when we're going to have to push them out of all kinds of places. And then it'll be U.S. troops going there. Anyway, the Ukrainians are doing our work for us. And of course, there's corruption. Of course, there's other issues. But Scott, spot on. I agree with you. Anyway, we want to hear from you. Send us your questions about business, tech or whatever's on your mind. Go to nymag.com slash pivot to submit a question for the show or call 855-51-PIVOT. Scott, that's the show. We'll be back on Tuesday with more Pivot. What are you doing for the weekend, Scott?
Scott Galloway
Well, I'm going to Tulum. What am I doing? I'm doing a lot of MDMA, but I'm going to Tulum.
Kara Swisher
Ah, cool. We're going to, soon the FDA might be approving MDMA for treatment. So that'll be a nice little time thing to talk about. Anyway, read us out then.
Scott Galloway
Today's show was produced by Lara Naiman, Zoe Marcus, and Taylor Griffin. Ernie Intertott engineered this episode. Thanks also to Drew Burrows and Neil Severo. Nishat Kerouac is Vox Media's executive producer of audio. Make sure you subscribe to the show wherever you listen to podcasts. Thanks for listening to Pivot from New York Magazine and Vox Media. You can subscribe to the magazine at nymag.com slash pod. We'll be back next week for another breakdown of all things tech and business. Kara, have a great weekend.