Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses various topics, including Amazon's disappointing earnings report, the potential for a recession, the FTC's low morale, and Apple's future prospects.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Additional Insights:
Kara Swisher
AI agents are getting pretty impressive. You might not even realize you're listening to one right now. We work 24/7 to resolve customer inquiries. No hold music, no canned answers, no frustration. Visit sierra.ai to learn more.
Not all journalism is the same. Take The Guardian. Our coverage has something unique: fierce independence. Nobody owns us or tells us what we can and can't say. So we're free to report the whole picture. We connect what's happening in Washington to the rest of the globe, expose corruption wherever we find it, and give fresh perspective on everything from wellness and soccer to culture, the climate, and more. Read, watch, and listen to The Guardian for free at theguardian.com.
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And I'm Scott Galloway.
Kara Swisher
So today we'll talk about Amazon's rough quarters, see what's coming for the market. That's a big deal. Also, the FTC could use some TLC. And we'll speak with journalist Tripp Mikkel about his new book, *After Steve*, which charts the difficulties at Apple after its founder's passing. I had an interesting short meeting with Lorraine Powell. Jobs were going to do something really cool, hopefully, at Code. So I was thinking about Apple quite a lot this week. Give us the dish on the weekend. You were fabulous this weekend.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I did. I had a great time. I, of course, didn't dress up at all as everybody else did. I did not go to the White House Correspondence Center because I did think it was a COVID soup of a situation. I hate it in normal times. And so I did not want to go in these times because it's this sort of – it's the Washington Hilton ballroom. I just don't like it. I've never liked it.
Kara Swisher
But you went to all the parties. The bottom line is you'll take risks. But just –
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
You won't risk the Hilton, but you'll go hang out with Trevor Noah at a bar.
Scott Galloway
No, I won't. That was indoors. It was like totally, utterly indoors. And it feels like you're inside of a Petri dish. It just does in general times. A lot of the stuff was outdoors, which is great, by the waterfront in Georgetown. There was one at the French residence that was fun. There was one, where was the other one? I don't know. I went to a lot of parties, and they were nice. And I set myself out on the patios and just had people greet me and stuff.
Kara Swisher
And I got to tell you, Scott. I set myself out on the patio and had people greet me. That is correct. That is correct. That is what I did.
Scott Galloway
You received people.
Kara Swisher
I receive people. That's how you do it. You know, I learned that from one of the big agents. I can't remember which one it was. He said he sits in a place and he waits for people to come to him. He doesn't mingle.
Scott Galloway
You know, there's a term for that, virgin.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, okay. In any case, it worked.
Scott Galloway
Just a memo to all young men. Don't do that. Go up to people and start talking to them.
Kara Swisher
We have so many fans, I can't even tell you. It was crazy. It was really kind of crazy. Go on.
Scott Galloway
It was like people love us. That's the most famous interesting person that came up and asked about me. Me.
Kara Swisher
Well, not you. Us. A pivot. Diane Lane likes our show. All these people came up.
Scott Galloway
Diane Lane? Yeah, I know, right? From *A Little Romance*? Simone Sanders, who used to work for Kamleris, she was bowing and everything. It was really quite just crawling.
Kara Swisher
Oh, I met Jen Psaki. That was interesting. She's very impressive. Is she on MSNBC right now? Is that right?
Scott Galloway
She is going, yes.
Kara Swisher
And then I ran into Kevin Systrom was there, founder of Instagram. Susan Wojcicki was there. There were a lot of internet type people there, which was nice. Senator Klobuchar was at some of the things, some of the parties. Senator Kay.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, everyone was loving on Pivot, I have to tell you. Good for us. Pivot, Pivot, Pivot. We are famous in a very weird way, especially among TV personalities.
Kara Swisher
Hung out with Don Lemon a little bit, who looks good. D. Lemon. He looked great. We dated up him and his husband and I and Amanda. We gated up. So it was good. It was very good.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, let's just hope we're famous and not infamous. That's my fear.
Kara Swisher
Well, yeah, that's okay. I think it's okay these days. It doesn't really matter. I met Tony Blinken, Secretary of State. That was nice. He's an impressive man.
Scott Galloway
He is an impressive man. He's a very handsome man. And he's got very good hair.
Kara Swisher
It just was, I can't even remember now at this point. Oh, and then Tammy Haddon, you know, had this White House Correspondence Center brunch. Tammy didn't invite me. Tammy pretends to like me and then she didn't invite me.
Scott Galloway
You could have come. You could have come.
Kara Swisher
This is the famous one that she's had every year, and it was great. It was all outdoors, too. It was at Mrs. Graham's old house, which was – you could be indoors, but I was – there's this beautiful outdoor area. They had a tent in – open tent and everything. And it was – I had been there a million times when Mrs. Graham was living, when I worked at the Washington Post in my 20s. They had different events there. And it was great. It's this old house nobody lives in, and it's owned by this guy named Mark Ein, who owns the Washington City paper. And it was cool. It was cool. It was nice for chit-chatting with everybody. It was nice to chit-chat. You want to know what I did?
Scott Galloway
No. What did you do?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, you do. Yeah, you do. You want to know what I did?
Scott Galloway
Yes, what did you do?
Kara Swisher
So I hung out with my, it was just me and my youngest, my 11-year-old boys. So it was literally, we did nonstop. We watched soccer. We took walks with the dogs and we ordered pizza and wings three times from Anthony's Coal-Fired Pizza.
Scott Galloway
Oh, that's nice. That's so nice.
Kara Swisher
It was really nice. That's not what we did. We were fancy. Amanda and I were fancy this weekend. And we had babysitters. We had babysitters. I haven't watched any of it. Was there a highlight? How was Trevor Noah? What is your take on it?
Scott Galloway
It was a bad look for much of a fish. There wasn't a lot of Republicans there. I'll tell you that. There were very few.
Kara Swisher
Biden apparently went to the big one. I saw him on the dais there.
Audio clip of President Joe Biden plays
President Joe Biden
I know there are questions about whether we should gather here tonight because of COVID. Well, we're here to show the country that we're getting through this pandemic. Plus, everyone had to prove they were fully vaccinated and boosted. So if you're at home watching this and you're wondering how to do that, just contact your favorite Fox News reporter. They're all here, vaccinated and boosted. Yes. All of them.
Kara Swisher
They were. There were a lot. I saw Brett Baier, a whole bunch of them. I don't think Sean Hannity was there. In any case, speaking of the White House, workers behind union drives at Amazon and Starbucks may be visiting the White House. That, of course, was President Joe Biden. He was very lively at the thing, and this is a big move by him. And it does in weird ways relate to Elon. The reason he doesn't mention Elon is because it's not a unionized shop. But I think that's wrong because Elon is clearly the pioneer in electric cars and autonomous. I think it's really petty on their house, as I've said. But in any case, they're bringing in – it's unconfirmed, but if it comes to pass, there's to be a reversal from previous statements. The Biden administration would not pick sides in the union efforts. Of course they are. So they may be at the White House. What do you think about that?
Scott Galloway
Well, it's interesting. After our guest last week, there was an interesting article in the New York Times saying that a lot of the union or the rejuvenation or new life that's been breathed into the union movement is a function of college grads who are making the money that they initially anticipated. That there's sort of – it's not the working poor, but it's college grads who've ended up in jobs that they didn't expect to be in. That they end up – there's just more college grads that are baristas than ever.
Kara Swisher
Sure.
Scott Galloway
And that this has kind of brought new life and organizational skills and into the union movement. I'm still curious to see the numbers, if you will. But the numbers – it's getting a lot of attention. So our guests last week, you know, I'm looking at the data because I'm realizing as is often the case, I may be wrong here. I think this is a giant head fake, but I'm open to the notion that there is something structural taking place here.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, we'll see. That was an interesting story. There is a lot of – listen, if you work at a media organization, whether it's New York Times or Vox, you feel the strength of the union coming on. within, I've talked to lots of managers at lots of media organizations and they are definitely, I think it's been a difficult road in general to understand what's happening. So I don't know, we'll see where it goes. And it's led by what this Times article talked about. And so we'll see where it goes. I think you could really breathe life into, as you said, into the union movement. Isn't Vox Union now?
Scott Galloway
Yes, it is. Yes, it is, yeah.
Kara Swisher
But some of it, not all of it yet, I think, or I forget. Anyway, we are not in the union, but I have been in unions before, as have you. In any case, it's an interesting time. We'll keep watching that with the White House, and especially if they focus in on Amazon and Starbucks workers, which I think are seeing the most activity. Obviously, Apple store workers, too, and some others. But Amazon is where the action is, really, and Starbucks.
Scott Galloway
Well, I heard that Bezos got divorced solely because he realized his marriage was a union. Get it? A union? Come on, that's good labor humor.
Kara Swisher
That is bad labor humor. Bad labor humor.
Also, Warren Buffett had some harsh words for investors looking to make a quick buck. The Oracle of Omaha, he just had his meeting, said the stock market has become, quote, almost totally a casino. Meanwhile, Charlie Munger lashed out at Robinhood, which he said encouraged gambling mentality. He also had some words for Bitcoin, which then Elon Musk attacked him for being old. I don't know why he's doing that. What a surprise. But that's not to say Buffett and company hate gaming per se. He revealed that he had a 9.5 percent in Activision, which was interesting, which means he's done rather well. He said the buys are his bet that Microsoft deal will close. I guess he just did it. Interesting. I like when Warren Buffett – I like when people get mad at him. I like his whole, like, grumpy man thing, older man thing. So what do you think about this?
Scott Galloway
I think Warren Buffett is an American hero. I mean, let me be clear. He's pulled off a little bit of a Houdini, and that is – it's kind of a hedge – it's an insurance company posing as an investment firm. The majority of their profits come from reinsurance. Insurance is the business that keeps on giving. I've said several times, find me, if you meet somebody who makes a half a million dollars a year and it's kind of likable, but not very smart, chances are they're in insurance. It's just an unbelievable business that plays off of fear, has all sorts of regulatory capture. And Berkshire Hathaway is essentially an insurance company. Warren Buffett, though, he's nice. He doesn't consume a lot. He has very interesting perspective.
Kara Swisher
Oh, you haven't had dinner with him. Yes, he does. But go ahead.
Scott Galloway
Well, you know what I mean. He doesn't have a – he's not on a boat.
Kara Swisher
He ate his meal, a giant plate of French fries and potatoes and half of my meal. But go ahead. Fine. I can't believe he hasn't – it just hasn't exploded. But go ahead. Go ahead.
Scott Galloway
What I mean is he lives – I think he lives in the same house. He's been married for 50. He just strikes me as a nice representative of America versus some of the other folks that are getting a lot of attention. And I think he's – my sense is he's a good man. And I think he's a good role model. And I like his approach to investing. He likes to say we only buy stuff that we want to be in for a long time. He admits his mistakes.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
I just like his approach. He answers the phone.
Kara Swisher
It's very strange to call there. I called her sort of early in the internet phase because he was very anti-internet, which I thought was a wrong call by him because he said he didn't understand it. And I get that if he didn't understand it. He missed quite a lot of upside by not being as big an internet investor, obviously, but he's an Activision here. So I called him to ask, get a quote when I was at the Journal at the time. I was like, this guy should be in the internet space. Like he sort of didn't – he thought it was also a casino, much of it. And much of it – some of it was. And I called, said, I thought I was going to be a PR person, right?
So I called in. I got his secretary directly, and then he comes on the phone. He was like, hi, Kara. And I'm like, hi, Warren Buffett. It was so strange. And that's happened several times when he called. How old is he now? I think the guy's an inspiration. I don't know. This was many, many years ago. But I had dinner with him relatively recently, just before COVID. But you could summarize this year's, you know, they call it Woodstock and Brothers. You could summarize it with one statement. Told you so. They're literally, oh, my gosh, are those guys feeling their oats, like going after.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
Also, I think I don't like it when these – I think he deserves more deference than a lot of these new hedge fund managers and these libertarian weirdo takerists. It's his record. He doesn't like cryptocurrency. I think he's wrong about that one too. The crypto and Tesla Taliban come for anybody. I mean I'm not comparing myself to Warren Buffett. But when I talk about Ethereum being an interesting one and I could see a bull case for Ethereum because of NFTs, people are like, you know, he's not that bad. But if I don't say Bitcoin, I don't understand how it's going to be worth $100. Everyone's like, oh, he doesn't get it. They're just so binary in their assessment of everything. And also, but at the same time, I don't think it makes any sense for Charlie Munger to call Bitcoin evil. It's not evil. I mean, it really.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I think they should consider it. Both of them should consider it at least. You know what I mean? And not – it's not similar to what they did around the internet, but, like, you couldn't – I'd like to hear what they think actually looking at it. That's what – instead of doing sort of a broad brush, I would have liked to hear their thoughts on it and their worries.
Kara Swisher
Well, here's the problem. When you're a little bit older and you don't understand something, you have a tendency to want to dismiss it because it threatens your way of thinking, right? It's a bit of a knee-jerk reaction. Where I do think they get it right is basically the way they go after Robin Hood.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
I just – they look at this thing and they go, okay, this is just bad for the world, bad for the planet, a terrible investment. I think they got it right there. But this was their kind of like I told you so meeting. The last few years, everyone's like, oh, Cathie Wood at ARK. She's the new Warren Buffett. And all these people saying, I'm the new Warren Buffett. And no, no, Warren Buffett is still Warren Buffett.
Scott Galloway
Yep, I would agree. It's a marathon, not a sprint.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it's good for him. I think he's an inspiration.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, yeah.
Kara Swisher
It was interesting. I still think you should reconsider cryptocurrency. Anyway, let's go to our first big story. The 2022 Reaper has come for Amazon. The commerce giant issued a disappointing earnings report last week. Some lowlights: Amazon missed its earnings target. It reported a loss of nearly billion for the quarter and had its slowest year growth in two decades, which is probably not a surprise coming out of the pandemic. The market took notice. On Friday, Amazon shares fell by 14%, wiping out over billion of its market cap. It did a Facebook faceplant, essentially. That's the stock's biggest one-day decline in 15 years. And Amazon's not alone. In April was NASDAQ's worst month since 2008. And there could be more bad news for the stock market, which many people have been predicting a correction of a significant amount. The Fed is expected to raise rates because of inflation on Wednesday. It's going to be doing a lot of raising of rates. What do you think, Scott? What do you think? Give us some little Scott-ness.
Scott Galloway
I'm just going to give a couple more facts. The NASDAQ composite, more than 45% of stocks are down 50%. More than 22% of stocks are down 75%. And more than 5% of stocks are down 90%. This is from Scott Galloway.
Kara Swisher
So give us your pontificate, please, if you don't mind.
Scott Galloway
Well, we have an entire generation of entrepreneurs and investors that have never seen a recession and see it as something that is worse against a crime against humanity. And the reason why every fiat currency has ultimately failed is the central bank and governments can't resist the temptation to be loved and pump trillions of dollars of stimulus into the market to prop up the market, which just creates more underbrush that once you have a reckoning, you have a super fire. And if you look at Amazon, okay, I think it's 30 or maybe 35% off its 52-week high. And it's down more than Apple. But basically, everything's getting taken to the woodshed here. Why? Because-
Kara Swisher
It is. I'm just going to look at Tesla today, but keep going.
Scott Galloway
Yep. Well, you've never had, this is what we have. It was stupid to call inflation transitory. Now, it's of our own making. There's no free lunch. We took an obese patient in America and we shoved 40,000 gallons of dryers down its throat and an overdone stimulus. Europe has the same supply chain problems, but they aren't registering the inflation because they weren't as ridiculous with this stimulus. So what do we have? We're now starting to pay some of the hangover. And the only way you get your arms around inflation, unless there's some new invention in economic history, is by raising interest rates.
And typically, every time we've raised interest rates at what most people are predicting the rate we're going to have to raise them is that you go into recession, which brings up a whole host of other things. So what you have in the NASDAQ is we're having what I would call a healthy drawdown, especially among the growth of your stuff, but no one's being spared here. And the fact that Amazon's down 20 or 30%, everyone's looking for reason. Granted, it did decline. A lot of the pandemic bump is being taken out of stuff. The core competence of any CEO right now is storytelling. And I don't think Andy inspires people.
I think if Jeff Bezos had done that earnings call, he would have pivoted to something else and his ability to say, yeah, we've taken a loss and positioned it as a positive because of our mass investments here. The other thing is if this stock goes below $2,000 a share, it'll be, I think, at about a trillion dollars. I think you'll see a spin of AWS. I think AWS is now worth more than the entire company.
Kara Swisher
Which Andy has resisted, as you remember in an interview with me.
Scott Galloway
Nothing like a 40% decline in your stock price to get you to reconsider your strategy.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, interesting. And if you look at it, I believe you're going to see a lot of people sharpen their pencils and go, you know what? AWS on its own is worth a trillion dollars. So when a company is trapped in a conglomerate structure, the market doesn't like pure plays. I don't need Amazon to diversify for me. They're going to say –
Scott Galloway
Really impactful on their actual business.
Kara Swisher
No, it doesn't make their actual business look a lot better. It really helps it.
Scott Galloway
Well, the disposition of assets is a creative when it trades at the multiple of a business that's in decline. AWS is still pumping on all 12,000 cylinders.
Kara Swisher
It is indeed. One, I think – my sense of Andy is he's an amazing operator. Unfortunately, we're in an era where it's all about storytelling. You know, he ran AWS, for those who don't know that. He was the one who thought it up and ran it and created it. I think he's a Tim Cook, Sachin Nadella-like operator. I'm not worried about him. There's a difference, though. Steve Jobs can't come back. Jeff Bezos can. I think Jeff Bezos is going to pull a Howard Schultz. And I think he's going to come back in a year to two years.
Scott Galloway
Do you think? I mean, literally, being the CEO of Starbucks is like being second lieutenant in Vietnam. You're just not going to likely last very long. And when you see this stock for the first time, I mean, that actually is not that. From 1999 to 2001, people forget what this is like. This is like we have never registered these types of declines except for 1999 and 2007. And it's playing out again. And people are whistling past the graveyard or they're focused on this other weapon of mass distraction called all this Twitter bullshit. But what's going on here is really striking.
Kara Swisher
Yes. Yes. Just the big tech companies have lost the GDP of Mexico. They have. They have indeed. They have indeed. Although I'm just noticing Tesla's down just a little bit today. I thought it would go down more, but it has not. But here we are. I'm not making a prediction about Tesla. I'll just say this. Everyone, everyone is going to get their turn at the woodshed here. Market dynamics, market dynamics always trump individual performance.
Scott Galloway
All right. And this market, there has never been an economy that has been able to raise interest rates at the rates I think we're going to have to raise them to get our arms around inflation that has not gone into recession.
Kara Swisher
And to recalibrate supply and demand. In other words, is what you're saying. There's so much demand and little supply, et cetera, et cetera. You have no choice. We'll see.
Scott Galloway
We have no – the only way we cool inflation – I am returning the oligarch's yacht I bought you as a present.
Kara Swisher
That's right. Finally investing in our relationship. And now you made me worried.
Scott Galloway
The SS Cialis. I'm on a boat. Oddly, it came with a torture chamber below, but I thought you could use that and enjoy it.
Kara Swisher
I'm not into pain. No, that's not me. That's not my thing.
Scott Galloway
All right. You know my safe word, right?
Kara Swisher
No. Maybe. Maybe. That's good. That's good.
Okay, Scott, let's go on a quick break. When we come back, low morale at the FTC. We'll speak with a friend of Pivot, Trip Mikkel. www.thumbtack.com
Ad break
Support for Pivot comes from LinkedIn. From talking about sports, discussing the latest movies, everyone is looking for a real connection to the people around them. But it's not just person to person. It's the same connection that's needed in business. And it can be the hardest part about B2B marketing, finding the right people, making the right connections. But instead of spending hours and hours scavenging social media feeds, you can just tap LinkedIn ads to reach the right professionals. According to LinkedIn, they have grown to a network of over 1 billion professionals, making it stand apart from other ad buys. You can target your buyers by job title, industry, company roles, seniority skills, and company revenue, giving you all the professionals you need to reach in one place. So you can stop wasting budget on the wrong audience and start targeting the right professionals only on LinkedIn ads. LinkedIn will even give you $100 credit on your next campaign so you can try it for yourself. Just go to linkedin.com slash pivot pod. That's linkedin.com slash pivot pod. Terms and conditions apply. Only on LinkedIn ads.
Scott, we're back. The FTC could use a morale boost. A survey found that employees' opinion of senior leaders dropped between 2020 and 2021, the year Lena Kahn took over as chair, and fewer than half of the FTC staffers who responded said they had a high level of respect for senior leaders in response to an agency-wide email committing to facilitating positive change. New leader. She was supposed to be an ambitious regulator, has not been able to do what she has said she wants to do. Lots of reasons. So what do you think? What do you think? Or is she just forcing them to do their jobs? So she's pursuing cases, but they haven't had this sort of big, you know, high five win anywhere.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, so I forwarded this story to you because I'm one of the people that was really excited about Lena Khan's appointment. It's just a great story. And I think she's an incredible legal mind.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
I believe that she's in way over her head. And it just seems so obvious. I know a lot of academics. And I take the most impressive academic you've met. She's an associate professor at the age of 31, kind of a few years out of law school, I think.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
She's put in charge. Brilliant woman. Brilliant woman. Of a bureaucratic organization with, what, 1,200 employees and 300. It would be like I'm trying to think of an associate professor I've ever worked with. I've worked at NYU for 22 years. We have a very talented faculty. It would be like all of a sudden dropping one of them into a 1,200-person company with a 300-man. And I think I don't know a single person that could do that. And we like to look at someone's attributes and someone's intellect. And she's a high character, incredibly impressive person. She has little to no management experience.
Kara Swisher
Right. I think it has to do with them not having any wins or movement. The movement's slow. But whose fault is that? And whether it's her.
Scott Galloway
Well, it could be hers. It could be these. They were pushed back on the Facebook deal by a judge, and they had to redo their homework.
Kara Swisher
She may be like, you did bad work before, which they did. And it may be that they don't have any. If they had a win, I think they'd be very happy. It's just that there's not. These cases are going forward, but it's slow going. The court cases are problematic for them. The judges are problematic. But one of the things that FTC employees complain about is lack of information they get from above. It could be due to remote work. It could be pandemic-related, like coming out of the pandemic. I don't know. There's so much demand for antitrust lawyers on the other side, maybe, that they are leaving. They're hemorrhaging time. But the rates are the same of people leaving. This is dramatic. I mean, when people, when they quote-unquote say senior leaders, it's really, it's a proxy on her.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. One of the most underrated attributes that people don't appreciate, it's a singular distinct competence, is management, your ability to manage an organization. And people incorrectly assume this is a good person who's super smart, which means they're a good manager. No, it doesn't. No, it doesn't. Management is like, it's like saying this is a high character, good person. They must be a great designer. No, they're not. It's the same with management. This is a unique skill set. And by the way, she has absolutely no experience in a management role and you plump her into an agency.
Kara Swisher
What would you do if you were there? If you were there, lots of people come into agencies with very little, you know, Pete Buttigieg is running the Department of Transportation. I'm sorry. He was at one of these parties, by the way.
Scott Galloway
Mayor Pete?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, he was giving an award to some veterans at Tammy's party. You know, he's in charge of like the infrastructure money. As I was sitting there and someone was making a joke about South Bend, I was like, oh, my God, is this guy qualified to give away all that money?
I think about that all the time. There's two types of managers, what I found, that are effective. I've never run big companies, but I've run midsize companies, and I've coached and been on the board of CEOs with big companies. And there's two types of effective leaders or managers.
The first is what I call the inspiring leader. They can stand up in front of a group of people, distill down to very basic understandable things, the North Star. This is what we're here to do. This is why you are here to do it. And this is why this is the right place and the right time for you to be here right now. It gives people a sense of connective tissue and that they're working for something bigger. It says to them, when you show up here, you're appreciated. This was a smart decision to be here. They can paint a really exciting future. That's the inspiring leader.
Then there is what I call the player-coach leader. That person is so good at what they do and takes such an invested interest in other people's success. My partner in my business, Catherine Dillon, is a player-coach. She takes her chair. If someone is editing a document, she goes and sits next to this person and says, this was good. I'm going to show you how to edit a document. I'm going to show you how to edit a video. This is where you got it wrong here. She's kind but very direct. She teaches people how to be much better players.
Scott Galloway
I'm what you would refer to as the inspiring leader. I like getting up in front of a group of my employees and painting the vision. The inspiring leader is effective over the short term but not usually the long term, unless their job is to pull forward the future by raising cheap capital. It's the player coach. You even reference this with guys like Satya or guys like Tim Cook.
I, quite frankly, don't mean to be harsh. I think she's neither. I don't think she's able to get up in front of the FTC and get them excited and paint a vision. And I don't know if she's a good player coach. She's a world-class—Tim Wu is in the right seat. He's an inspiring, huge brain. And yet, think about all these people that the Trump people put in who are wholly incompetent.
Kara Swisher
Oh, okay. You're making my point. That's decimated. You're making my point.
Scott Galloway
I think the federal government feels overwhelmed, and especially the FTC. When I interviewed her, I felt—remember I said she seems exhausted already. She seemed overwhelmed. She seemed over her head because she's intellectually rigorous. She seemed like she got in there and it's like, we can't do anything. They're inert. And I think if you work at a place like that where you're not going to—they haven't gotten the funding because it got sucked up into one of the bills that didn't pass. You're not getting any kind of wins. If they had a win they'd feel better instantly.
Kara Swisher
But Kara, these are the same problems the FTC faced for the last three decades. Yes. You've never seen this sort of decline in morale.
Scott Galloway
Well, I don't know. I think people are feeling bad about working for the federal government.
Kara Swisher
And also, let me just say, let me compare her to Pete Buttigieg, which is a much bigger job. I'm sorry. If you're going to talk about qualified, then neither of them is qualified in that regard. And by the way, I think they're both perfectly competent. So I'm not sure. There's been a sort of "government sucks" narrative. It would be interesting to see similar surveys at the Department of Transportation. I don't know if they do those. But she needs to step up. She can be inspiring.
I still think part of it has to do with who is this young woman of color who just came in here and is telling us what to do. You think there's a bias towards her by the rank and file? I have seen it myself in places I've worked. I've watched it. And it depends on who's saying it. If you see her in a different context and she looked a certain way... I don't know. And I don't blame that for everything, but in this case, believe me, I don't. There are bad managers of all kinds.
Anyway, she's got to get it together because they've got some real challenges and they need to get some wins on the board, period. Can you name anything the FTC has done? They have cleaned up some previous stuff. That's what they've done. Cleaning up is not enough. Getting it moving forward, but a win? No. No.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
All right. So now let's bring in our friend of Pivot. Tripp Mickle is a technology reporter at the New York Times and author of *After Steve*, a new book that charts the tensions between Tim Cook and Jony Ive in the years before Ive's departure from Apple in 2019. Welcome, Tripp Mickle.
Tripp Mickle
Hi, thanks so much for having me.
Kara Swisher
No problem. So I've been thinking a lot about Apple this weekend. I've been thinking about my Code Conference, for example, and I've been thinking about how to think about Steve. It's my 20th year of doing this. He was the very first speaker at our first Code. So I want you to give us an idea of what this is—*After Steve*, the time after, which has been a long, long time. He died a very long time ago in real terms and in terms of Apple. Can you talk a little bit about your premise of the book?
Tripp Mickle
It's designed to focus both on what Tim Cook has accomplished. He's turned Apple into this multi-trillion-dollar company. And then also at the same time, the company has lost Jony Ive, who was considered a creative soulmate of Steve Jobs. The literal soul in a way of the company. And more than that, in Jony's departure, his growing disillusionment was really rooted in this idea that Apple was once a place where art led to commerce. And increasingly in the Tim Cook era, it became a place where commerce dictated art. Some of that's a consequence of just the size and scale of the company and the expectations and demands of Wall Street.
Kara Swisher
So you felt that—I would point to what you just said. Apple's never been bigger, never been more powerful. You could create a company out of the software and services. It's been nothing short of a miracle what they've done there. AirPods, all kinds of things. So this romantic idea of Apple, which I've covered since a very long time, I always found a little twee, honestly. I was like, "Oh, stop. You just make stuff." So why is that? Why was Jony so important in that regard? What is missing, given the results are pretty damn good?
Tripp Mickle
The results are tremendous, right? But the results are largely rooted in the past.
Kara Swisher
Are they?
Tripp Mickle
The twee era, if you will, is really the foundation of the success of today. It's taking the iPhone and saying, "Well, what can we bolt onto this and create more sales opportunities out of?" Whether that's services, the watch, or the AirPods, they're all laid on this foundational device that was revolutionary and introduced in 2007. But to poke back at the twee idea, for people who worked there and for you when you were covering it, there did feel like something magical was happening. If you go back and look at the run of iMac, iPod, iPhone, iPad, it's really a series of just cultural shaping devices that were introduced by Apple in that period.
Kara Swisher
So you think they aren't as creative. You left out Ping. I don't know why. Their social network that lasted 14 minutes. But you think that has been missing here despite the financial success of everything else? You could say that the Model T is the foundation of the car industry, and people have managed to figure out new and better ways to do it. But you think that it's missing this, and that's deadly for it or just the way it is?
Tripp Mickle
If you talk to people who work at the company, they feel this more than people externally feel it.
Kara Swisher
Yes, yeah.
Tripp Mickle
You talk to some of the people who have worked on designing some of these products that have been so influential in all of our lives. If you ask them, "What's Steve Jobs' legacy?" They'll say it was making amazing products that really changed the world. And if you ask them, "What's been the legacy of the past decade?" They'll say making a fuck ton of money.
Kara Swisher
I think we can say that on this podcast. Yes, you may. Say "fuck ton" as much as I want.
Tripp Mickle
It's just a different viewpoint on what they achieved. They appreciate that that's a consequence of how big they were at the time that transition happened between Steve Jobs and Tim Cook.
Scott Galloway
Nice to meet you, Tripp. I really enjoyed reading some of this. So it's harder to go from zero to 300 billion, where Apple was when Steve Jobs passed away. But there hasn't been an individual who's created more shareholder value alive than Tim Cook or overseen it. He's gone from 300 billion to 2.7 trillion. So if you use that as a metric, he's the most successful operator in history.
What struck me reading some of your thoughts was that doesn't this indicate or isn't this a proxy for a larger shift in our economy? Apple has gone from being a brand or creatively driven organization to a supply chain, an operationally driven company. And quite frankly, that's where the juice is. That's the story of Amazon. This old era that we're nostalgic for of brand and creative—the sun has just passed midday on that. Tim Cook is the CEO. He's added more value than any CEO in history. Doesn't this represent a shift from creatively driven companies to operationally driven companies? And what's the negative in that?
Kara Swisher
Do you believe this shit, Tripp? She edits my questions.
Scott Galloway
What's the negative in that?
Tripp Mickle
There's no negative in that. But if you're working at the company, that experience is difficult to undergo. For those of us who are getting their products, there's a little less of a wow factor year to year. There's almost an understanding that the new iPhone will come out and it will have another camera or more sophistication in the camera than the previous one. So that's a facet of it. But Scott, the book, as you know, doesn't seek to diminish what Tim Cook has accomplished.
Scott Galloway
100%. I think you highlight it. It seeks to accentuate it.
Tripp Mickle
His ability to anticipate—"We're going to introduce the watch. That's going to unlock some new sales for us. But we have to have that next step after that." To anticipate that they needed that and to introduce services on the back end of the watch—that is a testament to what he was able to do as an operator. And there's an art to that too. There's an art to being sensible enough to say, "We need to continue to grow. What do we have?" and pulling that lever at the right moment.
Kara Swisher
You know this company as well as anyone. What are your thoughts around the prospect of an Apple car? Do you think they're headed there and do you think it's a good idea?
Tripp Mickle
I think they're headed there. I think the book highlights some of the challenges with why they're having a hard time getting there. One of the things, Kara, to get back to what Steve was able to accomplish, and the book goes into great depth on this, and Jony kind of carried this on with the watch—inside Apple, someone needs to take on and drive a product forward. Steve did that for years. Jony did that with the watch. The AirPods were born on the back end of the watch. I know Scott's a huge fan of the AirPods. Me too.
But there hasn't been somebody, as Jony became wayward, to step in and lead that stuff forward. Not to mention, as Jony was adrift, as the book documents, when he went to this kind of part-time arrangement, there was tension between his vision for what the car could be and some of the engineers' vision. That's why the car was never delivered in 2019 as they set an internal goal to do. But they're continuing to work on it.
One of the most interesting things that I came across as I worked on the book is what they did to change the construction industry with Apple Park. This seems like weird—why are we going from cars to construction? But they wanted to do this amazing curved glass in the building. Nobody made glass like that in the world. But between their deep pockets, their engineering sophistication, and their design demands, they were able to bring on a German company and get them to manufacture this glass at scale. It's opened up new opportunities for architects everywhere. So if they can do that in the world of construction and architecture, you can only sit back and say, if they brought that to bear in the world of auto manufacturing, we could really be seeing something incredible on the roads in the years ahead.
Kara Swisher
Talk about the glasses then, because I think they're closer to that—the idea of the AR. I've seen Tim in the interim, but one time, many, many years ago, all he could talk about was AR and Auburn football, which neither—I was interested in the first, not so much the second. Can you talk a little bit about the glasses? That seems to still be illuminating a lot of people there I talk to, this idea of AR glasses, not VR glasses, and where that is.
Tripp Mickle
According to the public reporting on that, they're certainly closer on AR glasses than they are on a car. They've had less difficulty in developing that. But again, that has taken time. If you look back at the watch and the way the watch was introduced, and I cover a lot of this in the book, they introduced it early. It took some persistence to get acceptance for that watch because it didn't have some of the functionality that people would expect. Like time—telling the time constantly every time you looked at it—you had to turn your wrist towards yourself in order for the time to show. So with the AR glasses, there's an open question as to whether or not that's going to be another product that, when they introduce it, it's going to take persistence to get acceptance.
Kara Swisher
The last specs I think I saw were kind of a unit that looked akin to ski goggles. It's just hard to picture a lot of people adopting that. I think Oculus has had trouble with that up to this point as well.
Scott Galloway
Where do you think—if you had to bet—these companies are running up against a lot of big numbers. They can't go after niche markets. If you look at Apple's stock and business, in order to maintain the kind of stock trajectory they've been on, they literally have to add like a quarter of a trillion dollars to their top line, which limits them. As far as I can tell, it means that they either go into healthcare or the automobile market. I just don't see where else they can go. Every person who makes a certain amount of money has iOS, so they can continue to add to that. And then they recast it as a recurring revenue firm. That will take their stock price up. But they've got to find an enormous new carcass to feed off of. If you had to bet on where they're going to try and find that quarter of a trillion dollars, what would your bet be?
Tripp Mickle
I would wager it's got to be audio, right? If you go back and look at what they were wrestling with shortly after Steve Jobs' death, they recognized that they were getting to the point where the law of large numbers was going to create headaches for them. Tim Cook literally said, "We need $10 billion businesses. If it's not going to be a $10 billion business, we can't pursue it." Internally, that created some of the frustration because some of the product leaps that they could have made in the decade prior were foreclosed. They just weren't going to be big enough to make a dent for them. HomePod, for example. Is a speaker going to deliver enough sales for a company that large to satisfy investors on Wall Street? No.
Scott Galloway
But that's still rooted in the watch. It's been a slow and steady growth. The wearables business, which includes the watch and AirPods, is a $38 billion business. It's become quite sizable and it's immune from antitrust criticism at this point. So they can still squeeze and build that. It's just a question of will they ever turn medical records into something that profitable for them? They haven't quite shown that they're on that path yet.
Kara Swisher
Who is the Jony Ive of that company then? Is there one or do they need one? Obviously, there's no right way of leaving a company. He was such a legend there, no matter what. As a person, he's so interesting compared to most of the executives there. And Tim goes out of his way to be dullish, trying to be sort of quiet and kind of brainy. Is there someone there that fulfills that role?
Tripp Mickle
That's the open question. That's what I'm eager to see unfold in the decade ahead. If you look back at Apple, the real alchemy of it has been this series of pairs.
Kara Swisher
Art and commerce, yeah.
Tripp Mickle
The series of pairs, right? You had Jobs and Woz, and then you had this decade that was really Jobs and Jony Ive. And then though Tim and Jony Ive are less close, they were key to this most recent decade. I think the key to Tim's success going forward is finding who he's going to team up with in the future.
Kara Swisher
Anybody? Is there somebody?
Tripp Mickle
The early evidence suggests that Johny Srouji may be that person. He's clearly brought forward a lot of innovation in the chip sector that's unlocked a lot of value for the company in its Mac business.
Kara Swisher
But nobody like a Jony Ive character, correct?
Tripp Mickle
What Jony brought to bear, you could argue, is like a bit of a legacy. If you look at products in the world, they are already shaped by what Apple has done in terms of its minimalism. And is physical design going to be, industrial design going to be the way forward in a world where we're increasingly interfacing and interacting with computers through voice or augmented reality? It's going to probably be software driven. So who is that person at this juncture? I couldn't tell you, Kara. I think that's the other question about Apple at this point.
Kara Swisher
I can't think. They'd have to buy someone like Snapchat or bring in Evan Spiegel, who's quite creative. They could have bought Instagram, Kevin Systrom. Those are more creative types of people. Scott?
Scott Galloway
What do people not understand about Apple? What was the biggest surprise for you writing this book?
Tripp Mickle
I think the biggest surprise for me was just getting such a deep appreciation for how after Steve Jobs died, the creative part of the company wound up having the people who were on the outside, the operators, come into the middle. Just how confusing that was for everybody. Both those on the outside who found themselves in the middle and were having to adjust to how do we build a product and how do we make the watch happen? And for those in the middle, working with the operators in a new way. There was this real period of adjustment in the wake of Steve Jobs' death. Apple managed to navigate that. I think that's why we've seen this value unlocked. But it was not an easy road.
Kara Swisher
No, no. Everyone thought he was going to fail. I remember at that time they thought they couldn't do anything without Steve Jobs. One time when those stories were going around when he was sick, the one thing he did say to me was, "I'm not Willy Wonka." He was trying to disabuse people of the idea that he was the only factor that mattered here, which was unusual because he was also somewhat of a narcissist. So it was an interesting thing that they have managed to go on. But is there a game-changing product for them coming up? Are any of these—the car, the glasses? Do you imagine that there's something coming that's really—if you had to pick between those two, which is where they're headed, would that be it for them?
Tripp Mickle
All signs and all reporting indicate that glasses are first and car is second. That's largely because of the challenges with each one and the technology that they have to bring along.
Kara Swisher
Not Hollywood. Not Hollywood. Is Hollywood a new product? I don't know. I mean, I'm enjoying *Slow Horses*. They're doing okay.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I think it's been fantastic.
Kara Swisher
Oh, that's great. That's great. Agreed. I've always felt that great companies have three or four people that can be the next CEO. And you just don't hear a lot of names that are the heir apparent. Are there any heir apparent to Tim Cook?
Tripp Mickle
There's a tremendous amount of respect within the company for Jeff Williams, the COO, who's now running the design team and has been really involved in product ever since the watch. There are some other names that Tim has brought into the fold, like Deirdre O'Brien, who also came from the operations side.
Kara Swisher
But do you hear these names often in the same way you heard like Jimmy Iovine or Angela Ahrendts? No. Remember Philip Schiller? Is he still there?
Tripp Mickle
He's still there.
Kara Swisher
They're all still there. It's so fascinating with this group of people. It's scary.
Scott Galloway
You'd appreciate that somebody was telling me that they'll have to take some of these people out in a body bag. They just love the company that much.
Kara Swisher
Well, they're also remarkable that they have been together for so long. I'll never forget, Walt was retiring and there was a little party with all of them. And I was like, it was all the old guys. And they're still running everything and they're still there. They were remarkably resilient for a management group, despite all the tensions and various fighting that goes on at any company.
I have a last question. Regulatory issues. Apple's trying very hard to pretend it's not a monopoly or say it's not. It's been declared not a monopoly by a judge. Their argument being that Android is bigger. And in the scheme of all phones, they aren't. But they're certainly facing a lot of headwinds around the App Store and the marketplaces and the other things they compete in. How much of a risk is that for the company?
Tripp Mickle
They're playing a game of App Store Jenga right now. Every once in a while, Europe or the US will poke at a piece and put it on top. It's just a question of when that whole game of Jenga collapses and what that means for their business, because the App Store itself has been such a driving force for their explosive growth in the past decade.
Kara Swisher
Absolutely everybody should read it. It's called *After Steve*. It's by *New York Times* reporter Tripp Mickle. How does Apple like it, Tripp?
Tripp Mickle
You know, I don't—I'll give you the answer. They don't. They don't. Tim commented on it, on some of the thrust of the reporting that's at the back of this book, and said that it distorts relationships and narratives and facts and so on and so forth. So that tends to be there. They don't is my answer to you.
Kara Swisher
And it's a good thing. Probably means it's accurate.
Tripp Mickle
That possibly.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Anyway, it was very funny. I said "no comment" when I was hearing some of the complaints. I just said, "Oh, good. I can't wait to read it. I'm so excited." Anyway, it's a terrific book. Again, *After Steve* by Tripp Mickle. Thank you so much for having me.
Tripp Mickle
It's great to see you guys. Thanks, Tripp.
Kara Swisher
All right, Scott, one more quick break. We'll be back for predictions.
Ad Break
All right, Scott, it's time for predictions. I'd like you to make one. Please do.
Scott Galloway
I think that, as I was saying, everyone's getting their turn at the woodshed here. It just doesn't seem like anyone gets out of this alive. There are very few companies that are going to go untouched from their pretty significant drawdown. I think everyone's in this consensual hallucination that we can continue to avoid recessions forever.
The company that—because of this weapon of mass distraction called the shit show at Twitter, we're not talking about a lot of stuff that's really important. I think that's a business story that a lot of people are missing is what Netflix did to the entire media ecosystem. They basically sucked a quarter of a trillion dollars out of traditional media, whether it was movie theaters or the cable bundle. And now they've lost a quarter of a trillion dollars. But what no one's focused on is I think the company that is feeding off the Netflix carcass is a company that now commands more attention than Facebook and Instagram combined, but has a content budget of zero versus 17 billion at Netflix. And that is TikTok.
The company that has increased more in value than any company in the world over the last 12 months in the face of everyone going down 30, 40, 80% is TikTok. If you look at its metrics, it has the short-form dopamine, ADHD characteristics of this new generation of people that need constant dopamine. And at the same time, it's managed to avoid some of the shit show that is Facebook. It does have at least a perception of increased moderation. We've got to stop thinking of it as a social media platform. It's basically streaming entertainment.
Kara Swisher
I've always thought of it as entertainment.
Scott Galloway
Without a content budget. It's Netflix. What would Netflix be worth if it didn't have to spend $17 billion a year on content? That's what TikTok is.
Kara Swisher
One of the things that's interesting, this new antitrust bill that got out of committee, Amy Klobuchar—the YouTubes of the world and others are all nervous because TikTok won't be under the $600 billion thing. These companies might have to—there's going to be a lot of pushback. And they're using TikTok as the cudgel. "If we have to reveal things, why doesn't TikTok?" So it'll be interesting. They're going to be in the crosshairs of a lot of this. The fact that they don't get marked every day because their stock is not public has been such a huge benefit for them.
Scott Galloway
People are coming for them, though. Meta has been cut in half. Amazon's off 30%. Apple's held its own. Google is flat, maybe a little bit down. I bet if TikTok was a public stock, it'd be up substantially. And everybody would be going—
Kara Swisher
Let me just say people are coming for them. That's my prediction.
Scott Galloway
And then just on an anecdotal level, I was vacationing with some friends a few weeks ago. They, like me, have boys. The dad said, "Look at this." The kid said, "Can we be excused?" And he said, "Watch my 11-year-old." He went over. He takes his phone. He lies on his side. He pulls up TikTok. It was so reminiscent. Remember all those images of the monks in opium dens where they just lie on their side and love life? It's true.
Kara Swisher
I can't watch TikTok because you get sucked into it. Oh, my God. It's so entertaining, as you know. And you know what? Don't do it. I find if I go on TikTok, the algorithm—I can look up and it's an hour and a half later. It's the closest thing to a modern-day opium den.
Scott Galloway
It's so fascinating.
Kara Swisher
I'm telling you, I watched an hour of Air Fryer content the other day, and I was like, "Stop, Kara." And I was happy. I was very happy, more so than being on Twitter. I was like, "I'm getting off of Twitter. I'm going on to TikTok." I have a burner phone. It was weird. It was weird.
Scott Galloway
I agree. But people are coming for them. In any case.
Kara Swisher
I could watch for hours. What is yours? Chiropractors adjusting people. Who would have known?
Scott Galloway
Oh, nice. Dogs, which I knew. And then very attractive people talking about systemic racism who forgot to put their bra on. I also find that just fascinating.
Kara Swisher
I find that really interesting. There is our entire relationship. I watch air fryer content and you watch chiropractors adjusting people.
That one I could see. I would have thought that. There's a guy in Chicago that can literally make your ankles and your hips.
Scott Galloway
I just had a chiropractor appointment and I was so happy. I got cracked in the neck. It was such a deep crack that the chiropractor did this: "Oh!" Like that, which was disturbing, but nonetheless, it was very pleasing.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, there we have it. Send us your questions. Go to nymag.com/pivot to submit your question for us, or call 855-51-PIVOT. The link is also in our show notes. Scott, that is the show. We'll be back for more on Friday.
Scott Galloway
That was a relatively Elon-free thing. I liked it. It was very nice.
Kara Swisher
Thank God. We talked about really important things. We'll be back. I'm sure something crazy will happen by then, but we'll see what happens. And we'll be back Friday for more. Scott, read us out.
Scott Galloway
Today's show was produced by Lara Neiman, Evan Engel, and Taylor Griffin. Ernie Injitat entered this episode. Thanks also to Drew Burroughs and Miel Severio. Make sure you subscribe to the show wherever you listen to podcasts. Thank you for listening to Pivot from New York Magazine, Vox Media. We'll be back later this week for another breakdown of all things tech and business.
Kara Swisher
Kara, I will see you on Thursday. Will you receive me? Will you receive the dog?
Scott Galloway
Thank you.