Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses various topics, including the New York Times' acquisition of The Athletic, Tesla's adaptation to the chip shortage, and the rise of authoritarianism in the US.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Kara Swisher
Not all journalism is the same. Take The Guardian. Our coverage has something unique. Fierce independence. Nobody owns us or tells us what we can and can't say. So we're free to report the whole picture. We connect what's happening in Washington to the rest of the globe. Expose corruption wherever we find it. And give fresh perspective on everything. From wellness and soccer to culture, the climate and more. Read, watch and listen to The Guardian for free at theguardian.com.
Scott Galloway
AI agents are getting pretty impressive. You might not even realize you're listening to one right now. We work 24-7 to resolve customer inquiries. No hold music, no canned answers, no frustration. Visit sierra.ai to learn more.
Kara Swisher
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Cara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And I'm Scott Galloway.
Kara Swisher
So what's going on, Scott?
Scott Galloway
I'm in Las Vegas, Cara.
Kara Swisher
Why are you in Vegas? Are you at CES?
Scott Galloway
Mostly for the prostitutes. No, I'm speaking here today. I'm speaking at a gig that I committed to six months ago, thinking, "Oh, Vegas, that'll be fun. The pandemic will be over."
Kara Swisher
Wait, is CES still going on? You didn't go to CES, correct?
Scott Galloway
No, I think CES was cut down to two days.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. I think CES is over.
Scott Galloway
Oh, I think so, too. I was over for a while before the pandemic.
Kara Swisher
But what are you speaking about in Vegas?
Scott Galloway
I'm doing my prediction stack for a cast of 1,100 people. I can't imagine 1,100 people coming to a conference in Vegas, much less to hear me talk about predictions. But here we are.
Kara Swisher
Here we are.
Scott Galloway
Here we are.
Kara Swisher
What did you do for fun in Vegas?
Scott Galloway
What did I do? I double-masked, did remote check-in, came to my room, and watched *The Morning Show*.
Kara Swisher
I like *The Morning Show*. Do you?
Scott Galloway
It's all about the pandemic, though, at the end. It's really fun. I got to admit it. I didn't like it. I was angry at how much money they spent and how marginal it was. And it's totally sucked me in.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. It's totally sucked me in.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. But you watched it.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. I've watched both seasons now. Let me just tell you, watch *Yellowstone*. Get onto the *Yellowstone* train.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, people. Get on the *Yellowstone* train.
Kara Swisher
I'm going to interview the creator.
Scott Galloway
I want to interview him. He's very good.
Kara Swisher
It's not like this whole thing about it being the Midwest. It's not the Midwest. It's like *Dynasty* over and over again. And he's terrific, I have to say.
Scott Galloway
Do you like Kevin Costner?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, the woman who plays his daughter, Beth, who's a real hot mess. She's fantastic. She's fantastic. Everybody is. It's really good. You'll like it. Watch it. You will not regret my recommendation.
Transition
But today, we're going to talk about the New York Times' bet on sports and Tesla coding its way out of the chip shortage. We'll speak to Jonathan Greenblatt of the Anti-Defamation League about authoritarianism. He has a new book out and why it may be here to stay. I don't think it ever left.
Music
But first, 2022 is off to a rocky start for tech shareholders. Prices are down Monday morning following a week of sinking numbers. This comes after CES, as you just mentioned, where the industry tries to impress with big announcements. It really is pointless at this point, actually. Both GameStop and Samsung say they'll launch NFT marketplaces. GameStop's stock briefly rose on the news, but it fell with other tech stocks on Monday. It doesn't even deserve to go up. Anyway, meanwhile, PayPal says it's exploring its own stablecoin backed by the U.S. dollar. A lot going on. But talk about the stock market. It's not my area of expertise, it is yours, comparatively.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I wouldn't describe it as my area of expertise. It's just something I play a stock expert on TV. But anyways, what people miss is that the stock market, people always look for some sort of underlying cause. I think it's two things. The thing they miss is that the bond market has a huge impact on stocks. Bonds have had such terrible risk-adjusted returns. You're basically getting negative rates factoring in inflation. Bond yields have been surging, which just makes them more attractive relative to stocks. People have been reallocating out of stocks into bonds. And then they think, "Well, what do I reallocate out of?" And I'm like, "I know. I'll pick stocks whose valuations make absolutely no sense and have also been at all-time highs."
Kara Swisher
That's right.
Scott Galloway
They just got so out in front of their skis, whether it was Virgin Galactic. My proxy for whether a stock could go down 80 or 90 percent is this: stocks trade on fundamentals—earnings or growth accelerate or decelerate. Technicals—sometimes a stock is oversold, overbought, or there's a short squeeze or a mob squeeze. And then the third, newer one, is the notion that it represents some sort of movement or new orthodoxy. The movement trade is unwinding like crazy.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, the Robinhood traders are done or what.
Scott Galloway
And you're just seeing these guys. GameStop at 120, but it could still go down another 80%. There's still a lot of air that could be let out of this balloon. People are just taking a moment.
Kara Swisher
Now, it's interesting because you talked about tech stocks being still the best investment going forward. Was that an opportunity to buy, as they say?
Scott Galloway
What I said last week was, if you're a venture capitalist or an investor, a diversified portfolio of tech investments at the seed stage and venture and growth stage—those vintage funds are just likely going to perform better because you can have a snowflake that might go up 80x. The tech trade... If you're like me and you're old and you're a boomer, you have certain truisms of the market. One of them is fundamentals—at some point, a stock is meant to be an underlying ownership in an asset that is supposed to return cash flows. Ultimately, it returns to that type of valuation. The other truism is cyclicality.
The US tech trade has been on fire for 12 or 13 years. I realize it's the future and there is tremendous innovation there. Instead of giving recommendations, I'll just say what I'm doing. I'm slowly but surely taking money off the table out of the tech trade, which has been the gift that keeps on giving for the last 13 years. I'm putting money in real estate because I think it's a more enduring trade. Psychologically, it's less taxing because you don't get a scorecard every day. And two, I'm investing in European and Latin American stocks because the thing we have learned through the markets is that at some point, flows do return to other sectors and flow out of even the hottest sectors.
The US tech trade at some point will run out of breath. Does that mean they aren't great companies and won't do really well? No. It means they just might be overvalued at this point.
Kara Swisher
What do you think about all these coins? Like Facebook coin, PayPal coin, these moves in that asset class? People are moving into them. Everywhere I go, like PayPal right now, I was just paying someone—a vendor and a cleaning lady, actually—on PayPal. And all of a sudden I was presented with "please buy these coins." And I was like, "Oh, hi. Nice to see you." It was interesting.
Scott Galloway
Say more. Who was?
Kara Swisher
PayPal. It was offering me a whole section now to buy and trade. I think Ethereum was on there, Bitcoin. I forget what else was on there. I didn't really look. I was like, "Huh, okay, sure." But then I thought about it. I sure did think about it. I know a lot of people have little bits and pieces of Bitcoin, et cetera.
Scott Galloway
Look, I think there's so much human capital and financial capital going into crypto that there's going to be a lot of enduring innovation. I like the fact that for the first time, the same proportion of people of color are investing. They've been drawn into that market. They like it. Young people like it. I think I made the mistake of infantilizing people who are investing in crypto early on. But the boomer in me emerges and says that Bitcoin has established itself in terms of scarcity credibility. It might be a new store of value. Ethereum is mentioned whenever you're talking about NFTs or smart contracts.
It reverse engineers to Ethereum as a protocol or the coin or the technology for a lot of these new innovations. I think the vast majority of these coins are going to zero. The nightmare scenario here, Kara, is that the communities that were incorporated into crypto and that everyone's advertising as a great egalitarian democratization of assets—my fear is a lot of this goes down 90%. And exactly the wrong people at exactly the wrong moment get hurt the hardest. My colleague Aswath Damodaran would say, "Scott, life lessons are the best regulators." I get it, but I think you're going to have a lot of young people and a lot of communities that are under the impression that you use leverage in these.
One thing I'm comfortable saying: never use leverage or margin to buy cryptocurrency. Also, don't be drunk. There's a study out there—59% of Gen Z investors trade while drunk.
Kara Swisher
Tell us about that article.
Scott Galloway
59% of Gen Z investors say they've traded while drunk. I don't know if it's true. And it widened out to all investors—the number only drops to 32%. So people trade while drunk.
Kara Swisher
Well, it's the same reason that people mate while they're drunk. Alcohol is a social lubricant. It lowers your inhibitions. So you'll go up and talk to that guy or gal you're attracted to. There's some benefit to that. But should you be lowering your inhibitions when you're trading stocks? I don't know if that goes anywhere good.
Transition
Speaking of which, Amazon workers now only get seven days of paid leave, down from 10 days. This policy change follows new guidance from the CDC. Obviously, Amazon's been hiring so many people. This comes as the U.S. is averaging around 650,000 new known cases per day, and 5 million U.S. workers were forced to stay home last week. It was crazy. My kids' school, Clara's school, three kids were there. Everywhere you go, whether it's garbage pickup or whatever this week, people are out. I didn't know we had it in our family. Now it's done, I guess. We'll see. But they say they have additional leave options in place for those who remain symptomatic, but they're cutting the time to keep people working. This is a really interesting challenge. Walmart, all the restaurants are suffering. Every city will see a story about restaurant workers or whatever. So what do you think about this? It will probably learn itself out in a short amount of time.
Scott Galloway
We all fall into a narrative that makes us feel better. The first narrative was, "Oh, it was going to take the summer off, small surge in the fall, and then be gone." And here we are two years later. The narrative I've adopted, and I'm really hoping, is that when you see infections up three and a half fold, but you see deaths flatter down—true, there is a lag—you're hoping that the virus does what a lot of viruses do towards the burnout phase: become more contagious but less lethal. In a certain way, we're giving people a lot of immunities. I'm very hopeful that we'll look back.
Kara Swisher
It's interesting. I said the same thing to my brother. I said, "Oh, I'm so sick. I'm just going to... what the hell? Deaths are down. If you're vaccinated, you're safer." And he goes, "Cara, you're not thinking of young children." They are certainly going in the hospital, not at rates compared to adults, but record hospitalizations. And then he said immunocompromised people. He made me feel bad. Dr. Swisher made me feel bad.
Scott Galloway
There's no doubt about it.
Kara Swisher
I really thought about it, and I wasn't a good citizen. I went out this weekend for the first time in a while, and I remember being in certain situations thinking, "I'm just not being a good citizen being here." I do think that when something becomes so contagious that the Chinese lockdown doesn't work, and at the same time it doesn't appear as lethal, there is some credence to the notion that we need to rethink the calculus around lockdowns. We have a really talented doctor on the board of my kids' school. She said, "I don't think we should be testing." I said, "Gosh, tell me more about why you think that." She said the lockdowns and the hysteria around kids is doing more damage than having kids infect each other. I was like, "Wow, walk me through that math." This is a thoughtful person.
Scott Galloway
Sounds very DeSantis to me, but go ahead.
Kara Swisher
I'm not a fan of DeSantis, but it is true that when the data changes, you need to change your calculus around what it means to have a lockdown. Ian Bremmer, the geopolitical rock star, basically said the Chinese extreme lockdown was the right way to go, and now it's absolutely the wrong way to go. But record hospitalizations—there's just no getting around it. I think you're seeing more of what Amazon is doing: "Just get back to work. It doesn't matter." There's very little patience now because there's a vaccination. Everyone that was doing this before there was a vaccination, I'm still saying "fuck you" for saying "get back to work."
But now there's a vaccination. People who can take it can take it. It's a really interesting moment because teachers aren't getting the same amount of gratitude from people. If they don't go to school, there's a big fight in Chicago. Some people I did not expect to tweet about it—I think it's Nicole Hannah-Jones—was like, "Just because we're saying you need to go back to school..." It was really interesting. People are coming down, especially people with kids, like, "Wait a minute, we're vaccinated. We did everything right." I recommend Dr. Wachter from UCSF. He did a whole thing on his own son getting sick and what he did.
He's been a prominent tweeter on this topic. Anyway, we'll see. I think most people will follow Amazon. If you're vaccinated, I think the Jared Polis thing is with people who are vaccinated. If you're unvaccinated, you are in very... do not do that to yourself and do not do that to other people.
Scott Galloway
How is your family? Most importantly, how is your family?
Kara Swisher
They're good. They're out of COVID prison. Clara and I and Louie continue to... we did test. She has to test for school. Negative. We'll see. We're pretty careful, but not demented. There's definitely a strain of too far on the careful side. I think that is problematic, but not as bad as the crazy unvaccinated people.
Music
Time for our first big story. 2022 is already looking like a big year for media. This is an interesting buy, which was long rumored. The New York Times will buy The Athletic for $550 million. The Athletic had 1.2 million subscribers as of November. Still, The Athletic is not profitable. I have some inside information on this, not from The Times, actually from other buyers. I talked to a bunch of other buyers. It previously pegged 2023 as the year that would change. In other news, Reddit may go public by March. It's seeking a $15 billion valuation. I've always liked that site. I thought it was fascinating.
And Parler, who I just interviewed, this new CEO George Farmer, has raised $20 million in new funding in that competitive space of free speech slash conservative. It is conservative. He was trying to pretend it wasn't, but it's all conservatives that are attached to it. So what do you think about this Athletic purchase? You were on the board of The New York Times. They're trying to do a subscription service in sports. They want to get to local sports. The question is whether these subscribers are very sticky, how much they came in on these discount rates, and what the Times can do for that. And then what's going to happen to the company, because there are a lot of people there with two sets of marketing people, two sets of this, two sets of that.
What do you think?
Scott Galloway
There's a lot here. I think both of us know too much. It's hard to read the label from inside the bottle. The New York Times are terrible acquirers. They acquired the Boston Globe for $1.1 billion. Ended up selling it for $70 million. They acquired About.com for $400 million. That was terrible. Sold it for a lot less. These acquisitions made no sense. This was when you were on the board.
Kara Swisher
Well, it was before. I mean, the reason I went on the board was like, "These things made no sense, divest them." We essentially bought the seventh tallest building in America. What the hell was the New York Times doing owning the seventh largest tallest building in America?
Scott Galloway
Anyways, it's a very strong culture. And the thing about sports... Wirecutter, we did well. That was a good purchase.
Kara Swisher
Did it? Yeah, I think it's doing well.
Scott Galloway
There are probably some examples. But the thing that triggered a memory for me was when you go on the board, the first thing they do is send you down to something called a Page One meeting that doesn't exist anymore. All the editors of the sections go around the table and pitch their idea for top of the fold, Page One. They're like, "Hillary Clinton, Africa." Then someone else says, "New legislation." And then I remember the sports guy trying to pitch this thing and everyone rolling their eyes like they were going to laugh at him. Sports did not get a lot of love at the New York Times.
Kara Swisher
But it does now. They got great sports.
Scott Galloway
But I kind of like this one because it's interesting. Newspapers used to be the bundlers. Now they're unbundling because they recognize that news and politics or current events can get that much money, but finance can, crypto can, sports can. A move to subscription is the way to go with niche, deep offerings.
Kara Swisher
So you were just doing a backhanded compliment there. You like this deal.
Scott Galloway
I do.
Kara Swisher
That was sort of shocking. That's almost a lot of their cash.
Scott Galloway
The New York Times, which came dangerously close to bankruptcy in 2008, has a billion dollars in cash on their balance sheet. They would either have to increase the dividend, do a stock buyback, or get on their toes. They buy it for like $500 a subscriber. But there's some scary stuff here. It's $50 or $60 million in revenue, $50 million in losses, which is real. They're going to have to increase it. I always thought my big idea when I was on the board was, "Take DealBook, put some more heft behind it, and make it charge $1,000 a year to be a thinking man's Bloomberg." The idea of unbundling niche offerings, subscription, value-added services, events, and charging people more... The New York Times in sports, we'll see. I wonder what the culture is like.
Kara Swisher
Well, they've done it in podcasting. They've made some very significant purchases—Serial and some others.
Scott Galloway
Serial?
Kara Swisher
But we don't know how... Vox is buying one. New York Times is buying others. It's interesting. I know Vox was interested. I know Vox looked at this one.
Scott Galloway
We couldn't afford it. Or didn't want to afford it, right?
Kara Swisher
Maybe there are other things to afford. That would have been a big bet-the-ranch bite for us.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, yeah.
Kara Swisher
In any case, you like this one. Just because you made bad purchases later doesn't mean you can't make good purchases now. So you like this one overall.
Scott Galloway
I think I heard that in this great show called *Yellowstone*. "We're going to buy those cattle. We're going to buy those steer." The steer moves around a lot in that show.
Kara Swisher
There's a lot of steer. *Yellowstone* is about this resort in Montana where the biggest douchebags in the world go for Christmas.
Scott Galloway
There is a whole stream of douchebag rich people making resorts. There's a character who does that. But get back to this. You think this could be a good deal. What would have to happen to make it a good deal?
Kara Swisher
If the New York Times can become the premier place that gets large margin subscriptions based on unbundled, focused niche offerings—whether it's DealBook, their crossword puzzle, their cooking—and then if they can establish credibility around sports. I like this. I think the founders of The Athletic were really bold. They hired a ton of sports journalists. They spent a ton of money thinking there's a market in this. They were playing chicken with the market because when you're losing $50 million bucks a year, that's pretty scary. Good for them. I love it when entrepreneurs who are journalists get taken out and said, "We're going to get the three best journalists covering the Green Bay Packers and pay them well.
And people are willing to pay for this." I think the New York Times, when they do their quarterly earnings call, can say, "We're the most robust subscription company in the world of aspirational, thoughtful, fact-checked, non-conspiratorial content." That's a good wrap. Whether or not they're able to execute—it's an executional thing. It'll be retention, the percentage of members that renew, and dollar renewal. Are they able to increase rates or layer on more services, tickets, additional content? I'm going to see the purchase of a lot more of these kinds of things. I think it's a great idea.
It's an interesting move. It's the first big move by Meredith Levien, who is the CEO. Maybe we'll be talking to her somewhere live with warm weather at some point soon.
Scott Galloway
Hello. Hello.
Kara Swisher
It's a big move by her. I'd love to hear more of their thinking about this. Execution is really the big deal here and changing a culture like the New York Times. It is a much slower moving culture. It has been in the past, as you know and I know. But it's an interesting move. It certainly is. And I think they kind of had to do it. I think they have to do stuff like this.
Scott Galloway
What about Reddit going public?
Kara Swisher
I'm an enormous fan of Reddit. I can't wait to read that S-1 because any content company that's able to exit the stranglehold of Google or Facebook is exciting. Reddit has gotten so much attention over the last year, whether it's meme stocks. People call it the front page of the internet. I would love to see the numbers in terms of their revenue and advertising. My first thought when I heard Reddit at $15 billion was that sounds cheap. I like that CEO Steve Huffman. I think he's terrific. Some people don't, but I do. He's always been a really interesting thinker. I've always enjoyed interviewing him several times.
And then Parler raising the money. I know nothing about that. What do you think of Parler?
Scott Galloway
I think they had to raise the money. It's fine. There's not enough people there. Everyone's got to be at this messy party. It's got to be a hot mess. None of them are. We'll see if they can offer something to their constituency. I just think young people aren't going to jump on these things, including Trump's Truth Social, which is expected to launch on President's Day. It's going to be a lot of Marjorie Taylor Greene screaming at each other. That's no fun.
Kara Swisher
Right. So we'll see. What's going to happen is there's going to be a lot more of these fundings and acquisitions in the media. This is the media space, no matter how you slice it. Parler is the media space. So is Reddit. I think there'll be cuts in staff. They're going to have to lay off people. You don't know if you're bringing these things together if they work, but you're going to see a lot more equity in this. We'll see if people will use it. I don't think young people are using these things. Conservatives are using them. I think they're using Twitter, if they're using it at all. There's a lot of them: Parler, Gettr, Trump Social, Rumble, others. I forget. There's Signal. I can't remember all of them. It's a lot. These are networks. How do you get to that network tipping point? I'm really interested to see what happens on day one of the Trump thing.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
And just what kind of attention. We're going on there. You and I are going to do it. We're going to wade right in there.
Scott Galloway
We're doing it? We're going behind enemy lines?
Kara Swisher
What's your name? What's your name going to be?
Scott Galloway
I'm Grandmaster Flash.
Kara Swisher
No, come on. Something dirty. I want something dirty.
Scott Galloway
Yes.
Kara Swisher
To see if they knock us off. First off, they'd be really nice to us. They'll be really cool to us, would be my guess. We should go on. Okay, we're signing up. Full names. We're going to go on.
Scott Galloway
I'm on Parler and Gettr. I'm not on Rumble because it's super noisy.
Kara Swisher
There's a secret dirty part of you that likes ultra-conservatives. You kind of occasionally... I can sense it with you. There's a weird...
Scott Galloway
No, I don't.
Kara Swisher
Oh, yeah. 100%. I speak to them as opposed to other people because I want to hear what they're saying. I used to always read when Focus on the Family was attacking gay people. I read everything they did. I want to know what they're up to.
Music
All right. We're going to take a quick break. And when we come back, we'll discuss Tesla and the chip shortage. And then we'll talk to a friend of Pivot about authoritarianism.
Ad Break
Avoiding your unfinished home projects because you're not sure where to start? Thumbtack knows homes, so you don't have to. Don't know the difference between matte paint finish and satin, or what that clunking sound from your dryer is?
With Thumbtack, you don't have to be a home pro. You just have to hire one. You can hire top-rated pros, see price estimates, and read reviews all on the app. Download today.
Ad Break
Support for Pivot comes from LinkedIn. From talking about sports, discussing the latest movies, everyone is looking for a real connection to the people around them. But it's not just person to person. It's the same connection that's needed in business. And it can be the hardest part about B2B marketing, finding the right people, making the right connections. But instead of spending hours and hours scavenging social media feeds, you can just tap LinkedIn ads to reach the right professionals. According to LinkedIn, they have grown to a network of over one billion professionals, making it stand apart from other ad buys. You can target your buyers by job title, industry, company roles, seniority skills, and company revenue, giving you all the professionals you need to reach in one place. So you can stop wasting budget on the wrong audience and start targeting the right professionals only on LinkedIn ads. LinkedIn will even give you $100 credit on your next campaign so you can try it for yourself. Just go to linkedin.com slash pivot pod. That's linkedin.com slash pivot pod. Terms and conditions apply. Only on LinkedIn ads.
Ad Break
Scott, we're back with our second big story. 2021's chip shortage made some surprising winners and losers. Toyota was America's top-selling automaker in 2021, taking the title from GM. Toyota's success is credited to a large stockpile of semiconductors, which helped it weather supply chain issues that hit the automotive industry last year. Meanwhile, Tesla adapted to the chip shortage by rewriting its software so it could run on different chips. Elon Musk has done a soup to nuts kind of supply chain at Tesla, which a lot of people thought was terrible. And it turned out to be a good thing during this supply chain shortage.
It manufactures its own chips, writes its own software, something that people used to make fun of. And the idea of having vendors was another thing. People made fun that they didn't have enough vendors. So what do you think about all this? It's not like it's perfectly good news for Musk. There was actually a complimentary store in the New York Times, but he also had to recall half a million vehicles and some other stuff that was happening. Showcase tunnel beneath Vegas was clogged with traffic during CES, for example. But this was a win by him. So what do you think, Scott?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, as much as I'd like to criticize someone who criticizes me, I just don't think he can get around it. I think what they've pulled off here is remarkable and visionary. And I just always go back to this, what was supposed to be an absolute of business strategy. And that was the notion promoted by Sikha Prahala, University of Michigan. And that was core competence. And that is you do one thing really well and you outsource everything else. And the last 20 or 30 years, the most impressive companies in the world have been in a lesson in why that is absolutely not true. And even Apple kicking out Intel, everyone totally questioned that.
And they started producing their own microprocessors, and they're like, our point of differentiation and our user interface and the way we interact with software is so unique that we need to process the brain here. And to outsource the brain means our differentiation will be commoditized. And if you look at the Wintel environment in terms of the margins they get versus the company that made the, quote, unquote, business crazy strategy of going total vertical, it's just increased verticalization. And the notion that they weren't a subject to this chip shortage because they were able to go into other chips and reprogram them to supplant or basically to plug holes in other chip shortages.
I mean, there's just no good around it. It's fucking genius.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, this story in the Times is really interesting. And this is a key line, I thought. Just a few years ago, analysts saw Elon Musk's insistence on having Tesla do more things on its own as one of the main reasons the company was struggling to increase production. And Musk did talk about that. He talked about it in an interview lots of places. Now his strategy appears to have been vindicated. And then one quote, Tesla controlled its destiny, I think, on critical things it did. And he's a perfectionist in a lot of the ways that Steve Jobs was. It's interesting. Like, they have to do it this way.
And this is the way we do it. It's a common trait, which can be much pilloried. And, you know, the whole idea of this whole vendor, they sell the cars themselves. There's not like they don't have to deal with, you know, franchises and this and that. And it's just everything they do is we are making the entire biscuit right here. And I think it's an interesting and, you know, it may switch. A lot of people in my comments said, and then it's going to switch back, you know, where vendors will be better. But one of the person who was responding said he's been playing chess while most of us were playing checkers.
Scott Galloway
I commend Elon Musk for having a boatload of foresight. There's just not getting it right. If you look at the automobile manufacturers, they're really not manufacturers, they're assemblers. And that has really come to haunt them in a supply chain crisis. And if you look at the most successful retailers, they've also gone fully vertical, whether it's Lululemon, which makes its own materials and has its own stores, its own distribution. If you look at Amazon, they've gone vertical in what's appeared to be crazy, and that is they've forward integrated into the actual fulfillment and delivery and last mile.
If you look at the other side of retail that's just done exceptionally well, at the high end, the luxury end. So, Gucci acquired or purchased a Python farm so they could control the quality of their bags. But that's where it's going. The firms that want to maintain differentiation and margin are going vertical. And then the ability to control your destiny and not be subject to the whims of supply chain interruption. I'm blown away, Cara. I'm blown away. I'm a reticulated python of IQ right now. Regardless of how we feel about him. Personally, one has to admit the guy thinks and solves problems differently.
Kara Swisher
Oh, no doubt. No doubt. So what others thought – perhaps we shouldn't be surprised. Clayton Christensen argued in one of his earlier papers that when performance was not yet good enough, the integrated manufacturer had the advantage. And it's true. This was the early times of these cars. So I think it's just interesting. I think it was, I got a lot of really interesting responses. Someone called the New York Times piece a grudging vindication. Is this a grudging vindication from you? I think it was your phrasing.
Scott Galloway
No, it's not a grudging vindication. I just don't get it. Look, the definition of intelligence is your ability to hold two contrary thoughts in your mind at the same time. Brilliant man, amazing company, fucking wildly overvalued stock, and at some point his inner child will develop an outer man. I can hold all of those thoughts in my head at the same time and so can you.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, yeah, yeah. Last thing I'm going to read. These comments were so good. Vertical integration is very hard and bloody expensive to set up. But once it's there, you have full control and can adjust to changes very quickly. It's a complex but comparable version of having feature teams in Agile. So anyway, interesting time. And then Toyota, let's not leave out Toyota. They were also, it's an Agile company.
Scott Galloway
It's an Agile company.
Kara Swisher
And it's still the top selling. I mean, compared to Tesla, it's so much bigger. So both companies And actually I almost bought a Toyota Because they were available too Because everyone was trying to buy cars And at the same time their cars were great Both at the same time You have very strange taste in cars
Scott Galloway
I do. I'm not down with your taste in cars.
Kara Swisher
I don't even have to drive the Kia down to your house in Florida And just park it out front and embarrass you That's what I'm going to do I'm going to park it right out front The Kia
Scott Galloway
You know what I did? I'm so angry I am so angry that Elon Musk got to my 11 year old who asked me what a numbskull meant. I have a Tesla and I banged up the front fender in a small parking mishap. And I'm not going to fix it. I'm going to put like duct tape on it like teenagers do with no money. Like when I had no money and I bang up my car, I just put like a sticker over it or something. I've got one of those, I've ordered one of those roof signs from Hooters. I'm going to put it on my Tesla. I'm going to take that brand down single-handedly, Kara.
Kara Swisher
Actually, one thing a friend of mine who has a Tesla, who loves Tesla, is that the service stuff is harder, found it harder at the time. Maybe this is because it was Silicon Valley and everybody's got one, but she was having issues around that. Anyway, interesting times. And again, you know, they're going to have problems. They did have to recall things on, there's a couple little things that were problematic. And obviously he's still going to struggle with accidents that happen as people move into autonomous. But I have to say, impressive, impressive, impressive, as I say. No getting around it.
Scott Galloway
It says I'm too nice to him. Well done. Stock's so wildly overbelly. Sorry, can't help it. Can't help it. You numbskull. Can't help it. Insufferable. Insufferable. You insufferable numbskull.
Kara Swisher
Okay, let's bring in our friend of Pivot. Jonathan Greenblatt is the CEO of the Anti-Defamation League. He previously served as special assistant to President Obama and the director of the Office of Social Innovation, whatever that is. He can explain that. His new book, It Could Happen Here, Why America is Tipping from Hate to the Unthinkable and How We Can Stop It, is out now. Tell us what you're thinking about with this terrible title. And I don't mean terrible, bad. I mean, ooh.
Jonathan Greenblatt
No. I mean, I think, look, we are in a – I think we have reached a perilous moment in our country's history. You know, the ADL has been fighting hate for over 100 years, and yet I don't think we've ever seen a time quite like this. I think oftentimes we talk about anti-Semitism as the canary in the coal mine. for society, and it's a sign of decay. And indeed, in the last few years, there have been multiple symptoms of a kind of social decay that I think have reached an alarming crescendo. And to be speaking now kind of in the shadow of the one anniversary of January 6th is just no accident
Kara Swisher
So explain what unthinkable is Explain what you what is unthinkable because hate is bad enough right And that something you spend a lot of time and you and I have talked about it in the past. We have. So what is, what's the difference from hate to the unthinkable?
Jonathan Greenblatt
I think the unthinkable for me speaks to the total, the total breach of our social fabric. It is the unraveling of what we know today. And, you know, there's been talk and by the experts, like we interviewed Greg Stanton for the book. I spoke to him. He's an expert in genocide who says that all the indicators are telling us that this country is at a place where it never has been vis-a-vis the risk to marginalized communities. I spoke to Barbara Walter, a professor out on the West Coast, who talks about the fact that all the indicators suggest that we might be closer to a kind of civil war than we've seen in the past.
And it doesn't need to look like the North versus the South, and I don't think it would. It might look a lot more like the Troubles in Northern Ireland. And I talked to folks in St. Louis from the Bosnian-American community who talk about what happened to them. I mean, keep in mind that before Yugoslavia dissolved, it was a very successful, you know, pluralistic society where you had different ethnicities and different religions living side by side for hundreds and hundreds of years. But, you know, Kara, for me personally, these issues hit home much closer to that. So I'm the grandson of a Holocaust survivor from Germany who spoke to me before he passed my grandfather, who I dedicated the book to, about the fact that when he was a young man growing up in Germany, it was the only country he had ever known.
His family traced their lineage back generations. My great-grandfather fought in the First World War. And he never could have imagined that, again, that his homeland would turn on him, destroy everything that he ever loved, slaughter almost all of his family and friends, and send him fleeing to this country. And I am the husband of a political refugee from Iran, also Jewish, whose family traced their lineage back hundreds, they would say thousands of years, to the Babylonian exile. and they never would have imagined before the Islamic revolution that the only country they ever knew would turn on them, regard them as enemies of the state and force my wife to flee and her family to flee and come to this country.
So I think my wife's experience, my grandfather's experience tells me that all this, the only thing we have ever known, There is no natural law that tells us it will last forever. So the American experiment is breaking down. And look, I will be honest, like I am someone who believes in American exceptionalism. I think this country for its first 250 some odd years has been a light unto the world. And we haven't gotten everything right. But the ability to iterate and evolve is unique in human history. But, you know, again, all the indicators that I see from ADL, doubling of anti-Semitic incidents, steady increase in hate across the board, the coursing of the public conversation, deepening gridlock in D.
C., which I've seen up close and personal, all suggest to me that, again, we've reached a really perilous moment.
Scott Galloway
It's so nice to meet you. I really do appreciate all your work, Jonathan. I think it's such important work. And we have this cold comfort that it couldn't happen here. And if you look at which is absolutely not true, if you look at Germany, pre-World War II was this incredibly advanced, cosmopolitan, science driven, educated. There was a formidable gay rights movement in Germany pre-World War II. And then it digresses fast. And there's always a playbook, right? It's a strong man propped up by conservatives who usually think they're going to be able to control this person. And then it gets out of hand and we go to very dark places.
The thing I don't think gets enough attention. And this really is a question and a comment. is that the incendiary here is income inequality and specifically young men who aren't doing well, not attaching to relationships, not attaching to school, not attaching to work, that are prone to conspiracy theory. And then a strong man comes along and says, this isn't your fault, rise up. Have you thought about in America, relatively speaking, that young men are just doing so poorly relative to past cohorts, that that is a huge existential crisis, that that could lead us to a very dark place?
Jonathan Greenblatt
Well, I think it's certainly true that persistent economic inequities and the kind of inability to fulfill this long-held notion of the American dream, at least in the conventional way in which it's been thought about and sort of mythologized, contribute to a kind of animus that is growing, Scott, and that's building. I would actually say, though I don't think it's unique to young men. I mean, the reality is if you look at, for example, the people who, and by the way, not young men, nor necessarily like the unemployed. If you look at the people who were marauding through the Capitol a year ago, there were a large number of small businessmen and kind of people with no criminal records, middle class and married.
We found at ADL that 21% of them had known white supremacist ties of the people who were arrested. which is kind of galling, by the way. You'd see such a critical mass of them show up in public. But the more frightening thing is the 80% who had no extremist ties whatsoever. I mean, so there's a radicalization that I think is happening, and it's not delimited to one subset of the population. I think it's a working class issue. I think it is a geographically distributed issue. But I think a lot of the people who watch Fox and a lot of the people who believe this baloney don't necessarily fit to the stereotypical way that we've thought about those who are prone to radicalization.
Kara Swisher
So you mentioned Fox and the perception is it's Fox and then Trump with that that's just arrived. Is that accurate or where do you see the sources? And obviously you and I have talked a lot about social media, which has been a problem. That's been the recent thing that sort of set people off to the edge. So can you, where do you imagine it comes from? Also, we have been authoritarian in the past. It just has been more effective for the people in power than anything else.
Jonathan Greenblatt
So, yeah, I think there are a couple things on that. I mean, number one, vis-a-vis what's driving this, again, the economic inequities, but I do think our media culture, all right, it can fuel the fire. And we certainly see that here. We've talked about Fox before. I've been very public in my back and forth with Lachlan Murdoch. I mean, freedom of speech, you know, as our mutual friend, Sasha Baron Cohen talks about, never equated in American history to freedom of reach. And so, you know, iHeartRadio and Bob Pittman have a lot of podcasts. But when they choose to privilege Steve Bannon, you know, with their platform, they're making editorial decision.
Steve Bannon can say whatever he wants. The question is, where does he find sustenance? Same with Tucker Carlson, Sean Hannity, Laura Ingram, and The Ilk. I think Fox, we will look back in history and see Fox as our Pravda. But the problem is that it is indeed Facebook, which is a kind of accelerant for all of this anti-Semitism, racism, and bigotry. And it has done more to fuel the fire than I think anything else. And that's not uniquely an American phenomenon. We know what their platform and their products have done in places like India, Myanmar, other parts of Europe have been well-documented.
But here in particular, Facebook, again, today, we could literally share a screen and we could find examples of armed militia groups who they're continuing to algorithmically amplify in ways that boggle the mind. And I think the lack of any government oversight. And I say this as somebody who, as we've talked about here, like, look, I come from the industry. I worked in this space. And I'm someone who believes in self-regulation almost reflexively. but Mark Zuckerberg has proven to me again and again and again and again that that no longer works when you have a company that puts in his own words, you know, company over country.
Kara Swisher
And you guys, but you guys tried, right? You tried with your effort with other groups with color change. We tried and we tried.
Jonathan Greenblatt
Well, look, there's a couple of things with, with our interaction with Facebook. Like we initially tried to be very embracing and inclusive because again, I think you've got to work with industry. If we're relying on these senators with their hotmail email addresses to regulate, you know, quantum computing and crypto, God help us. And yet, you know, although we tried to be inclusive in the conversation with Facebook, they failed again and again and again, and just seemed to be when Mark made his comments about the fact that he thinks there's a legitimate perspective that maybe the Holocaust didn't happen. That was a bit of a sort of, that was a bit of a tell.
Scott Galloway
He was on with some hack journalist when he said that, right? I know what he was talking about. John called me almost immediate. And he's like, what? Look at Kara smiling. Look at Kara smiling.
Kara Swisher
I'm not smiling.
Scott Galloway
And she gave him, Kara, you gave him the chance to walk it back.
Kara Swisher
Oh, I did. You're like, oh, is that really what you meant to say? Yeah.
Jonathan Greenblatt
But all that being said, you know, that's why we launched Stop Hate for Profit, you know, with the NAACP and Color of Change.
Kara Swisher
Did you consider that successful in any way?
Jonathan Greenblatt
I did consider that successful because what we did there, look, we never thought we were going to get businesses to pull off the most sophisticated targeting platform in the history of advertising. What we wanted to do was bring to bear reputational pressure. And that worked. And I think that sort of, for the first time, set them back on their heels. And they did classify Holocaust denialism as hate speech after that. They did take down a lot of white supremacist groups. They did agree to work with the World Federation of Advertisers on a bit of an audit for the first time. So they made some concessions, but they're, you know, trillions of dollars later. You know, I mean, their last quarter was, I think, 29 billion and counting. So they are so big. They are such a behemoth that we've got to do more if we really want to put a dent in the issue.
Scott Galloway
I would argue, and I say this collectively, like I use the term we as a collective that see the problem here are threatened by it. I don't think it's working. I think these advertiser boycotts, the Facebook advertiser base of three or five million is the most elastic, resilient business advertising base in history. And while some will signal stuff and say they're getting off for 30 days, it's a monopoly. They don't have a choice. My sense is Facebook will do just enough to get you to compliment them and other organizations short term. But I don't see anything resembling long term intention to change.
I think it's actually getting worse. And so what I'll ask is what will be required to have sustained change, not stuff that feels like window dressing? Is it identity like LinkedIn? My sense is there's not nearly as much of this hateful speech on LinkedIn because it enforces identity. Is it? And by the way, it's not just Facebook. Twitter's pretty bad around this stuff, too. Is it reconnecting as we do with every other media company? liability that if there's a hate crime, the media platform that inspired it bears some responsibility? What are the solutions? Because so far, I would argue, what we're doing isn't working.
Jonathan Greenblatt
So I think there are a few things I would suggest. So I'll give you three kind of tactical things and then a big strategic thing. Tactically, number one, I do think anonymity, while it provides so much good in so many ways to that, you know, that young person questioning their sexual identity and afraid to be open about it, right? Or to that domestic abuse person who needs an outlet. On the other hand, anonymity has allowed the worst elements in society, and not even just people, trolls and, I mean, the software bots that drive it, a kind of shield they never had before. And I do think, Scott, that has coarsened the conversation dramatically and contributed to the situation.
So number one, if you were smart about how you remove anonymity, it could help dramatically. I think number two, I am a big proponent of reforming Section 230. I think the lack of liability is part of the reason why the companies behave the way they do. And I think I've used the example with you before, Kara. Look, if you look at the way J&J handled the aspirin crisis, right? That was the Tylenol crisis, right? We know what they did after a few bottles were tampered with because they were liable. And we know, I mean, I often use the Oduala example. Oduala was a small juice company in the Bay Area, right?
They had a situation where a young toddler died because their product was not flash pasteurized. They took every bottle off every shelf in America and reformulated their production process because they were liable. Like, I don't want to say that Greg Steltenpoll, and I don't want to say that the J&J leadership didn't have some moral compass, but they were reliable. James Burke was a fantastic CEO too, like who had a lot of moral background. So, so, you know, let me give you, if I might, let me give you the third thing I think we really need to do. And this runs counter to what we've been believed.
Again, we think this is some natural law of the internet. I think we need to slow it down. Like, why is it that when I hit post, the post immediately goes up? Like there's a six second delay or seven second delay on broadcast television for a reason. And I think even delaying it, you know, we had the person who rampaged through the mosques in Christchurch was live streaming it. This is crazy. And I don't think there's any need for that. So I think if you slowed it down, if you made them liable, if you remove the shield of anonymity, but ultimately I also think a lot about what my friend Roger McNamee talks about, which I think you got to break them up.
I mean, I think they are so big. And I worry deeply about Mark's vision of an encrypted backend across WhatsApp and Oculus, let alone Messenger. I think you got to break it up because if they were smaller, they didn't have so much dominance, it'd be much harder for them to do what they do.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. But hey, don't you want to get in the metaverse or try Supernatural? Come on, what's wrong with you? They like to change the subject. So talk about the bigger thing. Obviously, you and I and Scott all are in violent agreement about this idea of what social media does. But what is some of the – give me the worst-case scenario if, say, Trump gets back in office or – he doesn't even have to at this point, I think, in a lot of ways. I think he's just a sort of – not a figurehead precisely.
Jonathan Greenblatt
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
What's the worst-case scenario? What's the best-case scenario from your perspective? And then Scott might have a final question.
Jonathan Greenblatt
I think the best case scenario would be the Democrats are able to sway some kind of Republicans with a moral conscience to pass some voter, to pass some legislation that would stop the voter suppression and would enable a more open Democratic system to persist and prevail. Because that's not where we are right now. I think you would reform big tech. I think you would literally make it easier for people to vote. And I think that would avert what could be a catastrophic situation. I also think a lot about Supreme Court justice reform, whether it's term limits or expanding the court. What's the worst case situation?
Kara, I think it's pretty bad. I don't think it's crazy to imagine that whether it's Trump or one of his kind of acolytes, I always worry about Tucker Carlson and some of the others who are far more sophisticated and just smart than former President Trump. But I think they win. I think certain kind of speech like this kind of speech could suddenly become too dangerous. It could become illegal. I think you could have martial law light imposed, make it difficult for people to assemble if they're deemed to be doing something dangerous to the public good. Like in Kazakhstan right now. It's like this is not so crazy.
And I also think you could make it the gerrymandering that we've seen. You could institute some of that more permanently. So you could make it difficult, as we've seen Viktor Orban do very effectively in Hungary. Hungary is still ostensibly a democracy, but he shut down certain press outlets saying they're dangerous to the public interest. He's made it difficult for people to assemble and exercise freedom of expression. And he has also kind of hardened the electoral laws to make it difficult for the opposition to mount any kind of challenge to him. By the way, that's also Erdogan's playbook in Turkey.
I think those are very reasonable outcomes. And the third thing I also think is real is what you saw happen in Israel under Bibi Netanyahu, impugning and intimidating the judiciary, making it impossible for judges to do their job. So I think all that's very real.
Kara Swisher
On that happy note, Scott gets the last question.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, well, I'm not going any happier. I went to the Kigali Genocide Memorial in Rwanda and the thing that struck me was that there are just few things that we as a society or we as a species are better at than genocide You know we talk about the middle of the 20th century, but it just, it happens every 10 or 20 years. No matter how evolved we think we are, we talk about, you know, coming together and not letting stuff happen again. It just happens over and over. And the question I would have for you as someone who's very knowledgeable on the topic. Is there a prophylactic? Is there a way to vaccinate against genocide against this? It just keeps happening. It's a hard question.
Jonathan Greenblatt
Yeah. Because I don't think there's any silver bullet.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Jonathan Greenblatt
That may be the most difficult realization of all. Like, I think many of us would like to entertain the fantasy that democracy is a silver bullet. It's not.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, agreed.
Jonathan Greenblatt
And democracy is a democracy is not a spectator sport that you can watch from the bleacher seats, you know, from the, and just from the bleachers and the cheap seats, like, yeah, everything will work out fine. Democracy requires all of us to get engaged and get involved. It's not education either. There's these tropes that, yeah. So I think we have to be involved, Scott, whether you're voting or volunteering or running for dog catcher. I mean, I think you got, like that old lotto commercial, you got to be in it to win it. And I think our civic muscles have atrophied, right? You know, Tip O'Neill, you say all politics are local. Now it's like as if all politics were national. And I watch what Jesse Waters is saying and I somehow believe it to be true. As crazy as that sounds, right?
So the reality is local matters, rolling up your sleeves and engaging matters. And I think if people don't play that, don't realize that it's a contact sport, democracy, and it happens around the corner from where you live, then I think that's the only way we can.
Kara Swisher
You forget because you're safe where you are. It's absolutely true. And then the comfortable stay comfortable and the less comfortable become extraordinarily less comfortable.
Jonathan Greenblatt
But I will say that's really why I wrote the book, because we've seen this happen, to your point, in Africa, in Europe, in the Middle East in the last 50, 60, 70 years. It's not a history lesson. It's present day. Look at what happened to the Rohingya and the Yazidi in the last five years. So I think it's incumbent upon us to engage. And there are strategies and there are tactics that we can use to stop hate when it happens here at home. Last thing I'll say, dehumanization, which we see happening now, this is one of the things that Trump has really imported into the public conversation. We all can stop that. We, you, me, can push back on that when it happens at the water cooler, in the locker room, at the dinner table. And I think that's the first step to kind of reversing the time.
Kara Swisher
That was one of the key steps of Nazism. It was. Dehumanization was right up at the top in lots of ways, in cartoons and public – the way you call people. People say, ah, it doesn't really matter. Nicknames, have a sense of humor. And then it makes you feel bad. Some things people could have a sense of humor on, but not stuff like that. Anyway, Jonathan, you're a depressing man. But everybody should – Doing important work. ADL is doing important work. It's one of the first groups that really had contacted me about these issues around Facebook was the ADL. And in fact, I used the ADL as an example when I went to YouTube to complain about the anti-Semitic videos on there. You know, how it was just rising and you could see it happening. In any case, you're doing great work. Keep at it, Jonathan. And again, his book is called *It Could Happen Here: Why America is Tipping from Hate to the Unthinkable and How We Can Stop It*. So let's stop it.
Break in conversation
All right, Scott, one more quick break. Boy, what do you think of that interview, huh? I'm bummed again.
Scott Galloway
He's exactly right, though. Just this notion that it couldn't happen here. We kind of did – genocide's a terrible word. But we locked up – we imprisoned behind barbed wire thoughtful, law-abiding citizens that were Japanese only 75 years ago. We put them in camps. What if the Japanese had split the atom first and they started drawing atom bombs? Wouldn't we have moved to genocide pretty quickly? So the notion that it can happen here, if you look at the worst genocides in history, they tend to have a lot in common with what America looks like now. Exceptional nationalism, income inequality, propping up strongmen, a dissatisfied underclass from income inequality or economic underclass, a consolidation of media. I mean, there's just a lot of conservatives believing that they can control a strong man for economic interests. There's a lot of things lining up that just feel very uncomfortable. And we should remove any notion, and Jonathan, I think, does this really effectively, of thinking that it can't happen here. Oh, yeah, it can. And it's happened in very similar societies.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, yep, agreed, agreed. That's quite the speech. And I'm in Vegas. Yeah, in Vegas. Did I mention I'm in Vegas? As long as we have Vegas. Hey, what do we care? Like, that's what I feel like. I'm here with Jerry Lewis and seven prostitutes. Hello, Vegas. Jerry Lewis. All right, Scott, one more quick break. We'll be back for wins and fails.
Ad break
All right, Scott, let's go to wins and fails. Scott, I'm going to go first. Bob Saget.
Scott Galloway
Oh, my God. I love Bob Saget.
Kara Swisher
You like? Tell me about it. I was really shocked at the outpouring of affection for him. Because he's, like, I love when he was, like, I watched that show. I secretly, I didn't secretly. I love the Olsen twins. I like everything about them. And I also like the other Olsen, who's Elizabeth Olsen, who's so manifestly talented. I always liked him. And then I liked when he went dirty. Like, I liked he had a whole thing with the aristocrats or whatever. And I just liked his whole vibe. And let me just tell you, I've never seen such an outpouring of so many different people who do not agree on anything, agreeing on the kindness of him from Don Stewart to Kathy Griffin to like it was dozens and dozens of comics that all were very different people and don't get along, I would say. All like Bob Saget. And the suddenness and of course, the ghouls of anti-vaxxers are coming out saying he said he got a booster. He was joking about it on one of his podcast things or whatever, blaming it on the booster and then linking it to Betty White getting a booster. I just literally like go get away from Bob Saget, you people. I literally like get your –
Scott Galloway
Yeah, that's what happened. Diseased mitts off of Bob Saget.
Kara Swisher
People are dropping dead in CVS after the boosters. Coincidence? He got a booster three weeks ago. I was like coincidence? He had water. Like, what is wrong with you to take this guy's lovely comic legacy and do that? I really like Bob Saget, I have to say. And very funny. When he went blue, oh, man, was he funny. Was he funny? Anyway. Bob Saget, rest in peace. Rest in peace.
Scott Galloway
When?
Kara Swisher
Oh, I watched *Cobra Kai*. It was fantastic. So good. The guy who plays Johnny is so funny. So funny. I am so pleased with *Cobra Kai*, this new season. And I can't even tell you. It's wonderful. They're all wonderful. Every one of them.
Scott Galloway
Thank you. That's great. Who do you watch *Cobra Kai* with?
Kara Swisher
Amanda loves it.
Scott Galloway
Amanda, who is like real fancy on her literature, fancy person.
Kara Swisher
Don't. Amanda hates that you've said that.
Scott Galloway
I know, but she is fancy. But she likes this a lot. She loves *Cobra Kai*. There was one line they did, and she's like, that was brilliant. You come down to my place, I want to watch *Cobra Kai*. Instead, you queue up the great Boston art heist. And I'm like, really? That's what we're in for here? We'll find something good. That's what we're in for here. Anyway, *Cobra Kai*. I love *Cobra Kai*. Please watch the next season. It's really good.
Kara Swisher
I thought they might falter, but they have not. Because you run out of hijinks for these kids. But they've introduced this adorable young kid who's getting beaten up by Daniel's son, actually, at school. So it's very ironic. And this kid is just so winning and fantastic. Anyway.
Scott Galloway
Was Elizabeth Shuback?
Kara Swisher
She was. I don't know if she's coming back. I'm doing them slowly, like fine wine. I'm doing it once a night. I'm not binging it. Anyway, go ahead, Scott.
Scott Galloway
I'm not sure fine wine and *Cobra Kai* have been in the same sentence.
Kara Swisher
I believe Amanda was drinking fine wine when we were watching it.
Scott Galloway
Well, there we go. My win is someone I've made or been critical of, but I just can't help it. I just love Jack Dorsey's tweets.
Kara Swisher
Oh, yeah.
Scott Galloway
And I think they're really insightful about Web3. He wrote, "The VCs and their LPs will never escape their incentives. It's ultimately a centralized entity with a different label. Know what you're getting into." And I've been thinking a lot about this. Whenever you have overvalued companies or these great new orthodoxies, whether it's democratization or which is nothing but I'm going to figure out a way to depress young men or the new one is decentralization.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. And it's such bullshit. It plays into this idea of like you have your own fate. It plays into this sort of crazy nationalism in a weird way.
Scott Galloway
Well, and that's a weird form of a libertarian. When VCs are talking about decentralization, what they want to say is we want to shift the shareholder value from J.P. Morgan to us. And we want regulatory arbitrage and we don't want to be constrained by Sarbanes-Oxley. And when you're talking about decentralization, you're talking about technology that is largely financed and influenced by people whom 40% have come from two universities, Stanford and Harvard.
Kara Swisher
I could not agree with you more. 70% of their capital allocation is from people with the same mentality and the same reason why concierge medical services are overfunded, but we can't get prenatal care funded. And this notion that it's somehow libertarian. No, it's not. It's a bunch of guys. Elon Musk moves markets. That's centralization. When the majority of stable coins have a disproportionate amount of insiders who still are not stable coins, the majority of crypto has a disproportionate amount of insiders controlling these coins. This is the opposite of decentralization. It's centralization to a bunch of people who want to create this myth that somehow they're getting power to the people. They love to do that. You know what? Honestly, let me just say I know all these people. You're better off with Jamie Dimon.
Scott Galloway
And Jamie Dimon is regulated. It's all, whenever you hear the term decentralization, it's a bunch of white guys that look, smell, and feel more like any organizations in the world, more centralization of thought, who are looking to become billionaires by creating shit that cannot be, it is not regulated, and want to centralize power. This is the opposite of –
Kara Swisher
I would just say, though, there is a really good essay that people should read by Moxie Marlinspike, who was the founder of the Signal app, who wrote a really good – it's very technical. And again, I got lost several times. It's called "My First Impressions of Web 3." And I thought it was really interesting. And he – just listen. We'll talk about it next week maybe because I think it was really interesting. He's sort of in the Jack door. Jack, look, I found it via Jack, actually. Which I thought was interesting. So, yes, you're right. I think Jack has really become untethered now that he can do what he wants. He was always like that when you encountered him before. He was always very thoughtful. I love his stuff. I think it's really insightful.
Scott Galloway
Very thoughtful, man. It's catalyzed a lot of my thinking around, this isn't decentralization. It's centralization of a bunch of white guys that want more power and more money under the fake myth of decentralization. Anyways, that's my win. Jack's tweets. My fail is I've been thinking a lot about unlocks and opposition as a fail, but I do think it's a huge opportunity, is just our fetishization, our continued fetishization of incarceration. The U.S. spends about $90 billion a year on prisons, more than we spend on the DOJ, the IRS, the EPA, and NASA combined. In most G7 nations, they average between 50 and 200 people per 100,000 incarcerated.
We're at 700. We're up there with the worst autocracies in the world. About half of the people incarcerated in state prisons in 2015 were convicted of non-violent drug property or other public order crimes. And there's just a huge opportunity when states reduce their prison populations, crime rates actually fall faster than the national average. Between 1999 and 2012, New York and New Jersey downsized their prison populations by 26% and violent crime dropped 31% and 30% respectively. COVID spread four times faster in prisons than it did in cruise ships. So we released 20% of our federal prisoners.
And when I think about young men feeling, I think we need to put more nonviolent men back in low-income households. When I look at the money we spend, when I look at what a poor reflection is on our society, it's the for-profit motive that we've put into prisons has resulted in incredible damage to certain communities. And I think it's a huge opportunity to take—
Kara Swisher
You know who agrees with you? The Koch brothers.
Scott Galloway
Gigantor. Oh, White LeBron, Vanilla Bron?
Kara Swisher
Vanilla Bron. This is an issue he talks about with me all the time.
Scott Galloway
Well, it's an exciting opportunity. And I want to be clear, you can't just let these guys out into society. But if you want to talk about what you would do with those savings, put it into vocational programming. We need more trained workers. We need, you know, what John McWhorter got me thinking, you need to, in my view, discourage but decriminalize drugs so you reduce the economic incentive for people who don't have great opportunities to get into these industries. And also, we just need more men back in these communities. And I'm not suggesting we put violent men back into households, but the level of incarceration in our household means that either Americans are just born criminal or something's come off the tracks here.
And I think a huge unlock, and if you look at what they did with releasing these prisoners because of COVID at the federal level, and when you've had programs to let out nonviolent criminals, a lot of good things happen. And I hope that this is something that we take as an opportunity coming out of COVID, that we need to rethink incarceration, decriminalize the reason so many of them are in prison. But I think it could be a huge unlock for low-income communities, a reduction in federal spending, and just quite frankly, a righteous movement. And we keep talking about it, but it doesn't happen on a major level.
Anyways, my fail is America's continued fetishization with incarceration, but I think it could be a huge opportunity for us coming out of COVID.
Kara Swisher
I like that, Scott Galloway. That's a very serious one. Well, you and Gigantor can discuss it when we come down and stay with you. Let's go to something lighter like genocide.
Scott Galloway
Genocide.
Kara Swisher
I know. This is a bummer. Well, you know what? Soon we'll be down in Miami, and then I'm bringing the whole family down there. So we'll have a whole show down there with them. Anyway.
Scott Galloway
You know, let's bring your whole family. We're coming. This weather here, I did it this morning. I was like, that's enough with this freezing cold weather in our house. These aren't conferences. They're Swisher vacations where you bring in interesting speakers. We're going to come another time, too.
Kara Swisher
You don't understand. We're coming down for the month. We're ready. We're already planning it.
Scott Galloway
Okay. We're ready.
Kara Swisher
All right, Scott. That's the show. We'll be back on Friday for more. There's so much news going on. Can you please read us out?
Scott Galloway
Today's show was produced by Lara Naiman, Evan Engel, and Taylor Griffin. Ernie Indratot engineered this episode. Thanks also to Drew Burrows. Make sure you're subscribed to the show on Apple Podcasts or if you're an Android user, check us out on Spotify or, frankly, wherever you listen to podcasts. Thanks for listening to Pivot from New York Magazine and Vox Media. We'll be back later this week for another breakdown of all things tech and business. It could never happen here is lazy thinking. It could absolutely happen here. We need empathy. We need understanding. We need an intolerance of intolerance. Have a good rest of the week, Kara.